Discussion Locked

Should the US foot the World AID Problem - I say let Canada and France doit

0 helpful
159 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

From the Leader of the Pedo UN -

LONDON - The United States must lead the fight against AIDS with the same commitment it shows to financing the battles against terrorism and weapons of mass destruction, U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan said on Tuesday.

?We hear a lot about weapons of mass destruction. We hear a lot about terrorism, and we are worried about weapons of mass destruction because of their potential to kill thousands of people,? Annan said in an interview with the BBC.

?Here we have an epidemic that is killing millions. What is the response?? Annan said, calling for the United States to lead the world in devoting more funds to fighting the killer disease.

The world puts substantial sums of money into fighting terrorism and containing weapons of mass destruction to protect people, he said. ?And here we know (about AIDS), it?s not that we don?t know, we read about it, we see it around us -- where?s the international solidarity??

Why - should the US foot the world AIDs problem - no one likes us - just ask OZ-Media ... so why should we spend our money helping the world. When Annan controls his solders from having sex with 4 year old for food - then I would say - we can spend some money on World AIDS problem... As so many have pointed out in post the US is not the controlling force in the world - How about Canada and France footing this one ...

159 replies

by sullyman

Typical troll - Check your facts before you post dribble. Canada ranks in the top 5 globally for funding Aids and world hunger issues, based on % of national funding. The dollar amount may not be as high as the US or other countries, but the % we donate is the kicker.

by skipperusn

US already gave 14 billion - lets see that would be about 23 Billion Canadian right...

Why Should the US pay for the world - Not anymore - You don't like our foriegn policies - or our leaders - then you mustn't like our money... so we keep it... Let the other rich countries take care of the world.

Hum - Interesting isn't it - you all don't like us when we act on terrorism - but love our money.. Sorry can't have it both ways anymore..

by sullyman

Did you even read my post before you replied, or just assume that it was anti-US. It is not, it was simple straight to the point reply of some wrong information in your original posting. But, since you have opened up the can of worms let me make a comment. Relief and charity funding go hand in hand with military action, you can have relief funding alone but when you have military action relief and charity funding acommpany it.

I think I read an article sometime in the last year or so that said that 25%-45% of the cost of a military action was relief issues, and re-building costs.

by oz_media

'...Not anymore - You don't like our foriegn policies - or our leaders - then you mustn't like our money... so we keep it... "

Perhaps you should let Bush know htat you are now deciding on Americas policies for him, it couldn't hurt I guess, even from a patriot such as yourself.

by jamesrl

Canada is behind an initiative to provide lower cost generic aids drugs to third world countries.

Canada donates towards world wide efforts, and sponsors medical research in Canada as well.

We always get this static from the US, based on an assumption that the US leads the way in foreign aid. That may be true on a raw number basis but on a per capita basis many countries contribute more than the US.

I'm not suggesting that the US increase or decrease its spending - I know from managing a multi million dollar budget that there are always competing demands and changing priorities. I'm just suggesting that before you suggest that others aren't doing your share, that perhaps you look at facts rather than what the Bill O'Reillys of the world would have you believe.

James

by skipperusn

Sorry to say but no were close to the 14 billion in US dollars - if you figure that the 14 billion is twice what all the countries have given...

I no longer support the UN - or its efforts - I no longer support the US governments support of the UN. I believe the US needs to get out of the UN - sell in the building in NYC ... and I have addressed that to my senator/congressman and president...

by sullyman

Skipper,

For crying out loud, before you spew your propoganda load your brain. Do you understand what per capita even is, if you did the $$ amount would be secondary. Nowhere near the 14 Billion who cares what the dollar amount is, what is that per capita. Your attitude towards the rest of the world is what makes most of the rest of the world dislike the US. Learn how to have a conversation, like Max. I might not agree with him most of the time, but I respect him for his views.

by jamesrl

Canada is one tenth the size of the US in population and in the size of the economy. Should we make the same size contribution.

Someone else posted that Japan contributed 9 Billion - with their population being less than half of the US population that would make them more generous than the US.

James

by cactus pete

I think the US SHOULD keep its money - and stay out of the entire issue.

Unfortunately, the trade agreement currently being negotiated with Thailand - who makes CHEAP generic AIDS drug - will force them to stop producing these generic drugs.

Sounds like the Pharms are raping everyone, every time.

by admin

I want to know by what measure these wars will be won:

1. The War On Poverty
2. The War On Drugs
3. The War On Terrorism
4. The War On AIDs

I don't recall us having an official War on WMD's, but maybe I missed that one.

I liked having wars where you knew that when a particular property line was held or objective reached or surrender was accepted and we could rejoice that it was over.

By what measure will these wars be won? How much will they truly cost us until they are won? When can we have the parade?

by maxwell edison

.
1. The War on Poverty:

To a large degree, people who remain in "poverty" (whatever the heck that is), do so by choice (and I'm talking about in America). Their own choices and their own decisions determine their own outcome. Moreover, even if they remain in "poverty" (whatever the heck that is), they're hurting no one but themselves. (They "choose" to be dependent on a government instead of "choosing" to take personal responsibility - if you can't afford kids, then don't have them, etc.) Yes, I truly believe that, and if "they" believed it as well, they'd be taking a large first step outta' there. (And I did say "to a large degree", not in all cases.)

2. The War on Drugs:

Again, the people who choose to use drugs, are choosing their own lifestyle. Not considering drug related crimes, which is a "crime" issue, not a "drug" issue, these people are hurting no one but themselves. They choose their lifestyle, so let them be responsible for their own outcome. Let them hit "rock bottom". Let them make their own choice between life and death. Don't "enable" them. We've become a nation of enablers.

3. The War on Aids:

Aids is caused by, at least in 99 percent of the cases, personal behavior (At one time, it was 100 percent). Peoples' behavior is a matter of choice. A person can make the choice to always remain in a monogamous relationship, and in such cases aids would never be an issue. Aids in the blood supply is certainly a related issue, and one that should be addressed separately from the "behavior" issue, but it was personal behavior that started the whole thing. No, I'm not suggesting that science stop trying to find a cure, but let's call it want it really is - a behavioral related disease, and STRONGLY EMPHASIZE that different personal behavior choices can also keep it at bay.

So those first three are, in a large part, people making personal decisions that determine their own individual outcome. Trying to "fight a war" to change peoples' behavior and individual choice will always be a losing battle.

The war on terrorism, however, is a war against those who wish to inflict harm on others (even including others who make bad individual choices that result in bad individual outcomes). And we can't identify one nation-state that harbors it, because it knows no borders. But it still must be fought, nonetheless.

When is the parade, you ask? When all the Islamic nations of the world, in concert, denounce terrorism, with no exceptions; when all the Arabs of the world, in concert, and without exception, accept the Jewish people as having a right to exist; when the Arab and Islamic hatred of the "western world" is replaced with acceptance; when the world has been free of any acts of terrorism for at least a couple of years; and when the preverbal snowball really stays frozen in hell, we can then have a parade.

(I'm not sure "ALL" those things can be won, per se, at least in our lifetimes, but I do think they can be somewhat contained.)

by oz_media

Ok Max, while I don't COMPLETELY agre ewith your thoughts on Wlefar (poverty) I noticed that you did say "a large degree" and not all of them. Perhaps weeding out the abusers would help increase funds for those that are legitimately in need.

With respect to your comments about 'if you can't afford children, don't have 'em' I agree here for the most part too, although I do know a coupld of people who HAD support and a father who became a deadbeat and slit leaving them to it, we need to be able to support those who have not made a CHOICE this way but circumstance has landed them there.

I see a MAJOR problem with this though and that is, how do you segregate the good from bad without descriminating? Much like finding that elusive line between SPAM and false positives.

oen thing I certainly agree with is your saying they are the same, except I am sure i see it in a different way.

I generally feel these PEOPLE ARE the SAME PEOPLE for each group.

Poverty often leads to drug use, which leads to crime, which leads to Aids.

Solving poverty would solve most other issues or at least make the bad ones stand out against what is now a grey background.

So it's easy, lets just stop poverty! Uhhh, ok...easier said than done I suppose.

I think our governments have both jostled ideas on this subject since the day they were established (or whatever it's called when a government is formed)and nobody yet has reached a conlusive or decisive answer. I would even be willin gto see them try your own ideas of slicing welfare and medical support all together for a while, I think it will be more detrimental than helpful but it's at least something new to try.

So while you see these subjects as related I also see the PEOPLE in all of them s related too, same person, different stage of life, or poverty.

by nd_it

Is a complicated issue for any politician, whether it's a Democrat or Repulican. I do think there needs to be a goverment assistance in place for those that truly need it. Some people get into circumstances that are beyond their control and need to have the government help, whether it be food stamps or welfare to get back on their feet. I know some people who were embarrased to "ask for help" because of their beliefs and values in the way they should live their lives and work hard to get back on their feet. Others, on the other hand will gladly except a check from the goverment. IMO, for those people that are struggling, but making an effort to get back on their feet should have some assistance programs and/or tax breaks until their reach a finacial status. But again, it goes back to the question of who really does need it and who doesn't.

by admin

The war against Islamic and Arab radicals could be won, just as when the western powers united and won the war against Germany and Japan. This of course would be similar in that after crushing certain ways of governing and thinking we all would help the remaining Islamic and Arab people. It certainly has worked out pretty well in Japan and Germany in retrospect.

I am afraid that these goals, this war against Islamic and Arab nations is NOT what has been declared though. In fact, it has been made clear a number of times that the War on Terrorism is NOT a war against any particular group. As much as I would like it to be against Bin Laudin's group and specific to 9/11 it is much more broad and general than that and includes "Acts of Terror" by whomever, whenever, wherever.

I like your goals instead of the general war because they are quantifiable:

"When all the Islamic nations of the world, in concert, denounce terrorism, with no exceptions; when all the Arabs of the world, in concert, and without exception, accept the Jewish people as having a right to exist; when the Arab and Islamic hatred of the "western world" is replaced with acceptance; when the world has been free of any acts of terrorism for at least a couple of years"

This would be much more clear and some specific public statements and 2 years without an Islamic or Arabic act of terror is acheivable.

If you are correct, and our real goal is as you state, why do you think the President is so reluctant to explicitly state this? Or has he?
I am not aware of a statement that the War on Terror is in fact specifically only a war on certain Arab and Islamic factions. If it is, I would gladly agree with you and thank-you for enlightening me. :)

by oz_media

This morning's newspaper has an article on how American pharmaceutical companies are ofefering Canadian doctors immense sume of money to fill prescriptions for American patients and supply OUR low cost drugs to meet a US demand.

Based on your theories, I say no way, get your own drugs if our socialost medicine is so horrible.

