Discussion Locked

Okay all you "Free Speech" people - comments?

0 helpful
202 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

202 replies

by jdclyde

first of all, The people that have hijacked the Democratic party have no character, and no class. Respect is not something they even think about, because they got where they are by giving away government funds, not respect.

The way the mindless masses are motivated is through emotion, specificaly hate. The easiest emotion to use to get people motivated. John Kerry lost the last election because he ran on "Not being Bush". Until they become a party that stands FOR something, and gives the people something to vote FOR, instead of against, they will continue to lose more and more political "power".

They scream at the top of their lungs that President Bush has caused a divide in this country and it is more divided than ever before. Then they turn around and say they lost the election because they were not liberal ENOUGH. That they need to move the party MORE to the left. Who does that sound like is causing the divide?

It will be interesting to see what happens at the next presidential election. They won't have Bush Hate to rally around, and will have to invent new reasons to hate new people. What a pathetic way to live.

by oz_media

NO it is not 'proper' but it is expected and understood by most of the world's population, I hope.

Hopefully, people are smart enough in the 21st century to realize what the news says, what the papers say, what the documentaries say and even what the politicians say, MUST be taken with a grain of salt.

If people choose ot believe one side without first looking at and comparing views from all sides and all countries/sources, ot is only their own fault if they are discouraged, upset, offended or deluded.

Are you suggesting that laws are passed to ensure that the naiive are not fooled by the media?

Perhaps a rating system such as we se in movies and now even video games?

Shall we have our government's clean up the media so we only see news that is morally acceptable? If so, to who's standards?

Why can't people be expected to sift through and watch what they choose to watch?

It's like the American network broadcasts of movies, they are all clipped and bleeped andedited to a point where some movies don't evenmake any sense.

Take The Breakfast Club, they are all sworn enemies, absolute opposites with nothing in common. The US network TV version has it go to commercial while they are arguing and then they are happily sitting around having a deep discussion on each persons individual hurdles in life.

The REAL versionhas them grudgingly follow John Bender to his locker, where he gets weed and they all go back and smoke it..again withmuch reservation as they are not compfrtable with each other. THEN they go andhave a deep discussion.

With the edit it removes all meaning and context of teh psychological hurdles they beat to come together and arrange to write the detention paper.

But this is removed in US network versions because SOMEONE decided it was wrong to show them taking drugs and communicating while able toset differences aside.

Who's morals will decide what is political news and what is political slander? Who will it be four years later when the tables turn again?

YOu either allow freedom of press or you control it. You (the USA) have proven that partial military and political censorship results in two divided political sides that simply won't accept a word the other says.

I thought you were against government control and all for freedom.

by maxwell edison

The intent of a comment I posted in my original message (which really had no intent at all) was apparently elusive to some, so this is to correct my blunder.

President Clinton did not write the letter to which I linked, but rather his lawyers did. Whether those Clinton lawyers were speaking on the former president's behalf or on their own, is something on which I offer no speculation. (But feel free to speculate all you'd like.)

And while former President Clinton did not pen that actual letter, he did utter the following words:

"I think they ought to tell the truth, particularly if they're going to claim it's based on the 9/11 commission's report," Clinton told reporters in Arkansas on Thursday. .... "They shouldn't have scenes that are directly contradictory to the factual findings of the 9/11 commission. I just want people to tell the truth .... I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Ms. Lewinski...." (Whoops, I got my quotes mixed up! Sorry 'bout that!)

http://www.cnn.com/2006/SHOWBIZ/TV/09/08/abc.movie/index.html

by absolutely

Very mature. I hope the crowd will follow your lead, and discuss free speech, and whether criticism of journalism and/or entertainment by elected officials equals de facto government censorship. Or, did I misinterpret the intent of your opening post?

by tonythetiger

That they started with the 9/11 commissions's report and added information from other sources? As to additional sources that contradict the 'base' source, I should imagine that happens quite a bit.

by tony hopkinson

Famous incident with that paragon of journalistic excellence the BBC and their coompletely unbiased presentation of events.

While Thatcher was destroying the mining industry in order to break the power of the unions, she passed laws allowing the police a legal way of making their protests less effective.

This brought them into conflict with the police on several well publicised occasions.

The BBC did report the facts, they missed nothing out. They showed the miners attacking the police, true, they showed the police doing a mounted charge into rioting miners, true.

They showed it in that order, it happened the other way round.

Presentation is everything.

by oz_media

I was simply noting it, just as you would have if I posted it myself.

But your clarification is there all the same, whether you were holding your middle finger up at the time or not.

by maxwell edison

No big deal on pointing anything out -- just having some fun with it.

By the way, I plan to address the rest of your comments as well.

P.S. Besides, it gave me a sneaky opportunity to throw-in that Clinton "I did not have sexual relations...." quote, following the word "truth" in the current-day quote.

by nicknielsen

Or did somebody spit in your oatmeal this morning?

[b]Tribunals[/b], Max. We were talking about the rules of evidence for military tribunals for the [b]detainees[/b]. If I neglected to explicitly state that we were discussing military tribunals, I apologize. But I had thought that everybody with a clue knew that the accused terrorists would not be tried in civilian courts.

Military tribunal or civilian court, the rules of evidence are the same; the defendant must be permitted access to all evidence against him. For these tribunals, we should consider adopting a Nuremburg-style charter (http://tinyurl.com/p4sww), to include the following statements:

IV. FAIR TRIAL FOR DEFENDANTS
Article 16.

In order to ensure fair trial for the Defendants, the following procedure shall be followed:

(a) The Indictment shall include full particulars specifying in detail the charges against the Defendants. A copy of the Indictment and of all the documents lodged with the Indictment, translated into a language which he understands, shall be furnished to the Defendant at reasonable time before the Trial.

(b) During any preliminary examination or trial of a Defendant he will have the right to give any explanation relevant to the charges made against him.

(c) A preliminary examination of a Defendant and his Trial shall be conducted in, or translated into, a language which the Defendant understands.

(d) A Defendant shall have the right to conduct his own defense before the Tribunal or to have the assistance of Counsel.

(e) A Defendant shall have the right through himself or through his Counsel to present evidence at the Trial in support of his defense, and to cross-examine any witness called by the Prosecution.

By the way, Max, I expect the first Marine to lay eyes on bin Laden to do what comes naturally to Marines: shoot first and ask questions later. Screw Miranda, this is a battlefield.

by maxwell edison

It could be that my apparent 6 steps to the right is only an illusion caused by your 6 steps to the left, but I guess neither of us really knows for sure, do we?

What has the Bush administration accomplished, you ask? Well, regardless of how I might answer that question, you'd see it a different way because we both have a different basis for our opinions and a different outlook for what the future should be. While one person, for example, might enjoy the heck out of a 1-0 baseball game because of the fine pitching, another might abhor such a game because of it's pitiful hitting. So that's a tough question to answer. Perhaps one of the two million (or so) women who are going to school in Afghanistan for the first time in their lives could answer that question for you. But I don't think I'll try.

You mentioned Iran, North Korea, Hezbolah, Venezuela and Cuba as being emboldened. How so? And therefore what? And what should be done in that regard at this point? And who else, other than the USA, should do anything and why?

Immigration reform is in abysmal shape, I agree. But whose fault is it? Sure, the buck stops at the top, but isn't this bigger than one guy over a few years? Hasn't this been building for decades and over many administrations? But remind me what the president has proposed and how his political opponents have responded to his proposals? And what have those political opponents proposed? And what's really possible? And how would you, personally, reform immigration and address the immigration problem?

Social Security reform, now that's one of my hot button issues. I'm in favor of abolishing SS by phasing it out over a 50 year period. And you're right, when the president suggested something, it was too little too late, and he was absolutely massacred by the press and his political opponents for proposing even that. And all he was suggesting was allowing the wage earner to control a lousy 4 percent of the 15 percent SS deduction. It was so insignificant, yet he was blasted for it. The most that could possibly be would be a measly $510 per year for a person earning $85,000. Only $255 per year for a person earning $42,500. The only way to successfully reform SS is to abolish the entire program (phased out over 50 years). It's a disaster waiting to happen, and anyone pointing a finger at any one person is either partisan, ignorant, misinformed, or any combination of such things.

On the "crying terrorism" comments ...... oh, never mind. What's the point? You and I will probably never agree on much. Besides, we like different kinds of ball games.

by absolutely

how typical it is. Your cynical attitude only enables more useless people to be considered "qualified" to hold office, lowering the standards of conduct and ability for all political parties. Competition is good. Mediocrity is bad.

by absolutely

During the debate over the contents of the Constitution, and in the decades just after its writing, the phrase "separation of church and state" emerged, describing the [i]principle[/i] that the state should not interfere, for or against, any religion, in order to allow the practice of every religion to be equally free. The same [i]principle[/i] applies to the free operation of the press, which is also protected by the same First Amendment to the Constitution that guarantees religious freedom, as long as the Union stands. The pledge of any political party to protect individual rights can only be as good as their track record for respecting those rights, including when their adversaries' free speech is exercised to say things that are inconvenient or unpleasant to them, but legal to say (not a threat or incitement to aggression).

[edit: content]

by maxwell edison

While Jefferson was president, he received a letter from the Danbury Baptist Association in Connecticut stating that they were concerned about their minority status in that state, suggesting that their religion was not viewed as their right, but as a favor granted by the state legislature. Jefferson replied to that letter as follows:

Gentlemen

The affectionate sentiments of esteem and approbation which you are so good as to express towards me, on behalf of the Danbury Baptist association, give me the highest satisfaction. my duties dictate a faithful and zealous pursuit of the interests of my constituents, & in proportion as they are persuaded of my fidelity to those duties, the discharge of them becomes more and more pleasing.

Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should "make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof," thus building a wall of separation between Church & State. Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore to man all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.

I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection & blessing of the common father and creator of man, and tender you for yourselves & your religious association, assurances of my high respect & esteem.

Th Jefferson
Jan. 1. 1802

by maxwell edison

Although I don't believe government (or former government) officials should pressure the press to either print or refrain from printing (or showing) politically damaging information, I do believe that people in government have just as much a right as anyone to question what might be printed, and even challenge what's printed or said. I don't consider the press the watch-dog of government, per se, in an unobstructed and unquestioning manner. In my opinion, if the press is the watchdog, we need a watchdog to watch the watchdog. President Bush, former President Clinton, or any one else has every right to challenge what might be said about them.

Moreover, I also believe that government has a right to request something not be released for national security reasons, such as when the Bush administration requested the NYT to hold a story about the terrorist surveillance program. As far as forcing them to withhold the publication of information that would be damaging to national security or war plans or any other such issue, I wouldn't make a carte blanch statement either way. Government could certainly abuse such power, just as the press can be extremely irresponsible and abuse their freedom and power as well. How it's measured and monitored, I have no idea.

Just as many people (myself included, in many cases) have a significant mistrust of government, I have a significant mistrust of the press -- especially the established main-stream media (NYT, Wash. Post, CBS, ABC, NBC, AP, et al.) A great many people in the media have an agenda, and they use their pulpit to advance that agenda. In many ways, they're no better than elected officials advancing an agenda -- and in some ways, they're worse, because they're accountable to no one -- not even to the truth!

Who do I trust less, the press or government?

Who do I trust less, the press of the former Clinton Administration?

Who do I trust less, the press of the current Bush Administration?

All rhetorical questions, in a way, because I don't think I'll answer them. But if anyone else wants to........

So my agree or disagree question: Should the press have carte blanch power to print anything and everything, regardless of the potential outcome? (And I'm referring primarily to national security issues and such.) I say no. But a person could convince me to change my mind, if such a person (or organization) could be tried for treason or some other aiding the enemy type charge.

Dateline: June 4, 1944.....

EXTRA EXTRA READ ALL ABOUT IT! ALLIED FORCES TO INVADE AT NORMANDY ON JUNE 6TH!

Would something like this be going too far?

by absolutely

The definition of "war" includes an adversary which is a sovereign nation. We are at war against Iraq & Afghanistan, literally. We are in a figurative war on terror, which includes those literal wars, as well as criminal proceedings against any individuals apprehended committing or attempting to commit acts of terrorism outside of the Iraq & Afghanistan war zones. Strategically, I believe the United States is stronger when we citizens are more safe & secure in our persons & our possessions against government interference. When we are frantic, nervous, and all under suspicion, we are, by definition, terrorized. What is the difference between terror of Osama bin Laden & terror of criminal wiretapping and imprisonment without probable cause nor reasonable suspicion requirements?

by maxwell edison

I don't really want to get into a "war of words" with you, but will you please provide your source for that limited definition -- that is, "war" being only an action against "an adversary which is a sovereign nation". Or did you just make it up to satisfy your desired definition in order to justify your argument?

by tonythetiger

I seem to recall a little incident, oh, in the 1860s... :)

[i]...criminal wiretapping...[/i]

Monitoring conversations to/from suspected enemies of this country is no different than the police following your car after you pick up a hitchhiker who is a criminal suspect. It's not you who they are monitoring, it's the other person.

Let me ask you this? If they are legally monitoring a suspected gangster's phone, and he calls a pizza place, are they violating the rights of the employee who answered the phone? How about when the employee calls back to verify the order?

by tonythetiger

it's not limited to Democrats. The 'We are your mommy' mentality has infiltrated most of our government.

by jamesrl

or Kennedy.

I can't testify to anything about what might have happened while they were president.

If you believe many credible biographies, Eisenhower had an affair with one of his staff and arranged to have that woman accompany him throughout much of the war. Should he have been dismissed as SACEUR?

Kennedy had numerous affairs, including one with a woman who was also involved with a mob boss. That would have been potentially compromising. Some of these were while he was a senator.

And yes, I agree, it wasn't just the affair it was the perjury. And it wasn't the affair, it was that one party to the affair was a subordinate in a work relationship - a no no.

James

by maxwell edison

In the case of Eisenhower, I'd like to say that my comments don't apply because ........ because ........ because ........ because ........ well, just because I like the guy. In the case of Kennedy, however, what he did does apply to my comments.

Kennedy, in my opinion, was one of the most corrupt and unprincipled presidents we've ever had, inasmuch as stealing the election in the first place (with the help of the mob), the abuse of his powerful position in regards to his philandering (and one of the affairs, as you suggested, was with a mob boss's girl), appointing his own brother as attorney general, possibly being involved in and/or connected to the death of Marilyn Monroe, either directly or indirectly (or was that Bobby?), and so on. In fact, I'm convinced that either the mob and/or Castro had President Kennedy killed.

President Kennedy is also somewhat of an enigma to me, as I both admire him and abhor him. I certainly don't place him on a pedestal, like so many people seem to do, but I do admire the moxie, the optimism and "can-do" attitude, the charisma and oratory skills, the way he held the United States in such high esteem (much more than just lip-service), and so on. (And I remember my mom crying when he was killed.) The moon challenge is one of my favorite (and most impressive) events in history, and I remember watching on television the fulfillment of his challenge when [i]The Eagle[/i] landed on the moon in 1969. The way he stood up to the Soviet Union (to the brink of all-out war, by the way), the way he realized tax-cuts can actually increase revenue (one of the first "trickle-down" proponents), and other policy positions are ones that I can relate to and agree with.

Okay, I'll admit that my personal views of these guys might skew my judgmental opinions of what they did. However, I also acknowledge that both the times and circumstances are different. I wonder how many sitting presidents, for example, had affairs? In the twentieth century, John Kennedy and Franklin Roosevelt, to be sure. (Another side-note on Roosevelt. I loved his policy decisions and actions on the world stage, but he literally set America on the path to socialized, liberty-killing, financial destruction with his domestic agenda.) I think President Kennedy actually placed the country -- and his personal well-being -- in extreme jeopardy with his philandering. It doesn't appear that Eisenhower or Roosevelt did; and I don't believe Eisenhower's affair carried into the White House years. Moreover (not that I'm justifying anything), look at how the affairs were structured. Eisenhower and Roosevelt had one long-term mistress, per se (and if you consider Eleanor and Mamie, one might understand why!), whereas Kennedy and Clinton might be more accurately compared to a couple of popular college jocks who would poke anyone and everyone who would have them. (And in the case of Clinton, even a few who didn't want to have him.) The former were "controlled" affairs; the latter were out-of-control philandering.

Concerning Eisenhower, a person in history that I admire, that's a tough one, because he did a magnificent job as the allied forces commander, and I'm not sure an affair with a subordinate warranted dismissal. However, those are the rules in the military, at least they are now; I'm not sure about the 1940s. But if a four (or five) star General has an affair with a Captain or a Major, it's not only frowned upon, but regulated against, at least I believe it is. If there are any military experts out there (and I know there are), feel free to chime-in and clarify. Is it or isn't it? Was it (in the 40s) or wasn't it?

Okay, Ill admit that my comment suggesting an affair should automatically qualify as an impeachable offense was more emotional rather than rational, something I don't usually do. Chalk-up one gotcha' for James! I will say this, however. There are times when such behavior by a sitting president, especially when it takes place IN the White House and in the out-of-control and philandering manner in which it took place, could be tantamount to dereliction of duty. (That's the title of a book, by the way, written by one of Clinton's former military aids.)

by jamesrl

My intent was to expand it out farther than those recent examples where we have a lot of emotional baggage.

I am sure that if we did digging we could find "dirt" on many if not all presidents, regardless of the party. Where the line can and should be drawn is not necessarily (IMHO) on an affair or indiscretion alone - though I know Max may disagree if the timing is while they hold office. To me it makes a difference if the affair is with a staffer, or it negatively impacts the performance of the office holder.

Jefferson had kids with his slaves - and slaves obviously don't have the right to decline, making it even worse. Additionally its hard to understand how someone in that position could know that they had children born into slavery and not work to make them and their mother free.

But Jefferson also did many wonderful things in terms of his influence on the course of the development of the government.

Don't get me wrong, Canada's founding Prime Minister may have been an alcoholic, and there was certainly more than a whiff of scandal about the implementation of the national railway. I'm sure we could find the same thing in other democracies.
I liked Ike. I especially admire his going away speech.

My time with politicians has taught me much about the fallabilites of all individuals. I've come to know some of these people behind closed doors and in social settings. There are good and bad people in politics in all parties.

James

by tonythetiger

is similar to one forbiding nepotism in intent.

One cannot consort with anyone in one's chain of command, nor can one consort with anyone they work directly with, nor can officers consort with enlisted personnel.

by too old for it

In WWII, JFK had a cushy job in DC and was seeing a German spy. This was way before he married Jackie.

Old Joe Kennedy made some phone calls and had JFK sent out the the middle of the Pacific to keep him out of th limelight, and the rest, as they say, is history.

Actually, Jackie was an arranged marriage that was so obvious that it would have made the crown princes of Europe blush.

by local support

As far as I remember, JFK stopped hostile placement of nuclear missiles on an island in the Caribbean.

My father and mother were worried, but I was too
young to know.

\Local support

by oz_media

I certainly hope you were joking but I couldnt see the jest you were getting at.

Perhaps, if you actually are serious about your statement (perhaps I missed the joke somewher), you could explain to me just HOW America won a war that ended on the Russian front?

Were there other countries involved also or was America the soul survivor? I don't get it, you don't REALLY believe that do you?

I (and millions of others including the majority of American peers on TR) can prove you wrong if you do. In fact if you can find me a single historical fact to support your claim that America won WWII, I would even concede at that.

Fact, you can't, America didn't win the war in Europe. Sizeable numbers of American forces HELPED see the end of the war, wih a great effort by Russia that thwarted Germany's attempts to gain control of the oil south of Stalingrad, which was to be obtained by controlling Stalingrad.

Did the German army surrender to the USA or was it not the two largest and most experienced of Hitlers armies that actually surrendered to Russia on Jan 31st 1943 that was the turning point?

Are you one of those unaware folk who claim the Brits would be speaking German if it weren't for America? Even though Hitler's attempts to invade England were thwarted long before the US arrived in force on D-Day?

Or are you one of those who feel that the American tactics on D-Day were the turning point? Even though Canadian and British troops proved to be far more successful in their D-Day missions than the US was, which was almost a complete slaughter due to poor military engineering and execution of your D-Day role?

I am not saying the US didn't HELP win WWII, but you CERTAINLY didn't WIN it, as you so claim.

Therefore, I am somewhat confident you were joking, I haven't seen anyone here make such a false claim in several years now. Not someone known to be pretty aware, such as yourself, anyway.

You did NOTHING for the world 'on our own' as you claim, you only came on board after you were attacked yourselves, again in fear of a complete take over by Germany. The US acts out on fear, not defense, always has and always does it seems.

To correct your comment, the US joined the millions of allied forces who won WWII over a 5 year period without the ACLU. 3 years late to the party but welcome and wanted all the same.

by absolutely

The Soviets eventually stopped Hitler with their secret weapon: unbearable cold. The Japanese were defeated less by the United States than by the atom bomb, designed mostly by Jewish physicists who defected from Nazi Germany for obvious reasons. The Manhattan Project was a race of all the best minds to recently leave Germany, versus the one competent German physicist who remained - Heisenberg. He essentially solved the problem too, but miscalculated the amount of radioactive material needed. If you take the United States out of this political equation, the same scientists would just have gone to England, and constructed the same Nazi killer, for the same reasons. No nation is important enough to justify your jingoistic gibberish. What is important in any war is who has the better life to defend, which means: which country is more free. People will always flee oppression in order to live in the freest countries available to them.

In those days, the assault on personal liberty may not have been so great that the ACLU would have had much to do, but that in no way implies that their function is less crucial to the long-term success of the country than the military, all branches considered together.

by oz_media

While ytuo want the right to hold th eleft accountable, th eright is not prepared to accept accountability of their own actions.

SOME people, not most, are STILL claiming that the initial reason for entering Iraq was justified. Even Bush mumers around teh subjkect, his only recourse is that it was a good solution in teh long term. THat still doesn't explani or justify rash action that goes against you r own words or plans.

The other day he had teh audacity to claim that the allied coalition and UN supported it too? Supported the end result perhaps, but THEY were opposed to Bush going against his word and invading anyway. that's why he invaded with the if your not our freidn your our enemy bullspit.

But hey, no finger pointing inward, just at those nasty democrats who want government to support THEIR people and not those in another nation.

I agree, the bleeding heart left is over the top, but no more so than the insanely righteous right.

by x-marcap

I often berate myself for not being able to convert people to my point of view by mere logic. Some people want to fight against what I perceive as obvious truth.

Oz, sometimes, I think you are exactly my polar opposite, and then you come up with something that makes perfect sense. As a group, many people follow the group. I tend to not exactly follow the group. It is almost impossible for any large group to head exactly the same direction. I may be the only person going exactly the way I am heading.

I do criticize the Republican policies that are off base. Especially immigration and foreign workers. I believe we should now lock down the Southern border and only allow unrestricted egress to the US in areas like North Dakota and Minnesota. At all other places there should be customs and border security.

by too old for it

... to scoop up Bin Laden and put him in a box.

We didn't have Club Gitmo then, tho I'm not sure that would have been the place. I'm thinking Galena AFS brig or NAS Adak would have been about right.

by x-marcap

It is a public relations coup that the GOP and the critics want. They want to "improve the image" of the USA to the international community. They should not be treated as enemy Army members. These are terrorists.

I think these terrorists are spies, collaborators, and saboteurs, and thus should be treated according to the Geneva conventions for spies and saboteurs, and collaborators. This may be harsh, but it would set the precedent that should be established.

This is far less than Lincoln or FDR did.

by oz_media

I did laugh out loud at your Clinton yuk, nicely presented.

One of those rare times where I actually agree and see humour in our comments.

You see, I don't think Clinton is any better. I'm not one of those who feel that because he supported my political views I would defend him regardless. Thus my 'displeasure' in the way Bush has handled many aspects of his job is not pure bias and is not motivated by personal political preference.

I'd wrap up with a Lewinsky joke but we've all heard them a thousand time now and I don't feel very witty right now to offer one of my own. (Probably for the best).

I appreciate your post, I just pictured you saying 'yeah, well FU, middle finger to OZ, while posting an drolling your eyes.

But hey, you have to admit, YOU would have nailed me on the same issue as well. If I had said "a Bush letter", and it was written by ANYONE else no matter how closely related or even dictated, you would have still corrected me, it's just what we do, Max.

by absolutely

I formed my position based on the definition, learned at an accredited four-year college, studying International Relations. This definition of war is absolutely correct, but I no longer have my textbooks from that major that I didn't complete. I was reminded of it on C-SPAN recently, but will find a source affiliated with the Cato Institute to cite, if you still wish to challenge the definition.

[edit: removed unnecessary occurrence of "it" from title]

by maxwell edison

War: The Definition

American Heritage:

1a. A state of open, armed, often prolonged conflict carried on between nations, states, or parties.
1b. The period of such conflict.
1c.The techniques and procedures of war; military science.

2a. A condition of active antagonism or contention: [i]a war of words; a price war[/i].
2b. A concerted effort or campaign to combat or put an end to something considered injurious: [i]the war against acid rain[/i]

Merriam-Webster:

1. A state of usually open and declared armed hostile conflict between states or nations.
2. Period of such armed conflict.
3. A state of hostility, conflict, or antagonism b: a struggle or competition between opposing forces or for a particular end.

Stanford encyclopedia of Philosophy:

War should be understood as an actual, intentional and widespread armed conflict between political communities. Thus, fisticuffs between individual persons do not count as a war, nor does a gang fight, nor does a feud on the order of the Hatfields versus the McCoys. War is a phenomenon which occurs only between political communities, defined as those entities which either are states or intend to become states (in order to allow for civil war). Classical war is international war, a war between different states, like the two World Wars. But just as frequent is war within a state between rival groups or communities, like the American Civil War. [b]Certain political pressure groups, like terrorist organizations, might also be considered ?political communities,? in that they are associations of people with a political purpose and, indeed, many of them aspire to statehood or to influence the development of statehood in certain lands.[/b]

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/war/

Gary Dempsey, Foreign Policy Analyst, Cato Institute:

.....treating terrorism as a criminal justice matter is wrongheaded......

But defining what happened in New York and Washington as crimes misses the point. One of the primary constitutional responsibilities of the U.S. government is to defend the American people from external attack. It's striking, then, that the last administration and its defenders were so willing to use the U.S. military for social work and peacekeeping around the world-mostly on missions that had little to do with the direct security of America-but treated the slaughter of American citizens and destruction of U.S. property by international terrorists as a law enforcement issue......

[b]That means the United States has little choice now but to respond to the recent attacks as only the initial acts of war and to defend its citizens by taking the war back to bin Laden and whomever else supports him[/b]......

[b]It wouldn't be the first time the United States has gone to war against non-state actors.[/b] In 1801, President Thomas Jefferson went to war against the Barbary pirates, who preyed upon European and American shipping in both Mediterranean and Atlantic waters. James Madison supported Jefferson's efforts, which proved successful by 1805.

Jefferson, unfortunately, operated without a formal declaration of war from Congress. He later admitted that he was "unauthorized by the Constitution, without the sanction of Congress, to go beyond the line of defense," and that it was the prerogative of Congress to authorize "measures of offense also." Lamentably, Congress last week sidestepped its duty to formally declare war and instead granted the president the authority "to use all necessary force."

Of course, formally declaring war would not mean that U.S. bombers must immediately launch air strikes or that the Marines must eventually conduct a full-scale land invasion. Rather, it would signify that a profound threshold has been crossed that there are certain things Americans absolutely will not tolerate happening to their fellow citizens.

https://www.cato.org/current/terrorism/pubs/dempsey-010925.html

by absolutely

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=6656

"Compared to the lethal menaces of the twentieth century, the strategic threat posed by radical Islamic terrorists is minor league...True to their label, the Islamic terrorists are terrifying, and they can sometimes inflict nasty damage, as we discovered to great sorrow five years ago. But terrorism has always been the strategy of weak parties, not strong ones, and radical Islamic terrorism is no exception...However fearsome they are, we must keep their threat in perspective. Even in the improbable worst-case scenario?the one in which Al Qaeda gets its hands on a nuclear weapon and somehow figures out how to detonate it (not an easy task)?the scope of destruction, while terrible, would still not begin to rival the horrors of the last century's bloodletting, much less what would have happened if the Cold War had turned hot. There is no realistic prospect of Al Qaeda obtaining thousands of nukes...We must recognize that terrorism poses a frightening and tragic but manageable threat to the United States. Gingrich, Podhoretz and other panic mongers do us a huge disservice by exaggerating its danger. The only way the current struggle could ever become a world war is if American leaders followed their advice and escalated our response into a war between the West and Islam. As we mourn our dead, we must remember that we have more power than our enemies to worsen our fate. For both the dead and the living, we must make sure that does not happen."

You will have to wait for the academic definition I mentioned above because I have more important things to do, but I promise you, that specialized definition is based logically on the inability of any entity that is not a state to have the military might to pose a serious threat to any but the most chaotic governments. As Ted Galen Carpenter explains (though he doesn't quite say it) a bona fide war is a different phenomenon, of a greater magnitude, than Al Qaida, which have received much more attention than their ability to destroy or kill truly warrants. The worst thing enemies of terrorism can do to themselves is exaggerate the importance or potency of terrorists.

by absolutely

Here is a reference to terrorism as violent crime. As you said, there is disagreement even within the Cato Institute, and I'm not hoping to convince you. But, I felt I should try to provide some citation of the usage, although I'd still prefer to have found the definition as I asserted it. Maybe later.

"Any violent crime is terrible, but terrorism is extremely rare in the United States. The risk that any given American will be killed by a terrorist is about the same as the chance that a randomly selected high school football player will one day be a starting quarterback in the Super Bowl. One's chance of being killed in a terrorist attack is many times less than one's chance of drowning in a bathtub or being killed by a fall from scaffolding or a ladder. We would not adopt the "if it saves one life'' theory to justify a ban on bathtubs, even though hundreds of lives would be saved each year. Accordingly, America should reject terrorism legislation that will probably not save any lives and that demands that Americans give up things far more important than bathtubs.

"Terrorists cannot destroy a free society, but they can scare a free society into destroying itself. In 1974 Irish Republican Army terrorists bombed pubs in Birmingham, England, killing 21 people. Home Secretary Roy Jenkins introduced the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Bill. Approved without objection in Parliament, the bill was supposed to expire in one year, but it has been renewed every year."

by absolutely

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War

Somewhere in there, hopefully, is an explanation that in the academic study of politics & international affairs, war means two (or more) sovereign nations in armed conflict. I haven't found it yet, and it's too late to keep looking.

by jdclyde

But there are many, depending the definition you choose to pick, huh?

http://www.webster.com/dictionary/war
[b]1 a (1) : a state of usually open and declared armed hostile conflict between states or nations [/b]

2 a : a state of hostility, conflict, or antagonism b : a struggle or competition between opposing forces or for a particular end

1 : to be in active or vigorous conflict
2 : to engage in warfare

Both right, both wrong.

by absolutely

http://www.cato.org/pubs/handbook/hb105-21.html

"Any violent crime is terrible, but terrorism is extremely rare in the United States. The risk that any given American will be killed by a terrorist is about the same as the chance that a randomly selected high school football player will one day be a starting quarterback in the Super Bowl."

Now, is Al Qaida in the same league as Hitler, Hirohito & Mussolini? Jefferson Davis?

by absolutely

"Let me ask you this? If they are legally monitoring a suspected gangster's phone, and he calls a pizza place, are they violating the rights of the employee who answered the phone? How about when the employee calls back to verify the order?"

When such surveillance is legal, it is not necessary to LIE to the public about whether, and how, it is being conducted.

by tonythetiger

Do you really believe that police, FBI, etc, always publicly announce if they are monitoring a suspected criminal, or that if asked, they must tell the truth? Have you never heard of "Undercover operations"? Have you ever heard of misdirection to confuse a suspect?

I can assure you that it happens all the time and has been found to be perfectly legal in many different courtrooms.

by absolutely

The ability of police, FBI, etc to eavesdrop without publicly announcing on [b]whom[/b] they are monitoring is not in question, and was never under discussion. They must still get a warrant, not announce to the suspects that they are eavesdropping on them. The ability to eavesdrop [b]with[/b] a warrant is known to all, and perfectly legal. The ability to eavesdrop [b]without[/b] a warrant is absolutely illegal under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, and George Walker Bush's order to keep [b]warrantless[/b] surveillance secret was due to his fear of being prosecuted for the felony that he committed, not to protect the citizens. Misdirection to confuse a suspect is also irrelevant. Al Qaida knows that the government is doing everything possible to identify and surveil them. They do not care a bit whether the eavesdropping is done with a warrant or without one. It matters only to law-abiding citizens of (or visitors to) the United States such as myself whether my government is spying on me [b]without[/b] a warrant.

by nicknielsen

our country was founded on, are we any better than them?

They have their own principles, no matter how repugnant we find them, and they stick to them. Can we do any less?

by absolutely

"Who do I trust less, the press or government?

Who do I trust less, the press or the former Clinton Administration?

Who do I trust less, the press or the current Bush Administration?"

This reminds me of a quote (from the Cold War, if memory serves): "We don't distrust each other because we have guns. We have guns because we distrust each other."

Similarly, we don't distrust the power to coerce because of the Constitution. We have the Constitution because the power to coerce, unguided by requirements of proof with due process, has proven in every era to be abused whenever anybody holds such power. I don't [i]trust[/i] anybody. Not the press, and neither of the two parties, or any individual president. I [i]respect[/i] individuals who respect my right to live free of coercion. I have no implicit trust of the press, but I observe that the more an institution is separated from the coercive power of the government, the more it tends to be worthy of respect. When government more closely "comments" on (interacts with, and governs) the press, it invariably interferes, and can have no other effect in the long term, than to favor the institutions [b]most[/b] willing to submit obsequiously to every whim of the worst, most coercive, noisiest employees of the government, elected and appointed alike.

The government will of course retain the right to protect its military secrets. I see no credible evidence that this ability is in any jeopardy.

"Should the press have carte blanch power to print anything and everything, regardless of the potential outcome?"

Of course not. The existing laws regarding libel and slander, and prohibiting treason are sufficient to delimit the freedom of the press, and actions (for example, "leaking" the existence of the felonious NSA domestic wiretapping order from the White House) not governed by those existing laws are not as important as the totalitarians in the George Walker Bush administration wish to portray them. The current White House got hysterical about this program's secrecy, not because of the threat to the country, but because of the personal threat to the criminals who ordered or complied with the illegal orders to ignore FISA.

Finally, Maxwell, the ultimate power to censure an abusive press must belong to the free market, or at least with the economic market, inasmuch as it is free. If the press is to be subject to special, more onerous accountability to the coercive power of the state, what right have you or I to complain about taxes we pay to drug addicts? To recipients of corporate welfare? To censors directly?

by absolutely

that the Cato Institute owns a crystal ball!

Read it & weep, warmongers. The pros saw the Iraq quagmire before it even began.

"Robust Response to 9/11 Is Needed but Poking the Hornets' Nest Is Ill-Advised
by Ivan Eland

Ivan Eland is director of defense policy studies at the Cato Institute.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Executive Summary

To date, the Bush administration has responded well to the terrorist attacks of September 11. The administration has wisely focused its military response against Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda terrorist network and al Qaeda's supporters in Afghanistan's Taliban regime. The administration's surgical approach, using air power, marines, and special forces to support the opposition Northern alliance, is the right technique.

However, the recent imposition of stringent financial sanctions against terrorist groups not affiliated with bin Laden's network and most likely not involved in the September 11 attacks should raise a warning flag. If that expansion of sanctions is the first step in a global war on terrorism that would eventually include covert or military action against all terrorist groups on the State Department's terrorism list, then it is cause for concern. Given the ability of terrorists to hide in the shadows and the erosion of U.S. human intelligence capabilities, conducting a worldwide war against terrorism would be difficult, might create more terrorists than it eradicated, and could unleash retaliatory strikes on U.S. targets from terrorist groups that have not previously been adversaries of the United States. Indeed, some of the groups designated for the tightened U.S. sanctions have never attacked American targets. By taking on such groups, the United States would unnecessarily be fighting the battles of other nations.

It is vital to show that the heinous attack on U.S. soil will not go unanswered and to eliminate the threat from al Qaeda and affiliated groups, but it is foolhardy to draw a bigger bull's-eye on the United States by taking up the fight against numerous other terrorist groups on behalf of other nations."

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=1593

by Member 25348569

[b]and[/b] dragged the UK into it.

We are now in the situation that the greatest terrorist threat to the US at the present time is from British-born Muslims.

by tony hopkinson

the basics of strategy and the tactical doctrines that will support it.

Personally I suspect, he read a history book and had a passable understanding of human nature, no crystal ball required then.

by absolutely

"Personally I suspect, he read a history book and had a passable understanding of human nature..."

Or, is it more likely that Bush, Blair, Rumsfeld, Rice, Ashcroft, etc., simply are not interested in the goals they claim to pursue? (peace & general prosperity) These goals [i]obviously[/i] cannot be achieved by demonizing sovereign states in answer to 3 attacks (WTC 1, Cole, WTC 2) by [i]a non-state actor[/i]. So, given that the purported goals [i]cannot[/i] be achieved by the observed methods, is it more reasonable to assume that the aforementioned elected officials are astonishingly stupid and ignorant, or that they are astonishingly dishonest?

by maxwell edison

You went from affording terrorist detainees the same protections guaranteed to American citizens under the Constitution, to ...."Tribunals, Max. We were talking about the rules of evidence for military tribunals for the detainees. If I neglected to explicitly state that we were discussing military tribunals, I apologize."

Why not read your messages all over again, starting from the first one to which I replied, read my disagreement with them, and tell me again, who's being "obtuse".

Going back to your first message in the string, you and I, my friend, are entitled to protections under our Constitution. Osama bin Laden and his merry band of terrorists are not. Do you agree or disagree?

by maxwell edison

....while I was there getting my article from Cato. Even some of the Cato people apparently disagree.

You'll never convince me that war is limited to only nation-states, and I'll never convince you that its definition is broader, and includes terrorist organizations. So don't bother researching anything else. We can agree to disagree, and everyone else will see that you have the weaker argument.

by absolutely

Having your assurance that you will not accept the academic definition of war that excludes non-state actors, I will not bother trying to convince you. If I stumble across this definition, I will post it here, but not in order to convince you. It would be worth a couple seconds to prove that I didn't make up the definition I provided earlier.

by nicknielsen

Are "Osama bin Laden and his merry band of terrorists" entitled to the protections of our Constitution? No. Should we provide those protections to them during any trials/tribunals? Within reason, yes, as stated in my previous post. Give them a chance at a fair trial. I believe that failing to do so would violate the prinicples this country was founded upon.

by jdclyde

[i]"In Britain wiretapping does not need judicial approval. If committed pursuant to an order from a secretary of state, acts such as theft, damage to property, arson, procuring information for blackmail, and [b]leaving planted evidence are not crimes."[/b][/i]

From what is popping up after a google search about the "Prevention of Terrorism Act", I have a lot of reading to do before I can respond to this.

I would think that if nothing else, history has taught us to step in BEFORE another Hitler has taken over a few coutries? Never allow anyone to GET in the same league again.

by absolutely

What [i]does[/i] the Geneva Convention allow me to do to spies, saboteurs, and collaborators? Of course, I'll look it up myself, but good point, X-Mar-Cap

by absolutely

Certainly, the standard should be made precise enough that modern lawyers can't evade the essential meaning of "high crimes and misdemeanors" intended by the authors.

by tony hopkinson

When it was over they were the dominant world power. Crippled us brits, a quality piece of statemanship. I just hope we get to return the favour at some point.

I'm not uncognisant of US support during both world wars, but I also know what we had to pay to get it.

Given the only other option was defeat, I suppose you've got to consider it a good deal really.

by maxwell edison

Disclaimer: Oz (and whomever else), you probably know that I seldom comment on these W.W.II tangents. I tread lightly, however, to make a simple observation. I may or may not comment further, depending on how this is taken.

The outcome of W.W.II would have been vastly different, as I'm sure you will agree (or should agree), without the involvement of the United States. It simply could not have been won without us. Anyone who denies that is being foolish.

To be more specific, the one thing that I would consider was most crucial for all the allied forces, and without which Germany would have dominated Europe, and Japan would have dominated east Asia, for decades to come, perhaps even up to this very day, and if you had to identify that one thing that was absolutely vital in winning the war for everybody, it's the United States Navy. (Of course, it goes without saying, the Russians might have eventually defeated the Germans for European dominance.)

But without the United States Navy, everyone else's fate would have been vastly different.

by maxwell edison

Oz said, [i]"The US acts out on fear, not defense, always has and always does it seems."[/i]

No, Oz, that's about as far from the truth as can be, and it illustrates why people like me consider you nothing more than an American hater, not to mention being an asshole.

If I had to identify the one thing America might act on, what might that be?

http://www.gadsden.info/i/wallpaper/1152x864.gif

by maxwell edison

Anyone who suggests that the people you mentioned are, [i]"astonishingly stupid and ignorant, or that they are astonishingly dishonest"[/i], only reveals those things in himself. Disagree with a person's policy decisions and stated goals all you'd like, but to suggest what you did is extremely (Did I say EXTREMELY?) ignorant and foolish. I might expect such things from a naive' teenager, but this really takes the cake.

Now remind us again why anyone should take anything you say seriously when it comes from a mind that conceived such nonsense as that?

(P.S. It might be worthy of reminding people that this comes from the same person who also expressed the wish that the terrorists would have succeeded in killing President Bush. Although he later retracted that asinine comment, it reveals a certain juvenile mindset nonetheless.)

by absolutely

The comment you reference is not a "get out of any argument for free card". You're wrong here, completely. Making enemies of so many Muslim nations, and making many others far more nervous, and alienating most of Europe, is not an intelligent way to achieve any of the goals George Walker Bush claimed in both Presidential campaigns that he would seek. His chosen methods cannot possibly make the world a safer or more prosperous place, and his honesty is no longer in question. It is verifiably as fictitious as the god which he claims to hear.

by maxwell edison

One of your comments that I reference is your death-wish for the president comment. I reference it (again) to support the mind-set that I suggest you must have when you spew what you did in your current comment about, [i]".....it more likely that Bush, Blair, Rumsfeld, Rice, Ashcroft, etc., simply are not interested in the goals they claim to pursue? (peace & general prosperity) So, given that the purported goals cannot be achieved by the observed methods, is it more reasonable to assume that the aforementioned elected officials are astonishingly stupid and ignorant, or that they are astonishingly dishonest?"[/i]

Whether you agree with them or not, and/or believe the path they pursue is the correct one, all of those people are extremely intelligent, educated, dedicated, and savvy. And to suggest that the president's honesty is no longer in question is the icing on the cake, unless you are suggesting he's unquestionably honest. Perhaps he's been mistaken, but he is honest whether you want to believe it or not.

And you keep digging your own verbal grave when you suggest that he claims to have "heard" God speak to him. While you're looking for that other piece of information (about your mistaken definition of war) that you'll never find, look for proof that President Bush has ever claimed to "hear God speak to him". And if you promise to not come back until you find both, we'll never see you again.

It's comments like the one's you continually make that paint you with a wide brush of ignorance. Especially when you want to put forth a facade of being a "fact" driven person. The only fact that's obvious is that you continually make juvenile, silly and nonsensical accusations and claims, all showing that you simply cannot be taken seriously. Come back to the real world when you both grow up and wise up.

by oz_media

Nobody, including myself, has ever denied that teh Allied invasion was the turnign point of the war. That the larger allied numbers due to US assistance was also a key turning point in the war.

Before D-Day and the war starting for America, Hitler had been defeated several dozen times while trying to take over the waters. The Royal Navy was one of the most formidable forces in the world, still is. He was unable to claim contorl of the sea.

In the case of teh US Navy, seeing as that was the most common, convenient and cost effective transport to get millions of troops and supplies to Europe, it kind of goes without saying that your Air Force would not have been the biggest contribution to the effort.

Your tone implies that without teh US Navy and without the US intervention, Germany would have succeeded in acquiring Europe. Of course that is sheer speculation and not at all based on facts or even likeliness.

Hitler HAD tried to conquer the UK, by sea and by air. He was defeated TWICE by the Canadian, Portugese and Polish forces in England. Aptly named the Battle of Britain, this did not include the united states forces who landed on D-Day, it also did not involve the United Kingdom being taken over by Germany.

Thanks Poland, thanks Canada!

So after being defeated in teh seas and after being defeated in the air, it was a matter of culling the herd and driving them back to Germany.

With teh MASSIVE allied force that landed on D-Day and pretty much the entire continent now fighting against them, the German army was thinned, worn and beat down after four years of living with war 'on the road'.

The forces were ample enough to drive the Germans bask eastwardm this is when Hitler turned tail and ran to tae over Russia and their booming oil economy. Controlling that woul dofferhim control of Easterm Europe and Russia woul dnot be able to stand up. BUT...Russians also won Hitlers arrogant attampt at taking over Stalingrad. His two most experienced and formidable armies were beaten down until they finally surrendered to the Russians.

So yes, America's support of the Allied war effort was a great turning point in th ewar, it was also a way of seeing a rapid dismissal of such a broadly spread out occupation by German forces on many fronts. I understand the maneuvers/battles and timelines behind the US forces advances and accomplishments quite well.
I also understand those of other forces though, and THAT's where the world differs from the US mindset. The US sees only what the US did, the rest of the world see what 'The WORLD' did.

If you ever want to get a real good ass whoopin', drawl back to Europe, not just England, with your Colorada accent and try telling a European that American Won WW11. Have a friend video tape it though, it will be like Rodney King all over again. You can BS and fabricate all you like on TR to amuse your American peers who agree with such codswalop. but don't try it in the real world, people know better.

Do you have a US history book version of your facts that we can all read for our amusement instead?

Nothing better than a good fable to take away the pain of reality.

by maxwell edison

The words of Bevin Alexander:

From the outset of our history, Americans have focused on creating a great nation in North America, not on conquering other peoples. For more than a century after the Revolution, Americans were preoccupied with establishing the economic and political foundations of this nation. During the entire period we took advantage of the fact that we were largely insulated by a great ocean from the quarreling, avaricious societies of Europe. The British Royal Navy, more to protect Canada and its trade with Latin America than to guard the United States, largely kept other navies at a distance. We saw no need to interfere with European empires, so long as they stayed away from our hemisphere. Therefore, the United States played only a minor role on the world stage, and?despite establishing splendid records in wars on land and sea?created no world-class navy, and allowed its army to atrophy after every conflict.

Around the turn of the twentieth century, Americans realized that the protection we enjoyed behind the Atlantic and the Pacific could not endure. An American strategist, Alfred Thayer Mahan, proved in his 1890 work, The Influence of Sea Power upon History, that there can be no partial control of the sea because the sea is indivisible. A superior fleet can move over the whole sea, sweeping all lesser navies from it. This was the means by which the Royal Navy had dominated the oceans for the previous two and a half centuries, and the reason why Britain had been able to accumulate the largest empire in the history of the world.

In the first decade of the twentieth century, Germany began to challenge the naval power of Britain, and by implication Britain's world domination. It was this threat, above all else, that caused World War I of 1914-18. This war brought calamity to Britain, France, Germany, and much of the rest of Europe. At war's end a gravely weakened, almost bankrupt Britain no longer could afford the world's largest navy. The United States saw that protection of the Western Hemisphere now rested on its own shoulders. Far more significant, we saw that we could not wait until an aggressive power had built enough strength to invade our hemisphere, but that we must go out to the aggressor, wherever he was, and smash him there. In short, we must take over the world hegemonic role that Britain had exercised since 1660.

This meant that the United States was obliged to build the largest and most powerful navy in the world---a task it took on at the Washington Naval Conference in 1922. The public saw only that Britain accepted naval parity with the United States, the first time it had done so with any country. But leaders of both nations knew the treaty actually signified that the Royal Navy would decline in the decades ahead while the United States Navy would grow.

It took the United States until 1940 to undertake fully the task of creating the world's greatest military power. The spark came with the disastrous collapse of France and the ascendance of Nazi Germany, and in the next five years, the United States developed a military able to defeat any provocation anywhere on earth. We have never relinquished our place since. Indeed, the superiority of the U.S. military has grown exponentially since the end of World War II. Its power now exceeds that of all the rest of the world combined. Along with this power has grown American political strength.

Throughout the Cold War, the United States held back the spread of Communism, and promoted democracy, the rule of law, market economies, and free trade everywhere. After the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, no nation was able to match the United States. Some countries feared we would use our power to dominate the world. To prevent this from happening, they tried to tie down the United States by means of international bodies like the United Nations and the World Trade Organization.

Since the United States saw no insurmountable dangers on the horizon, it was more or less willing to work within an international context. Then the terrorists attacked the World Trade Center and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. For Americans, the world changed in an instant. The terrorists had struck directly at our island, at what we hold most precious?at the very treasures we built our overwhelming military and political power to protect in the first place. The attacks transformed our nation from a benign hegemon into a ferocious avenger.

This was another right decision of the United States, and a most vital one. For terrorism and dictatorial rogue nations pose as great a danger to the peace of the world as ever Adolf Hitler or Joseph Stalin did. We saw this with absolute clarity on that horrible day of death and tragedy. And we resolved that this we would not allow to endure.

As New York Times columnist Thomas L. Friedman wrote, most other peoples have not yet comprehended that our primary intention is to preserve and keep our own land with all its liberty and all its prosperity, and that we will do anything and go anywhere to make this happen. Most people in other countries were unprepared for our resolution after 9/11 to proceed door-to-door in the very heart of the Arab-Muslim world, to make clear we were ready to kill and to die to stop our society from being undermined, and to say, gun in hand, to the people and to the governments who permit terrorists to exist, "What is it that you don't understand about leaving our country alone?" [2]

Misconceptions about American motives and aspirations are not limited to lands that harbor terrorists. In the spring of 2003, France , Germany, Russia, and China refused to sanction America's overthrow of the Iraqi dictatorship. We didn't actually expect the vastly different and more repressive societies of Russia and China to fathom the injustice perpetrated on our people and institutions, but we did expect such sensitivity from Western Europe, fellow democratic societies that supposedly stood for the same value we hold dear.

Americans were compelled to confront a bitter truth: we were dead wrong in our conviction, held for the last half of the twentieth century, that the United States and Western Europe share a common resolve to preserve and advance freedom throughout the world. We have been forced to accept, as Robert Kagan has written, that Europe "is moving beyond power into a self-contained world of laws and rules and transnational negotiation and cooperation."[3] A century ago, when a rising Germany was facing insufficient challenge from other powers, Winston Churchill warned that "we live in an age of great events and little men." Europe once more is living in an age of great events and little men. Americans believe that Western Europeans bury their heads in the sand when difficult decisions must be made, abstain on issues where they should display moral leadership, and take positions only when their own interests are directly at stake.

This has led Americans to conclude that ours is the only nation that will actually go into the world and strike down evil. We were encouraged when Britain and Australia especially, but also some Continental nations, lined up with us. But we know that they would do little without the active determination of the United States. For these reasons, we must dominate the political life of this planet, and we must keep an invincible military as an ever-present deterrence.

---Bevin Alexander, author and historian

http://www.bevinalexander.com/about.htm

Mr. Alexander's comments cut and pasted from: http://www.militaryhistoryonline.com/excerpts/howamerica.aspx

------------------------------

By the way, Oz, why don't you buy and read Mr. Alexander's book, [i]How America Got It Right[/i]. The title alone should send you spinning into an uncontrollable hissy-fit!

by Member 25348569

One of the issues that we effete Western Europeans have with joining with the US is your highly questionable definition of "evil". The good Dr. Alexander is so obviously well wide of the mark in his appreciation of the motives behind the actions of European countries that I fail to see why I should regard him as an authoritative source on anything else!

Also, to describe - as he does - your country as a "benign hegemon" really is stepping over the edge into fantasy land. The widespread hegemonising actions of the US I do not contradict but they are rarely benign - as the economies of most of South America can attest to at one time or another. The hegemonising actions of the US via its World Bank puppet are either centred on gains for the US in terms of access to resources and infrastructure or based on some warped idea of what you think "Free Trade" is about (whilst failing to adopt any such economic strictures yourself).

In fact, the majority of conclusions that are in the piece from Dr Alexander are open to a very different interpretation from a perspective not coloured by nationalistic pride.

Still, it was a good laugh...

by Member 25348569

to force Japan to surrender quickly in order to stop Russia from declaring war on Japan and thereby gaining the right to be involved in the post-war negotiations.

Maybe not the only reason but certainly a significant one that is rarely mentioned as it means that the dead of Hiroshima and Nagasaki died for a political motive.

by oz_media

YOu stated that the reason America turned the tides on th ewar and saw it's demise, which it wouldn't have without US assistance; that it was due to the US havign a superior navy? Actually it was your paratroops that did the most damage by holding front lines (from BEHIND the front lines)it was the paratroopers that succeeded in thre of the most notable military campaigns to date, successes that today's military worldwide teach the tactical maneuvers of. Your paratroopers were the formidable force during WWII, not the USN.

From your own copied quote.

"Indeed, the superiority of the U.S. military has grown exponentially since the end of World War II. Its power [i][b]now[/b][/i] exceeds that of all the rest of the world combined"

So Max, while you have learned your WWII history from history books, carefully created US media and possibly the yarns and tales of former troops. I have learned what happened to MY country and why. It's like me trying to tell you who did what when the towers came down, 0 years of history after the fact and with my facts completely ignoring all historical fact to date. In other words, pure crap, utter lies.

I have been studying both world wars and the participants, who did what, when and where since I was a wee lad. I sat with my father and grandfather as they recounted tales and showed me pictures and medals, I walked through the building and have heard teh survival stories of those who were there, have walked through th etrain tunnels that were used as bunkers and been told astories REAL living stories from those who were there all about what had happened on thos edays. THis was several years before America was part of teh picture. I lived on an Island in teh English channel, where Hitler had planned to move his troops as a stepping stone to the mainland. I'v eseen the ships and was am related to several ship builders and RN personelle. After 30 years of learning about the wars, not the declaration of indepenance, the constitution and all that other crap, I have learened about who did what in my country and what allies did what, when and where.

In NO text ever, British, Canadian OR American, have I ever even heard mention of the US Navy having a key role in WWII. All I have seen,. including from Norgh American history shows, was how the USN actually came so close to failing horribly on D-Day but pulled it out of the hat with sheers numbers. Since D-Day, barely a mention of USNavy force in Europe other than support roles with a couple of major ships. Ships unable to properly maneuver in the waters and seek out the enemy in the Channel.

Except from you, based on a book written by one man. I'd say the cards were stacked against you and your colourful writer.

As it is, no matter if you (America) is right nor not, you still think you are the biggest and baddest at everything anyway, the world knows that and that's why nobody believe what the US claims anymore. Perhaps why they all say you are arrogant and stupid.

I have seen COUNTLESS accurate descriptions of the forces used and how they were used. The Royal Navy was Hitler's worst adversary. Germany tried and tried to acquire naval rule ever since WWI, had they come out with U-Boats a few years earlier he may have even succeeded. But by then they were no real match anyway.

Shall we look at the mistakes the US Navy made on D-Day that cost many US lives at the hands of their own people?

The fact that US ships were firing shells SUPPOSEDLY for the beachheads but they were misfired from too far out at sea and were landing in the water just short of the beach, killing your own landing troops. Those that made it to the beach ended up resulting in many more deaths because they restricted the advance of your troops up the beach by placing enourmous eholes for them to navigate. The best support your troops had on the beach that day was from the Nazi's own defenses that they were able to hide behind while landing because you attacked at low tide when they were uncovered. Nice start!

Then the majority of your tanks were sunk too, they wre launched from ships too far off shore and most sunk. Despite the allied encouragement to use more funny tanks (as they themselves did)you thought sending more engineers was a better idea, the engineers were either killed on the beach by your own fire, restrictions landing and progressing or from Nzi fire. Not a great chance. But your tanks initially had a miserable turnout as most are still at the bottom of the sea.

Not so good really, especially for the largest and most formidable navy in the world, as you claim. It must have been amusing for the Germans, kinda like watching someone without a clue try to parallel park, "Pour a coffee, this is entertaining!"

This is also long after the British had already won naval superiority over Europe (and Hitler's forces). So at what time exactly did your navy win the war for America?

Let me guess, you never said that did you. You never implied as much and certainly don't believe it. LOL. You are priceless sometimes, Max. Where do you get this tripe?

by oz_media

"meaning the soldiers died for political motive"

So you mean it was like Iraq? Sorry couldn't help that one, LOL!.

Kinda sad, now that they forgot about Afghanistan and teh Taliban os no longer news, Canadian troops who took over operations in the area have been surroundng the Taliban in Kandahar but are seeing even stronger forces that were initailly met with the full force there. While they now have hope for an end, they have driven Taliban into one area where they are fighting back with ore verocity than ever before, they have still ost far more lives than needed due to lack of allied support and resources that are tied up elsewhere.

Just another reason to not support the stupid American political moves.

by maxwell edison

...that whenever anyone points out the abysmal failures of Europe to contain and/or prevent tyrants from gaining power and running amok through Europe, you question them. However, all one has to do is look at history.

Europe was a literal killing field from 1900 through 1945. I'd love to see any of that blamed on the United States (longer than that, actually, going back into history); the only "blame" I've seen levied on the USA for that was for the USA being too slow to respond. (Or should we mind our own business? It's so confusing.)

How was Europe, by the way, for the last half of the 20th century -- when the USA maintained a presence?

by absolutely

I'm beginning to be amused how consistently you depart from discussion of fact & resort to personal attack - whenever I criticize George Walker Bush!

So, back on topic, if you will: I agree that the freedom of the press [b]does not[/b] extend to publishing secret [b]military[/b] strategies, but short of announcing the invasion of Normandy, do you believe the press ought to be restrained by government, or only the free market?

by absolutely

Conquering and not being conquered are both political motives. I am unfamiliar with the assertion that the bombing of Hiroshima & Nagasaki were motivated (in whole or in part) by concerns of territorial expansion, other than preventing Japan from expanding its territory to include the entire Pacific Rim. Assuming what you say is completely accurate, I feel no shame that my country fought "all-out" war against a sovereign nation that attacked. I am ashamed that in response to attack by a non-state actor, the United States invaded and overthrew a sovereign nation that was not involved in the attack.

by absolutely

I want to respond to "I would think that if nothing else, history has taught us to step in BEFORE another Hitler has taken over a few coutries? Never allow anyone to GET in the same league again." The best way to do THAT is to keep the power of our own government limited, especially the executive branch.

by jdclyde

We have a problem when ANY branch over steps their bounds. Got the three branchs, and each has a check over the others. When we allow people to forget that our Constitution is what controls what our government can and can't do, we are in trouble. The "living, breathing document" that some want to redefine meanings all the time has caused us a world of hurt. The meanings are set. When they don't fit anymore, there is a process in place to offically change the meaning.

All branches right now have more power than they ever were meant to. The founding fathers never would have approved stealing someones home so you could improve your local tax base. The interstate commerce clause has been so bastardized and abused it isn't even funny. If something MIGHT cross a boarder, they control it.

Question though, are we worried more about a hitler HERE, or a hitler in another part of the world? Look around you and there are a few hot spots around the world that are more of a potential threat than we ever would have at home.

by absolutely

the other two branches have more than one individual of nearly equal power at the top. Although one Supreme Court justice or one Senator is always most senior, there is no other individual as powerful as the President. But the point that all branches have exceeded the powers granted to them is well taken. The arguments of each, that it must increase its power in order to check one or more of the other branches, is wearing thin.

by absolutely

The headline "Dateline: June 4, 1944.....

EXTRA EXTRA READ ALL ABOUT IT! ALLIED FORCES TO INVADE AT NORMANDY ON JUNE 6TH!" would be too much freedom for the press. But I also feel strongly that outside of their power to enforce laws in their roles as civil servants, elected officials have no [b]more[/b] rights than private citizens to question & challenge what's printed or broadcast. I can't tell from the text of your post where you would have the line drawn.

by Member 25348569

The surrender of Japan at the close of WWII was stalled only the US insistence that the Emperor be deposed. This point was conceded to the Japanese [b]after[/b] the Bomb was dropped to expedite surrender as that particular sticking point was so obviously non-negotiable to the Japanese.

The entry of the Russians into the Japanese war was one of the primary spurs to rush through the surrender.

The Bomb was dropped without the knowledge - and obviously the approval - of the senior commander in the Pacific Theatre, McArthur. It served no purpose to wipe out two cities.

by tony hopkinson

It was your uninterruptable manufacturing capacity. Essentially you out materialled every body.
You could make more ships ,planes, tanks and guns than anyone else.
In terms of strategy and tactics with 'modern' technology, you were years behind both your allies and your enemies. You learnt fast and above all learnt to use that material advantage.

Not knocking your troops efforts on land, sea or in the air. But once you committed your industrial capacity to the war effort, no one had a hope in hell of beating you.

by Member 25348569

I was saying that Dr Alexander was - for my tastes - just a little over the top in his interpretations. Implicit in the piece you posted was the somewhat contentious idea that the US is always [b]right[/b] in its actions. There is also the similar unqualified notion that the US definition of "freedom" is something aspirational for the rest of the world and that the US economic model is the only one that works for anybody.

I don't blame the US for any of our wars. I thank you for your invaluable help in the last big one. As for being "too late", most of the serious UK historians that I have read reckon that the timing was perfect. Any earlier and the Wehrmacht would have ripped an unprepared and underresourced US expeditionary force to shreds. What that would have done to US public opinion I leave you to imagine.

by jdclyde

They SHOULD all be BACKING UP to be equial, not stepping up to catch up.

This is something that drives me nuts. And then to hear people say they want MORE "government" controls and "government" doing more "for the people".

I don't see an end, and I only see it getting worse.

by tony hopkinson

The best face I can put on what's going on is that the politicians must be seen to be doing something. Doesn't really matter what, but something.

I know that big business funds political campaigns and I know that big business is getting bigger business from the war on terror. That's about the worst face I could put on it. So we are probably somewhere in between, ie hip deep in shit, a lot of us seem to be doing hand stands as well.

To be quite honest I find the possibility of them being lying b'stards less worrying than them being astonishingly ignorant.

by tony hopkinson

Popular opinion is that we were duped into entering the iraq conflict. GWB and Tony the poodle get the blame. I'll let some of our french and german colleagues communicate their feelings on the rest of europe.
I doubt you'll like it though.

If some one had asked me me whether we should go into iraq, I'd have passed them a history book and a paraphrase of a quote by a famous general of spanish extraction.

Those who cannot appreciate history, will not last long enough to have one of their own.

by tony hopkinson

We've got even less excuse though.
A good portion of our history has been to arrogantly interfering in other peoples business on the basis we couldn't possibly be wrong, and then paying the price.

If you don't agree that we did, can we have our colony back.

Ignoring or worse continuing to appease Hussein (done through the cold war and as a buffer against Iran's brand of shi'ite theocracy) would have been stupid, effectively setting ourselves in his place was imbecilic though.

by oz_media

As you were able to prove nothing, and there is countless fact to support my brief rundown (I mean endless counts from the US and other countries too), your only reply is to sit and laugh as if you wer correct?

That's sad, even for you. I know that when you are wrong you simply avoid the topic and flame the messenger, but this is pathetic even for you.

You know when you are corrected and then don't have any retort, it is a pretty obvious sign that you know you were wrong but can't admit to it. How big of you.

Now I think I'll sit and laugh at you for a bit too.

by oz_media

While you seem to feel that teh USA protected Europe fo rthe last 60 years, you may want to be reminded that forces from all over the world have occupied and kept peace in Europe for the last 60 years, not just the USA. You'll have to take a crayon to your US history coloring books and add that too.

A good friend of mine was stationed in Germany for years, before that it was a roomate who was there. Funny enough, both were Canadians, wearing Canadian uniforms. How does your account of histopru confuse uniforms? Sure you were there, so wer British, French, purtugese, Polish Canadian and Australian troops, have been for about 60 years.

Funny though, they must have all worn US Marine fatigues, because you seem to have them all confused as the US military that was preventing England and Europe from certain doom.

'kin Americans, what a ripe lot you are!

by oz_media

Max, you claim to be laughing at the fact that I credit your partatroopers as your best asets durign the war.

First of all, show me otherwise (in real form, not one oddity with a rare opinion).

Secondly, if you wish, I can begin suporting my claim by showing you the names of the battles and maneuvers used and by what company of the 501st infantry. Although you had first THOUGHT if th eidea, it was not put into practice until Germany's paratroop successes in Holland.

If it is Russia's defense being the turning point that you laugh at, then just about any real news source or doumentation of WWii will confirm that Russia was the key in ending the war when it ended.

If its America's mistakes on D-Day you question, that information is available on several WWII recount and timeline sites, including a few I found in the US, so you should have learned the facts if you paid attention in school,. or were you so fixed on yoru own conclusion that you didn't listen top facts you didn't like when school either?

Either way, you are horribly wrong, for someone so intune with modern day politics, your knowledge of WW history is absolutely hideous. I wouldnt be too upset though, I am sure you are not alone, what American school wants to teach children that America was an important team player but not the coah. That woul dbe wrong, I wouldn't be surprised if such fact was supressed intentionally from your schools at that time in history, when the US war censors (as dictated and conducted by the White House at the time) were at their best.

by observant

But Bill "I never had sexual relations with that woman" Clinton simply asked the media to tell the ummmm, is "is" a word?, ummmm oh, the TRUTH!

So a liar asks a liar to tell the truth?!?!?!

AHHH HA HA HA HA HA.

by maxwell edison

...you're arguing against things I did not say. I would much rather you quote me fully and in context, and address exactly what I said, not what I did not say -- and certainly not what your warped little mind might extrapolate from what I did not say. For example, I never said Canadians weren't stationed in Europe; but just because I didn't specifically state they were there, it doesn't mean that I don't know or acknowledge they were there, nor does it mean anything else. Just because I don't say EVERYTHING, you assume, incorrectly, that I don't believe or know more than I do say.

Sorry, dude, but I can't write the entire history of W.W.II and its aftermath in these short messages, even if I wanted to. If your little mind can't comprehend my intended message, delivered in a general way, that's your problem, not mine. And as I said going into this tangent, I don't really want to debate or discuss W.W.II with anybody, especially you -- since you are so narrow-minded about it. Yea, sure, Oz, Canadians saved the world. Canadians are the best. Whatever you say, dude.

You forget, Oz, but I was stationed with a Canadian unit for two years. (But I must have forgotten, right?) I developed some great relationships with them. And I place much more stock in their opinion of the U.S. military than yours. In fact, I don't value your opinion one iota.

If you're looking for a W.W.II pissing match, try competing up a rope. I'm not interested.

by jamesrl

Without the entry of the US into the war in Europe, Britain would have stood alone. Germany could not fight the Soviets and invade Britain.

Its important to remember the context. Hitler and Stalin made a peace pact and later agreed to carve up Poland between them. Did either of them think there would be peace between them forever? No. But the longer they could delay the inevitable conflict, the more they could build up.

Stalin had had a major purge in his army in the late 30s, and it left them sorely disorganized and unskilled. Many many officers were liquidated. This showed heavily when Hitler invaded Russia. But over the course of time, officers and leaders emerged and learned and became able to fight back on more equal terms.

What would have happened if USA had not enetered the war in Europe? Stalin would have eventually pushed Germany to the point of collapse. He had the manpower and manufacturing. It would have taken a couple of years longer. There is some debate as to whether it would be a pyrric victory - so draining on the Soviets that they would have ended up weak from the effort. The map would be different - certainly all of Germany would have become soviet, perhaps France as well.

And the Manhattan project was more than just jewish scientests who fled Germany. Britain and Canada also contributed as did many home grown Americans scientists.

James