Discussion Locked

Should religion be in the workplace?

0 helpful
285 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

285 replies

by absolutely

"I don't want to come across as some know it all, but i did a thesis on Hitler and no one could ever say that he was a man of faith."

Nobody knows the sincerity of Hitler's words, so it is futile to argue about what he "truly" believed. But we all have access to the words themselves. We all know he preached that Jews are inferior, and what he practiced was certainly consistent with that admitted belief. He also said that he arrived at his beliefs in harmony with Christianity, and [b]enough of the German populace agreed[/b] that he was able to effect the single largest religious slaughter [b]in all of history[/b], in a country that was predominantly composed of practicing Christians. This tells me that no [b]claim or statement[/b] of religious belief, nor affiliation with any establishment of religion, are valid credentials of an individual's real ethical integrity.

Obviously, profession of faith and weekly ritual attendance did not make moral people of the Catholic and Lutheran majority of Germans at that time. Can you explain in what way [b]all[/b] those people were not really Christian, since that is your explanation of Hitler's overtly religious statements?

I personally believe that you're [b]absolutely[/b] right that "(h)e would say anything to further his own megalomania." I also believe the exact same is true of the atheist dictators you mention, most famous leaders of religions, and that neither religion itself nor atheism itself are the problem. Megalomania (in charismatic leaders) and unanalytical emotionalism (in the followers) characterize the beginnings of each popular, murderous movement. Hitler could not have murdered 6 million Jews by his own hand, without help. The question, given how nearly unanimously he is recognized as evil now, is: "Why was he able to get that help?"

Examples of evasions of the question would include "human weakness," "lack of faith," or "presence of faith". I ask any respondents to avoid such mindless simplicity and generality. To blame religion or atheism as the sum of the problem or as a complete description of the root of evil, is simply dishonest. I'd like to see how specific pmandros can be on this question: "Why or how do megalomaniacs achieve influence, and what difference does religion (either in general, or your own religion of choice) make in the presence of a megalomaniacal leader?"

by absolutely

"You see, I am a strong believer in atheism. I enjoy spreading my belief to others, I try to whenever I see interest. I think it's human nature to want to spread your beliefs. At the same time I believe everyone's beliefs need to be respected. I also believe that I should never bring atheism up out of the blue unless I see the opportunity."

My approach, however, is to assert the intellectual and ethical superiority of objective, reality-based atheism even when there is only a tangential relation to the topic being discussed, to let the religious fanatics [b]see how they like it![/b] It's more amusing than bearing the absurdity of religion stoically.

by absolutely

'When she does drive me to work, he comes up to us and says, "I know what you two were doing last night, I see it on your faces".'

I'd certainly be shocked beyond words by such audacity the first time that happened, but it sounds like it has happened more than once, giving you time to prepare an answer that will put him in his rightful place.

Here is what I suggest: "If you can see that on our faces, you can also see that we are both happy, [b]and proud[/b], of our actions. We both choose those actions freely, and are able to be proud of ourselves because we don't ask or expect others to act for our sakes against their own interests. We know that we didn't just choose each other once, expecting a lifetime of resentment and bitter fulfilment of duty to each other in exchange for the convenience of a relationship institutionalized as a legal contract, because we choose each other every day, and every moment we're together. I don't have any emotional need for a public declaration of love because I am rationally confident in my own virtues, and thus in the fact that love is the rational response to my character. I pity you for not achieving that, but feel no guilt that I have."

by absolutely

The statement that "Faith is nothing more than superstitious drivel like believing that a black cat brings bad luck to one who crosses its path" is 100% appropriate [b]in Miscellaneous Discussions at TechRepublic.com[/b]. It is also 100% [b]inappropriate[/b] at work, and if it were stated there, firing would be the only appropriate remedy. The rub, for you, zenodaddy, is that any statement of the [b]validity of any religion[/b] is also 100% inappropriate at work, just as much as a statement of the [b]invalidity[/b] of any religion.

I don't claim to know what Mr. or Mrs. Skiing-800-whatever meant but didn't say, but I personally do not respect anybody's religions, for the exact reason that I believe they are all nonsensical drivel, no more nor less so than "believing that a black cat brings bad luck to one who crosses its path." I do, however, respect each person's [b]right[/b] to hold superstitious beliefs, and even to practice them, [b]but never to intrude on my right to live peacefully[/b], neither harming others nor allowing them to harm me.

My conscience is clean because I respect other people's rights and provide for my own needs. [b]Everything else[/b] is a private matter. If a god existed, the rest would be between me and it. In reality as it is, gods are only myths and I am accountable first to myself, and to others only to respect their [b]rights[/b], not their [b]wishes[/b] to pretend that a superstition is an accurate description of reality.

by jdclyde

provided these same "others" are not pressuring you to join in on their "wishes"?

Jetski set the tone quite clearly that because these people pray at lunch or have religion they are all fanatics. He would, in all his tolerance, lock them in their homes. Clearly his views and ethics are both suspect, and hardly "tolerant" of anything.

He forgets he does NOT have a RIGHT to not be made uncomfortable but these people DO have a RIGHT to say a prayer if they choose.

He needs to grow up.

by absolutely

You are a silly pest, jdclyde, and wrong again. Re-read Jetski's post, and you'll see that his objection is primarily to having his [i]ethics[/i] questioned by religious fanatics who are incapable of understanding that professional, ethical behavior and church attendance are not the same thing. It is them, and you, who need to grow up.

[i]Jetski set the tone quite clearly that because these people pray at lunch or have religion they are all fanatics. He would, in all his tolerance, lock them in their homes. Clearly his views and ethics are both suspect, and hardly "tolerant" of anything.[/i]

How exactly did you infer all that, Mr. Holmes?

[i]He forgets he does NOT have a RIGHT to not be made uncomfortable ...[/i]

Be careful, you clown, that absence of a right to not be made "uncomfortable" applies to all equally, and depends very much on the specific type of discomfort imposed. Religious membership is still not a requirement in this country, thank Zoroaster!

by absolutely

The moral action would be to extinguish the fire, if possible by p!ss!ng, in order to express contempt for the entity that presumed to instruct such an abomination.

