Discussion Locked

NO IT, world comes to a stop within a month

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The world needs to understand that if IT went on strike then everything would just stop, no email, no access, not anything.
Unionizing would be the best thing to happen to IT if we could get our own Union, the Govt isnt going to protect us, they are happy keeping us as wage slaves, with a Union it is in their best interests to protect their members.

23 replies

by forum surfer

Until the unions become power and money hungry like so many other unions. Then we're forced to pay exuberant dues or just not work. Next thing you know, some idiot is working a job you are more qualified for because his management doesn't want to pay the legal fees associated with firing a union member.

No thank you.

One more thing: Anyone can be replaced. Period. No one is that important at their job. People just think they are not replaceable right before they get replaced.

I hate unions. I've seen few occasions where they are beneficial to the work force. I have a friend who makes the same salary I do, which not to boast, but it isn't slave wages. What does he do? He puts tire labels on new tires. The guy is a friend, love him to death...but he doesn't deserve a salary like that for unskilled labor just because he got out of bed and came to work for the last 8 years.

I'm sorry, but you can keep your union. I'd prefer to work in a competitive environment like IT and continue educating myself so that I can ensure I make good money. I'd rather not pay some union schmoe for the right to work. I'd rather not lose a new job I'm applying for because someone else has more union seniority as opposed to qualifications for the job.

:)

by tony hopkinson

BOLLOCKS !

We have that many incompetents within IT, it would be probably be better if they did all go on strike. It would make my job easier anyway. A union would protect those incompetents, in fact a union's most strident and active members would be the incompetents. Well I don't need you, bog off and flip burgers or something, all you are doing now is reducing my earning potential and irritating me.

I did 19 years in union, you are talking out of your arse.

by delbertpgh

I've worked for employers who thought little of me, but I never encountered any agency with so little respect for me as a union. The employer treated me like a pawn who needed to be made useful; the union treated me like I would never be of use to anyone. The employer gave me orders about work; the union told me how little to work, and gave me orders about everything else that the employer thought was none of his business. Hell with that.

by locolobo

is they inevitably are taken over by power-crazy, self-serving politicians. In my limited experience with them anyway.

by tony hopkinson

if he got the union he wanted
across the globe,
suddenly,
before anybody noticed what was going on.

Reminds me of those silly films where a bunch of mad scientists took over the world to be thwarted by a vaguely sober Dean Martin.

So about a 100 minutes, and the last person on the closing credit, just after his white cat....

by santeewelding

The world coming to a stop -- his initial premise.

Mine wouldn't. He might be the first one I field dress and cook in my ongoing desire to eat.

by jaqui

would be to have a single, internationally recognized, certification board. It guarantees a certain level of skill, much as the apprenticeship programs for the trades do.

by jaqui

not a lowest common denominator worthless piece of paper.

literally, more along the lines of apprenticeship systems, with basic knowledge via schooling and supervised work experience using the knowledge to gain certification.

a set of "standards" for each level of certification that are accepted as required internationally. The standards would be based on the actual technology, such as tcp/ip rather than any os' implimentation of a technology. The "business schools" wouldn't even come close to being acceptable education for admittance to the program by their current level of education.

by dr dij

no bankers, world would stop in two weeks next time you got your check.

without electrical workers power plants would shut down and you'd be out of job same day.

without dr's world would end when you got acutely sick (ok about 6 months)

without supermarket owrkers world would end when your fridge got empty in a week.

and without water you'd dehydrate in a day.

without cops ravaging hordes would steal your stuff and kill you.

by tony hopkinson

that this CRUD app I'm working on is absolutely vital to humanity's continued existance.....

So did I.
A few people would have to make some adjustments, doesn't bother me either. My ambition was to be a landscape gardener anyway.

by charliespencer

No electricity, IT comes to a stop immediately.

No food, electrical workers come to a stop in a couple of weeks.

No water, farmers come to a stop in a couple of days.

Get over yourself; IT isn't the be-all and end-all you think it is. It's just one more piece of the puzzle.

by older mycroft

I witnessed it reach the point that actual friendships could be destroyed when it was discovered that the 2 'friends' were in different unions and felt it difficult to maintain their friendship.

The Print Unions, of which there are no less than [u]SIX[/u] of them, have a throttle-hold over the Printing industry to the point of having differently coloured lines painted on the shop floor. Depending on which Union Card you happen to carry, defines which coloured lines you are allowed to cross.

So, you end up with situations where an employee has to walk all the way round the edge of a factory shop floor the size of 2 or 3 football pitches, because he doesn't have union membership that let him simply walk across the shop floor.

The concept of trade unions can be taken too far. Woe betide if Unions ever got into IT.

by jkameleon

As for the rest of the IT... i guess this is what it would look like.

A while ago, I pulled off to get gas on this gas station (and no, it's not me on the picture, just some drunk driver). Nothing worked, and there was a queue of customers inside the shop. I went inside, to see what's going on. Inside, there were two wide eyed attendants, totally lost. One was under the table, yanking the cables and pushing Reset button, and the other was explaining to the customers that their server went down, and that they are totally lost without it. And then, one of the customers (not me) said: "Say, dude, why don't you just use pencil and paper? You could sell the gasoline at least to those of us with cash on us until you fix the server." Problem solved.

by tony hopkinson

It has possibilities, but 'IT' is huge, can get very cross disciplinary, and historically however laudable the intentions of the people who set such bodies up initialy they've always ended up being very conservative and concentrated more of preserving the literal interpretation of the rules instead if the spirit. The commercial pressure to introduce lowest common denominator validation would be intense.

If you wanted to even start making a real success of it in terms of power within it, you'd have to really balance off those who set themselves as masters, which all too often was a position gained from longevity and political ambition.

Apprenticeships as in combining academia and practice, well the adavantages are obvious, unfortunately all most businesses see is the initial short term cost.

And of course it makes people way more expensive, than some poor gowk straight out of academia with their new shiny vendor cert.

by delbertpgh

The idea that all people who are creative or otherwise necessary to society could prove their vital role by unifying and going on strike is a loopy fantasy. It's just a narcissistic exercise in power, which would never work.

IT workers are about as essential as cops, coal miners, and doctors. All of those professions have gone on strike from time to time, but civilization failed to stop.

I have foggy memories of a distant time when there were only a few dozen computers in the world. I was a little boy in short pants, living in the most prosperous country in the world, and we were all having a pretty good time. A few nerds were out there doing their computational thing, in white lab coats no less, and their productivity was measurable in reams of paper with numbers printed on them. It had marginal impact on the rest of us.

by the scummy one

in the past few years I have seen a stupid f**king retarded thread started like this. You dumba$$, unionizing would make things worse, not better. Why not go through the TR search (if it works) and look up responses to all of those other pathetic POS threads.
what a waste of space -- want a union, go work in construction.

by charliespencer

This is the first time I've seen it combined with the "IT is indispensable" line of hooey as justification. Both notions are being greeted this time as they are usually treated around here: with total contempt.

by jaqui

and yup, I have noticed that.
The chaos we have now doesn't do anything for I.T. at all.

Something is needed to fix the problems, but a union isn't it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.