Discussion Locked

Michael Moore is a [i]Sicko[/i]

0 helpful
160 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

160 replies

by dadspad

oversimplified. I also realize it is worthy of a whole different disscussion that does not belong here. Unless, of course, if you want to pursue it. :)

by pser

For the record.

You mentioned the little girl who was shot ... in two posts. Let's touch on that. The boy (who found the gun and took it to school) was "living" in this "crack house" as you put it, because his mother was forced in to the "Welfare to work" program (that Dick Clark's restaurant was participating in) that required a 3hr to and 3hr from commute via the transit system for a job she was forced to take. That six hrs added to her work hours ... she had NO choice but to turn to her family as far as living arrangements and "who" would watch her child while she was gone at LEAST 15 hours a day. The "welfare to work" program was the catalyst to this whole unfortunate incident ... to say the least, was Moore's point. But of course, you guys (u know who u r) would blame the mother for being poor, in Poverty stricken Flint (Thank you GM) having a child, and for the shooting itself. Niccccce...

"(what does this have to do with Columbine?)". Obviously you missed the point of BFC. It was NOT just about that one incident. Moore's BFC was asking the question of "why", Why so much MORE "gun related deaths/crimes" in America than in any other civilized Nation? I'll not go into stats or debates concerning gun control in any Nation, as that horse has been beaten enough around here. I just find it hard to believe that you watched that film, with that title, and walked away thinking this was a documentary about the Columbine shootings alone. Wow!

As far as Heston and the different outfits and different rally's. Again, Moore was pointing out that the NRA was Johnny on the spot right after the Flint shooting, as well as the Columbine shootings (and other similar shootings as well). He was showing and acknowledged that these were different rally's at different times (Within days of each shootings in the towns of the shootings ... NRA, Bad Form). So, again a little confused about how we watched the same Doc. and walked away with such different takes on what was actually being addressed, stated, acknowledged, expressed, explained, etc.

You can call it "INTENTIONAL misrepresentation" all you like ... it doesn't make it true. Sounds more like INTENTIONAL misinterpretation to me.

http://www.michaelmoore.com/

by jdclyde

it is time to talk out against clear examples coming from the other direction as well.

I well recall you not being pleased with the bias in our news broadcasts, that were and ARE trying to do the same thing Moore is, distort and mislead.

I just wish we could get people from political "sides" from using past bad behavior from the "other side" to justify their own bad behavior. It is the first thing people do.. "Well, so and so did THIS...."

I am so tired of it all, from all of them.

Cheers.

by jdclyde

I clearly talked about more than just a few shootings, and from different parts of the show.

Please explain who's fault it is that this woman "had" to take that specific job? Was it Dick Clark's fault that she had a child she couldn't support? Did Dick Clark FORCE her to work there, or did he offer a chance for poor people to get a foot in the door? Sounded like he was helping out a lot of people that no one else would. How many "poor" people does Moore employ?

Poor and with a kid. It [b]IS her fault[/b] that she was a welfare mom that didn't either get a local job or move to where a job was. Any parent that takes their child to live in a drug house SHOULD be charged with child endangerment and have their kids taken away.

NRA and their rallies. If you had paid attention, the rallies were not scheduled BECAUSE of the shootings, they just didn't CANCEL them because of the shootings.

NRA has always been a supporter of LEGAL, responsible ownership. They have also always been supporters of tough penalties for all criminal activity involving a firearm. They also know a lot of feel-gooders will use an incident like the shootings to justify depriving law abiding citizens one of their rights. They don't have the brains to realize that more laws would not have stopped that shooting because it is ALREADY illegal to shoot someone with a stolen gun you find in a crack house. Yeah, rocket science.

by dadspad

seriously, and correct me if this is wrong, I remember reading that 5% of doctors are responsible for 95% of the malpractice cases. If true, then if the Medical boards would stop these 5%, insurance would go down.

Also would help if all employees of a facility, such as a hospital or clinc, was exempt from being sued. The facility should be held accountable for the employees it hires, but not the employees. Why should nurses and technicians be paying malpractice insurance? Unless they are in private practice, then they have a responsibility to the patient.

by tonythetiger

We could start by sueing people, not corporations. If some[b]body[/b] does something wrong to cause you harm, sue [b]them[/b].

Corporations don't pay anyway, their customers do.

by cactus pete

Max,

With all due respect, attempting to find an answer to the conflict is why we, as a society, have instituted health care for the populace. Leaving it to a 'higher power' is just hard to swallow when the only thing between someone's life, liberty, and pursuing happiness is cash.

Being born with a treatable illness (or genes making you prone to it) should not condemn one simply because of also being born into a small bank account. Sometimes libertarianism needs to compromise with humanitarianism.

I don't know just how hardfast you cling to libertarian views in all cases, but I know you're fairly staunch. For the progress of the discussion, can you find reason to compromise in certain cases? If so, where do YOU cross that line?

by tonythetiger

[i]Being born with a treatable illness (or genes making you prone to it) should not condemn one simply because of also being born into a small bank account.[/i]

Nor should it condemn someone else who had nothing to do with your circumstances into paying for the consequences.

[i]Sometimes libertarianism needs to compromise with humanitarianism.[/i]

Compromise requires give and take by both sides. Demanding that someone else pay your bills is not compromise.

I have been of assistance to many people who are "trying" but just need a little help. If I had my tax money back I could and would do more. Government IS the problem.

by oz_media

I always see Americans using the term 'socialism' when referring to necessary services, as if America doesn't socialist services that are imperative and wanted/accepted/expected by Americans.

Police, Ambulance, Fire, nobody complains of these socialist systems. Why should YOUR tax dollars help someone that is careless, colllecting welfare and growing weed, when they burn the house down?

It a free handout for them on YOUR dime. What a rip off! Make fire response a system where you buy fire insurance (not just for your belongings but to get the fire department to turn up) and THAT ensures you will see the fire department when the house is on fire. Of course, the level of your premium will decide what fire department arrives, whether they have new trucks or just water and sand in buckets etc.

When a drug addict stabs another drug addict in a fight, YOUR tax dollars see that the issue is resolved by police, often at ridiculous costs only to see it tossed out of court a year later due to a technicality.
If you were to get rid of your socialist government, then only those who had police protection insurance would get help. Others would just be left to bleed. Of course again your insurance would need to provide good quality policing, from a local area.

YOUR tax dollars are constantly being wasted on these useless socialist programs, why not get teh Republican government to stop their socialist ways?

And yet you feel that offering medical attention to all Americans is not a social program worthy or your support?

As for early death and not paying into the system, what about the senoir citizens who's tax dollars are used to fund the military? They should be able to opt out and save the money, when the tax money isn't used it is given back to the people right? Many won't even see any benefit from Iraq, but they still have to pay it.

What if they die and stop funding the war with thier tax dollars? Did they then rip everyone else off because they stopped funding the war?

Why should YOUR tax dollars be given to a library so that someone else who can't afford a $10.00 paperback can read that book? They haven't earned teh right to take your money either, as Max always says, taking YOUR money and giving it to those who did not earn it. tsk!! tsk!!
BAD library, BAD socialst republicans!

Try looking outside the box, or gettig a wiff of reality, your country, my country and many free countries are rife with what you deem 'socialist' programs that TAKE your tax dollars and use them to help those who cannot or will not help themselves. But you don't complain about them?!

The one thing you complan about is helping a fellow American live, and giving them a chance in life or as some would say, living the American dream.

Freedom, democracy, good will to all men...or at least those who can afford it.

How dare they live the American dream on YOUR dollars!?!?

by tonythetiger

As in Microwave ovens?, Dish washing machines? A second car? Cable TV?

Over half of the "poor" in this country have all of the above.

Perhaps we're talking about two different things when we talk about poor. The middle class in most other countries would love to be doing "as well" as the poor do in this country.

Which brings up another point. It doesn't matter how much you give to anybody, there is always going to be a "poorest" group of people. [added: Unless, of course, you're a socialist country, where everybody gets the same no matter what they do, what they need, or how hard they work (unless, of course, you know somebody who knows somebody who can get you an extra pound of beans). Yeah, that's how it should work.... NOT!]

by cactus pete

Do you live in a society? Do you wish to NOT live in a society? Where do you draw the lines for societal responsibility?

For the sake of argument:

If you were facing death within a short period of time (not long enough to earn or borrow sufficiently additional funds) that could be prevented for a price of merely $1 beyond the amount you had... Well, you'd be happy to accept death?

You don't feel it is proper to pay taxes at all for the benefit of society? If Health Care is not a right, neither is fire fighting. But you are OK with paying those taxes? After all, the lightning that hit your neighbor's house wasn't your problem. But the spreading flames might be...

I'm just curious as to where you draw the lines. What is the breaking point at which you say, this deserves my tax money, and where you say, but one straw more and it is a violation of my liberties.

I can't believe you don't see the value in saving a life.

by tonythetiger

[i]If you were facing death within a short period of time (not long enough to earn or borrow sufficiently additional funds) that could be prevented for a price of merely $1 beyond the amount you had... Well, you'd be happy to accept death?[/i]

(If I didn't have to pay for all the deadbeats, I'd have had that dollar, so it's all your fault! Maybe my widow should sue you. Or wouldn't that be fair?)

[i]You don't feel it is proper to pay taxes at all for the benefit of society?[/i]

Who's to say what a benefit is? I'm sure we'll disagree on that. But in a nutshell, I think it's proper to use tax money to build, maintain, and protect the infrastructure, that ALL of us benefit from. That's it!

[i]If Health Care is not a right, neither is fire fighting.[/i]

I partly agree. I would be happy to pay the firemen to sit around the station waiting for a fire. That's protecting the infrastructure. But when they are actually fighting a fire, the owner or insurer of the property should pay for the services rendered. I don't know where you live, but that's exactly the way it is here. If I fall and break my leg and have to call a squad, I get a bill from them. Same with fire. Even the police give you a bill when they transport you to jail, and the jail gives you another one, for your keep.

[i]I'm just curious as to where you draw the lines. What is the breaking point at which you say, this deserves my tax money, and where you say, but one straw more and it is a violation of my liberties.[/i]

If something is only going to benefit one or a few people, that person or those people should be responsible for it, and not burden society with it (that includes disaster relief. Any tax monies used for other than public infrastructure repair (except private donations) should be paid back).

[i]I can't believe you don't see the value in saving a life.[/i]

It depends. I know you'll scowl at this but: Some people are worth saving... Some may even be worth giving up my own life for. But some are not.

[Edited for format]

by cactus pete

You still didn't actually answer the first point. You're OK with a shortfall of cash causing you to die? Even if the disease or injury wasn't your fault?

"Who's to say what a benefit is? I'm sure we'll disagree on that."

True, we will likely disagree, but I don't have a proper sense of your context, which is why I'm asking. If I knew where you drew the line, we could actually discuss why it's drawn there.

Let me further the example of the firefighting - Lightning strikes City Hall and spreads to your home. Is God responsible for the bill? The City? (That's a trap, isn't it...) You are responsible for your own home, even so removed from cause?

"If something is only going to benefit one or a few people, that person or those people should be responsible for it, and not burden society with it"

A "few people" is a sticking point. And you build in NO exceptions? In lieu of a solid definition, I err on saving lives.

I suspect that Health Care would not have advanced to where it is today if we hadn't supported those in the past who could not always pay. If we did not try to heal the less fortunate and learn from that, the fortunate would still be treated with older, less effective methods.

And before anyone jumps on it - I'm not advocating treating the poor as lab rats.

Many people who claim that their rights are bestowed upon them from some higher power seem to be the ones who can say "Some people are worth saving... Some may even be worth giving up my own life for. But some are not." If you're not prepared to allow others to judge for you, I don't think you should be sitting in the big chair yourself.

by faradhi

Microwave ovens, Dish washing machines, A second car, Cable TV: Source please...

I have worked in zip codes that were at the time one of the 5 poorest in the nation and I guarantee that none of the people I have met had any of those. My wife worked for a school that 98% of all the students qualified for free lunches and breakfasts. Those students rarely got dinner. The school had a clothes closet for those students that would show up to school without shoes, coats, and shirts. The parents and grandparents had none of those. Some were working and not on any assistance. Many had no home at all.

Although there are a lot of people take advantage of the system, I would say from experience that MOST do not. At least in the zip codes where I spent time. Most people who are not in the system do not see the majority that are in the system legitimately.

I know many people who can say stuff like, "I worked with this lady who made more than me that had food stamps and welfare..." What I remind them, is that In the normal course of most peoples life, they do not meet people who legitimately need social services. People who legitimately need social services do not work in places we do.

We all hear about the abusers because it is news. We all know someone who knows someone else that met someone who was abusing the system. It would not make it in the news or be a topic of conversation if they actually met only people who did not abuse the system.

Although Social services in this country need serious reform. I am not so quick to say they need to be eliminated. Maybe because, when I grew up and my father was putting his life on the line for our country, we were on food stamps. Further, Naval housing was the only thing that kept us from using public housing. Oh yeah, my mother worked full time as well. No we did not cheat the system and we did not eat high off the hog either. I remember a lot of pot pies and fish sticks.

I know before it is said that when you drive by the projects they ALL have Cadillacs and all have dish television. But then again, How many of us have actually been in the projects? I cannot say I have.

All that said, the system is Broke. Many who need Social services are denied. Many who have Social Services do not receive them legitimately. But just because the implementation is bad, does not make the idea bad. Often, I have said that government programs suffer from good ideas with bad implementation. So rather than eliminate the good idea, just fix the bad implementation.

by tonythetiger

[i]You still didn't actually answer the first point. You're OK with a shortfall of cash causing you to die? Even if the disease or injury wasn't your fault?[/i]

It doesn't matter if I'm "OK" with it or not. I'll be dead! You're trying to rationalize taking money from me... by what, playing God?

[i]You are responsible for your own home, even so removed from cause?[/i]

I am responsible for my own home, unless another person is found to be (that's why I buy insurance).

[i]I suspect that Health Care would not have advanced to where it is today if we hadn't supported those in the past who could not always pay. If we did not try to heal the less fortunate and learn from that, the fortunate would still be treated with older, less effective methods.[/i]

That's crap. Most places had free or reduced cost care long before the government started paying for it. If anything, the levels of redundancy in testing now required by the government before a treatment is available [b]hampers[/b] advancement. It also adds significantly to the cost. Who's to blame when testing is not completed in time for the treatment to save YOUR life?

Here's an example I heard on the radio just today. Cosmetic surgery, which is usually not covered by insurance or medicaid, and less regulated than other medical treatments, has gotten better AND less expensive in recent years.

[i]Many people who claim that their rights are bestowed upon them from some higher power seem to be the ones who can say "Some people are worth saving... Some may even be worth giving up my own life for. But some are not." If you're not prepared to allow others to judge for you, I don't think you should be sitting in the big chair yourself.[/i]

Like it or not, you may one day be in a position where you WILL have to pick one over the other. An extreme example: You and your wife are walking in the park, and you stop to re-tie your shoe, while she walks ahead. Just as she crosses a bridge, a rapist jumps out and grabs her, and they struggle. While you are running to her aid, they both fall into the water. nobody else is around. Who are you going to save?

"All people are created equal", but they don't remain that way.

by faradhi

First, thanks for the post.

Further, If the Heritage foundations article is true, what the government is defining as poor needs to be seriously adjusted. Like I stated in my post, the Social Services in this country needs to be serious restructured.

I have seen in this country real poverty. I guarantee that there is real poverty in this country. Given that, Social Services that support those in poverty in this country should continue.

by tonythetiger

Some people have everything they want and are happy with it. Who is the government to tell them they don't have enough?

by hal 9000

What is their catch phrase [i]We give you the facts and let you decide[/i] or at least something like that when in fact they chose which facts to dish out to spoon feed the people silly enough to watch the joke that passes as News from Fox.

Personally I wouldn't take the time to Pi$$ on More if he was on fire but then again the same applies to some people on the other side of the fence as well. I just am amused with the idea that America is the worlds Biggest Democracy when actually the people are being dedicated to by unelected officials who have their own agenda and they are the leaders of the Political Parties.

Hardly a democracy but then again it's not in these peoples best interests to actually give the people a real choice is it? :^0

The only decent thing that I've ever heard from M More was WMD's actually mean [b]Words Of Mass Deception[/b] and when it comes to Iraq that is about right. It was a mistake to go there for the original stated reasons and while Saddam was a nasty piece of work he was nasty to everyone now they have some weak willed do nothings in Iraq who are incapable of governing the place and keeping it safe for the general population and what's worse are totally Dependant on the COW to keep them in power so we are stuck there no matter what.

The mistake here is that there was no firm Military Plan in place before the invasion occurred and just like Vietnam it will degenerate into a complete fiasco unless someone is willing to take a stand and come up with some firm Military Goal that is possible and then be willing to place all of the available resources to accomplish this goal. If that isn't done there is no hope for Iraq and we are just prolonging the suffering that could be over quickly if we withdrew and allowed the Civil War to run it's course.

While we are wasting so much in Iraq the Talaban are now making a comeback in Afghanistan and they really did have something to do with International Terrorism but Bugger All is being done to stop them over running the country again and starting all over again with what they where removed for.

What the War of Terror has shown is that we have learned absolutely nothing from History if you start a war on 2 fronts you loose and this has happened every time that it has happened so what did our Politicians do they started a war on 2 fronts and just expected the enemy to lie down dead and not be a problem.

What we are currently facing in Iraq is exactly what the Germans faced in WW11 in most of occupied Europe and we consider these people as Freedom Fighters not the Terrorists that the Germans called them and treated them as such. We have made this mess for our selves and now we have to accept the incompetence of the Politicians who made it without the ability to fix the problems that they have created. So all that we can expect is an acceleration in Deployments and costs while over a protracted time we will eventually be worn down and have to run home to mommy with out tails between out legs and then the real damage will have been done as we will then be fair game to any fool who takes it into their head to pick a fight with us. They will win because we lack the fortitude or common sense to work out a workable plan and follow though to the bitter end.

It's called [b]Knee Jerk Politics[/b] and that is exactly what we get from the fools offered for election. They are more interested in what happens to their approval ratings today than the good of the country and while we have fools like this there is no hope of ever getting anything done in a manner that would lead to a satisfactory outcome.

About the only item of consequence is that all the returning service personal we as citizens of countries involved in the COW will be paying the Health Bills for these people who will eventually represent a large % of the community and at the same time be unable to work and contribute to their own care.

Is this the US or GWB's idea of a Medicare system?

Col

by oz_media

Tony, yo ureally have a complete mmisunderstanding pof socialism and how a socialist country compares to what you consider socialist medicine. It's like you deem having what MOST would consider to be imperative services as being equal to a Siberian prison camp.

I think you'd give Michael Moore a run for his money when it comes to exaggerating viewpoints.

It's like watching one of those US WWI propaganda films made in the 40's. How BIG RED EVIL RUSSIA was pushing the world toward socialism. "Watch out for that hammer and sickle!" Talk about paranoia and loss of reality.

by oz_media

We have all seen the film of the downtrodden and 'conveniently set aside' in America.

They live in dumpsters, with a second car, microwave, computer, cell phone and LCD TV.

At least that's what some will choose to believe if they refuse to acknowledge the 'conveniently set aside' are actually real people fighting to live in a nation of prosperity and good will to all men.

I have found that what is undesireable in the USA is 'conveniently ignored', out of fear of reality.

Well that reality is gonna hit hard soon. Once China is a super power and the US economy tanks even further (thanks Bush, good job ol chap).

There is a push for Canadians to invest in all teh repo'd US proerty. A guy in the office was reading from the paper about the hoards of homes available for next to nothing in Colorado. Everyone has overspent and isgoing broke as thier fortunes are not as stable as they predicted. Overspending on credit cards, mortgages and cars have forced many put many Colorado homes on the government repo market, or just people selling o settle debts. Wasn't that the state (or one of them) that backed the Republican administration the most? (wonder if Max is selling up to pay the bills)

There are no poor if you fail to accept it. There is no pointless war if you tell yourself it is right and just, there will be no recession if you pretend you have money.

Heads in the sand, just sticking thier heads in the sand.

by oz_media

Because teh US poverty level now (possibly wrongly) includes many people who really are NOT that poor, this doesn't mean all the actually poor peopleno longer exist.

The convenience of a stat like that is, just like those stupid learning curves your schools use, the AVERAGE income increases and thus for national stats it looks better.

If the number of POOR people was said to only earn AVG. $15K/yr, then why not raise the '[pverty level' so that those earning mroe and living more comfortably raise the avg.?

Include the lower middle class and now your poverty avg is more like $25K. Sure looks good on those, 'the US wants you' ads.

Once again, propaganda to pretend everything is okay. As Ameicans are bred to react negatively to fear, making everything APPEAR better than it is, keeps up morale, it's not very truthful though.

by oz_media

Tony, children in Ethiopia smile if the wake up in the morning. It all depends what your mind has been trained to accept as 'okay'.

Without such a good foot forward attitude, these people would perish.

After the London Blitz, do yuo think Brits were happy and feeling fortunate? No. They made the best of what they had. A bar of chocolate was a luxury, does thyat mean they were happy and shouldn't be told they can have support or help to live better lives?

What an oddly narrow minded view!

He's happy, who am I to tell hoim life offers more? He's happy having old shoes and wearing clothing from the dumpster, who am I to tell him he can have better or help him achieve more?

It goes against every moral grain of what makes an American. YOu tout about helpng the world, having riches and prosperity for all, how you all stand by one another and have become a free and prosperous country full of winners. All are welcome in America, land of the free, land of big cars, big stores, ten gallon hats and all that money!

ut when it comes to your elected government helping Americans see thier dreams, or even just eat a hot meal or get a broken leg fixed, you all whine and complain about YOUR money being stolen.

What hypocrites, if only you could see America the way the rest of the world does, it really is as funny as watching a 10 year old trip with a lie.

by oz_media

I 'hear' that Colorado is one of the worst places in America right now for forclosures and homes being taken over, or picked up/leined on on lieu of debts. Gotta love those title theory laws. They have been advertising hoards of Colorado homes to Canadians that are up for grabs cheap from the government as people can't pay mortgages, over spend on credit cards etc. Apparently Colorado is not looking so good these days.

Seems to be that the last time you guys had it this bad was in '89, but only on a per capita basis. With nearly a million homes up for forclosure last year, it sure doesn't look so prosperous down there.

If you move up here, you'll have to keep the Bush talk quiet, or else you'll never get ahead.

by faradhi

First, it only looks as Census Data. Census Data rarely included homeless and areas where they cannot get Census takers to go. So the poorest of the poor are left off. Also, the mid year census data is largely obtained from polling via mail and phone. Well the poorest of the poor do not have phone and are the least likely to reply via mail.

Further, the article and the Census Data fails to take in account how this was obtained. Was the car given to them? The microwave could have been purchased at a Goodwill for almost nothing. Etc.

The article uses the official US poverty levels. These levels are not adjusted for local economies. In Memphis $15,000 goes a heck of a lot further than in New York. So without a geographical breakdown of the data, it is really meaningless.

Finally, what this article fails to acknowledge is that these items could have been obtained prior to hitting poverty levels. The car for example could have been purchase before a major illness devastated the family's economic status.

The biggest problem with these studies is that they paint the entire country with a wide brush and fail to account for the many intricacies of the US economy.

So, while the study is first step. It is not really an accurate indicator until the data is first confirmed by other studies, second expanded to include geographic data, and finally data on how the items were obtained is included.

Of course, the heritage foundation will never put the resources into such a study since they have gotten what they wanted from the surface study.

Largely, I have not addressed these now because I wanted to see if I could get my hands on the data. This has proved more difficult than I would have hoped and I do not have the time go through the US Census office to obtain it.

by tonythetiger

[i]Because teh US poverty level now (possibly wrongly) includes many people who really are NOT that poor, this doesn't mean all the actually poor peopleno longer exist.[/i]

... that poor people don't exist. What I think the data is indicating is that the resources our government is applying aren't going entirely where they are supposed to go!

by tonythetiger

[i]It all depends what your mind has been trained to accept as 'okay'.[/i]

... everyone who doesn't have the level of resources you deem "appropriate" and who isn't begging for more has "had their mind trained"?

Is that what you want? You want them to beg? Does it give you a feeling of superiority? Or is it so you can steal resources from others to give to them and tell yourself that you "care"?

[i]YOu tout about helpng the world, having riches and prosperity for all[/i]

[b]You could not be more wrong![/b]

What I "tout" is the freedom to determine one's [b]own[/b] happiness and the freedom to pursue it.

by oz_media

Every system is corrupt, or not even so much corrupt but abused due to loopholes or failures to confirm claims.

I know the Canadian welfare system is grossly abused, but as they have not found a way to help those who really need help without cutting them off completely, it is something we grudgingly accept.

People screw the medical system too, car insurance, fire and theft insurance etc. Systems will be abused.

But i think that the only way to help those who genuinely need help is to accept that some will always ruin a good thing.

I don't think the welfare system is a bad concept, except it isn't enough to REALLY help people get going (barely covering basic rent and immediate needs).

It's those who abuse the system and waste resources that screw it up, sorta like how the US and China abuse Canada's resources. We need teh trade and you need the imported goods, but there will always be companies grabbing for more, abusing the ability to log or drill etc. But for what it's worth, ew all come out ahead, even if the trees are clearcut, the fish are over farmed etc.

Until we have measures to protect this abuse, perhaps never, it is in our best interest to stomache them...even though I get really burned over the abusive waste of our resources (NOTE: the Canadian government is as much to blame for allowing it as the US or China is for abusing it in these cases).

by oz_media

How you reached that conclusion is beyond me. If that's what I meant, that's what I would have said. Instead of reading it at face value, you simply dig for a hidden meaning, that isn't there unless you dream one up. It perhaps explains why you can't see what others do anyway.

As for touting your prosperity, I was inferring AMERICA as a while. America promotes itself glo bally as a land of freedom, happy lives, wealth and happiness. As if other countries don't find these same qualities themselves. I've seen the same opportunity in Canada and England too. Some people in Europe get disillusioned about the great wealth and happiness of America, and soon find out it's no different than at home, except everyone is bragging about it, and the politics are a joke. I know many who have moved there and left a year later saying it was not what it was chalked up to be. It's an illusion, and MANY think that illusion is unique and something to cherish that others don't get.

But it's not, America has it's uncared for poor, they have uncared for sick and if you cant earn the money to keep up, your screwed.

by cactus pete

It wasn't a dumb question. You're just evading an extreme question so you don't have to admit something. That's OK.

You don't want to have a real discussion about it, fine. Repeating your opinions is not a discussion.

by jdclyde

First, put limits on the assistance. If someone is able bodied, it is inexcusable for them to live, generation after generation, on one system or another.

Second, harsh penalties for abuse. If someone is going to be doing hard time AND the liquidation of all assets to repay the fraudulently made money, people would think twice. Make the price higher than most people are willing to pay.

Or we can continue to make excuses for people and keep our heads in the sand.

by tonythetiger

[i]The article uses the official US poverty levels. These levels are not adjusted for local economies. In Memphis $15,000 goes a heck of a lot further than in New York. So without a geographical breakdown of the data, it is really meaningless.

Finally, what this article fails to acknowledge is that these items could have been obtained prior to hitting poverty levels. The car for example could have been purchase before a major illness devastated the family's economic status.[/i]

And in largish metropolitan areas, one has less need of a car because of the availability of public transportation (in fact, I know several 'well off' people who don't own one).

Also, someone who has (a car, a 'paid for' home, a garden, etc.) doesn't need as much help as someone who doesn't; yet the system doesn't distinguish. They make their determinations solely on income and family size. They also barely pay lip service to the concept of someone at least trying to improve their circumstances. Someone who is trying should get a little more help than someone who has no interest.

The most maddening thing to me is that by not doing it as efficiently (for us!) as possible, the government is [b]wasting[/b] the resources. I almost literally feel like they're taking $100 out of my wallet, and flushing $75 of it down the toilet!

by tonythetiger

[i]Every system is corrupt, or not even so much corrupt but abused due to loopholes or failures to confirm claims.[/i]

Part is corruption on both sides (besides fraud, there ARE social workers who believe that by keeping these people down, they'll ensure the continued need for their jobs... similar in mindset to firefighters who commit arson.), but the majority, I think, is just gross mismanagement.

I think these systems would work better if controlled locally. Locally it is easier to determine how much, as well as what kind of help is needed. Locals are also more likely to know who is genuinely in need and who is just trying to milk the system.

The goal is to minimize waste, thereby minimizing the cost. Not only for entitlement programs, but the entire government itself.

by tonythetiger

[i]How you reached that conclusion is beyond me.[/i]

Conclusions end with periods. Questions end with question marks.

[i]America has it's uncared for poor, they have uncared for sick and if you cant earn the money to keep up, your screwed.[/i]

"Poor" is a relative term. If 51% of the people in this country had a million dollars and 49% had two million, over half the people in this country would be "poor".

And you're still clinging to the belief that everyone wants to be wealthy. They don't! I don't!! As Thoreau said: "That man is richest whose pleasures are cheapest."

I am happy to simply be good to the people I know, and take comfort in the knowledge that they're the same way toward me, and we WILL take care of each other without the use of force. That's the gist of the America I tout.

by faradhi

[i]And in largish metropolitan areas, one has less need of a car because of the availability of public transportation (in fact, I know several 'well off' people who don't own one).[/i]

How many of those people that live in large cities fall into the group with cars in the report? We don't know because the Heritage Foundation did not provide a geographical breakdown. That information is probably available from the census data.

[i]Also, someone who has (a car, a 'paid for' home, a garden, etc.) doesn't need as much help as someone who doesn't; yet the system doesn't distinguish. They make their determinations solely on income and family size. They also barely pay lip service to the concept of someone at least trying to improve their circumstances. Someone who is trying should get a little more help than someone who has no interest. [/i]

This has long been a problem with the system. There are actual penalties for doing better. This must be corrected for social services to be successful.

Most people look at the reports like the one from the Heritage Foundation and say, "Hey, look at this! We just need to eliminate Welfare." Where in fact, what needs to be done is an overhaul.

by cactus pete

I love the paradox of it all...

Trying to enforce your view upon everyone that no one should be able to enforce different views upon anyone.

A society, by its nature, demands that certain individual characteristics be given up. Certainly, what those are, and to what extent, are debatable.

To have a realistic debate, we must define what issue we're tackling, and saw back and forth about it until we find out where we agree, where we don't, and how big the chasm between is.

