Discussion Locked

p4 vs. xeon

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

i am going to build a new computer for
running porgrams like bryce4 and
autocad..what is the difference between the
xeon and p4..or is it better to use amd's xp?
and what would be the best chip for a
workstation?

21 replies

by maelgwyn

I would recommend the AMD XP because of the cost factor, and that they are a faster processor. However, if the money isnt yours... I would go for the Xeon if you need dual processors, but the P4 if you need more speed.

Anyways, I hope that answers your question

Maelgwyn

by darthkim

We have 20 3D cad HP visualize workstations and i think its minor whether you went with a P4 or a XEON (we have the Xeon)

IF support is an issue i would stick with Intel, otherwise, the other guy is right, the XP are very quick.

Even more important is the Video Card. Make sure to grab yourself a ATI FIreGL4 or a Wildcat card to do your rendering. Trust me, you'll save yourself plenty of time.

by akula

A Xeon may be better suited to your needs. Although an Althlon XP or Pentium 4 has enough power, the motherboards for the Xeon are higher end products that would support very powerful graphics cards, onboard SCSI, etc. You may also want to consider the dual Athlon MP CPUs with the Tyan Thunder K7 motherboard- that should be plenty capable for what you are planning.

Just make sure you get a motherboard with an AGP Pro slot if you intend to use an AGP Pro video card.

by timthetoolman

Hi,

The difference between the Xeon and P4 is essentially the amount of L1 cache. The Xeon has significantly more and so doesn't go to main memory as often - resulting in overall increased speed.

BUT... I concur with those who said your graphics card is the most important part of your system. It is.

Any high end CPU will do fine as long as you have a very good graphics card. That's where you should spend your money...

Cheers,
Tim.

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Unfortunately you wont be able to get anything that will have "punch" after 4 years.

Moore's law states that processing power doubles every 18 months - and this has proven to be true over the last 20+ years.

In 4.5 years time, your pc will be 1/8 the power of "current" PCs.

Looking at it another way, you would own today, the equivalent of a P266. I dont think anyone would say that any P 266 has "punch" by today's standards.

You'd be far better off going cheap and upgrading once or twice over that time.

Xeon's dont come cheap. They're targetted at the server market. The motherboards are expensive too. AMD has the best bang for your buck now.

Cheers,
Tim.

by revnathan

the more responces , the better , i an looking to see what people have to say and then make a desision..thanks

by revnathan

i keep seeing benchmarks for both amd vs intel's p4..they are about the same , one says intel is better the othe rsays amd..but i have yet to see a benchmark where they put a xeon vs any amd....what i need is speed and pucnh..i am takeing mulit-media for comunications as a major in college...so i need somehitng that can puch and keep punching for at leat 4 yrs..thanks

by grimreality

For multimedia purposes use the MAC as it is created for the sole purpose of Multimedia and it will blow everything else out of the water. If you are doing engineering then go with AMD for the price, larger bandwidth for the FSB, and the processor blows all Intel low end out of the water, which is the pentium series. As for XEON, unless you are rich and are planning on running servers not workstations forget XEON. Love the processor but the price will choke a horse.

This discussion is closed to new replies.