Discussion Locked

Q&A's in Discussions, I made my case

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well, I sent an email to R regarding the constant Q&A's in discussions and suggested that they use a checkbox or flag of some sort to indicate incorrectly posted questions.
I also mentioned that people closing questions without allocating points should have to fill in a form field explaining why the points were not allocated based on the responses gathered or offer a blacklist so that users who are found to misuse the R site can be flagged so members can use thier own discretion before offering solutions in the future.
Feels kinda like pissing in the wind but you got to start somewhere I guess.

Any support of my ideas or new ideas that could be offered (by you) to TR would be appreciated but not expected.

27 replies

by cactus pete

In the grand scheme of things, it IS a rather trivial matter, but I would really rather like to have this given some consideration, as well.

Since the last discussion about Q&A in the wrong place, things seem to have gotten even worse. I wouldn't be surprised if a *vast* majority of the threads started in the last month here are actually topics better suited for the Q&A section of TR. It begs the question of why there is a separation at all...

So, consider yourself supported, though I haven't anything new to contribute. I would very much like to see this concern addressed.

by oz_media

You're right, the Q&A's in the discussion forums aqree getting really bad now.
Max had some great suggestions based on the old TR layout that would be great.

It only takes a voice to get action, I appreciate your suuport.

by maxwell edison

TR used to show the statistics on how people treated their questions, but they removed it some time ago. (I wish they'd bring it back.) For example, it might indicate that a particular person asked 10 questions, received 50 (total) answers, and none were accepted - for a 0% acceptance rating. (Or 45 were accepted - 90%, and so on). It was similar to the chart showing the statistics of how many questions a person answered, how many were accepted, etc. With this in place, a person could determine the likelyhood of having his/her answer accepted before taking the time to post one. There were times, for example, when I saw that a person rejected 90%, 95%, or more of all answers, and as a result, I would take a pass on trying to post one. (Unless I had a different reason to post.)

I'd like a system that's similar to the one they have rating - or scoring - the top question answerers. Let's see the people who are tops at accepting answers given.

I'm of the opinion that most all answers are worthy of being accepted - especially if it's an "opinion" type question. After all, even the elimination of "wrong" solutions can be helpful in determining the "right" one, so even if the answer is off the mark, if a person is willing to giveme a few minutes of his/her time in an attempt to help, then passing on a few points - along with a show of grattitude - is the least I can do. Out of all the questions I've posted, I've probably accepted 95% (or more) of the answers, passing along close to 200,000 points, and usually leaving a personalized comment to each and every one. Some people treat their questions just about the opposite. I must admit, that I just don't get it - not saying thank you, and not passing along a few lousy andworthless points.

by oz_media

Your response is accurate and eloquesnt as usual.
I have noticed that you offer comments on almost all suggeations in the Q&A forum, which in my case is helpful when I get to see your thoughts behind my resolutions, it gets me to look at things from a different perspective sometimes.

I don't knwo how much time you feel like putting into this subject but I'm sure an email to TR would help. NOTE: I posted to the contact listed for Discussions.

Thanks for your input.

by maxwell edison

It seems that this has happened more and more since the issue was brought up a while back. I must admit, however, that I sometimes have answered such questions, even it's posted in the discussion area. (Maybe I shouldn't do that.) I must also admit,that I've been tempted to post technical questions in the discussion area myself, just for the purpose of gaining more exposure. However, that would be in addition to posting the same thing in the Q&A section, not instead of. I've noticed that many people (but not all) tend to migrate to one or the other areas, but not both. (But some do indeed visit both areas.) I currently have a question posted in the Q&A, and I must admit that I almost posted it in the discussion area as well - just for theincreased exposure. How many more replies could I get if I posted in both areas?

by oz_media

Perhapse a discussion relating and then pointing to your question in the Q&A forum. I think I know the question you are referring to in this case.
Although relatively new here, I don't think you make a practice out of 'abusing' the site at all.
If you were to post here and explain that you didn't recieve the answer in the Q&A should be considered apropriate. Or just state your case and point to the URL so people could answer there and recieve the goodies if accepted. People know you here and don't think that you are just sucking resources out without some valuable input for others. There's a little personal discression needed, perhapse a good reason to FLAG an incorrectly posted question and let your peers decide for themselves whether to help or not. Obviously, if you were constantly sucking info without any input for others, you would become known for it and when flagged, people would NOT offer as much help in future.

by cactus pete

You may recall that I posted my question about KVS last week in the Q&A section. I closed it with little input [granted, the three top answerers contributed]. I was rather hoping for someone with hands on experience giving me some advice.

This week, TR themselves [re]created my post into the Discussion arena, and backdated it enough to get it off of the recent posts. They did not ask me if I needed the help, or inform me that they would do this, other than my noticing my alias in a techmail.

Honestly, I was considering posing the question here in the discussions, as I was looking for opinions, but thought that the 50,000 points would get me some attention. Oh well.

by maxwell edison

After you said TR recreated your question and put it in the discussions, I searched for it (out of curiosity).

