Discussion Locked

Rant of the Week - Taxes (05/28/08)

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It's that time of the week again. You all get to hear me rant, whine, stomp my little foot and generally just give my feable opinion (which we all know is small at that).

This week - its taxes. No matter where you live I'm sure we can all agree when it comes to taxes in one form or another we pay too much. I've never heard someone say - hey you tax me too little - tax me some more! But, I could be wrong (wouldn't be the first time, and won't be the last). :-)

However, on that same note, I'm sure some of us wouldn't mind a tax increase if there was a benefit to our quality of lives - whether that be in the form of better roadways, better healthcare, better services (i.e. fire, police), etc... And as long as said proposed tax increase actually goes toward what it's suppose to go toward and doesn't wind up as just another form for the government or what have you to siphon extra money, leaving nothing for what it was propsed to go toward.

Course in the above case, it's a matter of how to do such that it doesn't harm those who are already struggling in this world, which in return causes its own set of different problems.

Now like most there are certain taxes that drive me nuts. So much so I just want to scream (so plug your ears, I can scream rather loudly)

As mentioned in last week's rant (we managed to get ourselves side-tracked and onto the subject of taxes) - Service taxes, FCC taxes, income taxes, sales tax, inhertience tax, personal property taxes, school taxes, view taxes (for those who have a nice view or not so nice view of something that city thinks is a view even if you have to strain your neck out the window and peer between the two houses blocking your view to catch a sorta glimpse of the so called view - this tends to be a New York favorite) taxes on shipping, and everything else inbetween. Oh and of course my favorite - being taxed for receiving a refund for having paid too much tax to begin with - thats considered income (what?!). If it can be taxed it more likely is in one form or another.

So here's my rant on ones that drive me nuts...

What's up with them FCC taxes anyway? Why do I have to pay it? Then to top it off when they add this tax/fee/surcharge (and we all know fees/surcharges at least in my opinion is just a fancy way of saying "TAXES" or what ever you want to call it to my monthly bill - I'm hit with an extra tax since I'm taxed on the total combined.

Service taxes... why do I have to pay taxes for a service? I go to have a nice dinner, and I'm hit with a tax. I go to have my hair cut, I'm taxed again, I pay taxes on my water bill, my electric bill, my cable bill. Why??? Oh and lets not forget the tax some companies charge if you buy something online - you get hit with a shipping tax - what?! Why? Why are you taking me on the shipping cost? (yeah, I know pick companies that give free shipping)

Why did I have to claim my refund I received for paying too much State tax as Federal income so they could tax me on it?? If I had paid too little and owed the State taxes, the federal government (its a U.S. thing) wouldn't be allowing me to "deduct" the extra I had to pay.

But enough of all that... it gives me one big ole headache and my little foot is tired of me stomping it. :p

So tell me, what taxes drive you nuts? Which ones do you see as being unfair (and yes, I know some would probably see them all as being unfair)

Should some taxes be lowered or eliminated all together? Maybe lower some but raise others? and if so which ones and how can it be done in a way that doesn't do more harm than good.

And lastly, if you raise the taxes on some things where would you like to see that money go?

-Tammy :-)

47 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

you really know how to stir it up! Googling 'wasted federal dollars' returns 1,870,000 hits.

I wouldn't mind paying taxes if our government didn't waste so much of our money. I think that their ability to raise their own pay should be halted. Among other things!

by Tammy.Cavadias

..stir real good and eventually you get something decent tasting (I hope, just don't eat my meatleaf surprise - the surprise is if it tastes like Meatloaf)

I never was afraid of "stirring" the pot so to speak :p

-Tammy :-)

<~~~ peeks out from under the bed just incase the pot boils over

by notsochiguy

...but the FBI's mishandling of its VCF (virtual case file) project would be enough for anyone in the US to consider packing their bags, and learning the chorus of O Canada! Half a billion bucks down with the Tidy Bowl Man's ship...here's another half billion, knock yourselves out. Federal Intelligence...INDEED!!!

That's what burns me. I can accept taxes as a legitimate way to pay for schools, public services, roads, etc. What I can't stand is that far too often, taxes are a way for these morons in public office to try and cover their egregious mistakes by throwing more money at the situation. "Hey, maybe if I keep spending, people will think I really am trying and care."

Couple that with obvious corruption (In Illinois, I'm surprised Corruption: How to Pull a Scam isn't an entire section in Poli-Sci texts) and I would be willing to bet that at least 15% of all public monies are wasted...utterly, totally, brazenly, uselessly wasted.

And for the record, I'll even accept a $600 hammer or $1000 toilet showing up on a federal ledger, because I believe that money is getting funneled into something top secret....I CAN LIVE WITH THAT....knowing that the next Stealth Bomber or better black ops will be the result. I can't accept that two dead relatives of an alderman are still receiving government pay checks...sent to the same address as the alderman has listed as his official residence.

I truly think that the only reason the government bothers with Rico cases is because they don't want competition muscling in on their extortion monopoly!

Don't get me started on Social Security, either. If I had the opportunity to opt out and fund my own retirement (freedom of choice...free economic enterprise...what crazy nation would ever contemplate allowing such notions to exist), the ink from my signature couldn't dry fast enough. And lest any government official try and dissuade me by stating how difficult it is to make money in the private financial markets, I have one name for you: Lenny Dykstra. If he can become an investment guru, I have no doubt that someone would be able to succeed by simply putting the WSJ into the bottom of a bird cage, and selecting whichever investment options Polly 'took note of'.

Good thing you didn't bring up a hot button topic or anything. I'd really have to rant, then! ;)

by rfink

If you really want to get upset read "The Tax Racket. Government Extortion from A to Z" by Martin Gross.

The tax I consider the most unfair is the property tax because:

1. The people who collect it determine the value of your house. That is a huge conflict of interest.

2. If I improve my house, I have to pay more tax. Why should I be "fined" for improving my house?

3. The money I pay the property tax with has already been taxed. (Fed Income Tax, FICA and state Income Tax).

As long as I'm looking down from my soap box...

I'm against multiple taxation of the same money. Once I pay income tax on it I shouldn't have to pay sales tax, use tax, sin tax, property tax, highway tolls, bridge tolls, license plate fees, driver licenses fees, dog licenses, building permits, or any other kind of tax.

I will always vote against any tax (school millages as well) until the taxing body proves that it can manage the money it receives properly with no over budget projects, no-bid contracts, etc. I'll probably die holding my breath.

by bjennings59

I agree that those who collect the tax should be the ones setting the value on which that tax is based (i.e., property value). It defintely is a VERY big conflict of interest.

by oz_media

But lets see:
[i]So tell me, what taxes drive you nuts?[/i]
GST, In Canada it is simply applied randonly at the vendors will. Some goods are taxable, some are not, but usually they just tax it out of fear of missing it if needed. Though FST used to be a hidden 13% manufacturers tax, the new GST at 5% is added to everything at the point of sale.

[i]Which ones do you see as being unfair (and yes, I know some would probably see them all as being unfair). [/i]
I think all taxes are unfairly applied in SOME way but not that taxation is unfair as a whole.

[i]Should some taxes be lowered or eliminated all together?[/i]
Yes, if you can fund our emergency services and our medical system by yourself.

[i]Maybe lower some but raise others?[/i]
6 of one half a dozen of another, no gain there, I don't think.

[i]and if so which ones and how can it be done in a way that doesn't do more harm than good.[/i]
That's the 64,000.00 question, isn't it?

[i]And lastly, if you raise the taxes on some things where would you like to see that money go?[/i]
Towards finding a better source of energy, reducing energy wasted now, developing a more responsible economy that is not as reliant on caarbon fuels as we are today.

Thanks Tammy, great post!

by Tammy.Cavadias

you all are training me right... I learned a lot in my last rant. Rant but think a tad more :-)

I know here in the US like you we do sometimes see taxes placed on items at random, sometimes withint he same chain but different stores. I never did understand this one - so I've learned to avoid the ones that do this (tax everything with the higher rate while the same store down the road only taxes some of the items or at different rates - in SC we have changed our tax rate for different items. Food/food stamp qualifier items now has a lower tax rate but things like cleaning supplies is taxed at a higher rate - since this still confuses a lot of folks, some stores if in doubt uses the higher rate)

I also think depending on a persons situation they can see some taxes as being unfair - recently it was over the school tax. I have children in school so I do benefit from this. Those who don't have children in school (whether it be because they don't have children or their children are now out of school), feel this tax (it's part of your property taxes in SC but listed seperately) is unfair. While I can see their point, at the same time I have to wonder - if we don't provide a half way decent education for our future generation - what kind of future does that leave for "All of us" those with and without children currently in the school system?

>>and if so which ones and how can it be done in a way that doesn't do more harm than good.
That's the 64,000.00 question, isn't it?

More like the one million dollar question :-)

What might be seen as fair to me based on my own lifestyle/situation might be unfair to others and vice-versa.

-Tammy :-)

by jamesrl

Unless you are old order Mennonite/Amish, having education for kids and roads benefits us all.

Education provides people for the workforce. That helps drive the economy (and has a side benefit of creating more tax payers so better for me).

And even if you don't drive, roads are the conduit by which the food you eat and the clothes you wear arrive(if you are a farmer, the gas/diesel/fertilizer you use).

Education lowers the welfare roles, lowers the crime has all kinds of benefits to society as a whole. I'm happy to support that.

And as I don't grow my own food or make my own cloth, I kinda need roads.

James

by jdclyde

is because so many people are standing in line with their hands out.

They are to stupid to realize that everytime someone says "The Government should do XYZ" that it is US, the Citizens, doing it with OUR money.

When people stop being so generous with other peoples money, the system will start to work so much better.

REAL charges for politicians that commit crimes that would cause any of us commoners to be locked up, would also be a good start.

Get back to what government is for, security and basic infrastructure that is good for the country. It is NOT the place of our governments to use TAX dollars for aid to other nations while we owe ANYTHING on a national Debt.

We should also NOT allow our government to RUN UP A DEBT. Balance the books and get back to basics.

by Tammy.Cavadias

..well maybe not a funny joke more like a point.. but I laughed and went hmmm... I like it (so I'm a bad bad girl)

It went like this...

Like a lot of folks in this state, I have a job. I work, they pay me. I pay my taxes and the government distributes my taxes as it sees fit. In order to get that paycheck, I am required to pass a random urine test with which I have no problem. What I do have a problem with is the distribution of my taxes to people who don't have to pass a urine test. Shouldn't one have to pass a urine test to get a welfare check because I have to pass one to earn it for them? Please understand, I have no problem with helping people get back on their feet. I do, on the other hand, have a problem with helping someone sitting on their rear, doing drugs, while I work. . . . Can you imagine how much money the state would save if people had to pass a urine test to get a public assistance check?

Now this is not by any means to imply everyone who does receive assistance is lazy, does drugs, etc... (I myself years and years and years and years and years ago did have to have assistance and it was a life saver at the time - got divorced - ex took everything out of our accounts and left me with no means to support 4 kids - assistance was a life saver while I got back on my feet) But I have no doubt we all know a few who do fit such description.

by tonythetiger

When we had temporary custody of 4 small children that were taken away from their mother, WE had to pass criminal and drug testing before we could take them... and I thought, maybe if you required that of the parents, the children may not have have been taken away in the first place ...

But that would be violating THEIR rights, wouldn't it? :(

by tonythetiger

[i]Who needs them more?[/i]

People who consume a lot (of whatever, for whatever reason). If you're buying 4 times as much food as someone else, it takes 4 times the number of (weight times distance) to haul it. Likewise some people buy less because they grow some of their own (I grow probably 20-30% of what my family eats, as well as contribute to extended family and neighbors), and although it does take some hauling for the seed and fertilizer, it's nowhere near what would be required for the produce.

Some people also drive more than others.

[i]Maybe the fair way would be to make "ALL" roads *tolls* then only those who use them pay.[/i]

Sure, but you can accomplish the same thing by getting the vehicle mileage at license renewal time and subtract the previous mileage (either the last renewal, or when you acquired the vehicle).

by jamesrl

Person A drives 50 miles each way to work each day.

Person B runs a home based business. Buying and selling items on eBay. He has a truck deliver items every morning and pick up items every evening. And he shops online for office supplies, computers, paking materials, all of which he gets delivered. And he gets all his groceries delivered.

If we tax only gasoline, then Person A will directly, Person B will have the cost of all his deliveries rise, by some amorphous amount. Some vendors may charege a direct fee so that the tax is visible, some will just raise their prices.

Person B will use the roads perhaps even more than A, depending on where deliveries are coming from, where he shops etc. But person B has no idea how much he pays in road taxes.

Person A could whip out a calulator and tell you.

Like I said in the earlier post, even people who don't drive need roads. The only way not to need them is grow your own food and make your own cloth/clothes.

James

by tonythetiger

people who use them more should pay more. That's essentially the way it was originally intended... someone who uses 10 gallons of gas pays twice as much as someone who uses 5 gallons (assuming the same economy).

A problem arises as cars get more efficient ... Less road tax is collected. Also less because the electricity to recharge your electric car at night is not being taxed as motor fuel. This results in an inequity. Rich people currently buying electric and hybrid vehicles are shifting the road tax onto others.

by Tammy.Cavadias

I agree. School taxes does provide a benefit for everyone longterm wise. As you mentioned it does lower welfare and crime rates (though the latter could be argued by some, as some of the high crimes have been commited by those who do have a higher education)

I would love to see my roadways improved, yet around here everytime they raise the tax on something to improve them roads, it never gets done. Oh sure they fill in a few pot holes here and there, but that is just placing a band-aid on the problem - 2-3 months later the pothole is back - bigger and badder than before. Meanhwhile I get to play the - dodge the pothole and cars game - which is played like this - you dodge the pothole and try not to hit the car next to you at the same time.

-Tammy :-)

by rfink

Maxwell, Where are you?

I like the idea except it has one fatal flaw. It doesn't tax "used" items only "new" items.

Using the web site's 30% sale tax here's two examples of why it'll never get passed.

Brand new $20,000 car. $6,000 tax. I can buy a used $20,000 car and pay $20,000 for a savings of $6,000. $6,000 will pay for alot of repairs, so I for one will give up on buying new cars. You think the big three are hurting now? You ain't seen nothing yet.

Example 2: Real Estate

Brand new freshly built $200,000 home comes with a $60,000 tax. $60,000 buys alot of goodies. I for one will be buying "used" or pre-existing homes and save the money.

That'll kill the home building industry.

What I see happening is the used car and used home prices will increase to capture some of the tax savings and industries take it on the chin.

Other than that, the fair tax is a great idea.

by tonythetiger

[i]Brand new $20,000 car. $6,000 tax. I can buy a used $20,000 car and pay $20,000 for a savings of $6,000. $6,000 will pay for alot of repairs, so I for one will give up on buying new cars.[/i]

Two things

The same car will be cheaper to make since the company doesn't have to pay the embedded taxes, so the 20,000 car will only be 16,000.

Who deserves to get the tax on a used car? I figure I do, since if I had kept the car until it was worthless, I could prorate the tax paid among the years I had it. If I sell it before then, shouldn't I get the tax I 'didn't use'?

[i]Brand new freshly built $200,000 home comes with a $60,000 tax. $60,000 buys alot of goodies. I for one will be buying "used" or pre-existing homes and save the money.[/i]

except that used homes usually cost MORE than new ones...

by Tammy.Cavadias

it is an interesting concept.. but I can't help but wonder.

As with any tax, there is different folks it works better for and for others its harmful. Wouldn't this cause more harm then good for those who say are living on a very fixed income? They already tend to pay the lowest tax rate to being with, about 10% (less with dependents), asking them to pay more for items they buy could break the bank for them even with the savings on income. Or how about those who receive no income (from working that is) - welfare for instance? or those receiving veterans benefits? No income taxes taken out for them and a increase in sales would impact them greatly.

Just a thought...

-Tammy :-)

by tonythetiger

[i]Wouldn't this cause more harm then good for those who say are living on a very fixed income?[/i]

I assume you mean "Low fixed income"... As we are not taxing the first $(poverty level spending) (by 'pre-bating' the tax for that amount to them) they wouldn't pay the tax at all (they can even MAKE money by buying second-hand where possible, growing some vegetables, etc.).

For example, say their income is $1000 a month (That's below Poverty Level). They will be pre-bated, say, $300 a month, giving them $1300. So they buy $1000 worth of new stuff and pay $300 in tax on it. It comes out even in that case. If they buy $500 worth of used stuff and $500 new, they'll only pay $150 in tax, and they make $150. That's not counting the fact that since corporations aren't paying corporate or payroll tax (the other half of FICA), and not including it in the cost of their products, the products themselves will be cheaper.

Yes, it will affect different people differently (just as the current system did when it was first implemented), and there will be growing pains and adjustments. But the biggest stumbling block I see to its implementation is the "me, me, me" attitude of most of today's citizens. You can offer to double their income and triple their neighbor's and they'd turn it down because if they think their neighbor is getting more, they perceive that as "harm" to themselves.

by jck

What one drives me nuts?

Airport tax on a rental car. Does it matter that you get it at the airport, or 1 mile off-site?

Evidently so.

I think some taxes are needed...to fund things like military, police, fire, etc. Things for the common good.

But taxing me because of where i pick up my rental car???? What a buncha crap.

by Tammy.Cavadias

I see that more of a convenince tax or you could call it - a fee. The fee the car rental place is chanrged because they are renting cars out at the airport (kinda like them extra taxes/fees they throw into your plane tickets)

by jck

and i noticed now that all the airlines...are gonna stop serving $.10 bags of peanuts. go figure.

i had a better idea for the airlines to save millions a year. stop paying executive bonuses and stop giving them shares of stock. they make $1,000,000s a year in their positions. let them buy stock out of their own paycheck like everyone else.

eek...here i go again...i better hush lol

by Tammy.Cavadias

.. when they run blood tests at least on the Mother (while she is pregnanat that is), and if they find anything, DSS is called in, and then DSS is there when the baby is born to ensure that the baby has no drugs in their system. And if found, they not only lose custody of that baby but any other children in they might have in the household.

I never will to this day understand how a mother can do drugs while pregnant. It drives me nuts when I see a pregnant woman smoking. I just want to walk over and go - have you lost your mind.. give me that.. then stomp it out.

-Tammy :-)

by jamesrl

I had a conversation somewhat like that with a pregnant woman of my acquaintence, and she basically told me to Frack off.

She said some of her friends smoked through their pregnancies and their kids were fine.

So I guess we should all go walk across streets without looking both ways and play in traffic, cause someone else did it yesterday and they were fine.

The thing is she wasn't unintelligent in other areas, but she was willfully ignorant about this one. I swear if the worlds best doctor told her not to smoke while pregnant she would still argue.

James

by Tammy.Cavadias

which is back before they really learned what nicotine could do to a fetus, my Mom did smoke while carrying me (now you all know whats wrong with me :p )

But in this day and age, where their are reports, and lets not mention - nicotine is very addicting - your addicting your unborn children whether you realize it or not.

I have heard that arguement many of time - but so and so's baby was fine - what about the many that weren't fine? Are you really that willingly to risk it? and if so are you willingly to live with your choice if it turns out opposite of your friends? It may or may not do physical damage but there is damage all the same. From low birth weight, to crib death (babies of smokers have a higher rate of them babies dying due to crib death - SID), plus you make it harder for the baby to receive oxygen while you are pregnant - since your own oxygen is limited this in return means the baby struggles to breathe.

Maybe I'm just a prude... But it has been proven that babies of smokers tend to have more health issue while children. (and this alone can lead to more taxes for us all if that mother can't afford healthcare) Pregnant women don't need to be smoking (my opinion)

I know I personally fretted over everything -OMG I had a cold before I knew I was pregnant and took some ny-quil - did I do damage? After all we all know why ny-quil works so well is the same as drinking two glasses of wine - lights out

-Tammy :-)

by Tammy.Cavadias

>>Sure, but you can accomplish the same thing by getting the vehicle mileage at license renewal time and subtract the previous mileage (either the last renewal, or when you acquired the vehicle).<<

Could except can you imagine how long that would take when you go to renew? It takes forever now when you need to renew, and since you don't want anyone cheating, it would need to be verified by someone official.

And lets not forget about those who may have extra milage due to driving in their own neighborhood (yeah they could walk - but tell that to a 16 yr old boy who just got his license and wants to show off)

Tolls allow you to pay from point A to point B. Makes me think of some of the tolls roads in Richmond VA. Ihad to go through that city once and managed to get myself lost (nothing new there), so I got off to turn around and go back, not only did I pay a toll to get off, but had to pay another once I got turned around and finally got off at the right spot. Plus I noticed for the most part - toll roads tend to not be so full of pot holes (have seen a couple that do though, so that isn't always the case) since the money collected goes to service them roads alone.

-Tammy :-)

by jamesrl

Taxing gas also encourages poor people with cars to make better use of them - don't use them for short trips, or combine a number of trips into one. Keep the car well maintained (if you can't afford a $10 tire pressure gauge you can't afford gas), etc.

Lets face it there are few plug in cars today - very very few. I hear you can convert a Prius, for $10,000 so that you can plug it in, but not suprisingly not too many takers.

James

by tonythetiger

[i]Could except can you imagine how long that would take when you go to renew? It takes forever now when you need to renew, and since you don't want anyone cheating, it would need to be verified by someone official.[/i]

... they can just take you at your word and you sign off on it, same as insurance or my address... I don't have to show them my policy, or show the deed to my house to prove where I live, I just sign that the information I provided is correct, same on car titles when you sell, they "ask" you how many miles it has on it, and you verify with your signature. As the penalties for getting caught lying are quite substantial (felony in some cases), most people won't.

On the other hand, the [b]amount[/b] you have to pay may make you want to question your legislators as to what they're doing with all that money :)

[i]And lets not forget about those who may have extra milage due to driving in their own neighborhood[/i]

You car wears out the road roughly in proportion to its weight and the amount of time it's on the road (mileage). You're wearing out the road, albeit a different road, and you should pay for it. Naturally, more heavily traveled roads would get more money spent on them...

[i]Plus I noticed for the most part - toll roads tend to not be so full of pot holes (have seen a couple that do though, so that isn't always the case) since the money collected goes to service them roads alone.[/i]

Wouldn't it be great to be that sure of where ALL of your tax money is going?

by captbilly1eye

You work hard for your income, work harder to save up enough to invest and then get taxed again on any interest you make.

This has always been a ridiculous idea that only inhibits investing.

Worse - if you invest in a Mutual Fund that ends the year at a loss but stocks were sold within it during the year that temporarily made money for the fund, you pay Capital Gains Taxes on that, too. - add insult to injury!

...want to [b]really[/b] stimulate the economy? - Get rid of such counter-productive penalties!

they make me so mad, I couldn't type straight :)

by Tammy.Cavadias

Ugh.. I forgot about them... Government tells you to save (so you save some of what you have left after you get taxed), then they want part of that... This is one I would like to see go away - I already loan the bank my money by saving it there, and the interest they give me as little as it might be, should be mine to use at will and not be taxed. Especially if the government keeps saying - social security is going away you need to fund your own retirement - I'm trying to fund my own retirment but you keep taking part of it - doesn't matter if its in a 401k, IRA or what have you. Stop taxing it and let it grow so I can find my own retirement.

by hal 9000

The Government is trying to Fund their Retirement so they need the Taxes on Interest much more than you do Tammy.

Just ask one of them they will explain it to you and Vogan Poetry will be a Godsend compared to that explanation. And no they do not stop when you pass out, Drop Dead or otherwise stop paying attention to them they have the Floor so they are Dam Well Going to use it till their Time is Stopped. And as there is no time limit out of Parliament they don't stop they have special training to do this didn't you know?

Col

by tonythetiger

[i]Taxing gas also encourages poor people with cars to make better use of them[/i]

that PAYING for gas would do a good enough job of that :)

by Tammy.Cavadias

[i][b]Could except can you imagine how long that would take when you go to renew? It takes forever now when you need to renew, and since you don't want anyone cheating, it would need to be verified by someone official.[/b][/i]

[i]they can just take you at your word and you sign off on it, same as insurance or my address... I don't have to show them my policy, or show the deed to my house to prove where I live, I just sign that the information I provided is correct, same on car titles when you sell, they "ask" you how many miles it has on it, and you verify with your signature. As the penalties for getting caught lying are quite substantial (felony in some cases), most people won't.[/i]

True... except do you really want to use the honor system for this? (Umm, yes sir that is right I onloy drove 5 miles the whole year) Personally, I don't think DMV should use it for Insurance, but I also know Insurance companies are suppose to alert DMV if your policy lapse (in my state you can get your license suspended for laspe policies)

[i][b]And lets not forget about those who may have extra milage due to driving in their own neighborhood[/b][/i]

[i]You car wears out the road roughly in proportion to its weight and the amount of time it's on the road (mileage). You're wearing out the road, albeit a different road, and you should pay for it. Naturally, more heavily traveled roads would get more money spent on them...[/i]

In a lot of cases which might be the same for some others... home association dues helps pay for fixing the neighborhood roads

[i]Wouldn't it be great to be that sure of where ALL of your tax money is going? [/i]

I keep dreaming, but then I wake up...

-Tammy :-)

by jamesrl

And I think I may be older than you, my Mom quit smoking as soon as she found out she was pregnant, and started up again after delivery. And that was.....45 years before this other person told me to frack off.

Perhaps it wasn't widely known back then, but my mom found out somehow.

James

by Tammy.Cavadias

now don't get me me me started...

But you are right - I did mean Low fixed income. Based on your statement I can see this as something that would benefit just such folks.

But I have to ask, would the above be based on monthly income or going by tax returns? The reason I ask, is while this can be seen as a benefit for those who could use the extra hand, what about those who don't need that extra hand but are real good at tax deductions that when they file their returns they are exactly placed pretty darn close to the poverty level.. I know this sounds like a me me me but I can't help but wonder all the same.

Also, what if everyone decided to just buy second-hand to avoid paying the extra tax? How will that long-term effect our economy? Would it cause prices to be raised to make up the difference in lost revenue? or worse yet, see property taxes or those similiar be rasied to make up for lost money that say services (medical/police/etc...) rely on?

Hope that makes sense (it sounded better in my head but not as easy to place in word.

-Tammy :-)

by tonythetiger

[i]But I have to ask, would the above be based on monthly income or going by tax returns?[/i]

Everyone gets the prebate.... even millionaires. Nobody pays tax on the first $xxx. Everything above that is taxed.

[i]Also, what if everyone decided to just buy second-hand to avoid paying the extra tax?[/i]

Uh... Do you have a teenage daughter? :)

Seriously, there has to be new stuff before there can be used stuff, and nothing lsts forever.

[i] How will that long-term effect our economy?[/i]

Well, people will have more money to spend since they're not paying income or FICA tax. They'll probably buy more stuff (the drop in price due to companies not having to pay tax is about a wash with the sales tax paid, so the extra money really is extra). More people will be needed to make the stuff, eventually people will be in demand, which will drive up wages... It looks like magic but what's really happening is that the money that is being spent to comply with current corporate tax laws, is being put back into the economy... but there are better explanations than mine.

by Tammy.Cavadias

if it works this way... but you know what happens when Government gets involved... nothing works the way it should :p

>>Uh... Do you have a teenage daughter?

Seriously, there has to be new stuff before there can be used stuff, and nothing lsts forever

Yes, a 19 yr old. She actually shops second hand like I do - I love consignment stores, thrift stores and yard sales! Its extremely rare for me to buy new clothes - I don't see the point if I can save tons for something gently used and get it almost dirt cheap compared to new. I take the savings and buy diet coke :D

-Tammy :-)

by Tammy.Cavadias

Mine didn't, nor did she quit when my brother came along. I actually weighed 6.5lbs at birth and my brother was a premmie (born at 7 months weighing 4.5lbs - course now he is 6'2 and weighs in at 200 - so you would never know it)

So James, just how old are you? I'll be 42 in December - the 10th to be exact (that's a hint to everyone hehehehe). Though I've taken to saying 42 now so I can get use to it by the time the actual date comes around and not be such a shock.

-Tammy :-)

by tonythetiger

[i]ut you know what happens when Government gets involved...[/i]

So many of the fees and taxes we pay are all but hidden. This one's in your face. People will know, [b]and can control[/b] what the government gets... with their wallets... it's even better than voting :)

by notsochiguy

http://preview.tinyurl.com/6hol3t

When governments start screwing over their own employees, you know there are troubled times ahead.

There should be a dummy tax on politicians. Give them a test each year to measure their knowledge on current events (things relevant to the position...economics, world affairs, etc). For every percentage point under 100% they score, they should be required to forfeit that same exact percentage in salary and future benefits. Additionally, if there is a collective score less than 90% or so for a given group (Senate Majority/Minority, Congressional Majority/Minority, aldermanic councils, etc), no pay raises can be enacted.

It's their jobs to know this stuff, after all. If any of us had system downtime percentages that were unacceptable, we'd be out 100% of our salary, methinks.

Asides, with all the standardized tests that kids get in schools, it is obvious that politicians are fans of them...so let them in on the joy!!

And no, I'm not joking in any way. The argument 'they're held accountable by the voters' is only true in election years...if then (read into how the current Todd Stroger took over for his ailing father as C(r)ook County president...absolutely despicable).

by cmiller5400

I wrote a letter to the Massachusetts Dept. of Revenue about clarifying "Automotive Core Charge" taxes. It's the one they charge when you buy an automotive part and they tack on an extra charge to get you to return the old part.

Example: You buy a mass air flow sensor for $150. They charge you a $75 core charge to get the old one back so that they can re-manufacture it. The state charges you $7.50 in taxes for the $150 , and then $3.75 for the $75 in core charges. That is a total of $11.25 you pay in taxes. When you return the old part, they give you back the $75, but do not refund the $3.75 in taxes because they consider the "core charge" as part of the value of the item you purchased.

Some states allow the taxes to be refunded, some don't. Taxachusetts does not. Guess they need that extra money to burn on the Governor's new Cadillac and his office decor. http://www.bostonherald.com/news/opinion/op_ed/view.bg?articleid=1096539

by williamonthefloor

Clearly Tammy is a shill who works for the IRS because the IRS knows people love to see other people whine about taxes. Whining keeps them unfocused.

If you want to stop paying taxes, just stop paying taxes. I stopped in 1984 and never looked back. People have been telling me Oh, look out Sam, they're going to throw you in jail...Yeah? And when do you think they're going to get around to it? Try this. The fifth of NEVER!

It's the typical American's gutless response and behavior that keeps the sheep in line. IRS agents snap their fingers and the taxpayer drops and polishes his helmet. IRS agent just laughs.

This discussion is closed to new replies.