Discussion Locked

Liberal looniness in the USA

0 helpful
122 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I find the following news item appalling. Such a thing would NEVER happen in Australia or any other nominally Christian nation that I can think of.

Face it. American politics is in very bad shape indeed. I don't know what you can do about it and I don't really care. You have a choice between a right-wing loony who thinks he is God, and left-wing loonies who are trying to eliminate God from the education system.

Read on and be appalled as I am.

[b]AgapePress, June 22, 2006[/b]

A constitutional attorney is denouncing a Las Vegas school district for pulling the plug on a Christian student's commencement speech because it referred to her faith in Jesus Christ. At a recent graduation ceremony, Clark County School District (CCSD) officials cut the microphone on Foothill High School valedictorian Brittany McComb after she began reading a speech that contained Bible verses and references to God.

The district officials claim McComb's speech amounted to religious proselytizing and could have been perceived as school-sponsored, thus making it a violation of the so-called separation of church and state. But Mat Staver, founder and chairman of the Florida-based pro-family legal organization Liberty Counsel, says the high school valedictorian has every right to take the school district to court over the incident.

"I think this is one of the most outrageous examples of censorship at graduation that I've seen," Staver contends. "For school officials to literally be standing by the switch at the mixing board and cut the microphone on a student, simply because that student mentions God or Jesus, is just unbelievable."

With high school behind her, McComb plans to study journalism at Biola University, a Christian college in Southern California. But during her four years at Foothill, she says, "they taught me logic and they taught me freedom of speech." However, when the school's 2006 valedictorian tried to apply these lessons in her graduation address, the graduating senior with the 4.7 GPA ran into a problem.

In vetting McComb's speech, school officials stripped it of biblical references and approved an edited version, cutting six mentions of God or Christ and omitting two biblical references. At the graduation exercises, however, the teen commencement speaker felt compelled to deviate from the edited version. "God's the biggest part of my life," she says. "Just like other valedictorians thank their parents, I wanted to thank my Lord and Savior."

For the Foothill High School graduate, it all boiled down to her faith and her fundamental First Amendment right to free speech. For those reasons , she asserts, she chose in this instance to rebel against authority for the first time in her life. And, according to an Associated Press report, a sympathetic crowd of nearly 400 graduates and their families booed angrily at the school officials for several minutes after they cut McComb's microphone.

An American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Nevada official who read the unedited version of the young woman's speech told the Las Vegas Review-Journal newspaper the school district did the right thing in cutting the valedictory address short. But Staver disagrees that the district's action was warranted and comments, "In my opinion it's reprehensible, and I also believe it's unconstitutional."

The ACLU spokesperson quoted in the Review-Journal made the argument that graduation speakers like McComb are given a school-sponsored forum and therefore their speech is school-sponsored speech. But Liberty Counsel's chairman insists that student commencement speakers' personal remarks and expressions are free speech under the U.S. Constitution.

"Clearly, the law protects students who are in the graduation podium, on the platform, because they are there for some neutral reason -- in this case, being the valedictorian," Staver says. "That student has the right to be able to give a message of his or her own choice regarding the viewpoint of the particular message that's being delivered."

While the attorney regards the silencing of McComb's speech at the Foothill High School commencement as one of the most egregious acts of graduation censorship he has seen, he notes that it is one among many such incidents that happen to speakers of faith every year -- a problem that has to be stopped. "Schools should not, must not, and must stop censoring these kinds of religious viewpoints simply because they are Christian in nature," he says.

Even now, Staver points out, his organization is involved in a similar case. Liberty Counsel is currently representing a Colorado high school graduate whose diploma was withheld after she shared her faith in Jesus Christ during a commencement speech.

122 replies

by Member 25348569

Lots and lots and lots of lawyers. All with nothing better to do than to nitpick over the Constitution and interpret and reinterpret ad nauseam with the intention of getting more publicity, more money - or more of both! And everyone in any form of authority who isn't a lawyer is running scared as to what the lawyers might do.

There are, I believe, more lawyers in New York City than in the entire country of Japan. I've also read that American lawyers probably make up somewhere between 25 percent and 35 percent of all the world's lawyers.

Really, Julian, your new habit of posting non-religious topics isn't any more inspiring to debate than your religious output. You could aim to be a little more selective and a little more challenging if you consider the standard of debate so low. It's also significant that your involvement in the threads that you have started is non-existent.

Are you in or are you out?

by jardinier

You know damned well that you are one of the most active participants in religious discussions.

Am I playing seagull? If you choose to believe that you are welcome to. The fact is that I am busy on various projects -- especially my websites -- and don't have the time for continual participation in discussions. However if you care to check you will readily see that I do in fact chime in from time to time, but usually not until I see the direction the thread is taking.

It is because of the websites that I publish that I subscribe to a number of online newsletters such as the one from which this article is taken.

If I find the discussion has taken off, I will pop in from time to time. Additionally I have been participating in Tech Q & A as you will notice by the number in my little yellow box.

As for my opinion on the quality of discussions, this is an excerpt from a private email by a formerly very active participant at TR. Naturally I cannot name this person because it is a private email. Suffice to know that I am not the only person who is disillusioned in the quality of discussions.

[i]On the discussions, it is not so much that I wised up in relation to the content or lack thereof. I just had to make some decisions about the wise use of my time.

Since I was neither learning anything from the
threads, nor convincing anyone with my thoughts, I
decided to let Max have his playpen to himself and his followers.

Even the few technical threads are degrading into
political diatribes.

Unfortunately, I think TR as an entity is degrading. It used to be that the new questions filled up 2 or 3 web pages each day. Now, a single page of new questions is a banner day.[/i]

by Member 25348569

I was being a bit unfair on you, anyway. Closest target on a sh:tty day.

I'm beginning to find the level of Islamaphobia here a bit frightening which, considering I have long been an Islamaphobe, is a bit worrying. I'd actually given up on the religious debates because I don't care enough and they care too much. As for the political debates - they always come back to Iraq. There's also such a level of Liberalophobia as well that I can't get my head round.

Basically, I'm only left with flaming.

Neil :D

I'm impressed with the 25K points, but!

by deadly ernest

New Mexico who got three lawyers on a Monday - the judged put him in prison - there was a 2 bag per day limit on lawyers, if he'd only shot 2 he would've been OK.

What had more penetration power than a 5,000 lb bomb dropped from 20,000 feet - a lawyer dropped head first from the same height , they have a header head.

by Member 25348569

372.01 Any person with a valid Texas state rodent or armadillo hunting license may also hunt and harvest attorneys for recreational and sporting (non-commercial) purposes.
372.02 Taking of attorneys with traps or deadfalls is permitted.The use of United States currency as bait is, however, prohibited.
372.03 The willful killing of attorneys with a motor vehicle is prohibited, unless such vehicle is an ambulance being driven in reverse. If an attorney is accidentally struck by a motor vehicle, the dead attorney should be removed to the roadside and the vehicle should proceed to the nearest car wash.
372.04 It is unlawful to chase, herd, or harvest attorneys from a power boat, helicopter or fixed-wing aircraft.
372.05 It is unlawful to shout 'Whiplash', 'Ambulance', or 'Free Scotch' for the purpose of trapping attorneys.
372.06 It is unlawful to hunt attorneys within one hundred (100) yards of BMW, Porsche, or Mercedes dealerships, except on Wednesday afternoons.
372.07 It is unlawful to hunt attorneys within two hundred (200) yards of courtrooms, law libraries, health clubs, country clubs or hospitals.
372.08 If an attorney gains elective office, it is not necessary to have a license to hunt, trap or possess same.
372.09 It is unlawful for a hunter to wear a disguise as a reporter, drug dealer, pimp, female legal clerk, sheep, accident victim, bookie, physician, chiropractor or tax accountant for the purpose of hunting attorneys.
372.10 Stuffed or mounted attorneys must have a state health department inspection for AIDS, rabies, and vermin.
372.11 Bag Limits Per Day
1. Yellow Bellied Sidewinder - 2
2. Two-faced Tort Feasor - 1
3. Back-stabbing Divorce Litigator - 4
4. Small-breasted Ball Buster (Female only) - 3
5. Big-mouthed Pub Gut - 2
6. Honest Attorney - EXTINCT
7. Cut-throat - 2
8. Back-stabbing Whiner - 2
9. Brown-nosed Judge Kisser - 2
10. Silver-tongued Drug Defender - $100 BOUNTY
11. Hairy-assed Civil Libertarian - 7

by jdclyde

They will stand up for your right to freedom of speech, as long as your not a Christian, as we have seen here.

If the speech were about the three-some she had that inspired her to get good grades so she would have the money to open a gay bar, they would have supported her all the way.

And people ask why Christians feel like they are under attack, like they were at Christmas time. It is because THEY ARE under attack.

You will notice that of all the outrage over Ann Coulters new book "Godless", the liberals have no problem with being called godless, just how Ann make personal comments about the "Jersy girls". And of course, all the complaining did was to ensure that it hit the best seller list.

by j.lupo

I don't care about a persons personal beliefs, but I don't think I need them pushed down my throat or that of others. I can't stand that happening.

If in the speech she is talking about how Jesus helped her (great for her) how does that relate to the rest of the class? Including those who don't believe as she does?

These types of speeches are suppose to be a reflection on the past, present and future for the whole student body, not a time to push ones own personal beliefs.

I would feel the same regardless of the religious or political tone. Yes, I include political beliefs too in this.

by jdclyde

This speech is about her, and what got her to be the single best student of that class. What was it that made it all happen.

It did not sound like she was doing a sermon trying to convert anyone, just stating HOW she got to where she is now.

You think all speeches should be censored from now on? Should they have to get turned in and approved?

How about college graduations where Democrats are running around the country making anti-Bush speeches. The scum in the ACLU would be right there if you tried to stop this from happening.

The speech isn't about the class, because they were not the best of the best, she was. The speech IS about her. The guest speakers are there for the motivational talk.

I think your wrong. I would hope you would not advocate censorship of this nature.

by maxwell edison

You said, "I don't care about a person's personal beliefs, but I don't think I need them pushed down my throat or that of others. I can't stand that happening."

I'm curious, do you apply that sentiment to all cases and in all forms, or just selected ones?

by old guy

the words Jesus, Christian, Christianity, God, or any other such words relating to this is even spoken the ACLU and many others get all up in arms shouting "I don't want your personal beliefs shoved down my throat" at the first mention or even syllable of the word without wondering or even caring what the person has to say.

Below is a quote from Brittany. She wanted to include God in her list of thank yous for how the people on her list helped her. I don't think that is called preaching, much less, trying to shove something down anyone's throat.
" "I went through four years of school at Foothill and they taught me logic and they taught me freedom of speech. God?s the biggest part of my life. Just like other valedictorians thank their parents, I wanted to thank my lord and savior,? Brittany said."

So, yes, this is another attempt to censor a Christian.

by x-marcap

If you go You may get lucky. I heard a feminist say that all sex was rape.

I sat politely through her speech at a college where I paid thousands a year to here her opinion when my daughter graduated. The valedictorian also had not taken a single Math class, as She was a Female studies major. My daughter ended up 3rd in the class behind two female studies majors, both mouthy lesbians...

One of them came over to talk to my wife, my daughter and myself. My wife disagreed with her civily, and explained that she never thought consentual sex was rape. When she told the Young thing ot go away, she got pushed. Wifey put Valedictorian in Arm bar and walked her to police who put mouthy girl in jail... Charges ended up dropped by campus police. Sad, real sad.

by j.lupo

I am just saying that the beliefs of one individual should not be forced on everyone else. Also, every graduation speech that I have attended the validictorian (sp?) did a motivational speech. I am not saying they didn't thank certain people, beliefs, etc that helped them acheive what they did.

I did not hear her speak so I can't say as to whether it was a sermon or not, but I know I would get up and walk out of any speech that was preaching to me on what I had to believe. It is something I have done in the past. I come back after the speaker is finished. That is my choice to not listen to it.

If she was only saying, as you suggest in your comment to me, that she was saying that was what got her through, then I have no problem with it. If however she was preaching to everyone that they need to embrace Jesus or something along those lines, then I would have issues with that.

I hope this clarifies my point for you. Right or Wrong is irrelavent to the discussion. This is my opinion. One I am entitle to and am always willing to discuss politely with others.

by vanessaj

Commencement speeches of any kind are the thoughts and beliefs, etc. of the individual and have never been censored until the past 15 years or so, when Christianity has come under fire in the press, from Hollywood, TV, and especially the ACLU. Some of the stunts they have pulled in the past 5-6 years can even be described as "hateful" toward anything "Christian", and I believe everyone feels it. It is popular to discuss anything from diet plans to menopause to religion...as long as you don't talk about Jesus.

In speeches at various graduations and even political rallies, meetings I have heard thoughts from Confucius, Buddah, from the Koran and even the Torah, but if you read from the Bible, then you are completely out of line.

You can hear "Jesus Christ" on TV all the times, and it's a favorite curse in most movies I see, but if you say his name with respect or reverence, then all of a sudden it's "religious people trying to condemn you". Why do we have "Jesus-phobia"? Isn't his story and his life an example of love, acceptance and forgiveness? Why would the simple discussion about a Christian's beliefs be taboo? Other religions aren't. And I, personally, in my 44 years, have never come across anyone who tried to shove any religious belief on anyone else.

Sometimes everyone wants to share things they are passionate about. I am certainly not threatened by the guy who just can't stop talking about his new girlfriend, or the woman who just can't tell you enough about her new baby, whom the whole world revolves around. It's boring, and I'm not going to run out and get pregnant, but I can appreciate her zeal.

You can put every kind of low-down, dirty piece of crap on your shirt or the back of your car, or in your movie or on TV, but you can't talk about Jesus or you're going to be VERY unpopular. Something's not right with that.

by old guy

I think you are right on about the "Jesus-phobia" Good call.

After reading some of J.Lupo's other comments in this discussion I think he realizes the difference in this particular case and I appreciated his comment that he thought the ACLU was wrong. Since he doesn't seem to be adamantly prejudiced toward Christanity as a whole I do await his thoughts and insights to my posts below.

I will say this and then you can read more of my opinion below, I do understand why some people feel the way they do about Christianity. Unfortunately, there have been zealots in the past, for instance, the Roman Catholic Crusades, the sexual abuse from some priest, etc, that has caused some people to be prejudiced against Christianity. As I said below, though, that's not my fault nor my way, or others that I associate with, those things happened but it does not give anyone justification for holding that prejudice towards anyone who is a Christian.

by jackofalltech

True christians are NOT interested in saving the world or making the USA a religious utopia or forcing our beliefs on anyone else. True christianity is not an external set of rules - that's religion - it's an INDIVIDUALS internal realization that what the Bible teaches is true (Relax, I'm not going to preach to you). We're just so grateful to God for what He's done, we want everyone to have the opportunity to make an informed choice.

by jdclyde

Point blank. Should someone be muzzled if they talk about their religion in a public forumn? Yes or no.

If yes, that is censorship.

If you believe in freedom of speech, you have to remember that it is unpopular speech that NEEDS protecting, not popular speech.

You do have every right to not sit and listen to anything someone has to say.

Do you have the right to prevent them from saying something just because you don't agree with it?

It makes me sick to hear politicians politisize major issues, and I think they should be held accountable for what they say. But no one should stop them from saying it in the first place.

by j.lupo

Yes, I believe in free speech. Yes I believe people have the right to their beliefs and to espouse them to those that want to hear it. However, if in the course of conversation, I am being told that I am an infidel because I don't believe as them, is that right? Is it right for them to bang on my door with literature? They can leave it in the mailbox. Is it right to be minding my own business walking down the street and have flyers flung in my face and being told how I will burn in hell if I don't except Jesus?

The point that I am saying, I hope :) , is that there is a fine line between discussing something passionately and forcing that belief on them. I have friends and colleagues from many different cultures, religons, etc. We discuss religon and culture and even politics, but the ground rules are that we don't have to agree with each other, we won't fight with each other, and we will continue to respect each others point of view.

I hope this clarifies my point.

by x-marcap

If you disagree bring it up to me politely, but do not violate my rights. The School district should be much poorer as well as should the ACLU after this...

by j.lupo

if I do not wish to hear what you have to say? If I feel it violates my rights, shouldn't I be allowed to walk out quietly?

See that is what I mean about forcing someone to hear a message they don't want or can't believe in. I am not saying to be rude, I am simply expressing my right by leaving.

Yes, you have the right to your opinion and to express it. I also have the right to not listen. If I choose to speak to you later about what you said, then that is a choice I can make.

by maxwell edison

...one person's freedom of religion is interpreted as freedom from religion, which is attempting to deny another's freedom of speech who is referencing her freedom of religion.

The founders made one HUGE omission in the Bill of Rights:

[i][b]You have the right to be offended, so STFU![/i][/b]

by tig2

I have had people tell me that the cross I wear offends them. As far as I can see, what Brittany attempted to say was as innocuous as the cross I wear.

The interesting thing is that those same people that don't think I should wear a cross also don't think that I have a right to disagree with them.

So- who is being narrow minded?

by j.lupo

I think it is one that has happened over and over. In some ways it is interesting because we are all entitled to our opinions and thoughts. We have the right to express them, the problem (as I see it) is when are we expressing ourselves and when are we pushing too far. How far is too far?

I think in a follow up post, I mentioned not know what the speech particularly said. However, now that I have been informed as to the actual content, there is no reason for her to be sensored, penalized or anything else.

Sincerely
J. Lupo

by jamesrl

What France did, in my mind in order to deny the wearing of the hajib, is to deny all students the rigth to wear anything religious- crosses, included.

I think we in Canada are a little more middle of the road. We may not have the predominance of christians, but everyone can express whatever they like.

Sometimes that means compromising traditions - like the Sikh Mounties wearing Turbans instead of the Mountie Hat (only worn rarely for ceremonies, it isn't working dress), or allowing Sikh vets to wear their turbans in a Legion hall. But I am ok with that. We can wear crosses, orthodox Jews wear yamulkas (sp?), we all get along.

I wouldn't have a problem with what she said. I might take issue if she did a full blown sermon, but that doesn't seem to be what she did.

James

by j.lupo

forms yes. That doesn't mean that I mind discussing different views, I just don't like it when it becomes "this is the only correct way". We all have our beliefs, we will change them or not based on our choices.

I do listen to others opinions, and then I make a decision, but when opinion becomes edict then I start to bow out and just leave.

I think I see some of what might be taken as inflamitory in my original post. Sorry about that. It wasn't meant to be.

To clarify as best I can, everyone is entitled to their own opinions and beliefs as long as it doesn't hurt or infrindge on the rights and beliefs of others. I know there are areas of gray, I also believe we are open to discussion and sometimes that means concluding that we agree to disagree on a topic. One party or group doesn't always have to be right all the time and make the other party or group wrong.

by maxwell edison

Infringing on one's beliefs involves more than simply squelching one's freedom to speak those beliefs.

For example, any social system (social security, welfare, school lunches, government provided health care, etc.), that takes a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not earn it, infringes on my beliefs; people have the right to decide whether or not they will wear a seat belt or a motorcycle helmet; people have the right to put drugs into their body; and so on.. Those are all based on "beliefs" of individual liberty. They're all being trampled upon.

Unfortunately, and it's the reason I asked the question, people are very selective on which individual "beliefs" will be tolerated. We better allow ALL of them, or none of them are safe. Today, unfortunately, none of them are safe because the basic, underlying core principle gets no mention at all.

When the government (by way of the voters) can literally force you to work for four months out of twelve (or six out of twelve?), to support other people, to give the fruits of your labor to other people, then no one should be surprised to see that same government (perhaps, again, by way of the voters) decide what a person may or may not say in some particular setting.

by tig2

Would you describe yourself as a Libertarian? And if the answer is yes, do you know of any good reading material on the subject?

I ask because someone recently described me as a Libertarian. As I was raised to be a good Republican, i was a little startled to hear somone else opine that I had stepped so far from the party as to have joined another. So now I am curious.

by j.lupo

I understand your point. I don't think censorship is correct. I will say though, that when Jesus is used around me (and this is strictly my experience) it has been by the "bible thumpers" that do preach and put it down my throat. Am I sensitive to it, you bet. You would be too if you had it painted on you for not conforming to the "Christian" way in High School.

by old guy

Please understand that I am not coming down on you for what you believe or don't believe. With that said, it is not my fault nor the fault of other Christians, such as Brittany in this instance, that you had a few id10ts do something like that to you. In the real world one can not judge everybody and everything strictly by what may have happened to them in the past by a few. There is a Pakistani that works for the consulting networking firm that helps us out when we need it here at the office. I like him and we have had some great discussions about his Muslim religion and my Christianity. We get along great and have a good time. Should I hold against him what the few zealots have done in beheading some of our soldiers and hate him? NO! Should you (anyone) hold what happened to you against someone who starts to say the word Jesus? NO! However, it has come to this in a lot of instances and the ACLU is paramount in pushing this agenda.

So, instead of jumping up and running out the door, or telling someone to quit running Christianity down your (anyone's) throat at the first syllable, Je, allow them the right to speak their beliefs. Once again, I've said this in other posts, the Christians that I know and work with do not try to shove anything down anyone's throat. We try to share what we believe in with anyone who wants to listen. A person doesn't want to hear it, so be it. We'll move on. Just because some of the Catholics in the past and some of the people you knew way back when were stupid and over zealous that does not mean the rest of us are. Nor does that mean that is what true Christians are either.

It just seems that at this point in our history it is ok to teach (run down their throats) children in elementary school that it's ok to be homosexual but not Christian. That is wrong, wrong, wrong. Some of the politicians (and ACLU) are trying to censor and take away some people's right to free speech and even their thoughts.

Once again, I'm not jumping on you personally but this is what is going on now. I agree that if someone tries to belittle you or tries to make you sit and listen without the option of not listening to their belief then they are truly wrong and needs to be stopped. But, to not let a young lady, with a 4.7 GPA, not to say, (paraphrased) ..and I want to thank Jesus for what He has done for me.. is censorship and totally wrong.

Edited to add word.

by j.lupo

we are saying the same things just in different ways. I am sure when or if you choose to read some of my other posts that I added this night, you will see where I am coming from.

I don't take it that you are coming down on me. I consider this discussion, just that a discussion, a sharing of ideas on a subject. From that discussion, I have learned that a very nice young lady was censored - which I do believe is wrong. I hope that I have conveyed that my "chip" isn't towards all people of any particular faith, political party or other group.

I get very annoyed by those that don't allow me my point of view and have to convince me they are correct. The incident from my past is only one of many. We all live in different areas and unfortunately, I still experience this type of behavior today. However, I only hold my "prejudiced" feelings towards those that perform that behavior.

I have many friends from all over the world, my current manager is from India and we get along great! We give each other respect and we can even joke (sometimes off color) with each other. I can't do that with my project manager who is the other type of person and she and I are of the similar background. I don't have a problem with people expressing themselves. That is their right. I can walk out if I don't want to hear it.

To Max's point, I don't think we need government interference in most of this. I think as a society we need to work together and teach each other tolerance and respect. I think those things have been lost.

(oh, and I am female in case you were wondering)

by x-marcap

I have a problem with bullies... My brother is 8 years older than I am as well as being 6'6" and 350 pounds and he was all muscle until he turned 50...

I will stomp the snot out of those who try domination games as the old 6'1" Marine can wear big boots...

My one son has the heart of a bully. He is 99% on height and weight for a 9 year old. My wife and I have been watching guiding and disciplining the bully out of him. This last week when someone tried to bully a friend who is much smaller than he is, my son stood up to the bully for the other child. In fact he got a group of kids to all stand up to the bully. 10-12 9 year olds will stop one abusive 12 year old even if he is 6' tall.

by tig2

When it comes to having someone shove their particular viewpoint down my particular throat. I just don't have tolerance for browbeating someone else for the "pleasure" of being "right".

I personally assume that each person makes those private decisions for themselves. It is not up to me to judge their individual choices.

If someone wants my viewpoints, I will give that person my views. I don't assume that because one person asked, everyone wants to know.

The issue is one of tolerance, or lack thereof.

by old guy

that now that you have more data on this particular incidence you have a better understanding of how the ACLU mishandled the situation. Unfortunately, there are a lot of people who don't try to or even want to understand the facts (all of the facts) and just want to push their own agenda at the expense of another person's right. And, because of the ACLU and some of the radical judges, they are trying to stop other people's personal beliefs and rights to express their belief.

I do hope you understand in the post below to you that I am trying to point out some of the gross inconsistencies that is happening.

by vanessaj

Do they happen anywhere else outside of "Christian" organizations? If so, why doesn't the liberal press jump on those like they are the 'golden apple'? Do abuses not happen at public schools, colleges, at work or in social or political organizations? Nobody seems to make such a big deal about those...is it because it's expected, maybe?

But anyone who is supposed to be "Christian" doesn't get press time unless he's a loonie or commiting a crime. I never seem to hear about all the millions of dollars raised for the poor and needy all through the year by food pantries & clothing closets, houses that are built for free, donations to orphanages, school children and college funds for those who can't afford, senior citizens' aids and food for shut-ins, free medical assistance and medical equipment, not to mention the extra donations at Easter, Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays that total in the millions...probably billions across our nation alone. I have seen people saved medically here in the U.S. and many "Medical Missions" organizations that provide free medical care across the globe - frequently throughout the year and at no small cost to those who go. And there are so many more newsworthy "Christian" events both planned and unexpected...even some (what some may call) "healings" from prayer, that have been medically documented.

But I have never seen them get much attention from the press. Why is that, do you think? Why don't those make the news? I would want to know about these things.

Not that I think you need to be told at all, OG, but I just wanted to say it and get it out there for anyone to hear/read. Thanks for letting me say it.

by vanessaj

T2, I don't know what the common connotations are, because they always differ from the strict meaning of a term - especially when it comes to politics, but here's a link that gives the basics, if you want it. Probably stuff you already know, but I thought I would throw it in anyway. (Slow day = time to blog.)

by vanessaj

from what you report that Canada practices more freedom than the U.S. Seriously. That's what I remember it being like here (U.S.) growing up, but some change has occurred in the past few years, and I may be beginning to envy others countries' freedom of speech. Thanks for sharing, JRL.

by jdclyde

Do these Anti-Christians have a reason to be so openly hateful and hostile to any and everything Christian?

Did these people only change their ways after the homosexual pediphile prests did their abuse, or are they using this as an excuse to justify the hostility they already felt?

The way these same people give a free pass to current abuses done in the name of other faiths show that it isn't anti-religion, only anti-Christian.

People that don't want to feel guilty for their behavior, so attack an invalidate the source of their guilt.

by jamesrl

In terms of economics, Max I am sure would argue we that we are more restrictive;higher taxes socialized medicine and so on. And I wouldnt disagree.

But we seem to be more able to accomodate one another, and we don't have the looniness on either the right or the left that seems to take hold with our friendly neighbours to the south. :)

One hypothesis; in the US the extremes feed each others polarization. We don't have an ACLU nor a Christian Coalition. If we did, no doubt we would have had more political correctness, more backlash to political correctness and so on.

We have socialists who know they will never have a totally socialist state, so they live in the mixed environment we have. We have conservatives who know they will never get rid of socialized (i hate the term but there it is) medicine, so they live with it.

It was a national Liberal government who radically cut government spending, eliminated the budget deficit and put us into surplus. Though I have to admit that conservative Alberta, with its oil revenues went one better and eliminated both the deficit and the debt(thats right no government debt at all for the province).

In the 90s a socialist government in Ontario(New Democratic Party) found itself so deeply in debt that it have give forced unpaid vacations to government employees - the whole bureaucracy shut down on those days(and Max, I readily admit, the world didnt come to an end, I kinda enjoyed the irony of the socialist government pissing off the government unions).

I've always known politics in the US are more polarized - attack ads don't work in Canada - they often backfire. Mudslinging is often frowned upon. Liberal and Conservative aren't derogatory terms.

I might suggest the fact that we had 2 founding nations, not one, and that we have for our entire history had to balance those two interests. Now we have on top of that waves of immigration(the third nation), and other challenges.

This is NOT meant to be a criticism of the US at all. This is simply pointing out the differences in how we developed.

James

by old guy

It's neither. It is only justification. To me that's not the same thing that the means justify the end. It is only their way of trying to validate what they are spewing but without true justification. Ok, I know that's confusing. In context the way these folks try to use what people did in the past to justify their hatred of Christians now is false justification.

That's probably about as clear as mud but I hope you understand.

Edited to add: The abuses from the past do not give anyone a reason for their hatred nor does it excuse their hatred.

by old guy

explanation. I would probably disagree with some of the ways of life there but I do appreciate the differences and the way you explained them. Thanks.

by tig2

Thank you for offering me a link. Unfortunately it didn't append to your post. Would you re-post (darn TR glitches!) or send to me via peer mail? I would appreciate it!

by Member 25348569

It was the first sentence in his post. He can obviously correct me if I'm wrong!

The way I see it - and the point that Julian is making - is that we (US, UK and Oz) are all nominally Christian with similar(!) cultures yet it would be unthinkable for anything like this to happen in our countries at the moment (and I hope, never).

You really do need to work out what to do with all of your lawyers! You might all go off on a rant about the ACLU but, when all is said and done, they are as much part of your culture as the religious right.

Calling either of them names won't stop them being stupid.

Neil

by old guy

to go off on a different tangent. I don't think we were actually even trying to hijack his discussion--just centered on a different point than what Jules may have had in mind. In fact JamesRL had some very good points of difference in his post, https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045735 . We do have a lot of looniness here in the U.S. and that is unfortunate. But if all of us just took it at that and let the loonies (ACLU primarily) go unchecked then it would really be disastrous.

Tell you what, Neil, I'll be glad to sell you a whole heap of lawyers really, really cheap and you guys can keep all of them over there. :)

by Member 25348569

So what is it with the ACLU that gets you all fired up? Obviously, I know very little about them but I've just had a wander over their web site and I can't see the problem with their intent.

by jardinier

And as I travelled around the world in my mind to think of other nominally or predominantly Christian countries -- like the whole of South America and the whole of Western Europe -- I realised that such a speech would presumably not be censored even in countries where Christianity is a minority religion, as for example the predominantly Muslim countries like Pakistan, Bangladesh and Indonesia.

And add to that the countries which are predominantly Hindu or Buddhist?

Please correct me if you think I am wrong in these generalisations, but if I am correct, then it puts censorship of Christianity in the USA in a VERY bad light indeed.

by j.lupo

those that are prejudice (very big grin). Seriously, I do not feel prejudice towards any group. My concerns are for those that are the zealots who want everyone to be just like them and if you are not, then you must be converted.

I can assure you, that my comments are more for people who feel their point of view (whether religous, political, or whatever) is the only correct view and they will not listen or even agree to disagree with anyone else. That is what makes my "fur stand on end" and get me growling. I have experienced to much of that "hate" in my life. So now I choose to walk away from it.

You are correct Old Guy, that I do think the ACLU has lost sight of the primary purpose. That is to protect all rights. I think in many ways we have as a society become too politically correct on everything.

Everyone has the right to an opinion. Everyone has the right to express that opinion. What I hope for is also the ability to not force that opinion to be the only allowed opinion - George Orwell's writing comes to mind. (Animal Farm, 1984)

by j.lupo

That is the difference I keep trying to say. Guess I have to work on the writing effectively still. :)

by old guy

Thank you for expounding a little more. I certainly agree with what you are saying. That is one reason I made the statement that you don?t seem to be adamantly prejudiced against Christians, which I appreciate. BTW, my apologies on the gender. I don?t know if I should have known that you were female or not but thank you for setting me straight.

The primary gist of what I was trying to get across is that the ACLU has been fundamental in censoring people?s personal beliefs and it appears they have tried to forcibly stop any mention of Christian beliefs. I was tremendously relieved to find a person who realized that, at least in this particular incident, the ACLU committed a serious violation of censorship of a citizen, once you had more information.

I do hope you realize I am not trying to attack you personally but only the injustice that happens frequently because of the ACLU. I was also pointing out that a lot of people have the same knee jerk reaction that even you initially thought had happened but later realized that injustice. I just wish more people would follow through as you have.

I am in total agreement with you, as I stated in https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045595 ?I agree that if someone tries to belittle you or tries to make you sit and listen without the option of not listening to their belief then they are truly wrong and needs to be stopped.?
Thanks.

by old guy

same things. I think I have touched on a lot of this one in the post above https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045877

You have been one of the most engaging and refreshing folks for this type of discussion especially without needing a "heated" debate.

I certainly appreciate the fact that your prejudice is against prejudiced people (good reply!).

Regarding you being a lady: I usually don't read blogs due to time constraints. However, since I had the feeling I should have been able to figure out that you were female I did check your blog and I certainly should have known. Sorry about that. :)

Again, thanks for being able to discuss this reasonably.

by tig2

What I am hearing you all say is that you each believe that an individual has a right to their individual opinion and to voice their opinion.

You have each spoken eloquently and respectfully to and about one another. While it is evident in your writing that this is a subject that you feel passionaely about, you have all stated your truths without berating one another.

Considering the inflammatory nature of the subject matter, you each sought and respected the others beliefs and insights.

I applaud you. The discussion could easily have been nasty. You chose to make it an exchange of ideas. I am a beneficiary. And I appreciate it.

by maxwell edison

The Republican Party used to advance causes closer to the Libertarian principles, but it was back in the days of Barry Goldwater. It's been going downhill ever since, and today I consider the Republicans no better than baby Democrats (as it pertains to domestic matters).

Reading material:

On the Web, read anything by Walter Williams. He's an extremely smart guy, well grounded in libertarian principles, with a down-home style that only a ..... well, only a Democrat would not like. The Independence Institute also has a good site, some good writers, and is a good organization.

More later.....

by maxwell edison

...will admit their bias and the basis for their political principles and opinions, All of mine are grounded in basic libertarian principles, and I just let the chips of opinion fall where they may. Too many people are afraid to admit theirs -- especially liberal Democrats. If a person admits the principles upon which all opinions are based, it sets you up for a lot of criticism. And most Democrats can't stand to admit that they don't support the true principle of individual liberty.

by tig2

There ARE few who just simply choose to stand on their principles, morals, and beliefs. What I have seen in you is that you are WHO and WHAT you are- regardless of popular opinion. You speak and are willing to defend your truth. Your humanity is apparent but not coddling.

I can't say that I have been much more than a rubber stamp Republican. I feel strongly that I have to stop taking a short-time view and look at a longer road. I know that I probably whine forever on about this... and don't mean to. Don't want to. But I do. I'm working on it.

I look forward to learning more. I don't want to be an "only politically correct" person in a dynamic world. Country singer Aaron Tippin said, "You've Got to Stand for Something or You'll Fall for Anything." D@mn right and I have no desire to fall for anything I haven't considered and therefore chosen.

I agree that the party that my parents taught me to beieve in has changed. I prefer to stand on the things I believe in.

I appreciate your considered response and look forward to anything else you think will be helpful.

Edited because I NEED a spell checker!

by vanessaj

Thank you for distiguishing between religion and knowing Jesus. It really isn't about religious rules or having to "perform" and trying to be perfect (Even some Christians I've met don't seem to have gotten that understanding.) I have found it's about freedom, love, acceptance & forgiveness. Everything that Jesus taught in the Bible. All the good stuff without the bad.

It's hard for me to share this when most people think they will be made to feel condemned or that they will have to give up something good to know Jesus. Do you feel this way?

by vanessaj

I thought it was the best one that I found, although others who have posted here obviously have real, in-depth information that you can't find in a dictionary, but here goes. Let me know if you don't get: http://www.theihs.org/category.php/142.html

Might have been my mistake that it didn't get sent. (And if you ever get an email totally missing the attachment that is promised in it...that's probably me, too. I'm terrible at that.)

by old guy

(I've not much time right now but will add more later) they have orchestrated much of the aboloshing the rights of individuals, particularly if they are Christians, to the point of actual censorship. J.Lupo stated it rather well in one of her posts above, "...I do think the ACLU has lost sight of the primary purpose. That is to protect all rights. I think in many ways we have as a society become too politically correct on everything." I agree that they may have been more of a help in their beginning. Now it seems that at any chance to squelch the Christians they jump at it and they have controlled (directed/intimidated) the judicial system into running scared of being "political incorrect". Of course you may remember how sick and tired I am of being political correct. I think someone labeled it PCPTS awhile back.

JD could probably give you more insight but I have to run into the office for a couple of hours this morning.

You sure you don't want some of our lawyers. They're really nice. In fact I think everyone should own one. :)

by old guy

that would be too easy. Kind of like shootin' fish in a bucket. Come to think of it would it be possible to put the lawyers in the bucket instead? :^0

by x-marcap

But I am at a loss as to how to even start. Many people don't want to hear anything about Christ.

Some people won't listen and try to take simplicity for stupidity. I guess I have shook the dust off my feet and moved on, but sometimes I try to explain that they are on the road to hell, and they mention it's 55 miles that a way (Michigan).

Sometimes people don't know that there is a right and wrong. I guess I am just going to throw this out so they understand that there is redemption through the blood of Jesus Christ.

by vanessaj

Is that what Jesus did? Did he go around telling people that they were condemned? It seems that we all already know we are not perfect enough for a perfect God. In times of life & death moments in our life...in times of clarity we already see that.

The only people that I see, in the Bible, that Jesus ever called names in any kind of condemning fashion was the religious people who didn't show others love and compassion. He always became angry with proud people, who didn't fight their battle on their knees and remain humble in their interaction with others.

Jesus spent his 3 years offering hope, true and unconditional love, acceptance, forgiveness, true freedom and peace to anyone and everyone who wanted it. He offered. That's all. He never tried to convince or convert.

To love one another means to be a friend, to pray continually for those we see that do not know the joy that Jesus gives, to allow those heart-breaking moments when some don't want to hear about the freedom, peace and wonderful gifts that God has for them.

When I read about Jesus, I always see him living and loving, healing and preaching meekness, forgiveness, and love. Jesus IS love. People don't need a new religion. We've got too many already. We all need to find the source of love and joy. Pray for those you long to see come to know him...and let God draw them. Only he can do that. It is God's job to save the world. Not ours. Ever. It is our job to love. And pray.

So, just love people like you love God. And pray. And Love. And keep your chin up. Aslan is always on the move...

Edited for EXCRUTIATING length. (Sorry to put you thru that.)

by jdclyde

At what point is the speech no free anymore and it is time to call in the police?

I see and agree with what you are now saying, but the line I draw is they have the right to say what they want, I have the right to walk away.

Re-reading this, I think we agree more than we disagree on this. Just needed to not be as brief as we were in our first few posts.

by deadly ernest

stands up with a censored speech and says "I have a nice speech here to give, but I'm sorry that I'm not allowed to give it as the US constitutional right of free speech is not recognised at this school." then sits down.

by vanessaj

The way it's going, I predict that in not too many years from now, someone may have to be deadly earnest to give such a speech.

by j.lupo

I had a friend who went to take a final exam. The exam was interesting because the professor asked only one questions, "What is courage". My friend waited for the start and then walked up to the teacher and handed in the exam. The exam answer said, "This is courage"

My friend got an A on the exam but an F for the writing course.

by j.lupo

I am glad we had this discussion. I have enjoyed it because of what TiggerTwo indicated. We very easily could have gone down what I call the "anger" path. For me this is what discussions are about. Challenging each others ideas and discussing them.

OG: No, I did not feel that you were attacking me at all. Your points were passionate, but logical. You simply were educating me about what happened in this situation.

I believe many organizations, like the ACLU, have lost sight of their original purpose. It is important to be very careful the thin line of protecting EVERYONE's rights and stepping on the rights of others while protecting another group. Balance is what we need in this world.

by j.lupo

I think that is why my initial post was entitled "Ok, here is where we disagree some" I did put the word "some" in there. ;)

There is a very fine line between free speech and trampling on someone else. I believe that is why we have so many wars, people seem to want everyone else to be, think, act, live, etc. as they do.

This discussion was a good example of how we can each express our individual ideas without getting angry and cutting each other off. It is an example of how to have a passionate discussion with respect for other peoples views. If only the rest of the world could do half as much as we did here on this topic.....(sigh)

by j.lupo

This was very a very enjoybable discussion with you. Thank you for that. I agree that we are probably very close on many of the issues we discussed if not in total agreement.

Oh and I wasn't upset or anything that you thought I was male. Actually, I thought that was a compliment. In my worklife I have had to stand up to the "big boys" on their "turf". Although you see the jaws hitting the ground at official functions when I actually change the suit for a dress and makeup. ;)

by jamesrl

I know some of these types just like to be controversial to make a name. What they don't realize is how much they damage their credibility, even within their own groups.

When I look at these situations, I often use the substitution. If the valedictorian in this case had been a Muslim woman and had said "I'd like to thank Allah, praise be his name, for all the glory is his" or something like that (please if I messed up something, no harm was meant), I'd have been fine with that.

As I mentioned in another post, there was a recent incident in Toronto, where a professor at another university was given an honourary doctorate for her work in ethics. Someone found out that she has said that she favours traditional marriage with one man/one woman and was not in favour of gay couples having kids. Much protest ensued, and it was funny that the same people who fight for their "rights" of academic freedom don't consider that others have them too. Sad part is they protested at the convocation and some profs even sat down when she was applauded and refused to shake her hand. How sad. Personally I may disagree with her stand on gays raising kids, but I would not let that overshadow her fine work in other areas.

To me the boundary is hate speech. Saying all sex was rape (presuming she meant heterosexual intercourse) could be construed as anti-male hate if she used the wrong tone. If she approached it academically its one thing, but I have a hard time seeing how that is possible.

James

by jamesrl

I'm am quite certain, even though I wasn't there, that the valedictorian was hoping for a big reaction.

She wants people to go from the logical analytical perspective to the emotional reaction, so that she can argue with them on an 'academic' level and make them look/feel stupid.

The woman getting the honourary degree by the way has agreed to come and participate in an open debate about the subject at the university in the fall.

I once had a similar situation to yours where I went to an all candidates debate at my university, and one of the candidates was a professional gambler who believed and promoted that interest was evil and that the Bank of Canada should abolish it. He ran for so many positions I'm sure even he lost count.

As the candidates were leaving through the audience, a female friend of mine asked this gambler guy a rather pointed but still analytical question. He responded by pushing her hard out of the way. Luckily I had friends who restrained me, or he would have had the publicity he sought.

James

by x-marcap

That means that censorship of only the Christian message has been achieved.

Farakahn and Marouk, and Barak Obama get their say, why shouldn't someone of the Christian faith be treated with equal respect.

And if you do leave don't expect your diploma...

by j.lupo

you all might find it interesting. It relates to this topic and so I thought I would provide the link and see what you all thought.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060628/ap_on_go_co/obama_3

I am interested in feedback on this. We have had such a good discussion both pro and con about the issue of speeches and content and the ACLU. Well this deals with the idea of separation of church and state.

Please take a quick peek and let me know your thoughts.

by tig2

I think that Obama is saying some things that have needed to be said for a long time.

While there must be freedom OF religion, we have interpreted that as freedom FROM religion. The fact is that you can't have it both ways. Unfortunately the "Christians" that get the airtime are the Pat Robertsons and Jerry Falwells. I know that I don't care to be represented by those two.

"Obama mentioned leaders of the religious right briefly, saying they must "accept some ground rules for collaboration" and recognize the importance of the separation of church and state."

I can see where that might be a stumbling point as so many seem to be of the "Believe as I do or you're d@mned" school of thought. Personally, I think that it is failure to accept some basic ground rules that have caused much of the problem. You can't have intellegent debate when one person is intent on screaming the other down. Church should not rule state and allowing a broader debate cannot result in a blood bath of "My God can beat your God at Parcheesi". Should greater latitude be examined, it cannot be exclusive but rather based on a foundation of tolerance and debate.

Unfortunately, while we have seen what CAN happen in a calm and ordered debate between people intent on COMMUNICATING, that kind of debate is all too rare- especially as regards religion. Sad, really.

Obama also made an excellent point about "inauthentic demonstrations of faith". I believe the example he uses is a white polititian clapping hands (off-rythym) to a black gospel choir. And he's right. If I see the photo-op demonstration of your faith and see it nowhere else in your life, I disregard the photo. People know my faith because I live my faith. If they have to ask, I'm doing something wrong.

by j.lupo

I found the article quite convincing myself and it was well said as to a plan of what should happen. I agree that it is about tolerance and calm logical debate. We are all passionate, but I once either read or heard someone say "If you scream all they hear is noice".

Maybe we need to start having written debates. If all the politicians and clergy (from all faiths) had to write to communicate their points of view, maybe that would help the situation. Written communication is one of the hardest and also one of the best for everyone to get a chance to contribute to the discussion.

by x-marcap

The fact is I know many people with no ability to find the beat. I play several instruments and am always amazed when a drummer can't find the beat.

I always can find it playing, but dancing is a whole 'nother story.

by jardinier

As an Aussie this does not of course affect me, but from what I learn about American politics at this website, that is the best news I have heard in a long time.

by maxwell edison

....for all these years, Republican Christians have been vilified unmercifully, by both the Democrat Party and in the press, but when a Democrat proposes reaching out to them, and encourages fellow Democrats to "acknowledge the power of faith in the lives of the American people" he's seen as a friggin' hero? Who's the more principled person and/or party, and who's simply playing politics looking for more votes? Has the Democrat Party been wrong all this time, or are they (is he) simply pandering to a large group of voters in an attempt to retake a majority in the Senate?

[i]Obama coupled his advice with a warning. "Nothing is more transparent than inauthentic expressions of faith: the politicians who shows up at a black church around election time and claps ? off rhythm ? to the gospel choir."[/i]

Can you spell Bill Clinton, Al Gore, and other prominent Democrats who have been highlighted and praised for doing this sort of thing? And am I the only one who remembers that George Bush was vilified for refusing to attend several "black" functions, knowing that he would not be received well, and knowing that it would only be seen as pandering? And how many times has President Bush been vilified for showing his faith? Come on, all you "impartial" members of the media! Start treating Senator Obama the same way you've been treating President Bush!

I will admit this, however; I don't know the true motives and beliefs of Senator Obama, as he's not been in the Senate long enough to establish a track record that allows a person to notice what he does, rather than what he says. And I will give Senator Obama the benefit of the doubt that he is, personally, sincere. But if the rest of the Democrat Party capitulates to his urges and tries to take the moral high-ground on this issue, it'll be as transparent as a pane of glass. And if they do, I wonder if it will be pointed out in the press?

But I do know something else. The Democrats, especially the Democrats in the press, are always looking for somebody to put up on a pedestal, and Senator Obama seems to be the favorite flavor of the day. Is it really the principle of the issue that's the driving force, or is it the usual quest for Democrat Party votes, regardless of the obvious hypocrisy? If the rest of the Democrat Party, and if the Democrats in the press don't vilify Senator Obama the same way they've been vilifying Evangelical Christian Republicans and President Bush for all these years, the answer will be obvious. And I wonder if "the press" will point that out to everybody?

I'll point out one more thing. Barack Obama won that Senate Seat by defeating Alan Keyes. Alan Keyes wears his faith on his sleeve, and did so during that election. I wonder what the rest of the Democrat Party and the Democrats in the press said about him at that time on that particular issue? I'll bet (actually I know) that it wasn't as nice as what they're now saying about Senator Obama. And you can bet a dollar to dirt that the Democrat Party leadership are meeting behind closed doors, strategizing over what to do with this guy. And you watch, ALL of them will be saying exactly the same thing, using the same phrases, in the same way. The "talking points" will be identical from every one of them.

What's going on here, principle or politics? That's the question people should be asking themselves. Here's a clue:

[i]"I am a great admirer of our founding charter and its resolve to prevent theocracies from forming and its resolve to prevent disruptive strains of fundamentalism from taking root in this country. I think there is an enormous danger on the part of public figures to rationalize or justify their actions by claiming God's mandate. I don't think it's healthy for public figures to wear religion on their sleeve as a means to insulate themselves from criticism, or dialogue with people who disagree with them."[/i]
-- Barack Obama, Chicago sun Times, April 2004 (during his campaign)

by faradhi

... every time a d0mocrat expresses their religious beliefs they are accused by the Christian fundamentalists of playing politics and when a republican does it is just their faith.

Why wouldn't the fundamentalist community applaud the democrat that states they are strong in their faith? After all fundamentalist just want you to be saved, right? While fundamentalist do not believe it, it is possible to be religious without being agreeing with them. Not everyone who believes, agrees with the fundamentalists on all matters of faith.

As for Obama's comments in April 2004, He is not speaking out against religion in general. He is speaking out against fundamentalists specifically. Further, he is criticizing those who use religion barrier from criticism.

Further, Alan Keys was actually brought into the state from another part of the country specifically to run against Obama. That is why Keys lost. It was not his religion.

Finally, It seems to me that both sides do not like it when the other expresses their religious faith. When a democrat expresses faith, the conservitives balk. When a republican expresses faith, liberal balk.

My opinion, Personally I think they all use religion for their own purposes. I seriously doubt if the democrats or republicans have a deep spirtual belief in god. But then again, I am not the ultimate judge. So I don't vote for anyone on the basis of religion.

by maxwell edison

Senator Obama said, [i]"Not every mention of God in public is a breach to the wall of separation. Context matters."[/i]

I agree, 100 percent, with Senator Obama in that regard. In fact, I've been saying that very thing for years. Therefore, I both question and challenge the legitimacy of all the ACLU suits trying to deny free speech or display of anything and everything religious; and I both question and challenge the legitimacy of denying free speech in schools if it even mentions (heaven forbid!) the word God, such as the circumstance that started this discussion. But will Senator Obama join me in questing and challenging such things? And more importantly, since he's in the spotlight and in a position to be listened to, will he do so publicly, and will he specifically target the cases where it's happening?

Senator Obama said, [i]"It is doubtful that children reciting the Pledge of Allegiance feel oppressed or brainwashed as a consequence of muttering the phrase `under God"[/i]

I agree, 100 percent, with Senator Obama in that regard as well. In fact, I've also been saying that very thing for years. Therefore, I'm sure Senator Obama will join the Republicans in Congress, if and when the time comes, and vote in favor of allowing the Pledge of Allegiance, in its current form, in all public schools and at all public functions, should those schools and functions decide to recite it. In fact, perhaps Senator Obama should introduce such legislation himself!

Senator Obama said, [i]"Having voluntary student prayer groups using school property to meet should not be a threat, any more than its use by the High School Republicans should threaten Democrats"[/i]

Again, I agree with Senator Obama. Therefore, will he openly condemn the efforts of his fellow Democrats, call them to task -- by name -- and support such a thing, including allowing the Boy Scouts the use of public facilities that has been, at times, denied for that very reason?

Senator Obama said that lawmakers should, [i]"acknowledge the power of faith in the lives of the American people."[/i]

I keep agreeing with Senator Obama. And because of "the power of faith in the lives of the American people", and all the other comments he's made, will he then support school vouchers, so that parents can apply "the power of faith in the lives of the American people" by sending their kids to private schools, regardless of any religious affiliation that school might have?

It's easy to talk the talk in the heat of political campaigns. (And make no mistake about it, the 2006 Senate races will be waged by ALL Democrats, regardless of whether or not their seat is in play.) Let's see if Senator Obama will walk the walk. If he doesn't, it's all nothing more than political rhetoric and hypocrisy. If he does, look for the rest of the Democrat Party to destroy him, or in the very least, render him insignificant.

by jamesrl

My daughter "graduated" from Grade 5 yesterday - its the highest grade at her school so they hold a ceremony. She has been there since junior kindergarten, so a total of 7 years.

Instead of a formal commencement speaker, the chair of the parents council spoke briefly, the principal spoke briefly, and after each child received their certificate, they went up to the microphone and shared their best memory of the school.

Some of them were unintentionally funny.

One said "my best day of school was the first day of kindergarden" - I had to laugh because the rest of the time must have been downhill. Another said "I liked it when teachers were nice to me", which led me to believe that it was a special occasion when that happened.

What was a little disturbing to me is that some of the kids chose to dress to the nines - evening dresses and tuxes for a 930 AM ceremony. Maybe its me but the sight of a ten year old with a tux and a gold chain isn't natural.

But sadly the thing that disturbed me most was a girl who must have been 9 or 10 (grade 4, she wasn't graduating) wearing a T shirt that said, "Young, Sexy, Adventurous". I admit I wish I knew who the parents were to give them a piece of my mind on the subject.

On a similar subject there was a discussion on the radio about gifts to teachers - its de rigeur these days, but I don't like it, and neither do some teachers. My kids wrote a letter to their teachers instead of giving a gift. They had to thank the teacher for something specific. That in my mind is better than buying another coffee mug or cheap cologune or other inappropriate gifts.

James

by j.lupo

I remember when the only ceremony held was for graduation from High School into College. Maybe it is suppose to be motivational for the kids. A means to keep them in school.

The gift thing always bothered me when I was teaching. I used to say to my students, I don't need a gift. I do this because I want you to succeed. If you really want to give me a gift, stay in school, and succeed!!!! Give it your very best, that is the best gift they could give me.

by tig2

I read that in but was so certain that I did not go back to the story and confirm. In either case, what I heard from Obama in that is that an insincere, once-every-four-year appearance in a constituent church only reads as fake. I would see that if they showed up in ANY church.

Faith is meant to be lived, not lived around was the essence of the article to me.

Thanks for keeping me honest!

Edited for typos *sigh*

by x-marcap

Ugly, smart, people (like... um ... me) would then have a chance at political office. Today Politics is for Average to good looking people. Think Jock- Cheerleader with appropriate IQ.

Media makes the lovely powerful, and the stupid policy makers.

by tig2

I would vote for you. You make sense.

I like what Obama had to say on this issue. George isn't that pretty.

I agree. You just don't get much traction if you aren't young and beautiful. Doesn't say much for what people wil fall for, does it?

by j.lupo

the media and our culture. People just don't look beyond the surface on anything. The skim their e-mails or discussion threads and respond in haste without full understanding. Or they listen to very one-sided media coverage on a topic and jump to conclusions.

We also tend to listen to those who look and sound good to us - TV, Movie at fault?? I mean how many stars do we see that are "ugly" in lead roles?? Now keep in mind that "ugly" is a relative term, but I have been noticing how TV puts people in starting/leading roles that is the cultures view of what everyone should look like.

I could give examples, but am choosing not to at the moment. Obama had a good view and what makes me happy is he voiced it. Make this topic center stage as others are and people will at least discuss it. That is important.

by x-marcap

The School was wrong. They did violate her civil rights and she had completed the requirements for graduation. I hope she is a wealthy young woman soon.

Any agent of the State cannot enforce freedom from religion. That is in direct violation of the constitution and tacit support of a different religion, aetheism...

The amendment says "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances."

If the congress doesn't form a "First Church of the USA" there is no basis for any separation of church and state. What we have had for a long time is the state sponsored promotion of another religion--- Aetheism.

by maxwell edison

....you answered a question with a question? That's usually a diversion and deflection tactic.

For the record, I'm not a fundamentalist Christian. If they're not "applauding", you'd have to ask them why. Besides, I've not seen any opinion, one way or the other from these, so-called, "fundamentalists". Have you?

And did I say he was speaking out against religion in 2004? No, I didn't. I'm just comparing what he said in April 2004, in the heat of HIS campaign, and what he's saying in June of 2006, in the heat of the DEMOCRAT'S campaign to regain a majority in the Senate. Regardless of what he said in 2004, only an illiterate would suggest that the tone of the messages aren't very consistent, and it might appear to some that he's trying to play both sides, so to speak, but at different times. Why didn't he, for example, say in 2004 what he's saying today? Perhaps it's because it's the same thing Alan Keyes was saying in 2004. Regardless, I did say that Senator Obama has not yet established a track record sufficient enough for me to make a judgement call; and I challenge you to point to even one thing in my message in which I criticized Senator Obama. I didn't. In fact, I clearly stated that I'd even give him the benefit of the doubt that he was being sincere. That IS what I said, isn't it?

Sure, Alan Keyes was a carpetbagger; just like Hillary Clinton was a carpetbagger. Why did the Democrat Party exploit the former and give a pass to the latter? (Rhetorical question, as we all know the answer. And yes, both parties would respond the same way. That's how politics works.)

So there ya' go. You did not answer my questions, but I DID answer yours. Do you want to try to answer my initial questions again, or will you continue to divert and distract?

by faradhi

[i]I think they all use religion for their own purposes. I seriously doubt if the democrats or republicans have a deep spiritual belief in god.[/i]

Bush, Clinton, Obama, and Keyes all use religion for their political gain.

In as sense I am agreeing with you that democrats are applauded in the press for being christian and it is very hypocritical. However, I was trying to add that republicans are not any better. I have no problem critizing any political party. I know that the only thing they believe in is politics.

As for the answering a question with a question, some things are done for effect. So there ya' go.

edited to change affect to effect.

by tig2

The older I get.

Makes me wonder what would happen if the knowledgeable "unpretty" ever rose up against the attractive but brainless set?

Edited because TR won't give me a spell checker!

by jamesrl

The vaeldictorian I mentioned hoping for the big reaction was the one you mentioned that you saw , who said all sex is rape. That is a classic inflammatory, get me noticed kind of thing to say.

The woman who expressed her faith was not in my opinion trying to do the same thing - from what has been described here anyway.

James