Novell Linux and future of Netware
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by facciamerde
by oz_media
It is time for a reailty check though. You mentioned that "Companies that had netware 3.1 have switched to Windows 2000, rather than upgrade to netware 5 or 6, because it is more user friendly." I have upgraded two Netware 3.1 networks to 5.1 and 6.5 another from 4.11 to Novell Linux with XD@ desktops.
I would say that this itself renders your statement untrue as it is generalized and not specific to a couple of instances YOU'VE seen.
In no way was MS easier or more user friendly in these incidents, in fact the learning curve for MS was greater than the NW upgrades in these cases. Then again, users weren't Windoze junkies that love Webshots and Incredimail but actual savvy users who understand the advantages and don't have a learning curve to conquer.
by oz_media
"Netware is going the way of Banyon Vines."
Can you show me some market stats or any report that shows NW growth is down over last year, the year before etc.?
They have shown positive growth year after year and have exceeded thier market predictions many times over the last three years. They are one of the ONLY software companies outside MS that has shown a surplus cqsh flow in the millions last quarter.
Is your statement just an unqualified assumption or is this due to something you've seen or heard ?
by oz_media
I found an older text on Voice and Data Networking that I used in school, it shows comparissons between the older NT server and Netware 5 (both of which have improved over time)
But lets look at the underlying fact behind these NOS's and see just who is the pioneer and leader of Network operating Systems.
Netware 5 introduced the use of pure IP, in the sense that it doesn't require IPX or NetBIOS encapsulation.
Netware in 1998 had over 80 million users worldwide.
This brought the market share for Netware users (at that time) to 38% which was more then DOUBLE that of the Windows NT server market which was only 16 percent.
Netware was optimized to run for small companies up to a large enterprises with global networking needs. Windows NT on the other hand was a desktop OS that was stretched into an applicatio server. Windows NT, like Unix or Linux is an excellent application server and works well in THAT network space. However NT was NOT developed to do networking, therefore it didn't deliver on global and centralized management nor on reliable, scalabe or high-performance Web, file, print and securityservices that is needed today.
Now these figures and statements are a few years old now, but given the fact that BOTH of these providers have improved, who can possibly say that Novell and Netware are no longer the best solution for global networking, security and performance?
Did MS actually surpass NW's technology, not even close. Has MS had even a tiny bit of the success security wise as Novell, not even close.
Will MSs ever knock NW off the market shelf, not even close.
Novell was the leader, is the leader and will be the leader bottom line.
by itctonguy
by oz_media
We've had the NOS comparisson discussions so many times here it isn't funny. As I commented to another poster looking for answers, you will get very personal and heated answers here, welcome to TR.
you said yourself, the future can't be predicted. It is therefore impossible to offer a futuristic perspective that neither Novell, Linux or MS can predict.
I am actually sitting in the most boring seminar right now while some guy prattles on about the new MS CRM offering, that barely offers the features inherent in GroupWise collaboration for the last three years. This will be MS's NeW and Improved (and first real) CRM solution, slated for release sround August. Thank god for wireless hotspots, Keys are clicking all over the boardroom as everyone is bored with the whole 'been done before' concept.
If this is an example of MS improved products, they have some serious catching up to do.
I just had lunch with the editor who wrote Linux for Dummies and she is writing a report on the seminar. All her interviews have been "I can't believe I wasted a day here to see old technology finally deployed vy MS" and this is coming from MS
certified engineers working for the government here.
I got to helijet here so it was fun on a sunny day, but this sucks.
I hve tested and worked on much of the enw MS software as a friend is a MS engineer and he runs a mixed MS/Novell linux shop. MS can't handle the simultaneous logins, suthentications that the Novell servers do and he has demoted his MS servers to Application servers and SPAM servers as his users have too many issues with th MS servers.
What you seem to be overlooking is that with no predictive numbers available, the best you will get is mixed and contradictory answers from those that use the systems and what thier experiences are, that's all you can expect.
I'm sorry for not replying to your discussion but it's getting old, just like the Win2K vs XP debate.
if it bothers you, you are under no obligation to read on, or explore a discussion that you don't feel ansers the posters question.
I did notice that you didn't offer any solid answers for him either though, in fact you didn't even address anything to do with it, including just personal opinion or experience.
MARKET SHARE AND POSITION
If we are talking NOS market share, MS is not looking so good now. Russian businesses refuse to deal with MS because they don't want to support a US company. Two major Russian cities have recently depoyed Linux and Netware Linux for Desktops to avoid US spending, being open source, various government applications are being offered for free to other Linux shops in Russia. Germany is right behind as is Spain.
I BC, I see an sverage of 6 NW or Linux servers to every 1 or 2 MS servers people can't stand MS here.
So while the market and future of the US based company looks strong in the US, they are suffering elsewhere. Russia turned down MS after thier quote was lowered by tens of thousands to match the Linux offering, not only did they not get the deal, the city has launched a class action suit for price gouging.
Good in the states, not so welcome elsewhere.
by xanderx
The discussions are all good and well but I think most of us are forgetting the important part. We all have undertrained users who have to use and access the services we provide them with. I have had a few fall-outs with MS staff over support related issues but I have to admit that trying to train an end user with limited knowledge in "any" form of other operating system is as close to futile as it gets. If you take this into account that leaves the workstation portion in MS. However it has been my experience at my site that the following works the best :
Novell for logins, mail, storage and LDAP from the tree.
Unix based systems for DHCP, DNS, Mail Gateways and FTP
MS Server for all the products that cannot run on other OS's. It is however not advisable to mix Novell clients with Microsoft Clients.
This is my take on the issue from an objective point of view. I will stick to this because it works for me and my priorities are not necesarily to make my life easier but provide the best possible service for my end user as they are the people who matter no matter how infuriating they are sometimes.
by md.harrison
THE DIRECTORY - designed from the ground up with no Domain constraints. LDAP used with quality LDAP authentcation e.g. iChain. DirXML (identity Manager) pulls together identity management and single sign on capabilties. Moving down the open source route will probably provide APPLICATIONS. It'll take a few months (9-18 months) but in my view Novell will gain new clients and be taken extremely seriously, quite right too. The only real issue has been applications. There are issues with the Netware OS regarding 64 bit support (Doesn't exist) and clustering/load balancing more than 8 processors but this will be rectified on the Linux platform. Novell Cluster Services is ARGUABLY the BEST as it stands.
Mark MCNE
by driv101
none of it is afordable
why not just get the stuff we have up and going and
not worrie about new,
by therrington
I'm a "novice admin (as was so disparagingly referred to) who has learned NOvell from scratch ON MY OWN from the docs. Am I comfortable? No, but I can mostly do what I need to do. I am still impressed by the security that says if I don't allow it, you don't get it.
I recently began using M$ 2k server. From what I can see, it is no easier and perhaps somewhat more difficult to learn for a newbie. They redid things just to make sure you are forced to learn the M$ way, like it or not.
Me, I'm moving my stuff to Linux. It will be a challenge. But to me, it's worth it to be free of the M$ monopoply.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending