PROOF of climate change & Planet Destruction - WE'VE GONE TOO FAR
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by aldanatech
by ozi eagle
To paraphrase Voltaire (I think) when he discussed the existence of God, that he didn't know whether there is or isn't a God, but to be on the safe side ACT as if there were.
With GW lets be on the SAFE side and ACT as if there were.
.
Okay, Neil. Set this guy srtaight. Now he's applying creationism to the global warming farce.
by absolutely
by dr dij
we've got 200 billion damage plus from Katrina and 31 billion? from hurricane Rita. Not since 1921 have there been so many hurricanes.
an extra degree most likely lengthened season, spawned more hurricanes and intensified this one.
so the cost of NOT doing anything can be steep.
as mentioned, much of damage was from the flooding. this is a direct result of our building levees that constantly increase the riverbed elevation compared to what they protect thru silt deposition.
Bush could have ameliorated this by approving the 14 billion (over 30 years) wetlands restoration act for louisiana. this would have divered river water into struggling eroding wetlands, depositing soil, which helps with sea erosion, and the fertilizers washed downstream would actually make the wetlands lush and flush out seawater.
Lush wetlands help massively with erosion and as fish nurseries.
some people who are republicans and/or anti-environment seem to have odd reasons for this: we have to let them, because it is caused by business, and business is sacrosanct. or denial: it was caused by a capitalist system and this system can do no bad.
Well environmental degradation is caused by all of us, no matter what the political / economic system. Pollution compared to energy usage is particularly bad in developing countries that skip regulations for industry on toxic dumping, emissions such as CO2, soot, sulfur, mercury. And they let vehicles get away without smog devices or non-working devices to large degree.
Anyway, regardless of the cause of warming, it appears to be happening. Even if entirely natural (tho unlikely) we may need to do something about it as 70% of humans live close to the sea edge.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
It gives folk, such as Max, a reason to call everyone disingenious/duped/uniformed. (sorry Max, that was just right in my face!) :^O
Won't we all feel stupid in 20 years? No.
How can one feel stupid about taking the necessary precautions to protect life on the planet? GW or no GW, our spew is killing us in droves.
by curtispnkrtn
After talking about controlling the population, to save our natural resources, and give our world a chance to clean up after us and our pollution problem to many women now I have come to the conclusion that men will have to step up and make it happen. The entire United Nations is agreed that our population is out of control, and some are saying it is the cause of global warming. My concerns are far more greedy, as, at this time, corporations are seeing a labor glut and are getting tarranical with their demands as well as selfish with sharing the wealth. Quit and there are 100 others behind you to move into your desk. The housing market is out of control, and food and fuel prices are straining us all.
PLEASE MEN LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF KIDS PER FAMILY BY GETTING A VASECTOMY AFTER ONE OR TWO MAX. DO NOT COUNT ON THE WIFE OR GIRLFRIEND!!!! PLEASE!!!! AND IF YOUR A LOSER......GET A VASECTOMY NOW!!!DON'T WAIT FOR KIDS!!!! Our children and theirs and theirs will thank you, as will our creator. I've had mine since I was 23 and it was nothing to fear guys. The whole world thanks you, as do I.
by ozi eagle
Hey Max, where in my post is there anything about creation?
I paraphrased something from a19th century author and applied it to GW (global warming)ie if you aren't sure of something existing ,that could harm you, then you had better act as if it did exist and take steps to avoid it, BEFORE it hits you in the face.
Ditto CFCs.
BTW my only possible credence to creation is that "let there be light" refers to the Big Bang, though how Jewish peasants several thousand years ago were sophisticated enough to know about the Big Bang beats me.
.
.....to an intellectual, political, and principled arm-wrestling competition. In short, you are simply blowing smoke, you always have , and you always will. You're a political and intellectual light-weight. But nice try.
by oz_media
Anyone who disagrees with yout, shares a different viewpoint or sees a different concliusion is disingeious, uneducated, politically unaware, not as intellectually advanced as 'your kind' etc.
Tells us all one thing, you are arrogant, self righteous, unable to consider alternatives, VERY narrow or perhaps simple minded and quite ignorant as a whole.
Well done, Max, you pompous tosser!
.
I was hoping Neil would read it, as what I wrote might be considered "a private joke" that only Neil would understand.
Sorry, didn't mean to imply anything.
.
Go back to your admitted drug induced and infested life-style, and leave the enlightened discussions to those better equipped to handle them. What you know about such things could be shoved into a thimble, and it would rattle like a beebee in a boxcar.
by absolutely
by oz_media
Come on Max, now instead of making sense you simply rant away with nothing at all to substantiate your assertions?
You're starting to sound like 'ITLoco' now.
My admitted, drug enduced lifestyle? Could you perhaps explain what drug induced lifestyle I have admitted to? Provide proof to support your lies please.
I have no knowledge of this subject and you CLAIM you have even the foggiest clue what you are talking about? Actually you claim you are hihgly educated and intelligent about this scientifically proven issue that you claim does not exist.
I have a LOT of experience and information of man's destructive emissions and pollution; I am confident far more than a naysayer such as yourself would allow himself to understand.
As you should know by now I have been formally trained, in depth, on fossil fuel emissions and emissions control, alternate fuels, air care, the effects of our own emissions on man etc.
So really your entire argument (if that's what it was actually intended to be), is based on false claims.
You seem to be doing more and more of that nowadays, perhaps old age taking it's toll. You are no longer a bitter, middle aged man but a grumpy, old codger.
Only a complete blithering idiot would not accept a proven fact that pollution is destroying our lives and planet.
Reducing or even merely being aware of and responsible for our own desctructive waste of our resources is only common sense, not a theory needing of proof.
by ozi eagle
by jck
And for the debate moderator, I will get noted debate master...Chef Boyardee!!
hahaha :D
by ibis
Actually, this isn't about America. The expanding 3rd world economies (particularly China & India) will probably pose a bigger problem in the near future. US technology, and the various pollution controls being implemented at the State level, mean that America will pollute less per GDP than China/India - it may yet be less than the world's biggest polluter.
Most of this discussion is pointless, since the risk analysis profile for global warming suggests that it's worth spending more on fending off even a small possibility of climate change than it is fending off the probability of terrorism.
To those who think this is all natural variation, or that there's some kind of 'balance of doubt', let me put it to you this way: there are more scientists accepting climate change than not, to the extent that the number of scientists whose names begin with 'E' and support climate change outnumbers the whole list of those who don't accept it.
Nor is there a pro and anti position - this is a scientific matter. That there is a 'climate change industry' is irrelevant - there's a 'poverty industry' too, but I dare you to say there's no such thing as poverty.
And the "hey you've been dooped" line? Well, I hope we do look back in 30 years and say "what the hell was the fuss?". Speaking as a post-graduate-qualified environmental scientist, I have to say it's more probable that we'll look back and say "why the hell did we listen to the idiots"?
by hal 9000
Now I'm going to have to start hating you [b]Arrogant Solar System destroying Yanks.[/b]
You really must be a terrible lot to welcome this destruction on everyone including yourselves. :^0
Oh WOE is me no more Snap On tools, Zippo products, Bell Crash helmets or any of my most treasured positions I'll have to throw them all out in the garbage now. :(
But you'll never get me to like Harlie's the Ducati's suit me much better and if I can manage to get a Vincent V Twin thrown in I'll be happy. :p
Col ]:)
by rob mekel
Hope you are quiker at the wheel of a Ducati then in your reaction to Max :D :^0 ;)
Rob
ps didn't know Maxwell linked this thread in a more recent thread.
edited for ps
by jellimonsta
by rob mekel
that's why I stick to my car. And on occasion to a bicycle, and yes that has got a handlebar as well. [i]jiha, now I have the right word I can use it. :) [/i]
Rob
edited for emoticon syntax
by mark miller
If indeed human-caused global warming is real, here is what I'd like to see:
- Results of scientific experiments showing how carbon-dioxide in a volume of air increases the temperature of that volume (over a volume with less CO2), and shows a progression of heat increase that corrolates with the increase in CO2. For example, Vol1 with 3% CO2 has X temperature. Vol2 with 8% CO2 has Y temperature. Vol3 has 13% CO2 has Z temperature--Showing some kind of progression, linear, exponential, etc.
- Accurate measurements of how much CO2 is produced naturally in the environment.
- Accurate measurements of how much CO2 is produced by human activity.
- Show how much--as percentages--of the CO2 in the atmosphere is produced naturally and by human activity.
- Measurements of how much CO2 has increased in the last 100-200 years, since this is the benchmark so often used in talking about global warming, with estimates of how much CO2 was produced by industrialization over that period of time. The estimates can be derived from how much raw material (coal, oil, gas) was used in industrial sites/machinery. Records of this should be able to be found.
- An analysis, using the other results discussed above, showing that the increase in CO2 is directly responsible for the climate warming, and that human activity is responsible for most of it. And if not, seek to find other contributing factors.
Following this methodology of experimentation, observation, and gathering of data would be scientific and convincing. Anything short of that is conclusion by induction, which I feel is inadequate. What I see some climate scientists doing with their alarmist talk is a lot of hand waving. Nothing conclusive. I would like to see more proof. I think what the human-caused global warming advocates have been doing is irresponsible insofar as communicating their message. They may very well have the science to back it up, but they're not presenting it. Their message is "We're scientists and we know what we're doing. Trust us when we tell you, you need to reduce your CO2 emmissions by X amount by this date, or else the world is going to end." They make it sound as if just on their claims alone we should give up our lifestyle and change to something else. To me and a lot of other ordinary folks, that's just arrogant. It's not as simple to change to using non-fossil-fuel sources as they make it out to be.
I think they should pony up their data--explain it, if they have the conclusive results. If they do and it actually makes sense to us, I think people will get it and act accordingly.
that you go and do it, then.
The physics of CO2 and infra-red rediation was first described by Arrhenius a couple of hundred years ago and it hasn't changed because GWB wishes it to. The level of CO2 in the air and its sources are very well documented and go back a long way - at least the couple of hundred years that you demand. Reliable levels of CO2 from ice cores go back to 650,000 years ago.
The data has been gathered and conclusions have been drawn. The fact that you somehow believe that scientists haven't actually [b]done[/b] this is staggering. Where have you been?
Go back to the original sources and read the research data for yourself. Avoid the filtration through journalists and politicians and MAKE YOUR OWN MIND UP. Don't blames scientists if you're too lazy to ferret out the truth and you choose to believe a pack of lying politicians or journalists.
