Discussion Locked

Okay all you "Free Speech" people - comments?

0 helpful
202 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The following is a Michael Medved article that I cut and pasted, in its entirety, from TownHall.com:

As of this posting (Friday afternoon, 6.30 Pacific Time) the liberal campaign to censor the ABC miniseries "The Path to 9/11" has reached new heights of demagogic hysteria. Tom McMahon, executive director of the Democratic National Committee sent out an e-mail to supporters that began: "This is it: crunch time for getting the slanderous ABC television docudrama 'The Path to 9/11' yanked off the air. The network schedule has this slanderous attack on Democrats slated to start on Sunday night, September 10, at 8 o'colck -- and as long as it stays ont he schedule, we have work to do. Take a minute right now and tell Disney president Robert Iger to keep this right wing propaganda off the airwaves."

Unlike Mr. McMahon and his hyperventilating Democratic colleagues, I've actually watched the miniseries in question-- in its entirety -- and there is no chance that any sane observer who bothers to sit through all five hours of this riveting presentation could ever describe it as "right wing propaganda." As a matter of fact, the miniseries is particularly hard on the Bush administration and Condaleezza Rice, as well as highlighting the way that Clinton and his aides fell short in their dealing with the terrorist threat. In terms of running time of the presentation, at least ninety minutes of the mini series focuses on events during the Bush presidency-- representing at least 30% of the total program. Meanwhile, Bush was president during the period covered by the miniseries (February, 1993, through September 11, 2001) for only eight months; Clinton was president for eight years (less a single month). In other words, Clinton occupied the White House for 93% of the actual historical period under consideration, but his shortcomings occupy less than 70% of the miniseries running time.

In other words, by one easily quantifiable measure, "The Path to 9/11" doesn't inapporpirately focus on Clinton and his failures; if anything, it concentrates disproportionately on the disappointing performance of President Bush at the very beginning of his term.

The most depressing aspect of the concentrated Democratic campaign to "yank" (their word) this 40 million dollar production from the ABC schedule would be the message such censorship would send to other networks and producers. If ABC does (God forbid) decide to cancel the much-hyped showing of the miniseries because of liberal pressure, then everyone in Hollywood would learn the lesson that you must avoid serious projects, at all costs; you can easily get away with "Wife Swap" or "Temptation Island" or "Fear Factor," but if you attempt to broadcast a chilling, carefully crafted, deeply moving investigation of our national, bi-partisan failures in responding to terrorism, then some yahoo will squal and protest and attempt to shut you down. This is the text-book definition of censorship: prior restraint. That means cutting off speech before it even occurs, rather than protesting - or correcting the record- after you've actually heard what the other guy has to say.

Nor is the current Democratic effort to censor ABC in any substantive sense comparable to the conservative protests against the CBS miniseries about "The Reagans." The objection to that show was that President Reagan, stricken with Alzheimer's disease, had no possibility of responding to the sleazy, intimately personal attack on his reputation. By contrast, Bill Clinton can easily respond to any perceived cheap shot in the "The Path to 9/11" --- in fact he already has responded, while admitting he hasn't even seen the thing. The network is already making adjustments to the final edit to register some of President Clinton's objections. One can only hope that they stop there, rather than surrendering to the mob mentality, complete with pitchforks and torches, mobilized by Democratic Party demagogues who demand the cancellation of the miniseries.

That cancellation would represent a tragedy for the producers --who've already experienced the most vitriolic personal attacks, complete with publication of their home addresses, accompanied by death threats (one of them pronounced on my radio show, earlier today, by a troglodyte caller who talle writer-producer Cyrus Nowasteh "I hope you die") and warnings that "the gloves are off."

Please, put the gloves back on. Recognize that weeks ago ABC scheduled a one hour panel discussion after airing the miniseries so that people who objected to it in any way could make their opinions heard. As Justice Brandeis famously observed, the best remedy for bad ideas is good ones; the best response to bad speech is good speech. Free discourse -- and the whole medium of television -- will suffer if ABC buckles to pressure to stifle one of the most significant and substantive productions in TV history.

--------------------

And by Robert Novak:

WASHINGTON -- The unusual Democratic outrage over ABC-TV's "The Path to 9/11" film to be shown Sunday and Monday reflects private concern in the party that the fifth anniversary of the terrorist attack can reverse the political tide running against Republicans.

The highly partisan Rep. Louise Slaughter of New York composed a tough letter to Robert A. Iger, CEO of Walt Disney (ABC's parent company). The letter cites two scenes from the program casting doubt on the Clinton administration's legacy in fighting terrorism.

Slaughter added as co-signers of the letter three senior Democrats who would join her as committee chairmen if Democrats win control of the House. They were Rep. John Dingell of Michigan, senior member of the House; Rep. Jane Harman of California, a top party spokesman on national security; and Rep. John Conyers of Michigan, a left-wing leader.

--------------------

And a Bill Clinton letter to ABC:

http://electioncentral.tpmcafe.com/blog/electioncentral/2006/sep/09/in_new_letter_clintons_lawyer_demands_abc_yank_film

202 replies

by tony hopkinson

They are morons, you can't argue for free speech and then stop someone apeaking freely. Well you can but if you do you are an idiot.

I won't comment on the series, because I haven't seen it. I look forward to a fair and balanced treatment of this important issue.

by nicknielsen

The 9-11 Commission Report: http://tinyurl.com/6yq8p

These guys didn't pull any punches that I can see given the information available.

Television hasn't been about fair and balanced since Edward R. Murrow, if it was even fair and balanced then.

by tony hopkinson

a tongue in cheek smiley.
It's still too close, you can't get fair and balanced when emotions are this high. I still get a cold wash down my spine when I see the video, just before I get really angry again and I didn't lose anybody. It was too callous for articulation.

by btljooz

I feel that Hollywood ALWAYS 'fictionalizes' every true story at least to a point and always will, for whatever reason. I also feel that the media spin doctors will always spin.

That being said, could all this POLITICO controversy be propaganistically motivated? When everything is said and done, what politician has NEVER, ever used propaganda to his/her own advantage?

I say, let the show air and allow CITIZENS to make up our OWN minds about it! After all, this film was researched thouroughly and the families of some of the victims of 9/11 were even consulted for accuracy of some of the MAIN points.

by jdclyde

how the Democrats are trying to censor this, while they hypocritycally always claim to be the ones always in support of "free speech".

by x-marcap

The left tolerates lies and deliberate misstatements from Michael Moore, George Soros,etc, and repeat and amplify them.

When the truth is used to defeat them You have become "Partisan", or bigoted, or some other negative label...

What was the Million Man March really, 26,500 by estimate. (It was a million symbolicly).

The NRA is larger than all of the leftist groups combined, but the NRA consists of legal gun owners... There are laws about illegal use of guns so let's enforce them rather than make one more law against the law abiding who own guns.

The free speech censors from the left want to suppress negative truth about Bill Clinton even today. The truth is what it is. The problem with the left, including Fitzgerald is that even when they know there is no crime they try to create one when they have a political opponent in their sights.

The Senators and the SP (Fitzgerald) who knew there was no criminal acts committed by the administration should be impeached and removed. Especially, as they knew it as soon as the investigation started that it was Dick Armitage. Armitage had signed a letter of resignation from the State Deptartment, and communicated with the SP's office that he was the leak. The SP never even called Armitage to testify... He did try to trap Cheney,Libby,Rove,etc into committing a perjury. He got Libby on the date of a meeting... A date that Libby couldn't verify with his daytimer as it had been confiscated by Fitzgerald.

We are talking about a 2 week discrepancy. Early to late March, to April, and not a formal meeting anyway, nor a crime committed... If there is a libertarian bent in anyone we need to impeach Fitzgerald, and then indict (s)Ch(m)uck Schumer,Nancy Pelosi, and Harry Reed over their part in the charade. Schumer and Pelosi in particular were in contact with Fitzgerald over the incident, and from Fitzgerald's statements knew they were slandering Libby, Cheney,Bush et al. They should be held liable for slander, and impeached and removed for these criminal acts.

Libby was wrong on a date by two weeks two years later without his personal calendar. THAT is BS...
I think Libby should be reimbursed for legal fees, and back pay, and if everything is fair, Fitzgerald, Schumer, Pelosi and Reed should be the ones who compensate him, as they led the accusations against him. They should also apologize publically, and explain that the real culture of corruption came from the SP's office.

by tonythetiger

[i]I say, let the show air and allow CITIZENS to make up our OWN minds about it![/i]

Which party isn't confident enough in how well their followers will be able to distinguish fact from fiction? :)

by jdclyde

Surprise Surprise, the ACLU is in on this as well.

Where were they during the Oliver Stone Movies?

Where were they during the fraudulent "movies" by M. Moore?

It is only when a Democrat is looking bad that they wish to silence people. This was suppose to just be a hatched job on Bush, and all would be well?

I have said it before that one of my biggest problems with the Democratic party is the complete lack of consistancey. Add to that ethics now.

by colonel panijk

The core of the flap is that a number of [b]real[/b] people were portrayed as doing things which they say are totally incorrect and libelous. Perhaps ABC has addressed these issues by now and the presentation will be (to coin a phrase) "fair and balanced". If so, then the hysteria is unwarranted. If not, it's justified.

ABC has been told, [i]in advance[/i] of points in their story which a number of people consider to be blatantly untrue. If these charges (against ABC) were incorrect in the first place, then shame on the Dems. If they were true, and the miniseries has been corrected to be historically accurate, then no harm has been done. If ABC has chosen to go ahead and smear the reputations of a number of Clinton-era government officials in hopes of high ratings, then I hope the offended people sue for libel and take home [i]billions[/i] for having their reputations destroyed. Let the film roll, and then bust ABC's butt if they knowingly put something false on the air.

What was it that George W said? Something like, "If we just ignore Osama bin Laden, he'll go away."? It would be funny if [i]that[/i] was in the miniseries, wouldn't it?

by danlm

Both parties were shown to have problems. ABC has already said the story had dramatizations which were not always factual.
If you read the article, only how long was spent with President Clintons administration to how long was spent with President Bush's administration.
You do not hear anything being said from the current president, who is being portrayed in a negative way also.
I think that is what JD is trying to put forth with this.

Dan

by maxwell edison

You're the guy who likes to throw around the stupid and condescending "Maxie" label. Are you trying to be funny or insulting? Nope, you're neither. Are you trying to prove your immaturity and stupidity? Well, here's a clue - you're no comedian, and nothing you say could possibly insult me. That leaves immaturity and stupidity, doesn't it?

Here's another clue: you're a partisan Democrat. What else would we expect from you? And here's even another clue: I must have hit a hot-button pointing out your hypocrisy, lack of true principle, and lack of consistency. Can you spell Fahrenheit 9-11?

But you rear your ugly head, yet again, proving what a total ass you are. Keep posting, dude. People like you are the best proof for my arguments!

by colonel panijk

Hmm. Can I get "Maxie" so stoked up that he'll have a stroke? It would be fun to try!

I too have been following this story in the "mainstream" (i.e., left of the Nazis) press and I have seen nothing about calls for censorship. A lot of people are angry about false and misleading things said about them in this miniseries. Maybe they are right, maybe they've been misinformed about the content, maybe they [i]were[/i] right and it has been corrected to be historically accurate and fair.

ABC has admitted to making up large parts of the story line in order to give it more punch. They are presenting it in a documentary style, and even though they promise to run disclaimers that it is substantially fiction, you know damned well that most viewers will believe it to be the truth. "[i]I saw it on that there telly vizion thing.[/i]" Remember 1938's [i]War of the Worlds[/i] radio broadcast? Whether you'd like to admit it or not, Americans are stupid. By Monday evening a lot of fine people may find their reputations in ruins. I only hope that they can find compensation in the courts.

As for the rest of your mouth-foaming diatribe against me, it is beneath my dignity to comment on it, except to remind you that the police shoot rabid dogs on sight.

by tonythetiger

The intent of the objections may not have been to actually get anything changed. Perhaps it was a setup to increase publicity.

by mjd420nova

Free speech, the right of artistic license, aren't they the way we all see it?? I have always called that moving picture box "THE EVIL EYE, THE BOOB TUBE, THE ONE EYED MONSTER". Very lttle of what is shown is REAL. Everything is scripted, and rehearsed and should never be considered to be the truth. Even NEWS programs are tobe taken with a grain of salt as they are just like news papers, they are slanted to the sensational side and intended to attract more viewers. The almighty dollar holds sway over everything they air. Even News is subject to being either half truths or portrayed in such a manner as to lead the viewer to draw unfounded conclusions.

by jdclyde

They were talking about providing copies to schools to help edumacate the kids about 911. This is just wrong.

The other thing is, the majority of the people in this country are stupid enough to belive anything they ever see on a show or in a movie.

I personally am against the idea of this movie because they have "fictionalized" some parts, but the average person won't know which is which.

Just like the people that watch the lies and distortions by Moore, all it does is UNEDUCATE people because they are learning the hype not the truth.

by danlm

Even if the movie is done with dramatization, and they provide notices about that. People will accept it as god given truth.
By the way, where did you see the ALCU was up in arms over this? Id love to read that link, just to write to them and say what you did. lol
Sorry, your words were just too true. Where were these people during the other movies.

Dan

by nicknielsen

You seem to have forgotten (if you ever knew) that many Americans, particularly young ones form their opinions and beliefs from what they see on television. They know the difference between entertainment, news and history, but still believe that in cases like that, they couldn't say it (or show it) if it isn't true.

My students (when I was teaching) got many of their "facts" on the JFK assassination from Oliver Stone's movie of the same name. Their knowledge of the mafia came from "Goodfellas" and "The Sopranos," and their knowledge of the late 20th century from "That 70s Show." Need I go on?

Why was this happening? I believe it's because there was just enough truth in each of these movies/shows to make them believable. I often thought my most important task as a teacher was to teach my students to be skeptical of any piece of information until it could be verified by a reputable source, and no, MySpace and YouTube are not reputable sources.

Although the Constitution only applies to government actions, in this case, regardless of the accuracy of the show, the Democrats are wrong. Not because the show is more accurate than they suppose, but because of the threat to future controversial projects pointed out in the original article. I can hear the CEO at Universal now: "It might offend somebody in power, you can't do it."

by tony hopkinson

One of the scariest things I saw was news article where they asked a child

Where do giraffe's come from ?
The response was zoos.

Does a treehuggers heart good that !

I'm still smarting at finding out it wasn't the brits who won Tobruk, I was taught it was, but then I saw Rock Hudson was the key factor.

by colonel panijk

The scary thing is that if you asked most Americans about whether something on the tube is true or not, you'll get a reply like, "Of course it's true. They couldn't put it on the air if it wasn't." Yep. Even if the show is filled with disclaimers that "this is largely a work of fiction," most viewers will believe that it's the Gods-honest truth. Couldn't put it on the telly if it weren't! RIP, Democracy.

by jdclyde

First is the plan to distribute this to schools.
http://thinkprogress.org/2006/09/05/abc-distribution/

ABC has NEVER been a "Right-wing mouth piece", and is usually on the side of the ACLU.
http://www.debbieschlussel.com/archives/2006/01/abc_sides_with.html

If you start checking google links, you see that everyone, left, right, middle, up and down are all complaining about this mocumenary. Numberous reports of the FBI agent that was assisting quit half way through because he felt the directors were "making stuff up" as they went along.
http://www.hoffmania.com/blog/2006/09/fbi_consultant_.html
(one of many sites that say the same thing.)

Clinton, who has been trying to redefine his legacy for a long time is up in arms about this. From what I have heard, what they say is inaccurate in the movie, but the truth in the 911 report isn't any more favorable to him or his administration. He comes off bad either way because of his lack of action, and his refusing Bin Laden when he was offered him.

On the way home from work, a lawyer for the ACLU was trying to split hairs about the difference between someone stating an opinion and defimation. This was suppose to explain why an Oliver Stone movie or a M. Moore movie is just fine, but how and why this movie is different. Sounded like he was talking in circles.

Not sure what will happen, but there has to be something else going on that we aren't seeing yet.

Speaking on 911, I never have been amused by the "satire" of sites like the onion, but this one points out such a disgrace that I had to point it out.
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/52325

by danlm

There is some heavy reading there about the lawyers for the ACLU having some serious shady pasts. Lying, partaking in the same activities they are suing the government over, funneling money to various terrorist organizations.

This is the link I found the most intresting:
Who's Behind the ACLU NSA Lawsuit . . . And Why Are They Lying? http://www.debbieschlussel.com/archives/2006/01/whos_behind_the.html

Serious heavy reading.

Dan

by nicknielsen

from the land of tabloids and Page 3 girls? :0

They get them the same place the tabloids do...they make them up. :D

by tony hopkinson

Only kidding.

Kids don't read the sun anyway. It's on the top shelf with other publications where only the pictures are important.

by tonythetiger

Everyone has freedom of speech (unless you're physically prevented or medically impaired). But along with that right comes an obligation to accept the consequences of that speech, whether or not you anticipated those consequences. In this case, ABC anticipated the consequences (although the letter left very little to actually have to try to guess at), and decided they didn't want to suffer them.

It happens all the time. We should not be suprised.

by tonythetiger

is a perfect example. There was at least one suicide attempt, and weeks after the broadcast, the Red Cross was still trying to get people to come down out of the hills where they had fled.

by colonel panijk

Democracy requires an informed, intelligent electorate than can gather information about the issues, sort the wheat from the chaff, and make a sensible choice. Sadly, most Americans are content to be spoon-fed whatever's on the tube, believing whatever they're told, and being followers rather than thinking for themselves. This applies to crap being fed from [b]both[/b] the left and the right, but over the last quarter century it's become almost exclusively the domain of the right-wing christian-fascist-republican-industrial complex.

It has [i]always[/i] been a game for politicians and pressure groups to try to lead the public by the nose, but over the long run Americans have usually been able to realize when things aren't right. Nowadays, though, no one seems to be able to do critical thinking, and that means the end of democracy. The tactics of misleading the public have been perfected by Karl Rove and his ilk, and the right-wing ideologues now have smooth sailing to establish, in the name of Security, a one-party theocracy.

Attempts to mislead have existed for 230 years, but with the failure of the public education system (to teach kids to [i]think[/i]) and the immediacy and eyewitness "truth" of television (you can see and hear "it", as though [i]you[/i] were there, so it must be true), the stars have aligned to kill democracy. RIP.

You're welcome.

by jdclyde

First, I agree that the failed school system is in a large part to blame for the state of the country, but you convenently seem to forget who it is that controls the public school system. You are a fool if you even TRY to say anything but the corrupt DEMOCRATIC Teachers Union has resisted each and every effort to imporve or fix this system, crying only that we need to throw more bales of cash on the fire to get it going. Something private schools have shown time and again that more money is not the key to better education.

Karl Rove came out of no where and took over the world while no one was watching and no one the wiser, huh? Wow, he must be the single smartest and powerful man in the world if he did all that.

You might also check back on who is typically less informed. Many of a left leaning postition are more interested in "American Idol" than American news.

they learn sound bites that they share at the water cooler, and drive the party based on feelings, the most comon used it hate, because it is a powerful emotion. It is when they are requited to THINK, to logically defend and support their oppinions and explain how they came to a conclusion that they fall flat on their faces.

Not all Democrats are mindless idiots, but they have more than their fair share.

Finally, if you and everybody in the great liberal camp all know exactly what Rove has done and how he has done it, then he hasn't done what you are claiming, has he?

But yes, there are way too many people sitting around oblivious, waiting for "the government" to fix everything and take care of everything.

You take on this?

by maxwell edison

...this is a different program than the one addressed in the original message. (Not complaining about you posting your message, as it was an interesting -- and related -- article; but I thought I'd just point out it's a different film.)

by fjfish

Sorry - there must be a blizzard of 9/11 documentaries out there at this time of year. This explains why the Register didn't mention it as a side issue.

I do think the point is valid. Quite often in the UK things get moved for "other" reasons, but we all know the real reason is censorship and political pressure.

Thanks.

by maxwell edison

Look at this article:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/5333186.stm

"Their claims of edits notwithstanding, The Path to 9/11 had Clinton administration officials saying things they did not say and doing things they did not do," claimed spokesman Jay Carson in a statement.

I'm almost speechless at some of the things I hear these people (Democrats) say. How long and how often have these people (Democrats) been claiming things that President Bush did not say and questioning things President Bush did not do? The hypocrisy is incredible.

Another quote from the article:

"And it questioned the claim that former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright alerted the Pakistanis in advance of a 1998 US missile strike."

Well, President Clinton, Ms. Albright, and Jay Carson, don't just "question" it, go ahead and deny it and give your corrected version of events. They didn't deny it in their complaint, did they? It's interesting the way they are questioning so much that's being asserted, but they don't correct it. Why is that?

By the way, I love the way the movie made Madeline Albright look like a fool -- because she IS a fool!

by tig2

We set it up to record as we wanted to be able to watch it and be able to stop playback to allow for discussion. If we decide to keep it, we want to be able to edit together Part One and Part Two.

I have heard that ABC will interrupt the boradcast this evening for Bush's address.

I think that all the furor over this is ridulous. Clinton will look like Clinton looks and has looked all along. A desire to change history on ANYONE'S part will not result in an actual change. And truthfully, I don't think that any film is sufficient to change any thinking person's mind.

In response to your initial comments, I think that the Dems made a mistake by making this arguement. All they accomplished to me was to make themselves look pretty silly- free speech is not partisan.

by jdclyde

How many times have you heard someone stupid enough to make the claim that Clinton was impeached because of a blowj0b?

How many times have you heard someone of questionable thought process to say that "The courts GAVE Bush the 2000 election".

How many times have we heard someone of limitied reason claim that the ballot boxes in Ohio "stole the 04 election with a script that would wipe all traces afterwards?". And then back up that wild eyed, foaming at the mouth claim with, "it COULD have happened and now we will never know!"

Yeah, and pigs fly dumba$$.

History has been rewritten one sound bite after another around the water cooler.

Clinton has been trying to give himself a respectable legacy for a long time, but history will not be as kind to him as his mindless minions have been. (yes, Bush is going to have some answering to as well, before people jump in on this!)

But no, I did not see this. I was "distracted" dealing with my ex. Oh well. I guess I can catch it when it is out on video! :D

by tonythetiger

is to suddenly become 'literal' when they say they didn't do something ([i]It depends on what the definition of [b]is[/b] is.[/i]).

As a child, I got slapped when I did that ('But Mom, you just told me to put the clothes in the dryer. You didn't tell me to turn it on.'). It just happenned that once :)

by jdclyde

funny how it is just "satire" when "they" are the ones saying hateful or untrue things?

I only wish there was something that would happen legally to reporters and politicians alike for distorting the truth.

by nicknielsen

I was over on the Discovery channel with Ted Koppel and the town meeting.

Rational discussion. Very interesting. The type of dialog that should have been happening in Washington, but hasn't been.

As one of the family members said, "They're too busy playing politics with the memory of 9/11 to actually get anything done."

by maxwell edison

You quoted one of those people who said, [i]"They're too busy playing politics with the memory of 9/11 to actually get anything done."[/i]

I don't disagree, but I might define "they" differently. President Bush and his administration ARE getting things done, and it is ONLY the Democrats, at least for the most part, playing politics. If you (or anyone) disagrees, please point out how the Bush administration is "playing politics" when it comes to waging the war on terrorism. The Democrats are "playing politics" to such a great degree, that it's literally undermining the efforts -- something I consider aiding the enemy.

by jamesrl

The woman who played Madeline Albright (who I blame for Rwanda and much else wrong with the Clinton foreign policy) is Shirley Douglas.

Shirley's father was Tommy Douglas, who was voted Greatest Canadian of all time. He was a member of the CCF, the predecessor of the New Democrats, the socialist party in Canada. He was like many of his CCF associates, religious, and in fact a minister. He was anti-communist. He is widely given credit for founding medicare in Canada. Even conservatives respect him as a man of honour and principle.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tommy_Douglas

But his daughter is a piece of work, and something else. She is an actor, was married to Donald Sutherland (in the 60s), and is the mother of Kiefer.

She is also someone, as much as I respect her father, I don't respect. At every turn she uses demonizing language to criticize those in the centre and on the left. If you look her up in wikipedia, she formed a fundraising group for the black panthers. She prattles on about the evils of the right wing, and how they secretly plot to destroy her father's legacy. In fact Tommy Douglas never envisioned all of healthcare being paid by the government:?I want to say that I think there is a value in having every family and every
individual make some individual contribution. I think it has psychological value. I think it
keeps the public aware of the cost and gives the people a sense of personal
responsibility. I would say to the members of this House that even if we could finance the
plan without a per capita tax, I personally would strongly advise against it.?

Shirley, on the other hand said : "You either want a single-payer system in this country or you want an American-style health care system. And don't kid yourself that there's anything in between." Single payer being the government.

I do respect people on all sides of the spectrum who present reasoned opinions. She isn't one of them. She is, in my humble opinion, one of the worst examples of someone who sees everything in black and white, and uses rhetoric and demonization to sell her message.

James

James

by maxwell edison

But what are you suggesting, and how is it relevant to the subject? Don't get me wrong, I love "by the way" type tangents, and I learned something with yours. In the immortal words of the late great Johnny Carson, I did not know that. I think, however, I missed your point. Call me dense, but could you explain?

by tig2

I can burn you a copy.

I agree that people will believe what they believe. Unfortunately, they will do that regardless of the truth. And history books get re-written too.

I guess where my thinking was going is more on the line of events are events. SOMEONE recalls what really happened.

My father is a real history buff- specifically Civil War history. One of the things I have learned is that one book (read "account") is insufficient. You must read many. And do your own research. Unfortunately, I am afraid I am one of a limited number.

Let me know if you want me to burn a copy of that- I can ship it with the Red Dwarf... still bundled together with the address. I did finally get a box to ship them in!

by nicknielsen

was that it was a collective "they". No explanation for the feelings that led to this comment was forthcoming.

My problem is not that the President and Republicans are doing something and the Democrats are doing their best to move the country in a different direction. My problem is with the things that are getting done.

I consider the abrogation of the principles espoused in our Constitution, [i]regardless of the target[/i], as a net loss for our country. The President's continued attempts to deny the protections of the Constitution to detainees merely allow the radical mullahs to say "See? They don't practice what they preach! They are indeed corrupt," and convert another few to their cause.

by maxwell edison

You've got to be kidding?

Are you suggesting that the U.S. Constitution provides protections to all people of the world? Even to those non-citizen enemy combatants attempting to destroy the United States? What makes you think that? And when has that ever been the case? Even if you suggest it would be merely a symbolic gesture, if you think such a sentiment would get the terrorists to think better of us, you're crazy.

We're at war, and a serious one at that. I'm afraid that many people have forgotten the seriousness of the threat, or they've never really became fully aware of it. There's only one way to win a war, and that's to make the other side lose. It's the "can't we all just get along" sentiment that's been failing for the last four decades -- because they don't want to get along; they want us dead, and that's all they want. And here's another thought. If you think this isn't a serious war, and if you don't think it will be going on for ten, twenty, or more years, you should become more aware yourself.

If you think that abuse of any enemy combatant detainee is more than extremely isolated cases, you've been duped into believing a lie. And it's amazing that the same people propagating that lie and crying out for the rights of those enemy combatant detainees, remain conspicuously silent when the people the terrorists capture are all systematically tortured and beheaded -- all of them. You're worried about the rights of the wrong people, my friend.

And no, our constitution does not protect the terrorists, but rather demands that our leaders protect the nation from them.

I ask you again, who's playing politics with our nation's defense? I say the Democrat Party -- 100 percent. And it is, without question, the most shameful thing I've ever witnessed in my entire life.

by tony hopkinson

You me, Nick, everyone, how can we not?

When is it shameful? when we make it so, by denying that we are.

How can you not have a political viewpoint about defense, why is one side playing and the other not?
Everybody agrees defense of the nation is a serious matter, so are the means, however there isn't as much agreement on those is there.

I watched your president on tv this morning, not sure how effective his speech was, I doubt he brought many who don't agree with the means he's chosen round to his political point of view.

For those who don't know I'm a brit, which is why I said 'your' president, otherwise I would have been bound to say ours, no matter how uncomfortable that made me.

by jdclyde

Max said [b]"And no, our constitution does not protect the terrorists, but rather demands that our leaders protect the nation from them."[/b]

That deserved to stand alone, because that one sentence says it all.

Edited because it is the fashionable thing to do these days.

by nicknielsen

But you seem to have missed my point entirely. At no point did I hint that I don't think this is serious, nor did I even hint that I think this is a short-term thing. Nor did I mention abuse, "can't we all just get along," or almost anything else in your rant. I simply addressed the attempts of the President to deny the detainees the same due process rights guaranteed to Americans.

It's a matter of principle, Max. I think that [b]no matter who, no matter what, no matter where[/b], we should apply the principles and protections of the Constitution, war or no war. That's one of the reasons I spent 24 years in the uniform of my country.

The President's attempts to build his military tribunals to allow hearsay evidence and deny the defendant the ability to review all evidence against him ride roughshod over the rules of evidence. This will be an American court. These people, regardless of who they may be or what they may have done deserve a fair trial. The ability of the accused to challenge the charges against them should not be hindered in any way. Anything less makes us less.

by x-marcap

These people should be treated by the Geneva Convention. By the very letter. Since they hide themselves in with the general population they are not wearing uniforms, they are using explosive devices, they are spies and saboteurs. By the very words of the Geneva convention.

They have the right to be tortured, or executed on capture by the non-com or officer in charge, Anything we do to them is basically legal. They are outside the protection of the Geneva convention.

Any population that does not expose these individuals within their midst or gives them succor (love that word) is subject to the same treatment...

by x-marcap

These people should be treated by the Geneva Convention. By the very letter. Since they hide themselves in with the general population they are not wearing uniforms, they are using explosive devices, they are spies and saboteurs. By the very words of the Geneva convention.
< by this I mean the foreign terrorists, non-Iraqis, the collaborators are in the same bed.>

They have the right to be tortured, or executed on capture by the non-com or officer in charge, Anything we do to them is basically legal. They are outside the protection of the Geneva convention. < Read the lack of protection on saboteurs, they are not really a protected species>

Any population that does not cooperate and expose these individuals within their midst and/or gives them succor (love that word) is (and should be) subject to the same treatment as sympathizers...

by protiusx

become applicable to the entire world? Our constitution applies to our government and our citizenry. The people in Gitmo are at best associates of Terrorists and are at worst Terrorists themselves. I think the President should have authorized Military tribunal a long time ago, hung them and got on with the war. Heavy handed force is all these people understand. They are not respecters of life. You may sit there in your chair and wax eloquently about a persons constitutional rights but if the situation was reversed (as it has been on a few occasions) they don't quibble with whether or not the ""detainee" is being treated well or not. Their only concern is how to inflict the most amount of pain before cutting off the "detainee?s" head.

by jdclyde

we could explain to them that we really want to be best friends with them, and that we really are sorry for everything.

Don't you think if we pull every soldier out of the middle ease, force Israel to give up all lands and move to the artic or something, and give them lots of governmental aid, that we could all be best friends and dance in the flowers together?

Oh wait, I forgot. "kill the infadels", not "dandce in the flowers with the infadels". I get those mixed up all the time.

There was a time I believed that Democrats were good people with bad ideas. Many (especially the ones that have hijacked the party) are really lowering that opinion.

by maxwell edison

Of course everything has political implications; and of course those implications are considered. But it appears to me that you and I are defining "playing politics" differently. A person is not "playing politics" when he/she acts on principle, and just let's the chips fall where they may. If you believe that the path President Bush has been following concerning the war against terrorism has been based on "playing politics" instead of following principle, we must be living on different planets.

I would have the exact same position on this war (and so would President Bush) if the most liberal Democrat was running it. In my opinion, this war should be supported, especially by those in positions of power (because they know better) in a similar manner to how President Roosevelt was supported during W.W.II. These people (Democrats) are simply out to destroy President Bush and regain their lost power, and they compromising national security and the United States' reputation in the process, setting aside principle for political expediency -- and that is what I consider shameful. The only prominent Democrat who's not is Senator Joe Lieberman.

If you (or Nick) want to start listing specific examples of how "each side" is "playing politics", my list could be hundreds of examples long. Why don't you start, however, and list only a few of your examples. No rhetoric please, and support any assertion with clear and indisputable facts. You made the statement, now it's time to prove it or back-off from it.

by jdclyde

how many nutjobs in THIS country that won't say "our" president, because they are still chasing shadows and pipe dreams as well as flat out telling lies about the validity of the last TWO elections. The do not have the same HONOR that you have. Yet one more thing this country is losing quickly is that sence of decentcy and honor that makes up the character of a man or woman.

These people will all the time shrilly SCREAM how stupid President Bush is, yet they give him credit for "stealing" Two elections in a row with never a single bit of evidence to show anything was done illegally by the man. They make him out to be a MASTER MIND! B-)

Listen to what "they" say, and tell me it could have been accomplished by someone they LOVE to hatefully call "stupid".

No honor, no dignity. Sad.

by jdclyde

because this is exactly the way you handle international incidents, with international laws.

I can not understand the mentality to give an enemy that will not be happy until we are dead, any kind of an advantage, just to "prove we are better". Especially when all they see is this as proof that we are weaker, and more at risk now.

by maxwell edison

.....can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to an attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be provided for you. Do you understand there rights, Mr. bin Laden?

In times of war, things are different. If you, as a retired soldier, don't understand that, you missed an awful lot. You said you, "think that no matter who, no matter what, no matter where, we should apply the principles and protections of the Constitution, war or no war."[/i] To that, I suggest you're crazy.

I can just see it now. Let's take your sentiment to the extreme, and imagine that Osama bin Laden is surrounded by five thousand U.S. Marines. They're preparing to rush the compound and either capture or kill him. But wait, do they have a warrant? Let's call one of those nice federal judges, perhaps one sitting on a bench in Boston or San Francisco, and ask for a warrant. Assuming we get our warrant, and assuming some ACLU lawyer doesn't take the request to an appeals court (perhaps even the 9th Circuit Federal Court of Appeals), after we capture him, those Marines better read Mr. bin Laden (a little respectfulness there, you know, for the "innocent until proven guilty") his Miranda rights. If they don't, that's a technicality worthy of dismissing all charges against him.

And let's make sure that all instances in which a soldier kills an enemy combatant was justified, and he wasn't exercising undo force. Police Officers must surrender their weapon and undergo at least an internal investigation every time they fire their weapon, much less kill somebody, so why not the same treatment for soldiers on the battlefield?

And while we're at it........ never mind, I think I've gone far enough.

Yes, my illustration is stretched to the absurd. But it started with your own absurd comment suggesting that this is tantamount to a civil action and the enemy is afforded rights under our Constitution and in our courts.

This is a WAR. It's not a civil matter. Military rules of engagement, and military rules of judgement should apply, not civil rules. This matter DOES NOT belong in the American courts. I challenge you to name even one foreign enemy combatant of World War II who was tried in an American civilian court.

P.S. Since we're discussing different ways of defining the same thing (such as "playing politics"), we must also have a different definition of rant. If you think my message was a rant, you missed the whole meaning. But then again, it's obvious you miss a lot to begin with.

by Member 25348569

Erm? That would be you, then?

:D

Just a tiny bit disappointing, though. All it needed was the prefix "crypto" in there somewhere and we would have had you bang to rights!

by Member 25348569

Just one small point. OK, just one HUGE point.

They may be doing everything that you say "hide themselves in with the general population they are not wearing uniforms, they are using explosive devices" but they're not actually doing it in [b]your[/b] country. In the case of Afghanistan and in the case of Iraq, they are doing it in a country that the US invaded.

That "population that does not expose these individuals within their midst or gives them succor" have the right to do whatever they want in their own country!

I'm not saying that you need to treat them in any particular nice way but if you want to observe the rules of the Geneva convention then you really ought to get out of Iraq, at least.

C'mon, Tim. Stop feeding me such easy comebacks!

Neil :)

by Member 25348569

You're not trying to prove to terrorist organisations that you are better than them. You are trying to prove it - or you would be if you had an ounce of sense - to all of those nations who are supicious of the US and uncommitted to any side.

Prove your superior moral code to Jordan, Turkey, Malaysia and all those non-Muslim countries who are suspicious of your motives and seriously scared of your methods. Prove that you practice what you preach.

Neil :)

by maxwell edison

You said that you believe the US (and Britain) should get out of Iraq. All other arguments aside, assume we do just that. Assume we pack up today, and get the hell outta' Dodge .... (Sorry, I'm wearing my cowboy hat and got carried away!) ..... I mean Baghdad, lock stock and barrel. Look into your crystal ball and tell us what will happen if we do. And please expand on your answer by telling us what would happen if we just abandoned the entire region.

(I know, you actually said that if we, "observe the rules of the Geneva convention then you really ought to get out of Iraq." I'm assuming, therefore, that you believe we should get out of Iraq. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.)

by tig2

Or at least that is where I think he was going. EDIT- Not right vs left. Should have clarified. Takes an idiot to PLAY an idiot so convincingly. End EDIT

We started watching it last night. Raises all kinds of memories. Some of it is hard to watch.

Shirley Douglas certainly DID make Madeline Albright look like an a$$.

Only through the first 1.5 hours. Took a break to watch the President's speech.

by tig2

We recorded the President's speech as we were recording Part Two. I'm still mulling. I'll likely watch it again. Last night we were both in tears watching some of the rememberance coverage. It is still very painful to watch.

Unquestionably, great delivery. That was one of the best I have seen him deliver.

I think that Tim Russert nailed it though when he said that it would be perceived as using the tragedy of 9/11 to validate the war. I can see how he came to that observation. I don't agree with it.

I don't know that I have agreed with the war. I was a Navy wife through Gulf One and I always believed that we'd end up going back. I guess I felt that there was more validity to Afghanistan- that one I could understand- it was where the known enemy was last seen.

I know that there may be many who disagree with me, I think that Saddam, while a scum sucking bottom dweller, provided a level of stability (!). At least insofar as the various factions were concerned. Does that mean that leaving him alone was the right thing? Not particularly. But dividing the front, again- my opinion- was not the right thing at the time. And I think it will have repercussions.

I have agreed for years that Americans have no stomach for prolonged conflict- and that is not sufficient reason to avoid it when it is required. But I have very mixed feelings about Iraq- and can't say that they are all based in reason. To some extent, they are emotionally based.

I did feel that the content of Bush's message struck a very delicate balance. He had to address the war and do so in context. I felt that he managed that well.

by jamesrl

They used a "insert word" to play one....

I've never been a fan of her acting either..a bit over the top.

James

by Member 25348569

OK, Max. These are my thoughts on Iraq before I come to getting out.

One way that I differ from a lot of people - certainly those on this board - is that I reckon that nationalism seems to be totally misunderstood and underestimated by the Pentagon in Iraq and Afghanistan exactly as they did in Vietnam. It's a hugely significant force in Iraq today as well as the Islamic fundamentalism that we all seem to fear. If it wasn't for the sectarian Shi'ite-Sunni conflict, the US would be [b]really[/b] in trouble.

What we appear to have have is a set of objectives for the US in Iraq which are founded on a very American ideology and not on Iraqi aspirations which makes them pretty much unattainable because they go against Iraqi nationalism. I'm convinced that the US wants long-term strategic military bases and surely counts on retaining significant influence over Iraqi oil policy. Just as you've done everywhere else you've had influence or leverage, you favour unrestricted foreign investment. Iraq has a past history of intense hostility toward alien ownership of the country's economy and resources. Also, the US government would count it a monumental failure if "New Iraq" did not support America's role in the Middle East peace process even when it would mean aligning Iraqi policy with that of Ariel Sharon. That is just [b]not[/b] going to happen.

I can't see any way that the US Administration can modify those objectives to meet reality.

So, we arrive at today! We "can't leave" and we have to "support our troops" and the two statements, by the way, are pretty much incompatible! Just as an aside, this is extremely irritating for those of us who opposed the war as we find ourselves blackmailed into signing up for the project ("stay the course") because the very mistake we warned against was made.

"Failure is not an option". The point about failure is that it might be an option forced upon you but an option it is! Learn the lesson of Vietnam.

Staying in Iraq cannot benefit Iraq as each additional day that American and British troops fight in Iraq can, in the end, only cost more lives, Allied and Iraqi, disorganise the society further and reduce the chances for a better future for the country. What we have to do is cease all combat operations and, on a pre-announced and fixed timetable, get out. It is a simple fact that if the place goes to ruin without our presence, it would surely have done so with us there. It's so tragic that Israel was encouraged to trash Lebanon and that a UN peace-keeping force that could have got us out of Iraq is now being squandered to carry out the designs of Israel.

Unfortunately, we have to pay at many levels. We have to continue any economic assistance and make it so, so clear that we want nothing back - no strings whatsoever - and that way we might actually get something. So what if the Iraqis are corrupt? They're still cheaper than Halliburton! We should help international organisations - if that means the UN then so be it - in any way we can to help the transition to a new political order. We may only offer help to whatever degree is wanted by the local people and we may only speak when spoken to. Better, in fact, if we just back off and keep quiet. Tell you though, USD 10billion, no strings attached, will buy you a lot more cooperation that a military presence costing five times as much. What you also cannot do is just hand over to the UN, withdraw support and funding and then blame the UN when they fail. Actually, I believe that the General assembly rather than the Security Council should be the controlling Transitional Body.

Whatever government they form you [b]must[/b] accept it. It's theirs and not yours. Even a Shi'ite theocracy if that's what happens. You have proclaimed the principles of democracy and self-determination and so you have to abide by whatever results.

Unfortunately, it has to be seen as a US defeat simply because democracy is now associated with bloodshed in the minds of Iraqis. I don't know what will happen; maybe democracy and human rights will take a generation, but there is so much resentment and fatalism in the Middle East that they need something to accept that change might be possible. Face it, you got defeated in Vietnam but the South East Asian Dominoes never fell. The US remained the worlds's major power.

by x-marcap

Most of the terrorists in Lebanon were Syrian, Iranian, and Saudi, and in Iraq it is mostly Saudi and Syrians...

They predominantly aren't Iraqis currently.

The are spies and saboteurs, along with what is now collaborators against their own government and her allies.

I have riposted your opening. Shall we dance some more?

by Member 25348569

"Most of the terrorists in Lebanon were Syrian, Iranian, and Saudi" I really need the source of your information. I am going to go away and find my own sources. I can believe that most of the financing came from Shi'ite Syria and Iran but I can't believe that [b]anything[/b] would have come from EXTREMELY Sunni Saudi. Sources I've seen have Hezbollah down as local Lebanese Shi'ites which is why Israel can't try and kick them out like they did the PLO. Hezbollah came out of local resistance to the previous Israeli invasion when they did kick out the PLO and then overstayed their welcome (see the resemblance to something).

"and in Iraq it is mostly Saudi and Syrians..." Again, I think we have propaganda that focuses on foreign elements as an attempt to undermine the legitimacy of the insurgency in the eyes of Iraqis. The Allies are portraying the problems as terrorism foisted on the country by outsiders. It should be easy enough to ferret out the truth.

The BBC - "Fighters range from former figures in Saddam Hussein's Baath party to Sunni nationalists fearing Shia domination and foreign Islamist fighters who see Iraq as an arena for a global struggle against the West. The incentives are equally disparate - religious zeal, economic gain, nationalist feeling and anger at the loss of loved ones.

Estimates of the number of insurgents are impossible to confirm.

By 2006, US military estimates ranged from 8,000 to 20,000, although Iraqi intelligence officials have issued figures as high as 40,000 fighters plus another 160,000 supporters.

Fighters have been found among the insurgents from countries including Syria, Saudi Arabia, Yemen and Sudan but foreign nationals are widely considered to account for less than 10% of the insurgency. Their role is high profile."

Hmmmmm...

"The are spies and saboteurs, along with what is now collaborators against their own government and her allies." So, maybe some truth but the legitimacy and credentials of the partly US-imposed government and, most importantly, its real power, will be what finally defines who is a saboteur.

Neil

Over to you...

by too old for it

TWICE by the governemnt of Yemen, who wanted him off the block as much as anyone. Clinton said no.

Instead, Slick Willie was more concerned with getting a Lewinsky and keeping Hillary from finding out.

Of course, if I was in a position with Hillary being in power, I'd be on guard to keep her from finding out anything. Damn, she is one scary person.

by too old for it

Ollie North had told the world that Osama bin Laden was the world's most dangerous man YEARS before.

The Clinton administration (among other things) had no institutional memory.

Unfortunately after Bush the First caved on taxes, vast numbers of the electorate would have voted for a McDonalds Happy Meal if it wasn't running on the Rupublican ticket.

(No disrespect to McDonalds Happy Meals intended.)

by x-marcap

All he had to do was do what was right, keep his oath (Hillary, You get the same treatment as the rest of us in that manner), to protect the country against all enemies foreign and domestic.

Since he had the opportunities to get Osama after the first WTC bombing, it was his desire to have a calm presidency and not to have to deal with the situation and pass it to his successors that we had the 911 incident...

by maxwell edison

Anyone who says "it's only sex", and should therefore be dismissed as personal business are wrong on two counts.

Firstly, it (impeachment) was about perjury and obstruction of justice, not about sex.

Secondly, on having sex with an intern in such a way, especially for a person in his position, it's actually putting national security at risk. Not only was it a huge distraction (both the acts and the cover-ups) that was tantamount to dereliction of duty, but it was a classic set-up scenario for blackmail. Not that Monica would have set him up, but someone else who might have become privy to the behavior. (In fact, how do we know something like that didn't happen?)

When I was stationed at NORAD, which required a top secret security clearance, we had briefings and such all the time warning us that our clearances could be stripped, and we could possibly face dismissal from our jobs, if we put ourselves in such compromising positions. Any lower-level G.I. with access to sensitive information would have been canned if he was caught doing such a thing. In my opinion, a president having sex with an intern in such a way SHOULD BE an impeachable offense, in and of itself.

by absolutely

The Constitution does not provide for elected officials to have power over the media. Entertainment is a business, and in the United States, it is to respond to a [b]free[/b] market. These Democrats are violating the spirit of the free prees and of free speech, ignoring the same document they accuse GWB of ignoring when it is convenient for [b]him[/b].

by jdclyde

at least no one is surprised by it. This is very typical behavior for the heads of the Democratic party.

by x-marcap

I would have to suspect that it is. (This is our only real measurable pool of actual known combatants.) At Gitmo there are (by the report) 1268 prisoners by this report. 746 are Saudi, 211 are Syrian. 48 are Iranian. That is more than the Iranians. 113 refuse to be identified except by tribe. This comes from Amnesty International USA. Watch out they try to get you to donate...

http://www.kintera.org/site/c.goJTI0OvElH/b.1868559/k.38DB/GuantanamogoJTI0OvElH&b=1868559&en=giKIIZNKJaJIKWMFIbJIIWOFInJ3JbOGLgKWI8NOIgIRIbOYG

That is a known pool. I can accept these as
a valid population to be extrapolated from, Is that acceptable to you. I have seen these numbers other places, Is this population large enough for you statistically?

by Member 25348569

I have no idea where most of those were captured. I also have absolutely no evidence whatsoever that any of them are terrorists as you seem somewhat shy of actually trying any of them. given that then I do need evidence that pertains specifically to Iraq. As I said, the BBC report quotes ten percent foreigners although it does suggest that a good number of these are organisers, trainers and recruiters and therefore of more prominence.

by jdclyde

the email that is bouncing around about when they were questioning Ollie about his security system, he did name a terrorist, but it wasn't Ben Laden. During Iran/Contra, he was still a minor player.

by jdclyde

First of all, being better than them does not mean being stupid and tying our soldiers hands and making them fight the dogs that hide in temples and schools, in hopes to outrage other mindless dogs when the soldiers RETURN fire.

We follow the letter of the law, as put forward in the geneva convention.

WE do not randomly cut their heads off.

WE do not rape the women and kill the kids.

WE do not take innocent men out and kill them.

WE come down hard everytime an abuse by OUR troops is done, transperently and quickly.

THAT is how and why we are better than the terrorist dogs that boobytrap bodies in DIRECT violation of the geneva convention. They do not wear a uniform so they can hide among the citizens, again in violation.

There is nothing about being stupid enough to treat them like Americans citizens in the Geneva convention, and that is now what would make us "better" than them.

You will remember, that is why there IS a Geneva convention, so there will be a uniform set of rules of engagement, as well as a uniform set of rules of how to deal with the combatants when and where they are found.

The fact that people in our Democratic party are completely clueless about that, does not change anything. There is also nothing in our Constitution to indicate that OUR consitution applys to anyone but Citizens that live UNDER that constitution.

Just like "you" could not charge an insurgent with a UK law if he is committing his agressions in Iraq. There is ONLY Iraqie law and the geneva convention that have ANY jurisdiction to prosecute them.

by jdclyde

As obviously it is only they that have unquestionable freedom of speech, and it is their patriotic duty to question each and everything the President does.

by jdclyde

That was the million MOM walk that had the pathetic turnout and was not supported by the general population. It really was criminal they way the media in general covered it.

It was the Promise Keepers that well overflowed the area.

by maxwell edison

No, he never did say that ObL was the world's most dangerous man. He supposedly said it in the Iran-Contra Senate hearings, but it's a myth.

by maxwell edison

This is an area that we (as a nation) haven't really had to face before, nor has it been properly addressed. It's new ground for us.

On one hand, I consider this a war, not a civil action for law enforcement. (If anyone disagrees with that comment, stop right here and make your argument. If you don't stop here and make your argument, you are conceding that this IS a war, not a civil law enforcement matter.) On the other hand, it's not a conventional-type war against a nation-state, but rather a war against an organization (or organizations, I should say) not formally attached to any particular nation-state, and whose sole purpose is to wage war.

I actually consider these people prisoners of war, because that's exactly what they are. And prisoners of war ARE NOT entitled to due-process in our civil system of law. And prisoners of war ARE DEFINITELY NOT entitled to protections afforded to American citizens under our Constitution. I'm dumfounded that otherwise intelligent people would even suggest such a thing.

In all wars, combatants are captured, and they are subsequently put into POW camps (or shot by despot-led nations) where they sit and wait for the war to end. They would either be liberated by their own victorious forces, or returned to their home nation after that nation's defeat. POWs aren't given trials. POWs aren't given visitation rights. POWs aren't given lawyers to defend them. POWs should be given meals and a place to be locked up, no more, no less -- and they ARE subjected to interrogation and such.

How long are these POWs going to be held? As long as the war wages? That could be decades. And there certainly won't be a liberating force to free them.

I won't disagree that there are questions that should be addressed and procedures decided upon. And as such, I believe this is a perfect opportunity for the United Nations to step-up and do something in this regard -- but they would first have to stand firm against any and all terrorist activities (more than the lip-service of the past decades). Unfortunately, there are United Nations members sympathetic to terrorists.

One thing that is clouding the issue, however, is the constant barrage of charges levied by the president's political enemies (and advanced by the media) about prisoner abuse and such. It's absolutely absurd. And it's equally absurd to suggest these POWs deserve due-process under American civil laws. In my opinion, if we err, we should err on the side of caution, and consider them prisoners for the duration of the war -- however long that might be.

by tony hopkinson

a politician when they say they are acting on principle, I want to see them doing it.
I want to see what they are prepared to sacrifice to keep a principle.

Not familiar enough with US poltics

Tony Benn gave up his hereditary peerage, because he believed he should be elected to power not get it as a birthright.

Lord Carrington held himself responsible for missing the Falklands war. He resigned his office.

Sir Robin Cook, resigned over the war in iraq, making Tony Blair his political enemy until hell froze over.

Words don't mean crap to me, deeds do though. I don't agree with many of the things these men believe in or believed in, in Cook's case. I can respect them though, a personal principle was more important than power or class or party.

I don't trust politicians, I don't believe in politicians, I have very little respect for 99% of politicians. Polictics is the art of expediency, so the only time I respect them is when they aren't

As for your president or my prime minister, you can respect the office without respecting the person in it.

by tony hopkinson

I can barely think of a single issue that I agree with him on. He made president though, as you say twice, a stupid person could not manage that, not even with help.

As for your and our, the office demands respect whether the person in it does or not.

One of the true advantages of a non political effectively powerless head of state that by the way, you can attack policy without disrespecting the office. When dealing with americans I somethimes forget that distinction doesn't exist for you.

by oz_media

Firstly, before I reply to the post, what you say is a Bill Clinton letter infers that the letter was written by Clinton. It wasn't, it was by lawyers with the Clinton Foundation, not Bill Clinton himself. How much influence HE had on this particular letter we don't know, it could have been fullyhis comments, it could have been written without his knowledge but on his behalf.

Looking at all the typos, I am surprised nobody accuse dme of writign it, I assume these are the webmasters errors though as they are not marked with the [i](SIC)[/i] when quoting a mispelled statement without correction.

Anyhow....
To get to the matter at hand, yes I find it hypocritical, from both sides. ANY press whether right or left, positive or negative should have freedom to air. If the people watching are too stupid or politically focused to pic it apart and take it for what it is then that is a diferent issue. The program should air, and people should take what they can from it.

Personal experience here has shown me that no matter what it says or shows, people watching it will all have a predetermined conclusion anyway and would only discount what they don't like to hear and follow what they voted for, no matter what political preference they have.

I sincerely doubt th amajority of Americans woul dwatch this with an open mind or interest in learning from both sides anyway.

At this point what have you got to lose? You aren't going to create more problems for yourselves or solve thos eyou have. It's typical political docudrams, whether left focused or right, take it for what it is, you just may learn something new.

by maxwell edison

I didn't infer anything about, what I called, "A Bill Clinton letter". You know as well as I do (perhaps even better than I do) that a lawyer speaks on behalf of his client. If Clinton's lawyer said it, Bill Clinton said it by association. Regardless, I posted all the letters and articles without comment. I let them all stand on their own merit and in their entirety. For anyone to suggest that I inferred anything is reading too much into what I didn't say.

by oz_media

Well the comment on Clinton was only a brief comment that YOU TOO would have offered to correct anyone's slight variation from absolute fact. YOu do it all the time, it's not nit-picking in your case though, it is called providing the real facts and getting rid of left wing BS.

Anyhow, seeing as you claim you didn't infer it was Clinton's letter, here's what you did say (thus more than inferred, I was being nice).

Quote from your post "And a Bill Clinton letter to ABC:

http://electioncentral.tpmcafe.com/blog/electioncentral/2006/sep/09/in_new_letter_clintons_lawyer_dema"

NO....saying "And a Bill Clinton letter to ABC" does not infer that the letter was written by Bill Clinton at all does it? (In a republican's world maybe) I am sure it was a general feeling by anyone reading your post that a letter you linked to was written by or on behalf of Bill Clinton.

Now as for lawyers speaking for somebody, you are somewhat right but somewhat wrong also.

The letter is NOT initialled as written by somebody on his behalf, as any legal document would. Was this haphazardly missed by the webmaster who added all the typos, even though he added full writers credit at the footer, that didn't mention Bill Clinton as a contributor at all? Even the body of the letter itself didnt' say Bill Clinton said that or even thought that.

As for the letter writers, while they are both lawyers and formerly represented Clinton (B. Lindsey) in a questionable legal battle for evidence regarding the Monica Lewinsky scandal, where nobody retained any credibility; I don't believe he has actually been acting as Clinton's lawyer since that last account.

He appears to have taken more of an inactive, yet advisory role these days, from the Clinton Foundation site and a few quick searches anyway.

Bottom line, neither quoted Clinton, neither signed the document on Clinton's behalf.

It was a document written by people close to Clinton who chose to speak, PERHAPS, on his
behalf.

In such a case of someone providing links as evidence to support a comment, the credibility and accuracy of that information is imperative, as you know. (Or do we now accept anyone's comments as posted?)

Remeber the old Maxwell's constant corrections of "GWB didn't ACTUALLY say that", someone on his staff did. In that case, do these pople not also speak on his behalf and with his best interests in mind, just as those who wrote the letter you claim is Clinton's?

It's a case of the most obvious 'changing the rules to suit your own agenda'. Or to be more blunt, hypocrisy.

Seeing as you chose to reply to my opening comments and not the focus of my post, I decided to dwell on your inaccuracies. Now that is nit picking! But that's what we do when we are at TR, we nit pick to change the focus of the post. I think I learned it from all you republicans.

by jdclyde

Are there some events too important to have people, namely hollywood (why is the only thing I think of is the Japanese guy looking up in 1941 as the sub is going down and sees the babe?) play fast and easy with who did and said what?

Not is it legal, is it proper?

-----------------------------

Should organizations that never said a peep when Moore came out with his hack pieces that he actually CALLS documentaries now step up and complain? Does this not shine a big light on these organizations that are usually "free speech no matter what", until now?

-------------------------

Lastly, as you said, people will go in with their own beliefs already. What disagrees with those beliefs will be discounted and what they agree with will be latched onto as fact. A year from now, someone will try to use a line from that movie as why everything bad is Clintons/Bushs fault. That will be sad.

----------------------

I disagree with the ethics of them making the show like they did, I agree they have the legal right to show it if they wish.

by protiusx

It was sad. It brought back a lot of memories of that day as I remember watching the second plane hit the second tower. I remember watching as both of them came down and I remember the tears I shed that day for the families of all those people killed. It was senseless. There is nothing anyone can say that can justify it in anyway.

I can't get into the details of how and when but I had the opportunity to meet and hear from one of the authors of the 911 commission who detailed what they believed led up to the attacks on that day, how our immediate response was pathetic and how our government continues to fail at certain tasks that would cause it to become more efficient at the war on terror.

I think the movie bore out the facts pretty well. Clinton did have the opportunity to take Osama and chose not to. I am in no way a supporter of slick Willy but I am not so naive to think he was so shallow as to only be able to think about the skirts he was going to chase (Monica not withstanding).

He made a lot of mistakes during his tenure and in my humble opinion was the worst president to have ever held the office. He was a car salesman who was elected twice and impeached with impunity. He's not called "slick Willy" for nothing.

Ultimately, we were attacked because the US became weak. We showed all through the 90's that we didn't have the stomach to do what is needed to protect ourselves and indeed became that paper tiger. So, Osama bloodied our nose. What did we do about it? Well what has become the war on terror may not suite some but I don't think we've gone far enough. We need to be ruthless and brutal to those nations that harbor those who have attacked us or would attack us. We (like Israel) need to strike back in such a way as to make any other terrorists think twice before attacking us again.

by tony hopkinson

He made an oath before his family and friends and his god to his life partner and then broke it.

Instant DQ in my book too, I aren't daft enough to trust a politician anyway, but I at least expect lip service to the concept.

Hmmm lip service, another metaphor required I think.

LOL

by jdclyde

In front of the world stood an angry, tight jawed man "I never had sexual relations with THAT WOMAN".

Why did this even COME UP? Because he was already defending himself for sexual harrassment and the feminists rolled over like the b!tches they were while he rubbed their bellies. Anyone else and they would have been out for blood.

How many times did we fire off a few missles, at key points in the trial? Sickens me to think he killed people just to draw attention away from his problems cause by his lack of character. But that is just fine because people of lesser honesty have convinced themselves he was impeached over a blowjob.

Has anyone else seen the bumpersticker "will someone give Bush a Blowjob so we can get him out of office?" These people are so stupid that first they think that is clever, and second because they believe it!

But they are correct about one thing. Character doesn't matter, or at least it doesn't if you are a Democrat. A republican has an affair and he is done. a Democrat does it, no one is surprised and who cares?

by oz_media

The left is no better or worse than the right when it comes to spewing BS about the other party.

Any American with any semblence of a brainin his head would see that neither side is all peaches and cream. You guys spend so much time here slagging th edemocrats and spewing your right wing propaganda, it's no different than the left.

YOu couldn't possibly be arrogant or stupid enough to try and contest that everything the right says is right or reighteous and the left is just wrong and underhanded all the time about everything.

The problem with US politics is teh sides are extreme enemies/opposites, if you guys got together and found some middle ground, you really COULD be a super power, not just a questionable one.

As a copmplete stranger said to me the other day (it was a comment due to a news clip playing in a cafe'), with 330 million single-minded morons in the country, how did America ever become a super power?

To me, you could be so much more but unfortunately have become divided by your own media.

A country politically divided within itself, while trying to propose unity and democracy worldwide, what ever happened to the "United" states?

Now you are forced to breach our own Constitution because the parties won't agree to air all news, whether good or bad for both sides? And I am told over and over again, that your news is not censored? Leave the country for a while and see what the rest of the world does.

I am just glad I get fairly free news from canada, we really do get the good and the bad about our government from the same channel so we can weigh the odds ourselves (whether we feel it is BS or not), not just one line of BS vs another where we choose what to believe and what to discount based on how we voted.

by thechas

I stay out of the discussions for a few months, and you jump at least 6 steps to the right!

Just what has the Bush Administration accomplished?

Respect for the US, and our global political clout are approaching historic lows.

The countries that threaten global peace and stability are emboldened by our military being bogged down in Iraq. Be it Iran, North Korea, Hezbolah, Venezuela or Cuba, all are taking bold steps flexing their muscle in ways they could not if they thought the US had the strength and will to retaliate.

I take no solace in the lack of terrorist attacks in the US over the past 5 years. Considering both the amount of time it took to prepare and execute the attack of 5 years ago, and that our foreign policy has geometrically increased the number of individuals intent on raining terror and destruction on US citizens and interests.

Looking domestically, has GWB faired any better than he has in Iraq?

The Bush administration can't even piece together a domestic agenda that their own party will stand behind!

Immigration reform is going nowhere.

Social Security reforms did not even make it to the table.

Heck, the Republican controlled Congress is so desperate to make any of the tax cuts permanent that they are willing to tie tax cuts to an increase in the minimum wage!

While the CEO's and other top executives have been blessed with double and triple digit wage increases, those of us who actually work for a living continue to loose ground as the cost of necessities rise many times faster than wages.

I do not know of any among my friends or family who are in the same, let alone a better financial position than they were in 2000.

Besides, aren't even you getting tired of GWB coming out and crying terrorism, terrorism as the only way to shore up his pole numbers and any chance the Republican party has of keeping control of Congress in November?

So long as the Bush Administration remains committed to the folly in Iraq, they have no choice but to play politics with it. Even as poorly as the war in Iraq is going, it is the greatest accomplishment of the Bush Administration.

How sad to have thrown away the lives of 3000 young men and women for a country that does not care enough about democracy to fight for it themselves.

Chas

by x-marcap

And I defend his right to say stupid things. He has the right to say what he wants. However, I reserve the right to oppose him at the top of my voice, but nobody has to listen to us. That is freedom of speech, and freedom of choice.

The Left tends to use government as a force to limit whatever speech it dislikes. See the hate speech, hate crime legislations as a reference... The issue is the leftist Democrats (not all Dems) is wrong on those issues.

I think the moderate Republicans are wrong as they will not persue criminal acts from leaders of the left, nor support the pursuit. Currently, I am writing my congressmen, and the federal prosecutors to have Fraud and Theft in Office charges leveled at Fitzgerald.