Discussion Locked

Say no to Free "IT Advice"

0 helpful
426 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

426 replies

by cswearingen

I agree with tmcal. this is a DEAD horse. Just because we went to school for our degrees and certificates does not make us superior to others.

I get lots of people asking for advice on computers and I give it to them. It's ADVICE. Advice is NOT a service and should not be charged. My Dr. friend is also more than willing to give ADVICE to people around him.

When Dr. friend was asked to look at another friends arm after she fell of a swing set he advised that they go to the ER and have it x-rayed as he thought it might be a break. They went and he was right. Took less than 5 minutes of his time.

If people want service that's another story as service entails more of your time and skills than advice. Be up front with them. Point them to sites, books and/or other PC service shops that can help them. If they still want you to fix it come up with either a fee schedule or a quid-pro-quo arrangement (I'll fix your PC if you help paint my house, etc.).

Remember, there's a difference between advice and giving free tech support.

Christopher
-----------------------------------------
They say I have ADD but they just don't under.. HEY A CHICKEN!

by aglv01

When you are asked to provide advice two or three times a day, it's OK, Matter of threshold. you don't feel it cumbersome to provide advice. When it's 10 to 15 or more times a day, when they invade your life, when they call at 9:30pm when you're trying to sleep the kids...

Think again, maybe the horse is not as dead as you think!

Avner

by linuxinlibraries.com

> Remember, there's a difference between advice and
> giving free tech support.

That is correct. I don't mind giving advice but it really pisses me off when someone wants me to go out of my way to come fix their computer for free. I even had someone complain that they had to pay for the parts needed for repairs. Talk about ungrateful!

by oneshotstop

The problem is not the giving of advice. It is being interrupted constantly, both in and out of the office. Helping out a person is fine. But when you have 200 people wanting help, it gets to be too much. I can't go to the bathroom without getting questioned about this or that. People need to understand that IT people don't like to talk shop 24hrs a day.

by lcave

When people ask what I do. I tell them anything, but that I'm in IT. I've been in this business for 25 years and after a 60-hour week, the last thing I want to do is work on a pc....including my own.

by blueknight

I will give advice if I have the time. If I don't have the time, I'll make a quick suggestion as to what I'd start looking for/at and suggest they visit certain web sites or pick up a copy of a certain tech manual. I am never rude or short with people as most respondents to this question seem to be from their posts.

Back when I started in this field, everyone shared information, solutions etc. and offered suggestions to anyone who asked. It was that free exchange that made IT such a great field to be in. It still is, but not to the degree it was many years ago.

Many of the responses I've read in this thread explain why society has slid to the level it's at today. Remember, you may need assistance yourself one day. "Give and it shall be given unto you."

by sirlanse

Tell them to get a Dell, they have free help
from India.
Unless they are Gay, then
tell them to get a Mac.

If they insist, ask them a lot of background
questions about the situation.
When they cannot answer these, offer to do
on site service at $100 per hour.

by beads

Before Michael Dell got his company really off the ground I used to say similar things about Gateway.

Now for gays. For some reason all my gay nieghbors use PCs not Macs. Though I never had to think about it till you brought it up. LOL.

- beads

by shraven

You should never charge for your "advice" and you should hand it out freely - it only takes a couple minutes! But if someone is asking you to spend hours working on their PC, that's not advice and that's not a reasonable expectation on their part.
Just tell them you're a little busy this weekend, but if they'd like they can bring their PC by your house and you'll work on it while they paint your house... or whatever project you were plannign on doing.
If you're not comfortable with that you can take a more subtle approach: listen to their problem and recommend a very expensive upgrade. Be sure to qualify that it may not help their problem, but it's the quickest way to fix it. People will decide on their own to persue other avenues... the ones they probably should have been anyway.

by mad mole

I also treat my users on a case by case basis. However I'm extremely keen to see my users learn more about their PCs because it makes my life at work an awful lot easier!
A more IT literate user means I can talk them through complex tasks over the phone when the inevitable problems materialise at work. If that meant helping them fix their home PC first that's fine by me.

The more the user understands what they're dealing with, the better the info they give the IT Admin when things go properly wrong.

When it comes to purchasing advice it takes me 2mins to tell them what to avoid and another two to tell them what questions they should be asking themselves. Then send them off to do some of their own research. If they're keen they'll be back with a list of alternatives it takes me 2secs to advise on.

Whatever you do giving them confidence in the use of PC means they'll make decisions themselves in the future and aren't likely to bother you again.

by dumbuser

Folks,

It never seems to amaze me how IT pros don't understand customer service. Sure you're "giving away" some knowledge, but hasn't anyone ever taken you to lunch? They gave something away, with the hope of improving their relationship with you.

Instead of whining about how people get freebies and coming up with ways of dodging their questions, why not look at it as a way to build a better relationship with a customer? Ok, you can't sit there all day, but a few minutes won't kill you, and that person who's home computer question you blow off today may be the CEO of tomorrow---you know, the guy or gal that approves your budget....or position?

Every time I read something like this, I think, "the IT people still don't get it."

by mrmilt

It's not someone trying to get something for free. All the people I help have offered monetary compensation. They know they'll get a truthful answer from me and a good job done if service is needed. My compensation is a thankful human. If they really insist on compensating me, I tell them to donate to a charity or remember this when someone asks for their assistance.

by jb1

I think the lunch (or other times) sessions you mentioned are a great idea. We did something similar to that at a previous endeavor for work related issues to bring other techs up to speed on single, focused issues. Voluntary - if they wanted to attend. Very successful. I think we called them "Micro-sessions".

by snag

Explain that you have a personal policy not to give advice to people you work with, and that it's nothing against them in particular. Then, give them a couple of websites they can find information and answers at. Teach them how to do some online and book research, and they'll soon be the ones others are pestering for the free help.

by tampa hillbilly

I read the baloney about how "I spent thousands of dollars on training." Tell the truth... you threw thousands of questions at us old timers and spend thousands of your employer`s dollars for your education. How quickly we forget that we were also newbies at one time. Confused people are asking for a little guidance, no more, no less. I agree with randrews@... Good Will is priceless.

by xt john

9 out of 10 people I have helped in the past have been very appreciative, generous and insistant in whatever way they could compensate (whether fresh baked goods, a gift card or money). Numerous people have helped me to get to where I am today, so why shouldn't I share the Wealth of Knowledge? Be prepared for that 1 out of 10 who will be unappreciative, call you incessantly, blame you for their errors and make you swear you'll never help a soul again! Favors for friends, family and co-workers always return to you, in positive ways...

by deacon336

You are absolutely right. Pointing them to the local repair shop for the actual repairs is very reasonable. Many of them are simply trying to determine the right course of action. Furthermore, a little good will goes a long way in the office and in personal relationships.

The bad attitudes posted here offer some insight to why many executives do not want "techies" in the front office. Many of them have NO people skills.

Good technical skills combined with good people skills are a mighty force.

by sam.hays

I Don't know if this is *valid* per se. But I turn people down on the argument that If I were to give them free friendly advice, and they use that advice incorrectly or whatever, then they come back and blame my company because I gave them advice here at work and blah blah blah. Then I may become responsible for that. I've read of similar situations happening with online gambling on work equipment. So - i don't give advice because I don't want to be at risk... If it's not a work computer, don't bother me with it.

by cswearingen

What a way to really make an impression at work.

"Sorry I really don't know how the heck to fix your $2,000 home PC. I'd probably make the problem worse. But on the bright side I'm in charge of the company's million dollars worth of IT infrastructure!"

Yeah, that'll breed confidence in your abilities...

by danag429

C'mon, get off your high horse. My doctor supplies me with certain allergy pills and other supplies out of the samples she receives from the drug companies. If she needs some help with a simple computer glitch, I'm glad to help.

Similarly with other friends. If a total stranger asks, then I charge $70 per hour, one hour minimum. But people who we regularly interact with and are a friend of a sort, tend to share knowledge.

The concept is called "community", and it extends beyond your normal field. As a photographer, I am glad to help others. Even beginners in the industry, I'll help them with their business questions. The cadre of friends you build up is very valuable for the rest of your career!

by dumbuser

Perhaps there should be a 5-day waiting period for IT people who don't understand the nature of customer service......sounds a awful lot like American automobile workers in the 1970's---very smug. Look where that got them.

by jb1

I can relate if it gets out of hand as it appears it has with you. But I think this constant comparison of IT to MDs is getting out of hand. We're talking the difference of telling someone they need to get a CD cleaner and try that to a Dr. giving out medical advice that could adversely affect someone's health. Big difference there. On the flip side of that, the medical profession is getting pretty out of hand in it's own right. Health ins. costs, medicine and doctors fees are way out of the ballpark. It's everyone trying to make as much money off everyone else as they can and exploiting critical areas of life to do so.

Let's keep IT on one side of the fence, and the medical industry on the other.

by alacrity

Here's how I handle this problem. When someone comes up to me and says something like "I have this problem at home. I keep getting pop-ups" I'll quickly describe the steps I take to find out what is causing the problem, tell them where in the registry the problem is hiding, and how I would remove the offending program. When they ask (and they always do) "How do I edit the registry" I tell them "This is how I make my living. I told you what I would do. If I help you do it it becomes something I have to charge for"
I have also used "This is what I do for a living. You wouldn't {insert their profession here} Would you?"
On some small number of people I have to fall back to "Free advice: It's worth what you pay for it" followed by "I'll be happy to make an appointment"

Clarification: Family is ALWAYS free but even my best friends get a bill if it's for their business computer. Simple, One paragraph advice is always free, even to business customers

Just my free advice (which is worth what you pay for...)

by misterdufus

Actually IT and Medicine are very related. They are logical systems that run dependent of interrelated services. A diagnosis and a plan of treatment has to be applied to each individual situation. A medical degree is simply a degree, not a grade of how smart the person is. There are plenty of moron doctors, and moron IT "professionals" who bill you to rattle off advice they don't really understand, or comprehend themselves. A doctor provides no "guarantee", nor does an IT pro, but see how long either of them is in their field, or maintain a client list, if they are nutjobs.
One prescription (or piece of advice) can adversely react with stupidity (drinking alcohol or drinking water around the computer), and someone ends up spending a week in the hospital, or two weeks trying to reconfigure their computer, or regain lost data. Your "advice" that ended up costing them a lot of time, because you underestimated their level of intelligence or common sense.
By the way, I don't think this discussion was how to deal with questions from friends, but "staff members" Your friends should be the ones that you have something in common with, not someone trying to exploit your time.
SOLUTION:
Quote them your price, or refer them to a professional, just as the other person commented about a doctor sending someone to a professional at the hospital because their arm was hurting. He did NOT attempt to treat the person, or offer free advice to make a "friend", he told them to talk to a specialist.
Doctors fees and IT fees are not "way out of the ballpark". They are at the rate that a specialist in their field should be paid. That is how they got that way. Can't afford it? Then go see a doctor from Puerto Rico, or an IT tech from National University or Microskills.

by richard vickery

My answer to the question is to let your employees know that advise is never free, whether a teacher, lawyer, tech, etc. the same applies at work. If there is a problem with the company's machines and they happen to learn something from that solution, fine. Somebody is paying for it. It took you time and money to go to school and learn stuff, nothing is free even if it comes from a book they bought or borrowed. If the want free information, try barking up sommeone elses tree.

by seanwestgate

This is a silly thread. It is really simple, it comes down to personal character and how you look at the world. If you are a nice guy then you find a way to give advice without being exploited or feeling exploited because you welcome opportunities to spread good will and share your knowledge. If you are not a nice guy then you think the world is trying to take advantage of you and they should PAY PAY PAY. However if this is you then you do see yourself as a nice guy and you will never understand what I am saying here.

by antuck

I would have to disagree with you. This one is not a silly thread. I am the nice guy you speak of and do find ways to give free advice when needed. But at the same time, yes, I do think of getting paid. Everything in this world cost lots of money. If I'm giving free advice all the time how am I able to pay for anything? I do some bartering and that helps, but I spend more time giving free advice. Yet when I need to get something there is a charge for it. I spend a lot of time keeping up to date with the IT field. I spend a lot of time learning what is out there now. So why is it I shouldn't charge for my advice or services? I anymore don't like telling someone I work on computers because it never fails you are asked a question. And what is really funny is I am expected to know what is wrong with a persons computer just by them saying it locks up. Ask what error the computer is giving they just say blah blah I don't know. So I am expected to be able to fix blah blah I don't know and of course it needs to be just a couple of key strokes and no technical computer terms. I don't get free advice so why should it be expected of me to give free advice?

Oh by the way I started writing this 45 min ago and was interupted three times for free services. Yea its only 9AM and it starts.

by emmanemms

If personal questions ARE disrupting your productivity, that is another issue, and you likely need to deal with that problem! However, sharing knowledge for such a complex technology is just the nice thing to do. No one is calling you at home on YOUR time. No one is dropping by on the weekends! If that were happening, then you SHOULD expect remuneration of some kind. You are being paid by your employer while they are asking their questions. If your management doesn't have a problem with it, then you shouldn't either. And by the way, you probably get free advice all the time. You just don't realize it. If during your time off, your friends and acquaintences are picking your brain and are, indeed, "using you," then you need better friends. I have IT friends that can do things better than me or faster, and I ask for their advice. I'm mature enough, however, to feel that a "good deed" deserves another one--and I reciprocate in some way. This is all about Life 101--be nice, play well, do unto others... yada yada yada. If you missed that course during all of your time spent on IT training, call your mother--she was giving that course when you were still in diapers.

by emmanemms

Sean, why can't everyone understand your concept? It not only applies to IT, but to every aspect of our lives. I'll bet you sleep well at night and have a lot of good friends. People with good character usually do!

by beads

Though I agree that there should be a modicum of civility and graciousness in the world. All to often we are faced with the ruthlesness of the "real world". Get something for nothing attitude that all to often pervades our society. Not that I grew up that way but its what faces me now as an adult in a metropolis. Sad isn't it?

With that its all to often to get pizza instead of any monetary form of payment.

- beads

by smullster

T.J., is spot on. IT has a bad rep when it comes to customer service (and let's face it... that is what the job boils down to). Even though some see people asking for technical advice as being rude, I try to look at it as a compliment. If they didn't respect your opinion, then they wouldn't ask you in the first place.

I'd want someone with TJ's outlook working for my organization, compared to someone being rude to the end user.

That's my $.02.

Oh, one more thing... what's up with computer technician's / engineers compairing themselves to medical doctors??

by nottheusual1

.....you ask some poor schlub for a "freebie" - no matter what he does - fixing your car, mowing your lawn, fixing your phone, and the list goes on.

Freebies are a cost of doing business for those of us self-employed. They are a great way to build customer loyalty and create a patina of "invincibility" for you, no matter how illusitory it might be. Finding a balance isn't hard, and most people sense when the balance is reached. If they don't, the "it's out of my league" advice is solid.

But - you run the danger of them finding a guy for whom the task isn't out of his league. He could be your replacement. Why keep Underdog when Superman is looking for a full-time gig?

Don't forget that these same people who you are withdrawing your support from will be making decisions about your future, and, quite sadly, based primarily on perception. You control perception, and they don't particularly care about your reality. Business is business.

by arrichter

I work for a Cardiologist group with 3 locations expanding to 5. There are only 2 people in our IT department. We are very busy to say the least, but I try to give advice when someone asks for it because it creates a better working environment. The person you help just might have the ear of someone who makes the decision about your next raise. Think about it!

by itfreak

Well, it's obvious that some of the people posting to this thread have never gone to their friends in the accounting department right around April 15 to get their taxes squared away because of that one form for that one deduction that could make a difference between paying $1000 in taxes and getting a $5 refund.

There's really no good answer here and it all depends on who the person asking for the help is. All of us here knows that we can say no to an underling but can you say no to a director or VP? Let's be realistic and use common sense. If we ask people for advice on non-work related stuff, we should be willing to reciprocate in kind.

by rknrlkid

My brother taught me this one, and I modified it a little. When someone asks for advice (especially if its complicated), use this response:

"You know, that could be a number of things. Its really difficult to pinpoint a problem (over the phone)(during a conversation). You really need to be sitting in front of the computer to find out."

This isn't a direct refusal of help, and its more diplomatic than bluntly saying no or demanding payment.

Now, if they ask you to come to their house and fix it, THEN you can (politely) say no, you don't have the time, or (like I do) say "I'm a professional, and I have to charge for housecalls. My basic fee is $xx.xx to walk in the door, and $xx.xx for every hour after that. Do you still want me to come look at your machine?"

by benoddo53

Wow! you must be a recluse, or a hermit. Ever hear of bartering? Ever have a friend do you a favor? Ever do a favor for a friend? Sounds like you haven't. Lighten up! Money isn't everyting. The drive for money shouldn't cost you valuable interpersonal relationships.

I do for friends, they do for me. Use your skills to network and don't be afraid to barter. You will be better off.

by unclerob

Unless he's surrounded by water on all sides.

Seriously though, I agree with your comments.
People need to lighten up a little and if you're really that busy and can't help them, be honest and tell them you don't have time right now and you will have to talk with them later on their pc problems. As far as compensation, don't expect any, their friends and favors get returned, that's how it works and even if they don't get it returned, be happy that you can help out a friend.

Personally if someone at work has a problem with their home pc, even if they're not really that close to me, more of an acquaintance than a friend, I still tell them to bring the box in to work sans cables, mouse or kb and I let them know that there are no guarantees on what the results will be and how long it will take to fix if it's fixable. I work on the boxes during my lunch or coffee breaks or during some O.T. after work, I don't ever bring the stuff home with me. When it's done, they pick up their own pc and bring it home themselves and I've always rec'd something for my efforts without asking, never cash but a case of beer or a few bottles of wine, or a nice lunch or supper has always been the result. Is this profitable, not really but in the end you helped someone and they appreciated it and you probably moved up a few rungs on someone's respect ladder, you do that enough times for quite a few different people and word gets around and you'll notice the work environment is more pleasant and people treat you differently with class & respect instead of half glances and snotty noses, you'll also find that they'll offer you help when you may need it and you'll even take advantage of that opportunity too. It's not just about making money (which is important, we all have to pay bills) but it's about being a better human being which should be it's own reward.

Seriously, you watch CNN everyday and all the bad stuff that happens to people on this planet, I really believe that it's human nature to destroy ourselves, everything is me, me, me. Isn't anyone getting tired of this routine yet? And no I haven't joined the peace corps yet but it does get you thinking about how much you're doing (or not doing) to make this world a better place.

My sermon on the mount is over.....
Who's N E X T!!!!

by rgovaerts

I'm an Sysadmin and if a collegue or even the CEO asks me for information, I give them my cellphone number. They call me, I go over to their places and charge them by the hour.
Even the CEO is now a client of mine, and this had as result that my contract with the firm has been extended already a couple of times.

by coxd

This issue really depends on several factors: the work environment, who is asking, what their role/position is in the company, your professional relationship with that person, the level/depth of the question(s), and many others. The right answer depends on these factors. In addition to tmcal's comment on your co-workers charging you, you need to consider your professional career. Promotion/advancement is more who you know that what you know. People remember and value the little things...refusing to help a co-worker could burn a valuable bridge you might need to get ahead.

by reddittlouise

I don't think the problems is with them the problem is with you- perhaps mixing business with pleasure- If your at work and expected to perform your job- then talking about their problems at home would not be professional- politely explain that you get a lot of request for assistance and it's intefering with your job- you have a full plate during the course of the day- if your desire is to charge them- have some business cards made and when they ask pass one to them- that ought to shut them up-

by jalassiter

Always try to be polite and professional. Personally I enjoy helping others if possible, but there is a limit. My guideline is, if the answer to their question is less than 30 seconds I concider answering. If the answer is more involved give them the name of a reputable computer repair company or a website such at TechRepublic.com.

by commandgce

Make it clear that there are many variables involved - ask them if they know the 4 different ways to tell if their ... is at fault. Make it attractive for them to admit their ignorance and your superiority. Tell them you give an in-house discount that is a real bargain compared with the sharks outside. Then turn them into fee-paying customers. Everyone wins.

by markdmac

I think there is a big difference between coming to someone for work related help and going to someone for personal reasons.

A good example would be going to the company book keeper and asking them to do your taxes.

But the fact is that the lines between home and work are now often blurred. People have remote access to email and sometimes their entire work environment. Those machines connecting to your network could be a security risk if not up to date on virus software and anti-spyware software. It might be in your best interest to help them.

I think it is reasonable to answer questions that are not too involved. Just like you might ask the book keeper, the name of a form, someone at work might have a question that you can answer quickly without interfering with your day. Its the detailed problems that are really beyond the comprehension of the user that pose the real problem.

Some things you need to consider would be first off are you salaried or a contractor paid by the hour? If you are salaried I would look at this way, you are being paid to be a company resource. A partner asking for your help is your BOSS asking for help. Your pay comes from his pocket and he has a right to decide what priorities are. If you are a contractor then it is totally different as you are probably contracted for a specific purpose and charging by the hour. In that case I would suggest you have them run things for approval by your supervisor/manager first.

Under all circumstances, it is totally acceptable to tell someone you are currently working on a priority and ask that they return at a certain time or to tell them you will find them when your schedule clears. That way you can get done what you need to and prioritize things.

A public folder in Exchange or a task list in SharePoint can be a good way for you to divert some of the questions. Let people post things for you rather than ask you in person. That way you can quickly provide an answer (I can type faster than they can absorb what I am saying).

Some people get really bugged by people asking for help and I personally don't understand it. I've been in IT for 13 years and have enjoyed a great career because I love what I do. For my friends I always offer to help them, at a price, I charge them a hot cup of tea.

Naturally there will be people who will try to abuse your generosity. When I encounter such people I can honestly tell them that I don't have the time resources available to help them and suggest a local computer store that might be able to help them.

by cswearingen

This is the best response I've read:

"Under all circumstances, it is totally acceptable to tell someone you are currently working on a priority and ask that they return at a certain time or to tell them you will find them when your schedule clears. That way you can get done what you need to and prioritize things."

by cswearingen

If you're getting harranged (sp?) to the point of not being able to get your work done then it's a problem. This point is very important.

But this horse is still dead. This topic has been brought up multiple times in past threads. The answers have always been the same "Do it if you're a decent human being" and "Don't do it if you're getting exploited".

Bottom line is that freeozraelised needs to figure out where his/her priorities lie and go from there.

by danag429

Very well put. You will feel exploited if you are an exploiting type of person. If you're easy going, you might make less money but you'll live a longer and happier life.

It's all in your priorities.

by linuxinlibraries.com

> The concept is called "community", and it extends
> beyond your normal field. As a photographer, I am
> glad to help others. Even beginners in the
> industry, I'll help them with their business
> questions. The cadre of friends you build up is
> very valuable for the rest of your career!

I agree with this comment completely. I am not a bit afraid to "share resources" or barter my services. I just choose not to be taken advantage of by those who want something for nothing. :)

by itguy04

I always get asked questions about computers also. I try to answer them without getting to much involved. If there is a problem I would handle it on a case by case basis. You will always get questions from people as long as you are in IT. I am not saying you should give free service. Just talk with the person and tell them well if you want me to fix it for you I would have to charge you and nominal fee or direct them to somewhere they could take it and get it fixed. They will then see just how much work it can be when they have to pay to have it fixed.

by keyguy13

And yes, tmcal, we are obviously above you in computer knowledge or you wouldn't be asking for advice. But here's the thing, there is nothing wrong with people ASKING for free advice. All you do id say "no". Generally when I ask someone to help me, they will give one of two answers; yes or no. Why does saying no seem to be such a big deal with people? If they were demanding that you help them, then it wouldn't be a question would it? I think that is the problem. People think that someone asking a question is demanding something and that isn't the case. Just say "no". You don't need a reason. You don't have to feel guilty. Just say "no". What else is there to discuss about this?

by is girl

Doctors, lawyers, and computer people always get asked for advice partly because people assume that you love to talk shop in your down time. When a doc or lawyer is asked for professional advice at a cocktail party, they usually say "Hmmm....sounds like it could be serious...." then, they invite the person to make an appt or they offer to recommend someone who might be able to help.

In IT, the problem can be handled the same way. Offer a simple suggestion - like installing service packs, etc - then suggest they get professional help if that doesn't fix it. Recommend someone who is good and who is "reasonable". If they still want free help, tell them you are very busy but might be able to set aside some time for them in .....say....about two weeks to take a look at it.

That should do it....

by mhasf

I am always asked for free help. I always answer them with a high level answer that does not completely solve the issue. If you want to do consulting on the side then tell them that this is what you do for a side business and give them your price. If you don't, then tell them to go to Fry's or Comp USA.

by krichmond

All IT people live in that boat I think. There are days I can barely get to the coffee machine and back without getting stopped several times.

I have resorted to pointing the requestor in the right direction by telling them were to look to get the help they need or what to search for on the internet. If they cannot help themselves I carry a few business cards of a local, reputable computer repair shop. I know these people and I don't mind recommending them. In return I get great discounts on parts and software.
Ken

by eureeky

When's the last time you saw a doctor happily give out free medical advice? Or an airline pilot giving free flight instruction? These people are highly trained professionals and so are we. Why should we be the only professional group expected to give away our expertise and years of training? I thought we made our living by selling that expertise.

by pauln1

You know...many people...Doctors included give free advice. I have been in Automotive, Construction, and IT and have always given free advice. It usually will lead to business. If someone tells you they are having a problem that is more than just a quick answer let them know that you will have to take a look at it and give them an estimate of your time and cost to resolve their issue.

I just don't understand most of the thinking in this thread!

by Thorarinn

Living in a small community (60 miles from the nearest town with any sort of commercial computer support) I've been asked many times to "fix" computers.

Most often it's a question of removing spyware and viruses, then installing patches to the operating system(!) and explaining why some sort of virus protection and a decent firewall is a good idea.

I've never asked for payment but none the less, I've often been paid. I never set my price and always accept what they feel it's worth. (I'm also careful never to promise something I can't deliver.)

The payment? Anything from $30 (after driving 15 miles to a farm to remove a corrupt e-mail via web-interface) to a whole lamb, fresh from the slaughter-house (after removing some spyware for the second time from the same laptop).

Why do people pay me? Because they say they "want to be able to call you again". They know I've taken the time to help them out (sometimes many, many hours) and most realize it would cost many times more to take their computer to town.

I realize my situation is somewhat unusual and I do understand those of you who are reluctant to sort out your co-worker's mess (been there, done that).

But apart from being able to put food on the table (quite literally!) my greatest satisfaction comes from the gratitude of those "clueless" people. To me, that's what makes a "community", taking part and helping each other out. (TechRepublic, anyone...?)

If anyone attempted to earn a living in the area by "fixing" computer, I wouldn't hesitate to point people their way. In the absence of a real alternative, I'm quite happy to be my community's computer "geek".

by dc_it_consultant

First of all some you sit there and talk about comparing yourselves with doctors, please, just because you study and bunch of brain dumps and exam crams doesn't even give you close to the same training that a doctor goes through. It's disgusting and makes the IT profession look bad when you try to compare. Secondly, I have a doctor in the family and I know first hand that a doctor would not say no to medical advice especially to someone they know or work with. You so called "IT Specialists" need to get off your high horses. Just because you understand a few acronyms and know how to ghost pc's doesn't mean you should be treated as the new messiah.

The attitude of the old "computer geek", wherein he hardly speaks, reveals no information and thinks that he is smarter than everyone else is really lame. What's even more lame is the fact that this type of attitude is still being hired in the work place.

by apdureha

I too am pretty surprised with the problem here I personally am of the opinion that sharing and helping is must in IT field If we do not do it then we are ourselves limiting our own growth. i always help people and expect them in turn to help others. In a number of problems have been resolved while helping somebody else with their issues.....

by emmanemms

Do I understand that the people who pay your salary (i.e., partner) and the people who keep the organization running (i.e., staff members) need your assistance for their PERSONAL PCs while on company time? Since when is IT advice something which needs to be payed for? If you can't get your "job" done because of all the personal questions, that's one issue, but it doesn't sound like it. I, too, don't understand the majority of the people who've replied to you. I know MS Office products on an advanced level, and though I don't use them on a routine basis, my coworkers do. Isn't part of being a human being who takes up space on this planet (above the ground!) to share their knowledge? Would an attorney tell his legal secretary to "make an appointment" to ask simple questions about a personal legal matter? That list could go on and on. In a nutshell, my experience with IT folks is that they know about networking, hardware, etc., but they know little of the advanced uses of major software (e.g., Excel, Word, etc.). So if one of your non-IT coworkers can generate a complex spreadsheet which would make your life easier (because you don't understand "sumif" or "pivot tables" blah blah blah), then she should tell you, "sorry, I took classes to learn Excel, but I'd be happy to train you on the weekends for $50 per hour!"? GET A LIFE PEOPLE! We all possess some kind of knowledge which someone else likely doesn't have... share it, it's an obligation (or at least it should be). I hope I never have to work with most of the people who have posted here today!

by j_t_c

I encountered this very same thing all the years of my IT. This is very simple to solve which has worked for me. Advice is free... As long as it doesn't involve too much of your "work" time. In the long run the help that you provided may in some way profit the company you are working for (i.e that person was able to complete a report or project on time). Having said that, actual work performed should be on an "off the clock" basis. This work should be compensated for. For example I would give someone some advice concerning spyware/malware removal. That was free, but if they could not handle it on their own I would ask them to bring the computer in during my lunch hour and I would take it to my home office to perform the repairs. I let them know up front the charges and the average cost for the service. I would then bring it back in the next day and do the exchange again during my lunch break. No conflicts of interest, no hassle, and they knew up front what it would cost them. Most people were happy to pay a competent PC person if they actually fixed their problem and did not give them grief about it. With my current lifestyle I simply don't have time to do that anymore so I give the free advice and let them know about a local computer shop that can do the work.

by mnelson

As an independant VAR, computer and Network service is our only commodity. When people (not friends or co-workers) call asking for free advice they not only take away from from us, they hold up the repairs in progress for our paying customers. We are in business to make a profit. Most of the callers however have never spent a dime in our shop and probably never will. On the other hand friends, neighbors, people who know my neigbors and so on attempt to get free service "on the side". Before I started charging for my time I was inundated with sick PCs taking up all my free time. My real friends Know that I'll always take care of them gratis and the rest... Oh well.

by dalin

my theory of moderation seems to apply here as well. i agree with it being rude to repetitively ask personal computer questions. i'm an IT manager but mostly write software/code. i used to do mostly hardware repairs, upgrades, and maintenance so i know it pretty well. it does seem like some days my job extends into parties, weddings, going out to dinner, movies, etc. i know a doctor where we have an understanding that we give each other free professional advice. that's easy.
the hard part is, what do you do when your girlfriend, parents, brother, sister, best friend, or close friend asks for advice. what are you going to do, invoice your mother? maybe she'll invoice you for all the things she's bought you throughout your life?

by emmanemms

they're asking for advice for necessarily a home visit!!! there has to be a compromise between silence and telling them how the watch is made. however, your tact will probably ensure that you are, indeed, the only one--one by yourself with no one to call on in a pinch! Can we sing, "Lonely, i'm Mr. Lonely..."

by emmanemms

Is that REALLY how you would want to be treated? IT/PCs are complex. It is amazing to me that home users even manage to keep their PCs running given how quickly technology changes, viruses advance, etc. You have knowlege that most people don't possess, and if you're already being PAID through a "real job," then you are NOT a consultant for hire technically! If I knew the "trick" to unstick the elevator in the office at your job, and you were stuck between the third and fourth floors, using your MO and since I'm NOT the elevator repairman, I should (1) yell down to you to call the maintenance company from your cell phone or (2) find the 50-page instruction manual to the elevator and throw it down the shaft to you (I'd be nice enough to dog-ear the 10 pages on troubleshooting for you though). How selfish.

by sugarat

Tell them you do IT stuff on the side, but you use the barter system. Then ask them what can they offer in return for computer advice/repair. I never have to work on my own car, and I recently had my garden tilled by trading skills.

by the admiral

I don't know. Is it greed or is it work ethic? Stopping and on the company time giving information out on a personal matter?

by deritchie

The simplest way to handle this is tell people that you don't have a lot of time to give away free support, and you make your living doing this.

And your hourly rate, paid in advance.

by lwebb

When does it end?

It's the same principle as why you should charge by the hour and not by the job.

The "client" is always trying to bring in work that's not in the scope of the original project.

If you give them free advice, they expect more, like the guy you politely try to explain that you couldn't possibly diagnose his machine in a 5 min conversation without actually seeing it, so he asks if he can bring it in tomorrow and put it on your desk.

NO.

by Former member

This is a tricky question. I give free advise. It's short and sweet. Usually I recommend they seek out reliable company to assist them. I explain that for house calls I charge $125.00 an hour. Funny part is that those people who usually ask for assistance have little or nothing to exchange with me. I'm not above bartering, but free without any exchange doesn't seem practical.

by djjonas

When people knock on your door at 9:00 at night or call you and want advice or to work on their computer at odd hours it makes a person say no, because these people are not willing to pay and are looking for something for nothing.

by captg

If these people are interrupting your work, let them know that they're keeping you from maintaining their business environment.
If you're willing to help these people out let them know that you can get together with them outside of the workplace & talk about it over drinks, dinner, or whatever.
I've found that most of the time people asking for tech advice are just trying to be social with the tech guy.

by gphoto45

I was just wondering how many of these people who are so against taking a few min. to give someone some advice are the same ones that use Linux, as it is free, and are constantly pointing out that knowledge is property of the world and should be shared. Paying real money for a software is evil, and MS is the home of the devil himself.

by r_fernandez

... and everyone else here who understands that this is not about payment for services. If people know a car guy, they ask him questions because they respect his opinion and they recognise his training and knowledge. If people are asking YOU for advice, this is one way of saying "I respect your opinion on this, maybe you know something I don't."

If you choose not to share your knowledge, perhaps you have bigger issues, like insecurity, loss of job, arrogance. To quote George on Seinfeld, "God forbid we disturb the precious genius!" If you are truly too busy to answer, offer to talk over lunch - they might even buy!

On the other hand, if you understand that you have an opportunity to build friendships and professional contacts, and you are willing to barter or just receive good karma, you can take 5 minutes and make yourself look real good to others.

by lwebb

I have LOST thousands of dollars and flushed days and days of REAL time down the can on "non-revenue generating clients".

I took myself and my family temporarily in the poorhouse and made them sacrifice so I could change careers...

So after giving out free services and getting burnt time after time I'm NOT supposed to have learned my lesson?

Giving free advice = "How to LOSE friends and piss off family members"

I am no longer ANYONE'S IT Slave. Except maybe my wife's...but she's the one exception.

by contact

A bit strong, but I understand you point. It is true that you can feel like being everyone's IT slave. This is why this thread is certainly no dead horse.

You can see RIGHT HERE the confusion at the heart of the problem : some talk about advice, some about free IT work.

See that medic that gave advice so a broken arm could get fixed ? He didn't do the job at all. Nor would he have given advice on a heart attack or cancer problem. (I hope so :)

Same with the mechanic : he will not REPAIR your car for free, only presume the battery's dead, whatever.

For IT's, giving advice is part of the actual work : diagnosing IS getting the job done.

Samples of good advices :

- try to write the problem down and send it to me
- Try system restore
- Install security programs
- Google it.

The rest is .... getting the job done.

Working for customers, I am constantly -everyday, every hour- asked for something I didn't came for. I used to be gentle and nice, pausing when needed and fixing what I could. It turned into a nightmare and it happened that I spent weeks when days could have been enough. Changing the price was not an option.

Having friends like anyone, I fell into this trap of fixing or setting up their box during week end or evenings. I ended up losing them as friends, as they often started to harass me with their problems, obviously thinking I was responsible for them. I must say I never got a single bottle of wine in return. Sad, but true.

No I try to give short advices or ask for detailed informations. Otherwise, my friends KNOW that I hate it when they ask me to work for free : they have their own IT, pay for it or... find a new IT friend. Which happens to be good trade.

I know some look at me as arrogant. I swear I am not, but I accept this burden: if you look at me as someone feeling superior, you certainly don't need me as your friend, do you ?

Now if I was working as IT for a company, I would definitely fix my collegue's boxes: why would I get paid for, otherwise ?

by zerooneonezero

A couple of times a month, I make an updated do-it-yourselfer Disk to remove viruses and spyware. I make people bring me a blank CD to exchange for the one I am giving them.
Let's face it, 9 out of 10 of these requests are usually 'my computer is slow' what can I do?

I created a CD with an autorun file, a readme with step-by-step instructions, which is also printed on a piece of paper that becomes the envelope for the disk. Included on the disk are several progs. such as VB Runtime files, A Winsock fix program, Ad Aware SE, Spybot Search and Destroy, AVG Antivirus,MS Antispyware (for XP only), and Zone Alarm. I do not include tools like HijackThis for obvious reasons, I also put in a disclaimer, which says specifically not to call me for support for the disk, but rather to use the help files included with each program, and an advisement that if this does not fix the problem(s), they need to take the machine to a qualified professional.

I also include a buddy's business card, because he is really good, honest, and charges a flat fee.
This way, they know I care, and it empowers them to fix their own problem, or if they are just computer stupid, or have more serious problems,
I feel safe knowing that I referred them to a professional, not someone who will do a half-@$$ed job and then rape them on the fee.
I hope this helps.

by beads

Years of being asked for free IT advice, especially on weekends often makes me feel more like a Pizza Delivery than a Physician or Lawyer.

Yep! Put it over there. Here ya go!

- beads

by lwebb

"can YOU come take a look at it tomorrow? Just real quick (doe eyes) I'm sure someone with your technical skill can just punch a button or something..."

Been there, done that. Many times with different people of vastly differing familiarity.

by noortech

I agree with UncleRob thoroughly. Knowledge is to be shared. You have one Life. What do you want to be remembered as? Greedy or Kind.

by rafquinn

Tell people that if you were to give them advice and they unwittingly damaged something on their computer, your company could be held responsible (espcially if you give advice on company time). Our company has a "strict" policy - NO outside work allowed. Of course, the company president says we CAN work on other computers, but this way we can say no to people we work with and not be the bad guys. Good luck.............

by disciplen2k

If the store I'm working at is any indication, the Geek Squad is doing pretty well. I don't think you have too much to worry about as far as losing your SMB clients, though. One of the bad things about the Geek Squad is that we tend to hire high school/college students that we can get by with paying $10/hr for tech work. As a result, we occasionally end up with longer than necessary turn around times, incomplete jobs being sent back with the customer, and REALLY aggrivated clients. If the quality of your work is solid, you should have nothing to worry about.

In regards to the original topic, I have yet to refuse giving someone free IT advice (except when prohibited by my current employer). As someone who is fairly new to the IT field, I consider it a great compliment when people come to me for advice or help with their PC. Because of my eagerness to help with these types of problems, I became the "go to guy" for technical problems at my previous job and now have several new people who can attest to my technical abilities. Being so willing to help has helped me to develop my network of professional contacts and get my start in the IT field. As far as I'm concerned, if you're new to IT, take every opportunity you can to demonstrate your skills. As for how to deal with it when you're already established in the business, I guess I'll just have to figure that part out when I get there!

-Disciple

by lwebb

I only got screwed.

It turns out in our Corporate environment that helping people higher up the totem pole than you with their personal machines devalues the importance of IT to the company.

They don't give me free training in Accounting...Aseptic Supervision...Tetra Mechanics... They DO see the value in these things, but not the computers that make it happen.

by beads

We can rarely leave anything alone. It usually takes IT folks years to get over our little pet issues.

My personal favorite: "Real men don't use mice..." debate from back in the late 80s or early 90s.

No, no. This would be mild. This horse isn't only dead but unrecognizable as a horse any more.

- beads

by dgood

This goes beyond asking for advice! I have been asked to "Format C:" by a neighbor and to rebuild a computer and then asked, "Can I buy you a 6 pack for your trouble?" For some reason, people seem to think that what we do is a hobby and we'd be happy to do it for free.

Try asking someone in the "Trades" to swap you hour for hour, their time for yours and see what reaction you get. HMmmmmm.... I think a computer rebuild is worth a new toilet installation or taping up some drywall.

Maybe that's the solution.... If you can get that doctor to trade some open heart surgery for a new network, you're on the right track.

Good Luck

by nip2655

First off, let me say close friends and family are completely different territory than co-workers. Some co-workers fall into the category of 'friend', sometimes, and as a friend, do your best to help!

However, casual advice is one thing, dedicated attention to solving the issue at hand is another. If the user cares enough to ask your advice, they should care enough to do a quick Yahoo! or Google search. If the problem is too complex for that, it will usually require attention beyond the bounds of simple 'advice.

Don't forget about the issue of liability. Ask a doctor or lawyer why they HATE giving free advice and they will typically tell you it isn't just a matter of giving something away....it's a matter of liabaility.

If the user had a big enough issue to stop you in your tracks to ask your help, he/she is obviously in over their head. To give advice without taking a good long hard look at the problem yourself is to assume you are getting a good run-down of the 'issue' from someone who obviously doesn't know what they are doing in the first place. At the very least, they don't care enough to get the problem professionaly dealt with, other than to ask an offhand favor from a co-worker.

To give advice is a minefield. A couple years ago, a co-worker who really couldn't afford professional computer help asked my advice without giving me ALL the details necessary to diagnose and I was dumb enough to assume I knew what the problem was. I gave her a tip, she screwed her PC big-time and you can imagine where the story goes from here.....

Never again! That's why doctors, lawyers AND IT professionals have a job. We are trained professionals and as such, we have a duty to give these sorts of problems our full attention...and that does not come cheap. Leave the friendly and casual advice to the computer guy/gal 'wannabes' and make sure you stay professional.

by jeff the project manager

Perhaps I've never been overwhelmed with requests because I teach friends "how to fish" -- get online and find the answers themselves. To track down a thorny error message, Google Groups is the place I go first. Anyone can do that.

If they've already searched for the answer, then I'll help them more. Call it sweat equity. But just that first reply that gets them working on the solution themselves cuts down the number of repeat requests.

by Member 24580169

I have been doing IT administration for over 20 years now starting with Mainframes. One thing I've learned is you don't burn bridge. You never know when you will need a friend:) That being said, I make sure I'm always honest with them and if after talking to them it appears to be something that will need my personal attention I let them know they will have to talk with the Geeksquad or something similar to help them fix it. That way, even if you don't give them the answer you have pointed them in the right direction. One thing to remember, to the user, as an Administrator you are a Customer Service respresentive, whether you like it or not. Shutting out your users will only alienate them and possibley make it harder to advance in the company because no matter how good you are a company looks at the whole person. Hope I didn't sound to preachy:)

by macquarrie

The "at-work" hat is on. You're obligated to determine if it is a problem that might impact your company. If ***ANY*** warning bells go off, immediately take whatever action you deem necessary to protect the company.
If they are simply asking you where to get the best prices, refer them to whoever you use and make sure you get your commission....

by bp7226

I have been doing that for years and as soon as I started doing that my phone quit ringing after 9:00 PM. The "free advice" is dispensed on company time, if asked at lunch or after hours, I politely ask them to drop by my office and where we can talk about it without interruption. I pass out business cards that indicate I own a computer business and everyone can rightly infer from that fact that I charge for my work. It is no longer a problem for me and I am never rude to anyone who is seeking "free advice," they are probably my next new client!

by lwebb

I noticed if you scroll up to the top you can see how I'm getting flamed like an AOL'er for suggesting that you mention your "normal fee".

Hey, I used to give out free advice. I used to think it would advance my career, I needed the experience etc. etc. etc.
I got burnt far more times than it takes the average person to get cynical.

Nowadays I restrict my "free advice" to software recommendations, manufacturers, and reputable technicians working locally.

I have a family who wants me at HOME when I'm not working, so when someone gets insistant, I WILL charge them $100/hour and not feel bad about it.

by vltiii

I'm not sure why this is an issue. If you don't want to help, just say no. If you want to be politically correct say, I'm sorry, but I cannot deal with personal problems on company time or my workload does not allow me the freedom to address personal technical problems, or any wording of your choosing. It's really not that hard unless you're worried about offending someone in which case I say give the free advice.

by lwebb

My boss summed it up like this:

"Lew, repeat after me...
NO.
This is the only word you need to know.
NO.
It's my personal favorite word.
NO.
Get used to saying it.
NO.
You've got Servers to run and printers to install I can't have you yakking about people's spyware problems all day...
If you don't cut them off, they'll never leave you alone."

by vltiii

Well said, I'm curious how we got to the point in our society that we don't want to help anyone unless there is something to be gained.

by ultra_blue

Hello:

Apply your knowledge, folks. What's the most likely cause of home machine problems? Right, scumware. So, create a CD with common scumware removal applications. Put some directions and a disclaimer saying you (and your employer) don't take any responsibility for the use of anything on the CD.
Include links to your favorite sites for other questions, and commercial products (like virus protection software, backup software, etc).
Try to get your employer to agree to give the CD to *anybody* who asks for it. Put the files on a public share.
Put other stuff on the CD (things like helpful docs, your own words of wisdom, etc.).
Keep it legal and make sure you understand all the intricacies of distributing the files on the CD.
Educate your users. We'll all be better served by it. If they want a quick-fix, either charge them your regular on-site rate or suggest someone who can help.
Offer your advice in exchange for lunch. This will help to establish the boundaries between work and not-work, and will re-enforce that your time isn't free.
Offer your service in exchange for goods or money.
Don't be passive aggressive -- say no and mean it, or say yes and mean it.

Blue

by minjrb

When you go to the train/bus station and ask an employee the best way to get somewhere, they do not charge you a fee. When you call a mechanic or plumber and ask them what they think might be wrong, they should not charge you a fee. When I am asked for advice, (as I was by my wife's co-worker just before I started typing this reply,) I give them enough to point them in the right direction. I give that away for free, I even throw in a smile.

However, to ask me to take time out of my day and do work supporting your desktop or laptop, requires compensation. My true friends value my time as I do theirs. As a result, either my friends give me cash to, at the very least, cover the gas I use getting to their homes. Or, we barter like my good friend who is a lawyer. I give him and his family tech support and in exchange he gives me legal support. We are both professionals and we both understand that time is money.

Those to whom I have given free advice felt comfortable and confident enough to come back and ask me to provide support at my established rates. This has been extremely helpful in building a client base. Long story short, sow free advice, reap a network of clients, simple!

Get it? Got it? Good!

by chris

Here's the thing, people will not respect you if you always drop your pants when they ask for advice or help with IT matters, personal or business. What most people don't understand is that a vast majority of IT folks are not your social butterfly, granted there are some, but not many. And most people who come to ask for help do not know if you have a life other than computers, and frankly do not care.

It's ok to say no.. tell them that you like them and if you give them bum advice that you don't want them to feel poorly about you. Secondly go find a hobby other than computers. Something that is so different there would be little chance of you getting asked IT questions. Oh and make up a story about what kind of work you do, you're a diver or a bus driver.. not an IT professional. Makes you more accessable on a personal level.

So, like most who have said "This is a dead horse" they are right, it's a zombie. It's a bad penny that keeps coming back.

So, as Nancy Reagan always said "Just say no". Go for the confrontation.. if you don't you'll just feel grumpy and pissed off that you are getting taken advantage of. As my 12 year old Son likes to say "Grow a beard and move to a foreign country."

Tell them No.. if they get ticked, all the better they won't bother you anymore. And if they are a true friend they will understand and respect you for that.

Blah blah blah.. too much talk, not enough NO.

NO

by sam01

I gather by the number of responses to your query that this seems to be very topical. What people are missing is not whether you should or not (that would depend on the person and their situation) but more to the point "How to say NO to free advice".

I'm sorry, but I am tied up on this project ...

I don't think it is appropriate for me to be looking at your personal computer ...

As a rule, I don't do 'home work' - it gets messy and personal etc ...

I think you should get someone to look at it for you as I can't do so, I can recommend someone (maybe) ...

==========

I'm sure that given enough time, everyone can come up with a diplomatic way of saying no, and over time most people will come to accept that. It has a lot to do with setting the expectation level of the people you are dealing with, the problem is that if you have done this type of thing in the past, then the expectation level is that you will continue to do so.

Now if you had asked whether you should or shouldn't give free IT Advice ......