Discussion Locked

Liberal looniness in the USA

0 helpful
122 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

122 replies

by vanessaj

I'm not sure that the knowlegeable "unpretty" could ever rise up (as T2 mentioned)...as long as the media holds us in its power. Actors are idealized and trusted by most of America and, it seems, even the world. They endorse political candidates, like they have some special knowledge or wisdom, and sway hundreds - possibly even thousands - toward those they want to have popularity and therefore power. And why? Because they're good ACTORS. Doesn't the general masses realize that they are just that - actors? Their lives are ensconced in "pretending" and making people believe in characters/people/situations/morality & social norms that don't even really exist, until they make a funny movie or TV show about it. Their life is about working full-time on their individual "image". It's understandable, that's what pays the bills for them, of course, and pays them quite nicely, too.

They live in luxury behind their big gates and security systems, guards and servants and live unconnected to the average joe - the rest of the world that is not "elite", never knowing again what it is like for those of us who walk down the average street in our towns and cities and deal with the everyday fears, taxes, laundry and car-washing lives that's the norm for the rest of the world. So, what gives them the right to "pretend" that they know who is best for us politically, to tell us who to vote for or have in leadership over us, anyway?

Anyway, my point being that we seem to idolize the "pretty people" and I don't see that ever giving way to intelligent discussion and an actual search for truth when it comes to political and social agendas, issues and power.

Except on TR discussion boards, of course. That's why I enjoy these so much...they are from real people. Those of us in the trenches, working it out, who see things from the same viewpoint and have some of the same goals - to get through each day alive and with a little time to spare for a coke (or beer) and a laugh or two. You are all priceless!

by x-marcap

In the one case, it was deliberately abusive.

In the second case it was actually a denial of civil rights, and a first amendment issue of free speech. She obviously wasn't being supported by the school (govt entity). What they did is a US criminal act of denying a person's civil rights.

by maxwell edison

But if you want to claim that you did, well, whatever floats your boat.

You said, [i]"Bush, Clinton, Obama, and Keyes all use religion for their political gain."[/i]

Sorry, dude. I disagree. Clinton (either Bill of Hillary), I would agree. The others, however, (giving Senator Obama the benefit of the doubt since it's too soon to know for sure), do not use their faith for political gain, but rather, perhaps, as a guiding light. To suggest otherwise is both silly and disingenuous. President Bush, for example, could gain more politically if he wasn't a man of faith, at least it appears that way since he's so vilified for it.

by faradhi

The very reason politicians express their religious beliefs is for political gain. Whether or not they actually hold those beliefs they espouse, I am not the one who judges their actual spiritual wellness. Neither is any other human.

edited for spelling

by j.lupo

comment. We don't all have the same viewpoint. However, we at least (most of us that is) do provide an realistic and somewhat educated, if not knowledgeble (sp?) view point that we enjoy sharing. We in TR world express our opinions, we even back them up with examples. Sometimes we influence each other and sometimes we flame ;) each other.

The important thing is we have the discussion, something the mass population do not do. They just want to know about Bradjolina, etc.

Note: I am too lazy to spell check and proud to admit it. I'll just point it out upfront.

by faradhi

[i]Why is it that for all these years, Republican Christians have been vilified unmercifully, by both the Democrat Party and in the press, but when a Democrat proposes reaching out to them, and encourages fellow Democrats to "acknowledge the power of faith in the lives of the American people" he's seen as a friggin' hero?[/i]

Maybe, because it is such a novelty for democrats to do so. Unless, your in the south. Then both parties do.

[i]Who's the more principled person and/or party, and who's simply playing politics looking for more votes?[/i]

It is not that Democrats are being any more hypocritical when espousing political beliefs than the republicans. They are just newer.

[i]Can you spell Bill Clinton, Al Gore, and other prominent Democrats who have been highlighted and praised for doing this sort of thing?[/i]

Don't forget Kerry. He did it as well. So do the republicans. There were favorable press on Bush's faith as well.

[i]And how many times has President Bush been vilified for showing his faith? [/i]

I don't know, I do not keep a tally. I am sure it has happened. However, It goes both ways. I remember Kerry being vilified for his faith as well. Just because some people stated that you cannot be christian and believe in abortion. Kerry had the Gall to disagree. (Note, I am just pointing out an instance where it goes both ways. Not in any way agreeing or disagreeing with anything Kerry has said.)

[i]But if the rest of the Democrat Party capitulates to his urges and tries to take the moral high-ground on this issue, it'll be as transparent as a pane of glass. And if they do, I wonder if it will be pointed out in the press?[/i]

It will be presented as a good change. It will not be pointed out as a political ploy. No more than it is pointed out that the republicans use religion as a political ploy.

[i]Is it really the principle of the issue that's the driving force, or is it the usual quest for Democrat Party votes, regardless of the obvious hypocrisy?[/i]

It is hypocrisy. Again the Dems are not alone. Just newer. Politics is about getting votes. Both Democrats and Republicans only care about getting votes.

Re:keyes [i] I wonder what the rest of the Democrat Party and the Democrats in the press said about him at that time on that particular issue? [/i]

The democrats attacked him on every point. The republicans would have done the same. The democratic party beat him on the basis that he was not from the state.

[i]What's going on here, principle or politics?[/i]

Politics is going on here. But Democrats are not the only ones playing.

I think that covers it. If not just let me know what I missed and I will answer it.

My initial point is that I do not delude myself in thinking that the republican party is better that the democrats on this issue. It is not that Democrats are being any more hypocritical when espousing religious beliefs in the course of politics than the republicans. They are just newer.

---edited to add ---
In all fairness to Max, in case someone is reading this for the first time. The above was posted after and in response to https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2051750
I accidentally posted it in the wrong location.

by j.lupo

As you said in another post, Obama is still new and we have yet to see what happens. I am hoping that he steps forward in a leader by example role. I don't think this should be Democrats and Republicans, it should be a discussion on each issue for what the people want. These "elected" officials are "suppose to represent" us - the people.

Now Max, I have been reading your other threads, so you don't have to repeat your views - unless you want to (choice is yours). I would wish that we could get more public awareness of both sides of an issue and then have free choice. Guess all I can do is continue to work towards it knowing it might never happen.

by vanessaj

I love reading your posts, by the way. I suppose what I really meant by seeing things from the same viewpoint and having some of the same goals was the "...to get through each day alive and with a little time to spare for a coke (or beer) and a laugh or two" statement. I have been reading these for more than a month now, (which I realize makes me a real n00b) and it is apparent that we don't see eye-to-eye on everything. That's what makes it so lively, isn't it? ("lively"...does that make me sound old?)

I was just trying to distinguish the "us" from the "them", I suppose. Thanks for calling me on it. I need to make certain that I am clear on my posts. And thanks for all the other investments of your time on this and other discussions. Your posts are always a good read. I don't agree with you all the time, but your intelligence shows and you're a good sport.

Keep it up.

by jamesrl

Like it or not, the media responds to the same market forces that other parts of the economy does.

I remember my high school tour of the local newspaper when the business manager explained the facts of life to us. The stories are the bait to get you to buy the paper, so that you can read the ads from the advertisers. The other media aren't any different.

So if you wanna know who to blame about the media - blame us.

Blame us for the fact that fewer and fewer TV news shows do hard hitting in depth news. Blame us for the sound bite story. Blame us for more coverage of Brad and Angelina's baby than a million refugees in Darfur.

Because if we stopped watching, they would change formats, and their focus.

I went to a school famous for its journalism program, which was primarily for print and radio journalists- same one Peter Jennings went to. I worked closely with many of those students on both student newspapers and the campus radio station.

Few of those people - dedicated to hard news - are working today at their "dream" job, because few people do hard news anymore, at least in proportion to lifestyle, entertainment, fashion, etc.

James

by j.lupo

have a different opinion and call me on it when it differs from mine. One of the things I love about TR is the willingness to have debates (logical debates, ok emotional too). For me it is a chance to express my thoughts and ideas and the TR community makes me do it clearly. I can't just pick up the phone and call someone or run down to their desk to clarify a point. I have to do it in writing, which I have a lot of trouble with.

When I joined TR back in 2001, I did a lot of reading and was afraid to actually comment or post. As I matured into the community, I learned it was ok to have an opinion and express it. I learned not everyone would agree and I had to learn how to discuss versus argue. :)

I enjoy reading your posts as well. Again, agreement isn't the point, but I do get a great education about all sorts of topics. That is the point for me.

by j.lupo

have a different opinion and call me on it when it differs from mine. One of the things I love about TR is the willingness to have debates (logical debates, ok emotional too). For me it is a chance to express my thoughts and ideas and the TR community makes me do it clearly. I can't just pick up the phone and call someone or run down to their desk to clarify a point. I have to do it in writing, which I have a lot of trouble with.

When I joined TR back in 2001, I did a lot of reading and was afraid to actually comment or post. As I matured into the community, I learned it was ok to have an opinion and express it. I learned not everyone would agree and I had to learn how to discuss versus argue. :)

I enjoy reading your posts as well. Again, agreement isn't the point, but I do get a great education about all sorts of topics. That is the point for me.

by j.lupo

have a different opinion and call me on it when it differs from mine. One of the things I love about TR is the willingness to have debates (logical debates, ok emotional too). For me it is a chance to express my thoughts and ideas and the TR community makes me do it clearly. I can't just pick up the phone and call someone or run down to their desk to clarify a point. I have to do it in writing, which I have a lot of trouble with.

When I joined TR back in 2001, I did a lot of reading and was afraid to actually comment or post. As I matured into the community, I learned it was ok to have an opinion and express it. I learned not everyone would agree and I had to learn how to discuss versus argue. :)

I enjoy reading your posts as well. Again, agreement isn't the point, but I do get a great education about all sorts of topics. That is the point for me.

by j.lupo

have a different opinion and call me on it when it differs from mine. One of the things I love about TR is the willingness to have debates (logical debates, ok emotional too). For me it is a chance to express my thoughts and ideas and the TR community makes me do it clearly. I can't just pick up the phone and call someone or run down to their desk to clarify a point. I have to do it in writing, which I have a lot of trouble with.

When I joined TR back in 2001, I did a lot of reading and was afraid to actually comment or post. As I matured into the community, I learned it was ok to have an opinion and express it. I learned not everyone would agree and I had to learn how to discuss versus argue. :)

I enjoy reading your posts as well. Again, agreement isn't the point, but I do get a great education about all sorts of topics. That is the point for me.

by j.lupo

have a different opinion and call me on it when it differs from mine. One of the things I love about TR is the willingness to have debates (logical debates, ok emotional too). For me it is a chance to express my thoughts and ideas and the TR community makes me do it clearly. I can't just pick up the phone and call someone or run down to their desk to clarify a point. I have to do it in writing, which I have a lot of trouble with.

When I joined TR back in 2001, I did a lot of reading and was afraid to actually comment or post. As I matured into the community, I learned it was ok to have an opinion and express it. I learned not everyone would agree and I had to learn how to discuss versus argue. :)

I enjoy reading your posts as well. Again, agreement isn't the point, but I do get a great education about all sorts of topics. That is the point for me.

by j.lupo

Sorry. The site is giving me all sorts of fun. It tells me it didn't post, I get the 404 error and then I finally get in and there are 6 copies of my post. :( :( :(

by j.lupo

I mean, I know I turn the channel and don't buy the paper for that reason. I use the internet to get as much perspective as I can. I ask questions and I talk to people. It is just so sad that we cannot get back to "real news" versus the "shock and awe" of today's journalism.

My post was the media and our culture if you remember. First line of the post. The media feeds our cultures desire. I think it is a round-robin type situation. We demand big stories, the media gives them to us, so we demand even more stories, and they give that to us. The visous circle is never broken or at least not easily broken.

by maxwell edison

...all the [i]"they both do it"[/i] kinda' stuff. Come on, don't justify one's actions by comparing them to another's "alleged" actions, and you did that in almost all cases. If there's something specific you want to bring to light, go ahead and do it. But don't use the standard retort, "they all do it", because no, they don't "all" do it.

For example, for the life of me, I can't think of a single Republican "getting down and funky" in a "black" church, like so many white Democrats have done, including our first "black president", Bill Clinton. So no, they don't all do "it" -- whatever "it" is.

Moreover, people can indeed be people of faith, wear that faith on their sleeve, but not use it for political gain. Presidents Bush and Carter are two such examples. It's just who they are.

And as to the subject of this tangent, Senator Obama, is that who he is? It might depend on what the definition of is is, but in my opinion, the jury's still out. Time will tell.

Overall, however, thanks for answering all those nagging question marks -- some of which were, admittedly, rhetorical. Well done.

by faradhi

I am just not going to delude myself into thinking anyone in politics, republican or democrat, will do anything in public for anything other than gaining more votes. That includes wearing religion on their sleeves. I look at all politicians with the same skeptism.

---- edited to add

I stated in a previous post that I agree that if democrats make the change it would be hypocritical. I just am not going to give the republicans the pass that you are willing to give them.

by maxwell edison

(And I predict that you will simply say the same thing back to me, although it would be unfounded.)

This article was about a Democrat Senator, not Republicans; and it appears to me that Senator Obama is not receiving the same treatment (by the press and other Democrats), even though they do, in essence, say the same thing.

When there is an obvious double standard, one must wonder what the hidden single-standard really is. If you don't wonder the same thing, I would presume you're simply predisposed to think that way. Nothing I can say can make you see it any differently.

by faradhi

I would also ask what part of I agree with you do you not understand. I would say that the press and democrats have not responded with the skeptism due.

I am just not ready yet to say that the republicans are any better. There are many espoused christian republicans that get caught in ethical issues. (Tom Delay)

by vanessaj

...just kidding. The TR site seems to be acting kind of weird lately - and I STILL can't update my profile.

As re: the media rant...I can see where you're coming from, and I guess it's the old "does life imitate art, or does art imitate life" debate. And it's true that it's our fault that we listen to the crap that is thrown out at us from the media...we could just turn off the TV or not ever go to a movie. But instead, we consume what is offered us.

While it?s true that we have some influence on what is made/written (movies, TV, news, magazines, etc.), I believe that these media have much more of an influence on us. Sure they stick to social norms (our input) as long as we buy (more of our input) the crap they spew?but it seems their input is so much greater. We don?t really get to choose what is made for consumption. Like, for instance, how those who choose what is going to be made always seem to be trying to ?push the envelope? with regard to how much LOWER they can take the generally accepted norms and morays. The easy path. Maybe it?s what they know.

Every awards show praises the ?envelope pushers? and rejects so many quality productions. It?s typical who they choose to win. Why do they like these ?pushers? so much? Why doesn?t a morally-rich, stand-up-to-one?s-good-values, no violence, no language, no nudity type of show ever get the Hollywood nods? Show me an actress that hasn?t slutted herself in film or on paper, and I?ll show you one with a very short media life who will never be a ?star?. Why aren?t they taken seriously until they do?

But don't you think that if good, quality entertainment that presented more respectful, in-depth, more realistic yet still exciting and suspenseful programs, that there would be a lot of people who would choose that over the crap that is on now? How many times have you sat down in front of 300 channels...and nothing on? And it can't be simply about ratings, either. Look at movies. Do you know what single rating-type of movies make the most money in the movie theatres? G-rated movies. They always make truckloads(I'll try to find that link again with the $ stats). Maybe not the first day or two, but family movies always make the most cash in the theatre and afterwards with video sales. Kids like them, a lot of adults like them, they are given as gifts, etc. I keep a stock of the latest and don't even have kids, but for the occasion that friends may visit that bring their kids and need a movie for them during their visit.

But what rating-type movies do you see most in the theatres and most marketed? PG-16 and R-rated movies. Mostly R, at least in the neighborhood theatres around here (on Long Island). Why do you think that is? Wouldn't movie-makers go for what makes the most cash? And why do all the awards shows always give the awards to those people "pushing the envelope"? I can't see that these movies have any better writing, directing, acting, anything...they're just dirtier, scarier, more sexually explicit, blah, blah, blah. Anything even remotely ?morally clean? is mocked and disdained for laughs. That?s like the popular thing now. Why is that?

j., do you ever watch any of the old movies that were considered R-rated just a few years ago and they seem so tame?what has happened to our general perception during in those years? How have we grown so cold and hard over just these few decades that we accept easily what once made us turn our faces?

Without the fantasy of the media (all of it), if we were to live just in the reality of connecting with each other on a human level, talking and interacting person to person?do you think it would ever have become so popular to curse at each other as we do, for one example? The hardness of our language didn?t come from respectfully working with each other. We accept sexually explicit terms that are degrading to others because we have heard them, literally, millions of times as acceptable language IN THE MEDIA. And we just swallow it whole like that?s what?s normal. We are told the abnormal is normal every time we click the remote or buy the ticket. It?s fun to laugh at course jokes from comedians, but isn?t it so much harder to tell those same jokes to the face of someone it might hurt?

The general public (millions of us) is told what?s funny, what?s accepted, what?s cool, what?s popular, etc. etc. by a very small number of people who make those decisions. And it is accepted on the whole by and far. TV, magazines and the movies do it?and don?t even get me started on the news! It?s like a freakin? conspiracy or something. How cool would it be to be able to trust the news?

I?m sure that there are some exceptions to the rule, but on the whole, as a rule, well, wow!

We really are what we eat, mentally as well as physically. And when I step back and look at our media-soaked generation, and take a look at what the media is feeding us, I feel like I need a mental bath.

So, ranting and ranting, but I still haven?t said the half of what I see. But I encourage you, if you?ve had the stamina to read all of this post (if so, I?m really impressed) to let me know what you think about it, too. Do you ever get angry at the deterioration of society by the bombardment of input from the media elite? Do you think we will ever become completely free of it?s lure to feed with the bottom-dwellers and instead become truly independent thinkers, rejecting the banal and spurring each other on to beauty, grace and truth? Do you think, in the future, we will ever come to a place that we look back at the popular movies made 50 years ago (now) and think that the media then (now) used to be really cheap and dirty?and aren?t we glad they are so uplifting, respectful of each other, encouraging and edifying now?

Do you think we can change direction and are headed there? What do you think can be done? Anything?

by j.lupo

Ok, I admit I skimmed your message. I am stating it up front, cause I am a very slow reader, but I did read through it to know I am definitely going back to re-read.

1st, I think you stated your position wonderfully. I agree we need to do something about the situation, but most people are just lazy (like I am about writing and reading, which is why I participate in TR) and take what is there. In addition, how do we account for taste? Supposedly there are polls done by the movie industry to see what people want in their movies. If so, I would like to know their research methodology, cause I think it is flawed.

Now here is an example of what I mean. I like Bill Cosby as a comedian, but I didn't like the Bill Cosby show. I thought that was pretty bad. Yet, a lot of people loved it. The new show Rescue Me - I can't stand - but I know there are a lot of people that like it.

So, my values and morals are different and all I can do to change things is to switch stations, shut the TV, don't go see a movie, etc. That is me making a difference the only way I can. I can also discuss the pros and cons of certain movies, TV, etc. with others and that is again me doing what I can.

do I watch older stuff - You Bet. Do I see the difference between R of yester-year and today - Yes again.

I am not sure what the answer is. All I can do is keep discussing it, keep bringing it up, and hope that enough people get tired of it to help make a change

This discussion is closed to new replies.