Discussion Locked

Should IT pros be required to speak and write literately?

0 helpful
253 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

253 replies

by johntd

"grammar incorrect posts" --?!!! how about "grammatically" incorrect posts -- where are YOU from?

And let's not even get into the "grotesque" part.

by deckmonkey

First you say you disagree with me and then go on to agree with pretty much everything I've said, in a roundabout way. So which is it? No one is bothered whether or not a term is 'new' because something that is old hat to you probably isn't to a non-technical person. Therefore, if you use it, you need to explain it at least once so that when you next use it your audience isn't left wondering "What the hell is an XYZ?". This is accepted practice in writing scientific papers and these are the most exacting presentation standards you'll find anywhere. The technical professions are too used to trumping up their own self-importance by raising a barrier of incomprehensible rubbish designed to confuse those not in the technical professions in an effort to make itself look better and feel important. News flash: It makes us look stupid and become less important because increasingly, if someone can't understand their techies, they'll go elsewhere and you will be marginalised. The same applies to those who cannot write or speak coherently.

Whilst your idea of a blog on Programming Aesthetics is interesting, it is entirely off topic since the aesthetics of your programming in terms of code design, UI design, reusability etc, whilst thoroughly important for good programming, are completely irrelevant in terms of communicating with the wider world in an effective manner.

by deckmonkey

Seeing as they will be the people who pay your salary and if they can't understand you then why should they pay you? You have just demonstrated the classic arrogance of the techie.

by merrua

Literacy is important for documentation of processes and programms, so it is needed for IT professionals.

If you need to be able to record and document your decisions and work then a certain level of the companys main language should be part of the job description.

The problem on the web however,
is that spelling and grammar changes from country to country. Just because a word doesnt seem to make sense, or the grammar seems off from american-english, doesnt mean it doesnt make sense in hibro-english, british-english, canadian-english, australian or new zealand-english.

Sidewalk means nothing to me and sheila's mightnt mean anthing to a canadan.

by hp-dledna

IT is a sided street____for 15 years was on the worker BEE side of the house and when your worried which direction the bits are flowing and how fast they are getting to point A and B, then your documentation is dedicated to the person deviating from the Process....

However, I used to be a 3 line email person, in mgmt its 3 paragraphs to start the conversation.

Currently I have been with Mgmt~and executive role for 3 years and its the MOST POLITICAL @#$% I have ever seen.

How well you post the problems, projects and potentials to you clients. Is extreemly important when in any of these situations . The last thing a CIO~CEO wants to do is understand someone elses email jargon.=== Each and everyone of the IT Pro's who are actually in "IT" (Worker BEE's and UP) should be really dig down and take a course, driven to the IT department...

It may be a slow class, and 98% of professionals who are willing to see the light, and work hard to ensure success, will find something positive with in any course you take. I guarenetee it will help!

Try it and you might notice!!!!!! good luck in your futures....

by mitch7

IT professionals can only do themselves a favour by speaking and writing grammatically, and paying particular attention to correct spelling and punctuation.
Precision and accuracy are essential in IT, and displaying them in routine communications not only avoids confusion but makes a favourable impression on recipients and chance beholders alike.
Life is simpler too, as there is only one standard to maintain.
In practical terms, it takes no more time to type or speak correctly than it does to do these things badly, so why not do it correctly at the outset?

by hal 9000

Maybe you are reflecting adversely on the Education system and nothing else. :)

If these people are unable to spell or use grammar when they enter the course what makes you think that they will be any better when they finish it?

The current crop of Word Processors are next to useless as I've lost count of the number of times that they have auto corrected something that I've typed wrong as they seem to think that they know better than the person using them. My favourite is always changing the word "the to Teh" and changing a persons name from Teh to The. Then they constantly insist on inserting the wrong words into the subject and it all goes to hell in a hand basket with no one being any the wiser.

With the Auto Correct turned off and on a short document it's an easy thing to fix but when you do a report 200 + pages long it's impossible to proof read the entire thing before you have to submit it for the customer who's paying for the report as they have inflicted such tight time schedules on you. I'm constantly going out doing inspections and the report is expected the next working day by E-Mail so I get there at 3.00 PM and spent 4 hours inspecting the damage or holes and then I've got to write a report for the next day delivery as the report is required immediately to fix the mess that has been made. But if the customers where willing to wait a few days and cover their losses along the way I could submit a far better looking report than what I normally do. :p

Real IT isn't about Information Technology but Instant Answers to problems.

Col ]:)

by giledwin

Speaking and writing well should be required in any discipline, not just IT. However, I think it?s because we have gotten so comfortable with email and IM that we take shortcuts in an effort to get our point across quickly. Being awful at writing or speaking well can also be attributed to the fact that we think faster than we can write ? or in this case type (on a good day I can manage 75 wpm). Here is another one for you ? MS Word, Word Perfect, etc, we depend so heavily on them that we are quickly losing, or not developing our grammar skills. In my organization there are quite a few department heads that couldn?t put a coherent sentence together if their lives dependent on it. I?m not the smartest SOB in the world, never claimed to be, but I have enough common sense to look over my transmission before clicking send, or in this case, post. IMHO.

BTW, I know my message will be critiqued, and I welcome it because I can learn something from each of you. Constructive criticism is good.

by cheesel

...about grammar and spellcheckers. I guess it is the Law of Unintended Consequences, eh? Why bother to learn spelling or grammar when the PC will correct it for you?

by nsim3008

I do believe excellent communication skills are needed for anyone working in a professional enviroment. IT professional work with individuals on all on all levels in a company. How you speak, write and basically communicate with an individual will become that individual's impression of you and your IT skills.

Being well learned is important, but I do think believe these boards are light-hearted communication vehicles. I would, however, like to see people take a second or two to briefly proof what they have written.

by tony hopkinson

is two minutes in prison.

Are you in charge then , perhaps I should watch my step, wouldn'nt want to miss anything vital.

Context is the cake, grammar and spelling are icing.

by too old for it

attending meetings on WebEx from the comfort of his home?

(The guy who is "Too Old For IT" sez as he makes some adjustments to a Pervasive.SQL.2000 box in rural P.R. China from the comfort of suburban Columbus, OH)

Tho I gotta admit, my manager here is pretty good. He takes all the meetings, keeps upper management off our backs, and signs our time sheets at the end of the week.

by tony hopkinson

My definition of accurate was the mathematical/scientific one. Its perfectly clear and those familiar with it would understand what I was saying. I'm not knocking you because you did not, nor for even leaping to the conclusion that I did not.

In order to communicate, the most imporant thing is not word choice, not sentence construction, nor the correct use of a colon, it's context.

Get the last one wrong and ....

by itgurl

English has been established as the "global language" (albeit unofficially), so it's not like we have much of a choice but to learn it (frankly, I would have loved to learn Spanish or French instead. lol). Still, it's still not our primary language, so naturally, most of us are not fluent. But we do try our best. =)

Besides, I've seen worse grammar and spelling from people who use English as their primary language - and they're not even bilinguals, at the very least. We, on the other hand, have our primary language, English as a secondary, plus a few other dialects to worry about.

by avi.arditi

I read some of the responses and the only thought and feelings that came up was sad and heartbreaking.
IT Proff? should know how to communicate, but you also must understand that when we communicate between each other that should be a second or third priority.
When communicating with your boss or clients you need to insure that you ?look? proff?. How many IT personal you know that look professional but are not?. They are the danger to our profession not the one that makes a spelling mistake or not a perfect speaker.
The type of work we do in many cases there is no time to think about the right way to communicate.
We don?t have any guidelines and on top of that IT Proff are misunderstood by management and co-workers.
It is US how try and break the barriers not our mangers or co-worker. I think with all the exams the amount of study the need to keep up to date the expectation for a quick respond or a quick answer will lead to weak verbal and written communication.

As long as an IT proff you understand that it is important to correctly use the tools of communication then you are on the right path.

Suggesting that IT is a field where idiots rule is offensive and you are selling us short to a community that all ready think that IT Proff are wired.

I will continue to communicate to the best of my ability and learn.

by rogerl

Hear Heere...
Well siad.
Dost thou expectith too muchith??
NO, I say, a thousand (100) times NO...
Can you here me nou...?

by surflover

the last 10 years or so I'll give you my 2 cents... Leadership is providing the enviroment for your team to be successful at accomplishing their jobs... No one in management is any more succesful than their team... It is my resposibility to make sure that EVERYONE on my staff (from the entry levels through the senior techs, managers, directors and VPs) has the tools, the time and the work environment to accomplish their work without impediments... and economics permitting, that I can create a work environment that is pleasant, and would attract additional talented people to want to join my team...

If that can not be said of my organization, I'm not doing my job.

by illilli

Communication is shared meaning. As long as everyone knows what you are talking about then that's all there really is to it.

I have to admit though that some of the posts I read sound like they were written by people from non-English speaking countries. I didn't think people from outside the United States were allowed to post in this English only forum. I think we should have some way to determine which people are second-language challenged, which people are poor typists, which people are in a hurry, which people are retarded, and which people didn't pay attention in the 7th grade when their boring English teacher with bad breath lauded over them with sentence diagraming candor!

by shtara42

To not be able to speak, read, and write fluently only makes the rest of the pros look like novices, besides the one who can't respond literately.
RMWilliams

by hal 9000

Speaking and writing! Many people can talk perfectly well and not have a problem and when something that they say isn't fully understood they can immediately expand upon what it was that they where talking about so they get the message across properly.

On the other hand a written report is so constraining that it's very hard to know what level to write to. When I construct a report should I expect the people who may read it to be literate in Technical Matters or just clerical staff who have no idea. If it's the latter the report becomes much longer and says far less.

Col

by absolutely

is sloppy character. When I see bad grammar and disconcern for misspelled words, I know I'm reading the output of a lazy mind.

by stargazerr

This was an international site. Everyone and anyone can come in and post stuff.

Not all of us come from countries where English is the main language. Considering that, I'll say that everyone's english is pretty good.

In my case, my english used to be absolutely briliant but now that I work in an office full of "lesser literate people" (to speak in your terms xalorous)...my english is slowly becoming...whats the word again?? oh yeah...HORRENDOUS .. (is that a word??) :)

My Point, in a nutshell ... WHO CARES IF YOU CAN GET YOUR POINT ACROSS?? ;)

by jim wyse

Surely, that is the whole point.

If the person in question, (i.e. the author), isn't fully literate, and makes spelling, grammatical and contextual mistakes, that makes the document much more prone to misinterpretation when read by others who are also not fully literate.

In such a complex, technical world such as ours, it is essential that we make our point clearly and concisely. Errors such as those listed above will tend to distract readers from the content, and will serve to undermine confidence in the validity of the article!

by stargazerr

Ok...I agree to that...

But does this mean that the people who are not 'Literate' enough should just stick to their own countries and not make a global opinion?? At least untill they 'Update' themselves??

How about double checking whether or not you have been misunderstood??

by jdmercha

I once worked in an office with 4 US born people who spoke only english.

We had two people from Viet Nam who spoke vietnameese, french and english They would often converse with each other in all three languages to make sure they understood each other.

We had two other people from India, who spoke hindi first and english second.

We had one person from The Dominican Republic who spoke spanish first and english second.

And we had one person from Italy, who spoke italian first and english second.

It was quite amusing sometimes listening to three peolpe converse in a language that was native to none of them.

by wellpaid

Literacy is truly of importance. But in written communications in a forum, lack of skill with a second language can be mis-construed as lack of knowledge or an inability to be articulate.

It is interesting and appropriate to categorize each post as to the value of the source, observing the short cuts an young (and often green) writer may include or the lack of plurals from many contriubutors whose first language is more efficient by using implied plurality. Or a seasoned thoughtful contributor where a lack of contractions idicates an unrushed reply; how about the angry person who hates his boss and vents using limited vocabulary often reserved for military personnel.

So can you really sort through what comments have value by the written communications skills? It is but one indicator of many along side content and context. Yes the world does give better service to blonds (and I am not one) though we may not like it!

by tony hopkinson

You are doing exactly what a leader who can manage should. With an attitude like that I'd work for you any day. You deserve a crack at me after all the assholes I've had to put up with looking over by shoulder and shouting at me when their plan went wrong.

You can tell a good manager from a bad one very easily, a good one, when they don't know the answer to a question from their superiors, consults with their people. A bad one guesses and then blames their team when it turns out not to be the case.

There is no I in Team as it were.

by etydings

If there is a lack of knowledge, understanding or concern for the language of our written and spoken communication, how can that person be trusted to know and explain the intricacies of our chosen profession. In other words if you can't talk or write the walk, stay away from my equipment.

by rm3mpc

Bless you for putting this question before the forum!

I expect and tolerate a certain amount of misspelling, grammar
and punctuation errors on a site like this. Sometimes people are
in a hurry, and as noted elsewhere, English is not the native
language for everyone here.

That said, there is little or no excuse for slop. If you can't be
bothered to express yourself clearly, you are showing disrespect
for your audience. Someone referred to content as the cake, and
spelling and grammar as the icing. Nice try, but not convincing.
If the icing is splattered on the cake, you won't buy it unless
you're half-starved or the price has been cut in half. Well,
neither will anyone else.

I learned years ago that you need to "put your best foot forward"
when you communicate with others, at least if you intend to
convince anyone that you are worth paying attention to.

In the IT field, bad writing always scared me. Is this same person
writing code? Command procedures? If they can't get it right in
English, what makes me think they'll get it right in C or Unix
commands? Computers do what you tell them to do, not what
you want them to do!

I used to manage systems development (I'm semi-retired and
out of the corporate thing), and I found it necessary to screen all
outgoing communications. In part, I was trying to ensure that
the content was correct and reflected what we had agreed to
with our customers. And in part, sadly, it was because I needed
to blue-pencil (actually, it was done with a red pen) poor
spelling, lousy grammar and run-on sentences that resembled
train wrecks. The impression on our customers, be they internal
or external, would have been awful if some of these missives
had ever made it out the door.

I know, it violates the contemporary stream-of-consciousness
lack of patience. What? Take the time to correct spelling? To
change a phrase to clarify or to tone it down? Can't be bothered!
Onto the next thing! Let 'em figure out what I meant! *I* know
what I mean!

by cheesel

I have no problem with the occaisional typo or misspelling but when u see peeple riting lik this an not usin punkchewashun jes havin runon sentenses it gits reedikulus and looks unprofeshinal

by jck

if they are required to effectively speak and communicate with others.

by jocey

Okay I understand the point made, but here is a question. When you guys did your degree programs they have Business Communication as apart of it? Well if not you can't expect that everyone will be able to be english suave material.And besides that, this is not exactly a presentation for bosses or potential customers it is a forum people are not very concerned with writing
proper diction. But your point is very vaild.

by absolutely

And your points are not valid.

Correct grammar and spelling are taught in elementary school, not college or trade school. Anybody who is able to understand the technical writing in a computer science class can certaintly write and speak correctly. If they [b]choose[/b] not to, they are insulting their audience.

by generalist

A lot depends upon the target audience.

Here a certain amount of leeway is granted because it is a tech forum, not an English language forum. I know a lot of tech types that know their fields like the back of their hand but have problems stringing three words together without spelling, syntax or typing errors.

At the same time, if you are presenting a topic or idea outside this environment, it can be essential that you make a proper impression by showing that you are literate. Failure to do so can result in people not treating your discussion with the seriousness it deserves.

Of course it also helps to proof read what you write. (Which I'm not doing at the moment.)

by dmoore9

Eveyone in the business world should be held to a higher standard than what exists today in terms of both written and spoken communication.

At least in the written arena -- have someone proof your e-mail before you send it.

by dr_zinj

Language is the ultimate swiss army knife. The alpha and the omega of multi-tools. Able to morph into any desired shape. No language is completely static; they change based on the needs of the speakers. English was transported around the world because of it's flexibility. I don't know of any concept that can be expressed in one language that can't also be expressed in English. (Although English does have some problems with multiple positional time concept expression - fortunately, I don't know any time travelers). Of course it's this very flexibility which drives people crazy trying to learn it - 'too' many exceptions to the rules. English technospeech is pretty precise. It's ordinary conversation that people get bogged down in.

by absolutely

Do you think there is something wrong with having higher expectations for the "leader of the free world" than for a notorious African dictator?

by john_li_it_guy

How can you communicate with the customer or end user if you do not have good grammar? I work with some people in the IT field who have poor grammar skills both in the way they speak and write. Part of my job requires me to write technical documents or e-mails that convey technical information. I have seen some technical documents and e-mails from peers in my field that look like they were written by a first grader. Does anyone remember that most applications come with a spelling and grammar checker?

While we are on the subject, these folks that come over from other countries, maybe you should invest some time in learning the English language along with whatever technical skills you choose. I can?t tell you how many IT people I?ve had to try and work with that are here on Visa?s that have such poor English language skills. English is the primary language we use here in the United States!!! If you want to work here learn the language!!! I?m sorry if I was going to go work in India, I?d at least learn the language.

by hal 9000

Between knowing the language and being proficient in it. Particularly with English where there are so many differences in the terminology used between different countries that allegedly speak the same language.

What is acceptable in the US could and does get people into trouble in other English speaking countries. As a simple example the term "Beaver" I believe applies to a furry rodent but I understand that it has a different meaning in some parts of the US.

Col ]:)

by elnegron

How can you inform or educate the end user if they do not understand what you are saying. More and more I hear from users that they could not communicate with the last tech that was dispatched to solve their problem. Had one client inform me that she terminated her contract with an IT company because she could not communicate with their techs.

If you can not write properly when submitting a post, giving the fact that you have time to compile what you are trying to communicate, then how can you speak properly when dealing with an end user?

by go_jetskiing_800sxr

The only thing I hate is stupid people using "l33t" speak or "hood" speak when they are speaking or typing. If I hear "yo" one more time I will shoot first and ask questions later.

by domiles

Ok, I admit I am fumble fingered on the key board!
But I do find people less and less literate in every day life. Too many icons, too many computer games that do not require reading.
I do spell and grammar check what I post in places like this, but the efforts of Microsoft etc: have lead to the use of icons and no reading. If I had my way, we would still be working on DOSS and have to be able to read and write to use the internet and the computer!
But if you grade us on typing errors, your might miss something important or interesting

by mr squeers

I was horrified to read such a politically incorrect comment. We have an egalitarian society where everyone who wants one can have a university degree. If requirements like literacy are re-introduced then it will become impossible to maintain this. It will become the thin end of the wedge that will divide our society into those with ability and a willingness to work and those who lack these things. Surely it is bad enough that we expect IT professionals to understand IT without making further demands upon them. Fortunately, as more enlightened educational reforms are introduced, our overburdened IT professionals will soon be able to attain self fulfilment without the burden of knowing about IT never mind literacy.

by joe.

Even the guys who write the dictionaries in America don't understand how English is supposed to work. Just buy a propper English (UK English) dictionary. We also spell words correctly.

This discussion is closed to new replies.