Okay, I've had it. I call for an EXIT STRATEGY to this war.
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by absolutely
There is no need for [b]you[/b] or any other person to [b]create[/b] the incentive to work: the nature of humans is to need food (among other things) and food does not plant and harvest itself, or slaughter and butcher itself. Reality has created the incentive to work. If you are serious about wanting to create the incentive to work, you are arrogant on a cosmic scale. The only thing necessary to motivate people to work is to [b]remove[/b] incentives to [b]not[/b] work!
faradhi: "If an individual can not work and live in poverty or work and live in poverty then inevitably that individual would not work."
What you're ignoring in that statement is that receiving government subsidies makes very few people rich, and even they have to spend a lot of that money bribing the Congress and Senate to keep subsidizing their "corporations". If [b]all[/b] subsidies were eliminated, the individuals who receive them [b]would[/b] have to work harder -- for a time. But hard work has a way of providing future rewards, in my experience. Slacking, conversely, provides incentives to STOP SLACKING! It's really, REALLY simple, and nobody, however wealthy, really has it "easy". It may not be as ugly as poverty, but everybody who works deserves respect for their effort.
by absolutely
maxwell edison: "Why is it that people like you are considered compassionate, while people like me are considered mean-spirited and selfish? Talk about bass-ackwards!"
Sorry, maxwell, but I personally do not give a rat's ass if ambition works for anybody else, I just want faradhi out of my way. I'm sure that a measure of compassion from people like me would get him out of my way faster than my present method, but ****amit, his type just [b]infuriates[/b] me. Sorry for contributing to the widespread misconception that selfish = mean-spirited. I'm trying to improve.
by absolutely
faradhi (about maxwell edison): "You think I am full of crap fine. That is your opinion."
That's my opinion, too. Rich people for the most part earn their money. (Exception for crooks & thugs of course.) Earning money means providing something or doing something that motivates other people to [b]voluntarily[/b] trade their money for the benefit they buy. In the case of a clerk with a 70 IQ or a NASA engineer with a 170 IQ, the money they receive for their work is money that somebody else has decided they are better trading away for the service provided. It's not compassionate or generous to encourage people to treat work as a burden when you [b]know[/b] it's possible for the same people to be proud of their effort, ability and their contribution to "making the world go 'round".
by absolutely
It's called the free market.
There is another problem with faradhi's arguments about a "livable wage". If somebody is being paid a wage, you can be sure that person is not working from their grave! Every wage that somebody accepts is a "livable wage" even if they have to take two other jobs to pay all their bills. Enduring that kind of effort builds character. What do you have against character?
by faradhi
My point was that there are things that people cannot do. There are cognitive and physical disabilities that limit how far someone can go.
I for example, cannot join the military because of a separation in the spine. All I wanted to be is a naval aviator. But no matter how hard I try that will never occur because I can not withstand the G-forces and still walk.
I also have godson and nephew who is Autistic. I am very encouraging of the child. He is very bright. However, he will have limitations on what he can and cannot do. Since he is only 4 we do not know what they will be. But I also know that my wife an I are the only ones who will baby sit. We are also the only ones who read, talk and treat the boy like he is a normal 4 year old (added other than his parents.).
Additionally, I have worked with an individual in a former job as a manager of a video store. He was below average in intelligence and the other managers did not think highly of him because they had to explain things more than once. He worked harder than any of my other employees. I worked with him for over two years because he wanted to be an assistant manager. I was the one that went over the district managers head to get him the position when he could handle it.
OZ was right in his statement. We using to have a saying at the Learning Disability's Association of Greater Memphis. People did not have a Learning Disability they had a Learning Diffrence. People are talented in varying ways. I donot think any more of the nasa engineer than I do the one asking me if I want fries with my burger. They both work very hard at what they do. They are both talented in diffrent ways.
by absolutely
faradhi: "I do not think any more of the nasa engineer than I do the one asking me if I want fries with my burger. They both work very hard at what they do. They are both talented in diffrent ways."
Admirable opinion, but you are only one of 6 billion or more members of the global market. The market has decided that certain tasks are [b]worthy[/b] of greater financial compensation than others. Who are you to say that [b]everybody on Earth[/b] is wrong, disproportionately tax those that the market favors, and give their loot to those that the market disfavors?
by jdclyde
you want to eat and have a place to live.
End the gravy train, and people have no choice but to go out and get a job.
Can't support their family? Maybe they should have thought about that before they decided to breed. You have kids you can't afford, then you pay a price for being stupid. Sorry, but we should not reward stupid lazy people with the free ride they have now.
For the worst case senerio, there SHOULD be a safety net, that you could exist on for up to two years max. After that, get a job or move to where you can get a job. Might mean moving to a place with a lower cost of living, and you can't have that second, third and fourth TV. You might have to give up your cell phone and a lot of your "bling", and probably even that second car.
You don't have a RIGHT to ANYTHING but "life, liberty, and PURSUIT of happienss". You have no right to happyness, just to pursue it. You don't earn something, you deserve nothing.
The ONLY thing that will ever "give an incentive to work" is the need to survive. When the begging and whinning don't get them the handouts to live off of, they will do what the rest of us do. Work for a living, and live within our means.
YOUR socialistic misguided attempts to help people will only result in making even more people poor by YOU forcing an increase on the COST OF LIVING. Really not a difficult concept.
FACT. In America you don't DESERVE a living wage, you EARN a living wage. You didn't work to get yourself in a position to be able to earn this living wage, you have no one to blame but yourself. I have seen "stupid" people succeed. I have seen retarded people succeed. Jaqui has also given first hand examples that "these people" ARE employable and DO not need or WANT your handouts. THEY are not the people that are getting ANY benifit from your socialistic world. Only the lazy, not the stupid. Lots of hard working stupid people.
Can't save everyone, only the people that want to be saved.
by jdclyde
the money conversion is a good example of what I have been TRYING to get across.
We can make someone feel good about themselves because they can say they make a higher wage, but if everything they have to buy is more expensive then you didn't actually help anyone.
Just one more empty promise to the poor poor.
by jdclyde
We are talking about almost a 30% increase, not 10 cents. You don't think that will raise how much EVERYTHING will cost?
The retarted workers are making a living wage because they have REAL jobs doing REAL work, NOT sitting in fast food flipping burgers.
You get paid according to the type of work you do. Not all work is worth the same amount and people in the local ice cream shop are doing nothing to deserve $7 an hour, but thanks to feel-gooders running around spending OTHER PEOPLES MONEY, we will all pay more AND have a longer wait to get our ice cream cone because the owner can not afford as many employees anymore. YOU have just put people out of work creating more welfare?
