The answer to your 1st question:
Without breaking a sweat.........unless you'll be running SQL or some other "intense application".....also, any of the servers (Brand)I mention can be take from two to eight CPU's.
Upgrades are not an issue. CPU & Power modules are sold together. (It's common today to consolidate server roles....many companies today are finding under-utilized servers comming out of the woodwork!) Not so long ago, your requirement could have "demanded" at "least" three servers.
Given your serving about 75 nodes it's more than adequate even configured with the server roles you mention. (Try to see it as a "whole" unit)Properly configured and managed you'll do more with less (and) use the server effectively.
Your Business is (or should be)interested in the following in order of importance:
Reliability
Availability
Serviceability
Manageability
(Server) Performance
Cost
"Brand Name" offers
Reliability:
Consistant manufacturing techniques and quality control ensure against premature component failures. All major components are redundant and/or hot swappable...including PCI bus.
Mean Time Between Faillure on most (Major Brands)
is usually 30000 power on hours greater than comparable "Tier 3" servers ie. Tiger Direct
Manageability:
These servers have tools & WEB based interfaces
for management or Admin functions. Alerts, such as impending faillures of any sort can be routed to pagers, e-mail and blackberry etc...This advantage alone makes an Admins life easier.
Warranty:
When a component does fail, most vendors like DELL, HP or IBM will overnight anything......give them the serial number and it's there. No cost, no grief.
Serviceability:
Tool free entry and hot swappable PCI buses. MTTR (Mean time to repair) is usually minutes, not hours. Redundant Power supplies & Disks of course are hot swappable as well.
I can't answer your Exch question.....there are a lot of clever admins out there that can probably answer that. "Symantec Corporate Edition" will run fine on SBS Server. See my note (Above) on my thoughts of "Tiger" Servers.
Of course, having said all this, it really comes down to "You know your network best". I'm just offering a different view on very little info here..
Is peace of mind & doing the right thing for your business worth 2K.. You bet.
Thanks for pursuing this.........& good to know there are others that care ennough about the IT assets placed in their care to bounce ideas arround and do "peer checks". Whoever you work for is fortunate to have you.
Hope these thoughts give you some ideas & good luck, actually, lemme know how you make out. DAFE2