Discussion Locked

Need all opinions regarding IT Recruiter

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Over the past year of unemployment I have interviewed with IT recruiters who have no computer or technology experience; and these are the people making the choice for my chances at a position?
It has been frustrating for me, a certified and experienced technician, to have to submit to the judgment of these paper pushing Management B.A.'s

To that end, I am collecting stories from fellow unemployed or contracted IT workers like myself with horror stories about IT recruiters or recruiting. I hope to compile them into an article that might serve to shed some light on the topic and also help others vent their frustrations.

Please send stories to: mytechrant@yahoo.com
If I choose to use your story to compile into my article I will contact you via email.
ALL SUBMISSIONS REMAIN COMPLETELY ANONYMOUS

24 replies

by areets

An extremely hot subject! As having suffered from this, I decided to also use my IT experiences and skills to attempt to be active about it.
After extensive Internet research, I have concluded that it is dire straits within the IT and even more soin the ICT sector.

ICT KSE set is at a much lower level than we have realized in the EU and those that do not have a solid ICT KSE literacy level are the catalysts between the employers and those in search to practice better approaches. How many time the IT recruiter interviews potential candidates without knowing the requirements. Once the potential employer provides requirements, one is unsuitable. Was that so difficult to have achieved on first contact? The IT recruiter is looking to satisfy their clients, since they could lose out to the bigger sharks out there.

It is scary and only the EC can truly do something about this. A professional code of conduct between the sectors? recruiters and companies must be established. Some companies take advantage of the knowledge lack in recruiting agencies.

Feel free to contact me by e-mail if any precise questions you think I can answer.

TSP

by oldefar

Since the recruiters are searching for prospects that meet criteria based on key words and checked boxes, an approach may be to saturate your resume with these and then clarify during the technical and hiring interviews.

This approach works best if you focus your searches - apply only for jobs where your interest and experience are matches. Since the recruiters seem unable to filter candidates correctly, the job seeker has to take on the responsibility and turn the recruiters into pass throughs only.

by admin

I know this works in this area. It's usually a more than full time job to do a job search- especially right now. It's often a matter of deciding on where to focus your energy.

I have personally found it's often easier to change systems from within, and what it takes to get in is often not preaching reform in the hiring process. You have to just remember once inside to try and keep your commitment to create positive change. :)

by john_wills

I have often explained to employment agents what the job requirements mean, how one IT term relates to another, etc. Some of them are quite honest about their incomprehension of the requirements and grateful for enlightenment. Of course, the enlightenment I give them may be what gets another candidate the job, but at least I have made the world slightly better.

by road-dog

The Typical recruiter's modus operandi is as much a product of the hypercompertive and repressed market, particularly as relates to IT/Telecommunications.

One beef that I have with recruiters as of late is their suicidal protection of client information. Many times job postings do not even list a particular point of contact within their organization for the position. If you do track this person down and make contact, they often want to submit your resume to the client without you even knowing who the client is or answering any questions about the context of the position.

If I cannot get information about the position, I decline sending my resume. I understand that they are concerned about competing recruiters running you into the client for an extra couple of bucks/hour or having you approach them yourself, but this gets ridiculous at times.

I also become alarmed that if the recruiter seems to have NO specific information about the position, then quite possibly they don't even have a contact with the client and are hoping to poach a position posted by another recruiter. To provide a resume to these types is damaging, because a client will often drop a candidate submitted by multiple recruiters to prevent a conflict over the finders fee. To shotgun a resume blindly out in response to a Monster posting can really hurt your prospects, particularly when multiple similar postings hit the boards simultaneously from different recruiters.

by road-dog

The answer is to have a trusted relationship between an recruiter and a contractor. I used to have such a relationship with one who would sometimes ask me about additional services he could incorporate into his bid to the client. We were able to "fast track" some engagements this way. That is in the past though, another casualty of high turnover in the body shops.

This situation will probably not improve until the market does and recruiters stay in one place long enough to get good at what they do. Then Clients and Contractors will get improved services and the commissions will roll in.

by oldefar

I have seen situations where the recruiters work directly for the company they are recruiting for. A key advantage is that it creates a limited customer base and drives customer satisfaction (the hiring manager) to the top of their key metrics.

Smaller firms tend to rely on external recruiters, and at the same time are too small a percentage of the recruiter's customer base to get the individual attention. It all becomes a numbers game.

by turnerc

The best way to deal with recruiters is to build as good a relationship with them as you can. The most important aspect is to build you relationship with a RECRUITER and not focus on the Recruitment COMPANY. This way you can weedle out the bad recruiters, even within a single recruitment company. By doing this you also have a recruiter who instantly knows your skills set, and your likes/dislikes.
I have used this tactic before, following one recruiter from company to company. At one point she moved from IT Recruitment into low-level secretarial, but she could always find me the job/contract that I needed.
Having used recruitment agencys and recruiters a lot, I find that it is hard to find a good and knowledgeable recruiter.
Having built good rapport with my recruiters, I have also learned that many consultants/job seekers see the recruiters as a place to drop off a CV/Resume and do little else. I have also been informed that a good many recruitment candidates are more than willing to talk down and snipe at a recruiter who's knowledge is not up to speed. They tend to be more a 'jack of all trades', so knowledge gaps are pretty common, but with a good relationship, and rapport, this point soon becomes moot.
Overall, a good rapport can bring as many contracts your way as a more knowledgable recruiter. With a better rapport, you are also more likely to be told information about the employers, as the recruiter feels that they can tell you, and trust you.

by b.mt

Hi Bob,
Your reply hits a very valid point. I'm interested in getting more of your thoughts as a techie on this.
If you're availible to discuss, contact me at:
submit@bmthomas.com

by ghstinshll

Always ask ahead of time for a job description for the job they want to submit you for, or for the one that's coming up to decide if you want them to submit you first. That's a great way to stay on top of things too.

You should be able to feel it out which companies in your area the recruiter is hunting for, and with a little experience, you'll be able to tell who all their contracts are with.

by areets

Your comments, truly justifies this posting. When looked upon across Europe, if a professional code of conduct between the recruiters and companies do not exist then we cannot move forward in harmonized manor. I feel that professionals and politicians in these sectors must agree on a pragmatic approach to setting up a coherent communication exchange platform that eases on time wastes and offer better quality to this service sector. Companies could be obliged to offer a standard description thatis presented once there is an established contract between the job seeker and recruiter. I see no negative impacts to a three-party agreement. The hiring process can be much smoother and with regular reviews, quality of service is almost guaranteed.

TSP

by jmottl

I replied to your 'techrant' email and got an automated response. Please contact me at judy.mottl@techrepublic.com and provide information on who you're writing this article for and please identify yourself to our members as well.
Sincerely
Judy Mottl
Senior Career Editor, TechRepublic

by b.mt

My name is Brian Thomas, I am a Systems and Network consultant. I am not writing the article for anyone yet. I am first writing it because I feel this topic regarding the current hiring state, vis a vis IT recruiters, is an important one. I am sending a ping out to others in my profession, the idea being that we can pool our suggestions, share our complaints and maybe boost each other's chances when that interview arrives. If I cull enough information and responses, then I might look to post orpublish it somewhere to keep the discussions advancing.
I think it's important right now that we afford each other the lessons we've learned from our own mistakes or achievements.

by pattim

Hello, I just happen to be a recruiter for IT and others. As a recruiter my job function is reading resumes for skills and experience, and interviewing the candidates for a match with the companies. I may or may not know all the tech terms and meanings, but that does not disqualify me from placing qualified candidates into IT jobs. The role of the recruiter is for you the candidates, to have someone linked to the hiring manager. When you apply for jobs online, you are behind 1000's of other resumes sent to the same employer. The recruiter offers you the chance to be in front of the line. It does not matter how much Tech info the recruiter knows, it only matters that the recruiter knows what skill sets the client wants. Clients almost always do not want their info out. You would not believe some of the candidates ways to get jobs, at the same time intruding on the companies=no job for you and a fired recruiter for giving the info out. If a company has hired a recruiter to find candidates, the recruiter is the companies contact. Thank You, Patti

by ghstinshll

I have had quite a bit of experience with recruiters over the years, in passively looking for jobs and kicking it into high gear when my company closed in 2/2002.

The recruiters I kept in contact with for nearly 4 years (before I really needed them) worked very hard to help me find a job in tough times, regardless of their situations with lack of open jobs at the time, etc...

To comment on someone's earlier mention of relationships with your recruiters, it is VERY important to keep in contact with your recruiters and keep a semi-personal relationship with them. It keeps them loyal to you and helps them understand you better as a person and candidate. A really trustworthy recruiter will talk to you on a personal level and get a feel for you. Part of their job is to find the right personnel in an operational point of view, as well as technical. Managers worry just as much about finding a person who fits in the puzzle on all sides, including personal, professional, and ethical. Ifyou seem like you have a chip on your shoulder, a recruiter may submit you, but he may already have talked with the manager that they feel you might be a good fit technically but not ethically. You HAVE to be proactive, professional, and personal tomatch up well with a recruiter.

by ghstinshll

On another note, it's not their responsibility to judge you out and seek you for their commission. If you show no interest in them and think they're just going to miraculously find you your dream job and go send you off for an interview, think again! You need to be proactive in keeping in touch with them. If you're actively seeking a job, you should be looking for things yourself (FULL TIME) and keeping in contact and checking with them on them. You should be looking hard enough and being organized enough to be able to "feel out" if a job posting you see on the web is a match for the one they are submitting you for, or if it's with the same company. Sometimes you can bring one to them and have them get an extra lead in a company they already work with. Do this and they will love you, and it will get you more results. It's a process of being a professional counterpart in your job hunt rather than a "do it for you service"...

Also, as to the caliber of recruiter you use, you should be able to decipher whether they're truly on top of the game or not. You CAN use multiple recruiters; just make sure they don't submit you for the same job. (-:{ Use the lesser capable recruiters to extend your reach, but don't expect them to take you to lunch before an interview to get you prepared for the manager and scenario (I really miss u, Cary Jo). Use them to keep feelers out in the people they work with, but keep your focus on who is (typically) the largest recruiter with the best contracts in the best companies. Keep active with them to find you something.

by ghstinshll

Companies don't like their candidates to know who they are until they interview with them. This keeps the recruiting channels free by not having dirty hunters go around to the manager, in addition to the facts remaining the facts, which are the job.This safeguards many shady employers from having people disregard them, as well as keeps the larger companies free of biased job seekers as well. It's a win-win for all. Know the system and how to go through it best to get the proper results achieved.

Ok, I know I'm rambling, so please reply and I'll respond with more if necessary. To wrap it up, you (should be) are a highly-skilled professional in the IT arena, act like it, manage your job hunt like the last new switch upgrade project you had in your office... Keep close tabs on it, your status, your future, and what's in the pipe. Keep proactive, keep in touch, and keep professional, and recruiters are great tools to get into the right companies under the right conditions.

Remember, your own hunting SHOULD be leading the path. Here?s another tip? Keep a spreadsheet of each recruiter with company name, recruiter names, and jobs you?ve applied for and their status?. This will keep you much more organized. Also keep a doc with every company name and internal job posting site you find, as well as every job search engine and recruiting site you know of. Prioritize them in a search order for your daily searches, and keep on top of the postings daily. With this kind of a process, you?re doing as much as you can to find that job.

by ghstinshll

Here?s a list of the recruiters I?ve had the best relationships with over the years? I use them in the following order, though I?ve had great career ops with both of the first two. Technisource has been good in finding various positions, but never found me a perfect match. There are others, but these are the most-recognizable names, as well as the most trusted organizations I?ve used. Do what you will with them.

Robert Half Technology (rht.com)
Tek-Systems (teksystems.com)
Tecinisource (technisource.com)

J

by oz_media

Your statement says it all,
"a certified and experienced technician, to have to submit to the judgment of these paper pushing Management B.A.'s"

You are a Certified and experienced technician, they are just Paper pushing Management BA's.
FLIPWe are Certified Managers with a Bachelors Degree, he is just some keyboard clicking geek that wants big bucks.

I find that MOST guys that apply to me, are cetified, so what, and don't present ideas, solutions or a benefit for my hiring them. Just a list of "Look what I can do".

Nobody really cares if you went to school, earned a computer degree and simply sent them a list of qualifications, some people call these lists resumes, call the employer, state your case and what you WILL do for them to improve their business. If more techs took sales courses or learned how to present themselves and their skills, there would be a lot less discussions like this one. Yes, there are TONS of similar discussions about techs who are stunned and shunned by prospects.

by oz_media

Who relies on a recruiter or job posting to approach a company? The unemployed do.
1) What do you want to do
2) Where do you want to work
3) What will you do for the company (not what degrees you have, nobody really cares how long you went to school)
4) Who is in charge of the decisions.

Result, no recruiter, no job posting, no competition
Now learn how to sell yourself and your proposal to benefit the company. If you are unable to find a decent IT job, maybe you you should focus on why you went to school, to get a cert (irrelevant these days) or learn how to improve someones business.

by ghstinshll

You know, using a recruiter SHOULD be used as an additional method of searching for a job. Recruiters have called me over the years for positions I was under-qualified for, and didn't pursue... If it had been the right time, with the right job, I would have entertained the idea.

You do have a good point though. You don't NEED a recruiter to land a job with a good company. Many companies in Iowa's metro areas use recruiters to temp-to-hire, to find the best people while fishing for them rather than taking the initial costs and benefits on themselves, while paying less. It's a smart idea, though I hate it as an employee. It'd probably cost as much to have a dept in house do it too!

Regardless, GOOD cover letter and resume writing skills are rare, added with people's lack of resources (or lack of motivation and creativity) lead them to rely on recruiters to find them a job. At one time, I had great opportunities going with recruiters, then I found my dream job online myself and nailed it with good inter-personal skills and interviewing skills.

Recruiters are necessary, but not an end-all to jon hunting.

by zlitocook

Or recruiters over the years and do not respect any of them! They will tell the company that wants to hire you what they want to hear. And tell you about the job but not all you need to know. Like the job is 60 miles one way and they do not pay milage. Or that you have Unix experince but the company needs a guru to fix problems. The eight recruiters that I use most of the time are a hoot(joke). I have alot of good/bad stories. Like the free lunch and the last minute call at midnight.

by manmohan74

Hi,

I do understand the plight consultants have to go through.

But how to you expect one technical recruiter in any company/staffing firm to know all the technologies. technology is an ocean, if recruiter knows all that technology why will hebe doing recruting he would have gone into technical line.

Recruiter even if they dont know, they just like to understand the skills of the consultant from what he projects on his resume and what he/she speaks. this helps them to fill up the companys lengthy consultant/appliant additional information which is obviously dosent appear on resume.

needless to when i was a recruiter, i had to request consultants which software skills they have used or know, which doesnt appear on resume yet apply for a position.

If any company selects the consultant/ staffing firm/recruiter helps to trace a job it doesnt mean they are good agency/recruiter they have found you to be the best in the number of applications that have come.

If we go on like this, this would be a never ending debate, its upto the consultant/ recruiter to understand their limits/skills/job profile and decide :)

by rburke_36

Patti, as an IT/Instructional Development professional, my skill sets are very specific to a particular market (my Master's is in Instructional Technologies). My point is that I have many IT-related skills that can be applied to a wide range of employer requirements (e.g. if I can write C++ code, my aptitude for writing object oriented scripts is most likely very good). If a recruiter does not understand this, then there is a disconnect and the employer is missing the opportunity to interviewa very viable candidate. Often, a resume with very specific skill listings can fly over the head of the recruiter who does not understand the applicability to relevant technologies. I understand that the list of technologies is ever changing, but it would certainly help all involved if the recruiter understood the overlappings in technologies/skills by having an IT background.

This discussion is closed to new replies.