RAID drive failure: Bad luck, or false failure? - TechRepublic
Question
July 18, 2011 at 01:26 PM
robo_dev

RAID drive failure: Bad luck, or false failure?

by robo_dev . Updated 14 years, 11 months ago

Dell dimension E520 Desktop with Intel SATA Raid Controller configured for RAID 0 (mirroring).

Initially I had a pair of Seagate 500 GB drives in there, but only after a week, the flashing red ‘drive failure’ Icon was there, indicating that the secondary drive had failed.

In preparation for returning the drive, I put it in a SATA drive enclosure, ran SeaTools Diags on it (passed), and then did a DBAN data erase on the drive with no problems.

After returning the Seagate to my friends at Fry’s Electronics, I put in a shiny brand new Hitachi 1TB SATA drive as my secondary (I plan to make the primary be an identical Hitachi drive, BTW).

The drive re-mirrored itself without a hitch, seemed happy as a clam, then two days later it shows the Hitachi is in ‘failed’ state.

Am I just having bad luck?

Is something killing my secondary hard drive?

Or is this a ‘false failure’? What would cause the PC to think a drive has failed when it has not?

I plan to swap SATA cables and check for BIOS updates.

This discussion is locked

All Comments