Discussion Locked

Support for the soon-to-be terminated

0 helpful
121 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

While this hasn't happened to me yet, but I'm guessing
it's only a matter of time. . .

Suppose you're made aware of some (non-tech) staff
member was to be let go within the week. For purposes
of this discussion, we'll go ahead and assume that the
aforementioned staffer has NO IDEA what's to come.
Upper mgmt. has, of course, issued a strict order of
silence regarding the upcoming "event."

Now, say about a day into their final week, the staffer
wants you to walk them through downloading thier
entire mailbox/contact list to thier computer at home.
This presupposes that this is not an unusual request,
and that people from assistants to executives regularly
call for help like this.

What would you do? Saying, "no,"post-termination is
certainly imaginable, but a salesperson's contact list
(for example) would certainly beneficial to them (and
the organization) while they're at home. Noodle on this
for me. I'm leaning toward "go ahead."

Thanks

121 replies

by syadm

The dilemma is brought by the silence thats been ordered from "above".
IMHO the right thing to do in this is to pass this up to those who initially decided to play this dirty.
There is no reason why you should eventually have to tell a lie on their behalf.
Let them do it themselves - they seem good at it.
BR
/Tom

by juanita marquez

I'm in complete agreement. This is why management gets the big bucks, making decisions like this for the underlings, ask them what to do. There is no reason to put YOUR neck on the line. The user can wait long enough for you to get your answer.

by oldefar

I agree - go ahead.

First justification - upper management has issued a strict order of silence, so acting other than normal violates the order. Note that the request is not unusual.

Second justification - the contact list is nothing more than electronic business cards collected by the individual in question. These generally go with an individual when they leave a company for any reason. The same for applies to personal correspondance.

Third justification - sales is often a matter of personal relationships. If the individual has strong personal relations, the company only creates inconvenience by hanging on to the contacts. They will get minimal gain. If he hasn't, the company loses nothing by letting him have his client list.

by tomsal

I have a strong opinion on this matter because its a very real issue I've had to deal with (along with other managers of course) with sales people at the company I work for.

Sales is nothing but contacts and relationships - that's the job. That'swhy good sales people can demand big commission rates.

I'm surprised at the advice previously given, only a very very foolish company wouldn't have non-disclosure / non-compete / privileged information agreements that MUST be signed before the hire of any sales person. We use all three for our sales people (and actually all managers and all MIS/IT employees as well).

When you are a sales person for a company the company you work for owns the client list - despite the fact that you bring in clients to add to that list, that is not your list to use other than according to the terms of any the three forms I mentioned above.

For example our sales people sign a non compete agreement that has effectiveness for 2 years. That means regardless if they are fired or they voluntarily terminate their employment - they may not use our client list within our market area for 2 years.

Once the 2 years is up however, they can open shop accross the street from us and call up any client on the list and we can't do anything about it.

The best action to take is consult management.

by lordinfidel

This is pretty standard stuff. I'm really not sure where the confusion is coming into play here.

I can understand the "personal relationship" aspect of it. But generally that is not the case.

Business looks at it like this. If you work for a company and get a set of leads from your company. And over time you add to that contact base. And then you leave and work for your prior companies competitor. What is stopping you from taking those clients that you gained or were given during your previous employment and pursuing them.

Let's say you started your own company, directly competing against your previous employer. Should you really be able to use the sales contacts you gained while you were there. No, of course not.

Now i'm not saying they should not be allowed personal contacts. I mean, I have contacts with vendors that I maintain regardless of the position I hold. But those vendors have nothing to do with the company making money. Since they are not a client of the company. It is vice-versa.

But if i'm a sales guy and I manage to swing a deal with a major player and I leave the company. Do I have the right to pursue my contact at that company if I am fired or leave, in an effort to steal them away from the original company. No.

As tom said, this is where the no-compete comes into play. Even I had to sign an NDR and Non-Compete.

by cdnitmgr

If the Non-Compete and Non-Disclosures are in place, then what's the problem with satisfying the request - if the request had come up 2 months prior, there wouldn't have been an issue.

Silence has been ordered, so acting on the request in a normal and regular fashion helps to maintain the 'silence'. Any action that is out of the norm (i.e. if the request has been granted to others without delay) could be cause for inquiry by the soon-to-be-terminated employee.

by gsg

In some states, like the one I live in, non-compete agreements are not enforceable. They've tried to enforce them locally, but the state laws prevent non-compete agreements. Now, if someone accepts MONEY to not compete, then they go and compete, then the laws will support the person paying the money to sue and get their money back from the other person. You can get around this by stating in their employment contract that all contacts made during the course of employment are priveleged information, and they can't take any intellectual property with them, etc...

Having said that, I think management should not be giving notice that far in advance. In our shop, we are told as the person is going in for their "exit interview", so that when they come out, all access has been denied.

by understaffed

In particular to non-competing clauses: when viewed by a court, such clauses cannot place undue duress on an individual. The NC clauses must take into account several factors, such as market saturation, geography, locations of other competitors, etc.
To tell an employee of a gas station that he/she could not open up or work at a competing store within a 10-mile radius would be excessive in ANY town, big or small, because it would effectively deny the person the ability to work in that field, with no potential gain to the contractor.
In court, the employee could also argue industry norms.
Frankly, what is the point? How would you know if the employee went to work for a competitor? If he started taking customers to his new shop, maybe the customer had a better relationship with him (and therefore more loyalty) than your company. In that case, you better look long and hard at your business practices. Personally, I would never work for such a place...
To deny an individual the ability to work in his/her field is morally wrong.

by lordinfidel

It has happened to me on several occasions.

It has also happened after the fact. Where I will be asked to retrieve their files for them.

First of all, their contact lists do not belong to them. They belong to the company.

I usually wind up "delaying" their support. Plus when ever I know that someone is going to be let go. I always take the precaution of doing a full back up all of their files and e-mail. Inlcuding their local files.

When they ask me for files after the fact. Itell them sorry and refer them to their supervisor.

If someone asks you for the files before they are let go. Contact your supervisor. If you are the IT mgr then you need to check with their top-level supervisor. If you have HR you can also contact them.

bottom line is, never give the employees files/contacts/e-mail so that they can take it home with them. It is a big violation of corporate policies.

As far as the "contact list being benefecial to them and the company at home". This is not entirely true. Since my employees who need to be mobile and work from home have either laptops or remote access to their files. Both of which can easily be retrieved/turned off.

WebMail (like owa for exchange) allows all employees access to their e-mail and contacts from anywhere.

No one should 'ever' be asking for this. With the exception of mailboxes being full and you are archiving old e-mail for them. But you always keep the archived mail copies. They don't get them.

by oldefar

Policies need to have a basis in business justification and must be enforcable or they are unneccessary barriers to business.

Policy - email contact lists in employee email accounts belong to the company, not the individual.

Business justification - ?

Enforcable - Hmm. I create contacts either from business cards I acquire or correspondance I engage in. I can take business cards in and out of the company premises with no problem and enter them on my own personal mail system at home.I can forward messages to my personal email account to save contact info in correspondance. I can print messages and take paper copies home.
----
I don't see a justified or enforcable policy here.

Can you expand on the justification and enforcement approach you use?

by lordinfidel

The business logic is simple (from a sales point of view)

Contacts made while acting as an agent for the company become the property of the company.

All because you made the contact does not mean it belongs to you.

This is the same as saying "I created custom code for a company project so the code belongs to me".

No, it does'nt. It belongs to the company.

This is actually a long standing legal point. A salesman does not have a right to the contact list, if that contact list wasgenerated during and due to their employment with the company.

However, If, an employee was hired "Because" of their contacts. Then those contacts are exempt from the rule.

It can and will be a gray area. Which is why *YOU*, the sys admin, Should not make the decision. It is up to the business managers to let us know on a case by case basis if it is ok for someone to have files or contacts.

The last thing you ever want is to be stuck in the middle of some legal battle.

by thechas

Follow company policy to the letter!

If there is no 'formal' policy, stall for a bit, and consult with at least your manager.

If you have helped this person, or others do this in the past, not helping now is a certian clue that something is going on.

On the other hand, if this person is in a 'key' position, taking their contacts with them could be a problem for the health of the firm.

At a minimum, you can use this as an opportunity to request that a comprehensive policy on personalcopies of company information be developed.

Chas

by oldefar

I have heard this a number of times while working in large corporations - "On the other hand, if this person is in a 'key' position, taking their contacts with them could be a problem for the health of the firm."

I have yet to understand the statement. If the corporation has been dealing ethically and has a quality product or service, the business relationship will have a strong chance of remaining in place. No matter how key the person is and how strong his personal relationship with the clients is (the root of sales), businesses will not severe ties based only on who they are dealing with.

If this key individual attempts to poison a solid business relationship after leaving, he will only succeed in hurting his own integrity with his contacts.

Likewise, if the company has been dealing improperly with the business clients, the terminated individual will not win any points with his contacts by pointing this out. He was a part of the unethical behavior and will get a good part of the blame and shame when pointing this out.

Holding on to his contacts will at best add inconvenience to the terminated employee. It looks like a petty act by the business to me.

by lordinfidel

It's not our place to make those decisions.

That is just the way it is. I personally can care less if they get the contacts or not.

But I'm not going to just give it to them because they ask for it. That's not my job.

My job is to protect the information. And that's what I am going to do.

If I am asked to do something that will prevent me from protecting the information, it is my duty to state so. Like in the case of forwarding company e-mail to personal e-mail accounts.

Don'tlose sight of what your job function is. It's not to develop corporate business policy. It's to enforce corporate policy. SysAdmins are like cops. We don't write the laws, we just enforce them.

by mrafrohead

For this type of thing. Remember, you stated management says make sure they don't know that it's coming.

Therefore if it's something that you would normally do for an employee, do it for this one. Because this person is still an employee until they have been finished. Just because they are set to be terminated doesn't mean that it's done yet:)

Also, if they're being cut because of the companies financial status and not because of performance reasons, that list could help that person keep afloat for a little while longer until a new job can be attained.

mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

Like I said in my above statements though.

Contact lists do not belong to the employee. Nor do files.

If for some reason this is "status quo" in a company. Do the executives know about it? Has anyone higher up in your chain of command explicitly said that it is ok.

If they have'nt then I would dare to say that it is not a "real" standard practice and they executives probably are not aware of the practice.

The argument can be made that the employee needs the contact list to work at home. But is that 'really' true. And if it is true, then the company needs to supply the employee the means to work at home in such a way that the companies interests are secured.

It is not a good practice to get into the habit of allowing employees to receive company e-mail at adress's other then corporate address'. It is not appropiate for employees to take files home unless prior approval from management is secured.

by oldefar

The email contact list owned by a company? What proprietary information or value added was created by the company on that list? The data itself (names, phone numbers, addresses, etc.) is certainly not owned by the company. My name and email is onmany contact lists in many corporations and not a one of them owns it.

If it were owned by a company, and that company hired someone based on their contacts, that would constitute knowing receiving stolen property when they let that person bring along contact information. Yet many companies recruit sales people based in large measure by the contacts they can bring with them.

I concur with files - internally developed company information remains with the company, not the individuals, unless approved.

As for email - if I were primarily in sales and I worked at a company where I could lose my contacts and personal correspondence upon termination, I would have ALL email sent to my personal email account and request anything that was strictly related to the company I was working at to be resent to my company email address. Sales is about relations, and the bulk of email between sales and clients is relationship, not company, oriented.

by mrafrohead

I am not in Corporate Management so I may be totally out of line here, BUT:

From working in sales I do know this much.

Sales people generally seem to have a list that they take with them of THEIR customers and contacts. They take them with them from job to job. The employee is the one that got that list. Not the company, therefore that would be the property of the employee. Not the company.

I am seeing this as this. Just because I worked for a company and during that time I purchased myself a library of information that pertained to the job that I was doing. It doesn't mean that that is the property of the company. When I leave the job, the library comes with me. And the company gets the finger.

Companies are no longer loyal to the employee's. So why the hell should we be loyal to them???

I honestly find it hard to believe that this discussion is really generating this much traffic.

I would stick with this. If you normally would allow a person to take theirlist home, let this guy take his list with him. After all, upper management doesn't want him to know anythings coming and if you do not give it to him, he may become suspicious.

Mrafrohead

by oldefar

If the contacts created at a company are the sole property of that company, and that company allows or even hires an individual "because" of their contacts, then isn't the company guilty of accepting stolen property based on your long standing legalpoint?

Not the same as creating code, since the code is unique and copyrightable, perhaps even patentable. Information on a contact list is not, although a unique approach to creating such a list might be.

It would be interesting to see how acourt of law would deal with the issue.

Since the scenario in question has a long standing policy of allowing and assisting users to export their email contacts and email, and the only directive is to NOT let on that the employee is to be terminated, I still support following the normal action within the firm. Help him export his contacts and email.

by lordinfidel

Has this standing rule.

At least corporations. Mom and Pop business may be different.

And yes, it is the same thing as code. A salesman is developing leads not for his personal gain but for the company. Therefore they are the property of the company.

99% of the time, those contacts are managed thru some sort of CRM tool. And are generally not even in the employees e-mail list.

I've been thru this several times already. When I first started I thought I was being the nice guy andhelping the guy out. Needless to say I was dead wrong and had my ass chewed out for it. I learned "really quick" that the sales force has no claims to the companies contact list.

Now you mentioned the companies "stealing" the list by hiring someone for their contacts. Like I said, this is part of the exemption.

A good scenario is, Someone is hired because of their relationship with a particular company. This is a very common scenario/practice with corporate sales.

The company though can't tell the salesman that the lead is now theirs not his/hers. But if that same salesman generates leads for the company and enters them into a CRM, and then is fired. The employee does not have the right to those contacts. It is the propertyof the company.

Our job is to protect company information. We can not do that if the information crosses boundries that are out of our control.

There is no fuzzy logic here. Contact your HR and they will be more then happy to expound on why you just don't hand over company files and company e-mail lists to employees who ask for them.

by oldefar

Let?s go back to the scenario first. Employee who will be terminated requests assistance in exporting his email contact list and emails, SOP at this firm. To treat this request special will disclose that a special condition (his eminent termination) exists, and senior management has insisted on no early disclosure.

The fact that the assistance is SOP is a key point. Precedent carries significant weight in US law. The employee can make a strong case for getting his contact list since it has not been an issue for other employees.

The precedent concept can be applied to the traditional approach of hiring sales personnel in part on the strength of their Rolodex. Contact lists are the electronic equivalent of that old paper system, and it traditionally remains with the sales person. A copy of the information is often put into the CRM system.

What about ownership of the information. Some information in the email contact list was given to an individual, not a company. Thingslike home phone numbers, private lines, pagers, and home addresses given to this employee based on his relationships.

Now business cards gathered at events and via other lead generation means are not the same, but the information is not particularly valuable. The C level names can be gathered via subscription at sites like Hoover?s. Without a relationship or a related event, it?s just a cold call.

Since we are talking about an export this scenario, the information stays with the companyas well. How much they can leverage is open to discussion, but they are not losing any information.

by madroxxx

How would that be stealing? They are paying the employee becuase of thier contacts. More like Renting than stealing the contacts.

by oldefar

The oposing position to mine is that the contact list belongs to the company, not the individual.

An employee develops contacts and relationships via employment in most cases. By the oposing logic, these would belong to the previous employer, not the employee. Same position as the company wants to take if the employee later leaves.

Hiring the employee based on his contacts is an attempt to obtain stolen goods. Paying for them does not excuse this, and if there is good reason to believethey were stolen then there is potential for criminal accountability.

Companies can't have it both ways.

by cajonesit

My God:

I cannot believe this! Did this person ask you to assist in shredding evidence about potential corporate mis-dealings (aka the Enron maneuver)? Or was this the electronic equivalent of a request to assist in placing business cards in anenvelope for the employee to carry home?

Come on, now; again, please forgive if you must my indignation, but WHERE IS YOUR HUMANITY? WHAT CORPORATION PAYS EXCLUSIVELY FOR CONTACTS?

I think it's time I retire. My heart's just not into this eCorporate mentality: they'll hire you to proselitize your previous employer then some morally-bankrupt downsizer expects someone else to rob you of YOUR CONTACTS!

Hey, obrian, go with your gut. You know the guy/gal. We don't.

Just don't ignore the fact that you might be wearing those same exit-sandles sometime real-soon-now.

Where's the French Revolution now that we need it?

by irenecm

I'm sure that the person being terminated has some wiff of a clue that it's about to happen. You are right to suggest that one must follow company policy to the letter to avoid the possiblity of being sued for whatever. You don't want to lose yourjob and get involved in some legal hassle that will follow you just for being nice. Some companies don't tell people until 4:30 on Friday that they're gone and then they have security stand at their desk as the pack up to leave. That's company policy. Other places give you a few days and a cake!? You have to go with the corporate climate.

by oldefar

a similar approach was taken following WWII at the Nuremburg war crimes trials. Just following orders.

A similar approach was used at Enron when improper accounting practices were followed and then documents were destroyed.

In fact, we are all responsible for our actions in the end. During my time with the USAF I went through a variety of training sessions where it was made clear - I was responsible if I failed to follow lawful orders or followed unlawful orders.

by thechas

One of the problems that our information age has brought about is the ability of a single user to damage the corporate network and files.

Or, easily copy critical company information.

As stated in other posts here, it is becoming S.O.P. to inform a terminated employee at 4:30PM on Friday, hold them in a conference room or office until there co-workers have left, and if they are LUCKY, allow them to claim their personal items under careful watch.

There have just been too many instances of employees causing damage and stealing company property for any 'prudent' corporation to continue the old practice of advance notice.

Humanity aside, the company officers are required to do what is in the best interest of the stock holders, not the employees.

Chas

by mrafrohead

Isn't it funny how you waive a few dollars around the room and all of the sudden humanity flies right out the fr33kin door???

I can't believe how easily people sell out to the almighty dollar.

Chas you hit it on the nose though. It's the stock holders that matter. Screw the employee's that make the company what it is. The stock holders don't do shit for a company really other than foot an initial bill. Then they just reap the rewards of the hard working employees that get crapped on. All the while removing our benefits. Slowly taking away our rights and abilities to do our jobs effectively. Then they complain because they aren't making enough money because we aren't putting in enough output because they thought it would help the bottom line to lay off half the crew and then double the workload.

After all. What would a company be if it weren't for us worthless pisson employees???

Mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

Where the saleperson wanted to have all of their company e-mail sent to their personal e-mail address.

Their reasoning was so that they could get the e-mail at their home and manage their contacts.

The executives said no way, because they would then have no way to manage the employee. They would not be able to monitor the correspondence.

They would not be able to see the contact information in CRM. The contact would then start sending e-mail to the employees personal address instead of to the corporate address.

They subsequently said no.

Now I 'have', upon authorization from the appropiate executive, given individuals exported copies of their e-mail and contact lists.

That is the jist of it. You need authorization before doing it. Just don't take the employees word for it. Salesman are used to lying and manipulation. They will use their skills to try to get you to do what they want.

I am not being cold hearted. But is your job really worth being the 'nice guy'.

IT does not have a pretty job when people get fired. When it happens we have to detach ourselves from that person and do what the company pays us to do. Safeguard their information.

Regardless if the employee is a friend of yours or not. I say, if you don't have a spine and you can't do your job, then get out of IT.

Our job is not to freely give anything to anyone who asks for it. You have to act like a well secured OS. You only get the information if you have explicit rights to it and it can only be used within the constraints of the system.

by oldefar

The non-disclosure prevents the signers from disclosing certain information. A list of clients, contracts, terms, etc. would fall into this. My email contact list does not, unless I disclose it in violation of a non-disclosure.

A non-compete agreement prevents me from taking or trying to take business from the company I signed it with. It does not prevent me from doing different business based on relationships I may have developed while at that company. A Nortel rep going to Cisco and pursuing his former client base is violating a non-compete. Even going to Cisco probably violates his non-compete. Going to KPMG and selling business consulting based on his relationships developed selling for Nortel would not violate the non-compete.

by tomsal

...meaning your assumptions, while I see what you are saying, are simply that -- assumptions on what language is in the ND and NC.

Here I'll tell you that the language in our NC excludes using ANY client information obtained while under the employ of this company for a specified period of time. Meaning it doesn't matter if you are talking email addresses, phone numbers, file folder documents, etc. - its all forbidden. If the sales person doesn't like what they read in the contract, they don't have to sign but then we won't hire them either. Its that simple.

One thing great (or bad I guess depending on your perspective) about America is that unless your employer breaks federal laws (like copyright violations, violates civil rights, fair labor laws, etc.) they can pretty much manage/run their business any way THEY feel like it. They can also write their contracts anyway THEY feel like it (barring that again, it violates no pre-existing laws or tramples on one's civil rights).

So to say you can do this or that regardless of signing your a ND or NC *may* be true for the one YOU signed by your company. But here, you'd get sued by our company if you signed it and acted in the manner you described with your contacts.

PS. LordInfidel - you are right, I fail to see the complexity of this issue. To me its clear as daylight.

;)

by lordinfidel

I checked with legal, HR and some of my executives.

They all said the same thing. The employee has no rights to the client list.

They did make some concessions. Basically the concession was that they executives can make a case by case decision on whether or not to allow the employee to have the list/files. It is their discretion.

They also added that unless there was a prior arrangement between the employee and the company at the time of hiring, that all bets are off. Anything thatis placed on the corporate system is property of the corporation.

by oldefar

In context of the original scenario, the decision was made some time before when it became SOP to assist folks export their email contacts.

Assisting this individual falls right in line with your position. Not developing policy, but enforcing policy.

by mrafrohead

But companies usually TAKE it both ways. They don't care either way as long as it works in their favor.

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

Quote From LordInfidel:
"SysAdmins are like cops. We don't write the laws, we just enforce them."

And in this case the law from the uppers was to make sure the firee doesn't know that it's coming. Therefore, giving him his list would also fallinto enforcing the uppers decision. Then when he does get fired, he'll never have known it was coming.

Mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

It appears that everyone is taking the liberty into thinking that the original poster's (whom oddly enough we have not seen yet) companies higher ups condone or are even aware of the practice.

I just can't buy that this is a "standard practice".It may be that he is just used to people asking him for stuff and he just does it for them. I just don't buy that a corporate company would just allow this to blindly happen w/o any controls in place.

It's just beyond any sane comprehensible logic. It goes against everything that is corporate.

You just don't give out that information. Regardless.

He could of just said, I've been told by my boss that I need to check with him now for these requests.

The person would not know any different because the next day he was going to get fired anyways.

Not like he can check after the fact.

by drew17

And telling him "let's get together next week when I've got some free time..." can solve the IT person's problem, too.

by mrafrohead

Something that I just thought of.

It's an example, probably a bad one, but an example.

You have your tools that you use when you're at work. You have spent a lot of time finding them and implementing them. Usually on your own time. These tools are of course freeware utilities that you have gotten from the net to do various tasks. Like, hack a BIOS for the auditor who can never seem to remember the password that he set. And to get yourself into the Windoze 2000 box that another chucklehead locked himself out of because he was having password problems also...

So, you quit your job. Is the company entitled to these tools or do you get them???

That's right, the company gets the finger and you leave with your tools.

Those tools are the salesmans business card.

I know that I'm not as well spoken as the rest of you, but I hope that you are getting my point and that it's coming across properly. Please let me know if this makes sense.

Mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

This is a gray area.

Why?

The company did not create the tools so they can not realistically own them.

However, they do own the system they are on. So the real question is, If I am forced out of the company, do I have the right to request or demand the files off of my system.

The answer is no. I do not have the right to access those files anymore. (This is one of the reasons why I own my laptop and all of the software on it, the other is that it is easier when I go to other jobs to know the system I am running)

Like I have said before. It all boils down to ownership. If the information is on the systems that the company owns. Then said information belongs to the company.

There are very little ways around this, and the law does support the companies right to their claims.

We may not like it or even agree with it. But we have to live with it and enforce it.

by mallardtooxx

But the difference her is that the tools you use don't sell you widgets and wedges at dicount prices nor do they buy your flugelscribers and coolioses and only yours. See that is why we as IT people are different. Sales People live and die buy a different code than we do and thus have different rules. Don't worry MrfroHead you're doin fine.

by mrafrohead

But it does kind of fall into this discussion. So if y'all don't mind, I think we should include it into this discussion.

That's partly where a lot of the emotion that this thread is producing in me comes from.

I remember when I was growing up (and I'm only 25 now, so it's not that long ago) hearing about how if you put in your twenty years with a company and you work really hard and take care of them. That in return they will take care of you. You get great bonuses during Christmas, you get a pension and retirement.

Now what do you get??? You get escorted out by security the day before you retire because the company fabricated some BS plot that you did something wrong that you didn't do so that they can forfeit giving you what you worked your whole LIFE for!!!!! That's right folks, your LIFE!

I think it's f***ed up that you spend more time at work than you get to be at home with your family and friends. And now the companies treat you like this.

I can't imagine being the guy who started this post. I would hate to have that type of information looming in my head. Knowing that this is going to happen. I remember once I was in that type of position. Management wanted me to search someones computer looking for stuff that didn't belong there. They put it on ME to make the call to keep/fire the person. I have a non management/piss on position for a reason. I don't like to make those types of calls.

I guess that's why I think that the salesman shouldhave gotten his list. Out of loyalty to other people. Because I'll bet ya my left nut that the company when it comes down to it. They won't be loyal to our friend here that started this post. In the Corporate world we're all just numbers. And to "them" it's easier to adjust the numbers than to think of the results that will happen to THE NUMBER.

mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

And why.

What we do as sys admins or help desk support or whatever; The way we handle these types of requests can have impact on the company.

While I would like to believe that I have complete autonomy in my decision making about the support I allow to be given. I know that is not true.

I know that there are potential rammifications on the business side that I may not be aware of.

These types of requests *MUST* be cleared thru business mgmt first. Not IT mgmt. They are 2 seperate things.

What you and I may think of as innocent, may not be.

Obviously in your case you purchased a list from your own pocket. Obviously the contacts are yours. If the company paid for them, then they are the companies.

The company hires a saleguy to work for them. Any contacts generated during that tenure "because" of their employment with the company, technically belong to the company. There is no way around that fact.

In fact, any information put onto any company system, automatically by default becomes the property of the company. You have no rights to that information once it is put onto a company owned system.

Regarless of company loyalty and all of the emotions that go into that. The pure and simple fact is that it is not yours nor mine's place to make the decision to export their contacts.

It's is business mgmt's decision.

by mrafrohead

Another quote from LordInfidel:
"Regarless of company loyalty and all of the emotions that go into that. The pure and simple fact is that it is not yours nor mine's place to make the decision to export their contacts.

It's is business mgmt's decision."

I really hate to say it. But when you put it in this context right up there... I have to say that you're right. Although I still don't agree with it, it is right.

But putting right and wrong aside. The moral aspect comes to play. If I was the poster. I would deeply consider the quote above. I would just give the guy his list. Not say a word and start to look for a new job. I wouldn't want to be in that type of position and I would be resentful for being put there... Not to mention, that sales guy could be you in a few weeks and I wouldn't want that. Not to mention not giving him that list could give him a harder time to get on his feet. There is no job in the world worth the weight of having to live with that.

Mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

I could never work in sales. I have too much respect for myself.

Unfortunatley, in the corp world, this is what we have to deal with. I'm not going to go look for a new job because of it.

Don't get me wrong, I feel for the guy. But again, it's not my decision. And we all know by now that I am not one to abide by all of the rules. But when it comes to giving away corporate information I look at it like this.

They hire me to protect and safeguard their inormation. If I feel that Ican not do that, then I need to get out of IT and security.

Whether we like it or not, We have an obligation to our employers to enforce policy. Regardless of how our feelings are about that policy.

We can object to the policy. Obviously if they want me to do something illegal I won't do it. But there is nothing here that is illegal or even immoral.

Don't let the guy's in sales snowball you. They are not your friends. They will kiss ass and suck up to anyone who they think will serve their purpose. That's why they are in sales.
I'm not about to lose my job over one of them.

by lordinfidel

This dicsussion, while rarely is talked about, is essential.

At the core of the discussion is the legal issue.
Not just who owns the list. But who is the owner of the system that the list is on.

An article that I would refer to is
http://www.whitehatadvisory.com/articles/020628-corpemail.html

It makes it clear that employees need to verify first the acceptable use policy of corporate machines. If the salesman has gathered personal contacts and placed them on a corporate e-mail system. He no longer has exclusive rights to them. Nor does he have the right to be able to take them with him/her.

Is it fair? That is not for us to decide. We have to acknowledge and accept that our rule is no absolute in all cases. That we have to abide by and enforce the acceptable use policies set out by the company we work for.

If your company has a written policy that says "Anyone can have unrestricted access to files and e-mail upon request" Then there is your answer.

But an "Implied" rule is no rule at all. And instead of taking the liberty and creating potential problems. A little delay tactic so that you can check and verify with upper mgmt may be in order.

There may have been a reason they did not want them to know they were being fired. Maybe it was because they did not want them to delete files or take information they were not supposed to have.

If you are not privy to the business decisions, take over step your boundries by making them.

by oldefar

I checked out the article.

The core issue seems to be one of ethics versus legality.

On the legal side, the article is correct that ever more companies are establishing use policies over their systems. However, policy is not law, and the USsystem is based on precedents. Unless there is a specific policy covering access and rights, the SOP will likely carry greater weight. As you state, an implied rule is no rule at all. This cuts both ways.

On the ethics side, we see individualslooking at situations from a human perspective versus a corporate perspective. An interesting dilemma. Studies have shown that individuals will act in ways they find immoral or unethical when they feel their action is directed by a higher authority - the corporate perspective. I am thinking of the study done in the 50's with volunteers giving electric shocks that they believed were painful or even lethal because the authority directed it.

I believe in questioning all policy that I don't understand or feel is wrong. Yes, this has had some career limiting effects. I sleep nights, however. Corporations have no special insight into common sense, ethical behavior, or moral directive.

by srisner

I'm confused as to why this order would be given so far in advance. Normally its a secret in the back room until such time for execution (forgive the pun) Could it be a "test" by management to see how far and which employees could be trusted? In the article you stated you were "made aware" then stated "Upper mgmt. has, of course, issued a strict order of
silence". It seems this silence has already been broken by the very people who are ordering it.

I've always disliked the sudden layoff approach by Management. To quote another "it is inhumane". Sensitive communication can lighten an otherwise burdensome task for both parties especially in a no fault situation.

I'd honor the standard request, why draw resentment?

by dave4e2open

Had a discussion with a peer on this;
Let's say your company sends you for training on some new technology or methodology. Hopefully you apply it on the job.
Now you also do some side work at home in an unrelated private venture. Say you use what you have learned in the training class for your personal gain. Did you do something legally or morally wrong?

by lordinfidel

If the company sends you to training, that knoweldge is yours. The company though expects you to use that training on the job.

Now this is where are gray areas come into play. If the training in question was for a propietary piece of software that the company developed and I went out on my own and used it. Then yes, I did something that is legally wrong.

But, if let's say I was sent to Chekpoints FW-1 training so that I can better administer the companies firewall. Well the knowledge I gain there is not something they gave me directly. I had to work to learn the information. And unless I have a prior written agreement stating that I can not do side projects. If I build a firewall for someone else or personally, I can use the knowledge I learned in the training session.

That's just the way IT works.

But if they paid for my books, then if I leave I am not entitled to them. (Advice- Never let the company pay for books, It's tempting I know, But break down and spend thecash on them, you will thank me in the longrun)

Lawyers actually sue each other all of the time over this same issue. It is not just limited to sales. If a lawyer leaves a firm and attempts to take the clients that were obtained due to their employment with the firm. The firm will sue them over it. Somehow even lawyers will use ethicisity to benefit them.

by mallardtooxx

and I must say that you guys/gals are all making valid points and counter points. It is true when a business machine is used to garner information it is no longer the property of the user but of the company. It is also true that when an employee is about to be terminated the Mngmt is the final responsible party. However I must say that your company is not too graceful in this matter. Do you honestly think this guy has no IDea? I would bet he is better informed on this matter than you are. He is a salesman which has been made abundantly clear here. He has made his living by testing the wind and telling the tides, he can smell blood, especially if it is his own, so don't beat yourself up. Someone prolly tipped him off and he is trying to get his ducks in a row. If you are not obligated to give him the info then do not. If you feel that you should then do but bear in mind that the company that pays your check will someday figure out he got his contact list....I say CYOA that is the Call of the Business Wild.

by mrafrohead

As have I.

And I think that I have finally been able to make a very pertinent life change due to this particular discussion.

I think that this was the kick in the butt that I needed to get myself a new job as I actually hate the one I currently am in. It just sucks. Just never had the initiative to do anything about it. And I figure that this discussion has proved to me what I already knew but didn't want to admit. The Corporate world is shit. I no longer want to be a part of it. I think that it's time for me to either start my own place or find a small business to work for. Where they VALUE their employees as well as their customers.

I think I also figured another thing out. I don't recall the name of the poster, but the person that basically stated: What are they waiting for???

Maybe that's what bugged me so much about this thread. If you know you're going to fire someone. Just cut the damned cord and let them fall. Don't let them just hang there in mid air waiting. Talk about being shoddy, cheap and disrespectful. But then again, that falls into the Corporate mold eh???

Newho - to ALL who have contributed to this discussion. I would truly like to thank each and every one of you. Hopefully you guys have helped the person who started this thread, but you definately helped me:)

Mrafrohead

by thechas

I can't site the exact case law, but your work product done for the company is the property of the company.

Yes, most sales people keep a list of clients. However, they are at risk of legal action if they court clients of their former employer for the same goods and services for another company 'if' the former employer can show that the sales person found that client while employed by them.

Likewise, ALL creative output be it programs or designs are technically the property of your employer unless you have a specific written contract that states otherwise.

If someone in IT was specifically told that an employee was soon to be terminated, the ONLY logic in informing IT was so that they could help prevent the employee from taking (or deleteing) important data and contacts.

Like it or not, it is becomming more common for a terminated employee to have HR or security watch over them as they empty their office.
Worse, some companies call the employee on Sunday night, and tellthem not to show up on Monday.
Then, HR or their manager selects what they will allow the employee to have from their work area and ships it to them freight collect.

Chas

by lordinfidel

In the Information Systems, Policies and Procedures Manual (a yearly publication).

In the terminiating employees section, it says that the "employees personal belongings will be packed up and shipped to the persons home". Which I infer to not allowing the employee access to their desk.

I'm not a big fan of that. Especially if I got the axe. Since 99% of the books and tools in the NOC are my personal belongings. (i keep my office in the NOC, i'm not a big fan of the cubicle world)

Iagree with the alerting IT could mean only 1 thing. Because when it happens in the company I work for and those in the past, it all meant the same thing. Back up the persons data. Monitor their actions. Shutdown their system remotely when they are called into HR. Do not give them any files.

Moral standards aside. This is part of the job I was hired to do. In line with the infamous words,
"If you can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen".

If you don't like being the bad guy, youdon't have a real place in Corporate Network Operations and Security.

by david500

is that the business decision makers are playing dirty. If they have already decided to fire someone, they should just be done with it. What are they waiting for? Maybe they will withhold firing the person if business needs at the moment dictate otherwise?

If, indeed, the worker has no idea this is coming, then this kind of data backup is "routine". Routine support should be provided.

David

by oldefar

A common mistake in corporate security is the approach that everything is secret. From an IT perspective, that makes the job easier - lock down everything. However, its a poor approach.

I speak from my military service where I was involved withsecurity. There were 5 clearly defined levels. First was unclassified. Next was confidential, followed by secret, and then top secret. Each had clearly defined parameters. When in doubt, the parameters were used, not an arbitrary approach of making it classified. A document carried the highest classification of the data within. However, it was common for pages in a secret or top secret document to carry the notation "this page is unclassified".

For example, part of the job was routinemaintenance of equipment, what we referred to as "once around tightly and brightly" since it dealt with knobs, mountings, and indicator lights. This was not classified information, but was included in the aircraft forms which did carry a security classification.

Take this to the issue of email contacts. The information in the contacts format is typically public information. Information that is not public is typically information provided by an individual to another individual. Even in the event that company proprietary information was entered, the extract could exclude this by the choice of fields.

I am not against policy, security, or companies making money. I am against arbitrary policy that cannot be supported by reference toobjectives.

Regarding sales - no one works without sales. I include goverment employees, since goverment has sold us a bill of goods so often. :)

by mallardtooxx

Lorfd is right, if the company is footing the bill on non pro stuff Windows certs for instance then no they have no recourse if you consult on the side. However, if you go to a competitor and consult them on a matter then you will most likely be in breach. The problem with your personal knowledge is (from a corporate standpoint) there is no true gauge to what you do and do not know. And Lord is right NEVER EVER let the company pick up books, or materials, even tuition reimbursment makes me just a little leery. IT is an everchanging field, if you pitch a tent at one place just be sure they are gonna be around for a while and you are gonna really REALLY like working there.
I don't think the matter is so grey though, I think what you do on your own time is your business, but if you are going to hurt MY business by what you are doing then there is a problem. Unfortunatly most Corps. do not make their contracts in plain english anymore so sometimes the water getss pretty muddy.
Good job on this one lordinfidel you have been all over this thread since post one!

by oldefar

Corporate leaders do not act in a vacum. The culture, the policies, and the procedures exist because the workers allow them to exist. Each time any of us compromise our principals or betray our beliefs in the name of "corporate policy" we are giving tactic approval to that environment.

What if all the workers IT workers said no to layoffs while senior management continued to receive their compensation packages? What if the workforce insisted on ethical behavior?

The flip side of the golden rule is to expect others to treat you as you have treated them. There is a reason corporations worry about what havoc current and former employees may take.

Congratulations for having the courage to stand by your principals. Best of luck.

by jkaras

Both Oldfear and Mrafrohead hit the nail on the head. Compassion and morality is all that is missing in our corporate world. Being new to the "industry" has made me see things a bit differently, not that good ol' retail was much better, but the gameisn't fun if the deck is stacked in someone else's favor. I stayed away from this discussion to witness reactions and can say I see wisdom in all points of view. However, if the company is to fire someone, it should of been done at the point of decision, and not awaiting a possible profit to come in from said employee. That's just wrong, and we as employees cower in the corners hoping that the axe doesnt arch in such a way that we too get chopped. In every job I've been in require CYA, and regret when I'm to afraid to speak mind (lost 1 job due to my mouth)The only consession I can give to the corp is maybe they are waiting for the holiday's to pass and are showing some consideration ( I suspect mostly to avoid neg backlash to current employee moral that ruins workplace) I remember a story an old man told me once that the people of our nation refused to pay taxes once, long ago that brought the nation to it's knees forcing the gov to listen to the people it make it fair. I dunno if itwas a lie/moral story, but took the point, maybe we as individuals might one day do the same to protect everyone rather than run afraid, we the people give management and the rich power by our hard work and money that pumps the life blood into our country. Good journey Fro!!

by weegeordie

I do not believe that it is in the best interest of the soon-to-be-unemployed for the corporation to pull the plug as soon as the decision is made. There is more to termination than 'There is the door'. Severance, pension and benefits all have to beconsidered. Being terminated is a stressfull process, (it has happened to me 3 times in the past few years), and it is a great help to know up front where you stand financially.

by syadm

No matter how many courses your employer throws at you it is still you alone that do the learning - a job done in response to the course throwed at you.
If you leave your position and ends up at anoter employer in the same line of business then youmay have use of the stuff you learned at the course. Thats just recycling.
Can anyone who had more than one employer honestly say that he/she did not have use of anything learned at the first employer while working for another?

BR
/Tom

by oldefar

made by the corporate lawyers. In the US, laws are open to interpretation and change. Of course there is risk involved with following one?s principals rather than current law. Americans opposed to British law interpretation faced charges of treason had the War of Independence failed. Early abolitionists faced fines and prison prior to the Civil War. O?Brien might never have raised his question if anti Irish statues had remained law. Union organizers were once prosecuted for their efforts under then existing laws. Segregation was the law in much of the South into the 1960?s. Corporations had no responsibility for environmental damage they caused until the 1970?s. Not so long ago, attempts to ban smoking from almost anywhere failed. Some non compete contracts have been struck down when they effectively prevented a worker from holding a job in his career field. Enron and WorldCom executives had corporate lawyers supporting their actions. Changes occur when people of principalrefuse to compromise their beliefs, or when the general public finally gets fed up.

by lindam

Would you like it if someone denied you basic technical information that is SOP in your company, even if it were widely known that this was your final week of employment? I wouldn't and I think that basic tech support like this should be offered regardless of extenuating circumstances. It's still unclear to me why the IT dept knows of the termination a week prior to the staffer, and yet there were no firm constrictions on any tech support to be offered. Odd. And to those others here who aresupposing this staff is in Sales, then read again. It never said that in the first place, this thread just got off track with assumptions.

by oldefar

Linda, you are right. This is a hypothetical situation (says so up front). The sales tangent comes from the reference the contact list would benefit a salesperson (for example).

by lordinfidel

It does not matter if this person was in sales or not.

The deepest core of this discussion was "Does an employee, regardless of position, have any rights to the information that they place on corporate systems"

I contend that the answer to this is no.

But then again, I also work in a corporate enviroment and have to follow and enforce the legal guidelines of corporate information security.

Was it bad practice for this company to allow it's employees unrestricted exportation of e-mail, contacts and files. Absolutley.

The only logical reason for IT to know of a termination is so that we can oversee that employees data use. This is routine in the corporate world. Depending on the employee will depend on the precautions I take to safeguard the companies data.

It does not matter if this employee is a developer, in sales, or the receptionist. Personal data, once put on a corporate system/network, is no longer personal. As long as in the employee handbook it is clearlystated that corporate systems are to be used for official business only. The company is well protected in restricting removal of data.

by thechas

Linda,

Much as I would personally like to follow your principle of "Do Unto Others", it no longer functions in our corporate cultures.

I am in full agreement with LordInfidel that the ONLY reason to inform IT that an employee is to be terminated is to monitor and restrict their network usage.

As I have stated elsewhere in this thread, gone are the days of giving an employee advance notice of termination.
Also gone is any semblance of decency to that employee when the termination happens.

Most employeers now escort the terminated employee from the premises. If they are lucky, they are allowed to gather their personal belongings themselves. Alebit under the watchful gaze of a manager, HR, or security.

It is sad but true thatyou can no longer trust your staff to react in a rational manner when they are terminated.

Chas

by jkaras

I agree with you Chas, it's quite sad to treat someone like that so not to upset morale at work. It couldnt get more cowardly or disrepectful if they tried..... on second thought they might bring back the funny manager armature (from old movies and classic cartoons)that opens the trap door under your chair and drops you into a pit or garbage dump. I'm actually lobbying for actual video of the total mental breakdown of the reaction to being terminated called "Most Embarrassing moments at Work" to be played in the breakroom on continous loop or pitch the idea to Fox. Whadda think? I got a winner?

by thechas

Perhaps I'm a bit jaded here.

My previous employeer was essentially a sole propriertership, run by a paranoid meglamaniac.

We started doing a head count every Monday, as that was the only way to find out who was let go the previous Friday.

They even started calling employees at home on Sunday evening, and told them not to come in on Monday.

Everyone who is left there, is simply waiting for there turn, or for the place to fold.

Chas

by road-dog

that stockholders do nothing but wait for dividend checks to arrive after purchasing stock.

This is entirely not true. It is common knowledge that the stockholders also incur risk from their investments. In the current economic environment it is easy to find shareholders that own stocks that are presently trading well below their buy in price. This constitutes a net loss to the individual stockholders, retirement plans, and insurance companies investing.

Company's stock value is subject to many factors beyond their control, such as petroleum prices, stock market hysteria, interest rates, terrorism, and numerous others. This being the case, you are assigning blame unfairly. Everybody is taking a hit right now.

Your take on the shareholders screwing the employees is an outright fallacy. Start your own company and take it public. You will see the entire situation in a different light.

by road-dog

"When ex-employees attack"

The show could give a $5,000 prize for the best look of shock and horror for the week's installment. Boxes of Pasta-roni to the runners up.

If you think that you might be becoming a contestant, Update that resume and print plenty of copies while you still have access to that color laserjet. Forward all information to your home email account. Practice making veins stick out in your forehead and prepare a speech about your 2002 Explorer lease payment. You could be a winner!

by lanman469

I have been in this situation. During layoffs and firings the IT staff typically knows first. The IT staff should be aware of the company policy regarding taking company information off site, which e-mail and contact lists stored on company equipment is. The IT staffer should tell the user. " am working on a really big issue right now. Can I get back to you in an hour". And immediatley go to his/her suppervisor and let them handle it.

by jimk8609

There has many times this has happened to me. If management would work with IT, this can be minimized. The other thing is that IT needs to prove that they can be tight lipped, even if it is a friend. You need to be professional.

by le.huey

I would go ahead and perform the request. Here's my reason... the soon-to-be terminated is still an employee of the company, and therefore still have the "Privileges" as an employee, and this request is not abnormal, lots of people have asked of it. Let's just side track for a second here... let's suppose it's not an IT issue but it's a health insurance issue... should the company deny or reject the request because of employee is a soon-to-be terminated?

by mrafrohead

"The other thing is that IT needs to prove that they can be tight lipped, even if it is a friend. You need to be professional."

You will need to define your definition of "friend". Because to me. A real friend is hard to come across. And it's hella easier to find a new job before a new friend. When it's between your job and a friend, tell your work to piss off and keep your friend.

Mrafrohead

by weegeordie

You have no choice in this scenario but to go ahead. It is assumed that the company has processes in place to ensure that copies of all important information are maintained in corporate systems, (backups if nothing else). If you are seriously concerned that there is an exposure to the company then advise your manager of the request before you complete it.

by le.huey

I would go ahead and perform the request. Here's my reason... the soon-to-be terminated is still an employee of the company, and therefore still have the "Privileges" as an employee, and this request is not abnormal, lots of people have asked of it.Let's just side track for a second here... let's suppose it's not an IT issue but it's a health insurance issue... should the company deny or reject the request because of employee is a soon-to-be terminated?

by silverback

Management has its primary responsibility to the stockholders--assuming it's a large enough company to have stock. If it's a small business, then duties are a bit more blurred. The business owner or manager has responsibility to himself, his/her partners, their families, as well as to his employees.

Where the manager/owner/operator earns his take-home is in balancing the health of his business against the welfare of his employees. Throughout this entire discussion, you've vented a lot of hostility toward management--and, I'm not going to pretend that a lot of them don't deserve some hostility thrown their way--but, there are a lot of good, responsible, charitable managers/owners/operators out there who don't deserve to be painted with the same brush that you've used so broadly on ALL managers.

In this particular instance, I think management DOES deserve a brickbat for the short-notice lay-off. However, we're not given any information about severance package, separation benefits, or anything of the sort. News of a layoff is unpleasant whenever it happens--and, I think it might be easier on everyone involved if the employee were given two weeks pay and told to clean out his desk, rather than being told of the layoff and then having to hang around and try to be productive for two weeks.

BTW--I'd handle the situation by delaying. That way, there's no deception, no flaunting policy, no breaking confidences. I'm sure there's not a one of us who can't legitimately claim that we're up to our eyeballs, can I help you with this next week???

by jwmort

I would simply tell them I am swamped right now, I'll get to you as soon as I can. I would then ask management if it was alright with them if this task was performed.

by mc_user

Friday morning I was working as always. I came back from lunch to find my boss at my desk. You can figure out the rest. The split was because the company was losing money and they were letting a lot of people go.

Policy is that information on the computer was made for the company, and stays on company equipment. I was told that if I wanted to I could set up a meeting with tech support and we could go through my files together and copy over anything to CD that was my personal property. Otherwise it stays.

by altairpdx

This situation highlights the need for clearly defined policies.

I would go ahead and do it, following this logic and assumptions:

First ? This is an established practice. If the same employee had approached you a week earlier, there would have been no doubt as to what action you?d have taken.

Second ? You?ve been asked to keep silent about the event, and sometimes our actions speak louder than our words. I?ve seen situations where people were treated differently, and they figured out what was up ? they then feel more betrayed than they might have felt otherwise.

Third ? There doesn't appear to be any policy in place to recover the data you have presumably helped other staffers download to their computers. If someone else approaches you for the same help, you?d presumably help him out; if that person were terminated next week, what would you do?

I think this highlights the need to have clearly defined policies and procedures in place. These policies would tell you not only how to react to this situation, but how to handle all the situation with all the other staffers? data, should they leave your company as well.

by mis

I have seen situations where this was allowed on a normal basis, but one instance resulted in an assault on company accounts and contacts post termination. Don't do it. Try to stall, set an appointment for after date of termination, get out of it slyly and go about business. IT regularly deals with sensitive data and issues, and must hold these sacred or risk limiting our functionality. -mis@sens-usa.com

by lordinfidel

I don't want to sound like a a**hole or anything. But this thread has been beat down like the taliban.

Not to mention that it is a month old.

by mallardtooxx

I agree with the lord on this one....let it go, the poor guy was fired 3 weeks ago by the original post....He is prolly happier any way...Let the horse die, we have beat it to death

by davea_in_darwin

As an IT staffer, I really don't think it is your place to make a decision on this. I'd tell the client I'd be happy to download their data, e-mail, etc. for them, but that I would have to have the written permission of their supervisor.

We're not paid to manage clients outside our department, so why should we risk our job and reputation? Let THEIR boss make the decision.

DaveA

by zlitocook

I always keep a back up of the things I have done for the company/customer. Check your contract to be sure what you have done is yours. If you do a migration or system upgrade be sure to document it. Always save any thing you do and document it!
Save the documents the staff of the company you are contracted to on a network share and let them know about it. But save your work to cd so you have some thing to show at the next job interview.

by pesk, mbcs, mcse, mcitp, sts

But the crux of the matter is that information gathered thru' normal working procedure and is stored for the profit of, and on behalf of, the employing company remains the copyright of the company. It remains at the sole discretion of the company asto what information to use and what to discard. Contacts lists are gathered to further the company's profits and as such are sexpected to be stored on the company's own database. It may be part of your job to actually GO OUT and GATHER these contacts. They are not yours to dilly-dally with. I think a "quiet" urgent email/word to upper mgmt requesting help on the matter would not go amiss. Telling the soon-to-be-axed employee that the legal standing of tranferring contact lists and their storageis in question and you'll get back to them ASAP sounds like a good way of buying time.

by plokhooy.1

There are several factors not in your article that make a big difference. The key issue is why is this guy being let go? If it is solely for "corporate savings" and not performance, depriving this employee of his ability to network through his contacts is poor corporate management and unfairly punishes the employee just to allow some executive to collect a bigger bonus. If it is performance related, the employee should already be aware the end is near. Loyality should run both ways and pre-determined dismissals are cruel to the employee and others who may be dependent on him/her. Forget the NS/ND stuff -- the employee had to bring his contacts in and did not have the right to an ND/NS with the company. That's why most don't hold up under legal scrutiny

by sandym

If it's a normal request, why not do it?

What reason would you give for NOT doing it????

I HAVE been in this position and believe me saying no is a big hint, the guy is bound to have picked up some "feeling" that things are not as they should be.

by wade wyss

The correct answer here is to let management decide how to handle this. There can be things that you don't know about regarding that information that the co-worker is asking for. Plead busy and run it up to management with a timeframe for an answer.Make them tell the employee why he/she cannot have this data if that is the decision.

by vpierce

I agree with Wade. Refusing to assist a user could bring about suspicion.

I have implemented the MAC request policy at our company and management has to sign off on any request from a user before I grant it. This takes the pressure off of me and puts it on management's back and boy has my stress level gone down.

by jekoski1

I would not help this person. I would say I was too busy and make an appointment for a later time, after the termination, so if it did not take place then I would do the down load.Most sales types have a list of their clients they carry with them.
J.E. Koski SR. Tech Systech.

by director of resource management

Most organizations consider contact lists created on the job as intellectual property owned by the business entity. This would include client lists, prospect lists, business partner lists, and other similar contact information.

If you have an employment contract or employee handbook, you may find specific wording that instructs the employee to turn over all such information to the company upon termination of employment.

If you plan to act as a "good Samaritan" and help another employeedownload such lists, you are putting your own position in jeopardy. My advice is to find some other way to help, but do not help with this download.

by gmedina888

Follow company policy and allow the process to handle the particulars. If the person being terminated has permission from a person with the proper authority to "download" contacts to their personal system, you're in the clear. Other than that, it's CYA!!! It is NOT your call!

by wthorpe

I have to agree with many on this thread that state using company policy to decide how to best handle this situation. However, what is not clear is how someone found out that this individual was being either terminated or layed off. It is a shame that information of this type gets around so quickly. However, I believe the most prudent thing would be to inform my management of the request to ask for guidance. Barring that guidance and the immediacy of the need for information, I would download the information per policy but would send off a message to management so they are informed of all information this employee currently has on his personal PC.

by Former member

Assumption notwithstanding, the timing of the request and the simpleness of the request - surely co-workers will suggest a workaround if you stall - suggests that the staffer has a feeling something's wrong and is using your response to the request to see if that feeling is justified.

by john.a.jackson

As long as the request is within the range of your normal support responsibilities and you are comfortable that the request is above board, i.e. the associate *really* doesn't know they are about to be canned - what justification can you give for not helping? We're IT Support not shills for HR or marketing.