Get your hand out of other peoples pockets. You have no right to be there. When you start up your own business, you are free to pay each and every underqualified person you hire this living wage you are speaking about. Of course, when you can't compete and go out of business, then will you be on welfare too?
When you make changes, the changes affect more than just putting more money in the hands of a college student working his summer job, and you need to START looking at that side of it for a change.
Frankly capitalism is a dogma and should be treated similarly to other religions.
Course if I said that I'd be limping incoherrently as well.
LOL
The socialist values I hold are born from seeing them being practiced and not practiced.
You of course may have seen similar 'experiments' and come to different conclusions. Even Abs' famed objectivity seems to fail him in this area.
Me I make no claims to being objective about it, far too personal to me.
I equate no socialist values with Thatcher and as far as I'm concerned she had the compassion of a bear trap in a children's play area.
identities give us a very different view of socialism.
For instance I view the american constitution as a very socialist document. In fact, off the top of my head I can't think of a better one.
Those rights you have written down to point out I do not. Why were they written down, so no one could welch on the deal between the state and the individual.
What I was trying to say, that to my lights, your constitution was created by socialists based on social principals. The purpose of the state is to guarantee individual liberty, to provide the environment for the pursuit of happiness. etc
My view is the state has a duty to try and provide that environment for everyone and that until a better idea than giving them some of my wealth comes along, I am happy to keep doing it.
To me it's a lesser of two evils as long as it does not continue to be institutionalised. If that continues to happen, we might find ourselves on the same side, though our reasons will be very different.
by faradhi
http://www.umass.edu/peri/resources/livingwages.htm
more coming...
by absolutely
"more coming..."
Did I miss it?
by absolutely
jdclyde: "Can't save everyone, only the people that want to be saved."
Absolutely: Saved? From what? I need only to be [b]safe[/b] from harm, to pursue my happiness, not have it bestowed by anything, seen or unseen. I'm quite talented, and pursue happiness extremely effectively, when safe and free.
by jdclyde
The NASA engineer may not be more important as a person, but he IS more important as an employee because he has completed years of training to gain the skills needed to do his job. This ABILITY and EFFORT are rewarded with a higher paycheck.
The thing that invalidates your emotion based stance on minimum wage is that the majority of unemployed or underemployed are NOT mentally retarted.
You talked about someone to do manual labor. Manual labor pays above minimum wage in most cases in shop jobs and construction. Many in both fields have little to no training, yet make a living. True, there ARE the highly trained construction workers, but there are still the general laborers.
Cleaning bathrooms and such. Janitors do NOT make minimum wage either, and these same people you are using EMOTION to justify your stance over are NOT helped by a minimum wage increase, but HURT by it.
As for people like your nephew, he is not like every 4 year old and that is really a sad thing. I can not speak for people with that form of disability, but there IS a form of support by the government that does help if I recall? Could very well be wrong. Either way, it is not the owner of the local McDonalds's responsiblity to just give away money to him if he can't do the job, and it is also not the owners responsiblity to pay above what the job is WORTH, just because the prospect employee can't get a job anywhere else, according to you.
We don't get to do what we want, we do what we can. I want to be a "kept man" to a hot international model, but I don't see that happening either. :( I have to be content being a geek instead.
"fair" has no basis in modern life.
I don't think your an evil person, even if you are advocating extortion and theft. I think you are one of the people out there that FEELS more about this than you THINK about this. I personally am not a very emotional person, and look at the cause and affect ratio of what your extortion would do to middle class America to bring it down to lower class America.
And yes, you wanting to legislate the taking of someone elses money is theft, just not being honest enough to do it openly. You have no right to someone elses money. If an employer is not paying a wage in line with the work, they will not be able to fill positions and keep them filled.
Worry more about employers hiring illegal aliens under the table, half the wage anyone else is getting. These people should be put in jail and punished more severily than the illegals themselves.
by faradhi
Every state I wanted to "you wanting to legislate the taking of someone elses money"
I never mentioned a minimum wage. I stated that to end poverty that employers must pay above the poverty line aka livable wage.
by jdclyde
you are doing exactly that. You are trying to dictate how someone spends their money. An employer is still a person that is doing the same thing we are. Working hard to improve THEIR lives. If you are going to make them pay more than a job is WORTH, YOU are extorting their money, and making them less competative.
Do you know why the train systems in the US are not competative, while trains in other countries are? Over legislation. Why don't we have a bullet train? Because it seems that the bullet trains that are used in Europe are not up to code for the US. Over legislation hurts us in the US, and giving an advantage to other nations.
When did companies first start to outsource jobs? When democrats decided to keep digging deeper and deeper in someone elses pockets, so to allow them to have the money THEY earned, they HAD to move part of their organization over seas. Democrats are directly responsible for the loss of these jobs, because it was their greedy tax grab that chased the jobs away.
Keep government out of our lives, and they have no constitutional right to be involved in labor in the first place. They, and YOU have no right to take money away from someone and give it to someone else. That is what YOU are doing when you push this silly "livable wage" idea and try to apply it to jobs that do not merit this same livable wage.
If someone wants a livable wage, they get rid of the credit cards and the cell phone and all the extra luxuries that are not a right for someone to own, but a privalige for people that work hard to afford them. I don't have a BMW, but can't afford one. Can I get a government check to pay for it? There is no difference between that and the poor poor having things like cell phones, and as ITgirli pointed out, the $200 shoes, and not to mention the gold and starter jackets.
You want something? Earn it or you don't deserve it. You have made excuses for the inexcusable. Being too lazy to get proper training to get a better position is not my concern. People living beyond their means are not my concern. People self-centered enough to breed when they can't even support themselves are not my concern.
You throw someone a lifeline, but if they don't grab it they drown. I will not carry them along.
by absolutely
I disagree, JD Clyde, and I think most of your message was very "fair", except the part where you let faradhi off the hook for being an extortionist. If he tries to practice his philosophy with my wallet, I'll shoot him in the face. He is nothing but a low-life thief, and doesn't deserve your patience.
It's no more fair to expect employers to provide higher wages than the market value of the work than to expect [b]consumers[/b] to pay higher prices than the market value of the food, clothing, shelter and other necessary expenses we have the right to purchase with money we [b]earn[/b], not extort.
by faradhi
according to Merriam-Webster dictionary is "to obtain from a person by force, intimidation, or undue or illegal power" At no time did I suggest anything of the sort.
I never once in the entire discussion suggested anyone should force anyone else to do anything.
I limited my points on what would happen if employers paid a livable wage. Further I backed that with documentation from business periodicals and economic studies.
YOU assumed I was talking about a minimum wage.
Instead of plastering your "Living Wage" links and pleas all over the place, let's start a new thread. And if you want to debate the issue, please do so in your own genuine words, not with links to articles or the usual political platitudes and rhetoric. If you want to reference those links to provide support for your own argument and assertions, which is something I often do, I would love to see that. But not a link to a page with dozens of links. No one will read them anyway.
Regardless of any and all arguments in favor of advancing the left's favorite buzz word (buzz phrase), "Living Wage":
1. It presupposes that an employer is responsible for an employee's life.
2. It presupposes that an employee is not responsible for his or her own life.
3. It establishes the basis for a third-party (outside the employer-employee relationship) to determine what that "living wage" might be.
4. It shows total disregard for an employee's wage to be based on that employee's output.
5. It infringes on an employer's right to decide what may or may not be best for his or her own business.
6. It infringes on the forces of fair competition.
7. It artificially inflates the value of both labor and the products produced by labor.
8. It's actually counter productive; as wages are artificially inflated, the cost of goods and services are artificially inflated; and the employee's very own living expenses are artificially inflated.....
9. .....Because it interferes with the basic economic forces of simple supply and demand.
10. It expands the role and influence of government in private affairs and private lives.
by faradhi
and plug your ears then there is nothing I can do to make you read the supporting documentation.
These are after the fact studies of citys that required all contractors pay all employees above the poverty level. The results show that the cost was minimal to both the employer and the city. In some cases both the employer and city broke even.
I will provide more supporting links later as time permits.
by faradhi
How can I possibly be in favor of government mandated wage demands if I'm against government infringing on personal and private rights, whether those be business or personal? The role of government is not to tell a private business owner how much he may or may not pay his employees.
Do you agree or disagree?
How can I argue a point if I disagree with its premise?
by absolutely
by absolutely
I'm going to define them for you.
(1) Livable wage: any wage paid to a living employee. If you're still alive while earning any wage, neither your employer nor anybody else has murdered you, and your wage [b]is[/b] a "livable wage".
by itgirli
The number of people living in "poverty" in the United States was in a steady decrease, in both numbers and percentages, every decade of the 20th century UNTIL the government started its "war on poverty". When will people realize that making people dependent on government, in any form, will only create a dependent class of people. It's made WORSE, not better. And I don't care what "it" is. And people continue to argue for more of the same thing. Insanity indeed.
Not only that, but the government is playing loose and free with the definition of poverty. The criteria keeps going up and up. For example, I've seen it said that the standard of living for America's poverty level is about equal to the lower middle class in Europe, in as much as the size of home, the amenities, the household income, etc.
Another story about something I saw just yesterday. I was in the grocery store in one on those self checkout lines. A guy who was buying a bunch of crap punched the food stamp button on the screen, and he then proceeded to swipe his government issued food stamp credit card. This guy was the epitome of a fat-ass, a big belly hanging down over his belt -- and I mean a HUGE belly -- while he was talking on his cell phone.
It's insanity. There's no other word for it.
by jamesrl
He is in line with what I believe on many things, yet he skewers both parties. I love that particular book too.
I lived in co-op housing in Toronto for a year and had my eyes opened. Co-op here means that a non profit tenants group runs the buildings, the buildings built through government loans. People like me paid market rates for rent, while the disabled or people on social assistance paid less than market. All adults were expected to contribute in one way or another to the association through labour - it could be making as part of the board, it could be cutting grass whatever.
My experience was that many of those on welfare had better cars than me, some had two cars when I struggled with one.
But the biggest lesson was that many of those (other than disabled) on subsidies didn't feel the need to contribute to the common labour - they didn't sign up for the work parties etc. They did show up to the association meetings and complain when things weren't done. They complained that we didn't have a washer and dryer in each unit (they did have a fridge and stove, and there was a common pay laundromat in the main building). Those of us with good jobs, who worked hard, also worked hard to make the co-op work.
I am all for a hand up not a hand out. I would be happy to pay someone on welfare or a dead end job to train for a better job, cause I know if they make more money they will pay more taxes and we all will recoup more than the initial "investment".
I'd be happy to subsidize the daycare of a single mother so she can work rather than stay home, since in the long run she will be less of a drain on the taxpayer and she will benefit as well.
But I am not happy to provide welfare to those who don't want to work. Ontario kicked many of those off, and provided workfare for some, which gave them job experience, and got them out of the poverty trap.
James
by jamesrl
He is in line with what I believe on many things, yet he skewers both parties. I love that particular book too.
I lived in co-op housing in Toronto for a year and had my eyes opened. Co-op here means that a non profit tenants group runs the buildings, the buildings built through government loans. People like me paid market rates for rent, while the disabled or people on social assistance paid less than market. All adults were expected to contribute in one way or another to the association through labour - it could be making as part of the board, it could be cutting grass whatever.
My experience was that many of those on welfare had better cars than me, some had two cars when I struggled with one.
But the biggest lesson was that many of those (other than disabled) on subsidies didn't feel the need to contribute to the common labour - they didn't sign up for the work parties etc. They did show up to the association meetings and complain when things weren't done. They complained that we didn't have a washer and dryer in each unit (they did have a fridge and stove, and there was a common pay laundromat in the main building). Those of us with good jobs, who worked hard, also worked hard to make the co-op work.
I am all for a hand up not a hand out. I would be happy to pay someone on welfare or a dead end job to train for a better job, cause I know if they make more money they will pay more taxes and we all will recoup more than the initial "investment".
I'd be happy to subsidize the daycare of a single mother so she can work rather than stay home, since in the long run she will be less of a drain on the taxpayer and she will benefit as well.
But I am not happy to provide welfare to those who don't want to work. Ontario kicked many of those off, and provided workfare for some, which gave them job experience, and got them out of the poverty trap.
James
by faradhi
Ignorance and handouts do propagate poverty.
People should work for a living.
I have seen those who cheat the system as well. Hell, I have had people try to play me in volunteer work.
But before condemning everyone in a poor neighborhood read Freakanomics. Expecially the chapter "Why do drug dealers still live with their moms."
Also I have also gotten some really nice stuff from goodwill. I mean never been worn fashion clothing. My wife gets fashion clothing for a fraction of the costs there. Stuff that has never been worn. You would believe the stuff there if you are willing to spend several hours sifting through crap. Luckly my wife likes to shop.
by itgirli
by absolutely
by itgirli
by faradhi
and show them that it is in their best long term interest to do so.
I never stated that the government should force anyone to do anything. I merely stated that until wages are above poverty levels, we will all be penalized more.
Here is a link from business week that showed that inflation and jobs were not hurt by the cities that have ordinances like I stated. Now I am not saying more cities should do the same. I am saying that since they have, it is a good real experiment whether or not businesses and workers will benefit by all employers paying a wage above the poverty level to all workers.
You said you never stated that the government should force anyone to do anything. Well, you never stated that they shouldn't, either.
Perhaps you didn't "state it" in that way, but which way would you fall? Should the government ever force anyone to do anything when it comes to wages? Yes or no?
If you say yes, you only proved you were playing with words, and you were only being coy and evasive. If you say no, then you agree with me. Moreover, if you say no, you will concede that any talk of "living wage" is silly, unless there's an enforcement mechanism, that is.
Okay, make yourself clear. If you support the implementation of a "living wage", what would your preferred enforcement mechanism be?
by faradhi
is to convince the employers that it is in their overall best interest to pay a livable wage.
Don't blame me if you assumed that I was talking about a raise in minimum wage. I deliberately stayed away from it. I did not want to discuss minimum wage.
You asked for an exit strategy. I gave you one. One that might work and has not been tried before.
I also gave one that if it was implemented, it would in fact, get people like me to tell welfare and public assistance people where to go.
I believe that if you can prove to business people in a capitalist form of economics that it is in their best interest to do something they will do it. Do you disagree?
by jdclyde
[i]"they have led to few job losses" [/i]
Would you want to be a part of the "few"? Did they get lifted out of poverty, or pushed down further?
[i]"mostly because contractor profit margins declined,"[/i]
Taking money away from the owners and giving it to someone else is the american dream? When it gets to the point that the owner can get a better return on THEIR money by having it sit in a CD or money market account than they do by running their business, who will be there to pay the "living wage"?
You will also note that this is about contracted jobs, not working in fast food flipping burgers. Jobs that were already above the minimum wage already.
A fair wage for a fair days work is great, but only if both sides are met.
Heck, working in a gas station today pays over what the minimum wage is.
One thing that is also scary is what happens when government throws a quick patch on something, like they did when they REQUIRED all full-time employees have medical. What did major chains do? Dropped most of the people down to part-time. Yeah, that sure helped people out.
by faradhi
I concede the first point.
On the second point, Those contractors were not required to do business with the cities. The contracter accepted the stipulations.
Read the studies by UMass how they were above minimum wage. They found that that was not always the case.
Again I am not talking about a MINIMUM Wage. I am talking about paying people over the poverty level. Look at a company like Fed-Ex, they pay well over the poverty level and offer medical to all their employees, including Part-Timers.
by faradhi
You said, "(Your) preferred mechanism is to convince the employers that it is in their overall best interest to pay a livable wage."
Okay, how would you "convince" them? And who would do the convincing? You? Me? Or someone else?
by faradhi
That it might work.
You engage business people in a discussion. You publish articles in business magazines read by business people. You have economists talk to leadership groups.
Again, If it is in a business persons best interest to do something won't they do it?
by faradhi
I am not responsible for your assumptions.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=192922&messageID=1993170
it's fuedalism writ large. Instead of Squire Tony and High Lord Absolutely, you have Moguls and Tycoons. Things would be worse then they are now. Working, middle upper class would not be vague demographic groups, but very real ones.
Now the ability to work and strive is obviously a much more acceptable qualification for success than who your dad was, but how long would it be, before it was considered pointless to educate those who will never have more than manual jobs.
Two generations after the cancellation of welfare, those not as successful as you in I in our current communities, would in the main have two options. Accept their lot as serfs, or become criminals, then you get anarchy and a fertile medium for revolution.
Fuedalism is not fair or just, the judiciary is for the rich, law is for the rich, voting becomes for the rich. Go down the route you are talking about, bring up a son in your own successful image and his child will be found wiping his ass on your venerable constitution.
It's happened before, humans haven't changed , set the environment and watch history repeat itself.
Been there, done that, seen the blood soaked rags.
You work your ass off, you pay your taxes, you get outsourced, you need a bit of help to tide you over til you get your next job.
That was the idea anyway, unfortunately there are some who are taking the urine. They get a lot of media as well, because socialist or capitalist they get right on our nipples.
Targetted, directed assistance with a meaningful welfare to work programs are what we need.
No welfare, hurts everybody not just fat spongers.
I mean meaningful, I don't mean a cheap ass manual labour pool for unscrupulous businessmen to have their wage bill paid by our taxes.
Seen the dig hole one week , fill it in the next one jobs, doesn't work.
Hands up all those who think if we paid less taxes, our employers would keep our salary up so we kept all that gain ?
Hey, I'm all for those things. In fact, I believe most employers realize their greatest asset is their employees. Talk all you want. Publish all you want. We're in agreement.
Now you answer my question. Are you in favor of any instance of government mandated wages, whether that be called a livable wage, a minimum wage, of whatever?
I'm against it. That's a pretty clear position.
How about you? Are you in favor of it or against it?
And "livable wage", as I'm sure you know, is just a smoke-screen for "minimum wage".
[i]"There ought to be a livable wage, and that is what this battle (minimum wage) is all about."[/i]
-- Senator Ted Kennedy (D) in 1998
[i]"The Earned Income Tax Credit works in conjunction with the minimum wage to ensure a livable wage for low-income families."[/i]
-- Bill Clinton (D) in 2001
(By the way, the "Earned Income Tax Credit" is a tax refund to a person on the taxes that someone else paid. It means that, not only do some wage earners pay no taxes, but they STILL get a refund!)
[i]"....working poor in this country. They're not making a livable wage."[/i]
-- Ralph Nader in 2000 in support of increasing the minimum wage
[i]"Living Wage Initiative" or "Living Wage Act"[/i]
These are all state and federal proposals to increase the minimum wage.
by faradhi
I do not agree with a minimum wage.
Making people do something they do not want to do only increases their opposition to it.
I believe that in a pure capitalist society, if there is one, business people will do what is in their best interest. That means paying people above the poverty level (livable wage).
Do I believe it will happen. About as much as I believe I will win the lottery tomorrow.
-edited for spelling and a misplaced "that"
by oz_media
On teh min wage issue, it wou dbe interestin gto see an alternative that actually did create a fair minimum working wage so that corporate pigs couldn't hire people for next to nothing (ony one person sees the American dream that way, the employer).
As for IQ/vs aspirations, I agree. That wasn't what I got from yoru post earlier though, no...not EVERYONE can become a CEO, but evertyone can and shoul dbe pressed to reach their goals.
As for the quote: Success is the progressive realization of a worthwhile dream.
To quote a very clever American:
"The only limit to our realization of tomorrow will be our doubts of today." --Franklin D. Roosevelt (sorry Max, you thought I was gonna quote you, right? :) )
"A dream is just a dream. A goal is a dream with a plan and deadline." --Harvey Mackay
And one of my favorites,
"I'm a great believer in luck and I find the harder I work, the more I have of it." --Thomas Jefferson
Okay, I admit it.. America has had some pretty good things to say.
by absolutely
I love it! Tell me some more about paying my dues!
Tony: "Now the ability to work and strive is obviously a much more acceptable qualification for success than who your dad was, but how long would it be, before it was considered pointless to educate those who will never have more than manual jobs."
Let's find out! 300 years ago, the [b]only[/b] qualification for success was "noble" birth, or occasionally some lucky savage with an exceptional ability to slaughter the "divine ruler's" enemies for him would become a minor noble. Dictatorship is always the result of an assertion that individual rights are not identical from one individual to the next. I say each person is entitled to exactly what they earn. You say each person is entitled to more than they earn if they earn less than $x, but less than they earn if they earn [edit out: less, replace with: [b]more[/b]] [b]more[/b] than $x. Your model is a variation of the rule of the jungle. Mine is consistent with the civilizing principle of human equality.
by absolutely
1) There are a lot of businesspeople that are just not smart enough to do anything other than run Enron into the ground and bankrupt savings & loan corporations. That is just a cold truth. These people should still get a profitable stream of revenue.
2) Those people that do have maximum salary jobs and are smart enough to be trained for something else, own stock in mulitiple companies to thrive. When are they supposed to get training to improve themselves?
by jdclyde
You work in a shop for 15 years. They close the door one day after you thought acceptably comfotable at that level of living. There are not other similar jobs available, and are now unemployable.
Retraining and job placement, is something I have no problem with. Mind you, I also support the proven practice of CHARGING the people for this service that get part of the way through it and drop out.
Some teenager gets knocked up, I would not let that baby starve. ADC steps up and helps, but they should not help after two years max. Get knocked up again? No, you do NOT give that person an extention or a raise. Can't support kids, then you have no right to have them.
For people that ARE on assistance, I would MAKE them show up every day and report for some duty. Clean this park, clean along the highway, paint a house. They are getting a check already, give them SOME sence of self respect by giving them a chance to EARN it.
Employers could look at these ranks of workers, and bring them on-board. doing SOMETHING always looks better on your resume than doing NOTHING for a few years.
The idea of handouts and handups just don't work. MAKING someone earn their keep or get real hungry, helps them put things in perspective and even a lazy person WILL work for a change if they get hungry enough. Gravy train has shut down.
by faradhi
...the notion of a "livable wage", and paying above the "poverty level", and all that crap. First of all, "poverty" in America is often in people's minds only. To listen to some of you people you'd think that people are destitute and dying in the streets. That's nonsense. Moreover, every time you say something like "livable wage", you might as well plant a big D on your chest and step up on the minimum wage soapbox, because that's what it is. You can say that you're not talking about a "minimum wage", but yet you continue to do just that, but only with other words. If it quacks like a duck, it's a duck.
You ARE talking about a minimum wage, regardless of how you phrase it or how much you deny it. Otherwise, you would concede that market forces and supply and demand will establish the wage structure, and everything else will just fall into place. Let a company try to hire people for a dollar an hour, for all I care, and we can all see that company fail as a result because the competitor will offer more; and on it (competition) goes. Take that away by trying to force, coerce or convince employers to pay more than the employee's output dictates, and you'll either see yet another business failure, or prices for products that are overly inflated; and usually the former will follow the latter because competition will kill that business.
Not all companies can pay their people like FedEx or Microsoft, and not all companies have to. Moreover, not all companies pay their people like Wal-Mart or McDonalds, because they have to pay more. There are market forces in play at both ends. But there's absolutely no reason why people have to be stuck in a lower end job. Not getting paid enough to meet one's wants, needs, and obligation is all the incentive a person needs to grow and move on. And if you take that away from him, even in the name of compassion, and you might even take away his reason to grow. In fact, that's exactly what the last forty years have proven.
Moreover, if we ignore market forces and the principle of supply and demand, and pay everybody above "the poverty level", as you seem to be hung-up on, even though that person's output doesn't justify a higher wage, then guess what will happen? Prices will be inflated, the cost of living will rise for everybody, and the "poverty level" will ALSO rise. In essence, it will do absolutely nothing.
Hey, if a guy and a family isn't earning enough to get by, perhaps it's time to make a choice between a cell phone and food. Or make the choice between watching television all night and getting a second job -- OR going to the local community college to try to better himself. It's worked for a lot of people who were not content with their lot in life, so it will work for just about everybody.
Quite frankly, I think you ought to get YOUR nose out of THEIR business. If they choose to wallow in mediocrity, get out of their way and let them do it.
by faradhi
Max, you asked for a strategy for an end to the so called war on poverty. I gave you one.
I did not propose a government enforce minimum wage. You are right that I am proposing a minimum wage of sort but a voluntary one. Based of the evidence that shows that employers and employees alike may benefit. I never called for the government to enforce anything.
You never answered the question I asked earlier that was; Do you in fact believe that in a free market society, business people will do what is in their best interest? By your insistence that I must be talking about a government enforced minimum wage then I and only deduce that you do not believe that business in an free market will do what is best for them. I, however, believe in the free market. I have been shown that businesses do what is in their best interest.
JD, You keep talking about people bettering themselves. However, you fail to address the fact that there will always be a need for unskilled labor. Some positions now are well paid most are not. My way keeps those people from getting food stamps and public housing.
You are reacting out of fear that jobs will reduce and cost of living will increase. However, I have yet to see any proof of that. In fact, in those documents you refuse to read show that job loss is either nearly none and cost of living does not increase beyond the inflation rate. However, if you find a academic or business publication that rebuffs the arguments, I will at least do you the courtesy that you will not and read them rather than dismissing them outright. If the evidence is enough to change my position, I will certainly say so. I am not one to believe in anything, other than God, without proof. Without such studies, I believe we are at the impasses that our conversations often hit. I look forward to other discussions with you.
[i]--edited to add JD and grammer.[/i]
by jdclyde
Over the years on many a date, I have repeatedly been called an animal. So do I rate some pity too? :D
[i]
(by the way, I LOVED your root post!)
by jdclyde
First of all, let me state that your LAST post was a FAR CRY from what your FIRST post was saying and how it was said.
Need for unskilled labor, yes. Demand though has always determined what that unskilled labor is worth.
Sure, there are companies that are almost criminal in the way they treat their employees, but many of the companies like that do not make it long term.
To the other extreme, we hear about 80+ year old janators at GM raking in over 70K a year. THAT shows just how out of line the Unions have gotten in the country, and why so many people would just as soon buy an import than a domestic car. The employees are paid more then they are WORTH, thus the cars cost more than they are worth.
Your last post I can live with. Throwing money at someone because they are too stupid to make it on their own I will never accept.
Oh, normally when you reply to someone in the title of your post, you ACKNOWLEDGE them in the post? :(
by faradhi
by jdclyde
Do you or do you not support like in the article you provided where all contractors that bid for the city jobs HAD to meet a predefined level of wage?
I think that is a stretch to say that is by choice if it is the only way to get the contract.
Also, keep in mind when [b]I[/b] started this thread it WAS about minimum wage, and that is when you started talking about the stupid people that need to flip burgers needing a living wage. I think you got emotional and in a rush, so that is where much of this misunderstanding came in?
Go back, detach yourself from what who said about what and re-read it. You will understand why I was starting to wonder if someone had hacked your account or something! :D
I assumed, but you LED me to that assumtion based on the context of the discussion.
Peace.
by faradhi
It was not intentional to mislead you.
Also, There is nothing that states anyone has a right to a contract. But I do not want to do that either. That still is making them do that.
The thing to learn there is not how it was done but the effects when it was done.
by absolutely
Some people assume that everybody who doesn't support Welfare also opposes voluntary charity. I may have just made the converse error.
Faradhi, as long as you don't propose to require me or employers to provide these "incentives" and "livable wages", and as long as attempting to persuade people with no threats, only your best reasoning, all I have to say to you is "Good luck. And I hope I misunderstood you."
by absolutely
If you were me, you would be me, and would do [b]exactly[/b] what I do.
I'm not holding a gun to your head, and I'm not forcing you to even consider my advice. But I believe compassion for the poor, in the United States, is a waste of your love of life. There are people elsewhere in the world for whom effort means [b]nothing[/b]. In the United States, bums are [b]fat[/b]. Elsewhere, bums are running the show and good people are [b]dead.[/b] If you were me, you [b]would[/b] go around telling people how to feel or think -- not forcing, but trying to [b]convince[/b] them that their pity is misplaced, and their ability to think wasted on parasites every time they think about how to more effectively give a "hand up". Excuse me, I feel ill.
by absolutely
Employers are not in business to "break even" any more than workers labor just to not lose the money, if any, that we already have. We are [b]all[/b] in it for $, and that is no more honorable in the case of minimum wage workers than in the case of maximum salary workers or maximum return investors. You're in it for the $. I'm in it for the $. I have the integrity to say so. What is your angle?
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=192922&messageID=1993304
by absolutely
faradhi: "I did not propose a government enforce minimum wage."
Yes, you did. The government, as employer, effects the market. When the government acts as a philanthropist instead as a competitive employer, the entire industry in which the government pays above the market value is disrupted. Nobody in that industry, in that area, works below the [b]government[/b] rate very long, and the [b]government[/b] wage becomes the only wage for that type of work. This was shown in NY/NJ in the construction industry, and elsewhere, I'm sure.
by faradhi
In the context of the article, the term [i]broke even[/i], was in relation to the cost of the project for both the city and the contractor. [b]In all cases the contractor still made a profit. [/b]
Additionally, My point in bringing the articles up was not to propose a method. I do not want cities to force any employer to do anything other than the job for which the contractor is bidding.
However, since it was done, studies on the effects are still valid. Since it was done and showed no significant impact of jobs or the overall cost of living, it suggests that all employers paying above the poverty level my be in their best interest and not have an significant negative effect on the overall economy.
I stated my method would be education of employers. Maybe, even, tax incentives for companies that pay all employees over the poverty level since by doing so they reduce the overall tax burden. (I thought of that one last night.)
However, as I stated to JD and Max, I am willing to reconsider if you present me with some academic, business, or economic publications that shows the contrary.
by faradhi
There is a business week article I posted later.
What is your point?
by absolutely
by absolutely
First of all, as to your perceived [i]solution[/i]. You provided no solution, as you suggested, but rather a reworded version of what's been going on for forty years.
Cutting to the chase:
[b]Scenario:[/b] A person is in a situation, any situation, whether that be [i]poverty[/i] (by a variety of definitions and/or reference points, by the way), or ANY situation.
[b]faradhi's solution: [/b] Someone else is responsible.
[b]Maxwell Edison's solution: [/b] That individual is responsible.
That's it in a nutshell, dude. I'm willing to work from that premise to help that person, while you get stuck on yours. It's no wonder we can never agree. I will admit one thing, however. My solution is not 100 percent effective, but neither is yours. However, if the entire world (or at least the entire USA) was like my version, more people would succeed. If the entire world (or at least the entire USA) was like your version, more people would fail.
You asked, [i]"Do you, in fact, believe that in a free market society, business people will do what is in their best interest?"[/i]
My answer: Yes.
My elaboration: And that is exactly as it should be. If business people don't do what's in their best interest, then they run a higher probability of failing. OR, if business people don't do what's in their best interest, it assumes that they will act based on what someone else perceives as their best interest, also a recipe for failure. Moreover, I ALSO suggest that individuals should ALSO act in their best interest, and for the exact same reasons.
And quite frankly, AGAIN, you can't seem to dismiss the notion that YOU should poke your nose into other people's business, whether that's [i]individual[/i] or [i]business[/i] business. If ACME widget company deems it in their best interest to pay their employees $X dollars, and YOU think it's too low, then don't work there. If you want to compete with ACME Widget company, and pay your employees $2X, knock yourself out. But it IS NOT YOUR BUSINESS what ACME Widget company pays people.
[i][b]Mind your own damn business[/i][/b] is something that all too many people FAIL to practice.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by jaqui
by absolutely
I take pride in doing my best. A logical consequence is the intellectual discipline to achieve that. Pride in doing a job well is the cause, I agree.
I was hoping you'd elaborate on [b]why[/b] you think it was, at that restaurant, that the mentally handicapped workers were better workers than the rest, and what the rest would need to do to ascend to the level of competence of the mentally handicapped.
by absolutely
My first impression of the first of the two links you posted is that they are mincing words in order to obscure any significant interpretations of their own data.
http://www.lowpay.gov.uk/lowpay/lowpay2005/chapter2a.shtml
"The October 2003 and October 2004 upratings combined increased the minimum wage by 15.5 per cent compared with an increase in average earnings of just under 8 per cent between October 2002 and October 2004...We estimate the impact on the aggregate wage bill of pay increases for these beneficiaries to be 0.08 per cent."
Since this was not written in English, but in whatever dialect you chaps in the UK use, I'm having some trouble interpreting exactly what it does, or does not, say. In the interest of mutual understanding, I'll describe the two phrases most confusing to me, and what I suspect that they mean in proper, United States English:
(1) "these beneficiaries" - people whose wages were effected in any way by the 15.5% increase in the minimum legally permitted wage.
(2) "the aggregate wage bill of pay" - Is this what we bloody colonials call "the paycheck"? If so, it seems we're more efficient even in the use of the language that came from Britain!
:p
by absolutely
by absolutely
If you believe it's wrong that "ACME Wingnuts" pays their workers only $X instead of your preferred $XX, and it's important enough to you to do something about it, the freedom of the press allows you to organize a boycott among any [b]willing[/b] consumers you're able to convince of [b]their[/b] self-interest in such. That, I am [b]absolutely[/b] certain, would get the attention of many employers, and convince them of what you (faradhi) have been trying to assert here on this thread about the best interest of employers to pay their (dead?) employees a more "livable wage".
LOL
by jaqui
a simple answer and a difficult one.
They were among the best because they had a positive attitude, and were always willing to try something new. [ The rest of the staff were very good at re-inforcing good work with compliments, this naturally helped the self esteem and confidence level ]
In the restaurant, to bring the same level of performance out of all staff, We [ the management team ] just made sure that everyone worked with the metally handicapped people. The performance standard was set by those doing the best job, to positive attitude is infectious, and the complimenting good work done by anyone, by all staff members, boosted the morale, which improved performance.
Currently, most people tend to feel or think: "I don't want to go to work." / "I hate my job." fairly often. This is a morale issue that simply focussing on the positives by the Management will start reversing. We generally tend to dump on people when they screw up, if we do not also praise them for doing good it hurts the morale, productivity and work quality.
During my career working in Restaurants I was frequently responsible for building teams out of groups of complete strangers. I learned fairly quickly that, for me, a flat management style works best at both maintaining a positive work environment as well as creating a true team attitude / sence of cameraderie.
By flat management, I mean whichever person has the best skills in any particular subject or area is the team leader for that.
Using the restaurant kitchen for an example:
there are six workstations, configured three on the front, three on the back. They consist of
Front { left to right }
Sandwiches, Hot Well / Window, Salad
Back { right to left }
Grill, Sautee / Griddle, Deep Fry.
The rule used, after everyone working was trained for all positions, first empty position is yours for the shift.*
The only times that I specified what position someone was to work in was when one of two conditions were met: 1) The volume was sufficient to warrant best skills on a station be there. Or 2) the person only knew that one position.
Everyone wanted to work sandwich, hot well / window or grill positions, so by letting people work first empty position they all got to work at them regularly.
* Hot Well / Window was team / shift lead position by default, and was Mine as I started an hour before everyone else on shift. [ Until I started playing games during the rush to show off the team. I would get everyone to swap one position to the left in the middle of the rush, when we all knew every position it pushed us to pay attention to what was happening around us at all times, so when someone was getting snowed in. those closest could help them out as needed. I would literally have everyone cycle right through every position every few minutes on occasion, just to show to all staff that we all can do the jobs correctly.
In that particular restaurant I had one person I worked with every day, luckily we hit it off well, and our teamwork was just flawless, the two of us could handle the entire dinner rush alone, 250 seats, flipped every 30 minutes for 2 to 3 hours. We would even play around in the kitchen tossing stuff to each other during that time, and by tossing I mean literally throwing stuff, often 45 feet through the air. 2 highly skilled people who respect each others skills and trust them can really perform incredible feats in a kitchen.
In one sentence, define "livable" wage.
If you use anything like "poverty level" in that definition, define that as well.
Define and list those people who fall under your definition, in both particulars and as a percentage of the working population.
List some of the companies that do not pay their employees a "livable wage".
What [i]should[/i] those companies pay their employees?
Lastly, if [i]those companies[/i] do not pay [i]those employees[/i] a livable wage, how are those people still living and/or why don't [i]those people[/i] quit and work elsewhere?
by absolutely
Or are you just his sycophant?
I haven't installed flash anyway, but I recognize the url pivpiv.dk.
It was funny once. Now, it's just tired. Grow up.
by jdclyde
If you are able to pay for food, cloths, and shelter, you are able to live off that wage.
I am no concerned if someone can afford luxury items or not. Multiple vehicles, fancy house, expensive cloths, cable tv in every room, cell phones, SMOKING, are all thing that you EARN, not something anyone has any right to. You have the right to get yourself qualified for a job that will pay you what you are worth, and based on that worth, buy the toys in life.
If this means public transit, thrift stores, generic brand food, then you do what you have with what you have earned based on what you are worth.
Some people, because of their own choices, are not worth much, so they don't get paid much.
by absolutely
You're free to your own opinion jdclyde, but it is not an addition to mine. I don't care at all how anybody spends their money and I have better things to do than discuss how much another person is worth, or what is the difference between "the toys in life", "luxury items" versus needs. Regardless of how responsibly anybody manages their finances according to jdclyde's priorities, they have no right to any of my property, regardless of whether that property is a need, "luxury items", or one of "the toys in life".
How you spend your money is none of my business, and vice versa.
by jdclyde
Is that a way of talking out of the side of your mouth?
To respond to my post, without posting it as a reply to my post? How rude....... ;\
This is why they have charities. People that feel so much for others should be giving freely of THEIR time and THEIR money to help the people that can't or won't make it on their own. And I agree that no matter how much someone cares, they have no right to extort the posessions of someone else to pay for anyone else.
by absolutely
That's a way of saying that my statement stands independently of yours, which is not an "addition", only a response.
No additions. I speak for myself. You don't. That's all.
by faradhi
[i]In one sentence, define "livable" wage.[/i]
A livable wage is the ability to pay for food (not resturants), housing (not mansions), clothing (not fashion), health care (insurance or otherwise), utilities (not cable), and transportation (public or otherwise because you have to get to the grocery store, clothing store, hosptial and work.)
Define and list those people who fall under your definition, in both particulars and as a percentage of the working population.
Between 7.3 - 16.5 million [b]workers[/b](5.8 - 12.3 % of the total workers) depending on where they live. These are workers currently making than $8.25. While that would be plenty here, in the Northeast and California it would not. The 7.3 million workers were all working an not making enough to meet the criteria above. The rest will be made up based on where they live.
source: http://www.epi.org/issueguides/minwage/table1.gif
Note: The table shows the number of workers that would be effected by a minimum wage raise to 7.25. Again, I do not present the table as an argument for minimum wage raise. I am using the data to answer Max's question only.
[i]List some of the companies that do not pay their employees a "livable wage".[/i]
Any gas station, any janitorial service, most hotels, Most retail outlets among others. I will not create an exhaustive list of something you already know.
[i]What should those companies pay their employees?[/i]
varies on the basis of what area since those things listed above have different costs depending on where you live.
[i]Lastly, if those companies do not pay those employees a livable wage, how are those people still living and/or why don't those people quit and work elsewhere? [/i] They live on your dime, Welfare, food stamps, public housing, etc. They don't work elsewhere because they do not have the skills for a higher paying job.
But since it is none of my business what businesses pay, I guess WE will be stuck paying for welfare, food stamps, public housing, etc. There is an old saying, if nothing changes, nothing changes.
While I don't agree with anyone dictating to employers how much they may or may not pay their employees, I'm also against the alternative you suggested, which is public assistance in the form of welfare, food stamps, and such to make up for -- or to subsidize -- lower wages (see note below).
Like you said, "if nothing changes, nothing changes." Well, I'm in favor of change -- BIG CHANGE, as a matter of fact. I'm in favor of BOTH allowing free enterprise to structure its pay scale according to the capitalist principle of supply and demand AND abolishing the public assistance programs that only create dependency on government.
I remember an early job I had in a gas station, one of the jobs you mentioned as not paying very much, and I did not, in fact, earn enough to pay all my expenses. Your solution, in such a case, is to either force the employer to pay more, or force the taxpayer to subsidize that person in the form of public assistance. Which one did I do at that time? NEITHER. I got a friggin' room-mate!
You just don't get it. I'm willing to be bold enough to suggest, unequivocally, that a person, if physically and mentally able, is responsible for him or her self -- period -- and I'm willing to just let those chips fall where they may. And no, it WOULD NOT result in people dying in the streets. In the worst case, it might make people more dependent on their family who, in turn, would probably help those people become more self sufficient. (This is where you might voice an objection that some people have no family, which only proves you CHOOSE to miss the point.)
And consider this, the mere fact that public assistance programs ARE available, it just might contribute to the lower wages you are so adamantly against.
My basic premise: People ARE responsible for themselves and their own lives -- period; and I'll just let those chips fall wherever they may. And get government and nosey people out of the way, and they'll stack up just fine.
Apparently, you disagree. I think it's people like you, with that mind-set, that has put the USA on its current financial slippery-slope. We've given people ten trillion dollars in some form of public assistance over the past forty years. It's time to change, and just not do it anymore.
Note: If you subsidize something, you get MORE of it. If you tax something, you get LESS of it. In this case, if we subsidize low wages, we'll keep getting low wages AND people accepting the subsidies.
by faradhi
I never suggested that we force anyone to do anything. As JD pointed out that my posting in the thread he started about Minimum wage that I may have implied that. It was not my intention and I regret the implication.
I suggested we show employers how it would benefit them in the long term. It would be better for them. In a pure capitalist way, that should be sufficent for them to do it. But you stated I had no right to "stick my nose in their business" Well, given that catch-22, I believe we have hit that impasse.
I would agree that if you COULD get public assistance eliminated that it may force those on public assistance to work. But I don't think you or any group could do it. I do not think you can get enough of the nation to agree with you. If that were possible it would have been done by now. The republicans have had the both houses and the presidency for how long now?
While you, JD, and absolute vilify me, remeber that our ends are the same. We both want less government, less taxes, less people working off our dime. We only disagree on the ways to get there.
Additionally, I renew my challange to find one economic, business, or academic publication that supports the assertion that raising income of low paid workers results in increased inflation and mass loss of jobs.
by absolutely
is the one who uses pity as a weapon.
faradhi: "Additionally, I renew my challange to find one economic, business, or academic publication that supports the assertion that raising income of low paid workers results in increased inflation and mass loss of jobs."
I'll do that. For the time being, settle for this: there is no need to automate simple, redundant tasks until the cost of paying humans to do those tasks exceeds the cost of automation, including purchase and maintenance. We all know that robots have been helping to reduce the number of auto workers, and that effective database programs reduce the number of data entry workers necessary. You want more proof, just ask, but I know that you already know that I'm right. Simply put, employers shop for the best deal just as much, and with just as much right, as their employees do in our personal lives.
faradhi: "Between 7.3 - 16.5 million workers(5.8 - 12.3 % of the total workers) depending on where they live. These are workers currently making than $8.25. While that would be plenty here, in the Northeast and California it would not. The 7.3 million workers were all working an not making enough to meet the criteria above. The rest will be made up based on where they live.
source: http://www.epi.org/issueguides/minwage/table1.gif"
Does that source detail the locations of those workers? Their ages? Their family size? How many of those millions actually live in the East or California, where you assert (without proof!) that life is only possible with wages of $8.25+/hour? Either way, their needs do not constitute a claim on my productive ability. Still, it's worth noting that your pity-based assertions are misleading, in that they overstate the number of people that make less than they "need", even by your pitiful definition of need.
by faradhi
I was not trying to artificially inflate the numbers, I just did not have the time to find the raw data. If I had I would have given the exact numbers. I did not see where this had any negative effect on the conversation. Further, the cost for the items listed in my reply to max changes from city to city and state to state I am sure you will agree that exact numbers are difficult at best. I will not nitpick with you. Just take the smaller number if you want.
Your argument about automation is not applicable since you are still arguing against a raise in minimum wage. I have stated in several posts that I am not arguing for any forced raise. The most government intervention I advocate for is a tax break for those employers who do pay all workers enough to cover the necessities outlined in the response to max. The reason behind the tax break is that they will reduce OUR tax burden and should therefore be rewarded. I purport that we engage the employers in a dialog not force them to do anything.
Throughout this conversation, you have not used one verifiable fact backed by any source. You instead resort to insults. Your the one that purports logic and objectivity yet you have not offered anything except attacks.
If you come up with a source, I will read it. I will evaluate it objectively. I am not steadfast for or against any idea if proof contrary to my ideas can be brought to bear.
by absolutely
It is human nature to seek the maximum return on any investment. This simple principle is all I cite when I state that automation is the consequence of past demands for increasing wages.
In response to your first paragraph, I won't ask you to find "the raw data" or sift through any more. I acknowledge that common, unavoidable expenses [b]cannot[/b] be paid with a wage of $8.25, at a single full-time job without overtime. Overtime, or a second job may be necessary for some people. I think a more useful study would be much more difficult to [b]conduct[/b] and much easier for (at least!) one of use to use in support our position(s). The [b]real[/b] problem for [b]real[/b] people is paying [b]their[/b] bills, not average bills. All these studies by all these "experts" use national averages too much, in their vanity and wishes for national publication. Any who truly wish to make any real [b]progress[/b] for any [b]real people[/b] will use a method that compares the total income of each individual or household to their local consumer price index, or to their monthly bills. I have never seen such a study, and lost all trust, long ago, that any organized "leftist" group has any of the interests of real poor people in mind.
by absolutely
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending