Discussion Locked

Okay, I've had it. I call for an EXIT STRATEGY to this war.

0 helpful
189 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The war on poverty was unilaterally declared by President Johnson on April 24, 1964. The battle continues, with no end in sight.

There was no formal declaration of war issued by the United States Congress.

It's been over forty years of waging this war, and according to the leaders in his own party, there is still no end in sight.

I call on those people to clearly define the objectives, so that success may be clearly measured.

I call on those people to force self-governance so that we may pull our troops fighting this war out of harm's way. It's time for those troops to tend to their own families.

I call on those people to put a cap on the cost of this war. We've spent upwards of 10 trillion dollars fighting this war, and all it's accomplished is to put our nation on the road to financial disaster.

This war has not eliminated the enemy, but rather strengthened their foothold in that territory and emboldened their cause; and it's even encouraged more insurgents to enter the fray.

We have become an occupation force, not a liberation force.

I call on those people who support this illegal war to clearly define an exit strategy.

And I call on those people who support this illegal war to set an exit date.

Who's with me on this?

189 replies

by bob in calgary

I'm with you 100% The War on Terror, No sorry, Drugs, Oops wrong again, Poverty (Got it right that time) Must come to an end.

by maxwell edison

The war on terror: Terrorism is a tactic, not an enemy. I have always maintained that the enemy, which is Islamo-Fascism, has never been clearly articulated to the American people.

The war on drugs: Not only has it failed to eradicate, or even curtail, drug use, but it has actually caused more crime. Moreover, the infringement on individual rights is contrary to both the letter and intent of the constitution. Law enforcement agencies are using this as a revenue generator. Smoke a cigarette. Drink a scotch. Smoke a joint. It's a personal decision, perhaps a choice between that person and her doctor, and I call for the freedom to choose.

by tony hopkinson

Tony the socialist tree hugger wno's comrades are regulary found under american beds clad in just a fur hat, agrees with Mr Edison.

The war on poverty pisses me off. Strategically I support it whole heartedly, the reason we haven't won it yet though is because the tactics SUCK.

Strategy number 1
Lend the leaders of the country money. So they can fortify they palaces, employ thugs and shoot them dangerous hungry f'kers outside.

Strategy number 2
Give the leaders of the country money, in return for preferential trade agreements, arms sales, rights to natural resources etc.

So they can fortify they palaces, employ thugs and shoot them dangerous hungry f'kers outside.

Have these solutions worked ?

Has our extreme, continuous generosity in muliple charitable events ever made a long term difference to the real problem ?

We need to help them earn money, not give them it.
Course one of that ways we've got to do that is free trade. There are certain interests in the developed world, who's concept of free trade means they are free to trade where they like.

We've got to stop that. They'll whinge and whine, buy some more politicians to block it. But until poverty stricken societies become affluent (all is relative). They'll have a cheap source of goods and of course labour, and we'll be faced with watching little kids die on tv and a freephone number for a donation to keep watching it.

by zlitocook

I am still in disbelief about looking for oil in our protected wildlife areas and bush telling our small towns to cut down forest to support thier schools. And then send so much money over seas that our support for any thing here is gone.
Our schools have cut out art, special events and alot of other things because they do not get enough money. Bush said that thousands of jobs were created but most are in the fast food, warehouse and other low paying jobs. But he is fast to let more low paid people into this country that take some of the higher paying IT jobs.
Bring our people home and start using our money here.

by maxwell edison

That you didn't read the message to which you replied?

Or

You didn't understand it?

Or

If you did read it and understand it, you decided to spew partisan rhetoric instead of addressing the initial message?

by absolutely

That's an odd debating strategy you have zlito. Are you even trying to support those ideas, or to make them appear stupid by association with your method?

by zlitocook

Yes I am!
Trying to get other to see what is going on is a bad thing and I try to confuse them with real life ideas.
Most people only see what is going on now not the full picture.
If I say or put an idea in the mix I make people stop and think, what a way to do things?
But wait I had replys to it? Sorry just trying to get people see more then what is going on in the real world. Not just the next day and so on.

by antuck

It will never happen. Every time the government says a war on something but doesn't send troops, you know it is a waste of money.

I'd be for it as long as we also stopped giving money away to other countries. As long as we dump billions into other countries pockets, then the American people deserve a piece of the pie too.

Also, take the tax breaks away from the rich as the can pay just like everybody else.

But as I first stated, it's a "war on" with no troops. So it will always be a money pit for someone.

by absolutely

Saddam was a bad guy, but the Shiites and the Kurds didn't wage their own insurrection, so we should not decide for them what is important enough to fight and what isn't.

Poverty is bad, but the people who are chronically poor aren't doing what's necessary to overthrow their own poverty, so we should not decice for them what is important enough to work for and what isn't.

by av .

This isn't like you. You are usually much more supportive of our government, especially (GWB).

I don't like that our government has yet to win the so-called "war on poverty" either. You know why not? They don't want to win. They make too much money from the taxpayers and spend it on whatever pork projects they want in the name of poverty. Meantime, the poor get poorer, and the money never gets to them. What a scam.

Our troops have to come home now. I don't think we're helping. Maybe there is never a good time to go, but it's time for Iraqis to step up to the plate and defend their own country. America has paid dearly for this war, in blood and money. Enough.

I think you can call on whomever you want, but everyday when I look at the news I realize we are in deep sh*t and our government is dysfunctional.

by maxwell edison

The troops in the war on poverty are the taxpayers who foot the bill.

And the people who should start governing themselves are those tax receivers.

I think you misread my post.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"This isn't like you. You are usually much more supportive of our government, especially (GWB)."[/i]

Well, either you haven't read very many of my messages, or you've pigeon-holed me into something you "think" I am, or both. If you want to discuss it further, and hear an overview of my positions, let me know. I will say thing, however, I'm not really supportive of any "person", per se, but rather a cause or a principle.

You said, "I don't like that our government has yet to win the so-called "war on poverty" either. You know why not? They don't want to win. They make too much money from the taxpayers and spend it on whatever pork projects they want in the name of poverty. Meantime, the poor get poorer, and the money never gets to them. What a scam."

The only thing I disagree with is that I don't think we should have ever started in the first place. Poverty in America had been declining, in both numbers and percentages, in the United States EVERY decade of the 20th century UNTIL President Johnson came up with this stupid idea. It made things worse, not better. It made people more dependent on government, not less.

On your Iraq comments, like I said, my message has nothing to do with Iraq. Absolutely nothing.

by av .

When you say troops and war, I immediately think of Iraq, not the war on poverty.

I've read enough of your posts to know that you have alot more trust in the Republicans than I do, and you don't like Democrats. Those are the people that give us all those nasty entitlement programs.

I wish they never started the programs either because they were mismanaged or unmanaged from the start. There were plenty of lazy people to abuse the system then and now there are even more. Soon, we are even looking at legalizing the mother of all entitlement programs, amnesty for illegal aliens.

I'm sick of paying for all of it with my tax dollars. I'm willing to pay some for the needy, but I want to choose the organizations I support. Welfare just enables laziness and is a taste of free money. Necessity is the mother of invention.

Maybe if we didn't have all of these entitlement programs, we wouldn't have an illegal alien problem.

by oz_media

Yeah I see where this is going.

Honestly, with your current administration, this war will go nowhere (for once). WHat administration could end it? I don't know, but it certainly wont be this one, nor the next, nor the one after that.

No matter which country we look at and no matter how hard wefight it, the battle will coninue. There will always be those who claim to be 'victims' of war and who will choose to remain held captive, we can't save them all.

What a comeback post you could have if people misunderstand your meaning, which has almost happened already..

by maxwell edison

That's an understatement.

The only connection to the war in Iraq is that it was a play on the words of many people opposed to it, primarily the Democrats in the U.S. Congress. I don't think a day goes by when some Democrat isn't calling for an "exit strategy" to the war in Iraq, which has been going on for only a few years.

These same Congressional Democrats have been waging the "War on Poverty" since 1964! Okay, Mr. Democrat, how about YOU define an exit strategy to YOUR war? The one YOU'VE been waging for forty friggin' years! My "troops" are the taxpayers, and so on. And I call for a full withdraw of the troops.

So that was my intention, to apply their demands to themselves. Some people didn't get it, however. Oh well.

by oz_media

It was pretty blatant for anyone who knows you, or at least I thought it would be absolutely apparent to any American voter that was your intent. ;)

You're right though, how can you prepare an exit strategy when there is still so much unrest in the middle east?

I agree that you have to be there(Iraq), and you could use more help too, Canada's soldier is busy in Kandahar right now and Canadians wouldn't be happy if we sent her to Iraq anyway. :D

As you very well know; I am just saddened that it had to happen this way to begin with, but you sure as hell can't call it quits now.

It would be nice to see an EFFECTIVE exit strategy for poverty though, Iraq too of course.

by Member 25348569

how some peers have seen the word "war" and kicked into anti-Iraq mode!

I'd like to mull this one over. The "poverty" in the US is - or at least appears to be - linked to race but whether as cause, effect or coincidence, I don't know. Poverty is also relative and I don't know how poor your poor are. I've got to go and read LBJ's original speech first, anyway.

by dawgit

He was not a crook. (he was a crack)
Peace and Prosparity.!. (we've already got the dirty little secret process down pat now)
so.... Dig him up and put him back in the (not so) White House.

by dmambo

Another apparently lost battle. The libertarians among us would also call that one off.

No matter how you feel about it, that war probably has the most casualties. OD's, gang violence, etc.

by maxwell edison

The war on drugs: Not only has it failed to eradicate, or even curtail, drug use, but it has actually caused more crime. Moreover, the infringement on individual rights is contrary to both the letter and intent of the constitution. Law enforcement agencies are using this as a revenue generator. Smoke a cigarette. Drink a scotch. Smoke a joint. It's a personal decision, perhaps a choice between that person and her doctor, and I call for the freedom to choose.

by tony hopkinson

Basically because it's a waste of time.
The libertarian ideal of people should be free to f**k themselves up if they want is all well and good. I'm more concerned with the impracticality of stopping them do it.

Do you want to know the most powerful interest group against the legalisation of drugs, drug barons. Watch out for lobbyist's some of them are nasty.

by absolutely

As neilb commented above, poverty is linked to race. Waging of the war on drugs is also linked to race via neighborhood, although drug [b]use[/b] is not.

by Former member

Maxwell,

your post is slightly confusing? Are you talking about the war on poverty or the war in Iraq. The current war in Iraq has nothing to do with poverty and everything with securing oil for our countries future needs. I'm just trying to understand what your main point is. Are more concerned with the poverty of other nations or the war you call illegal? I do think it is time they cleaned up the mess and quit dumping money into it, but just packing up and leaving with having a stable government (that is friendly to the US. think about the oil) is foolish.

by faradhi

Here's a strategy.

1) Employers should pay a liveable wage for all workers. That is a wage (for actual work) that is enough to feed and house.

2) Provide a way for all workers to obtain adequate health care. A sick worker is less productive. Adequate health care will reduce the number of days an worker misses due to illness.

3) Provide adequate long term care for those unemployable due to illness or other medical conditions. Mental health and physical disabilities are the chief causes of poverty and homelessness.

Do those three things and the "war" could be ended.

by faradhi

lets break this down

1) Employers should pay (oh yeah that was part of my original statement for this step) I am just funny that way. I believe employers should pay a wage. And yes I think it should be a livable one.

2) Most would obtain this through their employer as they do now. Those that don't should have a way to obtain affordable health care. But since this plan has them working for a livable wage, they will most likely be able to pay something.

3)For the last one you would be correct. I believe that we have a societal obligation to those unable to provide for themselves. I believe it is the Christan thing to do. If you don't then we will have to agree to disagree.

by old guy

Faradhi, that would be great if we could implement it. I'm afraid though that there are way too many who don't want to work. When Welfare was implemented it was for a good thing but people realized they could get it and not have to work. A lot of people would rather be lazy and take the hand outs. I feel it is self-propagating and passed down through the generations. I'm glad for the ones who take the initiative and gets out of it but just how many do that?

How would this affect your strategy?

by faradhi

If you give workers a livable wage they will work. I know this because I have worked on a volunteer basis with people on welfare. They want to work. However, if you could not work an live at a certain level, and work and live at the same level, what would you do? Working for minimum wage (well below the poverty level) does not provide them a better life. Pay them a livable wage an they will work.

Let me address the standard rebuttals here. The first rebuttal is, "Well if they would just work at bettering themselves, they would be able to get a better wage." There are people who are smart enough to do anything better than flipping burgers or digging ditches. Besides, we will always need people to fill those jobs that are now minimum wage. These people should still get a livable wage.
The second rebuttal is that there would be no incentive to do better because I can get by flipping burgers. Well if that was true then businesses can stop paying the higher wage jobs and pay just a livable wage. Now we know that won't happen. So there will still be people who want more than just a livable wage. Therefore, there will be people who try to better themselves.

by old guy

I work in Memphis too and how many women keep popping out the kids so they don't have to work? Yes, I agree there are some who want to work and better themselves and I wish that would be the majority by even 1%. No, there are too many people who don't know and don't want to know how to change their "fate" they just want to keep getting the hand outs. They also know how to play the game with those who volunteer to try to help them. Am I cynical about these? Yes I am. I've seen and heard them say they don't want to work.

by faradhi

I have heard the same. And I am cynical as well. I have see people try to play me and the system. I am not stupid or niave.

Again, If one can work in poverty or not work in poverty which will they choose.

My post applied to those who will or cannot work. Not the ones who don't want to. If there are jobs for everyone who wants to work and you pay a Livable wage. Then you can eliminate welfare. Suddenly, those people who don't want to work will. The trick to to have jobs for those people.

by old guy

about the ones who do want to work. And like I said earlier I really, really wish this could be implemented and caused to work. However, I'm afraid that we will always have this hugh drain on us from the ones who just wants the hand outs and pop outs.

Not trying to be funny or disparanging but how is it that most of the ones who don't want to get out of poverty or off welfare are so over weight? You just see so many that are extremely obese. (just wondering-not trying to get off topic.)

by absolutely

faradhi: "If there are jobs for everyone who wants to work and you pay a Livable wage. Then you can eliminate welfare. Suddenly, those people who don't want to work will. The trick to to have jobs for those people."

Absolutely: If people work diligently, and live at the wage they're able to obtain from the free market, they will, eventually, succeed at being promoted and finding better work. If you start by eliminating Welfare, they will have only the productive option, and then, you can be sure, they will all choose that option.

by johnnysacks

Goes for the rich little irresponsible brats and welfare recipients alike, except I'm paying the ones on welfare. Nothing more disgusting than someone on welfare the size of a pregnant walrus driving to a Medicaid appointment to treat a heart condition and diabetes in a Lexus at 2:00 in the afternoon after having a super sized KFC fried dinner for lunch.

Who out there expects that if he does not show up for work and perform a service for his employer, his employer will continue to pay him. I'm a fairly liberal person but that doesn't mean I'm willing to be the sap who perpetually offers hand outs to the same person just because he fell out of someones womb.

The system needs to provide the opportunity for a person to be compensated for performing a service, regardless of how demeaning or distasteful that service is. That in itself is extremely difficult, but once in place (and only then), if the service is NOT performed, CUT THEM OFF COLD ALREADY GODDAMIT!

by old guy

That could work. Tell you what, since they are trying to recall Mayor H why don't we put you in there. I can try to run your campaign for you. :)

by faradhi

than that Hack.

One other condition, you must become chief of staff.

* edited to add

Or even better county mayor.

by old guy

you try to invite the council or anyone else to meet you in the boxing ring.. :^O

by absolutely

faradhi: "I believe that we have a societal obligation to those unable to provide for themselves. I believe it is the Christan thing to do."

You're free to such beliefs -- at your own expense, not at mine. If you choose to commit charity you are free to do so, and to choose whether to give a convenient amount, to "give until it hurts", or to do as Christ instructed you: sell ALL that you have, give the money to the poor, and follow in his footsteps. Anything short of that makes you a hypocrite. Using the tools of Caesar (government) to achieve the goals of Christ makes you a hypocrite. Jesus strongly disliked hypocrites. That may be the only thing that he and I have in common, but I definitely have no patience with hypocrites, especially when they claim their superstition entitles them to dispose of my property.

by faradhi

The one who says he's a christian and does nothing.

Or the one who at least does something, and lives as a christian. I have worked with those less fortuniate. What have you done?

by absolutely

I did not say I was a Christian. I have said repeatedly, on other TechRepublic threads, that I consider myself above all superstitions, and consider Christianity nothing better than any of the other superstitions of the world. You mentioned Christianity, and you asserted that [b]your[/b] religion prescribes a [b]societal[/b] obligation. It does no such thing. Any item of Christian dogma applies [b]to[/b] Christians, not [b]from[/b] Christians [b]to[/b] atheists.

I have also worked with those less fortunate. I am not heartless, you are brainless.

by tony hopkinson

as well, nothing to do with christianity though. I believe in the safety net of the welfare state, for me it's an insurance policy to cope with the vagaries of the market.

Unlike a lot of socialists however, I feel no need whatsoever to provide for those who have no desire to provide for themselves.

As far as I'm concerned Abs could opt out of paying for the welfare state, however if he falls off the high wire, he needs to write out some big cheques on the way down.

Any one who is incapable of competing in our rat race, must be provided for, preferably by giving them skills to compete and contribute, anyone who chooses not to compete, well they can f'off. I've no time for them, they deserve nothing from any of us.

by faradhi

I never proposed to provide for those who WILL NOT.

There are people who due to mental and physical disorders cannot provide for themselves. They are an extreme minority.

I suggest that if employers paid a liviable wage to all workers and if there are jobs for all who are capible of working, then you can eliminate welfare.

I believe that if you meet those two criteria, then welfare will end itself. I believe that given the choice of living in poverty with welfare or not living with poverty by working, that people will choose not living in poverty. Many disagree.

To all who disagree, how about a compromise. When employers start paying a livable wage to ALL WORKERS, I will be the first to support ending welfare in all its forms.

by absolutely

Tony Hopkinson: "As far as I'm concerned Abs could opt out of paying for the welfare state,"

Thanks, Tony, but the role of government is to protect rights, not to become an insurance provider. That industry is one of the most profitable around because "disasters", by definition, are rare. The assumption of honest, industrious workers means that this insurance policy could be provided [b]profitably[/b]. Would you object to somebody earning a profit by securing the certainty of a livable income for you?

Privatize this insurance system you describe, make it opt-in, not opt-out, and place no penalties on those who do not opt-in, and I'll consider getting such a policy myself. There's little cost in being prepared. The insurance policies I do have are very inexpensive compared to the potential expense and inconvenience from which they protect me. That is the reason people buy insurance. The low number of claims compared to the number of people who purchase such protection is the reason that other people [b]provide[/b] insurance.

Tony Hopkinson: "...however if he falls off the high wire, he needs to write out some big cheques on the way down."

Fat chance! As long as my rights as described in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States of America are secure, "the high wire" is only a figment of your imagination!

by tony hopkinson

That's a hard one. Being a socialist, I do believe in the minimum wage for instance.

The idea that someone is financially better off claiming welfare than earning is an anathema to me. I don't like what it does to them, to me and to society.

The idea that politicians benefit from a welfare class and actually work to promote them as a group who will always vote for them if they give them more makes me livid. More of what ?, my money.

Until the state chooses to make the distinction between those who won't and those who can't, anybody on welfare looks like a scrounging sad sack, or is confused with someone who is helpless in the society we create for our own benefit.

by absolutely

Is that what they told you? Did they show you their willingness to work, or just tell you? And you, being such a warm & fuzzy Christian, took them at their word, right? On faith, so to speak.

Live by faith at your own expense, not mine, slacker.

by faradhi

Because they were in a training program.

You call me a slacker but I work to improve lives in my spare time. What do you do? except critize those who actually work to reduce the burden on the rest of us.

by absolutely

There is no such thing in reality as a free lunch. Wihing for it, arguing for it, even voting for it won't cause it to exist. Really.

by jardinier

You're getting quite clever with your deliberately misleading headlines.

No doubt there would be a job available for you as a sub-editor on the Sydney Morning Herald.

[b]You have been especially and blatantly deceptive by using the word "war" as the only tag.[/b]

No doubt you think it's funny here, because you are not misleading the masses.

However it is the same technique, and I find it at least somewhat hypocritical of you to use this ploy.

[Edited to add content]

by sleepin'dawg

In the twenties it was Prohibition, a war on the evils of drink. A noble cause that, with the exception of one minor detail, the vast majority was not in favour of it and it created a criminal element, which was better organized than the government. If anything it was Prohibition which provided the impetus for organized crime, which when you stop to think of it, is better than disorganized crime.

Somewhere somebody snuck something in called "The New Deal", which upon closer examination, bore marked similarities to the sentiments of Mr. Marx and Mr. Engels. Not quite communism but definitely the beginnings of the descent into the morass of the social welfare farce. Up until then people had existed by taking responsibitity for their own welfare. They somehow managed to get through The Great Depression without relying on government handouts and as far as pensions were concerned saved and set money aside for their proverbial rainy day, on their own. Nobody looked to the government for much in the way of help and if they had, they wouldn't have gotten it but they managed to survive.

Then a guy called Hitler decided to throw a war. It was quite popular; everybody who was anybody attended and when the party was over there was a hell of a mess to be cleaned up. The clean up was somewhat delayed because there was a bit of a bash in Korea but after a few years that slowed down, as everyone concerned, agreed to disagree.

There were a few other minor shindigs, the worst of which was IndoChina and the French, with their usual flair for things martial, royally screwed that up. This necessitated the US stepping in to bail them out but with there usual arrogance the French, rather than be grateful, tried to stab there rescuers in the back. Why the US chose to be embroiled in this nonsense, is anybodies guess but it was called the War Against Communism, a war that took almost 45 years to win but still isn't really over yet.

In the meantime, politicians, to get people to accept all this, started giving out incentives and each party did its best to out do the other. Old Lyndon Johnson got real fancy and labeled it the War on Poverty. It didn't do much for the poor other than to encourage them not to work and took away money from those who did. This phenomena was not confined to the US, just about every western nation has climbed on board the welfare wagon and now it rolls merrily along on the backs of the tax paying public. Rather than providing any insentives to the poor to climb out of their holes, they are being fascilitated in remaining in them. Of course they will continue voting for the politicians who give them the most for the least amount of input required of them.

Will there ever be an end to this war; unlikely as long as those on the welfare rolls continue to have a vote. If anyone was really interested in ending this, they would restrict the vote to tax payers only, something unlikely to happen as the politician hasn't been born yet who has the courage to call for that one. It would probably be political suicide.

Then there is the War on Drugs. This is much like Prohibition, in that the more you try to restrict it, the more it seems in demand. I really don't know if there is an acceptable way to handle this but the idea of legalisation, would cut down on crime and permit government to reap the taxes on the various products. It would also take away the glamour of doing something illicit, which I feel has a lot to do with people starting drugs in the first place. Another thing to think about, is that drug addiction wrecks havoc on many lives not just that of the addict. Instead of jailing the dealers treat them the same as murderers and either jail them for life or execute them. You execute murderers but the havoc created by these dealers is much worse than murder. Why shouldn't they face the equivalent penalties???

Then there is the War on Terrorism. I hesitate to comment on that as I've already stated my opinion which you say is too extreme. Basically it is my opinion that you have to drive home to these scum an understanding of risk- reward. Practise terrorism and we will hunt you down and kill you. If in the act of hunting you down, your friends neighbours and family get in the way; so be it, you will be the one to have brought it down on them.

Until the terrorism stops; there should be a moratorium on all immigration from terrorist sources. All terrorist nations should be embargoed and quarantined until the terrorism ceases. All aid to these nations should be halted including humanitarian aid for natural disasters. Nothing in, nothing out. Inform the so called peaceful Muslims they had better start speaking out against the terrorists more forcefully; If they aren't for us then we must perceive them as being against us. We should also stop tolerating their attitudes regarding women when they come here and ignore their whinings as regards their right to pray when and where they want. They come here unasked, they should adapt to us; we shouldn't have to adapt to them. Whether they like it or not our nations are based on JudaeoChristian principles; how far would we get pushing our Christianity or Judaism in places like Syria, Iran or Saudi Arabia. They should be free to practise their religion but they are not entitled to any special considerations. If they don't like it they can stay home.

Is there an exit strategy in any of this??? Yes there is but not one any of our leaders seems willing to act on. They either lack the moral fibre or intestinal fortitude to stand up to the regretably, inevitable onslaught that can be expected from all the left wing, bleeding heart, liberal-socialists of the ACLU and their ilk.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by gfisher9

The Johnson-era "bomb them into the stone age" gambit worked for a while, with cavelike tenements and "projects" springing up like Kudzu in summer, but that became recursive as we found ourselves both battling and sponsoring a growing population of cave dwellers sliding backwards along the timeline of civilization. By the time Carter showed up, most of the followers of the war's target philosophy were at or below the nomadic hunter-gatherer stage, and falling.

Then came Reagan and a turnaround of the Johnson war plan; now, instead of destroying, we moved to a strategy of building -- not cave communities but opportunities, hopes, even real education in those places where the old strategy wasn't too firmly entrenched. Today we've got unemployment at it's lowest level in decades (and among the lowest in the world), steady movement UP rather than down the economic "classes" and scale, and millions of successful small (and not so small) businesses started and run by the very people the Johnson Generation tagged as inherently dependant.

It may well be that the near-nuclear opening salvos of the war were necessary, but it's certain we'd have lost had we cut and run before retraining former followers of that fatalistic philosophy and constructing an infrastructure capable of truly overcoming it.

What remains is to work our way back out of the wartime economy, extracting less of the GDP from our citizens (who, after all, can spend it much more wisely than the Halliburton-dwarfing Welfare Industry) and return the nation to a peacetime path of progress.

Good post, "Maxwell." Love that silver hammer. (-:

by faradhi

Should be unacceptable. This is what you are doing if you are working minimum wage jobs.

Not everyone can be promoted. Someone has to be at the cash register, digging the ditches, washing the clothers, etc... Those people do not get paid a livable wage.

Again, someone has to do that job. Some people are only smart enough to do that job. Those are just facts. Those people should be paid a livible wage. One where they can get housing on their own, and pay to feed and clothe themselves.

Have you ever tried to live on minimum wage? You can't do it. $5.15/h*40h/w=$206/w. After Medicare/Social Security and Federal Income Tax that is $372 biweekly. $10416 per year.
Now because you make that much, you do not qualify for public assistance. So out of that $744 per month. You have to pay at least $400 for an apartment. $100 for utilities. That leaves $244 for Food, clothing, transportation. Public transportation here it is $25.00 for a 21 ride pass. You can't get anywhere in our public transportation system without transfering. That would mean at least $50 a month for public transportation. That leaves $194 dollars for Food and Clothing. And if you are eating off of less than $194 dollars, you are not eating healthy. Oh yeah, you haven't seen the doctor.

Now lets look at someone on welfare. They live in poverty. Just as the person who busted their butts working a minimum wage job. They are most likely in public housing. They can stay there an not work. Get Food Stamps and welfare. Get free medical. Or they can work in a store, get cussed on a daily basis by customers, have some half -wit boss treat them like crap, and live in poverty in a house worse than public housing. What do you expect them to do?

Ultimately, Employers must pay a livable wage.

by absolutely

I've talked to successful people who worked themselves out of poverty by holding two full-time jobs at once, plus a part-time job in some cases, and similar combinations of part and full-time work.

It isn't pleasant, and this isn't a fate I [b]wish[/b] for anybody, but it's a fact that work doesn't do itself. Another fact is that my wish for other people to live comfortably will not magically increase the [b]economic[/b] value of their work to the free market, which means me, you, [b]the poor[/b] and the rich.

I want a comfortable life for everybody, just like you. I used to believe in socialism, just like you. I learned that money represents a principle that cannot be ignored, except at the expense of unspeakable suffering for all who ignore it. That principle is free exchange. I'm not a cruel person because I prefer long hours for some over starvation for all. If your model were possible, I would support it. It is not.

Read about communist China, and the starvation of 65 million peasants, under Chairman Mao. It will change your life.

by absolutely

Evil: inimical to life on Earth.

Assertion of non-objective & unprovable assumption as basis of morality = evil.

Ergo, every religion is evil.

by absolutely

(1) Wage war on the causes of poverty, beginning with ignorance and anti-intellectual premises. First false premise to destroy: the government exists not only to protect rights, but also to do your work for you or pay your for work you haven't done. My employer only pays me for the work I have done in the course of the [b]preceding[/b] half month. Nobody is [b]entitled[/b] to payment for any value beyond what you have obtained in uncoerced exchange.

(2) No government assistance of any kind without [b]first[/b] availing yourself of [b]every[/b] private charity within reach of public transit and within walking distance. There are guilt-ridden churchgoers and superlatively productive industrialists falling over themselves to give away their money. Seek their help before demanding help from the police. Every penny spent on Welfare is a penny that [b]cannot[/b] be spent [b]fighting[/b] crime.

Words have exact meanings. "War" is not exactly the right word to use in conjunction with poverty, unless your goal is to murder all poor people, or all rich people. I'm still not exactly sure which is the goal of the welfare state, if it even has a goal. Whatever it is trying to accomplish, it is doing a crappy job.

by jardinier

but in Australia all Church and non-government charities are continually soliciting (begging actually) for donations to maintain the services which they already provide.

And these services are only band-aid or stop-gap services like giving short term accommodation to the most desperately needy, providing free second-hand blankets, furniture and clothing, food parcels, one-off payment of electricity or gas bills and so forth.

They also care for orphans -- a group that has tradionally been supported primarily by the religious.

As I have lived amongst some of the people who depend on charity, I know for sure that there is NO possibility of the charities carrying any more of the welfare burden than they already do.

So your point (2) simply indicates that you have NO IDEA of how the private welfare network functions, nor have you probably had any contact with genuinely needy people.

I have known young men who slept under bridges or in a cave in the bush because they were too proud (call that responsible if you wish) to claim any government benefits.

I have of course also known persons who scammed the welfare system.

As for point number (1) perhaps that should be introduced into the education system so that young people grow up with an understanding of the purposes of government.

However your whole approach to the problem is fundamentally flawed as you apparently take as your basic premise that every person in the world, but especially welfare recipients in America, is born with at least equal intelligence, health, opportunity and motivation as yourself.

Hopefully they are not required to have the same degree of cynicism and arrogance as yourself.

As mentioned elsewhere, who would do all the sh*t jobs if all were born with equal intelligence and motivation.

There is a gaping hole in your "logic" that could best be described as a bottomless chasm.

And while I have your attention, I will make yet another very obvious statement that atheism is in no way related to intelligence or insight.

There are intelligent atheists and dumb atheists, just as there are persons of all degrees of intelligence who follow the various religions.

I doubt that you will make it into the history books, Mr Absolutely, but if you referred to historical evidence you would readily see that many of the people who have made the greatest contributions to society have followed one religion or another.

This includes of course inventors, innovators, writers, artists of all kinds, military leaders, presidents, explorers and whatever else.

The wonderful heritage of Western art and music has largely been a by-product of Christianity.

If you have an ear for quality music, listen to Handel's Messiah. Remove the lyrics if you like, but still it is a magnificent work inspired WHOLLY by Christianity. Or visit Rome and view the art in the Sistene Chapel.

And which religion inspired the most beautiful building in the world -- the Taj Mahal -- why of course it was those murdering, uncivilised Muslims.

Why, even your revered President is not only religious, but aligns himself with one of the most anti-intellectual brands of Christianity.

by absolutely

What made my country great, may she rest in peace, was the freedom to speak for myself. George W. Bush rarely "speaks for me" in the sense that he has made very few statements with which I agree even in part.

In answer to the shortages experienced by your local charities, what percentage of their incomes are donors to those charities paying in tax? Do you believe it is fair to assume that in the absence of a welfare state, those that now donate voluntarily would only donate the same amount, or some other amount like a percentage of their after-tax income, which would increase if taxes were reduced?

My argument is not that "nobody needs charity", but that "nobody needs the government to tell us that some people occasionally need charity." Nor do I need a deity to tell me that, nor anything else. G'day.

by tony hopkinson

One of those rights is effectively the right to welfare.

You want people off welfare, pay for it. Vote for politicians who don't want a massive dependant underclass to secure a f'ing majority.

Society and community is not I'll take this bit and that one, but you can forget those and them.

All or nothing, you don't pay for welfare, you don't get welfare.

That f'ing figment of my imagination has struck down entire communities including the one where I was born and the one where I live. The state shut them down, sold their asses down the river and then knicked them for illegal use of a public waterway. I benefitted from that, so I get to pay my dues, how the hell else could I look my own family in the mirror ?

If you haven't been where I have, don't tell me how it should look.

by tony hopkinson

from ten at night 'til two in the afternoon ?
How many sixteen hour days in a row have you done ?
How many times have you put in these sorts of hours at a sh1t unrewarding job because you have absolutely no choice.

How objective would you be after doing this for a while.

My personal record by the way is 92 hours in one week, typing in six digit numbers in to a dumb terminal.

I will give you this it is a powerful incentive to move on.

Your arguments perpetuate a poor underclass, somebody has to clean the toilets and empty the rubbish. Somebody has to make a profit out of providing this service and that is the sole reason we have welfare. If we didn't, it either wouldn't get done or we'd eat into those nice company profits.

I always thought you were into tanstaafl, apparently you do want something for nothing though. You want people to understand that it's your right to have them do the crap jobs you are too busy to do and at a minimum cost to you personally.

Yes they could move on, but they have to be replaced, otherwise you would be stepping in litter and shit on the way up your handsome new drive.

Start by removing the need for welfare, your logic suggests that if we got rid of hospitals we would get rid of sick people. True admittedly, but exactly how healthy are you and what are your long terms plans for staying that way ?

I'd love to get rid of welfare, I doubt you would like my solution anymore than I like yours though.

Oh and no more pointing out Mao , Lenin et al, they had more in common with you than a real socialist.

by absolutely

I've put in as many hours in a single week as you also, and like you, the menial, monotonous jobs have also been an incentive for me to improve myself. An even more powerful incentive is the simple prospect of an improved self.

Tony: "Your arguments perpetuate a poor underclass..."

Nonsense. My arguments advocate a rising underclass that becomes a middle class. Socialism perpetuates a stagnant underclass. By the way, "poor underclass" is redundant.

Tony: "somebody has to clean the toilets and empty the rubbish. Somebody has to make a profit out of providing this service and that is the sole reason we have welfare. If we didn't, it either wouldn't get done or we'd eat into those nice company profits."

People on Welfare don't perform these services. How do you reason that "If we didn't (have welfare), it either wouldn't get done or we'd eat into those nice company profits."?

Tony: "I always thought you were into tanstaafl, apparently you do want something for nothing though. You want people to understand that it's your right to have them do the crap jobs you are too busy to do and at a minimum cost to you personally."

BS, Tony, I've paid my own dues, and 3/4 of the next person's! It has been my right to do crap jobs, to receive crappy pay for them, and to improve myself as much as I was able in my off hours. I chose to do exactly that. Now I have a slightly less crappy job than I used to have. It has [b]always[/b] been my right to be paid what my most lucrative skills are worth on the open market. No more, no less.

Tony: "Start by removing the need for welfare, your logic suggests that if we got rid of hospitals we would get rid of sick people."

Your logic suggests that nobody should cover their mouth when they cough, ever get inoculated, exercise or eat healthy. A government "safety net" will provide for us.

Tony: "Oh and no more pointing out Mao , Lenin et al, they had more in common with you than a real socialist."

I've never killed a single peasant, or blue-blood!

by absolutely

...to get you all riled up like that, eh, Tony.

Tony: "how the hell else could I look my own family in the mirror ?"

Why would you look at your [b]"own family in the mirror"?[/b] When I look in a mirror, it's usually at myself, and I tend to look at others directly. I'll wait for you to calm down, explain what thoughts were substituted by abbreviated profanity ["f'ing"], which I know is how people speak when we're too agitated, or stupid, to think. I've seen you write eloquently before, so I know you're not just incoherently stupid. Maybe you'll come down, sober up, or just relax as the case may be, and take enough time to clearly make your point, if you have one.

by tony hopkinson

Your objection against welfare is that it uses up your resources in ways that you don't personally condone.
You earned it, it's yours yes?

Anybody else is able to go out and earn theirs. If they did you would not have to pay to support them.

But how much have you benefitted from the system you decry ?

In a society with no welfare, those of us who succeed in our competition would have more, much more. Those who fail would have much much less. As the gap widens the chance of bridging it becomes less and less.

So the conditions in existance now ,for people to get off their ass and make it just like we did, would not exist.

Worse still the conditions that helped us make it would have not have existed, so would we have?

Don't know your background, but mine would have meant that the entire system would have been against me.

You want to talk about methods to get rid of the need for welfare, I'm with you all the way.

You want a talk about YOU not paying the price for the need for welfare, I ask myself, what have you done for this boon ? What massive contribution have you personally made to your community that you should not pay for it's existance which you benefit from everyday of your life.

The argument of no welfare, is also an argument against no public heathcare, no public education, no enfranchisement, no legal redress, no equal rights.

Don't tell me your constitution guarantees these things, because it would not exist or would become wholly meaningless, if your idea was taken to it's logical conclusion.

Community is about responsibility and debt, your community provided the environment where you could thrive, you have a duty to continue providing that same environment, or a better one.

How is your idea better when it negates the entire foundation that your community is built on ?

I got my first job on a welfare to work program, taxpayer's money was used to pay businesses to employ me for 6 months to see if I was worth anything. There were two reasons why I got a job.
The first was I put myself in position where I could be considered worth the risk of employing, the second was someone left while I was there.

I needed both those things to happen, one was completely out of my control, short of taking dead mens shoes a bit too literally.

A cautionary note to all gooder socialist types. We are almost at the point where welfare has become institutionalised, where it is not a choice made by education, region, abilitym economic circumstances or even sheer luck, but that of birth.

Politicians like welfare, businessmen like welfare (as long as they personally don't have to fund it). Continuance down this road will rob all of us of everything.

I have no problem with Abs' desire to get rid of welfare, just with his method and the fallacy that his own, mine and anyone else's success wasn't predicated upon it.

by tony hopkinson

you've paid some of them. Community isn't a pick and mix.

I know where you are coming from, I just don't understand how you can come to the conclusion that you bettered yourself soley through your own efforts in a community with welfare, social assistance, rights and laws for those who start out with nothing but their own naked brain and a fierce will to survive.

In the society you say you want you would not have succeeded except by killing peasants and the odd blue blood if you were ambitious. The rules give us an opportunity to succeed and a basic level of subsistance while we strive to do so.

by absolutely

Tony: "Your objection against welfare is that it uses up your resources in ways that you don't personally condone."

Absolutely: My objection is that it uses my resources in ways that are immoral.

Tony: "You earned it, it's yours yes?"

Absolutely: Yes!

Tony: "Anybody else is able to go out and earn theirs. If they did you would not have to pay to support them."

Absolutely: If they recognized their responsibility to do so, and acted accordingly as voters I would not [b]have[/b] to pay for them, but nevertheless would, through any atheist organizations providing such assistance out of pure benevolence with no BS about "heaven".

Tony Hopkinson: "But how much have you benefitted from the system you decry ?"

Absolutely: It's strange to hear "the system" from a leftist, used as justification. How much I have benefitted: net loss compared to a just, non-welfare state, which is the option I endorse, not the false pair of options you describe.

Tony Hopkinson: "In a society with no welfare, those of us who succeed in our competition would have more, much more. Those who fail would have much much less."

Absolutely: That's false, Tony, and you know it to be false because you are not a total failure professionally and economically, yet you endorse charity. You aren't the only one. The only difference between your concern for the unfortunate and mine is that I'm willing to help them without government coercion.

Tony Hopkinson: "Those who fail would have much much less. As the gap widens the chance of bridging it becomes less and less."

Absolutely: Absolutely false. Since the beginning of state welfare and other "egalitarian" economic wealth redistribution schemes, the distribution of wealth has become [b]less[/b] uniform, because any time that government is given power to do more than defend individuals' rights, the individuals in power abuse that power to do more than exercise their own rights, at the expense of those of us who have better things to do with our time than plot the looting of others' production.

Tony: "So the conditions in existance now ,for people to get off their ass and make it just like we did, would not exist."

Absolutely: Wrong, Tony. The present conditions were created, not bestowed. My country fought yours for independence, and [b]we won![/b]

Tony: "Worse still the conditions that helped us make it would have not have existed, so would we have?

Don't know your background, but mine would have meant that the entire system would have been against me."

The entire system against you? What do you mean by the system? And if it was against you, why do you now argue for it?

Tony: "You want to talk about methods to get rid of the need for welfare, I'm with you all the way.

You want a talk about YOU not paying the price for the need for welfare, I ask myself, what have you done for this boon ? What massive contribution have you personally made to your community that you should not pay for it's existance which you benefit from everyday of your life."

Absolutely: Which boon do you mean?

Tony: "The argument of no welfare, is also an argument against no public heathcare, no public education, no enfranchisement, no legal redress, no equal rights."

Absolutely: Wrong again, Tony. The argument of no government redistribution of wealth according to income is solely an argument for "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, (shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue,) but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." Mine is the argument for enfranchisement, legal redress, and equal rights. Yours is the argument against those.

Tony: "Don't tell me your constitution guarantees these things, because it would not exist or would become wholly meaningless, if your idea was taken to it's logical conclusion."

Absolutely: My Constitution promises individual liberty. The word "guarantee" may suggest a more respectful, literal interpretation than is presently common, but the words of the Constitution do mean what I say they mean, and I know that I'm right and you're wrong, regardless of how many people agree with either of us. As my idea has been decreasingly taken to its logical conclusion in law and courts, my Constitution has become less meaningful as a practical guarantee of the moral ideal it describes: absolute equal rights, without regard to race, gender, religion, birthplace, wealth, or any other measure of social status you may invent.

Tony: "Community is about responsibility and debt, your community provided the environment where you could thrive, you have a duty to continue providing that same environment, or a better one."

Absolutely: Communities have formed according to a great number of different principles. Responsibility in a society of equals is only to do no harm, not to repair the harm that others do. I get extra credit for having done some charity work, not condemnation for doing less than you would like for me to do.

Tony: "How is your idea better when it negates the entire foundation that your community is built on ?"

Absolutely: On this side of the pond, the community is built on the principle that each individual is born with inalienable rights, not with amorphous, arbitrarily, collectively-defined rights.

Tony: "I got my first job on a welfare to work program, taxpayer's money was used to pay businesses to employ me for 6 months to see if I was worth anything. There were two reasons why I got a job.
The first was I put myself in position where I could be considered worth the risk of employing, the second was someone left while I was there.

I needed both those things to happen, one was completely out of my control, short of taking dead mens shoes a bit too literally."

Absolutely: Good on you. If it wasn't for the welfare state, there would have been more jobs, not fewer.

Tony: "A cautionary note to all gooder socialist types. We are almost at the point where welfare has become institutionalised, where it is not a choice made by education, region, abilitym economic circumstances or even sheer luck, but that of birth.

Politicians like welfare, businessmen like welfare (as long as they personally don't have to fund it). Continuance down this road will rob all of us of everything.

I have no problem with Abs' desire to get rid of welfare, just with his method and the fallacy that his own, mine and anyone else's success wasn't predicated upon it."

Absolutely: I have had to work harder for less money because of irrational claims that I have a duty to certain collectives that supersedes my right to pursue my happiness. My success, such as it is, has been achieved in spite of the welfare state, not predicated upon it.

by absolutely

Tony: "You haven't paid your dues, you've paid some of them. Community isn't a pick and mix."

Absolutely: I agree that community isn't a pick and mix. Neither is the principle of liberty, or the meaning of the word "inalienable" which is the [b]primary[/b] obligation of every individual in [b]my[/b] community to every other individual.

Tony: "I know where you are coming from, I just don't understand how you can come to the conclusion that you bettered yourself soley through your own efforts in a community with welfare, social assistance, rights and laws for those who start out with nothing but their own naked brain and a fierce will to survive."

Absolutely: That isn't what I concluded, and I didn't start out as you described, either.

Tony: "In the society you say you want you would not have succeeded except by killing peasants and the odd blue blood if you were ambitious. The rules give us an opportunity to succeed and a basic level of subsistance while we strive to do so."

Absolutely: I disagree.

Capitalism does not mean anarchy, it means the right to own the property [b]that we earn[/b], no more and [b]no less[/b]. The welfare state arose in The United States after the Great Depression, which was the result of wild speculation, which was the result of collective ownership of the tools of production. I do not believe that further collectivization of the tools, or the products, of production, is a good solution to the problem of economic cycles I believe that basic understanding of the causes of economic cycles is possible for the average person, and provides a complete solution to the insecurity caused by life's occasional economic and professional misfortune.

by jdclyde

and everyone below that.

How and why did they do that? They raised the Minimum wage, ALOT!

In the surface, this will look real good to all you "feel gooders" out there, until you decide to take a logical look at the results of your trying to make yourself feel better.

If someone has decided to work full time at a minimum wage, either through not getting themselves the proper education and training to be worth more, or are just not motivated to achive more, legislating a raise for these people using someone elses money has just HURT EVERYONE MORE THAN IT HELPED ANYONE.

When you raise the minimum wage, (which is for jobs NEVER intended to be used as a lifes work) you have just raised the COST OF LIVING on EVERYONE. Companies have their profit ratio to maintain, and if you reach in their pockets and steal money, they will just raise the price of all goods and services to COVER THIS INCREASE.

People at the minimum wage can now say they make more, but if everything they have to buy costs more, how did YOU (the feel gooder) improve their situation?

Everyone ELSE gots hit by this increase in the cost of living, but THEY didn't get this two dollar an hour raise. Someone working in a shop making $12 to $15 and hour will not be getting this same $2 raise, but WILL have the shared cost of living. This has lowered how much of their money they have left after buying the bare neccesities [i](why can I never write that without hearing Balu singing that?).[/i]

People, when will you start thinking for a change, and see that there are consequences for your trying to make yourself feel good. YOU, and everyone that supports these extorted minimum wage increases have just devistated ALL the poor poor, AND all the middle class as well. The rich? Sure, they get hit by the increase in cost of living as well, but just like all forms of taxes, this being in more of a flat tax basis, can be obsorbed.

by absolutely

Students, not parents (mostly). Arguments for minimum wage (existence in the first place, & subsequesnt increases) use low income families as their justification, but the benefit is to young, unmarried students with no kids, not to poor families. For poor families, increase in minimum wage is only a cost of living increase, because they're already making $8+ per hour, and still barely paying bills.

Lazy, rich-by-inheritance kids and their lazy, rich-by-inheritance parents benefit from increases to the minimum wage.

by sleepin'dawg

Believe it or not, there are far more of them than the lazy variety. eg: Bill Gates.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

I don't understand how "rich-by-inheritance" people of any age can benifit from an increase in the minimum wage. Can you explain what you meant by this?

And yes, most of the poor familes do NOT work for minimum wage, but will still get hit hard by the increase in the cost of living.

Hmmmm, must be coming up on an election year, because this increase is spread out over a year or so, just in time to try to buy the poor poor votes?

by faradhi

1) There are a lot of people that are just not smart enough to do anything other than flip burgers and punch a cash register. That is just a cold truth. These people should still get a livable wage.

2) Those people that do have minimum wage jobs and are smart enough to be trained for something else, have mulitiple jobs to survive. When are they supposed to get training to improve themselves.

by jdclyde

1) Go in and look at your local burger joint. It is NOT run by 40 idiots (in the true sence of the word), but rather it is high school kids for almost every shift, with adults as managers.

I refuse to intentionally lower the standard of living for middle class and lower class people based on an idea that helps no one.

No one DESERVES anything. You EARN it. No matter how stupid you are.

2) Multiple jobs to survive. They can do what I did when I made $6.50 an hour with a family of four as the sole provider. I got a second job AND went to school. I lifted myself from that to middle class and am still lifting myself up higher.

If someone doesn't have the drive to keep their expenses low and get further training, the only thing they "deserve" is to live a life based on the effort they put into it.

Stupid or not. Lazy or not. These people have no right to a free ride or a handout. These same people are NOT helped by this tax on the middle class because if I raise your income but ALSO raise your cost of living, you are NO BETTER OFF THAN YOU WERE BEFORE, and you have only succeded in hurting the TRUE working class people that make $8 to $15 an hour because THEY don't get this stupid feel good raise in income but STILL get hit by the increase in cost of living.

So when YOU FORCE a pay increase like this to make yourself feel better, YOU are the one that is responsible for bringing down the middle class to lower income classes.

For the REALLY retarted people in the world, they have programs that DO hire these people and DO give them a living wage. There are employers that have seen that retarted people are HARD WORKERS, and CAN be trained to do many jobs. I used to work with quite a few, and they all made between $10 and $13 an hour. These people will NOT be helped with the minimum wage increase because they DON'T work for minimum wage.

This is a misquided and illogical list you have given me, and having worked my way up from dirt poor I have personal experience with a lot of this as well.

The people that are too lazy, deserve to starve. The rest will find a way because there are the programs in place to help them.

by jaqui

While working as assistant Kitchen Manager at a Keg and Cleaver Steakhouse, I personally oversaw the training for all the staff in the Kitchen, itwas part of my job.
The best people we had were those who are mentally handicapped. [i] If the training staff has the patience[/i] to teach them, they are usually not only the most reliable, but also the best employees vis a vis attitude / moral as well.
I actually had to fight with my direct supervisor to be able to train them for anything other than dishwashers, but once I did, he quickly realised the value of them as cooks, and made sure that the Corporate Home office found out and witnessed their performance.
[ at the particular location I worked in, the Corporate home office has it's main entrance right beside the restaurant, so the home office staff were always underfoot. they actualy witnessed the battle to let me train the handicapped employees for other positions. ]

The point? a mentally handicapped person is more capable than most people believe they are.

on the broader issue of minimum wages:
Here we have one of the highest minimum wages in Canada, at 8 an hour, yet for the specific area I'm in, that still leaves someone working full time at that wage earning a take home paycheque of 800 less than the poverty line. If the minimum was raised to change that, it would drive a lot of small business jobs right out of the province.
Everyone is entitled to a fair days pay for a fair days work, but using government specified minimum wages can cause a reduction in employment oportunities, so it's not the perfect solution to the issue. The best solution is to have the regional Government create an environment that is beneficial to Business, promoting more business startups in the area. When there are lots of opportunities to pick from, the pay rates increase without government legislation to cause it.
[ the old supply and demand thing, lots of demand, limited supply, better wages ]
Because of the construction boom around here for the 2010 winter olympic games, I have heard that even MacDonalds is paying their staff $10 in order to get people to work for them, most of whom are not high school kids anymore, not around here.

by maxwell edison

(I would say that you're full of crap, with all due respect. However, your opinion is not deserving of respect.)

You said, [i]"There are a lot of people that are just not smart enough to do anything other than flip burgers and punch a cash register."[/i]

Sorry, dude, but that's pure B.S. However, people like you make those people believe they're no better than that. In my opinion, people with your mind-set do more to keep people down than those people, themselves. And they run across people like you in all walks of life: parents, schools, politicians, etc., all through their lives.

Moreover, when those kinds of people are indoctrinated from early childhood that the whole world is against them, that they're too stupid to succeed, they begin life with the wrong outlook.

What you just said is one of the most cruel things a person could possibly say to, or about, another person. And politicians say that very thing to them under the guise of offering to help them, in exchange for their vote, of course. And people like you consider yourselves compassionate. Personally, I think it's despicable.

I, on the other hand, will tell and encourage absolutely everybody, from day one, that they are special and unique, and their success is limited only by their own ambition. And then, people like me will encourage them every step of the way, all the while, people like you try to keep them down.

Why is it that people like you are considered compassionate, while people like me are considered mean-spirited and selfish? Talk about bass-ackwards!

by absolutely

(1) Anybody not smart enough to [b]earn[/b] a living has my permission to be grateful to whoever provides him with the ability to live, [b]not[/b] to claim by right what he is unable to provide.

(2) Other people's management of their own time is their own responsibility. I'll manage my own, you manage yours, and the time we don't waste managing each other's time is time that we will both have to pursue our own happiness more efficiently than we could possibly pursue each other's happiness!

by av .

1. I don't want to subsidize a raise of the minimum wage as a taxpayer and consumer. It isn't fair to me. In NJ, I am taxed to the hilt already. If business won't subsidize it, than I think these people need to educate themselves more, so they can get a better paying job. Its their problem. That is a cold truth too.

2. They will have to find the time to improve themselves. It isn't easy, but you do it if you have to.

by absolutely

Tony: "That's a hard one. Being a socialist, I do believe in the minimum wage for instance."

Absolutely: Have you ever studied the effects of wage regulations on the job market? Can you connect those effects to the logical contradiction with your argument of a community responsibility, or do I need to draw you a diagram?

by absolutely

Minimum wage?

What?

Anybody, regardless of inheritance, who makes minimum wage at a part time job while going to school, can advance by effort. But when minimum wage laws reduce the number of entry-level jobs available, the poor suffer and the rich kids work as golf caddies.

by Member 25348569

Over here, the minimum wage is a fairly recent introduction - 1999 - and did not exist in any form prior to this date.

Looks like we're a pretty good test-bed for the economic effects if you reckon that it's such a simple model, Absolutely, those effects should be easily observed.

It appears that this may not be the case and maybe our economy - and, by extension, yours - is a little more complex.

http://www.lowpay.gov.uk/lowpay/lowpay2005/chapter2a.shtml

Trot out your answers and lets have a look at them

p.s. An add-in, see section 3:1 - "For all groups, the effect of the minimum wage on employment was
statistically insignificant from zero. Results were robust when using an alternative data source
and alternative estimation procedures. In other words, there does not appear to be any clear
evidence that the national minimum wage has resulted in job losses."

http://www.ifs.org.uk/bns/05ebn5.pdf

by absolutely

And probably not before next weekend, if ever. But if, as you say, your minimum legal wage did not effect the job market, I'll bet you 3 cows and a mail order bride that most workers were already making more than that minimum, before the law took effect.

I'd appreciate any data you have comparing previous wages of entry-level, unskilled labor to those wages after the UK minimum wage law.

by faradhi

I do not support slackers.

I want to create the incentive to work. If you cannot understand the simple principal that:

If an individual can not work and live in poverty or work and live in poverty then inevitably that individual would not work. The results will be the same and prior is simpler.

My method of paying all workers a livable wage, will in fact remove that incentive not to work. It would change to: If you could not work and live in poverty or WORK and NOT live in poverty then inevitably the individual will WORK.

This will ultimately reduce your burden because more people will be paying taxes. Then we could afford to take care of those who CAN NOT work. It will improve the overall economy because they will be paying more.

Additionally, there will not be as large of a government drain.

The federal government will recieve more in taxes because there will be more people who actually pay.

Local governments will save BIG money because you can eliminate public housing. Taxes will increase because there will be more taxable property.

State governments will save BIG money on medicaid.

I am NOT advocating for welfare. I say pay all workers a livable wage and eliminate it. I am not suggesting YOU pay for it. I am suggesting the EMPLOYERS pay for it. Again, I am just funny that way. I think employers should pay their employees.

Now what part of that is too diffcult for you to understand?

by x-marcap

Frankly, socialism is as much a religion with the left as any Christian's viewpoints and should be treated as such...

by x-marcap

The point is they don't want to work nor do most beggers.

I have stopped to help dozens of the "Will work for food" signholders.They run away rather than chop wood with an axe. They won't trim trees with a chain saw. They want you to give them money, not to earn it... The same for welfare, but they have the power of the state to steal my resources behind them...

by jdclyde

Not everyone who CAN work does. If they can make a little more but have to actually DO SOMETHING for it, many won't and don't.

If they CAN, often it is under the table so they get the best of all three worlds. What is the third? Not paying taxes on the under the table job.

People will use a welfare system if you let them. If they have made the choices in life that have left them with no skills then they have no one to blame but themselves and deserver no handouts or free ride.

You don't want the money to come from us, but from the employer. Take a business class sometime and find out where the employer gets THEIR money from. US, the customer. If you in your illogical and poorly thoughtout plan to give the handouts of SOMEONE ELSES MONEY to the stupid people you are refering to, the companies will increase the price of the services or goods to pay for that increase in the cost of doing business.

Very simple, very basic. YOU have no right to give away someone elses money. Employers DO pay their employees based on the work they do and the job market. The better the market, the better the wages. Some jobs are NOT intended as anything but intro jobs, or part-time jobs for people working their way through school or as a supplimental job. It is stupid to think someone should get paid a "living wage" for flipping burgers, and immoral as well because, again, it ISN'T YOUR MONEY TO GIVE AWAY.

by absolutely

I just couldn't resist!

It's the same as going to one of our land borders and exchanging $US for the local currency. You'll measure your wealth with a larger number, but you [b]won't have more wealth![/b]

DUH.

Edit: "doesn't" -> "don't" in title. OOPS.

by absolutely

You went into more detail.

My premise on this subject: only rich parents who want their lazy kids out of the house, and making enough money to leave them alone, have anything to gain from increases to minimum wage. It's a stereotype, but wtf, it also matches my experience with these "types".

by faradhi

I am saying that one should be making a livable wage if they work.

Second, there will always be the need for unskilled labor. Not all unskilled positions can be filled by underage workers. These people should be making a livable wage.

Thirdly, raising minimum wage ten cents might raise the cost of living because it does nothing to improve the buying power of those who benefit from it. They still live in poverty. However, a livable wage does increase the buying power. They will be purchasing more. They will paying for housing rather than using your tax dollars. Paying for food rather than taking your tax dollars to eat. They will be paying for health care rather than waiting until it is serious and not paying at all. When they don't pay guess who does. Your right You do. They will be paying for clothing rather than using your tax dollars.

Additionally, this will reduce the tax burden for all of us because they will not be recieving public assistance. Medicaid, welfare, food stamps and public housing will be drastically reduced or eliminated. The tax base will increase. Local, State and Federal taxes could be reduced even further because more people will be paying into it.

Then once there is a livable wage job for everyone, watch how quickly so called feel good people like myself calls for the end of welfare in all its forms. I guarantee it will be swift.

Finally, those employers that hired retarded workers paid them a livable wage. They worked hard and the employers did not go out of business. Which actually proves my point that a livable wage might work.

by faradhi

The REALITY is that as long as someone can work 80 hours and live in poverty, you will not get rid of welfare.

The REALITY is that you can not get 50% of the nation to agree to end welfare outright? If the majority of the nation believes as you do, why has it not been ended already?

The REALITY is that unskilled labor will always be needed.

Ultimately, you have to make a decision. Pay for it with higher taxes and give people welfare for no work OR pay a livable wage and let them contribute. You don't like the choices, tough, It is REALITY.

by jaqui

at least in my post I managed to not call him names for it... even though it shows exactly the same attitude as yours to people generally.

gods, that's twice we've agreed on a subject, third times means one of us has to die you know. :p

by maxwell edison

This mindless back and forth nonsense (not necessarily with you, but with others) is killing me anyway -- especially those stupid global warming threads. So please, put me out of my misery; or put me out of their misery; or whatever. Global warming is going to kill us all, anyway.

By the way, I didn't even read your reply before I posted my "flame". And I would have toned it down a bit if I just thought about it; but it was more of a reaction that just kinda' happened instead of a well thought-out response. One of my pet-peeves is people who limit their thinking, so it got my goat, so to speak.

by faradhi

My point was that there are people who's future is limited. People with 70 IQ cannot be NASA engineers. People with 80 IQ can not run a multi-national corporation. No matter how much encouragement I give them.

Those people wherever they end up working should be paid a livable wage.

You think I am full of crap fine. That is your opinion.

by oz_media

Many people flipping burgers are also not the least bit interested/motivated toward anything else. I had a friend who was absolutely thrilled to be working in a government dairy (BC Liquor Store). He wanted nothing more from life and therefore got nothing more out of life. He also wasn't SHARP enough for many jobs. He was a high school grad, quite intelligent but not quick to the draw, he didn't have what it takes to be a naturally good salesman or 'deal maker' for example. I have trained MANY MANY sales reps and other staff members from many departments, som epeople have what it takes others will always lag behind. He COULD have learned but would never have beengood at it.

So I agree, not everyne is cut out for every job,some people will just never get it. Like my damn talented sister, if I only had one OUNCE of her painting and creating abililty! But even the simplest 'knock-knock' joke gets you a blank look from her, she will get it but not quickly.

She's not dumb, she's just talented in another area, as am I.

faradhi, a bit blunt but who am I to call someone too cut and dry? :)

Your point is there and true, perhaps teh choice of words was too simple.

I agree though, some people just aren't cut out for all jobs, in fact for some people flipping burgers is a great achievement. I have seen many handicappedpeople working MacDOnalds jobs, I say all the power to them, well done!

Do what you can and do it well, then WHAT you do is really irrelvant.

by maxwell edison

Wages are a measure of a person's output. Once you start playing around with that, such as trying to implement government mandated wage demands, it's no longer a measure of output. I know all the arguments for minimum wage and living wage and all that, and some of it may be true (although much of it is pure B.S.), but government mandated wage demands are not the answer. The old saying, two wrongs don't make a right, applies in this case. Your problem might be a valid one, but your proposed solution is the wrong one. I would support dialogue to find another solution.

On my previous "flame" post, let me add this (in addition to my previous "kill me" message). Regardless of a person's lot in life, IQ, or whatever, he/she should be encouraged to be the best, dream big dreams, and establish goals. And not all people have aspirations of making it to the big time, so to speak. The best definition of success I've ever heard goes something like this. If you turn your dreams into goals, whatever those dreams might be, success is measured by the steady progression towards those goals. I doubt if a person with a 70 IQ would actually have a goal to become a CEO of a major corporation, but rather something closer to his/her abilities. There's another saying (that I'm paraphrasing) that might apply as well. If you can imagine something in your mind as a possibility, then the power to make it come true does indeed lie within. I believe that applies for almost every person alive. That should never be discouraged.