Question Locked

Looking for an AFFORDABLE core switch (gigabit)

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greetings all. I am finally able to move away from our 10 and 100 base HUBS (shudder), and getting to move to a switched network.

-- BACKGROUND INFO ---

Up till now, the only real investment I had been able to get was a 3Com 4400 switch for our core (24 port), and almost everything else was 3Com SuperStack hubs.

I have three remote locations, and the central location. I was able to change the remote cores to a Netgear FS726TP (24 port).

--END BACKGROUND INFO ---

I am now looking to upgrade off of the 3Com 4400, which is 10/100 to something Gigabit.

I need at least 12 ports, but would prefer 24.

Must be manageable and support VLANS.
Of course, need QOS. (goes without saying?)

Editied to add: Would really like a Layer 3 switch. end edit

We are looking at going to IP phones within a year or so, so are upgrading our infrastructure a little at a time, so we don't have to completely replace the network at THAT time, raising the costs of the IP phone system.

I am on a very tight budget, so the Cisco solution is out of the question.

Is there something you have used, or you regularly install for clients, that you can recommend?

If I have a 12 or 24 port Gigabit switch for my core, I can drop my 4400 as the secondary for this location, as I have about 32 connections in this building.

My main concern is getting our 7 servers, the uplink, the remote building, and my system on the gigabit. (did I say "my system" out loud?)

Include one port to the secondary (4400) and I am able to get by with the 12. Would MUCH rather have a 24 or 48, but will work with what is available/affordable.

Thanks for your assistance and input. If you don't feel like posting, feel free to peer me.

jd

Oh yeah, don't forget to visit Tigs discussion.
http://tinyurl.com/3cevo4
It is for a great cause.



15 replies

by hal 9000

I'm told that they work well and are cheap they have a 19 inch Rack Mount 24 Port Switch but you'll have to look for it. :p

http://tinyurl.com/2jbw8g

This crowd I've used a lot of unmanaged Switches on very small LAN'S and they have worked OK. Sorry no URL at the moment but here's a description.

REPOTEC G2400U 24-port 10/100/1000Mbps Gigabit Switch, Auto MDIX, 8K MAC Addresses, 2M Bits Buffer Memory, Auto-Crossover function
REPOTEC G2400U 24-port 10/100/1000Mbps Gigabit Switch, TP interface auto MDI-X function for auto TX/RX swap, 8K MAC address table, 2M Bits Buffer Memory, Auto-Crossover function, Media Support - 10BASE-T: Category 3, 4 or 5 TP, 100BASE-TX/1000BASE-T: Category 5 TP, Conforms to IEEE 802.3, IEEE 802.3u, IEEE 802.3ab and IEEE 802.3x standards, IEEE802.3x compliant for full-duplex, Store & forward architecture and performs forwarding and filtering, Back pressure flow control for half-duplex, LED indicators

http://tinyurl.com/33wnm5

I don't know just how well these work but the 4 port ones scream along and I've yet to have one fail in 5 years now. If that's any help.

Good to know that you are going to drive down to [b]Video Tig you Old Devil.[/b] :D

Col

by jdclyde

I seem to recall a bounty on Col!

So, who is it worth more to, for me to mark this as helpful or not? ]:)

by jiminpa

I set up the chair, popped the popcorn and cracked ope the first beer. This should be fun to watch. :D

by cmiller5400

I remember that discussion... Looks like you win JD. :p

by Sonja Thompson

He's just asking for it now... I think 667 has a nice ring to it, don't you?

by netman1958

take a look at this:

http://www.provantage.com/hp-compaq-j8692a-aba~7HEWN19W.htm

This switch sounds like it would fit your situation, but I don't know if it's within your budget. It is considerably cheaper than a Cisco with the same features.

I haven't used this particular model but have used a lot of different HP switches in the past. In fact, I have an old 80 port 4000M running here now. They come with a lifetime warranty and I've had great luck with them.

by jdclyde

But there was a bounty put on Col's head, for someone that could give him that one extra thumbs up to break the coveted 666.... :D

Feeling evil today, so what can I say? ;\

by jellimonsta

JD, what switch solution did you go with? And did you get your IP phone solution yet? If you are in fact going with a Cisco VoIP solution, I can point you in the right direction for the best implementation team in the midwest, but not a cheap one. :D

by jdclyde

We got a 3com 2824 sfp plus (3c16487)

10/100/1000, auto sense, 24 port.

As for VoIP, we connected our ancient pbx's at each location to each other by plugging them in to vwic cards, and has been one huge clusterfuk after another, that still isn't working correctly.

The company that was brought in the provide the solution was horrible, and to get everything useable, I had to do it myself with the help of my trusty smartnet account.

The part that doesn't work acceptably is when a call comes in a local line at a remote location, it hits the PBX, hands off the the Cisco, travels across the state on our MPLS network, hits another cisco, then our voicemail system, which takes the transfer, and sends it BACK across another channel to the remote. (so it is using two channels.)

Then to top it off, the contractors were suppose to have compression set, but seems the old phone system doesn't HAVE any compression settings, and the VWIC cards don't either, so it is a full 64k per circuit! Gee, wonder why it doesn't work?

At least the network part is set, so I can dump this back into the lap of the phone admin, who had dumped it in my lap. :D

by jellimonsta

Are the VWICs in Cisco routers?
You should make sure you have a PVDM card with DSP resources and you can set on box transcoding.

by jdclyde

I am running Cisco 2801's.

One core location, three remotes.

Each has a VWIC card installed and a T1 card plugged into the MPLS.

PVDM card. In the router or the phone system?

The phone systems are VERY old. Tadirans, running an old version of the software that does not support compression. Was told by phone company they would require a CPU upgrade to take the minimal software upgrade, or a total replacement to get to the current version.

I am now looking at what it would take/cost to do "Foreign Exchange", to have the calls all come directly into the central location.

I am NOT happy.

by oh smeg

And this answer was more than a year old I'm not worried. [b]Much[/b] :0

Actually after a year of inactivity I thought that questions had been wiped. At least that's what we where told at one of the site redesigns. :p

Col ]:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.