Discussion Locked

Questions of a Novice Network Admin

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

background: I work as a network admin in a small firm (1 Netware file server, more recently a Win2000 Terminal server has been added, 26 workstations, a standalone to collect the email and run some programs).

I was hired with the expectation that only part of my time would be spent in the 'network admin role'. This is the way it has always been, part accountant, part network admin. I was a comp. science student doing an accounting minor, the role looked good to me.

However, now I am realising that there has never been a network admin with any training. Consequently the system is very very lacking. Mostly the problem is bad documentation. But also with the previous networks admins primary responsibility being accounting, they had a 'fixit quick and get back to work' mentality.

I have worked in this firm for 18months now, and have really only been allowed to get my hands dirty (the previous Network admin still works here, and has been made to do more 'accounting'). I say all this to show you just how low a priority this firms places on the role of network admin.

During the last 3 months I have been a full-time network admin, I have gotten my way, gained respect, and am using what knowledge I have a(and am gaining by reading sites like this one)to create a system that will evolve with the firm.

I was just chatting with the previous network admin (did I mention he still works here), and he seems to think the role is unnessecary .."the users have a certain level of computer knowledge, to help them we only need to have a low knowledge, if the problem requires high knowledge we call DMS, they are reasonably priced"

DMS is a company that looks after our network, helps us plan the direction of our infrastructure, and if problems are too hard for me, I call them. I am happy with this, not just because I work with them when they fix things, ask alot of questions and come away with more knowledge.

Am I needed in a firm this size?
Or at least is a full-time network admin needed in a firm this size, do you think a part-time network admin would do?
Is documentation needed in a firm this size?

I say a definite 'YES' do the documentation (despite the previous network admins comments in the lunchroom).
But should my job really be a full-time one? I know most of my time at the moment is spent on pro-active issues, ie making things better for the users. One of the things I am working on at home is Word macros for all the templates etc.

I am really after confirmation of just how much time does a network admin need to spend being a network admin in a firm this size.

Thanks,
Cassie

16 replies

by lumberjack

Hi cassie,
First of all - by network admin - do you mean desktop, server and network support - or just network?
I used to work for an office of 70 users covering all 3 above. There was Unix and Mac systems - but they were administerred by a colleague and I helped when he was busy. My side was about 40 users and 3 servers. It started at about a 60% of my time (along with building maintenance & phones!) However there was lots of projects which I instigated, new AV - updated mail systems - NT domain etc. It soon became 110% of my time. (the maintenance & phones was given to a new part-timer).

So to answer your question - 1 office, 26 users, 2 servers may be only overall 80-90% of your time - just wait! It is a full time post.

by stalinvlad9

Les see a/c firm.
Application list say one office xx, some light DB's, maybe Lotus Notes or Exchange
A few moves and changes each year
Usual forgot password stuff

Yeah sounds to me like you should have a couple of hours in the afternoon to write documentation,
maybe write a few macros etc
Would say write some HowTos for the usual stuff people ask for, assume that you will be run over by a bus, how would the next person cope?
Rather a small network to bother drawing cable diagrams for, you don't say but I would assume no router and at most 3 hubs/switches, all in one 19" rack somewhere near the kettle make tea area

I would say 50+ people(or workstations?) require a full time admin, so 26 should really be a PT job, but then as you say you also do accounting stuff.

In these organic networks an admin is like a fireextinguisher,when the brown stuff hits the fan you call out a support firm (in this case some people called DMS)but your expected to cope with chip pan fires.

by cass.harley

You have hit the nail on the head, summed up nicely by:
>In these organic networks an admin is like a fireextinguisher,when the brown stuff hits the fan you call out a support firm (in this case some people called DMS)but your expected to cope with chip pan fires.

I have only really taken properly over in the last 7 months, actually pretty much the moment the TermServ was installed. We have had stacks of troubles lately with a new software release refusing to work with our Novell 3.12 server. Just put in an order for a Small Business Server. And you are right, I do what I can, but mostly all of this goes to 'DMS'. Thanks for you comments, I appreciate getting a feel for how much time my role should take.

by vida

You two aren't net admin, you're tech support - maybe. There are two of you on a 26 user network with 1 server and you are still outsourcing? Win 2000 Term Server was added? - did you set Terminal Services up yourself?

If you want and idea of a "full"time solo net admin...

I get to spend anywhere from 5 to 15+/- hours a week on my systems with 48 users (that I've trained from levels of not ever touching a computer to screamers and haters for changing from Word Perfect to MS Word. I have an Imaging Server, App Server (Terminal Server w/Citrix Metaframe so Boss can access Limited documents from anywhere), Print/mail/DNS server and a Linux Red Hat firewall, all of which I setup/built myself (well the linux i had a step by step) - starting with punching down my rj45s in the new building and parting out old pc's when one went down. I created and maintain a website and much needed databases that are still no where near what the demands are. I keep things good for my staff, they have no worries, if I have to stay up late reading about port blocking and iptables everynight for the rest of my life so dr. can say "oh, well i didn't know about the virus being so bad" to her stressed collegues at a laser convention in italy - I will.

I create brochures, inter-office forms, and macros for templates on the fly, that I would LOVE to deligate to a f@$!%ing secretary!

I train and notify and scare the hell out of everyone regarding security and I create all Laser Surgery PowerPoint presentations(ALOT). My Big Dr travels internationally throughout the year and she's a handfull herself (first female president of ASLMS this past year!)

As her Editor/Co-writer for All clinical abstracts, studies, chapters, magazine articles, and white papers - the other 4 docs and Fellows/Interns/Management staff have to bribe me for time - and even at that I Forced the clinical staff to "learn" medline searches for their docs.
And the only support/entertainment I have is TR member forums.
I just did my First kernel upDATE in redhat for crying out loud!
[THANKYOU LINFIDEL!]

Full time is what you make of it, and net admin is just something we get to say because we're the only "techs" in the building(s).
Although, with this paperless thing and new building and wireless being mentioned - i might just be a real net admin soon...

by cass.harley

I am not sure if you are being harsh or not. First let me correct one thimg, I am the only person in this role, although the guy who used to do it is still in the building, it is not is job anymore (he is 100% accountant).

As for the role, appreciate the comment. I never really know what to label myself, I do more then just tech support, but alot of it is the plain vanilla 'my computer is borken..wow how did you do that' kind of stuff.

I never wanted a tech role, I am not really into the IT field too much. I did a degree so I could get into software development, I am an 'I Love Maths' type of girl. When I took this job I was severly misled into believing they had a developer do contract work for them and and that I (being just finishing up uni at this stage) would be trained, and given a programming type role (at least part-time). It turned out that they had once contracted a guy to spend two days writing an Access .mde to track the client work in the firm...So here I am doing tech stuff.

At first I hated it, but now I am realising it is good. I always swayed to the Math side of software development. I love logic etc, and avoided the tech side of it. Working here means I know have to know the difference between a Novell Server and a Win2000 Server. I have to understand TCP/IP versus NetBEUI etc

I am glad you are busy in your job, but that wasn't really the heart of my question. You are right I have made myself very busy, but mostly I am cleaning up after the previous people (ie we have documentation in folders that lets me know that 5years ago the partners son turned off the computer and the backup didn't work). All knowledge has been stored 'up here' and they goes against the person I am. So I am busy trying to clean up this system. Look at patched-up problems, figure out why they were patched that way in the first place and either document or review. The staff are still wasting time with antiquated habits that stem from problems that no longer exist.

So yes, I am definetly making a fulltime job of it at the moment. I really just wanted to get a feel for how much of my time should be pointed in the Network Admin direction.

by vida

I attempted to give you an idea of how your situation could present itself, i felt you were approaching it from a restricted idea of your role. assess your environment and the potential critical needs that you could meet, project outside of "will this shoe fit in this box". in fact throw the box away all together - if you take into account the situation at hand and discern for yourself what you are willing to put into it, then you can answer your question yourself. in the instance of private industry, the rules are all different.

i just gave you the real-life scenario of how things might go, and points to consider as far as your role. if your firm is going to be expanding, it's an even broader ground for the significance of a fulltime/onsite - when i was hired, the practice had a 5 station peer to peer running some theos os. regardless, things change, and I.T. implements the change, in turn indicating the demand/significance.
you implied the network was outdated/insufficient,
you stated that you currently outsource and are learning (and liking it),
and you requested confirmation of how much time a net admin would spend in a firm that size.
from direct experience, i layed out possible directions this position could go.

proposing a time saving, cost effective, security minded upgrade to the "lacking" environment further expands your role and eventually cutting the outsourced I.T. - or keeping them only as a backup reference in the event of an emergency are solid goals for you to begin projecting the necessity of a "full time sys/net admin. in a firm that size."

documentation is needed where ever troubleshooting occurs. it's the key to your systems/network. the Next time the same or similar incidence occurs, documentation proves invaluable and $/time effecient. if you've got some downtime as an sys admin, don't hesitate to provide your range of services where needed. i didn't mean to portray that I'M so incredably busy as much as i was excited for the endeavor and to point out the endless ways to lend your skills to your particular environment.

i addressed your focus on "time necessary for a full time net admin in your small environment" by pointing out the variety of possibilities before you.
inadequacies are wide open doors for expansion.

i'm always self-debasingly sarcastic about my admin status around the Supers i still feel so green - text doesn't carry tone, i'm retarded.

Note: It's private industry! the rewards are endless - my boss/company put me front and center with Paul McCartney in appreciation for my role there(life time dream - accomplished)

by voldar

Hi there. I read your article and the only thing I have to say is: It's up to you to have a full time job or not. About the number of workstations - 26 - this does not mean anything. You have to start from something, and 26 is just the right number to start with.
The idea that a company of your size does not need at least an IT administrator is a bit (read much more) odd. Why? Because now information is no more "everything" - security instead is in the lead. And you can't have security when everybody do anything. This is what managers have to understand. Just imagine the following: one day, when you come to the office, you start your computer and you see that all data is gone. And you try on the other collegue computer - and it's the same. And your firm has a dead-line today, and everything is gone. What would be the result of this situation?

About how much time a netwok admin has to spend managing a network environment like yours, there is no "time limit". The admin work does not consist only on troubleshooting, help-desk supporting, maintenance, he also has to study/test/propose/implement sollutions so that the network become more stable, more efficient. But before starting testing it's very important to know what you are doing -> lots of readings and a good understanding before starting testing, because the computers work on the G-G principle: garbage is your input - garbage is the output.
That's it for now - hope my opinion help you to have an image about what really IT network administrator means.

by cass.harley

Your thoughts did help.
I am appreciating all the input.

You are right, I get the most satisfaction, not out of the help desk role, but out of solving problems before they occur, making things efficient, implementing solutions to make the staff happier. I am definetly only new to the IT game, and never thought I wanted to come here. however I am enjoying the experience, I guess with such a small firm I get to wear a lot of hats...Help desk, maintenance, programmer, management IT adviser, network administer, and yet I still get the benefit of looking over the shoulder of the engineers from DMS (our outsourced tech peeple) to learn more things.

I think I will continue to make this as fulltime a job as I possibly can, as long as I am producing productive-for-the-firm results.

Thanks

by maxwell edison

You ask, "Am I needed in a firm this size"? Well, either you are needed or someone like you.

Is documentation needed in a firm this size? Absolutely. Documentation of a network system will only help in maintaining it, and will, in the long run, mean less time has to be spent on it. Not only will the documentation give you a quick overview of what you have, but will allow you to better maintain it and plan for the future. How can you decide where you want to go - and the best way to get there - if you don't know your starting point? Moreover, by documenting the network, you'll learn a lot about what you have.

You go on to ask if this should be a full time or part time position. I would think that with 26 clients and a couple of servers, a part time position could probably take care of things, depending, of course, on the level of knowledge the person has. If a lot of research time, for example, is necessary to fix almost every problem, then perhaps more time would be necessary - but only for the short term, as hopefully this person could get up to speed rather quickly. However, "part time" in this environment doesn't necessarily mean that it's reasonable to expect 4 hours a day spent on accounting and 4 spent on I.T. each and every day. In this context, part time means that 1040 hours (out of 2080 per year) would probably be enough to fill the need. Some of those hours might be spent 40 hours a week for a certain window of time, while only a few hours a week - or no hours - during other times. It all depends on the task at hand. You can replace a failed hard drive and reload the system in a half a day, but to upgrade the entire office to the next generation of operating system should be done over a dedicated and uninterrupted period of time. So flexibility is the key.

A huge advantage, by the way, of having a dual role is that you have a wide understanding of how to apply the technology, and might have better insight than an outside consultant as to the specific needs. This consultant, for example, services networks for accountants, lawyers, insurance companies, engineers, architects, home owners, gas stations, bowling alleys, and on and on. Where you hold the advantage is that you know the technology AND you know how to use that technology for the specific purpose of accounting.

by lordinfidel

No matter what size the firm, 2 people or 1000.

There will always need to be a dedicated person who is responsible for the overall function of the network.

This person would be called the Network Administrator regardless of their experience level.

Now to the hard part. Full time or Part time. This will depend on how the firm see's your primary role. And this is how I equate it.

Full time: Your only function in the world is the network. Out-Sourced Consultants are rarely ever called. You do all the work yourself. Your responsible for the day to day security of the network; (ie servers, desktops, firewall, e-mail, etc)

Part time: You can trouble shoot desktop systems for the general user support. Although you leave all server maintenance and network monitoring to an dedicated outsourced IT Staff. You are their point person within the company. And it is your responsibility to oversee their work.

Finally: Network administration is serious business. If you are connected to the net and allow users to send/receive e-mail. Then the seriousness of the job grows.

The professional Net Admin understands this. The one's thrown into the role do not. And that is where the definition of part-time / full-time comes into play.

Depending on the level of expertise of the Net Admin will also depend on whether they outsource anything. Very rarely will you find the typical net admin outsource anything that is routine.

They might call in a consultant though to help them set-up and configure their $10k CheckPoint firewall or call a CCIE to set up their cisco 7200 vxr. But those things are not routine at all.

If you are going to dedicate yourself to the role then that's fantastic. It sounds like you already have somewhat of a grasp of what needs to get done, and you know your limits.

But I am sure that if the network is really in as dissaray as you believe it is. There is probably alot more then just creating word macros to deal with.

by cass.harley

You guys are making things clearer, and giving me confidence in what my role should be, and direction also.

Thanks.

by oz_media

That's how I got my start (and training) in Network Admin. The company I went to was running four servers with just under 50 stations over three locations. They also had a company on call for REAL emergencies and I was just brought in to be a general office fixit guy/netadmin/fire putter outer.

I have a lot of marketing and advertising experience so this filled my time when I wasn't waiting for something to go wrong with the server (good thing, the server NEVER went down in the 18 months I was there). I got them to put me through school and finally got my needed certs, then moved to the next company that paid to help finish my certs for me.

Now I consult for a VoIP vendor, as well as provide support for the first company's Island customers, as well as a few sidelines.

You should try to keep on full time and benefit from the knowlege you gain from the other support people. If you're bored, try to focus more on your other duties (accounting?) and see if you can grow within the ocmpany that way.

When I was in yuor shoes, I spent as much time as possible working on side projects that helped me gain experience, I was ALWAYS available for the company but managed to fill dead time with knowledge.

If it is salary that is the real issue, at least you have extra time to look elsewhere.

Sounds like you have an ideal position (salary depending) take advantage of the added freedom and spread your wings a bit, you may find you can even create your OWN position and justify the time (as well as a raise for being clever of course).

by cass.harley

>take advantage of the added freedom and spread >your wings a bit, you may find you can even >create your OWN position and justify the time (as well as a raise for being clever of course).

by cass.harley

Thanks, I sort of read it as 'you do nothing, what I do is real work, I could do your work in my sleep, how dare you call your self....' you get the picture.

I just came out of the lunch room with the previous admin when I asked the intial question. He has a very dim view on it all. I have a very dim view on him.
There exists a software cupboard, which has been cleaned out three times this year, by himself and a coworker. Finally as I have stepped into the fullness of this role, I asked if I could clean it out. I threw out manuals for Excel for Windows 3.11, a shelf full of win3.11 installation disks, folders full of emails sent 9 years ago letting me know just whose mouse needed cleaning....
Again, you get the picture. The guy knows alot more 'IT' stuff then I do, but lacks the formal training and general personality I have. I mean to say that I have an organising type personality, I like to solve a problem, not just patch it, and I have learnt (and researched) alot of admin techniques. He never realised that having a computer cupboard full of 30 unorganised Arch-lever folders is daunting, while having 10 well organised folders provides a starting point for a new admin.

I always have that in mind. The day I leave (if and when), the new admin will have no trouble understanding the system, will have a know what to read to bring them up todate on the system nuances, and the methods I used.

I had come off lunch with him, he thinks the proactive actions I am taking are unnessecary. (No doubt I do things that are unnessecary, that is alot to do with human nature often letting personal preference get in the way. but I am trying).

I reread what you said, you do present ideas, and I appreciate it.

Thanks.

by maxwell edison

Remember that, if ever audited for software compliance, you may need prove that you purchased that old Windows 3.1, and then the upgrade to Win95, and then the upgrade to Win98, and then the upgrade to W2k, etc. (Upgrades, instead of buying the full version.) If you only have the current operating system "upgrade", and not the one from which you upgraded, you may have some explaining to do. Of course, the same thought (and documentation) process applies to all the software, not just the operating system.

At least I think this is the case. If anyone knows otherwise, perhaps he/she can clarify this a bit. (For example, if the old software was registered with MS, or whomever, would that suffice? But then again, who really registers all their software?)

And then there's the OEM version versus the boxed version, but that's another can of worms.

by cass.harley

I have checked it out. All the win95 machines have full licenses out the back. The old software is going to charity, if there is a use for it, they will be more likely to find it then I.

This discussion is closed to new replies.