No need though, the government has already said it will impse massive penalities against Canadian doctors who supply US patients with low cost Canadan drugs. One such doctor oin Richmond, recently faced over $250,000.00 in fines for just such an action. If the privatized pharmaveutical industry takes a hold in Canada, we will be up the creek without a paddle and will be forced to become pharmacy junkies looking for the best deal on the latest drugs. So I say, no way, we aren't goin to supply the US.

Why - should the CANADA foot the US PHARMACEUTICAL problem...find your own drugs.

ECHO.......

by skipperusn

Don't like it when you have to pay for others do you Oz... Hum ... But its OK the USA foots the bill for AIDS ...

How about 14 billion from us is more than enough - and no more - Not another farthing - drama - euro - penny - na-da - zippo - zero - let someone else do it ... I named Canada and France - could be Germany and Great Britian - Austrial and South Africa - Iran and Israli - or any other nation... time others step up to the plate ... the USA will sit down - as you all want us to ... no problem..

by oz_media

I couldn't care less if you pay up or not, it is not OUR issue as Canada DOES spend in te fight to stop AIDS and is among the top contributors.

Not to mention, Canadians have made some remarkable medical breakthoughs over the years that have saved many lives in the US as well as around the world.

Our medical research companies are the equivalientof your military, we heavily support and equip our biomedical research labs, so we aren't the slouches on this matter. If YOU don't want to spend, don't. From my prespective, no matter how much of my tax money it takes, or how little of yours, if AIDS is prevented, reduced, stopped, or cured I am all for it. Talk about putting your money to good use, I do have a very close friend who is HIV positive, I cannot see a cure before he passes but would love to see and end to this horrible disease sometime. NOW this I would declare MASS DESTRUCTION.

by oz_media

This is Amerian privatized (non-socialist)pharmaceutical companies asking Canadian doctors to fill prescriptions for US patients.

ONE benefit to having a socialized medical system is that the government oversees and regulates our doctors and pharmaceuticals. This way we not only have consistency and control of our drugs but also it stops a hell of a lot of spam for pharmaceutical and enhancment companies, even though we still get it all from the US, even though the offers are available IN the US anyway. I call this clever target marketing and a great way to waste marketing dollars.

As for YOU always footing the bill for everyone else, don't flatter yourself. You take as much as you give to other countries, if not monetarily it is in resources. America requires MANY countries to fill it's demands, it in turn provides to a lot of countries too. We called this sharing when we were kids and were encouraged to do it, what happened in your scary childhood to teach you otherwise?

Here's a good answer, stop sending us money. We will prevent you logging our forests, you are gonna piss off a LOT of american people and companies that are in BC and logging our forests.

Stop fishing our waters, no more Pacific salmon for your lunch.

Stop asking for us to power California from our Capilano water shed. You may have to explain to the guys in LA why it is so damn cold and dark though.

You seem to think you are the world's providers and not takers fro others, think again, it's a two way street. But if you can get GWB to ditch NAFTA, we'd be better off and I may even support the little liar.

by maxwell edison

.
Africa News Service
Uganda: Getting Out of Rural Poverty By Exporting Rare Insects

Kampala, Feb 06, 2004 (UN Integrated Regional Information Networks/All Africa Global Media via COMTEX) -- For many people in Uganda, an impoverished, war-torn country, escaping the harsh conditions of rural poverty is a daunting task. But a young Ugandan seeking to do just that recently stumbled upon a dream money-spinner: he collects rare insects from the country's lush tropical forests, pickles them and exports them to wealthy private collectors.

----------

Lessons from Uganda on Strategies to Fight Poverty
Countries receiving debt relief under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries initiative will be among the first to benefit from the new World Bank-International Monetary Fund approach to strengthening the impact on poverty of concessional assistance in low-income countries. The new approach features a more inclusive and participatory process for helping recipient countries develop poverty reduction strategies. From these strategies, joint Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs) will bring together the country's own priorities and Bank-Fund assistance to the country.

In Uganda, such a strategy has existed for several years. Uganda was one of the first low-income countries to prepare a comprehensive national strategy for poverty reduction using a participatory approach. Indeed, its experience contributed substantially to the design of the PRSPs. Uganda's top leadership is heavily committed to poverty reduction. Formulation of Uganda's Poverty Eradication Action Plan (PEAP) in 1996-97 was the executive branch's effort to make that commitment and vision operational.

----------

Uganda is one of the few African countries where HIV prevalence rates are declining, and it is seen as a rare example of success in a continent which is facing a severe AIDS crisis. Uganda's policies are credited with having brought the prevalence rate down from higher than 30% in the early 90s to around 6% last year. The country is seen as having implemented a well-timed and successful public education campaign, reducing the numbers of people indulging in casual sex as well as significantly cutting the HIV prevalence rate.

More and more money is being channeled to Africa through faith-based organizations, especially by the US which has pledged $15 billion to fight HIV/AIDS in resource-poor countries. Uganda is lucky enough to be one of the countries on President Bush's list and many other countries are being urged to follow it's example.

Given that a number of other countries with a high HIV prevalence are being urged to examine what has happened there, the policies in Uganda could ultimately effect the spread of HIV across many other parts of the world. But the results seen in Uganda don't have a simple recipe, and with so many lives and such large sums of money at stake, it is important to look carefully at what has been done there.

In 1986 President Yoweri Museveni responded to the emerging HIV crisis in Uganda swiftly, embarking on a nationwide tour to tell people that avoiding AIDS was a patriotic duty, and that they should abstain from sex before marriage and then go on to remain faithful to their partners.

----------

It looks to me like some folks in Uganda realize that simply treating the symptoms is an effort in futility. Treating the underlying causes is what will result in ultimate success.

by oz_media

But I really liked the enterprising kid who is exporting rare bugs, what a clever little bugger! In my books, he deserves every single cent he can get, well done for finding SOME way to earn a life!

by garion11

James K. Glassman: Little show of gratitude for a job well done

July 15, 2004

THIS week, Bangkok has hosted 20,000 delegates from 160 countries - along with celebrities such as Ashley Judd, Richard Gere, Oprah Winfrey and Rupert Everett - at the 15th international conference to fight AIDS. But, as usual at these global extravaganzas, the real agenda is to kick the US in the butt.

Never mind that US taxpayers will provide more money this year to fight AIDS than the governments of the rest of the world combined. Never mind that US research and development has given the world the drugs that prevent a diagnosis of HIV infection from becoming a death sentence.

Americans are the villains. US officials are shouted down at press conferences. Journalists stampede to childish demonstrations featuring placards of President George W. Bush smeared with blood.

The conference co-chairman says it is shameful that the US delegation isn't larger. Everett declared at a press event that what is "extremely frightening about PEPFAR [the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief] is its judgmental attitude towards this subject we are dealing with - sex".

Nonsense. Prevention is a big part of PEPFAR's mandate and the US gives away more condoms to developing nations than any other country. US policy supports the ABC program that has worked so well in Uganda: abstain, be faithful and use condoms.

Since it's hard to ignore that the US gives out bushels of money to fight AIDS, Americans are vilified, as in a flyer from the group Health GAP, for promoting "treatment and prevention plans that pander to conservative religious special interests and to the powerful American pharmaceutical lobby". This, too, is nonsense. Randall Tobias, the President's energetic AIDS czar, in charge of dispensing $US15 billion ($20.6 billion) to battle the disease in 15 poor countries during the next five years, says loud and clear that he will buy drugs made in any nation - including (inappropriately, in my view) Indian knock-offs of medicines invented and patented by US firms that have spent billions on R&D.

The only stipulation: the drugs have to be safe and effective. In other words, no double standards. The US, unlike groups such as Doctors Without Borders, whose haughty officials are ubiquitous at the conference, respects the right of Africans to be treated with the same high-quality drugs as Europeans and Americans.

Tobias has even made it cheaper and faster to get approval but, so far, not a single copycat drug company has applied for clearance. Oh, and by the way, the activists say that's the US's fault, too.

I attend two or three global health and environmental conferences similar to this each year and I have come to conclusion that it's time for the US Government and US businesses to just say no. Yankee, stay home. Or go to Africa, where those we help appreciate us. Yes, Americans should continue to fight AIDS with all the resources we can muster. It is the most important humanitarian cause in the world. But do it on the ground in poor countries and at serious academic conclaves, not at sicko carnivals such as this one.

What Americans are doing to fight AIDS in Africa - an effort I saw first-hand last December - is inspirational, even breathtaking. But in Bangkok there is no word of thanks to the US or to Bush, far and away the world's top leader in the battle against the disease.

Just as vexing, the official US exhibition at the conference features no picture of Bush, no American flags. America's own AIDS executives appear embarrassed to be identified as Americans. To be fair, this is the pattern throughout the world. The US spends billions on global welfare, but we're afraid to tell anyone. Instead, every American should be proud that while the European sophisticates sneer and the noisy activists shout, the US does something significant to fight a disease that infects 40 million people worldwide and kills 3 million a year.

Americans are inventing the drugs, building the hospitals, training the healthcare workers, caring for the patients, nurturing the orphans and providing the hard cash. Americans are nuts, however, to walk around with a "kick me" sign on their backs. The next one of these meetings is set for Toronto, August 13-16, 2006. That week, Americans should be in Africa and Asia helping people with AIDS, not in Canada fending off insults from ingrates and morons.

James K. Glassman is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington and host of TechCentralStation.com.

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,10137636%5E7583,00.html

by skipperusn

Your brain working slowly and get an after brain idea - or do you just like posting to your own posts...

Do you ever post to technical stuff - or just the geopolitical stuff...

by cactus pete

The post to which you replied was a reply to your earlier post. He simply posted two replies to yours.

If you don't mind, at least practice what you preach.

by oz_media

Ther are supposed to be posted in the Technical Q&A forums, which YES I do participate in daily and offer help that is rewarded by the TR points system.

Discussion Center Activity -- Jay has posted comments to the Discussion Center

Technical Q&A Activity -- Jay has not participated in Technical Q&A.

So it looks as if it's the pot calling the kettle black here Skipper. You have lots to say btu offer no help to those with technical questions.
I, on the other hand, participate equally between both, thanks for bringing this to my attention. credibility on TR comes from a community perspective. We often argus here but will help one another and agree in the Tech Q&A section, that's where we learn to respect one another and gain credibility. Not just from shooting our mouths off. as I explained to Garion, yuo want respect, you want credibility and people to not think you ae an idiot?

become a valuable member of the IT and TR community, put your money where your mouth is and help a few people with your vast knowledge.

or if you prefer PUT UP OR SHUT UP.

by skipperusn

I elected myself - I work within the political system - now they may not like my suggestions - but I am an American and write my congressman, Senator and President - with my suggestions.

Do You - write to the PM of Canada - and your regional representatives? Or whatever they are called just wondering if you write your elected leaders -

So I elected myself - each american can voice their ops to their senators and congressman and president - or any elected offical.. Gee thats called a Representative Republic - not a democracy ... Dam that how the US government was set up -

by oz_media

My local MP is my former Science teacher so we know each other well.

As for writing our government, what for? Is there something I need changed? Everything works for me, I am not threatened, I am not stilfed, I am not restricted from anything, why would I write to our PM?

by jimhm

Other posts I've read you - that there were things about the Canadian government you didn't like .. Now its all peaches and cream...

Hum - well that great - to bad we can't say the same thing south of you ...

Hey Skipper - maybe we should Imagrate to Canada...

by justmakingit

Unlike America, we Canadians are able to knock on the door of our elected officals to voice our opinions, we don't have to write them.

by oz_media

I know BC's parliment buildings are open to public most of the day, most of BC's government reps live in Vancouver or Victoria/suburbs.

They are not surrounded by armed guards or secret service (well perhaps Paul Martin is escorted by RCMP color guards). I suppose they have nothing to fear for the most part except the odd wierdo)and have nobody that cares enough to want even bother doing harm to them. In fact if Paul Martin (even though I know who he is) was to walk into 7/11 while I was there he would probably go unnoticed by meself and anyone else in the store.
He's justs a guy with a job, a working class stiff like the rest of us.

I remember seeing Campbell at a BC lions game, he was with a friend or associate not a body guard, I didn't even notive him (and nobody else seemed to) until they pointed him out on the big screen.

Nobody made a fuss, the game began and he paid for ALL his beers just like anyone else. Who the hell cares, again, just a dude with a job.

by skipperusn

We also can pick up the phone - send email - or travel to their local offices or state / federal offices - and knock.. But to get to see them is normally an appointment.

See the USA has many more citizens than Canada - and that requires more effort.

Hey - can't help it our government wants to protect our leaders - and most of the time they do go a little overboard about it. But then again that us crazy Americans - always over doing things...

by maxwell edison

.
I've always suggested the same thing. The problems I have with it, however, is epitomized in the word "entitlement". Entitlement - entitled to something - WRONG!

No one is entitled to be given money (cash, goods, or services) that was taken by another person by force. The only such "entitlement" payments are retirement benefits for GIs, and other similar people who "earned" it. "Earned" is the key word here, not to be confused with a "gift" or "charity".

And the government should be the last resort, not the first stop. And what's wrong with repaying such assistance? People pay back school loans, at least the responsible ones do, so why not hold people responsible to pay back other type of assistance?

Change the dialogue from the "entitlement" mentality to one of temporary assistance. Quit making the government a permanent source of income for people. And yes, it took 70 years to get to this point, and it will take another 70 to get back to where we should be. But it's time we change the direction of the pendulum, and change the premise of the dialogue. No one is "entitled" to a free lunch - and I don't care how well intentioned it may be.

After all, we've all heard the saying, "the road to hell is paved with good intentions". And if we don't get off this road we've been on for 70 years, our kids and grandkids will have hell to pay.

by oz_media

It may surprise you somewhat to find out that first, Canadian welfare is 60% below the poverty level, we are not giving people anything they couldn't earn from merely breathing or collecting bottles (actually turning into quite a trade these days).
Welfare is extremely hard for most Canadians to collect, they are scrutinized more each year, in order to get a welfare check in Vancouver you need to provide documentation from EI stating you are not eligible for benefits (emploment insurance). THEN you have to attend two days at a local job finding club and register for their program (6 days of resume and interview skills and job hunting help provided by adult education center and funded by the government). Having completed this, if you STILL haven't found work, you are given a worksheet to fill our all the names of the places you have aplied for work. These are rendomly checked, time permitting, by case workers at the welfare office before a check is issued. You then get another appointment to arrange for support, take all your expense records and bank statement to the welfare office. Shoudl your bank accoutn show you have no money, your rent receipts show yuo pay rent and your family history questioning shows that you are unable to find help anywhere else, you have no car to sell, no property of any value, THEN you will be rewarded with a check for a whopping $553.00 canadian.

Personally, I could think of MUCH easier ways to earn $500.00 that trying to get welfare. With the effort needed nowdays you could easily earn $1000.00 in the same amount of time if you were capable.

So they are placing more and mroe raodblocks in the way, more and more restrictions in the way and making it much harder and far less desireable to collect welfare in Canada.

Welfare levels in British Columbia have dropped immensely, I forget the numbers but it was in a recent newspaper, something to the effect of 14% drop in BC recipients due to the low amount offered and the amount of time and work to get a check.

It used to be, apply at 2:30 and come back at 4:00 for your check, still $500.00 in the 80's and much more acceptable. People (not that I knew personally of course!)would all live in a party house and all apply for welfare on a wednesday afternoon (all gainfully employed by the way)and return with several thousand dollars that afternoon. The keg would be delivered shortly after (so I hear) the girls and party favours would show up son after. That is after spending the whole afternoon watching Vancouvers finest A-Class exotic entertainment at the local (so I am told).

It definitely is less of s cop out now and many have been weeded out, those that are FORCED to live on suport are usually busy workin godd jobs, collecting bottles etc. to try and make it through the month, ntobody gets a free ride anymore.

Just thought I'd outline just how easy it is to aquire funds from a 'socialist' country.

by oz_media

The title was about paying it back. Well after the daiting task of 'qualifying' for welfare, many will be given TEMPORARY assistance and not a continued omnthly check. They will then be expected to repay any monies in full when they are employed. Now this generally applies to people who collect welfare while waiting for EI benefits to kick in,. by the time they get their EI benefits, the government wants the welfare finds back. then EI finds out you collected welfare and garnishes you EI payout.

yes it is definitely in people's better interests to find a job, even if it's crime.

Yet we still have those people who saw how easy it was in the 80's and have worked ever since who take the attitude that WELFARE MUST pay me they have no choice, nor is it their job to decide who;s eligible, it's a government service and they are government employees hired to hand out checks. It's funny when they return with the
long faced, 'I didn't get any money
look
.

by dwdino

WMD is a global problem because its purpose is to harm neighbors, enemies, others. Therefore the threat of such is thrown upon all nations.

HIV is an issue of responsibility. Persons are reaping the results of their choices.

If a nation chooses to support another, that is the donors choice. No nation is obligated to another (excluding treaties/agreements).

The U.N. can go ... anyway ... (would be banned for comments).

Also, the cure for AIDS has been known for centuries.

1) abstinance
2) monogomy
3) faithfulness
4) responsibility - if your infected refrain from any sexual activity, drugs, children etc.

Harsh, yes. Necessary, definitely. When dealing with polio, plague, other epedemics, persons are isolated, sometimes with treament, sometimes to perish.

But these steps would eliminate aids (barring blood transfusion or accidents). As with any enemy (speaking of the virus), you identify, contain, destroy.

For instance, I work in the medical field. While waiting to assitant a client in a clinic I picked up an HIV publication. Mostly, the articles entailed treatments, social issues, etc.

Then, one article absolutely pissed me off! This article was the story of an HIV positive male who picked up a female friend. Both had knowledge of his HIV status. They decided to have sex. Just before, he prepared to "protect" himself. She said don't bother, he conceded.

The article went on to describe how great it was and this was just what he needed, blah, blah, ... This man should be tried and convicted of attempted murder or torture as HIV is a long death.

It is this kind of irresponsibility that has made HIV such a problem to begin with.

When inidividuals want to treat the cause, not just the symptoms, come back and talk.

by skipperusn

So true - Most of it is by choice - Welfare (in the US) - Drugs - AIDS - all are 99% by choice - now the new born didn't have a choice - but his/her parents did..

Let the world - take care of itself... these socialist are ungratful and just want more - because we have more - and we should give it all away until we are as poor as they are... Boo Hoo..

by sullyman

You keep calling the rest of the world socialist, do you even now what that means? If you did you would know that the majority of the world is in fact not socialist. You know what, you want to keep your money, then keep it. Evade your representation for the rest of your life, try and stay out of jail. Richer countries have a MORAL responsibility to assist other countries, in fact the US was supported by the French and British when it was first colonized.

by maxwell edison

.
I haven't examined all the "details" (the devil is in the details, so to speak), but the gist of my idea would be something like this.

Initiate a 50 year plan to reduce the size and scope of our government's "transfer of wealth" programs - ALL of them, including welfare, Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. We need to wean people off dependence on the government - even for their medical and retirement needs - and emphasize life-long personal responsibility. We reduce the "forced transfer of wealth" that pays for these programs by 2 percent a year for 50 years. Heck, I might suggest that a good 20 percent is lost through mismanagement, waste and fraud, so cutting 2 percent a year should be easy.

But what to do with the 2 percent per year reduction? Half of it, 1 percent, is simply no longer collected from the wage earners who pay for the programs. The other 1 percent is collected, but not paid to anyone. Instead, it's put into an endowment fund that is truly separate from all other functions of government. We let this endowment fund grow and grow for 50 years, at which time NO money will have to be taken from anyone to pay for those deemed "truly needy". Sure, the government will have a program to help them, but they won't have to play Robin Hood to do it.

An endowment fund such as that, would have grown to an enormous amount of money over 50 years, and the continuing interest gained from such an account would be all that's necessary to pay for the assistance. The interest pays for the programs, and the principle is never reduced. Many schools, especially higher-education institutions, have such endowment funds to grant tuition assistance - that never has to be paid back. But they use only the interest gained, never dipping into the principle.

And if the principle fund is ever in danger of being reduced, which is not likely if the "personal responsibility" expectation is successfully achieved, a "call for help" - voluntary, of course, is put out to keep it at adequate levels.

Okay, look for the devil that must be in the details.

by nd_it

Sounds pretty good. The only issue I see is the amount of assistance that would be rewarded to those that really need it to get themselves started again. An example of the higer education institutions is they rate on how much assitance you get from your parents financial status as well as other things, but generally look at just the salary your parent(s) bring in and base it off of that, but in reality, the parents would have a tough time making a loan payment because of other expenses, even though they look at your assets as well. So little Johnny heading off to college gets assistance from the school, but only enough to pay for one class and a couple books, the rest he has to come up with on his own.

by admin

hehe.. that's a good plan. You would have to stay in office for all 50 years to make sure it didn't get modified when there got to be enough money in it though!

:)

by garion11

reinstate the draft, require all 18 year olds to serve in the military for atleast 2 years. They will learn all that they have to, LOL.

Little punks scream and bitch about freedom and stuff, lets goo..let them see what freedom and democracy are and sometimes its cost. Thats one of the major problems with this country, too many people take things for granted (I have been guilty of that myself, I admit) and this will teach these dumba**es all the personal responsibility in the world.

NOW GIVE ME 20 SOLDIER! :)

by maxwell edison

.
I have a problem with the 48 to 58 year olds who are still in the same mind-set they had when they were 18, you know the "give peace a chance" crowd. They're old enough, or should be, to know better.

If you were to look at polling data, you'd discover that the politically aware 18-24 year olds are typically much more conservative than liberal. Yea, there are some who are misguided by their "old hippie" parents, but they're the exception, not the rule.

A quote:

"In contrast to many suggestions that 18-24 year olds are alienated from politics, the survey shows most young people are involved in and aware of politics. For example, 88.1 percent of those surveyed said that they were registered to vote and 76.9 percent said that they were likely to vote in national elections. 61.7 percent said that they followed political news some of the time and 29.4 percent said that they followed it all of the time."
- Zogby International in 2000

Who would they (18-24 year olds) vote for in the 2000 election?

George W. Bush - 44.5 percent.

Al Gore - 32.8 percent

Here are the words of one such young conservative:

----------

Don?t Save The Whales, Save Yourself!

An unholy combination of liberal social engineering and a mistaken interpretation of Christian charity is the second greatest threat to humanity. The greatest threat is Islamic fascism, whether terrorists or governments advance it. The second is subtler; well meaning, misguided idealists are using the powers of government to subvert natural selection. This column will not address the origin of life or species, which evolution cannot adequately explain.

Natural selection is the process through which species adapt to changes in environment. Superior species survive and reproduce, passing on genetic traits best suited to their environment. Inferior species lack adaptability and eventually become extinct. It is the survival of the fittest. Our environment is in constant flux; it produces ice ages, warm periods and changes in weather patterns. Our ability to thrive in various climates and even our skin pigmentation and body types are due to natural selection. Bacteria and viruses adapt and mutate as well, producing new diseases that can devastate populations; our immunities to diseases are the result of natural selection. Man is not excluded from the laws of nature; superior species must adapt even to the influence of man.

Interconnectivity is exaggerated. Dinosaurs were once the dominant species; their mass extinction did not threaten all life on earth; to the contrary, it enabled the prosperity of mammals. To measure the impact of an extinction, one must ask what other species eat the endangered animal with exclusivity. For instance, few species fed exclusively upon woolly mammoths or saber toothed tigers; their extinction had little impact. Similarly, the extinction of whales, manatees, spotted owls, eagles and alligators may be a loss from an aesthetic view but would have little negative effect on other species. Likewise, more common animals are not indispensable. If dogs, cats, horse, etc. became extinct; it would not imperil life on earth. Even if cows were to suddenly disappear, humans who rely on cows for food might switch to venison or chicken for meat and goats for milk, we would not starve - we would adapt.

The giant panda cannot adapt; its diet consists mainly (99%) of 9 varieties of bamboo. The panda requires a minimum of 26 - 33 lbs. of bamboo per day. Bamboo is becoming less available and pandas are nearing extinction.

Fortunes are being spent to save the panda - why? No species requires panda meat for survival. The panda is an inferior species. In his folly, man is resorting to cloning to defy the laws of nature under the banner of protecting nature.

As the science of cloning progresses it will be increasingly employed to preserve not only rare animals, but also particularly admirable specimens (such as show dogs) and even humans. A clone is an exact genetic copy of an existing organism. Cloning halts evolution and subverts natural selection. Absent gradual adaptation, species cannot survive environmental changes. Clones would perish when faced with an ice age or a new disease. Such mass extinction would have catastrophic consequences, as non-cloned species would not have the opportunity to adapt to the absence. Well meaning do-gooders could endanger all life on earth.

Similarly, social programs that minimize the negative consequences of human actions imperil our society. One learns what not to do through discomfort, for instance learning not to touch a hot stove by burning one?s hand. An 800 lb. woman was reported last week to have been unable to fit through the doorways of her public housing in Cleveland. A dozen firemen were required to remove her from her bedroom and transport her to the hospital. Taxpayers will now be required to build her new housing with doorways adequate for her girth, in addition to continuing to pay for her food, medical care, safety and all other needs. Such sloth is a flaw inherent to human nature, but a few generations ago it would not have been tolerated. She would have had to adapt to become a productive citizen or perish. She has become a giant panda.

Governmental social programs that protect the stupid, subsidize the lazy and coddle criminals are producing a society of giant pandas. If we continue to embrace this subversion of natural law, our nation will soon suffer the same fate as the panda. Don?t save the whales, save yourself!

----------

Here's another one:

----------

Question for America

"Leading up to Operation Iraqi Freedom president Bush was provided intelligence by the CIA and other intelligence agencies indicating that Saddam had and planned to use WMDs against the US. The CIA director claimed the WMDs would be a ?slam dunk.? Saddam was harboring terrorists, and rewarding Palestinian suicide bombers. Saddam had committed genocide on his own people resulting in mass graves containing over 300,000 people. The UN believed that Saddam had WMDs. Saddam was in violation of UN Resolution 1441, had kicked the UN inspectors out of Iraq, and the US was essentially blind because the CIA had no human sources in Iraq. Prior to the war Russian President Vladimir Putin warned President Bush that Saddam planned to attack the US both at home and abroad. After informing President Bush of this imminent threat however the UN Security Council members Russia and France (who presumable had the same intelligence) voted against UN involvement in the war. Had this intelligence been accurate, many American could have lost their lives because President Bush delayed attacking Iraq in an effort to gain UN approval to simply enforce its own resolution and protect the US from attack. President Bush was also armed with the knowledge that his predecessor, President Clinton, treated terrorism like a criminal investigation. Because of this he turned down the Sudan?s offers to arrest Osama because he did not have evidence that satisfied the ?beyond a reasonable doubt? standard, a standard so high that it resulted in OJ and Osama being free men today.

Now assume that Senator Kerry gets elected President. His CIA director claims that Osama is in Iran, he posses a briefcase bomb and plans to attack the US. President Kerry is assured that it is a ?slam dunk.? Russia and other intelligence agencies corroborate this position. The UN supports the findings. Given this scenario should President Kerry ignore the evidence and assume it is inaccurate? Should he spend precious time going to the UN for support, knowing full well that a weakened US in beneficial to the other Security Council members China, Russia and France? Or should he act boldly and in the best interest of America, form a coalition of the willing, and preemptively attack Iraq?"

(PAUSE: A Maxwell interjection here. The last word of the previous paragraph - Iraq - was, in my estimation, an intentional "error" to emphasize a point. Quite clever, if you ask me. Something I would do, and have done, myself.)

"This is the question America must ask itself, because it is very likely that this or a very similar scenario will face the next President of the United States of America. If you think America should act without the UN approval, as President Clinton did in Bosnia and President Bush did in Iraq, and attack preemptively; then you should vote for President Bush, and put your faith in the US Marines. If you think that the UN is the solution, and that law enforcement tactics, France and toothless resolutions will resolve the problem; then vote for President Kerry, and pray."

----------

Those are very wise words indeed, for a young 18-24 year old.

Credits: Those editorial comments were found on a "Young Conservative" Web site.

(And sure, there are, most likely, young liberals who are just as articulate.)

But when I was 18-24, I couldn't have come close to writing such a fine opinion piece. So let's give credit where credit is due.

by skipperusn

I like it - mandatory service just like Sweden - give them a chance to get money for college - a work ethic - some basic survial skills - displine -

And the military get loads of warm bodies - of course there goes my taxes - but what the heck its worth it..

by nd_it

I agree with the points that this "war on terror" is related to the 9/11, but not totally directed to Bin Laden. Even if we catch or kill him, which I think all of us would agree (except for MM of course)would like to see him dead, It is not going to stop terrorism in it's tracks. The terrorist in Iraq Al-Zaquri is actually competing with Bin Laden as the top leader in the Islamic extremest world! So, even though we get Bin Laden, that doesn't mean there won't be someone else to battle. And I for one would rather take the fight to them then have another 9/11 not matter where they are at.

by skipperusn

Its my money you socialist pig - and I don't want it going to that organization - Period -

I earned it - I spend it the way I want to - Who cares about how percaps - It my f'en money not yours or the worlds to dictate your socialist ways to ... Mine - I earned it - I spend it the way I see fit ... And I tell my government the way I want it spent...

And no more for that Puke Institution called the U.N. ...

You - socialist are all the same ...

by sullyman

Skipper watch your head on your gun rack in the truck, and go finish remodeling your lawn mower to do 35MPH. Post to the facts or don't bother posting at all.

First of all it's not your money ( taxes ), it's the USA's money. You voted for your representation ( I think you called it a republic reprsentation ), so send the IRS a note and tell them that you are keeping your PER CAPITA percentage of taxes that would go towards the War on Aids in your pocket. See how long you stay out of jail.

by jimhm

Gee - Skipper you peeved off the Sullyman - You can tell he is a socialist - its not your money its the governments money. You didn't earn it - Oh yea and all of a sudden the US now is paying a Per-Capta tax. So glade these folks know so much about the USA and its government than an American Citizen - kind of why they got booted 200+ years ago...

Gee and I always figured it was a Income Tax - Tax on Earned Income...

First Sullyman - it is our money - not the governments, if the majority of the US citizens decided not to pay the income tax - guess what there would be a change to the tax structure. Oh and there are at lease 12 current hearing going on about What is Earned Income - Dividends is not an earned income... hum non-taxable - And we are a free society - not a socialist society like GB (not GWB but Merry Old England) or are you a Monarchy??

The USA is one of the strongest economic power in the world because we are Capitalist, where the individual has the power to generate their own wealth.. And spends their wealth as they see fit - not the government or a collective of socialists..

by thechas

Since when does the desire to take the correct humanitarian action make one automatically a socialist?

There are 2 issues that the rest of the world has with the US reaction to AIDS.

1: Our Victorian insistence that the only way to eliminate AIDS is through sexual abstinence.

2: The fact that US drug companies own the majority of patents on drugs that fight AIDS.

So, until the US gets realistic, and adopts global standards for AIDS prevention, and works with the pharmaceutical companies to reduce the cost of treatment for third world countries, the rest of the world is right to call on the US for greater assistance.

Chas

by garion11

But demanding and excpecting to be "humanitarian" because he/she/it is rich IS ("from each according to his ability, to each according to his need"). I have no doubt US is doing a good job, but your failure to recongnize the patents that they do hold is a socialistc mindset ("abolition of private property"). Lets face it, patents don't pop out of thin air, these pharmaceutical companies invested YEARS, billions, and lots of man power to reasearch and devlop these drugs. They should have some say in how they are used, don't you think?

As far US policy is concerned, why should the US or any other country for that matter let UN decide how best to spend its money. Elimanate the middle man (UN) and go directly to the people that need it.

Here is an article from someone who has see this firsthand and his reaction. The Australian newspaper.

James K. Glassman: Little show of gratitude for a job well done

July 15, 2004

THIS week, Bangkok has hosted 20,000 delegates from 160 countries - along with celebrities such as Ashley Judd, Richard Gere, Oprah Winfrey and Rupert Everett - at the 15th international conference to fight AIDS. But, as usual at these global extravaganzas, the real agenda is to kick the US in the butt.

Never mind that US taxpayers will provide more money this year to fight AIDS than the governments of the rest of the world combined. Never mind that US research and development has given the world the drugs that prevent a diagnosis of HIV infection from becoming a death sentence.

Americans are the villains. US officials are shouted down at press conferences. Journalists stampede to childish demonstrations featuring placards of President George W. Bush smeared with blood.

The conference co-chairman says it is shameful that the US delegation isn't larger. Everett declared at a press event that what is "extremely frightening about PEPFAR [the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief] is its judgmental attitude towards this subject we are dealing with - sex".

Nonsense. Prevention is a big part of PEPFAR's mandate and the US gives away more condoms to developing nations than any other country. US policy supports the ABC program that has worked so well in Uganda: abstain, be faithful and use condoms.

Since it's hard to ignore that the US gives out bushels of money to fight AIDS, Americans are vilified, as in a flyer from the group Health GAP, for promoting "treatment and prevention plans that pander to conservative religious special interests and to the powerful American pharmaceutical lobby". This, too, is nonsense. Randall Tobias, the President's energetic AIDS czar, in charge of dispensing $US15 billion ($20.6 billion) to battle the disease in 15 poor countries during the next five years, says loud and clear that he will buy drugs made in any nation - including (inappropriately, in my view) Indian knock-offs of medicines invented and patented by US firms that have spent billions on R&D.

The only stipulation: the drugs have to be safe and effective. In other words, no double standards. The US, unlike groups such as Doctors Without Borders, whose haughty officials are ubiquitous at the conference, respects the right of Africans to be treated with the same high-quality drugs as Europeans and Americans.

Tobias has even made it cheaper and faster to get approval but, so far, not a single copycat drug company has applied for clearance. Oh, and by the way, the activists say that's the US's fault, too.

I attend two or three global health and environmental conferences similar to this each year and I have come to conclusion that it's time for the US Government and US businesses to just say no. Yankee, stay home. Or go to Africa, where those we help appreciate us. Yes, Americans should continue to fight AIDS with all the resources we can muster. It is the most important humanitarian cause in the world. But do it on the ground in poor countries and at serious academic conclaves, not at sicko carnivals such as this one.

What Americans are doing to fight AIDS in Africa - an effort I saw first-hand last December - is inspirational, even breathtaking. But in Bangkok there is no word of thanks to the US or to Bush, far and away the world's top leader in the battle against the disease.

Just as vexing, the official US exhibition at the conference features no picture of Bush, no American flags. America's own AIDS executives appear embarrassed to be identified as Americans. To be fair, this is the pattern throughout the world. The US spends billions on global welfare, but we're afraid to tell anyone. Instead, every American should be proud that while the European sophisticates sneer and the noisy activists shout, the US does something significant to fight a disease that infects 40 million people worldwide and kills 3 million a year.

Americans are inventing the drugs, building the hospitals, training the healthcare workers, caring for the patients, nurturing the orphans and providing the hard cash. Americans are nuts, however, to walk around with a "kick me" sign on their backs. The next one of these meetings is set for Toronto, August 13-16, 2006. That week, Americans should be in Africa and Asia helping people with AIDS, not in Canada fending off insults from ingrates and morons.

James K. Glassman is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington and host of TechCentralStation.com.

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,10137636%5E7583,00.html

by skipperusn

Lets see - how is aid spread (most common way) - not through kissing - hum - not through talking - breathing - eating - sleeping ... Hum can we say SEX! and IV Drugs! -

Is that a Controlable drive in a Human - YES - and you say "Our Victorian insistence that the only way to eliminate AIDS is through sexual abstinence." - DAH - How stupid are you ... If it is transmitted by sex - to reduce it - those that have it - Stop F'en - DAH - Hello! Victorian -

The You! (not you chas) the person that has aids is responsible to ensure YOU (yes You) don't spread it to others! But no You say its our victorian attitudes that should be challenged? That we should treat these people - Lets see the spread is around 1,500 percent in some countries .. can we say wear a Rubber! Can We Say keep it in your pants - or keep your knees together... Can We Say - take some responsibility for your own lives ...

Your BS just is just to freeking liberal - thats why AIDS is spreading - you want someone else to be responsible rather than holding them accountable.

by dwdino

...but the French and British did this with the desire to gain lands, wealth, and power. Therefore, that does not apply, as this is not colonization nor power struggles.

This is about people being responsible for their choices. No more "it's not my fault". Time to say, yes I got what I deserved, and now have to deal with it.

(note* Preceeding does not apply to those born into this situation, blood transfusion, etc.)

BTW, if we want to dive into morals, a large part of the HIV community would have no leg to stand on. What about their moral obligation not to infect another, be it lover, child, friend, etc. What about their moral obligation to not burden society with the cost of their choices.

Funny how low the percential of HIV infection is in abstaining, monogamous, heterosexual, drug-free persons. hmmmm......

by jimhm

Got to agree again ... It is their choice as you said (and again not new baby, blood transfusions)...

But these people like Sullyman - feel - it is our responsiblity to take care of them - feed them - pay for their medican - send doctors build hospitals... I say spend that 14 billion in the US for those uninsured people - it would be better spent.

Anytime you get something for nothing it isn't appreciated ... Look at the 14 billion we already gave - this arse wants more...

by jamesrl

Your last line kind of bugs me.

Before screening was done properly, people did contract AIDs through blood tranfusions, and I am sure that in the third world, this still happens. Tens of thousands of Canadians, and many Americans got Hepatitis C from the blood supply.

Not everyone who contracts AIDS is promiscuous. AIDS doesn't show up right away - in some people the symptoms are dormant for many months and perhaps more than a year. One person may unknowingly have AIDS, get into a monogamous relationship and pass it on before getting any symptoms.

Many children got AIDS because their mother got it. As to heterosexuality, thats the biggest growth area of AIDS - in Africa, its through heterosexual contact that AIDS is exploding.

So while I am sure you'd like to wipe your hands of it, unless your are a totally selfish individual, you can't.

No man is an island. Each man is part of the main.

Let me add - Let he who is without sin cast the first stone, and of course the golden rule - love one another.

While I don't like paying taxes, I don't mind that some taxes go for something things that are in the common interest - even Capitalists like Adam Smith(Wealth of Nations) recognise that there are common goals to which we all need to contribute in one way or another. Take education - without a public education system, our economy would not prosper and our streets would not be safe. You and I benefit from both - so we should not shirk from paying for it - how much is up to debate.

I'd like to say the same thing about AIDS - its is to your economic benefit and mine, as well as your social benefit and mine to fight AIDS. At since we all live on the same planet, we might just have to help each other - unless you want to put a wall around your country and do screenings before you let anyone from the outside in.

I'm not a socialist. But at the same time, I can't ignore my fellow man either.

James

by dwdino

First off, let me restate what I have put in every post so far:

Does not apply to blood transfusions, birth, or other involuntary acts...

Reading and understanding are two different things.

What I have said time and time again is to deal with the source not the symptoms.

It is like AA; one cannot deal with the problem until one admits they have the problem, that they are the source and root of the problem, and that they must change to resolve the problem.

And, the resolution is simple. Only have sex with one person of the opposite sex whom you marry. Don't use drugs. Don't get blood transfusions (LOL, a little humor to lighten).

Some of your points:

"Not everyone who contracts AIDS is promiscuous." - There are 4 generally accepted transmission paths: 1) Sex 2) Body Fluid Transfers 3) Birth 4) Drugs/Needles. Therefore, it pretty much falls into one of these categories.

"One person may unknowingly have AIDS, get into a monogamous relationship and pass it on before getting any symptoms." - Well, go back to abstinence. Also, it is the persons responsibility to check if active.

"Many children got AIDS because their mother got it." - Responsibility again...

"As to heterosexuality, thats the biggest growth area of AIDS - in Africa, its through heterosexual contact that AIDS is exploding." - Again, abstinence ...

"So while I am sure you'd like to wipe your hands of it, unless your are a totally selfish individual, you can't." - No, I want people to admit that they have received the rewards of their choices and must change their ways.

"Let me add - Let he who is without sin cast the first stone, and of course the golden rule - love one another." - It is love that makes one force another to see the truth.

The old proverb of the man banging his head on the wall comes to mind.

A traveler see another banging his head on the wall. The traveler asks if he is ok. No response. The towns people tell the traveler this is normal. The traveler pleads with the man to stop as this will hurt him. The banging continues. The traveler pulls the man away from the wall. The mans head keeps bobbing up and down as he walk back to wall and continues banging. The traveler is in awe. The traveler decides, to his own detriment he will place his hand between the man and the wall to protect him. The man's banging crushes the travelers hand causing the traveler to yell in pain. The man continues banging. The traveler scolds the man for not recognizing his attempts to help. The man keeps banging. The traveler makes one last effort, he leaves. He returns with a helmet for the man. He quickly slips it onto the man. The banging ceases. The traveler watches in bewilderment. The man seems perplexed. Then, the man removes the helmet and returns to banging. The traveler finaly decides he must leave the man to his folly and while leaving, whispers a word of hope that the man will see the error of his ways.

by jimhm

So what is the rest of the world ... Hum Sullyman - Skipper seems to have hit a raw nerve with you and Oz about being socialist or communists.

Now Oz doesn't like to be label - I guess your the same way... So what are you - and what is the rest of the world.

You say we have a Moral oblagtion - who says - you - The rest of the world - who made that rule. When England was the world power did they - Nope. Do you think China will when it becomes the world economic power house... Nope.

You all think you have all the answers - if they worked don't you think you would be back as a economic power ... Guess what - Your not - Socialist ideas don't work - communism doesn't work - nationalism doesn't work ... The only one that is working righ now - Gee can we say it ..

Dare I - Capitalism - A good old Free Economy - Works every time ... And gee China is getting the idea - look at that country so soon after getting back Honkong from the British. They see the light of economic power - is the freedom of a capitalist society ... Japan - hum worked well for them ...

Gee so tell me what is the rest of the world - what is Great Britian - What is Canada - If it Looks like a Duck - Walks Like a Duck and Sounds like a Duck - Then Its a DUCK..

by sullyman

The moral obligation comes from inside, in comes from a genuine caring for your fellow man. Morality is not a rule; it?s a concept and an ideal. I have never said I have all the answers, nor would I even begin to think that.

But, this whole conversation started when Skipper thought the good ?ol USA was the only country in the world who was giving money to AIDS and famine causes. The dollar amount is secondary to the PER CAPITA spending of the country on world issues.

What do you mean by we would return as an economic power? We aren?t? Could have fooled the UN, US, ASIA, CUBA, EUROPE, AFRICA, AUSTRALIA - Canada is one of the top trading partners with the US.

How sad it is when someone actually is trying to convince others that the US is of the only CAPITALIST countries in the world?..

by jimhm

There are many in the US that are getting fed up with the world - bitch about the US doing this - then bitching because we aren't doing that.

Well - many of us are to the point of to hell with you all - you try to help here - and you are wrong - you don't help over here - you are wrong ... you give 14 Billion to this - well thats not enough - you have a moral obligation.

If you get slammed on everything you do - you get to the point of doing nothing ... and that is were many of us are - We Will Do Nothing - rather than even trying..

So accept what we have given (14 Billion) - and if that isn't enough - then dig in your own pockets and complete that moral oblagtion you feel we should of... And why don't you - since you feel its a moral oblagtion - you should pick up the ball and run with it... since in your eyes the US dropped the ball...

by oz_media

How do you consider canada is a socialist coutry wheras America is not? In detail, in the meantime I will look for James Linn's most excellent comparisson that shows what little difference there is between our governments support systems. James knows a billion times more than I do about Canada's government and he recently showed it very clearly and vey well how we are really not nor haev we ever been a socialist nation.

Funny though,m the two peopl ecalling canadians socialists ar eboth pig headed American ex-military members. Hmmm, go figure. Oh yes an dthe commie thing is the same with BOTH of you guys, oh and the hmmm's and hum's, did yuo build a clone? Oh my GOD JIM IS CLONING HIMSELF! THE WORLD IS DOOMED. I'd support that invasion with any amount of haste, invade Jim's house.

Actually I'll wait for your reply, it won't have enough substance to warrant a search.

by jimhm

Look I don't mind learning something - I do have an open mind - I will accept new concepts - I don't see that coming from your side.

If it is explained logically and has proof I can accept that... So what is Canadian form of government - its not a representative republic - right - It has a PM which is elected by the parties elected - correct - so if the part-a has the most members - then the PM is a part-a person right...

Is it like GB - being a Parlimary form of government - that is very confusing to watch a session on how anything gets done...

If you read the book of Max - there are a number of taxes changed in the US by Clinton to prevent the passing along of wealth to your family (which is a Maxist/socialist form of Government). Clinton raised the tax to over 50% over $600,000 - and increasing as the wealth increases ...

So yes - if you or Jim (and I like his posts) would care to explain the Canadian or GB form of government - I will be all eyes...

by garion11

I thought you didn't want us around? We are too arrogant, too ignorant, too in your face type attitude. Now you are telling me that rich countries have a MORAL resoponsitiblity to assist other countries?

Assist them in what way? What EXACTLY should the rich countries do? What do you consider assistance?

by oz_media

You cut off Canada wecut off Ametrica. Who wins? It certainly wouldn't be america and I don't think Canada would be a winner either. We both rely heavily on each others resources, Canada is RICH with resources especially the West. We have one of the largest sources of natural gas, lumber, hydro electric power and sealife.

by garion11

Now go back to the poster who I responded to and then trace it back down to my questions. Hopefully you will get a better understanding of the situation.

by oz_media

Not to drag this out, but from what I have seen presented recenlt, we are no nearer to being a socialist country than the USA is.

There's a very well worded explanation from someone MUCH more politically aware than either of us or your alter ego, James Linn who has studied political science (hope that's right) in Canada for some time now.

Search out James's discussions, and you will see first hand how we are NOT really any different than you are with our medical and welfare programs, those you deem make us socialists even though we have never had a socialist government in office.

by oz_media

we have even had americans try to claim refugee status at teh Canadian border, no go, they were sent home.

But if you really paid attention to my last post, NO I don't think our government is perfect but they stay out of my face, unlike GWB and the US government.

Our government is as screwed up as any, but they don't wage war or create enemies the way you seem to. therefor eit is all peaches and cream.

I think the main issue in Canada is that we completely ignore our government and let them do their thing, in return, they ignore us and let us get on with our lives. Now if my clients started paying me less because the government is taking too much, well then I would take appropriate cations or at least take my stand against our government, but since I was ....as long as I've lived here anyway, they haven't changed much, NAFTA (pretty much a US thing that doesn't help us), GSt, well they ditched an 11% federal tax so the 6% GST is OK, plus low income earners get a rebate check four times a year (approx. $300.00/yr). For the most part, our government is no diferent than a bunch of accountants to most Canadians, we just let them push paper and count pennies, it makes them happy and they don't try to play cowboy or win the favour o Canadians by making great motions to improve the world. They aren't out to impress us (good because nobody's impresssed) but they aren't out to hinder us either, it's jut the government, much as many countries view their respective governments, stay out of my life, I stay out of yours, it's easy, it's quiet, we get to move on and live our lives.

This is hardly the hypocritical statement you were trying to impose on me though, they suck bobo, but I can deal with it because they don't try and play God.

by oz_media

I have a freind who's father (faithfully married for 28 years) is HIV positive. this man is married with three children, who in turn have children of their own. he is an accountant for a major airline, has never done drugs, had a transfusion nro been unfaithful (his religious beliefs would never allow him to do that).

They say he could have contracted the HIV virus up to 10 years ago without it being noticed, he doesn't have AIDS yet but inevitably will in time (for those unaware HIV is the virus that leads to AIDS) you simply don't CATCH Aids.

they have no idea where he contracted it, could have been contact with an infected person or infected blood. (he was in construction at one time) as a mechanic, I know first hand how easy it is to be in contact with blod on th ejob, scratches, cuts, dings whatever, nobody no matter what life you live ro how CLEAN you think you are is immune from Aids or contracting HIV, it's just one of those things that is. We know many of the MAIN causes or rather obvious causes for transfer of fluids but there are MANY mroe that we rarely consider. Eg. You have a cut finger (not bad just a nick)someone else infected with HIV (that may not even know it)has a cut finger, you grab the same pole he did in the subway and it is possible (not likely) to contract HIV.

So don't cut of your own nose in spie of your face, you could be th enext VICTIM of Aids and would be really bummed when the government has followed your ideals and said to hell with him, he must be a drug user, fag or got an unlicky transfusion.

Now I know that you didn't really invite all this upon yourself and I don't intend to point the finger at you per se, but too many people are just cluelesss about a disease that is simply eating at out population with a vengeance.

We NEED to stop the spread of Aids, we NEED to educate people on Aids, we NEED to find a cure for Aids, who knows it could be you next. My friends heterosexual nd heavily religious father
managed to get HIV, do you really think you are immune due to your actions?

by oz_media

Garion has made it quite clear ( UI believe in the last discussion) that America takes care of Canada, they SAVE us, they give us all their money for nothing in return. We need America to survive. THey should just cut us off and stop giving us everything and maybe we'll learn.

Th ereason I only mentioned Western resources is becase that is what I am surrounded with. I live very close to a US logging companies head office on Vancouver Island, they OWN most of the North Island forest district now (what isn't protected of course). Friends of min eare commercial fishermen who have battled the US openings in Canada and reduction in stock, income and price paid for a catch.

Alberta and north eastern BC has a massive reserve of untapped natural gas as well as mines that supply the US.

The Capilano and Seymour watersheds provide Califormia with a lot of their hydro electric power, they have spoken of removing this and the US went apesh*t knowing that they couldn't possibly replace the resources they fight to the bitter end to get our goodies.

I did not mention eastern canada because even thoug I did live in the Maritimes for a year or so, I am not too sure of what your current Us exports are or the effects of those exports on the eastern economy.

Perhaps you can enlighten me.

by justmakingit

Like you said, they have nothing to worry about. When Chretien came to the Maritimes he got hit in the face with a pie, he didn't have to worry about being shot, not going to happen here. May start carrying paper towel though.

by skipperusn

Now you saying that because the USA is a richer country (because of our economic freedoms) than any other - we have a moral responsibility or oblagtion to take care of those that have less.

Where does it say that? And what makes you entitled to anything I have earned? Where is it mandated that I must give you something for doing nothing but sitting on your fat Arse and sleeping. When did my labors and successes become part of your income for doing nothing! (Let me get this right - you want part of what I earned to be given to those that earned less or nothing - call me crazy - but isn't that socialism!~)

I have no moral responsibilities to you, your country or your citizens. I have some to mine - if I choose to.

So you wonder why I call you and the others socialists - - You believe that everyone has a moral responsibility to help and if they don't you have the right to take from them what you feel they should be giving to help. And that those you give it to have no responsibility to help themselves - or control themselves..

Pure Socialism - or if you would rather Social Maxism - which is a blending of two ideals that are both logically flawed. And can never work - USSR failed - Hum -

by sullyman

Skipper,

Skipper using your flawed concepts, socialism does work. You continue to ramble on that the UK, and Canada are Socialists and the last time that I checked out things we were doing OK.....Canadian economy is growing faster the most of the G8 - and the UK is flourishing even without the EU.

by maxwell edison

.
I think a lot of people get overzealous throwing around charges such as "socialist", "extreme right-wing", and so on. (And as a disclaimer, I've even done it myself - but only in the "heat of battle", of course.)

However, I believe these "charges" are levied to illustrate a person's observation of where the other person appears to be "coming from", so to speak.

A simplistic explanation would be that some people might be automatically inclined to look to the government to solve a problem - any problem, while others might be automatically inclined to look to the individual to solve a problem - any problem. The former being "socialist" thinking, while the latter being "extreme right-wing" thinking, or so it seems.

Moreover, I believe that socialist is often confused with, and interchanged with totalitarian. And a socialist democracy is certainly different than a socialist dictatorship.

Heck, I even consider the USA a "socialist" country simply because of the massive transfer of wealth programs we have. But everything being relative, it shows that my basis of comparison is my ideological desire for as much individualism and self-responsibility as possible, and as little "collectivist" living as necessary. ("Necessary" is also relative.)

Personally, I don't think there's much difference between Canada's "socialist" system (from my limited understanding of it) and the USA's "socialist" system, except that Canada can trump the USA by considering their nationalized health care system - at least for now, that is, until we get one of our own (which, personally, I would prefer NOT to see).

by skipperusn

So answer the question what is the form of government of GB or Canada - Or is it you don't have a clue...

Clueless in England ... Ha Sullyman.

by oz_media

YOu pay taxes?
You work and sweat for your money?
You survive and pay rent/mortagage, feed your family etc.?

I do too.

Your government spends it's money on military and showing it's might to the rest of the world.

My taxes support my country, and the people withing it by not letting them die because they are unable to work. Sure I know, what about those that just don't WANT to work, well they have it damn hard here, welfare is 60% below the poverty level, nobody is getting a free ride. They are no more or no less entitled to receive medical care than I am though.

I earn money so I can enjoy life, and I do, much mroeso than a welfare bum who site around all day becoming more and more depressed with his/her life, I win they lose, isn't that enough?

So whether our medical is privatized or socialized, I will pay the same amount of taxes each month, you are fooling yourself to think that taxes would not be taken anyway. So why would I not support the government paying for medical? Who cares who benefits, nobody dies and I get help too, LOW cost rpescriptions etc. I can wander into ANY hospital in Canada ro the US ANYTIME and be completely covered while receivig the same level or quality of attention everyone else does.

It's not that bad at all. You don't feel your country should take taxes and provide the poor or sick with help well that's your perogative, let your citizens die.

by skipperusn

You are correct about the taxes - but I hope never to see a socialized heathcare system in the USA. I have relatives in GB and they purchase private health insurance on top of the government insurance to get better care.

And from my limited knowledge of the Canadian healthcare system (only just started investigations) - is that certain deseases are treated at set limits IE to control costs only so many - Open heart surgery are done each year, or eye surgeries, or hip replacements.... If not why do so many Canadians come to the US for by-pass surgery?

Other deases have a limited amount of people - so if you have XYZ - and the limit is say 1 million and you are 1,000,001 well to bad.

If a doctor screws up - you can't sue them - even if it caused death or life long disability.

These are issues that Americans don't want to see in our healthcare system... but are attempting to be injected - current started in Califorina (can wait till it falls into the ocean) limited tort - to protect quack doctors -

So yes we maybe close but so is the genes of man and monkey - only off by a few - so close only counts in Horseshoes and Nukes - ;-)

by hargerd

I don?t feel as if i live under a socialist regime in the UK. We have a centre-left government but they nearly have more "free enterprise" spirit than some right-wing governments historically

by mlayton

...it's not a problem in one country. And it is naieve to assume the people are staying put where they got infected. In this global society, people are migrating (even, gasp! to America) and so then it becomes our problem. The fix is education - and if they don't know abstinence and protection in their own country, they don't know it when they get here. And guess what? By the time they get here it is too late. They may have already infected someone. So really, we are helping ourselves when we help the world. Pointing fingers does nothing to stop the spread. Research and a cure and education prior to infection are the only things that will. Too many people, good Americans, have been lost to this disease - whatever anyone can do to help needs to be done.

by skipperusn

I don't think he is saying that Oz - your missing his points.

If your friend got it - he got it in one of those ways 1) Sex; 2) Transfusion; 3) IV Drug Use; 4) contact with Contamated blood or body fluids... as you say you just don't "Catch AIDs".

He is saying that people need to take the moral responsibility of to control themselves and that will reduce the spread of AIDS.

Lets try something - everyone in the world - when you have sex you wear a Condom - IV Drug users stop using or get a new needle each time and don't share the needle - do you think the infection rate of AIDs would drop during that year by more than say 75%.

Thats what he is saying these people need to take the responsibility to control themselves - society is not responsible and neither am I.

by skipperusn

OK - what are you UK - Lets see you have socialized health system, you have a socialized welfare system, you have a socialized union system - correct me if any of these are incorrect please ...

You Have a PM - and house of Parliment - and King and Queen (monarchy) - you have the soicalist party, liberal party, conserative party - and what if the socialist have control of parliment isn't then the PM a socialist party member?

So what are you .... I am confused - of course I am just a dumb American that had bad education from grade to Grad school...

by sullyman

Ummm the US has a socialized welfare system, and union system. So if it looks like a duck, sounds like a duck, walks like a duck then it must be a duck!!!! SO according to your theory the UK is 100% socialist - then the US must be 66% socialist. Hmmm....too bad you didn't have a health care system that was funded by tax dollars then you could call yoursefl socialist as well. I guess you are right having a multi-tiered healthcare system the really geared for the rich is the way to go!!! To hell with the working poor and poor who can't afford proper health care.....

by garion11

My five minutes on Fox

Defending Canada against the broadsides of the U.S. right is a learning experience for the Dominion Institute's RUDYARD GRIFFITHS

By RUDYARD GRIFFITHS
From Friday's Globe and Mail

E-mail this Article
Print this Article

Advertisement

My descent into Fox News's bizarre take on all things Canadian started with a mention on Matt Drudge's website. The editors of the Drudge Report had posted the findings of a survey my organization had released in the final week of the federal election. When we asked 500 Canadian teens a series of questions in a telephone poll about our country's role on the world stage, 40 per cent indicated that they agreed with the statement, ''America is force for evil in the world.''

Albeit a strong opinion seemingly held by a significant number of teens, this statistic generated only a few mentions in the Canadian media -- a sharp contrast to what was soon to unfold on U.S. airwaves.

The first sign that the Drudge Report mention was whipping up a tempest in a teapot came in the form of a screed by arch Canada-baiter and top-rated Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly. I suspect his producers have Google news alerts set up with the key words "Canada," "socialism," "draft dodgers" and "anti-Americanism." On his show, Mr. O'Reilly used the single survey statistic to let loose on Canada's political leaders, the media and our "ignorant teens." One of his choicer utterances included: "The truth is that the USA has freed more human beings in 230 years than the rest of the world combined. France has freed almost no one. Ditto Canada. . . . I object to the anti-American foreign press and bums like Chirac in France and Chr?tien in Canada."

Sorry, but didn't our Governor-General and President George W. Bush just commemorate the 60th anniversary of D-Day together in France? Last time I looked, we fought alongside the Americans in Korea, during the long grind of the Cold War and served with distinction in Bosnia and Afghanistan. And by the way, we have had a new Prime Minister for seven months and his name is Paul Martin.

Getting mentioned on Fox News all but guarantees you the full, if fleeting, attention of America's conservative news media. In the ensuing 24 hours, my e-mail inbox was clogged with a strange m?lange of messages from Canada-hating O'Reilly fans and updates from friends on both sides of the border as to where our now "viral" poll was popping up in the U.S. media.

CNN's Tucker Carlson of Crossfire fame offered what was a familiar anti-Canadian refrain in the continuing coverage of the poll result: "It's time for America to get some self-respect. . . . Until Canadian attitudes change, there should be a moratorium on Canadian immigration to the United States. No one who says 'aboot' could come here."

It is easy to write off Bill O'Reilly and Tucker Carlson as blowhards or worse. But egging on their sound bites and overexaggerations is the roiling anger of a U.S. public fed up by the incessant tide of global anti-U.S. sentiment.

The United States is a nation long used to being loved. From their iconic and near-universal popular culture, to powerful memories of the freeing of nations and peoples in wars long past, Americans have taken great strength from the enduring popularity of their founding ideals and way of life. This sentiment propelled the United States, in the second half of the 20th century, to engage with the world and fashion many of the great international institutions and norms that underwrite the prosperity and, until recently, the security we enjoy.

Implicit in the anti-Canada rants of Mr. O'Reilly and his ilk is the belief that America is now alone. Indeed, many Americans feel acutely that the country is under constant threat of attack by its enemies and is misunderstood and unfairly criticized by ungrateful former allies. For this growing segment of U.S. society, the rational response is to give up on a global community that has seemingly given up on the United States and act unilaterally to preserve U.S. national interests abroad and security at home before it's too late.

Fox News and conservative U.S. media have the pulse of a tangible isolationist movement in the American heartland. And while recent events might sometimes make it difficult to discern the good that America does in the world, an international community lacking U.S. participation is far worse off than one that benefits from active U.S. interest and involvement.

Three days after our poll appeared in the Drudge Report, I got the opportunity to go on Fox News to try to do some damage control. It was an interesting lesson in talking to the prickly and standoffish America that Fox News proudly champions. The show was aptly named Heartland, and its host was the combative former Republican congressman John Kasich.

Right from Mr. Kasich's first question as to whether Vietnam draft dodgers had taken over our education system, I knew I was in for an uphill struggle. I tried to explain that Canadian teens were no different than American teens. They wear Nike shoes, listen to U.S. popular music and most likely know as much about U.S. history as their own. My conciliatory tone didn't satisfy the former congressman. What about the press? Is the same liberal media cabal that banned Fox News from Canadian airwaves responsible for our teens' anti-Americanism? My five minutes flew by and I felt I was failing miserably to counteract the stereotype that all Canadians are Yankee-haters.

Mr. Kasich wrapped up the show by proudly stating that he was going to Canada this summer to go fishing and what a beautiful country we had. In that characteristically gregarious American way, he suggested he and his "loud mouth" would try to convince Canadians that the United States wasn't a force for evil in the world.

As bad as global opinion might get toward the U.S., and despite the degree to which anti-Americanism abroad is feeding isolationism in the United States, I am optimistic about the future.

Frankly, they are just too damn friendly, even on Fox News, to fall captive to the false security of a Fortress America.

Rudyard Griffiths is executive director of the Dominion Institute. Its survey on Canadian teen opinion was conducted by Navigator Ltd.

by skipperusn

What was the name of that movie with John Candy and starting a war with Canada - over beer or something like that...

To Funny -

by oz_media

In Vancouver we have needle exchanges. This reduces theft from hospitals, unneccessary visits to doctors etc. to steal such items and also save outr medical expenditures as drug users will generally be on assistance and not paying premiums anyway. That aside, even local women of the night would not consider providing services without a condom, we have several non-profit groups (not government run) that provide a needle exchange and sterilization/safe injections conducted by volounteer medical staff.

Our provincial government suports and promotes AIDS awareness and finds it appropriately through our tax dollars.

I really have no problem with this, awareness is the first step to defeating this horrible disease. One thing I HAVE noticed is that there is FAR less concern regarding safe sex in the heterosexual community compared to the gay community. The gay friends I have or have had in the past are ALL extremely concerned about safe sex, proper sterilization and cleanliness, something that is completely ignored by MANY heterosexual couples.

Most have the "we've been married 20 years so I don't need to worry about protection theory, other feel that if their partner says he or she has never been promiscuous or had any gay sexual relationships that it is safe to not use protection.

I think the awareness of how easily HIV is transmitted between heterosexual couples should have a greater focus as more and more 'straight' people contract aids and blame it on the gay community or IV drug use somewhere along the line. These are the people who are not actively addressing the issues properly o taking proper precautions to prevent the spread of HIV.

I think the gay community an IV drug users are far more in tune with these issues and many have had close friends die from AIDS.

I conclusion, speaking from a local standpoint, we have excellent awareness and OKAY fuding available for AIDS prevention and awareness.
I think the focus needs to be removed from those that ARE taking precautions HIV drug users and the gay community and pushed on awareness for heterosexual couples, who until now know it's POSSIBLE to contract HIV must most feel it is unlikely, which is simply Russian Roulette.

by skipperusn

We are a representative republic - which has a few socialized systems running - which we are attempting to kill.... Social Security (if I would of invested that money myself I would of retired two years ago).. Welfare system (being worked on by GWB)... Unions are their own problem not supported by government... Healthcare system - hum for the rich - good one - wrong - but a good one... Lets see England has Socialized healthcare - but because it sucks so bad the rich also purchasing a private health insurance policies... (Got Relatives that live in GB).. Yes - socialized healthcare failed - and now you are going to a private/socialized system ... And you say ours is nuts.

You just proved yourself a socialist - you support taking money from everyone to pay for someone else that didn't earn it... That socializm... Clintons tried socializing healthcare in the US and it failed to even get out of the starting gate.

Our social security system - is being changed to be privatized - Welfare is being reformed - and unions have always and will always be a socialized system - but no association to the government.

So Anyway what is the GB political system - Sullyman you and Oz are very advisive of that question. What is it..

by oz_media

Just going from a report on the news the other day; in respect to a thread I posted about US pharmaceutical companies asking Canadian doctors to fill presciptions for US patients (under our health care plan). The story also mentioned what may happen if we did fall into the private medical system and mentioned some interesting points abotu the US medical plan.

Basically they referred to it as pay or die, in cases where poor families are unable to afford proper health insurance, in many cases these people must PAY UP for medical costs or die, nice program!

They gave a number of US cuitizens that have died due to inability to pay for medical costs each year, which was more than 19,000 people per year, that's more than the WTC several times over. This is happening IN your country BY your government, not Saddam or BinLaden.

The other figures they stated were just under 2000 US citizens die because their HMO will only provide services from specific hospitals and doctors, so the rich and well off actually get the bestter medical help.

When I go to hospital, I am able to get the same surgeon that would be operating on our prime minister, I can have the latest and greatest medical research performed, the newest equipment etc.

So if we are considered socialists due to our medical system, by those with a privatized system, yet we save more citizens than the privatized system does...so be it, I am a commie, socialist pig. And proud to be helping Canada save its citizens, if we had privatized medical our taxes wouldn't change at all anyway, we would just loose support. So why on earth would I not want medical support? It goes much farther than MY paycheck, it becomes a case of 'saving others' (sound familiar?) and protecting our families and friends, not just ourselves. You go help liberate Iaq, I will stay here and earn some money to help out the less fortunate Canadians.

by mlayton

...to teach the responsibility? You are not born with the knowledge. How can people be reaping what they sow, when nobody has told them a different path, or shown them a different way of doing things? Even abstinence is not obvious in countries where the local toilet is the ditch in the street. And in countries like these, consider all the other less obvious means of contracting HIV that exist!

by oz_media

YOu all echo the Pink FLoyd song MONEY, based on the greed or the have's.

"Money, get away
Get a good job with good pay and you're okay
Money, it's a gas
Grab that cash with both hands and make a stash
New car, caviar, four star daydream,
Think I'll buy me a football team

Money, get back
I'm all right Jack keep your hands off of my stack
Money, it's a hit
Don't give me that do goody good bullshit
I'm in the high-fidelity first class traveling set
And I think I need a Lear jet

Money, it's a crime
Share it fairly but don't take a slice of my pie
Money, so they say
Is the root of all evil today
But if you ask for a raise it's no surprise
That they're giving none away."
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
>Grab that cash with both hands and make a stash
>I'm all right Jack keep your hands off of my stack
>Share it fairly but don't take a slice of my pie
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Freedom for America. Save the people of America. Save our country. Looking out for each other. Protecting our citizens.

JUST DON'T ASK FOR ANY OF MY HARD EARNED MIONEY< IT'S MINE, NOT YOURS. YOU WANT TO SURVIVE? GO IT ON YOUR OWN. DON'T LOOK FOR HELP WITH MY MONEY.

Freedom for America. Save the people of America. Save our country. Looking out for each other. Protecting our citizens

LOL :-)

by oz_media

Like I said, in Canada we DO spend money on AIDS awareness and as a society we feel it is justified for our government to spend our tax money in these areas. To a Canadian, our terrorism is from diseases like HIV and allowig th epoor to die.

We will then work on having our government work on sewer systems. :-)

by skipperusn

I asked a simple question - What form of Government is Canada and GB - and you and Sullyman don't answer - is it that you both don't have a clue?

Hum - And the second you talk about taking my money and redistributing it to someone else you are talking socialism ... Period... Its mine - if I chose not to - It shouldn't - If I chose to It should and I chose how much... Not your business or your place to tell me how to spend my dollars/franc's/pounds -

by skipperusn

OK - Give with the other ways - I've been teaching Blood borne and air borne deases for the past ten years and there is only 4 ways to get HIV/AID - if you know of another way - fill in the world..

Your comment of "all the other less obvious means of contracting HIV that exist! " give with your knowledge or was that just some general BS and lack of brains..

Unprotected Sex - Contact with contamated blood or body fluids - IV Drug use - Transfusions. And two of those are repeats - IV Drugs because of contact with contaminated blood or fluid/same with transfusions.... so actually only the first two... So What are the other ways ..

Give - it need to go out to the world .. share your knowledge...

by oz_media

It's not fair on you that everyone blames America for everything, your president created all this disdain toward america and you should hold him responsible. He is involved in everyone's business but when they say "okay, this guy want to be in charge, let him take responsibility then, you all get pissed off."

I don't dislike America or Americans, I hold your president responsible for dragging your country through the mud, not yourselves. When americans are seen as arrogant or crass, that's just how we see American's, you are different than I am and I am different then other countries citizens are. When your president acts like a comlplete fool infront of the world and nobody in america raises an eyebrow, then people start to seriously dislike your position.

Personally I would be incredibly embarrassed to be an American now, much as the email from Americans on TR have sent me wuith the same sentiments. They are embarrassed by what their country is doing and how their country is viewed in the public eye.

It's not fair at all, yet you will still support it faithfully. At least you have faith in your government to act accordingly on your behalf Jim, many Americans have lost that now.

by oz_media

I think that the name SOCIALIST is being thrown around in a completely incorrect way though. It is being viewed as a negative aspect of Canada, and as you know, also has been equated several times to Nazi Germany.

So these people are confusing what you described as a socialist democracy with what they consider a socialist dictatorship.

Unfortunately this is only due to pure ignorance and not understanding the Canadaian system, which you seem to understand a little beter than you think.

I was looking for James to offer the eloquent breakdown of services between the US and Canada but I think he's has bored of this thread (rightly so) and moved on to enjoy his day.

Thanks Max, I think you really shed some light on these issues for the few US citizens who are loosely throwing these terms around.

by oz_media

We just finished electing a Liberal/Conservative government into office. If you are thinking SOCIALIST government, that would be our National Democratic Party (NDP) who haven't been in office since....well I don't remeber havign an NDP government.

So you see us as democrats or socialists, while we are neither and never have been, not as long as I can remember anyhow.

by mlayton

...what I said was consider the less obvious ways for contracting HIV. In a country where the local toilet is a ditch, Contact with contaminated blood or body fluids is possible in ways which we may not have considered. In countries where the local dump is the sidewalk, accidental infection by contaminated medical waste and needles is more possible than in fully developed countries. Just consider the frightening possibilities that just aren't issues for us, and that are not solved by simply claiming "take responsibility for your choices."

by skipperusn

God has nothing to do with it - This is a discussion of responsibility. Please explain your comment - Are you saying because its says in the Bible I am my brothers keeper - I have responsibile for his life? His Health? His Family? and he has none...

The Far Christian side of the house is just as wrong as the Far Islamic side or Far Jewish side of the house... Religon was written by man - and is interrupted by man - I believe in God and Christ and he is my savyor but ... and this isn't the thread - Lets just say - they are books written by man and interrupted by man for man... How many people have died in the name of God! Whatever you call him .....

by skipperusn

They are still the same way of getting infected - just to a higher degree. And HIV has not been found in urine or fecies unless there is blood in them.. Fact! -

4 ways - well actually 2 ways ... Only - now if you are talking Hep A,B,C,D or Other than you really have a problem with what you stated. But don't confuse the two - HEP and HIV have different infection avenues...

You are providing invalid information - from a lack of knowledge and pure emotions - which causes more problems than answers...

Look at the problem - The government of that country needs to clean up the streets and dumps - I am not responsible nor do I have a moral obliagtion to act in that foriegn nation. Unless the action of that nation endangers my citizens.

So you were speaking from pure emotions - lack of knowledge of the subject OK - Been doing this to long - to let someone that speaking from emotion spout invalid information without a challenge..

by maecuff

Yes, Of course the previous post is right. How dare you speak only on 'emotion'.. everything Skipper says is FACT.. and I'm sure he'll tell you that.

Puhleeze...

by mlayton

...in case anyone besides Skipper is unclear as to my meaning in my original post, when I was saying "consider less obvious ways of contracting disease that exist", I was speaking of ways that perhaps are not obvious to those lucky enough to live in developed nations. I was not speaking of means of infection, which there are pretty much 4 infection vectors.

Now Skipper, let me give some facts back to you. I know HIV has not been found in urine or fecies unless there is blood in them. I know also that where the local toilet is a ditch, there is great probability that one of the neighbors in your town could expel blood in their urine or feces. I also know these ditches have great potential for people to slip and fall into them, people with a cut on their foot, etc. I know this as FACT because I have used those ditches in Congo, and the "turkish toilets" in the airports in Ivory Coast. Which may not present as big a danger to men as they do to women, but trust me, the potential for slippage is high.

The government of that country needs to clean up the streets and dumps, true. Some of these governments however are embroiled in civil wars that have them quite often switch sides, or happen to be the uneducated militia leaders heading the government. So if we are depending on them to lead the charge in educating and preaching responsibility to their citizens, it is unlikely.

So to suggest that AIDS is perhaps a retribution to uneducated people who have never been taught abstinence or about condoms (with the exception of the involuntary acts and yada yada) and say they just need to take responsibility is, perhaps, unrealistic. Do you know to take responsibility for things unless you have been taught? I think we should be encouraging developing nations to look at what has worked in Uganda, per maxwell's posts - there is great potential for everyone to affect this disease.

See my post further down - in fact the actions of the nation do endanger your citizens, because these citizens may decide to take responsibility for their way of life and emigrate to another country, even gasp! the U.S. Then their infection becomes our problem. And guess what? Whoever they sleep with here, still not having been taught about abstinence and protection ends up with the problem too.

So maybe that is all emotion, but in fact having worked in AIDS research, worked and traveled extensively in Africa, and worked with some developing nations in public education campaigns, well, I've seen a lot that trigger emotion. But that's what makes humans human.