Islam is evil, terrorism is its logical consequence
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Is something that I never needed until the Evolution Lie thread came along and I started researching around some aspects of cosmology. Generally, as with Absolutely, reason works and if I can't prove or disprove something then I'll draw whatever conclusions I can from whatever evidence that I have and go on my way. Thus far, I had not needed faith and had not needed any sort of paranormal/religious/UFO crutch to explain anything.
Then I came across a phenomenon called "Quantized Red-Shift" and I now desparately need that science proves that it is an artifact with a reason other than the most current one - that the entire universe is centred on our Galaxy. That [b]must[/b] not be allowed - that the entire universe is a backdrop for our species.
But, I have faith that they'll come through.
re-evalute the big bang theory??
Theories are only accurate in so far as they give a reason for the data we are observing. When data and theory disagree, it is not the data that is wrong, it is the theory.
If data and theory disagree then a more complete theory needs to be developed, one that is in agreement with 'all' the data.
What if when looking at the quantized redshift data, the evidence indicates that a major re-evaluation is needed for the expanding universe idea.
so in that case...are we or are we not the centre of the universe???
by absolutely
Wolfram, maker of some very popular math modeling software, concludes that "(n)o good explanation for how this effect could occur has been put forward."
Also, Setterfield, who is the first match Google provided me, states a very common but unproven assumption as if it as factual as macroevolution: "Setterfield: If redshifts come from an expanding cosmos, the measurements should be distributed smoothly, but they are not. They are showing up as clumps, or quantized groupings. Because the cosmos cannot be expanding in jumps..." It would be inconvenient, but not prohibited by any discoveries I know, that instead of a Big Bang the universe is supplied by many Periodic Bangs, with equal timing between them. Black holes in our universe are known to rotate, and if the matter and energy was (is?) from another universe on the opposite side of a black hole, it is reasonable at least to hypothesize that such a body would also be periodic.
For this last claim I make I'll have to ask our resident cosmological expert for verification, but I believe that if our galaxy were the center of the universe, it would be expected to have more intensity, meaning more stars of higher temperature and density, than what is observed.
Panther, I'll re-evaluate the assumption of universal expansion when I have a good reason, not for one unexpected measurement that can be explained with a variety of simpler modifications to the Big Bang Theory.
Jelli, your downhill comment was not clear to me, but I take it to be an echo of Thomas Jefferson's warning of the tendency of government power to expand, absent active involvement of the citizens to prevent that. It is easier to passively watch the government grow than to take responsibility for preventing it, but that way leads to universal poverty via taxes on success.
by jellimonsta
I agree with the sentiment regarding the reluctance of any action for which a person complains Absolutely.
Reminds me of the story of the old friends on the front porch, you know that one?
Two old friends (Bill and John) are sitting on Bill's front porch. They just recently reacquainted after a number of years apart and Bill has his trusty old hound 'Buster' on the porch at his feet.
Every few minutes Buster would let out a startling howl as if in pain. After 3 or so of these incidents, John inquires of Bill as to the reason of Buster?s outbursts.
?Oh, he?s just laying on a rusty nail and it hurts his stomach? replied Bill. ?Why doesn?t he get up and move?? asked John.
To which Bill replied ?Well, it doesn?t hurt THAT much?.
by john.a.wills
by levannah44
Neil, Panther, Absolutely, I'll apologise in advance, but I'm just about to knock you all for a sixer!
Yes, friends, our galaxy, the Milky Way, IS the centre of the universe!
And if you lived on a planet in the Andromeda galaxy, you could say the same thing.
Or the Whirlpool galaxy . . . or Centaurus A . . . or the Sombrero . . . you get my drift?
That's exactly what the red shift thing [quantized or not] is all about! Every galaxy is moving away from every other galaxy, which of course makes the galaxy we are on appear to be at the centre.
And because we're expanding into 'nothingness', it will always remain so.
Ooohhh, sorry guys. I couldn't help that! Make you feel any better now?
The anomaly or whatever for which I need an explanation is the plotting of redshifts of distant objects appears to demonstrate that they don't occur in a spectrum of values but rather in discrete quanta. The only explanation seems to be that the distribution of galaxies in the universe - if redshift=distance - is in shells centred on our galaxy.
I'll find the original reference when I'm back at work.
Neil
by absolutely
by levannah44
I know where you were coming from Neil. The answer's still the same, and for the same reasons.
Why? Because the universe is a pretty big place!
PS: What the hell are red shifts doing in the middle of Islam and terrorism??!!
Yes. I'm taking the figures with a pinch of salt, as well. The reason I posted here was following someone's point about faith in science and [b]that[/b] is something that I don't have any more than faith in anything else.
It was just that the easiest explanation of the redshifts pattern - assuming nothing radically changed in the interpretation - was concentric shells of galaxies, centred on ours.
Very badly, I just want that proven [b]not[/b] to be the case! We, as a species, are not (yet?) worthy to be the centre of anything but concern! :D
If I have faith then the next step is superstition and then the search for "something more".
Neil :D
by generalist
Given the way some of the 'faithful' have acted over the centuries, not having faith in faith is a very logical conclusion to make.
On the other hand, I find it illogical to consider a religion to be universally false because of the actions of some of its members. This is especially true when those actions are filtered through the media, which finds that bad news sells more than good news.
You might want to do some research before claiming that reasoning is not part of nor compatible with the religous experience. All that is needed is one example to the contrary and your logic falls apart.
by absolutely
by sleepin'dawg
You have to consider the mindset of these people, who place very little value on human life, theirs or that of others. Signs of mercy are considered signs of weaknesses. Any weakness is to be exploited for furtherance of the faith. Further immigration of these people will only undermine our security and should be curtailed until the situation stabilizes and even then legislation should be put in place to return them from whence they came if any signs of further disturbances should arise. N.B.: I said [b]any signs[/b]. This should include the families of the perpetrators as well as the perps themselves. If these fanatics do not care for our system they should be made to realize that their acts will reflect upon not only themselves but also thei relatives. Lets see how long these animal can hide, undisclosed, within their communities after that.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by absolutely
by sleepin'dawg
You've nailed it square on the head.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by hs_
.. the whole post - I was referring to a contextual interpretation. So, for example: "And We have given you (mankind) power in the earth, and appointed for you therein livelihoods. Little give ye thanks!"(7:10) is a verse that 'applies' to the whole of humanity in the sense of describing a human pattern of behaviour or outlook. Whether one chooses to subscribe to that (or any other verse) is a matter of personal choice. After all the the Quran clearly states: "There is no compulsion in religion The right direction is henceforth distinct from error. And he who rejecteth false deities and believeth in Allah hath grasped a firm handhold which will never break. Allah is Hearer, Knower.(2:256). As a human being, it is up to me, or you, or anyone else to examine the evidence presented as a whole, and then choose or reject it. If I have chosen it, then that helps my understanding of the human condition. No-one can use Quranic scripture to force you to accept or live by anything. In fact, I will stand shoulder-to-shoulder with you to resist forceful compliance to any doctrine.
The following article probably does this subject better justice than I can : http://muslim-canada.org/elmasry.html
by absolutely
But I still do not agree that the words of the Quran, or any other book of mysticism, applies universally. They may contain passages that attempt to describe universal aspects of the human experience, but every reference to the uncertain, unprovable deities of each faith make universality impossible. Taking the first passage you quoted as an example: "And We have given you (mankind) power in the earth, and appointed for you therein livelihoods. Little give ye thanks!"(7:10)
In fact, nobody ever [b]gave[/b] me any power. The abilities that I have are all [b]learned[/b], through my effort and the instructions of those who taught me or provided example. And nobody "appointed" me therein a livelihood. I choose the work that is most profitable, within the options for which I'm qualified, according to my knowledge, training and experience. Your verse acknowledges the real fact that we work to obtain our livelihoods, but obscures that real fact by mentioning that fact only as an aside, in an insidious condemnation of humanity as ungrateful, to deities which, in fact, do not exist.
by hs_
Sorry for not posting in-line with your last post - I get a max limit message there ??
Anyhow - what an excellent response by you :) !
So what it comes down to in the end, is the basis upon which an individual builds their world view.
For some people this is a diety, for others something else, or nothing at all. In all instances, unfortunately, the best we can attain is a subjective understanding or belief. Objectively, we're limited by our senses or the extent of our instruments of exploration. All we can say truthfully and with integrity is something along the lines of "In my view,- blah". take it or leave it. But to go beyond that is to prescribe(force) a 'universal' compliance.
To relate this to the original subject : A person who believes, or not, in God/ pixies/ nothing/ something, is as valid as the next person. One cannot say that such people are somehow deficient in following what their perspective tells them is true. Otherwise, one would be just as guilty by maintaining that their own subjective perspective is the only 'universal truth' !
by hs_
For a muslim it is a mandated requirement to use reasoning (as well as reflection/ observation/ use of empirical data etc.) to develop their faith. For instance : "It (the Qur'an) is a Book We have sent down to you, full of blessing, so let people of intelligence ponder its Signs and take heed.(38:29)"
In any case, true faith has to be a 'state' arrived at through personal reasoning (or logical deduction ... e.g intelligent design discussions). Blind faith, on the other hand is something that we take take on by proxy - i.e not taking evaluative responsibility ourselves but subscribing to what others have said to be true.
I suggest that not everyone (myself included) is capable (or has the time or energy) to reason through the whole ontology ( we can work out parts of it ourselves). We therefore 'trust' experts in various fields, to fill-in the complete picture. The trick, I suppose is to seek out experts of integrity.
by hs_
One cannot excuse murderers of whatever persuasion or hue!
The recent atrocities in London (my home town, my local station-Aldgate !..) are just as despicable as any murders committed in the world against innocents - whether state-sponsored, corporate-sponsored, personal agenda or otherwise.
A good litmus test could be that "Godly people should not do un-godly things" - so for us to blame the Quran or Islam as the inspiration for warped minds is to follow the same myopic reasoning that murderers use when quoting scripture, whether it be the Conquistodores, the Spanish Inquisition or 'muslim' bombers in London.
by jdclyde
mix their remains in with pig blood.
Do NOT return the remains to their families.
How do you decide what is the remains of the bomber and what is the remains of the rest of the passengers?
