Discussion Locked

Obama proposes world welfare program at US tax payers expense

0 helpful
259 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

259 replies

by jamesrl

What relationship is there between a hand up and corporate welfare. NONE. Either can exist totally independantly of the other.

If I didnt know better, I'd swear you were reading Marx about the class struggle.

I don't believe in corporate welfare. Has nothing to do with my stance on welfare or foreign aid.

James

by oz_media

I look away for a few minutes and there's a whole side thread to read!

As to your question, I agree that a country needs to take care of its own first (uh, oh, welfare again!). I wish Canada blew more cash on helping Canadians as opposed to others but its a necessary evil for all stable countries; otherwise we'd be happier and more prosperous and that would just be wrong.

by oz_media

Firstly I don't disagree with your mindset that they should be able to fund and generate their own forces by now.

But you must consider the trillions that Middle Eastern billionaires have invested in the US to stockpile the Petrodollar. With those investments removed it would have a horrendous effect on your real estate and economy as a whole. That's also another reason that the US has to make good in the Middle East and try to retain a strong dollar value, some are already switching to the PetroEuro and that has direct effect on the USA.

You can't afford to play hardball when your economy sits in the palm of thier hands.

by oz_media

I think you guys remember when we had a major pi$$ing contest in 2005 over which country helped more after the tsunami hit Asia.
Actually it started out quite nice, with Max, Julian and I all in total shock and agreement (odd as I am sure we were all fighting in the war trenches at the time).
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=165852&messageID=1695842

Then it did get nasty,
[i]Did you know that although Americans make up only 5 percent of the world's population, they give about 35 percent of the aid? One-third of all aid given to others comes from the USA.

According to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, in 2003, the U.S. gave $37.8 billion out of a total $108.5 billion in foreign aid from the world's major countries. This is THREE TIMES the amount from the next largest donor, the Netherlands, who gave $12.2 billion.

You're welcome. [/i]

LOL :D here's a few more titles (all taken out of order):

Worldwide Generosity
USA #2 in donations worldwide
This is not a generosity contest
pssst..um...the govmnt has pledged $350 Mil
How Much???? [i](LOL, Maxwell)[/i]
A hair over 8,000 UK pounds
Australia Wins!!!
Some per capita perspective

At this late stage in the discussion
I just think maybe everyone's baked
Amen brotha, now pass that bowl...

LOL the good ole days.

What is it, an area of national pride or wasting your money?

One minute everyone is arguning about who is more generous and which country should be more proud of thier donations to help the world. The next thing you know (well, 3 years later and during an endangered economy)the argument is why countries should be helping themselves and not handing out to others.

Just struck me as funny; the war hits home financially in many indirect ways too.

by jck

What costs more:

a) Investing the money for 1 year to get someone trained in a vocation that makes them self-sufficient?

b) Investing the money for multiple years to pay someone to sit on the welfare dole and never to make them do for themself?

I'd personally opt for plan a, if i was going to endorse a spending plan.

Hand-ups are better than hand-outs in my book.

by jck

For all the trillions the USA has invested in the Middle East, where is our economy and real estate market as a whole?

Doesn't seem to have been the insurance we needed to solidify our markets, has it? OPEC hasn't increased their output sufficiently to ease concerns in trade for our generousity, have they?

Of course, it still doesn't help that the refining capacity is still under what the world needs. Yet, several American oil companies who have profited (at all-time record levels) $100Bs over the past 3 years still won't spend the $100Ms to upgrade and put into operation idle refining facilities in the USA.

Between OPEC and corporate greed, America is going to hell in a hand basket.

Saddest thing is: The American government is doing nothing to help.

Go figure.

by jdclyde

think about it for just a second.

I don't remember EVER reading about gay marriage in the bible.

I never said there were not gay people, just not gay marriage.

That is ok, I am adult enough to allow you to be wrong.

by jdclyde

"the government" does not set oil prices.

"the government" does not set gas prices.

"the government" does not set house prices.

"the government" does not set food prices.

You really scare me when you get your red coat on and start talking about all the governmental controls you want. And then you wonder why I often don't believe you are or ever have been anything but a die-hard bleeding heart liberal?

The things "the government" can do is either drill our own oil (despite what the ecoweenies say), take over a country and TAKE their oil (Like Saddam tried years ago), or walk in, hat in hand and beg.

Heard on the news the Saudies are pledging to increase the supply AND do something about what THEY call manipulated prices. Will be interesting to see how that goes, since they do have a vested interest in us doing well.

by jck

they don't set oil prices

they don't set house prices

they don't set food prices

they don't set gas prices.

thanks for stating the obvious

But, it [b]is[/b] government's job to protect and promote the general welfare of its people...[i][b]ALL[/b][/i] of its people...not just their campaign's big money donors.

That duty includes keeping business or any other entity from endangering the welfare of its people from assault: whether foreign or domestic...ballistic or economic.

I have [b]NEVER[/b] said they should "take over" anything other than healthcare, and that is because healthcare is ESSENTIAL. And, healthcare insurers have been gouging the consumer for years now much as the oil industry is doing today. Government has done nothing about that either.

However with the mentality of business to do as they wish, government needs to, on occassion, implement measures to keep the American public from being wronged. For example, some car dealers are selling hybrid cars now at 15-25% above MSRP simply because of "supply and demand".

Prices of those cars have gone up that much in less than a year. It is far above the inflationary measure (some 6 times the rate of inflation?), which should be considered price-gouging IMHO.

Government is not doing its job. It's obvious. They are letting big business run over the American public.

If a grocer sells a bottle of water after a hurricane in FL for $5, government calls it price gouging.

If a Toyota dealer raises the price of their Prius $4000 just because they can, government calls it supply and demand.

I don't want government takeover. I want government protection...that's what I pay taxes for.

by jdclyde

What would/could "the government" do about the price of gas?

What would/could "the government" do about medical insurance?

Is raising taxes even higher, and then "the government" giving the equivilent to medicaid to everyone a solution even though the COST of Medicaid is higher because of the government overhead, costing all of us more?

Ok, should "the government" have stepped in and forced Apple to lower the price of the iPhone because $400 was to much to ask for it?

Socialism is not the answer.

You agree that government doesn't set prices, so what DO/CAN they do then about the prices, short of nothing?

by jck

but taking the first step to solve problems is the best step. i see something like welfare, as it is today, like a dentist giving someone pain reliever for a tooth infection, rather than an anti-biotic. it helps in some ways, but it doesn't solve the real issue.

as well...with offshoring. i have been there too. and, my current employment is now threatened with programming farms overseas. so, that's one of the reasons why i've been contacting law programs.

of course, i guess one day those will get off-shored too.

by jck

let the government do [b]oversight[/b] with essential infrastructure things, much like states do with utilities.

for example, the Oklahoma Corporation Commission once fined Southwestern Bell Telephone over $200M for not keeping promises made, including charging fees to customers for upgrading phone systems but not doing so, etc.

of course, the US congress probably already has that power. but since oil and banks and insurers donate so much, they wait til it festers up so bad they have to do something or get voted out.

Again my plan is: make government protect people.

they call a convenience store charging $5 for a bottle of water after a hurricane price gouging...

but they call a Toyota dealer hiking the price of a Prius $4000 over MSRP because he can...supply and demand.

gouging is gouging. government should protect the public from it in all forms. not just what is the easiest target.

i heard congress is trying to get a windfall tax on oil companies passed now, because they've made record profits for years during the Iraq deal.

of course, they said it's not going to happen because...the republicans won't vote for it.

go figure.

by ic-it

It is a bit ironic that even though the government doesn't set the price of oil, we sure pay a lot to protect shipping lanes, invade countries, open government lands for drilling and then subsidize the oil companies.
No the gov. doesn't play a part ;-)

by jdclyde

What is an acceptable percent a company will be allowed to make, or do we set a cap on the total income?

Of course since MS has a higher profit return, will they be the next victoms of your wrath because you don't think Gates should be allowed to make so much money?

We all know that the clowns in Congress are not qualified to make a decision like that as most have never worked in the private sector and held a real job.

One of the MAIN promises Pelosi (As the Speaker of the house) promised was lower gas. Two years later and the price is over double and they have the majority. What have they done that this is a "Republican" problem? Yeah, go back and blame Republicans for everything, like you ususally do.

by jck

a) i'm not going to tell you what a "windfall tax" is. if you don't know, go back to high school economics. if you do, stop pretending to be obtuse.

b) congress is trying to pass it. if you want to know what limits they are thinking of setting...write your congressman...i'm not friggin psychic...or a politician.

c) do you know what is driving up prices right now? mostly refining capacity.

do you know how many million barrels per day US oil companies have off-line because of not wanting to have to spend part of their billions per quarter profit on retrofitting them to meet EPA standards? hundreds and hundreds of thousands.

but, they don't want to bring that online. why? because if they did, supply goes up, their profits go down. and they are liking driving the price up artificially. it's nice for them. they get big new houses and condos in the bahamas and a new bentley again this year.

while me and you figure out how to afford a tank of gas.

real fair, isn't it?

wouldn't it be nice if your government stepped in and went "hey guys. it's time to belly up and do what's right."

but of course, i guess that you will tell me exploitation of the market is just fair business...right?

by tonythetiger

that the Bible was put out by what were, in their day, the politicians and the press. As such, there is probably a lot that they didn't want you to know, so it was omitted. :)

by jdclyde

[i]"And by the way, how do you define "new" to exclude the
homosexuality recorded in myth & history as old as the
Bible, and including it?"[/i]

Will put it nice and simple for you, there was homosexuality, but there were not gay marriages. THAT is what makes it "new". Get it?

by tonythetiger

the real problem is [b]exposed[/b] by offshoring. The real problem is that wages and costs here have been artificially manipulated... by other than market forces... That can work... as long as you don't try to play in the world's sandbox... then what you get is what we are now seeing.

by jck

is what the government did to Japanese car makers for years when their cars were only produced in Japan: tariff the hell out of them.

I guarantee if Wal-Mart had to pay a 200-300% tariff on any product coming into the United States from a foreign manufacturer, they would go back to using American companies.

The basic, root problem is: our government is not protecting the best interests of its citizens.

Of the people, by the people, and for the people?

I think not nowadays.

by oz_media

YOu didn't have a choice when your government shelled out 350 million in relief for teh tsunami relief fund. Everyone was so proud of how much MORE money that teh USA coughed up compared to other, much smaller countries.

That was 100% compulsory, you had no choice in the matter but applauded the government for it all the same.

by oz_media

Bush wants higher oil prices, later in the post: but for now, your comment about the trillions the USA has invested in the Middle East.

My comment was that the MIDDLE EAST has invested many trillions into the US, they own a massive chunk of Florida AND California to keep money in a US dollar reserve.

If they pulled THAT money out of your economy, America would have a hard time of it al for sure!

After 911, thier investments in the USA dropped a great deal, in 2005 there was a sudden spike in investments again (buying up a share of Daimler Chrysler, 21,000 apartment complexes in the sunbelt cities and more in New York) , but that has dropped considerably. The Middle Eastern investors also OWN Churches Chicken, Caribou Coffee, Loehmann's, TLC and several US publications such as American Banker, the Middle East has a great investment in the US economy and loves to see your businesses fail and lose money, offering them a cheap investment that is funded by your buying thier oil at higher prices.

This was a marker, 3 years ago, when the Middle Eastern investors first topped other foreign investors from the UK and Asia to becoem the largest foreign investors in the USA.

[b]Here's one for you, they pay US workers workers at their companies a lot more than US companies in America do to, according to the Wash Post [/b]http://www.washingtoninstitute.org/templateC05.php?CID=2611

"Average annual compensation per worker at U.S. subsidiaries of foreign companies is about $60,500, 34 percent higher than the rate at all U.S. companies, according to the Organization for International Investment."

At one time, GWB had opened the investment floodgates, seeking mreo foreign investment into the USA. A hiccup was found when Dubai Ports World tried to buy Peninsular & Oriental Steam Navigation Company and in essence have control of 6 major US seaports. DPW also has close ties to the Taliban and a parnership with the UAE. They did find the relationship and DPW backed down from the bid.

Close one George!

Face it, the USA would not survive the way you are today without close relations and investments from the Middle East.

Severing those relationships would also sever the US economy.

They raise the price of oil, and invest MORE money in the USA.

So it is technically a balancing act between gettign oil at lower prices, which hurts foreign investment in the USA or paying ridiculous prices, which fills foreign pockets and increases thier investment in the USA, which is desparately needed.

The more the US pays for oil, the more Middle Eastern money is invested, Bush encourages and wants a greater Middle Eastern investment, so thus Bush encourages high oil costs.

by oz_media

[b]A solid fact: The US NEEDS the trillions in foreign investments in order to survive. You are the largest investor in other nations but also require the largest foreign investment back in America.[/b]

Higher oil prices mean richer Arabs.
Richer Arabs means more foreign investments/money in the US.

Why would GWB push for lower oil prices if his best interests are to make Arabs rich?

by jdclyde

If there has NEVER in history been Gay Marriage, and they WANT Gay Marriage NOW, that is something NEW (something new is considered "new").

Still waiting for someone to give a head count of the number of countries in the world that HAVE legal gay marriage vs the number of countries that do NOT have legal gay marriage.

Why? To see how "out of sync" with the rest of the world the US is on this subject. EVERYTIME it has been put on a ballot, the majority of Americans has voted against this, even in rabidly liberal California.

by protiusx

That sir is a weak argument. When did I say ?close the borders and cancel international trade?? I have never advocated that and you can not put those words in my mouth. To focus on ones country does not equate to closing the borders and totally isolating ones self or ones nation from the rest of the world.

Here is a good analogy:

Let us say you live in your home comfortably with your family. You work hard and provide a good home for you and your family. One day you come home and find another family has walked through your open back door and is now sitting at your table eating your food and watching your tv. What do you do? Do you ask them to leave? Do you call the police? Or do you ask them to stay, give them rooms, cloth them, feed them, learn to speak their language, and do this all by your self. Do you ask them to do work around your house and then pay them less than you?d pay your own children? It?s one thing to hire your neighbor or his son to mow your lawn but another thing entirely if he or his son moves into your house. I think you understand where I am going here.

Our nation isn?t perfect. We (collectively) have a great deal of soul searching to do to figure out what it is to be an American in the 21st century. My point is that we need to focus on America and be American. Not Mexican or French (God forbid) or Spanish or German or anything else. Change begins with each of us in our own homes and in our own communities. Our nation needs to focus on what it is to be an American. Notice I didn?t say we need to isolate ourselves from the world. I advocate making our country a better place for our children and their children. My hope is that my children will get along with their neighbors and offer value to their community which is another way of saying that I wish the America of my children?s time will be a place where American?s will say with pride ?Made in America?.

by nicknielsen

Very slowly, so you can understand it:

G o v e r n m e n t - s a n c t i o n e d   (" l e g a l")

h o m o s e x u a l   m a r r i a g e.

Edit: slowed it down some more.

by jdclyde

He knows exactly what I have said and understands it just fine.

He is just being a fuckwit trying to push buttons. Unfortunately, he needs to find someone that cares what he thinks to get the rise he is do desperately looking for.

by jdclyde

innovation is not of concern, protectionism is.

That, and "The Government" taking care of us from womb to tomb.

by jck

Do we make Americans take $5,000 a year jobs in tech center call technician roles like the people in India?

Do we make factories in our country 14 hour per day sweat shops like in China?

Just how do we, as Americans compete against 3rd world labor rates?

Fact is, you can't. Because, you can't make companies in India or China pay their people what people get paid here.

So, just exact how would you propose we deter corporations like Wal-Mart from using the low-cost Asian labor markets to pad their pocket even further?

I would love to hear this.

by jdclyde

That it is you always following me around like a dog in heat, and not the other way. Get off my leg.

Rarely do I seek you out and reply to you out of the blue.

Be a good little fukwit and go about your business of looking to argue for the sake of arguing. You are not able to shout me down, so scamper along and find someone that you can.

by jdclyde

Yeah, people in third world countries make a lot less. Lower cost of living combined with the going wage does that.

The same happens of working in Ohio vs California. The person working in California will make a lot more than the Ohio person. Are you saying California can not compete with California and that it is unfair somehow?

Protectionism needs to be a last resort, and looked at carefully.

I would take that low paying job if my cost of living were as low as theirs is.

After all, "who are we to impose our values and way of life on someone else", right?

by tonythetiger

[i]Do we make Americans take $5,000 a year jobs in tech center call technician roles like the people in India?[/i]

You take a job commensurate with your skills and work ethic at whatever the market will pay. Then either live within your means, or learn to have more means, all the while competing against the up and comers who are willing to work for less.

[i]So, just exact how would you propose we deter corporations like Wal-Mart from using the low-cost Asian labor markets to pad their pocket even further?[/i]

Ah, another Wal-Mart hater... That explains a lot. Funny thing is, if your socialist friends were in charge, society would be run much like you think Wal-Mart is run. 14 hour days? Bah! Adults only need 7 hours of sleep, so you'll be working 17!

by jck

California and Ohio are not in China. People in China don't pay US income tax.

If you are taking the stance it's okay to offshore because it's just business, that's fine then.

But for someone who is so about doing right by their country and making it the best, you sure know how to say you want us to have a strong, healthy homeland and then go and say it's natural for offshoring to occur because of labor costs... even though it kills your country's tax base which in turn kills your infrastructure and hurts your fellow Americans somewhere down the pipe.

You've offered no solution to stopping the bleeding of jobs out of this country (that I recall) that the twits in Washington won't stop because they're paid for like two-bit hookers by companies like Wal-Mart.

I say, government needs to (and it is their DUTY to) protect people. Part of that would be to level the playing field.

We can't go back 150 years to where $.25 was a good day's wage...so guess what? We need to make the product pricing similar on goods that are imported.

How do you do that? Golly gee. Is there a magic price fairy we can call to wave her wand and make it happen?

No, there isn't. So, you do as the US government did years ago when Japan was shipping all of their cars in here: you tariff them.

Or are you really so anti-union that are you against Americans having blue collar jobs? You think everyone should be an office jockey?

There were some words once written that said that Americans were trying to, among other things "...promote the general welfare and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and posterity...".

I don't see how sending jobs out of this country is promoting the welfare of the people or the nation, or securing liberty for ourselves and our future. All it does is weaken our economy and infrastructure and lower the moral of Americans on a daily basis.

In essence, allowing business the "freedom" you are mentioning...and letting them continue to offshore... is in essence allowing business to rape our country from inside and out all in the sake of individual gain. The companies prosper, but those outside of it don't. Especially those people in the sweatshops in China who are still worked half to death.

Perhaps my ideas are just falling on deaf ears though, and I'm not willing to try and explain what seems to me to be blatantly obvious to me.

But what do I know other than beer and .NET, right?

by jck

Taking a job for what the market offers is kind of hard when there are no jobs within your job market.

Just ask the people who worked at places like RCA/Thomson, Huffy, Rubbermaid, and dozens of other companies who were [b]FORCED[/b] by Wal-Mart (and yes, it's been documented) to lower their prices so much for product that they had no other option than to close shop in the United States and off-shore the work because they could not pay people enough to live and still make a profit to keep the company afloat.

Now again, I ask:

What is your so "manly" solution to stopping the bleeding of jobs out of this country? You called mine "cowardly", so I would like to know your solution.

Thank you.

by jdclyde

How can Americans be competative with the rest of the world?

First, make a better product.

Second, let people know you make a better product.

Third, don't pay everyone in the company more than they are worth.

Looking at the auto industry, there is nothing about working on the line that is worthy of making 60 to 100K a year, and is the cause of the prices being charged for the cars. Of course, the bonuses for the execs are out of line as well.

Where could government help THAT? Make sure that we penalize any and all countries imports that do NOT have an open policy for what we send them.

Dumping should be watched, to a point. I know this happens with Africa, to keep them from destroying our sugar industry. I know it is done with out steel trade as well.

No single good answer. A start? it is hard to even say "Buy American" because even the cars by GM/Ford have many of the parts shipped in from overseas or from Mexico.

If a company ships their jobs overseas, we need to do several things. Look at the taxes that chased them out of the country and see where the break point is where it is better to collect a lower amount of taxes than to lose the jobs.

We SHOULD raise taxes (teriffs) even higher on these companies when they go to bring their former amercian products into the US.

It should be looked into so that it is not cheaper to offshore, and it should be held up for all to see who is doing it.

Unions? A joke. Maybe if the union employees become union WORKERS again, but I don't see that happening. The unions are only looking to do as little as possible for as much as possible, and that pathetic lack of work ethic is another MAJOR stumbling block for Amercians to be competative. When I worked in a union shop, I got yelled at by the union old timers more than I ever did from management. "working to fast".

Don't shop borgmart.

by jck

but i really don't think most are going to do any good:

[i]How can Americans be competative with the rest of the world?[/i]

yes...please tell me....

[i]First, make a better product.[/i]

We did that for years. Didn't matter. If someone could get a cheaper Chinese made product for 10-15% less at Wal-Mart instead of a better brand at a local store...they buy Wal-Mart. That's what Wal-Mart banks on...and have won with.

It isn't product quality that matters anymore to most people. It's about having that extra buck to get your kid a kids meal and shut them up on road trips, etc. America people don't shop for pride anymore. They shop to get as much as they can for a buck.

[i]Second, let people know you make a better product.[/i]

Lots of places do. Of course, try finding a standard television or children's bicycle that is manufactured in this country...i believe there are no more.

[i]Third, don't pay everyone in the company more than they are worth.[/i]

Most businesses don't. If they did, they would go out of business fast. They only pay their executives too much usually.

[i]Looking at the auto industry, there is nothing about working on the line that is worthy of making 60 to 100K a year, and is the cause of the prices being charged for the cars. Of course, the bonuses for the execs are out of line as well. [/i]

I wouldn't say that. I'd say the head repair tech is worth that much. If he wasn't there, the company loses millions in lost production and work time waiting for someone from the outside to come in.

[i]Where could government help THAT? Make sure that we penalize any and all countries imports that do NOT have an open policy for what we send them. [/i]

Problem is, there's not a lot made in America anymore. So, how do you send things from here to there if there isn't product or a market to sell it?

We need to rebuild our production by getting suppliers to buy from American manufacturers first. Once we have capacity and product to send other places (like we did in the 70s and early 80s), then we can make trade agreements.

[i]No single good answer. A start? it is hard to even say "Buy American" because even the cars by GM/Ford have many of the parts shipped in from overseas or from Mexico.[/i]

It was a misnomer that things in the 70s and 80s were even entirely made in the USA. Car parts, electronic components, materials, etc, were often brought in from out of the country. Curtis Mathes televisions were touted as "American", but parts of their electronics were from Taiwan.

[i]If a company ships their jobs overseas, we need to do several things. Look at the taxes that chased them out of the country and see where the break point is where it is better to collect a lower amount of taxes than to lose the jobs.[/i]

That I have ever heard, taxes have not chased ANYONE out of this country in the manufacturing industry and were never a motivating factor to offshore.

It has been sheer greed on part of companies (the biggest one of them: Wal-Mart) to demand manufacturers provide a product at a certain price level so they can maximize their profit margins.

For example: when Rubbermaid (back then, they were manufacturing their product in the USA) was the ONLY full-line of plastic containers product in Wal-Mart stores nationwide, Wal-Mart wanted a higher profit margin and a lower price than anyone else...so they told Rubbermaid they would only pay them so much per unit for their product. Rubbermaid said that would not be possible without cutting their profits, and they were not willing to do that to their shareholders. So, Wal-Mart for a while got rid of Rubbermaid and went to Sterilite only in their stores, because it was a cheap Chinese knock-off of Rubbermaid and got them the profits they wanted.

Rubbermaid was forced to move to an off-shore manufacturer in Asia to compete...or go bankrupt. Wal-Mart almost ruined them. And, it was directly because of Wal-Mart. Former Rubbermaid executives and management have said it in on- and off-camera interviews.

And, people nowadays would buy anything that just gets things done and don't care about quality. America is now a "disposable society". Buy Cheap. Use it til it breaks. Throw it away. Get another cheapy.

As I said. That's what Wal-Mart banks on: complacency with the minimum needed, and acceptance of mediochrity.

[i]We SHOULD raise taxes (teriffs) even higher on these companies when they go to bring their former amercian products into the US.[/i]

I say put tariffs on everything manufactured outside of the USA that is coming into the country, so that it is an INCENTIVE to American companies to buy from American manufacturers.

[i]It should be looked into so that it is not cheaper to offshore, and it should be held up for all to see who is doing it.[/i]

I agree. Shame them all for stabbing their fellow Americans in the back in the name of simple, pure greed.

[i]Unions? A joke. Maybe if the union employees become union WORKERS again, but I don't see that happening. The unions are only looking to do as little as possible for as much as possible, and that pathetic lack of work ethic is another MAJOR stumbling block for Amercians to be competative. When I worked in a union shop, I got yelled at by the union old timers more than I ever did from management. "working to fast".[/i]

I don't know what union you worked for, but I have talked to truck drivers (teamsters), transmission dispatchers (IBEW), and government workers (NAFSCE,et al). Their unions usually do a good job representing them and taking care of them.

But answer me this:

Is it any less wrong for an employer to give you a job, define your duties, pay you a rate for that job, yet within your first few months task you with other jobs or more work hours in the company as they see fit for the same compensation?

No is the right answer. And, that is why unions are there. To speak as a voice for workers. It is just as wrong for an employer to ask an employee to do more than what they compensate someone to do, as it is for a union person to not do their job well. Both are abuses of the other involved.

I do agree. Some union expectations of employers are ridiculous. But something else you have to understand too. Union employees are often bound by rules of the contract that limit what they WANT to do. I knew guys at the power company i worked at who were union. And, they said often "I can't do that because of the bargaining agreement". They wanted to, but legally were restricted from it. So it's not always the worker's fault.

And btw, most union guys do work...and REALLY hard. Just because you've run into problems with unions and their people where you are...doesn't mean all unions are bad...or their members

[i]Don't shop borgmart. [/i]

As I said before. I only go in Wal-Mart 2-3 times a year if i need something either in an emergency, or it is the only place i can get it.

I've probably not spent more than $200 in there in recent times.

I do shop at Sam's Club tho. That service desk girl is HOT! mmmmmmmm ]:)

One last thing: You say it's wrong of union workers to want to produce the least effort for the most money.

If it's so wrong, then shouldn't a business be held to the same standard, instead of being like Wal-Mart and putting out the cheapest, sellable product in their stores at the highest profit possible?

I just wonder...if personal greed and lazyness is so bad...then what is corporate greed and lazyness amount to?

And, at least a union worker isn't putting another American by working slow.

Companies offshoring to get the cheapest product possible for greed's sake is putting Americans out of work.

by tonythetiger

[i]Taking a job for what the market offers is kind of hard when there are no jobs within your job market.[/i]

poor baby...

[i]What is your so "manly" solution to stopping the bleeding of jobs out of this country? You called mine "cowardly", so I would like to know your solution.[/i]

The solution is for the crybabies to quit whining that they are "entitled" to anything more than any other human on the planet has simply because of where they were born.

Take charge of your own destiny. Don't wait around for someone to "give" you what you think you are "entitled" to. If you don't, you deserve exactly what you get.

by tonythetiger

[i]We can't go back 150 years to where $.25 was a good day's wage...so guess what? We need to make the product pricing similar on goods that are imported.

How do you do that? Golly gee. Is there a magic price fairy we can call to wave her wand and make it happen?[/i]

As a matter of fact there is. It's called FairTax.

http://www.fairtax.org

[edit fix link]

by jdclyde

"greed".

People start up a business for one reason, to make themselves money.

When you put money away, do you look for the best rate of return for yourself, even if it lowers the profits of the group you are getting the rate from? Greed.

The union shop I was at is gone. The lazy union people are out the door and mexicans are doing the job for $5 less and hour, at a faster pace.

If YOU finish a programming project ahead of schedule, do you get put directly onto the next job or do you get to sit around until the allotted time is up?

When the union people DEMAND work comes to a stop until the one union person who's job it is to change that lightbulb comes along and does it, shows why unions are causing people to lose their jobs. They, in their lazy, greedy ways, have corrupted the unions to be for doing little, instead of standing up for the worker to demand a decent days pay for a decent days work, under safe working conditions. The decent days work just isn't there anymore.

by nicknielsen

We did? When? We were the 800-pound gorilla of the world economy during the two decades between 1945 and 1965 because ours was the only national economy that wasn't significantly damaged during WW2. When American companies started facing significant competition from outside North America, they didn't make sure their products were of the same or better quality, they went to Congress to get protective tariffs.

The reasons American companies that existed then no longer exist now are many and varied, but one significant fact remains: Had American industry [u]not[/u] ignored the teachings of W. Edwards Deming (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Edwards_Deming) until the early '80s, our economy would be much different today.

by jdclyde

well, it would be nice if you had even that to fall back on, but sadly, all you can resort to is mimicking back ever since I called your punkass a fuckwit. Ever since then, every one of your crying posts had that in it, like the kid in the school yard that just heard the big kids say something cool.

Sorry I hurt your feelings, little boy. Please stop crying, now that I have apologized. The tears might ruin your keyboard, and that wouldn't be very "professional" of you.

by tonythetiger

when demand started rising through the roof.

When my aunt passed a couple years ago, she still had the Philco refrigerator she bought in 1953. My cousin has it in his garage now.

by jck

did exist even into the 1980s

My parents had a console stereo that they purchased in the 1970s. It worked even up until the day they gave it away in the 1990s.

My parents bought a 25 inch RCA console television in 1981 that lasted until they moved to Florida in 1998 and they gave that away.

I have, in my garage, the original refrigerator from my house (can't remember the brand...I think it's a Kenmore) that was bought with the house in 1983. It still runs like a champ. Never had to put a penny into it.

American products did exist that were quality past the 1950s and 1960s.

Just that nowadays, Americans are willing to pay somewhat less and get something that will probably last 10-25% of the lifespan that better products would that cost more.

America has become a here-and-now, throw-away society.

Investing in our future has seemed to become an afterthought to hardship caused from poor planning...whether that's investment in property or lifestyle.

Sad case, but the truth.

by jdclyde

Yeah, I know.

Was making fun of what the removal did to the discussion, not you. B-)

One of many reasons why I preferred the editing of posts over the removal of them. When someone reads this a year from now, ABSOLUTELY no one will even know about the pseudo-intellectual poster known as Absolutely, and think strange things..... ;\

by jdclyde

or tastes better? :0

I will leave the two of you alone now. Here, let me get the light on my way out.... ;\

:p

This discussion is closed to new replies.