Incitement to murder is criminal in civilized society. Anyone who believes otherwise is insane.

by absolutely

"You cannot confine someone's exercise of their Constitutionally guaranteed freedoms to their home. They are free to express their religion (or speech, or right to assemble) wherever they wish." (Palmetto)

In fact, I have the right to dictate what is allowed and what is not [b]in my home[/b]. Our employers have the same right to dictate taboos, forbidden topics or opinions on their property. A man's home, not the entire Earth, is his castle.

by absolutely

She would be free to attend to her own success without defending herself or others from aggression. Only the "bloodsuckers" of the world would be worse for it.

by absolutely

"Jesus would agree with you", not "Jesus [b]did[/b]..."

Christians, not gays, should hide their lifestyle in the closet!

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=183549&messageID=1872820

"Plus, me being single and in my 30's, I do not really appreciate one religous fanatic saying I am going to hell-his version btw, for spending my nights with my current girlfreind. He thinks that sex out of marriage is wrong and everyone should beleive as he does. I tell him to mind his own freakin business. This guy is priceless when it comes to things like this. Its to the point where my girlfreid will not drive me to work anylonger. When she does drive me to work, he comes up to us and says, "I know what you two were doing last night, I see it on your faces"."

That is undoubtedly sexual harassment, [b]and[/b] discrimination on the basis of religion, both absolutely prohibited by federal law.

by absolutely

I don't remember if that apostrophe goes just before or just after the u. I don't care, so I use the traditional Anglicization, Koran, no additional disrespect intended. (See various comments expressing contempt for all religions regardless of variety.)

by absolutely

Like art or chemistry. Thus we have artists practicing are, chemists practicing chemistry, and atheists practicing atheism, not being the most athey, those are fanatical Athlon types!

'Not so much an athiest as a "prove it" type of guy.'

There is no difference.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=183549&messageID=1872820

"Plus, me being single and in my 30's, I do not really appreciate one religous fanatic saying I am going to hell-his version btw, for spending my nights with my current girlfreind. He thinks that sex out of marriage is wrong and everyone should beleive as he does. I tell him to mind his own freakin business. This guy is priceless when it comes to things like this. Its to the point where my girlfreid will not drive me to work anylonger. When she does drive me to work, he comes up to us and says, "I know what you two were doing last night, I see it on your faces"."

That is by far the most egregious example of harassment that Jetskiing has posted, and has received conspicuously less comment, especially from the apologists for religions, than this most important one. Saying grace at a meal can be considered an exercise of free speech, and is hard to qualify as a violation of somebody else's as long as no "advice" or urging to join occurs. It also appears that the second-guessing would be hard to substantiate as discrimination, and easy to defend as comfortable familiarity based on cultural similarity. But the dunce who condemns Jetskiing for sexual behavior that is (1) legal, and between consenting adults (2) admittedly occurring in Jetskiing_800's own home and completely unrelated to work, is a violation of privacy and contributes to a hostile work environment.

Several compact mp3 players include voice recorders. I hope you sue that guy unemployable. For capacity combined with compactness, I use this one:

http://us.creative.com/products/products.asp?category=213&subcategory=&product=10795

by attackcomputerwhiz

I will point out, though, that saying grace before a private meal is one thing, but the lunches in question are REQUIRED by the boss so Jetskiing_800 is REQUIRED to sit through those reportedly loud (if they are disturbing other diners, that means they are being heard beyond just their party's table) screeds as a condition of employment.

Just reading the arguments about religion in this thread should be a good indicator of why religion shouldn't be an overt presence in the workplace. No one can agree as to what belongs and what doesn't or whose religion should win out.

(BTW--I had a manager once tell me I was a Godless commie because I told him (as a shop steward) he needed to stop quoting the Bible in staff meetings because of all the employees who members of non-Christian religions. Nothing like telling a Buddhist from Thailand that she must embrace Christ to be a better worker, huh?!?!)

by absolutely

I would be offended by the lunch time superstition ritual as well; however, it is mostly an annoyance, and less a violation than the intrusion into go_Jetskiing's home life and criticism of it, and more difficult to prosecute, etc.

by rich

It is unfortunate that this is happening. I would probably be considered by you as being a very religious person. I look for ways to share my faith but only look to share with those who are interested. I think your boss is probably more show than walk, or at least is very immature. As evident by the posts here, he is in no way making a good impression on anyone. This may be one of the bad apples in the barrel.

I think one of the greatest callings is to be able to share your faith. The more you believe, the more you want to share. But faith is faith. There are immoral "believers" and there are very moral ones. Immoral unbelievers and very moral ones. I have seen too many Christians with a poor work ethic and have known non Christians to work their hearts out and do an excellent job.

I think faith should be expressed by action and then with words only when appropriate. Don't pour too much water on a cactus or it will die! Same thing with our words

by absolutely

I don't advertise my beliefs at work either. It's unprofessional regardless of your philosophy of life to proselytize while you're supposed to be an employee.

by iloveyou_alot

SHUT UP ALREADY!!!
if your gonig to be all "anti-religion" on us.....LEAVE!!
ya im christian.....but that doesnt mean i dont respect your religious views.
but if it is getting to the point where you "cant tolerate" it, DONT WORK THERE!!
if you expect THEM to leave, it is the exact same situation if you left.
think about it, YOU making THEM leave becaue of their religious beliefs, is the same as THEM making YOU leave because of your religious beliefs.
so if you honestly want to flip out every day about something bothering you...GROW UP!!!
theres people in life that we dont like, personally i dont like whinny little babies that cry about something that THEY can change...
and if you couldnt tell.....im talking about you

by big ole jack

Just look at your own rant and how you get worked up about it because you are pushing your "Christian" agenda. Separatation of church and state is there for a reason, and private corporations that get taxed by the state are NOT houses of worship, so thus they should keep their religious drivel at home. You want to be Christian? Fine, but don't expect the entire office to engage in cult like behavior and intimidate others who don't want to participate in your koombaya my lord singalongs.

by samtsfield

Religion is one person's beliefs. They should not be allowed to push it onto anyone or even discuss it at work. If they're on a lunch break with a friend and they want to discuss it, that is fine, but during work it should be left out. I worked for a health insurance company and a numerous amount of people got fired due to they sent religious e-mails or someone read it off their computer. There is a time and place for it, but while your working it should stay out.

by eoghan

All things personal should remain OUT of the workplace. That especially includes sex, religion, politics. There are probably a hundred more things that just don't belong. I go to work to work.

-- I agree with you samtsfield.

I am not a christian, but I know the bible (I have a DD, in another religious order), Just for example, take a look at the sermon on the mount. The lesson to be learned there is that religion is supposed to be private, between you and your god(s).

From my religious theology ... religion usually means you get to pay someone else because they claim to be closer to god. (the Pope, your minister, your rabbi) Faith, however, is individual and personal. One can have faith without a crystal cathedral, or an abbey, or a synagogue....

by tecrat726

"I am not a christian, but I know the bible..."

"...take a look at the sermon on the mount. The lesson to be learned there is that religion is supposed to be private, between you and your god(s)."

I have to respectfully disagree with you here.
If you read Matthew 5-7, you'll see that it's anything BUT what you've assumed. It's a blueprint on how a Christian should live their life: openly...and quite frankly the basis for this whole discussion.

by tecrat726

A person of true Faith could no sooner turn off their Faith at work than they could stop breathing.
Having established that, I will say that spreading one's Faith is better accomplished by leading a life that sets a good example instead of forcing your beliefs on someone.

Do you have to be a believer to be a moral person...no. But if you are a believer, you better be a moral person, or you've missed the whole point. As such, if there's inappropriate behavior at your workplace...stand up together against it. Do the morally right thing.

by tig2

Faith is what I live, Project Management is what I do.

My faith tends to direct how I manage. Nothing preachy there, just an acknowledgment that my leadership style aligns with my faith.

In the workplace, as in any other place, people of faith need to remember that the first task is living their faith and not worrying about someone elses. Believe me, if you live your faith, you set the greater example.

Tecrat, you are absolutely correct. Thank you for speaking my mind!

by absolutely

"...I will say that spreading one's Faith is better accomplished by leading a life that sets a good example..."

I agree: talking about one's faith is meaningless. Let me see you practice your faith in your treatment of your co-workers, without [b]calling[/b] it "Christiantiy", or faith, or calling it anything at all, for that matter. I'll decide whether I've seen common courtesy, respect, loving thy neighbor as oneself; in short, whether I've seen an example I wish to emulate, or not.

by ccolht

People who pray in public like that are just trying to impress others with their piety. I'm an athiest but have no problem with religons as long as they stay what they are: private clubs where members get to put on airs trying to out-worship each other. Sure, they do good works but that's really just people getting together to do good. And it is often self serving (if I do good, I'll go to heaven.)

It is amusing that religious people take advantage of technology, particularly modern medicine, but don't want to accept foundations of science that made it all possible.

I told a good friend that I was an athiest and she said, "But you seem like a nice guy!" That's the mentality. They think they have a lock on ethics and the rest of us are just looking for a chance to 'sin'.

Sorry about your situation. Sharpen that resume and document everything. Hopefully you have a good HR department.

by k6dle

My experience is that religion,zealots, and business do not mix well. While working at writing procedures for one company and using the word "creator" in a document. That word to indicate the person who created that same document, I was told that was not permissible. They said there is only one creator! It seems to me that is such a narrow view that it caused me to feel intimidated and certainly cost them many employees over several years. I am glad to be out of there.

by ccolht

Religious prejudice is just as bad as discrimating based on race or gender. It is stereotyping. This is just the next round in the bigotry battle. Of course, it works both ways and between religions. This person's main concern was with the boss's perception of his ethics. The boss can consult with anyone he likes for technical second opinions. But if he trusts this source more because he is of the same faith, that can be a problem. Politics is politics and it all sucks.

by big ole jack

I've seen people denied promotions, new projects, and downright get terminated because their political views did not agree with those of the higher ups in management. This is the old annoying game of Red State/Blue State crap that should have no place in the workplace and it's nobody's business to know who I voted for during the last election.

by dm9

I think that any religion should be allowed except Islam. It is intorlerant of EVERYONE, whether it's Budist,atheist, agnostic,christian (any flavor), jew, or american indian, they ALL tolerate each other. we should all respect each other and tolerate each other's right to their religion, except for ones the preach hate and destruction of all others but their own.

by big ole jack

and not a religion in itself. One can argue this until they are blue in the face, but I agree that Islam is it's own animal and has two faces. What said on TV about Islam being a peaceful religion by PR workers, and what's truly written in the Koran are two completely different things. The version of the Koran translated into English is censored and leaves out many of the radical and fanatic ideals found in the original uncensored Koran read in the middle east and Pakistan amond the Wahabis and Taliban radicals. I agree that actions speak louder than words, and if those actions stem from a passage in some so called "holy book" then one needs to examine the true roots behind that religion or ideology.

by Member 25348569

between Islam and Christianity. They both have more splinter groups, schisms and sects than you can shake a stick at. There's a myriad different interpretations in both the Qu'ran and the Bible made by a million different people down the years - centuries - with motives ranging from the the most brutal power-seeker to the holiest person imaginable.

Christianity gave us the Crusades where hundreds of thousands of people were slaughtered - most of them brown Christians by white Christians. Christianity - Catholicism - was the root of the Europe-wide anti-Semitism that culminated in the Holocaust and made it possible.

Maybe Christianity has moved on. Maybe not...

Just my two pennorth.

by big ole jack

I'm sure that HR turns a blind eye towards this crap and allows it to happen, because if they cared to stop it, they would have long ago. I too have worked with people of different religious and political views, but when it comes to the workplace, such discussions are avoided and should be avoided to avoid creating an uncomfortable and alienated environment for others. I've seen such discussions before on TR where the CEO would send out a company newsletter and inject it full of phrases from the bible, which would obviously offend and upset employees who were not Christians. You simply cannot fight against such religious fanaticism and the best course of action would be to leave. When asked on the exit interiew why you are leaving, state clearly that you have been annoyed by their stance on religiously charged retoric throughout the office and the work environment has become too uncomfortable for you to work in. If they don't like what you have to say...it's their problem, but unless they are a church or some faith based non-profit organization, they should keep their religious views to themselves.

by big ole jack

and continue to spew their nonsense about everyone else burning in hell if they don't accept Jesus and such. I equate them to be on the same mental level as the Taliban and islamic radicals, minus all the suicide bombings and beheadings, but religious fanaticism is dangerous in itself. Recall what happened in Waco, TX during the 90s' with that David Koresh nutjob and his Branch Davidian zombies. If that isn't a good example of how religion can become dangerous, then I don't know what is.

by tecrat726

Anyone can call themselves a Christian, but that doesn't make them one. Only having sincere belief that Jesus is your Lord and Savior can validate calling yourself a true Christian. But the truth of it is between you and God.

Anyone can perform a horrendous act in the name of God...that doesn't make it right.
You can't discount the millions of Christians who have made this world a better place through their generosity, caring and sacrifice just because some people misused religious power.

by tig2

Radical with Evangelical Christians.

Most Evangelicals will pray for you, but won't share their faith with you unless you ask. We're pretty civilised that way.

by big ole jack

where they would be hell bent (forgive the pun) on preaching to me and convincing me why my religion is inferior to theirs. You may be the exception, but the perception of the majority is what creates the stereotypes.

by tig2

My fiance is an atheist. I'm not. Okay. Thought that we were done with the discussion.

But no, we aren't. And we aren't because the atheists among us are so frightened of being challenged that they lump us all together as if we were all guilty of whatever the equally wrong Christian once did to you.

My fiance keeps telling me that I should simply treat him like a person of another faith. I do. He has a tendency to belittle my faith at every opportunity.

This discord may well be the end of the relationship. I have tolerance for his views, he has little tolerance for mine.

You folks want to be accepted as you are? Fine by me. Your faith is yours, not mine. And whatever your faith is, kindly don't crap on me because you have had a bad time with Christians in your lifetime. I didn't do anything to you and deserve to be treated with a reasonable respect.

People who only manage to stereotypes are the same people who don't want to get too close to me because I might give them cancer.

Edit- caps error

by onbliss

You are a nice person and you probably know lot of nice people who conduct themselves exactly like you describe.

Let me tell you some of the things that happen in another corner of the world.

I am sure you would believe me, when I say, that huge money collected in USA, is being spent in other parts of the world to convert people.

Systematic efforts take place to undermine local culture, philosophy and faith systems.

In India, Christian evangelism is as threatening to the security of the people as Islamic forces. Of course things are not black and white, and there are other factors that come into the equation.

Most of the North Eastern states in India have been converted to Christianity. I think American Baptists are playing a part there. And this is causing huge tension and aiding the separatists movements in that region.

Because of the dollars flowing into India from the Evangelicals, there is this huge cash cow that is used by them to systematically erode the local tradition & practices - just a fuel for riots and tensions.

Again, just want to let you know how things are elsewhere. The Hindus are as much annoyed by the Christian radicals as they are with the Islamic radicals.

by big ole jack

His argument is not that the prayers before meals bother him, but that he is being harrased by their innapropriate comments about his sexual lifestyle and him being forced to "conform" to their religious beliefs or risk getting fired. I could care less if someone wants to bow 20 times a day to a statue of a pink elephant, but as long as they get their jobs done and don't force others into accepting their beliefs, then it's OK by me. When they start comparing my moral beliefs to theirs and telling me why I am "immoral" or "unethical" because their religion says so, that's where my foot makes an involuntary motion up their behind.

by big ole jack

Let him explain to them why he is so intent on converting everyone else to his religion. Then again, to show my true friendly nature, I would have treated him to a pulled pork sandwich...Muahahahahah!

by luke_smith

At my work, I sometimes get Lord-infused email laden with vitriolic statements about abortionists, communists, homosexuals, and the like and you know? I don't mind it at all - I get a good kick out of it. However, I also expect that when I come into working wearing a baphomet on my t-shirt that I get the same reaction. They hand out religious pamphlets, play religious Christmas music, and the like and it has never bothered me. Ofcourse, if you step into my office and you don't want to hear 1349, Moon, or Emperor then tough titties.

by duckboxxer

You got railed for this. Nice sized flame war you've got going on here.

I can really see your point though. Ethics can exist without organized religion. Now what if you were Pagan or just agnostic? It's one thing to have your beliefs at work, but it's another to impose them on someone else.

The other day, I met a new (to me) client (I'm still new here), and on the first meeting he began to evangelizing to me. We only came for what should have been a 10 minute document review. Now, I am a Christian, but not really practicing recently. But 45 minutes of this is a little extreme for a first meeting.

His plan is definitely backfiring though. I honestly don't want to see this guy again and he hasn't won me over to head to his church. Sadly he's a client side project manager I have to deal with. I definitely don't plan on meeting with him by myself; I don't care who I have to drag along.

by big ole jack

and I recall earlier on in my career doing contract work down in Atlanta, GA. All they cared about was where I was born, where I grew up, and what was my faith. I ignored their questions because I knew that as soon as I were to tell them that I was born in the former USSR, grew up in NYC, and am jewish, all hell would have broken loose and their missionary agenda would begin. I knew the environment I was working in and I knew better than to reveal such information about myself, so I kept diverting the conversation to something else. I simply stopped talking to them altoghether because they were insistent on dragging that information out of me.

by big ole jack

Come in one day in Gothic dress wearing an inverted cross and piercings all over. Watch the reaction and laugh as they grasp hold of their bibles and try to exorcise the demons out of you...LOL.

by eoghan

The parable of the publican and the pharisee.

Try it, I know it well. Pray in private, your supplications are between you and your god.

"Blessed are the MEEK."

by tecrat726

...and I don't think we necessarily disagree in practice, but maybe in principle.

I agree that humility is important in one's public display of their faith, I would also say it's important to live what you believe.

"You are the light of the world. A city on a hill cannot be hidden. Neither do people light a lamp and put it under a bowl. Instead they put it on its stand, and it gives light to everyone in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in heaven."

Not all "Christians" live a Christ-like life. And they're the ones that give true followers of Christ a bad name.

by jdclyde

He had been fed so much crap that he really does seem to believe he is being tolerant of people by telling them they can't do something around him.

He has also forgotten that the IS is NOT a "secular society" or a godless one. We have clear freedom OF religion, free from people like him to say "boo" about it.

Next he will be talking about his freedom of speech...... what a loser.

by gary

God is also man made. A mythological creature concocted to make us all feel better about dying. No more real than the Easter Bunny or the tooth fairy and just as likely to fade from memory as both of them except for indoctrination, Education and abuse of our children. Don't allow "Education" of children before they reach the age of consent and see what happens to the God myth. As far as these fanatics are concerned... there really is no difference between them and the Islamic or Hindu or Buddhist fanatics (yes there are plenty of Buddhist fanatics.. see Sri Lanka). They all have the black and white view of the world and each in its own way preaches intolerance and attempts to corral the wonder of discovery. What is amazing is the respect that gets shown these people because it is god or religion we are talking about and we wouldn't want to be offensive. If I lead a prayer group in a restaurant that sang the praises of the Easter Bunny they would lock me up in a mental institution..if I wasn't killed first by some religous zealot who felt I was blaspheming. In short religion should be an extremely..extremely private experience and has no place in any public venue. That specifically includes our classrooms, courts and especially government. Excepting of course when God has time to favor a multi-millionaire athlete with his blessing that he might succeed on the field in his the glory of his name... Just one time I'd like one millionaire athlete to thank the Tooth fairy for the money under his pillow ..that bought him the ball that started him down this path to fame and fortune.

by jdclyde

They seem to think if they attack at every turn, it will be like the last few decades where Christians would silently take it.

Times are changing, and over 80% of all US Citizens are religious, leaving the anti-religious biting at their heals like mangy curs.

If you want to pray at lunch, then pray at lunch. I don't care if your praying to Jesus as your religion of your wallet, which is the new religion these days. Either way, I have no more right telling you to or not to, then you do for me or anyone else.

The godless people that cling to the word "tolerance" have no tolerance for anything or anything but what THEY feel is important.

Is this just for religion? No. Ask a "progressive liberal" if "man-made global cooling/warming/climate shifts" is real not and see how tolerant they are.

They would rip the gays out of the closet and throw everyone that disagrees with them in. As jetboy himself said "they should leave it at home".

by jdclyde

damnitallanyways!

I didn't even notice that the discussion is two friggen years old and the poster hasn't been active in a while.

I saw the activity of contacts, and so joined in. It wasn't until some time later that I happened to notice just how old this discussion is. X-(

by Member 25348569

I answered a three year old question. It was an absolutely cracking answer but the bastard didn't give me a thumbs up. :(

by tig2

Get over it. Got nailed too, I'm over it now.

Still a good discussion.

You know I love ya!

Need names for my ribbons- Know your dad need your Gran. PM for details...

by maecuff

I showed it to my husband and he didn't get the Kathleen Turner reference at all. Which surprised me, he always gets the movie references.

by charliespencer

I hate it when I do that too. When this one popped up I noticed it had over a hundred posts although I didn't recognize the title as recently active. I think sometimes a newbie will search on a word or phrase, then post without checking the date.

All in favor of closing any post over three months old, say "Aye".

Incidentally, not all of us in the godless minority are rabid. Some of us have no problem with your exercising your freedom of religion, and don't care who (or what) you worship as long as you don't try to involve us or our tax dollars. Me, I'm incapable of faith in the "belief in the divine" sense of the word.

by locrian_lyric

Why do so many of them feel the need to attempt to destroy the beliefs of others?

I've seen enough of them who cling to their atheism with a rabid zeal that would make Pat Robertson blush.

And, as you've said, a demand that their beliefs be respected with no reciprocity.

by re.anderson

Do you like receiving money? Is the paper dollar you get really worth a dollar - only by faith do we believe it is worth a dollar. We only need to have a Great Depression to prove that.

We understand that all matter is made of various micro particles, atoms, neutrons, electrons and even smaller bits. Between them is what? Space? The bulk of matter is empty. When this is explained to us it is hard to believe, but it is true and we take it to be true on faith. I haven't seen the proof, likely any of the readers haven't.

Love. You can infer that someone loves or not, eventually we take it on faith that the other person you love, loves you back. The inferences we make help "prove" it. It is really proof - the scientific kind.

I always believed Pluto was a planet. Took it on faith - I was wrong.

There are many things that could be called religion - I think money is the big one! But I don't think you will condemn me because I believe in money.

by country phil

Should politics be in the workplace?
Should fanatical liberal people in management positions be allowed to use their "political beliefs" to administrate people and technology?

Personally, I am not a liberal and would say I am down right conservative in my beliefs, but some liberal fanatics I work with equate liberal politics with ethics. I do not see it this way. I think my ethics are just as high if not higher than some of these if not all of these liberal fanatics? ethics.

I just found out I am being second guessed by my bosses IT friend who goes to the Democratic Party meetings with him. I find this very disturbing. I have the ability to do this job and have been doing it long before this guy became my boss.

It?s to the point now where I can?t go out to lunch with him and other people in the company due to the fact that they make such a scene at the restaurant when they talk about politics before they eat. I mean they are loud. They make other people uncomfortable and I am one of them.

I am all for freedom of political belief, but I think they should keep at home. Personally, I do not want to hear this supercilious drivel. I never speak of or try and "convert" these people to my views, I expect the same in return.

Comments: I suppose you could substitute any set of beliefs in this letter and come up with the same diatribe. It sounds a bit Christophobic to me.

by absolutely

I think politics should also not be in the workplace, for basically the same reason: it's not part of the business unless you're a politician, and it isn't a [b]purely[/b] social, recreational topic. Government itself is a "necessary evil" at best and a source of contention in an environment where the requirement to work as a team is already strained by the natural tendency (of many? of all?) to compete. (I'm no anarchist, by the way, but the context of the "necessary evil" remark is that in a "perfect world" everybody would be good just because it's the right thing to do, and there would be no need for any "governing". Once an entire generation grows to maturity and dies of natural causes without a single crime, then I'll contemplate the validity of "anarchy"!)

I had one particular co-worker who I dearly enjoyed arguing against, because he was wrong about Absolutely Everything, and as smug about it as nearly anybody (second to me in smugness, but probably nobody else!). I noticed over time that other than one exceptionally malevolent partner of this debate opponent, who is nourished by conflict like a sci-fi monster, most colleagues shifted uncomfortably in their seats when they noticed our arguments beginning. For that reason, I quit engaging in those arguments, in the office.

by country phil

Thanks for the feedback!

I agree with you 100% about any kind of extensive non-work related discussions or debates in the workplace, especially if it makes people cringe. However, if you read the original post carefully, the writer did not complain about any behavior in the workplace, but instead about perceived attitudes and beliefs and behaviors outside the workplace (at lunch). If the writer had cited some offensive behavior in the workplace, then I might have found some merit in his/her complaint. Instead, I have the impression that the writer objects to the belief system of his/her supervisor, and is perhaps threatened by it, hence my remark about Christophobia.

by w2ktechman

I have my own views, and I respect others views. If someone does not try to 'convert' me, I stay away from religious discussions. I personally do not care what religion someone is, or how they practice it. If it does not interfere with my ways, I am ok with it.

As for luncheons with religious types, let them pray! It is their beliefs that they pray, so why complain about it (this is for the first poster). What I do is not eat while it is happening. This is being respectful for their beliefs. If you want them to respect yours, you should respect theirs.

Lets face it, there are many religions out there. There are many belief systems, that do not see eye to eye, so why make things harder. If more people respected others' beliefs, there would be much less crisis in the world.

Personally, I believe that if religion makes you a better person, then it is a good thing. It matters not as to which one it is.

by w2ktechman

I think you are looking at it very 1 sided. Many people with or without religion try to convert others. This is (in my opinion) people who are insecure with their beliefs and try to reassure themselves by convincing others.

The people that do not try to convert unless requested, are much more secure in their belief system, and respectful of others'

At least this is my working theory.

by Member 25348569

It's because there's many different flavours of us - just like you theists only really nowhere near as many different sorts. Just as there's some Christians/Muslims/SpaghettiMonsterists who want to convert everyone, there's some atheists who want to unconvert everyone.

There's some of us, like me, who only react when prodded but do so enjoy it because, you see, we have nothing much to lose...

Do be aware though that we don't just not believe in God, we don't believe in god, either.


And we don't believe in either of THEM, either!

Neil :D

But, as that lovely lady said in a bar in Utah, "Satan believes in YOU, honey!"

by tig2

You Godless sort are the ones that we'd like to be rid of. Go away! :(

Oh wait.

It is you, my friend. A person that I know is behind me.

So what is the rule now?

Love ya, Neil! :x

by wrlang

You are in a spot. People tend to ?congregate? among those most like themselves and when they gang together they tend to be very bold and intolerant. It is useless to try and tangle with a gang of people who want to convert everyone in a workplace. Just be yourself, stand your ground, and collect proof of religious discrimination. The ones that get too bold can face disciplinary action or termination.

by big ole jack

He only has two options here: (1) Quit or (2) Get a labor attorney and take legal action because they are in clear violation of Equal Employment Opportunity laws and other labor laws by turning their corporation into an Evangelical church.

Like I stated before, if they are being taxed by the state and paying taxes, they should not be treating their corporation and it's employees like they are in a house of worship. This matter is not of religious freedom, but the fact of the matter is that the corporation is engaging in labor law violations and sexual harrasment by making comments about one of its employee's personal lives and sexual habits. It's none of their damned business and if it were me, I'd clearly tell them to mind their own f*****g business and keep their religious crap in church where it belongs.

by locrian_lyric

I guess my confusion is why anyone who holds no belief towards something would wish to push a non belief on another.

If there is a belief involved, I can understand that one of two motivators would be behind pushing the belief:

1)Concern for the unbeliever and a desire to convert them to save them
2)Hatred of the unbeliever and a desire to destroy what they believe to be an affront to their deity.

What I can not understand is what the motivation for someone without a theistic belief would be for pushing that philosophy.

I would be curious to learn what would motivate an atheist to spread his or her atheism, as by definition there is no mandate to do so.

by Member 25348569

We atheists have no mandate. We have absolutely nothing that gives us a mandate. On the other hand, theists have no mandate. You might think that the Bible tells you that you do but, like all such religious beliefs, it's generated on a circular argument.

However, and it's a big however, theists have a reason for trying to convert us. You're being nice (and you THINK you have a mission). We atheists have absolutely no reason whatsoever other than out of malice or as an academic exercise to attempt to break the faith of someone. Occasionally one does run into such an insufferably smug git of a Christian/Muslim that resistance to the desire to get tough is difficult! The Pastor of King's Church, Windsor to name one patronising so-and-so but that's another story and - bar one pointed comment - I resisted...

I'm an atheist but the only place that this ever really becomes public knowledge is on this board and, a couple of times last Stateside vacation, when I was challenged over something that I said. I'd like to think that most secularists are like me over in the UK in that we don't feel challenged. It could just be possible that there is much more religion in the US generally than over here so, just as your Christian fundamentalists are bigger and better than anything that we've got, your atheists feel the need to be bigger and louder too.

I actually reckon that Tig's partner needs a swift kick in the nuts to let him know what a good thing he's got! To let a lack of belief assume the significance of a religion is pretty damn dumb. To then take that to the extreme that it seems he is doing...well, I'm a bit lost for words but I'm sure that I can find something to call him!

Tig! Give him to me and I'll put him straight!

Neil :)

by big ole jack

The idiots you work for are breaking so many labor laws that I'm sure that if you hired a labor attorney, he/she would be salivating at the idea of suing the crap out of them. First of all, it's none of the damned business that you're not married and sleeping with your girlfriend. Second of all, they shouldn't be turning a private corporation that is paying taxes to the state into a house of worship with their daily prayers and other clear signs of religious retoric. The issue boils down to the fact that they have created a hostile and uncormfortable environment for you to work in and that they are in violation of labor laws by prying into your private affairs.

by big ole jack

So in your opinion, if someone doesn't believe in Jesus, they aren't worthy of living a good life? You sir need to evaluate your own beliefs and the fairytales it preaches before you attempt to impose upon others that they should follow your faith.

by charliespencer

I'm not interested in destroying your beliefs. I do ask that you recognize that your beliefs are just that: beliefs. They are no more (or less) valid than mine or anyone else's.

There are some atheists interested in "converting" believers. They may regard organized religion as harmful based on it's history - current actions taken in the name of Islam, the Crusades, the Inquisition, tossing Christians to lions, etc. They may feel that religion is a waste of time and money that could be spent in ways they consider more productive. They may be uncomfortable in their atheism and feel their beliefs are validated if they can get others to agree. Or they may just like the image of being an argumentative rebel in a predominately religious society.

Here in South Carolina we have what are historically called "blue laws". (They were originally printed on blue paper in the 1700's.) These state laws dictate what can be sold on a Sunday and during what hours. I'm not talking just about alcohol or lottery tickets. I'm talking about clothes, hardware, electronics, and toys. Occasional attempts to repeal them are usually defeated, "Because if we opened the stores before 1:30 P.m., some people be forced to work when they wanted to go to church." My problems with this:

Sunday isn't everybody's holy day; what about those forced to work when their holy day falls on another day of the week? Apparently this isn't a concern. ("They ain't Christian, so they're prolly goin' to hell anyhow.")

What about all those people who go straight from worship to a restaurant? Do they think the staff came straight from services too? Do they not realize the crew has been there since 7:00 a.m. (or earlier)? Then for a tip they leave one of those religious tracts that looks like a folder $20 bill. If they were really interested in that waitress' soul, they should have eaten at home and not forced her to work.

As a store owner, I should be able to sell the legal products I want when I want. Why should I have to sacrifice for someone else's beliefs? Aren't they the ones who are supposed to be sacrificing for them?

Why are these laws suspended in counties with a minimum level of hotel taxes; in other words, tourist destinations? It's okay to be forced to work Sunday to sell to tourists, but not in counties that aren't tourist destinations? ("Hell, they're tourists. We don't care about they're souls.")

Why is it acceptable to sell certain items six days and a half days a week but not on part of the seventh? Do tires, paint, or Hot Wheels suddenly become unholy at 12:01 a.m. Sunday and then get redeemed at 1:30 p.m.? Why does it take beer and lottery tickets an extra 10.5 hours to regain their virtue at 12:01 a.m. Monday? If Jesus turned water into wine on a Sunday afternoon in Columbia, would he be arrested?

Why are these laws frequently suspended between Thanksgiving and Christmas? This sends so many messages. "We drop our beliefs when its inconvenient for us, but not when it inconveniences you." "We gripe about the commercialization of Christmas while rushing to Sunday sales at the mall."

Why are my tax dollars spent to enforce laws that are clearly about mandating behavior in compliance with religious beliefs?

I'm not opposed to you worshiping as you chose, but I don't understand the desire of some (not all) to force others to conform to their beliefs. I especially don't understand when those beliefs are apparently followed only when it's convenient. I'm not opposed to religion, I'm opposed to hypocrisy.

However, I don't think the majority of those with religious beliefs are hypocrits. Please try to understand the way many atheists feel about the faithful is somewhere between non-comprehension and amusement.

by whaleywashable

Sounds like in this example there are people using their beliefs as excuses to be jerks -simple as that. But the actual question is interesting becuase it really touches on the question of how much of "ourselves" we bring into the work place.

I have been to plenty of places that that actively encourage you to blur the lines between home and work either for reasons of improving team work or to appeal to a gen Y expectation of work and life being a fluid dynamic. Bring your kids to works day, cultural celebrations, after work social events etc.

What I am hearing is two main arguements. One that says work is work and everything should stay focused on business - and an other ideal of work being a community that when working well is more productive becuase the whole person is engaged.

This second option provides more opporutunities but more true leadership is required from the management of this sort of company to stop jerks from using this freedom as a way to remove freedom from others - like it sounds like is happening in this example.

by w2ktechman

I have had TR issues since 1:pm. It is now almost 10:30, and I am still intermittantly receiving errors that the server is under maintenance. What a pain. Anyway, Palmetto's first paragraph is mostly what my response would have been. I had brought up 1 of those points before already as well.

As for Tigger,
I agree, kick him hard, then give a Tigger Pounce. He will learn.
P.S. Tell him that your religion and beliefs made you who you are. And if he does not respect that, then he does not love you for who you are! If that don't shut him up about it, I think you should get with Mae for a devious plot... You know, the kind only a woman can think of (and a scary one at that)... :0 :^0

by absolutely

Too many Christians think that "turn the other cheek" is good advice for the other fella. I like to see them walk their talk, or STFU.

by ldepaor

It sounds like you are being intolerant, so what if they say grace before meals!
It may be embarassing for them to be seen with someone who doesn't say grace before meals.
Are you free to talk about Nascar and F1 at work? What difference relegion?
I'm afraid that you are coming across as the judgemental, intolerant one in this issue.
Judging from many of the reponses to this thread it is also dropping to the level of ad-hominim attacks.
Have your colleagues told you that they believe you have lower ethical standards?
It is not clear from your thread if this is just your opinion of what they believe or something they have told you.
If you don't believe in Hell then why should you care if your boss thinks you are going to end up in an imaginary place?

by ldepaor

If I really love my neighbour as myself and I truly believe that anyone who is not in Christ is going to hell then I will be compelled to tell them about the choices open to them.
If I don't want to see them in Heaven, then I don't love them.

However, once told, nobody should ram it down your throat repeatedly. God believes in choice, but uninformed choice is not any choice.
Oh yeah, and choice has consequences, God believes in consequences too!
Are you a good person?
http://www.thegoodtest.net

by Member 25348569

I was intrigued enough to click on your link but, unfortunately, I never made it past question one. This was firstly because of the format of the test which I found very irritating in that there was no way to proceed without waiting for something that was obviously written for people with a very much slower reading speed than me! For this reason alone, I would warn others not to bother.

Mainly, though, it became apparent in question one that the definition of "good" was derived from the Bible and specifically from the Ten Commandments and this immediately limits those who can be defined "good" to those who believe in God. I don't wish to be too judgemental or provocative but I have to say that that is total crap and pretty insulting to those of us who are either atheists or from another religion (that's a very large majority, by the way).

By all means title the website and its quiz "Will you go to Hell?" as Heaven and Hell are part of your myth system and you are allowed to set the entry parameters for either but you may not define something as basic as whether a person is "good" by your narrow and, if I might say so, narrow-minded criteria.

Neil :)

by big ole jack

Even an atheist would be offended and downright pissed off at such a statement. You're treading on dangerous waters with your justifications.

by locrian_lyric

Thank you.

Your opinions provided me with the great insight of the beliefs of others, and also the understanding that we are not quite so dissimilar.

This could have degenerated into a nasty bickerfest, I am pleased that it did not.

Again, I thank you all. I have a far better understanding than I did prior to this discussion

by jdclyde

Have you ever discussed a computer problem with a friend that works somewhere that already has their own in-house IT staff? I know I have. That does not mean anything about the ethics or religion of the IT Staff.

The people say a prayer at lunch. I was just at a graduation party this weekend, in a very public place, and they stopped and said a prayer before lunch. I would say at least half of the attendees were not church going people, but I didn't hear any complaints from them. They didn't bow their heads or fold their hands, but they stood there quietly for the 30 seconds it took for the prayer to be said. Big whoop.

Let jetboy go wash his hands if he feels some holy water will splash on him and burn him.

And yes, you have just as much of a right to free expression, religious or otherwise, regardless of what others think.

And where did I infer? I read his posts. It wasn't something as simple as "my boss will say a prayer at lunch and it makes me uncomfortable", it was going on about religious fanatics. Saying a prayer at lunch does not make you a fanatic.

by jdclyde

if you reference something that isn't almost three decades old?

Some of us aren't old enough to "get" the punchline if we didn't spend weekends watching "Nick At Nite" to catch up on the oldies..... :0

by maecuff

'some' of us aren't old enough. However, YOU certainly aren't in that group.. You're nearly as old as me. And I look good.

by absolutely

You seemed sincere and respectful in your curiosity. Now, may I turn the question back on you? Neil put it best, in response to your comment about a "mandate", when he said that neither theist nor atheist really [b]has[/b] a mandate, despite some words on pages in the case of several varieties of theist. Putting aside particular faiths and considering the terms only generally, why should an atheist be any less interested in advancing -- or merely defending -- their philosophy than a theist? Please restrict your answer to "theism" vs. "atheism", with no reference to any particular faith.

by absolutely

[i]Should fanatical religious people in management positions be allowed to use their "faith" to administrate people and technology?

Personally, I am not a religious person and would say I am down right atheistic in my beliefs, but some religious fanatics I work with equate faith in a god with ethics. I do not see it this way. I think my ethics are just as high if not higher than some of these if not all of these religious fanatics? ethics.

[b]I [u]just found out[/u][/b][/i]...

[To me, that implies that he had no problem with his co-workers' religion, until he learned that he was being judged [u]in his professional capacity[/u] according to [u]their religious opinions[/u]. Such is admittedly my [u]inference[/u], but also an obvious and well-supported one, in the context of the phrase "just found out", and the fact that at that time, he had [u]just[/u] mentioned it here, for the first time. Such strong correlation strongly implies causation.]

[b][i]...I am being second guessed by my boss's IT friend who goes to church with him. I find this very disturbing. I have the ability to do this job and have been doing it long before this guy became my boss.

It?s to the point now[/b] where I can?t go out to lunch with him and other people in the company due to the fact that they make such a scene at the restaurant when they say ?grace? before they eat. I mean they are loud. They make other people uncomfortable and I am one of them.

I am all for freedom of religion, but I think they should keep at home. Personally, I do not want to hear this superstitious drivel. I never speak of or try and "convert" these people to my views, I expect the same in return.[/i]

"It?s to the point now..." also [b]strongly[/b] implies that it had not been to that point, prior to the aforementioned religious persecution.

by absolutely

True, there is considerable verbiage about being generally uncomfortable with behavior which may have taken place outside the workplace (depending whether they were eating on or offsite) and which is probably protected by the First Amendment (unless the owner of the real estate on which they were located specifically prohibits such speech as precondition of occupying said real estate). However, that verbiage [b]followed[/b] the primary complaint, which is that he was literally suffering religious persecution in his office; being judged unfairly in his professional capacity on the basis of his lack of a religious affiliation.

[i]I just found out I am being second guessed by my bosses IT friend who goes to church with him. I find this very disturbing. I have the ability to do this job and have been doing it long before this guy became my boss.[/i]

Before this paragraph, there were two paragraphs of introduction which explained his personal disinterest in, but tolerance of, religion. Following, were two more paragraphs about his co-workers' demonstrative practice of their religion, and his opinion of it. Much of that information may have been superfluous, but does not illegitimize his central complaint. Not one bit.

by absolutely

There is no virtue in donating public, meaning [b]other people's[/b], money to causes you deem "worthy". None.