.....that poverty is a permanent societal condition, one that's existed across all places and all times, and it's one that will always exist, regardless of the efforts to end it. For example, a person might not have been able to afford a loaf of bread in 1909 because it cost a whopping 5 cents, while a different person in 2009 might also not be able to afford a load of bread because it costs a whopping $1.00.
It's all relative, and I believe that was the intent behind the quote. I also believe that poverty is, and always will be, a permanent societal condition - something that simply cannot be eradicated.
(Note: I do believe that abject poverty - that is, those without the basic living necessities such as food, water, clothing, and shelter - can be helped by donations of such, but it would only create, at best, an environment of simply sustaining a permanent dependent class, which is certainly better than the alternative.)
[b]Definitions:[/b]
[b][i]Abject poverty:[/i][/b] Lacking the basic necessities to survive, such as food, water, clothing, and shelter.
[b][i]Relative Poverty:[/i][/b] One's position on the class scale as compared to others on the same scale.
With the slimmest of exceptions, I don't believe that abject poverty exists in the United States.
Poverty in the United States is measured by one's income, not by one's living conditions. And the worst living condition in the United States might be exponentially better than the best living conditions under which most people in some nations find themselves.
There always have been, currently are, and always will be a separation of classes - not just in the United States, but in every country across the globe.
In his 1949 book, [i]Social Class in America[/i], sociologist William Lloyd Warner suggest a class separation similar to this:
[b]Upper-upper class.[/b] "Old money." People who have been born into and raised with wealth; mostly consists of old "noble" or prestigious families (e.g., Earl of Shrewsbury, Vanderbilt, Rockefeller).
[b]Lower-upper class.[/b] "New money." Individuals who have become rich within their own lifetimes (e.g., entrepreneurs, movie stars, top athletes, as well as some prominent professionals).
[b]Upper-middle class.[/b] Professionals with a college education, and more often with postgraduate degrees like MBAs, Ph.D.s, MDs, JDs, MSs, etc. (e.g., doctors, dentists, lawyers, bankers, corporate executives, university professors, scientists, pharmacists, airline pilots, ship captains, high level civil servants, politicians, and military officers, architects, artists, writers, poets, and musicians).
[b]Lower-middle class.[/b] Lower paid white collar workers, but not manual laborers. Often hold Associates or Bachelor degrees. (e.g., police officers, fire fighters, primary and high school school-teachers, engineers, accountants, nurses, municipal office workers and low to mid-level civil servants, sales representatives, non-management office workers, clergy, technicians, small business owners).
[b]Upper-lower class.[/b] Blue-collar workers and manual laborers. Also known as the "working class."
[b]Lower-lower class.[/b] The homeless and permanently unemployed, as well as the "working poor."
A person is either born into a class or moves from one to another (either up or down). And I believe people can aspire to improve their position on the class ladder. But I further believe that those people who aspire to improve their conditions can ONLY do so at the hands of their own self-motivated desires. Such people can be helped and encouraged, of course, but I don't believe a person can be plucked from the lower-lower class, for example, and dropped into the lower-middle class and sustain that standard of living without a continuing and permanent dependence on another. It must come from a desire to improve one's own condition, otherwise the only thing created is a dependent class.
A Marxist solution would suggest taking from the upper classes (by a variety of means) so that it can be redistributed amongst the lower classes, thereby equalizing outcome. That solution never has, and never will work. If you want to argue in favor of such a solution, please do so - but admit what it really is.
I'd like to ask this question. If the United States has failed at eradicating poverty throughout its history, what country has been successful? What nation of the world has eradicated poverty within its borders, and has structured its society in such a way that living in poverty is a thing of the past? If you can name such a country, please provide support. (This question relates to relative poverty, not abject poverty.)
A concluding question, therefore, is this. What's the BEST way to get as many people as possible out of ABJECT poverty (which, with minor exceptions, doesn't really exist in most industrialized nations, i.e. the USA, Canada, UK, Australia, etc.)? And what is the BEST way to get as many people as possible out of RELATIVE poverty - that is, to have fewer people in the lower classes, with more people in the higher classes?
The answer is this, and charts will support my assertion. (Feel free to search for them - easy to find if you try.)
The nations that have the highest rates of poverty ALSO have the lowest amount of economic freedom. The nations that score the HIGHEST on the [i]Index of Economic Freedom[/i], also have the lowest percentage of their population living below the poverty line (however measured). The higher the level of economic freedom, the lower the poverty rate will be.
I might also add that the United States has lost its top position on the [i]Index of Economic Freedom[/i] over the years. Our goal should be to retake that top position. Unfortunately, silly and ineffective social programs - like the [i]War on Poverty[/i] - will keep us (the U.S.) from regaining that top spot.
How ironic - the very programs designed to end poverty only create more of it.
___________________________________________________________________________________
Edited: Because these discussion threads don't like some of the characters (apostrophes, dashes, etc.) that were created in [i]Word[/i]. (I wish the folks at TR could fix this problem.)
P.S. (Another edit): Living below the [i]poverty line[/i] does not necessarily mean living below the [i]happiness line[/i]. Three single people all earning $10k, sharing a house and expenses, would all be considered living below the [i]poverty line[/i], but it might not necessarily be a bad - or permanent - thing for them.