Discussion Locked

Tasers, should the Police have them?

0 helpful
109 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In the last few weeks here in Canada, the news services reported on three separate incidents where the Police used tasers to try to control an individual.

incident 1:
RCPM Detatchment at YVR [ Vancouver International Airport ] used pepper spray, batons then tsed a person twice. he died.
http://www.24hrspodcast.com/index.php?id=345
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20071025.wtaser1026/BNStory/National/home

incident 2:
RCMP in Chilliwack BC [ 30 minute drive from YVR ] used a taser on an individual who became combative when they arrived after 911 was called for their assistance in removing him from the business premises, he was hospitalized by the use of the taser.
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2007/11/19/bc-taser.html

incident 3:
Montreal police have said that the man was intoxicated when they stopped him for a traffic violation last Sunday and that he became aggressive when he was questioned.
Officers used a taser to subdue him and he ended up in critical condition in hospital.
He died from the injuries received by the tasing.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20071018.wmonttase1018/BNStory/National

If three separate used of the taser have cause 2 hospitalisations and two deaths, should the police be issued tasers? if so, should they be retrained in the correct usage?

Personally, I say take all the "less lethal" garbage away from them, and tell them to shoot to kill.
if not obeying the police means instant death penalty then it would be assumed that those who don't listen to police instruction are criminals with something to hide from the police. A funeral is cheaper than court and prison costs, it would save huge amounts of taxpayers dollars.

109 replies

by nentech

Should help with immigration

Should they shoot children who don?t do what they are told?
Children always do what they are told

Should help with population growth

There is no reason to fear the police

Lets hope the police never argue they may have to shoot each other
Or the poor person who they have hopelessly confused

Or the poor person running from a building with a bomb in it that is told to halt
Blown to bits but at least they did what they were told by the cops

Good to know the cops are always right

by oz_media

GUilty or innocent, they misused force, and used very poor judgement and no skill or experience at all. These are supposed to be professionals, they acted like a bunch of bouncers at a bar with no idea what to do.

by nentech

Tell it to jaqui
Please repeat the part about cops making mistakes until it sinks in

by ontheropes

I don't think so. We're people not cattle.

There have been too many avoidable deaths and mis-uses of the taser. I've seen video where people are continually tased while they're laying on the ground where they could be easily subdued and hancuffed. What about that "don't tase me bro" dude. From what I saw there were already several officers on him before ho got tased. How many cops does it take to restrain one unarmed college student?

You will submit peacefully or expect to be tased. Doesn't matter if you're 8 or 80. Welcome to the police state comrade. Smile nicely now for the cameras.

by locrian_lyric

Watch "COPS" some time, and you'll see just how many people it takes, especially if someone is hopped up on drugs or in a berserk rage.

I saw an episode where it took six cops to subdue a 5'2" woman.

Why does it take so many?

Because they are trying to subdue someone without killing them.

Tasers have more stopping power than bullets when it comes to stopping someone who is hopped up on drugs or berserk because they don't generate pain, they shake up the nervous system.

When someone is in a state that they feel no pain and hopped up on drugs or adrenaline, they may continue fighting even if mortally wounded.

The strength that someone gets in that state is also amazing, I've experienced that personally. I weighed about 230 at the time, my friend about 200. We were both tossed around by a man of 150lbs like a pair of rag dolls.

by ontheropes

I've seen what fear and anger can do to a person.

After having a cup of coffee and thinking more about it I'll concede that tasers may be alright in the hands of a trained officer.

Somewhere along the line I have watched too many videos of what I'll call rogue cops. I can't point to a specific incident or video right this second but they're out there on the Internet somewhere.

The bottom line in my opinion is that cops are going to have tasers because there will never be a vote to take them away. It would be seen as disarming the officers.

by oz_media

"and you'll see just how many people it takes, especially if someone is hopped up on drugs or in a berserk rage."

Our drug problem, mainly herion is very easy to identify, especially by the mounted police who are faced with it every day.

I agree with your comments about these whackos that need a half dozen guys to subdue them but that's hardly the case here.

The gguys body languane went from semi-aggressive/threatening to very passive and defensive as soon as teh cops walked in. Even the airport security could have handled this one without violence I think.

For FOUR cops to back a guy to a wall, where he quickly backed away and cowered before they tased him, is enough. No need to tase him at that point, I've seen these guys drop much bugger guys with ease, especially someone not really beligerent or violent.

It' snot like he was fleeing a gang shooting or holding up a store, he had a flimsy 5lb wooden table, which he instantly put down when the cops turned up. He knew he was outmatched and mellowed out, all but words, when he saw them.

by charliespencer

"If three separate used of the taser have cause 2 hospitalisations and two deaths, should the police be issued tasers? if so, should they be retrained in the correct usage?

Personally, I say take all the "less lethal" garbage away from them, and tell them to shoot to kill."

So the police should be retrained in the correct use tasers in a lethal way?

I'm not sure if you're opposed to tasers across the board because of the possibility of death, favor them but think the police need retraining so they don't use them lethally, or think they should be replaced with weapons that guarantee fatalities. This one lacks your usual coherence.

by jaqui

"less lethal"
That is part of why the police do go overboard with a "less lethal" device like the taser, they have to work their way up to lethal and face an inquiry after using lethal force.

and the lack of respect for their direction during something as simple of a traffic stop is caused by people knowing they can't use lethal force until all other options are proven ineffective.

It really would have people listen to them better if there was no "less lethal" tools available and they knew they would be shot if they didn't listen.

by jamesrl

I don't think the Polish guy at YYR knew about Tasers.

I think Tasers like guns are tools, and its clear that the RCMP either don't have sufficient training guidelines or enforcement of guidelines.

There have been scenarios in Toronto where tasers are not widespread, where a taser could have saved a life. I'm recalling mentally deranged guy with a sword. A taser could have stunned him from a safe distance. Instead he was shot dead.

Some of the analysis I've heard about that one instance is that after being tasered many have trouble breathing, and by knealing on the subjects neck with his knee, the officer may have done the very worst thing at the wrong time. This is worth review.

James

by oz_media

THey used ot be a laughing stock because they would spend an entire career in the RCMP and never fire a weapon off the range. There were just too many repercussions if the used deadly force and people knew it.

I think what is being too easily overlooked here, with teh YVR incident, is that they had no need to tase him to begin with. Lethal or not, it was completely unecessary use of force. He was submissive before they tased him. It's not somuch teh weapon of choice but the inadequate judgement of the RCMP, whicih again I finda little odd for them, they study ways to work around this without violence, unlike the Van city bulls.

by oz_media

Accordibg to an attending nurse at VGH, he was unable to recover because the police were kneeling on his back and kneck. His airway was restricted while he was in need to get oxygen back into his body, tasers cause convulsions which suck the oxygen away as muscles contract and require more blood.

What part of the incident shows you enough reason to use lethal force as an alternative?

by jaqui

YVR has at least one staff member who speaks polish and could have talked with they guy.
he was stepping out of the office after picking up some paperwork when the call first came into the security desk.

the entire incident didn't need to get to the point of police involvement.

the deceased did not know english, and there was zero communication with him from customs officers, or any airport staff.

by oz_media

He had also been held from clearing that little customs room since 4 PM, about 8 hours earlier. I've seen far mroe beligerent people walk out with a free lunch on that stupid show Airline. They have drunks, violent people, even peopl emissing a simple booking 2 minutes before take off will get more aggressive.

UNtil I see other information to teh contrary, I cannot agree that this was the right resolution and see the RCMP as 100% at fault without question. They simply f****d up and a guy lost his life, especially sad after waiting years for immigration to let him join his mother in the interior. He did nothing wrong that deserved what he received, it was terrible judgement by the piggers.

by jamesrl

Nor the pattern of abuse of the use of tasers. Clearly there is an issue.

But its with training and procedures. Wasn't this the same Vancouver RCMP force who went overboard with pepper spray at a protest over an economic summit?

James

by dadspad

in all restraining (lethal and non-lethal) methods.

It is very hard to be a police officer in any democracy or 'free' society. The officers are sometimes put in a position where they are the only ones to handle a violent situation or people, and not all are intensively trained to handle this.

Would you want to be the one to shoot and kill some one? I do not believe it is that easy to do, or it should not be. Is it a wonder that they favor a (supposedly) less lethal method?

I have a friend that is a policeman, he transports criminals. He has had to tackle criminals twice his size, and, even handcuffed and chained he was pretty beat up. He never even considered shooting him, but I would bet he would have loved to have a taser to use.

There will always be abuses in a system. Now with cameras everywhere, we learn of them more, especially with the availabilty of the internet to spread the news.

by dr dij

pepper spray and mace, which the police can use.

as Dad said, is very hard to be an officer. They are always the 'bad guy' beating up on innocent civvies in some people's minds.

Even pepper spray could kill someone who has asthma or seizures possibly.

I think they need more training and more non-lethal weapons. There are nets they can shoot over people. the list goes on and on.

Also if tasers ARE killing people, they may be able to recalibrate them so they simply stun. they may have voltage or amps too high.

As for those who suggested do away with non-lethal, consider this: then the police will have to shoot anyone out of control and will cause bigger hubub with those who decry shooting the people who drunk / nuts / stoned out on meth, etc.

by oz_media

In the case of teh recent airport incident, he was killed becaus ethey would not allow him to breathe rapidly and recover. He's even panting and huffing in the beginning of the video after picking up a 5 lb table to block the doors open between the customs and lounge areas.

by oz_media

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wYEBd-Mpus

The RCMP this time, a bit disappointing as they are generally far more logical and regimented in such situations. A friend of mine is a trauma nurse at VGH where he was brought, instead of Richmond General????

She said he died from having his airway blocked and was unable to recover/catch his breath again after being tased.

If you watch the beginning of the video, the guy is brething heavily, heaving his chest after pikcing up the table, obviously not the healthiest man around. For armed and protected RCMP were within arms reach of him more than ocne before tasing him. Whatever happened to four bulls that would just toss
a guy like this to the ground without the need for such assistance? Jaqui, you must remember the old Vancouver 'bull squad'. Enormous cops who didn't give you time to pull a weapon or anything, you were on the ground and cuffed in seconds. But once cuffed they didn't need on your chest for a while too ensure you couldn't breath. It was quick efficient and clean, perhaps s few bruises but not much more.

They also jumped the uy after tasing him as if he was putting up a struggle. It appeaars to me that he was simply spasming involountarily due to the electricity.

It's pretty sad when four trained and protected RCMP can't subdue a single, rather non-violent man with a language barrier issue. Even the security guards that were initially there couldn't do anything, out of fear of repercussions. Jaqui, you remember the old Coliseum guards, if you acted up in the Canucks game they would quite literally toss you dozen feet out the door toward Renfrew without a sdecond though. Pride was damaged and you missed the game and your friends but c'est la vie.

We only had oe problem with such a bounce and that was when bouncing out other ecurity guards that were off shift one night, even then they didn't have a case that made it past an initial enquiry.

Our security/enforcement needs balls again, they need to be able to act and take down people before it gets this far. YOu don't have to hurt anyone seriously, just remove the offender, which even in this case, I think could have been done with little resistance. Simply walk him somewhere else where there's no audience and he will soon shut the hell up and cooperate.

It should have been over in seconds, not dragged out for 10 minutes until he was tased and killed.

Absolutely pathetic!

by oz_media

I think I am getting a "DON'T TASE ME" T-shirt made up.

Perhaps a picture of a taser in a red circle with the line across it.

The next time I drive through a drunk driving road block, perhaps I should jump out and lay on the ground spread eagle while begging them not to tase me. When the police ture dup ast the airport, the guy's body language instantly became subdued and he backed away until up against the lass, which is where they tase him and he starts to convulse.

It's absolutely horrendous that our RCMP act like this.

They SHOULD follow through with Taser suspension this time, they've tried many times before to no avail.

The latest attempt: http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20071120/taser_report_071120/20071120?hub=Canada&s_name=

"Three in four suspects Tasered by the RCMP between 2002 and 2005 were unarmed."

Well it's a good thing it isn't in the US I guess, they'd have most likely just been shot instead.

by oz_media

They have tried and tried but it's getting to the edge now.
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20071120/taser_report_071120/20071120?hub=Canada&s_name=
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
[i]But retired superintendent Ron Foyle, a 33-year veteran of the Vancouver police who saw the video tape, said he didn't know "why it ever became a police incident."

"It didn't seem that he made any threatening gestures towards them," Foyle said.[/i]

[i]Police enter the secure area with no problems and can be seen with Dziekanski standing calmly talking with officers. They appear to direct him to stand against a wall, which he does[/i]

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2007/11/14/bc-taservideo.html

"NEVER BE A VOTE TO TAKE THEM AWAY?" Not so sure about that, perhaps there will be in Canada, but I agree I couldn't see it in the US where a violent drug problem is wider spread.

by ontheropes

From your article "...citing 17 deaths in Canada and more than 280 in the United States."

I didn't know that there was such a high number of deaths from tasering in the US. There's no huge outcry over it here unless I'm missing something.

Even our one-bullet Barneys have tasers now. I think some of them are just itching to use them.

by oz_media

Whil eI am not sugesting that police violence is acceptable anywhere, I think there is far more tolerance in the USA (obviously). Perhaps this is due to a nation where so many people feel it ok to protect yourself with a gun, and also a nation where violent (often unstoppable) drug users are in such high numbers. I've seen how the US cops handle these situations, many are quick to use lethal force (though not all cops are gun happy, there are many who do provide a great public service). I think in the USA there are so many people who would support a cop using a gun to take someone out, thta tasers are a "think yourself lucky" weapon.

In Canada, I think people are much quicker to call the government on mistakes, are more likely to support an unarmed person who was assaulted by a member of The Crown and more likely to stand up for PEOPLE before anything else. We have our druggies and rubbies, but that's all they are here. YOu can walk down Vancouvers skid row without fear, as nobody needs more than a slight push to take them down. Most can barely walk and are malnourished. I find that the same areas in the US are filled with organized drug dealers and gangs, mainly armed and very strung up. Out here the most you get is someoneannoying you for a smoke or change for a fix. The heroin here just takes people out they are preactically incapacitated and unable to do anything but double over in pain until the next fix.

Just thoughts, no data, no argument.

by w2ktechman

the public constantly wants to sue cities and law enforcement agencies over wrongful death.

I remember watching the news about a cop who shot a suspect in the leg (non-lethal) because the robber was caught coming out of the store he was robbing. After being told to drop his knife, the robber then raised it and charged the officer.
the officer shot once, and was suspended due to public outcry. Apparently the public thinks that the cop should have disarmed the guy instead of shooting him (non lethally). Charges were filed and dropped, and lawsuit was filed and dropped by the family of the suspect.

Personally, I think the cop would have been justified shooting the a-hole in the head. But there was a lot of public outcry against the 'misuse of force' by putting him to the ground....

by oz_media

http://www.cbc.ca/news/interactives/map-tasers-canada/

While I agree some were avoidable and definitely instigated, many are not.

Being so careful not to pull their guns unless "absolutely" necessary is something most know about the RCMP. Perhaps teh thought of non-leathal force is just being overused becaus ethey feel it is safer, instead of trying other simple 'muscle' tactics as they did before.

by tonythetiger

1. Police have as much right to protect themselves as any citizen.

2. The number of injuries/deaths is small compared to the number of times tasers are used. I recently read that in fact, deaths among resisting suspects who were tasered are lower than deaths among resisting suspects who weren't.

3. If a suspect was struggling with police and popped an aneurysm or something, are the police responsible for the death? How are they supposed to know he had an aneurysm? How are they to know a subject has a particular sensitivity to a taser?

4. Citizens are required to follow the lawful and legal orders of law enforcement. This has nothing to do with guilt or innocence of the citizen, it only refers to the lawfulness and legality of what the officer tells you to do.

by locrian_lyric

You reminded us that the map is not the territory.

What the reported statistics are not saying is:

-ratio of suspects taken into custody who have been tased vs number of deaths by tasing

-Wheter deadly force would have had to be employed if tasers had not been available.

-Whether the death rate is higher or lower w/tasers as opposed to without.

by nentech

There is a problem with that

The conditions or the environment is one of many factors

Some questions

Is the effect of the stun gun increased or decreased if the person is wet?

Is it the same for rainwater and sweat?

Which mental states are of high risk?

Is the weight of the person a factor (how much body fat)?

What about people who smoke and how much?

What about sex, is male or female an issue?

There are many more

Col

by oz_media

1) of course, the citizen in this case made no effort to protect himself, he was backed against a wall in the secured customs area.

2) You are right, in fact that number was recently posted above.

3) YOu are right, but the suspect wasn't struggling of opposing anyone. There were people in th elounge explaining he couldn't understand them, a Polish speaking attandant was called ad reportedly on his way to the incident when this happened. He posed on threat or danger to anyone in the area.

4)Citizens are required...He's immigrating from Poland, nobody spoke his language he had been waiting for nearly 8 hours in customs at the time. "lawfulness and legality of what the officer tells you to do. " It is quite clear from teh video that he INSTANTLY became submissive when the RCMP approached, he even backed away from the airport security guards that were there.

There was no threat to the officers or anyone else as he was behind a secured area. When he did enterthe lounge area, a lady was able to speak with him in a calm tone of voice, he made no aggressive moves toward her or anyone else. This was NOT an dact or stopping aggression or violent behaviour. He was quite passive once the RCMP were there.

So while I agree with your views, they simply didn't apply in this case. This is why it is a big issue, they had no viable reason for their actions.

"A Victoria man who filmed Robert Dziekanski's dying moments at Vancouver International Airport last month says the Polish immigrant was surrendering himself to police when officers shocked him with a Taser."

P.S. He didn't die from the relatively electrical Amps of the gun, police state he was a victom of Excited Delirium, ohwever attendig nurses at VGH's traima ward say he was suffocated and unable to regain his breath and steady his heart rate due to the RCMP on top of him. Watch the video carefully, one officer is on the guy's kneck so heavily, his left foot isn't even touching the ground. All the weightof a 200+lb man being put on ONE knee in the back of your kneck? Would have to work out the fore based on teh diameter of his knee, but it is a hell of a lot more than the 200lbs+ the copy weighed. Probably closer to 500lbs.

From teh videographer:

"Paul Pritchard condemned the police action on Friday, but said he had a different take on it when he witnessed it live.

"At the time I thought it was the right thing," Pritchard said in a telephone interview from New York on Friday. "I thought it was more of a stand off, but it wasn't. It wasn't like that at all."

Dziekanski, 40, Gliwice, Poland, had arrived at the airport 10 hours earlier on Oct. 14 - making his first airplane flight to begin a new life with his mother in western Canada.

Dziekanski, who only spoke Polish, began acting erratically after he did not see his mother in the baggage claims area, a secure area she could not enter.

She had told him to wait for her there, and he did, for hours. When she could not find anyone to help her get back to the secure area, and he did not appear, she thought he had missed his flight and she left the airport. "

by tonythetiger

Some are wanting ALL tasers removed because of a relatively few incidents that could have been handled differently. If THOSE police behaved inappropriately, hold THOSE officers responsible, don't penalize the ones who weren't doing anything wrong.

[i]Dziekanski, who only spoke Polish[/i]

Hmmm. Should every police officer in the world be required to speak and understand every language in the world?

by nentech

A job choice does not give you any more right to life than any other person

Cops also have to obey the law as well as the regulations and rules of the job
With no exceptions

by oz_media

Vancouver doesn't technically have an RCMP force. Vancouver and some surrounding cities such as New Westminster, Delta have their own police force, which is USUALLY where the problems arise. RCMP have much better training, or ar esupposed to have, far mroe vocus on psycholigy and stopping a situation eithout violence or aggression. That's why this one is so odd, not that it hasn't happened before but it is/was quite rare.

I think this is mroe of a Richmond RCMP issue, working with the Airport Athority than those who would be in attendance for the summit downtown or Victoria (of course).

by mjd420nova

In most cases, that is 95% according to police statistics, tasing un-cooperative individuals is a last ditch effort before resorting to lethal force. Some people don't react normally to being tased and go into cardiac arrest. Most deaths in California from being tased were from the suspect being wasted on drugs and required multiple applications. Others had pre-existing conditions that caused immediate cardiac arrest and death. In these cases I would rather that they tased them instead of shooting them, which would result in a 50-50 chance of causing death. A number of cases were cited where after being tased and remained combative the suspect was tased on the ground. Some of theses cases also resulted in the officer being knocked silly too. Myself, a taser would probably not have much of an affect as I have a very high tolerance to high voltages. Most tasers are near to 50,000 volts but of very low currents. I have been subjected to 12,000 volts without any effect except for muscle tightness immediately afterward but only lasted ten minutes. As you can see, there are some extenuating circumstances but the officer who's life is in jeopardy has no way of knowing about any of the suspects history. Tase away, better than shooting and possibly putting innocents lives in danger from errant gunfire or ricochets.

by jamesrl

In Canada, 3 out of 4 subjects tasered had no weapon, including the gentleman at the Vancouver airport.

There are a number of cases of tasers being used at "peaceful" protests. In none of these cases were the officers life in danger - they used them when they did not get compliance. Thats a different issue.

James

by oz_media

While your comments do ring true in many instances, such as someone wired and unstoppable, that's not at all the case here.

Firstly, I am confident a taser would rop you like a lead fart. I have seen people claiming to have high tolerances hit the floor pretty quickly. As you said, 12K volts will effect your miuscles for about 10 minutes. That's the whole idea of the taser. 50K volts, causes involuntary muscle spasms that drop a guy, they do however recover.

He didn't have a heart condition that police were unaware of, he was literally suffocated after being tased 4 times. Note the cop with a knee on his kneck also has the other foot right of fthe ground, indicating several hundred pounds on his kneck during the imperative time to recover.

In this case the cops F'd up, plain and simple. 100% negligence which should(and may still be) be tried as manslaughter.

The guy wasn't fighting them, the first tase took him down he was only seemingly struggling as he convulsed and screamed n pain.

by techexec2

.
Here is a video showing a minor speeding traffic stop escalating into a tasing and an arrest of a non-violent young adult man in front of his terrorized pregnant wife and infant child on a highway in Utah.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMaMYL_shxc

[b]Effin' Idiot Citizen Driver[/b]

The young adult male driver immediately pulled over when signaled by the Utah Highway Patrol (UHP) officer (good boy). When the officer politely and professionally asked for driver license and registration, this ignorant and foolish young man did not immediately comply. In a firm voice, but without yelling, he chose to argue about the alleged speeding offense instead. The officer immediately lost his professionalism and impatiently asked a second time (did you notice the dramatic sigh by the officer in the video?). The driver chose to argue about the alleged offense continuously for as long as the officer was in his presence. He was asked and then bluntly told to sign the citation and he stubbornly refused (it is only a promise to appear in court, not an admission of guilt). He immediately got out of the car when asked (good boy). But, he failed to turn around and put his hands behind his back when told very forcefully four times and with a taser weapon pointed at him. Instead, he foolishly responded twice with "what's your problem". He was never violent or threatening, just stunningly ignorant, stupid, and under-cooperative.

The foolish ignorant young adult driver was an effin' idiot.

[b]Effin' Idiot Utah Highway Patrol Officer[/b]

The UHP officer initiated the encounter professionally and politely. But, he quickly escalated to unprofessional, provocative ("...you're going to sign this..."), and violent (taser) when he did not get submission from the driver. The officer did not try to explain what signing the citation meant (it's only a promise to appear in court). The officer did not try to explain what not signing the citation meant (arrest, jail, and misdemeanor charge). I'm quite sure these simple explanations would have solved the non-compliance issue. This officer CHOSE to escalate this into a violent arrest. This was about ego. This was about telling stories back at the police station. It must be pretty boring patrolling the highway all day long.

This officer was an effin' idiot also.

[b]What is wrong with this picture?[/b]

This looks like two stubborned impatient people both having a bad day to me. The problem is, one of them has a badge, a gun, and a taser.

They say the taser avoids an officer having to use a gun to kill someone who is resisting arrest. I think it does. But, that argument doesn't apply in this case. The driver was ignorant of his obligations under the law (signing the citation). But, he never resisted arrest. He was never even told he was under arrest until afterward (although if he wasn't such an effin' idiot he would know). The officer was a bored cowboy cop who [u]chose[/u] to quickly escalate to a violent taser-enforced arrest of a non-violent citizen.

The taser is not the problem here. The problem is a poor cop:

** Lack of patience.

** Lack of professionalism.

** Lack of compassion.

** Lack of humanity.

** Lack of complete honesty and candor. Note his inaccurate cowboy recount of the encounter to the other officer at the end of the video.

[b]This is not a taser problem[/b]

I think the taser is a good tool for the police and it is being used to save lives by most police in most situations. The problem is, there are also some bad cops who are using tasers too freely. The taser should not be used to terrorize non-violent people into submissive behavior. They should only be used to avoid having to use greater force. I don't think police departments are up to fixing this. I think civilian leadership must intervene.

This needs to change. But, until it does, mind your manners around the police whether you think they deserve it or not. Otherwise, you might literally get the shock of your life.

---------------------------

P.S. I haven't had that many interactions with police over the many years. But, out of those, I have had [u]many[/u] more good ones than bad ones. The vast majority of police do a great job. It's the few bad ones I'm concerned about. There are too many of those.

Have you ever encountered a cowboy police officer like this in your travels over the years? I have, several times. But, I never acted like idiot-boy here and I was never arrested (came close though). How do you handle a very angry (in my case) out-of-control cowboy cop who doesn't want to hear anything you have to say? The more you talk, the angrier he gets. If you say nothing, you're sure his escalating angry talk toward you will result in him beating you unconscious and arresting you. Respectable appearance (how boring), short hair (yawn), a lot of calm but fast talking, and deference saved my ass from an unjustified arrest. This was way before tasers and in my youth. Today, I would probably have been tortured with the taser and falsely arrested. An angry cop and a taser are a dangerous combination. Like this, for instance:

This drunk terrified woman was repeatedly tasered for very long periods of time by an angry sadistic inhumane police officer. This is not what America is about. We need to fix this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vFH9kmKZX_o
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMpEr-MOSyk

Is the taser itself really all that bad? Check this out. It's painful (so they say), but it appears that fear and terror play a big role in the experience.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UncMrAt5gE4

Good example where a taser is justified. Great professional work by the police! Bravo! And, a great way to end this post.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1J9_Xcs0Tho

by oz_media

"How do you handle a very angry (in my case) out-of-control cowboy cop"

Don't say anything at all, just hand over your ceredentials and await the ticket. You'll get your day in court, and that's the place to drag him down.

ON another note: I've had a cop ask me to get out of my car so he can search it, I refused as my only obligation is to provide identification. I explained that if he wantd to arrest me, he could then search the vehicle. If i was under arrest I wanted to know what for and to speak with my lawyer before offering any other information, of body fluids.

He went to his car for 5 minutes, came back with my ID (no ticket) and told me to have a nice day. One thing about RCMP, USUALLY, if you know your rights (Canadian Constitution protects me from such searches and extractions of fluids unless plced under arrest) they don't cross the line.

You don't even have to blow the breathalyzer in a rodside drunk driving check if you don't want to. Mind you, in that case they will plac eyou under arrest and take you to the station to process you, you talk with your lawyer etc. then they make you blow anyway. In those cases, they arrest you knowing very well you are intoxicated or at least under the unfluence.

by nentech

I am sure many people think death is funny
Lets all joke about death
Lets all joke about the police and violence

Lets shoot all the criminals
Then we will have no crime

Hope Jaqui knows the police assume people are guilty until proven innocent

Best way to clean up these forums
Lets shoot all the idiots, jackass, frat boys, morons, jokers, trolls and anyone else who posts just to make sure

Sorry first lets shoot the spelling Nazis and Grammarian?s after all they are the biggest idiots

Can you spot yourself
Flame Warriors home page
http://redwing.hutman.net/%7Emreed/

Col

by nentech

Trolls should always be shot first
Their performance will be the most interesting

The worst will argue

?I have not been shot?

?No its sauce from my lunch box?

?You?re an idiot you don?t even have the gun pointing the right way?

?That?s not a real gun. Real guns are made from plastic you moron?

?I am not falling down. You are soo boring it?s sending me to sleep?

?Only someone as stupid as you would use a handgun. Using a flame thrower would leave no trace?

?Do you even know how to spell gun?

by oz_media

RCMP, especially, have such training. It is a lot more work becoming an RCMP member than a city cop. They go throught intense psychological training to teach them how to circumvent issues before they escalate into these situations.

That was the part that shocked me (sorry fo rthe pun), if it was Vancouver cops i wouldn't bat an eye, they are incompetent and quick to act without training. RCMP are supposed ot be well above that though.

by ontheropes

What an ass he was. He lost two cop jobs that I know of. Hopefully he's not working as a cop anymore or he could be the next one to pull you over. That's not funny.

by oz_media

Of course not, the airport customs officials had already contacted an emplyee who spoke Polish. He was apparently on his way there at teh time.

The language barrier isn't REALLYths issue though, the fact is, if he was not cooperating there was a reason. It's not like they asked him to put his hands on teh counter only to have him refuse or lash out, he was TRYIG to be cooperative when they arrived. His body language was passive, he shrugged his shoulders and backed away from them. There are dozens of reports of how quickly they walked in a tased him (most about 15-20 seconds), judging by the video I also counted about 15 seconds after they walked in.

Now 15 seconds when facing a beligerent or dangerous crackhead or robber is one thing, 15 -20 seconds after quietly walking in on a man who was as passive as this is not a very good action. They can't say that they had tried other means first.

The police state they didn't want ot use pepper spray because of the pubilc area, but they were in a secured area behind teh public lounge when they faced him. Nobody else was in the customs area at the time.

He was trying to meethis mother, who was also waiting outside the customs office, if they had found here she could have spoken for him also,or at least explained the issue.

For him to be held for over 10 hours in customs, with his mother asking for him on teh other side is ridiculous. Language barrier solved pretty quickly with a little thought.

She had left by this time though, not knowing he had arrived and figuring he missed the plane. The customs officials could have helped when she was asking for him, all they have to do is look or ask someone in customs.

Overall it was unprfessional, a result ofmany bad decisions and in the end, the ridiculous loss of a man's life.

Police say they tased him twice, then they said three times, but people in the lounge said they heard at least 4 cracks.

It's pathetic to think we place our security and lives in the hands of these unqualified clowns.

by ontheropes

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/11/26/un_taser_verdict/

"Taser International founder and chairman Tom Smith concluded: "We are taken aback by the number of media outlets that have irresponsibly published conclusive headlines blaming the TASER device and/or the law enforcement officers involved as the cause of death before completion of the investigation. These sensationalistic media reports completely ignore the earmark symptoms of excited delirium shown in the video."

"TASER International is transmitting over 60 legal demand letters requiring correction of these false and misleading headlines and will take other actions as appropriate. These unsubstantiated, false headlines mislead the public and could adversely influence public policy in ways which could place the lives of both law enforcement and the public at greater risk."

False headlines? You're lucky to see anything news-worthy in or on "the news" in the US. That's part of the problem. The other part is that people don't care that they're not getting real news. We just got done watching supposedly local news. Does anyone really care what Britney is doing? What about our schools? What about our State Government that is struggling to pay the bills.? What about the fact that Harley-Davidson gave their people time off because people don't have any cash to spare to buy a motorcycle?

I could go on and on about our "news". They're still keeping up the illusion about our "freedom" as Frank Zappa described it.

"The illusion of freedom [in America] will continue as long as it's profitable to continue the illusion. At the point where the illusion becomes too expensive to maintain, they will just take down the scenery, they will pull back the curtains, they will move the tables and chairs out of the way and you will see the brick wall at the back of the theater."
-Frank Zappa, musician and cultural iconoclast

I think he's right.

by nentech

There will be some idiot who will upset because the bricks are the wrong color(or is that colour)

Also present

he idiots who will insist the wall is art or necessary

The idiots who will insist the wall has always been there

The idiots who will tell us that we are stupid because we are facing the wrong way

The idiots who will tell us we should not fight it because it leads to violence and someone will get killed. That we should avoid war at all cost even the cost of freedom.

Know anyone like that?

by jaqui

the airport has it's own detachment.
They can and will call on the richmond detachment but it is not the same as at the airport, at least not the last time I was doing work out in the airport buildings.

by nentech

May find it hard to convince anyone it wont hurt if we use them as a battering ram against the wall

But you never know
I have seen Jackass the movie
Those idiots will give anything a go

Just looked up battering

Rough treatment
That?s how the cops will see it

Mauling
Think that was in the video

Beating
Yes that was

Injury and Damage
Yes they were there

They covered them all

Col

by nentech

By the way how long did it take to come with that little joke?

Don?t mind the jokes

But death gets less and less funny as you get older

Unless you are suicidal
Then it?s happy moment for some of them

by tonythetiger

[i]But death gets less and less funny as you get older[/i]

... to make every effort to avoid those situations which increase the chances of a premature one.

by jdclyde

Are there cases of police brutality? Of course there is and there always will be. They are people, and just because they put on a badge does not make them a good person. Some people just suck.

Are there clear cases where people need to be subdued? This video shows a guy get tazed several times before he consents. Is the fact that he is drunk an excuse for his behavior? Not in the least.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zQ0_d-BFM4&feature=related

Because we have people in the world that act like the cop is crooked as the rule instead of the exception, it takes away from the authority they are given to do their very dangerous job.

Here in the US, these same people will make excuses for bad behavior instead of holding people accountable.

by jamesrl

I don't think the Vancouver airport thing was brutality. I do know one of the officers asked whether he could use the taser even before they saw the person in question.

It was training and procedures and as such was a preventable death. That is the real tragedy.

The taser has the possibility of creating serious harm, if not death. It should only be used in self defense - when someone is in danger of physical harm. It should never be to enforce compliance.

Sure there are brutal cops, always have been, always will be - and they will be just as brutal with a nightstick if they don't have a taser.

James
James

by tonythetiger

[i]It should never be to enforce compliance.[/i]

What [b]should[/b] be used to enforce compliance? How does, say, a 120 pound female officer make a belligerent, intoxicated, 250 pound man comply with her lawful orders? Say "Pretty please?"

by techexec2

.
One disagreement. Otherise, I agree with you.

[i]"...they will be just as brutal with a nightstick if they don't have a taser..."[/i]

Yes and no. Because tasers usually don't kill and usually don't leave permanent damage, police can use them much more freely than a nightstick. And, they obviously do.

When an officer beats someone severely with a nightstick, he had better have a good reason. Not so much with a taser.

by Member 25348569

might just be deaf.

Under your rules, they would be dead. Or, if we go along with everyone else, crapping their pants after multiple tasering.

"those who don't listen to police instruction" might just disagree with what the police are saying. You know, that IS allowed and you shouldn't be brutalised for doing that!

"those who don't listen to police instruction" might just be right not to do that. I've met some stupid, arrogant and ignorant police in my time - as I think we all have. Doesn't make ME a criminal if the police are wrong!

Just my couple of coppers worth.

Neil :|

And they just might not speak English. Is that a good reason for a tasering? Speaking in a strong accent? Oh, and neither is 'smelling of foreign food' an offence.

by techexec2

.
James' complete point was:
.
[i]"...It should only be used in self defense - when someone is in danger of physical harm. It should never be to enforce compliance..."[/i]

The case you describe is where there [u]is[/u] danger of physical harm to the 120 lb female police officer who is trying to make an arrest of a 250 lb intoxicated man. In that case, necessary force is necessary force be it taser, nightstick, or gun. On the other hand, the taser is not necessarily going to make a very large very drunk (or high) irrational man [u]decide[/u] to comply with [u]anything[/u] at all. The taser would be simply torture and might just make the situation worse.

The problem with sanctioning tasers for use in "compliance" is they get used (abused) when there is NO physical danger whatsoever. It's just for the "convenience" of a sadistic and/or inhumane and/or lazy and/or dishonest officer.

I'm speaking about cases like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMaMYL_shxc

...and this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vFH9kmKZX_o
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMpEr-MOSyk

...and the harmless wheelchair-bound 78 year old mentally-ill woman in Florida who refused to put two knives down. Two cops simultaneously tased her 10 times ... and she died from it. Whatever happened to the tough cops that could overpower such a person without tasing her to death? Pathetic!

Just because tasers usually don't kill and usually don't leave permanent damage doesn't mean they should be used as if they are "free". Yet, that is how they are being used all too often.

I would suggest that if a nightstick is inappropriate, so is a taser. If the taser is used that way, we won't have non-violent people being tased and tortured without consequences for the police officer abusing the tool.

So, I think you're WRONG! ;-)

by tonythetiger

if a particular incident is "abuse" then punish the perpetrator of that abuse.

You "Johnny got caught chewing gum in class so EVERYONE has to stay in from recess" types are going to be the absolute death of this country.

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...You "Johnny got caught chewing gum in class so EVERYONE has to stay in from recess" types are going to be the absolute death of this country..."[/i][/b]

What?! You must be having a bad day. You're a lot smarter than that.

If you notice, I never said tasers should be taken away from the police. And, I never said ALL of the police are misusing the taser. In fact, I have explicitly said the opposite. You're barking up the wrong tree. You need to save that for the [u]true[/u] liberal weenies and hippies. :^0

I have yet to see a case where a tased citizen did not bear at least [u]some[/u] blame for the tasing he received. But, that does not mean everything is just fine right now. Tasers are being abused far too frequently. The many cases we see on video are merely the tip of the iceberg.

[b][i]"...if a particular incident is "abuse" then punish the perpetrator of that abuse..."[/i][/b]

Of course. But, the problem is clearly that certain kinds of taser use is not considered "abuse" when it should be. The taser usage rules, and enforcement of them, are too weak. As a result, certain cops are free to abuse the taser.

I am advocating further restrictions on their use and [u]real[/u] and [u]meaningful[/u] punishment for cops who violate the rules. Tasers are considered too "free" right now. That is reflected in how they are being abused on non-violent and/or non-threatening and/or non-dangerous people. That is reflected in how lots of the police crack jokes about it and make fun of people who have been tased. It's not funny. It is unwarranted abuse, sadistic torture if you will, and it should be a serious criminal offense.

Police departments are clearly not up to the challenge of dealing with this. Civilian government officials must intervene and force things to change. I think the problem with this is the usual one. Any politician who stands up against taser abuse will be falsely labeled as "soft on crime" and will be falsely politically vilified when someone is shot and killed while resisting arrest.

Meanwhile, non-violent citizens are being abused by certain sadistic cops on a regular basis.

I would only advocate a ban on tasers if further measures to stop them from being abused did not work. If the police want to have the taser as a tool, they must use it in a reasonable way ... [u]all[/u] of the time.

Violators of these tighter rules for taser use must be [u]significantly[/u] punished. Let's start with 30 days suspension without pay at the minimum. That would get their attention.

by nentech

Did you get the response you wanted?

"Personally, I say take all the "less lethal" garbage away from them, and tell them to shoot to kill.
If not obeying the police means instant death penalty then it would be assumed that those who don't listen to police instruction are criminals with something to hide from the police. A funeral is cheaper than court and prison costs, it would save huge amounts of taxpayers dollars."

That looks a lot like the crap the trolls write

Sad thing is this what it takes to get a discussion going nowadays

Col

by jaqui

since I wasn't looking for an answer.
I just wanted to get a discussion going about something that is serious.

We all need to look at issues like thise even if it isn't it related, since we do vote to put those who can change policies into office.

by jamesrl

"Simple" compliance - when an officer asking someone to do something but is not in danger- such as has happened in London Ontario when a police officer took a very intoxicated man who was handcuffed refused to remove his boots. He was tasered.

Or the people who have been tasered while protesting in a peaceful manner.

Or the man in Vancouver...who would have complied except he didn't know english - he certainly retreated when he saw armed officers and became passive before the tasers got him.

I would not taser someone in a scenario where I would not use a nightstick. So if the 250 lbs man was threatening and agressive, use the taser if you must. But if he is only offering passive resistance, do you want to threaten him with bodily harm?

James
James

by jdclyde

"resisting arrest".

If an intoxicated person refuses to get in the car, do they get a night stick up side the head or do you let them walk away?

by jamesrl

The person was already under arrest and handcuffed - clearly no threat. He could barely stand. He just wasn't compliant.

Would I put a nightstick upside someone's head because they refused an order? No. If they made threatening statements or took a swing, thats a whole other ball game. But simply being physically uncooperative does not merit a nightstick to the head.

And just so you know in University I was a bouncer, so I have some experience with intoxicated belligerants. My cop brother might have a different answer though...

James

by jdclyde

is how people in here think taking the tasers away from "bad cops" is any kind of solution.

Think people, we have given these cops a handgun and often a shotgun as well. If they are unfit to carry a taser, they are unfit to be a cop in the first place.

A cop with a gun is more of a threat than a taser any day.

by jamesrl

I think it is a matter of training, in the use of of the taser, and in the use of force guidelines.

There may be good cops and bad cops.

I have never had an issue with tasers being used when needed, I think they can save lives. But when they are used more than needed, we are bound to have problems.

James

by faradhi

Applying reason to an emotional argument. Tsk tsk. When will you ever learn?

I agree, the problem is not the taser. It is the wielder. However, it is easier to just take the taser than to correct the cop.

by jdclyde

and just bludgeon the buggers? B-)

A lot of this is along the lines of the problems with education in the US. Anytime you try to hold ANYone accountable for their actions, it is fought tooth and nail.

Maybe NCLB isn't the solution, but at least it was an effort to hold teachers accountable. I can't think of any other profession that doesn't base someones ability to keep their job based on their performance, but no one seems to WANT to see how the teachers are performing.

But that is another rant for another time.... ;\

by tonythetiger

[i]However, it is easier to just take the taser than to correct the cop.[/i]

... correct the cop. It will only force him to change his method. Maybe his suspects will suffer a disproportionate number of "falls".

by nentech

Are making is

Anti violence = Anti taser

Most/All of the people in this are against violence

Violence with some exceptions, not all exceptions

That is normal human (not animal) behaviour
The issue is the exceptions and what should be done with the cops who cross the line

Just encase you don?t understand that

Violence must be kept to a minimum in all cases

Please tell me why cops should not have to wait for people to do what they want

When they are allowed to make people wait for them with very little explanation

Col

by jdclyde

If a cop is arresting you for something and you decide you are NOT going to get in the car peacefully, you will get put into the car in pieces. Simple, straight forward, and predictable.

When is the last time a cop made you wait for them with "very little explanation"? Please give an example of what it is you are referring to, because I can't comment otherwise.

A cop has been given the ability to use force to stop force. You resist, a greater force can/will/should be used to put you down, hard.

by jdclyde

Don't tell me how NOT to handle the physically uncooperative, tell me HOW TO handle them.

What should the solution have been instead of tasing?

I have raised my boys that when a cop means business, that is not the time to discuss the issue. It is "yes sir, no sir, whatever you say sir". Don't ever give them a reason, because they do a dangerous job and might get wound up a little tight at times.

In a "he said, she said" situation, the cop will win in court in most cases.

by jamesrl

You have to spend a day in training to be issued a taser, and only senior staff get them.

The Toronto Airport is in my jurisdiction. Haven't seen an issues with excessive taser use here - in an area with 1 million people.

James

by jamesrl

What do forces without tasers do in that situation? What did police do before tasers?

I'm not anti taser - and I've repeated myself repeatedly. Almost every incident we've seen be an issue is where the use of force is the real issue. We could say the same thing about pepper spray. This is about force escalation happening too quickly.

James

by jdclyde

Blank slate question. You have someone in handcuffs that is not complying with demands (assuming they are reasonable demands of course, since YOU are the authority figure making the demand).

Step by step, how do you get them to comply?

What is the PROPER escalation of force in such a case?

[i] See, I really WASN'T just trying to be argumentative. B-) [/i]

While I have played bouncer/security before, I have never had any formal security training other than personal protection classes for firearms and rules of engagement of an intruder in my home are completely different than being a cop trying to get a drunk into their car. Simple solution in the home is empty clip in center of mass if they are a threat, threat eliminated. The drunk is not a threat, so not eliminated but must still be dealt with and taken in.

by ontheropes

I know some police officers who were given time off without pay for being physically rough but I can't say that I've heard of anyone getting time off for using a taser. Not saying that it doesn't happen just that I've never heard of it. Unjustified shootings yes, unjustified taserings no.

More power to the people that videotape an incident and/or release it to the public! Every tasing incident should go before a police review board just like a shooting incident. I don't know if it does. Probably depends on the department. Some control so-called cowboy/rogue cops better than others. Some municipalities control police departments better than others too. I can remember a time where it was a big deal to have the shotgun located in the drivers compartment. Some local departments still have to carry their shotguns in the trunk because of public perception.

After giving it more thought as I said, if I was a police officer again I'd like to have a less than lethal alternative for when the crap hits the fan. I don't believe that I'd abuse it. I know cops that would. Inside of local police departments they're called super-cops. They work too hard at making a simple situation worse and it's often just their word against the one arrested. Super-cops need time off and possibly a shrink or retraining if they're overly rough on someone and that includes over-zealous use of the taser.

by jamesrl

"Big Man Security".

I got the job because my roomate was the owner. I wasn't a big man back then; 6 foot tall but skinny.

What I had going for me was a) backup and b) martial arts training. Today I have the mass, but not in the same shape I was.

How would I deal and how would my brother deal with an intoxicated non-compliant in handcuffs. If his hands are behind his back, its pretty easy to use a wrist lock or arm lock to control him. If his hands are in front, I would first threaten then get the second body (if he is in custody he has to know thats a credible threat, and time is on your side). If no backup was available, and the handcuffs are on the front, and no amount of reasoning could sway them, I'd have them in a front arm lock. You can lock someone's arm in such a way that you can cause great damage (arm break) pretty easily if they misbehave. But I think thats much safer for them than a nightstick to the head or taser.

I did have to face drunken/stoned belligerants. I have used force on behalf of my employer. Luckily the cops were never called.

James

by tonythetiger

I actually misread what James said (that you agreed with).

[i]Tasers are considered too "free" right now. That is reflected in how they are being abused on non-violent and/or non-threatening and/or non-dangerous people.[/i]

"Resisting arrest" is a violent crime by definition and by nature. The police have a duty to stop this crime-in-progress using the means at their disposal. One would expect that they should use the minimum necessary force, but since I'm not there, I am loathe to call a method "overboard" unless it is glaringly so, and even then only on a case-by-case basis.

[i]Violators of these tighter rules for taser use must be significantly punished. Let's start with 30 days suspension without pay at the minimum.[/i]

Now your being lenient. What should a cop get for unjustifiably beating the hell out of someone with his nightstick? Punish the crime, not the tool.

(I just heard on the news during lunch that Massachusetts is considering making corporal punishment a criminal offense. I think they're going to be using their tasers a lot more when those kids get older!)

by jdclyde

they had an unscheduled stop on the way to the cop-shop....

He didn't get much sympathy from anyone I know.

by ontheropes

I know some of suspects that "borrowed the phone book." That's where the police would hold a phone book against a suspect and beat the phone book with their fists. Didn't leave bruises. Cop's word against theirs and without witnesses you know who they believed.

by jamesrl

Cherry Beach is a beach, but the larger area is an industrial area which is not far from downtown and largely deserted at night.

So in the 80s someone wrote a song about it.

Cherry Beach Express
Pukka Orchestra

I've got a bone to pick with you
not so friendly boys in blue
you come out of the station
and into the street
and everybody beats
a hasty retreat

Well it was late one Friday
I'm a little bit wrecked
you're on your way to serve and protect
you buzz out of a cruiser
like bees from a hive
and ask me if I want to
go for a drive

go for a drive?

That's why I'm riding on
the Cherry Beach Express
my ribs are broken
and my face is in a mess
and I made all my statements
under duress

52 Division
handcuffed to a chair
I'm joining the lineup
to fall down the stairs
I tell you I'm innocent
I try to explain
we're just making sure
you don't do it again

do what again?

That's why you're riding on
the Cherry Beach Express
your ribs are broken
and your face is in a mess
and we strongly suggest you confess!

I confess I'm mystified
by the way you're occupied
I confess I'm horrified
why are you so terrified?
does the pain get any less
if I confess

by faradhi

Those who make such policies are not worried about actually doing anything. They are worried about looking like they are doing something.

The harder thing is to terminate the abusive cops. However, if that were to happen it would make it harder for policymakers to get that Police Union endorsement the next election. Or they have to be worried about being labeled as "Soft on crime" by the next wannabe politician that comes along.

by nentech

With what you said

What is the most stupid thing I see in a lot of these forums

People giving the police more rights than any other person including their victims

What we don?t see enough of is cops being sacked because they broke the law or rules of the job

Most companies would fire people for a lot less than what these idiot cops have done

There is no place for angry or stupid people in law enforcement

Col

by oz_media

This year has seen quite a few Canadian city police and RCMP stand trial and pay fo rtheir mistakes. Law enforcement is not the end all here, they are held accountable, as is our government more and more.

It's a small but somewhat significatnt difference between teh US and Canada. We hold our politicians accountable, usually because they only hold aminority government and the other party will scrutinize them and publicly air any discrepancies. Unlike in the US, where it is just a he said/she said scenario, our Liberal party has to account for their actions when the Dems or Conservatices call tehm on it. It often results in a change of government due to misrepresentation or disillusionment of the paople of Canada.

Cops and RCMP are no different, I have personally sued a cop and won also sued a doctor and won. People can make a stand here.

In North Vancouver this year, a future police cheif (just due for promotion) was fired after a drunk drivign accident.

Several Vancouver police are on trial for mistreating a vagrant.

The RCMP that attended the airport fiasco are also being held accountable, once evidence is collected they will probbaly be tried also. So there is quite an onus on them to perform adequately, as other Canadian detachments have already said that (based on the video alone) it doesn't appear to have been handled correctly.

I see far more interest placed in the citizens of Canada than 'the system' over the last 10 years, they just don't stand for it anymroe.

I remamber one year, a decade ago, where a whoe team of Vancouver cops (The Bull squad) was fired for their unbridled suport for each other regardless of criems comitted. It used ot be that they would drive a paddy wagon into an alley, pull you out and beat the crap out of you, before letting you go miles from anywhere useful. They were all fired, I used to work for one, who's son ended up being the Abbotsford killer.

Just a screwy bunch! Since that time a lot greater focus has been placed on them keeping with the law and they seem to tread much more carefully now, knowing that the eye is always watching.

Perhaps not enough, but it is somethng to see them held accountable for their actions, as I am positive will happen with the Vancouver Airport issue.

by nentech

What the greater force should be used for your single situation?

We don?t want generalise do we
So be very specific

Please describe how the person is resisting?
And the exact amount of force and how it should be applied

Please tell me what percentage overall of resistance to arrests this would apply?

Please tell me what the percentage of people with injury?s or deaths should be?

Please tell me exactly what should be done to cops who exceed these?

You will need to define ?peacefully? and ?a greater force?

After all no one should generalise in a discussion about something as serious as this

Col

by jdclyde

There are many ways someone can resist. From running away, attacking the officer, or simply refusing to be cuffed and carted away.

The force to be used is the force required to get the job done. The person continues to resist, the force is increased until their is compliance. Someone that is a threat would/could/should be handled much more severely than someone that is just refusing to comply.

percentage it applies to? all of them, on a one-on-one basis.

What of injuries SHOULD their be? Well, as there SHOULD be ZERO resistance, there SHOULD be ZERO injuries. As the resistance goes up, the odds of the resister getting injured. This escalates to the point that yes, someone can/will die. If the resister is armed and dangerous, you do not shoot to warn or wound, but aim for center of mass. If not a danger, provided the person is not being physical AND does not have any medical conditions, there SHOULDN'T be any deaths. But again, it goes back to not resisting in the first place.

If a cop exceeds and pulls a Rodny King, they should NOT get set free, first of all, and should get assault to manslaughter, depending on if it is a beating or a death. Murder requires pre-meditation, so it is not valid.

Peacefully. Assume the position and follow orders. Do not resist getting patted down, cuffed, or being placed into the car.

Greater force is a twisted arm, a billy club smack, getting tased, or getting shot. The greater the threat, the more force is to be applied. If you aim a gun at someone, you should be "put down" before you can act, not after someone is dead.

I can't help but think of "Don't tase me dude" as an example though of a rent-a-cop getting out of line. A student is asking valid questions of a political candidate, so he is removed and tased? So much for the party of freedom of speech and ideas.

by nentech

Some of the people posting in this discussion haven?t

The answer to your question

Friend?s family and associates
Some time spent with some of the local law I know as friends

You want to listen to JamesRL and Oz_Media
They know the right way to deal with stupid drunks etc

Col

by oz_media

I was typing this last night but yanked the power cord out by accident and my battery was hooped so I lost it all, #^&#$.

My friend's dad is just about to retire from Richmond RCMP. We were talking about it yesterday afternoon, he knows 2 of the four (even though they still say there was only three of them there, LOL, how stupid is THAT!?) They all fight over getting the airport authority gig, I believe they go about 4 months in a row thrn back into Richmond city or somewhere else. They are moved all over the place during their careers, but the Airport Authority is generally staffed from the Richmond detachment. Perhaps it is possible to just work towards a full time gig at YVR, I'm not sure about that one though.

by oz_media

THanks James for the breakdown and that's exact;y what I used to tell my security teams to do. It doesn't matter if you're big or not, though size does help in many cases just in showing you are capable of overpowering someone. I am quite small, when I was working security I was VERY small. I rarely had problems though, and that was working hockey games full of VERY drunk people in all states of agitation and excitement.

Thumbs, when in handcuffs are like little leashes. People have no choice but to follow the path of their thumbs, just as with their head. Move the head, the body moves with it, same with thumbs.

People when really pissed will allow enough pain for a thumb to be broken though. Hopefully not a regular issue, but it is better than really harming someone. Usually just forcing the thumbs will lift someone's arm to a useless position, almost like placing someone in a headlock would, or is enough to drop someone where you need to.

They KEY to all security though is simply to remove the threat and get the person outside to where they can be dealt with properly. This is generally where RCMP win because of their psychological studies. MOST people (with sound mind) can be talked into settling down without issues, as long as you don't embarrass/upstage them in front of their peers and deal with it personally and quietly.