Discussion Locked

Should IT pros be required to speak and write literately?

0 helpful
253 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Are your written and spoken communications regularly misunderstood? Do people frequently ask you to repeat and/or rephrase yourself?

Today, reading a couple of posts at the Tech Republic Discussion Center, I was confounded by the sheer volume of illiteracy. Do I expect eloquent discussion of every tiny nuance of IT topics? No. Of course not. But I do expect noun-verb agreement and attention to the their/there type of commonly misused words.

How can anyone expect others to treat their discussion, no matter how knowledgeable and relevant, seriously if they do not express their ideas in a concise, accurate way?

253 replies

by maecuff

This isnt a real formal forum. And sometimes, when your typing fast, you loose track of the correct speling, because your moore interested in getting you're point across.

And wouldn't this work a little better?:

Should IT pros be required to be literate when speaking or writing?

by tony hopkinson

Should professionals in the discipline of information technology be required to be literate.

Speaking or writing is defunct as it would be hard to correctly apply literate to any other action.

Don't know what all this fascination with words is about anyway, it's only a group of sequentially arranged bits that make up an address anyway.
LOL

by rof

I hardly think "speaking or writing" is defunct. Do you do neither? Perhaps you mean, "the phrase 'speaking or writing' is redundant"? Or tautological?

by tony hopkinson

to six decimal places. No that's precision. Accurate is close to the estimate. The range on the estimate is an indicator of precision of course.
We talk to real people, we should talk in their language, I was going to take the urine out of you as I didn't think literately was a word. Fortunately I checked, and it is , so I'll just take a wild stab at the meaning. Anal springs to mind.

I hope yule bare this in mined from now on.
LOL

by maxwell edison

.
Required?

Who will administer the test?

What will be the passing grade?

Will this apply to everyone in the world equally?

Will everyone be required to meet the requirements in English, or will multilingual requirements be necessary?

And if they fail, will they be denied a job, or perhaps they will simply be executed?

Give us some of the details, so we can consider the best way to go.

(I had to edit my message to correct a mistake. I wouldn't want to be executed over a silly sentence fragment.)

by maecuff

A woman from the North and a woman from the South are at a dinner party. The woman from the South turns to the woman from the North and says "So, where are y'all from?" The woman from the North says, "We are from a place where we don't end our sentences with a preposition." The woman from the South says, "Okay. So, where y'all from, bitch?"

by maxwell edison

.
....a Winston Churchill story.

From now on, ending a sentence with a preposition is something up with which I will not put.

- Winston Churchill

by mjd420nova

Here i California we are battling against those
who would allow illegal aleins to get drivers licences. I'm all for that, line 'em up, sign them up, photograph and finger print them. But
they just want the ID, and not with their name
on it. This has to be controlled. What with
multiligual voting ballots and translators at
licence examinations, what has happened to our
homeland??? IT people should definately be well
schooled, and in ENGLISH. A simple high school
grammar test would suffice for a minimum
guideline. If other countries can land contracts to provide services to customers in
the US then those here should also meet a set
minimum of comprehension.

by too old for it

Max, I have to agree with you, all the while getting a chuckle from your post.

While I get deeply into spelling, syntax, sin taxes, and subject-verb agreement while I am writing professionally, not so in here.

I do posess an honorary degree in adequacy from some freebie diploma mill or the other. But from it I hold the opinion that in writing (as well as IT) most days you just need to be adequate.

by beads

All International pilots are required to write and speak English. I really have no idea who enforces these rules but that I do know for a fact.

Personally, writting is something that comes fairly difficult - since I don't enjoy weaving prose.

I will say though, Max. You humble me in comparison when it comes to writting.

- beads

by jardinier

in a relatively recent discussion.

Perhaps someone will be good enough to locate that discussion so that we don't have to cover the same ground twice.

by charliespencer

I think it gets brought up regularly every month, like my cat's worm medicine.

I hope many of our fellow members exercise better writing and speaking skills outside this site than they show here.

by s_k_k

You are completely right to me xalorous. I strongly believe that IT guys (also) should be able to talk and write clearly without errors.

Would we not want to do a job to the best of our capability? Why can't that be put into writing as well?

I have seen people misspell even easy words. For instance they write their's as there's; would have as would of; yours as your's etc.

I think if we consciously write even if we are writing something with utmost focus and attention we can still get away making very little mistakes.

I am not saying to write like the author of oxford dictionary. But we can try to (use dictionary.com for instance) keep the mistakes to little level which makes others from wasting their valuable brain(like CPU) time in 'trying to understand the real meaning' process and saves everybody's time.

Btw, Did I forget to mention that it also makes you to look like a real pro and gets your name in to their contact lists?

by jardinier

[Joined TR May, 2005] you should not expect anything at all. This is the way we "talk" and you can like it or lump it.

The discussion forums are not intended to be training for a post-graduate degree in the "correct usage of the English language."

I take particular care with my own posts because writing (journalism) happens to be my primary vocation. In fact I use these forums to refine my writing style.

Many of the regular contributors to the discussions have excellent writing styles, which is nice, but is of secondary importance to the primary reasons we are here: to exchange information, ideas and viewpoints, and have a bit of fun in the process.

I think I can speak for most of the regulars in saying that we don't give a ***** ***** about typos and grammatical faux pas. In fact they are frequently a source of merriment.

And no, we don't have a problem with communicating our ideas.

May I suggest that you lighten up, loosen your tie and undo your top shirt button, and participate in the fun which is liberally disseminated amongst the serious comments.

by jaqui

if they really irritate us we'll sick oz on them. ;)
(since hunting them down and ripping the butt plug out to stop anal retention would be illegal )

by sentineldot88

It is always expected for an individual to write and speak correctly whether IT or non-IT, if and only if the situation calls for it. Dis is the thing i lyk bout forums, i just type-in whatever pops out of my mind and I dont xpect pipol to take my ideas on this post seriously. And i don't have to bother bout clicking on spell check. Tho, i stil encourage corect grammar with a little bit of abbreviation on side, just to save "tym" in typing. The main thing is that i have express my ideas, isnt it that the main objective of internet is information sharing. ;)

But i do expect from articles and stuff to contain the main ingredients of technical writing. This i s the situation im talking about.

by Member 25348569

I gave up at the second sentence and, if I recognise your name, will not even bother to read any other posts that you might make.

You might "express your ideas" but I'll not bother to find out what they might be and any merit that they might have will be lost.

by xalorous

Your writing style is concise and to-the-point. I have no problem with people using informal style. Certain words (their/there, affect/effect, to/too/two) require a bit more attention when they are used. A split second to ask yourself, "Did I use the right one?" is all it takes to be clear.

Yes, I understand this is an informal forum. Yes, I understand we all make typos. Yes, I probably overreacted.

Two things will happen here. Those who frequently litter their posts with misused and/or misspelled words will come to be known as ignorant and illiterate. And I will be a silent grammar-judge.

by maxwell edison

.
. . .but it only resulted in flame sessions, hard feelings, and probably made me look like the idiot.

As it turns out, he's one of the nicest and smartest guys around here.

by tony hopkinson

most of your countrymen would fail, would they not after all you can't even spell, colour.
LOL
As an outsider looking in I've never seen language as the thing that united you as a country, I always though it was a common ideal, the 'american dream'.
The only criteria of comprehension an immigrant or an out-sourced worker needs to meet is that of their employer surely, anything else would be an unwarranted intrusion by the legislature into business and therefore be communist, so welcome to the party.
Tee Hee.

by jardinier

Nothing has happened to your homeland.

America always was a multicultural nation. It has simply become more so.

Can you speak Commanche, Apache, Sioux ?

by jdmercha

What are you trying to say?
What languages are you considering?
In what environment should it be required?
To what standards are we to be held?
How would different cultures be required to communicate?

by xalorous

I was simply trying to say that if you want more people to understand you and treat your comments seriously, you need to use language that is clear, concise and correct for the information you are trying to convey.

No matter what language, you should be clear, concise and correct with your communication.

In any environment where you want to be understood.

The only standard is whether you are understood.

