Discussion Locked

[i]There will always be poverty in this country as long as. . . . . .

0 helpful
276 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

276 replies

by tonythetiger

of people who make money under the table who are here legally (some of whom make well above minimum wage). That's a tax avoidance problem, not an illegal alien problem per se. There are also many people making at or above the minimum wage yet don't work enough hours to make "poverty level".

The solution to the tax avoidance problem is to make the tax unavoidable. Tax consumption, not income. That way if you're a drug dealer who made a million dollars a year, you'd pay taxes when you spent it.

The illegal alien problem wouldn't be a problem if we eliminated minimum wage laws.

by tonythetiger

How many of those foreclosed homes were second or third homes? How many are in foreclosure because the owner took out equity to buy a Beemer or some other bauble?

by oz_media

As always, nice little blocker at the end too, how immature.

I welcome your rebuttal.

You do nto see poverty and the current global economic situation as tied together to teh point of being one and the same? One breeds the other and, as I noted myself, poverty in one small nation can lead to economic struggle for the entire planet.

But if you wish to discuss the definition of darkness without recognizing absence of light is directly related to the cause of darkness, then you go ahead.

by tonythetiger

[i]You do nto see poverty and the current global economic situation as tied together to teh point of being one and the same?[/i]

because poverty existed even in the best of economic times.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"You do not see poverty and the current global economic situation as tied together to the point of being one and the same?"[/i]

Poverty and the economic crisis being [i]one in the same[/i]? Are you suggesting that the [i]War on Poverty[/i] caused the current economic crisis? Or are you suggesting the mere presence of poverty caused it? Please make your case.

Please elaborate. What, exactly, are you suggesting?

You said, [i]"One breeds the other and, as I noted myself, poverty in one small nation can lead to economic struggle for the entire planet."[/i]

Please, give me a break. Abject poverty in some interior African nation has absolutely no affect on the economy of the United States. If you disagree, I'd welcome your reasoning.

You said, [i]"But if you wish to discuss the definition of darkness without recognizing absence of light is directly related to the cause of darkness, then you go ahead."[/i]

No, what I wanted to discuss was the difference between abject poverty and relative poverty. Light, or the absence thereof, has nothing to do with it.

by dhcdbd

Title:
About New York; Where Police Are Eroding Self-Respect.
Authors:
DAVID GONZALEZ
Source:
New York Times; 2/10/1999, p1, 0p
Document Type:
Article
Abstract:
ALTHOUGH the wind and cold can make for a miserable walk home, Floyd Coleman refuses to keep warm and dry under his jacket's hood. Same thing goes for the bandanna he usually sports to protect the waves in his hair. As bad as the elements might be, he is preoccupied by a more elemental fear in his Bronx River neighborhood. He doesn't want to make waves with the plainclothes police officers on patrol. ''Even when it's cold, I try not to wear my hood,'' said Mr. Coleman, 27, who works at a youth center. ''Especially at night, because you're going to get stopped.'' [ABSTRACT FROM PUBLISHER]

Copyright of New York Times is the property of New York Times and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts)
Full Text Word Count:
1008
ISSN:
03624331
Accession Number:
29905723
http://web.ebscohost.com.tproxy01.lib.utah.edu/ehost/detail?vid=7&hid=112&sid=d968626e-092c-4645-8678-69e1247df611%40sessionmgr104&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=aph&AN=29905723

by tonythetiger

[i]Socialism does NOTHING better. It simply removes any allowance for exceptional people to perform so everyone is restrained to the lowest common denominator.
[/i]

It removes the motivation for better performers to perform better, thereby lowering the standard of living for every member (Hmm... where have I heard that before)

by tonythetiger

[i]Going back to the old days, where you had to have a certain income to vote seems like a really bad idea.[/i]

An intelligence test would be nice :)

by oz_media

[i]"For Oz to segue into a rant about the global economic crisis and how the United States sucks (what else is new?), it didn't do anything to answer any of the questions - especially when he opened with yet another insult aimed at me. (His preferred sport around here.) "[/i]

First of all, I am obviously not the only one who saw relationship. Instead of discussing this possibility you throw it out as me [i]"ranting about the current global economic crisis and how the United States sucks"[/i].

Please, while on the bandwagon of definitions you seek, [b]define rant[/b] and show me the passage where I mentioned [i]the United States sucks[/i]. In fact I equated your needs to our own, and said NOTHING derogatory about the USA in any way at all, except for in your own skewed vision.

I wait patiently for your insight and proof of your rash allegations, however it will suit you more to simply say you have had enough and don't find it worthy of your time, again being quite predictable.

[i]"he opened with yet another insult aimed at me. (His preferred sport around here.) [/i]

I said "There will always be poverty in this country as long as. . . . . .
...it isn't run by Max Edison, the true knowledge of what it takes to run a government."

How is that an insult of ANY kind? It is only an insult if you see it as sarcasm, however the exact same phrase can be quite complimentary, intoning that your wisdom could resolve such issues, its your choice to decipher you choose of course, just like everything else you read.

However, your speaking to a third party and commenting on my habits and intents in such a negative manner is definitely an insult to me.

The the hypocrisy in your lame pursuit of mental superiority is hideous.

[i]"As to Oz's message, I truly don't think it's possible for him to answer some general questions without finding a way to tie them into yet another slam America or insult Maxwell tirade. Out of the 90, or so, replies to the original message, he was the first to do it - and the first to see the alleged link between my original message and the current underlying economic situation.

Is it? out of 90mreplies I was teh first to slam America? Again, how do you read things like that when they are not said?

You didn't take the other 90 replies and use the same yardstick on them did you? Again illustrating your personal bias towards myself.

[b]But now that the link has been established,[/b] I gave my take on it"[/i]

So you admit you have great bias when reading my comments, in fact clearly so much so that you are blinded into a single, negative view towards anything I say.

You accept someone else seeing the relation, but from me it is anti-American ranting.

Yet you deem me shallow and on an undying misison to degrade America with a single, biased focus, which I haven't shown in my comments but you clearly display on your own bias.
[i]
"I truly don't think it's possible for him to answer some general questions without finding a way to tie them into yet another slam America or insult Maxwell tirade. "[/i]

"Slam America" and "tirade", great words! How are they applicable to my post? It was neither a slam on America nor a Maxwell tirade.

You just make it up as you go (and dig the hole deeper in the process) instead of just saying, 'oooops, maybe I read it wrong and got the wrong impression', as you clearly did.

This is a pi$$ing contest YOU'Ve created now, not me.

I offered a simple comment and explained how I saw it related to your original post, you saw that as an attack on America [i](somehow, or simply due to your personal bias against myself)[/i], and have said how you read everything I say that way.

I'll reneg my first comments, I think it takes someone much more aware of his surroundings to reduce poverty and economic struggle, or two different people because the two issues are clearly unrelated, or so I am now told.

by av .

They're here for the quick buck. Maybe I'm naive, but I think the housing scams were more perpetrated by legal citizens scamming the system.

AV

by maxwell edison

.
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/warner-todd-huston/2008/10/09/calling-old-media-five-million-illegals-have-illegal-mortgages-u

Not to say that those 5 million caused the problem, but it was damn sure a significant part of it.

I have always been critical of President Bush for failing to address the issue (the immigration issue) - just like the presidents before him:

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=44468

President Obama will, most likely, be no better - maybe even worse in that regard.

by tonythetiger

[i]have always been critical of President Bush for failing to address the issue (the immigration issue) - just like the presidents before him:
[/i]

That illegal immigration would not BE a problem if it weren't for the socialist-leaning policies that make it attractive for them to come here.

by av .

I do remember several years back hearing about that on Lou Dobbs, now that you mention it. But 5 million? I suppose we'll be bailing them out too.

No president wants to address illegal immigration because its such a political hot potato. If theres a silver lining in the recession, its that many of their illegal jobs have dried up. Many have left the country and many more will follow (I hope).

I think if Bush had initially presented a plan stressing border security instead of a temporary worker program, he wouldn't have had a problem. That wouldn't have addressed the 20 million illegals in this country, but we already have laws on the books to address them. All we have to do is enforce existing laws.

I don't think Obama is even remotely thinking about illegal immigration at the moment. His plate is full. He has to start thinking about border security though on the US - Mexico border. Not a good situation there.

I can't even imagine what Obama would come up with to solve the illegal immigration problem, but I'm not going to be happy with any kind of amnesty-type program. I want to see our existing laws enforced.

AV

by oz_media

That's a pretty simlistic view of reality but its at least a view.

So when poverty results in disease (the two are intricately tied together)in third world countries and raises the price of goods on your store shelves, reduces the amount of goods available to you for import, increases the chance of disease introduced through such imports, you do not see a relation between the current economic struggle and poverty?

By donating funds to help teh sick and diseased in third world countries, you are in turn protecting your own investments, foreign workers.

Without foreign workers you have no foreign imports, or at least affordable foreign imports, which you rely on so badly.

The economy and global welfare/poverty is VERY cloesly tied.

by tony hopkinson

I'm a real socialist.

That means I give the community at least the same level of priority as an individual. Anyone who acts against the community's interest for individual gain, gets a kicking.
Calling yourself a socialist and then ripping off society. Where's my axe...

Call it the right to communal happiness. :p

by tonythetiger

[i]Anyone who acts against the community's interest for individual gain, gets a kicking.[/i]

Does it work the other way too? Should "the community" have the right to determine that what's in an individual's best interest is not in the community's best interest, and deny the individual?

I'm imagining euthanizing the elderly or "undesirables" ... or forcing abortions... Not to mention forced labor...

Scary stuff...

by maxwell edison

.....that same [i]third party[/i] commented on the dialogue between you and me, apparently supporting you.

Nonetheless, you should really settle down. You're bordering on being extremely mean-spirited - just like you've been to jdclyde, sleepin'dawg, JamesRL,......

by jdclyde

"it isn't FAIR that you have so much while this other person has so little"....

Of course we don't hear how it isn't "fair" that the person with "so much" busted their arse to get it, while the one with "so little", well, didn't.

by the scummy one

but generally, yes..

Just like when they cover stuff like this in the news and try to make it out as these people are soo poor that they cannot afford things -- but they are getting high in the side yard and downing 40's, smoking cigs, and complaining that they cant afford rent, but chatting about how cool their new video game for their PS3 is.

LOL

by jdclyde

If black on black crimes are higher, then how is that NOT something to note about someone when looking for suspicious activities?

Ages, the way someone is dressed, where they are at certain times of the day/night, and yes, race, are all valid things to look at.

When there is not a higher percentage per capita, then we can talk about it NOT being valid.

The key isn't if they get questioned, but convicted based upon the profile.

Then again, I have found out first hand that the laws of this nation are for controlling us, not protecting us.

by dhcdbd

is implied in those three abstracts and the manner in which they are ordered in response to the post above it.

What you point out, while valid in each points own right, is not the question.

Call it a test of perception, if you will. What it addresses is the assertion that the poor and minorities fear the criminals more than the police and so side with the criminal. It is true that in the ghetto a drug dealer may be more respected than whatever, but this does not surrender to the idea that the poor side with the criminal; it would be more indicative of respect shown to a person getting ahead in oppressive circumstances.

Regarding dress, where I live one would get questioned by the police for wearing holey jeans, but when I lived in L.A., seemingly centuries ago, those holey jeans may be covering a multimillionaire.

If I am standing in front of a building at midnight and the alarm goes off, even if I am the only one in sight, does that mean I attempted to enter the building? How about if there is a bus stop there as well?

If I refuse to talk to police, does it mean I have something to hide?

If I were black and lived in Washington D.C. would racially profiling me be proper? How about Cuban and living in Tampa. What about if I were Hispanic and in Texas. Without something more, profiling is simply intolerable. The Hispanic, if I did not speak English or spoke English poorly with a heavy accent, then there would be reasonable suspicion that I might be an illegal immigrant. But the suspicion is only a suspicion unless proven. I know several Hispanics here in Utah that are about my age and whom speak no English and were born here in Utah.

Yes, the laws are for controlling us and not protecting as the police are for busting us and not protecting us.

It is a controversial area, which is why I switched to backing my statements; I had already stated, I believe to you, that my opinion is based on research, not sentiment.

It is a proven fact, that police are responsible for much domestic violence; that they take out their job frustration on their wifes and children. Why, then, are police allowed to carry weapons on and off duty that the rest of us are restricted from? Why is a convicted felon prohibited from owning a sidearm? If the conviction were for armed robbery, it makes sense; it the conviction were for bad checks, it is idiotic; if the conviction were for murder, then a grey area is entered because most murders are one off crimes of passion. Each item needs to be taken in total context.

by jdclyde

and more than just fear, there are also many that sympathize with the criminal as making the most of a bad situation. They rationalize the drug dealer.

by jdclyde

To many bleeding hearts for a reasonable amount of personal responsibility to be expected.

The bleeding hearts would talk about how it is "inhumain" to allow someone/anyone to go without, followed by crap about the "less fortunate".

It is the right thing to do, but will never happen.
[b]
"Don't feed the animals".[/b] is not a sign hung up to be "mean" to animals but for their own good.

by jck

impoverished doesn't mean you're unable to work.

try telling them that.

i still say let people who won't work for their welfare check starve.

if someone tries to work and holds a job and is still starving...then help them.

God helps those who helps themselves...and so do I. :)

by oz_media

But thanks for teh 2 cents anyway.

As for being mean spirited, you and your friends can have and hold your opinions close to keep you warm if need be. Its always one sided from yoru court anyway.

One person was trolling ever post I made and I got fed up with it.

Another person has a history of purposely being a loser and pi$$ing me off, not your problem either.

I agreed with the other person who felt a need to continuously reiterate his stand even though I had not said otherwise and therefore I was somewhat condescending, which is acceptable when it is coming from you.

So have a nice evening and find a better way to pass your time other than seeking conflict with everything I say.

You made false assertions about me that were shown incorrect and you couldn't/didn't support them, when called on that your only response is to talk about people that I have had differences with?

Moderator Max? Give it up already, its a pathetic game and I'm not playing.

by oz_media

Seeing as one feeds the other, they are very directly related, some even see the current state of poverty and economic weakness as leading to the predicted major changing of mankind in 2010. Not myself but I do see how these issues are all linked together and not just one nation's problem or solution.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

wasn't supporting anyone. Current economic issues are global issues, just as poverty is a global issue.

Governments can't do away with poverty, economic systems can't do away with poverty.

Poverty is a naturally occurring force that shapes life, not to mention the planet that supports that life.

I support a larger view in most things, which occasionally get me nailed for generalism. Whatthefuckever.

by oz_media

Poverty results in increased sickness and disease.

Povety in nations that we rely on for our daily means, results in reduced production of our imported goods due to a dwindlng, capable labour force.

A reduction in our imports means greater prices for our imports, which equates to a great deal of our daily needs.

Increased costs create poverty in our own nations, poverty creates greater risk of sickness and a reduced mortality rate amongst our own people; this is due to greater risk of disease transmission from imported goods, as well as reduced expendible income and thus a reduced ability to provde proper care for our families and ourselves.

The inability to pay for such imports increase poverty levels in other countries we rely on but who also rely on our purchasing thier exports, which further reduces our available products, which further increases our costs, which further increases our poverty, which further increases our risks sickness and diseases and so on.

Poverty in other nations has a very direct impact on our own poverty level, our health and our economy as a whole. Is it instantaneous? No, but the trickle down effect is undeniable.

by rob mekel

I agree that some of the money spend by government is bad spend, special if the money goes to companies that use that money to pay the extraordinairy bonusses to their kicked-out-for-bad-management managers.
At least we have, allthough minor, a vote in who is in the government.

Tell me if I'm incorrect, didn't GM and Chrysler ask the Obama-administration for money to survive in the private sector ... wasn't that same crisis brought on rol by the private sector by malicious management.
I guess I don't have to bring up Enron again or other themselfs enriching parties.

My guess is that we're [b]not[/b] better off with the private sector taking care of
[i]"the goal of assisting those living in poverty"[/i]
And given the 2 options ... the quest goes to ...
[b]government[/b]

by rob mekel

that can contains their own "cookies" :^0

The question one should ask is:
Why has the government to spend "our" money to companies that have to deal with bad-management ?:|

by rob mekel

even [b]if[/b] we leave it to private ... government will control it ... then wth don't we cut out the middle man ... let's say ... cut out private ... as the only thing that their good for is sticky fingers were the money stays ]:)

So all in all let's leave it to Government ;)

by rob mekel

"Take the money saved and put it into more law enforcement and criminal justice. Punish those who would commit crime to make money instead of working"

Oops, btw, ... isn't law enforcement a task of government AND citizens, who let the force-side of that to the authorities.
[b]Mmm, so after all you do agree: War on poverty is not to be left to the private sector[/b] :p :D ;)

by tonythetiger

Poverty does not increase the crime rate significantly. What he's saying (I think) is take money away from something the government shouldn't be doing (benefiting individuals) and apply it to something they SHOULD be doing (benefiting everyone).

by jck

that the "war on poverty should be left to the private sector"

with private sector comes the likely instance of putting private sector gains over what their clients benefit.

that's obvious no matter what sector of private industry you look at. profit is their main concern.

government is better at doing things with more concern to their client, because government is responsible to everyone...from Bill Gates and Warren Buffet, down to the homeless guys on the street I met in NYC in 2002.

private industry is only responsible to itself (shareholders) and any regulator authority overseeing it. once regulation is met, however, then all bets are off as to what private industry must do.

put more concern with quality of service?
put more concern with quantity of profit?

I would rather stake the war on poverty being fought by government, with all citizens overseeing its operation and making sure it does well enough or not.

by maxwell edison

[i]Abject[/i] poverty in third-world countries is one issue, [i]relative[/i] poverty in this one is another.

by maxwell edison

.....you started this with the first sentence of your first message. As far as those other guys, I was merely making an observation.

by tony hopkinson

If you are say talking about getting rid of grandma. If it's a communla decision, it's your grandma as well. Do you think truly think a community would be better off without our grandmothers?

I don't, I doubt many would.

The "if that old bat was out of the way, I'd have the spare room back" doesn't scale.

by tony hopkinson

after all they are cheaper so by employing one, you can cut your costs....

The only way to stop it is to make them too expensive. Like crippling fines and jail terms for employing them, anything else is a waste of money curing the symptom.

Giving Juan a good crack round rhe ear before you toss him back over the border, is simply an occupational hazard for him.

by larryd4

As a few people have questioned, what defines poverty and also stated poverty occurs across all goverment, social, types.

My point was poverty is a place to be in, a mind set that occurs, and a place in somce cases you are put.

No matter what system we have there will always be mean people, nice people, selfless people, donators, benefactors, people who lie, people who don't lie, people who don't care. people who care to much, the list goes on.

Poor people, rich people, people in between, its what makes a society work.

Just like their will always be a black market their will always be a poverty level.

Granted their will be those cases of poeople who lost, whether it occured in the system or out. But most people who have been in "poverty" for more than a year or two will probably end up staying there, because its become them.

Its what makes up our concept of good and evil.

As an example,
Their are people on this board who think Bill Gates is the anti-Christ. Others who think he's man of the hour.
But facts or not, I'm sure he has fired people and I'm sure at some point in his career, he has used his business powers to put under companies. But on the other hand he is really smart and business savy...

So rather then force a poverty issue on government I think it might be smarter to start realizing that we have to look at ourselves and our concept of fair business practices.

by tonythetiger

if that is a goal for community policy.

The question, perhaps better phrased:

Do the community's rights override all individual rights?

by tonythetiger

since the poorest can't really fall much farther, is people hanging on to what wealth they have.

Some of them deserve to lose it, and will get no sympathy from me... the piper has to be paid. Others will lose too, but have the wherewithal to pick themselves up, dust themselves off and start again. They will be the future leaders. They don't want or need sympathy.

by tink!

that legislation of custody should not default to the mother, but nor should it default to the father. Every situation has to be handled on an individual basis. The mother is not automatically the best parent. There are many situations where the father would be better for the kids.

by tonythetiger

how "the best interest of the child" issue only comes up in a divorce.

Then abracadabra, the mother wins because she's the "nurturer" (the only time she loses in contested cases is where clear danger is evidenced in court). Even though suicide, drug abuse, school drop-out, teen pregnancy, etc. are ALL much higher in homes where the father is absent vs. homes where the mother is absent. Girls raised mother-only homes are also 15 times more likely to end up on public assistance than girls raised in father only homes (across all income levels!). And yet the government, knowing this, INTENTIONALLY puts children with their mothers 89% of the time! It should be crystal clear that a child needs more than "every other weekend and two weeks in the summer" to get what they need from their father, and that money alone is no replacement for that.

"The best interest of the child" standard should not be applied any differently to divorced or never-married parents than it does to married ones. To do so is a blatant violation of the 14th amendment. It should have been thus decided long ago, but the courts know that the government would be giving up a significant amount of control as well as money, not to mention all the "victims" they are creating.

I truly despise what this country is becoming...

by tonythetiger

of these fines? The government?

What of the consumers who will now pay extra twice? Once for the increased labor cost, and once because the business will include the "crippling fines" in their product costs.

Do you suppose the government will turn over that fine money to the consumers of that company's goods or services? Fat chance! It'll probably go to some department heads new office furniture.

Stupid, stupid people... "sue them... fine them... make them pay..." don't they realize that in doing so they're screwing themselves? Every cost a business has goes into their product.

by tonythetiger

illegal is illegal, but in principle, yes. Everyone should have the opportunity to better themselves, regardless of any artificially imposed citizenship based entirely upon the accidental location of your birth. (They didn't ask to be born there!)

Also I think we should ultimately be trying to integrate the planet. The best way to do that is via free access (I thoroughly understand that many sovereign nations may object :) ). We should also be working toward eliminating protectionism (which adds to the cost of every imported/exported product, but adds nothing to the quality of that product) as an economic strategy.

The world needs a new kind of government, one that truly holds every human being and all human beings in the highest regard and respect, but none of those currently in existence are quite it. (Actually, I probably shouldn't have said that, because now you're going to expect me to explain what I mean... but I'm afraid I can't. It's like art... I'll know it when I see it...)

by jdclyde

you DO penalize any company that breaks the laws by employing illegal aliens.

There should be both criminal and civil penalties for such criminal activity.

Anyone having anything to do with the illegal hiring should be put in jail, and hefty fines that equate to much more of a savings the illegals would ever have brought them, will discourage companies from doing so.

When the jobs dry up, the flow of illegals looking for WORK will dry up.

Of course, as many are also looking at gangs and drugs as their livelyhood, it won't effect them at all.

Border security still should be part of the equation. Build the fence, and fill a moat with alligators. B-)

by tonythetiger

"control" is WHY our government does what it does.

[i]So all in all let's leave it to Government[/i]

No, let's not! Let's instead look for peaceful means to reduce government's control of the individual. And if that doesn't work, it's time to cram as many politicians as we can into Ted Kennedy's car and have him take them for a ride.

by tonythetiger

[i]I agree that some of the money spend by government is bad spend[/i]

The answer to that is to give them MORE money to "bad spend"?

by rob mekel

that's better then let it to private where the money is only spend on themselfs ... ergo is worse spend and not on educating/financing measures that will get those ppl out of their isolation and let them become workers that help the economics out of the dip to regain faith and create jobs again.

To make it more clear [u]I'm not in for a government that makes rules to control us.[/u] Otherside is that I'm even less for leaving all to managers that get big bonuses while meanwhile companies they suposed to manage go bankrupt.

by tonythetiger

[i]that's better then let it to private where the money is only spend on themselfs[/i]

I am paying wages of people who make what I buy. If I spend more, and other spend more, more stuff will have to be made, and more people required to make it.

[i]Otherside is that I'm even less for leaving all to managers that get big bonuses while meanwhile companies they suposed to manage go bankrupt.[/i]

Don't deal with companies that do that. They'll fail, and another will grow to fill the need. That's the way it's SUPPOSED to work. It's a self-correcting mechanism if you just leave it alone.

by oz_media

"I said "There will always be poverty in this country as long as. . . . . .
...it isn't run by Max Edison, the true knowledge of what it takes to run a government."

How is that an insult of ANY kind? It is only an insult if you see it as sarcasm, however the exact same phrase can be quite complimentary, intoning that your wisdom could resolve such issues, its your choice to decipher you choose of course, just like everything else you read."

Pull your pants up under your armpits and have a laugh for Christ's sake, get over yourself.

by oz_media

Abject poverty in other countries is exactly what contributes to relative poverty in your own country. That's the whole point.

You aren't running around looking for rice with your unicef bowl. But the constantly rising cost of imported goods to teh US certainly has had a very negative effect on your nation, as well as ours. Where I work, we conduct business with many American companies. They import products for sale in North America, so YOUR prices have skyrocketed and so have ours as a result.

Example: the cost of US imports rises, tthus th ecost of OUR products rises, in which case our housing costs rise instantly. You import low votage wire from Brazil, tha wire then faces greater markup due to the US dollar, that is again marked up when it enters Canada, by the time teh builder buys it, the cost of the home goes up. The owners spend more for thier home and have greater debt. Sure, if they had a US mortgage that debt is pretty much irrelevant but up here you have to pay the bills.

If we buy less Brazillian wire, YOU buys less Brazillian wire, if YOU buy less Brazillian wire they earn less and it increases thier poverty level. Increased poverty in Brazil means greater illness and fewer workers. Fewer workers means that wire costs more, which directly inflouences the price of a new home.

Your increased cost of living directly increases our cost of living. As two different countries we are the most reliant on trade and have the greatest amount of trade and economic dependency on one another, definitely moreso than any other nation on the planet, so much so that we are an example of how international trade can create very powerful alliances while still retaining national sovreignity.

So as far as relative poverty, the change in the cost of living a comfortable life in America and Canada, is directly related to abject poverty in third world countries.

I really thought you had a more encompassing view of reality than that. Your view of an isolated, relative poverty is completely devoid of the connection.

There is a VERY direct connection, one that you seem to convneniently ignore or pretend doesn't exist at all as it doesn't suit your previous conclusion.

by maxwell edison

.....to my three major messages on the subject:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=302419&messageID=3020272

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=302419&messageID=3020975

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=302419&messageID=3021412

You (Oz) said, [i]"Abject poverty in other countries is exactly what contributes to relative poverty in your own country. That's the whole point."[/i]

Well, don't think you've understood my point. Regardless, I totally disagree with what you said, and your supporting argument didn't convince me. At worst, we can simply agree to disagree.

I still maintain that the best solution for ANY nation to reduce its rate of poverty is to increase its level of economic freedom.

You apparently want to look at is as a global issue, while I want to look at it as a national issue. You apparently have more of a global mind-set, while I don't. I believe Canada can deal with its own issues better than we can, and vice-versa. As to the causes of wide-spread abject poverty in third-world countries, the two most common underling causes are a tyrannical government and little, or no, economic freedom.

I'm not suggesting that the United States practice isolationism or turn a blind-eye to the problems of abject poverty in under developed nations. But until the circumstances that cause it in the first place are changed - that being, in large part, tyrannical governments and little, or no, economic freedom - there's little anyone can do - unless, of course, you want Canada's Army to march in and take over the place and force the bad guys out of power and put the good guys into power. (Ours won't do it.)

I don't think we can solve all the problems of the world. And when we do try to help solve some of those problems, I think it's best to do so from a position of strength and having our own house in order first. And part of getting our own house in order is to stop the madness of creating and perpetually supporting a dependent class. I think we (the U.S.) can show the world that simply throwing money into programs that support poverty will do nothing to solve it, but rather exacerbate it.

Just like during an in-flight emergency, if during your flight the oxygen masks drop from above, help children and others with their masks only after yours is secure.

The best way to help other nations is to be a better example.

The nations that have the highest rates of poverty ALSO have the lowest amount of economic freedom. The nations that score the HIGHEST on the Index of Economic Freedom, also have the lowest percentage of their population living below the poverty line (however measured). The higher the level of economic freedom, the lower the poverty rate will be. I want the United States to top that list again. Canada, by the way, is only one spot behind the USA, while Australia, Singapore, Hong Kong, Ireland, and New Zealand are ahead.

http://www.heritage.org/index/

You said, [i]"Abject poverty in other countries is exactly what contributes to relative poverty in your own country. That's the whole point."[/i]

Like I said, I disagree. And your arguments were far from convincing.

I say, less economic freedom in my country is exactly what contributes to higher rates of relative poverty in my country. Feel free to disagree, but I'm not the only one who sees it that way.

http://www.africanexecutive.com/modules/magazine/articles.php?article=3641&magazine=197

http://www.fsu.edu/news/2006/09/07/economic.freedom/

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3512

http://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/article/318

by oz_media

Well that is a solution but it doesn't detract from my comments at all.

Whether you want to accept my examples or not, they are real life example from trade that I conduct on a daily basis.

1)Third world country's make many of our day to day goods.

2)Our day to day goods effect our cost of living.

3)Supply and demand, with a reduction of such goods, our costs increase, thus our expenses do also and our luxuries are reduced accordingly.

4)Sickness and disease in third world countries effects the labour force, it is also directly related to poverty levels in those countries.

5)A reduced labour force in third world countries effects the amount of exports to our own.

6)Supply and demand again, reduced product availability, higher prices.

Its SO simple I don't know who you don't see the relation. I am not suggesting that it is teh answer to all oru economic woes, not at all, but there is a major contributing factor.

If you only consumed products made in America, I could accept your point, but as you are reliant on the rest of the world to support your economy, how can you possibly suggest that economic issues would be solely internal?

It isn't logical, no matter how scientific you want to make it, it is just simple economics.

"All wealth comes from resources and resources are in the countryside."

"America, with 5 percent of the world?s people, consumes 28 percent of the world?s resources. The resources from which all wealth comes are primarily in the undeveloped world, the ?countryside? of the developed world. "

Though this is not where I got my beliefs on the issue, it offers a similar and somewhat interesting viewpoint anyway : http://www.globalissues.org/article/5/economic-democracy

How do you hope to control an economy that is completely dependent on the rest of the world, without viewing it as a global issue?

Your ecomony is not self-reliant or independent, no matter how much you would like to believe it is, it isn't and can't be.

It might be easier for you to look at it this way, if Canada was a very poor nation.

1) We would have a greater level of sickness and disease amongst our people.
2) We would have reduced labour forces and production due to sickness amongst able bodied workers.
3)Our exports costs would soar
4)Your import costs and costs to the consumer would soar accordignly.

So if we were all poor and sick, what would the price of gas be at your pumps?

How much would you have to pay for lumber and other trades where strong, skilled workers are required to meet demands?

Do you not see how our economy directly effects your own and how if we were poor, sick, diseased etc. how that would flow to you also?

Would it not be in America's best interests to support Canadian workers, to sponsor companies in our country and contribute to our workers health and well being? Of course it would be.

by tonythetiger

[i]Supply and demand, with a reduction of such goods, our costs increase, thus our expenses do also and our luxuries are reduced accordingly.[/i]

raise minimum wage to $100 an hour! That'll fix everything!

[oops! forgot the [/sarcasm] tag]

by tony hopkinson

The right to harm your community for individual gain.

Too much talk about rights, far too little about duty.

I'm talking about a 'new' approach. One different enough to make us look at the way we've always done things and question it.

I bet most of the time 'we' do it to benefit some fat tw@t who made a sizable donation to some other fat tw@t's campaign chest.

It's got to stop.

by tonythetiger

[i]The right to harm your community for individual gain.[/i]

"individual gain". If I need a hip to walk again, is that considered individual gain?

Define "harm". Is being lazy considered harm? Is no longer being able to contribute to society considered harm?

by oz_media

Not even the same planet yet alone the same page.

Here's an example I just gave Max.

You have 5% of the world's population, yet consume over 25% of the world's resources.

This illustrates just how independent you are NOT.

If you rely on Africa for grains, and African workers all die from sickness and disease, that effects the price of beans on yoru grocery stores. YOUR cost of living rises and your expendable income is reduced proportionately.

A closer to home example:

Lets say Canada was a poor nation, responsible for supplying 60% of your oil imports.

We are poor, and thus sickness/disease follows (fact). We have a reduced capable labour force, therefore our export costs rise and your import costs rise.

If your import costs rise, so does the price of gas at US pumps. Your gas becomes more expensive, you have less disposable income from each paycheck, reducing your quality of life and putting many people below the poverty level.

Simple, right?

So the health and welfare of those who provide your resources, directly impacts YOUR quality of life, your relative poverty level.

Its so black and white, I wonder why Americans can't see the light?!

If you were completely resource indpenedent, I'd agree that your economic issues are solely internal, but you are not independent, no matter what the Constitution says.

It's no different than if Microsoft workers all got sick, how much would Windows cost in Canada?

If your own workers get sick or disease spreads through a workforce, you need to make adjustments in order to maintain an even economy.

So how is it so hard to see that, being reliant on so many other nations to feed and clothe you, that thier health and welfare is not directly related to your economic stability?

by oz_media

Even as sarcasm it doesn't make sense. Who'd pay the workers? You would with every product you bought from that company.

As that is not the case, you can pay pennies per hour for third world labour, but that labour needs ot be healthy or your costs rise proprtionately. Not to pass blame on one sole player, but WalMart feeds such a system. They pay less and less for goods, the workers in third world countries earn less, get sicker and manufacturer's are forced to hire less skilled labour to retain production. Less skilled labour reduces the prodct available, slower workers, and SHOULD eaise yoru costs but in that case, WalMart just pays less or doesn't have to pay at all due to production clauses and perpetuates the cycle.

Your economical stance and poverty level cannot be internally resolved when it is externally reliant.

by tonythetiger

[i]Even as sarcasm it doesn't make sense.[/i]

Just that people who think a mandated minimum wage is a good thing should think that a higher mandated minimum wage is a better thing, right?

by john.a.wills

by law the rent must include the property tax. Each year the renter gets a statement of where his rent went: heating, taxes, what-have-you.
In Britain the renter gets to pay the property tax himself (this may have changed in recent years, I haven't kept up, and there have been some changes in local taxation).

by tonythetiger

[i]In Britain the renter gets to pay the property tax himself (this may have changed in recent years, I haven't kept up, and there have been some changes in local taxation).[/i]

In multi-family multi-sized dwellings. Would each unit have to be individually appraised (two, three, and four bedroom) separately?

by tonythetiger

we only consume 25% of the world's oil and natural gas. We have plenty of grain (the government even pays farmers NOT to grow it... A bad policy, I admit... which is why I DON'T trust the government to do what's in the best interest of anyone except the government.)

by tonythetiger

It really is all about the paperwork...

Many of you know of the trials and tribulations I've had with trying to children's services to do their damned job correctly for the last four years. Well, I climbed the government ladder, finally ending up at the Governor's wife's office (yes, I know... she's not an "official" but she claims to be a child advocate). Well, I got a call today, saying that the Governor's office has reviewed the agency's paperwork and concluded that there doesn't seem to be a problem. Oh, and I have no standing to make a complaint anyway, since I'm not a technically a relative (The children are my ex-wife's niece's (I used to change her diapers... I walked her down the aisle, but since my ex-wife decided to find a new Mr. Fluffy, I no longer have any standing?!?!?))

[b]WELL OF COURSE NOT, IDIOT!!! They're the one's who screwed up! Do you REALLY think they're going to put in their report that THEY screwed up??? And It's relatives who are doing this to these children... What, you can only report child abuse and neglect if, you're related to the one doing it? Or what, you're expected to turn yourself in??? What MORONS!!!![/b]

ARRGHH!!!!

I have one more agency to go to before I hit the media.

It just makes me want to scream! Why, when you have someone willing to take care of ALL of these children, would you repeatedly and intentionally put them back into an environment of drugs and violence? How many chances do you get to hurt your children before they'll do anything except fill out their stupid papers?

I really, REALLY despise what this country is becoming...

by oz_media

Many US farms were 'set aside' for production of bio fuels. As a result teh US buys a great quantity of Canadian wheat from Saskatchewan and barley from central and eastern Canadian provinces.

This is a big issue for US farmers, thought you would have heard about it by now, but the US still imports these supplies from Canada. In fact 56% of American farmland is used for cattle production, not grains, vegetables etc. Out of your minimal production, eighty percent of the corn grown and 95% of the oats are fed to livestock. This leaves your farms providing only 20% of thier production to US consumers. Not enough to feed such a gluttonous and wasteful society by any means.

I am not saying Canadians don't waste energy or food but in the American desire to be bigger and richer, the mentality results in a lot more wasted resources from the US than other nations.

You are correct in that you consume a quarter of the world's "energy" resources, which also includes hydro electric power from British Columbia. We have had water shortages so that the wtaer sheds remain full for US (California specifically) Hydro consumption.

The fact that you grow much of your own grain is irrelevant, you produce a lot of your own oil too, but you still import a great deal as you live in a country of consumption, over consumtion to be more exact.

some figures, though a few years old: http://www.mindfully.org/Sustainability/Americans-Consume-24percent.htm

Material world statistics: http://www.mindfully.org/Resource/Material-World-Statistics.htm

Interesting anyway, though I am sure many Americans would deny the reality of it all.

by tony hopkinson

But I'm fast coming to conclusion that not taking your communal resposnsibility seriously should carry the death sentence. :p

What is so wrong about helping your community to help yourself. What's so wrong about helping yourself and in doing so helping your community?

Here's one measure for you to think about, if you have the bottle to consider something different to the current status quo.

Tax breaks for co-operatives.

by tony hopkinson

You seemd to be down on illegal workers, then someone suggest an effective measure (taking any profit out of employing them), and you are whining that you have to pay more for your flip-flops?

Which is it?
If you want the profit from their labour, either directly or indirectly then you are by definition in favour.

Having it both ways, is where you are now.

by tonythetiger

[i]What is so wrong about helping your community to help yourself. What's so wrong about helping yourself and in doing so helping your community?[/i]

But I'm in a better position to determine how much I can help than anybody else. And in the case of a large country such as this, I am in a better position to determine if (since I know my neighbor, I am more likely to be more aware of his needs), what kind of, and how much help my neighbor needs than some bean counter 1500 miles away. I can also deliver that help more efficiently (It costs me $100 to give my neighbor $100 worth of groceries. It costs the government over $300 to provide the same groceries) and deliver it better and faster.

Here's a little anecdotal example: About 15 years ago, a small (3,000 population) town near here request buses from the state...saying the elderly in a (gated) assisted living community didn't have any way to get anywhere. So the state provided two buses, costing almost $250,000, and a budget of $20,000 a year for fuel.

About four months into the year, they sent a request to increase the fuel budget to $40,000. The state decided to investigate, and discovered that the buses were used quite heavily, but that most of the riders never went anywhere. They got on the buses in the morning, rode around all day usually, and got off at the same stop in the evening. They were just tired of being cooped up and lonely! Once they figured that out, they contacted relatives of the residents and community leaders, and worked it out so that many of the relatives would visit more often, volunteers would visit the shut-ins and those with no visitors, and they got rid of both big buses provided by the state, and the village bought their own, smaller bus.

The morals: Sometimes throwing large amounts of money at a problem isn't the best solution, and you never know if the help you need is in your own back yard unless you ask.

by tony hopkinson

I am not a fan of big money buy offs to cure symptoms.
Particularly when it's my money. :p

Why were they stuck inside by themselves?

It's all about outlook and approach. I was employed locally for 19 years, there available to all my family and earning.
Some bugger came along with some sound business thinking, and wrecked that.
Not just for me either. I'd like to create an environment where something like that is considered on more than a bottom line basis, not by saying NO, but by bringing in factors where the bottom line would include, more than we can slim down the workforce by a few thousand, make loads of money and have the remaining tax payers pick up the slack.

Address why it was sound business thinking, not throw sound business thinking out of the window, which is pretty much mainstream 'socialist' thinking.

Get some long terms benefits, and assesment of long term costs in there. It was particularly galling when you add in how much tax payer help my employer had already had, before they bogged off with the lucre.

by Member 25348569

The Council Tax is on the basis of "banding" of properties which was originally done on the basis of relative market value within the tax authority area - city, county, whatever.

The TAx is worked out as a basic figure to start with and then it is modified according to a ratio to place the burden of taxation on more larger - presumably more expensive properties. So if you're in a band A property, you pay two thirds of the base figure, whereas in you're in a Band H property, you pay twice this figure. There are discounts on single occupancy (25%) or second homes (50%).

The original banding was done by Estate Agents (real estate brokers) and is a bit general and there has been gradual adjustment and fine-tuning over the years that we've been paying.

Once we stopped eating woolly mammoth and took up farming, it was inevitable that we got a ruling class and a priesthood, then an aristocracy and - like it or not - government. For most of our history the process of feeding and paying for the government and its services (whether we want them or not, whether we need them or not) has largely consisted of a bloke on a horse arriving at your hut and nicking your stuff or cutting bits off your body, subject to status.

Not a lot has changed, then.

Neil :)

by rob mekel

Ah if that is your point then by all means ... tell me how do we stop the sticky fingers of "top-managers" grabbing around in [u]our[/u] money-pot. The Fannie-Mae-managers and others are hard to stop if there isn't anybody making rules to good managementship. For sure as shareholders have the more short-term then long-term gain in their mind ... the short-term visions are taking the jobs at the moment ... from 5 to up to 15% or more let-go-unemployed ppl in the USA at the moment within a month of time. I'm not sure if that is the way to go.

Oh, btw, is he still alive ?:| Wasn't he very ill at the moment his niece was candidate for the Senate's-job of Hillary ?

by rob mekel

to say whether what you believe he is saying is what he means to say.

All I can do is read what he says take his conclusions ... take his arguments put them to his conclusions and see what logicaly happens ...

Take the money of from "War on poverty ..." [i]your individuals[/i]
Put it to "Law enforcement" [i]your benefiting everyone[/i]

As law enforcement is a task we put in the hands of police ... government ... that is unless we (on election day) deside to change that.

Hence my "Oops ... " realizing that the money and control is still to the government to spend.

to make totaslly clear on were I stand:
I'm not in favour of a government spending money on individuals. I'm even less in favour of a government that gives money to private companies to let them to deside that to money is spend on bonuses for the few.
I'm all for a governement that spends [u]our[/u] money to the benifit of all

by tonythetiger

we're nearly perfectly aligned.

Perhaps you'd agree that we should completely un-tax businesses, since they only include that tax in the cost of their goods and services anyway.

by jck

if you also forced, by law, business to remove all of that cost from the price they are charging for...including eliminating jobs of people who are hired to calculate those taxes and report them, maintain systems that do that for the companies, etc.

if you're saying government can't have the taxes

then you must be willing to tell the private enterprise they are not entitled to a dime of what they did not earn either.

otherwise, it will just become more profit margin for them and people will get no benefit from it.

hence if you don't support it, then you are proposing taking those monies they don't pay in taxes (which supports programs for many) and putting it in the pockets of the shareholders (which is the few)

Are you willing to say you'd mandate they remove all that from their bottom line if business tax was removed, including the overhead of handling/accounting for it, and guaranteeing that what would be everyone's tax money benefit not become money being given to "the individual" or "the few"?

by tonythetiger

[i]tell me how do we stop the sticky fingers of "top-managers" grabbing around in our money-pot[/i]

to the extent that they borrowed tax money. We shouldn't have let them do that. Nothing we can do about it now though.

There are people who invested in the debt as well... sucks to be them. They accepted the risk. I chose not to, and should not be made to.

by jamesrl

About Canada's "biggest" salaried earner, the president of Magna auto parts.

http://www.thestar.com/Business/article/592582

In 2007 he took home 70 million (CDN), between salary, consulting fees and stock options. For 2008, it will be under 10 million.

Funny I had to go to a bank branch yesterday, and the closest one to my office is in a swanky high fashion mall, with some upscale restaurants etc.

It was deserted. Some big sales at some places. No line ups at the eateries at lunch. The staff at the bookstore were very attentive.

James

by tonythetiger

[i]Why were they stuck inside by themselves?[/i]

Mostly because they weren't visited often enough by family. I suppose that maybe the "gate" gave the impression that they didn't want intrusions as well. Miscommunication.

by tonythetiger

[i]I am not a fan of big money buy offs to cure symptoms.
Particularly when it's my money.[/i]

... when it [b]doesn't[/b] cure the symptoms (and in fact makes them worse!).

by jck

If you make people work to get a welfare check, then what can happen is one of two things. An example, a welfare person is made to go to work at McDonalds in Atlanta making $8.50 an hour. How it would work is:

1) They work their 40 hours a week and maintain their job, and McDonalds pays them their check. If there is any supplemental amount that brings them above poverty level that is needed, that is paid to them by the state/federal government.

2) They work their 40 hours a week and maintain their job, McDonalds submits a bulk transaction to welfare for hours worked by welfare recipients. Based on that, welfare pays up to an amount meeting poverty level for that area.

How does this save?

1) The system is automated. Anyone who did not work...gets no check. (no extra cost, other than implementation)

2) Anyone who didn't get a check but worked their hours would have McDonalds Corporate contact welfare immediately to handle it as an emergency case. (This is done already in the current situation for missing/non-issued checks...so no extra cost)

3) The person working would be earning the majority of their welfare check. This would offset a large part of what they are paid now in whole by the American taxpayers.

Why did I say put the money into things like police and jails?

Because those who won't work and still would want things...would likely:

a) beg
b) live off someone willing to support them
c) steal

in the case of (c), you need more police to capture and detain them for prosecution...and eventual incarceration.

after that, what you need to do is make prisons punishment again. not a weight room or pool hall or tv room or social club.

make it hard labor. make it rehabilitative.

if people in prison are busy busting rock with a sledge hammer 50 yards apart in a quarry 10 hours a day, they don't have time to make weapons out of toothbrushes and what not. they're too busy working and sleeping and eating.

but in the case of government:

intelligent reform is the answer...not absolute demand for piecemeal elimination cases

by tonythetiger

Yes... that my reasoning is not economically motivated.

1. I believe everybody has the right to try to better themselves (trying is not guaranteeing...) regardless of where they are or where they're from.

2. I think that's what most of these illegal immigrants are trying to do.

3. The fact that they're willing to work under such poor conditions for so little pay makes me wonder how bad what they're trying to better themselves "from" could be.

4. As a human being, I worry about sending them back to the "from" mentioned above.

5. I wish we didn't have (or didn't need) borders.