Discussion Locked

President Obama is doing a grave disservice by. . . . . .

0 helpful
416 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

416 replies

by maxwell edison

.....I wonder how much of it is symbolism instead of substance.

I've always thought that the best way to reign in the federal government would be for the individual states to do whatever they can to take back their power - to opt out, so to speak.

The federal tax code is the first thing that would have to be addressed - or ignored. When there starts to be serious discussion, and enough support to repeal the 16th amendment, then I'll believe there's real substance to a [i]States Rights[/i] movement.

by dhcdbd

That they were more about secession than about states rights.

The Civil war was about secession and not slavery as many believe. That war was to prove succession was not possible.

by tonythetiger

the tenth amendment. That indicates to me that these states think that the federal government is imposing on or interfering with them in ways it has no right to, and are voicing their displeasure via legislation.

It is encouraging in that it appears that a (growing) number of people beginning to assert themselves in this government "of the people, by the people, and for the people".

The point is not to secede and start another civil war. It is to clarify just who is supposed to be working for whom... that the Federal government was created by the states; it is an agent of the states; and it is ultimately answerable to the states.

by oz_media

Similar to the flag of hope that Obama has been waving?

If you really dig through the docs, they are all so mighty and exclusive, until the exclusions are noted.

It is seen to apply for all issues not outlined in the Constutution, and even then VERY finitely defined as to the boundaries that afford a sovreign state ability to act on its own accord.

Judging by replies I've seen here in the last 8 or so years, your constitution applies to everything from waking up in the morning to farting at noon. You apply your constitution in such blanket form and redefine the rules as needed to fit a given scenario.

With such loose and vaguely applied constitutional rights, the government would be able to negate just about any opposition to its decisions based on a variance of constitutional verbage.

Good luck with that, it seems like the states are at least tryign to appear to be independent or retain some form of independence in the divided states of America, however it all reads as just fartign in the wond to create some form of public support that the state is on teh people's side. When denied change it is the nasty government's fault for repressing them, not the state's for not acting out to retain independence. State politicians look grand and gain support, 'maybe next time', while teh government looks mean and unweiding, set on removing your rights as Americans.

It's only missing teh cheerleaders. "Go get 'em senator, keep our state independent!"

"We stand together and don't give a f**k!
If Obama's president we're sh*t out of luck!"

Like I said, sounds nice and all, but how effective is it without actually gaining full sovreignity as a state? It is too easy to drill down on loosely applied terminology when it is restricted by very tightly defined legislation and a vaguely applied constitution tha covers anything they want it to for the day's benfit

by tonythetiger

As most of these bills were introduced as far back as 8 months ago.

[i]Like I said, sounds nice and all, but how effective is it without actually gaining full sovreignity as a state?[/i]

They don't need full sovereignty to make a stand. They only need to act in concert, recall their senators, thereby preventing the federal legislature from passing a single law! Not saying that's what they're planning... but that they can, if they want, bring Washington DC to a screeching halt.

by delbertpgh

Seceding ain't an option, not even in the Constitution, as those guys are wont to argue. The Civil War (where the secessionists lost) pretty well settled that.

by notsochiguy

I was having a discussion about this with some buddies of mine prior to the UFC show this past Saturday.

The optimist in me hopes that this does help usher in a new age of self-reliance. That people finally 'get it' that no one is going to care more about them then themselves; and that they start acting accordingly. However, I can't help but have this sense of dread; that the nation is being setup to become even more dependent on the government.

Hopefully, this is unfounded paranoia brought on by being a fan of too many dystopian books & films.

by oz_media

My home country was established through many years of very brutal war of atrition, raping, pillaging of villages.

A King ruled the nation and goverened the people.

But this is 2009, times change and the people should change with the times.

You state that the USA was founded as a nation of [i]self-governing people,[/i]which I couldn't possibly object to.

But that was over 200 years ago and this is 2009. Your government has done as IT seems fit, as IT deems correct and simply 'insists' on the atonement of the people who oppose and instills fear into those who are to be easily led.

That is NOT a nation of self-governance. No mater how much you like to hang onto outdated but conveniently selective dogma (I don't see you justifying and hanging onto the slavery which helped build your nation).

No matter how much you insist that was your nations foundation, it is NO MORE.

You are a country goverened by elected leaders, the only way your ideal of self-governing can even be believed is if each and every action of the government falls in line with your own and every other Americans ideals of perfect government.

Of course such an event would only be pure fluke, absolute one in a million and you have a better chance of winning a million from Regis. So, forget this self governing nation shite,its pure, 100% garbage that only an American could be lead to actually believe.

I honestly don't think you even buy it yourself, you are far too politically astute to deem yourself self governing, but you must parrot it in order to sound like a true patriotic American I suppose.

I recognize that I can't go and claim land on horseback with sword drawn, or while swinging a mace, but that's how my nation was founded. Is it just the nice, convenient history you like to hang onto.

If your nation was not goverened by a single, independent body, which didn't always go with the people's view, you'd have perished centuries ago to armies/navies that were properly goverened and not just a motley crue of self righteous warriors.

In Canada, I can't ride into Chilliwack Indian reservation and shoot Indians until I have enough land to build a home, but that's the foundation of the nation, why can't THAT be continued, even if only by tradition?

Times change, just like everything else our nations were built upon, you can't simply hang onto the past that seems grand, hopeful and righteous while dismissing the bad.

America today is not even a vague reflection of what America once was, whether that is good or bad is not the point I'm trying to make though, that was then and this is now.

Look around you! You are NOT, by any means, self governing; that right has been taken away from you, deal with what you have now instead and realize that you, are no different, better or worse, than any other free nation on the planet.

You have the same deal everyone has, a bunch of liars and cheats that spend your tax money by the trillion in order to achieve their own agenda and hopefully it suits yours too, in some haphazard way.

Hey they created the marketplace, economy and jobs, now they take your money to suit their agenda, governing your people in the process.

Why dont you express concern about our government? Because they lay down and spread wide for YOUR government. If they opposed your government, you would be talking about invading Canada again.

God, even not tagging along into Iraq gets the 'you are either with us or against us' shite thrown at us.

Why do I express concern about YOUR government? Your government, has a great deal of global influence, due to your constant need for world resources. This creates a need for American money as it has become the chosen currency of global trade, for more than just oil.

Segue: In my business, I importa great deal of product that originates in China. But I have ot pay duty and brokerage on everything, meaning I cannot compete with US businesses that ship to Canada.

So why do I need to buy Chinese products from the USA? Because China likes American dollars and they sell to US distributors, instead of Canadians directly. Just an example of how your dollar is now a global currency and why YOUR politics concern me and effect Canadians.

The stupid decisions of your government place others in danger.

When was the last time Canada's political moves on a foreign field endangered Americans?

by oz_media

One of the much younger crazy old uncles here anyway.

Most of these guys on TR trump me in age, which mean that there is hope for both our nations if we can educate our young instead of filling them with outdated political dogma, like having them believe that their country is governed by the people, most high school kids wouldn't be stupid enough to buy that garbage.

Many Americans mock England having a queen. But that is more tradition and history than governing these days. Sure Canada has an AG that acts on behalf of the queen, but she doesn't run government.

However, you hang onto history as with some shred of hope that it will save you in the 21st century, and we are suppose to accept that.

by oz_media

I didn't realize he was a Dem, not that either party has my support anyway.
To suggest that the simian loser did not do the same is just being ignorant, blind or naiive.

Of course, when it is aimed at a republican, it is easily explained and defended, when aimed at a democrat it is an accurate political analysis.

An exmaple of Democrats [i]"giving hope preaching imminent disaster"[/i]

On Iraq: [u][b]THE DOOM[/b][/u]

"All free nations have a stake in preventing sudden and catastrophic attack."

"If this threat is permitted to fully and suddenly emerge, all actions, all words, and all recriminations would come too late,"

"Trusting in the sanity and restraint of Saddam Hussein is not a strategy, and it is not an option."

"If this is not evil, then evil has no meaning,"

[b][u]THE HOPE[/b][/u]

"Our mission in Iraq is clear. We're hunting down the terrorists. We're helping Iraqis build a free nation that is an ally in the war on terror. We're advancing freedom in the broader Middle East. We are removing a source of violence and instability, and laying the foundation of peace for our children and our grandchildren."

(A little slapstick from GWB)
"We would help Iraqis hold free elections by January 2005." LOL :D

On Iran: [b][u] THE DOOM[/u][/b]

"President Bush warned today that Iran remained a threat despite an intelligence assessment that it had halted a covert program to develop nuclear weapons four years ago"

[b][u]THE HOPE[/b][/u]

Diplomatic efforts to defuse the Iran nuclear crisis must be given every chance, President Bush said Friday.

On economy: [b][u]THE DOOM[/u][/b]

"Without immediate action by Congress, American could slip into a financial panic and a distressing scenario would unfold,"

[i]Action by congress? Isn't that against American ideals of freedom and self governing?[/i] I suppose not when it coems to GWB though.

"Ultimately, our country could experience a long and painful recession...We must not let this happen."

[u][b]THE HOPE[/b][/u]
"Facing the prospect of a financial collapse, we took decisive measures to safeguard our economy,"

Damn dems!

And here's a great quote by an elected leader of a free nation who prides themselves (yes, you were all spoken for) on being built upon a successful history self governance.

[i][b]"You may not agree with some of the tough decisions I've made, but I hope you agree that I made some tough decisions."[/i][/b] GWB 2009

by maxwell edison

Of course, what else is new?

And, of course, you conveniently overlooked when I said this:

[i]My fear is that self-governing is giving way (or already has given way) to a political-class.

by oz_media

Have you done similar digging over the last 20 or so years to see how many times similar petitions have been put forth or acted upon? or is this a first, therefore it seems unique?

I'm definitely not calling you a liar, Tony or takign you to task on your digging. I'm just wondering how much relevance is there. People petition and protest all the time to little or no avail. Is this really new or just more of the same political posturing that all nations face?

by tonythetiger

there have been lots of protests, but not often does an entire state do such. Off hand I know Georgia and California have done it, but those were clearly protests... sort of a 'no confidence vote' against something the Fed did. It's not a new right.... States have always had it... the legislation is just a notice that those states may intend to exercise that right.

Relevance? I don't know yet. Right now it's merely curious that several states would do it in seemingly close proximity time-wise.

If it would grow to a majority, we might be getting a feeling that something's definitely afoot. If it grows to a super-majority (38), It would be a fair bet that something historic is about to occur.

It's way too soon to start getting excited though.

by oz_media

I must question "several states would do it..." I understand what you're getting at, but I wonder if such petitions are placed when new presidents take office, just to show a clear viewpoint of the state.

Sorta like when i move to a new employer, the first things that I do is have my lawyer run through their contract, edit and request amendment to their non-compete (which is always some US contract downloaded online that doesn't apply by BC Law unless amended).

It's a formality to let the employer know I am going to work within my rights and that I understand my employee rights, often better than the employer.

I am wondering if this posturing is common for a state that may lean the other way (Dem or Repub) in order to identify the fact that they are not just blind followers of the existing government but understand and will exercise such individual rights if needed.

Again I am not contesting what you have posted, it is clear, the language is as concise as a legal document can be and very finitely defined.

They illustrate that while they know they understand they have little freedom to act independently, that there are exceptions and they may choose to exercise independence outside of common restrictions.

It seems like posturing to say, "hey, we don't like the current government's aims and if we are pushed we'll find a way out."

I could be wrong, but it really looks like a very common way of setting the ground rules that a lot of companies do with employee contracts too. "I know my rights, I know YOUR rights, now lets move forward and keep that in mind to avoid issues."

by oz_media

in fact I think your comment is exactly what spurred mine. A 'young' political class, one with the ability to think in modern political terms and not simply parrot ancient speeches, one liners from past presidents and hang on to outdated dogma.

A fresh new look at the world would be very refreshing from America. I see it on some forums, and it rears its pretty head here sometimes, but then the old codgers get in line and start telling the punk kids to go do their homework.

Time will do its job and then THEY will be the old codgers telling the NEW young punks to do their homework too.

I hate being seen as an old fart, 40 in a few weeks, and that's still very young in my mind (of course it is young to ME). But I look at the youth of today and try not to frown or sigh, they do things differently, well my generation did things differently too and so will the next and so on and so on.

I welcome young minds and inexperience to the table, it just sucks that I have to pass on the baton too them instead of joining them.

Can you imagine what a cool place Iraq would be if there were no elders to drag up antiquated religious and cultural crap that slows down progress? Look at Dubai, some extremely rich, hip Arab decided HE wanted a big flashy city too and viola, instant metropolis!
If you haven't been to Dubai yet, it REALLY is worth the visit. An incredibly beautiful place especially for a dust bowl that makes you realize just how pi$$ poor you really are. When I was there, it was really just getting started, but now it is insane! My buddy just got back a month or two ago and I didn't even recognize places I'd been in his pics, as everything else has grown around it now.

Now lets get that same progression mentality all over the middle East and we are getting somewhere....ooops, that would be spreading OUR values and culture upon them though, one reason we are at war today.

I guess its up to them then.

Youth, who needs them? WE DO!

Look at the EU, youths make it what it is today; an incredible, free continent. The remnants of WWI and II are still all over the place, bunkers still exist, pillboxes on cliffs are everywhere, as a quiet and almost haunting reminder of what war really does to a country. Just enough to keep the youth of today thanking their forefathers for the freedoms they have today, but still reminding foreign visitors that while they were t war, we are all the same, humans trying to live in peace and enjoy our lives. Its amazing how people in Germany welcome people from England with open arms, and usually a cold beer.

P.S. there's a difference in exposing reality and mocking. Its only mocking when your OWN false reality is exposed.

by maxwell edison

The key is to shut your mouth and open your ears (and mind). But you never will - your mouth won't allow it.

You're actually worse than the people you criticize - much worse.

Damn, Oz, your head is so far up your butt that you could blow your nose from the inside.

by jck

[i]The glass house is that you have expressed your own opinion.[/i]

This doesn't qualify alone as a glass house, and Oz neither glorified nor imposed superiority of his government or people over anyone's. If anything, he denounced his government as full of miscreants, and his people as being lackadaisical in just voting more of the like into place.

Therefore, his house in my estimation isn't made of glass.

[i]Dialog is a two way affair, not the practice of "Only my opinion counts."[/i]

If this is true, then many of the people on here are having one-way affairs.

Many people see their point of view on government as being "what would cure the problem" and not a point of discussion and discovery.

[i]Now please, for the good of the world, quit being dense.[/i]

Actually, Oz makes more sense than some here. At least, Oz makes references to direct points and gives valid comparison to others points of argument.

Just because he is passionate about his stance, others attack him.

Of course, there are those here who that espouse to be a follower of the teachings of the framers of our country's founding.

But if they really read much about Jefferson, Washington, Adams, and the like, they would know how passionate those men were in their pursuit to build a country that would escape the policy and beliefs of eliteism instilled into government.

And, believed that a government of the people, by the people, and for the people was what works best....not just would be good for some of the people.

by oz_media

Reply to a comment with flames and nothing to counter my comments or offer an alternate view.

Eloquent and well spoken to say the least, thank you for your insight!

Are you new to this now?

by oz_media

Honestly, I scoured through three or four, mainly the exceptions and understanding of restrictions (that's where contracts make the most sense and the truth behind the aim is seen). For example, a contract can be very open and seemingly fair. But then in the details you see things like, 'agreeing that the restrictions stated are fair and just and waiving a right to seek further action. etc.'

So while it seems one you really have nothing to stand on if there are issues, in Canada such a document cannot ask you to waive such personal rights, if you sign it and it hits a court, the judge will dismiss it immediately. However it happens and is applied in US courts quite often, where "Signing your life away" or your Constitutional rights is actually possible.

It just really seems like political posturing to gain favour of the people, while the document itself is very tightly defined and does not offer the state quite the 'freedom of choice' that it appears to offer. There are a lot of acknowledgments and exceptions listed that seem to knowingly negate many of the previous terms.

by jck

Here's a fire blanket for you in your time of fiery endurance :^0

by dhcdbd

However my position is based on things outside of this thread.

I do not do to others if it is avoidable, and will not tolerate being unnecessarily flamed. In real life, he and I would have had a knock down drag out. This is online, so the best thing to do is ignore any comment he directs at me or something I post.

