Discussion Locked

Is Vista Doomed from the Start?

0 helpful
600 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

600 replies

by centaur11

Users had a problem working out which version of XP they needed, it is going to be a nightmare trying to explain to customers which version they need now, or might need later on with VISTA. Then they will want the ultimate version, but at the home price. This is going to cause a lot of aggravation to vendors, and be very frustrating to users... I am not looking forward to it.

by dwight-watt9

I do not recall Windows 1 but I actually still have a copy of Windows 2 in the box on 5.25 diskettes. It was not a very friendly system.

by g_bigham

Microsoft Bob, It was a great idea (somewhere way back in the early concept phase). It treated all users as children (very young children).
Forget it!
Let me put it this way; I have a pirated copy (on a CD somewhere, I think) , I could send it to you and cc Microsoft and MS would ignore us.

by justwippet

After stripping away the layers of Aero Glass eye-candy and changing the default settings so that I could actually wrestle back control of the OS - I was shocked...there it was - XP! Microsoft has merely coated XP with candy and prevented the average user from controlling or changing the OS. Vista kinda reminds me of a security feature that they "added" to Outlook Express 6. By default, the user couldn't open email attachments..that sure solved the virus issue, right? "Sorry Grandma, you can't open those pictures of little Johnny."

As the Talking Heads say "Vista? Same as it ever was!"

by pkrdk

You must be crazy. At the time IBM had OS/2 Warp and WarpConnect running, an it still has features Microsoft even don't dream of, like - and not limited to almost 10 years later:
Any font in any window.
Different languages and keyboard in any window.
Switching to one window would give you f.inst russian keyboard, another would give you US keboard an so on.
Changes take place immediately - no reboots. Just like Linux.
Rename any file or folder, and your desktop and apps still runs.
No stupid flashligt searching and finding the wrong items.
Smaller and faster kernel with each upgrade.
New versions faster on existing HW.
Full preemptive multitasking at a time where 'multitasking' in Windows was a joke.
Full 32 bit, when Windows was 16 bit.
Full crash protection. When Windows - or any other app - crashed, the OS survived.

Windows set us back at least 10 years.

Vista will be a sales success because it will be present on any new PC from major OEM's, not because people go out and buy it. We even have to pay for it, even if it is the first thing we strip off the new box.

by maclark88

I think calling 98 good is a bit of a stretch. I have yet to see a 98 system (even lightly used) that didn't eventually self-destruct. OS's are a commodity these days. Redmond has yet to figure this out.

by deadly ernest

not being properly cleared. I had many Win 98 machines, that worked perfectly for ages once a memory manager program like MemTurbo etc was loaded, and it was set to auto clear the memory when it got down to 10 MB of free RAM. The system very rarely crashed after that.

by jcritch

Sorry to hear you think Linux is a duck (actually it's a pinguin). There are several desktop distros out there that hve really great GUIs (Linspire and Unbunto just to name two). The major problem with Linux is the perceived lack of software.

by pkrdk

IT is no different from shop floor equipment. Will the new lathe, welding automat, cutting machine, whatever improve the bottonline ? Will the new IT system improve the bottom line ?

Time to get business-like on the PC's. Maybe even drop them in favour of thin clients ?

by blutiger

You must think IT people are stupid enough to click on your URL when we probably already know it goes to a porn site. Lets get back to the real world dude, the real conversation thats going on in this thread.

by kiltie

I can see your almost blank profile, and learn that you only made one post 2 and a half years ago.

But if you did likewise, you would soon see that I am an enthusiastic member of TR, with a lot to contribute, and quite active in trying to help other members with problems.

However, if you were bright enough of a techie you can click a link, knowing you have full protection systems backing you, then find that the link goes to a post later in this thread.

and if you were a sensitive kind of person, you may even blush for thinking what you just have.

EDIT: To add that [b][u][i]TinyURL[/i][/u][/b] links have nothing to do with penis size, whatever you may think, they are an [u][i]often used resource in Tech Republic.[/i][/u]

Go look 'em up, Go do something techie, and leave the rest of us in peace

by stevef611

The link is a direct link to the place on THIS site where the listing is. tinyurl is a method/resource to give url shortcuts instead of the 438 character urls that often exist. The fact that you obviously spent most of your time with porn is not our problem...

by jerryfr

Coincidence, I'll tack one on next Monday 10/30 as well. A bit older though. I was 23 when you arrived and had been in IT (or whatever it was called back then) for 7 years by then.

I recall all of the PC history you mentioned. I agree with your assessment of Win98, that was bad news. Never even bothered with it nor with ME either. I don't know how Win2k and WinXP are couples together as one release. Both are 'good' releases.
I don't think this 'alternative releases' theory is being forceed a bit.

by thomasclark

When you look at it as black and white (good vs bad) then you do not get the full picture.

Dos 3.3 was good
Dos 4.1 was bod
Dos 5.0 was good
Dos 6.0 was OK
Dos 6.22 was improved on 6.0
Windows 1.0 was a joke (anyone else try it in production?)
Windows 2.0 was OK but many features were unstable
Windows 2.11 (first usable version of Windows was good for it day)
Windows 3.0 was OK
Windows 3.1 was Good
Windows 95 was an improvement over 3.1 but still was unstable
Windows NT was OK
Windows 98 first edition was OK but had stability
Windows 98 Second edition was best windows to date (Good)
Windows ME was a waist of time
Windows 2000 was OK, much stablier than previous version
Windows XP SP0 was OK but had stability problems
Windows XP SP1 was GOOD
Windows XP SP2 was also GOOD (I like the improved wireless support)
Windows Vista will probably be like Windows XP SP0 showing the promise of the new features but requiring a quick update (SP1) to fix stability issues.

So if you look it the details and fill in the blanks you see that there is not really a pattern just continue improvement and new features with a couple of steps back due to development delays.

by vernleblanc

I noticed you bundled 2 good oS's together to get the result you were looking for. I think your logic is flawed and Spock would be ashamed!

by mtbandit

The first two versions of Windows were not positioned as operating systems. They were created as add-on environment to lure Mac developers into a GUI environment for the PC. Windows 2 wasn't normmally sold separately -- you usually got it bundled with Pagemaker or some other GUI intensive program. (Anyone out there remember Digital Research's competing GUI, GEOS?)

For that matter, the Windows 3.x versions weren't marketed as an OS either. They were still sold as add-ons to MS DOS 6.x, though unlike the predecessors, Win3.x was the first sold on its own, unbundled. You still had to buy DOS 6.x, though.

Win NT was the first Windows-as-OS product (Gates said in an interview that WinNT would have been OS/2 if they hadn't split with IBM over the direction to take with it). Win95 was the first home version positioned as an OS, but underneath it was still basically Windows 4.0 over DOS 7. They made it so you couldn't just boot to DOS directly.

by ahenry

i dont remember pre-windows 3.1 well but from 95 to 98 was 3 years 98 to ME was 2 years ME to XP 2 years and XP to Vista 5 well 6 years. hopefully they have taken there time and got it working. I just attend an intoduction to Vista from Microsoft yesterday. It has problems already but it was RC2 i saw not the final release and as with any piece of software wait until a service pack comes out before you start working with it. With all the extra "security" I believe it will be harder for us to do some of the things we are use to without just through a lot more bells and whistles but hopefully it won't be as bad as we are all expecting.

by jimtheengineer

On the western edge of the city of Minneapolis here in Minnesota there is a street sign that says, "TO EDLIN PL." Yes, there is a street (or "Place") named Edlin - and yes, it is a dead end street. :o)

by fgladd3

Just as in most anything else, we can make the numbers tell us anything we want to hear. Odd and even OS releases makes for fun reading but it only works out if you skip some releases and group others together to get the results you want. I have my doubts about Vista as well but I think these groupings don't really tell the truth.

by deadly ernest

A few years an MS won't release security fixes, or anything else for XP. Also, once Vista is released, they'll not put much effort into keeping XP secure or helping people write drievrs etc for it. Thus it will not be compatible with new hardware or peripherals. Try getting a new printer with Win NT or Win 2K drivers - only get them if tis a Win 2k/XP driver because they may be similar.

by ndynamics

What, you guys don't use edlin anymore? :-)

I booted up my CP/M system the other day the try to retrieve some data and couldn't remember how PIP worked. But I did accomplish my task, reading an almost 25 year old 8" floppy with a dBase II database and eventually pulling the data into MS Access. I got most of it too!

Anybody remember the first double-sided 8" floppy disks - the ones you had to pull out and flip over to store data on the "double side"?

Punch cards and paper tape, blah. The first PC's were the real revolution.

by kiltie

I did some research on DOS and Windows versions, and found that only one site came close to the full list, but I couldn't find BOB even in that.
http://www.levenez.com/windows/

The sources I used are listed at the end, if anyone is interested in looking them up.
(Except M$s own site, which I didn't bother listing as it is heavily edited, showing only the highlights of what M$ wants to show)

As extracts from Wikipedia say, it all stemmed from QDOS 0.1 (Quick and Dirty Operating System) developed at Seattle Computer Products by Tim Paterson as a variant of CP/M-80 from Digital Research.
Although there is a lot more to the story than that, I think it is a good enough place to start.

Wikipedia also notes many other DOS-like OSs including PC-DOS, MS-DOS, FreeDOS, DR-DOS, Novell-DOS, OpenDOS, PTS-DOS, ROM-DOS, Caldera DOS, IBM DOS among several others.

This list is not chronological, indeed several releases overlap others, see the above link for a fuller picture (pun intended). It is split into 3 main groups, Early DOS, MS-DOS and Windows. It is not complete, There is far too much to list here, indeed from Windows 2000 onwards there spawned hundreds of Windows off shoots, mainly for niche markets, and it doesn't necessarily include Service Releases/Service Packs/Betas/Release Candidates, etc.

Early stuff first:
86-DOS 0.3
86-DOS 0.3
PC-DOS 1.0
PC-DOS 1.1
PC-DOS 2.0
PC-DOS 2.1
PC-DOS 3.0
PC-DOS 3.1
PC-DOS 3.2
PC-DOS 3.3
PC-DOS 4.0
PC-DOS 5.02
PC-DOS 6.0
PC-DOS 6.3
PC-DOS 7.0
PC-DOS 7.0r1
PC-DOS 2000

Now MS-DOS:
MS-DOS 1.1
MS-DOS 2.0 (Windows 1.0 is announced, then Windows 1.01 appears)
MS=DOS 2.1
MS-DOS 2.11
MS-DOS 3.0
MS-DOS 3.2
MS-DOS 3.25
MS-DOS 3.3
MS-DOS 3.31
MS-DOS 4.0
MS-DOS 4.01
MS-DOS 4.1
MS-DOS 5.0
MS-DOS 5.0a
MS-DOS 5.01
(Windows 3.1 appears)
MS-DOS 6.0
MS-DOS 6.2
MS-DOS 6.21
MS-DOS 6.22
MS-DOS 6.23
MS-DOS 6.25
MS-DOS 7.0 (Now part of Windows 95)
MS-DOS 7.1

Now Windows
Windows 1.0
Windows 1.01
Windows 1.03
Windows 2.0
Windows/386 2.0
Windows/286 2.1
Windows/386 2.1
Windows 2.03
Windows 3.0
Windows 3.0 (+Multimedia Extensions)
Windows 3.1
Windows 3.11
Windows for Workgroups 3.11
Windows 3.2 (Chinese)
Windows 95 (includes various Service Releases OSR1 and OSR2)
Windows NT
Windows NT 3.1
Windows NT 3.5
Windows NT 3.51
Windows NT 4.0
Windows NT Server 4.0, Enterprise Edition
Windows NT Server 4.0, Terminal Server Edition
Windows 98
Windows 98SE
Windows 2000 (from this point onwards it gets very messy, with hundereds of OSs being released - so I left a lot out)
Windows 2000 Professional
Windows 2000 Server
Windows 2000 Advanced Server
Windows 2000 Datacenter Server
Windows ME
Windows XP Home
Windows XP Professional
Windows XP 64-bit Edition
Windows XP Media Center Edition
Windows XP Tablet PC Edition
Windows 2003 Server Standard Edition
Windows 2003 Server Enterprise Edition
Windows 2003 Server Datacenter Edition
Windows 2003 Server Web Edition
Windows 2003: 64-Bit versions of above
Windows Vista (who knows how many they will finally end up with?)
Windows Fundamentals (for Legacy PCs aka WinFLP)
Windows WinPE (Preinstallation Environment)
Windows CE
Windows CE 3.0
Windows Mobile
Windows CE 5.0

It got a bit hairy at the end there, far too many Windows versions for me to select all, so I gave a sampling (or there would be over 100+ more in the list)

Sources used:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DOS
http://www.historyexplorer.net/other_history_timelines/dos_history_timeline/

http://oldfiles.org.uk/powerload/timeline.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Windows
[b]A fuller timeline:[/b]
http://www.levenez.com/windows/

by adriangal88

All is money. Observe the new prices for Vista and will understand why so many bells.
This new version of WINDOWS don't bring too much new things and improvements but prices are 3x bigger. Why Microsoft ?
Are VISTA 3x better then let's say XP ?
I think NO.
Few visual and security improuvements don't make 3X the price of XP. (:((
So will see the market reply in 2007.
Regarding algorithm, there are two parallel line of products: WINDOWS 9X and the NT.
Maybe some changes are required.

by argosy29

After "Windows 2000/XP: Good " , you should have added "Windows XP SP2 : Bad " !
If so , then that implies "Vista: Good " . At least we hope !

by deadly ernest

all it does it encourage staff to play videos and movies. from a purely office productivity aspect, the best MS OS ever released was Windows for Workgroups in the Win 3.11 or Win NT versions. The only way you could improve on those would be to change them to handle full 32 bit or 64 bit processing, and 128 bit encryption. It is extremely rare for an office situation to need the media playing capability or to have video conferencing at the desk. So why build an OS around such capabilities, because you're a fool trying to sell eye candy on the marketing hype again.

It's marketing pushing for the many versions of Vista - only need three Desktop (Pro) basic server (Server) heavy server (Advanced Server) end of story. Sell add on applications for the few who need multimedia hype.

by deadly ernest

And spent many thousands on 300 MB disc pack, that used 12 inch platters, and stood as high as a bottle of milk. Bought hundreds for client. Also did huge memory ypgrades, putting chips in that were the size of most people's thumbs, they had a whole 2 KB of ram each - the memory boards used about 50 each, ahd to replace all on the board at once.

even had an early micro computer, used two, wow, two brand new 5.25 inch floppies, one for the program, and one for data. the previous years version used a 12 inch floppy.

by argosy29

After the infecting of my machine with SP2 , my computer started to reboot itself at inopportune moments ; I've lost lots of data that way . The old XP NEVER did that !

by high altitude

I never wore a tweed jacket either but loved my white dust coat and very grimey pocket protector and enjoyed all the changes from DOS to Windows and the XP versions 1, 2 etc.

However, in the past 5 years, with the explosion of internet users and viruses and gazillion Microsoft patches, switching to Vista will wait... I'm in no hurry to get into another round of patching and re-patching MS patches with Vista.

by agent 77

First.....Vista blows whale genetalia.
why the hell would anyone want to have to keep giving programs permission to run every time you start them? If I didn't want the program to run, I wouldn't have selected it :-S

Second, there seem to be alot of folks posting here with great educational backgrounds, who still cant spell, or type things in any sort of grammatically correct way.

by hallockd

good observations, but didn't you ever hear the saying "never trust a dos that ends in .0" Odd or even, Msoft always had to relase the fixes that allowed each version of dos (and windows) to be "the one" for awhile. Me thinks you give Msoft to much credit for the good "odds."

by tony hopkinson

You want a choice ditch windows, until you do MS won't give you one.

http://www.microsoft.com/windowsserver2003/default.mspx

MS don't seem to agree with you !

So the question isn't am I good enough to work for you but are you good enough to manage me?
Resounding No, up to press isn't it?

If you insulted me simply because I missed "server" out, then your technical awareness is a moot point.

by mreimers

Where is the venerable OS/2 in this line-up.

This has been a stroll down memory lane for me! You young whippersnappers missed out on understanding the roots of coding and how the structure of the programs were created through trial and user feedback/error.

But wow am I impressed with the talent out there now.

by kiltie

[b]"only need three Desktop (Pro) basic server (Server) heavy server (Advanced Server) end of story. Sell add on applications for the few who need multimedia hype"[/b]

and to add.... drop the price of the Base OS accordingly, if these MM apps are "extra".

by gaston nusimovich

I think we should wait and see how Vista plays out its game.

So it seems that we won't have to wait too long to figure out if Vista will turn out to be a Star or a Dog as a product.

I put my bets on the Star side, but then again, it is too early to make any predictions.

Best regards, GEN

by ole man

of piracy or theft until you prove to Microsoft you are (using their tools and methods, of course), if you're using XP or Vista.

by awhite

I am not an it guy but let me start out by saying that everyone seems to have something different to say about each version of windows. Someone will complain no matter what, but here is the big thing if you dont like it dont use it or better yet spend millions to delvope and publish your own os no one can fix everything that needs to be done in an os. Why are there not so many viruses ect for linux well look around and see how many peoople use linux compared to windows. Every one seems to think that Bill Gates has the smartest people in the world working for him but this is not true there are much smarter people out there after all who do you think write viruses, spyware that find and use vulnerabilies in ms. If ms had the smartest people all these holes would be pluged before the first release and you would never need updates because it would be perfect the first time which in turn would lead to better hardware which inturn would lead to new oses......

by hatfira

I believe that there ARE some of the smartest people on the planet working for Microsoft. The issues you describe, I believe, are a result of numbers and not smarts. You may have a thousand people working on Vista, but potentially millions nit-picking on every little part of the code seeing where they can hack in. Even when it's a team, they have years to look at any part of the code, work on it on the instruction level, and try to hack it. That's something that the relatively small group at MS can't possibly do.

It's my contention that most of the Linux distros (just as an example) are no more or less secure than XP or Vista, but thy don't have the numbers of people trying to break in, nor by and large are they protecting things that people want to keep them out of.

When you're talking about mllions of lines of code, written in some high-level language, you are going to have holes. It's inevitable. Any software package is going to have them. Even games have patches preleased for them, and no one is hacking them trying to get your bank account number. What you hope is that when vulnerabilities are found, they are addressed immediately and a patch provided. As long as that happens, then any OS you use is going to be as safe as you can make it. (Excluding OSes such as 95 and 98 which didn't have security as a major consideration in design.

by stevef611

What do you mean going? 60 percent of our staff only have E-mail. Other can only go to certain sites. In defense of my boss however, it is a work computer and the user doesn't own it and etc etc etc.

> I think we're about to see cases where
> people are going to lose corporate
> Internet access at the desk, and only
> outside contact will be via the mail
> server.

by ndynamics

Well, if we're going to do this, at least let's get the list correct.

This does not include MS-DOS, although there were a couple of DOS releases that had a Windows-like shell. It also ignores all the embedded, phone, PDA, and automotive versions)

Microsoft Bob? Can we consider that a "released" version of Windows?

Windows 1.0 1985 Graphical Operating Environment
Windows 2.0 1987 Overlapping windows
Windows/286 1988 80286 protected mode
Windows/386 1988 80386 multiple virtual DOS systems
Windows 3.0 1990
Windows 3.1 1992
Windows NT 3.1
Windows for Workgroups 3.11 1993
Windows NT 3.50 Workstation
Windows NT 3.50 Server
Windows 95
Windows NT 3.51 Workstation
Windows NT 3.51 Server
Windows 95 OSR2
Windows 95 OSR2.1
Windows 95 OSR2.5
Windows 98
Windows 98 SE (Second Edition)
Windows Me (Millenium Edition)
Windows NT 4.0 Workstation
Windows NT 4.0 Server
Windows NT 4.0 Terminal Server Edition
Windows NT 4.0 Enterprise Server
Windows 2000 Professional
Windows 2000 Server
Windows 2000 Advanced Server
Windows 2000 Datacenter Server
Windows XP Home Edition
Windows XP Professional
Windows XP 64-Bit Edition
Windows XP Tablet PC Edition
Windows XP Tablet PC Edition 2005
Windows XP Media Center Edition
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2004
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005
Windows Server 2003 Standard Edition
Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition
Windows Server 2003 64-Bit Enterprise Edition
Windows Server 2003 Datacenter Edition
Windows Server 2003 Web Edition
Windows Small Business Server 2003 Standard Edition
Windows Small Business Server 2003 Premium Edition
Windows Server 2003 R2 Standard Edition
Windows Server 2003 R2 Enterprise Edition
Windows Server 2003 R2 64-Bit Enterprise Edition
Windows Server 2003 R2 Datacenter Edition
Windows Server 2003 R2 Web Edition
Windows Small Business Server 2003 R2 Standard Edition
Windows Small Business Server 2003 R2 Premium Edition

by georgev

Windows for Workgroups Version 3.0 was bad
Windows for Workgroups 3.11 good
Small business server was released on NT 3.1 and NT 4.0 as well as NT 4.5 .

But, The original post is about Desktop not Server operating systems. None of the above truely apply.
The list can be shortened, by considering base versions - extensions as options. Thus XP, XP-SP1, while not Tablet, Mutimedia, etc. They being extensions.
My reasoning that many Microsoft products were made useable in the revision - not the original release. ( WFW-3.0 vs WFW-3.11, W98 vs W98-SP2, SBS-4.0 vs SBS-4.5, etc )

by greytech

I started with main memory of 8Kb, yes bits not 8KB nickel delay line memory, 250KB magnetic drum, paper tape input and all valve(tubes for US readers) electronics in '63. My wife calls me a newbie as she started programming in '59. Sold Intel 4004s in '71, 8008 in '72, 8080 in '73 all with Intel development kits SIM401, SIM801 then into Intellec 80's. First HD on an Intel development system for me was in '78, a 5MB DRI (Data Recording Instruments) later to be absorbed into ICL.

CP/M and DOS 1.0 had little to choose between them DOS 2.0 allowed for HDD with a few other enhancements the rest has been said.

Yes I did wear Tweed but not 'til much later when I came out of management and went back to being a techie in the late '80s, because it was more interesting and less political.

by jerryfr

From what I see here, I don't think your premise is valid. Everyone has a different chronology of releases.Then which were good and which were bad? Pure opinion. Besides, hey, they may get 2 in a row right.

I'd have a hard time making a business case for Vista. I can hear the controllers now:
'We have to go through that upgrading again?'
'You technogeeks just want another new toy'
'How much? That's just the software?'
'Business is good, computers/network are finally stable, everybody is trained, get out of my office or I will kill you.'

by agent 77

That sounds EXACTLY like what I am going to say to the first person who tells me I need Vista

by jerryfr

All those unfortunate non-computer types who couldn't give a rat's butt about Vista and have just managed get comfy with Win2K or XP are now going to have to learn new Office releases, etc etc.
The net will be down 1/2 the time and their now too small PCs will hang, reboot or just drag along because they only have 1 gig of RAM. Meanwhile no work gets done.
But the icons fade in and out and the new screen savers are incredible! Not to mention virtualization and multi-tasking.

by tony hopkinson

The number of people I talked to who plugged their PC into broadband to download a firewall, av etc.
Poor buggers had a back door in their system before they could create a directory to save the download.
I want a hardware firewall, keep meaning to get sorted, but the missus spends my money on 'important' things.
I'm well out of date on the admin side, so if Santa is nice to me I'll be posting my first questions in January, after liberal use of google of course.

Sygate only causes me two problems, I have to allow my avg virus scanner to check for updates every time it updates (exe changes). Also it does not work too well with profiles, who ever logs on first get's it in their intray.

by g-man_863

I would love to see stats on what percent of new Windows versions and upgrades are purchased ?a la carte? (on a stand-alone CD), versus the percentage of licenses that are bundled with the purchase of a new PC. My guess is that the percentage of stand-alone upgrades sold is 5% or less.

As an example, the only time I have ever purchased an upgrade of Windows was to jump from XP Home to XP Pro ? strictly due to my having to occasionally tie in to my employer?s network via VPN to solve emergency issues. In addition, I know of one local software company whose dozens of help desk employees use hand-me-down PCs from other departments ? most of which are running 98SE or 2000 --with no problems at all.

The only way Microsoft seems able to get a new version of Windows into the pipeline is the same way I have purchased all my other upgrades -- by forcing PC manufacturers to include it in the OEM bundle on new systems. As soon as Vista officially launches, it will be all but impossible to get XP on a new system ? even from BTO companies such as Dell and Systemax.

It would be nice if Microsoft took the same approach as Intel does on CPUs: Price the new Vista as a top-shelf item, and still offer the older XP at a greatly reduced price for at least a year or two. Doing this could actually improve Microsoft?s earnings: It would drop the price of entry-level PCs (making a first or additional PC more affordable for lower income households, schools, etc) and would make Linux a less attractive option for average (non-geek) users.

by ole man

We had only ONE choice.....BS 1.0, and the only screens we had to look at was the screens on the windows, not the Windows on the screens.
We just shot pirates and locked up burglars, and if we got a virus we just went to the doctor, we didn't have to pay a ransome.

by tweten

"I have a pirated copy (on a CD somewhere, I think) , I could send it to you and cc Microsoft and MS would ignore us."

Thats Got to be the best line I've heard in a while
thanks for the laugh

by agent 77

do you remember the first time you heard of a "mouse"..... hahahahahahaha

before that we had to type uphill both ways to get there

by titssni

Ole Man,

Same here, Still do today just using more sophisticated solutions because they got smarters and started running on Windows and was multi-tasking - lol.

What can I say, I miss DOS :-(

The Suite

by sir_cheats_alot

...mostly...with a very small exception.

i missed windows 1,2,3, win95 a,c,and d, as well as every DOS before 6 so i can't really offer a opinion on them. i do have dos 6.22 somewhere around here. haven't played with the other DOSs. windows 3.1 was ok.. not great but still ok
Win95 hey, a taskbar..
win95b cool, USB support( at this point it still ran pretty good.)
Windos XP SP2 - great ATTEMPT at security. as far as actually achieving it.. they fell short...I find myself wondering; "when are they releasing sp3?" Lesson here? the only secure PC is one NOT connected to any network that happens to have internet access.
they kinda shot themselves in the foot when they tried passing off WGA as a security update. many costumers left for linux because of it *raises his hand* Kubuntu and ubuntu are great for beginners by the way. WGA kinda stepped on my last nerve.

by kiltie

You had better not venture out on the Glaswegan streets late at night, unless your Ma' can sew?

*** Stitch that!!!"

:) ;-)

hehe

by linuxland

What cracks me up the most is that, with out UNIX you would all still be using pad and pencil. You wouldn?t even have a digital calculator. Which brings us to LINUX not a duck, but a Mighty Penguin? ?Son of UNIX? Windows came way later. And for your timeline there was a Windows 1.1. Bill Gates worked for IBM on O/S2 long before, when Microsoft was just a dream. I also agree with an earlier post O/S2 Warp (or any version of O/S2) Blew windows out the door. I have been using Linux since it came out. I use
SUSE Linux and Windows XP. I like XP it nice however Linux is far superior. It?s a
OS superior to anything windows has to offer. I liked NT when it was out. And just to set the record straight on the first Post, DOS is an OS. Windows up to Win 95 was not. It was still a program running on DOS (that means it depended on DOS to run). So that changes the Good /Bad scores. I realize some of you are too young to remember things like this. It was a fancy GUI for DOS. Bill Gates wanted a GUI like the MAC. This is one of the reasons average people will buy Windows over Linux. It?s the GUI, they say ?Linux is to hard to learn?. They can?t handle the ?Command Line principle? They want to click their mouse on and Icon. And the Mouse was developed by Apple Computers not Microsoft. I loved DOS, I miss its text base OS. Linux has many pretty GUI?s but it doesn?t depend on them. If you are an IT, professional. You owe it to yourselves to see what is out there and try them. You would be surprised. And if you find them to hard to learn. Go back to school. On an earlier post. Someone took a shot at MAC next time you go to a movie. All or most of the SFX you see on the screen, done on a MAC. George Lucas studios all the Graphic work is done on MAC. PIXAR and most of the rest MAC. I think Vista will do very well. Not because it good but because Microsoft says, you need this and your life will be easier. People want the next new gadget. They won?t be happy. But they will just keep looking. But they won?t find it. Its just bragging rights. They can say ?I have the new Vista on my new Computer? and I don?t have a life.

by agent 77

back when the pc first started to came around, there was IBM or Apple and the REAL computers ran UNIX. But the reality is, working from a command line is time consuming and requires way too much effort for those of us who need to accomplish something other than typing all day. So I say more power to easier operation.

But someone else said it best when they brought up the fact that every new PC will be advanced enough to run Vista, because thats the way the techo ball bounces.... We strive for better, stronger, faster....and that's the way it should be.

And the other point about M$ dropping support of XP...just their way of making sure the new stuff sells.

by drew

I'm sorry I didn't have time to read this ENTIRE thread, but everyone seems to be taking a lot of time replying with accusations of porn and made-up words. So with that- I'll get to the point.

First of all, based on atroon's original pattern post. I agree with your evaluations, but I don't know if I agree with your order. I wouldn't group Windows 98 with NT. That's simply off. Windows 95 and NT should technically be grouped, but when you count all the service packs- NT ends up with 98. For that reason, NT should be on its own, not grouped with 98.

WinME was pretty much 98SE with extra bugs. Oh yeah... where is your separation of 98 and 98SE? I definitely rate 98SE MUCH higher than 98.

I could probably go on for days with this, and add in some DOS 1.1 etc to boot, but that's totally unnecessary.

My real point is that we should judge Vista on its specs/capabilities/editions/etc. It'd be real nice to find a pattern, but come on, all of you who work in the real world know it's not that simple.

And I definitely think that MS overcomplicated the different editions of Vista. Most end users won't get it, but as IT folk- it's really not that tough.

Thoughts?

by seximexi

At Beislule Consulting, we have been testing the RC1 Vista for over 3 months now and find it no so easy to handle.
The way they organized the folders and somehow the way to access them is quiet annoying and it not so easy to understand the way "security" affects all the users.
It is also bothering that fairly new video cards are not "Vista compatible" and what outstands the most is the fact that when you try to move full folders from one partition to another the OS seems to lack the ability to move them completely and keeps asking you that the folders is not empty and gives you a popup window where you only have the option to skip or cancell, plus the option of doing the same for all the remaining files in the folders to move....
We found this last part incredibly annoying. Enough reason not to use the OS.

In other set of ideas, In the list of Operating Systems, Windows Server 2003 is missing... (another case of the infamous Windows Me?)

We believe Microsoft should be liable for selling Windows Me.... By far the most disgusting OS ever!

B Munoz
Beislule Consulting

by kiltie

They certainly wouldn't want the Press to be reminded of that OS, just prior to the release of Vista tee hee

Hey! They might even pay you to destroy the copy???

.... now there's a thought, M$ paying us.....

Nay.... never happen in a million years, the bean counters might even devise a way to put WGA on it, to raise revenue. (which they will be short of, after Vista's launch)

by agent 77

I'm quite sure that they will eventually get to the point they put WGA on every peice of code that ever came out of their people.

by 1seer79

Upgrade; pay more money; ooops...
doesn't work right...
sorry about that...

I don't see why we NEED a new operating
system every couple of years other
than to line pockets.

At the very least it could be a
little cheaper to upgrade.

by stevef611

Are you NUTS? Stupid? Criminally insane? The biggest beta release in computer history (through that date)? After 2 couple of dozen service releases it was fine. We stayed WFWG3.11 until well into 1996 before anything but test/demo machines were using 95. 98SE twice as stable. They are getting better. We should see a good stable OS directly out of the box the 2012ish.

by cbrown

Running 32bit Vista Ultimate RC2. Besides lack of driver support from 3rd party hardware, no problems. Preferred to XP.

by hatfira

I heard the same speech about valuse, hardware requirements, etc when XP first came out. People were saying, "Why upgrade to XP? 2000 does everything, and is smaller, faster, and has fewer hardware requirements!" Sound familiar?

It doesn't take THAT beefy a box to run Vista. Look at my other osts, and you'll see why I say that. The "reduced funtionality" you're talking about it principally the Aero interface, which most users (especially business) would be able to live without. For the NEEDED part of the OS, the specs are not bad for today's machines, and over the life cycle of the OS, they will become rudimentry, just as the specs for XP have become. Don't be surprised if the next OS comes in 64 bit only and will want dual cores, and of course people will be up-in-arms about the "outrageous" hardware specs. IT just isn't as big a deal as everyone makes it out to be.

I don't see a large percentage changing harware for Vista either, but that's because they won't HAVE to. All thy may need to do is up the amount of RAM (similar to dozens of XP rollouts I have done) and go about their merry lives. Wen they DO replace the whole system, the Aero interface and all the otehr candy will be there waitinf for them, and they won't have to lift a finger to incorporate it.

As far as the thrid party stuff goes, MS already goes above and beyond to support thousands of devices it doesnt HAVE to. They could force the harware manufacturers to come up with new drivers, and force the consumer to go to eah of these manufactuers to get them, but they don't. Most of what you have will work, and there is the ability to create your own installation of Vista and include any drivers you need, so when you reinstall Vista, you will have them avaiable.

If Linux makes big in-roads from Vista, then I'm all for it. That's the way the Free Market Enterprise should be. But I want to to be because they built the better mousetrap and not because people are sewing the stinky cheese of misinformation.

by ole man

Is NOT MIS-information, but information that you conveniently omitt about Microsoft's obtrusive, monopolistic, abusive, intolerable EULA. Here is a link to a Comparison the GPL (free software agreement) to one of Microsoft's EULAs for anyone interested: http://72.14.203.104/search?q=cache:jIyh_0_YnHsJ:www.cyber.com.au/cyber/about/comparing_the_gpl_to_eula.pdf+Microsoft+EULA&hl=en&gl=us&ct=clnk&cd=5
This is not to debate your information (I did not say your statements are untrue, just adding a little information that seems to be omitted as "stinky cheese of misinformation".
Why not tell the whole story when spinning a tale?

by cbrown

The business world is not exactly ready to spend some money... but they should. There way behind the times. Everyone working IT knows we get the short end of the money stick, but businesses could benefit from better systems.

The reqs to run Vista are in line with current computer trends. At least Apple has it right with their method--they just dont sell anything older than a year or two. If businesses would keep up with current hardware then they wouldn't have to spend so much to keep up. Besides, if your company has a few hundred machines, a smart IT manager would have a contract with Dell or HP anyway, and you'll be rolling in new pc's each quarter.

It's funny, because corporate America will complain about lack of security, then complain when they have to purchase a new product to get it. Thats business.

by greytech

Whether Vista is good or bad is almost irrelevant. It will be part of the scene. What part, will depend on where you are looking. If it is the corporate world where user management, upgrades, security and cost per head are important issues, I see more thin clients, more specialised desktops and more Linux servers but still Microsoft will dominate due to inertia.

In the small business and home user arena (which is about half the market in units) Vista will dominate until the hardware manufacturers see Linux as a significant part of the market to produce drivers for it as standard. This will take more than Ubuntu in its present form. Better GUI than Gnome or KDE and setups of all products, software and hardware, to be as easy as in XP will be a pre-requisite.

by mtbandit

Do you recall WHY it was called a Winchester disk?

Actually, I've heard two stories, possibly related. One was that the first Winchester cabinet consisted of dual 30MB platters and the lead developer was a gun enthusiast (Winchester 30-30, of course).

The other tale is that it was developed at IBM's Winchester, England laboratory.

Unfortunately I don't recall which one's true. Maybe both...

by gm1cusnr

I'd overheard(long ago...and far, far away...)That the Company name WAS 'Winchesrter' and were out of are you ready for this... - Hartford, Conn. USA - However, I never thought to check and see if that was correct. To busy trying to save the world - one Byte at a time.

by cs

I remember when they invented 8 inch floppy disks that held 128K of data. A lot easier than paper tape so data input and storage ...

by kiltie

Most of those looking at Linux instead of Vista, are us techies.

M$ pooh-poohs that, think we are a just a few geeks.

But they are wrong, we also happen to be IT consultants, IT managers and the like. What we have is influence.
We will be recommending various Linux options to our customers, be they in the consumer marker, or in business. we'll even demo a few good free ones.
Once they see what Linux can do nowadays, and then start looking at REAL COLD HARD facts, such as [i]MONEY[/i], against what performance improvements there are(nt), they will be voting with their wallets.

and that is just the beginning, 'cos word will spread......

by ole man

Even if every word you say is true (which it is not), you don't even mention Microsoft's abusive intolerable Naxi-like EULA which anyone who takes the time to read MUST be incensed about.
Another simple little fact omitted from your tirade is the fact that Vista will cost an arm and a leg while Linux is either free or practically free so costs nothing or practically nothing to try and verify if what you say about it is correct. On the other hand, the Apple you mention is at least cost competetive, if not less expensive. I suppose you believe all the reports of the capabilities of Linux and Apple are just liars or fools, eh? That would include all the reports of Vista's hardware and power problems and lack of drivers ?
Lotta liars and fools out there?

by 73-cvr

I tried and tried to figure out a way to create a 20 page single publisher newsletter. I tried the Microsoft web site for answers, nothing. I tried News groups posted questions, no answers. Finaly I looked for updates got several, none helped. I solved the problem in a strange way. I created a 20 page news letter in Publisher saved each page as page01, page02, page03, etc. Then I opened Word 97 and copied the first page created in Publisher to Word, then at the end of each page I pressed "enter" and held it down till I saw at least 20 page count in the task bar. Then I copied each page created in Publisher in order. Then I noticed that scrolling from page to page some of the clip art and word groups did not stay in place so, on each page I formatted them to lock in place. Now I can scroll up and down with everything staying in place.

Now I select every page in the Word 97 document and paste it into Publisher 97 (after I did the Publisher updates)and to my surprise it created a 20 page single document. What a surprise. I tried to add a page within Publisher and could not find a way.

by tony hopkinson

Business requirements override them. MS's selling and marketing points is accessibility not security. The latter has been an after thought.

MS opened all their doors (and windows :D )and then put guards on them when they discovered they weren't the only people going through them.
nix based system close all the doors and then only allow people in the admin says can come in.
Also getting in doesn't mean you can do anything. Think of 'nix based systems as always running in vista's protected mode only better, because it was designed like that from the ground up.

So your contention is wrong.

by tony hopkinson

In business security on individual workstations is not a priority, on the boundaries it's extremely important and usually hardware.
If you've got a good perimeter then running 95/98 inside it doesn't matter does it.
No to mention most of the script kiddie stuff doesn't work on it any more.
Most of the added features on workstations where a w/p, worksheet may be access, email etc in 95 and 98 are perfectly adequate for general business needs.

by tony hopkinson

LOL
Lots of scots, local pub had an england vs scotland new year's eve rugby game once, total carnage.
Still mates that evening, but during the game ]:)

by stewarta

I've been already developing apps on Vista and doing research into its network layers, and originally when I installed Vista Beta 2, I thought it was going to be a spectacular failure. However, their Release Candidates (1 and 2) more than make up for lost ground. Both contain great performance monitoring tools that let you know what your computer is really up to.

Vista is running on my 1.5GHz 512RAM IBM laptop very happily, possibly even faster than XP. It has some annoying features like the User Account Control and other security measures, but these can be turned off.

I would suggest that people try it first before saying its doomed. I've also tried Windows Server "Longhorn" and set up an Active Directory domain using it... few bugs still, but a lot of promise and very easy to deploy.

by mtbandit

Remember, Windows ME was put out for one reason only: appeasement.

Win98 was touted as the last DOS-based Windows; Windows 2000, running on the NT kernel, was going to be the ONLY version of Windows released for use by home and business. I remember predicting at the time that they would back off that claim and release a home version if only to keep from losing the home market. the hue and cry was loud and insistent enough that Me was released somewhat quietly and without any fanfare a few months after Win2k. In fact, I recall that I didn't even hear about it until after it was released. It was a quick and dirty (REALLY dirty) "update" of Win98 in which, among other things, they remove some networking support in order to discourage businesses from using that instead of Win2k. It worked for us. We held onto Win98 until XP was released.

XP was the first version of Windows I felt totally comfortable and content with. I disliked NT and 2000 because it was hard to find things, and I didn't like 9x because they were too unstable. XP was the first time MS got the useability of the 9x series blended well with the workhorse nature and stability of NT/2000. My co-workers were AMAZED to hear me say "I like this..." (being a Netware engineer, it's been pretty much my schtick that nothing Redmond produced was any good).

by helpusobiwan

It isn't surprising that DRI* CP/M-86 was better. It was DRI's port of the popular CP/M series for the 8086/88 chip. But DRI wouldn't sell all the rights for pennies so Microsoft contracted with a fella across town to port an older CP/M to the 8086/88 and Microsoft sold that to IBM instead. So IBM got beef instead of filet mignon. The whole sordid history is laid out here (http://www.joewein.de/dri.html).

I am glad to see that Microsoft was later forced to cough up a few bucks ... probably a bittersweet victory of sorts for Gary Kildall ... especially after Microsoft had all the hard evidence destroyed (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2003/05/22/sco_pulps_calderams_trial_archives/). As Sir Walter Scott said, "Oh what tangled webs we weave ..."

* DRI = Digital Research Inc

by beowulf_cam

Stone box with a little bird pecking out bits and bytes on a stone HDD...hampster or other rodent providing power. Mainframes with small chimps using an abacus in a large box... To upgrade your O/S you get a smarter chimp... my mind was warped by the Flintstones when I was a child.

by titssni

Deadly Ernest,

I have been looking at your arguments and they are lacking a broader vision. What if you business model requires you to have access to the medias needed for a Media Player system?

Some companies do provide media and other such contents for their employees as a part of their business model.

Quote "It is extremely rare for an office situation to need the media playing capability or to have video conferencing at the desk. So why build an OS around such capabilities, because you're a fool trying to sell eye candy on the marketing hype again."
Are you for real?
What era are you living in?
With companies providing video conferencing at the desktop levels on PCs and communications devices you're saying what?
LOL.

One thing I notice with most of the posts is, everyone has vast experiences in many OS but NOT in many work environments. Vista is providing a wider array of resources for EVERY business in one install and that may be a plus or minus for your business model.

If it isn't, then so be it, pick what is suitable for you and run with it. Microsoft needs to stop trying to please everyone and just stick to a version for consumers and 2 at most for businesses.

We're thinking too narrow minded on the issue. I have seen a few sensible posts who hit specific issues on the head. Those are the people who will move ahead and be successful in their adoption and deployments.

The Suite

by deadly ernest

and most have general Internet access available to their entire work force. Having it restricted to only a few is a rare practice now days. And the most common use by general staff I've seen, is for viewing video.

by beowulf_cam

I provide IT support for Regional Government - including Public Health and Social Services. A lot of information they receive is in video file format which is played with a Media Player. They also use Media Player to present information on laptops and projectors. This was also true when I worked in the private sector.

You need to widen your horizons before you make blanket statements about what you need and do not need in an office environment. Even some sales tools need Media Players. Don't go through your career wearing blinkers!

There is a lot of interesting software out there and you limit your solutions and usefulness without considering all options - even those that may seem at first glance to be fatuous.

We also try to avoid being IT cops. Either you trust your staff to do their jobs or you don't. Banning certain products and software can demoralise staff and poison the work environment - which lowers productivity.

We let them play games in breaks and on lunch. If the work isn't done -- it WILL come back on the staff. Hire the right people and try avoid an oppressive corporate culture. We found that staff are willing to work harder and go the extra mile when they feel trusted and not oppressed.

by titssni

/me sets access permissons for BluTiger to technical, no porn sites, pics, files or adult contents, also sets access to a wider array of technical resources and turns on Parental control for his profile/account.

User is given permissions to access system 28hrs (yep, he needs more hours) a day to try and catch up to the techie world.

There you go BluTiger, there's still a chance to catch up.

Steve, you're bad man.
LMAO

by titssni

I have to say that as a personal beta tester over the past 16 months I have adopted and is using Vista in production. When it hits RTM I will be moving all my systems (except my tablet) to Vista.

I was never fond of people who speak of OSs without hands on knowledge and so I will leave things as is. Unless you do you due diligence, system reviews and risk assessments, then you won't know the benefits or the pros and cons. I know people who speak very badly of Vista because they are trying to run it in a PIII with 256MB of RAM and a 32MB video card. C'mon now, does that do you justice much less the OS :-)?

Oh, by the way, don't say anything about something you have no personal experience in. It doesn't sit well with us "real techs".

Vista will be a drastic change for every PC user, novice or professional and if you're waiting till final release then your logic is weak. Even at RC2 you can and will still get the most out of the OS experience.

The Suite

by ole man

Vista will sell prienstalled on many computers, so it will not be DOA. Plenty of inexperienced and uneducated (computer-wise) people will purchase new computers unaware of Microsoft's monopolistic, abusive EULA (well hidden until they start to use their computer, and then they won't read it, just click "I agree" so they can try their new computer). They still won't be aware of what is contained in the EULA until they have a problem and are told to "read your EULA".
That is why Windows became the most popular system worldwide. It would run on almost any hardware and was reasonably priced (compared to Vista). It had a GUI and mouse capabilities and was treated like "shareware" by Microsoft to insure it's adoption. Computers were new to most people and they knew most people would pay for it eventually if they learned how to use it. Most new users didn't even know what an EULA was or bother to read it or find out.
When the market was saturated (Microsoft on about 90% of computers worldwide), and their revenue started dwindling, it was time to start squeezing their no longer "customers", now "users". That's when they implemented "activation" for XP. It's been a downhill slide since then....went from "activation" to "trusted computing" to "WGA" and now to "Vista" with all their "crap" built in (including "DRM" starting with XP SP/2).
Here's my rating. I use two groups.
Pre Windows XP.......Microsoft= Good, at least they aparently tried to make the best software they were capable of for their "customers" and charged a reasonable to expensive price.
Post Windows XP......Microsoft= bad to worse, tried to put the screws to their "users" (no longer dignified as customers) any way they can. Don't give two whoops about product quality, it's all about $$$$$$$$ and controlling the world. Their ambitions are to own or control the internet and all computers and recieve payment from every one that uses the internet or their computer.

by gm1cusnr

And I thought I was old! OK I admit: 'I'm not worthy, I'm not worthy, I'm not worthy,...

by gm1cusnr

As I read through all the great Replies, Ideas, Thoughts, ect. - it occured to me: Has ANYONE thought of the HISTORY we're Living through, and Creating with this stuff? Lot of changes, both good and bad, Advances, and Backsteps all along the way.
I wonder how Archimedes, Da Vinci, Ol' Ben Franklin, or Thomas Edison, et;al, would've handled informational advances of this kind.
I'm sooo lucky to be here at this time!
<...I think>

by titssni

Very well said. I thank the father's, developers and coders of the past and for the people like Bill Gates who helped (in whatever way) to present us with such a nice GUI system to work, play, bitch and moan at. The guys took a technology and ran with it and look at how he's being playa hated for it. Today we still have such people in our midst and close to home, do we bitch and moan at em too :-).

We must salute those of the past and thank them for whatever they did in any way they did it. Kudos to Steve Jobs and the Linux/Unix world as well.

The Suite
(I contribute to these great developments by testing AND giving feedback and comments on how to make them better).
What do you do to help out the development and growth of these products and solutions?

by tcat375

Why can't Microsoft get it right the first time? Windows XP MCE/Windows Xp has been the biggest pain in the OS computer market ever. It has more holes in it than the best Swiss cheese and I am tried of all of those security patches and upgrades just to make it work. Redmond get a clue, make a staple OS system that does not suck up 3 gigs of hard drive space just to work! Does anyone in Microsoft know how to write simple and effective code? I guess not!

by barabbas

Example: I once used an old Win95 Pentium I clone in and ATX form factor at work as a standalone scientific data station to do gas sampling. The software was a custom VB4 front end. I wanted to upgrade to Win98 so I could run VB5 and take advantage of ActiveX. I did the install, without a problem and then, daring fate, swapped the hard drive into a still old, but newer Compaq Deskpro 533. Win98 woke up to the proprietary Compaq hardware and asked for the Win98 CD just one time. It then canvased the system and installed all the necessary drivers to get up and running without one request for human intervention. It even rebooted itself twice. how do you beat that? And I had similar positive experiences with Win2k.