Why would they do that, I wonder? And why change the date? And why change the wording and context of the question?

This link shows that it was created on 7-15

http://tinyurl.com/abd7

However, this link shows that it was created on 6-23

http://tinyurl.com/he2g

What's up with that?

(I noticed similar discrepancies with others as well.)

You really didn't start thatdiscussion?

Interesting indeed.

(But it did get an answer - on 7-15. I wonder........)

So this means that I can claim that all those "bad" (lack of tact) messages that only "appeared" to be from me were really posted by others (at TR) with some other motive. Yea, that's the ticket.

by don_c

Hi I just recently joined TR about 2 to 3 months ago and learned real quickly about the Q&A section. I have answer three question one got rejected. And the two not heard anything. I know all my answers were correct. Now I just stay in the discussions area. I strongly agree with you about the point system that is set up for TR. They should put stronger stipulations on that area. Cause newbie?s like me could get discourage reel quick. And not participate. I hope you get more support and TR listens because this situation SUCKS!!!!

by oz_media

Not everyone in the world is an upstanding citizen, not everyone has morals, not everyone has class. Some people give and take, some people take. Some people respect another's work, some people don't.

As long as you are one of the people who care, help and share, you are always going to be dicouraged by those who don't.

There are enough winners in the world that we don't need to worry about the losers.

Welcome to TR, don't get discouraged, I've seen some REALLY neat stuff happening here with some really decent people. Stay and you will find it really helpful to be a member here.

Thnks for your support!

by maxwell edison

TR doesn't have a moderator who monitors these forums. (Personally, I prefer it that way.) Having said that, the accepting or rejecting of answers is pretty much ruled by the honor system. Some answers are replied to in a timely and considerate manner, while others are not. OzMedia probably hit the nail on the head with his reply. Some people just don't care, while others go out of their way to show that they do. This is true in life, and it obviously carries over into forums like these.

I'll second what OzMedia suggested - don't get discouraged by the ones who don't care, but focus instead on the ones who do. And even if an answer is rejected, hopefully you'll gain something positive from the experience. It's there, but you may have toremind yourself to look for it.

Welcome to TechRepublic and its sometimes wacky cast of characters. Some of these discussions can get quite lively, oftentimes crossing the line of too lively. But in the end, I think you'll find that most folks around here - especially the regulars - are pretty decent people. Let them be the ones that determine how you form your opinion of us and the site, not the others.

As far as the questions you've answered, way to go - even if a correct answer was rejected. I've had 697 of my answers rejected (some deserved to be), 300 of my answers have had no reply at all, but I've had 1062 answers accepted and/or to which a comment of thanks was left. Those are the ones that count, not the others. Keep answering the questions, and you'll be the ultimate beneficiary - even if some of the answers are ignored or rejected. The accepted ones will come, there's no doubt about it. In the end, it will probably be in the 50-50 range, maybe more, maybe less.

By the way, if you want to get that first accepted under your belt, follow this link and give this question a shot:

http://tinyurl.com/hcuw

by oz_media

Hey Max, I enjoyed your positive comments and found your welcome to be very kind, too bad I wasn't as tactful at getting known here. Oh well, we all learn.

Then you slap the guy with your IPSec questions!!!???
C'mon give a guy a break! Not that I assume he would be unable to answer it but I figured the URL was for a straight-up and 'normal' question not for solving your Pandora's Box mystery, nice one!

by maxwell edison

Hey, a guy's gotta do what a guy's gotta do.

If he, or anyone else for that matter (Lordinfidel, where are you?), can figure out how I can make that IPSec VPN connection work with what I currently have and how it's described (without having to buy anything else) I'll bump the points up to 50,000 before I accept the answer. (I'll most likely accept all of the answers posted thus far, anyway.)

That'll make up for a couple of lousy rejections, don't you think?

By the way, we all occasionally "slip" in the tact department, don't we?

by oz_media

"By the way, we all occasionally "slip" in the tact department, don't we?"

As a HUGE Monty Pythons fan, all I can say is "Oh, no, no, no, no.........yes."

I hear you're a scout leader ! I was in scoutnig for 12 years, Senior Sixer, Chief Scout, Queens Venturer, Cub leader, Scout Leader etc. Best 12 years of my life. Unfortunately, kids don't see scouting as cool (didn't when I was a Scout either but Oh, well their loss).
Kudos to you for supporting and being a member of the best partof most kids childhoods.

Did you go to WJ83 in Alberta??

by don_c

OzMedia thanks for the advice. I haven?t got discourage. I like TR it?s helping me understanding the IT world. Which I?m studying for my MCSE and getting a lot of information form TR and MAX well I read your Pandora?s Box Mystery. I would like to help but as of right now it?s a little over my head. But ill give you this much. I haven?t met a satellite that I like yet. I?m a cable man myself. I like that solid connection an I have a Linksys router a BEFSR41 I have no problem and max

by maxwell edison

...scout leader. The top dog is a retired Marine Colonel - an F-16 pilot. A pretty commanding presence indeed. We do have a great group of kids. (Including my own, of course.)

In fact, we're doing our annual summer camp out next week (7-20 thru 7-26) at one of the scout camps in the Colorado mountains - camping, hiking, etc.

I've never even heard of WJ83. What is it?

(Maybe someone will have a solution to my IPSec problem when I get back!)

by thechas

Hi Oz,

I meant to post to this a few days ago, and got busy with other things.

As of today, I have 1067 answers that have not been rated!

I fully agree that it would be very nice to know why an answer was rejected, or what other informationthe peer needs.

I have had several on-going discourses on a few questions until the problem was resolved.
I like these, as I learn more along with helping someone out.

I have also been pretty good about not answering questions posted in discussions until they are a day old.
I may post sooner if someone gives bad advice.
I try to add a comment to each Discussion question advising the peer to use the Q&A forum.

Maybe we should start posting a wrong forum comment as soon as we see a question posted in the Discussion center.

I think that part of the problem is that some people treat anything that is free very poorly. Since the only cost for posting a question is a bit of time, I suspect that many of the open and rejected answersare from peers who found their own fix, and decided it is too much bother (or they are too embarrassed) to explain the rejection or even rate an answer.

I would like to see TR send out periodic reminders to those peers with open questions that have "not rated" answers.
Require a response to keep a question open. If no comments are added by the poster over a certian period of time, the question would be closed.

Chas

by oz_media

You have many good points as usual. I don't think TR is jumping on this idead but I've only sent email to the anonymous Discussion Forym contact so I guess if it gets worse, I'll tell someone who cares.

"Maybe we should start posting a wrong forum comment as soon as we see a question posted in the Discussion center."
This is usually what I do in the morning, it may seem cold or rude to some but if you spend much time here, it really starts to bug you. I generally offer very simplistic or evasive answers after saying that it should be in Q&A's.

Thanks for your support Chas,
take care.OM

by oldefar

I think we forget that for TR, the site is all about advertisement revenue. That revenue is based on usage, and anything that increases usage is therefore "good". The sale of their own products is a secondary source of revenue.

Now with that in mind, they have to look at the usage of the Q&A area and the usage of the Discussion area as revenue enhancing. If they can get a particular question to generate additional hits by repeating it in the discussions, so much the better.

This also explains why some tangents are allowed to go along for weeks, and some posts that seem to be focused on creating controversy are not dealt with by TR. After all, what is important is the count, and a flame fest counts as much as a thoughtful discussion.
Or so it seems to me.

by admin

As usual, you are right on there Oldefar. One question I have though... are we TR members ultimately more a product or more a service to the paying customers they are selling our presence to?

:)

by oldefar

I had to think about this a bit.

To the advertisers (paying customers for TR) we are the product. Same genre as a mailing list.

To each other we are a service. A consulting service to be more specific.

And on occaission, as when we work hard to come up with a legitimate solution in the Q&A section, we are serviced. Check with a livestock operation if you aren't sure about this. :)

Historical note - why did I leave my hat on when I went to CBPO to check on my orders? They had a sign posted "Please remove hat before being serviced", and after 3 changes to my orders I was tired of being "serviced".

by road-dog

I was in the Marines, and your Colonel may have flown anything from the A-4 to the F-18, but not the F-16. The F-16 is strictly an Air Force asset, although serving in air forces of some 20+ nations.

As for your observations on scouting, I was ascout during my formative years and have nothing but good to say about it... well, except for that unfortunate incident where the den mother got pregnant by one of my packmember's dads. Although being totally unrelated to the scouting, it was a lesson in honesty.

I think that there needs to be a mechanism where members can vote a topic out of the discussion side. Three "bounce" votes by members would kick the question over to Q&A... Does the discussion software support such a thing?

by oz_media

WJ83 was the World Jamboreee held in Kananaskis Alberta (stunning place). The African Scouts had problems with golf ball sized hail storms in the middle of a sunny afternoon but it all went well overall.

Hope your trip went well, OM

by admin

Growing up, I didn't know that ABS was a plastic.

I thought it was a mysterious person in a refrigerated truck who was never without a certain stainless steel bucket that sent up smoke like a witches cauldren on halloween....

But seriously, the feature I wish they had was a counter on each page so we could see the number of hits. Evertime I see a new post I assume many others read but did not post. From the postings I can tell that questions in the discussion forums and political squabbles seem to get the most posts and I can infer that they get the most hits. I can then postulate that the majority of advertising money is coming from off topic and innapropriate Q&A's in the discussions- at least on the discussion side.

I wonder if they are actually more concerned about the recent drop off of discussion activity and are looking forward to future off-topic and posts in the wrong areas? They are, after all, a business first...

by maxwell edison

He most recently flew F-18s, not F-16s; and he flew F-4s earlier in his career. By the way, I thought the Navy had the F-16, while the Air Force had the F-15s? (At least that's the way it was when I was in the U.S.A.F.)

This discussion is closed to new replies.