Discussion Locked

Obama and the Democrats in Congress CAN NOT . . . . .

0 helpful
188 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

188 replies

by ansugisalas

to every question it seems, especially your own :p

Non-Voluntariness, then, is your problem with government?

Your model doesn't account for ar$e-wholes. I like there to be ar$e-whole control, so that I don't have to get my hands all bloody every time someone feels like being one. Government can't be voluntary, because co-existence also, is not.
Once co-existence becomes optional, there's only a short step to ethnic or religious cleansing.
And I don't want to go there.

Non-voluntary government accounts for accomodating incompatibles into the same frames.

edited for censor mk3; it accounts for intentional misspellings too, now. And missplaced hyphens!

by ansugisalas

I'll try with pre
[pre]arsehole[/pre]arsehole
[pre]ars-hole[/pre]ars-hole
[pre]asswhole[/pre]asswhole
[pre]ars-e-hole[/pre]ars-e-hole

Ok, now I'm confused... wait! Someone is messing with the code as we speak!!! All of those failed me in one edit or other, pretty sure of it. Maybe more. But pre doesn't work sadly.

by ansugisalas

Get a room! :p

And Maxwell... are you going to get your knickers in a twist every time he does that? It should be apparent that it's a documented feature... it's the price you pay to have someone to talk to that answers, and without payment.

by dr dij

I hate them both.

You failed to pigeonhole me.
I'm probably more libertarian than you are,
what with wanting more govt liquidity
"because your friend couldn't get a biz loan" suddenly when his credit limit was reduced for his biz.

If he was a real capitalist he would have saved money (capital) he could have used to finance his biz.

Instead apparently he was sucking up on the cheap credit fake money spewed out by the fed, and you felt sorry for him not because it was right but because you were a friend.

A biz model dependent on cheap money is the trap distortion that this fed reserve printing press money thing screws into the economy. Then if they try to tighten people whine and cry-baby.

Same thing happened in the 70's and Paul Volcker tightened up. But we've been spend spend spend since then including sellouts like ben bernanke, who now loves the idea of inflating the money supply.
(see lukus post for example about 70's)
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/06/07/think_again_ronald_reagan

The teat of govt is always bad if we let someone else suck the taxpayers dry but OK if you get the benefit?

I was just trying to balance out your blasting of the dems. Who from recent klan Byrd poop dont' have an angelic history.

To me both parties seem pretty much the same.

Tea party is great in principle except it's being promoted by scatter brained dinks like pit-bull mom from alaska. She's about as smart as one.

by tonythetiger

The "meee" generation has graduated from the desire to merely acquire things, to the mindset that any perceived inconvenience or hardship (even those they create themselves) should be foisted onto "someone else".

by maxwell edison

What in the heck are you going on about?

You put something in quotes that I neither said nor eluded to.

What's that all about?

by maxwell edison

I erased or edited no post deleting anything even close to what you claim. I'd have no reason to. Moreover, I have no friend who's even applied for a business loan, much less been turned down. (At least none that I'm aware of.)

I think - I know - you're confusing me with someone else.

Or

People do it all the time. Dangle a lie and debate the lie.

P.S. Why the personal attack? [i]Getting senile, max[/i]?

You can't debate the message, so you attack the messenger?

Is it really that hard for you to admit that you were mistaken?

by maxwell edison

I highly doubt that. Heck, I've been called an anarchist (incorrectly, I might add) because of my less government stances.

However, if you want to compare some core values that will define how libertarian you and I may or may not be, it might be interesting to discuss - without preconceived notions, without pigeonholing either, etc.

Make up a list of 10, or so, things that might put us either in or out of the libertarian camp. And make it a nice mix of both social and fiscal issues. I'll answer. It might be fun.

By the way, did you vote for Obama? And did you (do you) support the recently passed health care legislation?

by dr dij

Max was replying to me.

No, I didn't vote for Obama.
The whole political process is an obamination [sic].
It is like voting on who will be the guy to whip you when chained to the oars of a roman galley.

I've mentioned endless practical suggestions in other posts to fix the problems.

And except for your denial of responsibility for your actions or industry's responsibility for actions when polluting, I think you'd agree with me on most of them.

by ansugisalas

And I didn't call you out on that either.

But your whole argument is so steeped in your own opinion, that it defeats itself.

Your A hasn't got anything to do with your B, except in your own mind.

contra principia negantem non est disputandum
- therefore I cannot converse with you, nor you with me.

by john.a.wills

We have them in California and, alas, legislators are NOT "more willing to reach across the aisle based on principle instead of their own personal gain". Actually, personal gain isn't the problem, it's the so-called principles of their ideological groups.

by maxwell edison

A straw women was not used 100 percent of the time, but rather 66 percent of the time - two out of three. The thug was a he. The global warming alarmist and gun control advocate were shes.

Unfortunately, the English language has no such gender neutral pronoun, so a writer is forced to choose one over the other, or constantly use something like, he/she, he and/or she, and so on, which just seems too [i]politically correct[/i] for me. (Although I have resorted to that from time to time.)

I have to wonder, if a woman writer uses she instead of he in such cases, would you consider her a misogynist as well. And if a woman writer used he more than she used she, would you consider her a misandrist? It could also be claimed, I suppose, that if a male writer never uses she in such cases, then he, too, is a misogynist for discriminating against any female representation at all.

Ho hum, what's a person to do?

Perhaps I should have incorporated a fourth straw person example - using another he; then I could have given precise 50-50 equal opportunity to the straw people. Straw people, after all, deserve equal representation as well.

All that said, I assume that you surely can't be serious. But I enjoyed humoring you nonetheless.

by Member 25348569

In governement, according to the views of some.

And Jerusalem.

And London.

Guantanamo Bay would be so easy to legitimise - well, give it SOME legitimacy - if you could convict one or two of the detainees in open court of something that we could all understand.

At the moment, it's just an Al Qaeda recruiting poster.

Obama is trying to close Gitmo but doesn't want to send any Yemeni detainees back because they'll just rejoin Al Qaeda yet no-one can prove that the detainees ARE sympathisers of Al Qaeda. Well, since you've had them banged up for the past half dozen years, I'll lay good odds that, if they weren't, they are now.

So, you can't send them back now. Maybe you should have been a little more selective in who you put there in the first place.

by delbertpgh

Here's what happens if we sink into a depression. Unemployment stays between 12 and 25 per cent for a decade or more; the whole country turns into Cleveland, except for Cleveland, which is worse. Kids don't go to college because they can't pay and have to work. The general wage level is pressed downward. The next generation tumbles out of school (high school for most, college for the lucky,) and earns less money not only for the depressed period, but for the rest of their lives. Government tax revenues fall, because as jobs and wages drop, you can't collect as much. More and more homes go into default, prolonging the lack of confidence that prevails in the banks and in the wealthy, that keeps them from lending money for new business or business expansion or modernization. Kitchen table fascists like Beck, Hannity, and Palin show their true colors and call for strongman leadership, reciting their litany of false diagnoses and dishonest remedies that have bewitched so many of the uninformed so far. All this happened in the 1930s in this country. It was only massive federal deficit spending on a ten-million-man make-work program (World War 2) that cured it.

When the next generation gets out of school to find no jobs, and scratches for a living for a decade, and instead of 3% or 4% economic growth America has 0.5%, will they thank us for holding down the deficit and freeing them of the burden of paying it back, as opposed to living amidst growth and prosperity, as Americans are accustomed to?

People don't know about the Great Depression and how it differed from the recessions we've experienced. They probably don't know that the Dow Jones Industrial Index dropped 90% between 1929 and 1933. (It made a snappy recovery in '33, tho... gained 50%! To only 15% of its peak, I must add; didn't exceed that peak for 30 years.) Republicans forget that influential parts of the populace were calling for fascism or socialism, or that in 1932 Democrat and socialist parties gained 101 house seats and 14 more in 1934, or that by 1936, Republicans were reduced to 17 seats in the Senate.

The economy is showing signs of falling into depression and deflation, largely because banks won't let anybody invest (and this after the Fed gave the banks $1 trillion in liquidity), and because state and local governments are cutting jobs so that they won't go into deficit. We are at a crisis, and we need to fix this, or your kids won't prosper and your 401k will shrink to peanuts, and all kinds of other crap besides.

Tax, borrow, and spend. It's the right thing to do, this time.

by jdclyde

but that isn't what has been going on, is it, nor will it start. Just targeted payouts to pay back people that got politicians in office and keep them there.

by delbertpgh

I'd like to see money spent on education and infrastructure. However, it doesn't look like anybody could agree to spend it that well, between interest groups, demagoguery, and political mutual backscratching. Some was spent well; most, not. (Hey, a big slice of the stimulus was dedicated to stimulating tax cuts. Remember? Disappeared without effect, apparently.) A lot of the bullsh*t and half measures were dedicated to mollifying Republicans, you may recall. Or may choose not to.

Do nothing and we start our way circling down the toilet, next generation and all. That's Option A. Do the best our system allows to keep people productive and avert the slide downward, that's Option B.

by puppybreath

by taxing the 50% of Americans that don't pay any income taxes. Talk about an untapped source of revenue for the Government!

by jamesrl

By the same standard, its only 30% of Canadians in the same position.

I've always been in favour of 1) a minimum percentage so that everyone contributes - say 5%, and 2) fewer deductions/credits and 3) a flatter tax curve. This would lessen the amazing amount of effort that goes into tax avoidance, and is a long ways closer to tax fairness.

James
James

by delbertpgh

Everybody ought to carry a share of the burden. Everybody should pay some kind of tax.

The rich is where the money still is, though.

by jdclyde

if the people didn't start with a purely political solution in the first place.

A good idea is a good idea, but if you don't believe it is a good idea, how do you "compromise"?

I am not hearing good solutions from either of the major political parties, and haven't for a long time. For MOST thinks, the country would be better off if they did NOTHING and just stayed in gridlock and let us live our lives.

by jdclyde

you forget, Obama got elected because people were NOT thinking about anything he said, they were just basking in the warm fuzzies. There was no analysis of "really? how will/can you do that?"

Now it is all back peddling and excuses.

by jdclyde

Democrats have never held their own to the same standard, why would they start now?

It is all about circle the wagons.

Do Republicans do otherwise? No, but intellectually dishonest people will use that for a justification of current bad behavior by pointing at past bad behavior.

by jdclyde

as the workers file charges that working around all the oil gave them unfounded/unproven medical conditions.

by Member 25348569

He just shot his mouth off without having the SLIGHTEST idea what to do himself. Then he was closely followed by a whole series of like-mouthed ignoramuses.

As to whether BP know what they are doing... Who else is there? BP have a number of wholly appropriate techniques for cleaning up oil spills that can't be applied because the US has a whole set of petty regulations that prevent them being used. If your President and your regulatory "experts" were to step out of the way and let the REAL experts do what is RIGHT, the effects of the spill would be considerably mitigated.

Anyway, whatever happened to "innocent until proven"? BP have been tried and punished because they are deemed foreign despite the fact that everything that was done was done by US contractors under US regulatory oversight. Yet they did, to use an Americanism, step up to the plate and commit to cleaning your ocean and shoreline up.

Check out the Ixtoc I spill for some intersting data. That put as much oil into the Gulf as Deepwater Horizon and the company that drilled THAT well was able to get out of paying much at all despite a huge quantity of oil coming ashore in Texas.

The weaseling out of taking responsibility is not my point but the fact that 3 million barrels of were spilled from Ixtoc I and yet the beach environment was back close to a pre-spill state within three years and, ten years on, you would be hard pressed to find evidence of the spill.

Neil :)

by delbertpgh

A large part of the reason nobody got so worked up about the gigantic Ixtoc spill in 1979 is that is was a Mexican oil company destroying the lives of Mexicans. Not our problem, really. We're actually pretty okay with putting down Mexicans, anyway. Some of the oil got up to the southern Texas beaches, but it seems not to have been a major issue. Besides, it happened in Texas, where people just think weird, anyway. Thirty years ago nobody thought about beach vacations in Brownsville, and the residents figured that oil smelled like progress, which they were for.

A big difference between Ixtoc and Deepwater is the business that is affected. There are huge fishing and tourist industries, which are based in a rich and expensive country; in Ixtoc, it was village fishing communities in a depressed portion of a cheap, developing economy. Deepwater draws in the U.S. government; Ixtoc had the Mexican government versus Pemex. One raises a stink and one doesn't.

Innocent until proven guilty? Well, who was the prime contractor on that platform? Who came up with the plans to drill under a mile of water? BP. Who was lackadaisical in their workplace oversight, audit, and practices? Everyone out there, but BP, certainly. I'd love to get the government's teeth into Halliburton, Anadarko, and the rest of the bad actors, but BP is culpable. There's just no question about it. Why BP didn't recognize that it had real money as a downside risk, I don't know. It speaks to a disfunctionality in the management of the company.

Incidentally, the only thing "British" is BP is in the name. Excuse me, in what used to be its name. Like Exxon, it is a huge multinational enterprise, with properties and managers from every country where oil is found, and stockholders any place there is money to invest. There's apparently an unwise sentimentality among British investors to plunk their money down in disproportionate measure in this firm, I guess due to patriotic inclinations. Maybe BP and the British people will both be benefited by the experience, in the sense they will become more appropriately cautious.

I don't think BP will be destroyed by this misadventure. It will have its earnings pretty well ruined for a year or two, but it is a giant among world enterprises and it controls a wealth of expertise and rights. It's appropriate that any agency that causes this much ruin should pay, simply so they know not to take risks that nobody can afford.

by jamesrl

Canada, in the early 90s faced a similar challenge. The country's deficit had been growing for decades (even under the conservatives). Taxes had also incrementally gone up. We had government owned airlines and oil producers/retaillers.

But I think everyone realized we couldn't continue on in that direction and there was a great will among the people to change.

A Liberal government slashed spending, reduced the size of the civil service, sold off assets like the airline and oil producers, and balanced the budget, and kept it balanced, where its been since then up until the most recent recession budgets. Once the feds had done that, the provinces were under great political pressure to do the same.

Now some of the reductions were made by downloading services and their costs to the provinces, and the provinces did the same thing with some of their services, downloading to municipalities (which are not allowed long term debt).

Taxes were reduced but only after spending was under control, which is the way it should be (I'm not a fan of Laffer).

But the feds lead the way, and it encouraged the rest to do the same.

What companies has Obama nationalized?

James

by jamesrl

For a country to truly nationalize a company, the government has to buy it outright. That is what nationalize means to the rest of the world. With no intention of ever making it public. Canada did that with an oil company (did sell it eventually, at a decent profit). A bailout is not a nationalization, even if there are conditions attached to a bailout by the government.

The government did not nationalize GM either, if you accept at face value that the government's intent was only to hold it until GM could buy back its shares. But of course Fox wouldn't see it that way.

I used to occasionally watch the first few minutes of O'Reilly for a laugh, but can't watch it anymore. And yes its carried in Canuckistan. And when it wasn't certain way back when that Fox News would get a license to broadcast in Canada, Fox claimed that Al Jeezera was going to be carried in Canada before Fox. Surprise, we just got Al Jeezera in Canada, but we have had Fox News for many years.

Al Jeezera's English edition at some point. is run by a Canadian,Tony Burman, a non Muslim. There are even people who are Jewish on staff. Unlike Fox News, it will cover Canada from a bureau in Canada.

James

by john.a.wills

The only references I can find for this number are to gun and ammunition size, which can hardly substitute for trials.

by jamesrl

Problem is he doesn't possess a magic wand to determine whether someone is a terrorist or not. I agree thats what courts are for.

James

by ansugisalas

Shoot them with a 5.56...
If they die, too bad.
If they live, re-apply as necessary.

But, I think that's about the dumbest idea since waterboarding, and training Osama to fight the soviets in afghanistan. It's the hydra, you see.
Except, if you take out an innocent head, the reaction is tenfold the normal.

by ansugisalas

If society is already screwed.

Who can pay more; ten million cash register ladies/gentlemen, or Donald Trump?

The poor is where the money's at, which is why the rich always love poll taxes, it's just the easiest way to strip the poor, while losing next to nothing themselves.

by puppybreath

When the Bush "tax cuts for the rich" expire in January and most working families find that their taxes have gone up.

Seems that "the rich" to many liberals is "anyone who makes more than me".

by delbertpgh

When the Bush tax cuts expire, will they actually affect $50k-75k working families?

As far as I can tell, the primary impact of the Bush tax cuts on the working class was to leave everybody's grandchildren with the bill for the bankers' wild decade.

I kept looking for the Bush bonus in my paycheck, from 2001 through 2005, and mysteriously it never seemed to manifest itself. I may have gotten a break of about $8 per week. Maybe not. All I can tell for certain is, my family's overall tax burden went up.

by nicknielsen

are the various Fox stations around the country. Some of them even have liberals on the staff! :p

I often get the impression that the Fox News editorial policy is to ignore those parts of the world that aren't part of the US.

by jdclyde

you must have missed I said politicians, rather than point fingers at one flavor of politician.

I would throw all the bums out.

by delbertpgh

I voted for the guy, having my doubts about Hope and Change, but none the less figuring he was more to be trusted than a guy so desperate he'd pick Sarah to be next in line behind his 72-year-old ass. H&C could have used more experience, because the aspirational president has not been able to get much accomplished, except to feed straight lines to an opposition dedicated to nothing more than his downfall. Hillary would have been a more effective boss. May still be. I'd like to see her lined up on election day, the most detested man-eater feminist nightmare the looney right ever could imagine, versus the lunatic mama grizzly sex symbol on four-inch heels.

by jdclyde

Still think Obama can be trusted?

McCain would have been JUST AS BAD, which is why I didn't vote for either. He was the single worst candidate, which is why the media via their coverage PUT HIM THERE.

Hillary, while an unlikable beotch, would have been better than either of them.

I disagree on putting Palin there on the same basis of Obama as NEITHER know what they are doing. I do like that she doesn't follow party line lock-step, because it is party politics that has been ruining the country.

I noticed you didn't explain what problem you have with the tea party? you do know at the local protests it is people both liberal and conservative, black and white, not just white conservatives. I am sure you can find a nutcase person who has stood up, but the ideas in general are what we need.

by delbertpgh

I frankly think that running a government in the red, handing out endless streams of goodies to keep voters happy (as Greece has done), is bad government. Taxing people up to their ears is bad government. Letting broad classes of people get away with paying no income tax is bad government. Making lots of rules is bad government. Running up huge debt is bad government.

Except...

When you have the greatest financial crisis of the last 70 years, one that would dive the country into a depression, a lot of sensible guidelines cease to apply. In a genuine depression, economics goes into reverse. Prices and wages fall, making old loans more expensive (in relative terms) to pay back. Worthy people with worthy businesses come open to risk. Banks are afraid to lend, and do no more than buy government bonds. People are afraid to invest, worrying that their invested dollar will be worth less in the future. Everybody gets very careful, cutting budgets, and firing people. Each round of firings leads to more insecurity about borrowing, and down it all goes further. Rational economic man starts behaving like a scared bunny.

In this environment, the only actor that can keep its head above water and act rationally is government. There is plenty of money out there, available for taxing or borrowing; hungry as the country is for employment, investment, and trade, nobody wants to let go of cash. Government has to. There's nobody else.

GWB, I think, greeted the sharp recession that followed 9/11 as an excuse to put his Grover Norquist dogma into law, as The Great Patriotic Tax Cut. It was really a huge gift to the investing classes, who were already doing very well, who had already captured a steadily increasing share of the country's wealth. I have no problem with rich people being rich or getting richer; but I did notice that between 1975 and 1995, the rest of the country didn't see its boat rise with the same tide that lifted the top 1% so buoyantly. Ain't there something wrong with that? After all, the rich aren't rich because they can dig ditches better than the poor; they just get to capture the income stream. Progress, to be true to its name, ought to be a system of mutual rewards, don't you think?

GWB gave back a trillion dollars, and to draw the teeth of his critics, he allowed more and more of the lowest-paid to elude taxation. (What the hell, they weren't paying that much in taxes anyway.) That stinks. I remember in 1970 filling out income tax on my minimum-wage year of work, and at the bottom of the page, adding another 10% to pay for the Vietnam war. Can't say I enjoyed it, but having a broad base of taxpayers is good for the republic, just as it is to have a broad base of voters.

by keighlar

does need reform, but NOT the complete socialistic overhaul that has been forced down our throats. (Yes... I mean FORCED.) I am one of those unfortunate people without coverage. My employer offers it, but at such a high rate, that I cannot afford it AND continue to sustain my two children. My children are covered through their father, but I am not. I do have several medical conditions that need to be monitored and treated, but since entering the field of telephony four and half years ago, they have not been. It's a hard story of reality. I'm gambling on the fact that paying outright for any immediate needs will cost me less in the long run than carrying a known monthly cost that would devastate my budget.

And despite this, I've already decided that I will not under any circumstances adopt Obama-care personally. I will pay the penalty fee for refusing to go along with their forced care before I will take the government plan. It's a matter of principal for me - if i do not agree with it, I will not sign into it. It is MY OWN personal responsibility to take care of myself. I take that seriously.

If we allow the government to coddle us and take care of us in these ways then we are in effect saying that we ARE NOT CAPABLE. Life is not always easy. It should not be made up of hand-outs. If we allow the government this amount of power in our lives, then the trade off is allowing it into ALL pieces of our lives. Personal freedom goes down the toilet because we gave it away in trade.

by maxwell edison

..... that [i]"..... leaving everybody's grandchildren with the bill ....."[/i] may or may not be a bad thing, depending on who it is doing the leaving, Bush or Obama, and for what purpose.

I see.

By the way, what do you think about the fact that the House is not even considering passing a budget resolution this fiscal year?

by delbertpgh

Borrowing a ton of money is a good thing if it keeps you from slipping over the edge of the abyss, right? If in 1930 the federal government could have responded to the world financial crisis by borrowing billions and spending it so as to avert a decade of poverty and 20% unemployment, would that have been a good idea? If in 2010, loading down your heirs with government debt saves them the opportunity to make a good living and pay it back, as opposed to 15 years of blight, would you so decide on their behalf? You should, I say, because that's the choice we face now.

As for your question about the current budget resolution, I haven't heard of it, and therefore have no opinion. If it's some deal about calling for a balanced budget or a drastically reduced deficit, I would be against it, because at this time the private sector is dysfunctional as an economic performer.

by puppybreath

There's already too many people who have kids and abuse them, so findng someone with kids who supports burdening them with unbelievable debt doesn't seem like much of a challenge.

by delbertpgh

A third grandkid coming, in a week or two. Am nearly sixty years old. Wife is a history professor. Last child is the only boy, senior in high school this year. Two dogs. Work in stock portfolio management for a giant bank.

In case the question is coming, no, I don't think it is wrong in this instance to rescue the economy and my kids' chances to prosper in it through unprecedented levels of deficit spending. Balanced budget religion, in this instance, is the economic equivalent of the Christian Scientist's treatment for anemia. For the government to take such a big hand in the economy is wrong when there is a private hand to take its place, but when the private hand is paralyzed by fear, government must yank us free of the danger. These is an exceptional time.

by maxwell edison

I can't imagine anyone who would willingly and knowingly burden their kids with insurmountable personal debt just so they, themselves, could enjoy a better lifestyle today - or even continue to live.

And if a person wouldn't do it to his own kids on a personal level, why on earth would he do it on a collective and national level?

My parent's generation has been dubbed [i]The Greatest Generation[/i] because of the hardships they endured and sacrifices they made, both in fighting the War and enduring through the Great Depression.

I'm actually ashamed of my generation - the ME ME ME generation. We're leaving a legacy of more debt, higher taxation, and less individual freedom and liberty than any generation in the history of the United States. I wonder what we'll be called in thirty or forty years. [i]The Sell-Out Generation[/i], I suspect.

Half of me actually believes Delbert is kidding or being sarcastic. Being absurd to illustrate the absurd. At least I hope he is. If he's not, I just don't know how to respond to his last few messages.

by maxwell edison

[i]"These is an exceptional time"[/i], as justification for more debt, more spending, more government control, and less liberty.

I prefer this:

[i]"These are the times that try men's souls."[/i]
-Thomas Paine (Common Sense)

I'll sell neither my soul nor my kid's future for selfish and self-centered reasons. Unfortunately, others would - and are.

[i]"The real man smiles in trouble, gathers strength from distress, and grows brave by reflection."[/i]

by mr_m_sween

Question: What steps would you take if you wanted to completely destroy a free nation from within?

Answer: Nothing, it destroys itself without intervention.

To solve any of the problems you described is going to require three things that washington is incapable of.
1. Choosing an ultimate goal.
2. Creating a plan to achieve said goal.
3. Stick with the plan until completion.

They love step 1, and they may even make a half ass attempt at step 2, but they are incapable of making it to step 3. Their egos simply dont allow it. Imagine the following situation.

Obama speaks to a brilliant economist who proposes a plan to fix the economy in 20 years. At which point all debt is eliminated and we are beyond self sufficient. He double checks with every economist he knows and they all agree, the plan is perfect. He puts the plan into congress and puts what personal stock he has behind the plan.

Now this plan, to reach completion, needs to survive 10 congressional elections and 5 presidential elections. Each time the opposing party takes over they want to scrub all the success of the previous parties decisions, not because the plans are flawed, but because they dont want their opponents names associated with its success.

The problem as I see it is not which party is in office, but rather that there are parties at all. A representatives position is a simple one, to represent the best interests of the constituents. Not business, not political parties, not private investors. Constituents. Big gov, small gov, blue gov, red gov, green eggs and ham gov, none of these matter as long as the politicians ignore their basic job as representatives....to represent.

by billmlod

Boy, did you ever say all the right things here. If we could get enough people with those thoughts in the house & senate the government could turn around. I don't vote party lines for those reasons, if the person will represent the people they get my vote, but most just promise that & then get in and its goodbye people.
Next November don't just vote the other party, actually look at the people running & vote for the best person for the job!

by ansugisalas

It is decidedly so.
Sounds like you need a president emeritus... one who isn't up for election anymore, who can veto the crap out of shortsighted nonsense.

Or... just keep the old prezzies in a presidental caucus, a bit like the supreme court, where they can keep them young whippersnappers in order.

It would at least introduce an element of stability into the system.

You should also consider scrapping most of directly elected officials... you don't want politicians deciding on whether to raise charges or not, or whether to hang someone or not... those decisions are too important to leave vulnerable to populism.

by delbertpgh

You said: "I'll sell neither my soul nor my kid's future for selfish and self-centered reasons," and, "I can't imagine anyone who would willingly and knowingly burden their kids with insurmountable personal debt just so they, themselves, could enjoy a better lifestyle today," and, "... Delbert is kidding or being sarcastic... if he's not, I just don't know how to respond to his last few messages."

Well, I ain't suggesting that I borrow money on my kids' account so I can buy Remy Martin today and leave nothing behind. I suggest spending money so that we avoid a depression that will stifle national growth and my kids' earning potential. Imagine an economy that grows at 3% per year, and one at 0.5%, for 15 years. One economy will grow by 56% and the other by 8%, a $17 trn economy versus a $12 trn one. Which will be more pleasant for a young person to mature in, start a family, and allow him to develop his full potential? Which will be more capable of paying back a trillion dollar debt? The trillion would just not be so insurmountable.

Our "greatest generation" was certainly great. Enduring the great depression called for substantial sacrifice. I can imagine them clenching their teeth through a decade of coitus interruptus, avoiding babies they couldn't afford, in addition to all the other things they would forgo. (I, personally, was not as great, by that particular measure, but I gave America a big bunch of new taxpayers.) Kind of a tragedy that the depression was an avoidable act; I doubt many of those people would opt for greatness instead of prosperity, had they known the choice. Fighting the war was great. Financing the war was great, too; it was the greatest expenditure of borrowed money in the country's history. Guess what happened when we came out of that war, staggering under an apparently insurmountable national debt? The 50s, and the 60s, times through which we grew technologically and economically as never before, and defended the western world and modernity, including two substantial wars.

As I said before, World War II was a vast government jobs program, and it left no assets behind. Ten million men were paid to march in circles for four years (punctuated by episodes of terrifying opportunities to be great,) while millions of other Americans built and worked in factories to create war materiel, all designed to be blown up, crashed, burnt, or sunk. And all on borrowed money. Suppose we put a tenth of that effort into public works, infrastructure maintenance and education? Quite a legacy.

The American way of getting out of financial trouble is to grow. I propose we don't stop growing. It's that simple.

by maxwell edison

"..... leave everybody's grandchildren with the bill ....."

Like this will?

"Tax, borrow, and spend. It's the right thing to do, this time."

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=332860&messageID=3319023&tag=content;leftCol

You are seemingly against it (passing huge debt onto future generations) when Bush was doing it, but you're in favor when Obama is doing MORE of it. And please spare me the platitudes about spending for job creation and so on. For the most part - including the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan - Obama is doing the same things Bush did - except MORE of it.

Look back at my past messages, and you'll see that I was lambasting Bush for his expansion of social programs, increasing social spending, not getting spending deficits under control, adding to the debt, etc.

But not you. When Bush does it, it's bad. When Obama does it, it's good. You have no credibility when taking such a hypocritical stance.

By the way, which one of the founders do you think would approve of the government we have today in regards to its building massive debt that's being passed onto future generations, its control over individual lives, and its infringement on individual liberties. And do you think they would be ridiculed today like you ridicule those in the current Tea Party movement?

by delbertpgh

I deplored Bush, from one end to the other. I hated his inarticulate image, because I hate politicians who base their appeal on seeming dumb. I hated his tax cuts. I hated his spending. I hated his dumb prosecution of the dubious wars he lied to get us into. But, when the financial crisis came, he and Henry Paulson recognized what needed doing, and they injected $700 billion straight into the banks, and for that we can be eternally grateful. We could have had a depression start right then and there, but George and Hank saved us. They were the men on the spot who made a very difficult and politically unpopular decision, and did what was necessary. Bush was probably the most inept and destructive president this republic has ever lived through, except for his last 12 months, when he (like Franklin Roosevelt) took steps that may have saved capitalism. So, thank you, George, from Delbert, who really means it.

Obama is a disappointment, because he is weak and ineffective. That's about all I can say about him. He's got a lot of sweet ideas, but we'll never see them. He waters the drink every time a Republican senator lifts an eyebrow at him.

Existence-threatening wars and existence-threatening financial crises call for leaders to break rules to save the republic. Most of what's going on I would not tolerate (yeah, like I could stop it) in ordinary times, or even moderately difficult times. However, enough of our politicians can smell the threat underlying this recession, and vote for the extraordinary amounts of money fighting it demands.

And, honestly, how much reason do you need to sneer at the tea party crazies, whose brain trust is Glenn Beck? If you look back at politicians from revolutionary days for comparisons, they generally knew how to talk, reason from evidence, present coherent argument, and abjure falsehood; all qualities generally lacking in their present-day imitators.

by maxwell edison

You STILL have not reconciled your hypocrisy of slamming Bush for debt but praising Obama for even more debt.

Keep trying, however. It's humorous.

by Member 25348569

Bush wasted the boom years. If you - and we! - had run balanced budgets during the boom years, the deficit would be manageable now.

Some, a very few, got it right. Canada don't seem to be having any problems over your side of the Pond and the only issue facing Germany, over here, is how to prop up Spain, Portugal, Italy, Ireland and Greece.

:)

You can't blame Obama for everything. You had two terms of GWB and your economy is buggered and you're occupying two foreign countries. Not a bad effort!

by maxwell edison

Delbert is not consistent, and is actually being hypocritical.

Whether or not the debt accumulated under Bush's watch was avoidable is not the question. (It was avoidable, by the way, with massive spending reductions on social programs.)

Delbert plainly criticized Bush for passing on debt to future generations - something with which I fully agree - not for how or why it was accumulated.

He then claims, however, that Obama's passing on debt to future generations is actually good - something with which I disagree.

I maintain that passing on such insurmountable debt to future generations - rapidly approaching 65-70 percent of our GDP - is bad. It's bad, bad, bad, bad, bad. And I don't care who's doing it. I also acknowledge that it's been accumulating for decades.

I might add this. Acknowledging that the president has a lot of influence on spending, our U.S. House of Representatives actually control the purse strings. They're more at fault than anyone else.

Nonetheless, Delbert has failed to reconcile his inconsistency. You've also failed to reconcile his inconsistency. Try again.

by Member 25348569

was that Bush, in doing nothing to reduce deficit in the "good" years, was passing debt onto future generations that didn't need to be.

Whereas Obama, in borrowing to spend to keep the country from sinking into a deep depression, is carrying out an action that is going to cause less immediate pain overall and possibly less pain for the future.

The problem is that we'll never really know if Obama is right but we do know that Bush was wrong.

by delbertpgh

This shouldn't be difficult to understand:

I don't believe debt is a good thing. I believe it should be avoided. However, if the choice is passing on a huge debt to the next generation, or passing on an economic depression, then debt is better. And, that is in fact the choice.

George Bush spent an enormous amount of borrowed money trying to secure the banking system against collapse and avert a global financial catastrophe. That was a good thing, for reasons explained above. Obama continued to pump money into the banks, and also into an economic stimulus, trying to shake the nation out of financial paralysis that could precipitate a depression. For the same reason, this is also a good thing.

When GWB decided he would offer a trillion dollar tax cut whose benefits fell mainly to the rich, and that he would finance this by borrowing money, that was bad. He chose to invade Iraq at the same time, also running the war on credit and not paying it from current tax revenue; this was bad, too. (In fairness to GWB, he may have actually believed Donald Rumsfeld that the war would "only" cost $100bn, and that the occupation of Iraq would be easy and self-financing. He'd be a fool to have believed Rummy's stories, but gosh, I guess he did. So, he was.)

Anyway, I don't believe in government spending, unless it's to address something that the private sector can't handle. And right now, the private sector is too afraid of every shadow to keep itself out of big, big trouble.

by jackofalltech

My parents came from Germany and Hungary. My father was drafted in WW2 by the Nazis and, since he disagreed with what they represented, allowed himself to be captured by the French. Then, before France was taken, he was transferred to a US facility. After the war, my mother joined him and they came to America. My mothers family in Hungary was very rich but they lost everything and also came here.

I don't understand how people can not see what's happening. What happened to the proud, independent citizens who would rather starve than go on govt assistance? What happened to taking responsibility for your actions? What happened to working hard to provide for your family?

Our founding fathers, if they were there, must be spinning in their graves to see what this Great Experiment has come to.

by maxwell edison

We are indeed speeding towards the very things we've historically opposed. And when liberty in the United States falls, where will the freedom-loving people flee, and/or who will come to our defense?

by redwine007

After 8 years of unpaid tax breaks for the rich and eight plus years of war the Republicans are posed to once again drive us deeper into the ditch. I feel deeply sorry for Mr. Edison because he has short term memory loss. Obama had debt and war and a ruined economy when he took office, The Debt we have taken on by Obama was needed to stabilize this country. It took a long time to for the republicans and democrats to make bad decisions in congress to get us to this point and sadly it is going to take time to get us back on the road. The something for nothing crowd aka the tea party need only look in the mirror, will they send their own children out to the fields to pick the food we eat? Will they stop shopping at made in china Wal-Mart? Will they give up their 10mpg suv for a more fuel efficient car?
Mr. Edison wants to bring this discussion down to talking points written by the lonesome rodes of the world aka Glenn beck and Rush. No one in the government is going to take your guns or step on your freedoms, well perhaps you should read the patriot act and see how your freedoms have been stepped on. I could go on and on about the other side but both sides are corrupt inept and scared to do anything for right of every person in this country instead they cow to the likes of Mr. Edison.
I am not angry at Mr.Edison only saddened that he is using this site to pushing his thoughts of the world on all of us.

by momtojustin

Hi, I am with you. I am a mean-spirited, racist, evil redneck because I believe in the same thing. It is very difficult for a red-stater to live in a long, caring tolerant blue state.

by slayer_

Far as I can tell, any required services are government run. Everything else is free.
MB has public auto insurance as well. I rather like it overall.

by charliespencer

the previous Republican administration showed no signs of doing any better. This was the first administation / Congress in history to try fighting a war AND cutting taxes. If the Dems are trying to lose weight while eating junk, the Reps were trying to run a marathon while eating bread and water.

by jaxent

Please, this is a site about solutions not for propaganda. I would think that people here would be more analytical and not just repeat what the parties are pumping out. Neither party is willing to confront the hard issues. So they frame the argument as us against them. Both parties support corporations over people! Both parties waste huge amounts of money! Members of both parties receive benefits on the backend by wasting money!

But there are many government services that are hugely beneficial to us all. Without US government spending, you would not be reading this! The US government funded the first computers. The US government funded the creation of the Internet. The US government funded the intercontinental railway and the US highway systems, the biggest boons to business ever. Other governments have done the same, Tim Berners-Lee was being paid by the governments of Europe at CERN when he developed http.

Don't buy the Tea Party bit either, it is not a revolution, it is counter revolutionary if anything. It is just cover to get those who don't think things through to work on behalf of their corporate overloads. The hard right or hard left does not have the answers.

The middle needs to stop the madness. The basic questions are: What services do we want government to provide? How much does that cost? Is it worth the cost? How do we generate the funds to pay for it? Just like we should do in our jobs every day. Not who's idea was that, they're stupid, I say no, like a lot of us really do in our jobs.

The US was not found by Conservatives or Liberals (although if you start a revolution, that may qualify you as a liberal in itself), religious zealots or humanists, lawyers, industrialists or farmers. It was founded by them all, men (unfortunately at the time only men) who were willing to sit down and discuss their differences and compromise. Now compromise is sold to us a weakness. It is not! It is the ultimate strength. It is sharing. It is why our first name is United.

E Pluribus Unum!!!!

by jaxent

Small business can't afford Representatives. On average each Representative has 700k constitutes. When the constitution written they had 30k. The population of a small city or large town. So we should have a larger government (government being the persons in constitutional offices not government employees).

There is no way that 435 people can know enough to run a country the size of the US. That is why the executive has so much power now. The executive has all the employees and can delegate, congress does have that ability, so they get their work done by & for lobbyists. "I have to write bills for 6 different committees. You know banking, you work for Citi, could you give be a rough draft. Yum this steak is delicious."

If we had 10,000 Representatives we could go back to a part time congress. And elect people with real jobs, committee members could be experts in the field they run. And Small Businesses would have access to their Reps or could the owners could run for the office.

This discussion is closed to new replies.