Discussion Locked

Our colleges are failing us

0 helpful
75 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a Network Administrator at my company. I have my MCSE NT 4.0, and am currently working toward my CCNA and hopefully my CCNP (boy ccnp classes are expensive!!!). Recently my younger cousin (who is crackerjack at PC systems) is finishing high school and wanted advice on which college to go to. He wanted a technical college but wanted to learn stuff he can use in the field. He didnt want to waste time taking too many stupid classes that had absolutely NOTHING to do with his goal.

Sowe sat down and hit the net. 4 hours later, we sat very dissapointed, staring at the computer screen. Pretty much it comes down to this:

College courses as so far behind the times that I was FORCED to tell my cousin to skip it. I told him to hit some high quality technical schools that can take him through his OS training (MCSE, LINX, UNIX) and his network training (CCNA, CCNP, NETWORK+) and pc training (A+), and light programming (C++, Java, etc).

This really makes me sick to my stomach. I was very very dissapointed with the class offerings in these "technical" colleges. I really felt that there was probably 3 or 4 classes out of 4 years of college that would help him get ahead in today's IT environment. What the hell is going on here? Do colleges really expect my cousin to sit through 80% classes that add up to garbage only to get to the 20% that really matter?

My personal feelings are this: (after the intensive search on the internet for colleges in the NYC areathat my cousin can go to) Colleges are institutions that just act too slow to keep up with IT today (except maybe really specialized ones that I haven't been able to find). And because of this, I feel technical schools (not really colleges aftera all) will RULE the training of IT personnel for the far future.

Just my 2 cents worth.

-public@lipan.org
Ginel Lipan

75 replies

by ahunter6

i have to agree completely. the only time i saw a college actually offer a course i could use was back in 96 when i took a DOS class. I learned a tremendous amount from that one class. and the kicker is it was a community college! I've looked at several schools and all I ever see is calculus, programming, higher math, programming, math, web design, programming. Where's the network achitecture classes? The routing and protocol classes? The HARDWARE classes? With all this focus on programming it's not surprising that a person here on my own helpdesk (CSC) doesn't know how TO INSTALL A DRIVER! But she's been programming java for years! My state (connecticut) is filled overflowing with colleges, but not a one i could actually afford has remotely anything I want to learn. I can't help but think that the people who put together these curricula are confusing programming with everything else. I know my non IT friends do. You are right on, Ginel. Have your cousin got to ITT or somesuch. I did.Best idea i ever had.

by bhaulma1

Do you really believe that a college degree is all about not taking courses that teach anything beyond your major? Technology in your case.

What you desire are programs in electrical/computer enginnering or systems design & analysis. Engineering courses. (You can legitimatly call yourself an engineer when you are finished.)Unfortuneatly, this requires that you "waste" all that time taking courses which are not of "interest."

By all means, hit a Junior College or trade school.

No, I'm sorry, the schools aren't the ones failing here.

by public

Electrical/computer enginnering??? Why would my cousin need to know that? I want my cousin to come out of college and be able to:

1) Know how to cable a 1500 node network (with fiber backbone)
2) Know how to design that network with gateways,
firewalls, sans etc.
3) Be able (if he wanted to) to BUILD each and every one of those computers and servers with a myriad of NOS's.
4) Setup an incredibly secure network and the infrastructure to support it.
5) Know and unstandand licencing agreements (this should be a seperate certification in-of itself)

Now I can see Systems design & analysis, but have you ACTALLY READ the description of those courses. Go to a college and read up on their courses. It has has almost NOTHING to do with what REALLY goes on in the real world. My brother in law is taking your "Engineering Courses" and he hates it. He pretty much says he had to go through a whole lot of "garbage" to get to his Network classes (2 in total. 2 cheesy semesters). He's very dissapointed at what he was forced to learn. He sees that his college doesn't have what's needed.

It comes down to this. Would an IT employer want

1) a 4 year college student with an ENGINEERING Degree (electrical/computer enginnering orsystems design & analysis degree)

OR

2) A student who used his 4 years (and the money that would of gone to colleges) to get his MCSE, CCNA, CCNP, A+, NETWORK+, CHECKPOINT FIREWALL certifications.

I DEFINATELY know who I would hire......-ginel

by hotshot3000

The role of colleges is to provide a well rounded education. In the area of computer science, another goal is to teach the theory required to DEVELOP the next operating system, computer chip, or routing protocol, among other things.

The role ofmost community/technical colleges is usually to provide job-related training of a more applied or practical nature. This is where to go to learn how to program a router, set up a network, replace a hard drive, or install software.

Your problem is that you are looking for the wrong thing in the wrong place. And from most of the job descriptions I've seen, employers want the CCNA, A+, MCSE, etc. (with experience, I might add), but ALSO that BS in Computer Science or a related field.

I'm sorry your relative feels those courses are unnecessary, but a lot of people in the industry evidently think they teach a student something. Maybe patience (also known as paying your dues)?

by ken

Take all of that certification and in 4 or 5 years time most of it will be woefully out of date. An engineer takes those "other" courses and becomes a well rounded professional who has proven that he KNOWS HOW TO LEARN. There is nothing wrong withcertification, don't get me wrong, but in the long run, professional designation will get you further!

by ghstinshll

You really didn't defend anything there...

The Schools are missing their marks as well because they're not teaching a complete IS degree. especially if they call it an MIS degree, as "Managing" including infrastructure planning in all aspects, which requires more than colleges are currently offering.

Supposedly Drake University is offering a MBA with an emphasis in Operations, IT, or Management, which sounds enticing... This is the most enticing one I've seen recently.

by ghstinshll

You really didn't defend anything there...

The Schools are missing their marks as well because they're not teaching a complete IS degree. especially if they call it an MIS degree, as "Managing" including infrastructure planning in all aspects, which requires more than colleges are currently offering.

Supposedly Drake University is offering a MBA with an emphasis in Operations, IT, or Management, which sounds enticing... This is the most enticing one I've seen recently.

by haagr

The problem is that colleges tend to look down on IT as a "blue collar" area. Most of the classes are done from a research/theory point of view, not a realistic one.

I go to the University of Michigan, and most of my Electrical Engineering classes focus on programming theory, hardware theory, etc., instead of how to make Microsoft products actually work.

by public

And why not show you how those NOS (network operating systems) work?!??! (not only Micro$oft!!!, how about unix, linux, novell etc). How about teaching those kids how to cable a HUGE cabling project? How about learning how to bring up a web serverusing a variety of routers, switches, NOS's, etc? How about learning how to troubleshoot those networks with advanced networking tools? How about learning how to setup and manage a PBX? How about learning how to setup a VPN for a 5000+ corporation? How about learning how to make a ROCK SOLID firewall using a variety of different products?