You feel that you don't like it, but you wouldn't impose your burden of $x onto society to save you - no matter what. I say that your life is worth something more than $x, in most cases, and I'd hate for anyone to die for that reason alone.

I don't have the time or inclination to take care of everyone to the extent I'd like to. Multiply that by a few hundred million people, and we need organizations to pick that up. Now then, I could send money to some place that purports to help solve these many plights, but how do I know which ones are honest? I suppose some governmental oversight is necessary, to make sure we are not being bilked...

Anyway, this is the direction I'm headed - I have to leave the office... perhaps more later.

by tonythetiger

[i]You feel that you don't like it, but you wouldn't impose your burden of $x onto society to save you - no matter what. I say that your life is worth something more than $x, in most cases, and I'd hate for anyone to die for that reason alone.[/i]

Ah, "in most cases"!

Please continue!

by oz_media

Okay, one issue is people claim to be 'unstable' or unableto function in a public or workplace setting. I know someone that did that over 20 years ago. Decades after a nervous breakdown, that person is still sitting on the couch collecting disability. Obviously this late in the game, the person is completely incapable of reentering teh workforce, or simply won't push himself to do it.

There are thousands who lose a job and due to a lack of skills, or appearance etc. are unable to findwork forLONG periods of time. Many are very capable of working, they simply choose to be seen as undesireable.

How do you determine the difference in a country where people's rights and discrimination is so easily thrown to the forefront? In order to stop those who do abuse teh system, we willinevitably stop those who DO need it and are just in collecting. These people will be discriminated against, though probably won't do anything about it. Those who are just screwing the system will be the ones to cry discrimination and start a very expensive fiasco that results in more of the same andno problem solved.

TO punishsomeone f a crime, you have to be pretty damn careful you have teh right person, with literally tens of thousands abusing the system, that would really open up a huge can of worms that nobody can sort out.

Your concept is a nice one, but not realistic in a democratic society.

Then there are those who really do need help, but they will get screwed and lose out again due to those who abuse the system.

by oz_media

Determining amounts to be paid at a provincial or even regional level would be impossible.

First off, who is a government employee to determine how much someone deserves? If that's teh case, the same abusers of the system will now devise new ways to get the ultimate payout from the system. Often those in real need will just wait and see what they are given and don't complain when it is not enough, those in need have the pride and are too embarrassed to beg formore. I find that those who abuse the system will milk it for whatever they can.

Also if it was a regional orprovincial issue, the annualpolitical battle of budgets would be insane. There would be union and government employee strikes so often that it would result in a worse system than now.

by oz_media

In your mind, riches are wealth and big homes cars etc. In reality, riches can be as simple as basic comforts to others.

What you deem as living happily and simply, to another 'poorer' person would be living in the lap of luxury.

When I talk of the poor, I mean those who BARELY cover rent, have little or NO food in teh fridge or cupboard, can't even afford a monthly bus pass etc.

Would you be "Happy" still if you didn't have much food, didn't have a cart or cable TV, no cell phone andno job?

No, you would feel quite poor wouldn't you?

You are considered rich and well off by many.

by delbertpgh

I think Faradhi may have been conflating Medicare with Social Security. It is amazingly efficient for distributing benefits, far more so than a 401k. That is, as far as administrative overhead goes. Since Social Security is not a pension system, but a pay-as-you-go insurance program, nothing you contribute accrues any interest.

by delbertpgh

Tony is so offended by the fact of taxation, he tries to dream up a social order that doesn't demand anybody pay for anything in the public realm. Except maybe for roads, sewers, cops, and soldiers. He probably carries his heart and soul in his wallet, interleaved among the larger bills.

Fortunately for Tony, there are enough folks who care about other people sufficiently to guarantee that the emergency rooms keep accepting anybody who shows up, including Tony, maybe some day. I think that this kind of social investment is necessary today, and is more important than the money I contribute to pay for it. I think it's even more important than Tony's money.

by tonythetiger

[i]Determining amounts to be paid at a provincial or even regional level would be impossible.[/i]

... First, money isn't the solution to every problem. If an alcoholic shows up saying he's cold, you wouldn't give him money to buy a coat ... he'd likely go to the nearest spirits store and buy more alcohol. No, you buy him a coat (yes, he could sell it and use the money to by alcohol ... so buy him a really ugly coat) and get him into a treatment program. If someone can't work because they are caring for a sick child, you get them someone to care for their child while they work (perhaps other needy people could be trained for this). Cash is very often misspent. Often times that misspending is what got them into the predicament they are in, so why compound the problem? Nutritious, storable food can be stockpiled, and can be picked up by or delivered to the hungry.

Oh, and failure to properly feed, clothe, and shelter your child should automatically be investigated as neglect. If the cause of this is found to be due to the parent's intentional misfeasance, then it is a crime and should be treated that way.

[i]First off, who is a government employee to determine how much someone deserves?[/i]

They are employed to do their job and do it correctly! If they can't or won't, keep firing them and hiring new ones until someone gets it right!

I think if they're going to be using public money, they damned well BETTER determine it, or they are not doing their [b]job![/b]

Likewise, the recipient of public funds should be made to show where every single penny is spent, and to prove it with receipts. If you cannot meet the obligation of supporting yourself and your family, you should be under the scrutiny of those who are paying your way.

Maybe this would be a place to use something like RealID.

[i]If that's teh case, the same abusers of the system will now devise new ways to get the ultimate payout from the system.[/i]

All the more reason to come up with ways to combat abuse and fraud. It's not terribly different from updating our anti-virus and applying security patches. It surely would be cheaper than simply allowing the abuse to continue.

[i]Often those in real need will just wait and see what they are given and don't complain when it is not enough, those in need have the pride and are too embarrassed to beg formore.[/i]

Sorry, It can't be helped. They'll have to swallow their pride and ask. We're not mind readers.

[i]I find that those who abuse the system will milk it for whatever they can.[/i]

Like JD said. If they're caught, penalize them heavily.

[i]Also if it was a regional orprovincial issue, the annualpolitical battle of budgets would be insane. There would be union and government employee strikes so often that it would result in a worse system than now.[/i]

I don't know of any other employer except the government that puts up with employees not doing their jobs. The system needs a major overhaul. The unions should be BANNED from the public sector. If a government employee doesn't like it, they are free to find another job. Why should they have any say over what WE (the people who are paying their salaries) want?

by tonythetiger

I take care of as needed. You don't even know me. I am not rich by most peoples standards (I'm probably in the upper half of the lowest third), and over half what I do make is to benefit those I care about (I can't take it with me, after all).

What offends me is that you think I should take care of the people YOU care about in addition to the ones I care about. It's easy to "care" when it's other people's money!

by oz_media

I agree complately and perhaps your understanding my view of MM is a bit off.

I don't think MM is an upstanding and righteous citizen just trying to bring the truth to people.

I think he's pretty clever when it comes to building his case, even with a predetermined conclusion. It doesn't mean he's right and doesn't mean he's showing an example of MOST or even a great deal of cases.

He focuses on what gets HIS point across, by not so much being a liar but on focusing on extremes.

The right is no different except...

Right now the 'right wing' is in control of America. They are representing the president (and vice versa)and they speak to the people about very serious political matters that change the course of America's future. Americans voted a party into office that they trusted with their best interests.

Michael Moore, is a left wing citizen, he doesn't represent the people or the country and is just another voice. He has not sworn an oath to the people of America and he hasn't been elected to run the country.

I can accept someone without REAL power (mainly just a bit of influence on those who follow the left anyway) who wants to have a go. I can't accept it from world leaders and an entire country being misinformed by elected officials.

Big difference, JD!

Other than that, you're right, they should all go have a time out and think about what they are doing and what their responsibilities are.

by oz_media

[i]If an alcoholic shows up saying he's cold, you wouldn't give him money to buy a coat ... he'd likely go to the nearest spirits store and buy more alcohol. No, you buy him a coat (yes, he could sell it and use the money to by alcohol ... so buy him a really ugly coat) and get him into a treatment program.[/i]

If someone appears to be a heavy drug user, alcoholic or mentally disabled, welfare pays rent directly to the landlord, gives them food vouchers (where they have to show ID to use them)and repay them if they need to buy a new coat, they offer them counseling. As for help though, some are clearly beyond any hope of recovery, in jail EVERY night for being passed out somewhere, absolutely lost! These people just get their drug money until they pass.

[i]Oh, and failure to properly feed, clothe, and shelter your child should automatically be investigated as neglect. If the cause of this is found to be due to the parent's intentional misfeasance, then it is a crime and should be treated that way.[/i]

It is, in Canada. They scoop up the kids and lock up the parents pretty damn quick these days.

"They are employed to do their job and do it correctly! If they can't or won't, keep firing them and hiring new ones until someone gets it right!"
Think..."insurance agent". Welfare workers are just there to collect a pittance paycheque, listen to everyone sing the blues and try to pull the wool over their eyes. They are there to STOP people collecting welfare but get tired of it pretty quick.

This is a crappy job, below teaching high school students, it's just like being an accountant or adjuster, what a drag!

[i]Likewise, the recipient of public funds should be made to show where every single penny is spent, and to prove it with receipts.[/i]

Most don't get enough to pay rent or buy food, it's not a matter of what it is spent on, it is who it is paid to. ANYONE can find a few food receipts by Safeway and many landlords (especially slumlords) will cur a receipt for a few bucks.

[i]All the more reason to come up with ways to combat abuse and fraud.[/i]

Once again, they do. They are constantly changing the system, adding new measures and trying new tactics. But there is a fine line gain between scrutiny and discrimination, and at a provincial or national level the constitution is always there for them to hang onto.

[i]
Like JD said. If they're caught, penalize them heavily.[/i] It is a federal offence punishable by very steep penalties and time. The issue is scrutiny without discrimination.

Your comments on a complete overhaul and removing government unions is very true though. They simply don't have a better answer, as you can see there is always another view and human rights and the constitution are right on the line here. Unfortunately until they can solve a problem this is the best we can do without causing more problems for those who really do need and deserve help.

You want an issue?

It is harder, takes longer and is under far more scrutiny to collect unemployment insurance.

You pay into it for years while you work, the company merges or shuts down and you are in need and very deserving while you get your feet on the ground again (within a reasonable time frame of course).

Most able bodied, driven and skilled workers will find new employment within weeks. The initial waiting period for insurance is 4 weeks. If you were paid to weeks vacation pay or severance etc. THAT two weeks is added to the wait time. (6 weeks now).

Once that initial 6 weeks is up, you get your first reports to hand in, then a week later you will get a cheque. Total time without a dime paid by your insurer, 7.5 - 8 weeks.

In that time, you will most likely have been hired again, and may have even see your first cheque if you get hired right away, if not they will come in together.

CATCH: IF you find work and even if you have not yet been paid, you must declare that work week on your first reports. The first $100.00 is okay but then they deduct the rest, so now you get nada after that initial wait because you are working, even if you don't get paid for two to three weeks.

This pathetic insurance company, Employment Insurance Canada, is harder than collecting welfare, and they take money from your every two weeks while YOU work.

Welfare? Try the EI #####uckers!

So you may say, have a nest egg and you're right. I worked for a record company in the 90's that started paying less and less, covering fewer expenses etc. as they slowly tanked. Everyone split, including myself when I went out to start my own, but not before suffering some big cash losses. Nobody had a nest egg left and some suffered quite a bit before they found a better job or got EI. Nice insurance company.

by cactus pete

"What offends me is that you think I should take care of the people YOU care about in addition to the ones I care about."

Can we agree that, in a given society, you can't please anyone all of the time?

by oz_media

Thanks Col, that was a great post. YOu did say, "...Talaban are now making a comeback in Afghanistan".

I can only assume you are simply being polite in that respect. IN fact you know very well that when this was first recognized (just days after the majority of troops were pulled from Agfhanistan), all we heard from Republicans was "BS".

Nobody was ready to accept the fact that the Taliban barely took more than a shaving nick from that "war". As soon as they had retreated to Kandahar, Americans figured it was a job well done and fled for Iraq.

In the meantime, AlQaeda and the Taliban (now very closely tied together) were back in Afghanistan, women were wearing bourqa's again or being spit on, they left the protection of women in schools and hospitals to the exact same local 'thugs' that they were there to remove in the first place.
the wells that were drilled were quickly destroyed and life in Afghanistan returned pretty much to where it was before coalition troops saved the world.

As this was being plastered all over world news, sans American news, people here were calling it crap. Since Canadian troops eventually took over the main campaign in Afghanistan, but with limited support and financial resources, fighting has remained and people are still being killed due to lack of support.

I wouldn't be surprised to find many Americans aren't even aware of what is going on there now, as it is no longer the forefront of the news.

Remember when GWB declared victory and sailed with his troops to continue a new world order? AT that same time, the Taliban had been noted as becoming stronger and larger than ever before, AlQaeda was in more than 60 countries (including America) and rebuilding quickly while the world was sidetracked to Iraq.

THAT'S what pisses me off the most I think, a cocky attitude that was simply flippant toward reality and focused on moving forward without looking back. Pure ignorance.

Oh well, we didn't expect them to get it right, we KNEW they were getting it wrong so all we can do is sit and watch the f*&k up until the changing of the guards.

Like I said, we all know it now, but you were just being polite. Yup, the Taliban are back, never left really.

by oz_media

First of all you are right, the press will sensationalize any story anywhere. I will not suggest any media is pure and clean or righteous.

BUT...in comparison to other world press. The BS flooding out from US sources is absolutely hideous! They ONLY show thier chosen point of view and nothing more. They will deliberately edit news footage and leave out what many others around the world leave in. TO A>B news between US, Canada and Englan, you will get two very similar stories from the UK and Canada, usually because cameras are allowed to run and air footage, but the US reports will only include snippets and omit anything that doesn't make the US look just great.

So yes, all news is SOMEWHAT biased, but what I see aired in the US is a complete farce and not even worthy of a cable bill.

by tonythetiger

[i]Can we agree that, in a given society, you can't please anyone all of the time?[/i]

Can we also agree that taking something that doesn't belong to you should be frowned upon?

by hal 9000

I personally find it abhorrent paying Politicians so why must I pay tax to pay these [b]Scum Sucking Low Life's?[/b]

Personally I would prefer every Tax $ that I pay to go to some form of Socialized Medicine where the Health Insurance Companies have no control over what is done and can not refuse to pay for pathology rather than have some Lowlife Politician take my hard earned money and Pi$$ it away like it was actually theirs.

Hell lets go further I don't support the war in Iraq so why the hell should my Tax $ support it?

I also don't like Police monitoring Speeds of Cars and Bikes as this isn't any form of Road Safety just an excuse to derive income so why should my Taxes be supporting this type of Police Activity I don't support it and don't expect to have money taken from me to support it so that the State can impose another Tax on me because they have a machine that says that I'm speeding that can not be cross examined in court.

Since when did a machine have more rights than a Human Being? It's wrong and not only has my Tax $ brought these silly things but they are also using my tax $ to persecute me to make me pay more money so that I can drive and then they try to deduct points off my drivers license and after I run up enough they will remove my drivers license so I can not drive anymore or contribute to their extra Taxes either.

Too bad for them that the last 3 that I took to court failed to meet the minimum standard required for evidence and the fact that one of the vehicles was a Technical Write Off 1 month prior to the last speeding ticket couldn't possibly be of any real evidence. I tried very hard not to allow the Police to Withdraw their evidence as I had proved that their so called Scientific Devices that couldn't be questioned for accuracy where wrong. But the magistrate who is also paid with my Tax $ is in on the conspiracy with the Police and Government and allowed the Police to withdraw their evidence so that no precedent could be set. The sooner that we can rid ourselves of these parasites who are only interested in stealing money off the unwary the better off we will all be so lets get rid of Politicians who steal my money, and all the services that they support so I can have more money in my hip pocket and chose who I want to support ME!

I don't work 100 hours per week to hand over a vast % of my income to some faceless bureaucrat because they think that they have a right to my money. Even better lets line everyone of those Blood Sucking Scum up against a wall and shoot the Shite out of them then proceed to do it all over again with any fool who wants to become a Politician or a Bureaucrat. And if some Ijiot thinks that they can come to the door and hand me a summons for not paying the tax that they think you should pay we should be able top shoot them dead on the spot and not have to worry about some Police Person coming out to investigate the loud noise. They have absolutely no right to set foot in my yard unless I ask them to come in and even then they shouldn't exist because I don't approve of paying them in the first place so I should be able to Cannonise them at every opportunity.

As I also own the Entire Military Fleet of equipment I should be able to use anything that I want to any time that I feel like it and should be able to prevent the spending of Billions of My $ on new equipment that I don't consider as necessary and I defiantly should be able to stop then buying the stuff that goes bang that they hang off these pieces of equipment. God I shouldn't even have to pay for the fuel that is used by these things unless I personally approve of that particular use in every case right?

All of these Bottom Sucking Scum are taking money out of my hip pocket and causing me to have less to eat or place on my table when I want to so to hell with them all they should all go immediately and we will all be much better off wont we?

Col

by brianmilke

In everything that I have seen Michael Moore produce or post on his website, I have yet to see anything untrue.

Even in this interview with CNN he was smart, lucid, and tactful in his replies. I fail to see the idiot here except in his accuser.

I am an unemployed college student, without health care, and I refuse to go on public aid, simply because of how a person is treated when they flash that health card.

Besides substandard treatement with the cheapest medicines, I have watched doctors treat animals with more respect than a public aid patient.

Country-wide free health care is not just a dream, it is necessary for this country to evolve into the leader it should be. The United States has been backwards in this issue for too long, instead of being the example it should be to the rest of the world.

The only thing stopping this country is the BILLIONS of dollars being spent on lobbying congress to not change it.

Consider what would happen if the doctors unions, pharmaceutical companies, and the legal system behind the current health care regime were all told that lobbying was illegal? That they could no longer take the patients money and use it to leverage the US Government to keep the current system in place? Universal Health care would become a reality very quickly.

So in my humble opinion, RIGHT ON Michael Moore. You keep making those movies, and I will keep watching them.

by cactus pete

I'm sure you can come up with a few reasons when it wouldn't be a bad thing to take from someone what isn't yours.

by dr. frumious bandersnatch

Ok, so, perhaps the ultimate insult: Who is Michael Moore and why should I care what he has to say? I checked out his website, looks like a whining bedwetter who never quite grew up and joined the real world. He will pass into obscurity soon enough with all others of his kind... What a waste of bandwidth...

This discussion is closed to new replies.