Discussion Locked

[i]There will always be poverty in this country as long as. . . . . .

0 helpful
276 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i].....half the people make less than the mean income.[/i]
- Quote from an unknown source

Interesting to think about.

President Johnson's [i]War on Poverty[/i], in my opinion, needs an exit strategy. What should it be?

Can government eliminate poverty? If so, how? If not, why try?

Has the definition of [i]poverty[/i] changed over time?

How do you define [i]poverty[/i], in abject terms or relative terms?

Is the aforementioned [i]War on Poverty[/i] waged against abject poverty or relative poverty? If the answer is [i]relative poverty[/i], is waging it an effort in futility? And if the answer is [i]abject poverty[/i], how much of that would really exist in our country (or your country) if left to its own accord?

And finally, is the goal of assisting those living in poverty best left to the private sector to address, or is government involvement more effective? Is it better addressed on larger scales or smaller?

276 replies

by tony hopkinson

I'd want to remain unknown if I said something as dumb as that as well.

The only way for that not to be true, is either everyone has the same income, or to make abject poverty a requirement.

Take it off the highest earners or the lowest....

Guy was banker wasn't he, access to a lot of numbers, can't do basic applied math though.

by jdclyde

when you look at some that make so much, and then look at almost half our nation that pay zero in income taxes......

It is little wonder the Obama supporters don't care about taxes going up, because it won't be effecting THEM.

by maxwell edison

When it comes to matters of deciding what to do in regards to those who [i]pay income taxes[/i], should those who [i]pay NO income taxes[/i] have a voice? Why or why not?

by maxwell edison

.....or thought provoking?

P.S. When coupled with the question, abject or relative, it speaks volumes. Don't you think?

P.P.S. You said, [i]".....The only way for that not to be true....."[/i]

Exactly correct. Therefore what? Therefore, what's the REAL motive?

by tony hopkinson

Mathematical incompetence?
Total loss of contact with reality.
Pseudo scientific lie?

Abject is a merely a point on the scale. It's as arbritary as a temperature scale.

Are you hotter or colder if you measure your temperature relative to the point where water or alcohol freezes?

Motive?

Well if you are poor, the motive is not to be. Of course the fact that you are poor limits your ability not to be...

Philanthropism, guilt, pure and simple. To be successful at though, you have to be rich...

Greed. Why would a greedy person want a war on poverty?. To make money out of it...

The war on poverty is bollocks.

The only way not to lose it, is not to fight it.

by nicknielsen

The statement implies that the speaker believes poverty=making less than the mean income. Such an attitude reveals a deep misunderstanding not only of arithmetic, but of economics.

Would I be surprised to discover the speaker is also a proponent of wealth redistribution? No. Would I trust the speaker in the US government? No. Would I be surprised to find the speaker has been or is in the US government. No.

by dhcdbd

wealth is based on scarcity. Eliminate scarcity and eliminate poverty.

But what to replace a scarcity based economy with? The rich would not then get richer.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

as a means of exhcange, and as a means of value.

As long as a 'third party', so to speak, stands for value, poverty will be an issue.

If people are valued, poverty becomes somewhat different from what we currently understand it to be.

Furthermore, poverty is a cyclical, naturally occurring phenomenon under any understanding other than that of a money based understanding.

One of my personal diatribes that could rage interminably...
Whacked out value system.

by maxwell edison

.....from government, at least as it pertains to the ability of one citizen to vote himself payment at the expense of another.

by jdclyde

We don't think of starving people somewhere in the world as poverty, but someone that can't afford a third or fourth car.

We see people that are "poor" with a cell phone pasted to their face. How? Cell phone in one hand, cigarette in the other. Over 3k a year blown on cigs and cell phone, sounds like a money management problem, not a cash shortage.

How many "poor" people do you know that DON'T have cable TV and multiple tv's in their home?

There used to be hard working people in this world that did not have their worth measured by how much money they had or the size of their house, but on the character of the person and the way they lived their lives. Proud, hard working people that made ends meet. Now, if you are "poor", it is "unfair" and "the government" should do something about it.

The world is moving backwards (devolving) rather than improving and moving forward.

by tony hopkinson

that resources are finite. The only way to keep getting yours, is to convince as many others as you can that it isn't theirs.

We can stave off collapse by going into space, then becoming interstellar, then intergalactic, then we fill up the universe and die in our own waste products.

To win the war on poverty we must trancend our biology, but then we would be something else, so did we win? :p

by jdclyde

The world is not setup so that in order for one to be successful, another has to fail.

Based upon your statement, do we have to limit how much money someone is ALLOWED to make?

by santeewelding

Are you asking about taxes, or voice?

Voice determines anything, including voice. Taxes determine only voice.

And then there appears your other option: that bit about "matters of deciding". Who be this? Somebody else?

by dhcdbd

I am not sure if there is a language problem in the use of the word "Bollocks."

When I looked the word up it meant 1) of the testicles and 2) rubbish. But those are the American definitions. English English being different than American English, can you explain how you meant the word? I understood it to mean "Rubbish" in context.

by tony hopkinson

testicles. :D

I guess if I was to say that, it would mean I wanted to indicate rubbish when my mum was present. :p

by santeewelding

Must be one of the excepted PTB that Max obliquely alludes to in his screwed-up tax scheme. I got one, too.

by tony hopkinson

Are you takling about those who don't earn enough to cover the cost of collecting it, or those who earn so much, they can twidlle with the figures and make it look like they shouldn't ?

Going back to the old days, where you had to have a certain income to vote seems like a really bad idea.

I prefer every one to vote, for that vote to mean something, and a constitutional cap, requiring an almost unamimous majority across all houses, in order to adjust it upwards.
Not just income tax, either, the lot. Government will never be small out of choice, so lets take the power to fund more away from them. I guarantee in that environment, they wouldn't be launching 'new' programs left, right and centre.

by santeewelding

I also agree with your effort to bring fundamental order and reason to a clusterfuck.

The scheme you dally with, however, is not it. I think you need to go more in the direction of "voice", which would then plunge you into the clusterfuck of who and how we each and all are.

ed: extraneous "l"

by santeewelding

Of franchise to voice.

I said "dally" in deference to your having dallied and not formally proposed same.

by maxwell edison

I could elaborate on any of the following points, but in a nutshell:

I believe every citizen should have a voice, regardless of that person's standing on the economic or social scale.

I believe it's both immoral and a recipe for disaster (or tyranny) for a system that allows one citizen to vote himself the earnings of another citizen; it's tantamount to both economic slavery and the purchasing of votes (purchasing with another's dollar, I might add).

I believe it's immoral to tax a person's earnings; that, too, is tantamount to economic slavery.

I believe it's the role of government to guarantee a society in which people are free to take responsibility for themselves, and have the individual right to seek opportunity and happiness for themselves, regardless of how they choose to define that desired outcome; it's not, however, the role of government to guarantee the realization of that outcome or to equalize outcome among the citizenry.

Benevolence is not the role of government. ([i] I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.[/i] - James Madison)

I believe the capitalistic system is not perfect, and those higher on the economic and social scale have an advantage over others, and often-times take advantage of others; call it an evil unintended consequence of the system. However, the way to address that evil is not with another evil, as I described in the aforementioned points.

I believe taxes are necessary and vital to maintain a fully functioning government.

I could go on, but my conclusion:

If one generally believes, in principle, either fully or in part, with the points I've made, then when it comes to the question of taxation and how to collect the vital revenue for government to function, then one might conclude that a tax based on consumption, not income, is the preferred method. The details of how a consumption-based tax should be structured should only be debated and discussed after the underlying premise is agreed upon.

If that's, as you suggested, the basis for a [i]screwed-up tax scheme[/i], then so be it. However, it's better, in the eyes of many (including, most likely, our founders), than the [i]screwed-up tax scheme[/i] we currently have to endure.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]I believe it?s immoral to tax a person?s earnings; that, too, is tantamount to economic slavery.[/i]

[i]I believe taxes are necessary and vital to maintain a fully functioning government[/i]

A little cognitive dissonance here, or would you care to expand on 'taxes' in the second quote?

by maxwell edison

.....in my conclusion.

Taxes defined: The means by which government collects revenue (not necessarily by taking a portion of one's income).

by thechas

Is the US income tax code overly cumbersome, complex and far to large? Yes.

Is it fundamentally screwed up? No.

The problem with the US income tax code is much the same as any part of the US legal code. Congress does a poor job at writing legislation with clear and concise language.

The portions of the US tax code that most individuals deal with are actually pretty simple and straightforward. If the tax code was reduced to what was required for 90% of individual taxpayers, the code code be smaller than an encyclopedia volume.

What makes the US tax code the complex entity it is is the tax breaks that members of Congress insert to aid a company or investor back home. It takes a lot of words to write a tax break that is so narrow that only 1 specific company could take advantage of it. But, no representative would write a law that gives a tax break to a specific company.

True, there is some social engineering in some of the deductions and credits.

Perhaps the worst feature of the US tax code is that a shrewd tax lawyer can help anyone with enough money to significantly reduce or eliminate their income tax. However, even that is more of a statement than a savings. The amount of money an individual needs to spend in just the right way to reduce their income tax rate almost always exceeds the total savings. The primary exception being when one is near a step in the tax brackets and can lower their taxable income to the lower bracket.

Even the churn that takes place when an individual spends money to lower their taxes accomplishes the intended purpose of the tax break. It gets money moving in the economy.

Any of the simplified tax plans will not eliminate social engineering in the tax code. A number of states have different sales tax rates for different items. Others have sales tax holidays such as late summer back to school tax holidays for cloths and related items.

Mankind has a built in penchant to meddle with just about anything. The simpler you try to make something, the more effort someone else will work to add "features" to it.

Chas

by thechas

The growth of impoverished people in the US has it roots in the GI's that returned from World War II and moved their families into the new suburbs that sprang up around all the major cities.

Those that did not have the money to move out stayed behind in what turned into the slums of the 1960's.

Prior to the economic migration of the middle class, urban poverty had the face of a friend or neighbor. Those that were putting effort into making the best out of what life handed them got a little help each month from their neighbors. Back then, the landlord was apt to live in the building and might lower the rent for someone who was working as hard as they could.

Those that wouldn't work, were drunk, or were just bad or mean neighbors ended up in the poor house or the poor farm.

After the middle class abandoned the inner city, there was no one left to sort out the good from the bad and the informal system broke down. When the problem of inner city poverty got too big for the cities to handle, they turned to the states who in turn turned to the Federal Government for help.

The only way we are going to "fix" the poverty problem in the US is to get back to full economic integration. Only when we have economic integration can we return to the informal private aid system that helps out those that need help and not those that just want a handout.

But, don't ask me how we will get there.

Chas

by jdclyde

And they are trying it in parts of the country. Government funds were being wasted to pay the lions share of "the poor" to get them into the upscale neighborhoods.

The problem? They brought the problems from the inner city to the upscale neighborhoods.

Until poor (bad) behavior is no longer condoned or wrote off as "their culture", the inner city lifestyle will continue to degrade, continuing to lower their own quality of life.

by dhcdbd

I have long supported that poverty is a taught value rather than something that one is born into or that happens to them.

To overcome the teaching, the various poverty stricken need to be relocated among the middle class. By having friends and acquaintances among those in better straights then themselves the impoverished learn new values and in-turn also learn to help others.

There are two issues with this approach however. The first is the elitism that we live from day to day. The second is how do we relocate the poor into middle class neighborhoods? A third related problem that we, ourselves and others, must learn to rely on ourselves rather than to look for others to do for us.

by jdclyde

is the middle class neighborhood is over run by the poor values that are brought into the community.

The people with values then move out, again, leaving another area devastated because of gutter values.

Now, if the community were ALLOWED to tell people to behave in a civilized manner and dress in a civilized manner, there might be a chance, but that is never going to happen, thanks to political correctness.

by av .

LBJ's war on poverty had good intentions, but there isn't an exit strategy, unfortunately. Its just going to get even bigger under Obama.

The question to me is why are so many people (50% according to the quote) living in poverty and why are they there in the first place?

Aside from people in abject poverty, I have to say to those in relative poverty - get a job! Get two jobs and stop having kids you can't support. Look at what Octomom did on the public dole. Take responsibility for yourself. They won't, as long as welfare exists. You can live on that for years.

Poverty used to mean abject poverty in the past. Most people were too proud to be on the public dole, but today its become a lifestyle. Thats where relative poverty comes into play. You can take advantage of the government programs if you have low income and live just like people that work hard. Why work hard when theres a free ride?

AV

by jdclyde

"they have a RIGHT to have kids". They have the right to have as many as they can afford to care for. Until states quit giving them a pay raise for having more kids.....

The high school drop-out that we are suppose to feel sorry for, because they are unworthy of a high end job? Hardly.

And then there is the poor communities standing with criminals against the police, means they deserve all the crime and violence they are in turn subjected to.

The city of Detroit knew what a low life Kilpatric was and is, but they LIKED their "gangsta Mayor" and kept re-electing him no matter WHAT he did.

It took him going to jail to get him removed from office.

Detroit deserves everything bad that is happening to them now because of this.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

we weren't so busy circumventing the process of natural selection via our technology, I don't think we'd have to worry about that sort of thing.
Or a whole lot of other things.

by dhcdbd

>"And then there is the poor communities standing with criminals against the police, means they deserve all the crime and violence they are in turn subjected to."

The poor actually have a greater respect for the police than the middle class. Because they have also seen greater abuses at the hands of the police, they have a greater mistrust.

by av .

I can liken Detroit to the lovely city of Newark, NJ. The ex-mayor Sharpe James is finally in jail too after being reelected several times. Kilpatric, a true disgrace, also belongs in jail.

The poor stand with the criminals because they face retribution if they don't. They know they won't get any sympathy from the police either. Many poor people turn to a life of crime in the ghettos. They don't look for any other way because the government takes care of them.

I don't feel sorry for the high school drop-out that can't get a high end job. If you are willing to work, you can be anything you want in this country. The problem is that they don't want to work for it.

AV

by jdclyde

There are ways you can gain control over a population.

One, as in Cuba, use the army.

Two, as in the US, promise to give something to someone in exchange for votes and a blank check.

When over 40% of our nation pays zero in income taxes, telling them you wish to keep taxes low is not going to gain you any votes. Telling them you are going to raise taxes on "the rich" and "big business" so you can fund social programs does get their vote.

Class warfare and class envy are powerful tools, and Obama is taking full advantage of both.

by dhcdbd

of the elitism I had written of. Also a very good example of the gross misinformation and prejudice that is common.

A few cities have tried what I suggested. The common belief is what you suggest. The belief was not supported by the actual events and facts. The individual poverty stricken family had their income increase in the first year by 30 percent. The families internalized the values of the middle class people in whose area's they were relocated. The trick was not to overload any area with masses of poor. Just incorporate one or two families into any given area. In contrast with the great "Ghetto's," this was a program that worked. The poor were not given anything except decent terms for subsidized loans on the homes that they were allowed to purchase; most of these homes were foreclosed HUD homes or homes that were condemned and refurbished. One of the cities that these tests (experiments, whatever) was conducted was Detroit, another test area was L.A., and yet another was Phoenix. The information is available from HUD if you really wish to look into the matter.

As a child I grew up in an affluent middle class neighborhood in Las Vegas, Nv. I was surprised in later life to find that that area was now considered to be near ghetto. On the surface, this would support your belief and assertion. The reality is different than appearance. The home was built in 1962 and my dad purchased it for $19,500 in 1963 as a new home in East Las Vegas about three miles from Sunrise Mountain. We, the children, grew up and moved to the trendier parts of town. The owners of those homes we grew up in either died or moved to trendier parts. The homes in that neighborhood that came up on market were older by the standards of the city and thus of a lower value than the new homes in the trendier West Las Vegas on the other side of the strip. This placed the value of the homes within the reach of the less affluent. The home I grew up in sold for $60,000. A new home in the more fashionable parts sold for $100,000. The artificiality of L.V. is a good example in this case because of the pretense and falseness of the city - Money talks, B.S. walks; if you have money the town is open, if you do not then get lost.

The poor or less affluent are just like everyone else; they desire to own their own homes. The poor purchased what they could afford. It often is the case that the poor do not invade an area, but rather move into the area's that the better off abandon.

Cultures are cultures, and cultures are taught not passed on genetically.

How someone dresses is really none of your business unless that dress is displayed in the workplace. The fact that a black man calls another black man "N*gg*r" is none of your business as long as it is not in the workplace. I frequently call my friends "Honky," as I do myself - when we are not on public display for work. I associate with Mexicans, Blacks, Whites, Indians, just about everything. Amongst ourselves we use every politically incorrect name you could think of.

It is not the blacks that are keeping the hip-hop culture alive - it is the wanna be white children that are doing it.

Assimilation is a part of our culture. To paraphrase the Eagles: "Just Get Used to It."

But please, verify your information on something more than unfounded opinion.

by jdclyde

as I see all to much the little white boy running around, having to hold up his pants because he thinks looking like a retard is cool.

As for my "opinion", it was based on news reports a few weeks back.

In the time since the importation of "the poor", crime shot up. coincidence?

And I am far from an elitist. I am far from rich. when my boys (twins) were born, I was making less than $20k a year. I did not increase my income by having someone else pick up the tab.

by dhcdbd

because race is often associated with poverty. News reports? Fox, NBC, ABC, etc., how much of the crime rising is really associated with the current economic trends? Pack reporting is sensationalist at best.

The individuals that I mentioned in those programs did not have someone else pick up the tab. To date, to the best of my knowledge, only one defaulted on the subsidized loan. Many gave up this opportunity and returned to the projects because they could/would not accept the cultural values. This is a hand up, not a handout. I would want the same for you in your current situation. I do, however, strongly disagree with taking homeless that choose to be that way and endlessly supporting them because they refuse to get sober, off the dope - whatever.

My opinion is based on research. Papers were submitted to the University of Utah several years ago.

by dhcdbd

The individuals involved in this study were all volunteers.

The most successful study came from Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Culture shock can be quit, well... a shock because it involves a paradigm shift.

More to your issue of forced busing ala Brown v. The Board of Education. Forced busing resulted in the Kansas Charter Schools that were listed as the best in the nation.

Old hack:
How many psychiatrists does it take to change a light bulb? Just one, but the light bulb really has to want to change.

by tony hopkinson

Which one of these statements is false.

The amount of reource we can efficientky convert in to that which we need to live , is finite.

There are more of us everyday.

The system itself will provide the limit.

One day one of us will have the last piece of available food, the other will have a gazillion dollars. Bon appetit.

by tony hopkinson

They know who pays the police, and they know why.

No one without power in the state, trusts the state, and the police are the jackboot of the state.

by tonythetiger

and I believe I've said as much.

[i]Has the definition of poverty changed over time?[/i]

I don't know if it's ever been properly defined. I also think you can't define it solely on one factor (like income). I think it's like beauty... in the eye of the beholder...

[i]And finally, is the goal of assisting those living in poverty best left to the private sector to address, or is government involvement more effective? Is it better addressed on larger scales or smaller?
[/i]

It depends... If you want to spend 3 times as much, let government do it :)

by tonythetiger

because they ARE paying them... A large part of the wealthiest in this country are wealthy because they make something they sell to others. The money they make (and the taxes they pay) ultimately come from the consumers.

Now, I think that if the average consumer actually [b]understood[/b] this, they might vote differently, but they shouldn't be deprived of the vote.

The same argument is often levied against renters voting for property tax increases... Unless the landlord is a complete idiot, he includes the cost of taxes in what he charges for rent, so the renter is actually paying the property tax.

by tonythetiger

[i]Well if you are poor, the motive is not to be. [/i]

do you know if you are poor? By comparing yourself to someone else? Why would you seek to make such a comparison?

Or is the label imposed from the outside?

by tony hopkinson

When I was poor as a child (not abject, but very few luxuries available).

Did I compare myself with my more affluent fellow pupils, you bet your arse.
I didn't consider my self poor, I just thought my parents were a bit tight. :p

Now I know a bit more, I've managed to be not poor, relatively affluent in fact. A major driver was not having my kid's look at me when little Billy went past on his brand new bycycle. Must have hurt my Da, that.

How do you know poor now?. Simple go to the supermarket, watch the poor tw@t filling up a small basket with own brand nasty cheap food, and telling their children the good stuff is bad for them.

Watch them near the checkout, when little Billy is getting snickers bar, and they get to pick two sweets out of a bulk buy bag of 'just like Haribo'

It's in your face all the time now, you can't avoid knowing there's something you can't afford.
There's big difference between that being a Lamborghini, with a jaw droppingly attractive brunette in it, and a loaf of bread that doesn't taste like floor sweepings.

by tonythetiger

should be "Not being able to afford what you want"?

Or is it "Not being able to afford what someone else thinks you should want"?

Or, in essence...

Is it possible to be in poverty and not know it?

by rob mekel

[i]"is the goal of assisting those living in poverty best left to the private sector to address, or is government involvement more effective?"[/i]

Seen in the light of now-a-days economic-crisis and how it came to that is easily answerred: [b]Better not be left to the private sector[/b]

by dhcdbd

Fear and poor/lower class:
"With the arrest of a 21 year old African American, Los Angeles's South Central neighborhood of Watts erupted into violence. On August 11, 1965, a Los Angeles police officer flagged down motorist Marquette Frye, whom he suspected of being intoxicated. When a crowd of onlookers began to taunt the policeman, a second officer was called in. According to eyewitness accounts, the second officer struck crowd members with his baton, and news of the act of police brutality soon spread throughout the neighborhood. The incident, combined with escalating racial tensions, overcrowding in the neighborhood, and a summer heat wave, sparked violence on a massive scale. Despite attempts the following day aimed at quelling anti police sentiment, residents began looting and burning local stores."

Middle Class and outrage:
"In May 1970, students protesting the bombing of Cambodia by United States military forces, clashed with Ohio National Guardsmen on the Kent State University campus. When the Guardsmen shot and killed four students on May 4, the Kent State Shootings became the focal point of a nation deeply divided by the Vietnam War."

Race and outrage:
"The Los Angeles Riots of 1992, also known as the Rodney King uprising or the Rodney King riots, were sparked on April 29, 1992 when a jury acquitted four police officers accused in the videotaped beating of black motorist Rodney King following a high-speed pursuit. Thousands of people in the Los Angeles area rioted over the six days following the verdict. Widespread looting, assault, arson and murder occurred, and property damages totaled US$1 billion. Many of the crimes were racially motivated or perpetrated. In all, 53 people died during the riots."

I believe it was Machiavelli who wrote "The best leader is loved and respected, if he can not be loved and respected, he should be respected, if he can not be respected, then he should be feared." (Paraphrased)

However, I meant exactly what I wrote. In this country, the poor generally have a greater respect for the police than the middle class. The respect is not without watchfulness though. The respect for the police is only unmatched by the wealthy whom the police respect and fear.

I find it somewhat ironic that the poor actually respect the police because our prisons are primarily filled by the poor and minorities who could not afford attorney's and were given second rate legal counsel that pretty much amounts to no counsel.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"In this country, the poor generally have a greater respect for the police than the middle class.[/i]"

That may or may not be true. However, I have to wonder how you could possibly support that assertion (or how the opposing opinion could be supported, for that matter).

I might also point out, since Police Officers are considered middle-class, that you're suggesting they're actually least respected amongst their very class peers? Doesn't sound right to me, although that's just an opinion.

Opinions differ from. Facts that can be supported; opinions are, well they're just that - opinions. When one offers an opinion, it shouldn't be presented as fact - unless it can be supported.

As a passing thought, I wonder what percentage of Police Officers have been killed by those in the middle-class compared to those in the lower-class? Violent crime is what kills Police Officers, and there's been a direct correlation between violent crime rates and being poor.

by tony hopkinson

It definitely isn't true in the UK.

Respect their power perhaps, as a body though, their only morality and integrity is their ability to enforce the law, no matter how unjust.

I went through the miners strike in the UK, and I was born in a mining community. I know the part the police played in that particular piece of politics, and I lost all respect for them on the spot.
My familily still have the boot print's to validate my opinion.

by maxwell edison

.....that poverty is a permanent societal condition, one that's existed across all places and all times, and it's one that will always exist, regardless of the efforts to end it. For example, a person might not have been able to afford a loaf of bread in 1909 because it cost a whopping 5 cents, while a different person in 2009 might also not be able to afford a load of bread because it costs a whopping $1.00.

It's all relative, and I believe that was the intent behind the quote. I also believe that poverty is, and always will be, a permanent societal condition - something that simply cannot be eradicated.

(Note: I do believe that abject poverty - that is, those without the basic living necessities such as food, water, clothing, and shelter - can be helped by donations of such, but it would only create, at best, an environment of simply sustaining a permanent dependent class, which is certainly better than the alternative.)

[b]Definitions:[/b]

[b][i]Abject poverty:[/i][/b] Lacking the basic necessities to survive, such as food, water, clothing, and shelter.

[b][i]Relative Poverty:[/i][/b] One's position on the class scale as compared to others on the same scale.

With the slimmest of exceptions, I don't believe that abject poverty exists in the United States.

Poverty in the United States is measured by one's income, not by one's living conditions. And the worst living condition in the United States might be exponentially better than the best living conditions under which most people in some nations find themselves.

There always have been, currently are, and always will be a separation of classes - not just in the United States, but in every country across the globe.

In his 1949 book, [i]Social Class in America[/i], sociologist William Lloyd Warner suggest a class separation similar to this:

[b]Upper-upper class.[/b] "Old money." People who have been born into and raised with wealth; mostly consists of old "noble" or prestigious families (e.g., Earl of Shrewsbury, Vanderbilt, Rockefeller).

[b]Lower-upper class.[/b] "New money." Individuals who have become rich within their own lifetimes (e.g., entrepreneurs, movie stars, top athletes, as well as some prominent professionals).

[b]Upper-middle class.[/b] Professionals with a college education, and more often with postgraduate degrees like MBAs, Ph.D.s, MDs, JDs, MSs, etc. (e.g., doctors, dentists, lawyers, bankers, corporate executives, university professors, scientists, pharmacists, airline pilots, ship captains, high level civil servants, politicians, and military officers, architects, artists, writers, poets, and musicians).

[b]Lower-middle class.[/b] Lower paid white collar workers, but not manual laborers. Often hold Associates or Bachelor degrees. (e.g., police officers, fire fighters, primary and high school school-teachers, engineers, accountants, nurses, municipal office workers and low to mid-level civil servants, sales representatives, non-management office workers, clergy, technicians, small business owners).

[b]Upper-lower class.[/b] Blue-collar workers and manual laborers. Also known as the "working class."

[b]Lower-lower class.[/b] The homeless and permanently unemployed, as well as the "working poor."

A person is either born into a class or moves from one to another (either up or down). And I believe people can aspire to improve their position on the class ladder. But I further believe that those people who aspire to improve their conditions can ONLY do so at the hands of their own self-motivated desires. Such people can be helped and encouraged, of course, but I don't believe a person can be plucked from the lower-lower class, for example, and dropped into the lower-middle class and sustain that standard of living without a continuing and permanent dependence on another. It must come from a desire to improve one's own condition, otherwise the only thing created is a dependent class.

A Marxist solution would suggest taking from the upper classes (by a variety of means) so that it can be redistributed amongst the lower classes, thereby equalizing outcome. That solution never has, and never will work. If you want to argue in favor of such a solution, please do so - but admit what it really is.

I'd like to ask this question. If the United States has failed at eradicating poverty throughout its history, what country has been successful? What nation of the world has eradicated poverty within its borders, and has structured its society in such a way that living in poverty is a thing of the past? If you can name such a country, please provide support. (This question relates to relative poverty, not abject poverty.)

A concluding question, therefore, is this. What's the BEST way to get as many people as possible out of ABJECT poverty (which, with minor exceptions, doesn't really exist in most industrialized nations, i.e. the USA, Canada, UK, Australia, etc.)? And what is the BEST way to get as many people as possible out of RELATIVE poverty - that is, to have fewer people in the lower classes, with more people in the higher classes?

The answer is this, and charts will support my assertion. (Feel free to search for them - easy to find if you try.)

The nations that have the highest rates of poverty ALSO have the lowest amount of economic freedom. The nations that score the HIGHEST on the [i]Index of Economic Freedom[/i], also have the lowest percentage of their population living below the poverty line (however measured). The higher the level of economic freedom, the lower the poverty rate will be.

I might also add that the United States has lost its top position on the [i]Index of Economic Freedom[/i] over the years. Our goal should be to retake that top position. Unfortunately, silly and ineffective social programs - like the [i]War on Poverty[/i] - will keep us (the U.S.) from regaining that top spot.

How ironic - the very programs designed to end poverty only create more of it.
___________________________________________________________________________________

Edited: Because these discussion threads don't like some of the characters (apostrophes, dashes, etc.) that were created in [i]Word[/i]. (I wish the folks at TR could fix this problem.)

P.S. (Another edit): Living below the [i]poverty line[/i] does not necessarily mean living below the [i]happiness line[/i]. Three single people all earning $10k, sharing a house and expenses, would all be considered living below the [i]poverty line[/i], but it might not necessarily be a bad - or permanent - thing for them.

by dhcdbd

Abstract:

In 2001, U.S. Senator Zell Miller and former Governor of Georgia obtained congressional support for a multistate research team to examine persistent poverty in the South and to make recommendations for regional solutions. This study built upon previous research on the Black Belt South by the presenters who were also among the principal investigators in the Miller Study. The Miller-Study's report, Dismantling Persistent Poverty in the Southeastern United States, directs attention to poverty and other conditions with a primary focus on the seven Southeastern states. This poster presentation extends the scope of the Miller Study by examining conditions of the broader Black Belt South and how these conditions contrast to the well-being of the rest of the nation. This is done with a series of color maps from 2000 census data and other sources. One map shows the counties of the larger 11-state Black Belt South in national context. Other maps show the locations of counties in persistent poverty across the United States. We show that most of the nation's persistent-poverty counties are to be found in the larger Black Belt South including places in the seven states that were the focus of the Miller Study. The presentation also outlines findings and policy recommendations from the Miller Study plus others added by the presenters of this display. One of the presenters' recommendations is to establish a federal regional commission, similar to the Appalachian Regional Commission, that will address the long-standing disparities of the entire Black Belt South.
http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p_mla_apa_research_citation/1/0/7/5/3/p107530_index.html

Some places in the south have poverty equally as persistent and as "Abject" (by your terms) as anything in Ethiopia. You have to go into the back bayous; ditto with the Ozarks and some of the mountain people.

by maxwell edison

[i]With the slimmest of exceptions, I don't believe that abject poverty exists in the United States.[/i]

I suppose it depends on what the definition of [i]slimmest[/i] is?

As a number pulled out of the air, I might suggest it's much less than one-tenth of one percent of our population - maybe even one-one hundredth of one percent. (Without research, I can't support that [i]guess[/i].)

No food, water, clothing, or shelter? Nope, you'd be hard-pressed to find it in the USA.

by maxwell edison

[i]..... a car, air conditioning, a refrigerator, a stove, a clothes washer and dryer, and a microwave. He has two color televisions, cable or satellite TV reception, a VCR or DVD player, and a stereo. He is able to obtain medical care. His home is in good repair and is not overcrowded. By his own report, his family is not hungry, and he had sufficient funds in the past year to meet his family's essential needs. While this individual's life is not opulent, it is equally far from the popular images of dire poverty conveyed by the press, liberal activists, and politicians.[/i]

Source, context, and the full story:

http://www.heritage.org/Research/Welfare/BG1713es.cfm

Here's what is very telling:

[i]As noted above, father absence is another major cause of child poverty. Nearly two-thirds of poor children reside in single-parent homes; each year, an additional 1.3 million children are born out of wedlock. If poor mothers married the fathers of their children, nearly three-quarters of the nation's impoverished youth would immediately be lifted out of poverty.[/i]

Instead of supporting those [i]poor[/i] with taxpayer dollars, I'd much rather favor a law that demands a father support his children, lest he finds himself in jail until his children become adults. (Disclaimer: That was an impulsive comment - not much thought given to any unintended consequences.)

by tonythetiger

"What is poverty?"

Is it having less income (than someone else? If so, who?)?

Is it not being able to meet one's needs? Needs vary, don't they? And who determines these needs?

Is it dependent on the local or regional cost of living? If not, why not?

by tonythetiger

[i]Living below the poverty line does not necessarily mean living below the happiness line. Three single people all earning $10k, sharing a house and expenses, would all be considered living below the poverty line, but it might not necessarily be a bad - or permanent - thing for them. [/i]

If someone is happy, who the hell are we to tell them they're not?

"That man is the richest whose pleasures are the cheapest."

Henry David Thoreau

by tony hopkinson

I agree wholeheartedly. :D

You might not want me on your side though.

To me the attacks on people receiving wefare, even those milking or even defrauding the system are a smoke screen.

The real problem is, the people who pay for welfare, that's thee and me , can't afford to buy politicians and get ourselves exempted, and are in minorities as a cohesive voting block.
Our politics for instance are different on so many issues it's unlikely we'd vote the same snout in the trough. The welfare types though will naturally and sensibly vote en masse, for some one who gives them more.
Better still the snouts use our money to buy them. The rich b'stards who fund their campaigns dodge their tax burden, after all they don't endure their company for a laugh.

So we are getting spit roasted, and all we can do is hope the rich guy prefers oral, because he's more likely to have washed.

by tink!

there will always be poverty. Poverty is a relative definition which can change with the times. Currently, if looking at our own country most of us consider the poverty-stricken to be those who live in the inner cities and primarily rely on welfare. In order to get them out of poverty we would have to a) move them into better neighborhoods, b) find them a good long-term job that they would appreciate enough to stay with, c) get rid of gangs.

Unfortunately doing all three is near impossible. Gangs are an answer to many who live in poverty as they provide support both monetarily and emotionally.

Just moving them into a better neighborhood is not enough to break the lines of racial and economical differences. Those already residing in the better neighborhoods are going to naturally react negatively which will have a tendency to push the new residents back out.

Jobs are difficult to find. Especially finding a job that you enjoy. So how in the heck would we find a job for every poor person? We might be able to find menial labor jobs for them - but if they don't like it (anymore than many of us would) they're not going to feel inclined to stick with it.

So, poverty seems to be eternal. Even if upon the minute chance that our economical society somehow managed to even things out enough to where poverty was no longer the inner city slums of jobless inhabitants, there would still be poverty. The definition would just change to include the lowest end of the spectrucm.

Poverty should not be confused with "lower income" which encases working folks that don't make that much (or enough to buy that 2nd car). Lower income is not limited to one particular area of habitation. It can be found in the suburbs as well as the cities. Lower income citizens represent a key portion of the society. They work, but also receive extra help from the government. They do not RELY solely on the government however - unlike poverty-stricken people. They pay taxes and therefore are benefiting from the money they put into the government. If we were somewhow able to upgrade the poverty-stricken to the "lower income" level and also somehow made them STAY there. Poverty as we know it would be eventually eliminated and the definition would change.

But as of now, I see poverty remaining the way it is for a very very long time.

by oz_media

...it isn't run by Max Edison, the true knowledge of what it takes to run a government. Sigh, what a wasted talent, and they couldn't find you when it came to seeking out presidential nominees?

Its interestng actually, I just watched a docu on poverty and how imperative it is to support poverty stricken nations that we rely on in order to feed our town.

Firstly, poverty breeds disease. Any country suffering severe poverty, also has a major problem of losing its population to disease. We rely on the growers and workers in Africa and many other poverty stricken countries to provide us with many of our imports. It is in our best interests to aide Africa and others to help keep their population healthy, able to work and provide for us in return.

If our resources begin to dwindle, then we in turn start succumb to poverty too.

I know this is extremely simplistic and doesn't cover specifics you had asked about, but I think the issue needs to be considered on a much broader spectrum than mere internal affairs, the definition of poverty etc. that most people seem focused on.

It cannot be denied that America is 100% reliant on the rest of the world in order to maintain its economic status.

On that same note, those other countries rely on US dollars to support thier own economy.

The domino effect is in play, and it takes a far broader scope than one definition of poverty over another, internal affairs or anything else 'internal' as the sole solution.

A global effort and solution is needed, a much broader view, even to simply stabilize the US economy itself.

[i]And finally, is the goal of assisting those living in poverty best left to the private sector to address, or is government involvement more effective? Is it better addressed on larger scales or smaller?"[/i]

Poverty in your neighbourhood may be assisted by the private sector, if your neighbourhood is small. But poverty on a national basis takes global effort, nothing you can do as an individual country on that one. With only 2 years to go before a massive change to mankind, its time to start looking at a much bigger picture, I think.

The end is near, we are all doooooooooomed!
]:)

by oz_media

so sarcasm is left for you only, fair enough, expected as much anyway.

as for the rest of the post, which looks upon the US economy and global economic struggles as a global issue, I suppose I lost you with my simplicity and lack of redefinition of all the terms used.

Why seek definition instead of awareness and global solutions?

From what I can see in the post you linked to, for what reason I am still unsure, you are simply looking to tear apart definition in order to make it seem like more of the same, with a different name.

I don't suppose you are trying to discount the reality of global economic crisis though, yet you are rarely too clear with your intentions.

by dhcdbd

"Abstract:
A brief narrative description of the journal article, document, or resource. Of the 27 million poor people in the United States in 1970, 10 million lived in the 11 Southern states. This was 38% of the nation's poverty population, making the South's poverty rate twice that of the remaining 39 states. This study, essentially a statistical analysis of regional poverty data derived from the 1970 Census, identifies the South's poor in detail in order to provide a statistical base for remedial action. Data were obtained on residence and poverty, the working poor, the South's elderly poor, family income and the poverty line, and poor Southern families with children. Findings included: while in "absolute numbers" more white males headed poor families than any other race/sex grouping, the incidence of poverty was highest among black female-headed families; the difference in poverty incidence between the South and the non-South was greatest for black males; the South's rural areas had the highest poverty rate; of Southern employed family heads, 54% of black females, 26% of black males, 18% of white females, and 6% of white males did not earn enough to keep out of poverty; almost half of Southern farm laborers and about one-quarter of Southern farm owners were in poverty; poverty incidence among male headed-families with children was nearly twice as high in rural areas as in urban areas; 9% of the white elderly and 23% of the black elderly in the South were poor and did not receive Social Security benefits. Appended is brief data on the Spanish American poor population in Florida and Texas. (NQ)"
http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED154966&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED154966

by tonythetiger

few people who are not wealthy even understand the concept of wealth or how it is acquired. Give them a bonus, and they'll buy a lavish bauble, rather than use the bonus as a seed that will grow and enrich not only their life but that of their descendants as well. And it's not something you can force someone to learn. They either get it or they don't.

So for those who don't get it, are we supposed to keep giving them bonuses so that they can continue to waste it on baubles?

by tink!

but I call it "lower income". Actually when applying for any of the assistance services, it is usually referred to as lower income as well. Although the scale used calls it the Poverty Level.

Before my SO went on disability (which comes out of the SS dollars he paid throughout his years of work) and before my last raise, we were considered Lower Income - just barely. Being on that end personally, I have no problems with working people receiving assistance from the government. I disagree more with fully funding non-working families.

As for the children with no father support - they do have laws to force the fathers to provide support or end up in jail. But if the father has no job - where does he get the support?

by tonythetiger

[i]The world is not setup so that in order for one to be successful, another has to fail.[/i]

who, unfortunately, have been convinced that it is, and operate under that assumption...

by tonythetiger

'incorporate' that threw me.

...[i]the light bulb really has to want to change. [/i]

Indeed... And if it doesn't want to, it should be left alone as long as it is not hurting someone.

by tonythetiger

[i]they have a greater mistrust. [/i]

... there is a growing mistrust of the government in general, and it's growing in nearly every social and economic sector. Heck, even the various levels of government don't trust each other!

The next few decades are going to be interesting...

by jck

[i]President Johnson's War on Poverty, in my opinion, needs an exit strategy. What should it be?[/i]

Make those capable of working...work.

Support those who have no means or ability (and I mean NONE) to support themselves.

Give nothing to those who will not work who can.

Starvation and homelessness and death is the greatest motivator to get off your ass there is.

[i]Can government eliminate poverty? If so, how? If not, why try?[/i]

Yes, but it would be in a way that too many would find too harsh. It's called: true responsibility.

[i]Has the definition of poverty changed over time?[/i]

Since poverty is a level based on income versus expense, yes. It changes moment to moment, location by location, person to person.

[i]How do you define poverty, in abject terms or relative terms?[/i]

Poverty is relative to too many factors to line out briefly here

[i]Is the aforementioned War on Poverty waged against abject poverty or relative poverty? If the answer is relative poverty, is waging it an effort in futility? And if the answer is abject poverty, how much of that would really exist in our country (or your country) if left to its own accord?[/i]

It is waged against [b]all[/b] poverty in a blanket fashion that will never work.

And, it is an effort in futility so long as you do not make those who can work do something for their check rather than to let them sit around on the post office steps the first working day of a month to collect a check.

[i]And finally, is the goal of assisting those living in poverty best left to the private sector to address, or is government involvement more effective? Is it better addressed on larger scales or smaller?[/i]

Neither. It would be best left to themselves.

If they can work, tell them "work a job we have for you, or don't get a check at all and starve."

Take the money saved and put it into more law enforcement and criminal justice. Punish those who would commit crime to make money instead of working a day labor job or a low job they think is beneath them to do.

This country needs to get its head out of its butt, and finally tell people on welfare:

The settlers of Jamestown had it right; if you are able and will not work and your family will not feed you, then you will starve. And if you commit a crime of theft to eat or drink and are caught, you are summarily and strictly punished for it. No exceptions. You have no right to use someone else to work for you to earn your way, unless you have no ability to do so.

Small children and infirmed elderly should not have to work. Otherwise, get off your ass.

by dwdino

JCK,

For the first time in remembered history, I must, without reservation, applaud your response.

OK, 1 check in the positive column and ... well, good job.

by tonythetiger

We are individuals, with individual wants and needs. For the government to shove us all into their neat little boxes is a disservice to all of us.

by larryd4

If we live in a country that operates on the basis of a free market, then their will always be "a poverty" level. Socialism does a lot better, in theory, of eliminating poverty, since everyone is equal. But the humnan condition proves that their will always be someone who is going to try and take adavantage of the uneducated and/or impoverished person.

Hence the issues with illegal aliens. If jobs that paid below the poverty level didn't exist we wouldn't have any illegal aliens trying to get in to the country on the level we have. The minimum wage is their to make sure all is paid above the poverty level. But to make minimum wage you have to be a legal citizen.

by dwdino

I almost have to bring a shovel with me to clear a path for response.

1) Socialism does NOTHING better. It simply removes any allowance for exceptional people to perform so everyone is restrained to the lowest common denominator.

2) "Free Market" Capitalism creates classes because it shows what people are made of (on the whole). As with any man made system, there will always be abusers. For the most part though, it allows those that wish to accel to do so.

Poverty is permanent until all people internalize two factors - honesty and responsibility.

by tony hopkinson

Though I'll admit the bit off the top is popular with so called socialist politicians. What they continually and in my opinion deliberately ignore.
If you taxed Bill Gates heavily after making sure his accountants couldn't find a way for him not to pay, you could use his entire income up funding one anti-poverty program for a year.

And they don't bother with the accountants bit (they use the same ones), so they don't take it off the top they take it off the middle, us.

Anyone with two brain cells in close proximity could figure this out, so statistically it's got to be deliberate.

Capitalism is fuedalism writ large, and feudalism maintains class distinctions for the benefit of the ruling majority.

Doesn't matter how good you are if you are competing with the CEO's nephew.

by av .

The underground economy. Cash under the table. Day labor. They make just as good a living as a person making minimum wage because they supplement their income by taking advantage of all of our public services and don't pay any taxes. Neither do their employers. Healthcare, education, etc. is all free to them.

Fortunately, with the economic downturn, alot of them are going back home. The work has dried up. I don't know if you ever saw this article in the Star-Ledger, but this is how desperate some illegals are.

http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/01/29/porch.cave/

It shouldn't be allowed, but it is because there is a market for illegals. No taxes. No laws. Cash under the table. Instead of paying minimum wage for restaurant workers, landscapers, maids, etc., they hire illegals, as needed. Authorities don't deport them. That undermines the lower-class legal workers in this country. As taxpayers, we end up supporting the lower class and the illegals. Its a no-win situation.

Sure, poverty will always exist to some extent, but I think its time to take a long hard look at who should receive our public services. Sure, theres lots of people content to be on the public dole, but we are not a socialist country (yet).

AV

by tony hopkinson

what you want is poverty.
what you need is abject poverty.

People have different wants and needs so what's the point of picking some number ot of hat, and saying this is poverty?

As far as I can see it's so you can isolate a mass of voters, promise them something you think they should want and then stick your face well deep in thr trough when the poor fools believe you.

by maxwell edison

First of all, the current global economic issues are another matter entirely. I didn't intend for the original message - a series of questions, really - to be tied into anything except an underlying question about the causes of and solutions for poverty - generally speaking. The reasons for you to segue that into an issue about the current economic situation is beyond me, nor do I care to go there right now.

Second of all, I linked to my other message because it answered the questions I asked in the first.

Third of all, your sarcasm comes across as a direct slam against me, and quite frankly, it's quite tiring. I thought we were beyond it, but I guess I was mistaken.

Okay, Oz, slam away.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Being rather intricately linked, even to some degree dependent upon the rest of the globe, I see no distinction.

by maxwell edison

.....that directly links the current economic situation with addressing poverty. If anyone else sees it, no link was intended.

Let's see, my original message started with a quote (from an unknown source) that was rather thought provoking, and I thought I'd throw it out for discussion.

About the only comment I made was expressing my opinion that President Johnson's [i]War on Poverty[/i] has been a failure, and we should devise an exit strategy.

Otherwise, I asked about a dozen questions, none of which were about the current economic situation, and all of which were about how to define poverty, the kinds of poverty, and other general underlying questions about it. I didn't answer them myself in the original message, nor were they leading.

For Oz to segue into a rant about the global economic crisis and how the United States sucks (what else is new?), it didn't do anything to answer any of the questions - especially when he opened with yet another insult aimed at me. (His preferred sport around here.)

But actually, since you mention it, I suppose there is actually a link between the current economic crisis and the, so called, [i]War on Poverty[/i].

Since 1964 when those programs first went into effect (and later expanded upon), we've spent upwards of 12 trillion dollars - [b]an amount equal to our entire national debt![/b] on programs funding poverty. And for what? It didn't eliminate a poverty class. It only created a dependent class. Moreover, in the United States, the percentage of citizens living below the poverty line had DECLINED every decade (with the exception of the 1930s) since the Civil War. Poverty was in decline, and most importantly people were lifting themselves out of it WITHOUT government help and without simply becoming dependent. The poverty level (as defined at the time) had actually dropped from 23 percent in 1958 to 19 percent in 1964, continuing its historical downward trend. The funds provided by the [i]War on Poverty[/i] did drop the level to the 12 percent range, where it's been ever since. (The definition and thresholds of [i]poverty[/i] are another matter.)

If you think about it, however, the only reason for that drastic drop was not that the circumstances changed so that the trend of people lifting themselves out of poverty continued, but rather it provided a flow of money so they didn't have to. It simply gave them more money (government money) to skew the statistics in favor of more people [i]earning[/i] enough to be counted above the line. But they didn't [i]earn[/i] anything, it was given to them. The natural and self-caused downward trend was abruptly halted, and a dependent class had been created.

Look at ALL of the underlying statistics attached to those living in poverty: drug use, single-parent homes, unwed mothers, absent fathers, teenagers having babies, gangs, school dropouts - ALL of them have drastically INCREASED since the government started funding poverty.

And I suppose our current mortgage and banking crisis could also be blamed, in large part, to yet another government attempt to make people more dependent, and to get more people into home ownership than otherwise would be. In 1964, a mortgage was one of the most secure loans a banker could make. None of them would dream of loaning mortgage money to someone who couldn't prove an ability to repay. But that was before government started funding more poverty programs. From the late 1970s into the 2000s, because of government guarantees on loans for people who otherwise wouldn't qualify, and because of government pressure to force more of such loans, we now see the house of cards tumbling down because of bad mortgages. (It's so easy blaming greedy mortgage executives. Yea, right!)

As to Oz's message, I truly don't think it's possible for him to answer some general questions without finding a way to tie them into yet another slam America or insult Maxwell tirade. Out of the 90, or so, replies to the original message, he was the first to do it - and the first to see the alleged link between my original message and the current underlying economic situation. But now that the link has been established, I gave my take on it.

Let the politically motivated flames begin!

by av .

I agree with Tony. They fear the police. They also fear the criminals, but they stand with them for fear of retribution.

AV

by tonythetiger

[i]Instead of supporting those poor with taxpayer dollars, I'd much rather favor a law that demands a father support his children, lest he finds himself in jail until his children become adults.[/i]

can be addressed by changing the laws that strongly favor giving primary physical custody to mothers (it's often just back-door alimony, since the father has no say in how the money is actually spent... it's amazing how many "new fluffys" get new motorcycles at the ex-husband's expense while the children suffer)). Unless there's a damned good reason, or the parents agree otherwise, physical custody should be required to be 50/50.

[soapbox]
(Or, if "the best interest of the child" was really what the government was after, they could read the statistics (that show that children from "father only" families do better in every category than children from "mother only" families), and legislate accordingly!)
[/soapbox]

by tonythetiger

[i]People have different wants and needs so what's the point of picking some number ot of hat, and saying this is poverty?[/i]

Yet that's exactly what our government does... and they don't even take into account regional or local cost of living differences!

by dwdino

But I have yet to see one socialist attempt that has not resulted in Marxism (or some close proximity). More importantly, any system which fails to reward the risk takers and the over achievers eventually sinks into the abyss.

Interesting points, but I have difficutly determining your stance.

First, taxing Gates as described above would due two things; create an unjust load, and a negative driver for success.

"Capitalism is fuedalism writ large, and feudalism maintains class distinctions for the benefit of the ruling majority." save one very important thing - capitalism won't behead you for changing your class.

by dhcdbd

NCJ Number: NCJ 060262
Title: MINORITY ELDERLY (FROM POLICE AND THE ELDERLY, 1979, BY ARNOLD P GOLDSTEIN ET AL - SEE NCJ-60259)
Author(s): V L WISE ; W J HOYER
Corporate Author: Pergamon Press, Inc
United States
Publication Date: 1979
Pages: 8
Origin: United States
Language: English
Annotation: A REVIEW OF THE PROBLEM OF CRIME AGAINST THE ELDERLY AS IT AFFECTS THE BLACK AND SPANISH ELDERLY, AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR POLICE-COMMUNITY RELATIONS AND POLICE TRAINING ARE PROVIDED.
Abstract: ALTHOUGH MANY OF THE PROBLEMS OF THE MINORITY ELDERLY ARE SIMILAR TO THOSE OF THE WHITE ELDERLY, THE PROBLEMS ARE HEIGHTENED BY SUCH FACTORS AS POVERTY AND RACISM. TWO AREAS THAT ARE ESPECIALLY TROUBLESOME FOR THE MINORITY AGED ARE FEAR OF CRIME AND FEAR OF POLICE. CRIME RATES AGAINST MINORITIES ARE HIGHER AND ARE INCREASING AT A FASTER RATE THAN AGAINST WHITES. ON THE AVERAGE THERE ARE BROAD DIFFERENCES IN THE SOCIOECONOMIC LEVEL AND LIVING ARRANGEMENTS OF NONWHITE AND WHITE ELDERLY. MINORITY ELDERLY ARE MORE LIKELY TO LIVE IN POVERTY AND TO BE CONCENTRATED IN CENTRAL CITY GHETTOS OR RURAL POCKETS OF POVERTY. MINORITY ELDERLY ARE ALSO MORE FEARFUL OF POLICE AS A RESULT OF HAVING LIVED DURING AN ERA WHEN POLICE BRUTALITY, RACIAL OPPRESSION, AND DISCRIMINATION WERE MORE COMMON. POLICE WORK IN MINORITY COMMUNITIES IS ESPECIALLY DIFFICULT BECAUSE OF LACK OF UNDERSTANDING AND COOPERATION BETWEEN POLICE AND MINORITIES, ESPECIALLY THE ELDERLY. UNDERSTANDING THE WAYS IN WHICH MINORITIES HAVE BEEN OPPRESSED AND DENIED EQUAL OPPORTUNITY IS HELPFUL TO EFFECTIVE POLICE WORK. THE SHIFT FROM CRIME-CENTERED LAW ENFORCEMENT TO FULL-SERVICE POLICING EMPHASIZING POLICE-COMMUNITY RELATIONS MUST GATHER MOMENTUM TO STRENGTHEN COOPERATION BETWEEN THE POLICE AND MINORITIES. A STATISTICAL TABLE AND REFERENCES ARE PROVIDED. (KCP)
Index Term(s): Black Americans ; Older adults ; Hispano Americans ; Crimes against the elderly
http://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=60262

The Influence of Race/Ethnicity, Social Class, and Neighborhood Context on Residents' Attitudes Toward the Police
Amie M. Schuck

University of Illinois at Chicago, amms@uic.edu

Dennis P. Rosenbaum

University of Illinois at Chicago

Darnell F. Hawkins

University of Illinois at Chicago

The purpose of this study is to extend our understanding of attitudes toward the police by examining how race/ethnicity, social class, and neighborhood context interact to influence four different dimensions of attitudes: neighborhood, global, police services, and fear of the police. The results showed significant racial/ethnic variation in perceptions of the police, with African-Americans reporting the most negative attitudes. The magnitude of the racial/ethnic gap, however, varied across the different attitude dimensions with the largest difference between African-Americans and Whites in terms of fear of the police. The findings also suggested that African-Americans' and Hispanics' perceptions of the police are moderated by the interaction of social class and neighborhood socioeconomic composition. Middle-class African-Americans and Hispanics who resided in disadvantaged neighborhoods reported more negative attitudes toward the police than those who resided in more advantaged areas. Overall the study findings highlight the complex interplay between experiences, community context, social class, and type of attitudinal assessment in understanding within and across racial and ethnic variation in residents' perceptions of the police.
http://pqx.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/11/4/496

A new survey released today indicates that public trust in the law enforcement system has dropped substantially among minorities, undermining the legitimacy of the criminal justice system, and hindering effective policing in minority communities. Only 20% of Latino and African American survey respondents say they have "a lot of faith" in local law enforcement, compared to 85% of white respondents. One reason for declining trust is the continuing practice of racial profiling, according to civil rights activists. Reginald Wilson, executive director of the Black Ministers Council stated, "Policymakers underestimate the burden placed on innocent people stopped by law enforcement officers because of racial profiling. These incidents lead to a reasonable fear of police officers, and risk alienating communities while doing little to serve law enforcement." Daniel Nelson is a typical example of how trust is undermined by racial profiling. Nelson is a well-dressed young African American man who works as an accountant. Last month he was stopped by state troopers: "It was early in the morning and I was driving my Ford Explorer when I saw the blue lights of a patrol car. My heart sank because I was worried about being late for a job interview, but I thought it wouldn't take long. Instead of simply asking for a driver's license, the trooper called for backup and started to go through every inch of the Explorer, pulling off door panels and looking under the carpet. They said they were looking for drugs, but of course they found nothing. Afterwards, sitting in my trashed SUV, I wept in anger and humiliation." Though publicly decried, police departments across the country continue to train police officers to profile based on race, ethnicity, and religion. In fact, the Drug Enforcement Administration's Operation Pipeline, which was intended to disrupt the shipment of cocaine on highways, emphasized the correlation between drug trafficking and racial characteristics. According to Jim Davis, a New Jersey state trooper, "Our supervisors trained us to focus on black- and brown-skinned drivers because we were told they were more likely to be drug traffickers." The reality, however, is that the "hit rate" ? the percentage of searches in which contraband is found ? is the same for black and white drivers according to studies conducted in Maryland, New Jersey, and California. But African American and Latino drivers are far more likely to be stopped and searched, according to a new U.S. Department of Justice report. Even when all factors are taken into account, such as the neighborhood's ethnic makeup, crime rate, etc., African American and Latino drivers are 2-3 times as likely to be stopped and searched as white drivers. "Racial profiling not only constitutes discrimination; it is also an unsound, inefficient method of policing," noted trooper Davis. And the impact, according to Wilson, "Extends beyond direct victims to negatively affect all persons of color, because we all lose faith in law enforcement when we hear about these injustices."
http://www.frameworksinstitute.org/ezine30.html

Put the data together and answer the question.