Discussion Locked

One step closer to National ID system

0 helpful
142 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

142 replies

by deepsand

If he wants me to read the content at the 2nd URL, he's going to have to find another method of delivery.

by deepsand

There's so many to choose from that one can always find one suitable for any occasion & attire.

RFID? What's the point in having it if you can't flaunt it?

by jmgarvin

The flaws of RFID are going to become PAINFULLY apparent in the next few months with all the "no swipe" credit cards. Perhaps then manfacturers will HAVE to fix a system this is obviously borked.

My solution? Bag RFID, go with a localized chip that is HIGHLY encrypted (512 bit or better) via a PKI type schema.

by apotheon

Bar codes make for great fashionwear / social commentary. Unfortunately, it loses that entirely when everyone has to get the same barcode type in the same place. Then, it just becomes a "feature".

by deepsand

There are an infinite number of possible encoding systems, so we'll never run out of unique codes.

Of course, some of them might require a whole-body tatoo.

by apotheon

Realize, you're talking to a guy that makes jokes in binary. To answer your question: Yes, we should.

Q: Option 1 or Option 2?
A: Yes.

by deepsand

Time and time again he has had the power to prevent the ills that have befallen us, but failed to recognize the dangers at hand & willfully invited the devil to dinner.

I find no reason to expect that the masses will awaken from their stupor any time soon.

by apotheon

Actually, as far as trying to awaken "the common man" to the dangers in government, it kinda looks like jck is falling under the heading "the common man" here. He seems to be singularly unwilling to see how granting additional power to track the lives of citizens to such a thoroughly flawed government is a Very Bad Idea, regardless of how that information is collected.

by apotheon

What really gets me about that second URL is that it leads to a page with NO CONTENT except a Flash object, and if you delete "/content/index.htm" and try to access some other part of the site that way, you just get a redirect to a page that doesn't exist and, judging by the URL, is supposed to "help" the user install a Flash plugin.

Three is literally NO WAY at that site for anyone that doesn't have a working Flash plugin to give them any business whatsoever. We can't even get contact information or references to related websites. It is a Big Black Void in the Internet.

That is about the worst case of customer discouraging behavior I've ever seen on a website. It's awful. Whoever decided this was a good design for the site needs to be fired and prevented from ever again working in a place where (s)he gets to make such decisions (unless someone better off out of business wants to hire this rube).

That's almost as bad as taking Chick Tracts seriously.

by deepsand

The 2nd URL is to the home page of Applied Digital, a provider of security products.

Their whole damn site is Flash, complete with audible links!

by jck

now you know why I might take opportunity in 6 months to 1 year to relocate.

"Hickory dickory dock..." - Andrew Dice Clay

by jck

Well, I'm glad to be a common man if it means that I can see that a National ID system doesn't have to include an RFID chip.

As I stated before, I never backed the REAL ID Act. I even admitted I haven't read the act.

I back the concept of a national ID as to prevent government fraud and expedition of government process. That doesn't have to include an RFID chip in a card, under your skin, or an alien anal probe like Cartman had that pops a satellite dish out your butt to send Dubya your coordinates.

And, I never said the system couldn't be duped. As I stated before, I worked in areas that specialized in figuring out how to get past preventative measures. Like the infomercial says: "Where there's a will, there's a way."

Nonetheless, think me a common man. That way when I do something right, you're even more impressed with me.

"Screw you guys. I'm going...home..." - Eric Cartman

by deepsand

As I've mentioned upwards a ways, I've an eye toward returning to a place where my odds of survival are greatly improved.

by av .

ID theft, illegal immigrants, terrorism. The Real ID is coming next.

I agree with the opponents. I don't like that this was included with the illegal immigration bill. I'm a legal citizen and I'm affected too.

We already have identity theft problems. Real ID will take it to a new level. I'm reminded of that movie, The Net. Its not the criminals I'm worried about, its the government.

by deepsand

This practice is all too commonplace, and has resulted in some of the most ill advised and poorly considered legislative results of all times.

by av .

Its almost like a bait and switch. What I hate is that we elect our government officials every so often, but major issues we really don't have a say in aside from prodding your representatives to vote in a certain way.

I think that people should be able to vote on major issues like this because of the freedom and privacy issues. There should be public questions. I don't think its enough to send a letter to your congressman either. Sure, maybe sometimes enough people respond and a bill gets through, but do you really know for sure if your letter made a difference? Or, was his vote partisan politics, for his own political gain and we get left holding the bag.

Anymore, I just don't trust any of our government officials to make good decisions for the rest of us. They can hardly make a decision at all because they are too busy fighting.

If there is even a remote chance that I will be wearing an RFID tag on my body one day, than I want more of a say than sending a letter to my congressman hoping he will vote against it.

I had read in passing recently that there are some places testing RFID tags in wristbands on school children as a way of tracking them. I also read that some people have them implanted in their pets for the same reason. Only the pets have them under their skin. Then I read that a person had an RFID tag implanted in his body with all of his pertinent information as a test. Test for what? For the rest of us!!!

Thats it! No more IT jobs. I'm going to start selling RFID jewelry before the market gets too flooded.

PS: Congratulations. I see you are now #1.

by apotheon

Of course, I had to make it as clear as reasonably possible for other potential readers that might be following this thread. Heh.

by deepsand

lest someone take offense; must'nt appear to be [i]too[/i] judgemental.

We don't want another IT_Lobo crying that his "rights" were trammeled while TR stood idly by .

by deepsand

If put directly to the populace, they circumvent the primary goal of the Constitution, which is to make it as difficult as possible for a (usually temporary) majority to run roughshod over the rights of a minority.

The only way to avoid such would be, as is the case in many state governments with regards to constitutional ammendments, to hold the public referendum only have the legislature has passed the bill in 2 consecutive legislative years.

But, if we tried this with every bill passed by Congress, nothing would ever get done on a timely basis.

I think the best that can be achieved is for the House to set, and enforce, rules that limit riders to those matters pertinent to the bill as originally offered by, and in keeping with the stated purpose of, its sponsers.

PS. I'm really not sure how the Rankings work, or how reliable they are. In the past, I noticed that, if one ordered members by the bar graph displayed a result other than that indicated by the numeric rating would result. I've also observed instances in which my ranking changed in a manner [i]inversely[/i] correlated to my recent posting activity. So, I tend to discount it except on a very gross scale.

by av .

But for ones that affect us all, like the national ID. Stem cell research. Social Security. I think our government is out of step with the people, so we need to be more involved with the solution. Plus, I just plain don't trust them to do the right thing, democrat or republican. They may do nothing and that does nothing for us. We are the ones holding the bag.

From the top down, I think our government is bloated, corrupt and ineffective. They've lost their focus and forgot that they are supposed to be doing the people's business. Instead, they are all wrapped up in partisan politics. I have to admit that it is quite interesting at times to watch, but, shows over, they need to go back to work.

They definitely need to limit riders attached to a bill if they don't pertain to that issue. That practice is just abused. It'll be interesting to see the outcome of the PA case you mentioned in your other post that pertains to this issue. Jockey fingerprinting and Casinos in one bill? Thats special.

PSS - I have no idea how TR ranks usage either. I suppose it just counts the number of posts you make to TR. Every now and then, there is a glitch.

by deepsand

all are somehow affected. To try to decide the depth & breadth of the effect of a particular bill simply allows those in a position of power to formally exercise their own particular bias.

The only way to attempt to curb the practice is to amend the US Constitution in a manner similar to that down by various states.

That's not perfect, of course, given that legislatures can either ignore such a Constitutional provision, or differ in good faith about its application, thereby forcing a Supreme Court decision, but it would be eminently better than the current sad state of affairs.

PS. Per TR staff, the number of posts is but one of several weighted factors used in determining rank.

by apotheon

I haven't even read that thread, and don't intend to. The title was enough to convince me it wasn't worth my while.

by deepsand

The PA Constitution requires that legislation:
1) Deal with 1 subject only; and,
2) Not be amended so as to materially change the original purpose of the bill as offered.

The legislative act that legalized slot machines here was a 145 page amendment to a 46 line bill requiring that jockeys be fingerprinted!

Althought the PA Supreme Court has in recent years struck down 2 Constitutional Amendments for having violated the aforesaid requirments, given the dollars here at stake, and the Court's history of being headstrong & volatile, all bets are off on this matter.

by jck

anyways...

I'm not looking to "survive". I'm looking for balance. I don't get it here.

Hence...I wait to see what happens with my opportunities.

by jck

When survival becomes your only reason for existence though, you have two alternatives:

- Live only to fight to survive
- Live somewhere you don't only live to fight to survive

Sure life always throws challenges at you. But when you constantly have to look over your shoulder for who's going to backstab you or worry about if you're being outdone by some social-climber because he knows it'll get favor with the vain boss, fight for survival becomes not a happenstance but a constant.

I prefer not to be around those I can not trust and who would compromise their integrity for pennies. I would rather give my time to those who do their best without stepping on others, etc.

Hence, why I look for something better in life. Whether that's professional, geographic, societal or personal.

by absolutely

deepsand's observation that survival is always the primary concern of a rational person does not imply that life is a brutal battle for survival, or that life and death are always in the balance. All he said is that whatever other values one claims to have are totally nil without life.

by deepsand

That one's first priority is survival does [b]not[/b] imply that the goal is mere existence.

by absolutely

Don't start quoting Animal Farm now, but some are definitely smarter than others. Surely you agree that intelligence is the most important trait of our species? And that those who exhibit less of it are more like the beasts of the field?

by deepsand

Assuming that it were possible to develop one without the other, I would have doubts as to its value.

(Speak softly, lest we be accused of egalitarianism.)

This discussion is closed to new replies.