Discussion Locked

Is the United States on the road to bankruptcy?

0 helpful
140 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

140 replies

by oz_media

The "economy" does not equate to a real number though, it is just a term to describe a decline in the situations you described.

by jamesrl

Its the debt.

Take it to a personal finance situation. You can be making a million dollars a year, but if you owe 10 million, and you have 10% interest, you aren't rich, you are on the way to bankruptcy.

by pser

eyes ...

Mine have seen many people (myself and my family included), throughout my life, live on beans and rice never asking for or receiving ANYTHING close to a 'government bailout', as you would label the measly checks one would receive in the form of unemployment/welfare checks.

My eyes have also seen ... multimillion (billions) of corporate 'government bailouts'.

In my eyes, they do not equate.

by oz_media

The US doesn't really sell anything. The rest of the world relies on selling to the US.

We could do Alaska though, not much different than a lot of the Canadian snow and tundra towns, it would just make BC a greater oil resource to pad Alberta's sands. BUT, then of course the US would want the oil and would want to pay less because they are broke. We'd set out some deal and ship them oil, they'd reneg on paying as per 'the deal' and still want even more oil for less and we are right back where we started. A broke US pretending they can save everyone from imminent doom (which they will fabricate somehow) if we lend them a hand.

by jamesrl

Bush has suggested in his memoirs he has no regrets about the automobile industry bailouts.

by maxwell edison

Re: [i]Bush has suggested in his memoirs he has no regrets about the automobile industry bailouts.[/i]

I haven't yet read President Bush's book, [i]Decision Points[/i], but I plan to very soon.

But as you may or may not know, I haven't always agreed with what President Bush did. Personally speaking, I think GM and Chrysler should have been forced into reorganization bankruptcy. But the auto unions wouldn't have anything to do with such a thing!

P.S. Who's going to bailout the United States government?

[i]I am disappointed that the Senate could not reach agreement on a short-term plan for the auto industry. I share the frustration of so many about the decades of mismanagement in this industry that has helped deliver the current crisis. Those bad practices cannot be rewarded or continued. [/i]
-Barrack Obama

And what about the [i]decades of mismanagement in (government) that has helped deliver the current crisis[/i]?

by jamesrl

I'm only suggesting that Bush has had time to reflect on his decision, and right or wrong hasn't changed his mind, though he could have easily done so with the benefit of hindsight.

From what I read and hear, many people have forgotten that the Bush government started the process, and a lot of people are blaming Obama for those bailouts.

by maxwell edison

I was also critical of President Bush for:

Failing to address the illegal immigration problems.

Expanding the role of Medicare.

Failing to push hard for real Social Security reform.

Failing to ......

by oz_media

Our government spends more than it takes in....I really can't see how anything oil-related has anything to do with that.

You buy, you don't sell. therefore you will always spend more than you take in unless...(don't hit me) you raise taxation but that's a bad thing, right?

The reason I went to oil is that is paramount to the US economy. The value of your money is so important to the oil trade that they use your currency worldwide (well, most of it) for oil trade. The oil trade has such a direct influence on the US economy that I don't see how it is irrelevant in this case at all.

Of course the consumption of oil, the investments that oil companies and private owners have in the US is directly related to the US economy. The value of your dollar directly relates to the value of the foreign investments in your country.

I honestly don't understand how you can't see a relation there.

Money makes the world go 'round and the value of your money makes America go 'round.

Was it not you who agreed with and justified the spending of trillions on a war but denounced increased taxation?

Isn't that just one example of how the government puts out but doesn't take in?

To be more specific I suppose its true that you feel that taxation is okay, just not redistribution of your taxes.

So, it's not quite the same, but more income (taxation) means more government. More government = unhappy Max.

Less taxes=less government=less income with same expenditures.

by maxwell edison

If simply rasing taxes will cure our ills, then let's raise them all to 80, 90, or even 100 percent! Would that do it?

If a small tax increase is good, wouldn't a really big one be even better?

P.S. It's consumers buying the oil (at least most of it), not government.

by oz_media

Raising taxes means most, average people will simply consume less, they won't buy things unless absolutely necessary. This means your expenses reduce, but so would your income. You'd still continue to lose jobs as everything will NEED to be sourced out offshore due to rising production costs and a need for lower prices to keep costs within the consumer's reach.

I don't mean any offense to you personally or even America as a nation, I honestly don't, but you are the world's biggest consumer of just about everything, to the point of gross gluttony.

However, you don't have the largest population, (though 10X Canada's).

WHY? Why is it that Americans use more fuel, consume and waste more food (one must go with the other of course)and God only knows how many other imports you buy to sate the needs of a consumer society?

Why? It's not that you NEED more just to serve more people, that is a given, but the amount EACH consumer "desires" is greater than other nations, without statistics of course but are they REALLY needed to make such an obvious point?

America is charitable, for other nations in need, and I assume that is a portion of such over expenditures but not the bulk of it nor even a relevant figure that would tip the scales.

So perhaps it's all of the above, over consumption of resources, imported goods, low taxation and a HUMUNGOUS amount haphazardly spent on war efforts (by haphazardly I don't mean the resources required should be questioned, they are out there with the bare minimum sometimes), but the reasons and rush to war should be, now look where you are.

I know you saw it coming, but you still supported less tax and more war funding all along.

Didn't that mentality, shared by many, have any impact on the state of affairs now? Especially since you've given up on Iraq now and didn't really achieve what you set out to do to begin with? Hindsight is 20/20 but not always free.

Instead of consuming less, the American consumer demanded lower prices for products they 'desire'. As a result they get cheaper products and continue at the same rate of consumption, instead of using less and saving jobs.

I think the mindset of too many Americans has been, "it's no big deal, we are big and strong, we won't suffer from it, I don't need to make any personal changes."

If the government were to impose changes, limit consumers, BEg people to be more resourceful, they simply question the source of the information and laugh it off as BS.

GW, perhaps true perhaps not, but that's irrelevant. As I have said all along, people need to be more resourceful. When the government urges it, people laugh and stick a middle finger up while bitching about false science and AlGore.

Are any of these individual causes for the current situation? No, I wouldn't even go there.

Are these all contributing factors? yes, and yet Americans thumb their nose at such concepts as it requires personal sacrifice and it appears that Americans don't like that unless it is patriotic and they are recognized for it.

by oz_media

Perhaps not your chosen investment but, in the case of health care, more healthy workers = more earning, taxpayers and less on compo or disability.

Maybe letting a bunch die off is just natural process of elimination, survival of the fittest. Fewer mouths to feed, fewer consumer etc. But that's not exactly the type of thing the world would accept from a Western Democracy. Perhaps instead of hanging Saddam you should have let him dictate America for a few years.

Could he REALLY have done worse than 'the last guy' ( I didn't say it :) !).

by oz_media

Of course it's a left s right thing, or else it would never have been posted to begin with. The "open discussion" stuff is really just just a means to an end. Look up, closed ended questioning. ;)

by j-mart

His view on any topic can always be defined in terms of his personal politics, he only sees in right wing or left wing points of view, unless you agree with his right wing opinion, and it is only opinion, not the absolute facts he credits his opinion as being, your opinion is worthless.

All the countries of the western world have economies that are suffering many of the ills of the US, some fortunately to a lesser degree, some unfortunately worse off. The world is not the same place as it was in the 1960's and 1970's, or even the 1980's. Its called the global market. Before globalization, the west did not need to compete on equal footing. the east was kept down but now the beast has been unleashed, in a market driven world why pay more than you need for anything, is this not the capitalist way? Let the market drive the economy, the Chinese and Indians will work much harder and for much less. This may have made large numbers of the western workforce now surplus to requirements, from factory assembly line workers to IT staff, many of whom will now have skills and experience the west no longer needs, they will either be unemployable or fast food outlet staff. The right wing view would be, its their problem, its not the job of the government to provide assistance, there will be some smart enough and resourceful enough to eek out an existence, but many will not be able to, they are now surplus to the requirements of society. The options, crime, labor camps, or as they are no longer of any use does the society that does not have any use for them and finds it against their politics to provide for them just simply get rid (exterminate) them ?.