"Pony up their data" - YOU ARROGANT IDIOT!
"people will get it and act accordingly" Idiots like you will never get it even if they print it out, wrap it up in pink ribbon and shove up you arse.
by mark miller
Re: ""Pony up their data" - YOU ARROGANT IDIOT!"
You obviously have not heard of the phrase used in scientific circles "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof". Or have you conveniently forgotten it?
All I was putting forward was an outline of actions that scientists (a process they should already know, because it IS actually the scientific method) could take to prove that human-caused global warming was real, real enough to convince even the skeptics. If climate scientists can't do this, then they may as well say it's God or aliens that are putting CO2 into the atmosphere, causing the Earth to warm up. If they want to put the blame on us humans, they need to show that we're the ones causing the problem, not just assume it.
I find it unconvincing that they can come out and say that there's been an increase in CO2 in the atmosphere, and a subsequent increase in temperature, and say, "Oh look. It's happening just as the industrial revolution started. That must be what caused it." No scientist worth their salt in other hard sciences like physics or chemistry would make such claims in their own fields or work. They'd have to prove the causal link. For some reason, some want to give climate scientists a pass, like giving an "A" for effort. Not me.
Re: "Go back to the original sources and read the research data for yourself."
The scientists are the ones making the claim. They are responsible for making their case. What did Newton or Galileo do to prove their theories of gravitation or motion? They made their case. They didn't tell people, "I'm not going to bother. You go figure it out." I'm intelligent enough that I could do a research project on this information you speak of. And if I become convinced, then what? Yes, I could take my own individual actions, but that isn't going to count for squat. You expect me to go out and educate the millions of others who are too busy and preoccupied with their lives to take action? You must be kidding.
I do not challenge the idea that global warming is happening. Even skeptical scientists have said that it's likely it's happening. The question is what is causing it. Your assumption through your whole post is that CO2 ONLY comes from human activity. Excuse me, buddy, but where have YOU been??
Volcanic eruptions put out LOTS of CO2. Forest fires like I see out west all the time put TONS of CO2 into the atmosphere. Scientists have done tests to measure the quantity of CO2 released from forest fires. They were shocked by the results. It's way more than they expected. Lest you think that forest fires are a sign of the times, the forest service would disagree with you. They say that it's due to 100 years of a policy of fire suppression. There's so much latent fuel in the forests now that they're ticking time bombs just waiting for a thunderstorm to set them ablaze.
Re: ""people will get it and act accordingly" Idiots like you will never get it even if they print it out, wrap it up in pink ribbon and shove up you arse."
I'm convinced you're the one who's arrogant. Might want to try looking in the mirror. I expect scientists to make their case SCIENTIFICALLY. If they can't do that, then they have nothing. THAT IS THE WAY SCIENCE WORKS!
by absolutely
They have, but they do not usually present the data in the straightforward summary format you request. So, here is my best attempt to answer each of your requests, in the time available to me for unpaid research today:
(1)
Results of scientific experiments showing how carbon-dioxide in a volume of air increases the temperature of that volume (over a volume with less CO2), and shows a progression of heat increase that corrolates with the increase in CO2.
For example, Vol1 with 3% CO2 has X temperature. Vol2 with 8% CO2 has Y temperature. Vol3 has 13% CO2 has Z temperature--Showing some kind of progression, linear, exponential, etc.
(1a)
Done, and the results are computed in the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, an annually-updated reference of the numerical values of various important quantities used by scientists and engineers in chemistry, physics, atmospheric science, etc. A few new particles' masses are occasionally added, but any old edition you can find will show clearly that the specific heat (c), in the section "Physical Constants of Inorganic Compounds" (in my 83rd Edition - previous or subsequent editions may be organized differently, but the physical constant is called "specific heat"). Any chemistry instructor can guide you through the necessary calculations to prove that "air" - the mixture of gases in the atmosphere - will convert more of the sun's light into heat if it has a higher concentration of carbon dioxide. To be taught how to do it, pay me.
(2)
Accurate measurements of how much CO2 is produced naturally in the environment.
(2a)
Done, in the form of census data. We know average or median ages, standard deviations in each nation, and total population in each nation to reliably estimate the number of humans, and other physical characteristics, to make reliable estimates of the amount of total carbon dioxide emitted by respiration. We can do the same for all species of animals, not being exact, but being close enough that the measurement error is tiny (by far!) compared to the measured number, and compared to the other quantities in the final equation. I don't mean to dismiss this request, but doing the calculations, or finding them done already, will be tedious, so if you don't mind, I'll stop now. If you want more, just ask, and I'll get to it when I feel like it, or get paid what my time is worth for it.
(3)
Accurate measurements of how much CO2 is produced by human activity.
(3a)
Totally done. Amounts of petroleum, in every form, that are purchased every year are carefully measured by the companies that refine it, and by the governments where it is burned. This is so easy to find, I won't be bothered to do it. You Google it if you really want the information.
(4)
Show how much--as percentages--of the CO2 in the atmosphere is produced naturally and by human activity.
(4a)
Instead of that, allow me to try to convince you that the percentages you request are not [b]quite[/b] the crux of the issue.
What I know is that before human industrial activity and before human pollution from burning petroleum, the Earth was habitable. I do not know that it isn't habitable now and I don't even know that in the future it will definitely not be habitable, but I suspect it is on a course toward being, at best, [b]less[/b] habitable, for humans. Deep sea fish, cockroaches, and a few other oddball species probably won't notice any inconvenience. As the Earth's atmospheric composition drifts toward carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, it tends to convert more of the light from the sun into thermal energy. Some of that thermal energy is passed to the Earth's bodies of water, which has a higher specific heat, and [b]that[/b] is the cause of the predictions of more severe climate events, instead of dramatic increases in air temperature. Some increases in air temperature have been documented, but the dramatic increases are in ocean temperature. I have looked for that data today, and am having difficulty querying www.noaa.gov. They also have some restrictions on publishing their data, so if I do find what I want, it may be problematic to publish it on this international forum. Whatever I find, I'll post whatever the law allows.
I believe that the actual bottom line is the [b]change[/b] in the composition of the atmosphere, and the [b]change[/b] in mean temperature in the atmosphere as well as the ocean that we can document over the same period. The natural sources are not under our control except by killing lots of humans, or ceasing to eat beef and raise cows for beef (cow farts also contain a lot of carbon dioxide, and there are [b]lots[/b] of cows on Earth). Either of those "solutions" are very unlikely to gain popular support.
Science magazine published a report in November 2005 that shows that the present content of greenhouse gases in the air is unprecedented over the past 650,000 years.
For me, that has answered the general question to my satisfaction, but I may have summarized some things too briefly or awkwardly. Keep the questions coming. I know what you mean about the conclusion of globabl climate change as fact compared to the presentation of data and studies in small parts. I've done a lot of reading myself, and haven't documented it as well as I would like, I suppose because I was still looking for the answer for myself, not trying to prove it to you. A bit shortsighted of me?
Edited for fat fingers: cows are raised for beef, not for beer!
by mark miller
I appreciate the effort you went through to respond to what I was talking about. I will save your message for later reference if at some point I can find time to look up some of the sources you've mentioned. I didn't expect a complete scientific exposition on here. I was thinking more along the lines of scientists and a production crew getting together and producing a PBS or Discovery Channel show on it that lays it out in a deductive fashion so that the layman can understand the reasoning behind the scientists' conclusion. I think that if human-caused global warming is real, it is crucial to gain public understanding and support. I've paid attention to when climate scientists have spoken publicly on the topic and I haven't been convinced yet, based on the information they've given. I'm always left feeling hungry for more information from them, like, "How did they reach that conclusion?"
The reason I'm not willing to just take their word for it just on their say so (I'd like to see the presentation of their evidence and conclusions), is that what they're asking civilization to do is huge. So if we decide to do what they recommend, they had better be sure about this, because the changes they're recommending are going to hurt badly.
People talk about converting to a hydrogen economy, but it's not what people expect, mostly because people don't understand how hydrogen is produced to make fuel cells. Most of our sources of hydrogen for this use now are based on fossil fuels. The process of extracting the hydrogen produces CO2 as a byproduct. It's my understanding that fuel cells use this energy more efficiently, so the process produces less CO2 than gaining the same amount of energy from burning fossil fuels, but it produces this greenhouse gas nonetheless. In fact, it takes some sort of energy source to produce hydrogen fuel cells, no matter how you look at it. If you use electrolysis, you need electricity for that, and that has to come from somewhere. Every prediction I've heard about this says that the only solution that doesn't produce greenhouse gases in the process is nuclear power, fueling an electrolysis process. Most lay people are going to take one look at that and barf all over it. "Hell no, we don't want nuclear power!" Plus it's my understanding that electrolysis requires quite a bit more energy going into it than what you get out as the end product (oxygen and hydrogen as potential energy).
I talked with a friend about this once and she brought up the topic of possibly altering the environment because of water vapor produced by hundreds of millions of people using hydrogen fuel cells, which produces water/water vapor as waste. If we get our hydrogen from water, then I would guess there's not much risk, since it's a closed loop: water-->hydrogen/oxygen-->water. But, if we continue to get our hydrogen from fossil fuel sources for I don't know how long, we're not only going to have the issue of the CO2 emmissions, but also producing water vapor that didn't used to exist in the environment. Water vapor is the most influential gas in weather systems.
There are some people who remember when 30 years ago climate scientists looked at their data and other indicators and thought we were going to enter another ice age right around now. Now the climate science community is saying something else. Anyone looking at this issue from the outside, as I am, is naturally going to be skeptical with that sort of prediction record. Plus, the layman says, "Look. My weatherman can't even predict what the weather is going to be like a WEEK from now! How can they possibly predict the weather 20 years from now?!" That may be an ad hominem, but I have heard this from friends. Extraordinary proof so that people can understand it is what's required, if you ask me.
In response to your (2a):
There are other factors besides biological activity that lead to CO2 emmissions. It's my understanding that volcanic eruptions put out quite a bit. Forest fires I've come to understand recently put out a LOT more than scientists expected. Some years ago they did an experiment where they burned an acre of wild forest, measuring the CO2 emmitted. I may be exaggerating a bit, but it was "off the chart". They were shocked, is how I remember it. Here in the U.S. (in the west) we have had some mammoth forest fires that spanned miles of forest land. The main reason is we had a policy for 100 years of fire suppression. The fuel load got so built up that the fires got much more intense than was the historical norm.
But I'm curious from your response, have these factors not been considered in the scheme of measuring CO2 from natural processes?
I know this may sound silly, but I wonder what effect the Iraqi oil fires from the Gulf War (1991) had. Was it negligable?
I suppose what could be done is take a look at the CO2 levels in the atmosphere now, look at the artificial emmissions, and basically subtract the artificial from the ambient levels to determine how much is natural.
In response to your (4a):
Re: "Science magazine published a report in November 2005 that shows that the present content of greenhouse gases in the air is unprecedented over the past 650,000 years."
I watched a 60 Minutes show with a NASA scientist (unfortunately I can't remember the name) who has tried to sound the alarm about global warming. He claimed that we haven't seen CO2 levels like we have now in 2,000 years. Far more recent. My guess is you aren't just talking about CO2, but other greenhouse gases like methane and others? I took a freshman atmospheric science course in college (about 16 years ago), and we talked a bit about what was then called "the greenhouse effect". The concern is more with CO2, because it stays in the atmosphere longer. Methane, by comparison, is not so much a concern because it doesn't stay in the atmosphere long. And yes, we did talk about "cow flatulence" as a major contributor to methane in the atmosphere. :)
by mark miller
you've already made your mind up ?
Get hold of James Gleik's Chaos. Not about climate change but it does feature, in that climate was the vehicle for one or the core premises of chaos theory.
PS I've never figured out why people find the idea of global warming so objectionable, is it some sort of religious thing ?
If human impacted climate change is real and we ingore it we and our descendants suffer.
If human impacted climate change is bollocks and we ignore it as such, things stay the same.
If human impacted climate change is bollocks and we do something about it anyway, we get a cleaner planet and switch our stocks from oil to anti pollution technology.
If human impacted climate chnage is real and we do something about it, we may be able to tip the balance, get a cleaner planet make money off our stocks in anti-pollution companies and get some respect from out descendants.
So my question is, are you in the oil industry ?
by mark miller
I don't think you read what I said that well. I do have an open mind to the topic, but before I make up my mind about it I need to see the conclusive evidence. Any scientist would ask for that before accepting someone else's theory. What you mistook as my intransigence was actually criticism of the way global warming has been presented to the public. I am in fact interested in knowing more, but all I hear from the scientists doing the research is "trust us". They need to do better than that, not just for me, but for the public at large.
I must admit I am not heavily involved in the climate sciences. I'm a software developer by trade, and no I don't work for the oil industry. Never have. You can drop the political correctness now, if you please. I do have a scientific background, so all I ask is for scientists who say they know what they know to come forward and explain why they think the way they do, in more detail than they've been doing. I'm not saying that they have to get into the nitty gritty details at the level they work with. Most people won't understand that, but I do want to see how they reached their conclusion. The primary reason being that what they are asking for is huge. It's not a little thing, like you make it out to be.
My primary motivation for liking the idea of alternative energy sources is due to the threat from the Middle East, not the environment, at this point. I'd like us to not be dependent on other parts of the world that are crazy. We're in the situation we are right now, and we have to deal with that, but I'd like a future where we didn't depend on those places.
The thing is that there are problems with alternative energy sources. For one thing they don't produce as much energy as we have now, with the exception of nuclear power. And hydrogen power is not "fully baked" yet. We're really only at the beginning stages of developing that technology. Granted, up until a couple years ago not much was spent on it.
Secondly it takes a while to "retire the fleet". A lot of people tend to keep their cars for a bit less than 10 years. Even if every car manufacturer out there only sold hydrogen cars today, and every gas station also sold hydrogen fuel (which would require a large conversion in energy-generating infrastructure as well), it would be a while before everyone converted. The price of those vehicles are very high at this time, and it would cause a lot of people, particularly the poor, to hold on to their gas vehicles until they wore out and had no choice.
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
by absolutely
mmille10: "I expect scientists to make their case SCIENTIFICALLY. If they can't do that, then they have nothing. THAT IS THE WAY SCIENCE WORKS!"
You're exactly right. Your premise, that they have not done so in the case of global warming, is understandable, but not [b]exactly[/b] right. What has happened is that the conclusion of global warming has been reached collectively, after examination of enormous amounts of data from piles of small studies. The NOAA website reflects the geographically small scope of the standard research project. For example, a state university might measure the waters along its coastline, or carefully examine the data from NOAA buoys closest to that university, and draw very precise conclusions about trends in their locale. Just 50 state universities begins to put this in perspective, but there are more than one state universities in most states ("University of ..." & "... State University"), plus private schools and other interested groups. Occasionally, somebody somewhere politely requests a wide variety of other people's data to find global trends, and whatever the conclusions, they are routinely critiqued on political grounds as much as, or more than, scientific ones. This is silly. Those who don't like the conclusions are free to review the data. Those who don't like funding the studies for political reasons are free to write their representatives in Congress and the Senate. But those who claim the [b]scientific research[/b] is incorrect because they don't like the [b]political ramifications[/b] are plain dopes.
Have fun arguing with neilb. I find it much more rewarding to discuss science with him than to debate opinions. He has a bit of an attitude, and a major vocabulary, and uses both adeptly.
by mark miller
Politics needs to be kept out of this. Just the facts, ma'am.
My local university has been running a series of interviews with current and former presidential science advisors. I had the opportunity to listen to Reagan's science advisor, and it was very interesting. He brought up the topic of global warming, and he said it was a major concern for our society. He implored those working on this issue at the university to keep politics out of it. He said the most poisonous thing in discussing the issue is people involved in this work get into political correctness, and they divide people: "There are the 'real men' on one side, and then there are 'the wimps' on the other side. The people who want to 'save the Earth' are over here, and the people who want to 'destroy the planet' are over there. It is nothing but pure COWARDICE!" I thought that was an interesting word he used: cowardice. I assume he chose it because he has seen how there are scientists who are set in their position, and they don't want to debate it. He is right though. Debate is an integral part of science, though evidence will prove who is right.
In the wider society, it's difficult for it not to be political, because as I've said, if this is true, it has huge implications for civilization. I've seen some in politics who have a tremendous capacity for denial. It's a natural human behavior, though not healthy.
by absolutely
It is difficult to change premises, whatever premises a person holds. I don't fling the word cowardice about as casually as I did in my teens & 20's, and I don't apply it to people just because they resist making fundamental revisions to their worldview. That is as unproductive as refusing to acknowledge the facts.
Those of use who view ourselves as able to see both sides of arguments and identify The Truth, be it on either side or somewhere in the middle, have the most difficult challenge of all. Instead of falling in line on one side or the other, we'll be arguing against both, appearing to both to be talking "out of both sides of our faces". The best solution I know is to keep an even tone, and always remember, in any discussion, all I have on my side are The Facts, and anybody who doesn't respond to those will respond far less to any passionate arguments.
You seem to think that I am being unnecessarily rude in my answer to your questions. I admit that I was rude so the only question that I have to answer is to whether I was rude "unnecessarily". In this, I suppose, we must continue to differ.
All of the data that you request is freely available. I have posted some links here chosen off the top of a Google search. Anyway, I hope that these are from sources that anyone would consider reasonably authoritative. Take them as starting points and you can follow your nose. It would be useful if you could follow that nose to the source data and make up your own mind. It takes quite a lot of work as there is a lot of data.
You seem to want those people who are good and honest scientists to publish their results and conclusions. I suggest that they are doing exactly this in the routine manner in peer-review scientific journals. what is obviously not happening, then, is that they are "ponying-up their data" to your satisfaction. Considering that the majority of these researchers are simply that - researchers - and not self-publicists, politicians, journalists or any other form of manipulative self-serving scum-sucking invertebrates, I'm unsurprised that the message doesn't get perverted on the way out to the public.
So. You want to know about atmospheric and ocean temperature rises? Well, start here and they follow the links anywhere you want.
http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/data/temperature/
http://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/
http://lwf.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/trends.html
You want to know about atmospheric carbon dioxide? Well, start here and they follow the links anywhere you want. This one has some interesting facts about isotopic carbon distribution with regards to sources and sinks.
http://www.radix.net/~bobg/faqs/scq.CO2rise.html
The biggest problem is that the computer models to describe the climate are hugely complex. As they are for weather forecasting which, even for the day ahead, is perceived more as an art than a science. Weather forecasting and Climatology are linked in the minds of the general public and their misunderstanding of the former translates into a misunderstanding of the latter.
It is entirely up to you to make up your own mind on the real picture and you need to answer the questions for yourself. The government and media on this side of the Atlantic are firmly in the "Global Warming is a threat" camp and on the other side are in the "Global Warming Is A Hoax Perpetrated By An International Anti-american Cartel Headed By The French And Financed By Islam" camp. Neither, having set out their stall, is going to admit to being wrong until mile-high ice has reached Watford or they have to build a boat-dock at the White House - whichever happens first. Actually, it could be both.
by hal 9000
David Suzuki! [i]At least I think that's how his name is spelt.[/i]
He would be a good starting point as he's been on this subject for a very long time and has moved from the Radical Science to the Accepted Science.
Incidentally I've deposited the money into your PayPal account when do I get my propriety? :p
Col ]:)
by absolutely
I might say the same thing about you, Neil. (I guess I got to you about your worship on the alter of extreme environmentalism.)
I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Most of the people who are advancing the notion that human activity is affecting the global temperature (or the global climate) are not scientists. While it may be true that there are some scientists who publicly make these claims (even though some of them also claim that they're being silenced from saying what they're saying), there are also many scientists who refute it, although they don't get the same exposure. For the most part, we hear the global warming warnings from environmental activists with absolutely no knowledge or training in the realm of climatology or science; or we hear it from politicians who also have no knowledge or training in the realm of climatology or science, but rather are only advancing a political agenda; or we hear it from some actor or entertainer, who has picked a cause to champion (like anyone really cares what Pamela Anderson thinks); or we hear it from various members of our illustrious main-stream media, who's intentions are anyone's guess.
And I will even make an admission that very few people will make. What I know about studying and predicting the Earth's climate, you could shove into a thimble, and it would rattle like a bee bee in a boxcar. And almost ALL the people advancing the global warming scare belong in the same thimble! (Although they try to come across as friggin' experts.)
However, if human activity was really affecting the global temperature or the global climate to the degree that we hear about it, every scientist in the world would be predicting and warning in concert. Just like every meteorologist will concur and speak out when it comes to predicting the formation and general direction and magnitude of hurricane, everyone in the "global warming field" (whatever the hell that is) would be in agreement if it was really that obvious. They're not, so it isn't.
Until such a time comes, I will not take the word of environmental activists, or politicians, or actors and entertainers, or main-stream media, or not even you.
And speaking of meteorologists, they can't even predict the weather a week in advance; and we're being asked to believe a climate forecast years and decades in advance? Give me a break!
by absolutely
Do you have any scientific argument to offer? Have you ever presented an argument that [b]the data[/b] don't support the conclusions of those scientists that predict climate change as a result of human activity?
Money motivates people, and thus moves the world of economics, but the world's climate will not be affected by the funding source of whichever scientists prove to be correct.
by absolutely
The data that convinced me of a global problem was ocean temperature data because water tends to retain heat once it absorbs it, while the atmosphere readily re-emits heat to space, water or soil. By the time mean air temperature changes are consistent and extreme enough to provide convincing evidence, our species will have been unable to survive the storms for decades.
I don't have the sources of the ocean data handy, either, but what I've seen of air temperature is that any trends that exist haven't been strong enough to convince me of more than random fluctuations. Mean ocean temperature is where I look for "proof" and I know I came across some a few years ago that fully convinced me, but I'm still searching my brain, my books & the Internet for the citation. I beg your patience until I find it.
by mark miller
Sure thing. So taking in what you said in your previous posts on this thread, you're saying that the greater indicator is the ocean temperature, not air temperature. That clarifies things, but I think it gets to what I and others misunderstand about it. Given what the scientists have disclosed to the public at large, people are led to believe that the air temperature is getting warmer, thereby affecting the weather, thereby affecting plant and animal life, and human "confort levels". What occurs to me just now is that even though scientists have been sounding the alarm, most people have clearly misunderstood the message. Again, I go back to what I said. I think the scientists need to explain themselves better to the public at large. Based on what you said, which I think is correct, the public here in the U.S. clearly doesn't understand the theory.
A question that came to mind when you said that, is since the phenomenon that is called "global warming" is postulated to only be indirectly related to CO2 in the atmosphere, what about the claims of some skeptics that solar flares and cosmic radiation from the Sun could be contributing to this phenomenon? Supposedly there's been a lot of sunspot activity on the Sun in the last few years, which is an indicator of an increase in cosmic radiation. I understand that a lot of that is deflected by the Earth's magnetic field, but some gets through. They then postulate that this is causing a temporary increase in global temperature, but that it is cyclical, and will change sometime in the future.
The first I heard of any global warming advocates pointing to ocean temperatures was when hurricane Katrina hit. I heard one say that this is part of the theory. As global temperature warms, water temperature gets warmer, and there is more fuel for hurricanes. I have also heard meteorologists who don't pay attention to any of that, saying that we've had times in the past when we would get hit by Category 4 hurricanes (turns out Katrina was Cat. 3 by the time it made landfall), and that there are 15 or 20-year cycles where we get stronger storms. The last cycle we had like this ended in the mid-1960s. They say we've entered another of these cycles, starting in 1995. People forget what it's like after 30 years to have these strong storm cycles, and so they're apt to associate it with any theory of climate change, rather than just a normal cycle.
What seems unusual to me though is the number of hurricanes we've been getting the last few years. Last year we broke the record for number of hurricanes in our hemisphere in a year. For the first 26 storms in a year they name the storms starting with each letter in the alphabet A-Z. We used up all of those, and the Weather Service started going into the Greek alphabet.
by jellimonsta
by absolutely
by absolutely
"I don't think you read what I said that well."
That's a tradition here on Earth. Enjoy your stay!
than to give the likes of me money and [b]then[/b] ask for something!
:^O
I suspect that the name "David Suzuki" would be like a red rag to a bull for our american friends. But we can try...
by tonythetiger
by hal 9000
That by producing vast amounts of Hydrogen we would be liberating way too much Oxygen into the Atmosphere and not allowing enough inert gasses to stay put so we would again be smothering ourselves as the Human Body [b]Can Not[/b] just breath Oxygen and live.
I still remember one of Douglas Adams Scripts for Dr Who in the seventies I superpose now where as a one line throw away the good Doctor insisted [i]that until the world accepted Hydrogen as a fuel we where bound to suffer from our own stupidity.[/i]
It left a lasting impression on an impressionable young Mechanical Engineer who couldn't see any down side to the argument as the only product of combustion would be H2O or pure water with only trace amounts of contaminants.
Col
by hal 9000
I suppose that means that I have to send Gino and Luigi around to GG and get them to tell her where you are now. :^0
Or I could just arrange for you to be admitted to the Hospital where my cousin works and let her administer Dialysis to you 24/7 [i]by the way did you know that you have Kidney Disease?[/i] for a few weeks and remove and replace the needle every 20 minutes or so. [i]I'll tell her that you're related to Kerry Packer and then you'll know what pain is.[/i] Thank God for the National Health System in the UK. :D
Or both. :p
Now about my property?
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Of course you know what an [b]EVIL BARSTEWARD[/b] that you are don't you? ;\
While the Evolution Lie has been left to rot into nothingness you just had to add a post didn't you? You couldn't let it die any form of painful slow death you had to feed it and give it another chance at life. Currently it's a [b]Green Festering Monster with the Bandages falling off[/b] and you had to feed it to give it another shot at life to come back to haunt us all over again didn't you? ?:|
Do you realise that your action is grounds for [b]Justifiable Murder[/b] and there is no Court in the World that would convict anyone for killing in a slow painful manner to allow you to experience the full benefit of [b]SUFFERING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!![/b] :_| X-( :_|
I hope that you are happy with yourself as you have allowed that monster to continue to appear on the screens of this forum for another 2 years. :(
Col ]:)
by bfilmfan
by mark miller
I'm sure future activists will find something. If we move to a hydrogen economy they'll complain about nuclear power and maybe even hydrogen itself. Depending on where we get hydrogen from, we could end up putting even more greenhouse gases into the atmosphere than we are now: CO2, and H2O from oil or natural gas-sourced hydrogen + oxygen. It turns out H2O is THE number one greenhouse gas in terms of potency. If we get hydrogen from fossil fuels, guess what? We'll be generating H2O that didn't used to exist.
I hear environmentalists have already started complaining about the wind generators that are being installed in some places, since they're killing birds.
Yep. No matter what we use somebody's going to have a problem with it.
get hydrogen by cracking the carbon off from fossil fuels. No-one would be that dumb - I hope.
Hydrogen is not an energy source but simply a means of converting energy - electricity from nuclear or renewable sources - into a form that can be use by cars and buses. I do agree, though, that water vapour is definitely a greenhouse gas but the one thing that it does that carbon dioxide doesn't is that - in excess - it precipitates out into a harmless form called "rain" that dissolves in the oceans.
"No matter what we use somebody's going to have a problem with it." Too true. So let's not do anything.
by tonythetiger
I found an interesting chart from the examination of the Vostok ice core.
http://www.grida.no/climate/vital/02.htm
My question: Who created all of those CO2 peaks all those hundreds of thousands of years ago?
by mark miller
Yeah I know hydrogen is not an energy source in and of itself. I just find it convenient in discussing it to describe it that way. In truth it's fuel for a battery, a form of energy storage.
Re: "You don't get hydrogen by cracking the carbon off from fossil fuels. No-one would be that dumb - I hope."
Most of the hydrogen that we produce now is from crude oil or natural gas, though I imagine we don't produce that much, since up to now hydrogen has only been used in science labs and perhaps some manufacturing processes. The process of generating it from these sources produces CO2 as a by-product.
I saw some science show on PBS months ago that showed a plant in Germany using a kind of algea to take their gaseous waste and convert it to hydrogen, and CO2, which they called an unfortunate by-product.
I read of an inventor's efforts a couple years ago to use a solar powered nanotechnology in "cells" (looked like plastic squares) to split hydrogen from oxygen in water (the water was inside these squares). Sounded pretty neat, but it wasn't close to being "baked" yet. His prototypes contained some metal, and they oxidized to the point where his "cells" were non-functional after a day's use. Other than that the technology appeared to work. He just needs to find a way to either eliminate or slow down the oxidation of the cells themselves.
What was neat was that the cells were powered by the Sun, but they were not powered using photovoltaics. Rather, the nanotechnology inside the cells used the sunlight to power their process directly. As I remember the inventor described the process as 40% efficient, and he projected that if someone had their house's roof covered with the cells, they could generate enough hydrogen in a day to power a hydrogen vehicle for quite a distance. I don't recall exactly, but it sounded like enough for a day's commute to and from work. Not bad for a prototype.
Other than that there's good 'ole electrolysis. That's where nuclear power comes in, if we're talking about generating hydrogen on a truly massive scale without also producing lots of CO2 (from coal or natural gas as fuel for the electrical generation plant). From what I've read, the problem with electrolysis is it's energy intensive. The ratio of the amount of energy that you have to put in, to the potential energy you get out (hydrogen and oxygen) is high (ie. not very efficient).
with the current level.
Or not.
Do I care?
by tonythetiger
I am comparing them. It looks for all the world like we are right on time, as part of a natural cycle.
Given an apparently well established pattern makes it difficult to assume that humans are causing it.
is around 379 parts per million.
Is there any point in us having this discussion?
by tonythetiger
"Current level is around 379 parts per million."
... Why has it been warmer in the past when CO2 levels were much lower?
"Is there any point in us having this discussion?"
I don't know. I just know that the relationship between the chicken and egg isn't as clear cut as some would have us believe, and since they are supposed to be a lot smarter than I am, they [b]have[/b] to know this. To me, this directly affects their motivations, and their credibility.
by sn53
stress junkie wrote, "I honestly don't understand... why people act like trying to preserve our environment is evil."
There is nothing wrong with preserving our environment. Environmentalists are just a useful tool of the Progressives who have the much bigger agenda of controlling every aspect of our lives.
If politicians were using the environmental special interest group as a reason for needing to expand individual freedoms, increase the quality of our liberty and to reduce our tax rates and tax regulations, I would be all for them.
by sn53
Oz_Media wrote, "I think the possibility. . . is. . .undeniable. . ."
Great statement. One I agree with. It requires no evidence. And it allows for the greatest possible fear mongering and political posturing. No wonder we have to act now. We cannot wait to see if the science actually holds. We must give up a substantial portion of our incomes and our freedoms to the state or the United Nations today. Because, as you say, ". . .the possibility. . .is. . .undeniable..."
If the need is dire shouldn't governments be slashing taxes so each citizen with have the necessary resources to deal with the possibility of a coming catastrophe? Or should we believe the present American administration whose philosophy is to not waste a crisis as so many things are possible during a crisis that are not possible otherwise?
sn53anon
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending