Discussion Locked

Size of IT Staff

0 helpful
262 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am a fairly new IT director at this organization. I am designing a new infrastructure and I am adding services. I would like to know if anyone has references for IT department sizes. I had a proposal to hire a network admin and a Systems admin on top of the help desk person that I already have. The Executive staff is questioning my proposal and they feel all they need is another help desk person. They want me to manage all the services. We are an organization of 100 people. Our organization runs our own conferences and we are a membership based business. Besides the basic services of Email and Internet, we will be running Share point , communication server, Oracle, MS SQl for Great Plains, E-commerce, VoIP, Web conf and Wireless.

262 replies

by kfellows

I think you have to have defined roles and tasks. If the call volume is low the Help Desk staff might be able to do backups and replace printer paper, but do you really want a Help Desk person building a production server or installing a network switch?

If you are small enough then a single person might be able to do both the Network and Systems Admin functions but eventually you are correct and will need two people. I suspect upper management is counting you as engineering staff when you should be managing the network and your systems. So I say maybe compromise and get one person now who can wear two hats.

by gario

So, if I read you correctly, you are a new IT Director with one help desk person, and Management wants you to run all services (workstations, servers, newtork, databases, website, and telecommunications). Once again, I see a company who expects a manager/director to be an administrator/engineer.

Ok, not knowing what your environment includes (how many servers, workstations, etc.), I would go after a Server/systems administrator at least. Possibly another help desk person and then possibly outsource network support if you have to.

by durbs

You need to be careful here. The correct size of an IT department is the number of people required to perform the agreed services to the agreed SLA's. Negotiate this well with management or else you will be in the firing line when services slip. Both your staff and the business management will appreciate this being planned correctly upfront.

by eli3050

Agreed. It depends what is the company's culture. Are they expecting a manager or hands-on technician with managerial skills. For one hundred people and up to 10 servers you may function well with two people. But your help desk person aka IT administrator, aka Network Administrator should savy and strong professionally.
Good luck and welcome to a lot of underappreciated work.

by pete1978

I agree fully. The question is SLA ... do they exist and, if so, is IT able to meet them? That is the question regarding the need for increasing (or decreasing) staff size unless other IT changes are happening (more on that later).

If the organization has SLAs, then the previous person with your responsibilities should have been keeping SLA documentation. Find that documentation. It may be your best defense that the positions are needed.

If the organization does not have SLAs, get them ASAP. But even before getting SLAs, start
keeping the SLA type of documentation ... it'll support your position on what SLA can be expected from IT.

Documentation is your best friend. It shows what your staff is doing, how long it takes, and the impact this has on the parent organization and much much more. There is a very real danger when NOT keeping documentation ... it could mean your job. Read the article found at http://itmanagement.earthweb.com/career/article.php/3359051.

Sounds like you need to look at something like ITIL. It addresses service and support (via SLA) but also addresses "capacity management". If the organization is expanding IT services (adding more workstations, servers, services, etc.), then capacity management is what you want to address. It addresses the question "Can the IT group support the extended IT infrsstructure without sacrificing support for the current infrastructure?" This is a very important question if the organization plans to grow the IT infrastructure! But, too often, it is ignored.

Tons of review literature on ITIL on the net, but you may have to fork out a few $$$ to get more complete ITIL documents. After reviewing the literature on the net, you may decide it's worth the money.

Finally, remember that the higher admins are your boss. Support your position strongly, but not at the expense of your career. And if they force their position, keep your documentation. Later, when they ask why IT isn't providing the support they want, you can show that IT is working full time but that there are not enough people in the IT group to meet the organization's IT demands. Then ask for the additional positions again (without using "I told you so" unless they buck the idea again).

In this case, patience is a virtue.

by ninjabeaver

Hi,

In the UK the recommended allocation is one IT staff member to every 40 PC's on site. For all the servers and extra services you are running I certainly don't feel your request is too much. Perhaps a compromise of a combined Network / Systems Admin and also an extra HelpDesk person might go down better. You could always train the Help Desk person upto the required level.

I will say that I know where you are coming from working as a school Network Manager. I've got seven servers and 500 + Laptops and PC's to deal with, plus 1500 'customers' (teaching staff, admin staff and pupils). There's only two of us running the site though.

Push for it, and possibly go the route of 'if blah blah goes down then it will cost you $$$' etc. That might work.

But, as I said, industry here recommends a 40 PC's to 1 Techie.

by ksutherland

I agree with my friend in the UK. However it depends on your environment. If all application run on the desktop the ratio could be as low as 25 to 1. If you are in a thin client (ie: Citrix) were all applications are running on the servers and the desktop environment are windows terminals and/or locked down PC the ration could be 40 to 1.

I once found a tool (I believe on this web site) that was and estimating tools to determine the size of IT staff based on the environment. It was good because my management was looking for industry best practices and this tool gave me the information they needed.

by philip.wang

two for server and netwrok and they can backup each other. Two helpdesks can cover 100 users with the applications you mentioned above. Of course if you are expert in IT you can take one of the server and network admin role particially.

by angry_white_male

We have 5 people... IT director, network admin, helpdesk, mainframe programmer, SQL DBA.

We run about 175 Win2K/XP workstations spread out over 11 locations, 25 Win2K/2003 servers (5 are dedicated SQL servers), an AS/400 midrange, some wireless sprinkled in for fun, etc.

For the most part, we're a busy shop... I'm always looking to work smarter so we can have some room to breathe. We're adding several new systems in the next 2 years which will mean about 10-12 more servers, the shut down of the AS/400. We'll loose our AS/400 guy (we're timing the phase-out of the AS/400 with his retirement) and will likely gain another DBA or programmer to help run the new systems.

Our helpdesk guy also takes care of the clerical functions, but he's getting busy to the point where he needs to be 100% helpdesk and we're looking at bringing in a part-time clerical person.

So - it really all depends on the level of expectation that your management has on the IT department - how fast you should be responding to issues, how many projects they want you to take on, etc.

The less rope you give your users, the less things they can break which means the fewer helpdesk calls you need to contend with. Make use of the available technologies to keep users from wreaking havoc on your network. Don't be afraid to tell people (or your bosses) "no" when things land on your plate that are not a priority and have an impact to your department that your cannot handle with the resources you currently have.

by swanepoell

You have to think about a person that goes on leave and he should have a backup for that time.
Anything can happen.
Always have a backup especially in crisis times.

Talk to management you all adults and work for one company.

Good Luck!

by mike.zammit

As an organisation, we have conducted various research projects in the public/private and not for profit sectors of business here in the UK. We find that the average size of an IT department providing good levels of service to the business is about 28 IT staff per 1000 employees, but this average goes up as the size of the organisation diminishes, which leads us to believe that there is a minimum level of IT staffing required to provide good levels of service regardless of the size of organisation.

I would suggest that your plan to have a staffing level of 4 (yourself plus three others) is probably about right given the number of different applications and systems your organisation is currently running. However, I would also recommend that you take a look at the need to run both Oracle and MS SQL Server. You need SQL Server for Great Plains, but could you migrate your Oracle databases to SQL Server, giving only one RDBMS to support.

by rcuk

Hi Mike,

I work for an FE/HE college in Scotland. You figures are
interesting. Do you have and reports which I could quote in my
bid for additional staff?

Wiith some of the staffing levels stated by others in the post, we
would appear to be fairly well of! However we fall into the 'being
forced to be reactive' category when my team are striving to be
proactive. Anything you may be able to provide would be
gratefully accepted and referenced to the supplier.

Ray

by bqualls

The Executive staff should determine how many persons in what positions are required to run the business. Their job is to prioritize which services are the most important services to run the company. Your job is to hire the best persons to meet their priorities. I suggest that you list all of the services, regardless of priority, you believe will be required to run the company 12 months from now. Go crazy. You need networking, phones, e-mail, web services, security, databases, user support, financial apps, etc. Document the role of each service to the business and the impact when the service is down (i.e. when the network is down you don't get e-mail, Internet access, customers can't access our web sites, etc). Let the Executive staff prioritize which services are most important to the business. Now design the IT staff to meet the requirements set forth by the Executive staff. Of course it will be bigger than they expected... But now it is on their shoulders to reduce the persons instead of on you to convince them to hire more.

by bburgess9

The responsibility of the executive staff is to listen to their subordinate mgrs so that they may make informed (responsible) decisions. If you have informed them of the need and why (in writing), then you have done your job. However you should push a little. In my experience, the executive mgmt does not believe that IT mgrs have the ability to make business decisions. So unless you push the issue, you will always be living with this self-destructive nature.

by dave.claridge

Before you can size the IT support services required for your environment you need to know what the business expects from the services you are delivering. The first step is to define the services you need to provide, e.g helpdesk, Email, Internet access, ecommerce application, WAN, Wireless networking. Great Plains (ERP).

Then define the SLA's. First of all what are the required hours of service for each service? What are the requirements for reliability (how many failures per period can be tolerated), availability (what is the percentage availability needed), servicability (how quickly do you need to respond to incidents e.g is the ecommerce app is down how long can the business do without it (minutes? or hours?).

Then use the information to analyse each service e.g for the helpdesk service given your use base of 100 people in a steady state environment then based on industry experience that will generate 100 calls (1 call per user per month) to the helpdesk in each month or say 5 calls per day. This obviously needs one person on the helpdesk with someone to back them up for holidays sickness.

If you follow this through with the other services you should be able to come up fairly easily with a staff profile and the Executive if they arent happy with this have the option of reducing the SLA's or services.

Hope this helps and best of luck

by bpennstsi

There is no formula to size an IT shop because they are all different.

What are your uptime requirements? Do you have bandwidth-intensive applications (imaging, multimedia, etc.)? When new staff come onboard, do you pre-configure their machines or take them out of the box?

What back-office support functions (backup, server configuration, etc.) need to be performed and how much time do they require?

