Should the US foot the World AID Problem - I say let Canada and France doit
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by cactus pete
90% of those infected with AIDS don't even know it. Just how do you expect to stop the spread of this disease by having those who are infected abstain?
Twisting your idea into something that would work - if you could get everyone to contribute - would be to have everyone [not just those infected] stop having sex until they were ALL tested. Then wait 6 to 12 months and retest. Then, after everyone knew who had it and who did not, you could start commenting on who shouldn't be out there "galavanting" about...
Of course, you would have to force everyone to test, whether they like it or not. And who pays for this? And you'd have to force the entire population to not have sex in the meantime, whether they like it or not.
Do YOU [not necessarily just Skip, but anyone reading this] KNOW for SURE that you aren't HIV positive?
Unless you've tested and retested, you don't know 100%. Even then, you're not immune from getting it - either from sex or some other type of transfer.
Oh, that's right... Sex isn't the only way to contract it... Guess abstaining could all be for nothing... How reassuring to the populace.
by cactus pete
Thailand makes its own generic drugs. The doctor who created the most promising drug basically took the active ingredient from the 3 top drugs out there and combined them into one pill taken twice a day. Other therapies include 22 pills a day on a strict schedule. The Thai meds cost less than a dollar a day - not the tens of thousands necessary for the old 22 pill way.
US Pharms came after her for 'Patent Violations' - but she argued that since the US Govt spent the money on the research and actually created the initial drug, there is no patent. The companies dropped their suit just before it went to trail.
The Pharms weren't looking to help anything but their bottom line. Even by lying that they had a valid patent or that they needed to charge so much to recoup the money invested in the research.
These are US companies, and as such they represent the US around the world when they sell their products there. It is no wonder that much of the world resents the profiteering they see coming from the US.
by cactus pete
...isn't that pretty much how it all started? Social Security was supposed to be something you basically ended up paying to yourself.
Pols can't just give a little. They have to be reelected, so they give a little more each time around. That's true on either side of American politics.
.
It did, pretty much, all start with Social Security. There was, in the early 20th century, some programs to help women, especially single women with kids.
Yep, people "voting themselves gifts" from the public coffers. I'm disgusted by both those who accept the vote and cast the vote for such reasons. That may sound rather harsh, however, since that covers just about everybody.
By the way, Mr. King of the (ant)Hill, have you heard the old Arab saying about the camel's nose under the tent????
"If the camel once get his nose in a tent, the body will soon follow."
- Saudi Proverb
Here's my interpretation: Once it's established that the role of government is to provide cradle to grave care, it's only a matter of time before government will begin to dictate how a person will live his or her life.
Interpret the "camel's nose" proverb however you wish, but any interpretation ain't pretty - unless, of course, you want to live in camel spit.
by cactus pete
Mandatory service is rather unamerican. Those who fought in the Revolution had to be convinced every day that it was worth it. But they were volunteers, too. That's how we got so strong.
But it isn't very Libertarian to suggest that all citizens must provide service to their country.
And you like the way Sweden runs things? Last election results [per CIA]:
Social Democrats 39.8%, Moderates 15.2%, Liberal Party 13.3%, Christian Democrats 9.1%, Left Party 8.3%, Center Party 6.1%, Greens 4.6%; seats by party - Social Democrats 144, Moderates 55, Liberal Party 48, Christian Democrats 33, Left Party 30, Center Party 22, Greens 17
The other point you raise is "of course there goes my taxes - but what the heck its worth it.. " So, forcing us to pay taxes to redistribute to conscripted soldiers is OK, but putting food on the table of the needy isn't?
by oz_media
First of all, stop makin gdemands of people.
Ever think that maybe people dont' even want to drag this discussion out anymore? Perhaps people don't think you ae worth the efort? If not, think again.
But seeing as you asled do politely, in Canada we JUSt finished electing teh Liberal Party for another term with Conservatives close behind. I supose that makes us commie, socialist, Nazis.
What you fail to understand is that OUR parties are MUCH different than yours. Liberals here are 'right wingers'. As for NDP or Democratic/socialist party, they haven't been in office as long as I can recall.
One thing that you COULD benefit from is that we do nto have our government sit in office for four year terms, they can be ousted for a new election anytime. That way they toe the line knowing they must appease everyone to stay there, nnot just throw some colorful smoke in the air every four years so they will be reelected. Noww I know you can throw out your government but generally public opinion will not suffice and they will remain in office until the next election.
by oz_media
I know for sure that I am not HIV positive. I do get checked once a year however it should be more as I am single now and have no reigns or halter.
generally those who feel that abstinence is the ONLY solution, are also people who do not realize that intercourse has created our planet. We cannot survive as a race with abstinence. Now what about staying abstinent util you are married!? This doesn't solve anything! It doesn't matter if you are married or single, you still can contract AIDS, that theory is for great grandpa's and people who ca't get it up or get any to begin with.
by oz_media
Well I slept on the Friday Yuk (your's was actually funnier than mine though).
but I think you take the cake with your 'puhleez!'
Do you actually roll your eyes as you type it? It's such a simple word and yet creates such a vivid mental picture of utter futility!
Love it!
by thechas
Skipper,
Personally, I think that people should be able to maintain monogamous relationships.
This would effectively stop the spread of AIDS and most S.T.D.s.
However, there are many in this world who can't or won't "keep it in their pants".
For these countries, the US needs to recognize and promote the use of condoms.
In most of the third world countries, where AIDS is spreading the fastest, the roles of men and women are very different than they are in the US.
Women are treated as property, and have no ability to refuse to have sex with their mate.
Men are judged by the breadth of their sexual conquests.
Abstinence won't work in these societies.
We need to promote the use of condoms for those who are sexually active, and help those who's infection might have been prevented if we had taken a realistic look at their society before limiting our prevention methods to abstinence.
By the way, as practiced in the US, sexual abstinence will NOT prevent AIDS.
Abstinence is being taught as something that each individual determines the meaning of.
It is NOT being taught as abstaining for all sexual acts!
A large number of teenagers in the US believe that abstinence means that you do not have intercourse.
ALL other sexual acts are okay!!!
Chas
by oz_media
I have personally sued a doctor here for malpractice that nearly cost my lief and won a fair settlement, so YES you can sue a doctor here. They are completely independant and DO NOT work for the government, they BILL the government for their services.
Limited amount of people, again another myth.