In the posts since then, he has calmed his stance and makes much more sense. Yes, I am trying to figure him out at this point.

by jck

we have already tried having no perfect government...kinda like Zaphod Beeblebrox had no tea. :^0

by jck

[i]However, the alternative to predicting a doom and gloom outlook is not necessarily claiming everything is lollipops, roses and butterflies - especially from a guy who's ONLY political platform was change and hope[/i]

Since when is saying that your political and fiscal policy as part of a presidential campaign "...claiming everything is lollipops, roses and butterflies...".

And, wasn't it Bush who was saying positives about situations when they were really not the truth?

Maybe Obama is just stating the truth now, and after 8 years of Bush propaganda (to quote Nicholson in A Few Good Men).... "you can't handle the truth".

[i]You don't give people hope by preaching imminent disaster - something the Democrats ALWAYS do, so there's no change there. Moreover, in my opinion, it's actually a part of the problem - consumer confidence, lending confidence, etc. He's not doing anyone any favors.[/i]

And you don't lead a nation by giving false feelings and half truths about the current state of things. We've had 8 years of that.

Examples? Ok:

[i]"I strongly believe he was trying to reconstitute his nuclear weapons program."[/i] - President Bush with Tony Blair present to discuss the War on Terrorism, White House, 7/17/2003

He believed in it, even though the intelligence community had told him there was no proof as well as months of UN Inspections for months before the war was starts having shown absolutely zero proof of it. So, he basically believed what he wanted to in his own head there.

Next example:

[i]"We recently found two mobile biological weapons facilities which were capable of producing biological agents."[/i] - Statement by President Bush to troops in Qatar, White House, 6/5/2003

He decided (along with his speech writers) that these trailers were biological weapons facilities, even though the Defense Intelligency Agency had already concluded in a report that their purpose was most likely...to make hydrogen for artillery weather balloons.

Another example? OK:

[i]"I was pleased to receive the Energy Information Administration?s final report today, which includes U.S. greenhouse gas emissions for 2006. The final report shows that emissions declined 1.5 percent from the 2005 level, while our economy grew 2.9 percent. That means greenhouse gas intensity ? how much we emit per unit of economic activity ? decreased by 4.2 percent, the largest annual improvement since 1985. This puts us well ahead of the goal I set in 2002 to reduce greenhouse gas intensity by 18 percent by 2012."[/i]

What Bush failed to mention?

Improved weather patterns/conditions and higher energy prices were the real difference...not his "policies".

That is documented in the EIA's report that Bush quoted the parts he wanted to.

Another example of him misquoting/misleading the American people with half-truths and deception? Here's another:

[i]"Terrorists and extremists who are at war with us around the world are seeking to topple Iraq's government, dominate the region, and attack us here at home."[/i]

According to the CIA, there is only possible one, organized group linked to a world-wide terror network which is "Al-Qaeda Mesopotamia", and they say that their confidence in that link to the main group is "low". Another vague and misleading statement.

Most groups are just trying to run us out of their holy land, not "rule the region" in Iraq.

So if Obama is "...claiming everything is lollipops, roses and butterflies..."

Then Bush was selling his "beliefs" as the cure-all snake oil remedy for the world's woes.

I'd rather have Obama give us the straight truth, and a real direction to go with contingency plans for what to do if things stray.

Rather than having false hopes to be shattered when things don't happen as promised and we're unprepared for what's next when it does.

by maxwell edison

.....in HER reply, [i]Oh look..a pink butterfly just flew by..oh, and is raining lollipops !!!! yay..sweetness for all.[/i] (Read her entire message for proper context.)

I replied TO SHELLBOT regarding HER message, [i]"However, the alternative to predicting a doom and gloom outlook is not necessarily claiming everything is lollipops, roses and butterflies - especially from a guy who's ONLY political platform was change and hope."[/i]

Geesh!

As to the rest of your Bush-bashing message, what else is new?

You may now go back to your Obama worshiping.

by jck

It's respecting someone who will talk straight to you, and not dance around the subject.

He even said it himself:

[i]"I want to campaign the same way I govern, which is to respond directly and forcefully with the truth,"[/i]
- Barack Obama, 11/08/07

Some people appreciate leadership who isn't lying about circumstances or misleading them with half-truths into a false sense of security.

Guess I'm stupid for that, huh?

Edit: added example quote

by maxwell edison

That's exactly what President Obama is doing.

[i]This fearmongering may be good politics, but it is bad history and bad economics. It is bad history because our current economic woes don't come close to those of the 1930s. At worst, a comparison to the 1981-82 recession might be appropriate.....

Mr. Obama's analogies to the Great Depression are not only historically inaccurate, they're also dangerous. Repeated warnings from the White House about a coming economic apocalypse aren't likely to raise consumer and investor expectations for the future. In fact, they have contributed to the continuing decline in consumer confidence that is restraining a spending pickup. [/i]

- Mr. Bradley Schiller, an economics professor at the University of Nevada, Reno, is the author of "The Economy Today"

[i]President Obama is doing a grave disservice by his continued rhetoric on how bad the economy is and on how long it will take for recovery (years, not months) and by claiming that our economy is in the worst shape since the great depression.

The former will only serve to prolong the lagging economy, and, in essence, help this self-fulfilling prophecy become reality. The latter is simply a blatant lie, not even close to being true.

The prophecy of gloom and doom is alive and well. Instilling financial fear in people is not only doing them a grave disservice, but it will actually keep people and businesses from fully participating in the economy, thereby contributing to its further slide and making recovery more difficult.[/i]

-Maxwell Edison

You may not agree with me, jck, but economics professor Bradley Schiller does.

You may now return to your blind worship of Barack Obama.

by tonythetiger

[i]Isn't it worse that the Republicans want to implement tax cuts that majority benefit the top 20% of income levels in this country?[/i]

Because the top 20% don't pay their taxes. They include it in the cost of the goods and services their businesses sell. It's the people who buy those things who are really paying those taxes, and it is they who will benefit if we cut the tax the taxes on that group.

by jck

is a political tactic, and has been used in almost every presidential campaign and subsequent administration.

Hunting down (non-existent) weapons of mass destruction in Iraq?

Star Wars initiatives?

What spurred those? Wasn't a Coca-Cola ad, I can tell you that.

Is the economic crisis any less real? No.

Of course, Mr. Schiller doesn't point how things have changed.

Such as since the period of the 1987 problems with the market, they have implemented stop gaps to keep the market from free falling. 40% three-day declines are now, in essence, not allowed.

Therefore, the market could not get as bad as it was in 1929. As soon as the market falls a certain percentage, the system shuts down and everyone goes home.

Hence, you're never gonna see days like that again. To expect any economy to lose 25% of it's value in two days now is absurd and essentially an impossible action.

Are Obama's words destructive?

I guess that depends on your view of things.

I stand by the belief that if they indeed are so damaging to the already ailing economy, they still will never be any more destructive than the people who have been running the US Automakers and US Banks already have been to our country.

Only difference:

Obama compensation: $400k a year

Bankers: a lot more

What makes those running private industry so much more destructive than Obama? Actions like these:

Richard Fairbank, the chairman of Capital One Financial Corp., took a $1 million hit in compensation after his company had a disappointing year, but still got $17 million in stock options. The McLean, Va.-based company received $3.56 billion in bailout money Nov. 14.

John Thain, chief executive officer of Merrill Lynch, topped all corporate bank bosses with $83 million in earnings last year. Thain, a former chief operating officer for Goldman Sachs, took the reins of the company in December 2007, avoiding the blame for a year in which Merrill lost $7.8 billion. Since he began work late in the year, he earned $57,692 in salary, a $15 million signing bonus and an additional $68 million in stock options. Merrill Lynch got $10B.

At Bank of New York Mellon Corp., chief executive Robert Kelly's stipend for financial planning services came to $66,748, on top of his $975,000 salary and $7.5 million bonus. His car and driver cost $178,879. Kelly also received $846,000 in relocation expenses, including help selling his home in Pittsburgh and purchasing one in Manhattan, the company said.

Goldman Sachs' tab for leased cars and drivers ran as high as $233,000 per executive. The firm told its shareholders this year that financial counselling and chauffeurs are important in giving executives more time to focus on their jobs. Lloyd Blankfein, president and chief executive officer of Goldman Sachs, took home nearly $54 million in compensation last year. The company's top five executives received a total of $242 million. Goldman Sachs got $10B.

It is irresponsibility by arrogant, out-of-touch, and frankly inept executives that have caused this to happen. If they had any sort of commitment to their institutions and shareholders, they would have halted excessive spending and stabilized their own situations.

Hence, I don't think Obama's frankness about what can happen with the economy if things are not done right is not destructive.

It's a wake-up call to America to take notice and make sure things are done right.

Otherwise, we're all f-ed.

by jdclyde

As a US Senator, was he talking out against this in 05? 06?

Anywhere but on the campaign trail?

Did he talk about against the bad loans that were being handed out, that was the first domino to start falling?

Did he talk out against Fanny/freddy, or did he higher their old execs and take the MOST funding from them?

by geek3001

Personally I don't care for continued negativity at any level. State the facts as you see them, without sugar coating. Make suggestions as to what people at all levels can do. Provide examples of positive things that have been happening. Help people fight fear with hope.

Unfortunately, in President Obama's case, he's trying to get a semi-reluctant Congress to quickly act on things that might improve the economy. About the only tool he has to do this is using negativity to apply pressure on the Congress critters. (If they don't pass the bill of the moment, dire things will happen... Now where have we heard that before?)

The United States has become the Disunited States of the Party of Your Choice, with each party complaining about the actions of the other parties and rarely offering praise for things they may secretly like.

This culture of negativity extends beyond the President, Congress and various levels of government. It needs to stop before it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

Perhaps the negativity could be toned down if negative comments were sandwiched by positive ones. Several sources, from the Bible to Public Relations and Human Relations manuals talk about this technique for dealing with people. It could work at a higher level, with what President Obama is doing.

by jdclyde

things haven't changed since the election trail, yet he was "hope instead of fear".

Now that he is elected, he is hopeful that he can use fear to control.

by jdclyde

after all, Obama has ended the politics of fear and instead is leading us hopefully to "change".

Of course any thinking human realizes the only
"change" is what is left in our pockets.

Notice how many of his appointees backed out because of not paying their taxes? I thought it was Democrats that thought people should be paying MORE taxes, not cheating on their taxes?

by jck

Having one professor agree with you doesn't make you right.

At least, Schiller is an expert in economics. The last "expert" you quoted that I actually took the time to look up had a degree and experience in a totally different field.

Of course if having one professor is what validates your theories, then I must be irrefutable in my belief in Obama...since most of the participating voters in America voted for Obama like I did.

I'm sure if I wanted to take time, I could find an economics professor at a much more prestigious institution than UN-Reno in financial and socio-economic studies to counter your one reference.

As for lying and half-truths...you have no evidence that Obama's plans have not worked and that he lied about circumstances.

And why would that be?

Because...he is just signing them today...he's done nothing but state the truth about the economy being down...and you are too closed-minded and narrowly-focused on the hate of someone who is in power that doesn't share your ideologies enough that you don't even want to let the man have his legal and electorally-designated right to have his chance to try and fix our country.

Anyways...I will now gladly go back to the "blind worship of Barack Obama"...

And, you can go back to the self-indulgent art of contortionism you've mastered by patting yourself on the back and kissing your own arse so much here on TR.

by jck

should I rattle off the list of Congressmen, Governors, etc., that have not paid taxes in the last 5 years?

you'd be shocked. it's not just Democrats.

BTW...

If it's so bad that Democrats want people to pay more taxes to fund things in this country...

Isn't it worse that the Republicans want to implement tax cuts that majority benefit the top 20% of income levels in this country?

How do you think Americans can spend...if only the wealthy are getting tax breaks?

BTW...my proof that Bush's "middle-class tax cut" was a crock of $hit:

My income level stayed within $1000 of last years....

My refund went down over $600.

What's wrong with this picture?

I'm glad those trusty Republicans gave me a bigger tax break!

What a crock. Keep thinking Republicans are any better, and you'll get back in office what we just got rid of.

by jck

Because there was no "crisis" to talk out about...because it didn't exist when he became a US Senator, and had just started showing itself when he started his presidential campaign.

It became a major issue while he was on the campaign trail. That's why he talked about it.

As for hiring their old execs...do you know who hired those "execs"? That's right: The Bush Administration.

Who oversaw Fannie and Freddie for 8 years while this all happened? That's right: The Bush Administration.

Who was in control of the Federal government while this all went down and could have changed things, while Barack Obama was a state senator from Illinois who could do nothing at a Federal level from 2001-2005? That's right: The Bush Administration.

For someone who hates Obama for not taking initiative from a state senate seat, you sure let the people who were IN POWER in Washington have a free pass.

Why aren't you complaining about:

Bush doing nothing from 2001-2007 if it was so clear it would happen?

Bush doing nothing to change leadership and reform the system from 2001-2007 if it was so corrupt and bad?

The Republican controlled Congress from 2001-2006 for not changing the things you blame Clinton for doing when they had the power to do so?

See, you are trying to blame Obama for things he [b]COULD NOT CHANGE[/b] 2 and 3 and 4 years ago.

But, you are not asking "Why didn't Bush and the Republicans fix the problem?"

Again, your bias shows.

Blame those who had power when it could have been prevented, not those who inherited the problem.

by dwdino

The evidence begins to show. Now, with bill on desk for 3 days, our almighty change agent waits to sign the resurrection of the economy...

Hmmm, why don't you come down off that pedestal.

by jck

over the weekend...gee. I guess putting the brakes on a bill for a week to go to Crawford is okay?

You guys are really sad. You call him the messiah/almighty in sarcasm, then expect truly miraculous feats from the man.

Give him a break, since you haven't even given him 30 days to do his job he's been given 4 years to do by the American voters.

by jdclyde

you will realize that the housing crunch started YEARS ago, while Obama was becoming the single highest receiver of funds from Fanny.

And I am not giving Bush a pass, but this is not a discussion about Bush. ( I know you just can't get over it )

This is about Obama, what he has or hasn't done, and what he will or won't do.

Try to follow along with the adults if you wish to sit at the adult table.

You are so obsessed about Bush that you can't hold a single conversation without going back to him. I feel sad for you.

by jck

when you get your facts straight.

1st: you do favor Bush. you give him passes, and you have defended him when he has been more guilty of things you would hang (proverbially) Obama for.

2nd: the housing crunch started about May 2007. That's not quite 2 years ago. And I know, because that's about the time I was trying to get my house on the market. by the time i did (Sept 2007) it was too late. the housing market was in the $hitter.

Trust me on this one, jd...i have been looking to sell my house since late 2006. i could have sold then and there for 50% more than what my house is valued at now. i wish i would have.

3rd: If this is about what Obama [b]has done[/b] in regards to economic reform, he hasn't had time as president. Or are you saying all presidents should be able to solve their country's problems in the first 27 days of their term??

As a senator, he couldn't do anything. There were less than a majority of Democratic senators in the Senate in Jan 2005. Democrats (Obama being one of them) were [b]in the voting minority[/b]. Does that mean anything to you? Or, have you forgotten how voting works in the House and Senate? Republicans were the majority.

Hence, you should be asking "Why didn't the majority party in both houses of Congress do something to fix this, since they had the power?"

That's where your problem lies. You want to blame Obama for something he didn't and [b]could not have done[/b] anything about as a member of the [b]minority vote[/b].

God, and you think I'm stupid and infantile? Go back to 5th grade social studies, dude.

Finally:

Let's get one thing straight that was a typical bunch of political spin and misleading crap that you ate up like it was your mom's homecooking:

You are taking it for [b]FACT[/b] that Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae's contributions were contributions from "Freddie and Fannie".

let's clear that up:

Corporations (as you've implied with your insistent clamoring about it that Fanny and Freddie did) can [b]NOT[/b] give to candidates.

Those numbers, that you ate up from McCain's little diatribe like it was McDonalds and you were starving, were really the totalling of all employee donations. Yes, totals of employees who donated...individuals and their families...not the corporation.

And if you look closer at who the board of directors and their lobbyists (not technically employees of Freddie or Fannie)...and who they gave to...you know...those people who ran them into the ground that you blame Obama for?

Who did they donate to the most?

Barack Obama: $16,000
John McCain: $169,000

So it seems...those guys who ran Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae into the ground...were supporting...McCain???????

I guess Obama really had them in his hip pocket, huh? So much, they wanted McCain as president.

That makes total sense, jd.

And as for your assertion that he was getting all those guys who made Freddie and Fannie fail to run his campaign, that was another John McCain spin.

[i]"While Fannie and Freddie were working to keep Congress away from their house of cards, Senator Obama was taking their money. He got more, in fact, than any other member of Congress, except for the Democratic chairman of the committee that oversees them. And while Fannie Mae was betraying the public trust, somehow its former CEO had managed to gain my opponent's trust to the point that Senator Obama actually put him in charge of his vice presidential search."[/i]

-John McCain

However, the whole truth is:

Obama selected Jim Johnson, the chairman and CEO of Fannie Mae from 1991 to 1998, to advise him on his vice presidential choice. But Johnson resigned the unpaid position on June 11, 2008, months before vice-presidential nominee Joe Biden was chosen. Johnson resigned amid criticism of compensation and favorable mortgage terms he had received.

Did you know that? Obama's campaign had him "resign" cause he was questionable.

Not very upstanding of him to do that, huh?

See, you need to look at and explore the [b]WHOLE[/b] picture and truth, rather than just what someone spoon-feeds you, jd.

Seriously, take off the Republican-rose-colored glasses and take the real mindset of a true independent (as you claim to be).

Doubt all who have done wrong.

Give opportunity to do good for those who earnestly make the attempt.

Ignore their party.

by maxwell edison

The amount of one's refund is not an indicator of the amount of one's taxes paid.

When tax laws change, whether the rates go up or down, witholding rules and amounts also change, and payment rules and amounts change for the self-employed.

The only thing a tax refund shows is the amount of the interest free loan one made to the government.

by jdclyde

well, for the people that pay taxes. For the others is was just one more welfare check.

This coming "stimulus" has very little to do with stimulating the economy, and most won't take effect for another YEAR.

But it sure has a lot of backdooring of socializing medical that could never pass in real legislation.

by dwdino

...stay on track. Your tangents grow tiresome. The bill was pressed for with the utmost urgency. The pressure from the top down was unrelenting.

If I had pushed for a Ferrari and received a call that the keys were ready, I would be there immediately.

So I ask, if this bill will save our economy and is Obama's desire, why has he delayed so long in signing?

by geek3001

The use of 'fear control' will probably change when there is positive news to report. I suspect that the President and his team are very much aware of how negativity is hurting their party and the country.

With positive news, the President will be able to use hope as a form of control.

by geek3001

I'm an optimist and a realist.

Negativity may be one of the few ways to get people to realize that we're dealing with a complex and serious problem and a lot of hard choices will need to be made. There are too many people out there that expect 'instant' solutions and will grumble if they don't get results now.

But as positive signs of recovery appear, he can play the 'hope' card again and show that changes are being made and those changes are having results.

by jck

Yep, and I guess that's a bad thing that they are breaking it down over a 2 year period, especially the forecast is about another year of down market before we see a turn-around.

I guess just throwing all the money at the problem at once is gonna solve everything, right JD?

If that worked in real life as much as it does in your head, parents would more often take 18 years of allowance and give it to their kids at age 5 or 6 all at once and say "Okay...go have fun".

But like kids, most Americans aren't reasonable enough to take a large, lump sum amount and do what's right with it. They tend to get huge chunks of cash and go "Well I could pay a bill off...but I'm gonna splurge on a new ...insert unneeded item here...!"

And again, you're not even giving the plan an opportunity. You are shooting it down before it even gets a chance to work.

Surprisingly and to the polar opposite, you still think (like others here) that trickle-down Reaganomics will work to get our country out of a rut when it did nothing more in the 1980s than level off the economy and put us in our worst national debt...until the point that Dubya took over.

I suppose we should just go with the Republican ideology and keep handing banks and auto companies money and let them be trusted to not lose that money too, right?

by jck

let me spoon-feed you the answers...

It seems that Obama had plans to go back to Chicago that day, and was already back in Chicago, spending time with his family (and Valentine's Day with his wife) and what not when Congress finally decided to pass the legislation that night.

You see...Washington DC is on the east coast, and Chicago sits in the middle of the country...and there's this thing called distance...and it means he couldn't just have the courier bring it from capitol hill to the oval office for him to sign...cause he wasn't there!

OH WAIT! Both Houses of Congress could have the legislation taken to him. But did they? Why, no they didn't. I guess Obama should have flown right back Valentine's day to sign it, rather than Congress sending it via courier to be signed ASAP.

See, it's really simple. And if you'd read about where Obama was and how they were not sure the bill would pass on Friday or not...Obama can't be expected to stay in DC while they hmmm-hawww and maybe get it done when he has other arrangements made. And, Congress could have had the legislation delivered by courier, or members from both sides could have taken it to him (as has been done before on occassion) to be signed.

As for tangents: it's not a tangent. it's a comparison as to how you are attacking Obama and his rather short track record for only the negatives you want to see, yet are not willing to point out that other presidents before have not pushed Congress to move this quickly before in times of economic downturns.

Give the guy some credit. He's actually doing a good job getting things moving and working with both parties to try and get our country moving again.

It's a lot more than Bush did to bring unity...at least until the point that he had to when Congress was taken control of by the Democrats and had to work with them.

by dwdino

I am aware of these facts.

The point remains, he pushes expectations he doesn't maintain. Apparently this measure is not that important to act upon.

I will give him credit when his choices and directives reap benefits, not just for being eloquant.

And unity, please... So we all decide to get in a car and drive over a cliff, yet the one who refused to go along is belittled!? Thank you, but no.

by jck

a president using "fear control".

case in point? this statement by a former president (which ended up being totally untrue):

State of the Union Address, Jan. 28, 2003: "The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa."

Yes, the famous 16-word phrase proven a total lie and some "fear control" that was used to force the hand of Congress to fund what the president wanted: money for the Iraq war.

Our former president stated those words, despite the fact he knew for a year that they weren't true. Former Ambassador Joseph Wilson, after a CIA-sponsored Feb. 2002 trip to Niger to investigate the allegation, reported back finding no such uranium connection between Saddam and Africa.

Is that not fear control too?

Sure as hell is.

by jdclyde

for admitting this was fear control "too".

My point entirely, and I am so revealed that even you see he has moved away from "hope instead of fear" to "fear".

by jck

you are "revealed" to see what you want.

Obama has not gone strictly to a message of only fear mongering (which...yes...is what Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and (by force) Powell did)...but he is telling you the brutal, honest truth...he just does it more eloquently than I would.

I would say it like this:

"Times suck right now. And, it doesn't look like it's getting better anytime soon unless the American people get their head out of their butt, make Congress pass a plan that helps America, and then get out there and work to make it happen. Otherwise, we're in the $hitter."

You just only want to see the negative "the economy is as bad as the great depression" but don't want to see the ", but we can turn it around if we get appropriate legislation enacted to help Americans get work and turn things around".

As long as you only keep reading and quoting singular lines from quotes from his entire speeches, you will only see the negativity in it.

Or, maybe the sugar fed half-truths just have you spoiled still.

I dunno. It's clear as day to me: the guy is giving us the brutal truth...the economy sucks...it's gotta be fixed...let's do it and do it right.

by jck

[i]The point remains, he pushes expectations he doesn't maintain. Apparently this measure is not that important to act upon.[/i]

Was Congress going to stay there all weekend and wait until he signed it, just in case he vetoed it so they could work on it further?

No.

So, there was no double standard. Congress headed home after they were done, and wouldn't have adjourned til after the holiday either if he had vetoed it.

Period.

[i]I will give him credit when his choices and directives reap benefits, not just for being eloquant. [/i]

But until then, you will only spin negativity about his plan?

Wait, you put him down for being negative about the current, factual economic conditions.

But, you will put him down for a plan you don't know will work or not?

[i]And unity, please... So we all decide to get in a car and drive over a cliff, yet the one who refused to go along is belittled!? Thank you, but no.[/i]

Where's the cliff? You are foreshadowing doom and gloom AGAIN, when you haven't given his plan the opportunity to work.

See. You damn him for doing it on TV, but you'll get in here in a public forum that 1,000s of people read and down his plan like it will only drive us further into financial hades.

Good job...nice hypocrisy lesson there. We'll have to implement that into schools next year as "theory of hypocrisy 101" :^0

by oz_media

You commented that all the great leaders have been able to make necessary changes in order to achieve their goals, obviously including altering those goals as time progresses.

However there was one great leader, who did not show any variance or ability/desire to change his strategy to suit the events of the day.

One great leader changed his focus a few times to his benefit and then became mad with an STD that he had carried for a few decades before. He then stood fast with his focus and took on an undying quest that was argued against by most of his top military leaders, to the point of them trying to assassinate him before removing themselves completely from his command.

And Hitler WAS a great leader at one time, unfortunately he lost it (went mad due to syphillis) and decided he wanted Stalingraad at all costs, much to his dismay and arguments of his leaders, they were decimated and the Nazis lost that battle too.

Had he not already lost his quest to conquer Britain, losing most of his once mighty Luftwaffe, and had he not lost the battle for Stalingrad, he would have had full strength of his 6th army, which would have REALLY changed how effective events after D-Day were. In fact they may have even thwarted the invasion altogether, as was nearly the case anyway.

Allies were successful despite countless planning and execution mistakes during D-Day and much of this was because they refused to change their plans and adjust to the changes of the battlefield. Had Hitler not have had a single focus of taking Stalingrad, he would have been an even mightier opponent to deal with and things just may have been quite different.

The only thing he had left was the smaller countries he had conquered in his quest to dominate Europe, which had failed long before D-Day.

by jdclyde

is Obama has been saying this is an emergency situation and HAS to be dealt with ASAP.

Weekends, Presidents day, Valentines day, sure, those are all more pressing, now.

And as his family is now living in the white house, how could anything be more important back in Chicago?

Wasted time, as you, the great republican, will hear no ill of Obama.

by maxwell edison

I don't care who it is or, unlike you, which party. There are simply too many people, myself included, who think that the wrong way to fix the economy is by what he's doing: adding a trillion dollars to the deficit in one year; adding three trillion dollars to the deficit over three years; putting the country in deeper debt; growing the size and scope of government; not addressing the 60+ trillion in future obligations; etc.

And you really need to let go of your tiresome fall-back position criticizing Bush and demonizing [i]the rich[/i]. Bush is gone. Get over it. You hate [i]the rich[/i]. Okay, we get it.

But you just don't get it. It's not about person or party. It's about bankrupting our country. Bush did a lousy job with fiscal discipline, but Obama is apparently doing even worse. This one porkulus bill will spend as much money in one year as the whole seven years of the war combined. It will grow our debt to a frightening degree; and it's reckless and irresponsible.

I would say that they're recklessly spending money like drunken sailors - but I have too much respect for drunken sailors to insult them in such a way.

By the way, I criticize not only Presidents Bush and Obama for showing fiscal irresponsibility, but their idiot accomplices in Congress as well.

by tonythetiger

It's going to get much larger as our currency devalues. In five years dollars will be worth less than pesos unless federal spending is drastically cut. And I mean by 80% or more!

by tonythetiger

It's GOING to recover regardless of what Obama or Congress does or doesn't do. The only thing they can do is affect how fast the recovery happens. They know this, and they also know that after the recovery starts, they will be able to take credit, either for their "action" or for their "restraint". Either way,they're going to take credit for what WE do.

That's politics... boo to all of them.

by tonythetiger

[i]But like kids, most Americans aren't reasonable enough to take a large, lump sum amount and do what's right with it. [/i]

"Right" in whose opinion? Who should decide what's "right" for me to do with my money?

(Maybe I'll buy more ammo with mine... Is that OK with you?)

by jdclyde

in dec, he was huddled up with execs, saying it isn't government that makes this country, it is the hard working people. It would also be the hard working people that would pull things back together, and he would do what he can to give business a favorable climate to thrive in.

he takes office and it changes to "only government can save you".

what a crock of sh|t.

by jdclyde

other than trying to set a record for the most tax cheats to try to get appointed.

Chicago, one of the worse school districts in the country, and that is where he goes for someone to lead all education?

giving social welfare style medical while pretending it is "stimulus" is neither stimulating the economy, nor being honest about his intentions. It is just a work-around because he would never be able to pass legislation to accomplish it.

I WANT him to do something positive because it is in our best interest. i just don't see any of this being good for us in the long run.

by jck

can you please provide me with what section this comes from?

I have all 5 PDFs from the GPO and want to find the exact text you are talking about in the bill.

Thanks

by jdclyde

again, watch the video and you tell me this isn't racist BS.

It would be silly to argue about this until you get a chance to see what it is you are trying to discredit.

And yes, "affirmative action" IS legal in many states, and I don't believe there is a federal restriction on that form of racism yet.

Thankfully, it has been removed in Michigan as a means of government money/jobs/funding. There are still many racists in the area trying to get it back on the books.

by jck

I already bought mine. Stop by with your gun on the way to the store :^0

by jck

not only do they pass on the (temporary) increased level of taxes, but then Congress writes in the loopholes created to appease their lobbies...and then they get tax credits and rebates and deductions that give them that back as a profit.

I wish I could go promise to sink money into things that I know aren't going come to fruition, have Congress give me tons more money to do what I promise, only spend part of that money on what I said I would, and take the rest as a profit.

Must be nice to be so downtrodden as a corporation.

by jck

it's a double standard.

Did you see Congress wait all weekend in Washington for him to sign it? In case he vetoed it? What if Congress didn't pass it? Is he supposed to sit in the Oval Office until they do?

And, why (if Congress considered it so important) didn't they have it couriered to Chicago?

See, you want Obama to make the sacrifice. But, you won't expect that of every other man and woman who is involved in the process.

Put everyone on the same level and make it fair.

BTW, Obama's family was already in Chicago. Read the news, and you'd know that.

I guess you want his wife and daughters to have to put their lives on hold and sit in the White House and wait on Congress too, huh?

by dwdino

"huh?
The point remains, he pushes expectations he doesn't maintain. Apparently this measure is not that important to act upon.

Was Congress going to stay there all weekend and wait until he signed it, just in case he vetoed it so they could work on it further?

No."

-Assumption.

"So, there was no double standard. Congress headed home after they were done, and wouldn't have adjourned til after the holiday either if he had vetoed it.

Period."

-Generalization.

"I will give him credit when his choices and directives reap benefits, not just for being eloquant.

But until then, you will only spin negativity about his plan?

Wait, you put him down for being negative about the current, factual economic conditions.

But, you will put him down for a plan you don't know will work or not?"

-Personal attack instead of issue discussion. Sign of weakness...

"And unity, please... So we all decide to get in a car and drive over a cliff, yet the one who refused to go along is belittled!? Thank you, but no.

Where's the cliff? You are foreshadowing doom and gloom AGAIN, when you haven't given his plan the opportunity to work.

See. You damn him for doing it on TV, but you'll get in here in a public forum that 1,000s of people read and down his plan like it will only drive us further into financial hades."

-Personal attack 2. I have pointed out the facts of his actions. Nothing more or less. I haven't even really discussed the plan. More weakness...

"Good job...nice hypocrisy lesson there. We'll have to implement that into schools next year as "theory of hypocrisy 101""

-Assumptions based upon failures above. JCK, please develop the ability to intelligently debate the subject matter instead of sheepishly falling back to personal attacks and whymsical assumptions.

by jck

are about as good as Donald Rumsfeld's were.

That one "porkulous bill" is $787 Billion.

Currently, the cost of the war in Iraq alone is over $1 Trillion, and is expected to top $2-3 Trillion when you figure in Iraq rebuilding we will participate in, and future expenses of maintaining the 1,000s of new, young disabled vets who will need care for the rest of their lives.

I invite you to go read these, Max.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03/07/AR2008030702846.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/17/business/17leonhardt.html

It's not just me making up numbers, Max. It's reputable publications, including commentary and analysis by Ivy League scholars.

So, you're wrong. $787B < $2-3T

QED

by jck

I can't watch media stuff at work, and if I remember to/have time to/want to take time to get on from the house I will.

Otherwise, I can't see what you're commenting on to talk about.

But if it's anything like your McCain (who you didn't like, but sure used his propaganda like a supporter) videos from YouTube, it's ginsu'ed up worse than Jack the Ripper had been there.

Besides, I can take Bush or McCain or even old Tom Foley or Bob Barr videos...and pull quotes or even whole sessions and make them look like fools.

Despite what you say, you and the others [i][b]intentionally[/b][/i] look for the bad in everything Obama is doing.

You have given him no opportunity to do his job...unless you consider 29 days ample time in a 4 year term. The man even started working 3 days after he was elected and not even being paid...working to have things ready for January 20. You gave him no credit for that. You just raged about how he wouldn't do any good, because he wasn't experienced enough. Yet, look at what the "establishment" of long-term politicians has done to our country in 8 years. Are you happy with that?

If you and the others would stop looking intentionally for all negatives in every word he says, only looking for his short-comings in what he does, and would focus on trying to see what things are going to be done...

Maybe you would have a more positive attitude about the direction of your country.

Otherwise, sit on your butt and mope and complain about it.

I for one am taking my $400 check and paying off a credit card. Go spend yours how you wish...on Xbox or scotch or whatever you feel.

by jdclyde

that is because I am still waiting for there to be anything positive about anything he is doing.

He is going to clean up Washington, and then fills positions with long time politicians.

Paying taxes is patriotic, and then he wants to put in charge of it all someone that intentionally didn't pay his share of the taxes he owed? And last I heard, part had passed statute of limitation, so he didn't have to pay it, and didn't.

No, I have seen nothing positive out of this much heralded first black man in office.

Oh, the link? The stimulus jobs are going to non-whites. And here people tried saying he wouldn't have a pro-black/anti-white agenda when he got into office.

I "hope" enough people are disgusted by this that they back down on their quotas.

by jdclyde

Now I know for sure that you are just trolling because no one is insane enough to think that after Obama spent the last few weeks saying what an emergency this is and it has to be passed NOW, but not until he gives a box of candy to his wife?

That is just stupid, dumb, and ignorant.

by tonythetiger

there shouldn't have been any bailouts. We know these people do these things, and that doing these things contributed to this mess, but we give them more money to do more of it. How stupid! Every member of Congress who voted for this crap should be sho^H^H^H removed from office :)

by jck

[i]"huh?
The point remains, he pushes expectations he doesn't maintain. Apparently this measure is not that important to act upon.

Was Congress going to stay there all weekend and wait until he signed it, just in case he vetoed it so they could work on it further?

No."

-Assumption.[/i]

Nope. In fact, several members of Congress went home to their home districts including 2 members of the House from Florida. I know. I live in Florida, and one of them was my rep. Not an assumption.

Also, you *assumed* that Obama mandated to Congress that they *must* get it done by Friday. He did no such thing. He may have pressured, asked, demanded, etc. However, Obama does NOT have power over Congress. Hence, you are granting him an authority he does not own in his position, then [b]assuming[/b] he made them stay there and then himself did not stay.

Hence, you have assumed.

[i]"So, there was no double standard. Congress headed home after they were done, and wouldn't have adjourned til after the holiday either if he had vetoed it.

Period."

-Generalization.[/i]

No. It's not a generalization.

Whenever the House or Senate dismisses for the weekend or a holiday, it takes a call for a special session to bring them back.

That's legislative procedure.

Fact.

[i]"I will give him credit when his choices and directives reap benefits, not just for being eloquant.

But until then, you will only spin negativity about his plan?

Wait, you put him down for being negative about the current, factual economic conditions.

But, you will put him down for a plan you don't know will work or not?"

-Personal attack instead of issue discussion. Sign of weakness...[/i]

No, it's a fact. You and others only expect good things from him, good things said by him, etc.

Yet, you don't hold yourself to the same standard. And, you criticize him when you say he has done that to someone else.

That, in the dictionary definition, makes you a hypocrite.

If you don't believe me, look the word up.

As well, you and others criticized the plan and [b]assume[/b] that it won't work. You don't give it a chance, and act like you are the all-seeing Oracle of Economic Recovery.

You assumed. Same thing you have accused me of doing. That is another text book example of hypocrisy.

Fact.

[i]"And unity, please... So we all decide to get in a car and drive over a cliff, yet the one who refused to go along is belittled!? Thank you, but no.

Where's the cliff? You are foreshadowing doom and gloom AGAIN, when you haven't given his plan the opportunity to work.

See. You damn him for doing it on TV, but you'll get in here in a public forum that 1,000s of people read and down his plan like it will only drive us further into financial hades."

-Personal attack 2. I have pointed out the facts of his actions. Nothing more or less. I haven't even really discussed the plan. More weakness...[/i]

And yet the same action (going into a public venue and only making negative commentary about the economic stimulus vs his going onto television and commenting that the economy is in horrible shape...which it is if you haven't noticed) you criticize him for, you do yourself.

Or haven't you? Should I quote you?

And I have pointed out the fact of your actions. You criticize him [b]personally[/b] for his actions, but you turn around and do the same thing.

[i]"Good job...nice hypocrisy lesson there. We'll have to implement that into schools next year as "theory of hypocrisy 101""

-Assumptions based upon failures above. JCK, please develop the ability to intelligently debate the subject matter instead of sheepishly falling back to personal attacks and whymsical assumptions.[/i]

Let's see. Another reason to call you a hypocrite:

I call you hypocritical for criticizing Obama for doing things you do yourself...and that you hold Obama to a standard that you don't hold all other parties involved in the passage of the economic reform to...and I am weak.

You call me weak and assert that I lack intelligence and that I make assumptions (even tho I have presented statements and fact)...and that makes you...some kind of phenom??

I assure you that just because you can't see your own short-comings and lack the cognizance to realize that you hold some resentment toward Obama (since you won't equalize the playing field for all involved in the process of legislation) doesn't mean I am the unintelligent.

It means that I won't expect something of someone that I won't expect of others.

Humility is evidently something you never learned in life. Otherwise, you wouldn't assume I lack intelligence just because I won't conform to your belief or let you get away with expecting things of someone that you don't expect of yourself as well.

Oh, and since I'm so lacking in intelligence:

it's [b]whimsical[/b]

References:
http://www.m-w.com/
http://www.askoxford.com/

Dictionaries are a great thing. I even have one. Must be because I lack intelligence.

by jck

I know we agree on that, Tony.

The bailing out of financial institutions and automotive manufacturers in the country, because of their inability to do their job and be profitable, is akin to me going to work and not doing my job and getting docked for it and expecting the government to supplement my income because I didn't earn my money.

BTW, we should really just let GM and Chrysler fail. Toyota and Nissan and Hyundai and Kia are all still profitable, and they make cars in this country.

Maybe it's time we got our nose out of the air, and realized that our greatness in industry...isn't so great.

by jck

[i] that is because I am still waiting for there to be anything positive about anything he is doing.[/i]

If you don't wait for things to happen, how can you only see negatives?

[i] He is going to clean up Washington, and then fills positions with long time politicians.[/i]

That's what all presidents do. And yeah, 4 of his choices have sucked ass. Hillary Clinton was his one great, solid choice.

Daschle is a goober and a snake. Obama hurt his credibility there. But, he couldn't have known Daschle's total background cause there's been no time to go through extensive interviews.

[i] Paying taxes is patriotic, and then he wants to put in charge of it all someone that intentionally didn't pay his share of the taxes he owed? And last I heard, part had passed statute of limitation, so he didn't have to pay it, and didn't.[/i]

Well not making the guy pay is the fault of the IRS, not Obama. Right?

Again, Obama has had 102 days since his election and 29 days in office to do everything. He has some 15 cabinet posts to fill as well as going through tons of briefings and all that.

I mean, I won't say his picks were great...other than Clinton. But, he's done pretty damned good considering that he's been in office barely a month.

Do you think you could do any better?

[i] No, I have seen nothing positive out of this much heralded first black man in office.[/i]

Well, I could compare what he's done to other presidents, but then I'd get told I shouldn't compare his presidential activities of his first 30 days to others.

So I won't. I hate being told that comparing president to president for a fair comparison is wrong.

[i] Oh, the link? The stimulus jobs are going to non-whites. And here people tried saying he wouldn't have a pro-black/anti-white agenda when he got into office.[/i]

So...the legislation says in it that the jobs are only going to non-whites?

I will get a copy of it and read that. I didn't know racial discrimination was legal.

[i] I "hope" enough people are disgusted by this that they back down on their quotas.[/i]

I really want to know what paper you read or TV you watch.

Someone really has you caught up in the Republican spin machine. Honestly.

by jck

You're holding him to a standard that you didn't hold others to as president.

Another president let a funding bill for the military for Afghanistan sit on his desk 5 days in 2007.

Are our troops not important? Do you think that president didn't know it was there? Was something so important just overlooked?

Honestly, I think:

1) you are listening to way too much Fox or Rush or something
2) you are only looking for the negatives in anything he does.
3) you are making too many assumptions based on the press you're exposed to.

I can guarantee you: no piece of legislation says "thou shalt only give jobs to blacks and hispanics".

If you go back and look as well, I bet few (if any) presidents have organized their staff as fast as Obama.

As well, I think you are empowering Obama as having been the only driving force behind Congress getting this bill done. I can assure you, Congress was pushing itself because they knew there was an expectation of their constituency to get something done now that Bush was gone and Obama was in office and he was a man of action.

Oh...one really critical question:

If you can expect Obama to not take 3 days to sign the bill.

How can you let Congress, with all their legal knowledge and experience, not have to get that legislation sooner than 1 month?

Congress could have drafted that bill in days. They've done it before with other spending.

So...why does Obama have to do things as quickly as possible, but Congress gets a free pass?

Just wondering that.

by jdclyde

but this discussion isn't about congress, is it? It is about Obama and the job he is or isn't doing.

Take your meds, and maybe you will be able to focus on a subject without making excuses or trying to change the subject.

oh, "A" for you, because you went a whole post without blaming Bush for something. Well done, we are starting to see some progress with you. Now, just focus a little more and one day, you may be able to discuss without the excuses/blame/distractions. Maybe.

by jck

For someone you don't think much of, you sure hold Obama to a high standard.

What is that all about?

And, yeah. Congress does suck. Has for decades. Why? Cause two parties are in there squabbling over little petty crap instead of doing their job.

That's why if we had housewives and barbers and farmers and postal workers making legislation and voting on things, we'd be better off than having a bunch of silver-spooned attorneys who most have never had a grain of dirt under their fingernail from a hard day's honest work.

We need diversity in Congress, rather than just elitist legal minds who think they know everything.

Otherwise, we're going to keep having issues like we have since the 19th century.

And again: whenever I compare president to president, it is fair and just.

See, I won't hold one president to perform miracles while I give a pass to another who took off more vacation time to his personal ranch than any other.

Why won't I pick at Obama?

Because...I'm really waiting to see what is going to happen and how Obama does, rather than assume he's only going to do bad and nothing he does will be positive.

by jdclyde

before commenting about it. One should never comment out of ignorance of a topic, correct?

And as for comparisons, there is a time and a place to compare people. You only do it to make excuses. "Sure this is bad, but YOUR guy did XYZ". That is sad and pathetic. Actions stand for themselves.

In conflict resolution, they teach you something called the "naked apology". When you are wrong, you simply say "I was wrong, I am sorry", NOT "I was wrong, but only because.......".

You continually try to excuse bad behavior based upon someone elses bad behavior. Why is that?

If you wish to talk about Bush, and his failings, start a discussion about him, and get it out. If you want to talk about Congress, start the discussion. Don't use them to make BHO look less bad.

by jck

Please give me the section of ARRA that only gives jobs to non-whites, please?

Can you give me that fact, or are you ignorant of something you have declared you know to be true?

Thanks.

And again, you're holding Obama to a much higher standard than others in government who are involved in the process.

So he said the economy is really bad? Is it not? Are you going to tell me that it is good and everything is great?

He said it's going to probably get worse. Do you have anything to indicate he's wrong? Can you prove he is wrong?

I'm asking...no...[b]begging[/b] you to show me concrete proof that Obama is wrong and that our economy is now rebounding.

His statements were dead right. Were they sugar-coated? No. Is it his job to play verbal patty-cake with the public to give them a warm fuzzy? No.

His job as president is to be truthful and fully honest about the state of the country, and try to lead us in a direction that makes things better for everyone.

So please, show me proof the economy is getting better and things are not going wrong?

by jdclyde

but you were the loudest against Palin on this site, right?

Oh wait, she is a working mom and horrible person, I forget that part all the time. Yeah, that explained how you were/are quite irrational about her.

by jck

but, I usually go home, workout, shower, then get in bed early now that I have to be to work earlier.

Affirmative Action is a pain in the ass, I agree. But, so are other things...like Veterans' preference.

For instance:

I once applied for a job, but was "beat out" by a guy who had served 6 years in the Army. Why?

He had "training" in the US Army (did not have a college degree), and was not a specialist in any one field. He was basically a tech who did some programming, had some classes in the military, and had some experience in the basic requirements. Someone I knew was involved in the interview process, so I got all the dish on the guy.

I had a college degree and 11 years exp at the time.

However, he claimed "Veterans' Preference" and because he'd had specific classes and met the minimum requirements to qualify to fill the position...even tho I was better qualified and had more experience...he got the job.

How, how fair is that? If you're not able to serve in the military, you can be discriminated against?

Discrimination is rampant in the USA...whether it's racial, familial, or otherwise.

And, the politically correct in the legal system call it "fairness" rather than "favors".

Well, it bit them in the ass. He stayed about 8 months and them moved back up north somewhere.

I didn't apply later. I figure if they had lots of people like him, I didn't want to work there.

by jck

Sarah Palin? Normal????? How many years has it been since she was in her house in Wasilla every day now?? 2? 3? Do normal housewives take trips to the Middle East to visit the troops?

You are deranged.

She's been a politico for years...running a city...being a governor...running councils.

And, she didn't run for Congress...did she? Now who is changing topics?

Stop distracting from the topic of what makes a good congressman with your bias for Palin not getting VP.

:p

by delbertpgh

What we're in now is not just a downturn in a typical business cycle. The whole banking and finance system has screwed itself. It did this by making preposterous bets on a real estate bubble, and by inventing new ways to make money easier to borrow so that it could be invested in real estate.

Just as the value of your home is (or was)probably several times the value of your annual income, the value of all the nation's real estate dwarfs the value of what we earn. The price of real estate stays high because of its worth relative to every other priced commodity we deal with. There's no way to know the "right" value; it's a balance. What's become clear is that as financiers made fat fees on money transactions on real estate, they discovered that by making it easier to put money into real estate the prices would rise, which made possible additional borrowing, refinancing, and fees. Very shady deals were perpetrated by the largest banks, because the finance industry fell into wishful thinking believing that steadily increasing prices would make any deal profitable in the end. And, the fees all came up front. Bankers bought themselves nicer homes and nicer cars; bankers' second wives kept getting prettier every year. It's obvious it had to stop, but when it was working, who would want to make it stop? Homeowners, who were borrowed to the hilt? Homeowners who were not in debt, but kept seeing the value of their investment rise? Bankers and brokers, who were becoming millionaires? Politicians?

The first sign that something major was going wrong was in February 2008 when the auction rate securities market, which had set the price for $200bn of municipal bonds and medium-term corporate debt for 20 years, simply ceased to function. The auctions all failed because banks ceased to bid on the debt. Through the summer, a few hundred thousand foreclosures made lots of those crappy mortgage-based securities non-paying, and major investment banks and insurance companies found that their sure bets were losing money.

Paulson and Bush (and Alan Greenspan, too) crapped their pants when they found out how bad it was, and proposed $700 billion dollars to keep the national banking system from grinding to a halt. That emergency sum exceeds the entire 2009 defense budget. AIG, the insuror that sold default protection on bonds, has by itself absorbed over $125bn to make its bets good. Nobody thought that $700bn would clear all the issues, and it appears that a further $1500bn is now called for. It could go higher. Meanwhile, the economy is contracting as people cannot borrow money and their asset values decline. World trade is also tanking.

The problem is on the scale of the crisis that led to the Great Depression of 1930-1941. For twelve years national unemployment never fell below 12% and was as high as 25% (and worse in some states.) Stock prices fell 90% between 1929 and 1933. We haven't gotten that bad yet. A lot of people (like your Reno economist, Schiller) make the argument that it isn't that bad yet, therefore it won't get any worse, and our real problem is just a fevered imagination.

It ain't so. Bush, Paulson, and Greenspan know how bad it is, and they are no sentimental liberals. This is a problem that could destroy your retirement, and could put 50 million people into poverty, and create a situation of financial stagnation that could last the better part of a generation. It could create the terms of the next world war. It's best to deal with it before it gets to doomsday proportions, which means facing it honestly now, and spending money now.

by jdclyde

There is a set list of what you can NOT discriminate based upon.

Race and gender are on the list, but not the case you mentioned. But you know this already, so why am I saying it? ;\

Not all discrimination is illegal, nor bad.

I discriminate everytime I choose one place to eat over another. Buy one brand of computer over another. Choose the cute girl over the not-so-cute girl. All legal and a part of our every day life.