Discussion Locked

Support for the soon-to-be terminated

0 helpful
121 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

121 replies

by mikeb_11

I agree with helping them out right if there is no policy in place preventing you from helping. I would consider the knowledge of their impending dismissal as irrelevant if you are suppose to keep this knowledge to yourself and act as if they were not going to be fired. Also, if the said person was a friend of mine and their was a policy to not provide this type of assistance, I would offer it to them after hours in the form of a personal training session. In other words, If you have reservations but still feel you should help them, teach them to do it themselves on your own time.

by lglitterhammer

IF: SOP indicates this procedure
THEN: honor the request.

RE: NC and ND
It is the soon-to-be-former employee's responsibility to honor any agreements that he's made w/ the company, not yours.

If a normal request is delayed or put off, you'll risk exposing the up-coming termination, let's be realistic, good salespeople are "people persons" and you're likely to alert them that something is not kosher.

As this is a routine procedure, they probably have a partial list in any case.

Ofcourse, if your company is laying off, you may be next anyway, especially if they're looking for a reason to terminate people.

by ken.w.murphy

This guy has not yet been teminated. He is still an employee. If it has been the practice to assist employees with downloading their address book to their home computer, then do it.

... and then the Judge says "Mr. Terminated tells me that the company would not allow him to do his job - they wouldn't let him load his contact list into his laptop - something that is done for all other salesmen at that company. Mr. SysAdmin, is this true? Consider carefully what you are about to say as this will help me determine if Mr. Terminated was a victim of constructive dismissal."

by darrell scott

Of course, the right answer is, if YOU think such a move would cause YOU trouble, it probably will - don't do it.
An answer that is not so "pat" is, it's a case by case issue. You really have to weigh the risk reward benefits according to eachperson. If you have been officially told by your Manager that an employee is being fired/laid off, it's probably best to tell the manager to "gently remind" that employee, company policy forbids several things, including the downloading of contact lists upon termination. General information, nothing specific that would make you out to be a rat. You are basically protecting the company business that pays you. Something you can remind that person if you are confronted.

I had a good friend that I felt was to be replaced at our work. I heard and saw a few things, but nothing official. I knew/thought he was the type of person that would confront management on the spot if I told him what I thought was impending, but not certain termination. I also thought he would tell management from where the news came, so I did not share my beliefs with him. A tough decision, but I had to protect myself and my family. This person was eventually fired, he started his own business and is betteroff. But I still wonder if I did the right thing.

by ken.w.murphy

... and the judge asks "Did you know that Mr. Terminated was about to loose his job when you suggested that a better time would be next week? Consider carefully what you are about to say as your actions are a determining factor in his constructive dismissal case."

by tnwilliams53

If the employee is in good standing, then when you lay them off, you help them to get their contact list & personal files. If not, then they should have had them back-up at home already. Never before. If they didn't see it coming, then they have not served themselves very well. The un-offical signs are there.

by ken.w.murphy

The corporate policy on this must be clear. There should be nobody downloading contact lists to anybody's home PC. Unfortunately, even if that policy existed, it was not enforced. It became the standard practice for IT to download contact lists.It therefore became standard practice in Marketing for sales reps to use their contact lists at home. If Mr. Terminated can't do that, his sales will suffer and he will be placed at a disadvantage. His lawyer will argue that by witholding the contact list, his client was constructively dismissed and should therefore be awarded this many dollars.

by anne.powel

If you use freeware at work, and want to use it for your own systems, you can always head to the website and get it downloaded at your house.
And if you know what you had to do to implement it at work, it shouldn't be that hard to figure out again later.

by solson9

There should be established guidelines for transfering company information to home computers. Part of the procedure is authorization from the imediate supervisor. All you would have to do is say you will do it when the worker has written authorization from his supervisor.

by qrazydutch

I am a supervisor. I would do everything within the limit of the law to assist this employee. I would also ensure the person assisting did not get the "hit", but I did. It is tough enough to loose people thru sizing (right, down, cap etc), your employees that are left are going to do what?
Help where you can, and forget the "knee-high" people. My folks know that already. You must have a code of ethics posted at work, if not, write one.
Try this:
Our Work Ethics
Be persistent
Work friendly
Soar to excellence
Be professional
Integrity is beyond question
Loyalty is a two way street
Disagreement is not disrespect
Disagree without being disagreeable !
Fix rather than blame? Always commend achievement
Develop the vision to see andthe courage to act
Boss is single point of blame: All praise is passed on!
Confront challenge & conquer adversity

The real issue: Look in your heart, do right and move on.

by tehonea

You need to weigh company policy against the SOP. When in doubt, follow policy if you want to keep your job. If no policy against the practice exists, and you feel it is the "right" thing, go ahead, but CYA. The safest route would be to stall and ask management for an OK.

As to the ND/NC issues raised, that really depends on the situation. My state is a right-to-work state. I have signed such documents in the past, and even consulted with a lawyer on them. Basically, in this state, they are not worth the paper they are printed on. Here, you cannot bar someone from work, and you cannot sign away your rights. These documents are common, but rarely enforced. But I would check the wording and local laws before I ever signed another one.

To obrian - if you are still out there, this was a GREAT topic. Keep-up the good work.

by paulw

My concern here is the reason IT was put in the loop regarding the termination in the first place. It could very well be so that they will know not to let the employee take control of their contact lists etc.

I would have to tell the employee that I'm swamped right now, and check with someone in authority before allowing the transfer to take place.

by don1950

Funny thing about loyalty, the management types always seem to take care of each other with massive bonuses, golden parachutes, etc. many times measured in millions of dollars.

Now the poor piss on at the bottom of the ladder wants his contact list and they want him to starve to death.

My nephew had job where they would pay royalties for the work the employees were resposible for as the profits rolled in. The key here is he was laid off as soon as the product went to the publishers and ofcourse he was no longer an employee so he no longer was in the royalty pool.

The program is selling very well and is making a profit for all those in the management who are still with the company.

by rob hogan

Throughout this discussion many valid points have been brought up and in my opinion they all lead to this:
1. If the employee brought contacts with him they were hired then they should have this information stored away somewhere. Any contacts that were obtained while being employed with the current company belong to that company, the company has paid them to go out and obtain these contacts therefore they should have rights to these contacts.
2. Management should be informed of the request and should determine what should be done. If their decision is not to allow the data to be transferred then the IT department should magically appear to be swamped with high priority tasks and they will "get to it as soon as possible" (a.k.a. Never)

by rob hogan

Management has informed you that the employee is being terminted, they have done this for a reason, so that you can avoid data loss, the best way to CYA as you put it is to let management know of the request and see what they feel is appropriate, since they obviously want to keep the cat in the bag then they can decide what course of action is best, this is the best way to CYA. If they say dont download the data, you can put it off, if they say go ahead, then you can help the user and in the end you still retain your job!

by tui

If you were told my management, then mamagement should direct how you should handle this request. If you were told "thru the grape vine" then, if the request is within company policy, you should honor it.

by gerra

If that is the "normal" company policy, this sounds like good sound advice. However, in this situation, I would think that supervisor approval would go a long way towards eliminating possible problems later on. If the employee is being "let go" for cause, there would be valid reasons for not allowing it. If the employee is simply being laid off or "down-sized, there may be no reason why it could not happen.

One thing is sure, the company policy should be updated to cover that circumstancenow, before this potential situation becomes a real one.

by eire_aine

I must concur with Tom.

IT staff have access to lots of confidential and sensitive information be it on the network or such as this senario. As such you are placed in a position of TRUST and your first responsibility is to the company.

Breaching this trust is unprofessional and unforgivable regardless of whether or not you have signed a confidentiality agreement. I suggest you consider were you to be fired for such a breach, who would then want to put you in another such position of trust.

by techytype

The impending unemployment is irrelevant to the request. So long as the request fits within company policy then support should be forthcoming as per established procedures. The hidden message is one of maintaining company asset integrity. It is not the techies place to write policy on the fly. Advise management of concerns, yes, but making decisions which are not within your authority is far more disruptive.

If management is so clueless as to asset management and yet leaks termination information I would be considering a job change.

by skytraveller

Whatever the business reasons.

Its also a no win situation for you

Pass it to management and you tag yourself as a wimp unwilling to take responsibility.

Refuse to help the employee and it could breach the secrecy order. Probably the best course of action as technically you have said nothing.

Help them and if the employee uses the contact list your neck is on the line - IF management can trace your help unless you have been ordered to help employees do this

In anycase you will hate yourself.

If you get requests for this help regularly you need a printed guide for employees to use.
If such a guide is not allowed NOBODY should have had any help. Distribute the guide before the situation happens so the employee downloads the stuff without your knowing (unless you have to grant access permissions). Include a PROMINENT reference to any NDAs the employee may have signed

If they are sales staff they probably have a laptop and backup discs and keep their twenty best contacts on paper at home so assume the data cannot be controlled.

Whatever I decided if a company put me in that dilemma I would be looking for another job right away- without telling them. After all I could be on the chopping list as well.

by skytraveller

Yes, a memo protects you by laying a paper trail to the real cuplrits.

I would make sure the memo is copied to all top management ( CEO, Director of HR etc) as well as the guy who ordered silence, laying out the situation, explicitly saying he ordered silence, and asking for guidance. This spreads responsibility.

I would also BCC a copy to myself if it were an email and in any case keep a few paper copies outside the company to use when I sued them after they terminated me to cover their tracks.

I would also say that in the absence of a policy decision by a certain date I would give the guy the list in order to follow the order of total silence.

I would finish by saying that unless ordered otherwise in writing I would not give this help to staff members in future without written authorisation from senior management.

IN anycase a company like that deserves all it gets

This discussion is closed to new replies.