Discussion Locked

So many zealots, so little time

0 helpful
347 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Why is it, even when presented with hard facts people refuse to budge on there religion of OS worship?

While I recognize that linux isn't the answer for everyone in every situation, I also recognise that the MicroSoft machine has a lot of short comings that are generally overlooked by the faithful.

Is having to not know as much really worth a system that crashes on a much more frequent basis than it's Unix and Novell counterparts?

There is also the issue of security, and anyone that has ever spent at least five minutes at the SANS site would see that there is a much bigger turn around to getting exploits patched from MicroSoft than the *nix OS's.

The difficulty of exploiting the *nix bugs is also much higher, as they do not have graphical script kiddie tools that can point and click their way into the system.

The Viruses and Spyware that runs rampant on the Admin by default Windows systems are out of control. This verses the restricted user the *nix run at which even if you DID run an infected file the WORST you would do is trash your home directory, not the whole system.

In the "Is MicroSoft at fault" discussion
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=89&threadID=173751&messageID=1771497
there are actually a few people trying to say that first there isn't a problem CREATED by SP2, and that if there is a problem it isn't the fault of MicroSoft.

People really need to expect more from their OS vendors than they are getting now, and they also need to accept that this isn't a religious issue it is a business tool. Get over it people.

No, this is NOT a *nix vs Windows flame war. This is just to get people to look and realize that MS isn't always doing right by you.

347 replies

by firstpeter

I think (or at least HOPE) folks are grounded in reality enough to accept that a Windows-based platform isn't the solution for everything. And by the same token neither is a *nix-based system. Which one is better? That depends on a lot of factors, including your situation.

You can make the same argument with Office. Is Office the best business productivity tool? In some cases, absolutely. In others it's a waste of money and aspirin (or beer, depending upon how you deal with crashes and exploits).

Plain and simple. To try and espouse one approach as "the best" in all (or even most) situations is absurd at best. I agree with jd - let's leave the fanatical approach out of it and accept that they're both tools and better suited than the other in different situations.

by apotheon

I'd say that, if you're only comparing two options, it's quite easy to be correct in saying that one is "the best" in most situations. Of course, part of that determination involves your definition of "the best".

Specifically, if you're only comparing Linux and Windows, I'm pretty confident in saying that Linux is "the best" in most circumstances, as long as your definition of "the best" involves the acceptance of non-Windows solutions not only by yourself but by those with whom you have to deal, as well. The major problem there, of course, is that Microsoft has leveraged vendor lock-in with surprising skill to ensure that it's very difficult to unseat it as the dominant platform in certain market niches, even though it does its job very poorly in (most of?) them.

Meanwhile, Windows might be considered to be "the best" in most cases if what you're calling "the best" is the OS that you just can't get away from in certain market niches. Hostageware has that effect, y'know.

By my definitions, you may not be able to make one single OS into "the best" for "most" circumstances where you're comparing more than just two OS options, but you can certainly make the honest claim that Windows is [b]not[/b] "the best" in almost all circumstances. I occasionally recommend a client stay with Windows, at least for he time being, even when the client is asking about switching systems to another OS, and even more rarely (almost never) I might recommend using a Windows machine from the very beginning for a particular purpose, but even in those circumstances I find that my thoughts on the matter is that Windows is only appropriate "until better support on another platform comes along".

Hm. I guess, to wrap things up, it's an in-depth understanding of Windows that made a Linux lover of me. Windows isn't really suited to anything other than serving the lowest common denominator in terms of the marketing-credulous. The fact that it has a stranglehold on certain markets is a recommendation for the Microsoft sales and legal teams, and not for the technology they peddle.

by firstpeter

You're right - it all depends upon the definition of "the best".

Having a more secure platform in application isn't always "the best". The more robust platform isn't always "the best". The most mainstream platform isn't always "the best". That was the point of my original post - for ANYONE (on either side of the fray) to come out and say that one OS is the best is either a) talking about a particular situation / application, or b) drinking way too much of the Kool-Aid various folks are offering.

Your point, though, about whether it's the technology or the sales and legal teams is a good one. But to discard it and say that it shouldn't be part of the discussion about which "the best" would be a folly (always wanted to use that one in a post, too!). Those things are a way of life. People are used to Windows because they use it at home. That alone makes a Windows platform a better solution in certain situations. Better technically? Not necessarily (probably not likely, even). Better feature-wise? Probably not (but perhaps). Still a better solution? Absolutely, because the folks that will be using it are more comfortable with it and the pain to move is minimal. Don't rule emotion out of any decision making process because it's there and it's a real factor.

by jmgarvin

Usually *nix is attractive because it and most of its apps are free or very inexpensive. MS is charging WAY too much and their upgrade cycle is out of control!

by hal 9000

You had to post this didn't you? ;)

You know how some will react and you still went ahead with it. :)

Well all I can say is firstly I totally agree with you on this one there is no one size fits all which some people are unwilling to accept or claim that only a very small section of the market is involved so they don't count.

When I go to M$ meetings I'm constantly told that because I first used Unix I'm expecting far more than any OS can or should deliver which I take as M$ speak as we are unable to reach that level so we don't try. :p

Unix/Linux has its places and with the advent of Thin Clients may be on the way back but so does M$ have a place and I use what suits each individual job best.

The problem is that so many have grown up on M$ Windows they just do not know any better and expect things to be the way that they are and can not conceive that there are different and very good OS available. ;)

What really got me was a posting to that particular thread where someone didn't see anything wrong with needing to install 146 MEG of patches after applying SP2 to XP computer on a clean install they said "That's the way it should be!" Now SP2 hasn't been out for all that long and was supposed to fix most of the inbuilt problems in XP but needing to download 146 MEG of Patches on top of SP2 is just a bit much for what I consider to be a stable OS. Granted currently M$ owns the desktop but only because so many third party applications only run on Windows and as yet the Windows emulators are not really that good to do away with Windows all together. So until these Mission Critical applications become available in Open Source or even on a buy as you need basis for Unix/Linux Windows will retain its current position. But the moment that Windows Emulators start working well or an application is written to run on one of the Nix's and can use the same data as the Windows Application and then export the data to the same or similar application on a Windows unit things will start to change as the need will no longer be there for a all Windows Desktop environment. It would make it so much easier to roll out desktops with Linux on them if they could access MYOB or Quick Books files and then export them to these applications that their accountants are running on Windows Boxes.

Once that happens it will no longer be necessary to have Windows only on the desktop and provided that they work like the Windows Applications most end users will not notice a difference. Once the Nix Accounting packages are developed to a standard where they are not noticeable to the end user as being different small business will grab them like a house on fire and embrace the new OS's.

But at the same time I think M$ will start making it more inviting to go Windows Only by offering even bigger discounts than they currently are to go that way. Or maybe even release their own Unix with a Windows like front end on it so the end user will not see any differences and the idea of having constantly restricted users who can type in an admin password to install something and then have the OS revert back to a user mode will be sold as a "New Improved Windows" and the word Unix will not be heard. Maybe the Windows Server 2008 will go this way if there is a marked increase in the penetration of Linux into the market.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

I tried real hard to be as objective and fair as possible. Didn't use the M$ or WinDoze once! (oops, now I did)

I use both and it just drives me nuts all the wackos out there.

The worst example was about a year ago a "tech" from the bank we do business came on site to make sure that the head of accountings computer could handle their new banking software. He asked me what kind of network we had and I said Unix servers and TCP/IP. His response "Unix? Never heard of it". I don't care if you can't run a computer without pretty pictures, but you had better at least KNOW WHAT unix is and that windows grew up from unix many moons ago.
No unix, no PC. We would all still be on dumb terminals!

If people stopped making excuses for MicroSoft and demand better, we would get it.

And at the same time, we need to have file structure standardization for the *nix's. Never get apps written for generic linux if each has a different layout of where their config files are located.

The next few years will be really interesting! Can't wait to see what SuSE is going to do next. The are going to be the ones to break open the desktop market.

by apotheon

There's the Linux Standard Base, which (among other things) specifies a "standard" for filesystem organization. Debian follows the LSB quite well. Gentoo and Red Hat are infamous for their deviation from the LSB (I still can't figure out why the NIC configuration files are in a scripts directory).

The fact that a business IT industry leading vendor like Red Hat is ignoring the standard is a big part of the reason the LSB isn't getting as much "airtime" as it should. Blame Red Hat, which learned some of its marketing strategy by competing with Microsoft.

by firstpeter

I think (or at least HOPE) folks are grounded in reality enough to accept that a Windows-based platform isn't the solution for everything. And by the same token neither is a *nix-based system. Which one is better? That depends on a lot of factors, including your situation.

You can make the same argument with Office. Is Office the best business productivity tool? In some cases, absolutely. In others it's a waste of money and aspirin (or beer, depending upon how you deal with crashes and exploits).

Plain and simple. To try and espouse one approach as "the best" in all (or even most) situations is absurd at best. I agree with jd - let's leave the fanatical approach out of it and accept that they're both tools and better suited than the other in different situations.

by wordworker

>>Never get apps written for generic linux if each has a different layout of where their config files are located.<< Just one example of why *nix isn't the be-all, end-all OS. All the puling and whining in all the Web sites in the world isn't going to change the fact that corporate America likes Microsoft, and Microsoft products, for the most part and in most settinsg, do what they're supposed to do. You can find talented people to use and configure them. The *nux zealots are considered the "weird" ones nowadays. Deal with it.

by jdclyde

I was pointing out that there isn't a single tool for all jobs.

Corporate America using MicroSoft because that is all the non-tech execs know. MicroSoft does one thing well, advertise.

Watch was SuSE does. They have a whole migration plan that gets your entire business off of windows on to linux. Server AND desktop.

People that follow one or the other religiously are going to be out in the cold. Better get a nice coat.

by wordworker

>even when presented with hard facts people refuse to budge on there religion of OS worship<

I think "corporate America" questions the so-called hard facts. I think Novell SuSE is too late to the dance. People who think a significant number of customers are going to migrate "off Windows" are going to go hungry. Better start saving cans of pork & beans.

by apotheon

"Microsoft products, for the most part and in most settinsg, do what they're supposed to do."

So do Linux and other major open source programs. In fact, I'd say that the open source unix stuff tends to do what it's supposed to do rather more often than Windows-platform software.

"You can find talented people to use and configure them."

You can also find talented people to use and configure Linux, proprietary UNIX, MacOS X, classic MacOS, BeOS, NeXTstep, MULTICS, OS/400, and just about anything else under the sun. What's your point?

"The *nux zealots are considered the 'weird' ones nowadays."

Not entirely true. Zealots are generally considered "weird" no matter what they worship. They usually don't see themselves as being considered "weird" as much as others see them as being considered "weird", though; this may explain why you don't seem to think Windows zealots are considered weird.

Corporate America isn't as wedded to Microsoft as you seem to think. Perhaps you haven't noticed that IBM, HP, and Novell have all gotten with the Linux program. Perhaps you haven't noticed that Industrial Light and Magic, Google, and Autozone are heavy Linux users. Perhaps you haven't noticed that most of the websites in the world, corporate sites included, are running on Apache rather than IIS. Perhaps you're just not paying attention.

by n3bu1a

It is important though to hold Microsoft to higher standards - as they do have the largest market share and have the capability of performing much better. I do not have a lot of experience with "alternative" OSs, but I'm pretty irritated with Microsoft's inability to stay on top of their game. Unfortunately, I'm a little relunctant to spend the time switching/learning an alternative, especially since my firm does 99% of its development in MS technology.

by jdclyde

that there isn't a single OS that is a fix-all for everyone.

The point is to not continue to limit the tools that can be used because of ignorance or OS worship.

At some point, this may be a fit or it may not. Ruling options out before even looking at them will always come back to haunt people sooner or later.

by firstpeter

I prefer SPAM. It holds longer.

Regardless of whether all of "corporate America" questions the facts or not, some companies, large and small, will move because it's a better O/S for their situation. And as they are successful and the corporate user base grows more tools will develop, migration will become easier, and more companies will jump. I agree that SUSE has an uphill battle, and I don't think in the next 5 years you're going to see a major power change, but I would be hesitant to count them out as a player.

Personally, you won't see me going *nix anytime soon because my clients generally fit in to the MS camp and won't switch. Are there problems? Sure. Is there a big enough (in their mind) issue out there to compel them to make the switch? Not really. Will I go *nix when they do? Probably - I do like to eat (more than SPAM).

by apotheon

1. I think the migration is more widespread than you realize. Entire city governments, both in the US and abroad, are standardizing on Linux solutions and chucking their old Windows licenses out with the trash. Major corporations are doing quite a bit of business with Linux vendors. The winds are changing.

2. SuSE is by no means the only option for migration from Windows. In fact, despite Novell's major push for migration from Windows to SuSE, many of the big stories I'm seeing about organizations making the switch are using Linux distributions other than SuSE. That doesn't mean SuSE isn't picking up steam, but it isn't the only distro to do so.

by firstpeter

Absolutely on both counts. My ultimate point was simply that SUSE being "late to the dance" (which I think is generally accepted) does not imply that they won't be able to make waves. All it takes is a success story or two and folks recognize that *nix is viable. Most corporations probably won't move (nor should they), but life won't be all MS.

Different situations call for different strategies and tactics.

by jdclyde

of linux groups that are making migration plans. I know it is not the linux that governments are switching to, but for people looking to switch but want someone to hold their hand this will be a big asset.

But you will never hear about that in the ms weekly, will you? more fud.

by black panther

We run our main Business ERPII System on UNIX along with our Automated Warehouse System ( because it's more robust and reliable, less prone to virus etc etc

I used to work for a Software Company who were up against a constant battle trying to sell their package to customers with a UNIX platform.

Unfortunately we lost a lot of sales as the competitors Windows based solution had a better look and feel than our UNIX based Thin Client Solution - even though our product won hands down in performance and functionality.

** ie it not what it did that was important to them it was what it looked like***

( similiar to our society in judging people for the first time )

What do the banks, insurance companies, rely on ?

What was / is the internet based on - UNIX.

The solution for us was to develop a Windows look and feel "Front End" so we were more attractive in the market.

I agree with your comments ... Microsoft is a "powerfull" marketing machine more than a dedicated Software Developer.

by rapell

So do you think it is better for the *nix based systems to act as back ends because of their secure feastures other than aesthetics, while M$ can capture front ends for its look and 'ease of use'?

by hal 9000

But I can see M$ doing just that. Last year they brought a license from SCO which many people thought of as supporting SCO in their Battle against Linux which it may have been but the person in charge of Product Development at M$ may just see it a bit differently after all Billy Boy seems to have a knack for coming up with what he thinks will sell.

So a Unix back end with a Windows like GUI would make quite a lot of sense. And would not be much of a "Sell" to business as it would still have the M$ Windows Logo on the front and they just would not realize that they where actually using Unix. Of course the source code would not accept anything other than M$ Approved code to run with because M$ would refuse to follow the set standard in an effort to retain their market share. And also allow them to service the Niche Markets that they are currently unable to service and desperately want to break into.

It really makes a lot more sense that it at first appears to and if implemented would secure M$ market domination for years to come if not forever.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

that the windows users ARE windows users because they like all the pretty little pictures and don't have to know anything.

Heaven forbid someone should have to learn something.

This is especially true in America because we have such a high concentration of lazy people that expect top way for bottom perfomance.

And think about it. It is the exec that approves or denies which systems get put in and which don't. It isn't the techs like wordworker that make that choice. And what do the execs have to base their decision on? Well, they have seen a MS add and it is pretty and even they can use it.

With major players using this, it is funny to see just how little people like wordworker know about what is going on in the computer market. Some MS drone told him that Windows has 99.998% of the market and he is CLUELESS enough to believe that?

by rapell

So do you think it is better for the *nix based systems to act as back ends because of their secure features other than aesthetics, while M$ can capture front ends for its look and 'ease of use'?

by jdclyde

that are not running around worshiping at the MS alter but are skilled in many will be better suited to survive.

If you would have actually had read what I was posting, it was that the mixed network is going to be the future, not that MS is done.

You are EXACTLY the type of person this post was about. Thanks for stepping up and making my point.

by wordworker

...the Libertarian Party is to American politics. It may be a decent alternative but it will never be mainstream. Beat your chests all you want about Apache, but the best you can hope for is that the less than 0.001% of corporate shops running Linux takes a dramatic jump in the next 10 years to say, 0.002%.

by hal 9000

The Internet and you just may be getting a little closer to the mark. The fact is that there are not only two alternatives even if you lump all of the Unix/Linux into one group and Windows into another. there are numerous other OS's available and they all fill a role in the market.

I've yet to see any company attempt to run Windows on their mainframes which is so small a part of the market like banks most big financial institutions and the like.

I have yet to see a decent sized server farm running Windows either as it is just not scalable enough for the requirements.

The best that can be said is that 2003 ES is good for small servers and that is it. If you want to try it on a big server it just will not work properly and suck up system resources like they are going out of style.

But stay with your small servers with at best Quad processors running and be happy as the real competition passes you by and leaves you on the IT Scrap Heap. Currently Thin Clients are making a come back and will in all likely hood replace a lot of the workstations in the near future and these will require high end servers for big business who are already running mainframes and do not need any power on the workstations. You will at least be happy until you realize that you have wedged your self so tightly into a corner that you will be unemployable to all but very small business who have up to 20 computers including their servers!

Col ]:)

by jmgarvin

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/business/148915_msftlinux19.html

Long story short:
MS pwns the desktop market with 93%, but Linux is starting to eat into that with almost 3%

MS only has a 55% share in servers (and losing) *nix holds over 30% and growing.

Apache pwns with 67% while IIS comes in with only a 21% market share.

MS is hurting outside the desktop market. They are slowly dying as a server and their upgrade cycles are urking CIOs and CFOs eveywhere. By 2007 *nix is really going to put the hurt on MS because of all the issues IT shops are having with it.

by apotheon

Actually, I suspect that the SCO licenses for which Microsoft paid were earmarked for a particular use when they were purchased. Microsoft probably saw it as an opportunity to kill two birds with one stone: put some legal pressure on Linux and grant Microsoft some UNIX licenses.

The worth of those UNIX licenses, of course, is probably mostly tied up in the ability to replace the open source systems that Microsoft is still using. This way, Microsoft can start to live up to its big talk just slightly more than before (though certainly not by very friggin' much). While running SCO UNIX on the back end of some systems is far from ideal from a marketing perspective, it's a darn sight better than running Linux or *BSD.

What's that? You didn't know Microsoft was using Linux and/or *BSD?

One of the major problem with Windows servers, particularly in very high transaction rate implementations, is that the integral GUI sucks up a tremendous amount of system resources. Windows servers just can't keep up with a CLI-only system that doesn't have to support a wholly superfluous graphical user interface environment. Add to this the fact that Windows suffers an awful lot of downtime, and you get a staggering amount of inefficiency in implementations as a high-load server. In other words, it scales like crap.

When Microsoft acquired Hotmail, most of Hotmail was running on open source unix (primarily *BSD, if I recall correctly). Microsoft started trying to replace the entire Hotmail infrastructure with Windows servers, but quickly realized how impossible that would be. The compromise was a long-term plan to phase out the detectable non-Windows servers that faced directly on the Internet (primarily webservers and proxies, I would imagine) and keep the high-load back end running on open source unices.

If that can all be replaced by proprietary UNIX systems, this would free up Microsoft's FUD factory to start pointing out their migration away from open source OSes in what they'll certainly call "legacy" implementations because, as Microsoft will claim, FLOSS is not secure. It's all BS, of course, but that won't stop MS from making such claims.

This, at least, is what I would think Microsoft would plan to do with SCO licenses. I suppose I could be wrong.

by wordworker

Okay jd, so I exaggerate the tiny market share numbers. You haven't quoted any facts to support your own brand of zealot-calling-the-pot-black. Here's one for you:

Market researcher IDC expects to announce within weeks that Linux PC market share in 2003 hit 3.2%, overtaking Apple Computer Inc.'s MacOS. And the researcher expects Linux to capture 6% of this market by 2007. That's still tiny compared with Microsoft's 94% share.

http://www.itfacts.biz/index.php?id=P723

Whoo-whoo! 6%!

But wait, what about this:
The Open Source Development Labs, the organization that employs Linux leader Linus Torvalds, has laid off nearly a sixth of its staff as part of a shift to new priorities.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/2100-10877_11-5717430.html?tag=search

And for your information, jd, your name-calling in these threads is pretty juvenile. Maybe IT-Lobo is your pseudonym?

by jdclyde

Yes, that is for PC's. Linux is still young on the [b]PC[/b] in the corporate world.

Go out and find how many [b]SERVERS [/b]are running *nix and you will find two things. One, the number is MUCH higher, and two, the number is inacruate.

As many *nix servers are not running under a license agreement purchased somewhere, how do you propose to determine how many there are?

Look at your bigger web and mail servers and most will NOT be MS. Now why is that?

Why do many of your bigger corporations use a Domino server instead of Exchange?

As for me being the zealot, remember I am the one that is saying use the best tool for the job, not that you have to use one or the other. That was your push, not mine.

That does it, I'm leaving TR (thanks wordworker).....

I don't think so.

As for "name-calling", are you refering to my ONE reference about you being "clueless" because of the information you have presented? That is the big juvenile stunt that gets me compared to Lobo? Talk about thin skin. Go back and re-read the posts, I didn't see a single other reference that could be concidered calling you names. Or did you read it in someone elses post?

by apotheon

Why is this posted in response to my post, but addressed to jdclyde? That doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Considering that the numbers I've seen quoted elsewhere in this thread listed only 2% for PC desktop systems, it looks like your figures are actually improving on Linux market share, rather than decreasing it as you seem to expect. Are you sure you know what side of an argument you're on?

You clearly haven't read a whole lot about what's actually happening at OSDL. Yes, a number of programmers have been laid off, but that's only in the OSDL headquarters in Oregon. The restructuring to which the articles refer involves expansion into additional markets, including new offices in China and Korea (where previously Japan had the only OSDL offices in Asia) as well as several additional locations in Europe. Are you sure you actually finished reading an article about the subject?

Perhaps you should pay more attention to market trends and industry technology standards. The most commonly used mail server on the planet is Sendmail (open source, often run on Linux), not MS Exchange Server. The most commonly used webserver on the planet is Apache (open source, often run on Linux), not MS Internet Information Server. All those little router/firewall appliances you can buy from the store with names like Linksys and Buffalo on them for use in home and small business networks run embedded Linux, not Windows. The fastest supercomputer in Europe is a Linux cluster in Spain, but there are no Windows supercomputers.

by hal 9000

I was going to use Hot Mail as an example of just how unsuitable Windows whatever was to high volume servers. :(

It is something highly visible to everyone who even plays with a computer and I know a lot of ex Hot Mail users who dropped it like a hot potato when M$ acquired it as they had way too many problems associated with their Hot Mail accounts. Which are or where great for travelers as they could log on from anywhere and get and send E-Mail, now most of them are using Yahoo as a better service.

But I wouldn't mind betting that M$ will bring out a Unix platform with a Windows like GUI as their next Server Product as 2003 in all of its incarnations has not proved as secure as M$ touted when they released it. They have had egg on their collective faces ever since particularly when at the launch the M$ sales people claimed that they had been testing in in real life environment for over 6 months [I think it was but it was a long time even by M$ standards} and no holes had been discovered. Then within 2 weeks the first patch was released to cover a problem in 2003. Maybe I'm just cynical but I do not believe that M$ could have been told of a problem or found the problem and rolled out a patch in that short a time they must have been working on it while the M$ Representatives where telling us all just how great it was and how it was almost unbreakable. :D

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

always muddying up the water with facts and logic.

How are we supose to have an intellegent conversation back and fourth when you don't leave room for an opposing view because of the facts in the case?

by geekchic

What if the bulk of homes and businesses used Linux...do you think that then it would also be more vulerable to being hacked apart?

Now, understand that I do not know much about the internal workings of Linux! I am just suggesting that pehaps people with that type of "skill" would want to disrupt whatever would make the biggest impact. If Linux is currently only used by 2 to 6 percent of world then there wouldn't be much thrill in spending time trying to disrupt the services that it supports.

We currently use a variety of operating systems including Windows, MAC, Apache, Unix and Linux. Of course it seems we are constanting updating the Windows product but, it is the one we use most often.

So, what do you think? If Linux was the #1 OS would we be having some of the same problems with it as we are with MS??

by firstpeter

Firefox is a good example of that. I heard folks touting how safe and secure it was. And if I recall last week it actually topped the list of critical bugs. Why? Because xM people downloaded it and bought into the "fact" that it's a more secure product.

Now, I don't want to imply that it's NOT a more secure product all told - but at this point folks are starting to realize that what Firefox got along with xM downloads is a big ol' bullseye painted on it. Why? Because as someone wise said in an earlier post - folks don't hack for the money (for the most part) - it's all about the pride of accomplishment. So if I can hack the "ultra-secure" Firefox that xM people moved to, I get a star on my chest.

When the dust settles and all is said and done I don't have the slightest idea who has the better browser. But I do think you hit it right on the head - if Linux was in MS' place right now we'd have a completely different set of threads going about who is better and more secure.

by apotheon

It's hard to believe that people are so up in arms over Firefox having such a bad week. News flash, folks: it topped the charts for one week because it had two vulnerabilities come up at the same time. Guess what: it had to happen eventually, just as going several weeks with none has happened more than once already. The fact that Microsoft's IE also lucked out at the same time, with a week in which it only had one vulnerability come to light, doesn't make Firefox "less secure" than IE.

What it does do is make the Microsoft "zealots" a lot more annoying.

Firefox is undeniably more secure than IE, for a number of reasons. First and foremost, it's not tied directly into the OS, and thus doesn't grant a direct pass-through from the World Wide Web to your OS kernel processes. Second, it doesn't grant arbitrary remote code execution through ActiveX, one of the worst misfeatures in the history of Microsoft. Third, its vulnerabilities get patched with immediacy, in a few days at most, whereas with IE you're lucky if it gets patched in less than a month, and there are all too common cases of vulnerabilities surviving unpatched for six months or more. In fact, according to Secunia, there are currently 19 unpatched IE 6.x vulnerabilities, dating as far back as 13 March 2003, and an additional ten vulnerabilities that have received only "partial fixes". Meanwhile, those two minor vulnerabilities that everyone has been so excited about for Firefox were patched with the release of Firefox version 1.0.4, mere days after their discovery.

As for Linux . . .
The situation is even more lopsided for Linux vs. Windows than it is for Firefox vs. IE. For one thing, all of IE's vulnerabilities are also Windows vulnerabilities, because IE is integrated directly into core OS functionality in Windows. This allows for rapid and easy privilege escalation for intruders and easy circumvention of security measures meant to stop arbitratry remote code execution. In addition to this, there are the software architecture characteristics of the OSes themselves.

On one hand you've got Linux. Linux, like any unix, is a true multi-user system, with strict privilege separation and sharply defined separation between "userland" and kernel processes, rendering privilege escalation almost impossible outside of social engineering (which does an end-run around technology entirely to take advantage of user stupidity, anyway, and equally affects users of any OS, assuming equal stupidity). There's also the difficulty of arbitrary remote code execution, as Linux, like any unix, doesn't play user-obsequious games with trying to execut every bit of code into which it comes in contact, based on a file extension. This is how image-embedded and macro-based malicious mobile code gets propagated, and it's nearly impossible for it to do so on a unix system: the user basically has to tell it to run with a conscious decision, thus bringing us back to social engineering as the major exploit of the system's weaknes (the human). Even if you get the user to execute some malicious piece of code, it only runs with the permissions of the user which, if you'll remember from my previous mention of strict privilege separation, means that malicious code is very limited in what it can do, thus essentially emasculating what might otherwise be a very dangerous virus. A virus designed to wipe out the boot sector and file allocation table of a drive, for instance, that is only run from a normal user account will simply fail to execute properly. No harm done. All data intact.

On the other hand, we've got Windows. Windows does not have strict privilege segregation. It's not a true multi-user system. It is, in fact, a single-user system with a user profiles application laid over the top of it to make it look like a multi-user system to the credulous user. Privilege escalation is extremely easy in Windows because of this. Additionally, because of the interconnectedness of all the kernel-integrated functionality of a Windows system, even when user privilege separation might stand in the way of privilege escalation, hostile code can simply bypass user permissions entirely and just access system functionality through intermediary applications. The canonical example of this is Internet Explorer, though that is by no means the only example. Furthermore, application and service operation in Windows relies heavily on RPCs (remote procedure calls), even for internal and intra-application interprocess communication. It's so bad that MS SQL Server won't run properly without RPC services running, and much of the feature set of the Windows GUI is crippled if denied access to RPCs (for instance, you can't drag and drop with Windows Explorer without using RPCs). Finally, to round out the comparison, Windows happily executes code willy-nilly based on file extensions, automatically and generally without consulting with the user, and since the user privileges bleed across different user accounts, including the admin account, that means that by simply writing a little clever code and naming it with a convenient file extension a malicious security cracker can create a quick piece of code that will own the box in seconds.

Besides, everybody runs with an administrator-privileged user account in Windows, since you basically can't do ANYthing useful in Windows without admin rights (another distinct disadvantage as compared with unices, but tied in with the fact that Windows is fundamentally a single-user system in any case).

Don't forget about that bit about faster response times on vulnerability patches, as for Firefox vs. Internet Explorer. The same people at MS that are neglecting IE are also neglecting Windows. Meanwhile, the Linux kernel gets patches [i]much faster[/i] than Firefox does, if you can believe that. Whereas Firefox gets its patches in a few days, the Linux kernel gets them in a few hours. I've seen patches for Linux posted in less than two hours after they were reported. I don't remember a Windows patch being released in less than a couple weeks, at the absolute best.

If Linux was the inarguable leader on the desktop and Microsoft only had 2% of that market, but all else was equal, we'd still be complaining about the lack of security of Windows, guaranteed.

Keep in mind that Apache, which runs on Linux systems all over the world, holds sixty-something percent of the web server market and gets hammered on a regular basis with new attacks, and yet it is Microsoft's IIS that falls on its face on a regular basis because of its inferior security of design. Popularity is not the sole arbiter of security issues with software. In fact, the more popular open source software becomes, the more people there are finding and fixing vulnerabilities before a writer of malicious code ever finds them. The common wisdom regarding market penetration leading to security issues is reversed when considering open source software development, and that is one of its greatest strengths.

by hal 9000

If Unix/Linux as the mainstay of the market it would be getting hit a lot harder than it currently is but it is also harder to hit so those "Script Kiddies" would either have to know much more or there would be fewer of them.

But once you remember that nothing at all is secure and you accept that everything has its weaknesses you can then go about living with the lesser of two evils and making the necessary safe guards to put in place to minimize any intrusions and the like.

The very first case of what we now know as "Hacking" happened at the Melbourne University in AU where a few people gained access to the Unix Mainframe and then had free rein about the world to do as they liked that was way back in the early 1970's where most people didn't have computers and those that did had paid an arm and a leg for them and even better there where no Laws in place to make it a Criminal Activity.

Since then we have become much more security conscious and the makers of the OS's are accepting their responsibility to minimize intrusions. The fact that it is easier to do on Unix/Linux platform is neither here nor there every OS has weaknesses that can and will be exploited but on the up side on a Unix/Linus OS unless you have just been installing something the OS reverts back to a restricted account and asks you for the Admin Password before allowing anything to install. Now if you've just opened an attachment in an E-Mail that isn't what you expected it can not install itself without you helping it by opening the Admin Account which is something that most people would not do.

The current versions of Unix and Linux are far more secure than Windows is and are a lot harder to crack but not impossible. The question really is are you happy that something can install itself easily without your knowledge or would you prefer some way to prevent/minimize this from happening?

The Fire fox implication is really a non issue as the problem there was a buffer overflow and was directly related to the platform that it was running on and not the program itself. M$ has for several years been attempting to stop the Buffer Overflows that cause the problem but because of the way that Windows works for every one that they stop several others are still available and while a bit harder to reach are still an easy target in comparison to Unix.

There is nothing at all you can do to prevent every attack but you can certainly make it harder for those who want to play nasty.

Col ]:)

by geekchic

Ok, I am getting information over load here!! Man have I learned a LOT about Linux AND many other things...thanks for responding to my question so openly. I do appreciate it.

I also wanted to comment on the statement in one of the repsonses about "users" having 500 word files in one directory. Around here, I am lucky if they manage to get them into one directory. I find them everywhere on their computers, on the C drive in the system files and on the desktop! And then they make copies of the copies of the copies and save them everywhere on the C drive in case they have a problem with their hard drive...they can get them back. DUH! If the hard drive is gone....EVERYTHING'S GONE! They have been trained, I have personally gone to their desks and showed what to do, written them instructions and when their hard drive dies, that data is lost. We back up My Docs, email and some other settings on a regular basis but if they don't put anything where it is supposed to be...there is NOTHING to restore!

Sorry that is my rant for the day!!

by jdclyde

My users have them all in one directory because that is the default and don't know how to change to a different directory.

As for backing up data, I put an icon on the desktop that takes everything in the "My Documents" and copies it to their ZIP drive. All they need to do is double-click an icon. Do you think more than 1% of my users will do even that? Not on your life.

Backup? We don't need no stink'en backup!

By the way, you had an excellent question that was worded very well. Too bad more people that don't know about something wouldn't just ask like you did instead of making statements based on things the had heard as if they are facts. Many could learn from you. (I always learn a lot in here too, just about everyday I get something new)

by jmgarvin

I would say no to Linux being more vulnerable for a number of reasons. You need to keep in mind that *nix holds about 35% of the server market and about 3% of the desktop market. Apache hold about 65% of the web server market and IIS holds around 35%. With that being said, you need a little background in the way things work in Windows and Linux.

Windows has a registry and "user space" that is simply folders that have various permissions on them. A user cannot modify the registry, you have to be a power user or admin. The problem with windows is that I don't actually have to change the resistry, I can simply create a library (dll) or executable that is called. Part of the problem too is that Windows is very open to letting Trojans do what they want (for some of the reasons listed above, but there are other insecurities with the way the Executive and Kernel interact, but that is a pretty long discussion)

Linux works on a pretty simple idea of permission control. User space is actually just that. A user has their own little homestead and they don't have to worry about others invading on their territory (unlike Windows). There are specific directories that share out resources to non-root users. As a non-root user you cannot do much to the system other than affect your own user space. Linux also has kernel level security that helps prevent some of the issues that Windows has.

Anyway, my point is that the way Windows is designed it is inheriently insecure. The way *nix is designed it is far more secure. I'd argue that while *nix would have security issues (it does right now) very few issues would be as critical as the plethora of MS issues that are patched on a regular basis.

I'd also argue that open source is probably more secure (in general) because of peer review.

by firstpeter

JD - are you really a *nix zealot in an independent thread's clothing? I hope not - your earlier posts made a lot of sense, and I'm afraid you lose a LOT of credibility if you've fallen to "the dark side" (whichever side that may be). While that credibility may be lost on a MS-zealot anyway, I suspect those folks who may be "open" to *nix (semi-pun FULLY intended, incidentally) would have given ample consideration to what you pointed out...as long as they don't think you're blasting one side or another.

I'm not even sure YOU made this post. Your "fact" that Windows users are so because of the "pretty little pictures" and because they "don't have to know anything" is completely off-base and wrong, and I know you know it.

Besides, a statement like that completely contradicts what you said earlier about one being right for a particular situation. If Windows is just, um, pretty window-dressing (wow - two puns in one reply!) with no realy function then you really can't argue that one is better suited for a particular situation - the latest logic would dictate that Windows is never the best solution.

Don't let people get to you on this. The entire start of your thread was devoted not to an MS - *nix war but to letting people know that folks who fall solely to one side or another need to understand that each is best suited to a particular place.

Back up a bit and let's keep this out of a flame war. There are plenty enough of those already here to go around.

by jdclyde

I am not trying to take one side or the other. But when someone comes from one side blindly, I will try to show the reasons that this is not logical.

I run a mixed environment now. I would even have a few more Windows servers now if my boss would let me. got a win2k server license sitting on the shelf not even being used and I can't do anything with it.

Using the right tool for the job means look at the good and the bad of each.

Windows has a lot of applications that you can run. There are lots of unified messeging systems that would integrate well with our domino system, if we could use that Windows license that is already paid for.

I would never concider running a web server on Windows because of security and performance. Same for ftp.

Windows got where it is by being easy, not good. OS2 warp was more stable, but not marketed is well. The one thing MS does better than anyone is marketing. I think they are even selling new refrigirators to the eskimos as we speak.

Now if windows 95/98/ME/NT4 would all just go away things would be so much easier. I can deal with a win2k or XP system. They still lock up, but not nearly as often. The also do make it easy to get work done with a minimal amount of training. That is good for business.

Thanks for the slap to get me back on track!

by hal 9000

I have one class of clients who run a mission critical application which only runs on NT and then nothing newer than NT4.

Because this is one of those limited applications currently there are no plans for rewriting it so I'm stuck with NT4 in site offices so keep the plant running. As this is an earthworks program that involves laser sighting and measuring equipment all over the construction site the software package is a very small expense when compared to the machinery on-site and the fact that the computers are in a very hostile environment doesn't matter as they are virtually nothing to replace when they die from dust inhalation which turns into mud when it rains and short circuits the M'Boards at the same time.

I just love the way that at every M$ meeting that I go to they just brush over the ease of migration to 2003 but fail to consider some mission critical applications like this that just can not be moved.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Nah not really:D I do think there is a place for everything in the current market and it is the server and Notebook sides that are the ones currently growing at an alarming rate. Currently the Workstation market is at best stagnant and maybe even slipping a little compared to last year.

Currently AMD seems to have forgotten about their Mobile CPU and is concentrating on their Dual Core 64 bit CPU's and Intel is cleaning up the market with their Centreno Platform and are introducing that technology into their upcoming range of CPU's which will only make them far more attractive to the business as they can save money in running the things and air conditioning as the masses of CPU's in their servers will be running cooler so not as much AC will be required to keep things cool. ;)

Now I've done it haven't I? I've broadened the discussion away from the OS's to include CPU's as well! Woe is me. :p

Col ]:)

by apotheon

You bring up an interesting point, regarding thin clients. I bet we'll see Microsoft turning out studies wherein the number of computers used in corporate America is measured to show Microsoft market share, and each case of thin clients running from a centralized server will be counted as only one computer (the server) while the Windows boxen will be counted individually. It's always helpful to skew the number, I suppose.

by hal 9000

He probably read that in the M$ mag as proof that Linux was on the decline.

I'll bet there was no mention of the anti M$ sediment that is currently being shown by many of the Asian Countries and the rush to develop Turbo Linux for these markets in these markets as an alternative to Windows.

While the USA might rule the world in computing at the moment things are rapidly changing in other parts of the world and there are a lot of incentives being provided by Governments to produce an alternative System.

But the simple fact is that if people and companies are unwilling to embrace change they will be left behind and others will take their place.

Dare I mention the recent Court Ruling in Europe that M$ Lost? :D

Col ]:)

by firstpeter

Back up just a bit - I don't know that everyone is "up in arms" about Firefox having such a bad week. The point is it's not 100% secure, it isn't now, nor has it been. I think we can all agree on that one, right? Regardless of where the problem stemmed from (OS or Application) the issue of security is that Firefox could have been protected ahead of time to prevent what happened (as evidenced by the fact that there is a patch available for it). Does that mean it's a bad program? No, it just means it not 100% secure.

So my point isn't that it's more/less secure than IE as functional product - I haven't the slightest idea. I've heard both sides of it and I'm not qualified to make any determination one way or another. I do know it's probably more secure in application because it's a smaller target for all the malcontents in the world that want to get a big gold star for doing something malicious. IE is much more lucrative because it's still what, 90% of the market? (I'm not sure how accurate that one is)

So to the original point from the Chic:
"Do you think that then it [Firefox in this case] would also be more vulerable to being hacked apart?"

I don't think anyone aside from a zealot can answer anything but "yes". (someone stop me if I'm being too general here - I'm not trying to be condescending) The lower-key you are the safer you are in application. Nobody is going to hack my proprietary software app because even if they ran across it a total of two users doesn't make it worth their while. They don't stand to gain anything from it, and they're not going to much of a sense of pride if they pull it off.

The moment we assume that our product (whatever product) is totally secure is the moment we set ourselves up for a big dose of hubris. (I've always wanted to use that word in a post - forgive me) That's life. People, even bad people, are creative, and they will find ways around it.

Now my post dealt primarily with Firefox, an open-source application that's well accepted (rightfully so - it's a great alternative). I took Chic's post to refer to any "mainstream" open source; I may have over generalized the intent in my speaking about Firefox. But I'll still hold that the more visible and widespread ANY application or OS is the more prone it is to be "hacked apart".

by jdclyde

As Apache IS more dominant as a web server, yet it isn't the one getting hit and hacked all the time.

That just shows that the part of the argument of the only reason MS is more vulnerable is because they are more common. There are many other things that make them vulnerable.

by firstpeter

I'm not an expert on which one gets hit more often, so I can't comment with much in the way of authority there. I would assume IIS, but I'm not around Apache enough to know what issues it faces. But it's irrelvant for my point. That gets to the argument of which one is better - not at all the point of this discussion (or at least MY point in this discussion).

The point was only in response to geekchic's question about whether it would be more likely to be hacked if it were more mainstream. I still hold to "yes" on that. It wasn't an issue of which one is better, but rather if it's more visible, if it's more used would it be hacked more. Yes. Would *nix flaws be as serious as Windows flaws? Don't know, don't care (for the purposes of this discussion, anyway - when all is said and done it DOES make a difference, but we're in academic world right now). Would there be as many flaws in Firefox as there are in IE given the same span of life? Don't know, don't care (see paranthetical comment above). Will Apache host my site more securely than IIS? Don't know, don't care (still caveated per above).

Does *nix have more flaws in it than it had when it was first created? No - some have been patched. But have more flaws been found as it becomes more mainstream? Yes - because now it's a bigger target than it was.

JD - I don't disagree at all with your take on this one. I think you hit it right on the money. I'm a primarily-MS guy, even, so believe it or not even us folks on "the dark side" can think logically about things. :) There is no "MS" pride here - it just happens to be the best tool for many things I involve myself in (see an earlier comment on the definition of "best"). My only point is that I don't think we're addressing the same question on this subthread.

by apotheon

geekchic asked if Linux, with greater popularity on the desktop, would be having the same problems as Microsoft is now having. That's not just a question about whether it would be more attacked than it is now: it's a question about whether obscurity is the real reason for its security. The "security through obscurity" concept just doesn't work, and that also means that security through obscurity isn't the reason for Linux having greater current security than Windows.

Linux has passed a minimum threshold of popularity: it is in regular enough use so that it will attract security crackers. Whether or not they succeed in developing effective exploits is another matter entirely. Because Linux is capturing such a significant portion of the low-end server market, running mission-critical applications and protecting sensitive data, it is already a juicy target for many malicious security crackers. In fact, because it has the less glamorous but more financially significant role of a server as its primary operational niche, it should be attracting more "professional" security crackers, more people who are in it for the money instead of for IRC bragging rights.

This means that the people most likely to actually discover a vulnerability and develop a malicious exploit are already paying attention to Linux, whereas people who try to compromise desktop systems for "fun" are the sort who make use of cracks developed by better minds than theirs. Desktop system crackers are the cast-offs of those who invade servers in search of something that might profit them.

Thus, all that Microsoft's desktop dominance really does is get it in the news more. The server side is where the vulnerabilities are found and exploited in the first place. If Linux isn't already being hammered with vulnerabilities as much as Windows, it never will be, if popularity is your only measure. Keep in mind as well that there's forty years of unix behind modern Linux systems, and general principles of security cracking for unix in general still hold true because Linux is a modern-day unix. One of those principles is "If there's a Windows system around, go for that instead: it's an easier target."

I responded to you as though you were trying to compare technical security characteristics of Linux and Windows because you were responding to geekchic, who was clearly referring to the likelihood that Linux would get as many exploits and as much damage to its security as Windows if it were as popular as Windows now is. If you were taking the discussion in a different direction, though, I'm afraid I missed that part.

by firstpeter

I did end up taking a slightly different direction - I took it to "generally accepted" open source (basically Firefox in my example) vs. just Linux / Windows.

"What if the bulk of homes and businesses used Linux...do you think that then it would also be more vulerable to being hacked apart?" --geekchic

I had read geekchic's statement above as being a question of whether it "would also be more vulnerable to being hacked apart" as a comparison of where it is now vs. where it would be if the whole world used it. Re-reading it I can see that another interpretation (which is the route I believe you went down) could be a comparison between where Windows is now and where Linux would be. I didn't get the impression that was where she was headed, but I can see where I could have misread the intent of the original post.

If the intent was the latter (head-to-head) I can't speak to the security of one vs. another with much authority, but I'd wager my money on Linux being the more secure of the two in a head-to-head "same time in market" situation. I don't think there are many people who would put money on MS coming out ahead. I'm not even sure you could get Ballmer to buy that one. :)

I don't disagree that most of the people who are up to no good are already paying attention to Linux. That's actually my point. Before Linux became a common platform for secure web hosting were these same people cracking it at the same rate? I doubt it - what would they get out of it? "Hey, Gary, I just cracked a Linux box! I affected fourteen users!!!"

Nobody hacks Windows 3.1 anymore because the user base is so minimal (but yes, there are still people who use it - I've seen it with my own two eyes. I didn't believe it until I saw it). If suddendly OSs went retro and 3.1 became the OS of choice* you can almost guarantee that someone would find a new way to hack it because now all of a sudden it's big stuff and there's (perceived) value in it.

* Side note: Can you imagine that world? I mean, there is a REASON parachute pants went out of style - please don't bring them back. But apparently anything is fair game (because they're back), so why not bring back the old OSs? :)

BTW: No offense intended to any parachute pant-wearing TR-ers. But really, there IS a reason they left...

by jdclyde

but STILL have one point more.

"Does *nix have more flaws in it than it had when it was first created? No - some have been patched. But have more flaws been found as it becomes more mainstream? Yes - because now it's a bigger target than it was."

New flaw get there because new features are added. Just like in all software.

And the Apache point was just goes to show that claim that the ONLY reason Windows is exploited more is because of the bigger footprint on the new. Apache has the bigger footprint and is still exploited less than IIS.

Glad to see reasonable people out there!

by apotheon

Linux has actually been around since before Windows 3.1 was invented. The press mostly hasn't noticed because it wasn't doing the "user friendly" thing at all until about five years ago. It has, however, been the platform of choice for programmers in certain industries since the early '90s and, for instance, most of the ballistic missile defense industry runs on Linux.

This is not a new thing. This has, in fact, been going on for years. Linux has been gaining significant server market share for years as well. People act as though Microsoft invented the Internet, but the truth is that most of the Internet has been running on various unices since the early '80s at least (I know much of the Internet ran on unices before that, but I don't know if "most" is a fair term). In fact, Microsoft didn't even have Internet-capable OSes until the '90s.

Apache on unix is pretty much the uncontested king of the Internet, and in fact in webserver admin circles the term "apache" is generally used synonymously with "webserver", just as "squid" is often used synonymously with "proxy server". Windows, IIS, and MS Proxy Server are Johnny-come-latelies that still haven't provided a credible threat to the majority hold on Internet services enjoyed by open source software.

. . . and most of it is running on Linux. Solaris and *BSD, in no particular order, are probably the runners-up for Apache and Squid server OSes.

Linux is not a new phenomenon. Linux is not something that will get cracked and attacked more often as it matures as a commonly used server platform because it is [b]already[/b] a mature commonly used server platform. The people who try to crack security on servers already know this. The only area in which Linux is a recent entry to the mix is mainstream end-user desktops. If Linux was going to be proven as vulnerable as Windows to the common cracker, it would have already happened. The only real threat to it now is pressure from within to include stupid, unnecessary features that might actual degrade its value and, for the really paranoid, the possibility of sabotage by proprietary software vendors that might like to see Linux fail to take much market share.

by firstpeter

I think we're saying the same thing. Linux, in it's current form, has been around for a while (I didn't realize the early 90s; I thought it was later than that), and I'm with you on Unix being what effectively runs yonder 'Net.

However, Unix (and until the last few years Linux) has never been intended as the "Joe Average" desktop OS (primarily because most average users would probably freak out if they didn't have a GUI). When it becomes more "mainstream" as a desktop OS I think you will see people adding all the "stupid features" and, ultimately, causing problems (because those tend to open up security holes). Just a thought.

by hal 9000

With Home computers is the switch from Windows 9X to various versions of Linux as the people are unwilling to dispose of their older perfectly working computers and buy new stuff just to run Windows 2000 or XP which their old computers are not capable of doing.

Sure thy do have new ones which they have the newer Windows OS's on but they seem to want to keep the old ones as well and quite a few are not only enjoying the switch to Linux but are also taking exams in Linux as well. I ran across this just yesterday and was a bit shocked to find that a Doctor was quite happy to be doing the Linux Exams that are offered here in the higher education places. His current idea is that as he becomes more familiar with Linux to first switch all his home computers to it {currently he has his Internet Gateway running Red Hat and likes it far more than Windows} and he eventually plans to switch all of his business computers over to Linux as well when he is more familiar with it. He see many advantages over Windows and while I don't think it may be the best solution he appears to.

It could be that M$ is shooting themselves in the foot by ending the life cycles of their older OS's and expecting everyone to dump their older computers and upgrade every 5 years or so which is great in Business but not such a good idea for the home market. And with the current push to recycle computer parts defiantly is not such a great idea for the environment either or the costs involved in recycling the hardware.

Col ]:)

by radiic

Thats a good point about the hardware Hal, but what do you do when its your Mom that wants to better up. I have a hard enough time now, showing her some of the things she can do. Besides showing her then a month later she asks if she can do what i just showed her the previous month. Argg...

But i do agree with the awesomeness of all the *nix's, that are out there. I was able to load RH and Suse (several different versions too)on an old Premio box i found here at work that was at leaset 7 years old, and it loaded no problem, and ran like a champ. With all the new disposal rules that are out there, we might be forced to start making our old hardware work better for us. I dont see using any of the new MS os's on anything older than 6 months to get the same performance.

by hal 9000

At first I used to bring her over here and use one of my workstations to do her work, she is completely computer illiterate and really doesn't want to know how to use one.

But out of desperation I gave her a Computer a few years ago now and I don't think she has ever used it admittedly she now turns it on when I go over there to do what she needs done and it does save one return trip but things have gone from bad to worse as she has just got a new Digital Photocopier which doubles as a printer so instead of doing the Magazine that she does 4 times a year by getting a hard copy sent to her and then making up A3 pages from A4 she is now getting the thing e-mailed to her and printing it directly from the computer. So instead of just going over there to do her "Volunteer" work for her which was previously just the members address lists and mailing labels I'm now also printing off the Quarterly mag as well.

And I thought that computers would make my life easier. :(

Currently I have her on 98SE and I'm not game enough to upgrade the computer to XP as she will just throw another fit claiming that things are constantly changing and she has no possibility of keeping up with things. ;)

But on the other hand I do a bit of volunteer work at a nursing home near by and keep their computers up and running just for my cost of parts and whenever I go there to fix something or do some routine maintains on the nursing homes patients use computers I'm constantly being bombarded with the latest Porn Sites that they have discovered. The women are the worse offenders as well as they not only demand to show you the sites but give you sound effects as well. I just laugh as I can not help myself and while the nursing staff are constantly complaining I'm not about to start blocking these sites as the patients enjoy them and they are certainly old enough not to be adversely affected by them, after all they have precious little else to do and it is one of their few escapes from the routine of the place. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

There was no GUI with that and people seemed to use it quite a lot.

Granted I did get a few calls back in those early days that their new computer that had been ordered without any software wouldn't work properly and they only got a strange meaningless C:\ prompt when they started the thing. But this was nothing to do with DOS but more a Hollywood thing where people expected just to plug it in switch it on and have a nice AI to do all the work for them.

Back in those days the PC was considered as Magic and a lot of uneducated people though that they could do everything including think. But even before the end of the DOS era this had been forgotten and people just worked with DOS without a single problem they considered the Command Line king and understood it fairly well.

But with the advent of Windows 95 the dumbing down began and people no longer know how to use computers properly after all they have a pretty picture imported to the desktop of whatever takes their personal fancy and they only have to click on an Icon to get a program open most of which are imported to the desktop to prevent the need to open the Start Menu which scares a lot of new users.

While some people may be able to drive individual applications very well by no means infers that they know how to use a computer just the application that they use and even then most would be lost without the pointing device as "Keyboard Shortcuts" are today an unknown thing by most end users. The number of times that I've had to go to a person because their mouse broke and they couldn't continue and couldn't shut down because they would loose all of that input is amazing particularly when I just walk in push a few keys save their currently open data and anything else that they have open and then reboot so that the new mouse that they have fitted works.

But they believe they know how to use a computer so who cares?

Col ]:)

by apotheon

These are "low-end servers". This doesn't even account for mid-range and high-end servers (stuff that isn't, never was, and never will be desktop hardware, like the AS/400 all the way up to a Cray or a Linux cluster supercomputer). There's still a lot of business done on mainframes, believe it or not.

by jdclyde

all the high end CG that you see is done on linux for a few reasons. To save buko bucks on licensing AND because it runs faster and is more stable than it's windows counter part. Go and look at all the cool things Pixar has done with it.

High end CAD stations have been Unix for a long time.

Login to your netgear router to update the flash and it is linux.

Many of the security boxes out there. MultiTech routefinders are linux boxes, that you run from a browser (or you can console in).

A year back when MS was getting DOS attacks against it's update server, it had a proxie hosted to block this out. That company used linux servers, to protect MicroSoft. How funny is that.

It is out there, more than you know.

(Sad to say I remember the first coming of the parachute pants. You can still buy them for about $5 at Normans too!)

by jdclyde

I (as one of about ten hats I wear) am in charge of all in-house training of our computer users.

Before that I taught Applications at the local college as well as a local training shop.

I have about 10 years of experience teaching zero level users how to use their computer so I have been there and seen that.

Most "users" don't know anything about the operations of the computer because they just don't care how it works or are afraid of it because it is more than they can comprehend. The fear imobolizes many before they can even start.

Most people could not rebuild a motor, but they can drive a car. That is the same aproach they take.

Because of this attitude, they do not learn time saving shortcuts. They do not practice file management AT ALL. How many users do you know with 500 plus word files in a single directory?

If the file isn't in the default location, most would never be able to even find it.

When I teach my classes, it doesn't matter if it is a word proccessor, spreadsheet, presentation, or whatever, the first half hour is nothing but file management and maintance. They would never take a file management and maintance class on it's own so this is how I trick them into learning something about the system.

I laugh when I see someone who does data entry into a spread sheet that someone else designed years before, and claim they "know" excel/lotus 123/quatro pro. No, if you can't setup and maintain that file, your nothing but data entry. I just got done with Fiscal year updates on a group of sheets for our accounting department. Every year, same old thing. grrrr. But they admit they don't know it, and that they have no desire to learn it because that isn't their job. (and it isn't, of course technically doing everyone elses spreadsheets isn't mine either...)

by jdclyde

Don't tell me your not only lefty swill, but a M$ zombie too?

Woe oh woe. When will it all end?

Is there an open source solitare I can go play to drown my sorrows?

(Bout time you showed up! Now add something to the conversation or I will hijack all your guiness)

by jck

as Vern Troyer would have of blocking a shot from Shaq.

I'd give up my computer before I'd give up my Guinness.

I'm not a Microsloth *zombie*, although I'm feeling like it beat the hell out of me.

The DataGrid, if anything, will be the downfall of VS .NET for Microsoft if they don't re-vamp it quickly. It's great for linking a table to it from a database, but to put formatted data into takes an act of God.

BTW, there are lots of games in Linux, man...I thought you were a Linux man?

Damn...20 minutes then I can go home and mow.

by jdclyde

Hey, they can't all be gems can they?

About 5 minutes and it is off to the golf course where there is no MS vs anything. Just me, my clubs, and a bottle a jager! Woo woo!

by jck

I'm glad I don't play golf with you.

You should be too. Jaeger makes me violent for some reason, unless I drink it with Brass Monkey.

Weird. I know. Guinness makes me happy. I'll stick to that.

by jmgarvin

So anyway, I says to LouLou, I says, "Boy I wish more games ran and Linux and..." ;-)

Actually there are some games that run really well either natively (NWN) or with Wine (WoW) in Linux. I highly suggest trying your Linux box for gaming. NWN is a treat and WoW runs like a dream (although I was having an odd problem with dropping frame rates...I think it was the NVidia driver.)

by jdclyde

but just don't have the time at work or at home right now. Got myself a huge backlog of project at work and with my divorce going on I am completely gutting out my house to eliminate all traces of the EX. Five rooms cleaned, painted and redecorated in the last month and three more to go. Also changed out the carpet in two of the rooms, shampooed the rest.

The next room is my new computer room, so I will have an area to set up many of my computers. Got three on the LAN and another four to load with various OS's.

Soon!

by firstpeter

It works fine on a Linux box? I'll have to give that a shot. Are the req specs the same (as best you can tell), or do you think I could boot it up on my white box 1.2 with Red Hat running (vs. my 2.4 with XP)? I have 768M RAM and a 64MB nVidia in both...

by jmgarvin

The mainframe market and the various clusters, crays, whatevers out there will probably ALWAYS be on the high end market.

My point was that the poster stated that MS owns all and *nix has no market share is completely wrong!

Of course the scalability of Linux puts it in a high end class anyway, but that is a different story ;-)

by hal 9000

Do you have to place shortcuts on the desktop to not only the programs but the files as well in a lot of the business?

It is something that drives me nuts I have all these data entry people who insist that they are expert computer users and they can't even find the app start icon in the start menu. Maybe I started the rot with one user who I was constantly being called to just to open the app and then the file that she worked with so I placed a shortcut on the desktop to the file which opened the program up whenever she clicked on it. Within a week I was doing this to every computer in the place and then they decided that they wanted the app shortcuts as well because they just might want to open that app with out that file as if it is a hard thing to do to open the file and close it down to keep the app running.

Don't get me wrong they are very good at what they do but they sure as hell are not expert computer users or even expert in a single app just are able to fill in fields in a pre designed format that they use. Just recently AU Post changed the rules for all their bulk mail and I had to go around to every workstation that entered data for this to change the fields and the label layout it drove me nuts as I constantly had these self proclaimed "Experts" looking over my shoulder asking what it was I was doing now? What made it even worse is it was a app that I do not personally use so I had to fudge my way through it to find the best solution it certainly isn't my job to do but there is no one else capable of doing it either even with all these experts around that use this program.

What gets to me is that working IT you are expected to immediately know every application and even what the differences are going to be on the new ones coming before you even see them. Because I do consulting work for several small business when I first go there I tell them all that I will not touch their accounting packages or any of their data as I don't want to know a single thing about what they are doing and the like and on almost every occasion that I'm called in for a software problem it is to do with their accounting packages or to alter a field in their spread sheets for their products or customer data base.

Or even better I made the mistake of showing someone how to do a mail merge which they had no idea could be done as the place that taught them didn't do "Advanced" stuff like that. To me it was a basic function of the Word Processor and back in the DOS days if you couldn't perform a simple mail merge you didn't know your job. This wasn't even a hard one just the name and address on a form letter. Back when Word Perfect was the must use word processor I used to see some very complicated mail merges done but today the users seem to have been dumbed down so much that instead of using 10% of the programs abilities I would guess that they are now using less than 2% of the abilities of an individual program in a lot of cases. I accept that the training is no longer available that we used to have but even still I would expect quite a lot of what the older people learn to have filtered down into the current work place.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

I will show them how to use Windows Exploiter to select a file to launch that way, but mostly they open the application (from an icon in the launch pad along the bottom) and then click on the pretty picture of a "file" with the arrow coming out and there are the millions and millions of fans of the Rock,... I mean all their files.

Some will let me create subdirectories (remember that word?) to help them keep the files organized, and others just let them fall where they may.

Yes I remember Wordperfect. I started teaching Lotus 1-2-3 ver 2.4 (yes, that was DOS). Didn't do much with Wordperfect until after Windows came around, but I started for personal uses with ver 5.

I still laugh when MS Word went from ver 2 to ver 6 because people were buying WordPerfect because it had a higher version number.

OOOOH! Remember when Apps had VERSION numbers instead of a YEAR?

And yes, I just got done updating a bunch of files for fiscal year end. The user could insert the area for the new year, but it didn't automaticly repopulate the graphs. So I would have to just select the range over again and it would apply the change. Simple changes that took a week because there were so many cussed little changes.

Glad that week is done!

by jmgarvin

I know it can be tough, but it sounds like you are in a happier frame now. Just tell me when you are done and I'll bring my bitchen rig over for a LAN party ;-)

by apotheon

I hope you didn't get the impression I was disagreeing with you. I was adding to your comments. Heh.

by jack-m

Microsoft has been beta testing it's software since the 1st version of Windows was released. When a new version of an MS product is released you can count on them releasing, patches, fixes and workarounds within months if not weeks based on customer complaints. Why have they been able to get away with this for so long? The *nix's, while not necessarily superior certainly don't engage in this type of marketing. The original MS GUI, with it's point and click operation grabbed so much attention and popularity so quickly because an employer or any user could grasp it and become productive immediately thus eliminating the training needed prior to the GUI's introduction. It was a cheap way for any company to have 'trained' computer operators quickly. We got lazy.

by jack-m

Microsoft has been having consumers beta testing it's software since the 1st version of Windows was released. When a new version of an MS product is released you can count on them releasing, patches, fixes and workarounds within months if not weeks based on customer complaints. Why have they been able to get away with this for so long? The *nix's, while not necessarily superior certainly don't engage in this type of marketing. The original MS GUI, with it's point and click operation grabbed so much attention and popularity so quickly because an employer or any user could grasp it and become productive immediately thus eliminating the training needed prior to the GUI's introduction. It was a cheap way for any company to have 'trained' computer operators quickly. We got lazy.

by jdclyde

To make an easy interface for users to get in and out of their applications easily. That is why most DOS and UNIX systems had a menu system setup to help with exactly that.

But then we traded ease for knowledge. The level of computer knowledge of the average computer "user" is so much lower than what it was ten or twenty years ago. And with MS and AOL hiding lots of the controls, I don't feel this is an accident. The less you know, the less you expect because you don't know better.

Why should I need 256 MB Ram (or more) to run a word processor? Why would an office package take more than a gig of disk space? I am writting a cussed memo, not navigating a space shuttle!

Even with computers being easier to learn because you don't have to remember long strings of commands that you could forget or mistype, the masses are still too busy to learn to be more efficent. Don't have the time to save time.

The users are as much the problem as the way MS rushes to market because they accept paying major bucks for a product that is a work in progress.

by firstpeter

I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing (inherently) to trade knowledge for ease. If that trade-off had never occurred you can rest assured that computers would not be as prevalent as they are today, and business would not be able to run near where it can today. I know a number of people that are casual users (no GUI = no go) that are able to turn around work in a fraction of the time they would have otherwise spent on it precisely because they can point and click their way around.

I can't argue on those other points - there is a lot of "short-term" thinking that goes on. I teach seminars on Office and I've had folks tell me after those that what they learned in my one-hour session was going to save them that much time within a week. That's not a bad investment at all. But many folks are reluctant to spend that hour (call it two for travel and such) in the first place. That's why training, at least to some degree, is always part of any new process/app I roll-out to my clients.

by gene.fellner

You say, "Most people could not rebuild a motor, but they can drive a car. That is the same aproach they take."

Boy, does that ever sum up the attitude of the IT Zealots toward the other 99.99 percent of the human race!

Dude: This frelling computer is SUPPOSED to be an appliance, just like my car! I'm not SUPPOSED to have to have the time, aptitude, resources, and interest to learn to be a software mechanic, just to make this appliance do more or less what I want it do to most of the time. I expect appliances to perform as advertised. If my electric range performed as poorly as my computer system, I would take it back for a refund the same day!

I expect to be able to find and use my own data without having to understand directory structures and know the name of the program that created it. I expect to be able to find what I want on the internet and use it interactively to do business without having my computer infested with little programs built by somebody else that can steal or destroy my data or my ability to use the computer.

I expect to have a problem that requires expert help OCCASIONALLY, just like I have with my car. OCCASIONALLY means maybe a couple of times a year.
The rest of the time, I expect to turn the key and drive off without having to waste one brain cell thinking about how the frelling thing WORKS!

You IT professionals just don't get it. The overwhelming majority of the human race is NOT INTERESTED in computer science. To them, the computer is simply a tool, like their car or their TV set.

You had better start writing software that gives these people what they want. Computers keep getting cheaper. More and more of those other six billion people are starting to be able to afford them. They will NOT settle for the kind of software that is available today.

It's your choice whether or not you like this. You can call them names and make fun of them and insult their intelligence. But they WILL NOT use your zero-quality, user-hostile, built-by-programmers-for-programmers software!

by tootz

My first couple computers, I learned enough DOS and Unix to do what I needed -- and far better than most others I knew. But this is all getting very frustrating.

I would suggest IT professionals (bless 'em, they sure do help me out a lot) might consider us poor old souls who really do have a few (thousand) other things to do each day and simply *cannot* focus on our tools, if we expect to get our work done--work, I might add, that could make IT pros' lives a little easier--if I can ever get to it (and if some virus doesn't destroy it, again).

How 'bout it, geek-kids? We love ya' but dang, my trying to figure out what I should be doing, so I can get to working at my own job, is just drivin' me nutz!

Thanks . . .

by apotheon

I'll get right on that, the moment publicly published specs for hardware interfaces and popular software becomes common enough to be able to start tying everything together. Until that time, you'll have to deal with either the mess of problems that Windows provides or the assumption of competence in systems like Linux that are required to allow users to deal with unexpected problems with limited-compatibility hardware and software.

by jdclyde

about pumping gas and when you need it.
Getting the oil changed.
Getting new tires, and knowing WHEN to get the tires.

There is also a TEST you have to take to drive a car. No test for the computer though.

I recognise that the users don't care how it works, as long as it works. Problem is, too often it doesn't.

I see lots of techs that lose sight of why they have their job. To make it so other people can do their jobs. Nothing more, nothing less.

As for this discussion, it is more aimed at getting people out of mindsets to try to find YOU the users the best tools that are the most reliable.

Yes, we all like to pass around the "dumb user" joke lists (only because they are funny) but most of us are just trying to look out for you the best we can.

by firstpeter

That opens up a good question. Is using a computer analagous to driving a car?

My take on it is that it's really not, but there's no reason it couldn't be. Right now personal computers are not designed for a single primary purpose. They're designed to be multi-functional devices, capable of web browsing, playing games, balancing checkbooks, and typing e-mails (among other things).

A car, on the other hand, is designed with the primary goal of getting you from one place to another in varying levels of comfort, economy, and style. Sure, it can be used to jumpstart dead lawn mower batteries or provide a good backstop for a kid's wiffle ball game, but primarily it's designed for getting around.

Computers COULD be made that specific. In fact, it's fairly easy to make them that specific by locking them down, especially in a *nix environment. Look at an Apache web server - if it's built right the first time (i.e., before it's shipped to the user) and configured correctly on site (i.e., when it's installed) you can pretty much count on just needing to do some "regular" maintenance every so often on it to keep it up to spec.

However, what will inevitably happen is that people will want to be able to do more. I don't know anyone that wouldn't want to do just web browsing and nothing else. So now you're starting to introduce complexities of multiple programs that may/may not play well with each other. If the two applications are from the same company that made the OS then maybe they'll play well together (no guarantees on that, even; I've seen that premise fall through a time or two). If they're not you've just put Honda Prius parts in a Mazda RX-8. Maybe they work fine, maybe they don't. They SHOULD, because they're supposed to be built to the same specs, but...

And even if that works, you'll have to go to the computer-equivalent dealer or mechanic to get new programs added. Most users I know would not be happy having to wait a couple of days for me to come by and install a new browser add-in. They want the ability to do it themselves. So now they're modding the machine with after-market parts that probably don't meet standard specs and might even be harmful to the engine.

I don't disagree with your point that folks aren't interested in being computer science majors (nor am I - I'm just here on Earth to help people with computers). I don't disagree that people won't settle for the kind of software available today - I've seen so many commercially-available software programs that fall so short on usability and security that it disturbs me that the companies that produce them are still in business.

However, I DO disagree with you that "IT professionals just don't get it". These boards are proof enough that yes, there ARE some fanatics out there that spoil the broth (no clue if that really makes sense, unless we're cooking the zealots...), but there are more than enough IT professionals here that understand the issue and do their best to deal with what they're given.

I'm willing to best most of the IT professionals you'll find on this board are more in the situation of DEALING with these problems than they are MAKING the problems in the first place. And I'm willing to bet that they couldn't agree more with the fact that people will not use zero-quality, user-hostile software (assuming, of course, that there is an alternative out there to use).

by hal 9000

We can only work with what we are given to fix and what is available.

It's no good blaming the tech for not repairing your computer properly to the way you want to use it if the original software isn't up to spec and does not do exactly what you want. Most of us here try to fix the things or find a work around to suit our customers but very few if any of us here actually are responsible for writing the programs and even fewer are responsible for writing the code that drives the things in the first place.

While we can rip out a bit of faulty hardware and replace it fairly quickly we are unable to rip out a couple of thousand lines of code and rewrite it. We are not responsible for the way that these things work only trying to keep them working in a manner that the OS supports.

Anything more than that we are unable to do and it would be better to address your complaints to the maker of the software and Operating System rather than take the easy option of always blaming the tech for the shortcomings of the software. That is like blaming the mechanic for fitting a genuine part that breaks and then when it breaks again it isn't the mechanics fault but the makers fault and in the case of a car most of the makers take responsibility for these manufacturing faults but for some reason the software houses don't and it is the techs who get the blame for something that is out of their control.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Something much better than M$ products if that is what they want.

But if Billy Boy has his way we'll all be using dumb terminals and paying a rental on the software that we use and for storing our own data. Just think how bad it will be them!

Whoops there was a critical hole in the M$ product and all the data has disappeared from the server that I was using what can I do now? You will not even have a HDD to take to the data recovery people to recover the data from. But it will make M$ even more money so they will not care.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

was more of an observation than a complaint.

If we recognise the short-comings of the end-user it is easier to provide them with the solution they NEED, not necessarily the solution they WANT.

It does erk me to no end when a user comes to me with a solution they want that is all wrong instead of coming to me with a problem. No, I will not set it up so 20 people across our WAN can print to your printer. No, I will not purchase 20 copies of AutoCad because people need to VIEW your documents. But I will find a solution for each.

by happyface

I started life in the computer field hating Macintosh computers, the shop I worked at had an IBM franchise and we hated!!! all things Mac's. Then I volunteered at a school that had only Mac's, My Wife was a teacher there and she kept asking about computers (Mac's) and so I had to sit down and learn how to run the thing! anyway to make a lone boring story shorter, I think that when you have a computer system, it's important to look at what's install, what people know and go from there! If it's mac's then just deal with it, the same thing with Windows system, Linux, etc... I am teaching my kids to work in a cross platform environment at home and not show any prejedice towards any systems they cross during there computer lifetime!

by apotheon

Until MacOS X, there just wasn't anything about MacOS that had enough value to me to bother with its drawbacks. Since the advent of MacOS X, the dubious benefits of Windows are beginning to look highly redundant.

It's admirable that you're trying to expose the kids to all the major computing platforms without bias, but you're doing them a disservice as well if you don't expose them to the benefits and detriments involved in each, and I have yet to run across such a run-down that puts Windows on anywhere near equal footing with Linux and MacOS X in terms of technical merits.

by jdclyde

I guess now that I think about it, I don't either.

It is always a matter of shoot the messenger.

And often it is because the top dogs will not finance the needed updates, because they don't understand the need for them.

A new computer for Sally? But she already has a computer. (yeah, a PII 300 with a four gig drive, four megs video, and 64 megs ram)

An upgrade of windows? Don't we already have a copy of Windows 95?

Accountants are the worst for this! I understand that if you spend the money, then you never really made it but at some point it costs more to stay with old technology than to update.

by hal 9000

Is to point out the disadvantages from a tax point of view that P11 300 MHZ is actually costing the company money as well as being unable to write off any of it's value as depreciation at the end of the financial year so it is actually costing you money. Accounts love that as they seem to think that they are saving money by buying a new computer. :)

Failing that there was one guy who backed an excavator over one to kill it. Then had the audacity to walk into the boss office and ask me to fix his computer because it wasn't working anymore. When I got to his office the monitor keyboard & mouse where all there but no box, he told me it was outside as the "Steam Powered Heap of S##T" had finally driven him nuts so with it not working he had taken it outside so he couldn't see it anymore. I walked around looking for the box and then he yelled from his office window over that way. If I didn't almost trip over a bit of the broken front pannel I never would have seen the thing as it had a 40 ton excavator track sitting on top of it. It was a K6 2 300 AMD and for some strange reason I didn't even attempt to fix it. :D

But I had to leave that place for the day as I was laughing way to hard for my own good. ;)

Actually I have on occasions been know to write my own OS's but that was a long time ago and my current customers seem unwilling to wait while I write them a custom one. :p

Col ]:)

by jmgarvin

I'd also upgrade to Fedora Core 3 and the 2.6.11 kernel. Make sure to do the following:
1) go to rpm.livna.org and get the Nvidia driver(s)
2) Check out:
http://gentoo-wiki.com/HOWTO_Install_and_update_World_Of_Warcraft_with_wine
and
http://forums.gentoo.org/viewtopic-t-246098-postdays-0-postorder-asc-start-0.html?sid=8b7707c9b98f82504047ca1a6888802d

They are both for gentoo, but with a little tweeking the instructions work in any distro.

You should be good to go...

by tony hopkinson

LOL
I can indeed rip out a thousand lines of code and rewrite it. But re-write it in what. Not talking about language pascal, C# etc here. But how to get data from the mouse or keyboard, put a picture of something on the screen. Those functions are provided by the os, in software design terms they are hardware. Indeed unless you write device drivers in windows programming there's no such thing as hardware, it's all aaccessed virtually though drivers, in windows at least.
I can in theory not make any errors, or at least fix the ones I have made, but all the ones in the OS I have to live with just like everyone else.

by hal 9000

All of us have to live with those errors and we are the ones who get the blame when something doesn't work out the way that the end users want.

It never fails to amaze me that the people want M$ Windows and then start complaining that it doesn't work the way that they want so we should fix it. I've yet to hear one customer complain about the attitude that M$ has, it is all the IT guys fault!

Col ]:)