Should government be allowed to regulate. . . . . . .
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Describre a problem, and you automatically assume government is the best - or only - solution. (Hint: It's neither)
Government does not provide the only solutions to the problems you describe. Turning to government is not the best solution to the problems you describe. In fact, it's probably the worst solution - especially considering the inevitable long-term disastrous outcome. All governments that tried to provide for all the social needs and wants of its citizens have eventually collapsed under the weight of its own obligations, and the United States will become the next victim.
Not only does the redistributionist agenda violate the true underlying purpose of the constitution - which is to guarantee and protect individual liberty - but it will lead to the downfall of a great nation.
You, Delbert, are killing the proverbial goose that laid the golden egg because it doesn't lay enough eggs to be redistributed in the manner you think necessary and appropriate. Redistributionists are killing our country, and James Madison would surely disapprove.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=310237&messageID=3088373
Health care, in its purest form, is one person providing a service for another. I don't care how you try to twist and turn it, but that's exactly what it is.
Is one step back from where you have it: healthcare, aka "government", is the operation of self.
Take a look at everything being said from there. Makes no sense.
by delbertpgh
I don't want to redistribute endlessly. I don't believe in society trying to level everything. There are select things to which this applies. As the military power of the country and the currency are sthings best handled by the national government, so should a few other items be as well, including the financing of health care. Not the delivery or administration of it, but the problem of paying for it, which (under the current mechanism) is unequal, incomplete, and disastrously expensive.
You bring up Madison's reflections on limited government, which are wise and valid forever, except to the extent the specifics are limited to the time in which he lived. In Madison's time the state militias were more significant than the national military, and Madison valued them more. In Madison's time any bank could issue paper money, and did. I don't know for sure, but I think Madison would have also upheld the banks' right to do this as a vital limitation on government. We can't live as Madison did; his solutions don't match modern problems. His world was largely gone by the time of the civil war, when organized business rose to dominate American life and pushed the farmer/village citizen into the background.
By the way, would you, as I asked a couple of times, be content to see those who couldn't pay for necessary health care driven to disability, poverty, and death by the uninterrupted advance of their conditions? The opposite side of the coin of health care as a commodity, to be paid for or abstained from, like a cell phone or a bag of Fritos, is life itself and the quality of life. Does your iron rule of transactional logic make an exception for life and self-respect?
by tonythetiger
in your eyes as to what an individual can demand from society? What, in turn, is that person's responsibility?
Should his personal choice to participate in activities that result, or are highly likely to result in exorbitant expense to society, be limited or eliminated?
Your Argumentum ad misericordiam is a typical ploy of the redistributionists, and not justification for establishing government policy.
Edit: Nor is it justification for violating the constitution's underlying principle of protecting and guaranteeing individual liberty.
The answer, however, is this. You should be individually free to do whatever you wish in regards to the [i]problem[/i] you described, and I should be individually free to do whatever I wish.
by tonythetiger
is living a lifestyle designed to minimize the risk of injuries and illnesses that lead to paying for someone else's goods and/or services.
If society is to be expected to pay for the consequences of straying from that lifestyle, wouldn't it be reasonable to expect that they would demand accountability from those who do? So government provided health care at the very least leads to loss of liberty, and at most will lead to the government deciding who lives and who dies.
So don't be surprised if one day you get a summons to appear in court because your neighbor called the tip line and told them you weren't exercising three times a week (first offense is a misdemeanor)... Or the cops pull a felony stop on you because the aroma of fried chicken was reported to becoming from your car (of course, if it was cigar smoke, they wouldn't even bother with due process... just execute you right there on the road!)
[OMG!!! What would cops eat at the former doughnut shops????]
by jdclyde
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=310237&messageID=3088422
The comment WAS Sexist and bigoted, only it was our next high judge that is sexist and bigoted, not I as they are her comments, repeatedly.
by delbertpgh
Tony, I can't figure out what you are advocating. I think you're assuming I must believe in something ridiculous, so you're suggesting ridiculous things to taunt me. Whatever it all means to you is going over my head.
I guess that if you're looking for something extreme that people in Europe expect of their governments that I would not, I remember a case in France where hundreds of motorists were trapped in the alps by a freak blizzard. The government gave them all monetary compensation for being inconvenienced by the weather. I think that's way weird, and not in the realm of government. I suppose you'll think that you should be able to argue that by my own principles I ought to support something as crazy as that. To which I have to say, lay off the crystal meth, and substitute good strong coffee.
Max, apparently you believe that if hospitals would just let people die at their doors if they couldn't exchange a commodity of value for the commodity of their lives, then the citizenry would wise up fast and change their behavior, and the problem of expensive health care would be resolved. Of course, at some point you, your wife, or your kids might well get expensively sick, and after the first go-around, you wouldn't be able to pay enough when the patient relapsed. You know that people with diabetes, for example, typically spend $26,000 per year beyond their insurance coverage? You won't be prepared for those costs once you retire, I can almost guarantee.
You said to Tony, [i]"Tony, I can't figure out what you are advocating. I think you're assuming I must believe in something ridiculous, so you're suggesting ridiculous things to taunt me."[/i]
You said to me, [i]"Max, apparently you believe that if hospitals would just let people die at their doors if they couldn't exchange a commodity of value for the commodity of their lives, then the citizenry would wise up fast and change their behavior, and the problem of expensive health care would be resolved....."[/i]
Delbert, I say to you, [i]"Delbert, I can't figure out what you are advocating. I think you're assuming I must believe in something ridiculous, so you're suggesting ridiculous things to taunt me."[/i]
Please, spare me both the Argumentum ad misericordiam and the Argumentum ad hominem.
The bottom line is this. I don't presume to tell you how you live and how to be charitable towards other people. But you do presume to tell me how to live and how to be charitable towards other people - and you apparently advocate employing the government to act as your broker (or, more accurately, as your [i]enforcer[/i]).
You've done this to me before - attacked my character by attempting to paint me as mean and uncaring. You have no idea what I do for other people or how much I care for other people. For you to confuse that with defining government policy is insulting. We've been civil up to this point, and I continue to be civil. But I don't appreciate the ad hominem attacks - and, in your own words, stop [i]suggesting ridiculous things to taunt me[/i].
by tonythetiger
[i]Tony, I can't figure out what you are advocating.[/i]
Personal responsibility. Nothing is free. Nothing is without consequence. You deal with your consequences the best you can, and yours as best as you can, and I'll deal with mine the best I can. Asking for help is fine. Demanding it is not.
[i]I think you're assuming I must believe in something ridiculous, so you're suggesting ridiculous things to taunt me.[/i]
I don't know what you believe. I was trying to ascertain that when I asked you "Is there a limit?".
Can I really smoke 4 packs of cigarettes a day, eat 3 dozen doughnuts for breakfast, then DEMAND that you pay for a heart transplant for me?
Or better, suppose my fat and smoke-filled self and some one else were both in the hospital waiting for an identical heart. We're both in the same (dire) condition, the only difference is that the other person is wealthy, having been in business for decades, providing value to his customers, and livings to his employees. Me, I'm a ne'er-do-well... had a few odd jobs, but really prefer idleness. Been in a few scrapes with the law even...
There is one heart available. In the system you would advocate, who would get the heart (the other one will be dead in a few hours) and why? (Remember, there is no medical difference)
by nicknielsen
First, I don't consider anything active or retired military receive a social benefit. The fact is, all military retirees are members of the Retired Reserve and subject to recall to active duty at the convenience of the government. There's a reason military retirement remains a DoD funding liability.
Second, you seem to believe that today's military has the same benefits package you saw almost 4 decades ago. I can tell you that just ain't so. Congress long since eliminated many of the discounts, subsidies, and benefits you remember. By watching for sales and specials, today's soldier can usually find cigarettes cheaper off-post than in the commissary. By watching for sales and specials, today's sailor can usually find beer and liquor cheaper off-base than in the Class VI. There is zero tolerance for DUI; this killed the on-base clubs. Free family medical still exists for active-duty; free family dental has gone the way of the dinosaurs. Retirees pay for everything. And if you don't have a service-connected disability, the VA won't even talk to you.
You say you guarded a desk, but there was always the chance you could have wound up in Vietnam or another hot spot. Had you done so, would you still feel the same way about the benefits?
Today's military personnel are [u]volunteering[/u] to offer their lives in the defense of their country. Ask the soldiers who've been in Afghanistan or Iraq if they feel they've been coddled, cocooned, or wrapped in a security blanket. Then ask them if they think they deserve it.
by delbertpgh
by delbertpgh
by jdclyde
the less you expect out of (many) of them, the less you get.
The more you expect, the more you get.
That is the great thing about personal responsibility, it gives people a reason to become more. A life on government handouts kills the soul/spirt.
Bare minimum safety nets to keep someone from going under, sure. Worrying about if they can afford that second car, and multiple cell phones is not. And instead of the rigged system we have that punishes anyone from trying to advance, give them a path off.
This goes the same for watching which companies and industries get kickbacks, and what the pros/cons of such kickbacks is. This goes beyond getting bogged down in discussions of welfare.
Does it make sense to ANYONE to put a punitive tax on someones private health insurance that they get as an earned benefit?
Does it make sense to ANYONE to put another punitive tax on petroleum?
by boxfiddler Hot topic
that makes or breaks us, hones us 'til we're our best.
Anything less, weakens us.
What are the (now generations of) recipients of social welfare programs monies going to do when those programs collapse? Better question - what do they know how to do?
by nicknielsen
Ask the child with cancer about cruel outcomes.
The only thing the government should guarantee the individual is the same opportunity as his neighbors. After that, it's up to him.
Makes perfect sense, jd. If someone gets healthcare costs paid as part of their job benefits then of course it should be taxed - at least to the same extent as the guy who doesn't get any benefits and then has to pay for them out of own pocket using salary that is taxed.
As for putting tax on petroleum? Why is the Great God Gasoline exempt?
:)
by jdclyde
And in this case, it is being used to discourage people from having their own insurance so they will get lumped into the same failed efforts as everyone else.
As a vet the care they receive in a VA hospital? There was a big deal made about the conditions at military and VA hospitals not long ago.
As for petroleum, I suppose you don't see anything wrong with having more cost in taxes than in actual product, huh? The Obama who claimed in his class warfare pledge to only go after the evil rich to pay for everything and let everyone else reap the rewards. Now he is greatly increasing the cost of living for the poor poor and they aren't smart enough to realize it.
Note: did you know it is ILLEGAL here for the gas stations to post on the pump how much of the price we are paying is taxes? Gotta keep people angry at the big gas as the evil ones, but we don't hear about governments "windfall profits" they get off of gas at the pump, while doing NOTHING for it.
by delbertpgh
What I advocate in the issue of health care is insurance. I don't know if for everybody here the doctrine of "responsibility for yourself" excludes the concept of insurance. (I'm unsure if for Max it does; he's philosophically strict.) Insurance means pooling money and risk, so that if the risks catch up with you, the pool pays, not you individually. That makes you not responsible for anything but your insurance payments, and with American workplace insurance, having your employer cover about 80% of those payments. I believe this is a good idea because the cost of medical treatment is so high that most people would be unable to pay for emergencies, or would have to sell their homes and take three jobs to meet the bills. I think that having hundreds of thousands more people dead or crippled and unable to work as they used to would be bad for the economy, as would be having college students drop out of school and sacrifice their future earnings so they could work and pay for dad's bypass operation. A good insurance system that covers the country is good for the country.
I also think that it is humane and decent, and the only fitting way for a country like ours to be. However, I won't make a big deal about that.
I'd rather see an insurance system covered in the private sector, but it's obvious from the price, the failure to cover 20% of the population, and the shorter life expectancies compared to other developed countries that we aren't doing an adequate job. Insuring everybody, and insuring them well, without creating a distorted market for services that drives cost through the roof, is something only government can do.
Nick points out that life is cruel; just ask a kid who gets cancer. Fine and true, but in 21st century America, we actually treat cancer. We have a lot of blubbering, sentimental reasons for doing so, but we do what we can to cure the kid, or the mom, or the dad. We don't just dig a hole and buy a stone, once the diagnosis come in.
Governments do nothing to get ANY taxes in - they just seem to tax what they want. Taxing gas seems fairer than some taxes as, by adding to the cost of everything, it works like a sales tax. "The more you use, the more you pay" rather than the thing that you all seem to moan about, "The more you earn, the more you pay".
Seems like a nice capitalist-friendly tax to me...
:)
by tonythetiger
[i]Makes perfect sense, jd. If someone gets healthcare costs paid as part of their job benefits then of course it should be taxed - at least to the same extent as the guy who doesn't get any benefits and then has to pay for them out of own pocket using salary that is taxed.[/i]
I agree that employer paid premiums are indeed income.
However, I disagree that any income should be taxed.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
I thought of something over the weekend about changing the way health insurance is done...
The problem seems to be that "a company" locks itself with a particular provider, so essentially, that provider has a captive customer base. This leads to high prices and little flexibility. Yeah, you can turn down the company's plan, but you can't come near replacing it for the 15 to 25% that you're probably paying on your current plan.
What if it were legislated that all employers who provide part or all of the premiums for health insurance simply pay that amount to the employees directly (adjusting your salary or hourly rate to include that amount... it would just be regular income).
The employees could then shop on the open market, and since there will be tens of millions of customers, competition and lower prices would result. There would also be wider selection of packages, so each could choose what he or she really needs (does a single man really need maternity coverage?), reducing costs even more.
This would not cost the companies a dime (in fact, might save them some), and would reduce the price of insurance to the point where more people (even those who don't have employer paid coverage) could afford it, thus reducing the number of "uninsured".
Am I missing something?
by nicknielsen
[i]What I advocate in the issue of health care is insurance. I don't know if for everybody here the doctrine of "responsibility for yourself" excludes the concept of insurance. (I'm unsure if for Max it does; he's philosophically strict.) Insurance means pooling money and risk, so that if the risks catch up with you, the pool pays, not you individually. [/i]
To start, Max [u]is[/u] philosophically strict, but I seriously doubt he's stupid.
The problem with the American health insurance program is in the priorities. The system ignores the ounce of prevention in favor of the pound of cure and preventive medicine falls by the wayside. Those relatively inexpensive treatments that can reduce later costs are often the least covered: dietary instruction, weight loss clinics, and stop-smoking classes. Even annual physical examinations are barely covered under some plans.
And don't get me started on dental insurance; my current company plan pays for two examination per year (not including x-rays), two cleanings, and one filling. 50% of everything above that is out of my pocket...and I'm paying for the "better" plan. My neighbor's son had to have mandibular and dental reconstruction after a motorcycle wreck. Even though he lost almost all his teeth when the id10t pulled out in front of him, only about 10% of the costs were covered because it was considered "cosmetic". Yet the lady down the street got 90% coverage for her new t|ts. What an absolute crock.
[i]...it's obvious from the price, the failure to cover 20% of the population, and the shorter life expectancies compared to other developed countries that we aren't doing an adequate job.[/i]
The price goes far in explaining why 20% of the population is not covered. The shorter life expectancy, I believe, is more due to our lousy diet and lack of fitness than anything else. When I was in Germany, I got into the habit of walking where I could. Here in the States, I am looked at as an oddball when I don't wait for a parking space to open closer to the store.
[i]Nick points out that life is cruel; just ask a kid who gets cancer. Fine and true, but in 21st century America, we actually treat cancer. ... We don't just dig a hole and buy a stone, once the diagnosis come in. [/i]
In 2006, the four leading causes of death in the US were heart disease, cancer, stroke (cerebrovascular diseases), and chronic lower respiratory diseases (COPD), responsible for almost 1.5 million deaths. Accidental deaths were in fifth place with less than 10% of the total of the top four. (http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/FASTATS/lcod.htm). From my understanding of preventive medicine, a large percentage of these deaths could have been prevented by healthier eating, regular exercise, and giving up smoking (the only one of my gross and disgusting habits still legal in public...at least for now...). Unfortunately, the American population as a group demonstrates the ultimate in stupidity by assuming that no matter how sick they get, modern medicine can cure them. Our system does its best to cure the patient, but not all can be cured.
by delbertpgh
You proposed, "The problem seems to be that "a company" locks itself with a particular provider, so essentially, that provider has a captive customer base... What if it were legislated that all employers who provide part or all of the premiums for health insurance simply pay that amount to the employees directly ... regular income. The employees could then shop on the open market, and since there will be tens of millions of customers, competition and lower prices would result. There would also be wider selection of packages, so each could choose what he or she really needs (does a single man really need maternity coverage?), reducing costs even more."
First, there are a lot of insurance providers, and employers switch between them freely. Having 100 times as many customers is not going to increase competition, except at the minimum coverage end of the business (see point three.)
Second, some employers spend a lot more on insurance than others. Turning a complex benefit into simple income will remove the incentive to provide a sweeter health deal than the boss next door does. A lot of employers will just look at moving to an amount providing minimum coverage and calling it a cost reduction.
Third, employees who are free to check out of zones of coverage they are unlikely to need, and thus pocket part of their insurance premiums, will do so. (Who wouldn't? You'd have to be stupid.) This means that (to use your example) only people more likely to need maternity care would pay for it; say one employee in four. To cover the costs of maternity on a shrunken subscriber base, the insurors would raise rates for it, possibly by a factor of four. This would be true for lots of different coverages, and for coverage in general. By the way, I've known a lot of single men who didn't need maternity coverage, until life surprised them. Maybe it's coverage they'd be unwise to skip, unless they were also sterile.
Fourth, big employers probably bring greater bargaining power to negotiations, and can sweat a better deal out of the insurer than can some little guy only seeking to cover himself.
by tonythetiger
by delbertpgh
The health care statisticians always rave about how much money is wasted on smokers making themselves sick, but they ignore a bunch.
First, smokers pay out the wazoo in taxes. The 27 cent packs I bought in 1970 were probably half tax, and I bet it doesn't cost much more than a quarter today to make a pack of cigarettes. However, the tax has gone up to three or four bucks per pack. One smoker supports state and federal government to the tune of $1000 to $2000 per year.
Second, as tragic and expensive as your death from cancer, emphysema, or heart trouble is likely to be, due to your early age at your time of passing, by dying young you still save us money. Yes, sir, Social Security and Medicare will be in much more trouble if you actually live to draw them. Sure, cutting out a lung is expensive, but as a geezer on the government dole you get more and more likely each year to need a triple bypass or some similar pricey remedy, and any heath actuary will tell you that your last year on earth is probably going to be the most expensive in terms of Medicare/Medicaid reimbursement.
So, puff hearty, Nick. And, stop walking around the block, and use the time you save to work up a drinking habit. Eat more fried food. The rest of us have an interest in your health.
by tonythetiger
[i]This means that (to use your example) only people more likely to need maternity care would pay for it; say one employee in four. To cover the costs of maternity on a shrunken subscriber base, the insurors would raise rates for it, possibly by a factor of four. This would be true for lots of different coverages, and for coverage in general. [/i]
So? Why should I pay for coverage for a condition I'll never experience? It's like requiring me to buy motorcycle insurance...
[i]By the way, I've known a lot of single men who didn't need maternity coverage, until life surprised them. Maybe it's coverage they'd be unwise to skip, unless they were also sterile.[/i]
I said SINGLE man... his girlfriend isn't covered :)
by tonythetiger
[i]The rest of us have an interest in your health. [/i]
I wondered why tobacco farmers get government subsidies :)
by tonythetiger
[i]Insurance means pooling money and risk, so that if the risks catch up with you, the pool pays, not you individually.[/i]
Normally you CHOOSE whether and which insurance to buy. A few insurance companies assign individual risk values based on lifestyle and set the premium based on that. I would choose one that did this over one that didn't.
Of course, one could choose to forgo insurance totally and pay out of pocket (or buy a catastrophic plan and pay for the small stuff out of pocket). Most providers I know of will give a discount (they don't have to fill out/submit your insurance paperwork) to uninsured. If you are particularly healthy and do not partake in risky activities, you should be allowed to take this route.
At any rate, the point isn't whether you're sharing the risk... the point is whether you're [b]required[/b] to.
[Was in wrong subthread]
by dwdino
Can one be destroyed by simply removing their ability to introduce change?
Can one be destroyed by devaluation?
Can one be destroyed by imposed limits?
Or must it be physical?
America the great already has been destroyed. The fight remains, for the classics, to raise her from the dead, and return to the prominent status once held.
Too many are looking at the issue inverted. Government this and that... Look into history and recognize how and why great changes occured. Government was the tail, not the head. When a body of individuals identify a common standard, then government can be called into service to uphold this commonality. By attempting to drive down the standard through government enforcement, destruction must come.
So my underlying premise is this - has government degraded, or have we? The founding fathers recognized this and documented it well, " of the people, by the people, and for the people." This phrase is often used to place responsibility on government; but truly, it places responsibility on us. If we neglect ourselves and rise only to the lowest common standard, our government has no choice but to follow suit. If our responsibility is discarded, how much less our government's? If we hold ourselves and our peers to limitless choice devoid of consequence, the government has but one path.
Take all of these issues discussed above, step back and view the mural, and recognize the markings on the canvas. Then, approach ever so cautiously the fine pigments and points that create this image and identify yourself. What is your color and shape? Is your mark misplaced? Does it contribute or detract?
When we as a nation measure ourselves and determine that betterment is the desired path, only then can our government rise to greatness. Great men created great governement.
You already have a fair grip on the supposition, its contrary, and the answers.
by tonythetiger
[i]When we as a nation measure ourselves and determine that betterment is the desired path, only then can our government rise to greatness.[/i]
The devil is in the definition (of 'betterment').
You want every American to have health insurance via government mandate, command, and control (and paying the bill for those who can't/won't pay for themselves).
I don't.
It's an irreconcilable difference.
What you want is neither the role of government in the United States (I'll debate that premise with you, if you'd like), nor is it an efficient or fair way to run a medical care system.
I think people who see that as a role for government in the United States are the reason for the destruction of individual freedom and liberty in America, and they (you) are the ones taking our country down the road to financial ruin - not to mention the destruction of freedom and liberty. Even people in Russia and China are warning the United States that its implementation of Marxist ideas will lead to our destruction. Your desire is a Marxist idea, whether you admit it or not. But Europe moves farther right as the United States moves farther left.
Like I said in an earlier post, you're killing the goose that laid the golden egg. And like I said in yet another post, if one were to set-out to intentionally destroy freedom and liberty in America, how would it be done? Well, you're doing it, dude. And you claim to not be a redistributionist? Yea, right.
P.S.
The delivery of medical care in the United States in the 1950s was more effecient, more cost effective, more fair, and more consistent with the underlying principles upon which our nation was founded. It started to get screwed-up when the government (via the redistributionists) started poking their noses into the individual's business.
by tonythetiger
[i]The system ignores the ounce of prevention in favor of the pound of cure and preventive medicine falls by the wayside. [/i]
It ignores the [b]responsibility for[/b] that "ounce of prevention".
The cost of insurance is based on risk. Should everyone be forced to pay more because some people intentionally choose risky habits and activities?
In a extreme example, I know two couples who intentionally had children KNOWING that they had congenital conditions that were guaranteed to require a lifetime of very expensive treatment. One couple was even told [b]prior to conception[/b] that they were extremely likely to a child with the condition, but they did anyway, and had a child that requires $100k of enzyme replacement annually for his entire life (as does the father!). Do they REALLY have the right to intentionally burden society thus? Sure, it's rude to ask, but couldn't they have adopted? It really makes me wonder what society's goals are...
[fix bolding]
..... an irreconcilable difference, what should they do to resolve the conflict?
My answer is to back-up and consider the premise, and to then debate - and resolve - that premise.
Delbert is debating with ad hominem attacks and ad misericordiam appeals, while I'm trying to debate the premise. (Delbert, look it up if you don't know what those terms mean.)
Back-up and consider the premise, Delbert.
But no, you can't do that, lest you acknowledge (to all AND to yourself) that you're actually advocating Marxist principles, while I advocate individual liberty principles.
Your premise, Delbert, and mine, have an irreconcilable difference. Admit that you're a Marxist when it comes to the delivery of medical care.
In your case, it hurts to be honest, doesn't it?
Edited P.S.
Delbert, admit that you're wrong, or admit that you're a [i]medical care Marxist[/i]. Those are your only choices.
by mr stumper
This is her speech from UC Berkeley's School of Law symposium entitled "Raising the Bar: Latino and Latina Presence in the Judiciary and the Struggle for Representation."
The title should give you a good indication about the subject, and the quote, which I feel has been simply taken out of context.
While I certainly do not agree with all of her rulings, I think this accusation of racism is completely overblown when you consider this context.
Our life experiences will affect the way we judge people, this is simply human nature.
I think that a person who has the same experience regarding a case would have the ability to best judge for that case. For example, this is for you too JD...I'm not a single parent, and I think that a judge who has experienced single parenthood would make a better judgement than I, regarding a case involving a single parent. Because of the experience that they possess that I do not. With that in mind, I don't find anything remotely racist about her comment.
As for the "policy making" statement...this is simply how it is. Any decision made by a judge can be used as a precedent in later cases. This is fact, not an opinion. Roe v Wade proves this, as do countless other decisions. To realize and take consideration that what you DO decide ends up becoming defacto policy is a GOOD thing. Knowing it and denying that the decisions you make will have future ramifications is really, really bad.
Edited: To clarify the single parent comparison
by jdclyde
THAT is the scope of their power.
Anything beyond that is a clear violation of Separation of Powers, which is the check and balance to keep any one branch from becoming to powerful, leading to a takeover.
As for life experiences, there is NO place in our legal system for such. There are laws, and they are to be upheld.
Or is she only going to preside over poor Latinas?
By the way, where is the link? :D
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by mr stumper
This is exactly why I learned to attach a document to email BEFORE crafting the body!
http://berkeley.edu/news/media/releases/2009/05/26_sotomayor.shtml
Again, in my opinion she has made a few dubious rulings and I'm not about to research them all, but I'll hold out on my opinion until she gets asked the hard questions at the hearings.
I think that the media has taken her quote out of context. In any other venue, if she stated the same thing but used "minority" as opposed to "Latina", she would not have been so scrutinized.
But again, due to the topic of the symposium, I think that what she said was not so terrible as the media portrays.
by nicknielsen
Those 27-cent packs you bought in 1970 were exempt from ALL tax, federal and state, because they were sold to the military on a military installation; it's one of those things that changed since then.
As for tax, I'm only aware of one state with combined federal/state tax rates over $4: Rhode Island. The next highest is Hawaii at about $3.66. (Although I understand New York City adds municipal excise tax to raise the rates above $5.)
The Federal cigarette tax as of March 31, 2009: $1.0066/pack.
State excise taxes on cigarettes: http://tobaccofreekids.org/research/factsheets/pdf/0097.pdf (1 page)
As for the rest? Not doing it. If I live to the average age of death of my grandparents' generation, I'll be 89 when I die. Half of them smoked, but [u]none[/u] were overweight.
by delbertpgh
I've got a lot to reply to here.
"Delbert is debating with ad hominem attacks and ad misericordiam appeals, while I'm trying to debate the premise." My premises (there are more than one, notice) in these posts are that American health care is badly delivered and is too expensive in the current model; and that in a society as rich as ours, it only fit and decent that all people be covered. You jumped to call that an ad hominem attack, thinking it implies you are unfit and indecent for holding a contrary view, but that is a logical fallacy in itself.
I get the impression from some things you've said that you think society (a) via insurance and guaranteed access to emergency care already does too much for people; (b) is sapping their will to care for themselves and makes them spend wastefully; and (c) would be improved if all socially-based coverage paid or mandated by government were cut back to zero, in favor of individuals taking care of themselves, or social care from voluntary charities only. If that is your idea, then I think it has inevitable horrible and tragic consequences in store for anyone who gets seriously (and expensively) sick. It seems to me that people under that regime would be impoverished trying to pay for a single bad episode, and would be unable to pay for a second at all. The doctrine of individual responsibility seems invalid to me because of the awful outcomes. I was not sure if you meant this, such an extreme application of individualism, and used examples of people who needed expensive care. This was not an appeal to pity (ad misericordiam), but a test to draw you out, to see if you actually did mean what I thought, to as harsh a degree, or if you had exceptions. Your reaction was to accuse me of ad hominem attack, a misinterpretation of my motives.
I do believe in freedom and liberty, and in the restraint of government. Howevery, once you're catastrophically sick, you have no liberty left, and if you indebt yourself to the limit to a hospital to pay for treatment, you become a prisoner of poverty, and again, out of freedom. If you are left crippled or enfeebled you are permanently less free. I think it is virtuous for society to address that, to do what is practical to relieve it. It's not charity; it's insurance. Under a doctrine of strict individual responsibility, most medical care would not be provided, because individuals would find it unaffordable. That seems bad to me. Among the jobs of government is to enhance and protect freedom, and for me, freedom from ill health is important and within the purview of government. I believe it makes for a stronger and more stable society, as well.
"Admit you're a medical care Marxist." Nope. I don't admit to that at all. I don't agree with much about Marx; he had interesting critiques of capitalist society, but no useful prescriptions. There are lots of positions between libertarian individualism and communism, different spots of philosophical and moral ground where one can stand and make an argument. To say that everthing aside of your left elbow is a slide into Marxism is a false argument, too.
Not that I think you are a liar for advancing a bad argument. I attack the argument, not the man.
by tonythetiger
[i]There are lots of positions between libertarian individualism and communism, different spots of philosophical and moral ground where one can stand and make an argument.[/i]
But who has the right to impose the tenets of their "philosophical and moral ground" onto others, and why?
by delbertpgh
"But who has the right to impose the tenets of their "philosophical and moral ground" onto others, and why?"
Well, we're all in this together. And we can't escape it. By "it" I mean modern life in the U.S.A.
Lots of agencies impose their philosophies and rules upon us. The electric utilities, the cable company, the State Department, the company you work for, the state highway agency, car companies. They concoct services for us, usually in response to "market forces", which give us certain choices, but also confine us to those choices. Unless you choose to go "off the grid", and stuff yourself and your kids into a cabin on a remote mountain somewhere, you have to live out a life in part staged and scripted by a powerful society that reaches into every corner of your life.
The idea that all government is an imposition upon you and a restriction of your freedom is false. Some government gives you more choices, protects you from foreign enemies, protects you from powerful domestic forces that would love to exploit you. The regulation of food, drugs, and insurance are examples of government stepping in and doing what no private party could do to guarantee your safety and give you better choices. Government, well done, can make you more free, in some situations.
We're all in it together, and we should make the best common life we can. There's no escaping the entanglements.
by jdclyde
Consider this a follow-up question to Tony's post.
Because it makes someone feel better?
Because it buys them votes?
Because it increases dependency?
by tonythetiger
Who (as in people... individuals...) has the right to impose their tenets of their "philosophical and moral ground" onto other (people... individuals...) who may or may not have the same philosophy/morals? And why?
by tonythetiger
Auto insurance companies charge higher rates to people who have more accidents. Do you think this is fair? Why or why not?
Home insurance companies charge higher rates to people who file more claims? Do you think this is fair? Why or why not?
Life insurance companies charge higher rates to people who partake in unhealthy or risky lifestyles (smokers, sky-divers, etc.). Do you think this is fair? Why or why not.
Should health insurance carriers use the same criteria as life insurance carriers in determining rates? Why or why not?
by delbertpgh
When I entered the service, I could still buy cigarettes for 35 cents a pack in Colorado. They were under 30 cents in Base Exchanges in Texas, because state tax (and presumably some degree of profit) did not apply. I was looking forward to a big price drop (federal tobacco tax was 8 cents then) when I went to Germany, but surprise; no price drop. Apparently the feds were collecting it in overseas bases by then. I heard, though, you could still get them free of US tax on Navy ships at sea.
What stuns me today is that the total tax is so much lower than the price you pay. In Pennsylvania, Marlboros go for about $45 a carton in groceries, but only $26 is tax. That means that somewhere along the line the tobacco companies really hiked their profit margin, probably using the tax increases as cover. I doubt it costs more than $2 or $3 to manufacture the carton and get it into distribution. A pack-a-day smoker is thus generating 600 or 700 dollars per year in profit for the manufacturers, distributors, and retailers. Then multiply by 50 million or so. Wow.
When I was a kid they were probably working on a margin of a nickel a pack. Times have changed. I see why tobacco companies are still so prominent in investment portfolios.
by delbertpgh
It might make sense to charge people more for risky behavior or conditions that would lead to higher treatment costs. Motorcyclists, skiers, smokers, heavy drinkers, moderate drinkers, children of diabetics, fat people, moderately overweight people, people with personal or family histories of cancer or heart trouble, families with allergies, people over 55... you could make a long list. If you price risk according to actual cost to the insurors, the way they do with other types of policy, then you could probably force some policies over $10,000 per year. Your risky people would probably forgo insurance in large numbers. Maybe some would modify their behavior, if it was behavior that triggered the rate hike.
Part of the problem with people giving up insurance (which would make it cheaper for the rest of us who kept it) is that the hospitals are not allowed to turn away anybody, by law. The hospitals would have to charge more for their insured patients so they could cover the cost of charity (which pushes the cost back up, close to where it was.)
by tonythetiger
[i]In Pennsylvania, Marlboros go for about $45 a carton in groceries, but only $26 is tax. That means that somewhere along the line the tobacco companies really hiked their profit margin, probably using the tax increases as cover.[/i]
They have to recover the money they lost in those lawsuits... It's merely a business expense to them, and ALL business expenses are part of the cost of the product or service...
Every company does it!
by jdclyde
First, don't forget that the tobacco industry is passing on the costs of the settlements to the customer. That is a hidden tax.
Federal taxes, state taxes, and possibly some sin tax for good measure.
Of course because of the state taxes, this does vary greatly from state to state. Michigan is one of the highest for state taxes on smokes.
Just one more golden goose to milk dry until it is killed.
by jdclyde
You have not been listening to The Obama, his plan will not be optional, and anyone that does NOT go along will face heavy fines to force you to comply with his wishes.
by tonythetiger
[i]Part of the problem with people giving up insurance (which would make it cheaper for the rest of us who kept it) is that the hospitals are not allowed to turn away anybody, by law.[/i]
They are not allowed to turn away anyone with an immediately life threatening condition... and once someone WITH a life threatening condition has been stabilized, they are not required to provide further treatment, although some states require some hospitals to donate a certain percentage of their profit to "uncompensated care".
[i]then you could probably force some policies over $10,000 per year[/i]
Most employer "provided" family plans are already at or above that. Mine is $1110 a month ($342 paid by me, which is still about $75 cheaper than I could get a decent catastrophic plan). Of course, if I were a single woman with seven kids, I could get the spousal surcharge knocked off and only have to pay $192 a month...
by jdclyde
Went into the gun shop over the weekend. With my boys coming hunting with me, more and more, I find I need more rifles/shotguns.
While I was there I found that many handguns are on about a 3 month waiting list, because as soon as an order comes in, they are gone. Manufacturers can not keep up with demand.
Is this The Obama's plan for stimulus? Trash one sector to create demand in another?
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]You have not been listening to The Obama, his plan will not be optional,[/i]
You don't HAVE to send your kids there, but you're STILL going to pay for it...
by tonythetiger
[i]Just one more golden goose to milk dry until it is killed. [/i]
every socialist attempt started... with stolen property and stolen capital... never creating anything... just riding the horse until it dies...
by tonythetiger
[i]There's no escaping the entanglements. [/i]
Of course there is... personal responsibility... personal consequences for personal failures... you just don't seem to have the stomach for it!
by dr dij
you alternate between ignoring it and burying your head in the sand so you can't see the evidence. Same thing, maybe the evidence of destruction will go away?
http://news.yahoo.com/s/mcclatchy/20090609/sc_mcclatchy/3249010
by tonythetiger
by dr dij
he wants congress NOT TO SPEND MORE THAN THEY GET each year!
and very strangely some republicans were against this.
by jdclyde
He isn't talking about cutting spending to make ends meet, he is talking about raising taxes. This was also something promised by Pelosi two years ago but I haven't seen it.
Not rocket science that raising taxes during an economic down time is going to hurt the economy, not help it.
There is only so much of other peoples money you can spend.
by mr stumper
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by mr stumper
The Supreme Court rules on existing law or strike it down as unconstitutional. Lower courts do not.
I do not see what you are trying to say when you state that "Anything beyond is a clear violation of Separation of Powers".
The Supreme Court has the final say regarding Constitutional matters. However, , precedence has been around for a long, long time. Lower courts always have to acknowledge the decisions of higher courts (assuming there are lawyers who check for such things). There is a reason for this. So yes, one can say that this is making policy. One can say that if it makes it to the Supreme Court that THEY make policy. How hard is this to understand?
As for "Separation of Powers" I'm wondering how this enters into the matter and how come, all the sudden, you are so concerned about it?
Regarding your quote about "life experiences", in a perfect world life experiences would have no effect on the legal system. However, since the legal system is compromised of humans, this is going to happen. I really cannot believe that anyone's life experiences would not affect their judgment. Either consciously or subconsciously. This IS human nature and you cannot get rid of it through legislation.
Remember, an activist judge is only "activist" when you do not agree with their rulings.
Regarding your "poor Latinas" comment, it is not worth commenting on.
I will say that from a political standpoint, this is quite savvy. The Democratic President picked a qualified minority woman who was nominated by G.H.W Bush to the US District Court and then appointed. So now, the Republicans have to object to this simply because that's the way politics work (you know, hate what the other team is proposing), and then come up with a racism angle (gee...who would have seen THAT coming????)
So now, the Republicans are faced with playing to their base and are once again alienating minority, especially Hispanic, voters who are increasing exponentially every year. Thus making the Republicans give more credence to the image that many hold of them as being For, By and Of rich white people.
Politics is WAY more interesting than religion!
Linearly, if that.
Politics/religion cannot be distinguished, at least by me.
by mr stumper
Religion is Politics and Politics is Religion.
Sorry, my best attempt at being cryptic. :)
by mr stumper
Nice vocabulary. It's like when you like think you know like what you are like talking about. Then, like there is a word that, like defines exactly, like what you are talking about. Like...and stuff. :)
And people complement me on my vocabulary. I guess I'm just average and they are just dumb! ;)
I walk up and tap your shoulder from behind, while you quarrel out your front whether it was their ring finger, pinky, or middle.
Carry on. I despair of a response. Much less a precis.
Obviously.
http://www.numberwatch.co.uk/warmlist.htm
You're being duped, Dij
by jdclyde
First, they use the words "Could" and "might" an awful lot.
Second, they talk about pollution from cars and factories, but what does that have to do with man made global warming? Blame every woe on GW?
They didn't even mention what "could" or "might" cause the oxygen depletion.
by tonythetiger
After it all comes to a head,
and dozens of millions are dead,
you might ask me why,
and I'll say with a sigh,
"So the rest of us could be fed".
by tonythetiger
Interesting...
We could speculate about recording pedometers that report to the government in relation to the mandate that all people must walk at least 5 miles a day, 20 days out of a month - since the governmenr is now in chagre of health care.
by tonythetiger
In Ohio, any claimant for Workers comp must submit a medical history as well as submit to drug testing (they'll try to use it to get out of paying)...
by darpoke
if it will prevent companies like Phorm here in the UK being permitted to perform DPI on public broadband connections at the ISP level.
Ditto if it means that the servers controlling botnets can be shut down at the ISP, cutting the zombies loose (albeit temporarily) and reducing the levels of spam globally.
Unfortunately, as jack8beans2 said, it sucks when this need for *some* regulation results in it being applied in areas where it's just not appropriate. Like the Great Firewall of China, which I hear has extended to Australia lately, thanks to yet more fundamentalists somehow getting elected (it's so hard to feel sorry for a nation once they've voted these people in).
It's the same issue I have with DPI actually. Once the infrastructure is set up, no matter that it's only for the purpose of targeted advertising. It'll be abused for other things, like tiered services and censorship.
by darpoke
...should the government be allowed control over the primary means by which the general populace can monitor and judge the effectiveness of the government?
I rather think "no".
That's kinda the way Sony got the Beatles copyrights from Whacko Jacko iirc...
There should be some independent control in place though, if there isn't already. Irresponsible reportage can result in people not scrutinising every word to mistake opinion for fact. The tone of an article can easily become at least mildly partisan and when it does, the article is effectively propaganda.
by darpoke
that the fact that all radio content is spoken by an individual, it's far easier to remember that it may not be impartial.
But otherwise in general I refer you to my comment above re:newspapers - which was, in brief, "no - but someone should"
by tonythetiger
by darpoke
a rather combative tone in many of your previous posts so I hold little hope that this will provoke anything but antagonism. Nevertheless I will say this.
You appear to be under the belief that regulation, government or otherwise, is unrestricted and across the board. This simply isn't the case.
Companies such as Microsoft are treated differently because they have achieved monopoly status in one or more market. This changes the rules and makes them liable to adhere to a different set of standards for acceptable behaviour.
The ability of CEOs to set their own pay is, as Ernest is saying, a highly specific and unconventional scenario in business - I certainly would have no success in demanding that I make 4 times what I currently earn on an arbitrary whim.
This qualifies it as a situation where special conditions could, and, indeed, ought to be applied. The current economic climate owes much to the avarice and irresponsibility of people in just such positions.
It is certainly not a step towards a Central Planning Authority to expect that regulations should prevent greedy individuals from robbing shareholders and destroying hundreds or thousands of jobs, which appears to be what you are supporting.
by darpoke
Just to stay on topic of food here - I'll grant that the practices Ernest described as taking place in AU schools is rather extreme. But.
To state that what these children eat is none of anyone else's business is shortsighted. You seem to live in some kind of airy-fairy world where no-one makes any demands of others and everything is abundant. Why can't these rulemakers just leave us all alone? How unfair, right?
We live in a world of scarce resources, however. Scarcity of space, scarcity of infrastructure, scarcity of public money. The whole point of laws, policies, practices (let's call them rules) is to enable a large body of people, such as a nation, to live together fairly and in such a way that no-one in particular is suffering much more than anyone else. Causing distress - or to put it another way creating victims - is punished by the legal system to avoid perturbing said balance. Hence this structure of incentives and deterrents is a means of maintaining social homeostasis.
Part of this framework, here in the UK (and I believe similarly in Australia), are publicly-funded healthcare and education systems. If we do something as simple as ignore what children are eating on a daily basis, we open the door to ramifications that ripple throughout society. A poor diet can impact their ability to concentrate (malnutrition causes this in many third world countries every day, for those privileged enough to receive education), reducing the effectiveness of their tuition. Over time, a poor diet will result in health problems, which will require more public money to treat and correct. Not to mention the discomfort suffered by the children themselves at poor health that they didn't realise was an outcome of poor diet. That's quite a large number of victims, caused by acknowledging some spurious 'freedoms'.
The fallacy in this particular case is that it's fine to eat whatever you want. The unavoidable fact is that, no, it's not the case. Biologically some foods are more nutritious and healthy, and others cause unwanted detriment to a person's health over time. This is not up for debate, although which foods fall into which camp might be. Given that there are consequences to the act of eating vicariously, permitting it on a large scale invites a large number of people to suffer for the actions of others. I don't support that.
It's not fun to tell people what to do, and humans naturally dislike being told to obey any rules. I'm not a fan of speed limits when I know I'm in control of my vehicle. But that's not the point.
For you to expect to have a life unconstrained by the needs of others is to fail to realise all the times when you have benefited by the restraint of others. You're still alive today because speed limits on public roads meant people couldn't do 100mph on a residential road, no matter that they felt competent to handle the speed.
Your idea of a 'non-marxist' society where no rules constrain anyone is a society where no freedoms exist at all. You don't have any space to yourself, because to do so is to prevent others from using that space if they wish. That means no privacy in your home, no home period. Just an area you may use if no-one's there first. And until someone else arrives. Or perhaps you wish to fight for it?
The central facts of human life on this planet are:
(i) resources are finite.
(ii) space is finite.
(iii) each person would like a certain amount of resources
(iv) each person would like a certain amount of space
(v) the amount of space and resources cumulatively desired by all people globally exceeds the amount available on the Earth.
Given this, we all need to agree to have less space and use less resources than we would ideally like in order to avoid conflict. When anyone fails to do this they are attacking the basic tenets on which our society is based. There's no liberty to be gained by that.
by tonythetiger
[i]Given this, we all need to agree to have less space and use less resources than we would ideally like in order to avoid conflict.[/i]
I have earned what I have earned, and will use the space and the resources I can buy with what I have earned. If you wish to alter that, there is going to be conflict, there IS no avoiding it. The weak and stupid will defer to the strong and smart. The law of the jungle ultimately trumps all others.
by dwdino
What tool or event can be implemented to promote the return?
Must we improve gradually like the decline of the last 30 years?
Of what you regard as long destruction, I have all the long while been constructing.
I am an irreducible atom and entirely necessary to the whole for it to be called whole. And, you?
by tonythetiger
is a fable. They are answerable to the shareholders, and indirectly, to the consumers. If they are "ripping off" the shareholders, there are legal remedies.
[i]Bonuses etc can be set in relation to performance. The best way would be to set a CEO wage as a percentage of post tax income, you may have the percentage vary with the company size a little to balance things out for the smaller companies.[/i]
"Performance" doesn't only mean profit. It could also mean mitigating losses, or managing resources to set up future profits, or maybe something else I haven't thought of.
[i]But say you set the CEO salary of big business to 3% of post tax income. The business makes a profit of 100 million dollars and he gets three million, but if it makes a loss he gets zip. This would encourage the CEO to perform better and to notify quicker of adverse trading situations. At present we see many cases where the CEO gets paid millions while the companies make losses and go bust.[/i]
You can certainly do that on a company that YOU own!
by darpoke
What you're saying is you are entitled to what you've earned or something of equal value.
What I'm saying is when people act in a manner that effectively has an associated cost, and that cost is borne by society, we are essentially paying for their actions.
Ultimately I don't think that this is ok. Do we disagree here?
As I see it what you don't want is for what you've earned to be taken away from you, and I feel that by abusing their health through poor diet, others can do this.
by tonythetiger
from the text...
[i]When anyone fails to do this[/i][u] (use less space and resources than we would ideally like)[/u][i] they are attacking the basic tenets on which our society is based.[/i] (underlined text added)
... that you were indicating that people who had already earned had some duty to use less of what they earned in order to provide for those who hadn't earned. Perhaps I misunderstood.
Personally, I don't want much... I'm a pretty spartan fellow who doesn't value "things" to a great extent (Had I wanted, I could have HAD a great deal more, but I CHOSE to use a substantial fraction of my acquired wealth to help those who were trying, but struggling, to help themselves.), but what (little) I DO buy and use with what's left, I intend to defend my right to have and to use vigorously.
by darpoke
not trying to be deliberately obtuse (no need when it comes so easily sometimes :-) ) - could you possibly clarify what you mean?
Or are you responding to my throwaway comment re: newspapers? We could continue in the thread above if so.
by darpoke
thank goodness it's friday.
I think we're of a like mind, I'm pretty easily pleased and the things that I enjoy most are cheap or free. Apart from the tech toys of course. But that's another matter.
I wasn't commenting on a sense of entitlement, though I do have feelings about that, or on earnings either.
What I was driving at is that the actions of a group of people exercising their personal freedom to eat what they want, come at a very real cost, in terms of additional healthcare, that is borne by society in general. Your tax dollars and my tax pounds sterling. Every monetary unit in whatever currency that is spent on stomach stapling and gastric bypass is one more monetary unit that won't be spent on education, or roadbuilding, or broadband infrastructure or any of the things that I consider important.
I wouldn't for a second deny these people the healthcare they need - I'd rather live in a country where people pay for others who need it than one where people are left to die. There are both these types of country in the world and there is a general exodus of people from countries of the latter type to countries of the former.
But there comes a point I think when a little scruples need to be used by those drawing on such a system. That's all I'm saying.
by darpoke
I find myself unable to refrain from pointing out - atoms aren't actually irreducible. They got that name when such a condition was presumed, but were split a fair old while ago.
That said, I support your sentiment, and apologise for the picking of nits.
I've been very specific about applying it to situations where they can, or do so in collusion. there are two ways of this happening that I know of, and have seen.
In both cases the matter is technically put to the shareholders and voted on, but they get no opportunity to say nay or deal with it in advance, the matter is put up after the event.
1. A private company goes public and the original owner keeps 51% of the voting shares and stays on as Chairman of the board and CEO, he can, and often sets his own salary and has the votes at the AGM to approve it by himself.
2. A company where the CEO salary is set by the board, and the board remuneration is set by the CEO. The CEO and board decide what they get and just put it to the shareholders, after the fact. usually shoved through with a lot of other routine stuff such as - Let's pass the financial report as is.
I'm sure there are a few others that can occur too.
...................
Another aspect is the CEO who knows the company is in trouble but delays reporting it as his high salary gets cut as soon as he does. The result is he walks away with a big bank account while most of the workers get cut on their entitlements. In such cases the CEO should be put in prison and the money shortfall for staff entitlements comes from his bank account to the maximum amount of two years salary.
by darpoke
a few asocial elements aside, I think everyone in the world would agree 'betterment' is probably a good idea.
Everyone in the world also has their own idea of what that means.
the kids have healthy lunches, then let them provide the said healthy lunches in a suitable range of choices each day. It's one thing to disagree with food choices, it's another to take it away and make the child go hungry or to deny them the days schooling because they object to the lunch.
On another aspect, we have an odd situation at the moment in regards to food here - if you want fresh healthy food, you have to pay more (sometimes up to double) for that than the less healthy processed stuff. 500 gm of fresh fruit is double that of 500 gm of tinned fruit. Now that's not a problem for some, but for the unemployed (whose money has NOT gone up while inflation has pushed everything else up) it makes the difference between having enough food to eat during the week.
It wouldn't be so bad with the food issue if the government took the same approach to the rest of the inputs for the health system. This is really a case of hitting those who can't hit back.
More misuse of health services is done by people who abuse substances other than normal food. The cost of alcoholics and drunk drivers alone is horrendous - the annual charge of these to the health system could feed all the school kids for a couple of years, but the government still allows the sale of alcohol. Then there's the sale of tobacco and the cost of that to the health system , still allowed and legal. And we still have to look at the huge cost of illicit drug users.
If it was as simple as the best use of resources they'd refuse services to someone on their second overdose of illicit drugs.
This is more about telling others how to live their lives than the use of resources.
by darpoke
the situation as you describe it is far more extreme than I would personally advocate. I also agree that motivations are rarely simple or transparent in politics. Very likely this form of meddling is not appropriate or helpful, and other, more productive actions should have been proposed.
I would personally group alcohol with food rather than tobacco, since the consensus on tobacco is far different. I doubt even the most seasoned smoker (pun intended) would claim that it's ever actually good for you, even if they'd debate how much direct harm it causes. And these ill effects are common to all people - which is how secondary smoke has come to be condemned as antisocial in many countries today.
Alcohol however may in fact be beneficial in small doses, or at least benign. Much like foods that aren't good for you, it's very easy to overdo it, and depends a lot on an individual's constitution and metabolism. Blanket rules are far more applicable to tobacco than to alcohol, in my experience.
As for the users of illicit drugs, the effects these people have on healthcare use are clearly negative and self-inflicted - but the government have already taken a stand of sorts by declaring such substances illegal to abuse in the first place. I don't think however that grouping all drugs into the class 'illegal', or even into several bands of varying illegality, is quite as productive or appropriate as more right-wing individuals might. But that's surely fuel for another discussion.
You're okay.
The lexicographer, according to Johnson, by means of Boswell, is a "harmless drudge". I know, for I am that, also.
Thank you.
that's why I used the term 'substance abuse' and spoke of alcoholics and drunk drivers instead of the use of alcohol. I agree, in moderation, alcohol is NOT a problem. But abuse of it is. The people who abuse it and then cause trouble are a different situation. Especially when they drive a car and put a number of people into intensive care units.
Drug abuse, illicit or otherwise is just as bad. Many people who abuse drugs use up an inordinate amount of health care resources with ambulances and ICU units when they OD, and the long term treatment. Then most go out and do it again, and again, and keep doing it until the day the ambulance is too late.
Many years ago, before we had Medicare and you had to pay for all health services, there were government supported emergency services and the like. People brought into hospital for an OD were got out of danger and committed to a rehab unit where they went through supervised forced withdrawal, by law. Even though there was a level of recidivism (they went back to using the drugs) the rate of people staying free was much higher than any other rehab program that's been run since. Seems many did NOT like the prospect of going through forced cold turkey again. Very few turned up to go through cold turkey a third time.
Sort by Trending