People CHOOSE to go to the USA for treatment that are MAINLY unavailable here as we regulate our medicine and techniques very carefully to ensure safety and consistency . Many patient will seek out 'new' or controversial treatments for heart and lungs, cancer etc. in the US where such practices are alowed to use humans as guinnea pigs. as far as someone dying from a heart transplant noy being available in Canada, this is crap. Canadians hospitals treat their sick on a basis of how life threatening it will be. If the patient needs a new heart but will survive three years without one, they will be bumped to allow someone else with less time to be taken care of. People seeking such operations in the USA are generally on a waiting list but in no immediate danger if a transplant is not available. The USA turns down MORE patients in needs that Canada does, if you can't pay, you will die. Nice though huh? Don't forget to pay your premiums!
Now If I decided nto to pay my medical anymore and was hit while being drunk and staggering across the street. I ought with the ambulance drivers and told all the medical staff to go blow themselves, they would still get me fixed up IMMEDIATELY, set me in a bed with a nice TV and a spinge bath daily from one of our BC beauties and then sauy have a nice day when I was better. What no bill? I haven't paid my medical!! Oh well, welcome to Canada.
by oz_media
by cactus pete
Still on top... Wonder when that will change.
I competely agree that this Social Security system is out of control. For starters, it's corrupted and wasted money. Completely inefficient handling and farcical collections. The payments from my salary are double [if not triple or more] taxed and I pay that against almost all of my income. Were I to make, say, $200k, it wouldn't prick me quite as much. The overall percentage would be far less. The tax system is not at all equitable.
A coupe of points that may stray from the above topic...
I stated in a different thread, in response to something Chas wrote, I believe, that we should be taxed only on what we purchase, not what we earn. That's far more efficient; if the govt wants to influence savings upward, tax more! people would be disinclined to spend the money and would invest. Should the economy need a kick, lower the taxes on common everyday items and minor luxuries [not necessarily mansions, etc]. People would buy like crazy.
And everyone would have the chance to decide their very own tax rates. A wealthy old miser would have extremely low rates as would the frugal blue collar worker.
well, maybe not so many points, I've forgotten already what else I had planned to say... Too much work this late on a Friday night.
.
I'm "shooting from the hip" here, as I haven't verified my numbers, but the USA's military spending, as a percentage of our GDP (Gross Domestic Product), is only at about 4 percent. In 1960, it was closer to 10 percent. However, in 1960 our "social programs" spending was 4 percent, while our military spending was about 10 percent - the exact opposite. So, as it relates to our GDP, our military spending has gone down, while social spending has gone up - both very significantly.
Our GDP is about 10 trillion dollars.
Our military spending is about 400 billion dollars.
Our "social spending" is about 1 trillion dollars - PER YEAR!!!!!
Which nations spend MORE than the USA on military spending, as a percentage of their GDP?
Turkey
Syria
Yemen
Tajikistan
Sudan (is lower, but very close)
Singapore
Saudi Arabia (10 percent)
Qatar
Pakistan
Oman
New Caledonia
Morocco
Libya
Lebanon
Kuwait
Maldives
Macedonia
North Korea (23 percent - WOW)
Israel (9 percent)
Jordan (20 percent)
Iran (close at 3.5 percent)
Greece
Ethiopia
Eritrea
Egypt (equal to USA)
Djibouti
Cyprus
China (5 percent)
Chile
Burundi
Brunei
Bosnia - Herzegovina
Bahrain
Armenia
Others:
Canada - 1 percent
UK - 2.5 percent
Australia - 3 percant
France - 2.5 percent
Germany - 1.5 percent
So actually, we don't spend that much at all.
Oh, I forgot one:
Terrorist nation - who knows, but I'd bet it's between 50 and 100 percent.
Okay - I looked up some of these numbers. Source: CIA Factbook.
Wow, look at this chart. Military spending's downward trend:
http://www.nationalpriorities.org/charts/MilGDP.html
http://liberalindex.org/military-relative-size.php
Interesting, don't you think?
by skipperusn
by skipperusn
From your government's Canadian Healthcare System 2002 report -
Health Care Spending in Canada
New Findings on Household Spending on Health Care
* Canadian households are devoting more of their after-tax income to health care. The average share of after-tax income spent on health care was 3.1% in 2000, up from 2.3% in 1978.
(Why are they spending their money if its free!)
* Canada's highest-income households spent more than three times as much on health care as the lowest income group in 2000, adjusted for household size. But the low-income group spent a larger share of its after-tax income on health care. Households were divided into five equal sized groups: the lowest income group spent 3.9% on average compared to 2.6% for the highest income group.
Total Health Care Spending in 2001 Forecast at over $100 Billion
* In 2001, Canada spent about 9.4% of our Gross Domestic Product (GDP) on health care. In 1998 (the latest available international comparisons), Canada spent 9.3% of GDP on health care, more than all but three other OECD countries.
* Total public and private health care spending in Canada was $102.5 billion (forecast) in 2001. On average, that's about $3,300 per Canadian. (Again you said it was Free!)
* After adjusting for inflation and population growth, total health care spending in 2001 was up 4.3% from the year before. Real health care spending per person rose faster on average over the last four years than in any period since Medicare was introduced. Spending trends over the last decade, however, average out to about the longer-term historical growth rate.
* Hospitals account for the largest share of spending (32% in 2001), followed by retail drug sales (15%), and spending on physician services (14%).
The Public/Private Split
* About 73% of total health care spending (just under $2,400 per Canadian) came from public sector sources in 2001 (forecast). The rest came from private sector sources, such as insurance companies and out-of-pocket payments. Most private spending was for drugs and dental care.
* Health care accounts for a larger share of provincial/territorial government expenditures than 25 years ago. In 2000, it was almost a third (32%) of total expenditures including debt charges, up from 27% in 1975.
* The latest data on private/public health care spending per Canadian for the provinces and territories are also available in the report.
--- Still Digging to check facts - -- -
Highlights of the report - - - -
What We Know
* More than 1.5 million Canadians worked in health care and social services in 2000. The largest regulated health professions are nursing (232,000 RNs worked in nursing in 2000) and medicine (57,800 physicians worked in clinical and non-clinical practice in 2000). The numbers, geographic distribution, workplaces, worklife, scopes of practice, and other characteristics of these and other health professionals continue to evolve over time.
* Canada's health care spending is higher than ever before. It passed the $100 billion mark for the first time in 2001. In total, we spent $102.5 billion (forecast) to improve or maintain our health, an average of about $3,300 per person. Hospitals still account for the largest share of spending (32% in 2001), but spending on drugs-now accounting for 15%-displaced spending on physician services (14% in 2001) as the second largest cost driver in 1997.
* According to Statistics Canada's Survey of Household Spending, average health care spending per household in Canada in 2000 was $1,357, up from $1,009 in 1996. The largest share was for health insurance premiums, followed by medicinal and pharmaceutical products and dental services. Health care spending also differed by household income. The highest income group spent more than three times as much on health care as the lowest income group, adjusted for household size. But the low-income group spent a larger share of its after-tax income on health care in 2000 (3.9% versus 2.6%).
* Today's students are facing rising health education costs. For example, the average annual tuition fees for dentistry programs rose from $5,425 to $8,491 (a 57% increase) between 1998/1999 and 2001/2002. Over the same period, average tuition for medical students increased 39% (to $6,654).
* Governments in all parts of the country fund some homecare services, but what is covered varies from place to place. In 1998/1999, Canadian governments spent just under $3 billion on homecare, up significantly over the last decade.
* The Internet has become a source of health information for patients and physicians alike. For example, a recent survey by the Canadian Medical Association reported that almost 80% of doctors were using the Internet at their home or office and 30% were referring their patients to web sites on occasion.
Outcomes of Care
What We Know
* Overall, 19.2% and 12.6% of patients died in a hospital within 30 days of initial hospitalization for a stroke or a heart attack, respectively between 1997/1998 and 1999/2000. After adjusting for differences in age, sex, and comorbidity, most of Canada's largest regions (populations over 100,000) had mortality rates that were about the same as this average, but some had higher or lower rates.
* Across all regions (large and small), 7.3% of heart attack, 6.4% of asthma, 1% of hysterectomy, and 2.5% of prostatectomy patients had an unplanned return to hospital within 28 days due to a related health problem. Most regions had rates that were similar to the overall rates, but some were significantly different, even after adjusting for differences in risk factors.
* Five-year relative survival rates for people diagnosed with some cancers vary depending on where you live. For example, five-year relative survival for people diagnosed with prostate (91%) or breast cancer (85%) was highest in British Columbia. This compares to national rates of 87% and 82% respectively.
* People receiving kidney or heart transplants between 1995 and 2000 had better survival chances than those who received transplants between 1989 and 1994.
* For many types of care and for many different surgeries, research shows that patients treated in hospitals with higher numbers of cases are often less likely to have complications or to die after surgery. Most Canadians receive surgery in high-volume hospitals, but many hospitals perform a very small number of procedures. For example, almost one in four pancreatic cancer surgeries-also known as Whipple procedures- performed in 1999/2000, were done in hospitals that did fewer than five annually. Some hospitals perform more than 25 procedures per year.
Public Health: On Guard Year After Year
What We Know
* Smoking remains a public health challenge for Canada. In 2000/2001, 5.5 million Canadians aged 12 or older (almost 22%) said that they smoked cigarettes daily, including 13% of 12 to 19 year olds and 10% of seniors. The proportion of Canadians who reported smoking daily has decreased over the past two decades. In 1978/1979, 37% of those 15 years and older reported smoking daily.
* Canadian children are routinely vaccinated against nine diseases: polio, pertussis (whooping cough), tetanus, diptheria, Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib), measles, mumps, rubella, and hepatitis B. Provinces and territories each develop their own routine schedules for childhood vaccinations.
* In 2000/2001, Statistics Canada asked Canadians if they had had a flu shot in the last year. About two in three seniors (65%) said yes, up from just over half (51%) in 1996/1997. This compares to 27% of Canadians aged 12 and older, up from just under 15% in 1996/1997.
* About a billion people living in developing countries are at risk because they are without clean drinking water, according to United Nations estimates. Most Canadians are more fortunate. We generally have access to safe drinking water, although outbreaks of water-borne disease occur from time to time.
* The Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care weighs the evidence on what should and should not be included in regular checkups for Canadians of different ages. For example, they recommend routine screening mammograms for women aged 50 to 69 years and pap smears for women from when they become sexually active or turn 18 (whichever is earlier) until age 69. In 2000/2001, 70% of Canadian women aged 50 to 69 reported receiving a mammogram for screening or other purposes in the last two years. More (73% of those 18 to 69) reported receiving a Pap smear in the last three years.
Medicating Illness: Drug Use and Cost in Canada
What We Know
* Millions of Canadians take medications daily. Almost eight in ten Canadians aged 12 and older (78%) said that they had used one or more prescribed or over-the-counter medications in the last month in 1998/1999. Women and older Canadians were more likely than others to report using medications.
* Painkillers-ranging from aspirin to morphine-are among the most commonly used drugs. According to a 1998/1999 Statistics Canada survey, about 65% of Canadians 12 and older said they had taken painkillers in the last month. Other commonly used drugs include heart medications (13%), stomach remedies (13%), penicillin or other antibiotics (8%), sleeping pills and tranquilizers (5%), and antidepressants (4%).
* Retail drug sales became the second largest category of total public and private health spending (after hospitals) in 1997, overtaking physician services. In total, Canadians are expected to have spent over $15.5 billion on drugs in 2001, up 8.6% from the previous year. That is just over $500 per person.
* In 2000, manufacturers sold about $6.3 billion of patented medicines in Canada, according to the Patented Medicine Price Review Board (PMPRB). That's just under two-thirds (63%) of total drug sales across the country, up from 43.3% in 1995. Most of the remaining sales (28%) were non-patented, brand-name drugs sold by companies that also sell patented drugs. "Generic" drugs-copies of drugs for which the original patent(s) have expired-accounted for about 9% of sales in 2000.
* Three-quarters (75%) of Canadians aged 12 and older reported having some public or private insurance coverage (with varying levels of deductibles) for prescription drugs in 1998/1999. Young adults and low-income Canadians were least likely to say that they were insured. In part, this likely reflects the fact that private insurance is often a benefit of employment, covering employees and their dependents.
So - Now I am confused - you say its free this report shows major dollaras out of pockets. I've been fighting cancer for 8 months now and my out of pocket is well under $200.00 - for it ... I'll show you the bills...
by oz_media
After one of your posts above I have already explained above in a post titled "excuuuuuse me" about exactly what government we just elected (Liberal/Conservative)and the fact that we have never had a socialist (democratic) party in office). You have socialized welfare and so do we, that doesn't make us both socialist countries.
Your government takes taxes from you, albeit less than we pay but generally we earn more so it equares pretty well, and it in turn uses that taxation money as it chooses and gives it to whomever it deems neccessary. Should your government decide to allow $1000.00 week to welfare recipients, they will.
What you see as your center and left wing is Canada's right wing. Our left wing is what you would ocnsider your absolute left extremists.
I think that it was Max who explained below that there are two forms of socialism :
"I think a lot of people get overzealous throwing around charges such as "socialist", "extreme right-wing", and so on. (And as a disclaimer, I've even done it myself - but only in the "heat of battle", of course...)"
"Moreover, I believe that socialist is often confused with, and interchanged with totalitarian. And a socialist democracy is certainly different than a socialist dictatorship."
Based on the above statements I would sat Canada would have a seocialist democracy NOT a socialist deitatorshop as you seem to imply.
If we think welfare pays too much we speak out and it can be brought to vote and raised. Government funding with a democratic voting system.
As for your precious money, may you never be in need due to unforseen circumstances and should you do so, hope to God that others don't feel the way you do.
I would give money to someone I didn't know if it helped them get by any easier. I like the fact that I can walk into any hospital anytime and it makes no difference who carries my medical, how much I earn or how much I pay in insurance.
I choose this life I am not forced into it.
I am a british citizen living in Canada, if I don't like it I will leave, simple as that. I feel the same way about most immigrants, if you don't like it and are NOT A CITIZEN, then get your citizenship and vote or move back home. This doesn't mean I don't think they are entitled to voice their opinion but they have moved here by choice and CHOSE this country and it's government. They can also choose to become a citizen and vote for a difference if they don't like the current situation. But if you are unprepared to be a citizen of the country you chose, then you can sit and complain about it too.
Before you equate this to non-Americans speakin gout against Bush. I am referring to those who choose to relocate and then complain about where they relocated without being a citizen, a completely different story than world affairs.
by oz_media
"My taxes support my country, and the people withing it by not letting them die because they are unable to work."
Your taxes support military, my taxes support medical.
Do you not think a portion of you tax dollars goes to support the Welfare systemor the US Army (same thing)?
How many soldiers truly want to see combat compared to those that had no hope of a college education or a trade or even a career?
In some ways one could say the US army is their answer to welfare reform.
Someone with low income has government sponsored medical in Canada. Others pay a premium rate of 34.00 month , some pay a little more not not a massive difference and we all get equal treatment from the same doctors with lower cost medication (much is completely free except a dispensing fee for the Pharmacy).
We pay very much the way you do, but we have government regulated doctors and hospitals (private hospitals and practices but quality assurance and ethically regulated by the government to ensure consistent medical aid no matter who you are or what level of insurance you own.
It is nice to know that no matter what happens in my life, whether I am rich or poor, I will always recieve proper medical attention.
So let's take your example above of spending $200.00 US for your insurance for 8 months. That equals $25 USD/month or $32.78/mo Canadian.
I currently pay between $36 > $40 month due to residual income that varies quarterly, yet I average over $110,000.00/yr all in.
That's a pretty good deal actually. Now I could also get a new heart if needed, a liver transplant, medication for the rest of my life if needed and still always pay the same or slightly more than a single person working at 7-11.
by maecuff
by thechas
As a Christian myself, and the US as a Christian nation have the responsibility to use our worldly gains to help and aid those that are worse off than we are.
It is usually better to contribute to a larger organization that has a plan and goal to eliminate the problem rather than just give individually.
If we wish to consider that the US is a Christian nation, then we should be willing to GIVE a minimum of 10% of the US GNP to the poorer countries.
Be it food aid, or disease control, we owe it to the poorer nations to help them out with NO STRINGS attached.
In fact, if we want to protect the US and strengthen our defenses against terrorism, the best way to do that is to become an unerring force for good deeds.
Want to eliminate outsourcing?
Raise the standard of living in the rest of the world.
Want to increase exports?
Build infrastructure, industry and jobs in foreign lands.
Want to reduce the strength of the terrorist leaders?
Don't allow US companies to do anything that can be perceived as unjust.
Do help EVERY nation in need with technical advice and money to improve the conditions in their country.
Don't preach and coerce other nations to adopt our morality.
Do respect a nations cultural and moral beliefs.
Chas
.
Our GDP is about 10 trillion dollars.
The US government spends about 2 trillion dollars a year.
To give 1 trillion dollars in foreign aid would take half of all government spending.
We do, however, transfer 1 trillion dollars a year domestically.
Personally, I don't trust any of the international agencies to manage the funds, nor do I trust many foreign governments. A good friend of mine was once assigned with the UN "peacekeeping" troops somewhere in Africa, and the stories of fraud, theft and bribery are amazing. How many of these African nation leaders are living in luxury off the "aid" they receive, but it never gets to the people who need it? Where's the UN to keep it from happening?
Personally, I don't want to give 1 trillion dollars (in cash or goods) to any nation. They can't be trusted to actually distribute it to those who need it.
by thechas
I tend to agree that the UN may be the wrong organization to solve most problems.
I would like to see our foreign aid money given to select NGO's.
Any group that distributes donations or public funds should be required to meet an effectiveness test.
Something along the lines of not more than 20% of the funds spent on "administrative" costs.
Measurable impact of the groups efforts.
Chas
by oz_media
When you first stated only 10 percent, I wondered how you had the biggest and mightiest military on the planet by only spending 10 percent.
Stated as the TRILLIONS invested, it allmade sense again. You are speaking on a basis of GDP and not what I am seeing as dollar values.
I Canada was to spend 10% it would be enough for a happy meal and MAYBE a movie. Therefore proportionately, you spend a lower percentage of your actual tax dollars on military but it equates to phenominal sums with just too many zeros.
I am thinking that if it was even further reduced in respect to the GDP, then would you not still be issuing immense sume on your military?
Turkey and Syria, top of the list, are they perhaps spending a higher percentile of taxation income on military funding but from a monetary perspective the actual spending is peanuts in comparisson to your own?
I just don't see how with the trillions you spend on the US military how you could not top a list for military funding otherwise.
YEs you have the most people paying taxes, would this money not be better allocated to helpthe less fortuate? NOw I know where you stand on that issue but how about taking existing tax dollars and simply redistributing the percentages spent on various 'neccessary services' to reduce the poverty level? You're paying them anyway, does it matter of they spend a few billion less on the military?
It's almost like 'military socialism' (I think I made that up)where the government takes your money and decides it is best allocated to the military. Whereas ours takes our spit in the bucket and gives it to the welfare system.
Is it not the same thing with a different focus of fudns transfer?
One could argue that the government taking money to provide your country's military is completely justified, which I agree with, but isn't it also just as justifiable to provide help for the citizens of the country if the need for military funding isn't in the trillions?
Everyone pays taxes, I see the difference between what we consider war mongers and what oyu consider socialists is simply how and where the money is spent. In both cases, they are simply taken from the worker and redistributed where needed. I work to support myself AND my country, doen't everyone?
.
Yes, the USA spends more in real dollars than any other nation. (If not the USA, whom would you prefer to "lead the pack"?)
I think the global GDP is around 30 trillion dollars, so the USA makes up almost 35 percent of the global economy. (No, I haven't looked it up. Just estimating and going from memory.)
But the charges of the USA being a "war monger" nation just because we spend 400 billion (plus) on the military - more in real dollars than anyone else - is not exactly an accurate charge. If you relate dollars earned and spent to te area of national focus, it is true that only 4 percent of our "focus" is on military spending, and 10 percent is focus is on transfer of wealth programs.
It would be interesting to compare the nations of the world, as it pertains to transfer of wealth programs as a percentage of their GDP. I wonder if Canada would rank higher than the USA? Maybe I'll do some research (when I care enough to find the answer), but I probably won't. But how about those nations that dedicate 20 percent or more of their "focus" on their military? What are they not spending it on?
Actually, comparing the military spending (as a percentage of our GDP) of 1960 to 2004, is probably more of an indicator of our booming economy, on balance, over the past 44 years.
However, it does make sense that the bigger "interest" one has to protect, the more dollars will be spent to protect it. New York City, for example, has a police force (~35,000) that's larger than the population of quite a few American cities (towns), and probably a budget larger than that of many nations.
By the way, this is an interesting question: If not the USA, whom would you prefer to "lead the pack" in military spending? (No "Polly-Anna, pie-in-the-sky" answers like no one should spend anything, because that just won't happen.) Be realistic, and try to answer the question. I say the USA. Who would you say? (This is the "therefore what" question.)
by oz_media
THat is almost a dead end question, if I was to say Canada (that would be untrue) as I don't think Canada has the troop numbers or money to hold such a title, I would obviously say England, but they've been there and probably will be again one day as the economies change. I can certainly say I have no problem at all with US military and the fact that you have the largest number of troops and the largest military budget and that in turn makes you the largest force. I can say I am glad to be on the allied side of course but as to WHO holds the keys really doesn't matter to me. I expect the bearer of such to handle it in a profesional and VERY careful matter as the bigest guy is also the biggest target to be taken down.
I think itr's all the incesant flag waving that goes wih it that REALLY irks people, nobody cares how tough you think you are, just do what is needed as it is needed to support the allied nations.
Now, do I think America should have such a voice in foreign affairs? Maybe not. I think the USA sometimes gets a little carried away with it's 'holier than thou' attitude and it is reflected in US citizens as arrogance.
You have seen everyone here that boasts of living in a nation that everyone else envy's and wishes they were part of, and you also know that it is pure BS.
So it is not really the US military might that people are impressed by (in fact definitely not)and it's not your wealth. In fact nobody I have ever met (excluding third world countries)wishes they were American or that they had America's military strength or money, it just doesn't matter to anyone but yourselves.
Sorry, I've strayed a bit here, therefore what? Well I don't think that at the current time I could think of anyone else, other than pretty much ANY allied country including your own.
It doesn't matter who has the military strength really as long as it isn't the enemy, but I wouldn't want it to be Canada, I don't think anyone here does.
THat point is relly moot though, I don't care about the US military spending but un terms of dollars, this is all TAX dollars, therfore I equated Americas biggest pride (military) to a 'socialist military'. Your government takes YOUR money and gives it to those who protect you.
In my country we have no need for protection at this time because we are no threat, we are seen as the cleanup crew that helps people rebuild thir lives and industries after natural or man made devastation, we hold a neutral positition in the world for the most part.
Therefore when I don't mind paying taxes that inturn go to our welfare and medical system, it really isn't absurd or socialists conformity. If our taxes went up because all of a sudden we needed to pump up military spending, I may start to be concerned about other taxes for medicine and welfare. All in all it does come out about the same, yes you pay less in taxes than I do, in fact everyone in Canada pays less than I do, we get it heavy out west for sure. I also get paid a better salary, we have a higher minimum wage and it all seems to balance.
I get really pissed when people equate Canada's social services to Communism and the NAzi party asit is not even remotely close and stands as a eally ignorant argument at a system that actually works for us, for now. It really isn't THAT much different than your own, yet people constantly say that we live in a socialist country and have no idea what freedom really is, BS.
To wrap up, sorry, my only point was that wheras Canada takes our taxes to pay for our social services, the USA takes your taxes in order to pay for military superiority. SO therefore if you can say we have a socialist government then so do you but in an ever so slightly different respect.
We both allow for our governmentto tax us and provide us what is in our best interests as a country, for Canada that is medical system and welfare (although I would love to see the lazy ones cut somehow). In the USA your best interests are in military power, you allow your government to take your tax money and distribute your funds there. How are we so different other than in our national focus?
by aldanatech
.
What would you call it?
by jimhm
First "So Called" - well Mr college professor - what do you Call it.
Second - You guys always whine about something the governemnt is doing - so lets have your side of the solution.
Rather than just flapping your gums and saying nothing - lets hear a solution from your side of the fence - or do you even have one.
So Far the US has spent 14 Billion - the other UN countries combined have spent less than 3 Billion (thats combined) ... And the spread has not decreased - so the UN's mission and plan is failing.
I'll put this in your format: Your answer should include a 1) plan to slow the spread of AIDs - and 2) how to spend any additional funds.
Many have posted their solution to the spread (Keep it in their pants - give out clean needles - and a few other measures, and those with it take responsibility for it) but most liberals expect the government (USA) to accept the responsibilbity for these peoples in action - "It isn't right to tell them to keep it in their pants"
I wait for your answer.
by aldanatech
by sleepin'dawg
Japan : 9 Billion
United Kingdom : 8 Billion
Spain : 3 Billion
Canada : 4.2 Billion
France : 7.8 Billion
Brazil : 2.2 Billion
Germany : 5 Billion
USA : 15.7 Billion note : higher than 14 Billion.
Where the 14 Billion number comes from I have no idea unless it's one more of Skipper's "facts". Maybe it's because last years number was 13.6 and he took the liberty of rounding it up. Who knows??
The USA is the largest single contributer but on a per-capita basis it is far from being the largest, in fact, it's somewhere towards the back of the pack, which is very strange since outside of Africa the US has the largest number of AID's sufferers in proportion to population of all first world nations.]:)
by oz_media
The comment you have made implies that society should all believe in YOUR God, as the moral structure of your God would not allow such a disease to circulate society.
Believing in God plays absolutely no part in the HIV/AIDS epidemic.
Even the most Christian of people have sex and YES HIV can be aquired by pretty much anyone regardless of lifestyle or religion.
Even if we could prove tha believing in God and living by Christian values will reduce the spread of HIV, we then would have to convince every other religion to follow suit, and stop all immigration unless by Christian's.
It's quite absurd when you think about it.
by jamesrl
The Canadian Government is similar to the UK government in that it is a parliamentary system. There are two houses - the house of commons, and the senate. The House of Commons is elects representatives based on regional divisions(seats or constituencies), on a first past the post system(person with hightest number of votes is elected). The party leader from the party who has the highest number of seats is the prime minister(though in minority governments this can get tricky because of coalitions).
The Senate is appointed(regional basis), but has no power(it can slow but not stop legislation). The Monarchy is represented by the governor general, who is a rubber stamp and ceremonial figure. Its been 70 years since the governor general actually had a decision to make.
The provinces have legislatures and lt. governors as well - similar setup but no senate for them.
I've watched a lot of parliament, in person, and on TV - its not really any different than the US. The main difference is that for one hour everyday you have question period, where the opposition can pose questions to the government. Thats what you usually see on TV. The rest of the time is spent in introducing, debating and passing bills - like any other democracy alot of this real work is done in committee before it hits the floor of the house.
The Prime Minister, if he has a majority government, has a lot of power - much more than a president of the US, legislatively speaking, because he automatically has a majority, and with few exceptions the senate can't stop him. He can pass what he wants.
Hope that helps.
James
by sullyman
Skip,
Do I know what type of gvernment I have in my own back yard, yes I do. Liberal.....Now before you begin rambling on about how Canadian are socialist spend a few minutes educating yourself about the political system that you are trying to put down. OZ summed it up, I did in a previous post the problem is you don't read the answer before you begin rambling.
by jamesrl
Here is one Michael Moore film I can recommend.
John Candy(a Canadianplaying an American) as a rowdy unemployed worker from an arms manufacturer in upstate New York -makes fun of Canadian beer at a Canadian hockey game and starts a riot. White House(Alan Alda as a smarmy President, Rip Torn as a hawkish advisor)seizes the opportunity to find a new enemy. Candy and company invade Canada - Steven Wright as a Mountie is hilarious.
Of course those of you who would never support anything MM ever did will want to stay away....
But I laughed quite a few times - even when the jokes were on Canadians.
James
by oz_media
by sullyman
Skip,
Nothing to add fromt he UK side of things, 'cause like yourself I am not too uptodate on the UK health system since I am a Canadian...But OZ is pretty much covering off all the bases, not too much to add. But, we can sue Dr's for malpractice and we do not have a ceiling price set for medicare, grant it it's not as loose as it was in the 60's and 70's we get what we need. If you need more than one by-pass per year then you get it, my grandfather is on his 3rd this year. A few people come to the US for by-pass surgery each year for two reasons, the first being that some of the top Dr's are there ( 'cept Dr. Keon who is one of the top heart surgeons in the world ) and the second because it is more convienient to go to the US. Instead of travelling across the province and being away from family, it might be closer to go to a US hospital so friends and family can visit.
by jimhm
I agree to a point - Find a cure for HIV/AIDs right now the answer is the drug cocktail - but that only slows it down the HIV to becoming AIDs.
But if we can slow the infection rate to under 50% that is a far better rate than 1500% that some countries have. Wouldn't you agree - The US drug industry is already spending billions on research for it... so if the Federal government. But if we got all the researchers in the world to work as a single team - me thinks a solution would be found.
Education - worked in the USA - and Blood screening - but most of these 3rd world countries the infection is from Heterosexal... so put a sock on it... valcanize that tool ...
Dumping cash at this problem isn't the answer - look at the war on drugs - has all the billions spent on that fix the problem ... Nope
For intelligences - on terrorism - well you can blame that lack on Hire Clinton and his party that made it illegal for the CIA/FBI/SS and other agencies to share inforamtion between them.
But you do have to take action - pure defense doesn't work - thats been proven time and time again.. If you find a cell from intelligance - then you have to take it out - and not sending them to jail ...
by jamesrl
The level of Canadian military spending has declined dramatically. During the early days of the cold war, we had an aircraft carrier, squadrons of planes in Germany, an armoured brigade(big bigrade but not a division) in Germany, and a committment to supply troops from Canada to support Norway. That plus a big role in continental air defence(NORAD). At its post Korean peak, we had around 200,000 troops.
Now we have about 65,000 troops - and way too many senior officers. We do also have a significant number of reserves, and like the US, we have had to use them in some of our peacekeeping missions.
I would argue that if Canada wants to continue its role as a peacekeeper and as a contributor to NATO and NORAD, we need to spend more -but its also spend smarter as well. All militaries make some spending mistakes - as does any major organization - either public or private.
James
by steve biko
If it can be proven that the USA are responsible for the AIDS virus, then surely the US should make reparations (small pox vaccine theory on the origins of Aids), or if there is any party responsible for the virus spreading, then they should make reparations?
Anyway, does it really matter who has more money or who gives more money? It's more about education of how Aids spreads that will stop it from spreading and no amount of money is going to stop people from acting irresponsibly.
The desire for a quick cure is typical of the day and age of Macdonalds, everything fast and quick. And just imagine, how much more money can be made if you find a vaccine against Aids. Maybe that's why a cure is being researched.
.
To even suggest that the USA is responsible for AIDS is absurd. (I know, you didn't exactly say that.)
From everything I've read, it's common knowledge that AIDS started in Africa.
So there ya' go. I'll be waiting, on behalf of the hundreds-of-thousands of Americans who've died of AIDS, for your reparation check. (And I'll donate it to a foundation that helps AIDS patients.)
by steve biko
The only info I have is that the WHO did tests of vaccines in Africa, which resulted in the AIDS virus. If this is true, then whoever is responsible for those tests (or runs the WHO) should be held accountable. Of course if that were true there would be some kind if international court case going on. My real point is that I think many people throw money at a problem such as Aids to ease their conscience, that they have money and there is somebody else suffering who could do with some money.
I'm just not convinced that money will solve the problem, money cannot fix everything.
It's more about what can be done with that money, ask Bono (of U2?), see how much effort he puts into solving the problem.
.
Money can't solve all problems.
by sleepin'dawg
by steve biko
The other thing to remember is the fact that many European countries over-ran Africa and even SOuth America and Australia, offering trinkets and rubbish for huge tracts of land. How many countries have European languages as their mother tongue, such as French, Portuguese, Spanish.
Many still say that Europe has taken what it wanted from Africa, leaving Africa to waste away whilst Europe continues to prosper.
by steve biko
First hand experience from a mission doctor in the kwaZulu natal region (not me, someone I know who is actively involved trying to stop the spread of AIDS and attends AIDS conferences):
Africa's people generally don't have bucks for IV drugs, they mostly smoke them or use other methods. The biggest problem is that to be a man, you have to have sex. If you don't, the belief is that semen will go to your head and you will go mad.
You also have to do it with a woman (or man if you're in prison, anything rather than pull it yourself).
If you're a real man, you have more than one partner, even if you're married you have a girlfriend. The rationale? Who am I going to have sex with if she has her period, or is pregnant, or sick, or I just feel like some fun, whatever. Fact is that many men have upto 6 partners and more. 1 gets AIDS and the rest are history.
Another problem: I don't wear a condom because it's like eating a sweet with the wrapper on.
Then of course there's the age old problem of education: how do you explain to somebody who cannot read or write, or at least with minimal education, what a virus is. They've never seen a microscope let alone understand what the hell you're on about.
Only recently some communities have actually begun to believe that Aids is a problem, what with so many people around them dying of colds and flu.
Problem is now they believe it, there has to be a cure. Ahh, so they think up one: if you sleep with a virgin, you will be cured. So every man who suspects that he might have AIDS goes and finds himself a virgin.
And if he cannot find one? I don't know if you heard it on your news, but the latest is that they rape small children and sometimes even babies. Sick? For sure. That's what myths do for you.
So what's the solution? Throwing money at a problem when you know that some corrupt official is going to grab it and the people it was meant for never get it (like Max pointed out). I can't see that working.
AIDS needs to be treated like a huge project: before any money leaves anyone, the person receiving that money should give you a clear plan, with budgets and time lines and plans of how the money is going to bring about the AIDS solution. Treat it like I treat my projects: give feedback to the donors as if they were clients buying a product and have ways to actually prove effectiveness of the project.
And that goes for any money donated for any project. You demand to know how your tax dollars are being spent, why not the donated money. The difference (as I see it) between giving money to ease a conscience and giving money to actually make a difference: If you want it to make a difference you will follow up on it and find out what difference is being made.
If it's just to ease a conscience, then rather give it to your local church.
by sleepin'dawg
Henry Ford once said you can buy a Ford in any color you want as long as it's black(This was said in the early 20's)and that is analogous to Canadian Medicare. It doesn't matter if we are rich or poor we all get the same level of care and that's where the problems creep in. Even if you have the money you are supposed to wait in line for your turn. This does not apply to emergency care but only to elective surgery. I have bad knees and if I waited I would probably have to wait until next August for my surgery but I have enough money to be able to go to a US hospital for it this Sept 7th. Note I have chosen my surgeon, a transplanted Canadian, and the hospital where the operation will take place and I am paying for it myself but I will receive some reimbursement, based on Medicare's fee structure, when I return and submit my bills. That will only
get me about 40-45% of my costs. My rehab and convalesence will take place in Canada and will be free and I won't have to wait for that, at least. Contrast that with the US and the HMO circus you guys have. You go where they tell you and receive care from any clown they tell you to go to. Oh and if the doctors screw up well gee golly whiz, we can sue them in Canada too. Your choice but I prefer the Canadian system, I just haven't got the patience to wait for my turn at it. So on my own initiative I've decided to take it on my own terms a little from the US and the rest from Canada. Another thing, for what its worth Canada's contribution to the war on AIDS is around 3.5-4 billion and until lately the preferred drug for treatment, AZT, is a Canadian discovery. We also discovered insulin and a few other things. The funny thing is the Canadian companies were shortly thereafter bought out by American pharmaceutical companies. There is only 30 million of us and 300 million of you if you look at the contribution proportionately the US contribution would be 35-40 billion. I am curious to know what kind of officer you were in the navy.
Most of the ones I know are a lot better informed on world affairs and history than you seem to be. We went to Desert Storm and are currently in Afghanistan, where a couple of incompetent field grade officers chose to ignore the rules of engagement and bombed Canadian troops, killing 4 and wounding 12. These men are still waiting for reparations from the US government and those asshole pilots still haven't appologized. After the Bay of Pigs fiasco, which was a US planned operation, that was really screwed up by the last minute cancellation of promised air support, JFK authorized the founding of The Center for Special WarFare in Jan/62. Due to a lack of qualified instructors, the US had to "borrow" instructors from other sources. There were 50 SAS officers and NCO's from Britain and 4 officers and 12 NCO's from Canada. Bragg is a much nicer assignment than Churchill in January. I,ve personally soldiered in Cyprus, The Congo(Zaire), Egypt and Canadian troops have done tours in a lot of other African countries like Somalia where they finally saw some Americans and yes we lost people there too but nobody made a movie about the Canadians killed, the number of whitch was at least as high as the American losses. Remember old Ayatola Coca Cola, the guy who penned up 80 Americans in their embassy, guess what country stuck its neck out to rescue a bunch of them? That's right poor little sad sack Canada. Hell your government even hung a medal on our ambassador. If you really want to get into a pissing contest; in WW II Canada declared war on Germany even before the Brits and definitely well before the Americans. You guys were a little late,like almost 2 1/2 years, before you caught up with us and in Korea The Canadian Government authorized the commitment of troops to that little fracas even before the US did. Vietnam was a bad war and we didn't go to that one, I admit but a lot of Canadians joined up in the US to go. I have a cousin who did two tours as a marine gunnery sergeant. He got a Purple Heart and Bronze and Silver Stars. Do you want to talk about welfare; well our pension plan isn't going to go bankrupt as soon as yours will. Yours is supposed to be tapped out somewhere between 2008 and 2012 ours is good until at least 2018 but that may get better as we've been cutting our deficit. I am no lover of welfare and socialism is a losing proposition. Socialism reduces everything to its lowest common denominator and kills or stifles incentive whereas capitalism rewards those who aspire to greater things and those with initiative. I resent anyone who calls me a socialist and would gladly meet them in any alley of their choice and I promise I'll be the one who will be able to walk out. The balls in your court big mouth and as we like to say up here bulls**t walks while actions talk. We had a motto "Who Dares, Wins" We seem to be of an age after all you said somewhere you were a 30 year man but I somehow feel I'm spotting you a few years. Be that as it may, I am still more than capable of demonstrating some of the stuff I was teaching back in 62. Look at it this way squid, it might be the last chance at fun you're likely to get and that's with or without your clothes on. Hell considering your age, it's probably going to be your only chance.
by sleepin'dawg
by sleepin'dawg
I take it you still are looking for a free lunch and in these days you ain't gonna get one. You're comparing apples and oranges. You say you're ONLY 200 bucks out of pocket. How about your health insurance??? How much do you pay annually for that, bearing in mind that I am intimately aware of health insurance costs in the US?????? Hmmmm.
I'll bet if you looked a little closer you would find that health care in Canada, where the pharmaceutical companies are prevented from ripping us off and our insurance is in our tax bill you would find that costs to the individual are about 60% less in Canada. A prescription that costs $25 in Canada can be well over $100 in the US. Now why is that???? Its the same company and the same drug so why does it cost 3 times as much in the US???? Is it perhaps the pharmaceutical companies have to pay for all their lobbiests in Dizzy City???? Now there's a thought!!!! We don't have very many pharmaceutical lobbiests, or very many other types in Canada. Maybe you would like to talk to the bus loads of US senior citizens who arrive every weekend in Montreal, Toronto or Vancouver for the sole purpose of purchasing their medications???? Maybe you could convince THEM of just how superior your system is. As it is, we have learned to avoid the prescription counters of any pharmacy near a bus station on a weekend because there are so many Americans lined up for their drugs. As I've said elsewhere you are nothing but a loud mouth, ignorant blowhard, bulls**t artist and my offer still stands. I can respect Max and Jim even though I sometimes disagree with them, just like I feel about Oz who can annoy the s**t out of me with some of his pinko rhetoric but I don't have any respect for prevaricating blowhards. You must have been with Kerry on his Swift. The Swift Vets have a thing or two to say about him. Maybe you're a Kerry fan???? Evan Garion, who can piss me off royally with some of his anti-Canadian rants, I can respect because I'm never too sure just how serious he is being. If you really want to get to specifics; I broke my wrist in Daytona in 1995. I was taken to an emergency ward at some hospital and spent 10-12 hours being Xrayed and having the bones set and a cast put on. When I left I paid my bill on Amex whitch came to slightly over $6000 but having little experience with American hospitals thought this must be the going rate. Imagine my surprise when I showed the bill to my American friends because I was a bit taken aback by some of the detailed charges and they all to a man thought I got off light. The charges that made me curious were things like $6 for two aspirins or Tylenols, $8 for a pillow that I never put my head on, $4.50 for a bandaid whitch I could have lived without and a smorgasborg of other similar charges. The bill was four pages long. I had never seen a hospital bill like that before and was really quite taken aback. My American friend who took me to the hospital said he had expected the bill to be more in the range of $7500-$8500 and he thought I was being a bit ungrateful for complaining about $6000. Back in Canada a week later, I had to have the cast removed and the wrist rebroken because it had been improperly set. Funny thing is I never saw a bill for that and I spent over night in the hospital. I guess judging by that bill your medical system is much more superior than Canada's.
by garion11
Thanks for your comments, some I agree with and some I don't, some I wasn't born when it happened, so I can't comment, lol.
But glad to hear your opinion. I wish more people around the world would see the problem isn't America, but radical Islam.
by sleepin'dawg
by garion11
Canada has a lot of these people running around. I sincerely hope nothing happens. After watching these videos it scared me, because these aren't terrorists that are saying this on National TV. They are ordinary everyday muslims.
by garion11
He didn't say the war was against radical Islam (or maybe he couldn't). He used the term Terrorists. Thats such a vague and general term. Anyone can be labeled a terrorist if and when the word suited them.
Yes you are right about the PC war bulls**t. If you are going to fight, don't fight a half assed fight. Sadly because of these loony lefties in our country, people are afraid of being labeled a racist or bigot for acknowledging the truth about Islam. I fear we will pay much harsher price for Bush's choice of words.
by skipperusn
Oz stated in a post that Healthcare in Canada was FREE - No Out of Pocket - So I researched it - Found those figures from the Canadain Government healthcare site...
Now that doesn't sound free - even thou you are paying for healthcare in your taxes - you still have out of pocket expenses of $1,200 (candain) yearly? I am confused Oz - in his all knowing mind says it is free - Free tells me once I paid taxes thats all I have to pay - for Heatlhcare -
Now its 10, 20, 30, 40, ---- 100 a month - for additional on top of my taxes and I have to wait in line - and wait months for elective surgery - some health problems are restirceted because of costs are to much to treat - you all come to US to get it done because you all don't want to wait in line...
And Oz says the US should have a healthcare system like Canada ... Something doesn't smell that good - over 100 billion (canadian) spent in 2001 - and climbing ... it sounds like taxes will be going up up up ... in canada..
I pay 25.00 (US) a month - my employer pays the rest - medicare and medicad are for low income and retired folks - Med+ and CHips are for poor and low income families and kids in PA -
Healthcare in the states is one of the best in the world - no lines - no waiting for elective surg's - no divying out care - Other states have County hospitals - that cover the uninsured -
I'll take it over socialized healthcare any day .. you all can keep your system.... Free my arse - you will be paying 3 times what I and my employer pay ...combined,.,
by oz_media
First of all, I have yet to meet a single Canadian who was denied surgery based on cost and not the urgency of the surgery needed.
Secondly you said I told you medical was free and then came up with the $34.00/month figure I provided to you when you didn't understand the first time.
Do you actually believe you are clever or something?
by hermix
By the way he did die.....but not of AIDS.
Something is definetly cooking......just the tip. Unless of course you swallow the party line.
by steve biko
by steve biko
I read up on Dr Willner and then spoke to a doctor who is very involved in the treatment, diagnosis and prevention of AIDS.
Experience is something very important and with a very large percentage of people "allegedly" affected by AIDS in South Africa, he appears to have some credibility. He is also very involved in AIDS conferences to study this "disease".
My concern of his claims (and the few others like him) are that they are in direct contradiction of what is happening here. Many people die of sicknesses which they should not be dying of in the 21st century. The causes of death are often something as simple as a cold, pneumonia or something else which the doctors can normally treat very easily.
In addition to this they are able to test the effectiveness of the Immune system and can tell when a person's immune system is depleted and are often able to predict when a person will die, despite all efforts to prevent the death.
You may say that it is all about drugs and the desire to make money out of a new drug, thereby creating a "phantom disease" for pharmaceutical companies to make more money.
That kind of argument does not "wash" in Africa, people have no money for the expensive drugs and therefore such a market would be very poor.
In fact the claim that AZT causes AIDS is disproven in South Africa, it has only recently been administered to some patients, so it could not have caused AIDS in the millions who have never had the drug.
Proof that people are dying of AIDS? Check ups done on the local population indicates that the younger population is being depleted at a rate only seen in times of war, yet we have no war in South Africa, so where are all these AIDS orphans coming from, and why are their parents dying at such an alarming rate?
I find it hard to believe a few people's claims, when the majority of the scientific and medical community are so involved in this fight against AIDS.
Don't believe everythig you read!
by steve biko
With reference to the statement:
My concern of his claims (and the few others like him) are that they are in direct contradiction of what is happening here.
The he I am talking of is this Dr Willner.
by low_dan
by sleepin'dawg
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending