Discussion Locked

recommend backup for 50-100 GB of storage

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have had bad luck with tape drives so I am looking for other hardware to use for backing up 50-100 GB of storage daily.

What have you used successfully and consistently (more than three months) or what do you recommend I use that is more reliable than a tape drive?

If you want more history and details you can keep reading. We are on our second Dell backup tape drive. It works pretty good for 3-4 months than it starts to have drive errors. No system changes happen during this time so I think it is just cheap and unreliable hardware. We are using Veritas 8.6 for the backup software.

One employee will take the latest tape back up home with them for the usually reasons. So hopefully the new solution will also have a way to keep a back up off site.

I have thought about an Iomega solution and an external hard drive solution, but I don't know if multiple external hard drives are pratical.

26 replies

by djameson

We had precisely the same problem. We have built 2 6TB Backup servers ~$6000 ea. all SATA, then we put them into a raid 5 array for a net yeld of 5.6Tb / box. Then we use Veritas BX 10.0 and mirror the volumes from box to box (to comply with our companies Offsite policy) there are obvious benefits to not using tapes, but the biggest advangage, is backup time, I can back up all the machines at the same time and still use less then the 1GB of the nic, of course all the servers have 1GB nics but that is an easy upgrade now. I provision the backup server so each server (10) has it's own directory structure that it stores it's backups in also a seperate folder for full incremental and archive backups so you can tell the amount of space required for each box the archive folder is used for drive images or important restore points. so the ds looks like
RV__
|___Server1__
| |_Full
| |_Incremental
| |_Archive
|
|___Server2__
|_...

by thesheriff

I've been running Veritas 8.x & 9.x for many years with little problem. Hard has been a combination of DLT 40 and LTO-2 drives. We've used either HP or ADIC hardware. Results have been great! We started with about 40 GB of storage, today we backup around 1 TB between a number of tape drives. We have been able to get by with this solution, but are now out growing it.

We are now budgetting for off-site disk backup solutions. On-site solutions are nice, but don't provide for a good D/R plan if something happens to our facility. This would explain the need for a tape solution where we can take it media off-site. Disk storage solutions have become more reasonable, however portability is an issues. This is why we are looking at off-site backups over more expensive communication lines.

by jbaker

You need to stay away from Dell tape drives. Go with a name in Drives such as Sony, HP, or Centance (formerly Veritas). I have a100/240GB drive that costs about $1300, and have never had a problem with it.

by djameson

I have never had a good tape drive, I have had virtually every mid grade tape drive there is. YOu only find out the tape is bad when you go to restore after a failure. With a dedicated backup server you can restore any file you have backed up from any time that the file is still on the server. Gives a quasi historical archive. The disadvantages of a dedicate backup box is once it's full it is difficult to add capacity, even though we've got that nailed too. just build another and attach the storage as a mounted drive.

by jgaskell

I have had nothing but trouble with Sony drives, both individual drives and autoloaders. The HP drives I have dealt with have been reliable. I haven't had any trouble with Dell drives, either, but haven't dealt with many.

by jsfald

I work for a small company where the IT budget is allocated as needed, at least if there is a specified budget then I haven't heard about it. I doubt we could have a $6000+ solution.

I like the idea of a dedicated server for backup and archive purposes. Offsite is a necessity but not as important as a succesful daily backup.

How do you all feel about this strategy. After the backup is successful to the backup server I could have a second job to try and write the backup file to a tape drive or external HDD, which can then be taken offsite. This way we have data to restore from quickly and in the unlikely event of a fire or other disaster we will have an offsite backup. This solution could be under $2000.

by djameson

The problem with going cheap is when you need it it won't be there. Our first attempt at a backup server was a machine with 4 250 Gb drives on it no raid etc. we spent so much time replacing drives that we had patchy backups. If you are going to use an off site device I recommend you get a maxtor 300GB hdd and use it. WAY more reliable then tapes, quite a bit of storage and, it's portable. In my private business I use them quite a bit, I have even built complete backup systems just using them get a USB 2.0 adapter and stack them sideways on a shelf. Then just mirror the FS using the windows raid 1 stuff, or script it. It is cheap and portable. just rotate disks however you do. Backups are the second most important thing to a network, don't let anybody convince you to cheap out, We are a small shop too only about 140 users but we have 80k worth of servers. 6k for a backup server is less then 10% of the total cost. If you look at it that way try to figure a way to spend 10% to protect 100% that is like buying a 1,000,000 life insurance policy for less then 100,000 but the law of averages says you WILL need it next year some time.

by dwhelan

An elegant solution would be a Snap server 4200/4500 with integrated Bakbone NetVault software. It has the capability to configure the Snap server storage as a Virtual Tape Library. It then backs up your servers to the VTL and you can configure an additional backup job to copy the virtual tape to real tape media via the Snap server SCSI port.

by sysnetmgr

We have been using this system for almost a year. The drives are reliable and backups are fast. We backup 106 - 150 GB on 2 drives each night and the backups only take 4 hours with a verify. We also use Veritas 9.0 backup exec. HP are good - a hardware failure is normally diagnosed or a new drive sent within 24 hours.

by bassemak

Given the small budget, here's what I recommend:

- Make sure you test backups by restoring some files to another location at least once a week. This way you'll avoid bad surprises should a disaster occur.

- If the drive capacity is adequate, get DELL to replace the faulty drive. If you've given up on Dell and definitely want to change to another drive/brand, there are many brands to choose from: STK, ADIC, HP, IBM or Quantum. I recommend checking the price per GB of consumables (tapes) as this will be the bulk of your cost in the long run.

- Make sure you frequently use the cleaning cartridge to keep the drive in good condition

- If you're using Win 2003, explore the possibility of enabling the Snapshot feature (Shadow Copy) and having at least daily snapshots for a week and weekly snapshots for a month. This will make restoring files accidentally changed or delete a snap. If you're using a different OS that doesnt support Snapshots, look into investing in a 3rd party app that helps you do that. This would normally eat up 10-15% of your disk space.

- Your drive might be overworked. Try having a full backup every week and an incremental during workdays. the amount of files you need to backup will hopefully shrink drastically.

- I would recommend an autoloader if budget permits. If you can't get an approval for one try convincing the management by showing them the benefits of one. Point out the cost of NOT having a working backup. All of a sudden an autoloader will become very reasonable ;-) You might find good deals from reputable resellers on ebay for a fraction of the cost of new.

Hope this helped.

by sjsalian

Have you tried using one of the pocket drives. We are using 2 drives with 80 GB capacity and have been doing so for last 2 years. Not had any problems with the drive as such. using a USB 2 cable the rate of transfers should be pretty good too. Cost about a $ per MB.

by mhambrecht

I have a professor for my networking classes, he works for clear channel communications and all of his backups are to IDE hard drives that he swaps out of a computer that hehas setup strictly as a backup device. He has several of these PCs setup throughout his area of responsibility and he has had a good deal of success over the last 10 years. He has I believe 15 Hard drives per Backup PC and he uses Windows backup to schedule his backups.

by drummerb0y

our project has had, and dealt with, almost the same problem you're having. We use Dell Vaults (tape library, don't remember the model #) connected to a Windows 2000 Adv. Server, (now) running Veritas 9.0. We previously used 8.6 (of course!). And we encountered the same errors you've faced. Tape errors, the device suddenly not a part of the system (in Device Manager), etc. It might sound simple (though it wasn't; we had problems), but we got updated drivers for the tape device, and upgraded to Veritas 9.0 when it came out.

Well as for recommendations, I'm not sure how large your actual storage solution is (you say you back up 50-100 GB/day, are those incremental/differential backups, or a full every night?). But unfortunately for that amount of data, tapes ARE the most cost effective and reliable for data integrity. Yes, hard-drive based archival setups are faster to backup/restore, but you run the same risks of data loss that you do with your normal storage. Hope this helps!

by randy

I work for a local school district. We have the High School where the NOC is located and seven remote buildings linked via fiber. I have 2 backup servers, each with 1.2TB capacity. (5x300MB SATA drives in RAID 5). I back up all serves locally via an HP SCSI tape drive and Backup exec.I back up all important data daily to the BU server at the HS using NTBackup and batch files. I then copy the entire contents of the BU server at the HS to the BU server at the Business Office. All this happens overnight and has no impact on my day-to-day operations. When I needed to add space, I just took the BU server at the HS down, added drives and let the scheduled tasks fill it up overnight. The next day, I did the same to the BU server at the business office. This way I never had less than 2 copies of all my data. (Tape + 1 BU server) The servers are homebuilt white boxes and the total price was less than $1500 each.

by daniel.muzrall

Disk-to-disk-to-tape is the way to go. Like Randy said, you never have less than 2 copies of the data. I would also recommend that you look at Robocopy, available with the Windows Admin Pak...this command-line util allows for easy replication of entire directory structures, is fairly quick, and can generate a summary log of the backup. If you're looking to save costs, going with SATA RAID-5 is an excellent option, though the SATA drives are no where near as fast as the nice 15000 RPM SCSI drives. I'd also recommend getting the largest capacity tape drive you can...an autoloader would be great if you can afford one.

Good luck!

by scress

We have had several customers with tape drives that failed at critical times. Our solution for the past 2 years has been to replace them with an external hard drive, such as a Maxtor One Touch. As of lately we purchase a case and insert the size of drive needed for the customer.
We have used several types of backup software includung Veritas. Our customers are happy with the drive there easy to store and swap out and less expensive to use (no additional tape to buy) With a hard drive we are able to mirror image the complete system (not just the data) once a month, with incremental data backup dailey. We have found in the past with doing this if a machine (case in point- a server and several machines) is damaged by lighting we can completely restore a new machine with minimal down time usally 1 - 2 hours instead of days.

by john.a

Been there - done that. We backup 170GB raw. After tape disasters, we now use a combination of electronic vaulting and D2D backup. We use electronic vaulting for our mission critical data, 37GB compressed. The remaining data is backed up with Computer Associates ARCServe R11 using D2D backups. The primary backup disks are on the server itself, followed by a copy of the D2D backup to removable 200GB USB drives. One removable for daily, one for week 1, and one for week 2. Our Electronic Vaulting provider is www.trueevaulting.com They use a technology that backs up changed blocks, not changed files. Thus our 37GB of compressed data has not exceeded 40GB of storage. Yet we have 12 revisions online. The cost is $400/month. Hope that helps you. If you buy ARCserve R11, get the maintenance contract for atleast the first year. Veritas 10.0 is comparable to ARCserve R11.

by tom glahe

The company I work for has had several terrible experiences with tape backup that I was able to convince them to buy a couple of Axion E device from a company called Avamar. Their product is disk based and comes with a GUI interface that is similar to Varitas. We use its replication capability over a frame relay to give us the off-site data protection for desaster recovery. We have two terrabytes of data to backup each night as well as the C:\ drives on about 10 users machines when they are logged into our network.

Don't know what your IT budget is for a backup solution, but a disk space storage solution relieves you from the fear of a bad tape backup and gives you a very quick and easy way to restore data.

Just some of my thoughts.

by tom

We had the same issues with all sort of Backups. We actually got tired of Tape failures, Drive failures etc. We invested in a company called StorNet. http://stornet.net They are an online backup company. If for some reason our backup does not come through because we shut a server down etc. One of their Techs will actually call us! Now that service.

This also kills to bird with one stone Back ups and Disaster Recovery.

by mrbriancollins

what about VTL ? Virtual Tape Library's are in essence a SATA array with a tape solution attached to the back of that:

[Network]-----[VTL]----[Library]

The VTL takes care of backups, and since it is disk to disk, it is faster and you get no media write errors or failures. After that the data stays on the disks until it expires or needs to be stored offsight it will write to the Library. This way your backup window extends and your Library can run 24x7....

by radio-active

*everything* is on PCs. Commercials, music, all my show prep and my karaoke files. Our PCs use HD that range in sizes between 3GB and 40GB. We backup our files using external HD cases and 40GB HDs via a USB 2 port. When we make large changes to our music, I copy everything to another PC and then do the USB backup. Its cheap, easy and fast. Its also saved our business more than once. Best of Luck! Dave

by malcolm.mccowan

We use a simple Celeron server fitted with mirrored removable 250 GB Firewire disks and software supplied by a company called System 5.
Backup is performed to disk at night. Only new and changed files are added - nothing is overwritten so recovery can be from any date/time. Can even re-boot a failed machine across the network, as everything is backed up. It uses 2:1 compression, so lots of history can be retained. We use three pairs of disks as we have large CAD data models as well as standard stuff.
Disks are removed for off-site storage. An older disk is re-inserted and quickly refreshed during the day while the backup system is not used.
File recovery means just using a menu, and disk to disk copy - all in a few minutes, rather than hours. It is inexpensive.
This is free plug for a genuine small company with offices in USA, Australia, South Africa. Get in now before he sells to some big outfit that will charge megabucks for it.
Refer to the web site at www.sysV.com

by W Bahny

We have used a Quantum SDLT tape library for over three years and a Quantum SDLT tape drive for over a year at two of our locations and have never had a problem. A good part of the problem may lie in the type of tape you are using. Be weary of the DAT tapes. We used them for a while at one of our locations and had all sorts of problems. We finally got sick of it and gave them an used HP DLT III drive that we had used for umpteen years without problems and they've been going strong ever since.

This discussion is closed to new replies.