General discussion


Software evaluation methodology

By martin.d.camilleri@magnet ·
We are currently in the process for evaluating an open office solution for our company. We will be building a pilot for evaluation.

Can someone please help me out and tell me if there are any formal or effective methodologies to carry out proper evaluation. We were thinking of using a cut down version of the ISO **26 but we are open for other suggestions

Thank you

This conversation is currently closed to new comments.

Thread display: Collapse - | Expand +

All Comments

Collapse -

Software evaluation methodology

by SteveH0039 In reply to Software evaluation metho ...

I apologize in advance for preaching, but here goes:
An open office solution needs an open office problem statement. Any standardized evaluation criteria will be ineffective for your organization without a concise statement of goals and realistic expectations that have been vetted with as high a level of organizational management as you can manage to pull in.

Solutions don't exist in a vacuum and they cannot be compared objectively except in the framework of providing their solutionto a specific set of 'problems'.

In short: 1) Identify the goals/ expectations/ short-comings you wish to address with this software. Be as specific as possible, encouraging team members to speak to sample documents, processes, etc. that they expect to be 'solved' through this software (Remember that when it's all over, you have to support this s/w and if people had unrealistic expectations, it will be a *real* headache for you).
2) Match s/w features with needs collected above
3) Call their references. Arrange to visit installations and to talk without the salespeople present. Be wary of relationships between vendors and sites that appear 'too close'. You might not get an unbiased story.
4) Don't forget performance. benchmark with other organizations if possible. Feature-rich software can be slow.

I'm not sure this helped and it's certainly not original, but sometimes these points need repeating.

Best of Luck with your project!

Collapse -

Software evaluation methodology

Sorry Steve for the late reply. Thanks for your suggestions which helped greatly. Infact our approach will be very similar to the one you suggested.

I thank you again

Collapse -

Software evaluation methodology

This question was closed by the author

Related Discussions

Related Forums