Discussion Locked

Pros and Cons of Windows

0 helpful
476 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

476 replies

by jfowler

Updating the BIOS is a REQUIREMENT before applying SP2 to an HP XP machine. After that is done they run just fine. (For a factory built box that is :>)

by dwdino

I still have yet to experience all these horrors and I have been supporting MS platforms large and small for many years.

What is the old saying ... ounce of prevention ...

Macs - Physical designs are great, but I can handle more than one mouse button.

Linux - Great, if you know and understand IS well enough. Not refined or restrained enough for average joe yet.

Anyway, have a good day.

by apotheon

Some of us prefer our OSes un-neutered (oh, sorry, I meant "unrestrained"). As such, I'll stick with something like Linux.

As for what is presented to the end user: a Linux system can be much more effectively locked down to protect the end-user from himself than a Windows system. It's just not locked down that way by default, usually, because it's meant to be useful to the IT genius as well as the knuckleheaded luddites of the world. If you want it neutered for your end users, neuter it yourself.

by jdclyde

Unrestrained with insecure.

A DEFAULT linux box is still generally a secure box as most protocols you need in order to get remote access have to be TURNED ON by the admin (root) before the box will even LOOK for anything coming in.

Yes, a clean install of XP with SP2 IS much better than all previous WINDOWS systems, but how much are you saying when you can only say it is more secure than the last products you bought from MS?

YES, a clean install of XP with SP2 is more stable than older WINDOWS boxes. Just hope your vendor paid to be certified by MS so their application will run on the system.

by jck

don't talk about me that way!

You know, some of us knuckle-headed luddites are sensitive. :(

hahahahahahhaah

I got a dummies book on Linux...Friggin gave up on learning it all on my own from websites...info is too sporadic and twisted...I got a book that includes my Xandros distro, so I'm off to the races :)

btw...I've seen more NT server crashes than *nix crashes...by far...and I have been around Windows server systems and *nix server systems for around a decade (NT 3.5x in the mid 90s and Unix as far back as the late 80s).

I think the biggest factor is the quality of your server admin. If they know their stuff, they can lock either down.

And, I do think Linux/Unix admins do have to be more intimate with their OS, i.e.- Windows has an easier learning curve...hence, you have less "weeding-out" of the less-able to learn admins. Hence, why it is easier to be a Windows admin...it's more stupid-user/admin friendly.

Their new slogan should be:
Microsoft...which idiot do we want to login today?

Oh wait...that's their old push...
the new one:

Microsoft: The only thing more fun than creating tomorrow's technology...is making a bundle of money from it!

by jdclyde

cringe cringe cringe....

Worse than finger nails on a chalkboard is the rantings of the uninformed.....

How about when someone gets a hot water hearer? Why would you heat hot water? I PERSONALLY have a COLD water heater.

by jdclyde

The person he had the bet with KNEW what it meant, and also knew that there had been a purge big time of any reference to it from the M$ site and was hoping for the loophole to win this bet.

apotheon came along and saved the day!

It is all in the details.

by jdclyde

both mine and peers who I respect. (most are Windows guys).

How long has your PC been running non-stop? Did you load it up with 512 or more RAM? Are any of them under a Ghtz?

Not every windows system crashes all day long and I never said that. Just that there is a much higher instance with the windows because of poor memory management among other things.

Can you have a Windows box handed off to an enduser who runs minimum of three applications concurently all day long AND is on the internet and not have their system lock, crash, or need any assistance? Why do you think there are so many help desks? How many of the windows "problems" are solved with a reboot?

I am glad in your issolated world you have never had a system need to be rebooted, but I guess the rest of the world isn't as good as you or as lucky as you.

How many linux desktops have you EVER walked up on? Let alone tried to do work on? You are commenting on something you have never seen and have no intention of seeing.

State that you like windows and it works for you. Fine. That doesn't make people using something you know nothing about are idiots.

by wordworker

The guy started the discussion asking about Wintel versions. The Linux-zealots glommed on and took the whole thing off topic and turned it into yet another boring same-old Microsoft bash. You're also incorrect - I have walked up to many Linux desktop machines and promptly walked away from them in disgust. And I know and like and respect the people who have tried to demo them to me, but I have neither the time nor inclination to learn it. Until I am forced to learn Linux and use it for pay, I don't see any reason to bother. That doesn't make me a less capable IT person than the people who embrace it and just LOVE it. I'm not saying Linux lovers are wrong or idiots or anything of the sort. But I resent it when you try to say Wintel boxes crash all the time (they don't) and you don't back up your assertions with facts. This was a thread about versions of Windows. Linux shouldn't have been mentioned in this discussion at all, imo anyway.

by jmgarvin

Step away from the thread...step away from the thread.

*Disclaimer: Tangental topics will crop up in every thread given enough posts. While you may not agree with the content of the tangental information, it is pointless to "fight the power."

by jdclyde

Now if the threads evolve into a discussion of the pros and cons, that isn't always a bad thing and doesn't take away from the discussion. It wouldn't be a "discussion" if it was just a list of what everyones independant thoughts were about Windows products.

I didn't see you rake the MAC users over the coals even though they weren't invited to the party either. One would think you have an axe to grind here?

I also notice your post was not just a clear view of the pros and cons of windows. Strayed off topic yourself about people straying off topic? Half of your post was off topic.

How was mine, "Pros and Cons?" (post 9)

One of the FEW that stayed completely on topic. Too bad you can't say the same.

You just came to the table looking for something that isn't an issue. Enjoy your Windows.

by hal 9000

What was actually loaded?

If they had Gnome or KDE as a desktop GUI very likely you would see very few differences except that every time you install a program you are asked to type in the Administrator Password.

If they had a stripped down server with only a Command Line Interface it was for a specific job and didn't need the wasteful things that can be added. But even the most basic Live CD Distro has a GUI that while being different from Windows mainly because you have 4 available desktops and not just the one are very useful and extremely easy to use.

Granted I'm biased as I started working with computers on mainframes that took up entire buildings running Unix and we just even then didn't have the issues that even the most current Windows Box has with anything. Todays Linux is so much like Windows that I can honestly see very little difference on the desktop and the main difference is that they just run faster crunch more numbers in a shorter time and remain generally secure with very little attention which is a lot more than can be said for all the Windows Boxes that I also maintain.

But if you really want something funny have a look at the banner advert across the top about the TCO of Windose VS Linux they add is quite correct if you consider the very limited confines that it was run in but I've also seen the same thing run to prove that the TCO is far cheaper using at least Servers with Linux on a Windows Network as you do not run into all the licensing problems that you do with any of the MS server products like needing additional licenses for an already expensive product.

The fact that in all honestly about 80% of Desktops could be migrated to Linux without any noticeable differences being realized by the end users is just a bonus. There must be a reason why the big Blades, Server Farms and Mainframes run Unix/Linux or whatever if only because MS just doesn't have a product to compete with these installations.

Col ]:)

by wordworker

All I'm saying, like I said in response to JD, is this started out as a question about Win versions. People started going off on *n*x tangents and bashing Wintel performance without backing any of it up with facts. I think that zealotry has been played out. If and when I ever have to learn Linux or Unix or AIX or any other flavor in order to earn a living, I'll learn it. Until then, I don't bash it, I applaud people who do learn it and use it, but don't try to tell me that because I live and work and make a living in the Wintel world that there's something wrong with that. There isn't.

by apotheon

"Not I," said the fly.

Make your money how you like. Use the OS with which you're comfortable. Be my guest. There's nothing wrong with that, in and of itself. The comparative technical merits of Windows and Linux are immaterial to personal preference, often enough. I just tend to prefer technical merit. Heh.

by wordworker

JMG, the bashing non-responses started in the very first response! Yeesh. They didn't crop up so much as they took over.

by jamesrl

There are still enough Mac dealerships to get service at for most people's needs.

As for memory and HDs, you can always get third party for the Mac. Even in the early macs, Apple used a special ROM on the HD board to identify that it was an Apple drive and could be formatted by the OS tools. But third parties quickly came out with tools to format any SCSI drive in a Mac and they worked flawlessly. ATI and NVidia have both made video cards for the Mac. And RAM, when I worked in an Apple dealer in the 80s, we bought third party RAM, and I am sure most Mac dealers carry third party. If you want a second HD, get an external USB enclosure, they are pretty cheap these days.

Back in the good old days I tried all kinds of third party tools, from processor upgrades to 486 cards that would run windows (worked well but about 2/3 speed of equivalent 486). You could get all kinds of third party video cards and monitors, keyboards, hard drives, memory. And they usually installed easier than doing the same thing in a PC. This of course was in the Mac's that had slots, as opposed to the all in ones.

James

by hal 9000

I have a passion for Classic Mercedes so whenever I spend way too much I just say it is a present for her. Then she can not complain only say I shouldn't have done that. :D

But best of all she can not complain when I throw buckets of parts at it either as I'm making it better and safer for her to drive. Currently she owns 3 of the 7 classic Mercedes here. :)

Just like my passion for Snap On tools she used to bitterly complain about just how expensive they where and just how much money I actually spent on the things that I brought until two things happened the first she came with me into a Snap On van and I brought her a pair of folding scissors and the second and far more important thing I used a spanner that she had bought me and it broke undoing a tie rod nut so I fell back and caught my neck on an open draw and was paralyzed for 2 weeks from the neck down. Luckily I knew it was only temporary but it could have been much worse and ever since that incident I've never heard a word said about the cost of the Snap On tools that I buy and she raves about just how good that they are to anyone who even comes close to my tool trolley as it is by now far to heavy to even consider lifting. :D

Of course the blades that I brought home where ones that I pulled out and had replaced with new units but they where just so good that I couldn't bear to part with them even though they are big, bulky, heavy, attract dust like a magnet and so on I got lucky there as I didn't pay for them so she couldn't really complain toooooooooooo much she only goes on about the space that they take up. so I dumped the 1U cabinets and just stuck with the Blades all around the place I'm currently using one as a Gateway to the Internet a waste I know but she can not complain that I'm not using them. ;)

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

WordWorker is talking purely about a desktop that he can send and e-mail from, type up a document or play solitare from.

With no way to qualify what these many "linux desktops" were, you can't concede or discredit it because who knows what he saw?

He LIKES windows. He is COMFORTABLE with windows. And even though MS is CONSTANTLY saying with each OS release that it is "more stable" he still wants proof that it ever wasn't stable.

You can't show someone what they are unwilling to look at.

by ni70

Hahaha network interface card card! That chaps me big time, especially if it comes from colleagues or instructors!

by jaqui

prairiedog (11:54 AM) :
well finally i have come up with a good use for xp. a disposable operatin system.
Jaqui (11:56 AM) :
well now I gotta use that line
prairiedog (11:56 AM) :
lol
prairiedog (11:57 AM) :
it takes about 5 seconds to clone a fresh one and about the same amount of time to delete it again

by jamesrl

Cause if you find this hilarious......

That would make you a pedant.

Get a big dic(tionary) and go look up pedantic.

James

by hal 9000

That was more of a reason to avoid M$ products you can work away quite nicely thank you very much while at the same time knowing just what problems the competition is having on their M$ Boxes that you are deriving a dividend from. :D

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

Never seen that side of you. Someone cut down your favorite tree?

And just because he pointed out EXACTLY the same thing that was in the post he replied to is no reason to go off the deep end.

You Canadians are WAY to radical. You need to mellow out some like your American neighbors!

by apotheon

HIV virus. Friggin' scientists and doctors say this. WTF?

Has anyone mentioned HIV virus in this thread, yet?

by apotheon

The original post was asking for pros and cons of Windows versions. It didn't say ANYTHING about that necessarily being in relation to other Windows versions, and the initial answer post never mentioned Linux. The fact the responding party has a penguin in his user icon in no way guarantees he's a Linux zealot or that he was suggesting anyone use Linux instead of Windows.

wordworker: You assume much.

The original post for this thread might easily be construed as asking for comparisons between Windows and other operating systems in general. Get over your attachment to Windows. Methinks you speak too hastily about who the zealots are.

by jmgarvin

Virutal VLAN!! ARRGGGG...Venti is another word I hate, but it is a purely personal thing...

by jaqui

how was my own opinion on why to not use windoze and why a non response?

I never said anyhting about other os.
I only gave 5 reasons not to use windoze and one reason to use it.

it's a response, and an honest one.

take your office xp word document and open it in word 97.

you can't the file formats are not the same.

take that win95 app and run it on your xp system.. you can't the systems are not compatable.

do not spend money every month on licensing for the ms products.. oh, you aren't yet, ms hasn't gotten the "distributed .net system running yet"
where you have to pay to buy the software license, and pay every month to be able to use it, off thier servers, costing you data transfer on top of the license.

ms's own news releases are what I used to say do not use thier products.

by jdclyde

are programmed in on purpose to MAKE you have to call the support line? How would you ever know?
Oh yeah, I forgot that we trust MS to only behave in an ethical manner and have OUR(the end user) best interests in mind first and formost!

by hal 9000

But the main purpose of M$ continued existence is the belief that what is great for M$ is good to some extent to the end users.

How do I know that this is right M$ told me so themselves. :D

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

Anyone who isn't a die hard Windows user is a zealot? But if you ARE a die hard windows user with no intention of learning anything different you aren't one?

How does that standard work?

Your WAY too defensive. Why?

by hal 9000

Blindly Believe everything M$ is PERFECT and that there is no other product available to use is because they work in an environment where money is not important and they along with their bosses have swallowed the M$ bait Hook, Line & Sinker so they are unwilling to even open their thought processes to other possibilities particularly if a lot of people tell that that there are cheaper ways of doing the same thing.

After all if they admitted that it would mean that they chose the wrong product in the first place wouldn't it?

And just how many people like to admit that they made a mistake?

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

It IS the people that have no concern for what costs the company has that are less likely to try to find ANY savings ever. "It isn't my money and they can afford it". Heard that many times.

Todays business machine in the M$ brianwashed senario of XP/2003, it costs twice as much for the software than it does to buy they system. And that is just for a "common" word procceesing person and no concideration for extras like CAD or graphics!

by hal 9000

It's one of the things that I just when handing over a quote for new computers I list the cost of the Hardware and then the software as on many previous occasions I've been told that I'm actually robbing them blind by attempting to charge for the complete computers when they can see adverts for rubbish starting from $1,000.00 AU or less but of course these things do not have an OS or any software.

With just OEM Windows XP Pro and Office Pro the costs to me are around $800.00 AU per install which suddenly makes the hardware costs not look quite so bad as they generally are only slightly more expensive for the really good stuff that I use and then I get to add the M$ Software which just drives the price through the roof. On almost everything but the basic units that I build the Software costs far more than the actual Hardware ever does and I don't use all in one M'Boards or unbranded RAM and things like that they suck up system resources. With ATI Video cards and Cosair RAM added in the hardware unless it is something really special always costs less than the software for the same installation. About the only thing that could be improved on the workstations that I build is the quality of the speakers that I supply with them as I only use 120 W crap for any office work as really they do not need anything better but I have seen some one who complained bitterly about the cost of a complete package go elsewhere and buy a less sophisticated system for a server and then buy the software separately for their needs only to have it cost them far more for less of a machine. The fact that the PS died within a week and allowed mains power into the case and then out across the LAN is really neither here nor there but that Court Case will be coming up soon I spent most of last Friday in with the Legal People going through my report on the destruction of the entire network.

You really have to be a total lost cause to work IT some days and this is one of those years for me anyway. :(

Col ]:)

by mjd420nova

I really want to get into this discussion but don't really have the time to go through all
the replies and rants that I know will be here.

by jdclyde

whos judgement you respect so you can sort through a post like this for the main meat of it.

I personally completely ignore myself as I am just an over opinionated know-it-all it seems because I don't exclusively use Windows.

Tip for faster reading, go into print posting mode and you can read all of the postings without having to keep hitting "next" and then wait for the page to reload. Goes much quicker.

Read what others say and then make up your own mind.

Happy sifting.

by jdclyde

I don't think so. That will be XP home version. Not what your looking for buck-o.

And the integrated video/sound/NIC will quickly drain that 128 M Ram that it comes with.

And of course the 250W power supply will cause many crashes as soon as you start adding upgrades.

I am amazed to see they even MAKE a 250W power supply!

Now buy Office, a corportate Anti-Virus and upgrade to XP Pro.

Better put more memory in that pig or you will really be hurting with crashes multiple times a day. Many computer "problems" fixed by adding more memory. So we run up to staples or what ever office supply and hope that we accidentaly grab the correct type of memory. Of course we get the cheapest we can to save money for the company!

Need another hard drive? oh, this quantam is much cheaper! Lets get that!

Oh the humanity!

I love the smell of melted motherboards in the morning.

by jamesrl

You have me confused with those left coast mellow dudes like Oz. Here in Toronto(and all of the rest of Canada hates Toronto, moreso than say Americans hate New York), we aren't very mellow. We have traffic and smog and overcrowding.

In the past ten years my suburb has gone from 300,000 to 400,000 people with no new major arterial roads, not enough new schools, no new hospital(being built now). Day by day, the commute is getting longer and more dangerous.

So why would I mellow out?

James

P.S. I've probably said NIC cards before. But hey I've worked with thousands of them, from 3C503s to IBM Token Ring to Apple Local Talk and Ethernet to wireless cards. Its one thing to point out the humour, its another to be pedantic. Life is too short.

by wordworker

By my count only 5 of 145 responses in this thread actually attempted to answer the original question. That's sad.

by jdclyde

If you counted YOUR reply, then back it down to FOUR as yours was half off topic rant as well.

That's sad.

by apotheon

Not only are you ignoring what has already been said about on-topicness and how one's post qualifies in this thread, aside from the fact you've contributed as much to off-topicness as anyone else, but I count rather more posts that tried to answer the original post even by your own artificially narrow standards.

In addition to all that, you seem to be confusing responses to responses with responses to the original post. If a post answers the post to which it responds, it's on-topic to some degree at least. You should really only be measuring the on-topic rate in top-level responses. There are only five top-level responses that are really on-topic by your standards (several more if we use inclusive standards that aren't designed to make people look bad by excluding their responses from "on-topic" by imposing your personal interpretation of the original post's vagueness), this much is true, but rather than 145 posts now we're talking about only thirteen top-level responses.

Of those thirteen top-level responses, whittled down to eight off-topic according to your apparently arbitrary standards, two are yours. Of those two, one is entirely off-topic. That gives you about a 50% contribution rate to being off-topic and failing to respond. Your off-topic post is actually off-topic by the standards of [b]any[/b] reasonable interpretation of the original post's meaning, in fact, and not just by [b]your[/b] standards. Another is off-topic because some Mac user decided to say nothing of much value. Another is off-topic because some Windows user decided to proselytize without actually answering the question or even acknowledging that it exists. Another is just a random troll.

I'm most interested, though, in the facts that A) the actual percentage of on-topic top-level responses [b]even by your own standards[/b] is not 3% as you suggest, but 38%, and B) of your own top-level responses, 50% are entirely off-topic, and the other 50% is full of off-topic complaining, [b]even by your own standards[/b]. People in glass houses, et cetera.

by jamesrl

Characterized by a narrow, often ostentatious concern for book learning and formal rules: a pedantic attention to details.

A pox on both your houses.

James

by jmgarvin

Why don't you try and load the "Evolution Lie" thread. Make sure you have at least a minute to wait...almost 2500 posts and not one of them is on topic ;-)

by hal 9000

After all every one of my posts about the "White Mice" is directly related to the EL thread. :D

So I contributed while it was still possible to navigate. :(

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Is that you are continuing the trend not to answer the original posters obvious Assignment Question. :D

Well as you obviously do not want to help this person why is it that you think the rest of us should? :p

At best in one attempt you made some half hearted attempt to answer the question but them instead of providing facts you used this as an opportunity to go off on a tangent to attack others who didn't seem to want to contribute to a students question with comments that would help them obtain a mark that was better than what they deserved, but you took this opportunity to attack the non Windows Community in general and Linux in particular, so you where on your Soap Box more than anyone else here. :D

Why is it that you see a need to stay on topic by others when you yourself are unable to do so? ;)

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

There will be a few shots across the bow, but nothing that will support any kind of a point of view that has more thought to it than "I know you are but what am I?"

Notice when he attacked the of-topics it was only the linux and not the MAC crowd. Didn't say a peep to them. That doesn't show a trend does it? Didn't think so.

by apotheon

2. n. An individual who chronically trolls in sense 1; regularly posts specious arguments, flames or personal attacks to a newsgroup, discussion list, or in email for no other purpose than to annoy someone or disrupt a discussion. Trolls are recognizable by the fact that they have no real interest in learning about the topic at hand - they simply want to utter flame bait. Like the ugly creatures they are named after, they exhibit no redeeming characteristics, and as such, they are recognized as a lower form of life on the net, as in, ?Oh, ignore him, he's just a troll.? Compare kook.

(from the Jargon File)

by jmgarvin

Ya, that thing is a monster. I can't even figure out who is replying to what and what threads are "live" anymore.

by hal 9000

But EL is now nearing 6 months and still looks no closer to stopping that when it started. I wonder what they have still got to say to each other. :}

I escaped when they started going round in circles about the 4 th time. :D

Col ]:)

by apotheon

You could just do searches for the string " 06/" to find posts made during the last month. Heh.

Not that I'm suggesting you do that, mind you. I haven't read that thread since the last time I posted in it.

by hal 9000

I was just trying to point out the Hypocrisy's of his entire argument, these Big Bad Nasty Nix's people out there are all trying to make it into a war of OS's. :D

While I do accept that there are a few people who are Linux only there are far more who will use the best tool for the job in hand and quite often Windows just doesn't have a product to fill that need. I've just had to reboot my Debian gateway after 325 days of up time because I've just upgraded the OS to the latest kernel where as I'm lucky to see a Windows Server running for 1 month without a reboot. Although the patch that I got today for all the XP boxes here didn't require a reboot so it must not have been anything important. :)

You had better be quite about the Apple products as being a confirmed Windows Supporter I didn't think that still existed. ;) After all M$ hasn't told me about them for several years now. :p

Col ]:)

by wordworker

Actually I meant to make it plural and direct it toward nobody and everybody in particular. I just couldn't resist jumping into the cyberslangfest you guys had going on.

by apotheon

I'm pretty sure I was the only one to use hacker jargon in this. James Linn is just really fond of the word "pedant" and its variants, apparently.

by hal 9000

At first I thought it might be interesting but I very quickly came to the conclusion that it was nothing but a waste of time so I just kept posting Jokes which a few took seriously. :D

But honestly it was like when I did Government work it only felt really good when you stooped bashing your head against that big solid brick wall. :)

Col ]:)

by cardinal

Strange that you don't use the mouse you want. I have a variety
of mice on my Macs -- they all work perfectly --though
personally I like Mac's own best.

by sailnow

I am using Win XP home on a laptop and XP Pro on a desk top.
1. Love the "System Restore" feature
2. Love the seeming "self healing" after near crashes - much better than my original Win 95B and Win 98SE.
3. Don't like slowness of loading - but I do have a lot of stuff on the computer (Laptop 60 GB) and running in background - though I try to eliminate unnecessary things by accessing config.
4. Cost - I guess I feel it is bit steep - and the accompanying user software by MS also steep $. Am using some FreeWare that works well and gradually exploring "Open Source" programs like "Open Office" and IrfanView for photography.
5. Like the automatic updates.

HATE the MS windows AV & Firewall. BUT I never turned it "ON", and do like the alert that comes up if either my AV or Firewall are accidentaly turned off. I use Panda for AV/Firewall, run Lavasoft "Ad-Aware" and "SpyBot" all the time and do a scan at least once a week and keep the data files up to date nearly every day. Occasionally I go online to "BitDefender" site and download their online scan to be sure there is nothing hidden that my other programs happen to miss. No invasions yet, and I want to keep it that way.
Bill Wilcox
sailnow@bluefrog.com

by joseph.ford

One thing you must put in your report is a comment about support. While Linus is free it's a question on getting people to support the OS in a business situation.

The availability of IT Staff for Windows OS vs other os is high. End-to-End support for other Microsoft WIndows applications from a single source.

by jlangdon

If my employer were to switch to a more stable desktop OS, I'd be out of a job. Windows pays the bills.

by roch.leduc

1. Pro: company. you have plenty of company, like 95% of the desktops in the world. Unless your client base is esoteric, you will profit from everybody else's bug reports.

Con: company. you are a small fish to M$. You are painting a bulls eye on your systems because they are the most actively hacked; your specific, esoteric bugs will be lost in the millions of other bug reports.

2. pro: integrated: your software stack in the M$ environment is the most integrated software on the planet. M$ Office is a high quality, high productivity environment for office automation. They have a variety of features that is downright dazzling.
Con: integrated. When you adopt a software stack, you adopt the whole thing when its integrated. Beware of versionitis and cascading dot upgrades. Also, you are adopting a business model. You cannot achieve this integration at 0 cost. you have to do business the M$ way, or the integration is shot.

I could go on and mention: standards; support; development environment; certified resources.

bottom line: pick your poison, because there is no way to dodge all the trouble.

by dotxen

Pro - Familiarity
Cons - Stability, Security, Price, endless tedious patching and updates.

I am sure that this is less than a granular answer, but it is pretty accurate.

by alexandrescu_emil_cristian

Pros:
Windows OSs are there for a long time, wide spreaded and there is a lot of "down the hall" answers one can get; there are a lot of applications too.

Cons:
Everything else! sorry, but that's the trueth about Windows OSs.

by kedia990

Look at it practically...Windows now forms the base for each and every software, game or anythong else that is ever launched.

NO! not everything works on linux/mac, too...

o'course, a hell lot of faults in the kernel, but u gotta accept it.

by cardinal

"people that DO are more interested in looking trendy than
anything else."

Rubbish!
I have a business to run and no time to keep fixing Windoze as I
used to have to do when I worked for a large consultancy.
Our Macs just work and don't waste time.

by jeff.mcfee

Good post except for the ME bit. Microsoft took 98 and removed stability and proper domain control! I am finding myself on a large network reinstalling ME atleast once a year - something I rarely do on any other platform.

I have 2 vendors who will support their products on 95/98/2k and XP but refuse to support ME because they have so many problems.

We are migrating all PC's to XP-PRO (just intime for Longhorn ;) ) starting with ME before Windows 95.

by jardinier

I am merely stating a fact. I have had ME running for four years on an AMD 550 with 64 MB RAM and it has NEVER given me any grief.

I have heard that it is a disaster when used in a network, but my experience is my experience. It is the most reliable and fastest computer that I currently own.

It runs faster than 98 SE on a Pentium 400 with 256 MB RAM. It runs faster than 98 SE on a Celeron 633 with 128 MB RAM.

I'm sorry, but whatever your own experience with ME may have been, you simply cannot refute my personal experience on a single machine.

by helpdesk

Windows is an OS , all your referals to other MS products like Access or Word is kind of off-topic seems to me.
If you have the knowledge , you can create a very stable, fail-safe environment with windows 2000 or NT & XP . the cath is that the easy interface makes it appear that enyone who can click a mouse is en expert.

by abmartinez

Hi,

I am a Systems Security Administrator of a local telecomunications company for the northern part of Spain. We have always used Sun Solaris systems for supporting our core business applications. However and contrary to my preferences, We are moving more and more to Windows servers.

As I am a Systems Security administrator, my pros and cons will be based on security reasons:

Cons:

-By Default, Windows Servers have a big deal of open ports. But this is not the worst of it, the worst part is that you cannot disable some of them if you want the server to work properly. I am talking about RPC Locator: 135 TCP, Netbios: 137-139 UDP/TCP and SMB: 445 TCP.

-It frecuently happens that the before mentioned ports are the ones where most of Windows critical vulnerabilities tend to be concentrated on.

-The Internet Explorer is integrated within the operating system to such extend that makes this browser a huge security hole.

-I could tell you more cons, but I think that it is enough for today.

Pros:

-It is by far the most extended and popular operating system, you know, most popular things are not always the best ones.

-In seems that Microsoft is making a big effort in trying to secure their products as a result of his security strategy started in early 2002. As a result, Windows 2003 is a very solid and secure operating system by default comparing with the other operating systems of Microsoft.

Nothing else for today.

Have a nice day!!

Regards!

by briancatt

I am a Native Mac User who is forced to use
PCs at client sites and also for homeworking
and conference presentations to avoid
hardware and driver compatibilty issues. I will
answer within the Windows space first then in
comparison with Mac OS, can't do Solaris or
Linux but they look like they need command
line propeller heads at config level like
Windows only worse - on the other hand UNIX
is proper multi tasking joined up code so hard
to break, unlike the Windows house of cards
architectural approach.

My first and primary experience is Windows
overall requires a whole raft of technical
support Mac OS does not, and can involve
users in complex activities beneath the GUI
layer to keep it alive or ecover crashes which
are unnatural acts witth a User/consumer
device. So reducing this is very importnat, and
MS made continuous progress on this apart
from Me. The major step was Win2000 after
the darkest hours of Windows Millinenium,
which was where all the Y2K bugs actually
went.

Windows systems Win 95 was great in that it
made the PC accessible to many more
people with its useable GUI (built from the
Mac GUI) from Windows 2.0 and 3.0 on up...).
But it was horribly unstable, was a peripheral
driver and generally crash prone nightmare
which didn't support USB much , and anything
that went really wrong showed it was just a
horrible mask over DOS. REGEDIT! Whats
THAT! - "DOS Inside". None of this was fixed
well until NT. Windows 98 was mended and
more solid but the same horrible DOS Inside
architecture, Windows Me introduced some of
the self maintaining features due for NT/2000
but layered on 98 using that generation
architecture which made it horribly buggy.

Win 2000 was based on the multitasking
Windows NT OS written by Dave Cutler's team
Dave was Mr VMS from DEC so Win 2000 at
last got a decent multitasking and network
aware underbelly underneath its Mac look 'n
feel. The less MS DOS the better is the
principle to use. The self fixing and updating
features made it a lot less user hostile and
reduced the need for support nerds a lot
more. While much improved it still seems to
have all the same old horrors of the DOS
legacy carried along with it for forward
compatibility, so can bite yer bum from time to
time.

I found XP a sort of Win2000 plus, a bit of an
overweight Win2000, again addressing the
self maintenance issues better but with
bloatware rather than tightly integrated
sophistication for the average user. It is less
prone to crashes and problems than before,
but not the great step made with Dave Cutler's
step change NT technology in Win 2000.
Windows remains a GUI layer on a very
overweight and kluged architecture relying on
increasing CPU and memory to keep itself out
of trouble.

Its also a complex nightmare for a self
supporting user to back up and restore, even
with Acronis True Image (DONT USE GHOST!
EVER, it has tho w]switch the machine into
DOS mode and is a real give away about
what's inside Windows - ECCCHHHH!).

BEST UPGRADE if you must is Win 98 to Win
2000. XP is OK if the PC has the resources,
but 2000 is fine and was the large step. My
call at the moment is stick with Win 2000
untile whatever comes next (Little Big
Horn/Gates Last Stand) Series 2, the Series 1
will be standard MS over complicated then
rushed to market by Bully Ballmer and its
taken FAR too long to get it right working from
MS single user up rather than network
computer down approach.

FINALLY If you are worried about technical
support resource, utilisation, TCO and
useability get Macs. If you want to continue to
create a lot of technical support work stick with
Windows. It won't let you down.

All the standard Windows applications files, IE
and Outlook applications run across both
platforms. Generally back up and recovery of
Macs is easy , even unto image restoration
which is a simple copy to external and restore
when required. The Mac interface is easier to
learn and use and the machine takes much
less time as a % to keep clean and backed
up. NO TECHIES NEEDED. The difference
between GUI's is really marginal, and YES the
Mac could use the Task Bar as much as
Windows need to put the Drives on the
Desktop.

Both Mac and PC can co exist and share files
happily on the same LAN under TCP/IP the
great unifier (And UNIX - yes, I know Mac OSX
is A-UX 2.0 updated = UNIX inside after
Apple's internal OS wars - but you can't see it.
I'm still running Mac Classic OS 9.2.2 - which
is also possible under OSX - because, wait for
it - I can still run all the applications and open
all the files on my Mac which I have run since
1989 without very having an irrecoverable
disaster, so I have total continuity of GUI
computing from 1989 and Mac OS 6.0.4 - what
would you do with such a record?

Just think how few upgrades and changes to
user apps have been saved...Apple didn't
need to force application software upgrades
with OS upgrades to make money like
MS...........

BUT there's a gotcha -

LAPTOPS:
........if youwant a real lightweight 3 pound 12"
TFT x 1" thick Laptop for the briefcase to avoid
the carry on fascists it has to be a Dell
Latitude X300, SONY Vaio or HP Thingy -
which is another reason I have a PC Laptop -
form factor. Apple has not really GOT IT as far
as a truly portable is concerned, the 12" Power
Book is beautiful but not there - yet.

Now if they just got rid of the CD - it was Apple
that dumped its proprietary connections for
USB and IEEE 1394 but has apparently not
heard of exterrnal USB optical drives ...
nobodies perfect :-)

The plastic iMac looks tacky and weighs a ton
- its a desktop substitute luggable really - the
nearest thing yet to a consumer friendly
computing device though.

Brian Catt
01932 772731

by deadly ernest

First thing to remember about MS Windows is it is aimed at the lowest common denominator - a user who knows nothing - and it achieves the goal. Having been around pre MS and seen it all I know that the current computing status owes a lot to MS. If you want me to expand on what I say please email me. now to the grit.

The most stable version of Windows was Win 3.x. Win 95 was a cut back of Win NT, Win 98 cut back of Nt 3.51, 98SE from NT 4. ME is a cut back on 2000. In each case the cutback version had less security and were harder to network and more vulnerable. Many of the security holes were never fixed between versions just new patches for each version. Most problkems were due to having different coding terms working in rotation on different versions. All have memory management problems and need a good memory manager to regualrly clear the RAM and avoid the Blue Screen of Death. Most instabilities due to bloating the kernel without recoding it tighter and putting to many thngs into the kernel.

Win 3.x sat on top of DOS - with 95 they tried to merge the two and did not quite manage it, thus cause instabilities. Most stabilities fixed in 98 and imporved in 98SE. NT best for servers not workstations. 2000 Pro more stable but ME was as bad as 95. XP is much more stable but Home version is as bad at 95 and ME.

Best Workstation is XP Pro with SP1 not 2, best server is 2000 Advanced Server.

Pros for MS are that many people have learnt on them and the basic feel is the same through out thus learning the changes is relatively easy on the average user and almost anyone can load the software.

Major cons not mentioned above - default configurations waste too much space (drive reserves - 10% recycle bin, 12% restore) and leave the system wide open to any attack - need an expert to configure properly in all versions. Cost much more than most alternatives (not the case originally). Often not backwards compatible.

After 20 years of using MS I am in the process of going to Linux with WINE to run my applications because most of my old 98 apps wont run in XP, thus I need a dual boot XP/98 where as Linux wiuth WINE will run them all without a reboot.

by grant22

Unfortunately, due to end of life announcements, there is only one choice, Windows XP. You can choose between home and professional, but that is all. You have no other choice until probably 2007, when Longhorn will likely come out.

Now, if you want to talk choices other than Windows, we need to start looking at what tasks you expect to perform, and then see if Windows is the best for what you are doing, or if something else would be better suited to your needs. However, if you have already chosen Windows, and want security patches, your only choice is Windows XP, service pack 2.

by morphen

MS Dos worked and Win 3.1x seemed to make life easer at least you could go back to dos to repair some of the problems. Since MS moved to 95 and upwards they have gone backwards not forwards. You would think with Unix/Linux out there that MS could at least take a page of there book and make there Os setup more configurable without second guessing what it is we want to do.

95 worked but it had to many compatablity issues.
98 one of the better Os's to come out of MS.
2000 probably the most stable pity it's fading away.
XP (Xtra Problems) the name says it all.

Xp has caused more problems than it has fix

by techniquephreak

I love all the anti-Microsoft phreak-wannabe's out there, like you, who are so blinded by their hatred for Microsoft that they cannot see the weaknesses of their own beloved platforms/suites.

Most good distros of Linux are going to cost you money in the long run, and Mac and Linux are just as vulnerable to security threats and viruses. In fact, it is SO much easier to hack a Linux box that it is just laughable that folks still cling to it as a viable alternative!

And regarding your weakly formed opinion of MS application suites, almost all open source software is just a cheap knock-off of an MS product anyway, only with more bugs and less support. And there are very few MS programs that don't carry good cross-product compatability. Mainly Access and Publisher, which only a complete moron would use anyway. Of course, this dude was only asking about OS's anyway...

Do you really think Joe Schmo computer user is going to want to sit around having to learn about upgrading kernels and rebuilding libs?

I scoff at your remarks! You're obviously either a Newb or a total wannabe/tool!!

by txtom

You complain of 'apple centric' parts. I would go so far as saying the only parts you MUST get replacements for from Apple would be the motherboard or the case components. Other than that, there are choices in optical drives, hard drives (current standard in the towers is SATA and prior to that it was ATA) memory (using industry-standard memory components as mine has PC2700 sticks) and even video cards. The cards do have to be 'mac centric' but you do not have to get them from Apple.

Apple got away from NuBus and other proprietary components like that years ago.

Maybe you should look again.

by txtom

Your comment about FoxPro also indicates you were running the older 'classic' OS. The new X OS running off the BSD sub-layer is extremely stable. I've been running OSX since the day it was released to the public. The ONLY time I've locked it up was installing a trackball that installed kernal extentions which conflicted with a third party USB2 card I had. It took Kensington all of a day to fix the conflict and I was on my way. In day-to-day use, I've never locked up the new OS.

by txtom

One purpose? Ok, they're stable.

Two: their color quality control has never been matched by any other platform for monitor-to-finished-product color accuracy. We call it ColorSync and no one else has anything close to it. Care to guess why it's the publishing world's dominant player?

And who goes to a 'start' button to shut down?

by ke_xtian

...we have Windows 2003 boxes just go dead for no apparent reason. We open tickets with MS and spend hours on the phone with them trying different things, to no avail. The end result is almost always the same: the old Microsoft 3-finger salute...CTL-ALT-DEL. Reboot fixes everything until it wants to break again.

by tango

Windows Firewall is ok as inbound protection goes - so, Microsoft is heading in the right direction. However, I use ZoneAlarm Free to notify me of any outbound connection attempts, which Windows Firewall is clearly not capbable of at this time. I use WinXP Pro SP2 and keep it up-to-date with all of Microsoft security fixes. The day that Windows Firewall can pass all of the tests at http://www.firewallleaktester.com is the day I will turn Windows Firewall on again. I run with it off and use ZoneAlarm Firewall to stealth my ports, and also run PC-Cillin Internet Security 2005 with a lightweight firewall and network virus protection.

Thomas

by txtom

Trying to stay on topic and NOT going into why I use Mac over Windows or even Mac Server.

Windows has the great advantage of being deeply embedded in the business market due to being in right place at the right time for moving to the PC platform. Being embedded did not make the OS better, it made it cheaper for IT depts. to move from DOS machines to Windows machines. As a result of the ubiquitous nature of 'being everywhere,' it has compatibility advantages. There are truly problems of upgrade path compatabilites, but that's true across any OS from time to time. Being everywhere, you stand a chance that your product/output will be usable by a huge user base.

Cons to me far outweigh the advantage of market saturation.

With the market saturation, the OS(s) are the target of every hacker, PO'd geek and thief out there. Security has always been and continues to be Window's biggest weakness. If you don't commit a good deal of time applying security patches and virus definition updates, you're leaving yourself vulnerable in an increasingly hostile environment.

Cost is also a major con. And I'm not just referring to the upgrade pricing and Microsoft's migration towards 'software rental'. But the IT costs are trememdous in manhours spent fixing the holes and damage caused by yet-unseen vulnerabilites. As robust as some claim it to be, it's a real siphon on IT manhours.

As for individual OS's, I pretty much concur on the individual releases: 95 as a decent upgrade from 3.11, 98 a more robust verson than 95, ME as the worst OS release EVER, 2000 as the first REAL corporate-worthy Windows, XP as 2000SP3 with unnecessary eye-candy. And ALL of the above real DOGS on IT manhours.

by pctechmgr

I now think Windows has the stability that it lacked for many years. I think there needs to be more competition in this space to keep Microsoft bringing better products to market.

by invisible bunny

These are just opinions, but since I have worked with everything from CP/M through DOS 1 and Unix, Xenix, Cromix & a teensy bit of Linux, also of course Apple DOS and Mac.

To be honest, I never used to like Windows as it was a blatant rip off of Mac OS at the time of Windows 1, however, it grew and matured and eventually became stable. It was really about Windows 98 that I began to trust it as an operating system that worked with me and started to save me endless configuration, especially with installing devices & new software.
I have been impressed with the update & service pack system that allows me to keep my XP laptops up to date for free. I must admit I didn't expect it, so found it gratifying to think they would continue to upgrade the system I bought years ago.
Thankfully hardware has matured too, so the true Plug & Play nature of many devices means I can get on with my job and not mess about.
I am also grateful for Microsoft's new initiative to provide anti-spyware as they are clearly in the position to do the most effective job of stopping it. The version I have was free to download for a decent length of trial period and although the pop up window alert looks "unfinished" it does seem to do the job, so I am happy.
I am pleased with initiatives like those which address windows in foreign languages, being resident in Wales where the native tongue is a fairly rare thing (in terms of numbers of speakers)
I also like the charitable initiatives, such as providing operating systems for computers which have been donated to charities.
On the other side of the coin, I am no longer able to understand the operating system, especially when things like DLL's come into play, so I feel sometimes programmes take over my computer in ways that I cannot comprehend and therefore cannot prevent. I would not play with the registry, but appreciate there is a lot going on there and also that it is accessible - assuming I had time to learn how to handle it.
I feel much of the Windows code is probably superfluous and only takes up valuable system memory, both on hard disk and in memory, running so many concurrent applications and offering so many colour schemes and patterns, too many options, but a nice feature at the expense of my resources. There seem to be dozens of services running at any given time. I often wonder if they serve any useful purpose, but am not in a position to judge as my technical skills don't extend that far.
I do know what I am doing with computers, right down to machine code level - but nowadays I just want to get on with the job and not get into the technicalities.

On the whole, I believe Windows is good, especially XP. I like it, but, it has taken a long time getting there. I have however changed my mind about Mr Gates products and am a happy convert. I still love Apple Macs though! but that is because the hardware is a better platform than the X86 pentium system.

I hope this helps in some small way, good luck with your project and report.

regards, Ian

by linuxinlibraries.com

You are going to get a million or so replies on the evils of Microsoft(tm) Windows and I am not going to rehash that, it isn't entirely evil. Windows has the most software commercially available and is easiest to use for non-techies. It also has the most hardware available. SuSE Linux is a pretty decent distro for "newbies" too. I have no experience with Unubtu or Gentoo but I hear they are decent as well.

I want to point out that I have two machines running FreeBSD 4.11 and am having decent luck finding software that is already ported and ready to install relatively easily. Check it out here http://www.freebsd.org/ports/ and see what programs are avaiable. :) (Warning: OpenOffice should NOT be installed through the ports unless you have a few weeks to spare!)

by robert.jean.mcleod

Have been a user of DOS to WINxp Win98 was the best yet I am new to XP used 98 for 6 years with compaq system with almost no problems. BSD a few times but nothing serious. First pc was Packard Bell, no windows but it did use a program to access the software. Linited exposure to win 95,
#.11 and 95 were used at work but I did not get a pc with win95, too unstable it alwasys hung or crashed at work so I moved to WIN98 when I bought the compaq. Now using HP system WINXP with 512 meg ram and it is working well so far. Have seen WIN 2000 I liked it as it did have a lot of time savers in networking and such. May your project work out for you.