Discussion Locked

One step closer to National ID system

0 helpful
142 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Senate Passes Bill Creating Electronic ID Card

President Bush expected to sign Real ID Act.

Linda Rosencrance, Computerworld
Wednesday, May 11, 2005

The U.S. Senate passed a bill Tuesday that would create an electronic ID card designed to stop illegal immigrants from getting driver's licenses. The U.S. House of Representatives earlier this year passed its version of the bill, which was tacked onto a measure to pay for military activities in Iraq.

Advertisement

The legislation, which President George W. Bush is expected to sign, requires states to issue federally approved electronic ID cards, including driver's licenses. Anyone without such a card would not be permitted to board an airplane or Amtrak train, to open a bank account, or to enter a federal building.

Called the Real ID Act, the bill mandates that driver's licenses and other ID cards include a digital photo, various features designed to thwart counterfeiting, and a "common machine-readable technology" such as a radio frequency identification (RFID) tag. The technology must meet requirements set out by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

The provisions take effect in May 2008.

"The Real ID is vital to preventing foreign terrorists from hiding in plain sight while conducting their operations and planning attacks," House Judiciary Committee Chairman F. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wisconsin) said in a statement. "By targeting terrorist travel, the Real ID will assist in our War on Terror efforts to disrupt terrorist operations and help secure our borders."

Opponents' Stance
But critics, including the San Francisco-based Electronic Frontier Foundation and the American Civil Liberties Union, said that the bill will bring the United States a giant step closer to creating a national ID system, which would be a tempting target for identity thieves.

"The Real ID Act would establish a vast national database of ID holders, where even a small percentage of errors would cause major social disruption," according to a statement by the EFF. "The ID would essentially be an internal passport that would be shown before accessing planes, trains, national parks, and courthouses--an irresistible target for forgers and identity thieves."

The EFF also said that by calling for the use of "common machine-readable technology," the REAL ID Act will pave the way for the federal government to force every state to put RFID chips into the ID cards.

Plans to issue electronic passports for U.S. citizens traveling abroad have raised concerns of their own.

"The federalization of driver's licenses and the culling of all information into massive databases creates a system ripe for identity theft," said Timothy Sparapani, an ACLU legislative counsel, in a statement. "New standards could place our most private information--including photographs, address[es], and Social Security numbers--into the hands of identity thieves."

The ACLU also said that the measure, if signed into law, would make it harder for legal immigrants to obtain a driver's license. And it denounced the way the law won passage in the House by being added to a funding bill for the military.

"The Real ID Act was sold as an illegal-immigration fix bill, when in fact it reduces every American's freedom," Sparapani said. "The provisions of this bill could not have passed on their own. Sadly, their inclusion in a 'must pass' bill means that immigrants and citizens alike will face an unnecessary loss of freedom and privacy."

For more enterprise computing news, visit Computerworld online. Story copyright ? 2005 Computerworld, Inc. All rights reserved

142 replies

by hal 9000

I thought that your Social Security Number did exactly the same thing.

But I suppose that adding a few more layers of Bureaucrats into the mix helps to keep the bureaucrats working doesn't it?

Col ]:)

by salamander

...for one of those bureaucrats to sneak up behind me and airgun a chip into the back of my head "for my own good." Good thing most bureaucrats are slow runners. :D

by deepsand

given government's inate tendency to seek to expand it's power, it's use for purposes other than the original was gradually increased, first at the Federal level, by way of the IRS using it in lieu of a separate Taxpayer ID, then by State governments & private commerce, to the extent that many now [i]believe[/i] that it was intended as a means of personal identification, [i]despite[/i] the fact that one's Social Security card states otherwise.

Once people [i]believe[/i] it to be a personal identifier, it becomes very easy to transform it from a [i]de facto[/i] identifier into a [i]de jure[/i] one.

by deepsand

This is about being required to produce certain [i]additional information[/i] as proof of both identity & place of residence, such required info. to be stipulated by the Feds and to be maintained by the States, subject to access by the Feds, in order to acquire and/or renew a driver's license.

This will quite likely be the end of the ability to renew one's license online.

Incidentally, such requirements are [i]already[/i] in effect with regard to acquiring and/or renewing a Box Rental with the USPS. Some of the elderly, as well as residents of some states which only recently began issuing such, by virtue of not having photo-ID driver's licenses, are finding it difficult to provide the proof needed to keep their PO Boxes!

by apotheon

This is just one more reason to ignore the USPS as much as possible. In this particular instance, it's a good idea to go to independent mailbox providers that still allow a certain degree of anonymity. I mean, really, what's the point of a junkmail-magnet like a PO Box if you have to provide personal data, including home address, that will end up in a federal database that can be accessed by junkmailers anyway?

By the way, deepsand, you might want to have another look at your post. It needs editing. You have a typo in some text-formatting.

by antuck

Don't tell them about an airgun. They will use it. I wonder do the politician have to get the same card or will they be exempt from being bar coded.

by salamander

Given government budget cuts, they may have to make do with a nail gun and an air compressor.

by Member 25348569

I came across some amazing websites covering "The Rapture" - which I'd only ever heard about because of The Simpsons - in which the Post-Armageddon world was discused in detail.

1) First "rapture" happens and people start disappearing (snap!). As this will, obviously, be whole churches full, even comitted atheists like me might catch on.

2) Armageddon (first bit), nuclear war caused by Israel and Russia (I think).

3) Post Apocalypse and those of us left get implanted with an ID chip by the Anti-Christ except - and this is the clever bit - for the people who now believe. (They caught on that SOMETHING was going on with the mass disappearance of Christians!) The fact that you will need this ID chip to get food means that believers will be easier to rapture 'cos they're thin.

4) Armageddon (big bit) and FUBAR for the rest of us!

Salamander! It's gonna happen! If you see lots of buraucrats out speed training - start hoarding food!

Neil :)

p.s. If I have offended any Christians in this post. TOUGH! You are sending me to eternal damnation so fair's fair!

by hal 9000

Think of it this way.

The idea of Heaven and Hell only arose with the Pauline Christian teachings and they imported a lot of pagan beliefs into the Jewish teachings so to make the people more amiable the the church leaders will they could have introduced the idea of Hell to keep the faithful in control after all how could they have continued to extort money out of the faithful all these years. :)

I've just watched a series on the Minitor and from the description given of this Mythical Greek beast it bears a striking resemblance to the early Christian description of the Devil, Satan. Lucifer or whatever they are calling him/it now. :p

The whole Christian thing is a myth and we are forever doomed to relive our lives until we eventually get it right and reach enlightenment or the universe ceases to exist which most likely will come first. Now isn't that a joke! :D

Col ]:)

PS I'm first in line to have my site rating hard coded to 666 so back off! I thought of it first so you have to wait until I leave TR to get it! :p

by salamander

...in the Dilbert comic strip, Satan is now more politically-correctly known as "Phil, Prince of Insufficient Light."

I'm sure that he has a staple gun loaded with ID tags.

by salamander

Neil...haven't you weaned yourself away from EL yet? Be careful, a twelve-step program might be required to wean oneself away from it...or a patch...or gum...:)

I am unfortunately familiar with the Rapture, as I have a somewhat overzealous cousin who reads those "Left Behind" books and keeps trying to force them on me. I'm a little peeved that she left a copy of "The Purpose Driven Life" in my kitchen last week. Urk! I know she means well, but...aaargh!

Of course, being a pragmatist, I ask incredibly intellectual questions like: "Oh...so if you vanish into the Rapture with only what God gave you...do you leave your clothes behind?" :D

by Member 25348569

so I've been Googling.

That clunk you heard was my lower jaw hitting the keyboard! They outsell nearly anything in the US!

I precis the first one I found...

"On a flight from Chicago to London, several passengers aboard Capt. Rayford Steele's plane suddenly and mysteriously disappear. When Steele radios to London to report the situation, he discovers that the incident on his plane is not an isolated phenomenon but a worldwide occurrence. As Steele begins his search for answers, he learns that the Christ has come to take the faithful with Him in preparation for the coming apocalyptic battle between good and evil and that those who have been left behind must face seven dark and chaotic years in which they must decide to join the forces of Christ or the forces of Anti-Christ."

Yeah! Like, we'll go with the Anti-Christ, won't we? I mean, Hell? It's much the better option. Christ? what can he do for us? Heaven? Nah, I'd much rather burn for eternity.

Who ARE these people?

I'm out of my depth, here.

Neil :D

by dr dij

if they'd disappear. They appear to be preoccupied with trying to remove my rights to any # of things, including teaching science in schools.

I was driving a friend (who is religous) to the car repair, had on a particularly loud song, and he said something like, 'what if there is a rapture and you aren't included?' I told him I was getting a nice dose of rapture from the music, it seemed he was unable to enjoy life fully due to religion.

by salamander

...The rationale was that it would keep them safe from child predators. I really don't think that it would do much good for that purpose, but it's a nice way to tap into parental anxieties.

'Course, that's my jaded view. It seems that parents do more to put their kids in harm's way than anybody else, but that's another rant for another time.

by deepsand

Introduce a new technological feature, tout it's feel-good features, get enough people to adopt it for the touted reasons, and soon enough you'll be able to move on to using it for other purposes as well.

All you need do is play into peoples fears by portraying such as being for the "greater good."

by bfilmfan

Papers please, papers.

I never really thought I would live to see the day that freedom died in America, but I fear I am going to witness it.

Mr. Peabody please show up with the Way Back Machine and take me to 1870, please.

by apotheon

It has been dying since some time in the 1800s at least. Of course, its death was written into the Cosntitution with phrases like "the general welfare" and oversights like the lack of protection against amendments that supersede the Bill of Rights.

Things have been going downhill in earnest in the last ten years, though. Recent threats to Roe vs. Wade and Miranda vs. Arizona, the DMCA, the USA PATRIOT Act, the DSEA merry-go-round, and a plethora of other such legislative circus acts, have been leading us gaily down the garden path toward where we are now. The degeneration of liberty in the US of A is only picking up speed, and the passage of the REAL ID Act as a rider on an appropriations bill is just a symptom. Expect things to get worse before they get better (if they ever do) in this country.

by deepsand

The greater danger is the likelihood that the US will not be alone in this unholy quest for an unattainable security.

Should that come to pass, I'm afraid that it will be an exceedingly long time, if ever, before the tide ebbs.

by montgomery gator

With Abraham Lincoln suspending Habeas Corpus and expanding the federal government powers. His restrictions on freedom and the growth of government were balanced, though, by his bringing freedom to the slaves, which did expand freedom for several million people. However, his expansion of government and reduction in freedom was small compared to Theodore Roosevelt and his expansion of government regulatory powers. Then Theordore's cousin Franklin Roosevelt really got the ball rolling to take away freedom and expand government with his New Deal. Got even worse with Lyndon Johnson with his "Great Society", and all presidents since. Some may have slowed down the rate of growth of the Federal government and its powers that take away our freedom, like Ronald Reagan did, but government still grew under him, although at a slower rate. We need a new Congress that does not vote to expand, but instead contracts the Federal government, and a President that would veto any bill that expands federal spending. The only part of federal government I want to see expanding is our military and national defense. The rest needs to be cut back greatly.

by jck

so sad for the poor little illegal immigrants...they can't a license...wahhhhhhhhh

how about they already drive here in FL without one and slam into people without insurance already? I know 2 people that had that happen to them in the past 3 years.

I'm all for the technology if it keeps illegals not only from getting a license, but also keeps them from collecting welfare, social security, etc.

This could save our country billions every year at the state and federal level.

by jessie

It will mean that illegal immigrants who snuck into this country so they could work hard and hopefully find themselves and their children a better life will have a hard time getting a license... but there hasn't been an ID given out EVER that MONEY can't buy... so the drug dealers and the terrorists will have ALL THE ID'S they want.

I'm not saying that illegal immigrants SHOULD be able to get drivers licenses easily, or that they should be in this country at all without going through the proper channels... I'm just saying that this really only affects the POOR. RFID isn't going to stop anybody with the money to buy themselves a bureaucrat.

by pcbuddy

I guess they are forgetting who this law is being targeted at and in the end, its the poor that suffers.Lets say the 3 hijackers in the 9/11 situation had legit IDs, was that going to stop them from carrying out the attacks, how does having RFIDs stop illegal immigrations? there has to be other ways that this can be effected without affecting the citizens hard earned tax payers money which has been wasted on the war in Iraq, not to mention the irreplaceable lives that we've lost.......

by jmgarvin

My first question is, why RFID? I mean come on, it just doesn't make sense. Everything it transmits is in the plain AND it is passive, so it doesn't go very far...or are they planning on citizens carring around a battery pack too?

Why does the national ID do? Nothing? How is it different from having a SSN? It isn't. It is just another layer of bureuracratic bogus that is being pawned off on an unwanting American public.

FREE KEVIN!
/rant

by jck

If you have an verifiable American birth certificate and you can have your identity verified...how would a national ID card only affect you if you're poor?

Personally, I liked the card San Diego WIC was using in 1995. An encrypted dataset stored in a 2D barcode that stored name, information, and a key associated to the cardholder's fingerprint. You couldn't use the card to buy anything though WIC if you didn't have the right fingerprint. It was almost full-proof. It supposedly reduced their WIC fraud by 68%, according to what I heard from them.

If they implemented smart cards or RFID with the same technology, I'd think it'd be good for poor people. You could be allocated your WIC if you're on that program and no one else could steal your card and use it.

Unless of course, they cut your finger off.

Plus, a national ID would make it safer and easier for all people since you could walk up in a train station or airport or government office and not have to have 3 forms of ID to prove who you are.

My only concern is the expressed idea of someone getting a hold of the database. That would jeopardize a lot.

It is an idea that has to be worked through to perfect, but there hasn't been an idea in mankind's history that hasn't had its own trials.

by deepsand

Its purported purpose is to thwart terrorists.

This, despite the fact that [b]all[/b] of those involved in the 9-11 attacks, who had Driver's Licenses issued in the US, had [b]valid IDs![/b]

Please read my post at
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=173798&messageID=1769506[/v].

I've personally witnessed elderly people unable to renew their PO Box for lack of "acceptable" IDs.

Should you choose to abrogate any of your rights, feel free to do so.

However, I & many others would ask that you leave ours alone.

To quote Ben Franklin, [i]"He who would give up a small essential freedom, in order to secure a little temporary security, is a scoundrel, and deserves neither freedom nor security."[/i]

by pcbuddy

dude, i think you missed my point.the new ID system will not help in anyway to thwart illegal immigrations or terrorism, there is certainly better ways this can be addressed and effected and the proposed ID system isnt one of them...its total waste of your tax payers $$$

by jck

illegal immigrants obtaining driver's licenses when it said:

"The ACLU also said that the measure, if signed into law, would make it harder for legal immigrants to obtain a driver's license."

I was being sarcastic about those poor immigrants not being able to get a license when in reality they are people who broke our laws to be here in the first place and for the most part are already driving without one anyway.

As for rights, what right am I giving up? To get a card that uniquely identifies me with information that the government already has?

As for freedoms, Ben Franklin also wrote "Beer is proof that God loves us, and wants us to be happy."

I am free to love beer. I have a right to drink beer, since I am over 21. I haven't given that up.

BTW...the elderly people you saw who didn't have the ID...why? Did they forget to renew it? Did they leave it at home? What ID were they using...a CVS card for ID?

In Florida, you're required to have valid photo ID here on your person. Whether it's a license, resident card, passport, or other identifying document. It's not strictly enforced, but it is a misdemeanor they can charge you with and law enforcement can request it from you at any time.

I'm just not sure why all the uproar about what info the government has on you. In fact, most people who use TR probably have at least 2 pages in a database somewhere right now. And if you've ever been a member of a political group you can be assured your file is larger. I know my friend's file was larger than mine.

BTW, you can request a copy of your FBI profile. You just have to know how to do it. :)

The government probably already knows where you work, where you live, who your family is and there's nothing you can do about it. And if they don't have it on file on some computer, they can get it all within about 72 hours. The feds have a way with that. I know they had 2 guys in my hometown within 48 hours to do my TS-SSBI.

If you are defending your freedom to not be tracked and keep everything about you as secret and to yourself as possible, then you're defending a freedom that, if it did exist, has already been violated.

BTW...what "small essential freedom" are you defending here? I wanna make sure I'm clear on this, deepsand.

by jkaras

Funny that Bush senior wanted a new world order and now it appears his son is setting up the pieces. I have to say that I am against this. To me this wont solve anything, increase security, or guarantee safety in any way but encourage a more way to tag us like livestock and promote racism. Can you say MOOOO?

The politicans are using fear buttons to facilitate racism, if it isnt white get rid of it. Lets face it this is the land of opprotunity for all not some or the chosen few regardless of color, creed, or religion. "Give us your tired your weak...." sound familiar? To deny them opprotunity is spitting in the face all that shed their blood t oprovide that right we the people have. Our country has benefitted from this wink, wink come and do jobs that no one wants for next to no wages. You want to limit the illegal immigrants? Grow your own produce, raise your own livestock for slaughter, mow your lawn, and sew your own clothes. I honestly dont see the most feverant people opposed to immigration cutting back on their luxury at the expanse of exploited immigrants. These people are not stealing any job that you, I, or your children aspire for. How are we more safe? How do we look at the other countries that we try to set the model for? Be like us but somewhere else, we're better. We need them, they need us, its that simple. I buy parts that were assembled in Mexico knowing full well that the American company built the factory there to save billions while paying them nothing. Have any of you ever been to Mexico? I went there on my senior trip where they took us through tent city. That was no movie prop, that was survival at its most basic definition. I am really lucky that I am not them, but I dont begrudge them from attempting to make a better life and encourage it. If I was them I would run through the Majove no matter how many times it takes. I alway see us giving billions to other countries, but not our neighbors who dont have decent water to drink?

JCK made a point about collecting unemployment, social security, and welfare? I am a bit of a novice when it comes to these socialist programs patterned off of Russia but how can an illegal alien profit or file from this?

As far as I am aware if I as an American go to another country I could get a drivers license quite easily cant I?

by cp7212

His main issue on his ballot was to shut down immigration. I always wondered why we take people in, give them interest-free loans to start their own businesses, let them live tax-free for seven(?) years, and oh yeah, welfare. Who wouldn't want to come to a country that you can get a free ride from?

I've been working since the age of twelve and I'm darn proud of it. But it is NOT my intention to work so others can have a free ride.

I believe that 9/11 was a horrible thing, but sometimes I believe that the govt. (in retrospect) see it as a good thing. They use it to prey on people's fears to implement whatever they choose. If I had a nickel for every time I heard, "To combat terrorism.....".

Why do they keep changing the twenty dollar bill? To try to keep counterfeiters from producing more. The govt. doesn't think that these ID cards will be forged? How naive.

The next thing will be they will come and take our guns by force, then the only ones with firearms will be the criminals.

by dr dij

We BUY Mexico!

Shouldn't be too many trillions. Then they wouldn't flock to cross the border, they'd be already inside :)

At the least, we should pickup Baja, would kind of even out the US map, balance out Florida and that hump in the middle, Texas. Would make the surfer dudes real happy!

And if you dislike poor mexicans, there's less in Baja. But if you dislike poor Mexicans, we should go for the whole country. Think how their economy would boom with hordes of lawyers and new laws. And any who wanted could go on welfare so they wouldn't be poor anymore. I'm sure the govt would be happy to print up the $$ needed and indebt us for centuries to do this.

by apotheon

I thought Phil was still using a tranquilizer gun and a pneumatic tag-attacher for those radio tags on our ears. You know, the big red plastic things we're incapable of noticing.

by deepsand

that's one that got past me.

The irony of this demand for better proof of identity is that, as would be the result of a ban on the personal ownership of firearms, the people en masse lose some freedom, while the criminal element will continue to operate as before.

by apotheon

You're absolutely correct, of course. When you outlaw something, only outlaws do it. If it's something that good, law-abiding citizens can do to their benefit without hurting anyone, and you outlaw it, all you do is reduce the freedoms of good people and turn a lot of them into criminals when they refuse to give up something they should be allowed anyway.

Of course, that's often the point. More criminals means more governmental control.

by roger99a

Will we really notice when a half dozen people come up missing?

And don't worry about A-Christ. He'll have no problem raising a team.

by deepsand

a mere number.

See
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=173798&messageID=1769504[/iv]

and
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=173798&messageID=1769506[/v]

by jmgarvin

I didn't realize it was so over the top. So WHY do we need this?? Come on politicians this is a political ploy that will infring on the rights of the citizenship!!!!

by deepsand

Just don't tell jck where you're going. He seems to feel that this is the best thing to come down the pike.

Perhaps, after the jackboots haul him off for leaving his papers at home, he'll come around. But, by then it will be too late.

by salamander

Well...I'll give it a shot. I may get flamed, but ah, well...

In the U.S., there is a persistent permeation of evangelical Christian themes in entertainment. I try not to judge that...to each their own. We actually have cable channels devoted to Christian entertainment (and a channel devoted to Muslim-oriented entertainment, as well, BTW, on basic cable). On network television, we had "Touched by an Angel," and now "Joan of Arcadia," in which the protag has a direct pipeline with God. If you've not been exposed to it across the pond, there's also some ground being made by Christian rock. My city has at least one Christian rock station that I know of. I will, of course, leave "The Passion" alone. So...the "Left Behind" books should not come as much of a surprise.

I think that everybody ought to seek out whatever speaks to them, and they wouldn't exist if there wasn't any market demand. It doesn't float my boat, and I personally find it to be a bit disturbing. But I also find a lot of things disturbing, so I'm probably not the best gauge of such things. :D

I think that, with respect to the "Left Behind" books, that there's a persistent fascination with the Rapture, Armageddon, etc. I suppose that I can understand that, from a wish-fulfillment perspective, that if I were a Christian who believed that I was not being rewarded in the present life, that I would want to daydream about a time in which everybody receives their just desserts.

BTW, in those books, I believe that the AC is quite the charismatic figure. If I remember what my cuz said, he might have been some kind of world leader...involved with the UN? Can't recall.

If and when that day arrives, I entirely expect to be tearing into a bag of marshmallows to toast, because I'm surely not qualified to get sucked up into the Hoover of the Rapture. In case the Hoover misses you, I'll save some marshmallows for you. :D

by salamander

He's left me in charge. In his absence, I've decided to do things the old-fashioned way: with a hole punch and zip ties.

by salamander

It amazes me, to no end, the inane things that people will do to feel more secure that involve surrendering control of their lives to others. At some point, I think that the masses lost faith in their ability to provide for and protect themselves, and have happily surrendered their freedoms to a collective whole.

As a sidebar on technological features, one of the things that amazes me is the use of GPS systems in civilian recreational vehicles. I can't say that I've ever been so lost that I was unable to find my way without a map.

by radiic

Hmnn...Sneaky legislatures they are, whats to stop them from making a piece of law that says ok insert new field in database=ArrestOnContact what then?

Also can you imagine trying to secure a database like that?

You think some little high school kids wouldnt like to hack their way into that!> Ha.

Scares the hell out of me>!

by apotheon

He's always going off to the Bahamas when the real work comes down the pike. He actually did me a favor when he fired me for unnecessary cruelty in the performance of my duties.

Do you need a consultant to help streamline your operation with the hole punches and zip ties? I'm available.

by salamander

Phil felt it was time for a softer touch in the Inferno, so that's why he hired me. Giving the damned a fifteen-minute break every hundred years has done wonders for their productivity, in addition to ending all that rabble-rousing union talk.

As far as consulting work goes, we've undergone some budget cuts in the Inferno. Phil's only paying consultants in used souls, anymore, so that probably precludes your involvement.

by jck

about their welfare costs.

The way illegal Mexican immigrants benefit from welfare in California:

1) they come here illegally
2) they work illegally
3) they buy an illegal fake ID
4) they go to the welfare office that has spanish-speaking workers because of the political correctness thing
5) they get on welfare
6) once a month, they cash the check and send it to Mexico

I think it was Dateline NBC that did a story on this a few years ago about how illegal immigration was driving up the cost at the state and federal level of public assistance programs astronomically every year.

Personally, the National ID thing would help to solve it. You'd have to have a birth certificate from the USA or be naturalized by the Federal government and have to file. But once you got approved by the government and got the ID, if you needed welfare you just walk in the welfare office, scan the card, put your finger on a reader, fill out the paperwork...and there's a 1 in 1.5B chance someone else has your same finger print so fraud would go WAY down and therefore cost would as well.

by deepsand

Even the best and the brightest economists are as yet unable to agree as to whether the net effects of illegal immigration are postive or negative.

Furthermore, a National ID has [b]nothing[/b] to do with citizenship. It [b]does[/b] have everything to do with increasing the Federal government's control of the populace.

by apotheon

A national ID won't prevent fraud. It'll just change the sort of fraud that goes on. As long as there's a welfare system, there will be people using it in violation of its supposed intent. In fact, the left-wingnut contingent will almost certainly start passing laws almost immediately to make it easier for illegal aliens to access welfare and other social program benefits without being citizens.

The people who gain the most from social programs are the politicians who enact them, and the people who pay the most for them are the hardest working, lowest income crowd, because welfare and other social programs drive up minimum prices due to the creation and sustainment of an economic class that gets money without having to work for it. Meanwhile, the politicians gain voters and a ready-made dependent class that requires these social programs (and thus these politicians) to maintain its collective lifestyle.

The answer to welfare abuse is to eliminate welfare, not to start tracking the movements of law-abiding citizens.

by jck

San Diego, CA in 1995 implemented a system by Unisys that used a card with a 2D barcode that encrypted information containing, among other things, the person's fingerprint identifier.

The chances, according to Unisys, of another person having the same print was 1 in 1.5 billion. The chance of them being to duplicate the barcode with the proper data was much higher.

Sure, eventually someone will break into the technology and figure out how to dupe it. That always happens. But, San Diego cut their WIC fraud with it by over half.

So maybe it doesn't prevent it, but if it significantly reduces it and saves the people of this country billions, what is the harm?

Seems to me it's gonna do more good.

As for tracking people...are you afraid the government is gonna know they buy Libby's instead of Del Monte?

The ID doesn't have to be RFID to be effective.

Man...I just don't get it what everyone is so worried about.

by jkaras

I actually lived on California during my teen years in Stockton. I have always known that welfare has its loopholes, but never considered the possibility of the fake id for getting a check. I guess its possible or at least happens, but what if they get a white person or African person? Do they walk out and retry till they get a sympatheic hispanic? I just have a hard time believing that this is rather commonn to just a few occurances. Could they add up over time, yeah, but are you sure the accuracy of the reports since they apparently know about the scam?

The truth is this is a hot button topic for Politicians to grandstand like they are doing something. They keep maintaining that our boarders are a threat when shipping, power plants, and airports are far more deadly threats. How many 911 terrorist infiltrated the US through the Mexican border? How many terrorists in general? Truth, none, they come through just fine in Airports, they are safer and more comfortable. The difference is good old fashioned racism facilitates compliance coupled with a recession in our job market. Exploits in any system is the "part of doing business". Every company deals with theft in the millions whether internal or external no matter how profitable. WHen I worked for Home Depot our store had an allowed $1.3 million dollar shrink as normal loss yearly during our inventories. These inventories were less than a year period per store. To them that was acceptable loss.

I am not inferring that you are a racist by any means, just that politians are hiding behind that guise to spark controversy to facilitate an agenda at honest people's fears. There is so much disinformation and political spin from all forms of media to the government spin doctors that the people cannot ever get an objective answer of truth. But what do you think will happen if we get rid of all of the illegals? Will it put our economy into a more violent tailspin of a recession? How will people afford produce, hotel prices, resturants, clothing industry, and so forth. We have always profitted from this symbiotic arrangement and do so on a daily basis. Just look at everything you own, buy, injest, or services you pay for. If you had to pay full price for quality American employees with pension, 401k, and benefits would you still spen the same way or cry outrage at the explosion of cost of living? Just look at the ire at the price of gas, imagine everything else? Fast food will not beable to have any produce on their food because it would sell a burger at $12 or any other foods. If I could I would kill all bugs because I absolutley hate them. IF I did then nature couldnt thrive without their impact pollenating plants, asssiting in decomposing waste, feeding other animals maintaining the food chain. I am not equating hispanics or any minority as bugs, just using the parallel that you cant remove something out of an equasion without destroying everything. Everything needs balance and their contribution helps maintain that balance. The ones that do these jobs for next to wage for long hours spend money back into our country buying food, clothes, rent, entertainment, and every other facet. I dont like people getting a free meal anymore than you do but that's life; somethings fall through the cracks, but I am not about to surrender any liberties over a fake promise of safety that wont do any good or improve our nation in humanity or economy. I know that when I buy something that profited off of exploited workers at least I can hope that they eventually get the opprotunity or their children to improve to a basic standard of living or something successful, its just a sad compromise.

by deepsand

For the sake of readability, you might wish to break your posts up into more & smaller paragraphs, each addressing a specific point.

That will make it both physically easier to read as well as more quickly comprehended.

by deepsand

I find it both ironic & hypocritical that the party which claims to want "smaller" government is all too frequently that which seeks to expand Federal powers with regards to controlling the populace.

And, it is the same party which decries "activist" judges, but is more than willing to take advantage of the fact that is was the US Supreme Court who, by allowing Congress to overstep its Constitution authority, by equating the goal of "providing for the general welfare," as stated in the Preamble, with the power to legislate in matters [b]not[/b] specifically enumerated as being within the scope of the power of Congress, has provided them with the ways and means to advance their agenda.

Conservatives? I think not.

Merely activists of a different stripe.

by deepsand

Most states do [b]not[/b] mandate that one carry personal ID at all times; but, Nazi Germany did.

You seem to believe that everyone has a drivers license bearing a photo of them; nothing could be further from the facts.

For example, until recently NJ continued to issue [b[non-photographic[/b] drivers licenses; those who have such, will not have a photo-license until their next renewal. Furthermore, many people, particularly the elderly, do not drive, and therefore have no license at all.

Finally, there is nothing in the US Constitution granting either Congress or the Executive Branch the power to engage in the activities under discussion here.

The Federal government succeeds in overstepping its authority not by being able to enforce its wishes, but by monetarily penalizing those who fail to comply.

The essential freedom here being lost is the freedom to not be illegally coerced.

by jck

That's why it's states rights to mandate whether or not photo IDs are required by state law.

BTW, nice comparison to Nazi Germany. I guess we burn Jews in ovens in FL too? Real nice. You're a real tribute to the people of PA.

And as much as the government has no power to engage in those activities, they also have no obligation to provide welfare, WIC, or SSI either. They can start there and make the ID a requirement for social programs.

If lawmakers really want it, they'll find a legal way to implement it.

Again, it's not Nazi-ish to have a national ID system. You're not losing your right to vasoline it up in your bedroom, you're not having a tracking chip put under your skin so big brother can watch you. You're not being asked to do anything other than carry another card in your pocket or purse.

What's the big deal?

by deepsand

Are you really so unaware of the ongoing efforts of some to [b]dictate[/b] what does & does not constitute allowable [b]private[/b] conduct?

Do you also not know that these are the same parties who have historically striven for more governmental powers with respect to law enforcement.

Wake up & smell the coffee; it's later than you think!

by deepsand

It seem that most people have forgotten the basics of navigation, such as where the Sun rises & sets, that streams flow toward rivers toward bays into oceans, etc..

But, this should come as nw surprise. Witness the number of people who can no longer perform simple arithmetic calculations by virtue of having become dependent on calculators, etal..

How many science & engineering students are today capable of using a slide rule?

by salamander

As far as navigation goes, I'm amazed at the number of people who can't recongize common constellations, understand ascenscions and declinations of stars, and lack basic orienteering knowledge. My dad was always into astronomy, and would be quite embarrassed if either of his children couldn't find their way back to civilization under a dark or light sky.

Reminds me...have you heard the joke about BlondStar? A woman calls an OnStar-like service in complete hysteria because she's locked herself inside her car...and the keys are in the ignition. If you ever run across it, it's great.

by Member 25348569

A London cab driver pointed out me me many years ago that all satellite dishes in the UK point due South. I don't know whether the same applies elsewhere.

Now, I can navigate anywhere in the UK - the Pole star at night and satellite dishes by day.

(It also helps that England is about the same size as Florida and all farmers are rich and have satellite TV.)

Now if I could just remember on which floor I parked the car...

We're going for ID cards, as well. Must compare notes, sometime, once we both get nearer the day.

by jck

yeah...and Adolf is gonna come out of hiding and consult with Walt Disney's frozen head.

haha...get real, man.

Fact is, the USA has means in place right now that if they really wanted to listen to you or see where you're at, it takes them about 10 minutes to target you and see what you're doing outside or listen to you even if you're inside a building.

If they really want to know what you're doing, they don't have to put a chip in a card and make you carry it. Take a valium and relax.

by dr dij

they're going to disappear.
Then the engineers among us can install air conditioning, lifts, and escalators (from a previous friday yuk)

by dr dij

All those active emitters to read the badges will give us guys a nice toasty feeling down there, and keep the population in check, in addition to supporting doctors incomes at cancer clinics.

by deepsand

Having grown up in the country, where the air is sufficiently clear for viewing the night sky, learning to navigate by the stars was easy, commonplace, & taken for granted.

However, when I later became acquainted with large cities, I was appalled to find that the night sky was rendered a mere milky haze.

It is little wonder that so many never developed an appreciation for the beauty of the night skies, let alone the ability to navigate by them.

by deepsand

For the moment, I will give you the benefit of charity, and assume that you are too young to be able to place this matter in its proper historical perspective.

How else to explain your apparent blind trust in those that hold power?

by salamander

I was raised in the country, as well. Living in an urban area, now, I miss a lot of the sky. I'd like to buy a telescope sometime, but feel like it would be sort of wasted here...unless all I wanted to study was the moon and a handful of other stars. Fortunately, I live about forty-five minutes from an observatory, and I try to make it up there at least twice a year, summer and winter.

by deepsand

you just odn't get it.

That is not intended as a personal judgement; simply an observation of fact.

While such is clearly attributable to a lack of knowledge & understanding of the historical facts & perspective, the reason(s) for such remain unknown to me.

So as to better understand this, with an eye toward helping you to understand the issues at ahnd, I would ask that you provide a synopsis of your biography, including age, where schooled, family background, political bent, etc..

by mjd420nova

I think a national ID card for imigrants is what's needed. California has a real problem with illegal immigrants driving in the state, and with out insurance no less. Why do I need
to protect myself when the state can't do it's
job properly?? Much has been published about
those individuals who went to the Arizona-New
Mexico--Mexico border to do the job that the
border patrol couldn't. The groups that screamed the loudest about this are saying that
it puts undue hardship on the migrant farm workers. I have no problem with anyone coming
to this country to earn a living, if they do ot legally.. sign them up, photograph them, fingerprint them and do a background check. Why
should we as a nation become a haven for the
people other countries don't want. A melting
pot has turned into a boiling pot.

by jmgarvin

I live in New Mexico and illegal immigration is an issue, but more so is are the citizens.

Lack of insurance, DWI, sex offenders, meth labs, etc are all here is spades. Hell, NM is so lax with DWI laws that there are cases of people with almost FIFTY...FIVE ZERO...DWIs!!!! WTF is that?

Politicians do what is best for THEM...they don't care about the average joe, they care about the VOTE and the kickback.

by deepsand

Read the rest of the thread.

The impetus behind this is a desire by some for Federal [b]control[/b] to an extent [b]not granted by the US Constitution[/b].

by apotheon

The fact that you and other supporters of the idea can't imagine any way of circumventing the supposed positive aspects of a national ID system other than by direct counterfeiting is a pretty clear indication of how it is that it will be disturbingly easy for people to circumvent the sort of controls you can envision. Those who are willing to give up freedom for safety (yes, privacy is freedom) are typically blind the ways in which privacy violation can lead to abuses by far more people than merely the enforcers of those privacy-violating regulations.

Most welfare fraud has nothing to do with one person pretending to be another, to say nothing of the fact that it's as easy to get around automated fingerprint authentication as it is to cut off a finger. Personally, I'd rather have my food stolen than my thumbs.

by apotheon

1. The danger is primarily not in the actions of malevolent men, but in those of well-meaning men who do not understand the danger they present with their poorly-considered plans. You seem to suffer the same delusion of a vast, pervasive governmental conspiracy to help the little guy that most of the citizens of the US believe, and I've never understood that attitude.

2. A quote:
"First they came for the Communists, but I was not a Communist so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Socialists and the Trade Unionists, but I was neither, so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Jews, but I was not a Jew so I did not speak out. And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me."
- Pastor Martin Niemoeller, from the Kirchenverwaltung der Evangelischen Kirche in Hessen and Darmstadt

There are already American citizens being held without access to a lawyer long beyond what would previously be considered lawful because of the extra powers granted federal law enforcement by the USA PATRIOT Act. Combined with other laws that have been passed and are still circulating in Congress, the US government is building a body of law that will allow federal law enforcement to arrest someone without a court-issued warrant, hold him or her indefinitely, make a summary determination of status as an "enemy combatant", revoke citizenship, and deport to foreign soil, such as Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib. Perhaps most frighteningly, laws like the DMCA are being tied more closely with those like the USA PATRIOT Act, such that trading "pirated" software and music can be defined as "hacking", which in turn can be defined as "terrorism", which in turn can be defined as "treason".

Things like this don't happen overnight. They happen gradually, coming in the back door when you aren't looking. The only reason you don't noticed the butt-monkeys coming to get you is that they're holding you face-down.

by jmgarvin

Man, with the DMCA and THIS...I'm starting to think the nut bags in Taos aren't so nutty.

The FBI can wiretap without a warren, the RIAA and MPAA can declare you a "hacker" and put you in jail forever. Your TV card, CDRW, and DVDR are all hacking tools...see ya! Oh man, stop the world I want to get off!!!

by deepsand

Same here.

That's one of the reasons that I try to get make to Central PA as often as possible.

by deepsand

of Central PA, where I grew up.

If the Sh*t hits the fan, at least I'll be able to live off the land if necessary.

by jkaras

I have to type fast because I am supposed to be working, not offering opinions while at work. I just try to get every quick thought out rather than carefully structuring my argument with a well formatted page before someone sees what I am doing. If my old english teacher even read three sentences of my posts I would be doing excerises on the chalkboard as well as essays. I just hope that the person reading them gets my gist of what moralistic opinion I am trying to convey.

by jck

My age is irrelevant.

The fact is that to eliminate process that furthers progress and technology because of a few who would misuse it is to stop our ability to improve the world around us.

If there are those who would misuse, punish those few appropriately. Do not punish the rest of America just because you are paranoid about all the ilk who have embedded themselves in the system that misuse resources.

A national ID system would work wonders for expediting public program distributions to those who need them.

But I guess in this day and time, we have neither the ability to figure out a way to make a safe and secure ID system nor a way to keep it from being misused.

No one is asking for everyone to have to put their life story, medical records, income tax statements, etc., into a database that's insecure.

It's a real shame so many people, like yourself, see a technology as a hindrance when it can really work (when done well) as a catalyst to progress.

by jck

1. The danger in acts of malcontent is in those who commit them. There are only so many things you can do to prevent those from doing them from committing such actions. Once you've established boundaries, punish those who commit acts of wrong-doing with them.

I find your first statement akin to blaming firearms manufacturers from murders involving guns, or liquor manufacturers for drunk driving accidents.

The blame for the misuse of an asset does not lie with those who make it, but with those who would do wrong with it.

2. As for who speaks for whom, I don't understand what that has to do with a national ID system. I do understand how that relates to people being detained under the Patriot Act, but I don't understand how that relates to an ID system.

I, for one, was not in favor of Ashcroft and his boys getting the Patriot Act. I knew it was vaguely worded and pushed through Congress at a time when the Bush Administration knew that it could be because of all the outrage from the 9/11 terrorist incident.

It was *not* a well-planned piece of legislation purposefully, because of a Republican president and his party constituency in a Republican controlled congress. They wanted control so that they had blanket power to take people in who they saw as a "possible threat". Well, I could be considered a threat because I'm 6'6.

Hence, I don't know why the Patriot Act is linked here. I neither endorsed it nor used it as supportive content to back my ID argument.

I agree with you that the Patriot Act is a bad concept in its current form. However, what should we do about it?

Get out and vote.

Get out and talk to your neighbor.

Get the idiots out of office that got put in *and* re-elected this past year.

Talk to your congressman and tell them the one thing they don't want to hear: I know how you vote and I won't be voting for you or your party next election.

Again as I expressed in my post to deepsand, don't kill ideas for progress because of the people who would misuse them. Make them better. Do what you can to prevent misuse. Then if someone misuses them inappropriately, punish them.

I just hate to see things that would forward mankind and benefit him stopped because of a few token bad guys.

It's not that I'm naive. I just think that as Americans, we should be more active in making the system work right rather than having the passive "Oh well" attitude that is prevalent nowadays.

by jck

I never said anything can't be gotten around.

I worked on projects that discovered and implemented ways to "get around" implemented technology access roadblocks quite successfully. I worked personally on a software product that 2 branches of the US Armed Forces use to secure their networks to this day.

But, the technology *is* there (when properly implemented) to stop rogue entry. It has to be well-planned and thought through and can't happen overnight, but it can be done.

I admit, nothing is full-proof. A disgruntled DBA can go in and commit these acts you predict happening with distribution of personal information. You're never going to stop that.

However again, how do you compromise someone's livelihood, rights, etc., by making them have an ID card? By the government knowing where they live? How old they are? It makes no sense. The government already has this information.

Next thing you know, you're going to say it's illegal for government-run libraries to make you give personal information to have a card because it violates your rights to privacy.

Plain and simple. No one says the ID card has to carry sensitive information about you that jeopardizes the integrity of your well-being. It can be designed to carry information for only verified identification so that services can be secured from as much fraud as possible.

I really don't get the mentality. You'd think that you guys are here to fight against the people who represent you in government that you or your elected representatives put into office.

If you don't think honest, competent people are in office who can implement safe and secure plans, vote someone else in.

If you don't think those in office can hire competent people to design and implement things, vote someone else in.

Again, I just hate to see progress stopped because of lack of faith in the system to do what is right. If you don't think those who are in office are capable, then get rid of them.

But, don't punish the rest of the country because lawmakers, policy setters and their underlings aren't doing their job right. Make a change. Take positive action.

As for welfare fraud, there is quite a bit. However, welfare fraud usually occurs either with illegal immigrants collecting under work visas, and with those collecting on persons either deceased or made-up.

The case with San Diego county, CA I spoke of that people were taking WIC cards into grocery stores that they'd bought off WIC mom's for sometimes as low as 10 cents on the dollar to get cheap/free groceries. This also happens with food stamps. San Diego had within a few years seen the system pay for itself in the reduction of misuse and fraud.

Their Unisys implementation simply had the cardholder's name on the card, and a 2D barcode on the back that contained fingerprint identifier info so that the scanned fingerprint information could be matched or not.

And also, I'd tend to think cut-off fingers would start to smell after a while. If it's a thermal issue, there are fingerprint readers that are thermally sensitive as well that can tell if you're using a cold or fake finger.

Again, I'm not saying that security can't be gotten around. However, you can make systems secure enough as to not allow simpleton or even experienced hackers from making access to such data with any ease.

By the way: if you're so worried about people getting your personal information for misuse, perhaps you should call your representatives in support of Bill H.R. 29 of the 109th Congress, sponsored by Mary Bono of CA. It is a bill that legislates to protect users of the Internet from unknowing transmission of their personally identifiable information through spyware programs, and for other purposes.

I trust the government a lot more than I trust Western Digital and others who implement spyware in their software products with my private information.

by jck

I'm all too aware of what Bush and his political allies are looking to do.

Fortunately, I didn't vote for him. So, you can't blame me. I also told my friends who were voting for Bush what a mistake they were making.

I also know what the religious right has been doing for years. Now with them in solid PAC control of the Congress and White House, they are doing things as bold as pushing Bush and the FCC to levy fines of MILLIONS against individual broadcasters (not their employers) for "questionable content".

With the influence right-wing religious groups like the "American Family Association" and people like Robertson, Falwell and others have with being closely tied to Bush, they *will* leverage their lifestyle and belief systems on us. And, that is beginning with guys like Howard Stern and others being run off the air.

You know, I know Michael Powell (before his announced departure from the FCC) had passed the AOL deal while owning stock in them. I wonder how much stock he and his buddies hold in Sirius and XM with all these air personalities migrating from terrestrial broadcasting.

Yes, I'm fully aware of this problem. However, you do not treat the cancer by just giving pain meds unless it is terminal (hopeless case). You treat the cancer, not the symptom.

So next, I guess you're saying it's too late and we should quit passing laws and give up on our government system?

Quite the idea you have there.

If you're not happy with who's in office, I'd suggest you vote them out and get someone in there who you think can do the job right.

Sorry, but I'm just sick of the mentality of "this government isn't doing it right, so it shouldn't be doing it at all". Your officials are elected. Get them out or quit complaining about the poor job they do.

The government is supposed to be "Of the people, by the people, and for the people". Vote to make it that way, talk to your neighbors and local business owners, and maybe work on a campaign instead of giving a donation, and maybe it will be again.

For right now, I have no faith in the current presidency or congress. I'm waiting til next year to vote out people. After that and depending on what happens, I might be moving anyways.

by deepsand

'Real ID' Faces Reality

The federal government wants driver's licenses that are more trustworthy and tech-enabled. State IT leaders will have to figure out how to make that happen.

By Eric Chabrow and Larry Greenemeier , InformationWeek
May 16, 2005
URL: http://www.informationweek.com/story/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=163102234

Delaware CIO Thomas Jarrett bumped into Michael Shahan, director of the state's Division of Motor Vehicles, a few days after Congress passed the Real ID Act last week. The bill, which also was signed by President Bush last week, will set national standards for driver's licenses, raising privacy hackles about a de facto "national ID card" and technology and security worries about how data will be stored and shared among states and with the federal government. Yet there aren't enough details available right now to let those concerned do much more than worry. "I told him we need to have a conversation about it," Jarrett says of his colleague at Motor Vehicles. "But at this point, I'm not exactly sure what needs to be done."

Congress didn't spend much time debating the merits of the measure, which has been discussed in various forms several times since Sept. 11, 2001. This time, it got tacked onto a bill to fund American troops in Afghanistan and Iraq. The key provisions of the bill are that states by 2008 will need to verify data with the feds and other states before issuing driver's licenses, and the cards must include certain minimum data and be "machine readable."

The legislation, primarily aimed at denying illegal immigrants driver's licenses, is vague about how the government should implement technical provisions. It's up to the Homeland Security secretary, in conjunction with the Transportation secretary, to devise regulations for states to follow. Neither department offered any guidance last week.

The most-difficult challenge created by the act will be sharing birth-certificate information, Social Security numbers, and other data found on a driver's license across multiple agencies in the 50 states, territories, tribal jurisdictions, and the federal government. It isn't necessarily cutting-edge IT, says Richard Hunter, a Gartner VP and research director. States will need to restructure existing databases, which is more time-consuming and costly than innovative. What's difficult will be determining rules for access, management, and security for these state records if they're all connected. "The legislation creates a mandate to gather info without specifying controls over the use of that data," Hunter says.

Indeed, securing personal data that will crisscross the country is a major concern for Jarrett. "As technologists, we start getting paranoid when we move information outside our walls," says Jarrett, who also serves as president of the National Association of State CIOs.

Verifying digital-record information is going to be difficult, says Dillinger, Iowa's Driver Services' director.

Photo by Steve Pope

There's already some cross-state data sharing. Thirty-nine states use EDI to access a Social Security database to verify a driver's name and Social Security number, which this bill requires. Other verifications will be tougher, since most states don't have birth certificates and other vital records stored digitally. "It's one thing to present a document; it's another thing to accept the document as valid," says Terry Dillinger, Iowa's Driver Services' director. "Most of the documents we can accept at this point for the authentication process are difficult to verify. There's not a system online to go to in which all states' vital records can be checked."

A small, federally funded pilot that uses a simple Web interface--the Electronic Verification of Vital Events--has shown that verifying records such as birth certificates isn't technologically challenging, says Jay Maxwell, CIO of the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators. Images can be called up to be checked against the real document but only after they're scanned into a document-management system. "The only way you can get cranking on this system is to get the data in there, and that will take years to do," he says.

The National Conference of State Legislatures estimates it could cost states as much as $750 million to implement measures required by the act, including some $80 million to create links among state databases. Other costs include purchasing equipment to collect, store, and encode data onto the licenses. Anticipating this bill, Iowa has allotted $1.2 million this year--about 3.5% of the Office of Driver Services' annual budget--for compliance, including a major redesign of its driver's license card and the motor-vehicle IT system to support it. The act is billed as voluntary for states and therefore isn't creating a true national ID. But licenses from noncompliant states won't be acceptable ID to get on an airplane or for any other federally regulated use.

For most citizens--and businesses considering how they'll use the new IDs--the biggest unanswered question is what the "machine-readable" technology will be. Iowa's driver's licenses have three pieces of machine-readable technologies: a magnetic strip and a two-dimensional bar code contain the data printed on the face of the card, and a linear bar code contains the cardholder's driver's license number. Dillinger expects those will meet the new requirements.

In last year's Intelligence Reform Act, Congress already had asked the Transportation Department to explore the best technology for use in ID cards, notes Ari Schwartz, associate director of the Center for Democracy and Technology and a member of a Transportation committee that in April started looking into the issue. That effort has been disbanded, because the Real ID Act will supercede it. Still, Schwartz hopes the approach is similar. "One good thing about [the Intelligence Reform Act] is that technology experts were going to have direct input," he says.

Critics seized on the current lack of technology direction to raise the specter of massive privacy invasions. Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, said in a speech on the House floor that Homeland Security could require technology such as radio-frequency identification tags on licenses, which in theory could contain far more information on a computer chip than is on a license today, including biometric information such as retina scans, fingerprints, and even DNA information. Apparently envisioning a world of ubiquitous RFID readers to capture such information, Paul warned his House colleagues that "including such technology as RFID would mean that the federal government ... would know where Americans are at all time of the day and night."

That's perhaps a bit far-out. But the feds this summer are experimenting with RFID in passports and visas carried by some foreigners entering the United States at the Los Angeles airport and select border crossings. The objective is to simplify processing and security efforts at borders by automatically capturing arrival and departure information, as well as ensuring that passport holders are who they claim to be.

Homeland Security is exploring the use of RFID at land borders in Arizona, New York, and Washington state. The department plans by the end of July to automate a process for populating the Immigration and Naturalization Service's I-94 arrival-departure form by scanning arriving foreigners' documents, a spokeswoman says. RFID tags would be embedded in a receipt portion of the I-94 form that's distributed to visitors as they enter the country and then scanned as they leave to verify that their departures are in compliance with their visas.

As machine-readable IDs take hold, the private sector could rely on them in new ways and perhaps play a more-direct role in helping verify identities before IDs are issued, says Maxwell of the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators. If states allow an electric or gas bill as evidence of residency to issue a driver's license, they might need to link to a utility's customer database to prove the invoice is real. Databases such as those managed by ChoicePoint Inc. and LexisNexis could be checked to verify information provided by a license applicant. Maxwell envisions airport-security personnel or even banks scanning in an ID, then being allowed to link up with state motor-vehicle databases to compare the images and data on driver's licenses before allowing a person to board a plane or open an account.

Those types of applications are likely a few years away. Today, state IT and motor-vehicle officials are just anxious for the government to tell them exactly what they must do now. "We know it's a huge issue," Delaware CIO Jarrett says, "but we don't know how serious it will be yet."

-- with Tony Kontzer

by deepsand

neither you nor anyone else has the right to demand the same of me or anyone else.

You're too damned trusting of government.

by deepsand

When concerned about others observing your activities, you may wish to try 1st composing lengthy posts using a simple editor, such as Note Pad, and then copy/paste the result into the Body field here.

It's a method I use when I have doubts re. my ability to complete a lengthy post without interruption or feel that editing and/or error checking will be called for.

by deepsand

Honest politicians are no match for the dedication & zeal of those who would control all that they survey.

As I've said elsewhere, you are simply too trusting of government.

by apotheon

"I find your first statement akin to blaming firearms manufacturers from murders involving guns, or liquor manufacturers for drunk driving accidents."

Not even close. Blaming firearms manufacturers for people being killed by firearms would be more like blaming the companies who are developing biometric, RFID, and database technology for the way the government uses it, not like blaming the government for misusing the technology. Don't confuse use of technology with development of technology. The government misusing the technology, in your analogy, is more like a cop shooting people indiscriminately in the hopes that a few bad people will be among the wounded.

"The blame for the misuse of an asset does not lie with those who make it, but with those who would do wrong with it."

Precisely my point.

"As for who speaks for whom, I don't understand what that has to do with a national ID system."

That was meant to point out how rights and freedoms can be gradually eroded without anyone doing anything about it because they don't see how it affects them. I didn't think you would be so dense as to miss my point.

"I, for one, was not in favor of Ashcroft and his boys getting the Patriot Act. I knew it was vaguely worded and pushed through Congress at a time when the Bush Administration knew that it could be because of all the outrage from the 9/11 terrorist incident."

And yet, somehow, you don't have a problem with a vaguely worded REAL ID Act that was slipped in the backdoor as a rider on an appropriations bill. That's not a very reliable set of standards you have there.

"It was *not* a well-planned piece of legislation purposefully, because of a Republican president and his party constituency in a Republican controlled congress."

That's no different from what's happening with the REAL ID Act.

"They wanted control so that they had blanket power to take people in who they saw as a 'possible threat'."

Now, of course, they want the ability to track us (and I don't just mean our physical movements) better. Better information leads to better control.

"Hence, I don't know why the Patriot Act is linked here."

It's very simple, and I thought I explained it before: [b]No new law should be considered in a vacuum.[/b] The body of law in the United States is extensive, and the interaction of those laws in practice leads to a great many unintended consequences (as well as surreptitiously intended consequences) that will have a net negative effect on liberty and rights protection. The USA PATRIOT Act has changed the landscape of legislation significantly, and things that might have seemed more innocuous a decade ago are now quite a bit more suspect than they were, in terms of their effects. Anything the USA PATRIOT Act does to violate the rights of US citizens can be more easily accomplished with a centralized database that identifies people against whom the USA PATRIOT Act's provisions can be arbitrarily applied.

"I agree with you that the Patriot Act is a bad concept in its current form. However, what should we do about it?"

Write to your congressional representatives. Vote for candidates that don't support the USA PATRIOT Act (even if they're not Republicans or Democrats: don't forget there are other parties out there). Spend your money in places whose elected Congressional representatives oppose(d) the USA PATRIOT Act and similarly rights-violating legislation. Don't support bills that either take advantage of the provisions of the USA PATRIOT Act or grease the wheels of law enforcement's uses of the Act (which is one major point against the REAL ID Act).

"I just hate to see things that would forward mankind and benefit him stopped because of a few token bad guys."

The REAL ID Act is not such a "thing". Anything that decreases liberty contributes to the discouragement of progress.

by deepsand

are two quite different things.

Unfortunately, we've long passed the point were a few elections will remedy that.

Unless and until the Supreme Court invalidates Fed. legislation that lacks a nexus within the [b]limited[/b] authority granted Congress by the US Constitution, the Fed. government will continue to encroach further & further upon those rights reserved for the people & the States.

Read the news article that I've posted at the bottom of this thread. You will there find that implementation of the act in question by the States is voluntary; i.e., the Fed. government has no authority here, but hopes to induce the States and the people to comply, in this case by denying access to Fed. Properties, etc..

See
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=173798&messageID=1774852[/v]

by apotheon

Politically, jck, you're an idiot.

Badnarik was my Presidential candidate of choice in the last election. Guess what: Bush got elected.

I have been voting the corrupt out of office for as long as I've been voting, and I've been overriden by trusting nincompoops like you all along. You may not have supported Bush, but you support the REAL ID Act, so you fit the description. You probably voted for Kerry, anyway, and he's just as bad.

Yeah, great. Vote for someone else. I do vote for someone else, but I still keep getting stuck with the ass-weasel candidates the rest of you deserve. In the meantime, I'm trying to educate you dumb idiots about the dangers of lost privacy, and you're trying to equate the misuse of technology with technological advancement so that you can justify your support of the REAL ID Act.

Get over yourself.

by deepsand

in the past, have warned of impending dangers, only to be scorned & held up to ridicule, and belatedly cursed for not having [i]made[/i] others listen.

by carlitosway

Hello all,

I felt an incredible conviction to write this post and I hope all of you read it with an open mind and heart.

First of all I would like to say that when I read the post I was blown away. I am posting not to teach relgiousnism, but to confess about what I know regarding my saviour jesus.

I know most of you are already thinking "Here we go again, another religious nut!" So I did something a little different. I am not much for words so here is a link for a book illustration:

http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/5025/5025_01.asp

Further more, here is the company that I think is currently implementing this RFID system:

http://www.adsx.com/content/index.htm

And for those who feel offended, Please read below:

"Am I therefore become your enemy, because I tell you the truth?"
Gal. 4:16

God Bless,

Carlitosway

by apotheon

Hang on. This guy (CarlitosWay, named after a halfway decent cyberpunk genre novel I think) is actually citing a Chick Tract. Hey, CarlitosWay, are you for real?

This has got to be a joke, or a troll, or something. Chick Tracts are infamous joke fodder. There's so much closed-minded, bigoted nonsense in the things that they're funnier in their natural state than they are when people modify them to spoof the things.

No, I don't believe this was a serious post. It has to be some kind of weird joke.

Since I don't allow remotely served Flash to run on this system, the second link was of zero use to me. Alas.

by Member 25348569

Now I really thought that the first URL was to a joke site. It's not? I must read more!

Anyway, it would seem that the second URL is to the home page of a company that make human-implantable RFID chips. They've been used, so far, in Mexico to limit access to a criminal data repository.

What's interesting is the way that religious nutters - perceptive post by CW - grab the potential of this technology and warp it into their fantasies. The mark of the Beast is now an embedded RFID chip! Previously it was a post-apocalyptic barcode.

Reminds me of the way in which astrologers absorbed the discovery of each new planet into their lexicon without any hesitation.

Neil

by jck

A) I'm not an idiot in any sense. I have the ability to comprehend things, including politics.

B) I didn't say I support any Act, legislation or law in respects to a National ID. I support the concept of a National ID if done *correctly*.

C) The fact I voted for Kerry means I didn't want Bush in, and that I didn't see a more qualified "third party" candidate out there on the ballot in Florida who I believed could do a better job than Kerry.

I've been getting "overridden" just like you when it comes to who's president. The only winner I've voted for was Clinton. So, don't lump me with the guys who voted for "ass-weasel" candidates.

I'm glad you're trying to educate me, apotheon. But let's just say, you're "preaching to the choir". I've never said government, law, politicians, legislation or myself were perfect. I just don't totally discount the ability of someone in this country to do what's right and fix the problems.

If you want my opinion on the REAL ID Act, I'll go read it and tell you how good or bad it is. I'm not going to draw my opinion on it though from some posting on TR. I'll go read the actual written legislation.

But, don't tag me as an idiot just because you think you're more knowledgable and omnipotent in political dialogue and legal wrangling. Just because I think something is achievable and that the sacrifice of advancement shouldn't be shelved because "ass-weasels" are in office doesn't make me a nincompoop...it means I have more faith in the people to get their heads out of their asses and get people into office other than glorified car salesmen.

Maybe I shouldn't though. Maybe you're right. Thanks for the direction. I'll follow the one plan I have for a new job direction.

I think you need to get over yourself as well, man. Just because people have faith in the system to be corrected and that capable people can be found and put in office doesn't mean they're idiots. It just means they have less pessimism than you.

by jck

I have a lot of faith in the way the system is setup to work.

I have a lot of faith in the people of this country to wake up and do what's right.

I have little faith in any politician.

Although as I said in my last post, maybe apotheon is right. People in this country are into electing smiley-faced overglorified car salesmen to run the country...not leaders.

As I said, I actually am waiting for results on a possible job direction. If so, I'll not have to worry so much about it anymore.

by jck

And yes, it would take more than one election to fix it...another flaw with most Americans...they want everything overnight...that's why the debt to income ratio in this country is so bad...that's why our divorce rate is so high...and that's why so many people get laid off with corps and execs still get huge bonuses after that.

Because most people here want things *now*.

Yep...and as I said elsewhere in this thread...I'm working on not having to worry about this whole thing anymore.

If no one else in this country wants to correct the wrongs and work to make it better...why the hell should I try.

by apotheon

"B) I didn't say I support any Act, legislation or law in respects to a National ID. I support the concept of a National ID if done *correctly*."

Good friggin' luck with getting it done "correctly" in this country. It'll be wrong every time, and as such I oppose it every time. I examine the facts every time it's brought up, and every time it's wrong.

Of course, I rather suspect that you have a different definition of "done right" than mine.

"C) The fact I voted for Kerry means I didn't want Bush in, and that I didn't see a more qualified "third party" candidate out there on the ballot in Florida who I believed could do a better job than Kerry."

We clearly have very different standards. You probably wanted a "better" Democrat, and I wanted a non-authoritarian candidate.

"The only winner I've voted for was Clinton. So, don't lump me with the guys who voted for 'ass-weasel' candidates."

You voted for Clinton and Kerry. It looks to me like you voted for ass-weasel candidates.

"I just don't totally discount the ability of someone in this country to do what's right and fix the problems."

Nor do I. I also don't have faith that anyone is doing what's right: rather, I expect it to be shown clearly that what's right is being done, and that it's being done in a way that won't give the next guy increased power to do it wrong.

"Just because I think something is achievable and that the sacrifice of advancement shouldn't be shelved because 'ass-weasels' are in office doesn't make me a nincompoop"

See my previous postings about "advancement", and how this isn't it.

"...it means I have more faith in the people to get their heads out of their asses and get people into office other than glorified car salesmen."

I have almost zero faith in the positive results of unconstrained democracy. This is for a very clear reason: democracy without limits is mob rule. Our system of government has limits, but most of them are the wrong limits. The Consitition undermines itself and fails to limit some powers of government that should be very strictly limited, and this allows the voting public to screw the principles behind the Constitution over pretty thoroughly by way of elected representatives. Over the last couple hundred years, the voting public has consistently done just that.

"Just because people have faith in the system to be corrected and that capable people can be found and put in office doesn't mean they're idiots. It just means they have less pessimism than you."

I'm not pessimistic at all. I'm more of a practical optimist (which is to say: I'm a cynic*). I believe that, barring tragedy (end of the human race, et cetera), we'll eventually end up in a good place politically. I also believe that things are likely to get a lot worse before they get better, probably several times, simply because humanity as a race has a very short memory and a shorter attention span. As things are going, I believe that ultimately the US will fall and eventually be replaced by something else at least once before we arrive at a good place politically with real longevity.

* cynic (n.): optimist that learns from life experience
[this definition CCD CopyWrite Chad Perrin]

by apotheon

If the "mark of the beast" has any relevance in the real world, it's entirely possible that RFID (or some similar concept in technology, perhaps to follow RFID) is it. I'm willing to concede the possibility, regardless of whether I attend that supernatural beliefs club's meetings. I'm even thoroughly opposed to the effective requirement of RFID implantation for convenience in American living.

I'm not impressed by unthinking hysteria, bigoted assumption, and general lunacy, though. Chick Tracts fit that description nicely, as well as several other unflattering descriptive phrases that I won't use at this time.