My point being, in the world we live in today is, there will be no straight forward right wing or left wing politics answer, that will solve these problems. Paying taxes to provide for many who will only be a burden for the rest of their days may seem abhorrent, but many of the alternatives are far worse, considering also that terrorists and the like tend to be pissed off, hungry, have no real future other than misery, and take up their causes because they see nothing better in their future prospects. Even from an economic viewpoint, a government supported social program can be cheaper than the alternative.

by oz_media

[i]"My point being, in the world we live in today is, there will be no straight forward right wing or left wing politics answer,[/i]

Left or right has never been THE solution. I believe in weighing issues from both sides, sometimes the left is closest to my opinion, sometimes the right but I find both are usually extremes and middle ground should be sought. There are many countries where parties represent extreme opposites and do so just to differentiate themselves. I prefer a more centered government.

As for Max, while he adamantly opposes the left, I believe he prefers to be seen as more libertarian than extreme right, though he clearly sides more with Republicans than Democrats. He's entitled to his opinion though and I'm sure he'd share it if he found something relevant to reply to. I wont speak for him though.

by maxwell edison

..... you haven't been paying very close attention.

Re: [i]His view on any topic can always be defined in terms of his personal politics, he only sees in right wing or left wing points of view, unless you agree with his right wing opinion, and it is only opinion, not the absolute facts he credits his opinion as being, your opinion is worthless.[/i]

by oz_media

Perhaps a document written several hundred years ago, my men who's minds were limited by technology and vision, were unable to predict a more complicated state of affairs 200 years into the future.

If a group of men were to found a new country today and set out a constitution, do you really expect that it would apply to all situations in 200+ years? Not bloody likely! We don't even know what's around the corner and what would need to be changed in just one, two or even five years.

It is possible we could lay down a very basic framework from which we can elaborate later as needed, just as the Constitution offers, instead of seeing it as an unchanging, unmoving set of 'laws' to be accepted verbatim for eternity.

by maxwell edison

..... our constitution is outdated because it was written over 200 years ago.

Do you also dismiss the English Bill of Rights, written before our U.S. Constitution because it's also outdated dogma?

How about the 1948 Universal Declaration of Rights? Will it, too, become outdated in 100 years?

But instead of simply asserting that the U.S. Constitution is outdated, perhaps you'll indulge us and point out the exact articles and/or amendments that you consider outdated and no longer valid.

And like I said, I don't consider the concept of liberty and freedom outdated - the very concepts the U.S. Constitution was designed to protect.

by oz_media

Max, I understand that you are struggling in a situation where there is just no much work, even for the highly skilled and experienced people with years of stability with their company, I sincerely hope that things will get better for you very soon.

Your CHOICE to not collect unemployment 'insurance', which you have paid into for decades is entirely your own choice and doesn't make you any more upstanding as a citizen or more noble than anyone who actually does collect the insurance that they paid their premiums for.

[i]"Where there's the will, there's a way. Unfortunately, all too many people lack the will. But government will, for them, ride in and save the day! (Yea, right!)[/i]

When you have a car accident, their fault or not, you rightly collect the insurance that you have paid into for however long. When you visit the doctor, you also use your insurance that you have paid into for X years.

If you choose not to collect your car or medical insurance and pay out of pocket, that is entirely up to you and if you didn't use your insurance, you wouldn't be considered the sharpest knife in the drawer by any means.

So why you feel that the unemployment insurance is any different, if you are eligible to collect it, is no different.

People who pay into and then collect insurance in such times of hardship and need, should not be chastised or looked down upon for doing so. I am sure than the vast majority would much rather work and pay into it than collect it, but many don't have that luxury.

So when you say [i]"Unfortunately, all too many people lack the will. But government will, for them, ride in and save the day! (Yea, right!)[/i]you are looking down on those who pay for insurance and collect said insurance in times of great need.

Not everyone lives your life, not everyone is able to create income as needed to get by. Why you would condemn people for collecting from a system your government designed for just such hardships is beyond me. It merely illustrates yourself as thinking you are superior to others and don't see why anyone would burden YOUR government and jeopardize YOUR future.

I'd like to think that I know you better than that and that you are really a warm hearted and empathetic member of society but if you insist on showing yourself otherwise...

When I lost my F/T gig last Xmas, I just did my own thing for 8 months until I figured I was tired of actually working for a living and sought out an employer again. I collected UI for 2 months then, as I was declaring self made income, I earned too much to collect UI anymore.

This doesn't mean I was a burden on my country, my neighbours, my society. I paid for insurance, I collected it and worked until I was earning more than UI would pay me, then I eventually got a day job again. I am fortunate that way, I can earn a decent living with a 3 line ad on Craigslist an dbe so busy I have to turn down work. Many are not as fortunate as me, but I don't condemn them or expect them to suffer just because I can sort my own sh*t out.

by oz_media

You often refer to the Constitution and expect it to be adhered to verbatim and unamended.

as for me, YES I do think the UK Bill of RIghts is outdated, and so do many Canadians who have lived under Canada's Bill of Rights (based on the British)and have no problem with modernisation and amendment to bring the basic principles into modern day society.

The base concepts of the Bill of Rights/Constitution are fine.

But specifics and amendments are necessary if we are to move forward as a modern society.

This whole redistribution of wealth kick you are on, you base on very basic principles and don't seem to accept that there should be variance and exception applied to accommodate changing times and an evolving, heavily populated and global society.

We can amend our basic rights to facilitate the needs of a changing society.

If they wanted to rewrite the entire bill of Rights, I wouldn't care. if it retained basic freedoms, rights that we assume in any free Western Democracy, that would be fine, if not I'd just move to a country I preferred. Nobody OWES me anything, I can always leave if i don't like it.

by nicknielsen

To a large extent, as I see it, it does. Does all of it benefit me, even indirectly? Of course not.

You seem to think that because I can accept some, I will accept all. There are federal departments that need to be greatly reduced or eliminated. The Department of Education is one; it should be a coordinating committee under the Commerce Department, with the sole function of promulgating national education standards. There are federal programs that need to be greatly reduced or eliminated. Any and all subsidy programs come immediately to mind: you don't promise people a minimum price for their product, nor do you pay them to NOT do something. It distorts the market. On the other hand banking regulation, medicine, transportation safety, product and food safety, and other public safety issues are the province of government. This is not a black or white issue.

The laissez-faire government of the 19th century allowed (and sometimes actively participated in) the rise of the robber barons, the slaughter of native Americans, and the repression of free men. I don't want a return to that kind of government, and I really don't think you do either.

by av .

I can't see this country ever going bankrupt, though. We can fix this, but its going to take many years and people have to be very patient.

The TARP program instituted by GWB, even though I'm not a fan of bailouts, actually prevented our economy from collapsing. Much of the money was repaid and the taxpayer could actually see a profit from some of it. It was one of GWB's better decisions.

Obama's stimulous packages created only temporary growth that wasn't sustainable after the government stimulous money ran out.

Then there is the health care bill. Everyone needs healthcare and there are good things in the bill, but it has contributed to an uncertainty in the business community as to the cost of it all and suppressed job growth.

I can't forget that before Obama, Wall St. and the like did what they wanted without oversight. Now we have lots of regulations, maybe too much.

So here we are.

We can fix this if we can get Congress to work in a bi-partisan fashion so that they make more balanced decisions.

Our country is divided in their political views and neither party in Congress wants to compromise. That attitude has got to change or we will all go off the cliff together.

Our government has to stop the spending and borrowing, and start cutting. Everyone will feel the pain, but its the only way.

Lets start with getting out of Iraq and then Afghanistan.

AV

Edited: Added we

by ansugisalas

the legal framework for the natural impetus for government.
A constitution is the basis for legality, nothing more.
Legalities can be added later, through additional legislation, and these should at the very least be keyed to items set fast in the constitution.
The natural impetus for government (vide natural rights of subjects) is to observe good practices of government so as to secure and improve the upholding of the natural rights of it's citizens.
Running an economy isn't in the constitution (only the levying of taxes to pay for the military, or so I hear), but it is still a prerequisite for realizing the purpose of government.
Military investments, BTW, are just "spending" too, according to your own measure; there are no immediate returns, only further spending.

by the 'g-man.'

You say: "Besides, I doubt very much the G-Man was referring to the military use and/or defense of the flow of oil. He just saw an opportunity to paint Americans as greedy."

Totally incorrect - you asked and I told you exactly what I meant.

So am I talking to the real 'Mad Max' of the future when petrol is a premium and a currency?

by oz_media

So is medical and welfare, however we cannot devise a system that weeds out all the false claims and I feel it is imperative that people have access to SOME support whilst, as you suggest, finding alternatives.

Many if not most people these days live check to check, they don't have a nest egg to lean on while getting their feet on the ground again. Therefore the insurance system in place, sees that people are helped with the absolute BASIC needs to pay rent, buy some food and pay minimal bills. It's not like most people are able to live comfortably on welfare, which doesn't even cover basic rent in most cases.

I have no problem with such a support system, whether it helps me, my friends or people I have never met. They would add to the homeless and become a much greater burden on society as they became drug users, criminals etc. I have SEEN this myself.

I have seen someone (over 50)go from a high level role with an Airline to living in squalor on the streets, turning to drugs and then finally lifting his head up again, getting clean, getting on his feet again and shortly after, passing away due to related diseases from when he was on the street.

This is someone who had a family, a home etc. It was all lost, his life was over within 7 years.

He actually GOT support, just very limited and not enough to get out fast enough.

This is not unique in anyway, and until a better system is devised, I accept that people abuse it, but it is still better than NOT having any system of support for those in real need.

YOU, are extremely fortunate, as am I, and I hope you realize it, I know I sure do and I don't have that much. I am not well off or wealthy by any means, I live comfortably and that's it. It's not the case for everyone though, I know you are driven, like me and will do what you need to do to eke out a living in harder times, I honestly tip my hat to you and I understand that not everyone can do it, as you or I may.

I guess what I find most odd is how people support their government sending aid to countries faced with disaster and publish it proudly to the world to see how generous they are, but when it comes to a citizen fallen on equally difficult times, it is unacceptable to support them with tax dollars.

by maxwell edison

Re: [i]You often refer to the Constitution and expect it to be adhered to verbatim and unamended.

as for me, YES I do think the UK Bill of RIghts is outdated, and so do many Canadians who have lived under Canada's Bill of Rights (based on the British)and have no problem with modernisation and amendment to bring the basic principles into modern day society.

The base concepts of the Bill of Rights/Constitution are fine.

But specifics and amendments are necessary if we are to move forward as a modern society.

This whole redistribution of wealth kick you are on, you base on very basic principles and don't seem to accept that there should be variance and exception applied to accommodate changing times and an evolving, heavily populated and global society.

We can amend our basic rights to facilitate the needs of a changing society.

If they wanted to rewrite the entire bill of Rights, I wouldn't care. if it retained basic freedoms, rights that we assume in any free Western Democracy, that would be fine, if not I'd just move to a country I preferred. Nobody OWES me anything, I can always leave if i don't like it.[/i]

--------------------------------------------

I've often mentioned the amendment process to make changes in the constitution when changing times makes changes a necessity, and I've suggested that it was that amendment process that should be used instead of trying to interpret the constitution to say what one wants it to say. In fact, you've even blasted me in the past for suggesting the amendment process was the best way to go! And you criticized the USA for the [i]high number of times[/i] it's been amended.

[i]This whole redistribution of wealth kick you are on.....[/i]

It's not just a [i]kick[/i] I'm on, Oz. I see it as the very thing that's created whole classes of people dependent on government - something that's neither good for them or government - and it's a primary contributing factor in causing the very financial problems we're facing. Moreover, there is no basis for such wealth distribution in the constitution - and, as I've said before, if that should be a [i]new and modern[/i] role of government in the USA, then use the amendment process to specifically spell it out.

Two things are crystal clear to me: you simply don't have a good understanding of the US constitution; and you criticize me just for the sport of it. (As evidenced in your contradictory criticism regarding the amendment process - blast me because I do, then blast me because you claim I don't.)

by oz_media

[i]In fact, you've even blasted me in the past for suggesting the amendment process was the best way to go![/i]

I fully support the amendment process, always have. Can you show me where I have blasted you for doing so also? I believe amendments are imperative to keep basic governing principles evolving with changing nations.

[i]And you criticized the USA for the high number of times it's been amended. [/i]

Not for the process of amendment but to illustrate that The Constitution does not apply to all instances in modern times and thus amendments are needed in order to stay current.

Pointing out the number of amendments simply illustrated my point that The Constitution does not apply to nor hold the answers to all of today's issues. I am sure it was yourself who implied that amendments were abused and that they detract from the core values of the Constitution, which should be adhered to and not simply adjusted to suit people's needs.

[i]I see it as the very thing that's created whole classes of people dependent on government[/i]

Of course it has, it has also helped millions get back on their feet and not become a permanent burden on society. Half full/half empty. We all know that ANY system will be abused, including the very basis of political power, democratic voting etc. It is ALL up for abuse but we keep it as it works, for the most part.

So welfare, is one of the main contributing factors for your financial problems today?

The trillions spent on war don't have any impact? The millions of unqualified citizens that were given mortgages and can't pay the trillions in accrued debts are not a major factor?
It's mainly due to those that are unable to work and get $500 a month to live on that are the problem?

Selective vision.

[i]
You also assume that without a nanny government, people would be unable to find alternatives to cure their own life's challenges. They would.[/i]

Don't tell me what I assume, especially when it is merely your own assumption.

SOME if not MANY people CAN find alternatives, but SOME if not MANY cannot.

SOME people's alternatives are selling drugs, robbing stores, committing fraud etc. Those that abuse the system would be the first to find alternate crimes that would impact lives wore than by collecting a welfare check. Those who don't abuse it either need it or will use it while getting back on their feet, dismantling it does nothing positive except push more people into the crime and poverty pile.

What if they ABOLISHED welfare tonight? Would you have more money in your pocket? No, of course not, it will be allocated to something else, war, corporate bailouts, new letterheads for the Oval Office etc. You won't see penny ONE in return, you know better than that, governments reallocate taxes they don't refund them.

Even companies that reply on government funding PURPOSELY waste money near their fiscal year end just so they can justify asking for more next year, money does not get given back. If you want to have more money you have a few choices, earn more, earn tax free income, move.

[i]"I'm no smarter or better than anyone else. I simply adapted to a period of change. Others can too.[/i]

You really don't understand that people are not all equal and many have problems that would not make it possible. I know a lady who is VERY good at her job, she has done it for over 35 years and has seniority out her yin yang. She was let go last year at age 56. She doesn't have the foggiest CLUE how to compete in today's job market. No motivation at all, just complete defeat. She is skilled but too old, over qualified, etc.

Please explain what her recourse is in this situation, in detail please so I can pass it on to her.

[i]I also know that many people - maybe most people - abuse the unemployment system. So many of them earn money on the side and don't report it to the unemployment office. And I know some of them personally. [/i]

Heaven forbid!!! No kidding! but what is it, many, maybe most or some?

The lack of conviction or proof leads me to believe that you know it exists but don't have clue who really needs support and who doesn't. You know that everyone TALKS about making money on the side, as to how much and how many actually do, you have no idea though. So your only basis of any fact there is that you know the system is abused, well done, common knowledge.

If we did away with welfare, would these people then just go out and get jobs then? Criminals wouldn't continue to be criminals once the gig was up?

As for the unemployed, many DON'T report that income, if they do they can't pay rent as UI is not paying them enough as it is. They are all but forced to go to work, but if they declare income they earn they are penalized for working and earning SOME money while seeking a permanent income. In many cases just reporting that you have earned ANYTHING, even money for babysitting, means you then have to fill out a self employment form, and your benefits are withheld while they 'process' you in the system, meaning you lose your home for not paying rent, can't feed your family, can't pay your car insurance etc., all because you TRIED to actually start supporting yourself and supplementing your insurance payout.

UI is a bitch, it's not a cakewalk for free money and neither is welfare.

Sure there are many who abuse the system, those who do not abuse it need it though and what do we do with them? Tell them to suck it up and find a good park bench until a job comes along? Let them press that shirt and iron a tie in the public bathroom until they begin their next career in such a competitive marketplace?

Stop talking out of your arse, Max. Just because you can do it, and again I tip my hat at your tenacity and fortitude, it doesn't mean everyone else can and that's where you are HORRIBLY mistaken and UTTERLY clueless.

by charliespencer

http://www.statesman.com/news/nation/deficit-reduction-plan-targets-social-security-spending-taxes-1038671.html?page=2&viewAsSinglePage=true

I'd appreciate it if someone could find a site with more details. My morning paper had more details, but apparently they can't post syndicate-provided content (AP?) on their home page.

Nothing here I can't get behind, at least not at first review. The question is how much it will be watered down. I can support another 15 cents gas tax; we were paying more than that to foreign supplier 3 years ago. I can support reduced social security benefits; I'm going to be eligible for them in a dozen or so years and was planning on them not being available anyway. I use national parks but wouldn't object to paying user fees; it might make them less crowded.

by jamesrl

Do you not have user fees?

I haven't been to a National Park in a while, but our provincial parks here not only charge user fees, they have also been privatised. Each park is run by a separate management company, the park rangers are still provincial employees, but the people taking reservations, cleaning the washrooms etc are not provincial employees. And the user fees are set to try and cover all costs. So camping, which I do a fair amount of, isn't as cheap as it used to be, but thats ok. And I wish it made a dent in the crowds, its difficult to make a reservation here unless you do it 5 months in advance.

James

by charliespencer

But in many cases, no.

Most national parks (including the 'lower tier' monuments, battlefields, forests, recreation areas, seashores, etc, in addition to the top-tier 'National Parks') are available at no charge for any services offered. Others are free to enter but charge a nominal fee for programs (guided hikes, canoe rentals, campsites, parking, etc.) or parking. A few, usually the most popular, charge an admission fee in addition to program fees. These parks usually mandate you park your motor vehicle during the most popular months, and require you travel by shuttle bus if you want to cover long distances by vehicle. Obviously you're free to hike and bike instead.

State parks fee schedules vary for state to state; I assume some may vary from park to park. I don't think any part of the SC park system is privatized.

by delbertpgh

United States national parks don't charge admission fees for the most part. They don't have any income of their own except what Congress allocates, and in tough budget years (they're usually tough,) the allocation is smaller than is needed. Most parks have a long list of deferred maintenance issues. They aren't well cared for.

Tying their budgets to actual use, rather than to taxpayer generosity, is a more sensible management policy.

by delbertpgh

Erskine Bowles (Democrat) and Alan Simpson (Republican) released this plan ahead of the deficit commission's vote. They admit freely that they doubt a majority of the commission will agree with their proposals. I think they were either trying to use publicity to force a vote, or just grabbing the maximum exposure they could get because they didn't believe their commission could ever vote on a hard choice.

The commission is supposed to deliver a proposal to Obama by December 1st.

It's interesting that they propose very low income tax rates, 23% for top earners, as opposed to about 31% now. However, they propose to do away with special rates for capital gains and dividends, and re-introduce the estate tax at 45%, but with a much higher exclusion for estates up to $3.5 million ($7 for a married couple.)

by charliespencer

They also propose to eliminate the mortgage interest deduction on secondary or vacation homes, and cap it for primary residences. That will offset the lower top rate for some taxpayers.

Based on what I've read today, I hope the majority of the commission goes along with them. There may be some 'gotchas' still to come to light, but I could accept what I've seen so far. I just with someone would 'man up' and accept that balancing the budget is going to take some form of sacrifice.

by delbertpgh

I got stuck with a second home I can't afford, can't rent, can't sell, and don't want. I inherited the thing when my mother died; I had cosigned the mortgage, so I can't walk away from it easily. It was supposed to be worth a pretty sum, but now it's worth less than nothing, and even pricing for a big loss I can't find any buyers.

by jamesrl

I was thinking more about the "camping" style parks. In Canada, National or Provincial, even day use has a fee. As a result they are generally well kept.

Having lived in Ottawa for a while, I know there is a special government body, the National Capital commission, that looks after monumnents buildings etc. in that region. None of them have fees, for Parliament etc. The NCC spends big bucks on free festivals, including a Canada day celebration, but no one seems to mind.

The national museums do charge fees, though I suspect there is also some taxpayer money there are well.

This discussion is closed to new replies.