Discussion Locked

Please Don't Feed the Wildlife

0 helpful
145 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

145 replies

by nicknielsen

I've lived it and was lucky enough to have the government there to help me get out of it.

You fed the animals, and now you're making surprised that you got bitten?

by nicknielsen

that government can be too big or too small. Our government is doing some things well. It's not doing other things well at all. It's also doing some things it shouldn't be doing, and not doing some things it should be doing.

With regard to financial regulation, government has been shrinking since the 1980s. Compared to the relatively [financially] calm half-century before that, we have been subject to almost regular financial bubbles or frauds as the regulations have been pared back since that time. The almost-immediate S&L debacle, Enron, Worldcom, the dot.com bubble, Madoff, the housing bubble, a rising tide of bank failures, and the derivatives crash were all enabled by lax enforcement or reduced regulation.

The Department of Education is a bloated bureaucracy that has never seriously attempted to do the one thing it should have been trying to do from Day One: set national educational achievement standards by grade level and subject for all American schools. By that I mean "this is what students must know to progress to the next level". How to get students educated to that point would be up to the states, counties, or cities. Instead, the Ed Dept tries to enforce the idiotic concept, now enshrined in law, that all children can learn to the same level in the same amount of time. Here, government is too big for the wrong reason.

The recent spate of food contamination appears to indicate that theire aren't enough inspectors. Too small.
Trying to regulate individual medical choices? Too big.
Our public infrastructure is falling apart. Too small.
We're fighting a war for a now-questionable cause. Too big.

There are no easy answers, Max. And there are no absolutes beyond the first Ten.

by maxwell edison

...... whether [i]"government can be too big or too small."[/i]

Considering it's never gotten smaller, that doesn't make a lot of sense. Moreover, your assertion that government cannot be [i]"too big"[/i] is absurd. Of course it can; and it is!

You're really stretching, Nick, to avoid having to defend your indefensible comments about wanting to grow the already burgeoning, 48 million strong, federal food stamp roles.

by nicknielsen

Every suggestion I've offered here has been intended to help people become [b]more[/b] financially independent, making them [b]less[/b] dependent on government for support.

And because I defend the existence of the food stamp program and understand why it has grown to the size it has, you think I want it to grow further? You're making stupid assumptions and creating your own false dichotomies.

by ansugisalas

And their appliances and devices?
If it all eventually comes down to more jobs, what the hell is the problem with it?
Your line of reasoning only makes sense if you think there's competition between public and private. There isn't.

by ansugisalas

now we can get back to dissing Obama in peace, without a freaking Mormon bishop trying to take advantage :D

by aidemzo_adanac

I know he's a bleeding heart to Americans, but your centre is our right. Our left makes Obama look more right than Meri Kahane.

by nicknielsen

If we did, the money-men would be tripping over beggars and starving children in the streets. Food stamps keep them out of sight, in the supermarkets.

by aidemzo_adanac

"We're supposed to be the greatest country in the world, but we don't look like it."

Um, yeah. At least reality has set in for you guys now. Sorry it was at the cost of home, marriages and livelihoods but that's what it usually takes when countries slowly start to lose their place.

by nicknielsen

I think it's illogical to complain about the government keeping people from starving, which is what food stamps does, while ignoring that the same government spends hundreds of billions of dollars to obtain and maintain the capability to destroy other countries, even the world, in the name of "national security".

Either it's about [u]all[/u] the spending or it's not about the spending at all.

by ansugisalas

Right. Ok. And the nation has no vested interest in children being born, right? Coz, you can just replace the citizens with H1Bs, LOL.
Where the fluck did you store your brain, AV?
Ok, first of all; let's say you're entitled to say where the nation spends your money. It's a long shot, but sure, OK.

Well, the Democrats have decided to put *their* tax money on keeping the poverty below riot level.
That then is *their* decision, with *their* money, and you should stop flucking whining about it.
You want to spend on something else than war and subsidies for megacorps? Stop voting Republican, simple as that.

by ansugisalas

"It's a shame they didn't consider the cost of water when they decided where their ancestors put their homes"

by nicknielsen

First, you make a false assumption. My wanting to reduce the power of the two dominant parties does not preclude my favoring current government programs. Nor does my favoring a program mean I think there is nothing wrong with that program..

Second, where do I even mention Romney (except once, obliquely) or criticize how he made his money (at all)?

Third, you've already pointed out the history of the modern food stamp program, yet you lead with Obama as the 'owner' of that spending, adding the federal government as an afterthought. There have been no substantial changes to the program since the '90s, other than the number of participants. Shouldn't that be Clinton's spending? Or, given the root causes for the current levels of government spending, GWB's? Or, given the history you present, Johnson's? Or Nixon's? Or Reagan's? Or even Eisenhower's, Truman's, or FDR's?

And the minute you start talking about "intergenerational dependency", you are, intentionally or otherwise, stereotyping in the same manner as those who use less subtle terms.

AV, the wealthy may not owe anything to the rest of us as individuals, but they owe [u]everything[/u] to the country that made it possible for them to become wealthy in the first place. That they think they are should have their wealth without having to contribute to American society is no less an entitlement mentality than that displayed by the Obamaphone...person.

by av .

What I'm talking about is when you have people that are already on welfare programs and they continue having more children they can't support. People like that have made a lifestyle of living off entitlement programs and they never get off of it. Welfare is supposed to be a helping hand, not a lifestyle.

This lifestyle is particularly rampant in our inner cities. Mostly single mothers and multiple fathers that are absent and do not support their children. In many cases they continue to have children so they get more government money. It isn't as if the children benefit from the welfare, they don't. The kids go without and the mother takes the money and spends it elsewhere. The government enables this lifestyle by just throwing money at it without any strings attached, such as making them work for it in some capacity or mandating some kind of job training so the person can eventually get off the system and support themselves.

Some states, like NJ, have workfare instead of welfare and it has been somewhat successful in preventing people from using the system as a permanent source of income.

Maintaining the poverty level with welfare programs for so many people is not an answer. The answer is growing the economy and providing good paying jobs for anyone that wants to work or even those that don't. It comes back to personal responsibility. The Republicans want to grow the economy and provide an atmosphere for business that will be attractive for investment. If we had a robust economy, people would be able to find decent paying jobs to support themselves. The Dems don't seem to have an answer for how to create a robust economy.

AV

by av .

They are still funded by the taxpayers. We need more good jobs being created by private enterprise. We can't all work for or because of the government.

AV

by av .

Sometimes career paths don't necessarily mean you stay at the same company and work your way up. You may start at McDonalds flipping burgers, but you leave and go to another company that offers you a better job and better pay.

In larger companies, say the Pharma industry, you would have more opportunities to move within the company.

We should rebuild our infrastructure without a doubt, but it should be done in partnership with private enterprise. Private enterprise will benefit from it. The government should try to foster that relationship between government and private enterprise so that projects are not totally funded by the government. We need to give private enterprise an incentive to invest in this country again and that isn't happening.

AV

by nicknielsen

Those better-paying jobs have been moving to other countries for decades because those better-paying jobs were in manufacturing plants owned by corporations that received government subsidies in the form of tax breaks when they moved their jobs overseas.

What's left behind is Walmart or McDonald's or jobs that require education or training people not only don't have, but can't afford to get because they work at Walmart or McDonald's, can't afford tuition costs on their own, and don't want to take a student loan because they're smart enough not to volunteer for indentured servitude.

by ansugisalas

you mean the corporations that own the capitol, then I'm sorry to say that the profit margins on building up your country are far outstripped by the profit margins on tearing it down.
Business is business, I'm sure you understand.

If you mean something else, well, perhaps you need to look into what that would actually take.

by av .

It's Obama's policies that make him left wing. Tax and spend is his mantra. Big government. Wealth redistribution. Its not as if new tax revenue will go to pay down the debt, it will go for new spending and wealth redistribution.

The Republicans want to cut the size and scope of government, but the candidates that ran for President failed to convey that message as a positive path to prosperity. It sounded more like a path to austerity.

Half of the people in the US are apathetic about voting. They barely know who the candidates are and don't bother to find out. In the case of Romney, many of the conservatives in his own party did not back him because of his more moderate views. I think it harkens back to the "compassionate conservative", GWB. They elected GWB to be fiscally conservative and it turned out he wasn't.

Now that Obama has been reelected, we can look forward to four more years of the status-quo or worse.

AV

by maxwell edison

...... should be eliminated.

And has nothing to do with the food stamps discussion. It's just another diversion; another straw-man.

by nicknielsen

Eligibility for food stamps is based on household income. If you're the sole wage-earner for a two-person household (think single parent) working full-time at the current minimum wage, you are eligible for food stamps.

Raise the minimum wage so that single parent can earn enough to buy sufficient food, and you've eliminated the need for the program.

by ansugisalas

GROSS OVERGENERALIZATION!!!

Are you aware of how the human reproductive cycle works?
Did you know that accidents happen? Did you know that most people, even pro-choice people, won't actually get abortions on just economic grounds?

Besides, having twins is an entirely different thing than having a single child at a time, and much more expensive even than getting two children one at a time.

Over here firing someone over pregnancy issues is *illegal* because it *negatively affects the entire economy*.

Have you ANY idea of how much it costs all of you to drive people from functional to dysfunctional? The cost, to the ENTIRE SOCIETY, of messing up people's lives is *prohibitive*. You have no idea.

by maxwell edison

Geesh - take your Danish, or Finnish, or whatever the hell it is outlook and shove it. I don't give a damn what you say or think, Ansu, and anyone around here who indulges you is foolish. A northern European idiot who comes across as though he's an expert on all things American. A bigot who thinks Fox News is the enemy. What a total idiot you are, Ansu. You must have a sad life to have the time - and desire - to post the crap you do all over the Internet. But then, it's fitting for a sad - and insignificant - little man from insignificant Nordic Europe.

And truth be told, you know nothing. How many times, for example, have you spouted off about [i]"Fox News"[/i] and how much influence it wields with those on the right? Too many to count. But I wonder if Fox News' measly one million viewers (as compared to the 23 million who watch CBS, NBC, and ABC) really stretches all the way across the Atlantic? I think not. At best, the European News outlets would only provide a brief "sound bite" from Fox News from time to time. Which means Ansu formed his opinion about Fox news either on a few sound bites or from repeating what others have said. I suspect the latter. Proves Ansu spouts off on things about which he knows absolutely nothing.

How's it feel to be seen as so insignificant, Ansu? An insignificant little man with an insignificant and uninformed opinion from an insignificant, out of the way country. I just laugh at you.

by ansugisalas

and it doesn't take a computer.

If you really wanted to drag in the Libertarian perspective you could have easily done so. All it would have taken was to acknowledge that Walmart is abusing the system, and that not having the system would force Walmart to pay their workers a living wage.

But you didn't do that. I wonder why.

by hal 9000

Just that it was announced around the same time he was sworn in and it just may have been Clinton getting his own back on the incoming Administration.

I would however suggest you look at a BBC Series called Yes Minister and then Yes prime Minister. In that you'll see a perfect example of who runs the system and while the Politicians make the finial decisions their options are limited by those who tell them what it is that they can and can not do. And because the Population want the Process of Government to continue even during a change of Government it's most defiantly not going to change any time soon if ever. ;)

As for the Population being aphetic that is one thing and the system that you have there for actually voting where there are no National Standards and hours of queuing to vote is more an indictment on just how poor the system or as I should say Different Systems actually are. It's neither normal or necessary in any part of the world except the USA. The Electoral Commissions are so grossly underfunded and underresourced that it's way beyond a joke and except for developing countries doesn't happen anywhere else in the world.

As an Aside I was with some friends a couple of nights ago who are part of Doctors Without Borders and because of the US's abysmal Child Birth and Infant Mortality Statistics they are considering setting up services for those areas of Obstetrics in the USA as the Governments both State and Federal and Statutory Authorities are incapable of offering the most basic service to the citizens. They actually suggested that the Food Stamp Program needs to be radically expanded to cut back the Infant Mortality Rates as well which is something I found difficult to actually believe but unfortunately the Statistics speak for themselves.

The USA has the worst Child Birth/Infant Mortality Rates in the Developed World and over the past 20 years those Rates have got worse which is a very sad indictment on your country.

Col

by av .

We never could compete with it because its cheaper and companies definitely still get tax breaks for doing it. There still are jobs here though, its just a more competitive environment.

Forget Walmart or McDonalds. Small business is the best way to get some good experience on which you can build a future. Obama's plan to tax people making $200k per year will likely kill small business growth though. Many small businesses are taxed on the personal level and not at a corporate tax rate.

AV

by nicknielsen

Since those costs are distributed over hundreds of meals sold, I shouldn't think they would need to raise prices that drastically. Heck, over the past year or so, prices at most of the places I eat lunch have gone up a good bit. I used to be able to get out of Subway, Atlanta Bread, or Panera for about $6-7dollars; now, I'm lucky if I can do it for under $9, and that's usually getting the cheapest sandwiches.

by nicknielsen

But most of those small businesses are incorporated in some manner: LLC or S corp, usually. And the proprietor of every one of those businesses can deduct everything he or she puts back into the business. Payroll, equipment, supplies, franchise fees, real property costs, whatever, are all deductible from gross receipts.

I did it for years as a softball umpire. Everything I spent relative to officiating–travel costs, uniform costs, equipment costs, meals, etc.–was deducted from gross receipts, and usually reduced the net taxable to 10% or so of gross, sometimes to even less than that. Didn't usually even affect my tax bracket.

And regardless what many say, outside specialty businesses, the pay at most small businesses usually sucks, even for the owner.

by nicknielsen

It's a hell of a lot more fiscally responsible than the borrow and spend practices of the Bush administration.

I'm still trying to figure out how Republicans–the party of 'fiscal responsibility'–became the spendthift children they are today.

by ansugisalas

If a person is making 200k they're not in any trouble, financially, right?
If they want to avoid a tax for going over that take, they can hire more people. Most small business owners are caught in the "why should I hire someone to do what I can do myself for free" thinking.
They overlook the fact that it's not for free. It takes their effort, and the business owner's efforts should be worth quite a lot.
So, many people actually hurt their own businesses by trying to do everything themselves.
Time spent balancing the books or writing letters or mowing the lawn could be better spent looking after customers or drumming up new ones or straightening out sub-optimal business practices.

by hal 9000

Are places like Donald Trump not real Small Business with the computer shop down the road run by a guy who has no staff and lots of bills.

How any politician could say with a straight Face that people like Trump where Small Business is so far beyond belief that they are obviously treating their potential electors like the complete idiots that they actually are to believe stuff like that.

Col

by ansugisalas

[b][i]Mark my word, if and when these preachers get control of the [Republican] party, and they're sure trying to do so, it's going to be a terrible damn problem. Frankly, these people frighten me. Politics and governing demand compromise. But these Christians believe they are acting in the name of God, so they can't and won't compromise. I know, I've tried to deal with them.
.....
The religious factions that are growing throughout our land are not using their religious clout with wisdom.... I'm frankly sick and tired of the political preachers across this country telling me as a citizen that if I want to be a moral person, I must believe in 'A,' 'B,' 'C,' and 'D.' Just who do they think they are?... I will fight them every step of the way if they try to dictate their moral convictions to all Americans in the name of "conservatism."[/b]

- Barry Goldwater, (19091998), five-term US Senator, Republican Party nominee for President in 1964*, Maj. Gen., US Air Force Reserves, author of The Conscience of a Conservative.[/i]

Preachers know all about spending other people's money on pig-headed crusades... that is their purpose in life, after all.

Not being willing to compromise always means running up the expenses.

by hal 9000

Yes most certainly those jobs are still funded by Tax payers but would you really have it any other way?

Part of the Government Job is to provide Security to the Citizens and I have yet to see anyone in the US claim otherwise. If they where to it would simply mean that the Government isn't responsible for Security and there is no need for the Military and associated hardware used to defend the General Population.

What I do find more than a bit troubling is how the Military Outsources Jobs to the Private Sector who have the idea that [b]Near Enough is Good Enough[/b] for the Military and [b]We'll Fix it in the Field.[/b] Neither of those is what any serving Military person wants to experience because it means that they are dead and the Country has lost a lot of money with it's investment in that Serving Military Person.

For way too long the Military has been propping up a [b]Substandard Private Sector[/b] who really doesn't deserve any support. While it is true that the Private Sector can do it cheaper it is also true that they simply don't. They charge as much as they can and provide as little as possible to meet the specification that was asked for, many times actually not even meeting the Minimum Specs.

Look at the history of any Major Private Sector Military Project and tell me it isn't so. ;)

The Tea Party People on the other hand would have you believe that those Weapons should be funded by a [b]User Pays System[/b] so they effectively want those who would attack the US to pay for the Weapons that the US stockpiles to defend itself. Imagine the scene well you are naughty and we are going to nuke you so please provide the $20,000,00.00 for the cost of the ICBM that we will have to use to kill you lot. If you don’t pay we’ll leave you alone to do what you like and we’ll just ignore you as you are unwilling to pay for what we would use to destroy you.

Sounds nice in Theory but is completely ridicules to any sane person. Of course the last bit of that isn’t spoken about it’s just User Pays which sounds great till it’s actually tested. ;)

Col

by ansugisalas

Nothing wrong with taxation as such.
Nothing wrong with spending as such.
It's [b]only[/b] the tea party and other wingnuts that think [b]any[/b] taxation is too much, or that [b]any[/b] spending is too much.
Borrowing has its place, taxation has its place and spending, obviously, has its place. Only damned fools say otherwise.

This discussion is closed to new replies.