Hell, thats the kind of student i need in my office! I dont care if you know theory!! Dont waste my time. My WAN connection to Chicago just went down! Go troubleshoot it!

-Ginel

by ghstinshll

Let's all pool together and open our own university. The NCAC seems to accredit so many less-worthy insttutions....

by cactus pete

The first step to being good at something is learning how it got to be the way it is. Theory classes are just that. I certainly would prefer that someone who works for me has a thourough and complete understanding of what they're working with. Add to that the ability to troubleshoot previously undocumented issues.

Anyone should be able to read the manual and press the appropriate key. That's not what colleges are for. Well, they encompass that, too, but they take you further.

Doing well at a 4 year college and THEN getting certs will create a better employee [or boss].

by nettek

I equate your logic with saying that if you want to major in mechanical engineering and work for General Motors, then colleges should teach how to design internal combustion engines and transmissions. Law school graduates will tell you that their schooling didn't really prepare them for becoming a trial lawyer, it only taught them legal concepts, preparing briefs, contract law, etc.

I, like yourself, am Microsoft certified, and know NT inside and out, but I could not tell you how to design an operating system.

I also know plenty about how to set up switched Ethernet, Token-ring, install NICs, and configure switches, but I could not design the hardware that these systems utilize.

I can rattle off all kinds of information about the OSI model that came out of a textbook, and I understand basically what is occuring, but I don't really know what is happening at the packet or bit level from an engineering standpoint.

Computer science or computer engineering degrees are meant to give you foundations in concepts like mathematics, engineering, and electronics as they apply to computers. They'll teach you general knowledge about algorithms, GUI's, programming languages, optics, signal processing, power systems, circuitry, etc. I don't think colleges were meant to teach people how to become experts at intalling Windows 2000 server, programming Cisco routers, install NIC drivers, or creating Oracle databases.

by public

Oh for sure colleges should be teaching that!! And not only Micro$oft! How about all the other great NOS's out there? A student that comes out of college with only theory under his belt will NOT work for me.

But then again, I have to remind people about the article I wrote. My cousin is interested in the PC/Network aspect of IT. He doesn't care about learning how to build a CPU or what happens on the molecular level. Hell, when you go to driving school, they dont teach you how to change the oil. What I'm trying to say is this:

When it comes down to teaching PRACTICAL IT knowledge to our students, our traditional institutions are LACKING. And that is a damned shame.

That last statement covers a whole lot.

-PC Design, Analysis, Repair, Assembly
-Network Design, Analysis, Repair, Troubleshooting
-Intense programming in languages that are used very often. Not just 2 or 3 classes on Java and C++. No, make it very intense. Let the student come out of there ready to be a crackerjack programmer.
-Intense Database programming. Let the student come out of college able to program databases in SEVERAL languages.
-And a lot of other stuff i cant think of right now.

-watta ya think?
-Ginel

by jellimonsta

I am originally from the UK and graduated a 2 yr tech school 10 yrs ago. I now live in the US and have been working in IT for 2 1/2 yrs. I have my MCSE and am looking at my CCNA. I thought about going for my BA in CIS or something but I hate school!.... I am not sure where I would eventually like to end up in IT but probably somewhere in management at least. The only problem being my certification in IT from the UK is I am sure, not transferable to any kind of credit in the US and I do not wantto go back to school for 4 yrs to learn c$#p!.... what would people recommend for someone in my situation? I am already gaining valuable experience as a Net Admin in a 14 server, 200+ user environment but what should I do about the 'next step' when school really does not look too appealing to me?

by the chad

My knowledge does not go out of date. The people that you hire that know something specific about a specific OS/net topo/whatever only know things by rote.

The difference between them and me is that I know how to reason out any new technology that comes down the pipe. DOS, Win 3.x, Win 9x, W2k, WXP, *nux, VMS, VB, C++, Java, etc., blah, blah - I know it all because I have the ability to adapt and learn.

College didn't teach me all these things (some of them didn't exist when I was in school), but it was an environment in which the OPPORTUNITY to learn HOW to learn existed. My degree itself is worthless because I will never directly apply it to my work. The paper itself is worthless because it doesn't represent who I am as a whole and what I bring to the table. My experiences in college provide a rich background that I can draw upon to solve unique problems.

...and that is the real power of college.

When you want someone to redefine your business processes (including ITprocesses) to do more with less and do it better, faster, and cheaper than you are now, you hire someone like me. If you want to do something you never thought possible in your wildest dreams, then you hire someone like me. If you want a monkey (apologies to all simians) to put a CD in the drive and double-click SETUP.EXE, then go get you an A+ "certified" person.

by nettek

Tech schools are to train people how to install, program, and configure the very equipment or software that was designed and developed by those who graduated from college with computer science or engineering degrees.

I think what you really desire is a tech school education, but you want the piece of paper that says, "degree" that comes from a college.

by javafox

Do you really think many come out of school as crackerjack anythings? Hardly the case. That is the exception rather than the rule. As proof of this, experienced people in the fields doing the hiring so often require experience. They do not do this out of stupidity.

Personally, I went to a two year technical college for programming. It has served me well in my profession since... 19 years now. I therefore cannot speak to the issue of colleges teaching what they should be teaching these days.I can speak to the issue of expeience and your crackerjack comment. Good luck finding such people, they exist but are rare indeed.

by tomsal

First off reading the thread here I just gotta say...I admire the orignal author's passion. ;)

However for the extremely comprehensive training she/he would like colleges to offer it would :

A - take 7 years to complete the training (they callthem Doctors)...the plain truth is in some of the threads the level of training you wish students to learn takes VERY long and I won't even explain how I think much of what you suggest simply CAN NOT BE TAUGHT! You have to learn it yourself through experience!
B - you think colleges are expensive now? ;)
C - the training would have to void out "non-IT related" courses....so then you'd pretty much not have a university anymore but you'd be back to a technical/trade school.

Secondly, this thing about theory not carrying any value -- well I know you're not a "nitty gritty" hardware tech that's for sure!

by cactus pete

But you're missing your own point, I think.

Colleges are not technical training institutions. However, you should look at the colleges' other programs, like internships with local companies and the like. Perhaps you should see if your and/or your cousin could audit a few classes. And not just computer related classes.

To further a career, one should be capable of articulating well enough to impress management. I'm sure your cousin will have to write reports in real life, and draft proposals and be able to support them... It would be a shame to have an otherwise intelligent person become a grunt and be stuck there forever. The rest of the world would suffer for the unrealized potential.

by dbgirl

Colleges are there to teach you how to think for yourself. You learn theory, and how it applies to current situations. You learn how to take general knowledge and apply it to specific situations.

If all you want to know is what is spelled out for you, go for the certs and forget the college degree. If you want to be able to figure things out for yourself, then got to college.

Colleges are not failing, they are working exactly as they are supposed to. It is up to the student to apply what they learn in school to everyday life and work. Education is a tool. As such, there are several types of education. College, community college, technical school, certifications, and the list goes on. Decide what you want, then pick the appropriate tool. Don't assume the tool is broken if it doesn't do what you want... Check to see if the tool is the right one.

by ghstinshll

getting into the hard core lfe events is what's more important, so go ahead and teach threory, but don't waste it by haveit be the degree! Have it be the foundation for being truly over-qualified instead of being told that because you have no real experience!

by ghstinshll

...including project experience Sr. Year...

What this comes down to is a theory i've had all along in my career. I got my start by being a self-taught "crackerjack" like many, and then used that to get into the enterprise support arena, absorb asmuch as possible, experience it, then pass it... i've been doing this for years. When my friends came to be after college for degrees, they had to start on the same help desk I had moved up and away from. I helped them through and on, but me belief has always been this.

Colleges need to restructure so that the student gets the full education and training, including experience... I have always advised people to go to school for a 4 Year CS degree, and pass as many certification tests as they can in-between parties, because they're what's really going to get them the job when they come out, and it'll give them an edge over other applicants. This way they are guaranteed success, and possibly a management position later in their career because they have the degree. And if you get a master's in the same arena, all it does is boast theories, not a masterful career in technology.

Believe me, we're all righ here... But it's up to the student to make sure he gets the most out of his education (not being PC, but grammarically correct instead) by gaining certifications as well. This is his responsibility, not the school's. This is the new standard for success in life if you plan on working in IT for your career.

J

by zeraf

Thats what they should be doing. I recently had an offer to pay for an Degree I wanted to achieve. And as my specialty is IT I though about expanding my degree's/certification in this arena. ONly one of all the Universities in Texas offers any of the MCSE or Cisco classes in any way shape or form. the basic core "Computer Science" program best as I can decern from the classes is designed around microprocessor design. Not one class on network protocol programing or anything to do with putting power to a computer system. While this is a field some are interested it is the ONLY "computer science" track they offer. I'm sorry though for what I plan on doing does not require 4 classes of physics and math beyond what I already have. What I think has happened Universites have taken the opinion if people want to learn/earn MCSE/CNAA certifications they will go to these 11 mo courses. If they want a "DEGREE" which alot of emplyers are requiring lately thanks to the undereducated wannabe's comming out of these crash course schools. Problem is employers never did the homework to understand Universities have given up on trainig people for the high tech world. As IT for training or buisness has and will always be a cost center. They want to make a profit so they have to toss technology training to the side to make a profit. What I think we will see in the not to distance future is a Microsoft university, not only get yer Microsoft certs but a degree to boot. as mush as I hater to support Microsoft or Cisco at this point if they had a school of that sort I prolly would attend as our state institutions have failed us.

Granted not all startes may have, but Texas definately has. And more are sure to follow.
Also I do acknoledge alot of this problem could be controlled by the various states regulation to teach in those states.

by pauleugene

You seem to be getting confused with the difference between education and training. Universities are academic institutions. They should teach the basic theories needed to understand computer systems. They are not training centres on how to apply thelatest vendor specific technology.

What is needed is more funding into technical colleges that can provide training in the areas you mention. Plus a cultural shift in the attitude of society that traditionally views an academic qualification overa vocational one.

Thumbs up to you as you already seem to have made this shift.

by public

Yes, theory is important but..... How will that help my cousin come out of college and get a job in the IT field. Like it or not, he will not have the skills an IT professional needs desperately. Pretty much what I have been told is that he has towork his way through 4 years and THEN he can start learning what he needs to learn. I find that unacceptable.

To tell you the truth, I was kind of hoping I could go to a few of his classes with him so even I can get some more training. But when I saw the kinds of classes and the description of the classes, I wouldn't even waste my time with them.

I'm still dissapointed in the state of affairs these days when it comes to our colleges teaching our future IT pros the skills they need.thanks for you comments.

-Ginel Lipan

by oehls

I FIND THAT THE 4 YEAR COLLEGES ARE WAY BEHIND IN IMPLEMENTING IT STUDIES. TECH SCHOOL CAN BE A GREAT ADVANTAGE. EXPENSIVE, YES. THE PROBLEM WITH FINANCE OR TUTION REIMBERSMENT IS THAT THERE ARE FEW GRANTS THAT APPLY TO TECH SCHOOLS.
I HAVE NOT FOUND ANY COST OF LIVING GRANTS FOR SOMEONE GOING TO TECH SCHOOL. IT'S CRAZY BECAUSE WITH THE AMOUNT OF STUDY TIME REQUIRED FOR IT MUCH MORE THAN REGULAR COLLEGE STUDY. IT STUDENTS NEED MORE SUPPORT THAN OUR SYSTEM ALLOWS. CRAZY AGAIN BECAUSE WE ARE THE PEOPLE THAT ALLOWS FOR IT TO SUPPORT ALL THE MANY NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITY. I WISH I HAD 2 CENTS TO GIVE.

by road-dog

Global Knowledge and other technical training firms have a hard enough time keeping up with the "code ver.12.0.TuesdayPM" world that exists today.

Colleges don't stand a chance at staying current. If a curriculum is created using the "latest andgreatest" and a class attends an entire term, the material is obsolescent by finals.

College is to teach fundamentals and theory. It is up to the graduate to pick up current skills on the way or immediately after graduation.

Every six months, Everybody goes to Interop to see the newly rolled out technologies. It's hard enough creating courseware for a 40 hour class. Keeping it relevant is a nightmare.

There is no single solution. Have your nephew suck it up, learn the fundamentals, andget into the field and try to keep up.

Learn the difference between single mode and multimode fiber in college, then crack a Cisco book to find out how far a GBIC will drive on it.

by public

Its going to be difficult to tell my cousin, "Hey, suck it up, go to college for 4 years out of your life, (even though you KNOW its almost worthless), spend thousands of dollars doing it, spend thousands of hours beating your head against the wall learning what you mostly don't need, and THEN get out in the world and LEARN what you really need to know.

How do you expect me to look the kid in the eye and spout that? Hell, I can't even look in the mirror and tell that to myself, much less tomy cousin (who has a place in my heart with this problem).

Now I am most certainly NOT going to just throw theory and fundamentals out the window. But to force that sort of thing on to my cousin for almost 4 years of his life? Don't get me wrong, there is definately a place for theory and fundamentals, but theory and fundamentals should not rule the cirriculum.

I still feel colleges, as institutions, have failed this "part" of the future IT professionals.

And one more thing that has been brought up in this discussion, obviously vendors, OSes, programming languages change very fast these days. But the truth in the matter is, once you got one down solidly, it's SO much easier to pick another one up. Like it or not once you get to really understand C++ or Java, C Sharp is going to be HUGELY easier to pick up. Once you get to understand windows 95, windows XP is HUGELY easier to pick up. Know Unix? Then linux is going to be a cinch. So if you do teach the latest and the greatest, of course it will be obsolete in 4 to 5 years, but guess what? The next generation of software/hardware is going to be BASED on the previous generation. Hey, do you know IP? then IPv6 should be easier to understand and implement!!!

Nope. Sorry. I'm not going to tell my cousin to suck it up.

Thank you for your comments.

-Ginel Lipan

by hotshot3000

If you think a Comp Science or Engineering degree is a waste, then tell your cousin to get a management or business degree, and follow that up with the technical training you value more. He will always be able to use those skills. Very few colleges teach anything about managing employees either, but with the better paying jobs, you can count on having to manage people.

by timwalsh

Ask him where he sees himself in 10 or 15 years. If he sees himself doing ANYTHING more than installing and configuring software or installing network cards or running network cable or writing code, then both of you need to do a reality check.

By your definition, every bit of education he has gone through for the past 12 years was WORTHLESS, because it didn't teach one hard skill. Is this the point you are trying to make?!

It's all about paying dues. The purpose of a college education is to give you general body of knowledge to succeed in life (and in business) in a general area. That is why there are law degrees, but not degrees in divorce law, realestate law, business law, etc. Likewise, intthe Technology arena, you find degress such as Computer science, but not degrees in C++ or COBOL. You find degrees in Computer Engineering, but not degrees in CISCO or Intel.

Why/how are you forcing anything on your cousin? He is presumably a grown-up and can make decisions on hisown. If he doesn't want to "waste" four years of his life learning all that "general stuff and theory", maybe he'll be happy being a low-paid technician for the rest of his life. He won't EVER make the big bucks without a college education and a degree. Don't blame it on the colleges. Blame on your cousin's (and maybe your) lack of ambition and lack of a realistic view of how the REAL world works.

Cheers.

by public

Well for one thing, you're right. Things become obsolete. But guess what? (copied from another one of my replies).

"But the truth in the matter is, once you got one down solidly, it's SO much easier to pick another one up. Like it or not onceyou get to really understand C++ or Java, C Sharp is going to be HUGELY easier to pick up. Once you get to understand windows 95, windows XP is HUGELY easier to pick up. Know Unix? Then linux is going to be a cinch. So if you do teach the latestand the greatest, of course it will be obsolete in 4 to 5 years, but guess what? The next generation of software/hardware is going to be BASED on the previous generation. Hey, do you know IP? then IPv6 should be easier to understand and implement!!!"

See my point? Even though you may be familiar with an obsolete language, the learning curve to learn another one is MUCH MUCH less steep.

Your quote "When you want someone to redefine your business processes". If I wanted to someone to redefine my business processes, I would NOT be hiring someone who is good at networking, server maintenance, etc. Of course the network admins would be PART of the process, but I would not hire them to redefine business processes. I would hire a professional systems integrator. Thats practically another career path than the one my cousin wants to get into.

Your quote "If you want a monkey (apologies to all simians) to put a CD in the drive and double-click SETUP.EXE, then go get you an A+ "certified" person."

I am NOT looking for a monkey. I am looking for a highly TRAINED network/PC administrator that has a WIDE range of training. Colleges have not been putting out these types of professionals. Thats my complaint.

-Thanks for your comments
-Ginel Lipan

by public

EXACLTY. What I want to send my cousin to is a college that can give him a tech school education, but with an accredited college degree.

Guess what. They don't exist. And that is the frustration my cousin and I are facing right now. I'm we'renot the only ones who feel this way.

thanks for you comments
-ginel lipan

by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/

A good part of most college degrees today is remedial work (for degree credit) on what the high schools failed to teach.

If we had quality elementary and secondary education, the colleges could be more focused on training people in paying skills and for the work place.

by ahunter6

it's pretty damned offensive to be lumped in with "monkeys" because you don't have a sheepskin on the wall. forget microsofty. where do i learn cisco? I've read a good portion of the course selections and it's all programming in some schools. some people love college a little too much. are you really telling me you don't trust somebody because they went for certs that (when tested properly) actually show demonstrated SKILL? I've never believed that colleges OR tech schools should have courses for certs before real world experience. there's alot of paper (fill in your favorite acronym here) that can't do what us "monkeys" do, installing and configuring things. i don't know what school you went to, but they forgot to instill in you a respect for other's experiences and skills. there are no less than 5 people on my helpdesk that have MIS/CS degrees and came straight here so they could actually understand what enterprise level IT was all about. how come they are not making 60k+ in some high level job? because college didn't get them anywhere. half of them didn't know what the hell DNS was before they got here. stick that in your frat pipe and smoke it

by nettek

You let your emotions get the best of you, and missed my point. I thought techs were logical.

Yes, I have a bachelors degree, and it is not in any IT related field. However, I also went to a technical school some years after college and receiveda degree in Network Engineering and Data Communications. I am also Microsoft certified. I am now one of the "monkeys" you speak of (although I also manage other "monkeys").

All I am saying is that I don't think colleges were meant to be technicalschools.

by ahunter6

i hit the wrong post. it was the chad that said people with A+ were monkeys. no, of course colleges weren't MEANT to be technical, but my point is that when you label something as broad as "Computer Science" and you're learning it four years, you should know more that how to make memory arrays and C+ when you leave. as I said, I looked at the course descriptions for just about all the affordable colleges in the state, and believe me there are a lot of colleges in CT, and none of them have any semblance of usability to anyone but a future programmer. And if college isn't about gaining knowledge to go to work with, what ARE they for? What I've noticed is that college prepares nearly everyone else to work, and expects US, professionals like anybody else, to go to entirely seperate schools! Lawyers get to have a degree that they can work with right off. Doctors do, Business majors do, marine biologists do, aerospace engineers do, hell, even SOCIAL WORKERS do, but we're expected to get along with a few certificates that MAY be translatable to college credits, and go to how many different schools to find all we need? Why are WE in such a unique position? Are we not professionals? Don't we RATE on that scale yet? I want a degree but if I go back and blow my time on those touchy feely fuzzy courses it'll take a decade. Sure, younger people need to be exposed to alot of stuff, alot of different experiences-but why can't I have a bachelors I can use?

by ghstinshll

Assuming he's a real "crackerjack" like you say:

Summer before College - A+

Fall semester - Network+
Spring Sem - Win2k PRo
Summer break - Server +

Fall semester - Win2k Server & AD
Spring semester - Win2k Networking
Summer Break - INet+

Fall Semester - Cisco CCNA
Spring Semester - MS 70-218 Managing 2kNet
Summer Break - IT Project +

Fall Semester - MS 70-220 W2k Security
Spring Semester - MS 70-223 Clustering

This will give him an MCSA, MCSE, Proj+, A+, Net+, INet+, and Server+. Oh, and make it so he really becomes a manager some day too.

This will all guarantee him success, and no time for drinking and exercising, so then he won't get hired because he's an insurance risk.... (-:[

Either way, any student can pass a college course, but it takes a die-hard to get a 3.75. Thus, any hard-working student can find time to pass his classes and complete some remnants ofthis outline... At least the basic +'s and MCSA... there's experience and a degree for you...

by road-dog

continuously in these discussions is a career long experiential growth. Documented training and certification are great; particularly if there is a large amount of it, indicating a substantial investiture by employers.

When my company expands,I'm looking to hire IT persons who have "been there, done that". An MCSE or BS/IT is useless if the employee does not have solid troubleshooting skills and an adaptive attitude that will ensure success in a challenging environment. More importantly, with the IT market the way it is, soft skills are ever more important. Companies don't need to coddle employees with "birth control personalities" and prima donnas. Suffice it to say, I can train up weak areas in an employee's skillset, but I can not and will not finish raising someone else's kid.

These "tastes great, less filling" degree vs training discussions really ignore the primary qualities posessed by a great employee. They are a drive to succeed coupled with work ethic to learn what is needed to get the job done.

by ghstinshll

Road Dog, I agree with you totally! I guess that was a slight oversight on my part, being that all this is a given in my skills and abilities... (-:{

by tphillips

I believe that incorporating theory with specific IT Professional training is the way to go. I agree with the fact that technical colleges even some community colleges provide a better overall training for the IT Professionals and obvious decrease in coast. I am attending a two-year technical college and maintaining an internship where I am gaining ?hands on? experience when it comes to network administration and IT. Would you hire me? :)

by maxwell edison

I would advise you not to give any advice to your cousin, or anyone else for that matter. Advice from a cynical person is useless at best, and potentially damaging and misleading at worst.

You think colleges are failing us as indicated by this discussion.

You think that IT schools are failing us as indicated by the following discussion:

"Lies of our IT schools"

https://www.techrepublic.com/forumdiscuss/thread_detail.jhtml?thread_id=32736&src=bc

(REMOVE SPACES from the pasted URLs.)

You gripe, complain, and assume the worst - as indicated by a search of the discussions in which you've participated. In short, you're not a very happy camper - about anything.

You get out of life - and any of life's endeavors - that which you put into it. If you approach life with a negative attitude, you'll get negative results.

The bottom line is this. If you want to work for other people, for other companies, etc. you will be better off with a college degree than you will be without one. You’ll get better positions, you'll make more money, and you'll have more access (to whatever). If a young person has a chance to go to college and passes on that opportunity, he’s a fool.

(If you want to open your own businessand work for yourself, college is much less important. Bill Gates, for example, doesn't have a college degree.)

Regardless, your sour attitude towards a myriad of things should tell you something about your outlook - it's all negative.

Look for the good, and you'll find it. You should change what you're looking for.

Good luck to you and your cousin.

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

I assume he is young, 18 to 22 range, he has no family to support, and he is basically starting out in life.

Go to college. Get a degree in whatever interests you - computer engineering, business, whatever. (I'd go for an MBA if I could do it over again.)

During the summer and over spring and winter breaks, work for a company doing those IT things you mentioned. In addition, build your own computers and computer network at home and study for the certifications.

In 4-5 years, he'll havethe best of both worlds, he'll have more options available to him, and he'll make a heck of a lot more money as well.

That's what I'd advise, for whatever it's worth.

Maxwell

by alpha geek

I think your stamement sums it up pretty well.
If he wants the best advice for his cousin, he should have his cousin consult a professional counselor. His attitude toward training/education would not server him or his cousin well.

by ahunter6

this amazing reverence for colleges HAS to go. Not ONE of the people I know, barring the lawyer, actually works in their degree, and I make more money than any of them, again, barring the lawyer. And I'm only a helpdesk analyst! College gets you precisely DOOKIE unless you wanna be management. And don't hand me that "larger world view" crap. A couple years in the army gets you that, and THEY pay YOU. College is an excuse, nothing more, to let youngsters be irresponsible. And another thing-why in christs name does it have to be so expensive!

by kajer

I went to college, learned my trade (yes, I did learn how to work on systems and program) and now I'm working in the computer field. If I hadn't gone to school, I never would have gotten my job. College is not an "excuse to let youngsters be irresponsible." Hard to be irresponsible when you are taking a 22 hour course load plus working full time.

I will be the first to admit that college is not for everyone, some people just don't have the inclination, there is nothing wrong with that, and there's no iron-clad rule that says if you don't go to college then you will be a failure.

However, those who say that no one should go to college, are just as bad as those who harp that everyone should.

by jon chappell

Come on. College can indeed be a waste of time, but that is up to YOU.

Some words to say to yourself:

"I am responsible for my own future"
"I am responsible for my own learning"

etc.

College, tech schools, certification courses and
self-study all have one thing in common: Each is an OPPORTUNITY for learning. Of course there are people who get degrees who don't seem to have the skills required to do a specific task. It happens.
So what?

It's all about what you take away fromit. Many things you learn today will be useless to you within a year, and many things you learn today that you think are not important right now will prove to be invaluable to you years from now.

If you are going to be successful in IT for yearsto come, you are going to need to think broadly.
Fill your head w/ as much technical AND non-technical knowledge as you can get your hands on, because you can use it in the future when you encounter new situations.

Keep digging.

by thechas

The problem with most 4 year institutuins, and the community colleges that fead them, is that they are run by Liberal Arts majors that see education as a means onto itself.

If you look over any 4 year engineering or technical curiculum, you will find the first 2 years full of courses that are not related to the core disipline.

While some of these courses are important, I believe that the primary purpose of these cources is to provide employment for Liberal Art graduates.

The facet of the education system that realy upsets me is that students persuing non-technical degrees can take lower level math and science courses. Many of these courses are easier than what most technical students take in high school.
Yet, there is no lower level humanities courses to allow the technical major to concentrate more of their efforts on their core courses.

Let us not take into account that the American people are in an ever growing need of technical knowledge to function in modern society.

The only advantage of the 4 year degree is that you prove that you know how to learn. And, many companies require that degree to hire you for a technical position.

Chas

by admin

I majored in Philosophy and Literature at a private Liberal Arts School where I got to learn things like logic, ethics (including tech ethics) and AI. All the time I was developing my computer skills in the labs and in our dorm rooms. Did I work in the computer industry first? No. But after a short stint in production (Where I got both management experience quickly and got to help develop prototype electronic controls for hydraulic systems..)I developed a career path in management and electronic systems. What would have I learned in a tech school? Specific hands on ways to do things needed at that time in the industry. Of course, I then may be outdated already upon graduation, or not even have the ability to learn extremely quickly, which is the real skill needed by tech employers.

All of the friends I graduated with now hold well paid good positions, none of them currently in the exact discipline they trained for. What's the secret? Liberal Arts teach you to learn. As you said: "The only advantage of the 4 year degree is that you prove that you know how to learn" It's not the only way to prove you can learn, and a lot of tech program folk are devouring as much as they can in and out of class, but it's not the specific skill that will keep them employed over the next 40-50 years... it's their ability to learn as they go that will. Wherever you get it, get the mindset that you will NEVER arrive at the pinnacle where you will be well paid and taken care of for your currentknowledge the rest of your life and instead that learning is a fun, continuous adventure.

American people are in an ever growing need of technical advancement IMO

by thechas

Congradulations. Based on my experiance, you are among the rare Liberal Arts majors who are making a positive contribution to society.

I admit, that my opinion of Liberal Arts Majors may be tainted.

I work in aerospace electronics. My exposure to Liberal Arts Majors is mainly supervisors and middle managers. For the most part, I wonder how most of these individuals made it through high school, let alone college.

These "managers" by and large show no capability to learn and adjust totheir situation. If problems don't respond to the standard solutions that worked in another industry, it is the fault of the technical staff for not implementing their ideas correctly. Never mind, that there are a lot of specifics to electronics design and assembly that just cannot follow the same techniques used for furniture or stamped metal parts.

Best wishes to you, and I hope to meet some Liberal Arts Majors that have your insight and skills.

Chas

by maxwell edison

Unless a person wants to wallow in the trenches, attending to all the tedious day in and day out “hands-on” tasks for his or her entire career, then a college degree is a must.

It’s commonly thought that the pinnacle of our profession is a position as CIO. Without a college degree – preferably, in my opinion, an MBA degree – the position of CIO will never become within a person’s reach. Nor will any upper level management position.

There’s more to“IT” than running CAT5 cable, loading software, and building computer infrastructures. Having the vision, the wisdom, and the wherewithal to apply technology to a business model is the ultimate challenge. After all, without a “purpose” all the technology and computer equipment in the world is useless.

A college degree isn’t intended to simply teach skills. It’s intended to prepare a person for all facets of life – problem solving skills, communication skills (both the written and spoken word), and critical and creative thinking, not to mention the enormous personal growth opportunities.

Financially speaking, the benefits of a college degree are substantial. A recent study published in USA Today indicated that a person with a degree will make anywhere from $600,000 to $1,000,000 more over his or her career. It was also noted that a person with a professional degree (PhD, MBA, etc.) would earn 4-5 times the monthly salary of the person without a degree.

Also, consider this: I can honestly say that I’ve never met a person who regretted getting a college degree. But I have met scores of people who have regretted not getting one.

Maxwell

by max98037

I am tech training right now. My school has a great program, its a community college that specializes in tech training. 109 credits long + 1 year of required interning. 90% of my program is technology related. I will graduate with an Associates in Networking, an MCSE, CCNA, and A+ cert. I'll have linux/unix, network security, and web design knowledge.
And later on I can transfer all of it to a 4-year school, learn for 2 more years and tack on a Bachelors too.
And best of all, it's affordable and there is financial aid available.
Those little tech schools (BCTI, ITT tech, etc) are bulls@#$. They usually wanted around $10,000 and give you NOTHING. No accredited degree, no experience. Only preparation for certs. Should be fraud.

by pauleugene

As you point out, the top level management positions will almost always be taken by someone who has a degree.

But not everyone can reach that level. For many people getting a degree is not always the best option. They often come out with questionable qualifications and no practical skills.

Vocational options are not given the funding and importance they should. Maybe this guys cousin is someone who would benefit more from more vocational as opposed to academic education. Unfortunately he is having trouble finding places to fulfil that need.

This is wrong. More money should be invested in technical colleges. Even if this is at the expense of universities.

by guruofdos

Where you say 'our' colleges.... I assume you are in the USA. It is a well known fact in the rest of the world that education standards in the USA are much more lax and out of date than the rest of the world. In fact, you can 'graduate' from collegein the USA just by attending or being good at sports!! If you want a 'real' technical education, I suggest you look overseas. Germany have probably the best technical colleges, with British Universities way ahead at the cutting edge of innovation and R&D. What lets us Brits down, is that we have all the ideas and invent all the technology (CD-ROM springs to mind - made a commercial reality by Philips in Holland although it was first invented and prototyped in the UK), and then no-one has the balls to turn the ideas into commercial propositions. That gets left to the rest of the world, especially the Asians, who can't innovate for toffee, but know a good money-spinning idea when they see one.

There is also the misplaced notion that Microsoft Certifications actually mean anything! I'd employ a graduate with a degree (a European 'real' one, obviously...we don't 'sell' ours on the internet!) who has been taught to think for themselves, over anybody who had only studied Microsoft material and managed to regurgitate it parrot-fashion for an exam.

The world does NOT revolve around Bill Gates, and neither should technical education curriculae.

by ghstinshll

I'd like to see the curriculum in an institution you're speaking of, it sounds great! Maybe would even give me a chance to use the 4 years I spent in high school speaking German! (-:{

You are wrong on the MS certifications, I have over 4 years exeprience, and plenty of MS certs to boot, and that is what has given me the open doors to my current career status. Starting in the industry at 25k, and increasing that by nearly 90%, I'd say it has done well for me, but I ahve done well for myself. I currently run a Novell environment based on my experience in the industry, not just on my MS certs.

Certification's aren't all there is, you have to establish yourself and build a career on the foundation you create. That's how you build a career with a degree or certifications. Being a respected expert in your area is what earns you the right to move up and on. You need a degree to be where you think you should by the time you're 50 though...

As for the Brits inventing everything, don't steal too much credit, everyone does that. Just internally at Xerox... The mouse, the GUI, network, the icon... all unprotected internal innovation that they never utilized for profit, and then Mr. Jobs and Mr. Gates took it off for a killing. It's funny how that works out. Great point though.

by isadmin

The British do invent most things but either don't have the money to take it forward or didn't invent for profit in the first place. Here's an example of each. Charles Babbage and Ada Lovelace invented the computer, as I'm sure you're all aware, butthe British government wouldn't fund the research - the Americans took it forward.
Second, the internet was invented by Britsh intelligence ( MI5, GCHQ )and they couldn't profit from it because they didn't want anyone else to have the technology.

by guruofdos

Some things we didn't invent. Some things we invented, but were comercially developed by others. One or two things, we simply improved on!!

The original 'floppy' disk was created at Reading University back in the 1950's. It started off as strips of 1/4 inch mag tape (from a reel to reel tape machine....remember them!!) stuck to a plastic backing and read using a magnetic tape head scanned up and down and side to side on a converted X-Y plotter!! It was 3M who then made the magnetic media circular and spun it to remove the delays in tracking from one strip to the next. The prototype which is still operational holds something of the order of 2Kb of data...

I personally had a hand in some early development of LCD projection technology and spent many lab hours modifying small LCD displays to work in a
Kodak Ektapro slide projector...Sanyo and Epson made it a commercial proposition after British venture capitalists, banks and industry 'missed the boat'. How many people use LCD projectors today?!!! Oh, for my share of the royalties!!!

by rashidah

unfortunately,I have to agree. I graduated from new Jersey Institute of Technology in Computer & Information Technology. Subsequently, I had to pay $11,000 to attend PC Age a technical school and now CCNA/CCDA to get a solid foot with reasonable compensation in the private sector. The only courses that is somewhat related is the C++ programming (converting binary to decimal and
hex to decimal and the reverse - smile)

I am happy to see that someone has the heart to state the truth about our institutions of higher education..Kudos to you

by javafox

Ah, politically correct liberalism and it's many forms of social engineering at work in the good ol US of A! It has been said that you reap what you sew. Apparently the yoga, the newage and many other such courses being taught in our institutions ofhigher learning are not exactly what the market place desires afterall.

by esanchez

I totally agree with you. A lot of curriculums out there do not keep up with today's technology. However, I will not discouraged at all your cousing to go to school and pursue a degree. Companies they always look for a degree when it comes to salaries and packages even though you might have all the certifications of the world. I have two collegues of mine who did not get the promotions they wanted because they didn't have a college degree!! They were told also by HR that they couldn't get the salaries they wanted because they didn't have a college degree! So, in the long run it pays to have a formal education even though it might be worthless in someone's eyes. Companies see IT training as such, just training not as a formal education. In the long run having a college degree pays off. Besides, the formal education process is something that will benefit beyond just the technical aspect. You need a well grounded knowleged in business, management, accounting, finanace, etc... that can prove valuable as you mature in your profession and move up the ladder. I am in the IT field and I am grateful I went to school!! It has paid off for me. Now I have several IT certifications and that has put me in a very, very competitive advantage that I don't think I could have without a formal education. Currently, I'm pursing a masters degree in Computers and Informations Systems. Besides, the job market for IT has changed dramatically after the collapse of the boom of the 90s. We are in a different reality now.

My two cents...

by ghstinshll

One word describes the bureaucracy that surrounds colleges... They create an environment that is surrounded by study, for the sake of study, and for the pursuit of study--thus the creation of "lifetims students" in universities. A few years ago, I spent about an hour on the phone with a doctor from the U of Iowa about how degrees related to Information Technology All I could gather from the conversation was that this guy was so full of himself and his department that I was not going to go to UIfor an IT-related degree.

One thing I can say now that a couple of years have passed is:

A degree is necessary if you want to move into upper management. Most likely a BA, MBA, or maybe an IS degree....

Certifications are necessary to prove your worth with a great employer, and to move around within that employer to gain experience.

Those two facts aside, I point back to my previous posting above (degree + certs) that you need both. Someone listed shortly above this posting thatthe accounting, fianance, project management, and other invaluable skills are achieved by going to a university and getting a degree. When you are in technology, you will invariably spend the rest of your career worrying abot budgets, planning projects and implementations, and learning along the way. Those skills are so important if you want to keep moving up in the world, so that you don't get stuck and burned out by the time you're 30. I don't know about a lot of tech workers, bt after a hostof certifications, I will be going back to school to obtain a MBA some time before I reach upper management, so that I can make it to where i want to go some day.

by ghstinshll

As for the quality of education? There was a school in the town I just moved away from that had a respectable training course in Cisco architecture, but it wasn't transferrable towards your degree. Schools are coming around, but just realize that there is so much more out there than just technology.

Don't give up.
Do what's right.
Do what's best in the long term, not now...

by big trent

I worked for company as the assistant Net admin and the company liked to sponsor interns (cheap labor), so I would usually have 2-4 comp. sci. or MSI interns under me, usually in there senior year. You would expect that by now they would know something, they would be really good at explaining the pricibles of coputiing or the history, or even some breaking concepts ie. super computing AI. But, practical info, ie how to turn on the PC, were not even covered. To be good in this field you have to be of an engineering mindset (design and application of knowledge), not a of the scientist mindset (research and under theory), that is why it is called comp. sci. Most the guys and gals that I know in this field have either been doing all there lives, or just started at the bottom, some have gone to tech schools, and those are very helpful too. Those that I know that are say they needed a B.S. said the only use they got out of it was that some company's will not hire or promote w/o a degree, but many will overlook this in lieu of experience.

by tony

I teach college AND own my own consulting/nework business in Silicon Valley. The problem is two fold: Cost of new technology, when to an ignorant administrator, an old IBM PS/2 looks just like a dual Xeon Server is one problem. Staying up to dateis another. I do it, 'cause it makes me money in the field. But too many instructors want to set up a course and bleed it for five years. 'Works great with English Lit, but not technology. GERMANY invests in schools!

by nathanh

Then your plan makes great sense, though I would certainly aim higher if I were a youngster that showed a lot of talent in the IT field. One has to have a well rounded education that you get from college. Are you forgetting communication skills, research, business acumen, team participation, cognitive skills, and most importantly practice and development of one's ability to learn.
I beleive the greatest thing one can get out of college is learning how to learn, which they do not teach at tech schools.

Nathan

by maxwell edison

The Brits “invented” the floppy disk like Al Gore invented the Internet.

Dr. Yoshiro Nakamats invented the floppy disk in 1950. He granted the license to IBM.

Source: http://www.iit.edu/~jfiga/BI/PATENTS/

No. No. No. Yoshiro NakaMats says he invented the floppy disk, a claim disputed by IBM, which says its scientists came up with the technology.

Source:

http://www.wired.com/news/gizmos/0,1452,48237,00.html

No. No. No. The "floppy" was invented by IBM engineers led by Alan Shugart.

Source:

http://inventors.about.com/library/weekly/aa110198.htm

No. No. No. No one person has ever been credited with inventing the floppy disk. It was really a team effort, led by IBM.

Source:

http://www.sciencenet.org.uk/database/Maths/Original/m00022d.html

No. No. No. The claim was that the Brits invented the first magnetic tape – a concept “borrowed” by others.

Ok, who invented the magnetic tape?

Danish inventor and engineer Valdemar Poulsen invented the first magnetic recording device. (In 1898?)

Source: http://www.savemyfiles.com/magtech.htm

No. No. No. Get real. IBM invented magnetic disk storage.

Source:

http://www.cse.ucsc.edu/classes/cmps158/Winter02/ibmssd.html

No. No. No. Here’s the real deal. This technology was first invented in the lost civilization of Atlantas. The Atlanteans had developed a primitive computer science during the latter stages of their civilization. Simple computing machinery is thought to have been built by the priest caste to help them with astronomical calculations but later finding applications in many aspects of Atlantean society. A primitive form of magnetic tape storage was invented during the dying days of the Atlantean civilization.

Source:

http://www.aisb.org.uk/hacker/1979.html

So there you have it. The Atlanteans really invented the floppy disk. Unless, of course, Al Gore take

by al.olson

I've been in the industry for nearly 20 years and every company I've had the opportunity to work for has required a 4 year college degree. Its understandable when you look at the technical analyst position and see what is involved; communication, documentation, office politics, budgetting,interviewing, planning, coding, designing, etc. You need a well rounded education not a specialized one. Programmers don't just program, and managers just don't manage, there's a lot more to the job now days than meets the eye. College prepares you for the unknown.

by isadmin

Forgive me if this has been said but I haven't read all the postings.
I agree with "Colleges are doing the right thing". I went to a top Red Brick university where I gained a degree in Computing Science. I came away with an all-round knowledge. I can explain how a routing table works, Write programs in several languages and several types of language....and i am currently a network administrator, but Higher Education has always existed to prepare us more for life long learning than current issues. They teach us to question and improve on what we know. Somebody fresh out of college/university will have strong will-power, a will to succeed and see projects through to the end. They will be self motivated, a good listener, have excellent communication skills, have repect for the fellow colleageus, have sound time-management skils...the list really is endless. With this foundation, the graduate can get into I.T and gain the vendor qualifications along with experience. "paper MCSEs" are notwanted or required by anyone. What good is an MCSE who can't change a network card?
One last point, without colleges/universites we wouldn't have the technologies we take for granted, like IP. All the major R&D is done at these institutions.

by admin

And also, while I would wholeheartedly agree on the benefits of college with you, I doubt seriously that there would be no IT without it. First and foremost, the military would continue it, and secondly, the hobby etc. community would push it (Linuxetc.) and last, check out how many influential people in IT went to college not in IT, but other fields and still succeeded here.

by etabbott

Phewwww that brings back memories of ten years ago.
I started out in life as an English major - swallowed the crap that college will prepare you for the real world by giving you the ability to know how to learn. I enjoyed myself thinking deep thoughts but employability = zero.

Worked two jobs to just survive my college bills while living in my parents basement. Self Respect was zero. Felt definitely used by higher education. Was glad to know that my 5-10% annual tuition hike did not help myprofessors get better pay but DID provide a new sports training facility for the functioning illiterates.
While working my crap job I reevaluated my position and cynicism about life. Like one of the posts above said life is what you make it. I went back to school - this time for a materials engineering degree(researched this actually and liked the job content) - made it after four years. Felt I had the world by the tail. Had finally done something right. Went to the job market - guess what? Idon't have a PHD and so the firms I was trained to work for had no use for me. I stuck to it and found a job kind of related to my field. Paid 13/hour. Went to night school out of boredom. An engineering job that all it required me to do was calculate percentages. Night school enabled me to get my CCNA. Got a job at a phone center and made 18/hour - took a class on Visual Basic and doubled my income. Now I am trying to start my own business.

the real lesson to learn from school is that other people are impressed by it. It costs you a hell of a lot but the long run income makes up for it. Schools are just like the Wizard of OZ - you can cry their fakes (and they are) but they still run the Emerald city.

uh ohhh gotta go
the flying monkeys from the university research lab are knocking on my window

by tomsal

I couldn't agree with Edgeben more.

I too can't stand the need to take math, political science, and literary courses on my way to earning a 4 year MIS degree - but you gotta do what you gotta do. I've done the cert thing, I have MCSE cert and I've done all the studying, review and hands on work for my CCNA now I just need to find the time to take the actual test, along with the money for the test fee (long story but stuff came up that doesn't make that too easy to do as it sounds). I've alsoalready went to a community college - earned two AAS degrees from there. Not to mention my many years of on the job experiences....the only reason I point this stuff out is so you hear it from someone who's been there - I know about certs, I know about community colleges, I know about experience....

Certs are not the holy grail you are being putting them up to be.

I sure hope you don't call someone a "network engineer" just because they have a CCNA or CCNP cert. I hope a hardware repair tech in "your book" is only someone who has a piece of paper that says "A+" on it. I'm not an egominded person, nor do I boast of myself - but I've taught supposed "A+" and "CCNP" (mind you CCNPs, not even CCNA's - the lesser cert) a thing or two about hardware and networking in my time.

Certs are tests. They are good for self confidence building, they are good for organizing good mental discipline and exercising study habits. They are BAD for ranking someone's expertise.

Like edgeben hinted to, I don't know where you or you cousin are looking to work but ever employment ad I see for IT jobs REQUIRES two things EXPERIENCE (first and foremost) and a 4 YEAR DEGREE...certs in 80% of all cases are "preferred by not required, optional, etc.".

by admin

Anyone here study Licklider? He was a psychoacoustics person who became facinated with computers and wrote "Man-Computer Symbiosis". The rest, shall we say, is history?

Speaking of IT programs (maybe we all should study psychoacoustics?) how about Bob Taylor who majored in psychology, with minors in mathematics, english, philosophy, and religion and then went on to work in psychoacoustics and of course had his hand in everything from ARPA to Altavista and beyond.

Just some food for thought :)

by cactus pete

Consider going right for a masters degree. A local institution may let you in if you can pass the entry exam. Certainly, they consider experience in the real world when you apply.

The added benefits include only having to take classes which aremore in line with your interests.

by dbgirl

"Lawyers get to have a degree that they can work with right off. Doctors do"

Doctors and lawyers don't get to practice their profession with just a bachelors degree. They have to go to special schools (ever hear of 'law school' or 'medical school'?). Some of the other professionals you listed don't have to go to special schools, but they aren't as highly paid either.

This discussion is closed to new replies.