What are your actual/historical call volumes to the helpdesk? How quickly are responses required when calls come in? What hours does the helpdesk need to be staffed?

Who will evaluate new services prior to implementation? How will they be implemented (in-house or outsourced)? (This is more of a budget issue than a staffing issue, but you can be sure it will impact IT staff time.)

Once you've done this kind of analysis, you can evaluate the skill requirements and the time needed for each skill.

While this may seem time consuming, it's a task you can do easily in a spreadsheet and it will provide the justification you need to sell your executives on the level of staffing needed.

by fcleroux

There is some great advise in most of these posts. I consult fo many firms and worked corporate also. Several law firms I deal with cannot afford to be down at all. That is AT ALL. If they were to be down for 30 minutes that is OK. A total loss of services for 4 hours could cost thme upwards of 500K. Staffing is important and CHEAP when you look at what it will cost if systems are down. Staffing is very important but properly designed and implemented systems are sometimes more important. Unfortunately you can only get there with staff.

Another common issue is that companies way to often get back logged and turn into "reactive" IT departments as opposed to being "proactive". In other words they tend to always be busy looking after problems rather than making sure there are no problems. You need to be ahead.

How many readers companies here have time to proactively test out Updaes, Upgrades, Patches for Servers, Workstations and such in a timely maner and implement them all!! Most don't. Eventually this catches up till dissaster strikes. That is usually when I get called in to help. Usually to late.

Ask you execs if that dissaster is allowed to happen. Can you company deal with being down for a day or two every couple of years with lots of little problems along the way??

by busy_bee

I agree with Dave. This is an appropriate way to approach it, and it translates easily to dollars and cents terms that the bosses and business owners understand.

The translation from services and SLAs to number of bodies may seem like a bit of magic, but if you define SLAs well, and then estimate the number of hours it will take on average to fulfill them, that will give you a rough number of bodies.

You should figure a maximum resource allocation of 80% (32 hours / wk per person), less if they need availability to respond to critical issues (i.e., help desk must support server issues as well).

Ultimately, you will want to present a somewhat formal document, so that if you get shot down on your proposal, you can refer back to it when you are explaining later why the service levels are lower than desired.

by dask

It seems to me that your staffing should depend on your IT needs based on the current services and future growth. This all comes down to the processes and time requires to provide the services with an eye on the future.
From a business viewpoint, what is the cost of an outage, backlog, etc. If you can acquire the metrics of what you are doing, the skills of the existing personnel and the strategic vision or marketable growth of the organization, then that should build your business case for staffing.
Needless to say, the abilities and skills of your existing staff (novice, trained, expert, etc.) directly effects the time it takes to do something or diagnose an anomoly.
Hope that helps.

by breirden

The determination of proper staffing ratios depends on a lot of factors including the size of the organization, amount of standardization, level of complexity of the user applications, sophistication of the users, expectations of executive management, the level of risk they are willing to accept, your ability as a Director, the skill level and work ethics of your people, etc., etc.

I looked into this exact question several times over the years, there is no specific answer. The bottom line is: are the executives happy with the service they are getting for the money they are paying? You can be getting 150% from your staff and there is no gurantee of satisfaction.

Educate the executives, and your staff, build solid SLA's and work toward continuous improvement. I also suggest getting into ITIL as a way to develop your working processes.

by reb413

I ran a network by myself consisting of one WAN connecting three LANs with 85 workstations in total. I did it all. I also had responsibility over the three telephone systems and the company cell phones.

During the last six months I was there, I spent about 35% of my time studying for certifications because the entire place was runing so smoothly.

So, the number of staff you need really depends on how well you tune your entire enterprise.

by 3kl

I agree with Reb413. I work in a university with around 14,000 users total. My team run the servers (75) and labs/classrooms with 600 desktops. We have 3 of us managing the whole thing. An exchange system (with 2000 staff members and 12,500 students) that is run solely by me. By any stance we are understaffed compared to where an IT shop should be. We do a damn good job of keeping things running and patched, but the university sacrifices our ability to be proactive due to the amount of break/fix issues we have to deal with. The same will most likely hold true for the small IT shop. You can probably slide by with 2 staff members, but if they want any progress they need to give you at least one more tech and one level 1/level 2 helpdesk employee.

by dean.h

I work for a Technical College, with 700 computers on 4 campuses, with 12 servers, VoIP, Active Directory, and 2500 users (faculty, staff, and students). In the past I have been the only IT staff the college had. I now have one other IT tech to help. If it gets done, the two of us do it. Our Director of IT Services is a librarian (yes you read that correctly), she doesn't even understand the basice of internetworking and has some difficulty telling the difference between a computer that is turned on from one that's turned off. We do the network administration, AD administration, desktop support, hardware support, in other words, we do it all. How many people does that make me?

by beads

There have been some very good comments but I don't think anyone has enough information to clearly make accurate suggestions - yet.

Can you explain the following?

What is your role as "Director of IT"? Directors generally have managers working for them are you planning on having an actual network manager/engineer/administrator fill this role or are you planning on doing much of the design and engineering work yourself? Its a pet peeve of mine like VP's of IT when they have no Directors, Managers or staff to oversee. Sue me. LOL.

What is the capacity of the current help desk person? Is this a phone support (level 1); very basic support; 2nd level, able to visit machines and resolve most problems; or level 3 able to configure several workstation varients, troubleshoot and configure possibly conflicting software. The next step would be the admin type who should be able to do everything above plus keep the network up and running without much in the way of day to day supervision.

Sounds like your help desk is really doing much of the admin functions, now. What role will this person play in a four person group? How will this person feel when two people join the group and is suddenly relegated to more mundane tasks?

Can you clearly define the roles of the two new positions? If you came to me with two positions that sound remarkably similiar, i.e. Systems Administrator and Network Administrator I'd probably pushback as well because they sound much the same. Clearly defining the roles will make the push for staffing much easier all the way around. Its a guess that your really looking for more of a "DBA lite" for the SQL server/back-end products and a Network Engineer for the more internal client facing side of the business. These need to be clearly defined responsibilities as well. Who runs the email system? Who runs your SQL? Switches? DNS?

Then and only then will you have a real case to take back to the rest of executive management. A Director level position is generally considered executive management as well. So these should be your peers as well as your senior management partners. Time to wheel and deal your ideas, about.

One help desk person should be able to do desktop support for 100 people standing on thier head so I would hope your in good shape there.

One Systems person should be more than enough to support a dozen or so servers. Really, this has gotten much easier if you plan for your patches and use best practices. This person should be almost bored at times.

Back end servers like SQL and Email may require some additional hand holding but since you are not mentioning a developer/dba type I am assuming that most of this is either off the shelf or supported from outside the organization meaning that this position is much more likely to receive the greatest amount of pushback from your peers. Since it seems to be the most suspect.

Add the above positional descriptions and I think you'll have a much better shot at getting an accurate responses from folks. Right now we're all over the board with great comments and lots of pats on the back for asking for more IT folks.

- beads

by barbarad

Hi trtjj,
We work with a number of companies with 100 or more employees. My company provides the Help Desk support to these companies allowing them to run the on-site IT support with only a small staff of one or two people. Consider lowering your costs by outsourcing your help desk to a competent local provider and redeploy your internal people to more complex issues that require on-site work.

Best, Barbara

by mike

I am the Network/Systems/Helpdesk personel at my company for roughly 75 desktops, 25 servers, and all the network equipment. Our management has also been hesitant to hire the additional staff, but they have been very understanding when it comes to how that choice affects response time.

The other item I would think to consider is how much change the environment needs to undergo. Our environment has 'calmed' significantly over time, making it far easier to run with just one person. Try not to staff up just to settle some immediate issues and then have little for people to work on afterwards. Consider one full time admin and possibly a part-time or intern to assist with the daily fire fighting until things become stable.

by warpindy

Not knowing your the new # of pc and servers that you are currently running I would at at least try and get two people in the door. One person would have to wear two hats in this can. You stated that you like ot have a network and systems admin try and find a person that can do the job of both jobs for now and a hire a help desk person that can also do the job of a sys admin. I would write it up to the executive staff that you would need that one person would help with the new demands of a new infrastructure, the network/sys admin, and that you would hire a more advanced person on the help desk side, helpdesk/sys admin, to help with new user demand.
Document they change in demand on the old going into the new infrastructure now so that if need to hire one more person all you would have to do is take your network/sys admin and make them your network admin, your helpdesk/sys admim you full time system admin and then hire another helpdesk person. All of these would be lateral moves and might keep the exec staff of your back when you ask for the new hire within another 6 to 12 months.

Good luck

by 3kl

Hopefully this goes without saying, but is the current help desk staffer someone that could be moved up to an entry level sys admin? I know if I was that person and totally ignored when a new job was added I would be bitter and consider leaving the company at that point.

by jrenatok

Good point. Since I don?t have enough information about your company?s requirements, but the size of 100 people, I suggest you a very pragmatic approach of paying a 3rd party company to provide you remote and on-site service (this case, on-demand).

This situation is as long as your company accepts this kind of service support. I?m not saying this is a wreck solution. It works fine, but you get what you pay for.

Security issues regarding remote access to your environment can be solved with technology (point-to-point links, VPN,...).

The challenge is finding a company that could fit your budget, based on Executive Staff expectations. You can deal SLA with your service provider regarding scheduled and non-scheduled actions, as well as the amount of effort the monthly cost is covering.

Consider that an interim solution. It can last as long as it fits business constraints.

It?s really hard to let Executive Staff understand how complex are IT activities and this is not an one-man-show, but in other hand, it doesn?t make any sense to have IT structure with significant costs compared with business structure.

It?s easier for you to manage a service provider than manage an undersized poor broad skilled IT staff.

Let me know if this worked well for you.

Regards,

Renato.

by sr10

You need to start with the service level you are expected to provide. Here are some, but not all, of the questions I would ask:
How long can it take to fix a network outage? To add a new hire?
How long can E-commerce be down?
How much manual effort does it require to make E-commerce go on a daily basis?
How long can VoIP be down?
How many hours a day are you committed to service availability? Are you a 24/7 shop? Can you rule out being called between, say, 10pm and 6am?
Who writes the one-off reports for Great Plains?
How much IT involvement is there in basic repetitive functions like monthly close?

The answers to this provide your level of staffing demand. You write job reqs to fill the demand. Then the execs can either approve hiring to the demand or scale back the service level requirements. If they approve, you know exactly what you're hiring for and can communicate that in the interview.

by jdlucky

Your Oracle system itself should have a dedicated DBA, unless of course you're outsourcing. I could see you getting by with one other strong network admin person but definately see why your exec team is questioning your proposal. You're asking to double your staff and most shops with 100 people only have about 2-3 people as it is if they're lucky. My shop has 130. I am the IT Mgr and I have a strong help desk/network admin working with me. We are very busy, but currently have a proposal to bring in a DBA for building a data warehouse and hopefully one more help desk person, but I won't hold my breath. Basically, IT is an expense and you're always going to have trouble justifying additional head count unless you have good documenatation and metrics to go with your proposal. You're going to have to baseline your workload and show you actually need the help because service levels or user satisfaction is not being met.

Good luck.

by sumjay

The IT shop I managed in Delaware, had similar issues and requirements (I am going on assumptions here for our friend TRTJJ).

A strong network guy and a strong help desk person could be quite adequate, if they were cross trained (in their basic function as back up) in case they were sick or something.

I had a remote DBA who was very capable and was on call whenever we needed him thus reducing costs substantially.

We had about 75 to 80 users who had to be kept happy. I discovered that training the users periodically helped keep our calls and help desk tickets volume down.

This allowed my staff to pay closer attention to do the real nitty gritty stuff our systems needed to run smoothly, like maintaining upgrades, DRP testing etc.

by kate

There used to be a white paper that helps you calculate the IT staff to user ratio, but it doesn't seem to be in the White Paper section any more. I used it as the basis to justify hiring more staff in my IT dept., and also used it as a benchmark to show management how much more efficient we are compared to industry recommendations. I still have a copy of the paper I downloaded, if anyone wants it.

by leanne.gutsell

Hello kate,

I'd like to take you up on the offer of getting a copy of the whitepaper please.

Thanks
Leanne

lupaleanne@hotmail.com

by lordanubis

Hi Kate,

If you can overlook the fact that I graduated from KU, can you send me a copy of that whitepapter? I'm strugling with this problem like so many others and the whitepaper might help.

Thanks,
ogvada@yahoo.com

by cta

Dear Kate,
I would also like to have a copy of the white paper. thank you.

by techrepublic.com

The last time I was hiring I used:

IT manager and project leader
=============================
One manager/supervisor for eight staff positions.

System/Network analyst
======================
One analyst handles $886,000 in network monitoring devices, systems and interfaces (or up to $2.5 million, if voice telecom is included).

Intranet/Internet specialist
============================
One specialists for every 35 Web sites.

E-mail administrator
====================
One administrator for every 1,400 mail users.

Help desk staff
===============
One analyst to handle 600 transactions per month (average contact handle time is 12 minutes).

by mehodgsonsr

I would like to see the white paper you mentioned. Please send it to mehodgson(at)westech-inc.com
Thanks.

by awestbrook

Kate,
Could you please send me a copy of this white paper? I'd love to have it.

Please send to awestbrook@simplylala.com

Thanks,
Arthur

by jeng

can you send me a copy of the white paper? thanks!

jeng@newvisions.org

by Member 34940552

kate

would love a copy ...wonder why they removed such a popular white paper...hint hint TKN!!!

nooly77@yahoo.com

by bkuner

Kate,

I would like to get a copy of the whitepaper.

bkuner@chmca.org.

Thanks

by mike.zammit

I would be very grateful if you could send me a copy of the white paper. It is always useful to have multiple, independent sources to refer to when running a sizing project.

Thanks in advance.

by rholz

Could you please send me a copy of the white paper, too?
Thanks a lot in advance.

by jspain

Kate,

I would also appreciate a copy of the White Paper that you referenced that helps you calculate IT staff to user ratio. Thanks!

jspain@nc.rr.com

by joongll

Hi Kate,

Could you also send a copy of the white paper that you've mentioned to me as well.

Thanks a lot.

Cheers,
Jo.

by mitchc

Kate
I realise you have been inundated with requests for the white paper but could i also recieve a copy.
Mitch

by mje

Hi Kate,

Looks like you got yourselves some of a job here :-)
I'm very interested in the white paper too.
If you have the time, please email it to
***
mje@mag1.aarhus.dk
***

Thanks a lot in advance

Best regards
Martin Jeppesen

by Former member

Kate,
you have opened a can of worms. It seems that staffing is a big issue that everyone needs help with, including me. A copy of the white paper would be a big help. Thanks.

