Report: Senior Saudi cleric OKs girls to marry
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Hardware
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
"1) A society will, as it [b]has a right, to determine if other cultures are inferior, different, similar or superior.[/b]
[i]You have the [b]right[/b] to judge others and deem them inferior[/i]
2) [b]A society can do something based[/b] on (1) [i]so you are ALLOWED to do something about it, says who? Is it the same person who says you have a RIGHT to judge other societies? Still haven't found that in your Constitution, I'll keep looking though[/i]
2.1) Maintain status quo - do nothing. - FAIR
2.2) Adapt from the other society's superior culture - FAIR
2.3) Influence the other society's inferior culture to reform and adapt." - UNFAIR
So you have a right to judge, you CAN do something about it and influence those YOU deem inferior to your own to reform and adapt.
sorry, I'm not missing anything. You just think you have the right to judge others, say what you want and encourage others to comply to your way of living....and people think I am arrogant!?!
by jamesrl
After Pat Roberston, someone with a much wider audience has said some pretty shocking things too:
"(T)he feminist agenda is not about equal rights for women. It is about a socialist, anti-family political movement that encourages women to leave their husbands, kill their children, practice witchcraft, destroy capitalism and become lesbians."
"You know, I don't know about this doctrine of assassination, but if he thinks we're trying to assassinate him, I think that we really ought to go ahead and do it. It's a whole lot cheaper than starting a war ... We have the ability to take him out, and I think the time has come that we exercise that ability. We don't need another $200 billion war to get rid of one, you know, strong-arm dictator. It's a whole lot easier to have some of the covert operatives do the job and then get it over with."(re Hugo Chavez)
"Maybe we need a very small nuke thrown off on Foggy Bottom to shake things up." (Foggy Bottom=US Deptartment of State)
Yet when one muslim cleric says something, its a scandal, when Pat Robertson says bad things, its just another crackpot.
There are plenty of Muslims who would think this cleric is off his rocker.
Without any stats that show just how prevelent this is in Saudi, then how is this any different than what happened with the fundamentalist Mormons in BC and Utah who married kids of 12 years old. Does that make all Mormons evil paedophiles? Surely not.
As for India, I've seen evidence that those pre-teen weddings are more like intentions to create a future couple than anything that would have sexual consequences. I don't deny Onbliss' assertion that foreigners come in and "get" young girls, but that is far from saying its part of their culture.
James
by dmambo
It could be the Pope, the Grand Mufti, Pat Robertson, Jesus, or the Great Kazoo. Whoever supports taking a pre-pubescent girl (or boy), to live with as man and wife, is morally wrong and no society or religion can justify it in my eyes. It's an absolute.
Again, I'm talking marriage as I understand it, not betrothal, not some future contract, but marriage.
Certainly I'm judging this through the filter of my western upbringing. I'm also judging this as the father of 2 teenage girls.
by jamesrl
My point is that it is only CONJECTURE that this cleric represents the views of Saudi society. I don't know one way or the other. I'm fairly certain that it was more common in the past that it is now.
What I suggest is to take one cleric's comments and ASSUME that it is representative of the Saudi culture is a little premature - maybe it does, maybe it does not.
I don't support the Fundamentalist Mormons or the Saudi cleric position. But it is hypocritical to attack the Saudi society and ignore what is happening in our own backyard.
I have daughters 10 and 12 years old, and do not for a minute think that I ever condoned this kind of thing.
But I won't leap to conclusions about Saudi culture, Arab culture or Muslim thinking based on one Cleric - especially considering the lack of a hierarchical structure - no muslim equivalent to a pope.
There are nutbars in every religion (and aetheists too).
James
by boxfiddler Hot topic
which is ripe with cruelty, suffering, death; in the name of every 'right' and 'religion' and 'philosophy' currently known to man.
Riiiight.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
if the results of that determination aren't going to be acted upon?
Determining is itself an action.
by oz_media
well, all but the religious aspect, religion has lost the wind in its sails now that logic is part of life.
But as you say, societies and religions evolve all the time. So what part of that gives ANYONE, the obligation, right, permission of 'correcting' other societies and cultures to become more complacent or acceptable with your own beliefs, society and cultures?
by onbliss
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by onbliss
Yeah, we all know life is unfair. But that is what happens. History tells us.
You are missing my whole point. I can't help but wonder how come you don't see the nuance.
by onbliss
by oz_media
First of all you are on about rights, you live in the USA and therefore are bound BY LAW to the US constitution, the description of YOUR rights as an American, not as an Indian. You would have to move home to be bound by another set of rights.
If you want to go on about YOUR rights, which only exist as outlined in the US constitution, than THOSE rights and THAT country's rights are the only topic of discussion.
You don't get to talk about another nations rights as if they were your own to live by, unless you live there. I am from England, I am not even a Canadian citizen, i hold a UK passport and citizenship.
When I am living here, my rights are the same as those of any other Canadian, I don't hold diplomatic status yet.
So if I go on about my right to do this or my right to do that, it is only as described by Canadian law.
You CHOSE to live there, you CHOSE to accept being bound by US laws and rights, as far as laws and rights are concerned, you ARE American.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Okay, so you have a right to judge.
and you feel you are allowed to influence ohers to yuor way of thinking. And if they don't see that as fair, tough ssh1t, life ain't fair?
So how about this, the US can no longer track their criminals into Canada and we are able to influence your society to pay for a socialized medical system. We have also decided that your archaic gun laws need revision to become less inferior to our own more advanced gun laws, you need tighter control over the ease of obtaining guns. And gay people, they CAN get married because we are more advanced and culturally capable of accepting our differences as a people without being bound to antiquated scriptures and religion written by people who thought the world was flat and that the sun was 17 miles away from us.
For those Americans who say "No way, that isn't fair, Canada can't make changes to our society, who are THEY to judge us and call us inferior" TOO BAD SUCKERS!
LIFE ain't fair, and we deemed your society to be inferior to our own, more advanced society, so stick it.
Yeah, sounds pretty absurd and insane doesn't it.
Exactly.
Funny how things change focus when applied differently and you are forced to look at yourself.
by oz_media
Between illegal actions, prevented by a country's laws and cultural allowances that are within a country's laws.
I know, in order to make yourself somewhat vindicated you have to add the double standard to your own comments, and see everything as applying the same way, funny how there are all kinds of allowances and exceptions to that rule when it comes to judging your nation though.
What year were you forced to abolish slavery by all those nations who had tried to influence such change for decades?
Was it England's duty to force that upon you? Perhaps it was Belgium's influence and lessons. Was it Spain that straightened you out for your illegal activities?
not bloody likely, America is correct, will always be correct. Americans can neither be taught or lead. Americans ARE however in charge of liberating the world, saving our souls and straightening everyone else out that doesn't conform to America's ideals.
America is a 'kin hypocrisy, not a democracy.
Did you take the hypocratic oath too?
one thing this discussion HAs proven beyond a shadow of a doubt, Americans live by double standards and NEVER look inward when they can point a finger outward at someone else.
And that's how the whole world sees you these days and why the world resents having an America and while most have even given up offering pity to such a backwards nation of immigrants, it's more of a sad feeling nowadays. It's those poor Yankees that are just too simple to catch on, oh well, let them be and they'll just quietly carry on, if only you did.
by oz_media
I point out what I see as flaws in your system and, what I consider, inferior society, I learned today that I have a RIGHT to do that.
your spew is just spew, no validity or reason or even a hint or truth to it. But let me guess, its all the same for one as simple and two dimensional as yourself.
by oz_media
America will save her, "HERE WE COME TO WRECK YOUR DAAAAY!"
When my parents were younger, they were married, my dad was a certified machinist and studying to be a marine engineer. My mom was pregnant with her first child, they lived on teh AFB in Singapore.
Mom was 16 and they were the epitomy of a normal young family from England.
Today, that story would be on Springer.
That horrific man has taken away that poor girls youth! (Though he was only a few years older too.)
Cultures are very different.
Why aren't you winging on about how African women beat young girls breasts with a hot stick each day to keep them from developing?
Its a fact, it happens to most girls in school there, but you don't give a rats arse because it doesn't offer you a chance to appear righteous and good. Is it some form of deep desire or guilt for supporting the killing of thousands of innocent foreign citizens and accepting the deaths of thousands of your own?
Who are YOU of all nations, to point fingers at others?
Your government, on a global scale, is right up there with Pakistan, Iraq and all the others you see as repressive and horrific governments, do you really think other nations see you ANY differently?
by dmambo
Sorry if I even gave a hint of implying otherwise. I never meant to.
Elsewhere I have stated that it's the act and this particular idiot, and for that matter anyone who would use this statement to justify his actions, that I'm condemning, not the society.
I AM conjecturing the meaning of "wife" as used here as well.
by jdclyde
last friday, I was at my boys school for the swim match. It is a mixed school of both middle and high school, sharing one building, just different wings. The youngest would be 6th graders, age 11. A group of them walked by on their way to a pep assembly, and I realized that THEY were at least a year older than what was being talked about in the main article.
Using the excuse of "culture" (or lack of) to justify forcing a child to become a wife? Pretty disgusting. Yeah, there is a defense for that.....
by tonythetiger
by onbliss
There is no denying on what you are saying. I am bound by the laws of where I live in. I adhere to it.
But that has nothing to do with my views on a particular society's customs. Heck, even in my own society, in the past, people got married early. I don't look at it as right or wrong. It was then, times have changed. And people have changed.
by onbliss
Where did I say a society is allowed to influence others? I said a society can influence other societies. If and when a society does that it does not mean it has the 'rights' to do that. It simply does that inspite of its interfernce being right or wrong.
The rest of your post is a rant against America.
by onbliss
...Indian. I am the kind that Colombus actually wanted to meet but did not meet :-)
I picked on the word 'reservation' so the chain of thoughts....Sorry, if I understood your post incorrectly.
by oz_media
"Where did I say a society is allowed to influence others? I said [i]"a society can influence other societies."[/i]
so CAN and ALLOWED are your finite definitions that all are supposed to read into.
So when your kids say, 'Can I go to John's house for dinner?' and you say 'okay.'; that doesn't mean they are ALLOWED to go to John's for dinner then. It means he is ABLE or CAPABLE of going to John's for dinner but he is not ALLOWED to do so.
Nice backpeddle, a sieve will hold water better than that.
by oz_media
and its not just foreign policy's in the sense of what has been written or passed as law. It's more to do with how America thinks its a US obligation to control and monitor other nations.
Plus the dumb Americans really get on your nerves, massive population puts more idiots and redknecks in the picture (plus they are the ones constantly epitomized on TV and movies), which NOBODY can stomache.
by oz_media
If that helps you sleep at night, you just keep on fooling yourself.
First of all, NOBODY is 'scared' of America or Americans, NOBODY, well perhaps a few camel jockeys in caves in Iraq but that's about it....well
The only fear is that America will continue to place the rest of the world in danger by association.
British soldiers still fear fighting near Americans, they learned the hard way that American soldiers are to be avoided in battle, too may 'friendly casualties' when fighting near them.
But don't flatter yourself too much Boxy, most people just don't like America or what you stand for and what you believe in, that can be done without fear.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
I don't speak for America. I don't speak for anybody but me.
When I say people, I make no distinction between nations, races, sexes.
Further, when I say fear I don't even come close to intending 'fear of America'.
etu
by oz_media
Well, seeing as this part of the thread deals specifically with people hating America, then any sub comments would rightly be applied to the same, unless specified, which you have not.
"They like to hate because it masks their fear."
This comment was with respect to why people hate AMERICA (as America is teh topic of discussion, not generalizations of human psychology).
You like to say things and imply what you want, just vaguely enough that you can backpeddle and say that's not what you meant.
When there is a specific topic being discussed, as there is here, you will make a generalization and then you can easily say it doesn't apply specifically as it is a generalization.
It's lik eme talkign about Boxfiddler and someone else saying "Great unput and very astute views" only to then say, 'Well it wasn't about BoxFiddler, just people in general"
BS, sorry but you'll have to play your kiddie games with kiddies.
by oz_media
Well, seeing as this part of the thread deals specifically with people hating America, then any sub comments would rightly be applied to the same, unless specified, which you have not.
"They like to hate because it masks their fear."
This comment was with respect to why people hate AMERICA (as America is the topic of discussion, not generalizations of human psychology).
You like to say things and imply what you want, just vaguely enough that you can backpeddle and say that's not what you meant.
When there is a specific topic being discussed, as there is here, you will make a generalization and then you can easily say it doesn't apply specifically as it is a generalization.
It's like me starting thread about Boxfiddler and someone else saying "Great input and very astute views" only to then say, 'Well it wasn't about BoxFiddler, just people in general"
BS, sorry but you'll have to play your kiddie games with kiddies.
by oz_media
Nobody has made those judgments by themselves, I mean I wouldn't know ANYTHING about America if it weren't for the media.
To be fair and honest, I used to love America. I saw it as a land of fortune and opportunity, I made money, I worked hard and enjoyed the travel, people and general 'air' of America. But it seems that the worse the country got, the harder people waved the flag, and that was one of the few things most people DIDN'T like about America, the patriotic flag waving to the extreme.There's pride in one's country and then there's America.
A delusion of perfection, an example of a screwed up nation that deems itself perfect.
Today, America is a mere shadow of its former self, its almost too long ago to remember when America still shone as a bright new world in my eyes, now a faded grey old hag of misfortune and delusion.
Yes, America once was a great place, though a little over the top, today its nothing but a nation to resent; and STILL citizens think it's the greatest nation and wave that tattered old rag of a flag with hope, a distant glimmer of a deserved pride that once was.
America today is not even a glimmer of the nation it once was, not even close to second best.
by oz_media
Most welcomed the oncoming war, promises of freedom and democracy.
It has been shown that these same people soon changed their minds as they found out it was all just lip service to make people accept the invasion of their country.
"there's no freedom now"
"Things are worse now than when Saddam was ruling us"
"We just wish America would leave"
Quotes from an Iraqi documentary about how the war has effected citizens.
They, just like you American citizens, were fooled into thinking it would benefit them, not just make a bad situation worse with no end in sight. NOW, even Bush is saying, it is up to THEM to seize Democracy. When just a few years back he was assuring us that there WOULD BE democracy (or Americans would die trying to force it upon them which they have done to no avail). Now he's put the ball in their court. Well, after many decades, one would think Democracy would have been seized IF that's what they truly wanted.
by jdclyde
by oz_media
America as a whole, as a generalization.
No different than people sayign Canada is a cold place, lots of snow, half french speaking half english etc.
They are generalizations that offer an outside in view of a country.
I am sorry but there simply isn't enough room here to personally interview each person living outside of America to offer individual thouhts and opinions, nor is there even enough space to interview each and every American.
Though i was not talking about any specific Americans anyway, just the outside in VIEW of America that is not singular nor the view of all people not livign in america, but simply the general concensu, the overall take, what most people say, how others feel, etc.
YOu can take it and seclude yourself if it helps you sleep, you can take it and dismiss it as simply an anti-American rant, but truth is, I am not alone on this one and what I say here is exactly what I hear over and over again from others around the world.
Whether personal, friends, local news, global documentaries etc. There seems to be a very common view of Americans, with a few exceptions of course and I definitely don't stand alone with my opinion, no matter how much people in the US will fool themselves into believing otherwise.
America today is a country of VERY little global respect, Americans are all seen to follow the sam eroute and attitude, though i personally know they do not.
You have lost respect from allied nations, you have lost the respect of most of the worlds citizens (I suppose someone had respect for the US at some time).
YOu have lost the trust, faith and hopes of so many that I am surprised it hasn't kicked in and become a reality for more of you. Don't you see the news and how people react when teh word America is mentioned around the globe? At best I think you'll get rolling eyes and a sigh...."Oh, America".
When I go to shows in the US now, its hadr to find anyone that wants to go, most people would rather miss a show that isn't coming up here rather than go to the US to see it.
Nobody cares about the US anymore, its no longer a mighty nation, just one that that bit off too much to chew and has rapidly lost favour, support and respect of others.
Sorry, but that's reality from the outside looking in.
by oz_media
Though I think I see more generalizations, false assumtions and skewed observations from Americans than any one else perhaps due to a lack of exposire to others or no real geographical education, unless with respect to America.
English people, drink tea with a pinky up and say Pity all the time.
Canadians speak french and live where it snoes a lot.
East Indians grew up living in the dirt, have no education or infrastructure.
Iraq's support terrosism and want Jihad upon America.
It goes on and on, these blind stereotypes which are perpetuatd by US media.
however, when someone speaks a general view of Americans that is shared by millions worldwide, it is unheard of, singular and couldn't include anyoen you know.
Oh yes, hypocrisy...another common, American trait.
This your version of cloud computing.
Or, rather, fog, which obscures the ground, to which you have become untethered, and flying upside down in a corkscrew.
This includes your apparent surmise that I need instruction as to the use and purpose of generalization.
Yep. Fog.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by oz_media
As you tried to make it seem that perhaps a wee percentage of Americans fit such a mold. I was saying to another peer, another forum, when he had commented on how disappointed he was with his fellow citizens, Americans; from what I am lead to believe, all of these so called stereotypes only apply to perhaps three or four Americans, which are hired by the media to portray American opinions. Nobody HERE fits such a sterotype,I wonder where they find all the stupid ones?
Because the Americans, we see on TV, read about in news or meet on the streets of America, are not actually examples of Americans.
Americans deny these people make up a majority of the population, though that's all we see and hear, with a few exceptions of course. Therefore the thousands of idiots, the carboard cutouts used to show mobs and demonstrations, the wax models used to portray Americans to the rest of the world are all just media props. These Americans don't actually exist because I think Americans, the REAL ONES, are hiding at home so that the world can continue to get the wrong impression set out by a mere handful of the 330 million there are.
Next time you see dumb Americans on TV, look closely and you'll notice its the same ones you saw last week, but with different hair styles (probably a wig) and different clothes on, to make the world think that more than 5 Americans act that way.
The next time you are in public and see/hear nothing but rude, classless freaks and morons, remember they are not how Americans act, they are just local talent hired to portray what the media wants us ot think of Americans. Of course this is because teh media hates Americans, probably because they are jealous and wish they were Americans....oh yeah they ARE Americans, but that's an exception to the rule of course.
Denial is a funny thing, and so rampant in the US these days it seems. We didn't do anything wrong! We had every right to atack Iraq. We don't need your help. If you don't help us you are opposed to freedom! Back us or forget about us. I never thought the war was right from the beginning. I never said I supported it at all.
Whereas one time they would simply agree with the idiots and say that we just don't understand them (thuse defending the idiots), today they try and pretend the idiots are an exception and not the norm.
I suppose its all relative, the OTHER guy is always the idiot in some people's eyes, making themselves feel quite clever in the process.
See, the difference is, I see dumber people around me all the time and I KNOW I'm not THAT smart, its scary sometimes, I know!
In the case of Americans, they are ALL brilliant but there are a couple of dummies that we see in the media all the time.
I suppose they write their own material though, beacause they were everywhere during the writers strike too. Clever bunch of idiots, I must say.
by oz_media
by oz_media
Not.
I spoke of exactly 1/300,000,000.
I dare not speak of any "hiding at home". They could be hiding and reviewing, say, a manual of AK maintenance alongside Roberts Rules of Order, for all I know.
This, or much of anything else, is not apparent in the adoptive, wholesale scheme you push.
by onbliss
by onbliss
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending