Question Locked

non booting toshiba p15-s470 laptop, inconsistent symptoms

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was hoping that someone might have encountered a similar problem to the one I'm having with my laptop & might have some advice.

PC Notes:
PC is running XP sp2, BIOS is already flashed to most recent version (2.0), not getting any POST beeps,

I have a 3 year old toshiba p15-s470 that is 2 months out of warranty. The problem started when the PC froze & I had to do a hard power down on it instead of shutting down. After the shut down it wouldn't boot back up. When trying to power it on it does one of several things:

1. power light comes on, but pc immediately shuts back off.
2. splash screen comes up, but locks up there
3. partially boots into windows & locks up during startup.
4. Boots all the way into my desktop & immediately locks up.
5. Power light comes on, nothing else happens, screen remains dark.

I know this is nonsensical, however it seems that the longer I leave the laptop unplugged with the battery out the further it boots, which would make me think it is overheating, however I cleaned the heatsinks last week & the fans spin up when I power on. When leaving the power & battery out of the PC & turning it back on as part of the PC's diagnostics check I get a CMOS checksum error as the battery has completely discharged, however I can clear this by entering BIOS setup & exiting BIOS while saving changes.

Here are the troubleshooting steps I've taken to try to resolve/isolate the problem.

1. switched out RAM chips for older, known working chips. Also tried booting with only 1 chip in each slot. No change.
2. removed CD/DVD drive & booting. No change.
3. removed HD & tried booting. No Change, didn't get as far as saying HD not found.
4. Used HD in enclosure in another PC & was able to run chkdsk & virus scan. No problems, no virus. While in other PC I can access all files on HD.
5. Removed Wireless NIC & booted. No Change.
6. Booted with no battery, only AC. No Change.
7. Tried booting into windows recovery console to perform fixmbr & fixboot, however pc locks up before I can get that far.

My thought is that its got a bad mobo, which wouldn't be worth fixing in a 3 year old PC. I wanted to try changing the battery on the mobo, but I'm not sure if it integrated or not.

4 replies

by kds1398

I was just able to boot into a windows install & select the repair option. After windows deleted what looked like 100 or so files it went to copy new ones & locked up.

by acaleb

How did you change the HDD?
Looks like it is a bad mobo
I have a same issue here
Appreciate fi you can send me the instructions for changing HDD
Regards
Caleb

by smartacew0lf

This resolution has come as quite the surprise to me in at least 3 different laptops of varied manufacturers. All of the 3 I speak of had similar symptoms. As a last ditch effort with each, I decided to try a known working Optical Drive replacement. This remedied the problem in all 3. What this has resulted in with my troubleshooting is that I will try that before giving up (after I have exhausted all of my other bag of tricks). I have observed one other factor they all had in common. All had Toshiba Optical Drives. Just a thought. Oh and I might add that the last 2 of which I speak were especially troublesome because I had assumed that the drive in one was good and it was initially my first choice for the "known working FRU". At this stage of the game I couldn't venture what else to do. Seems you have covered all the bases. If this doesn't work, scrap it?

This discussion is closed to new replies.