Jody Sweeney
jody.sweeney@state.de.us

by kenneth.leake

I'm coming fashionably late to this discussion (as usual), but would be grateful for a copy of the paper.

Regards

Ken Leake
Health Solutions Wales

by s.mcnerney

Please send me a copy of the white paper. I am hoping this help address my staffing needs for support as well special projects. We have many of them thrown the way of my department and we can't keep up with the projects or support.

I have a staff of 4 including myself, the IT Manager. We are implementing ERP, wireless and have many other special projects such as building moves and remodels. How do you account for staffing these projects when you do not know they are coming?

Any other idea's?

by cmeid

Please send me a copy of that white paper if you still have it! My company is big on making us all wear too many hats, and the white paper you are describing might just help our Network Admin hand one of his hats to a new hire and letting him dedicate his time to the network.

Thanks

themeid@hotmail.com

by lfguerrero

I could certainly use the white paper also. Thanks for your kind offer.

guerrerol @ hpumc.org

Given the amount of interest this has generated, perhaps Tech Republic should consider reposting the white paper.

by ctkenyon

Kate,

It might be worth seeing if the WhitePaper can be re posted to the site. In the meantime, would you please send me a copy at ctk9090@yahoo.com

by pagwu

Kate, your paper will be quite helpful to many it seems. I am also interested and want to suggest that perhaps you should re-post it in the download section and everyone can then download it from there. Saves you having to respond to potentially hundreds of request.

Your thoughts?

by rickt

Please send me a copy of the whitepaper also, my email address is rickt@boatfun.com

by bwoolard

Would you please send me a copy of this white paper to brian.woolard@longaberger.com, and thank you in advance

by tfinnegan

Please send me a copy of the whitepaper when you get a chance. Thanks!

tfinnegan@alphanumeric.com

by djholmes824

In my experience I have used a ratio of 1 IT support specialist (Level 2)/150 desktops and 1 help desk person/200-300 desktops. For network administration/infrastructure I have gone with 1 administrator per 500 desktops (regardless of servers or network switches). For business applications I have gone with 1 apps specialist per 3 dedicated business apps. If there is a white paper that would be great. Look forward to viewing a paper that gives you a benchmark.

by twendland

Kate,

Please email me a copy of the IT Staff Ratio Calculator white paper.

Thanks in advance,
Tim
twendland@ucg.com

by neteng

Would really like to get my hands on the staffing white-paper. As our client keeps piling more new systems on we a looking for some supporting documentation to justify the corresponding need for increased staff.

wheasley@ut.edu

by waynes

If you don't have budget to get two people on board, you may try to add one position first. Try to find an all-in-one person. In small company, you can't expect to hire expert for every software/hardware. I'm not an expert on one particular function. But I can handle from helpdesk to SAP support and from fixing a desktop/laptop to rebuild a server. As an IT Manager (helpdesk/system admin), I handle 60 PC/Mac/laptop and 7 servers in 8 different locations). In your case, I would said you should spend about 20 to 50 percent of your time to do the hands-on technical work. Unless your company has a lot of money then it would allow you to do 100 percent management work.
(Before my previous employer relocated to different state, I was an IT Director to manage 15 people from IT, customer support, and technical marketing departments.) Keep in mind; you MUST customize your IT department for your company. Every company has different customer service level requirement, budget, and so many other factors. If you like, you may contact me at waynes@jdfine.com, I will give you more suggestion from my experience.

by Member 25812923

I read another reply stating 1 helpdesk per 40 pc's, which is a good figure. As a rule of thumb one helpdesk per 50 users to support is really the maximum.

So in your case at least you need another helpdesk engineer.

Yet to cut you some slack a third person (comming down to 1/33) who can or share basic system administration will give you flexability and knowledge.

The amount of staff required to support hardware alos depends on the homogenity of the hardware. With two you can easaliy manage up to 1000 exact the same systems.
My opinon is that for every extra OS to support, you can add another engineer.

If your environment is stable and purely focused on usage, not development, have system/application maintenance outsourced/managed (a guy a day or two a month might be sufficient), and your own staff do the everyday system management.
With runbooks, provided by the externel party.

The amount of systems is not mentioned, but based on the variety of services, I would say that at least one full time admin is required, but for continuity I would suggest two, who can share tasks. One of them could support the helpdesk.
They could be of comparable skills, cause it is not clear if it is required to have a pure network engineer on the role.

Your whole plan could benefit form having drawn up a kind of Service Level Agreement with your organization with clear KPIs, and a good inventory of daily tasks an occurance of issues.
If you have a good notion of the time spent on user support, and on systems and applications management, you may be able to come to a good staff planning.

In your case I'd say, at least another helpdesker, and a system manager (with helpdesk backup support), but- if room is there, add another system admin, or a good outmanagement company.

Good luck!

F

by rkendsley

Our organization has, 1500 employees, 2000+ phones, approximately 5000 desktop/laptop computers, more than 45 servers, but I will stick with 45 at this point, and a WAN that connects 22 sites. THIS IS ALL RUN BY 9 (Conut EM) 9 people!
A mixed environment of Windows (98,2K,XP), Macintosh, & Linux.

1 Phone person
1 audio/visual person (Did I mention the 1000+ televisions, vcr, dvd players?)
1 postmaster/web developer
2 technicians
1 network manager
1 database administrator
1 clerk
1 director
----------
9 People

Employee's call the person of their choice for help, which as you might have guessed really causes alot of interruptions in our days.

You have 2 and want 4?
Wow....... I do think you need 3 people, a person with technician skills and some network skills. Four people really seems overblown.

by stb

Good luck getting them to add the people that you need. I AM the IT department for a corporation with 4 locations, 75 internal users, 50 remote users, running Exchange, a Unix implementation of Informix SQL, load balanced Citrix Presentation servers, and Cisco PIX vpns. Oh, and I'm responsible for the GPS locators on all the remote users as well.

by ou jipi je

Ok, I'll cut you a slag for I don't know what did you tell them to get the job.

If you however want to keep it, hire one _senior_ IT technical person and assign him with the task to draw it up for you.

A competent senior IT professional can asses the technical requirements and draw out preliminary infrastructure outlining possible amount of technical personnel needed. Combining this with uptime/ redundancy requirements you should get close to what you need.

Make sure he won't replace you as soon as everyone else realizes that you have no clue... :-)))

by bschaettle

You neeed to track down the person you were hired to replace and find out why they left. I suspect they'll tell you that the Exec staff didn't want to hire the staff necessary to get the job done. You also need to find out how many IT Directors they've gone through in the last 5 years or so, which will be a good indication of your chances of success.

by sekar.t

We have around 100+ employees at our organization, we have one manager who monitor and provide guidance to the IT department. IT department consists of two hardware engineer who provide support to 100 employees on need basis. To make this model & size work for your organization, you must have established good processes.

Let me know if you need a further help on this.

This works pretty well.

by grumbledook

1 to 40? Luxury!

At the risk of sounding like one of the four yorkshiremen ...

In educational establishments there is a serious shortfall of IT
Staff (support staff that is, not teachers)

Because of changes to the pay structure for teachers they are
finally no longer allowed to do tech support and so schools need
a decent support team. It is still the case that over half schools
have this managed by the Head of ICT and not a support
specialist.

We are reasonably lucky. We have me as Director of IT (on the
Senior Leadership Team ... but not a teacher. A rarity in schools),
a Network Manager, an Assisstant Network Manager (in some
places this would be Senior IT Technician), 1 term-time only
technician, 1 full time student placement and 1 part time
website manager (basic HTML but generally updating existing
templates).

This is for 11 servers, 400+ workstations, 250+ laptops and
1500+ users.

Considering that users may log on and log off up to 10 different
machines a day, having 22 different makes and models of
machines with over 200 different software packages ...

Well, you get the idea. And this is not unusual for a school.

We work to the idea that we can get 1 to 150 ... and then hope
to get down to 1 to 100 within the next 2 years, but considering
we add at least 100 laptops a year at the moment it means our
wages bill is very high and unsustainable for a school.

Solutions include outsourcing (which we already do for chunks
of cabling, hardware support, etc) but to outsource the lot would
lose the benefits of having IT Staff with experience of dealing
with students and teachers.

Catch 22?

by rcuk

Hi...
I work for an FE/HE institution in Scotland. I am an ICT Team
Leader for myself and 3.5 mambers of staff providing desktop
support to 800 computers upto 400 members of staff and if you
believe Console1 about 5000 students. I am presently trying to
work through this very problem of staffing at the moment. I am
studying for a Dip in Mmanagement, and the course work points
out a lot of the shortcomings of the resources I have available. I
will use this to formulate a document outling SLAs and support
expectations of the team.

The white paper would be a fantastic aid to do this.

Ta.

by questor1

Any help desk staffing requirements depends on how well your network is documented, organized, and implemented by your staff. Users need to be aware of SLAs and understand what is expected of help desk staff. Networks are supposedly easier to manage, but the breadth of knowledge and education needed by help desk staff has risen.

The problems that I experienced is that end users often would dump computer projects they were responsible for upon help desk staff at the last moment - outside of SLA requirements. The user would often assume that IT support meant help desk staff would do all of their computer tasks for them.

However, the help desk responsibility was really to educate users on software use and how the user can complete tasks on their own. Many times, users that demanded extra IT help to complete their tasks were inexperienced or "afraid of computers"...

In my contracting days, IBM Global Services at a major consumer products company account had a ratio of 1 help desk support person per every 125-150 client employees. This was determined by IBM to be optimal staffing for most (but not all) contracts.

Since your organization has 100 users and the support person may not be fully occupied with tasks, you may want to expand the help desk responsibilities by requiring cross-training in Server Support and/or place certification/education requirements on their job title.

Each company and department has different needs, but you should be careful about overstaffing when there are budget concerns. I saw a lot of contractors cut from a federal government contract where the contracting company intentionally overstaffed with 4 help desk support staff for 125 users. By artifically increasing the number of staff, the contractor icrease company billing amounts. That company was eventually released from the fed contract and the new contract company cleared house and went to only 1 support person.

by questor1

I forgot to add that the government and corporate contracts had very rigid job descriptions and responsibilities where large organizations require this.

Since you are apparently in a smaller organization, you probably have to wear a lot of addition hats, so 1 Mgr and 2 support staff is probably what is needed based on the software that you have described...

by tommy orange

I was in a similar situation about 1 1/2 years ago and have been building the department ever since. we are very IT heavy due to the fact that we try and replace people with systems whenever possible but we have similar systems. I now have 2 support staff who are well rounded enough to build servers and fiddle with Cisco kit. a senior DBA type and a business analyst for the ERP system and have just added a programmer to keep up with the enhancements of the ERP and CMS systems. my suggestion would be to create detailed job specs and areas of responsibility for each role so that you can justify your support needs. also, if you keep track of how much downtime actually costs the company as far as lost revenue and productivity, that should give you some extra ammo for justification of new staff. I am not sure how many projects you do and if you outsource them or not ... but you will probably need more staff to help with those also. looks like you have your hands full ...

by muhannad

I haven't read others feedback. What I would suggest first is to really define your department's mission and responsibilities. From there, try to draw a very basic chart of the functions required to take care of each responsibility. So, let's assume that you must maintain the email system, develop/update the Web site, address external customer's inquiries and issues, and support internal office software. To do so, you need to staff for: Systems Administrator, Web Developer, Customer Support and Technical Support, respectively. Now, based on the volume of work expected daily, monthly, and yearly, try to decide the proper number of seats per each function. For those functions that require seasonal effort (installation of a new router/switch, for example), you may consider consolidating two profiles under one position. From my personal experience in an electronic services company, I defined two positions in the infrastructure team; Systems and Database Admin, and Network and Security Admin. Having to support an online business where no remote branches are involved and few operating systems and databases to take care of, that proved to be a good option. For other highly demanding functions (on-site technical support or call center agents, for example), be careful not to overstaff. A review of history problems/calls log might be very helpful in deciding the volume and pattern of user/customer requests. In shall be highly emphasized to take the statistics at various snapshots in time. Once you have that, you will need to get the management's feedback on expected quality of service; responsiveness-wise. There are many helpful resources which provide a systematic approach in covering this particualr area based on paramters such as accepted wait time and response time.
What you will learn by experience, however, is that you will never feel that you are staffing as required. Top management gets very skeptical when it comes to hiring, and your budget might not allow it in many cases. Don't staff for all functions; sometimes outsourcing and short-term contracts make the best option to overcome an unusal or short term demand.

by poteatj

Currently, I'm tech director for a public school district with about 6,000 students, 450 staff, 3000 desktop and laptop machines. We support Exchange, IIS, SQL, student information and curriculum management systems, a host of specialized services, PLUS all telephone, security camera, intercom, and anything else that plugs into the wall. This with a staff of 12 positions: 1-director, 1-network/server primary, 1-developer/database manager who backs up the network/server position, 1-telecom/wiring, 1-A/V tech, 2-district-wide elementary techs, 2-middle school techs, 1.5 high school techs, 0.5 web site manager, 1-office manager.
Previously, I was in a school district half this size with a staff of 4 where I was the network manager, systems/data manager, director, and developer.
Then I worked 80 hour weeks regularly and stayed behind. Now I go home on time, get more done, and am not quite as far behind.
One big difference here is a culture that demands that their technology be available when they need it, 24/7/365, so they support it (IT).

by rogjr

"Then I worked 80 hour weeks regularly and stayed behind." This reply is the primary problem in IT today. Too often people are self sacrificing their lives for work. If a company expects you to work excessive amount of hours for them, get out. The SLA's are good start, but it should be based on a 40 hour week, and the time for vacations, sick, training, etc. In other words, all managers should staff based on employees having lives other than work. End the self sacrificing.

by michael.bartholf

The most important consideration to get your hands around is to determine the Executive Staff's expectations. Are they asking for improved levels of Help Desk support because of a perceived shortfall in that area? Are they asking for another Help Desk person because that is what they think they need? You are faced with what appears to be a lack of understanding on your part of three things: (1) What you think they need; (2) What the Exec. Staff thinks they need; and (3) What realy is needed. Until you can pin down the real needs versus/compared to the expectations, you will continue to hear "add one more Help Desk person" from your Exec. Staff. A recommendation: in a point paper, provide the Exec. Staff with an analysis (simple of course) of the daily activities which support your initial recommendations and provide them with examples of what might/will occur if these positions are not filled. It appears from your comments that the organization has been able to exist without some of these positions in the past. In the face of the current business environment, they may well be willing to live without them in the near-term.

by jim.lawson

I'd appreciate a copy of the white paper as we. We are going through a similar tranistion and this would be helpful.