Were we able to separate the remains then I would [b]feed[/b] them to pigs. But then, I'm not very nice! We've recently had anti-blast film applied to the windows of the office where I work. It sure sharpens the opinions!
by jdclyde
go for the family. Anyone ACCEPTS blood money for their family member being a camel F'n terroist should be sprayed with pig blood as well.
Give them a transfusion!
I still think the way is to put a mafia hit on them with pig blood coated bullets!
Not very PC or understanding, am I? Tough. Some people, the only way to stop them is to kill them BEFORE they kill you or anyone else.
Fact is, when caught they will be treated much better than they deserve, and way better than they would treat you or me if the roles were reversed.
by hs_
.. just like the angry rhetoric of the terrorists who jetison their human values when 'hit' by their "sworn enemies" - revenge at all costs. Let's give them as good they give. No! Better!!
But once we've vented our spleen and covered them and their families in pig's blood how further are we in addressing the problem ?
How are we demonstrating that our values are more noble. After all, their actions are borne of anger and desperation (Oh, please don't regurgitate the Murdoch headlines of divine sanction bullsh*t.)?
by jdclyde
While other than ranting and raving in a tech discussion board, I would never personally REALLY sanction the killing of the family.
The point is NOT to prove to irrational scum that you are better or more noble. It is to kill the enemy before the enemy kills you.
You can not reason with unreasonable people. Their lives are not made the worthless things they are because of the US, even if that is what they have been brainwashed to believe.
And before people blame Iraq, Bush, or the current US relations, this has been going on for DECADES. The problem is no one would step up and DEMAND that countries not support terrorists. It is time EVERYONE stands up and says no more. You support terrorists, you are a terrorist and WILL be delt with accordingly.
Anyone that pays out money to the bombers families must be treated as the enemy they are.
No more excuses.
by absolutely
by jardinier
I belong to several American Christian websites. They are extremely top heavy with evangelical fundamentalists.
Predominantly these people take the view that the extremist Muslims are the true Muslims. These "Christian" folk express such a hatred towards all Muslims that Muslim terrorists might well take "hate" lessons from them.
The big difference is that the fundamentalist Christians do not blow themselves up. I think this is a pity as they are, in my estimation, just as counter-productive to world peace as are the terrorists.
by absolutely
I haven't claimed that any other faith is superior, nor do I intend to do so. The issue at question is Islam versus peace, not Islam versus Christinanity.
Can you defend Islam on its own merits?
by hs_
If you are seriously enraged by evil and concerned about the world we live in, then any re-occuring pattern of evil behaviour needs to be condemned. If you are in the business of tirades against the "muslim", "islam" etc. labels then that's a different matter.
The "my label is better than your label" in the human psyche is our major collective handicap ! It blinds us and constricts our hearts.
by jdclyde
Just because someone else does something bad does not excuse bad behaviour. It just means that the other people should be held to the same standard.
Looking back at the history of other religions does NOT excuse ANYONES behaviour today. You learn from history so you don't ALLOW past mistakes to happen again, not to use them as justification.
It is NOT the Islamic extreme funimentalists "turn".
Just like it should NOT be accepted or condoned from ANY religion that advocates hate and/or death for anyone who gets in their way.
by hs_
Please provide a reference(s) in the Quran where muslims are commanded to carry out suicide acts in order to attain an orgy in heaven.
In the meantime ...
Suicide is expressly forbidden in the Quran :
"And DO NOT KILL YOURSELVES. Surely, Allah is Most Merciful to you. And whoever commits that through aggression and injustice, We shall cast him into the Fire, and that is easy for Allah"
(4:29-30)
---
"And spend of your substance in the cause of Allah, and make not your own hands contribute to (your) destruction; but do good; for Allah loveth those who do good. (2:195)
Instead, the Quran recommends justice and forgiveness, even when asserting one's right to self-defence :
"The blame is only against those who oppress men with wrongdoing and insolently transgress beyond bounds through the land, defying right and justice. For such there will be a chastisement grievous (in the Hereafter)" (42:42).
---
"O ye who believe! Remain steadfast for Allah, bearing witness to justice. Do not allow your hatred for others make you swerve to wrongdoing and turn you away from justice. Be just; that is closer to true piety."(5:8)
---
"Invite all to the way of your Lord with wisdom and beautiful preaching. And argue with them in ways that are best and most gracious . . .
And if you punish,let your punishment be proportional to the wrong that has been done to you. But if you show patience, that is indeed the best course. Be patient, for your patience is from God. And do not grieve over them, or distress yourself because of their plots. For God is with those who restrain themselves, and those who do good."(6:125-128)
---
"Oh you who believe! Stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to God, even against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be against rich or poor, for God can best protect both. Follow not the cravings of your hearts, lest you swerve, and if you distort justice or decline to do justice, verily God is well acquainted with all that you do."(4:135)
---
"The recompense for an injury is an injury equal thereto (in degree), but if a person forgives and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from God, for God loves not those who do wrong."
"But indeed if any do help and defend themselves after a wrong (done) to them, against such there is no cause of blame."
"The blame is only against those who oppress mankind, and wrongfully rebel in the earth. For such there is a painful doom."
"But indeed if any show patience and forgive, that would truly be an exercise of courageous will and resolution in the conduct of affairs."
(42:40-43)
---
"Goodness and evil are not equal. Repel evil with what is better. Then that person with whom there was hatred, may become your intimate friend! And no one will be granted such goodness except those who exercise patience and self-restraint, none but people of the greatest good fortune."
41:34-35)
by absolutely
Peaceful, [b]submissive[/b] people are not news. People going about their business is not a headline, it's only the minimum that is required of people. In the words of Chris Rock, "What do you want, a cookie? That's just what's expected of you!" Nobody expects terrorists to turn into do-gooders like Mother Teresa, only to mind their own business peacefully like the other 7 billion earthlings instead of attacking like cowards in places of commerce. It's obviously not that hard, ALL the rest of us are doing it! (Exceptions for criminals obviously, but even serial killers rarely claim divine sanction, making them that much better than Muslim terrorists.)
The Koran, in somee places, does prohibit violence against peaceful unbelievers. The problem is that it does that less emphatically and less repetitively than it demands murder. Behold:
"So, if they hold aloof from you and wage not war against you and offer you peace, Allah alloweth you no way against them." (4:90)
"O ye who believe!...say not unto one who offereth you peace [the salutation 'Peace be upon you']: 'Thou art not a believer,' seeking the chance profits of this life [so that ye may despoil him]. (4:94)
It would seem, then, that George W Bush and other leaders of western nations could simply have said publicly "Peace be upon you", clearly addressed to all Muslims, and since we had not been at war with any Muslim nations before we invaded Afghanistan, Al Qaeda would have been prohibited by the Koran from attacking -- ever again -- and that the Koran and Islam are indeed peaceful when practiced consistently. Unfortunately, the Koran itself is insonsistent.
"Allah forbiddeth you not, with regard to those who warred not against you on account of religion and drove you not out from your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them. Lo! Allah loveth the just dealers. Allah only forbiddeth you, with regard to those who war against you on account of religion and have driven you out from your homes and helped to drive you out, from making friends of them. Whosoever maketh friends of them -- [all] such are wrongdoers. (60:8-9)
These two verses begin by [b]allowing[/b], not requiring, extending justice to "those who warred not against you on account of religion and drove you not out from your homes". But in true bloodthirsty Islamic fashion, it concludes by forbidding Muslims from making friends of "those who war against you on account of religion and have driven you out from your homes and helped to drive you out". Is this verse the basis for the claim that IDF bullets imprinted "MADE IN THE USA" is equivalent to a joint war against Islam, declared by Israel and the USA alike? Although I disagree with selling arms of any kind to any foreign country, the armaments sold to Muslim nations makes this claim of favoritism ridiculous and hypocritical.
Justice [b]requires[/b] that only aggression be answered by violence. The Koran does not require justice. The Koran only [b]permits[/b] an exception to hatred of infidels in the case of infidels who deal peacefully with Muslims, but this passage does not [b]mandate[/b] justice toward peaceful infidels, it only permits justice, in context that looks to me like justice is an exception rather than the rule.
The Koran again:
"And if two parties of believers fall to fighting, then make peace among (sic) them. And if one party of them doeth wrong to the other, fight ye that which doeth wrong till it return unto the ordinance of Allah; then, if it return, make peace between them justly, and act equitably. Lo! Allah loveth the equitable.
"The believers are naught else than brothers. Therefore make peace between your brethren..." (49:9-10)
For these two verses, my source ([i]The Eternal Message of Muhammad[/i] by Abd al-Rahman Azzam) provides and illuminating footnote about the exact meaning of "doeth wrong". "'Doeth wrong': [i]wrong[/i] translates the Arabic [i]baghat[/i], which combines the meanings [i]do wrong[/i] and [i]commit aggression[/i]. Since I do not know the Arabic language, the author expects me to take this claim on faith. But I am not illiterate, and I do know that words with several distinct meanings are used to express only one of those meanings at any time. For example, the word "proceed" may be used as a verb meaning "to come forth from a source", or as a plural noun, to mean "the total amount brought in" (revenue). That was just the first English example to come to mind. My goal is not to establish the intended meaning of the Prophet, but to say that if peace was his goal, he expressed it very vaguely, inconsistently, and with less passion than he expressed the mandate for war in defense of the faith. If he was not a warmonger, his ineloquence makes him better suited to serve the cause of peace by being silent than to commit such obtuse and self-contradictory ramblings to paper. Compare the requirements to go to war with the occasional allowances for peace in the Koran, and it becomes abundantly clear that violence is required repeatedly, while peace toward infidels is only permitted, and in carefully limited scenarios.
by hs_
...still waiting for the quotes on the above.
Nevertheless, in your last post your statement "But in true bloodthirsty Islamic fashion ..." - gives a lot away about your current worldview. But I still regard you as my fellow human being carrying a precious soul (a/theist differences acknowledged) that is sacred. I still hold out hope that ( I believe it was Black Panther who alluded to this elsewhere ) light shines into that world view (in the nicest way - no aggression intended!)
If current stats. are to be believed, muslims make up ~ 1/5 of the world's population. That's 1 person in every 5. If war/bloodshed etc. were the major emphasis of the Quran, I suggest that 1 in 5 of every human would be trying to fulfill their religous obligation that way !
The Quran does sanction fighting when attacked. It also lays down clear guidance on the parameters and (as posted above) recommends forgiveness.
But, That does not imply some sort of blood-lust as you suggest. Did Europe not fight the German invasion ? What would you do if the Cubans invaded the US (not to mention laying crude pipelines back to Havanah - but that's for another thread)? Would you not defend your home and family ? Would you not kill the invaders ?
The Quran is a holistic guidance and therefore touches on major aspects of the human condition -Self-dence being one. To pick those instances out of context and present them as the main theme of the scripture is erronious at best, disingenuous at worst!
by absolutely
by hs_
What is it regarding a holistic / contextual reading that you don't(choose not to?) get??
Let me help you with the task :
1. "Dozens of virgins .." - Chapters 55 and 56 each contain one verse (go read) mentioning virgins (untouched) within a discourse on paradise and hell. contains 78 verses and contains 96 verses.
- Those humans who believe in an afterlife have a notion of heavan as a reward for a rightious life (including not killing innocent people/upholding justice/ spreading good-will and compassion/ being patient in adversity ... etc.), and hell as a punishment.
2. "Paradise to martyrs" : Paradise is promised to the righteous. If someone dies upholding justice / fighting oppression / defending their families and communities from unjust invasions .. then that makes them a martyr i.e. someone who get up from the couch to be counted fighting evil. For example, muslim commentators have described the NYC firefighters who died pulling bodies out of crumbling sky-scrapers as martyrs - a far cry from some sort of 'martyr cult'( i.e. someone who gets up one day and thinks "Hmm, I know I'll go and get myself killed for a place in paradise" - don't work that way!!
3. "Dying committing violence" : pretty much explained above. One could argue that a soldier in a battle who dies , died commiting violence ...
If by that you are trying to imply that commiting violence for it's own sake is a directive of the Quran - then that is an erroneous conclusion. The Quran's theme is to remind human beings of their collective origin and to where they're going. In the Quranic worldview, this life is transitory where a person must strive to lead a good and wholesome life in safety and peace. It urgers muslims to strive (jihad in Arabic) against their egos and in self defence if threatened.
------------
Wishing you a safe and pleasant weekend.
by absolutely
Now that hsheik has admitted that the Koran [b]does[/b] promise Paradise to killers (as long as they kill "to defend Islam" or "to defend Muslims" or "to defend locations important to the Prophet's life" or...), and that 12 virgins [b]are[/b] promised to all the (male?) inhabitants of Paradise, we can move onto the alleged theme of the Koran.
"The Quran's theme is to remind human beings of their collective origin and to where they're going."
I'm not interested in the collective. I'm interested in myself, and to the extent that I value them, my acquaintances. The rest of the world is only my backdrop.
"In the Quranic worldview, this life is transitory where a person must strive to lead a good and wholesome life in safety and peace. It urgers muslims to strive (jihad in Arabic) against their egos and in self defence if threatened."
Does it urge Muslims to also strive against the egos of others, or to live and let even those they deem "egotistical" live according to their consciences? How many of the verses that use the word jihad imply war or murder? How many do not? How many verses [b]demand[/b] that Muslims take up the sword for their faith? How many distinct types of situations require Muslims to kill? In how many distinct scenarios are Muslims [b]required, not just allowed,[/b] to coexist peacefully with non-Muslims, the answer to which should address the very unclear preference over other infidels reserved by the Koran to other sons and daughters of Abraham, and other believers in the god of Moses, and to believers that Jesus was in fact the deity incarnate.
by jdclyde
[i]"someone who gets up one day and thinks "Hmm, I know I'll go and get myself killed for a place in paradise" - don't work that way!![/i]
Isn't that exactly what was done with both the bombing of the trade center AND the planes crashing into it?
They were defending themselves from the civilians from all over the world that worked in those buildings? That is a bunch of BS and you know it.
Suiced bombers hoping on a crowded bus? These people were NOT attacking them, so they didn't need to defend themselves. More BS.
Blowing up a disco?
Setting off bombs in Britan?
Blowing up the train in Spain?
All the work of cowards that attack people that have nothing to do with anything in the bombers lives, and they mean nothing to the bombers.
And if dozens of virgins isn't an orgy, what is? Most guys in North America are content to fantisize about TWO women. Dozens? Lets here if for womens rights in the middle east? Or don't they count either?
by hs_
I'm disappointed that you resort to mis-representing my posts ( as you've done with your selective quotes from the Quran ) - for example the use of parentheses at the start of points 1,2,& 3 in my previous post mean that I was quoting your (erroneous) assertions, before responding to them. I suppose your choice of title for this discussion is a give-away of your paradigm. It detracts from the otherwise generally honest discussions within TR.
If you re-read my posts in this thread, it is very clear (unless one tries very hard to warp the meaning) that the Quran teaches the following :
1. Human life is sacrosanct.
2. A Human Being's prime duty is to be righteous - (be truthful / strive against one's own ego / promote peace and justice for ALL. etc.).
3. There is no compulsion in one's way of life- each Human Being is free to choose their own way.
4. The taking of any innocent Human life is prohibited.
----
I sincerely wish you well and hope that your heart is illuminated. Peace.
----
by hs_
Those who perpetrated these acts do so out of anger and frustration at real and perceived injustices (i.e. not prompted by a directive to commit acts of violence in return for an orgy)!
Their actions are WRONG and are severely condemned by all Muslims who understand and live by the Quran.
I completely agree with your 'Never excuse bad behaviour' post.
by jdclyde
I understand how this must be hard to be patient with so many people that truely do not understand what it is to be Muslim, and have wrapped every bad sterio-type into what they see. Between the 7/eleven jokes and the 911 terrorist, it isn't a pretty picture that is painted.
To then have this distorted mental image held up as an example of what it is to be muslim would have to be painful to a TRUE muslim. I get similar reactions to the many anti-christian posts.
I try to always make a point of saying it is the fundimental extremists that are the problem, not muslims in general.
The problem with crediblitiy for muslims in general that I HAVE seen is when something happens (bombing somewhere) and they show people in the middle east dancing in the streets. This is what the world sees and until muslims rise up in force and stop this bad behavior that makes them ALL look like blood thirsty savages, they will continue to look like blood thirsty savages.
The desicration of the contract workers that were burnt and hung from that bridge after being dragged through the streets, while people around danced with joy IS what much of the world sees.
A sad thing, a sad day. I wish you well.
by levannah44
Ouch! That's all pretty tough stuff, JD. However, while I have read the Qu'ran (in English, let it be said, as I don't speak Arabic) it's got to be remembered that, like the Bible, the Qu'ran can be interpreted in various ways, probably depending on the Imam doing the interpreting, I'd guess.
The Qu'ran definitely promotes peaceful co-existence with ones' neighbours, no killing, other than in self defence, and a whole heap of other things we (of the west) also believe in.
What has to be remembered is that SOME Muslims, for their own reasons or whatever, have taken some of the Qu'ran's teachings and completely turned them on their head, wilfully misinterpreting these teachings for their own ends. They are NOT true Muslims, but instead ISLAMISTS, which is something entirely different.
The vast majority of real Muslims, like probably 90% or 95%, are peaceful, law-abiding, Qu'ran observing citizens of their country who just want to get on with their lives, thank-you very much, and have nothing whatsoever to do with any violence, the same as you and I.
Okay, I didn't like 9/11 either, or Bali, or Madrid or London or any of the other places where violent acts of so-called 'retaliation' have taken place. They don't get anyone anywhere fast.
Just remember, though, it's only a very tiny minority of misguided Muslims -- sorry, ISLAMISTS -- who are giving such a bad name to the rest, just like fundamentalists of any kind do anywhere in the world.
Unfortunately, it's always the innocents who pay.
G
by jdclyde
Isn't that what I was saying (regardless of symantec)?
But the majority WILL continue to pay for the crimes of the few as long as they condon and allow such behavior to continue.
When they say the majority of muslims support Bin Ladin, it DOES blow that "whole respect for all life" and "commint no murder" thing right out the window, doesn't it? Do you think that there isn't a single truely faithful muslim that knows where he is hiding? What have THEY done to put that mad dog down?
In the mean time, yes it does look bad and there will be lots of race hate. We have a large muslim comunity in Michigan, and there have been incidents for years. Mostly between blacks and muslims, for a long time, even before 9/11. Not from that area so I don't know a lot of the history of it.
by absolutely
You quote from the Koran at least as [b]selectively[/b] as I. Some selection is necessary in order to meet the maximum character limits of these posts, but in a thread about the violence inherent in Islam, is it more dishonest to select those quotes that mention violence (my approach) or to entirely omit the many demands to kill infidels (your approach) in order to mis-represent Islam as a pacifist way of life?
I do not deny that a complete reading of the Koran shows "that the Quran teaches the following :
1. Human life is sacrosanct.
2. A Human Being's prime duty is to be righteous - (be truthful / strive against one's own ego / promote peace and justice for ALL. etc.).
3. There is no compulsion in one's way of life- each Human Being is free to choose their own way.
4. The taking of any innocent Human life is prohibited."
I'm even aware that your point 3 is nearly a direct quote of the Koran 2:256. However, it is absolutely false to pick those four themes and claim that they are the [b]only[/b] conclusions that might reasonably be drawn by a person who accepts that the words of the Koran are all literally true.
When I read the Koran, I did not get the impression that peace was its [b]primary[/b] theme. I admit not having made a precise tally of the message of all the verses in the Koran, but the impression it made on me is that the most important aspects of being a Muslim are that no Muslim has any [b]rights[/b], only duties, and that primary among those is charity to Muslims, with no limit to protect the rights of people to keep some of what they have earned, and that the second most-repeated duty is to defend Islam, which is under attack by all "pagans".
I challenge you to document evidence that any one of the peaceful themes you describe is repeated more frequently in the Koran than the theme of warring with infidels.
by absolutely
They read, and quote, from the same Koran. Obviously, there [b]are[/b] many verses in the Koran that demand killing infidels -- admittedly, under specific circumstances, not without liimit. I'm suspicious that the difference between a peaceful Muslim and a terrorist Muslim is based less on the interpretation of the Koran than on the interpretation of the world.
There are numerous verses in the Koran demanding that Christians be treated better than other pagans, so how can any verse in the Koran be construed to support the conclusion that US military support for the various theocratic Muslim nations of the Middle East is in any way invasive? I hypothesize that this distortion is possible because here in the United States we have the freedom to choose whether or not to be Christian, and that personal freedom itself is far less supported by the Koran than various duties to the Muslim collective, including but certainly not limited to warfare on behalf of that collective and its faith.
PS/FYI JD: At risk of being called pedantic, "Symantec" is a software company, "semantic" means "of or relating to meaning in language".
by hs_
Some articles and quotes giving the Islamic view on terrorism :
by oz_media
here's another site with views both positive and negative.
Take time to view the various sections on Islam and Iraqi Transition, you'll see opposing views from the people directly involved.
by absolutely
"Why We Are Losing Hearts and Minds
Our leaders have failed to answer the evil moral ideal of totalitarian Islam with a rational ideal of our own.
By Keith Lockitch
Four years into our "war on terror," the Iraqi insurgency is raging, with no apparent end to the new recruits eager to wage jihad against the West. Support for offensive action is fading among a disheartened American public, while the terrorists are growing in numbers and in boldness.
Where have our leaders gone wrong? What kind of leadership failure can demoralize a whole nation of honest, productive citizens, while leaving suicide murderers stirred to righteous action?
The power that inspires righteous action--and which, by its absence, breeds discouragement--is the power of moral idealism. What has brought us to our present state is our leaders' moral weakness in response to the jihadists' moral zeal.
Observe that what draws the recruits to terrorist cells is the advancement of their religion. They are fighting to impose the rule of Islam worldwide, whether others agree with its tenets or not. It is no accident that the Koran (or the Bible) is full of calls to inflict violence on the recalcitrant unbeliever. Obedience to God is his highest moral obligation, whether he can be rationally persuaded of this or not. The jihadists' eagerness to subjugate and kill is not a distortion of religion, but a consistent expression of it. It is an expression of the faith that establishing God's kingdom on earth is one?s sacred cause--a cause worth dying for and worth killing for.
A twisted moral ideal of this kind must not be tolerated; it must be denounced without compromise and answered by a rational moral ideal proclaimed with equal righteousness. America was founded on the principle of individual rights--the rights to "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness"--a principle which bars the initiation of force. One cannot properly defend America, or Western civilization more broadly, without acknowledging the basic conflict between faith and reason, force and freedom--without upholding as a moral ideal, not submission to religious authority, but the freedom to live according to one's own rational convictions and values.
But on the inseparable connection between freedom and reason, our leaders are silent.
Have they at least condemned the jihadists' evil religious motives, showing some of the moral confidence necessary to defend our lives? Clearly not. Consider that a mere two weeks after Sept. 11, with the ruins of the World Trade Towers still smoldering, our planned Afghanistan campaign, "Operation Infinite Justice," was renamed to appease Muslims protesting that only Allah can dispense "infinite justice." Our leaders continue to insist, preposterously, that religion is incidental to the terrorist threat, that the terrorists have "hijacked a great religion," that America is (at best) neutral on the issue of faith and force.
Unable to defend America intellectually, our leaders are unable to defend her militarily.
Have they asserted that the purpose of our military is not to better the world, but to secure our non-negotiable right to self-defense? No. Our military resources have been squandered, and too many of our brave soldiers sacrificed, in a futile quest to spread "democracy" around the globe. This "Forward Strategy of Freedom" rests on the absurd moral premise that protecting our freedom is legitimate only when we "compassionately" bring voting booths to nations mired in endless ethnic and sectarian conflict.
Have our leaders acted consistently against terrorist regimes? Consider our policy toward Iran, the primary state sponsor of terrorism. Refusing to identify Iran as the fatherland of Islamic totalitarianism, our President beseeched its Mullahs to join our war on terror. And he has consistently answered their chants of "Death to America" and their quest for nuclear weapons with negotiation and spineless diplomacy.
The reason the terrorists and their state sponsors are not demoralized is that our leaders have failed to demoralize them. Our leaders' words and actions have signaled that we are not as morally committed to our lives and freedom as the terrorists are to our destruction.
No one wants to fight and die for a hopeless cause. The jihadists will continue to be emboldened and to attract new recruits until they are convinced their goal is unachievable. They must see that we have the moral confidence to defend our lives--to answer their violence with an overwhelming military response, without pulling punches. They must see us willing to visit such crushing devastation on them that they fear us more than they fear Allah.
Our safety does indeed depend on winning "hearts and minds" among the supporters of totalitarian Islam: their hearts must be made to despair at the futility of their cause, and their minds must be convinced that any threat to our lives and freedom will bring them swift and certain doom.
The ideologues of totalitarian Islam have seized the power of moral idealism in the service of our destruction. It is time we reclaimed that power in defense of our freedom.
Keith Lockitch is a junior fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute in Irvine, CA. The Institute promotes the ideas of Ayn Rand--best-selling author of Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead and originator of the philosophy of Objectivism.
Copyright ? 2005 Ayn Rand? Institute. All rights reserved.
Op-eds, press releases and letters to the editor produced by the Ayn Rand Institute are submitted to hundreds of newspapers, radio stations and Web sites across the United States and abroad, and are made possible thanks to voluntary contributions.
If you would like to help support ARI's efforts, please make an online contribution at http://www.aynrand.org/support.
This release is copyrighted by the Ayn Rand Institute, and cannot be reprinted without permission except for non-commercial, self-study or educational purposes. We encourage you to forward this release to friends, family, associates or interested parties who would want to receive it for these purposes only. Any reproduction of this release must contain the above copyright notice. Those interested in reprinting or redistributing this release for any other purposes should contact media@aynrand.org. This release may not be forwarded to media for publication.
ARI's media releases are solicitations sent to addresses obtained from individual subscription requests. You are subscribed as _____@comcast.net. If you prefer not to receive future releases, visit our Web site to change your email preferences.
The Ayn Rand Institute, 2121 Alton Pkwy, Ste 250, Irvine, CA 92606 "
I would have described the "ethnic and sectarian conflict" in Iraq and other uncivilized countries as mindless, but not endless. With every other word, I agree fully. History is full of blood feuds that end when the cost exceeds the desire for vengeance, and until we wait out eternity, nothing can accurately be called "endless" with certainty. Whether these conflicts end with a truce, conquest of one party by another, or conquest of all by outside opportunists, they will end.
My personal opinion is that third party involvement is likely to defer that cost, leaving the resentment to seethe and fester until the peacemaker once again leaves the feuding parties to their own devices, at which time some new offence will spark new violence, possibly with more potent weapons. I also suspect that the author knows all this, but chose "endless" for effect. But that is all speculation. I include all this to emphasize my overall agreement with the above article from ARI.
by hs_
by absolutely
Did you notice how little Rockwell substantiated any of his claims against Peikoff, ARI, and other Objectivists he smeared? The longest quote of any of them that he offered was "please throw that man out." Rockwell said that this was "imperiously demanded" after "someone in the audience cried out in horror at this brazen display of naked evil", but does not quote any of the words that the audience member "cried out", and thus does not lead me to believe that the request was a response to anything other than a crazed outburst. Read the article again, HS_, and you'll notice that no more than a single word is quoted from any of the printed articles of the Ayn Rand Institute, with the exception of one title, with link provided.
And when two sentences excerpted from the Objectivist Center are quoted, it is dismissed by a quote from a CIA analyst, which frankly is noting more than another individual's opinion. You and Rockwell are free to [b]assume[/b] that the opinion is based in fact, but no facts on which you or I might [b]independently[/b] form the same conclusion are presented therein. So, as long as he's taking liberty with the words "cult" and "theology", it's fair to remind anyone reading that article that they are expected to take that analyst's conclusions [b]on faith[/b], as well as Rockwell's insulting descriptions of various Objectivists' personalities.
Lew Rockwell attacks via keywords, not facts. Here is a sample of some of the triggers he expects to have been effectively programmed by our brainwashers:
thuggish hectoring
admonitions
maniacal bloodthirstiness
wholesale slaughter
total war of annihilation
put to death
depths of depravity
Peikoff cult
If I were to take all those phrases [b]on faith[/b], I'd run screaming from anything bearing the name Objectivist or associated with Ayn Rand's legacy, but instead I think for myself. And I judge that Rockwell should have presented something of substance, if such existed. Since he did not, I conclude that the unsubstantiated insults he did present constitute his best argument, which I thus dismiss accordingly.
by hs_
The quotes and passages you quote from the Ayn Rand Institute also make ludicrous and wild statements on religions in general and Islam in particular. That's their prerogative. They are free to express their opinion based on their 'objectivist' paradigm - but they are in the end subjective opinions - because they provide no substantiated proof.
Therefore you, or I, or the next person are free to think for ourselves and take on faith the opinions that make most sense to our individual reasoning.
You cannot project the 'Objectivist' paradigm as the ONLY TRUTH, otherwise that would be doing what you accuse the religious 'absolutists' of doing - they too maintain that they hold the 'ONLY TRUTH'.
by absolutely
In truth, I can "project the 'Objectivist' paradigm as the ONLY TRUTH", and what's more, I can do so without condescending to the level of terrorists, because [b]expression of ideas[/b] is [b]not[/b] "what you (I) accuse the religious 'absolutists' of doing". They use violence to express their belief that religious tyranny is moral, I use words to express my belief that individual liberty is moral, and if "they too maintain that they hold the 'ONLY TRUTH'", their inability to convert by other means than force serves, to people of intellect, as evidence of the logical fallacy of their claims.
I am confident based on my independent judgment. Prosyletizers, some of which inaccurately arrogate to themselves the label "Objectivist", can achieve an illusion of confidence only by seeking consensus because they have no confidence in their independent judgement as such.
Are you willing to cite one or more of the "quotes and passages you (I) quote from the Ayn Rand Institute" and accompany it/them with the most relevant facts that lead you to conclude that those quotes and passages contain "ludicrous and wild statements on religions in general and Islam in particular"?
by ukbajwa10
by imranhussein
Some muslims are not evil because they do not know the real islam. They are brought up in communities that are ill-informed with creative religious leaders known as Imams who feed them with a character of muhammad that is totally different from the real person.
If you really want to know what islam is about see the following links:
http://www.realmuhammad.blogspot.com
http://www.muslimsopenyoureyes.blogspot.com
.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending