Question Locked

Motherboard manufacturer

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I was wondering if you guys could list some good manufacturers of motherboards. I'm just researching for when I upgrade my current motherboard.

13 replies

by oh smeg

Gigabyte, ASUS, ABit are the ones that I use with a preference for Gigabyte because they have a 3 year warranty.

Col

by midgetdoggy

weird that you say Abit because I bought an Abit mobo from the local electronic store and did a bit more research (I know I should've researched first) and the reviews on it were pretty bad. It's an Abit AN52V.

by oh smeg

The AN52V is a budget M'Board with a older Chip Set so you basically got what you paid for.

I don't buy a M'Board with On Board Graphics as this kills performance and I only use Intel Chip Set M'Boards which is useless for AMD Processors but as they work better and are more stable I only use Intel CPU's.

You asked for M'Board Makers not ideal M'Board models all of the major M'Board makers have Budget Lines and these are terrible from a performance point of view but reliable from a length of time that they work for.

So if you where to compare a ABit 520 Chip Set Board to a PC Chips 520 Chip Set M'Board you would find that the ABit one was brilliant and tended to remain working where as the PC Chips one fails on a more regular basis.

You have to look at what you are comparing a particular M'Board against so you can have a valid comparison. If you where to compare the AN52V ABit against the AN78GS the 52 is a very poor second compared to that but compare it to VA 10 and it's positively brilliant.

But if I was going to use a AMD CPU I would be insisting on a ATI Chip Set not a NVidia one. The CPU maker is the best qualified to produce compatible Chip Sets for their CPU's and this is why AMD have brought ATI to compete on a equal footing with Intel who may not make the best product but when you use a Intel CPU on a Intel Chip Set M'Board the all round package is just better than a AMD CPU on a VIA Chip Set as there are no compatibility problems.

You not only need to look at the Brand of the M'Board but the Chip Set and what it can do and then how it is integrated into the M'Board. You need to look at the entire package not just a Brand Name.

For instance I at one time bought a ASUS M'Board with a ASUS Video Card and the Chip Sets of the two units where not compatible. You had to use a different Brand/Chip Set Video Card to work with that M'Board. With Intel Chip Sets you just don't have these problems. Granted AMD has got better now with the purchase of ATI but they are still not in the same league as Intel yet.

Col

by .martin.

two i would really recommend is either Asus or Gigabyte.

by midgetdoggy

Do you guys have any suggestions to good manufacturers to hard drives and power supplies? Oh, and cooling devices too.

by oh smeg

They are rated to a constant use where as the No Name PS's are a peek value which they can not supply for any length of time.

I had one Antec PS blow during a thunder storm when a tree fell onto the Overhead Power Lines and brought the 33 KV Lines into contact with the mains. If it had of been a No Name PS the entire computer would have been destroyed in that case only the PS needed replacing well the Monitor, Printer and all the external connected devices but as they didn't get power from the PS they don't count.

For HDD's I like Seagate at the moment and with a 5 year Warranty they tend to be reasonable. Though Samsung now has a 5 Year Warranty here at least but they have yet to overly impress me though I will use these when there are no Seagate's available. Hitachi HDD's I wouldn't touch no matter how much you paid me to after all the problems with the Death Stars I could not trust them till they have had a great reputation for many years. That is yet to happen.

For Cooling depends on what you want Case Fans Zalman or Antec CPU Coolers I stick with the CPU Makers offering or go with Liquid Cooling. It just depends on what it is you want to do. But no matter how good something is supposed to be I never trust it anywhere enough to overclock. That is just begging for problems.

Col

by midgetdoggy

because I haven't researched Liquid Cooling enough and I don't wanna mess it up when I install it.

by midgetdoggy

I just didn't know if Abit was a bad company generally or just the board. It WAS on sale :P

by oh smeg

I stick with the Standard CPU Heat Sink/Fan unit as buying another one may not be necessary but if you buy CPU's on the Card then you can use a Bigger Heatsink one with at least 50% more surface area than the Standard one. The down side here is that being bigger they can tear off the M'Board and do damage if the case gets moved around. A Printed Circuit Board can only hold so much weight on it before it fails with a Heavy Heat Sink attempting to pull the M'Board apart. Even the newest Xeon Heat Sinks which are big do not mount on the M'Board they screw to the Case after the M'Board is mounted in the case to attempt to prevent this happening. Can be a trap if you have never assembled one of these M'Boards previously though. ;)

For Case Fans I like the Antec Ones as I have only ever had one stop working with a dry Bearing which just required a bit of oil to get working properly again. They don't seem to fail like the cheap No Name ones that are available and now days with the Case Fans Drawing their power from the M'Board if they where to fail and seize they could damage the M'Board. While they may be OK I don't take the risk as a Fan costs so little and replacing the M'Board is a nuisance and downright expensive compared to the cost of a decent fan to begin with.

If you are worried about noise you need to remove the cut out from the case and fit a Fan Guard that has round wire this decreases the noise from air flowing over and through the metal slits to such an extent that the fans become unnoticeable. Though you need to be very careful removing bits of case as any metal filings that are created need to be removed before you fit as M'Board. You should also remove the Power Supply to prevent it getting metal inside it and creating a short circuit. The better PS's will not have a pressed out fan guard they will have a Wire Fan Guard bolted to the outside of the PS.

I also try to have air being sucked in at the front of the case and being blown out the back as it's easier to filter the incoming air behind the Front Bezel of the case without detracting from the looks. I also try to have more fans sucking in air than blowing out so there is Positive Pressure inside the case and any openings blow some air out rather than suck it in though this is not always possible.

Zalman make a brilliant Fanless Case and PS which I have used in some very extreme places as it relies on the Case to disperse the heat and there is nothing being sucked into the case. Great for very dusty places but expensive and the cases are not the easiest to find as they are not carried by many Retail Outlets.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.