Discussion Locked

Outsourcing and the presidential election

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A political analyst states the following in a ZDNET article (link: ):
"It's safe to say that almost none of the really important Internet and technology issues will be debated during this campaign...In an attempt to shore up votes and campaign cash for the technology community, all the candidates will probably just play it safe and stick to bland platitudes and generalities about how 'technology is vital to the U.S. economy.' It's just a bunch of hot air."
What's your take?

42 replies

by oz_media

as the new candidates have not spoken publically on Canadian TV (other than little snippets etc.) I will refrain from offering opinion at this time (you're welcome).

One thing that made me chuckle was the suggestion of .xxx or .sex top level domains.

I suggested a .CUM or .SEX domain about seven years ago when discussing Internet porn with some aquaintances. It would be SO easy to rid the net of porn sites, INSTANTLY. If you have a porn site on a .com, .tk or whatever, you're done, end of story, YOU CANNOT HAVE IT THERE. How easy is THAT!? then just turn around and create a filter blocking ALL access to .CUM URL's, now you have stopped CHILDREN being subject to pornography.

I think I shared the idea here when discussing the WHITEHOWSE.COM vs WHITEHOUSE.COM names, one was a porn site, the other presidential (although in the Clinton term they could have been one and the same).

Oh well, I can't run for pres of the USA anyhow so I'll let the guy take the credit and wish him well in his campaign.

Good luck you guys, hope you do better this time around!

by oldefar

The first goal of any politician is to be elected to office, and to take a hard stand on any issue is sure to alienate some portion of the voters. The exception is when the politician believes a particular stand represents a majority view of the voters.

A bigger concern is that issues of outsourcing, privacy, free speech, and government regulation get confused with technology. Technology itself is neutral.

Issues that won't be addressed but should be include the imbalance in compensation. As wages fell for the typical worker, executive pay soared. From 1989 to 2000, the wage of the typical (i.e., median) chief executive officer grew 79.0%, and average compensation grew 342%. In 1965, CEOs made 26 times more than a typical worker; this ratio had risen to 72-to-1 by 1989 and to 310-to-1 by 2000. The richest families continued to pull away from the pack over the decade: the income of the top 1% of taxpayers (including their realized capital gains) grew by 59% from 1995 to 1999 (the most recent available data of this type) while that of the bottom half grew by 9%. It was only in 1998 that the wage level for middle-wage workers (the median hourly wage) jumped above its 1979 level. The median male wage in 2000 was still below its 1979 level, even though productivity was 44.5% higher in 2000 than in 1979. One reason for this divergence is increased corporate profitability, which drove a wedge between productivity and compensation growth.

Coupled with this is the impact of outsourcing as it relates to stock values. The wealthiest 1% of all households control about 38% of national wealth, while the bottom 80% of households hold only 17%. The ownership of stocks is particularly unequal. The top 1% of stock owners hold almost half (47.7%) of all stocks, by value, while the bottom 80% own just 4.1% of total stock holdings.

These issues impact fundamental aspects of the American self-image, and require the type of serious introspection that never comes out in a political campaign.

Other issues include the surrender of personal responsibility to government agencies in the name of national security. While 9/11 was a tragedy, it is worth noting that the terrorists suffered a 25% failure rate, 100% once the threat was understood. With no government assistance, passengers stopped the fourth hijacked plane once they understood that the rules had changed and this was not a hostage type hijacking scenario.

by oldefar

The article can be found at http://tinyurl.com/2j7o4
and the article is called "The State of Working America 2002-03".

Third and fourth paragraphs of my previous post are primarily direct out takes from the article. It is late and I forgot to give credit when I posted.

by hal 9000

Are about the same on this side of the pond. But we have a totally different Political situation here.

Currently we are in the mist of a State Erection whops that should have read Election but who cares anyway. Our current Queenlsand State Premier said the day before yesterday that for him to be like the leader of the Oppisition he would need a Full Labominty which he had to apoligise for latter but at least he got a lot of laughs at the time. We have a lot more colourful group of pollies over here even though they constantly push the PC line it appears that it only applies to the plebe's and not the pollies themselves as they just behave as normal like spoilt little kids who can not play nice in the same sandbox at preschool.

And some people wonder why I just dismiss all pollies!

Col

by oz_media

Thanks for the stats, very educational to say the very least. I don't know how reliable the source is,I am not to familiar with the EPI site but I will assume that you would take all of that into account vefore posting.

We are also watching local campaigners go at it, today we heard frmo a new candidate who suggested banning marijuana but supporting gay marriage. I won't offer my views on the subject but these two go hand in hand, it like shooting yourself in the foot to split these two groups in Canada (Western Canada anyway) apparently not a single MP backs her ideas. Oh well, we tend to just giggle at our candidates, they aren't running for 'leader of the free world' though.

This is also somethnig I may have overlooked regarding American presidential elections. I think the reason for placing such importance on your Presidential vote is that the USA has appointed the President as leader of the free world (no sarcasm or shots here at ALL). When we vote in a P.M, who cares he's just going to sit in his office and run Eastern Canada, they never make any noise out here in the west.

The President of the USA must be someone who you can see contorlling world affairs for four years and I now see the importance of yor votes.

My next question would be, when people in USA are deciding on a party, what are the factors taken into account, now this will vary geographically as well as demographically. Those who are more ecnonomically aware, such as yourself, I assume would take into account the economical effects on the USA. Others may choose just based on favoritism and what others are doing. How much thought is put into HOW this President will act toward the rest of the world? Was this a consideration when Bush was elected or just what he would do for the USA?

Should you vote based on your country's gains or perhaps on a mroe global perspective?

During campaigns, do these candidates address world issues for resolve while in term or do they sell their ability to improve America?

If the President is elected based on National focus and then starts to take international matters into his hands while in term, should you still support him?

Wow, glad I'm in Canada, it seems that no matter who is in office here, in B.C. we have the highest cost of living, highest taxation, most expensive cigarrettes and booze (Taxation again) and get F-all for tax breaks. It's damn expensive to live here. Then again, on the other foot, it is probably what has kept BC's wildlife and wilderness in tact. We have a MASSIVE asian population, as this is the place they want to move to make money. I am sure that our Asian population would meet or top that of ANY US state, although I haven'tresearched the stats. EG. You take a bus in Richmond BC, the ratio of Asians to caucasians is at least 25:1 (not exaggerated at all). You come to port Hardy where I live it is about 0.25:1.

There is no commercial trade in our area, it is forestry, fishing or sightseeing tours (whale watching, sealion caves, bears etc.).
Sorry for running off track but what I'm gettnig at is because MOST of B.C. is protected wilderness and undeveloped/uninhabited, it is easy to 'get away' and enjoy the real world around us without seeing anyone for days. For this, we pay extreme taxes, rent/mortgages etc. But it pays us back by providing isolation.

Again, sorry for the segue, you got me thinking.

by maxwell edison

.
Many of our foreign friends seem to take objection to the "leader of the free world" label attached to the President of the United States.

Who was the first to use that term to describe the President of the United States and why?

(I have an answer, but I could be wrong. I haven't found an earlier reference than the one I have. I'll reveal it later, but not now.)

More interesting questions to consider: Was it justified then? Is it justified now? Why or why not? If it was justified then, but isn't not now, when did it change?

by oldefar

Its always interesting when you see something from a different perspective than before.

As I have said before, I don't speak for anyone but myself. I will have to give your questions some thought before answering.

by oldefar

The article indicated US CEO were paid about 3 times that of CEO from other developed countries on average. No specifics by country, however.

We have our share of politicians who were more carictatures than men of character, and more image than substance. As for PC, I think its a pendulum. All a question of good taste, and that is still a regional perspective.

You are right about the sandbox. Problem is, I have to be in that same sandbox (like you, too old to expect emmigration to the moon or Mars) so I can't simply ignore them.

Besides, I come from a long line of windmill jousters. "I yam what I yam and dat's all dat I yam!"

by hal 9000

I used to have to work with Government instutions and negotate contracts for their IT needs. Now I know this is not in the general topic of discussion but it was a nightmare for the first 2 years of negations and by that time you began to get suficentlyhigh enough up the ladder to start getting some sence. Then you would finish that contract and the very next job I was given was to start negations on thenext Government Contract so I had to start all over again knowing full well that by the time that the original proposal was even looked at by someone high enough up the totem pole it would be so far out of date as to be next to useless.

I got sick and tired of bashing my head against a brick wall so I've set up my own sand box and play in it with a few friends and simply refuse to have anything to do with Government or Medical contracts anymore. I do not need the hassles and unless the Governments actions directly impact upon me I just tend to ignore them.

But just to make me feel good about myself I was contacted a few days ago about a proposal that I put forward about 10 years ago for the Australian Government and I was over rulled as being too far over the top. But now it appears that my original proposal is going to be impelmited as the cut price option that they chose is now costing them far too much and exactly what I said would happen is happening. So now they are going to rollout a bit of fibre optic cable all around Australia. Now if thay did this all those years ago it would have saved them millions as then the telco was doing the same thing and they could have easily just added another cable in that roll out now they have to do it from scratch.

But it did save them something like 10 Million back then but now it is going to cost them well over 100 million to do exactly what they could have for less than a 10 th of the cost now days.

So do you see just why I'm so sinical about Government's?

Col

by oz_media

I soaked the government sooo many times for thier ridiculously high contract prices but they took forever to get approved.

The brick wall analogy reminded me of a former employer, they'd ask me to prepare ROI's for projects, would have me spend weeks researching and testing software and when it hit thier desk..............

I'd have reps calling to follow up, I'd say "sorry, try me again next month approval should be through soon" (Should have just changed my voice mail to provide a scripted speach ).

4 months later the boss's would start complaining that they need to get these issues resolved now! I'd have to contact all the former reps and get requotes, then test the new versions, then apologize for wasting thier time again.

Needless to say little got done, I was being paid to aste my time, when the pay didn't warrant my time anymore, I said FO and left. Who needs a reference from idiots like that anyhow.

Yes, beating your head on a brick freakin' wall!

One thing though, you sure learn how to run your OWN business from studying other's mistakes though.

OM

by oz_media

I am not interested the least little bit in another political debate right now, I have travel to plan and that would just get me pissed off.

I don't knw WHO or WHY or even WHEN nor do I care the least. What goes without saying though is that whoever started it, Americans JUMPED on it and now state it as if the pres is God, which to me he is not, to YOU he may be but not me. this does explain why he is in my face day and night whereas Canada's 'leaders' (oxymoron(s)?) aren't.

In a nutshell, I couldn't give a tinkers dam about the US president, just keep him in his cage next time and out of my face or I will keep biting back.

OM

by oz_media

I am not interested the least little bit in another political debate right now, I have travel to plan and that would just get me pissed off.

I don't knw WHO or WHY or even WHEN nor do I care the least. What goes without saying though is that whoever started it, Americans JUMPED on it and now state it as if the pres is God, which to me he is not, to YOU he may be but not me. this does explain why he is in my face day and night whereas Canada's 'leaders' (oxymoron(s)?) aren't.

In a nutshell, I couldn't give a tinkers dam about the US president, just keep him in his cage next time and out of my face or I will keep biting back.

OM

by maxwell edison

.
Wasn't trying to start anything. But contrary to what you may think, I can honestly say that I don't recall a time when I, or anyone other American (in these threads), called the President the "leader of the free world". However, our foreign friends refer to it often. Interesting.

So as to avoid diverting Judy's thread more than I already have, I'll give the answer, at least how I've discovered it to be.

"If Washington is the capital of the Free World, the President must be its leader."
- John F. Kennedy February 12, 1960

Thus, a label was born.

by oz_media

I thought it was coined by an American.

Yes America itself has been referred to as the leader of the free world itself by American peers.

But I didn't realize a Canadian had coined the term. Especially that Washington was the capitol of the free world. Guess some guy called John Kennedy wanted out of Toronto.

I always assumed it was coined on the US side of the border as a self appointed leader of the free world, of course that would be pretty arrogant though.

My mistake. I stand corrected.
OM

by oz_media

And I hope you understand I spoke without motive and am not trying to set anything up. It was a sincere realization.

Thanks,
OM

by oldefar

The issue is less one of party association, foreign or domestice issues, or even particular stands on agenda items.

What is perhaps most important to remember in politics is:
Politicians and diapers have one thing in common. They should both be changed regularly and for the same reason.

In the US, its a scheduled event.

by oz_media

You politician is potty trained, at least for the time being. He may start to fill them in year 6 or 7. If you replace him in year 4, you may get someone else with a full diaper already, be syuck with the daiper load for 4 years and waste the two good years you COULD have had with the first guy.

I understans the beed for systematic change but feel a 'fixed' term is unneccessary. Yes you can oust someone early but unless he smokes pot or sleeps with staff, everything relevant seems to go unnoticed.

I can't believe the stir created when Clinton got a piece from Lewinski. Who cares, if anyone it should have been his wife not the American public. This has no bearing on his ability to do his job, in fact maybe even let him perform better, a hummer a day keeps the wife away.

I'm not referring to how Clinton RAN your coutry but the amount of stir that was created around something irrelevant to the Presidential duties.

In the same sense, GWB (In MY eyes) BS'd the people into feeling threatened and then turned the tables to Liberation after his alleged threat was unfound. This the people accept?
But if he said he smoked pot once, he'd be ousted?

The BUSH family has a history dating back to cooperation and support for the Nazi's, this is not a concern to re-evaluate his position? SIre the war was 60 years ago, but Cliton wasn't hotboxing the Oval Office, he wasn't nailing Monica INSTEAD of performing his duty.

It just seems that you will chastize out of morality but support regardless of morality?!?

How about pick someone to run YOUR country, not everyone else's, let him run YOUR country until he stops putting your interests in front of his own?

by maxwell edison

.
All too many candidates try to play all sides of the issues, and when that becomes too much of an obvious contradiction they try to avoid the issue altogether. Candidates run the risk of being labeled as either anti-job or anti-trade, so they try to be both. Is a candidate in favor of globalization, or does he or she prefer to protect the American worker and be more of an isolationist? Is a candidate in favor of creating more American jobs, or would he or she prefer to help American business become more profitable? When a candidate takes a stand one way or the other, he or she runs the risk of polarizing a large segment of the voting public, something none of them wants to do. And it is rare indeed to find a candidate who can skillfully and honestly find an acceptable middle-ground or convince the constituency that their thinking is flawed. After all, how could a candidate possibly convince an out of work IT professional that IT offshoring is really a good thing in the long run? (Not that I'm suggesting it is or it isn't.) To make matters worse, most of the political banter we hear from many of them is no more than questionable rhetoric intended to mislead at best, or deceive at worst.

Standing up for one's principles, and just letting the chips fall where they may, is a virtue that is found in all too few politicians. That's not to say that ALL politicians fit this description, but those who are more principled in their stance are often labeled as extremists. That could include extremists on either the left or the right, by the way, although most extremist charges are, in my opinion, levied by those on the left targeting others on the right. Clarence Thomas, Ronald Reagan, Newt Gingrich, Tom DeLay, and other Republicans, for example, are among those who have been demonized simply because they take a principled stand. How many Democrats have been demonized in such a way? Was (and is) Ruth Bader Ginsburg demonized the way Clarence Thomas was (and is)? No, absolutely not. Both are extremely principled justices, but the difference is that one leans towards the left while the other leans towards the right. Are representatives Nancy Pelosi, Barney Frank, Major Owens, David Bonior, Maxine Waters or John Conyers demonized the way Tom DeLay is now or how Newt Gingrich was then? No, absolutely not, even though all are servants of their convictions, the only difference being the direction of those convictions.

I can't help but suggest that, in my humble (or not so humble) opinion, Republicans, in general, are more prone to such attacks for taking a principled stand and being labeled as an extremist, and Democrats are more prone to posturing themselves on both sides of an issue. I don't mean this as a slam, but rather I see it as almost a function of the way the Democrat party has progressed over the years. The Democrat party has had a history of pandering to particular groups, and oftentimes contradictions are inevitable. For example, the Democrats see themselves as "pro-choice", but the freedom to choose doesn't apply if a mother wants to choose a different school, by way of school vouchers, for the child she chooses to have. In the quest to attain and maintain their power, Democrats have created an umbrella so big and so diverse that contradictions are inevitable. But it doesn't have to be that way if a person (especially the voter) focuses on the bigger picture. For example, the Democrat party is considered, as a rule, the party of the worker and labor unions, but that is often seen as anti-business. And we all know that Democrats as well as Republicans want to see American business thrive, at least I hope we do. On the other side of the same coin, Republicans are considered, as a rule, the party of big business, and this is often seen as anti-worker. But we all know that Republicans as well as Democrats want to see the average worker thrive, at least I hope we do.

But I digress, even though it's all related. Back to the candidates and their stand on IT issues.

I think the biggest problem is the voter himself. I'm going to go out on a limb here, and suggest that many people in the IT industry want it both ways. (This is not just the IT industry, by the way, but this could apply to any industry.) On one hand, most IT professionals will admit that ours is a shrinking globe, especially with the advent of technology itself, and that free and open trade and globalization is inevitable, perhaps even preferable. But on the other hand, many are demanding that their American jobs be protected against such global change. Which way do we want it? Okay, the reality is that companies are forced to look for ways to become more profitable. Why is that, and therefore what? "Big-business" is just being greedy, one might argue. Oh really? Is it really just "big-business" being greedy, or do many of us have our own financial interest at stake here as well? Take a look at your company's retirement plan or your own 401(k) plan. Microsoft, Intel, and other technology "big-business" is a big part of that plan. If the company's profits decline, guess what happens to the value of your retirement plan? What happens to the country's overall financial stability, and what "domino effect" will result when those profits decline? Okay, the reality is that more IT jobs are going overseas. Why is that, and therefore what? Do we therefore cry foul and demand that our politicians protect us? Or do we therefore realize that we, as Americans, have to find ways to be better, we have to be more productive, we have to be more competitive, and we have to do it all at a lower cost?

Taxes and the Internet is another big issue. On one hand, no one wants their Internet access taxed. But on the other hand many people expect more and more government services to provide for their basic needs, services all funded by taxes. On one hand, no one wants taxes levied on their Internet transactions, but on the other hand we might all see a need to level the playing field so that the established brick and mortar businesses in out local communities can continue to thrive and employ our neighbors.

How about standing on the principle of your convictions, and just let the chips fall where they may. If the American voter wasn't so fickle, and if the American voter quit trying to sell his or her vote to the highest bidder, perhaps the candidates themselves wouldn't have to walk such a tight-rope. Put another way, who's going to be the first to stand up for the convictions of their principle, the candidate of the voter? The answer makes a strong argument for the underlying principle of self-reliance. And that just scares the heck out of too many people.

by oz_media

"How about standing on the principle of your convictions, and just let the chips fall where they may."

This is interestnig, I have been looking at the recent Canadian Conservative candidate (would be the first conservative PM since Brian Mulrooney).

She is 38, single, QUITE attractive and stands with what I see as conflicting opinions.

eg: She doesn't want marijuana laws lifted as she is concerned of the repercussions from the USA. She does agree that more testing is needed and that the government would be able to rax it and gain HUGE revenue, although the black market would still flourish as the gov. grows would be much lower quality than the norm.

On the other hand, she is FOR gay marriage.

Now these two aren't realted BUT the gay community in Vancouver is VERY pro-marijuana, there are sevral resons for this that I see: a) These people are generally not accepted in thier youth and turn to drugs fro comfort, b) Those suffering from HIV and AIDS will find benefit in marijuana as they will have an appetite that is removed from thier prescription medication.

So from what I see Brenda Stronach has actually decided to take a stand and let the chips fall.

Unfortunately, she will gain MANY votes by those who like her looks, many more from supporters of her father (who inceidentally lost by a long shot several years ago)but I am really confused as to how she hopes to win over the gay and marijuana communities (yes there is a marijuana community here). In fact even though numbers of users are very different depending on the source, there are MILLIONS of users here. Almost EVERYONE in BC has tried or still smokes marijuana, even Brenda has and she admitted to inhaling AND enjoying it as she grew up where it was completely accepted.

If you vivst downtown Vancouver at lunch time, you will see stock brokers, lawyers, bankers, CEO's etc. in suits sharing a joint at lunch in broad daylight. It is not frowned upon so I don't see it hurting her campaign even while trying to win teh Gay voters with the same sex marriage support.

In conclusion Max, I see her as someone who is prepared to make her stand and let the chips fall where they may. Then again, I think she has VERY slim chance of winning the vote.

Your points are accurate, one must play the people and stroke them just right in order to be elected. This should almost be seen as purjury and should disqualify and elected official once they reneg on thier intents.

I feel it happens in many social groups too, schools, clubs etc. The politicians have just learned how to make it an art form.

Ms. Stronarch claims she is NOT a professional politician but a mother (unwed mom's rejoice) she came from an poor immigrant family and went to public school, says she was never fed with a silver spoon, however she just quit her job as CEO for Magna to persue politics.

I think she is just trying to settle a score. Someone beat out her father many years ago, funny enough, that guys son is also running against Stronarch now.

Games or people's livlihoods, what are we voting for these days. There's too much smoke and mirrors in politics to allow voters a fair appraisal of candidates and a logical vote. Unfortunately, they also make the laws, so we just dip out all around.

Perhaps another reason Canadians give up on politicians and just live daily instead.

by oz_media

Sorry , Max, she is a new politician that has just quit her dayjob ay a multi-million dollar corporation to persue a career in politics. not a familiar face.

I referred to her as Brenda Stronarch however her correct name is Belinda Stronach.

by jardinier

The fundamental dilemma facing any politician, no matter how honest, sincere or idealistic he/she may be is that in order to implement their ideas they first have to be elected to parliament.

Once in office, compromises usually have to be made to accommodate the general view of the party, and election promises are often qickly forgotten.

The only real statesman Australia has produced in my lifetime is Gough Whitlam. Afer 23 years in Opposition, he led Labor back to power in 1972. He proceeded to legislate his election promises one by one -- you could have ticked them off in a list. He also held a weekly press conference which was published verbatim in the major newspapers.

He made a couple of slip-ups, and was booted out in three years. Yet in that short time he introduced some 370 items of legislation.

The new Labor leader, Mark Latham, has some revolutionary ideas, and is obviously a man of integrity (why, he even replies personally to my emails from time to time).

It is quite likely he will be Prime Minister before the end of the year as John Howard has to set an election date by November. It is going to be an interesting year politically for both the US and Australia.

by oz_media

Turns out our dope smoking, ex-hippie, millionaire, single mom, half-assed hottie candidate may do better than first predicted. She has MILLIONS and MILLIONS of dollars for campaigning (just like GWB does) and is a good friend of the denial ridden Clinton!

Her opponents are already being overrun by her campaign money that doesn't need funding by others.

Uh OH!

by maxwell edison

.
It is a fundamental dilemma facing any candidate of any party. That's why I place most, if not all of the blame on the voters who, in essence, sell their souls, I mean sell their votes to the highest bidders.

And so my fellow Americans: ask not what your country can do for you ? ask what you can do for your country. ? John F. Kennedy, Jan., 1961

That was then.

This is now:

And so my self-centered fellow Americans: ask not what you can and should do for yourself ? ask instead what your government will do for you. ? The American voter in 2004

(Just thinking about it disgusts me. Where's that ticket to the next "new world"?)

by oz_media

Well you have an extremely valid reasoning here Max. I completely see your views and agree with the onus being put pon the voter to not demand the best of both worlds from candidates. This in turn allows the candidate to campaign with a more focused and realistic objective.

I agree with your points about companies being forced to outsource in order to retain a market share and stay competitive in a market that is slowly being shared with internet transactions.

I do have a different view on why the corporations publically say that they all strive to see the worker thrive.
This is obvious in ANY form of business in ANY country in the world. The companies pay thier workers a very small portion of their gross revenue (rightly so in most cases and to a certain degree)but ultimately if the worker is earning more, then so are the companies.

As sincere as this is, it would be unrealistic any other way, a company that overpays its emplyess and buys them chauffer driven limos would be great! In the same sense, it wouldn't last and that same company would be responsible for a numnber of layoffs, not so great.

So the reason EVERYONE agrees that the worker needs to thrive is because it is essential. It isn't insincere, it is neccessity.

I don't think such thoughts detract in any way from the fact that too many companies have overpaid upper management and therefore cannot afford to increase wages or keep business within the country.

I am also not implying that this only occurs in the USA by any means.

This is a global problem and will probably grow as far as India where the workers will demand more money due to the higher number of jobs being outsourced to India. Their employers will in turn raise costs for their services, the worker in the USA for example, will be earning less due to outsourcing, the worker in India is demanding more. The Employer in the USA will now start to see more value in bringing the business back to America, and so on, and so on the circle of life goes on.

Companies need to reduce costs by eliminating ridiculous salaries, paying higher salaries to workers such as nurses and teachers.
One thing I have noticed in US corporations I dealt with the early 90's is that they had removed middle management in order to control costs. There were 'peons' and then a multitude of freshly promoted Upper management staff. THe CO's, CTO's, CFO's etc. cost money and way too much of it. It is here in Canada too, but I think less here out West than in Toronto for example.

Your post all makes sense to me but I think I see the larger corporations as greedier than you do by a long shot. Working with portfolio design for pubic companies in the mid 90's showed me just how greedy these guys are, it's not QUITE as bad as it was then but that's only due to streamlining and cutbacks in what I see as the wrong areas. This does not show that the companies want employees to thrive, but for themselves to thrive, after that the employee can have some.

by oldefar

As I was reading your post, it occurred to me that you were regarding the company or corporation as a person. This is something we all do, and is part of the self illussion that makes change so difficult.

It wasn't a corporation or company that removed middle management. It was an individual in a senior level at a corporation or company. It isn't a corporation or company that layed off workers or outsourced work. It was an individual or group of individuals who did that. Now, it is very hard to hold a company or corporation accountable, and very easy to excuse an individual for his or her actions because the company or corporation made them behave as they did.

If the gap in the ownership of wealth is to be lessened, if the gap in the standard of living between people at local, regional, national, or global levels is to be reduced, and if the general respect of people to people is to expand, I think it has to come in large measure by dropping the illussion of corporate or company actions and putting responsibility back on individuals.

The same holds true for the actions of nations - people act, nations are illussions to hide behind or containers some individuals control and exploit.

To me, this is in full agreement with my perspective of individual sovereignty.

So what? Well, just something for each of us to consider.

by oz_media

You're right but I don't think at anytime that I was referring to a company as an entity more than I was representative of those that run it.

In these multi-million/billion dollar corporations, decisions are made by various people. Sometime a board of directors, others a CO, CEO, CTO, CFO etc. As I said before, there are too many high paid cooks in the kitchen. It takes the identity AND responsibility away from an individual, as you noted, and lumps it into a more acceptable (due to anoninimity) collective, the 'corporation' or 'The Company'

This generalization may have been adopted from terms of law and legal contracts that simplify the blame by reducing ownership to 'The Company'.

Perhaps it is due to seeing a paycheck or stub with a big logo embossed on it. Taking away the personality of a signed check. This would also show the money train and great deductor as a company or logo not the person they are working for.

Yes, people are often seeing a large brick building with a big sign instead of the snake behind the desk, just to the left of the plant, behind the coffee mug, under the phone book...yes that's him, hiding in the corner under the big logo.

by oldefar

I don't you personally, only by your postings here at TR. My comment was to your post only because while reading it I realized how often I and those I do know have forgotten or avoided putting a specific name to an action and instead used "the company".

I receive a number of newletters from various organizations, and I see this quite often. For example, union newsletters often refer to companies in their comments on outsourcing. I can't help but wonder how many of the union workers or impacted workers have ever personalized the action. IBM didn't outsource anything. It was an action by an individual at IBM. Boeing did not close anything. It was a decision by an individual. Companies don't freeze wages, cut benefits, or award stock options to senior management. Individuals do this.

Now, what happens when John Doe worker makes this personal and asks Dick Boss why he is moving the work to someplace else, or closing the plant, or eliminating staff? Dick Boss can no longer hide behind a logo. He has to answer why he is taking a particular action that means John Doe will be out of a job. He has to take personal responsibility for the options considered and rejected, or never considered. And perhaps he has to look at an end of quarter bonus as John Doe's annual pay next time and still sleep at night.

Of course, the individual accountability increases as the company shrinks in size. When workers pass the owner in the hall and know his name, the decisions are personal, and the human impact is known and considered by all.

There are problems everywhere, and behind all of them are people who have made decisions not as individuals but as elements of a company, a corporation, or a government. We have all at times hidden behind these illussions to avoid making the right, ethical, moral, and painful decision I suspect, or at the least let others off the hook using that same illussion.

by oldefar

who at TechRepublic decides on how the Web site navigation occurs? How about a name and an email? How about individual responsibility? Why did you put Discussion above Technical Q&A? Why is there a default topic area at all? Why do we not have a spell checker for users posting discussions or questions?

At least give it to Oz so he can complain directly! ;-)

by oz_media

I have learned to read your posts a little more carefully lately as i see a lot of logic and common sense in your ideas.

I wasn't trying to sound defensive in my last post, I just wanted to be clear that I was not intending on singling out a proprietor as these were much larger companies that I spoke of and ones that have many responsible parties involved.

You actually sparked an interesting thought for me (uh oh !)

A guy I know was complaining about the family run business he works in (small town life for me now, almost all business are family operated here except Weyerhauser and Crown Forests)he was complaining that they had a small town attitude and him being from Victoria (Capitol of BC) he was shocked that they aren't interested in his thoughts and ways to improve efficiency. He also complained that(bosses name)was this and that and he said this and did that etc. Very personal!

He then said he preferred working in Victoria for the larger companies just because THE COMPANY was so well run and THE COMPANY did this and that.

When I speak with him next, I will remind him of what you've said here, it was quite thought provoking and I think he'll see that just because THE COMPANY now has a name, this doesn't mean he is being treated differently, just that the company has now become personal as it's owner is someone he works closely with and knows in a more personal nature.

You're right, this does effect the overall reaction to changes, decisions etc. Once a face is put to a logo or corporate image.

Thanks

by dc_guy

Oldefar raised an issue that I have been trumpeting for years, and I am gladdened by the thoughtful responses to it. Many of the problems in what we call the "free market" are due to the existence of what lawyers call "artificial persons": corporations. The free market as described by Adam Smith was supposed to be a level playing field populated by producers and consumers of more or less equal stature. He never envisioned corporations with the wealth and power of small nations "competing" with individual employees, suppliers, and customers. He would throw up if he read the chapter in a modern economics textbook describing the "holding company": a pyramidal corporation that contributes absolutely nothing to the free market but just skims the profits off the top of other corporations, routinely tossing them, their employees, and customers off the playing field as casually as chessmen. The corporation was invented by government as a modern version of the disappearing aristocracy: able to perform the nefarious deeds that the government itself could not get away with (especially one that must now deal with elections), but with no accountability. Corporate leaders used to strive to achieve a modicum of good citizenship, recognizing that their families' future was linked to the prosperity of their country. Today's corporate leaders are either less educated and don't understand the pitfalls of living only for the next quarter, or else they really are part of an international conspiracy and plan on moving their families to an enclave where they can be provided with luxury goods by low-wage workers while the rest of us go jobless.

by oldefar

Just want to thank all the posters at TR.

Ideas are a lot like seeds. For a seed to grow, the soil has to be prepared by breaking up the ground a bit, sometimes adding a bit of fertilizer, knocking down competing plants, and adding the right amount of water and sunshine.

Now the soil at my place in the blackland prairie region of Texas can be tough to break up. When wet it is so sticky it will suck the toenails off you right through your boots, and when dry it can challenge concrete for hardness. It takes time and effort to break it up for farming, and takes a whole lot of manure to get it workable for gardening. Most of the time its too wet or too dry except for weeds, and those weeds can be mighty tough to deal with. They will burn you, prick you, cut you, and generally block any attempt of a useful plant to grow.

Now my mind is a bit more like that blackland soil than I care to admit. However, there is hope. In this forum there are plenty of posts that keep plowing into those weeds of foolish ideas and concepts. A whole lot of manure gets spread around on a regular basis! But there are some good seeds being dropped as well, and enough sunshine for some of those to grow.

So to all of you who have helped plow into my brain, spread your manure, kept dropping those seeds of ideas, brought a bit of sunshine, and even rained on my parade - thanks!

DC-Guy - sometimes you have to sow a lot of seed before it lands on prepared soil.

by oz_media

I'm sorry for the typos but my right arm is out of action so my hen peck is now single handed. I am having problems typing at all, yet alone making changes.

by oldefar

The diaper analogy is funny, nothing more. Seems to me many posters from throughout the world have a similar general perspective of politicians.

At any given time, roughly half the public are unhappy with whoever represents them at all federal levels. There are some exceptions, but on average any elected official has at best the support of half. Of that support, I suspect less than 10 percent are in complete agreement with that official. I state this because it seems you generalize a much higher level of support in most of your posts. If I am misreading the "you" and it is meant as reference to me alone I apologize, but I will not argue a position I haven't taken.

If we are held accountable for the actions of our parents and grandparents, a whole lot of us could find ourselves in deep trouble. The allegations of a tie between Prescott Bush and Nazi interests IF PROVED make a case for prosecuting Prescott Bush, make a case for eliminating inherited wealth and property, and make a case for more aggressive investigation and prosecution of business relations at all times. Nothing more.

On a side note, for those who are opposed to the US position on various global issues, would not they be guilty of the same behavior as Prescott Bush if they have business dealings with the US today? If not, why not?

A recurring critisizm of the US is its reluctance to get involved overseas as well as its overseas involvement. An interesting contradiction. How about a universal set of rules for all countries on when they should or should not become involved with each other? Universal in that without regard to the countries involved, the same rule applies.

by oz_media

You're right in that people generalize support and no I wasn't directing at it you specifically.

Ad for the BUSH past, I too agree that someone should not be accountable for his past as much as what the person NOW brings to the table, with exception to being a pathalogical liar or something.

This is why I was shocked to see Clinton thrown out for his drug testing and relations with Monica. Nobosy would have even batted an eye if he ws the Canadian PM, it'd irrelevant.

I was just using the BUSH /NAZI thing as a reference.

I don't think history should be recalled so often, everyone has made mistakes over history as we developed our intelligence and formed new alliances. We shouldn't use the past as 'justification' as much as a 'guide' for positive and negative actions and the repercussions of our past victories/mistakes.

My point was when does the past matter and when doesn't it, who determines this?

I meant diapers literally in the sense that politicians come out all clean and smelling of baby powder and end up wading in it and slinging it all over the place as it becomes deeper and deeper.

Why must a president have four years? Why not until he is no longer favored of until he makes a mistake like Clinton? What if he us great for 6 years and you oust him after four only to losed out on the first guy?

Maybe they will be a little more focused on improving the country from WITHIN the country, instead of looking for fireworks and fanfare by resolving external issues.

These guys know they have four years, one to win some of the nonsupporting voters over, the next two to try and actually DO something for a country and one to campaign for the nest election, which can begin while doing something for the country.

In that short time, they are held accountable for helping progress one of the largest nations in the world, with millions of people from every ethnicity known.

To oust someone, who is performing a suitable job, due to past history is ridiculous.

Politcs, what a piss-off pain in the ass. I'm just glad they are not an issue here or a topic of discussion anyone wants to even start to consider.

I mentioned the new Conservative candidate in Canada here and was answered with a question about the Canucks hockey team. I tried bringing it up with a client, but got the same 'who cares' response. Political discussion will get your butt kicked here real fast it seems.

Nobody trusts cares about or even thinks abour our politicians, they just get into office, raise our taxes every year and grow old until they are replaced. We don't want to grow old watching them grow old so you may as well just ignore them.

by oldefar

I can't speak for anyone other than myself, but I do vote based on what I see as what is in the best interest of my country. In each instance, it has been a compromise vote and I don't have any illusion that this will change.

What I do is consider several factors. First is a close enough alignment to my own beliefs. I have yet to meet an individual I am in complete agreement with. However, I have met many that are so far out of sync with my own ethics and values that I choose not to associate with them if at all possible.

Next is the limitations of what a particular office can do. While much of the world attributes the US President with absolute power, the fact is there are significant limits to that power. A recent example - Clinton would have implemented Hilary's universal health coverage while he was President. Abortion would have been illegal during the Reagan, Bush1, and Bush2 administrations. Understanding these limitations means that certain agenda's are not going to be implemented and a candidate who focuses on these issues will accomplish little even if elected. So a position on issues that I believe can be influenced by the particular office is important, and can outweigh positions on issues that I perceive as currently dead end issues.

Finally there is my recognition of how a particular office influences how those in other nations will perceive America and Americans. Now 50 years on this planet have taught me a few things. One is that the appearance of strength and a willingness to use that strength is a good way to avoid fights.

As for how a candidate sells a particular issue to a larger audience, I would have to acknowledge selective hearing. If I am already in agreement with a proposed course of action based on a set of facts or beliefs, then I really don't pay attention to all the words used to convince those who are not in agreement. In this respect I suspect I am no better or worse than anyone else.

One area where I suspect I differ from many other Americans is that I don't buy isolation as a viable option. The world is too small, life too interdependent to ignore what happens outside of our borders.

by oz_media

"One is that the appearance of strength and a willingness to use that strength is a good way to avoid fights."

I actually USED to think that way but realized I was horribly wrong. One thing I learned during my days in martial arts was that expressing outwtward strength CREATES conflict it doesn't suppress it.

Eg. A night club is FULL of testosterone ridden guys trying to look like head peacock. Tight shirts, strutting chest out etc.

These are the FIRST guys that others will look for conflict with. Many times it's the smallest guy that beats up the biggest 'looking' guy, or the guy who think he's the biggest, size has no relevance in had to hand conflict.

In my too MANY (16!)years as a security foreman, the most important thing I told new staff was NOT to look like a bouncer, if you don't try to look cool and tough, people don't want to knock the chip off your shoulder.

The guys that end up in brawls on the street are always the 'tough guys', only sometime do they prevail.

I have a video clip of a US helpcopter in Iraq that shoots four Iraqi's in a field, destroys the transport tuck they are with, makes a small pickup practically explode from who knows HOW far away all without any of the Iaqi's having ANY idea they were targeted, via FLIR and auto tracking late at night.

To the Iraq's on the ground, they just see four guys literally explode without even seeing any helicopter. To them this is America flexing her muscles, even the good citizens in Iraq can't see this as a 'man's' fight, it looks like a cowardly and brutal attack.

I understand this is war but what about those you are trying to liberate. It must just look like a ore powerful Saddam on thier doorstep.

No, I TOTALLY disagree. Showing strength and posessing strength are in no way related whatsoever and aren't perceived that way by others. People who SHOW strength are just people wo need to be taken down a notch, not cowered to, only the VERY weak would feel that way and that would just be out of fear.

This is where the North and our neighbours differ. You are seen as warmongers due to your constant muscle flexing, very few see you as tough though.

by maxwell edison

.
(From snopes.com)

Origins: Many readers have asked us about an MPEG video clip, roughly a minute long, depicting a U.S. Apache helicopter gunship firing at men in a field. The men are Iraqis shown handling a long cylindrical object; the accompanying audio indicates that the helicopter crew believes the object to be a weapon, so they ask their commanders for permission to engage the enemy, then take out the three men one by one with the helicopter's 30mm cannons, firing over 100 rounds in all.

All we know so far is what ABCNews (presumably the source of the video) reported: the action depicted took place north of Baghdad on 1 December 2003, the soldiers heard on the tape are from the Army's 4th Infantry Division, and the men on the ground were fired upon because the helicopter crew believed them to be armed with rocket-propelled grenade launcher.

According to ABC:
A senior Army official who viewed the tape said the pilots had the legal right to kill the men because they were carrying a weapon. He said there were no ground troops in the area and if the Apache pilots had let the three Iraqis go, the men might have gone on to kill American troops.

Keane agreed. "Those weapons were obviously not being pointed at them in particular, but they [the three Iraqis] are using those weapons in their minds for lethal means and they [the Apache pilots] have a right to interfere with that," he said.

Anthony Cordesman, an ABCNEWS defense consultant who also viewed the tape, said the Apache pilots would have had a much clearer picture of the scene than what was recorded on the videotape. He also said they would have had intelligence about the identity of the men in the vehicles. "They're not getting a sort of blurred picture. They have a combination of intelligence and much better imagery than we can see."

As to whether the Apache pilots could have called in ground troops to apprehend the men, Cordesman said: "In this kind of war, wherever you find organized resistance among the insurgents, you have to act immediately. If you wait to send in ground troops almost invariably your enemy is going to be gone."

Army officials acknowledged that the 30 mm cannons used by the Apache gunners were far bigger than what was needed to kill the men, but said it is the smallest weapon the Apaches have.

Authenticity of video: Undetermined

by oldefar

Products of our environment and prisoners of our experiences.

When I said strength you heard toughness. Your mental image was immeadiately that of the muscle flexing swaggart looking for a fight.

Now I have not taken martial arts, but I suspect the aspect of it that avoids trouble is the same element I was referring to. The strength I referred to is self confidence to take a position and to act on it if necessary. Most times, that attitude is sufficient. However, every once in awhile someone will challenge it. Back away, and you find yourself challenged again and again by all who saw.

Bush took a stand on behalf of America. He was challanged on it, and he acted. Now a number of other nations who have questioned the will of America to back her position have changed their minds and we have positive results without war.

This discussion is closed to new replies.