As far as I can tell, we're involved in a single culture within this forum.

/sarcasm

Different cultures would probably require protocols in order to understand each other. They'd probably start with handshaking or some such authentication, then each side would send their information to a translator. The translators would then pass the information between each other in a common language. This would then be translated to the destination in their own language. Repeat until finished.

/sarcasm off

by rof

As a bit of an English pedant, I agree completely. If someone is reasonably literate and a good speller, nothing is more off-putting than having to parse a semi-incoherent, badly spelt document. This can have very negative effects: when I am browsing email feeds from an employment agency, I find myself being unfairly and illogically put off those jobs where the description is barely English, even though I know they are written by a recruitment hack.

One thought does occur to me - if some of these seriously misspelt posts are from programmers who are unable consistently to spell language elements and variable names, don't they get fed up, trying to find and correct the syntax errors they must get? Or is Microsoft's Intellisense to blame for increasing illiteracy?

by cactus pete

"...badly spelt document."
...poorly spelled document.

"This can have very negative effects: when I am browsing..."
This can have very negative effects; when I am browsing...

"...seriously misspelt posts..."
...seriously misspelled posts...

To answer the posed question - I dunno, whadya think yerself?

(References are from personal American English knowledge)

by tmbrwlf

"(References are from personal American English knowledge)"

It might be worth while to note the differences between English and American. Those raised on the Queen's English (with demonstrable literacy) are often appalled at Americanisms. Color versus Colour; traveled versus travelled; misspelled versus misspelt ... (in the UK Misspelled is also acceptable.)

I too find it tiresome wading through nonsensical passages of text where words are misspelled (!!) or are used out of context, tenses are misused, or punctuation is incorrect. However, I'm not a leading expert on English. Nor are the majority of the population. In fact most people aren't even native English speakers.

With respect to requiring any professional (IT or otherwise) to be literate: Yes I believe it should be a requirement. It shocks me to think that people with degrees are unable to communicate coherently in the written or spoken medium. One should realise (Am. realize) that there are differences in "English" depending on which country one hails from. No wonder non-native anglophones have such a difficult time.

by tmbrwlf

"(References are from personal American English knowledge)"

It might be worth while to note the differences between English and American. Those raised on the Queen's English (with demonstrable literacy) are often appalled at Americanisms. Color versus Colour; traveled versus travelled; misspelled versus misspelt ... (in the UK Misspelled is also acceptable.)

I too find it tiresome wading through nonsensical passages of text where words are misspelled (!!) or are used out of context, tenses are misused, or punctuation is incorrect. However, I'm not a leading expert on English. Nor are the majority of the population. In fact most people aren't even native English speakers.

With respect to requiring any professional (IT or otherwise) to be literate: Yes I believe it should be a requirement. It shocks me to think that people with degrees are unable to communicate coherently in the written or spoken medium. One should realise (Am. realize) that there are differences in "English" depending on which country one hails from. No wonder non-native anglophones have such a difficult time.

by charliespencer

You addressed the issue with one sentence buried in the middle of a political rant. I'm not pro or con on the immigrant license issue, but based on your post, you wouldn't pass your own test.

By the way, the word "homeland", selected by our president because of the strong emotional weight it carries, was also used by other enlightened regimes like Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. What was wrong with "Domestic Secutity"?

by maxwell edison

.
Actually, you are mistaken in suggesting that President Bush came up with that name.

It was actually Senator Joseph Lieberman (D-Conn.) who introduced the "Department of National Homeland Security Act" to the Senate in October 2001. And President Bush was initially opposed to it. But anything "homeland" originated with that bill.

By the way, what made you think that, "..... the word 'homeland' (was) selected by our president because of the strong emotional weight it carries"? ..... (Or was that something you just decided to make up?)

by too old for it

I swear, President (for life) Roger Mugabe can bury a thousand of his fellow citizens alive in a pit on a weekly basis and get more respect in here than President Bush.

by maecuff

If you had a stick and found yourself near a sleeping bear, you wouldn't be able to help yourself, would you?

by too old for it

... are riding the train into town, and Annabelle asks Gertrude if she does goes itno town often.

The Gertrude replies, "Why yes. I go into the fish market once a week to get scrod."

Annabelle pauses for a minute, and remarks, "I never knew that *that* was the past perfect tense!"

by cactus pete

Badly is bad. Not a personal style choice.

A colon has a different purpose than a semicolon.

Spelt... Well, I disclaimed my American English perspective. Which illustrates a point - this is not a one-country forum.

Neither rot nor you have a location specified. So in that respect, yes, I'm ignorant. However, if you want to express yourself in a manner such that no one cringes at the sight of your text, you will have to be fully NOT ignorant of each and every possible viewer. This isn't really likely, is it?

OH!! I almost forgot:

"...unable consistently to spell ..."
...unable to consistently spell... OR
...consistently unable to spell...

So, my point... If you're going to bash others for their perceived shortcomings, leave none of your own.

by maxwell edison

.
Spelt: Subspecies (Triticum aestivum spelta) of wheat that has lax spikes and spikelets containing two light-red kernels.

http://www.britannica.com/ebc/article-9379279?query=spelt&ct=

----------

Main Entry: spelt
Pronunciation: 'spelt
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Old English, from Late Latin spelta, of Germanic origin; perhaps akin to Middle High German spelte split piece of wood, Old High German spaltan to split -- more at SPLIT

2. a wheat (Triticum aestivum spelta) with lax spikes and spikelets containing two light red kernels.

----------

Spelt- What is it?

www.spelt.com

----------

Spelt's "nutty" flavor has long been popular in Europe.

(Gee, no kidding!)

----------

Did you know that people in Ohio use spelt more than people in other states? Yes, really!

----------

I hope I spelt spelt correctly. I'd hate to be executed over a misspelt word!

by cactus pete

We would all like to be perfect. We all know better. Yes, sometimes it hurts to read a post. Some people just aren't good at spelling.

Personally, I'm not great at spelling in the typed form. But I make the effort. Take, for instance, the word "spelling". For some reason, when I type it, the screen somehow shows "speeling" instead. Doubled letters get me...

I also don't read very well. So the poorly written posts are particularly hard to read. But the extravagant sentence can be even more difficult.

My preference? Adequacy.

I fully expect to be more intelligent than some posters here. I fully expect to be less so than others. Sometimes this reveals itself in grammar (either way) and sometimes in my ability to solve a problem (either way). But we're all here to help others in our industry, so politely offer to help where you think it's needed, or ignore them.

I feel your pain, but you need to let it go or go get some more coffee. I'm going to get some more coffee.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "....this reveals itself in grammar."

I'd rather read an error-laden message from someone who is reasonably intelligent, than a message that some dweeb wrote in a lame attempt to make himself sound and look intelligent. (I could name some names, but I'll refrain.)

Mae, where's that stick?

by cactus pete

The economics degree is showing...

I made an assumption that everyone knew I'd be referring to intelligence being multifaceted. Some people have genius in spelling, while others have genius in sports, and still others have genius in music or painting, etc.

So, I might be a monster at math but a goon with grammar. (Come to think of it, I might know someone like that.)

By the way, thanks for not mentioning the typo...

If you were to name a name, would it be frank?

by dc guy

The word "literately" violates your own premise by being bad English! For shame! It means, "in a manner consistent with the ability to read and write." By definition, if one can write, one writes literately.

See how easy it is to make a mistake and how there's always a wise guy out there ready to pounce on it?

But yes, IT pros should be required to COMMUNICATE EFFECTIVELY. This isn't just about spelling and grammar, it's about being able to get your ideas across. About being concise, organized, accurate, consistent. About actually knowing what you want to say before you start talking or writing.

I've seen plenty of IT requirements, meeting notes, test results, and user manuals that contained none of the errors that are under discussion here, but nonetheless were worthless because A. they were difficult to understand, or B. they were too wordy and no one had the patience to read them.

If someone has a serious problem with basic grade-school speaking or writing skills, to the point that they have trouble expressing themselves and being understood, then of course they should take a class in remedial English or ESL as the case may be. But most people just need some training in business communication or specifically in business writing. Those classes are available everywhere. I've taught dozens of them myself on my lunch hour. And I also take them because I'm all in favor of "continuous improvement."

As for not having to write perfectly here, of course you're right. But if a post is so full of errors that it slows me down and makes me wonder what I'm reading, I'll probably skip it and use my time to better advantage on the next post.

BTW, the thing about not ending a sentence with a preposition is a myth IN ENGLISH. Teachers who were drilled to death in Latin 150 years ago used to say that because in Latin it really is wrong and they assumed the rules for all languages were the same. I don't have a copy of Strunk & White handy but I seem to remember even them admitting that it's not incorrect as long as the MEANING OF THE SENTENCE is clear. (S&W is a joke anyway; it hasn't had a serious edit since the 1950s and most of it was written in 1919. There are far better and more up-to-date style manuals.)

And the disappointed little girl said, "Mommy, what did you bring that book I didn't want to be read to out of up for?"

by cactus pete

The one time I dangle the bait in front of you... I debated for all of about 10 seconds whether to capitalize Frank... Too obtuse? Or just too lame?

by m_a_r_k

The term "IT pros" covers a huge territory. Everything from code rats who have their head buried in their computer monitor all day to sales people and executives who spend their entire day meeting with people and writing reports. At a minimum, everyone needs to be able to at least spell correctly and write phrases that make sense. his bare minimum would apply to s/w developers who comment their code. They even need to know how to spell to come up with meaningful variable names. So to answer your question, somewhere around a 10th-grade writing ability would be a miniumum for an IT pro. The more people-interfacing you do (and the higher level of people with whom you interface), the more you need to speak and write eloquently.

by ram mohan

It's at the core of every inter-personal (or even impersonal) interaction in your career as an IT pro - communicating effectively.

IT professionals (and all professionals) have a responsibility to provide clear and concise information to their audience - and make sure that it is free of jargon.

The question is almost rhetorical.

by tony hopkinson

is judged by your audience, not by whether you've used a semi-colon correctly.
The word literately for instance could easily be considered jargon , lets face it you are more likely to see it on a scrabble board than in a company document.
Using it would get you a slap round the head from the technical authors I work with, they are running a plain english campaign

by director of resource management

I am dumbfounded by the illiteracy I find common in technical discussion threads. What amazes me is the fact that the majority of people in the technology sector are degreed individuals, but write worse than high school students, or at least when posting to these public forums. I manage a mix of programmers, analysts and computer technicians. Regardless of an individual's technical skill and knowledge, I base a good part of his or her annual performance review on written and spoken communications abilities.

by tony hopkinson

thought the english language was far too ambiguous for much of that.

Personally I'm always wary of people who spend a lot of time telling me how well they do their job, makes me wonder if they've got enough work.

Strange you would probably consider my language skills inadequate, and yet in one job I saved the company ?50,000 in one year with the skills they were paying me to have. Are you seriously telling me that you would have reduced my performance related pay, because of a spelling mistake in an email ?

by xalorous

As a manager, you need to be able to manage your people. Therefore both sides need to communicate effectively. Therefore one's ability to communicate effectively directly affects his ability to accomplish his assigned tasks. Therefore his ability to communicate effectively should be a prime factor in determining pay.

Ok, so that was a wordy way of saying that someone can't do their job if they can't understand what they've been told to do. So, effective communication is very important to consider when reviewing performance.

Also, please note that occasional typos are not necessarily a hindrance to clear communication.

by maxwell edison

.
For argument's sake, I'll agree with you. But I didn't challenge that assertion. I only pointed out that the word "homeland", used in this context, did not originate from within the White House, and especially for the reasons that guy stated, but rather from the Senate bill as I described. Would you care to challenge that? If not, what's the point you're trying to make, and why are you trying to make it?

by hal 9000

I started to make up a little book of all the Jargon that we in IT use so that people could understand me when I try to tell them something technical. When I stopped and looked at the page count it was 165 A4 pages and not in big print either, granted I was up to the S's by then but I also realised that

1 I would be wasting a lot of paper handing out printed copies.

2 No one was going to actually attempt to read it anyway so I was wasting my time.

As for grammar anyone who uses Basic will never be able to type in or write correctly in the accepted English {whatever that is} as they have already forced themselves to use a different set of punctuating and the like. The fact that Basic doesn't even use actual English doesn't help either.

So what would you suggest currently the Spell Checkers and Grammar Checkers are not much chop so what would you like someone capable of writing a nice clean letter or punch in the code cleanly and quickly?

Actually if you think that we are bad you should see what some upper Managment come out with without their secretaries to translate for us we are all lost if they hand us a hand written note for something. ;)

Col

by gsquared

The amazing part, to me, about IT pros writing in a less-than-literate fashion, is that these are the same people who understand that code has to be exact or it won't work.

You can't expect the following to work in VB:

Computer, post a message thingamaboby that saying sumtheng a bout errormessage

What happens when you leave out necessary structure in an XML file?

What would happen if you sent a network packet with missing bits from the IP address?

Misspell a UNC or URL and see how far it gets you.

But, these same people, perfectly happy to follow these esoteric and often extremely strict rules, are often quite happy to write something like:

u go to party? me 2. will be gr8

(Okay, I'm using a somewhat extreme example, but the point is still valid.)

English grammar is slightly more complex than most computer languages. It is also more flexible, can communicate things no computer language can and is significanly less strict about its structure. BUT, it does have standards. Writing a post about how bad it is that Microsoft breaks the Web standards, and using poor grammar in that post, is blatant hypocrisy.

So, if we IT professionals expect others to follow IT standards, if we want computers to communicate with each other, we need to follow set standards in our communication protocols.

Proper grammar and spelling are easy standards to comply with.

by too old for it

... isusually a March or April affectation, but if there is adequate wind this weekend, I may just have a go at it.

by tony hopkinson

If you are being clear and concise but I have to get a dictionary out, or do a year long course to understand what you have communicated, it would hardly be described as effective.
If you don't target your audience the only person you've communicated effectively with is yourself.
If that means going round the houses, deviating from exact nomenclature then so be it. I'd rather be understood by those who I need to understand than by those who already do understand.

by tony hopkinson

about telling people what to do, it's about providing things to do and an environment in which they can be done.
Managers's are no more capable of setting their requirements in stone than customers are.

Besides the point are you agreeing with the poster that a saving of 50k a year should be of less importance than clear and concide emails when judging someone's performance ?

by Member 25348569

at the time then you had to beat us. Still, we have cold beer in our pubs now. All you have to do is to start serving real beer in yours - cold or not - and we'll both be OK.

I reckon that after Waterloo we should have shipped Wellington and the British Army across the Atlantic, deployed the Fleet and kicked the crap out of you but it had all been settled by then.

Sorry about the White House. You rebuilt it, though, so no real harm done.

:D

by ozi eagle

The amount of lousy spelling and grammar that exists out there in general, I find appalling.
If you used the " as long as we get our meaning across its OK" attitude to software then you would wind up with a worse mess than M$ has made. The same with language, it is a code that we use to process information. If the code is wrong we can't process it correctly.
I often wonder what goes on in someone's head when their language is all over the place.
Yes I concede that typos happen, but they are obviously typos, space in the wrong place, double letters etc., however, words that may have some correlation to the phonetics of what is trying to be expressed may for very difficult interpretation, and as another post has stated, I don't waste my time on them.

On the other hand, according to neurolinguistic programming, none of us can really understand anyone else correctly, since we all assigne a different meaning to a word, depending on our life's experience. eg. RICH, to someone on $10K pa $25k would be RICH. To someone on $25k pa then $50k would be RICH. I have come to conclude that RICH means anyone with more than I have.

by maxwell edison

.
Yea, we rebuilt the White House as good as new -- even better. And if not for that, Dolly Madison would have never saved the portrait of George Washington which, undoubtedly, led to her inventing those Dolly Madison cakes and pastries.

And speaking of beer, it'd probably be a real hoot to tip a few with you -- cold or otherwise. I can just imagine the turns the conversation would take after just a few.