Tony: "Your objection against welfare is that it uses up your resources in ways that you don't personally condone."
Absolutely: My objection is that it uses my resources in ways that are immoral.
Tony: "You earned it, it's yours yes?"
Absolutely: Yes!
Tony: "Anybody else is able to go out and earn theirs. If they did you would not have to pay to support them."
Absolutely: If they recognized their responsibility to do so, and acted accordingly as voters I would not [b]have[/b] to pay for them, but nevertheless would, through any atheist organizations providing such assistance out of pure benevolence with no BS about "heaven".
Tony Hopkinson: "But how much have you benefitted from the system you decry ?"
Absolutely: It's strange to hear "the system" from a leftist, used as justification. How much I have benefitted: net loss compared to a just, non-welfare state, which is the option I endorse, not the false pair of options you describe.
Tony Hopkinson: "In a society with no welfare, those of us who succeed in our competition would have more, much more. Those who fail would have much much less."
Absolutely: That's false, Tony, and you know it to be false because you are not a total failure professionally and economically, yet you endorse charity. You aren't the only one. The only difference between your concern for the unfortunate and mine is that I'm willing to help them without government coercion.
Tony Hopkinson: "Those who fail would have much much less. As the gap widens the chance of bridging it becomes less and less."
Absolutely: Absolutely false. Since the beginning of state welfare and other "egalitarian" economic wealth redistribution schemes, the distribution of wealth has become [b]less[/b] uniform, because any time that government is given power to do more than defend individuals' rights, the individuals in power abuse that power to do more than exercise their own rights, at the expense of those of us who have better things to do with our time than plot the looting of others' production.
Tony: "So the conditions in existance now ,for people to get off their ass and make it just like we did, would not exist."
Absolutely: Wrong, Tony. The present conditions were created, not bestowed. My country fought yours for independence, and [b]we won![/b]
Tony: "Worse still the conditions that helped us make it would have not have existed, so would we have?
Don't know your background, but mine would have meant that the entire system would have been against me."
The entire system against you? What do you mean by the system? And if it was against you, why do you now argue for it?
Tony: "You want to talk about methods to get rid of the need for welfare, I'm with you all the way.
You want a talk about YOU not paying the price for the need for welfare, I ask myself, what have you done for this boon ? What massive contribution have you personally made to your community that you should not pay for it's existance which you benefit from everyday of your life."
Absolutely: Which boon do you mean?
Tony: "The argument of no welfare, is also an argument against no public heathcare, no public education, no enfranchisement, no legal redress, no equal rights."
Absolutely: Wrong again, Tony. The argument of no government redistribution of wealth according to income is solely an argument for "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, (shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue,) but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." Mine is the argument for enfranchisement, legal redress, and equal rights. Yours is the argument against those.
Tony: "Don't tell me your constitution guarantees these things, because it would not exist or would become wholly meaningless, if your idea was taken to it's logical conclusion."
Absolutely: My Constitution promises individual liberty. The word "guarantee" may suggest a more respectful, literal interpretation than is presently common, but the words of the Constitution do mean what I say they mean, and I know that I'm right and you're wrong, regardless of how many people agree with either of us. As my idea has been decreasingly taken to its logical conclusion in law and courts, my Constitution has become less meaningful as a practical guarantee of the moral ideal it describes: absolute equal rights, without regard to race, gender, religion, birthplace, wealth, or any other measure of social status you may invent.
Tony: "Community is about responsibility and debt, your community provided the environment where you could thrive, you have a duty to continue providing that same environment, or a better one."
Absolutely: Communities have formed according to a great number of different principles. Responsibility in a society of equals is only to do no harm, not to repair the harm that others do. I get extra credit for having done some charity work, not condemnation for doing less than you would like for me to do.
Tony: "How is your idea better when it negates the entire foundation that your community is built on ?"
Absolutely: On this side of the pond, the community is built on the principle that each individual is born with inalienable rights, not with amorphous, arbitrarily, collectively-defined rights.
Tony: "I got my first job on a welfare to work program, taxpayer's money was used to pay businesses to employ me for 6 months to see if I was worth anything. There were two reasons why I got a job.
The first was I put myself in position where I could be considered worth the risk of employing, the second was someone left while I was there.
I needed both those things to happen, one was completely out of my control, short of taking dead mens shoes a bit too literally."
Absolutely: Good on you. If it wasn't for the welfare state, there would have been more jobs, not fewer.
Tony: "A cautionary note to all gooder socialist types. We are almost at the point where welfare has become institutionalised, where it is not a choice made by education, region, abilitym economic circumstances or even sheer luck, but that of birth.
Politicians like welfare, businessmen like welfare (as long as they personally don't have to fund it). Continuance down this road will rob all of us of everything.
I have no problem with Abs' desire to get rid of welfare, just with his method and the fallacy that his own, mine and anyone else's success wasn't predicated upon it."
Absolutely: I have had to work harder for less money because of irrational claims that I have a duty to certain collectives that supersedes my right to pursue my happiness. My success, such as it is, has been achieved in spite of the welfare state, not predicated upon it.