Discussion Locked

Size of IT Staff

0 helpful
262 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

262 replies

by taba469

I would appreciate receiving a copy of that white paper (IT staff ratio). Please send it to taba469@yahoo.com

by ctkenyon

Not knowing all of the details, it's impossible to provide a single, correct answer for you.

One question to ask before taking any new IT job, is "What is the value of the IT Infrastructure Services to your business?" If neither the executive team nor hiring manager can provide a reasonably articulate answer with a few examples of key business areas heavily reliant on IT, this should raise a flag. It is all too easy (especially in small shops) for owners / execs to focus on the 'Administration' in Systems/Network/Database Administration and think of their IT support staff as over-glorified Secretaries who know how to use computers. The response from your Executive staff may be indicative of this mindset.

On the other hand, you haven't described why you are designing a new infrastructure and adding services. Were these tasks / projects for which you were hired, or does the new infrastructure fall into your comfort zone of technologies with which you are more familiar, or have you been tasked with providing a set of additional services, and you are simply designing the infrastructure to support them?

There are generally a couple of ways to determine the appropriate staff size - top-down, bottom-up, and reference-based (what is everyone else doing). Ultimately, it is best to try and use a high-level pass at all three and see if you can relatively quickly converge on an answer. For example, you might take some of the excellent suggestions provided within the other responses to determine a bottom-up headcount - i.e. - put together a spreadsheet with services, response times and your estimates of staff (man-hour) requirements - I would suggest keeping this exercise at a relatively high level until you start to converge with the other approaches. You can compare that to some reference-based formula such as: 1 sysadmin/20 servers + 1 heldesk/100 users + 1 helpdesk/50 desktops + 1 helpdesk/25 laptops + 1 dba, etc...
If these approaches provide reasonable correlation, you have a little more weight behind the request. Management should also be able to provide you with insight on their top-down approach - % of overall budget, etc...

If there's a big discrepancy, you can either diplomatically challenge their budget allocation
(see if they have access to Gartner info, or perhaps a state-run small business association can provide details for companies of similar size and technology profile), or identify where the difference in perception arises. Are your service level expectations too high? Are they expecting everyone to work 60 hour weeks? Did they simply not realize just how much turf there was to cover?

Regards,
Chuck

by chhughes

FYI--When you find the answer to your question and you're ready to hire, one resource for staffing is Cisco. Cisco has a job board for alumni of the Cisco Networking Academy Program to post their resumes.
Employers new to the site just create a profile and start searching through the resumes using search criteria. http://www.cisco.com/go/US-CC-jobs It's free!

by king_wesley

I know you're flooded with these requests, but I'm new to my organization and would love to get a copy....

Tx,
Wesley King
king_wesley@yahoo.com

by mickeyg

I would also like a copy. My company is hiring someone at $13,000 to tell me whether I need more staff or not. I have me and one on-call person (less than 20hr/wk), 11 Servers, 200 PC's then laptops, printers, phone system etc. I'm thinking for $13,000 I can tell them but they don't seem to think so.

by bhabing

Hi "kate@" just wondering if you wouldn't mind sending a copy my way as well. Thanks.

bhabing@genesysnetworks.com

by jseichelb

Please send me a copy of the white paper or let me know where I might find it to download.

Thanks.

by jon.guth

If staffing the IT department is not your responsibility, then you are not an IT Director. Supervisor, Manager, etc. might work, but Director does not. You either need to find a way to get a chair at the directors' conference table, or manage as best you can in a passive role.

One more word - Budget! Put together a budget showing what your support requirements will cost with their staffing suggestions (add contract services where needed). Then put together a budget showing employees doing the same work. If it costs less to have employees, then management will consider hiring. Sometimes it is better to hire, sometimes better to contract, but let the $$$ have some say in the matter.

The bottom line - show management the money.

by quick\help

You're boss might not be right, but at least you know how much he will tolerate.

Hire another person to help you in the department (witch is the amount you're boss will acept maybe another after a couple month) and asign him the workload you need, from what i read you'll have enough with one for now. latter as thing progress you can mold the HH.RR. of your department until your needs are met.

Main thing is showing your boss something he agrees with.

by vernonhorn

I work for a non-profit organization with about 25 employees, and I've been asking the question about IT staffing ratios for years, mostly because I'm interested in knowing how well I do my own job.

I've put the question to numerous of my peers at other organizations, and the best rule of thumb estimate that I've been able to come up with is about 1 full time IT staff for every 50 employees. Of course actual conditions vary quite significantly. In my case I have two production servers in house, and two in a hosted environment. My end user base is reasonably smart, and not overly demanding.

As it turns out, general IT management works out to about 40% of my job, and I outsource some of the more complex tasks.

by roger.higgins

I would also like a copy of this white paper. Staffing levels are an ongoing challange and I would appreciate any help I can get.

Thanks,
Roger

by jattas9

Your problem is the size of your organization. Senior Execs, think that computer's run by themselves. This has always been an IT dilemma mainly because with earlier simplistic dos systems, they did. Windows makes everything seem simple, unless you are the person trying to be productive. You are not going to like this one. I had 970 systems I was responsible for in 10 locations, and 4 different business groups publishing newspapers. My entire staff, including graphic arts, finance, payroll, mass distribution etc., etc. was a total of 8 with 60 servers, 32 T1's, 2 T-3's etc. Until very recently the staff size was 4. I don't count the IT Director, since he was just a manager in our operation and did not participate in solutions or planning.
In your case, if you get a staff of 5, I would guess you are lucky, and you will be managing the different services yourself, unless you can get some of those people to pickup a little of this and a little of that. That's just the way it is these days in IT.

by pofadda

Boy, you must be sorry you even mentioned The Calculator! Since it was TR's originally, maybe you can send _them_ a copy for the White Paper section and save yourself a raft of trouble. Just warn us that you've done it and we'll probably bring down their server in the rush!

(PS if they won't accept it I'd like a copy too: itstaffcalc@sravaka.org. I'll even re-post some if the demand keeps up.)

by sean.alexander

Your offer of providing a copy of the ratio calculator white paper is most generous. Although you have been inundated with requests, can you handle one more? I very much appreciate your help.

by msharp

Kate, Is it possible for me to get a copy as well. This paper should be reposted.

Thanks

Mick

by jkempista

I would like to have a copy of that white paper also. Sounds like good stuff for backup.

by jasecaul

Hi Kate,
Bet you wish you had never made the offer now!! But if you can face sending another copy I would like one please.
Thanks
Jase

by tonythetiger

We have all kinds of people using computers nowadays, from carpenters and auto mechanics to engineeers and attorneys, with greatly varying needs as well as levels of expertise. It can be challenging for a small staff. Today for example, after the long weekend, over 50 people had to have their passwords reset after they forgot them. Of course, that's not typical, but

I know there is a lot of pressure to limit costs, but I like to equate it to the local fire department... How many firemen would you want to show up if your building caught fire, knowing that you have to pay them anyway even if there wasn't a fire?

I'd say plan for a substantial fraction of the worst case, then be glad if it doesn't happen! I mean, they wouldn't balk at paying for fire insurance would they?

by lsorour

I would be very gratefull if you sent me a copy of the whitepaper

lsorour@oucu.edu.eg

Thanks

by techrepublic

Just a thought, as it seems you'd be EXTREMELY busy sending e-mails! A link to it might be better all round?

by sambo1580

When working out how many people you have, write out every job that is done by your department and then consider segregation of duties and adequate coverage and backup coverage of your services. By doing that, you will know what roles can be combined or which need to stand alone.

This way you will know exactly how many people to ensure a quality level of service.

This is how our organisation handles it's I.T service delivery.

by rkpillay

i be grateful for a copy of the whitepaper please :)
rkpillay_fj@yahoo.com

thanks
radha

by bhs-tech

Please add me to the list of people Kate for that white paper.
dfox@balmoralhall.com

by markemark

Please send me a copy of the white paper or let me know where I might find it to download.

Many Thanks.

by Member 23157921

So many people are requesting the paper... could it not be posted on the web somewhere?

However, I would definitely be interested to see a copy.

network.admin@hillcrest.vic.edu.au

by geerue

Kate, you must be tired. Look how many of us need this. I work in govt, and we actually have a fairly huge IT staff, relatively speaking (about 16:1). But among Help Desk, Systems, Network, and Security requirements, we still feel under-manned and are trying to defend our numbers. Thanks. Jill

by kasuun

I would begin to keep careful documentation of what you and your staff do. If necessary, document in 30 minute increments. Bring this to your boss with your request for staff. Your document will speak for itself.

by asympt0te

We also have 5 people.. It manager, ERP/BI specialist, 2 sysadmins, helpdesk.

We run about 150 laptops worksations in 6 locations, an AS400 and 20 servers.

I feel we have a good size staff. We are always busy, but never too busy to repond to problems or investigate new projects.

We try do everything in-house and outsource very little.

We have a team that works well toether and we all multiskill to help each other out as far as we can. Management have high expectations of IT and we manage to meet those expectations almost always.

If you are prepared to outsource more, you can get away with fewer full time staff. If you employ very junior people, you will need more. You have to get the balance right.

by biasuzzi

hello Kate , would it be possible to get a copy of the white paper you mentioned ? I appreciate that , thanks in advance

alberto

by spidershrek

I work for a High School with over 3000 users includings faculty staff a students. there are over 1000 PC's and a complex variety of application. There is only 2 of us technical support for the entire system and 3 people in charge of various computer labs( Not Technical).
Even thought is pretty rough when the tech personal knows what they are doing you don't need anything else. When the system is always in good standing there is realky no need for more than a couple of techs. Something else that you can do is talk to the univercities around your neighboorhood. They provide assistance with there students so that the students can get practice on there field. This internship programs can be both beneficial for you aans the school. Hope this helps...

by migglet

I would love to have a copy of that white paper as we are helping a client determine the appropriate size for their staff. Thanks

by cwise

If possible may I recieve a copy of the White paper or where I might be able to download a copy.

by cwise

Kate, IF have the TIME n ENGERY I would like a copy of your white paper or maybe post it in the download section where everyone could then recieve a copy themselves and let you have more time for other important things you need to get done. ( cwise@vbgov.com)
Thank you for your time n patience.

by swgoldwire2546

It seems everybody has requested the white paper on the info. tech. staff ratio. I would also like a copy of that paper, Kate.

My email address is sherika32@netzero.net.

thanks.

-swg :)

by masfarahnak

Dear sir,
Hiring another person, mostly depends on your active devices, you are using for your office. If your active devices have module management. you can easily troubleshoot your network. Try to use this way, and you get 100% chance to solve your problems without hiring any person.

masoud

by mark_lt

Can I have a copy of that white paper.

We are a team of 3 staff, supporting 4 wan sites, 300 users, 20 windows servers and 8 Unix/Linux servers

by cwise

If anyone has a copy of the caculator which kate has written about or knows where to dlownload a copy. Please email me at cwise@vbgov.com
Thank you one and all for your time in reading this and especially for a copy of the mentioned caculator. Thank you again.

by etmr18

could you please send me a copy of the IT white paper.
Many many thanks,
Ethan
etmr18@gmail.com

by jsamuelson

We need it! This office has 250 workstations and the entire IT support staff (including director) numbers three -- yes, 3. Do you have any other calculators as far as staff planning or justifying budget expenses for formal Help Desk software etc.? I'd appreciate anything you care to pass along, thanks so much.

by mlanphea

I dowloaded this in 2002. It should still be as valid now as then. It provides a formula for you to calculate your staffing needs. You have to do the work. (Putting it in this window screws up the formatting. Try pasting it into a .doc file.)

Staffing for Technology Support

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Background
The image of an information superhighway recalls the success of the interstate highway program, which efficiently linked remote areas of the country contributing to decades of prosperity. In order to take maximum advantage of a communication superhighway, schools and districts must provide properly trained personnel to keep the networks running smoothly and help users properly navigate their routes.

Technical support staff falls into two basic types; those that support the equipment such as file servers, workstations and other network components and those that support the users, typically at a software application level. The number of support personnel necessary will be a function of many variables, including the size of the network, its complexity and the level of support desired for users (California Department of Education, 1994)

There is much discussion about restructuring schools and integrating technology into curriculum. Adequate support staffing has not kept pace with the acquisition of new technology for several reasons. Skeptics see the infusion of technology as just another cycle of reform, or educational fad, and have been reluctant to shift scarce resources when many existing programs are already underfunded. Also, those charged with making decisions regarding technology are frequently school boards, superintendents, or in some states, departments of education made up of senior educational administrators who may not have any current technology training or experience.

A 1989-90 survey of superintendents in New York and Rhode Island showed 85% knew nothing about computers, had never used a computer and did not intend to use one. In the same year another study indicated that universities charged with the training of school administrators offered little in the way of computer training or computer-based curriculum training. While these studies weren?t conducted yesterday, they do indicate that part of the problem schools have in providing the necessary support for effective technology based systems is a lack of training and knowledge of educational decision makers (Morton, 1996). An examination of the current requirements for administrators and superintendents at one of the state universities in Arizona confirms this is also a local area of concern and neglect.

Today, schools across the country spend an average of nine percent of their technology budgets on training and support, while experiences of technology rich schools suggest that more than 30% of much larger budgets would be invested in these areas (U.S. Department of Education, 1996).

Some fully equipped schools provide a full or part-time technology coordinator to maintain equipment, provide on the spot assistance to teachers in the classroom, and assist teachers with identifying technology-based resources (such as software, video programs, on-line databases, and use of the Internet). Other schools rely on teachers or part-time aides to supply less than adequate support.

Existing Standards
Nineteen Hundred Eighty-Four is noted by some as the beginning of the computer revolution. Since then we have had a second revolution based on computer networks and a third based on the Internet. This rapid rate of change has made it difficult for educational organizations, with their compartmentalized budgets and financial constraints, to recognize and adjust to the expectations of this new digital world.

How much support is needed and who is going to provide it?

Most school districts have had a data processing department or centralized computer system for payroll and other business functions in place for years. While a single, fully trained support person can maintain a district?s main frame or mini-computer, support needs change when a distributed client-server system is installed. School districts need to look closely at what private sector companies, universities and community colleges have established as standards for staffing complex infrastructure similar to those being planned for K-12 settings.

Forrester Research Inc. conducted a study in large corporations and found that typical support staff includes one support person for every 50 PC?s at a cost of $142 per PC per year. According to the model, a school district with 1,000 PC?s would need a staff of 20 and a budget of 1.4 million (Microsoft, 1996).

A 1993 study by the Gartner Group on the life cycle cost of a single PC broke the total five-year cost into four subcomponents. Capital costs were 17%, administrative costs were 14%, technical support was 12%, and the largest cost was end-user operations for 57%. In other words, for every $1,000 spent on computers, an additional $5,880 will be spent over five years to support the computer (Gartner Group, 1993). These figures were for large corporations. In school districts many of the tasks identified as administrative or end-user operations, such as software license management, installation and training are the responsibility of the technology support staff, and cost such as loss of productivity is typically not measured with teaching staff.

Project Athena was an educational computing initiative conducted at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in partnership with the IBM Corporation and Digital Equipment Corporation from 1983 to 1991. Under Project Athena a mature, distributed computing environment was developed. Support requirements for distributed computing environments were developed as part of the study.

The approach taken by the study was to determine the human resource skills necessary to support the total environment, and then translate this into real numbers based on full-time employees. The following variables and staffing ratios were established.

Workstations. Resources are required to install, maintain, track and update.
Resource estimate: W/500, where W is the number of workstations.

Users. The number of users affects account administration, user training and "how to use" assistance, documentation and configuration services.
Resource estimate: U/1000, where U is the number of users.

Clusters. Clusters are physically co-located workgroups sharing servers, printers and other peripheral equipment.
Resource estimate: C/15, where C is the number of clusters.

Supported Applications. The number of applications provided and supported centrally affects the resources required to install, update, support, track and document software licenses.
Resource estimate: A/50, where A is the number of supported applications.

Vendor Operating Systems and Applications. Operating systems for different platforms all have frequent revisions and updates to install and ensure interoperability with other systems and applications.
Resource estimate: V/1, where V is the number of distinct vendor operating systems and platforms.

Licenses Required. A license is defined as the right to use the application software for multiple users on multiple platforms.
Resource estimate: L/25, where L is the number of licenses.

To determine the total human resources (HR) required use the following formula (Arfman & Roden, 1992):

HR=W/500 + U/1000 + C/15 + A/50 + L/25 + V

An example of this formula approach to determining appropriate staffing levels would be a school district with 1,000 workstations, 2,000 users, 30 clusters (e.g. school offices), 25 applications supported, 3 operating systems (OS400, Windows 95 and Mac), and licenses required for 25 different software packages. The staffing would be determined as follows.

HR=1000/500 +2000/1000 +30/15 +25/50 + 25/25 +3/1

HR= 2 + 2 + 2 + .5 + 1 + 3 (for a total of 10.5 FTE)

Although telecommunications and network support were not included in this study, similar FTE ratios could be developed to establish appropriate staffing levels for these and other skill sets based on industry or university standards.

Current Issues/Options
Schools fall on a continuum for support staff issues and options for dealing with them. A single school will be far different from a larger K-12 district with thousands of network computers and a multitude of supported programs and applications, including the complexity of a distance learning system.

Recognizing the need and determining the appropriate skill sets necessary is generally the first step in building a plan for adequate support staff. This should be included as one of the questions to ask vendors before purchasing any new technology. Other districts with similar installations should be contacted and consulted. Educational or technical consultants may also be used to assist in determining support requirements.

Finding qualified staff who will provide the necessary skills is the next step. Districts have traditionally relied on the famous last line in employee contracts, "other duties as assigned," to assign technical responsibilities to a willing teacher or administrator. A point is reached where the skills become too specialized, or the time demands too great, to continue with a part-time or untrained person. The use of part-time staff or teachers who have classroom responsibilities also means response time will be constrained and users who cannot receive immediate assistance will be angry and frustrated. On the other hand, current market demand for trained technology specialists is very high, and the pay is frequently outside the range of what schools are accustomed to paying classified staff.

Providing effective training for existing staff members who have been assigned the responsibilities and have the basic technical background poses a different set of problems. Training costs are high due to market demand and control of "certified" training by large vendors. A five day class on supporting Microsoft?s Windows 95 can cost over $2,000. Training on operating systems such as Microsoft?s Windows NT or Novell NetWare can cost in excess of $10,000. Once trained, a staff member then commands more salary in the open market than a school?s salary schedule is able to match.

The major option to providing in-house service and support is to outsource these services. Negotiating these types of contracts again requires a district to clearly understand their support requirements and be able to put out a comprehensive request for proposals (RFP) to select a qualified vendor and manage the resulting contract.

Some districts manage to offer classes or create opportunities for students to assist in various aspects of the support function. This requires having someone on the teaching staff with the technical background necessary to offer the class or provide an appropriate level of supervision.

Providing adequate compensation to staff, assuming a district can afford to provide the appropriate training, is another major issue. Unless this is done in relatively short order, retention of the newly trained "techie" may be problematic. Technical staff is in constant contact with other districts as well as vendors and they are well informed regarding current salaries and wages. Any turnover in key technical positions will result in significant loss of support to staff and students. Extensions of employee contracts based on the cost of training provided is one method of ensuring the district receives a reasonable return on its investment of training.

Most districts will have difficulty in meeting the salaries paid by business and industry. However, benefits such as security, more vacation days, and less stress may be used to offset the dollar differential.

Consistent and comprehensive funding for technology systems is difficult due to the common practice of funding the purchase of technology through the use of bond issues or grants. This type of funding typically is good for one-time expenditures, but is inadequate as a funding mechanism for on-going cost such as training for teachers and the necessary support staff. Districts must also establish a replacement cycle for older machines. This will become more of an issue as the technology base at a school expands. Most schools migrate equipment or "repurpose" it in order to maximize the life of a computer. However, at some point it will become more costly to maintain than replace. It will be more manageable to fund replacements through the capital outlay budget rather than relying on passing a bond issue every five years.

Some state and federal funding agencies now require that any technology plans funded by them provide for a percentage set aside for teacher training and support. On-going costs typically must still be funded through the district?s maintenance and operating budget, which is the same budget used for teachers? salaries and supplies. Reallocation of these dollars tends to be the more difficult for school boards and administrators. Until this can be established, long-term planning which includes operational expenses is not realistic.

Impact on Education
According to Karen Sheingold, "The successful transformation of student learning and accomplishment in the next decade requires effectively bringing together three agendas?an emerging consensus about learning and teaching, well-integrated uses of technology and restructuring. Each agenda alone presents possibilities for educational redesign of a very powerful sort. Yet no one has realized, or is likely to realize, its potential in the absence of the other two.

Successful implementation of technology into education is obviously dependent on a number of variables. While technology supporters are quick to advocate the benefits of technology, the requirements for adequate technical support are slow to be understood and funded. It should however, be fairly easy for most of us to appreciate the frustration teachers face when a piece of "technology" doesn?t work or requires the skills of a technician just to make it work. When you have a class of 30 eager students watching and not always waiting patiently, unworkable/unsupported "technology" quickly gets relegated to the back closet.

The evolving concept of technology-rich education is being defined in many districts and schools throughout the United States by teachers, administrators, or technology committees. These technology plans have many similarities. With few exceptions, the products of technology committees are less working documents than wish lists with timetables attached. The limited and uncertain availability of funding and a clear understanding of technology systems often frustrate the best of intentions.

Probably the most striking omission from technology plans has been a realistic model of technical staffing. While administrations maintain modern staff for business operations, purchasing, curriculum, human resources, building and grounds, few superintendents or planning teams have recognized that a large network of computers will require a substantial group of trained professionals to cope with its many demands.

Districts will continue to build large complex networks to take advantage of resource sharing, Internet access and communication capabilities. School boards and administrations also have increasing expectations for student performance, staff productivity and information systems to provide the necessary data and information for sound decision-making. Teachers and students, without the support of a certified technically component technology coach or site coordinator, will not be able to take advantage of the potential benefits technology can provide. Trained support staff for these technology systems are a critical part of any successful implementation and operation.

Recommendations
Because dollars will always be in short supply for additional staff, especially for those other than teachers, districts must develop a realistic and cost effective support staff plan as part of their overall technology plan.

Develop a blueprint of the support system as part of the overall technology plan. Effective leadership and management of the district?s technology plan and resources are part of a tiered approach to a total support system. Districts have begun to recognize the importance of having an administrator at district level with technology expertise to make purchasing recommendations, advise on new construction and remodels, and work with building level principals to increase the use of technology in the classroom. A survey conducted by School Planning and Management magazine found that two-thirds of the responding districts had a person in such a position and 80 percent of the rest plan to add it within five years.

Today, in most institutions, there are three levels of support in an information system (IS) department. Below the IS manager or Director of Technology there is usually a network administrator and/or analyst who has hands-on management of network resources. The next level is made up of various support providers including workstation technicians, help-desk operators, repair person, installers, curriculum integrators and on-site support personnel such as building technology coordinators or lab assistants. Staff at each level is driven by the size and complexity of the network. Establishing FTE ratios similar to those in the Athena project for each skill needed to provide for future staff additions as the inevitable expansion occurs.

Establish a market-based approach to determine competitive compensation for key positions in the IS department. Schools typically use a point based classification system to establish the pay range for classified (non-teaching) staff. Many of these systems may not take into account the current high demand for skilled network and computer managers and technicians, thereby causing the pay scale to be inadequate. Reference to industry surveys should be used to establish and adjust compensation for key staff positions. This may require developing an alternate pay schedule rather than using the traditional model, which bases compensation, increase on years of service and college credits only.

The following information is taken from a salary and job satisfaction survey conducted by Computerworld magazine and is referenced to provide a sense of current key job functions and average nationwide pay scales. Nonprofit institutions are noted as being the lowest paying among industries surveyed. Compensation is identified by industries including the educational sector. The figures shown are for the educational sector.

CEO or VP: The top IS executive of the organization. $76, 918
Director of IS Operations: Directs the data center and system operations group. $ 59,343
Director of Networks: The top networking position manages voice/data communication. $ 53,018
Manager of Voice/Data Communications Manages voice and data communication. $ 47,815
Communications Specialist: Provides technical expertise for the company?s voice and data communication. $ 37,175
Network Administrator: Responsible for departments? administrative functions. $ 38, 770
LAN Manager: Responsible for all procedures related to the LAN environment. $ 37, 950
Technical Programmer: Performs basic system programming tasks. $ 24, 273
Help Desk Operator: Answers user support questions. $ 27,560
PC Technical Support Specialist: Responsible for overall maintenance of the company?s PC?s. $ 30, 489

Systems Programmer: Performs basic system programming tasks. $ 38,444

Technical Programmer: Performs basic system $ 24, 273

programming tasks.

Help Desk Operator: Answers user support questions. $ 27,560

PC Technical Support Specialist: Responsible for $ 30, 489

overall maintenance of the company?s PC?s.

Minimizing the support staff requirements. There are several things a district may do in order to minimize the support staff required. The most significant approach is to minimize the complexity of the network and associated systems by establishing standards.

In any system there will be a trade-off between flexibility and standards. A set of firm and well-chosen standards is the single most important contribution an administration can make to limit the cost of maintaining a network system. Non-standard networks require one person for every 50 to 70 computers. Highly standardized systems on the other hand, require one support person for every 500-700 computers.

The most significant standard is the hardware platform. Traditionally, Apple Corporation products have been the preferred platform of choice for the K-12 market. However, in recent surveys the WinTel platform has made serious inroads in the educational market share as well as dominating the corporate and home market.

Functional identity is another standard to establish. Every workstation or file server in a functional group should be identical to every other. Exceptions and deviations from this standard cause an enormous increase in documentation and support requirements.

Network components such as routers, switches, hubs, network interface cards, and printers should also be standardized. This will minimize the number of vendors and equipment types staff has to deal with. Medium and large districts will want to move toward the use of network manageable tools allowing for remote access of file servers and network components even down to the desktop. Advantages include being able to maintain systems, upgrade software, track hardware for asset management and configuration settings, and track licenses without expending valuable time driving to individual sites. The ability to remotely log on to a user?s workstation and demonstrate a procedure not only saves the user frustration, and loss of productivity, it provides a learning opportunity, and makes the support staff more efficient in providing support.

Limiting the number of software titles supported is another area a district can control that will have a direct bearing on the cost of software and the support needed by teachers. Typically, vendors negotiate better pricing on a district wide basis rather than school by school, or for lab packs. Training can be standardized and teachers and staff are able to provide support for each other on adopted packages. The perennial upgrades, license agreements and bug patches can be dealt with in a uniform fashion.

Establish a consistent funding process. Base funding on a percentage of the school?s capital outlay and maintenance and operating budget. School budgets can accommodate technological change systematically by using "technology-based budgeting." This is a simple concept: school budgets must have a minimum percentage of their total funds allocated to technology maintenance and change every year. This minimum is 3% of the total operating budget. Changes can then be gradual and carefully planned. Educational authorities must accept the fact that computer technology has a built-in obsolescence period and must be changed regularly. The simple analogy is that computers are like chalk, only more expensive.

Serious mistakes on the part of school administrators in budgeting for technology use in schools have left many districts in disastrous positions. Whole systems have become useless, and replacing them has meant the expenditure of huge amounts of money from single budgets. The process of annual "budget hopping" (leaving an item out one year and picking it up the next year or the year after) cannot continue. The public will not accept the huge outlays or bond issues every three to five years to replace old equipment and planning structures en masse.

Develop a statewide educational technical academy. The state of California has established such an academy for the purpose of providing cost-effective training for school personnel responsible for providing technology support at the school or district level. West-Ed, the regional education lab facilitated the Internet Technical Academy (ITA). ITA was funded by the California County Superintendent?s Educational Service Association and the California Technology Assistance Project. The ITA is conceived as a brokered service that is administered by a contracted agency. An advisory committee identifies the types of courses that need to be offered. Bids are prepared and publicly disseminated. Prospective bidders might include LEA?s, other governmental agencies or training organizations. Courses are offered on a fee basis to cover the costs of the provider and the cost of administration of the ITA.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

by wrw

Wow!

This paper is in demand! I've been asking for help, and this may give me the ammunition I need.

TIA,

Will

by mboyle

I have been running IT benchmarking studies for over 15 years. Key ratios for small sites <250 PCs are Help Desk - about 150 calls per Full Time Equivalent per month, Client/server 85 PCs per FTE, network 550 connected devices per FTE.

Hope this helps
Martin

by subscribeksm

I am sure that your company hired or promoted you to this position because you have earned it, but:
In my experience, the focus of an IT Director should be on leveraging IT to resolve business issues. A person in your position cannot possibly do this. In reality, you are a line supervisor who is expected to perform significant hands-on work. If you outsource PC support or various network services, you can probably keep up with the work load. If your end users are demanding, if any of your business units have special needs, if your one staff person becomes a problem, or if you have a strong work ethic and a need to do work well, you are in for some long hours.
In answer to your questions, standard metrics call for 1-2 IT support staff per 100 people. This works well when you are speaking of organizations of a thousand people or more, with strong standards and a tight control over desktop configurations, and good outsourcing contracts. With a staff of 10 or more, you can spread the load for specialized skills such as server support, database support, firewalls, and other services across a reasonable number of staff. A staff of 1 in an organization of 100 is ridiculous: A company of that size is subject to hiring and other regulations require supervisors to put a lot of work into supporting staff. My advice:
If you cannot justify more staff, perform the job for no longer than it take you to find another one.

by frank abate

I would like a copy. I used to have a similar whitepaper, but it is VERY outdated. I would love to see how yours compares.

Thanks!

by lclarke

Hi Kate

Can you please forward me a copy of white paper as well? Thanks!

Laura Clarke
lclarke@agia.com

by pagwu

I wonder if this document exist at all...obviously a lot of folks would find it useful and I suggest again that perhaps Kate post it here so that all can copy it and terminate the "me too" clutter!

Just my opinion...

by rparkhurst48

[XLS] IT StaffFile Format: Microsoft Excel 2000 - View as HTML
IT Staff Calculator - Rev7. Your. 2. Data. Result. 3. Here. 4. Add. Divisors. 5. Average Number of Patrons Who Use the Public Access Computers Each Day ...
galecia.com/weblog/mt/archives/IT_staff_calculator.xls
- Similar pages

by briblank

I just got back from vacation...(I am sure that is a mark against me;)

I did a search for the post to see if TR had received the upload...

Since I didn't see it would anybody be so kind as to send it to me?
Thanks

by marco.vannetti

Hallo Kate,
It seems your white paper did have a great success. Do you think I'm too late to also have a copy of it?
Many thanks
Marco

by noyoki

Room for one more on the download please?

Thanks!

tearsong6 (AT) gmail . com

by marco.vannetti

Hallo Kate,
As there are many people looking for your white paper, wouldn't it be possible to put it back to the download or white paper section again?
Thanks
Marco

by bwalker

Kate,

If you are still providing this document, I would like a copy of it as well.

Thanks,

Brody Walker
bwalker@fsbancorp.com